Why isn’t there a consistent message about alcohol and health? How do you know if you’re putting yourself at risk? Is it really “all things in moderation”? Dr. Sarah Wakeman is an Associate Professor of Medicine at Harvard Medical School & Sr. Medical Director for Substance Use Disorder at Mass General Brigham. She is also the author of Treatable: Rethinking Addiction and How to Get Care Right. In this episode, she shares why we hear conflicting messages on alcohol, why what “one drink” means is subjective, the actual health risks even for moderate drinkers, drinking stigma & what real sobriety means. If you liked this episode, you’ll also like episode 265: HOW DO YOU KNOW IF YOU’RE AN ALCOHOLIC? [REMASTERED] Guest: https://www.drsarahwakeman.com/ Book https://a.co/d/0afUgsLE https://www.massgeneralbrigham.org/ https://www.instagram.com/massgeneralbrigham/ https://www.instagram.com/drsarahwakeman/ https://www.facebook.com/MassGeneralBrighamInternational/?brand_redir=45556346121# Sponsors: https://www.historicpensacola.org/about-us/ 1:04 - How People Measure Their Own Drinking (Spoiler: They Don't) 2:08 - Why the Science Is So Confusing: CDC vs. WHO 3:35 - What "Class 1 Carcinogen" Actually Means 4:39 - Why We Can't Study Alcohol the Way We Study Other Things 6:09 - What’s “a” drink? 11:04 - Does It Matter Why You Drink? 12:27 - The Capsule Wardrobe Approach to Alcohol 14:21 - Health Risks for Moderate Drinkers 16:08 - Breast Cancer and Light Drinking: The Uncomfortable Truth 17:42 - Toxic Load: Can We Blame the Country We Live In? 20:04 - The Challenge of Counseling Patients on Alcohol 25:00 - What Alcohol Does to the Brain 25:34 - Alcohol-Induced Dementia: How Would You Know? 27:17 - Alcohol, Anxiety & Depression: A Two-Sided Coin 29:10 - Dry January: Helpful Reset or False Start? 33:00 - Moral Incongruence and the Drinking Stigma 34:38 - The "Alcohol Puppy" in Your Brain: Dopamine & Reward 36:20 - The Endorphin Connection: Why Alcohol Feels Like a Painkiller 37:17 - Naltrexone & the Sinclair Method: Medicine for Moderation 39:22 - How to Talk to Your Doctor About Drinking 41:40 - The South Dakota 24/7 Sobriety Experiment 44:00 - Is Alcoholism a Disease, a Behavior, or Both? 46:31 - Contingency Management: Rewarding Sobriety 48:23 - "The Opposite of Alcoholism Isn't Sobriety - It's Connection" 49:31 - Where to Find Dr. Wakeman & Her Book Treatable Request to join my private Facebook Group, MFR Curious Insiders: https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1BAt3bpwJC/ Follow me in all the places: https://www.meredithforreal.com/ https://www.instagram.com/the_curiousintrovert/ meredith@meredithforreal.com https://www.youtube.com/meredithforreal https://www.facebook.com/curiousintrovert
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00A glass of red wine with dinner is good for the heart. A little liquid courage helps us connect. A glass of champagne is the perfect way to celebrate. Drinking socially, medicinally, and occasionally have all long been a part of human culture. As the saying goes, all things in moderation. But as they also say, the devil is in the details. My next guest is an associate professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School and Senior Medical Director for Substance Use Disorder at Mass General Brigham.
SPEAKER_00She is also the author of Treatable Rethinking Addiction and How to Get Care Right. Today, she's going to help unpack the tangled mess of stigma, medical rumor, and human connection. As we ask the question, is moderation a myth? This is the Curious Introvert Podcast with me, Meredith. Around here we explore taboo questions and societal blind spots. Please help me welcome the woman working to destigmatize beverage choice, addiction physician, Dr. Sarah Wakeman.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for being here. Thanks for having me. So I feel like when it comes to assessing our own alcohol use, we all pretty much have the measuring accuracy of fishermen. You know? So what do you see people considering as moderate drinking? Is it they don't visibly get drunk or that drinking doesn't interfere with their job? How are most people measuring moderation?
SPEAKER_01So it's hard to measure how much you're drinking if you're not sure what are sort of health-related benchmarks to think about, or even what is one drink. You know, you can go to one restaurant and one drink can look one way, or at home you may have a glass that's a different size. And I think for many people, it's not widely discussed or talked about. And then people's sense of what's normal is just heavily influenced by what's around them. And so we tend to measure ourselves based on people in our lives or our social context or how we grew up. And alcohol use can vary tremendously by social circles, by background and context. And so what is normal in one group may be very different in another group.
SPEAKER_01And none of that is necessarily benchmarked to what we would recommend from a health standpoint.
SPEAKER_00So, in other words, they're just not thinking about it.
SPEAKER_01Well, I would say more and more people are having this conversation and there's a lot more attention than there used to be. But I think, yeah, I think historically people haven't really thought about it. And honestly, the science is confusing and the messaging from public health has been really confusing. It's an area that's evolved a lot, but also it's a tough thing to study in an accurate way. And so I think therefore, you know, you can read one article saying one thing and a few years later see something that seems to say the exact opposite. And that sometimes leaves people just totally confused.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Like the CDC I read says that moderation is measured by one drink a day for women and two drinks a day for men, while the WHO says alcohol is not safe at any use level and it's a class one carcinogen. Why would those two health organizations measure that differently? So they're sort of both right.
SPEAKER_01So alcohol is considered a carcinogen. So is sunlight and so is meat. So there are many things that we incorporate into a healthy lifestyle that don't have to be an all or nothing that do, in fact, are known to cause cancer. And that's true with alcohol for sure. And it's known to cause cancer, is associated with higher risk of cancer the more you drink. And so I think the challenge is taking these very nuanced scientific findings and then making it easily understood to the public. And in that translation, I think the nuance gets lost and different groups have come down in different perspectives in terms of how they've portrayed that evidence to the general public.
SPEAKER_00In my non-clinical mind, when someone announces that a substance is a class one carcinogen, that is like a big red X over that thing. But I never thought, like, oh yeah, well, so is sunlight. You know? So am I interpreting and internalizing that information in too much of an extreme way? Or yeah, am I doing this wrong?
SPEAKER_01I don't think you're doing anything wrong. I think you're probably reading more than many people are and trying to understand the truth. I actually think the messaging is what's confusing. You don't really hear the government saying sunlight is a carcinogen or even, you know, that bacon is a carcinogen. And so I do think that's a little bit of a hard thing to interpret. What does that really mean? Because I agree when I hear something described as a class of carcinogen, I would think, oh God, I should never ever be exposed to that. But the reality is the science is a little bit more mixed than that when it comes to alcohol.
SPEAKER_00Oh, interesting. Okay. So that's where the whole nuance and difficulty of studying something like this in that sort of lifestyle bucket becomes a little messy, right?
SPEAKER_01It's so messy. Cause if you think about how we do scientific research studies for other things, the gold standard is something called a randomized controlled trial. And so what happens there is that researchers would randomly assign people to two different groups, and one group would get the thing that you want to study the effect of and the other group wouldn't. But you really can't do that with alcohol. You can't like randomly assign people to drink for the next 20 years and the other group to not drink for the next 20 years and then actually understand what happens. And the outcomes that we care about, things like death and cancer and heart disease, really do take 20, 30 years to accumulate.
SPEAKER_01So you can't do sort of a short study where someone maybe would agree to not drink and be in a control group for that time period. And so scientists are left with really big observational studies, which is how a lot of public health data is done, that generally leverage other studies that have followed people for decades, where people were asked about their drinking habits as a part of that study. And then based on that, they try to control for different factors and understand is there an association between alcohol and certain outcomes. But that's a much more imperfect science than knowing I just administered, you know, 10 ounces of alcohol to this person every day for 20 years and this was the outcome.
SPEAKER_01We really don't have that kind of data. And so I think it's a combination of the science that exists is somewhat messy. But then two, the findings differ. So if you're looking at cancer, the outcomes are actually different than if you're looking at overall mortality or risk of death or heart disease. So it is not a simple thing to understand or to try to explain in public health messaging.
SPEAKER_00No, it totally isn't, which makes your job super challenging because that educational piece is part of what you do. Obviously, we're here today. You wrote a book about it. And I want to come back to that unpacking the study details of the health outcomes of alcohol in a minute. But I I want to go back to the topic of moderation, because when asked, most people will say, Oh yeah, I drink in moderation. And I'm wondering how that is different than gray area drinking.
SPEAKER_00Can you help differentiate the two?
SPEAKER_01So it's confusing, and different organizations have changed their stance on this over time. But for a long time, we went by in the US, by the NIAA drinking risk limits. And their recommendation or sort of definitions were that lower risk drinking was seven or fewer drinks per week for a woman or anyone over 65 and no more than three drinks on a drinking occasion. So you couldn't sort of save up all seven for Saturday and still be in that lower risk category. And then for men under 65, it was 14 drinks a week and no more than four per drinking occasion. So if you have, you know, six drinks on one occasion, that is considered sort of a binge drinking episode.
SPEAKER_01But it doesn't necessarily mean that you have alcohol use disorder, which we'll talk about, which is what we think of as addiction. It just means that above those lower risk limits, in the studies that we have, we've seen evidence that health risks start to accumulate. And so that can be things like um cancer, high blood pressure and heart problems and acid reflux, sort of more mundane medical problems. And so they with the best evidence we have from these large survey studies, they sort of set these thresholds of what they think are lower risk strengthening limits. And so when I think that's kind of the best we have. So I'm giving guidance to patients.
SPEAKER_01That's sort of the general rule of thumb I try to keep in mind is, you know, as a woman, seven or fewer a week and no more than three on a drinking occasion. And as a man under 65, 14 or fewer a week and no more than four on a drinking occasion. That does unbeg the question of like what is a drink? Because that's the other piece of that equation. So if you have, you know, a drink is a bottle of wine, that would that would not count and would be over the recommended amount. So the definitions in the US are that one standard drink is five ounces of wine, 12 ounces of beer, or one and a half ounces of liquor.
SPEAKER_00Five ounces of wine is like, I mean, that is a tiny glass. It's a small four. Yes. Yeah. A small four. Yeah. Yeah, that's a small four. That's what we call like, you know, when you get a flight of beer, I don't know if, or like it's it's basically like a wine tasting, you know, is is five ounces. Okay. So let me repeat that just so that it's in my brain. One drink is considered five ounces of wine, 12 ounces of beer, or one and a half ounces of liquor.
SPEAKER_00So like a one and a half ounce shot. Okay. So like the little glass shot is one and a half. The metal one at the bar, that's two.
SPEAKER_01There you go. Exactly. So you can see how tricky it is already to measure your drinking, because you know, depending on where you are, these things will look different. Yeah. I guess the thing I would add, because the goal here is not perfection. The goal is thinking about overall health improvement in my mind. And so, you know, these recommendations are based on these large studies that ask people, how much do you drink? And so that also is very much open to interpretation. And so it is not a perfect science.
SPEAKER_00So back to the term gray area drinking, is that more of a behavioral distinction or it does it have to do with quantity?
SPEAKER_01So if you think of it as a pyramid, you know, then with sort of health risks increasing the further you get to the top of the pyramid. At the bottom of the pyramid are people who don't drink at all. You're obviously not going to have any health-related problems if you don't drink alcohol due to alcohol. Next is kind of the biggest group, which are people who drink in a way that actually doesn't cause obvious risk to their health or their life. And so that's that kind of lower risk or moderation bucket.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's unpack that really quick. Hold on. Oh, yeah. It doesn't cause, say it again.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't cause negative impact on their life or obviously on their health.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's hang out there for a minute. Since this episode is about that department. And uh, so if somebody goes to the doctor and the doctor says, Hey, your drinking is negatively impacting your health and they choose to drink anyway, would that be more on alcohol use disorder side of things? Yeah, great question.
SPEAKER_01One of the diagnostic criteria of alcohol use disorder, there's 11 and you have to meet at least two to be diagnosed with a mild alcohol use disorder. One is if you have known medical problems related or worsened by alcohol and you continue to drink despite that. But that's different. There's sort of two things embedded in what you said. One was a doctor just generally saying you shouldn't drink for health reasons. That's very different than a doctor saying you have liver inflammation. And if you keep drinking alcohol, alcohol is going to cause your liver to get even more injured and for you to develop cirrhosis. If you continue to drink despite getting that very personalized medical feedback that alcohol is making a health condition worse for you, that would be sort of one of the criteria towards alcohol use disorder.
SPEAKER_00Interesting. Okay. And does it matter why a person drinks? So, like, say we're hanging out in the moderate zone, right? Yeah, yeah. But the reason that we drink is specific. You know, it could be you feel sad or you feel anxious or you feel angry or I don't know, you feel bored, or you want to socialize? Like there's so many reasons that we drink in our culture to celebrate, to mourn, to unwind, to wind up. It's a long list. Does answering that question matter when it comes to moderate drinking?
SPEAKER_01It's not something that is on any of our sort of screening tools, but there are studies that have looked at that that people who drink to relieve bad emotions, so like who drink because of sadness or trauma or grief, are at increased risk of ultimately developing an alcohol use disorder compared to people who drink for sort of positive reasons, like drink to socialize, drink to celebrate. You know, it's hard to know is that speak to the fact that one of the biggest risk factors for addiction is trauma. And so if you're drinking to relieve sadness, you may have sort of pre-existing trauma versus is there something different about that type of behavioral pattern?
SPEAKER_01But certainly that is something that would make me as a clinician more worried or sort of would my ears would perk up if someone said that they really drink to relieve depression or sadness or guilt or loneliness. That is a riskier situation than someone who's drinking, you know, at a social event with their friends or their family.
SPEAKER_00I did a very casual Facebook survey of just personal contact to see, you know, what people do in terms of moderation. Do they have specific strategies that work for them? Do they have rules that they follow? Or is it just kind of a, you know, take it or leave it feeling towards alcohol? And the the responses that I got were all over the place, but very passionate. A lot of people who had decided to just not drink at all. And I'm starting to see, based on your answers here, how just not drinking would be like the drinking version of a capsule wardrobe.
SPEAKER_00You know, like how Steve Jobs had all black t-shirts and jeans. And so he never had to make a wardrobe decision a day in his life because he just wore black t-shirts and jeans. I'm starting to see why people kind of exit the mental spinning that involves like, okay, now this is a drink. Now that counts as two drinks, and how many have I had? And oh, wait, I only do this on the weekend. Am I drinking because I'm sad? I could see where people would just go, you know what? I'm just not gonna do it.
SPEAKER_01Totally. And I think it also depends on what someone's relationship is with alcohol. So for, I mean, it's sort of like if you think about food or eating dessert, there's similarities there where for some people it's sort of take it or leave, and it's not that big of a deal. They eat dessert when they're at an event, but it's not something that they are constantly thinking about or having to resist the urge to eat, or that it sort of consumes their mental energy or decision-making capacity. But there's other people who share this concept of like food noise that if you put a bag of cookies on the table, they're gonna be spending most of their mental energy thinking about whether they should or could or how many cookies they're gonna eat the whole time.
SPEAKER_01And that's exhausting. And so, in that circumstance, some people just say, you know, I'd rather just like not make that decision or not have to deal with it. So I think there's a lot of individual nuance here. And that again is really tough to sort of talk about or educate about, you know, when we think about these kind of gray zone topics like alcohol use.
SPEAKER_00So for those who are moderate drinkers based on CDC guidelines, one drink a day for a woman and two drinks a day for a man, what are the health risks for those folks?
SPEAKER_01Great question. So I think and and the CDC is sort of an extrapolation of that seven drinks a week for a woman and 14 drinks a week for a man. So just averaging it out of birth.
SPEAKER_00I have a hard time with the total week count up. And so the days are like every day is easier for me. I don't know. So sorry if that's messing things up.
SPEAKER_01No, that's really fun. I guess the the thing I would poke into that is that, you know, as people are thinking about how alcohol fits in their life, sometimes it can be helpful to think about having alcohol-free days so that it's not that, you know, alcohol is a part of your everyday life. And so in that case, the sort of how many drinks a day can get in the way of that. So thinking I could add like seven drinks a week a week-ish. And so as a woman, you know, two drinks a night for three days or having those kind of benchmarks can be helpful if people are thinking about sort of their own personal practices with alcohol. In terms of pelvis, I think the biggest one where there are concerns even with light drinking and there being an association with negative health outcomes, are for certain types of cancer.
SPEAKER_01So for most health conditions that alcohol is associated with, thinking of things like fibro disease, heart disease, mortality, the risk really starts to increase as people are drinking more and more. And then flexion point of where that is varies depending on what condition you're looking at. But for mortality, that sort of light drinking, which would be less than those limits we just talked about, there does not seem to be a negative impact on mortality. But once you get above those thresholds that the sort of 14 drinks a week for men, seven drinks a week for women, depending on what study and what definitions they're using, you stop seeing any sort of reduction in mortality and you actually begin to see an increase.
SPEAKER_01For cancer, it's a little different. There are some types of cancer, including breast cancer, where even light drinking has been associated with an increased risk of getting breast cancer. So if you think of women, that one drink a day, actually, breast cancer, is associated with a very small increased risk of developing breast cancer. And so from a cancer perspective, there really is, you know, no amount of drinking that is safe or not associated with an increased risk of these types of cancer like breast. And that's probably most relevant, especially for women who are listening. That then varies again with your personal history.
SPEAKER_01So if you're someone who has a strong family history of breast cancer or a personal history of breast cancer, if I were your doctor, I would counsel you very differently around thinking about alcohol use than someone without that risk factor. And then people have different preferences around their life and what they value in making health decisions and different risk tolerance as they think about different behaviors in their life. And so it really is this situation that is a little exhausting to your point about factoring in all the data, but deciding sort of what matters to you, what's your own health history, and then how do you think about this health-related behavior in the context of that?
SPEAKER_00Is it common for a cancer doctor to tell their patient who has cancer to stop drinking alcohol?
SPEAKER_01I think cancer doctors are counseling very differently about alcohol than they were 10 years ago before all of this data came out. You know, both alcohol and obesity are known risk factors for multiple different types of cancer, including breast cancer. And so, you know, I'm not a cancer doctor, but from my colleagues, my sense is that people are talking about alcohol in a different way, especially breast cancer specialists, of thinking about sort of really the less or or no alcohol is the safest option if you're if you're trying to reduce your risk of cancer.
SPEAKER_00In other developed countries, the toxic load for people would be less than the US. And so they might have some of these what we call bad habits, smoking and drinking, and they could have different rates of cancer. How do we know that our breast cancer rates, to use this specific example, are specifically due to even moderate alcohol use and not the total toxic load of the country we live in?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, great question. And this is one of the real limitations of the type of data that exists around alcohol use is that again, we don't have these controlled research environments where we can isolate the specific factor of alcohol. So, what researchers try to do in studies is, you know, with breast cancer, for example, they would take a big massive study that followed women for many decades that asked about lots of different health-related behaviors, including alcohol. And then they would compare the association between the amount that someone drinks and their risk of ultimately getting breast cancer across those groups.
SPEAKER_01And they do this sort of statistical analysis where they try to control for other things that might be contributing to the risk factor. The issue is we can't control for all those things. Like we actually don't measure on these surveys, like, you know, do you live in an area that's more exposed to pesticides or other chemicals? Or, you know, they often ask about diet, but they don't ask in that great of a detail about sort of diet or preparation or, you know, many other elements. And so the science is imperfect at best. I think what they can say is that with the limitations of those types of studies, when you control for things like body weight and exercise and, you know, other health habits like tobacco, you do see this association with increase in alcohol use being associated with increasing rates of cancer.
SPEAKER_01There's also the always the possibility of what we call confounders, which means that things travel together. So for example, if you didn't control for smoking, you might find that alcohol is associated with this really high risk of lung cancer. But then actually you look and you see that people who smoke are also more likely to drink heavily. And so you're not actually isolating the effect of alcohol, you're actually measuring the effect of tobacco. So that's one of the challenges is the studies are only as good as what inputs of data they have from these surveys and then what things they control for. So it really is this imperfect science. And I think, like many things, should be just sort of factored in as you're making health-related decisions.
SPEAKER_00Does all of this make it particularly difficult for you in your job to help patients stop drinking? Because, you know, you it's it's not completely accurate to say, oh, this 100% causes X and Y, but we see a strong correlation and you're so good at it unpacking all these nuanced details. However, someone who is maybe negatively affected by their drinking habits, so we'll call that like diminished capacity, right?
SPEAKER_00They're not feeling well, you know, and maybe there's some, as you said, trauma happening and they're dealing with that, and they're just trying to be like, lady, do I drink or do I not drink? And, you know, and you have to explain with accuracy and integrity, medical integrity, oh, well, it could cause this and it could cause that, but we don't exactly know. Doesn't that make it a bit difficult for you to really sell it?
SPEAKER_01It's actually much simpler when, you know, when you think about addiction, which is what I spend, I do general medicine and also addiction. So I take care of patients, you know, come in for their annual visit. And that's where I'm really talking about sort of the moderation side of things. Once someone develops addiction, you know, by definition, at that point, they're drinking in a way that alcohol is causing negative consequences in their life. And so in that context, it's not that hard because sort of the horse is out of the barn at that point that however you measure it, alcohol is causing problems to them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think the nuance or challenge can be that people have different goals. So some people's goal is to never drink again. And for other people, their goal is to try to drink in a lower risk way. And so that is a more nuanced conversation and does vary person to person. But I actually think the much messier thing to understand is this moderation bucket where, you know, the science is not perfect. We do have really good data suggesting some things, and it is this very nuanced conversation. And, you know, I asked a dear colleague of mine who's an addiction specialist who's since passed away, but he was an alcohol researcher, you know, someone that I would turn to in the field to ask questions.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, I would see him drinking a cocktail at dinner or at events. And so I sort of asked him, like, how how do you think about this? Because that, you know, alcohol has been known to be a carcinogen for a long time. And he said, you know, I think our problem is that we've been promoting alcohol as sort of a healthy positive behavior as something that improves your health. But it's actually a different conversation if you think, can alcohol be a part of a healthy lifestyle? So the shift there is a little bit like, I don't think anyone eats a bag of, you know, Skittles thinking they're going to make their health better. But many people have a healthy lifestyle and like eat dessert now and again and, you know, eat candy and it's not the end of the world.
SPEAKER_01Same thing, you know, with bacon or with sunbathing. Like I think everyone knows melanoma can kill you and skin cancer is bad. And being out in the sun, you know, increases your risk of skin cancer. And yet we still go to the beach and, you know, we wear sunscreen, we kick precautions, but we're able to have a sort of nuanced framework for that. And I think alcohol's kind of in that bucket where it, you know, for some people is absolutely deadly. The more you do of it, probably the more health harms you're going to have related to it. And it is possible to incorporate low-risk drinking into an otherwise healthy lifestyle.
SPEAKER_00Well, hey there. Since you seem to be enjoying this episode so far, double check that you've hit the follow button on your podcast listening app and subscribe on YouTube. And to join my free private Facebook group, search MFR Curious Insiders on Facebook or click the link in the show notes. Okay, back to the show. That's such a great way to explain that. And you're right. I remember when everyone was singing the praises of resveratrol. And in my research for our episode, I learned that in the 1700s there was this hospital in France that used to give two liters of wine per day to its patients.
SPEAKER_00And so I thought, okay, well, this is not, you know, a particularly modern phenomenon, but it is a longstanding one, which makes it harder to undo. You know, especially when we see these robust centurions drinking their, you know, whatever, brandy at night, or, you know, grandma is drinking her wine at night, and we think, okay, well, it must be fine because it's fine for them. But the personalized approach does simplify it because you don't you can't outsource all of your thoughts, you know, to a study.
SPEAKER_00As scientific and reliable as the study is, you have to make that decision for yourself. And if I'm hearing you right, what you're saying is that's what you help patients walk through is that individual decision.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. And I think, you know, for better or worse, that's true of so many health decisions, that there are very few things where we have sort of a black and white answer of, you know, you should absolutely only do it this one way. Often it depends. And it depends on your own personal history and and other factors. And so I think it is simpler to your point of the capsule wardrobe, it's simpler to just be like, tell me what to do and I'm gonna do it. But yeah, you know, in this space, it really is sort of an individualized perspective.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So talk to me about other health risks that are potentialities in with moderate drinking. So, how about like, let's talk about the brain? What are the impacts of alcohol on the brain?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so the impact of alcohol on the brain depends on the sort of moderate level versus higher risk level. I'll start with the easier side, which is a higher level. So when people are drinking in a heavy category, we know that when their risk of stroke increases. So that obviously has negative, terrible impacts on the brain. But also we see an alcohol-related dementia can develop. So people can get cognitive impairment over many years of heavy drinking that looks almost like Alzheimer's or another type of dementia where they have just profound cognitive impact from heavy alcohol use.
SPEAKER_00How would you know regular dementia from alcohol-induced dementia?
SPEAKER_01There's not a clear diagnostic way of determining that. So dementia is actually a big bucket term, and then there's lots of causes of dementia. So people can get dementia from Alzheimer's, they can get dementia from having multiple strokes, they can get dementia from rare causes like frontotemporal dementia. So dementia is really sort of the end state that we understand and how we see people who've lost their, you know, are losing their memory and all of the symptoms of dementia. But the reason for why someone develops dementia can be varied. And with alcohol, it's really based on history and sort of excluding other causes.
SPEAKER_01So if you see on, you know, on MRI or CAT scan that someone's never had a stroke, you know, they don't have classic findings consistent with Alzheimer's and they have a heavy alcohol use history, it would be sort of attributed to alcohol or alcohol-related dementia.
SPEAKER_00I I know someone who has dementia right now and his symptoms get worse when he has a beer. Is that pretty normal, pretty common?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you think alcohol impacts, you know, so many different parts of the brain, it crosses the blood-brain barrier very quickly and can make people more impulsive or, you know, more dysregulated. And so if someone already has a neurocognitive disorder or dementia, you know, that can really cause significant symptoms for them.
SPEAKER_00Is it true that it reduces the neuroplasticity of your brain?
SPEAKER_01You know, that area of research, I think, is more ongoing and evolving and a little bit tougher to determine. There have been earlier studies, much like the confusing cardiovascular literature, that sort of light drinking was associated with a reduced amount of dementia or a reduced risk of dementia, but then more recent studies have suggested perhaps there is an association. So I think it's it's not as clear as sort of the data around heart disease or cancer.
SPEAKER_00And what about mental health? Because a lot of people drink to improve their mental health. I mean, it, you know, can make you feel relaxed and it can help you go to sleep. Sometimes not always stay asleep, but at least you're getting to sleep. It can help you socialize, which is good for your mental health. Is there, is it a two-sided coin?
SPEAKER_01Yes, alcohol and mental health is a really interesting conversation because it can be bi-directional. So people with other mental health diagnoses, so people with depression, certainly trauma, we talked about adverse childhood experiences or PTSD, people with anxiety are more likely and at greater risk of developing alcohol use disorder or problems related to alcohol use. And part of that is, you know, again, that idea of seeking relief through alcohol and then the spiraling effect of the negative consequences of alcohol setting in. There's a saying that, you know, there's no problem that you can't make worse by drinking, that I haven't heard that.
SPEAKER_01People think that drinking may relieve sort of a worry or stress or anxiety, but often it it ends up being the exact opposite. The other thing is that you can actually get what's called a substance-induced mood disorder. So someone who's drinking really heavily, that can actually cause rebound anxiety and depression. And so it's sometimes really hard to differentiate, you know, clinically, if I'm seeing someone who is meeting criteria for depression, feeling hopeless and has depressed mood, is having difficulty sleeping, low appetite, if they having heavy chaotic alcohol use, it's actually hard to know.
SPEAKER_01Is this major depressive disorder that has led someone to drink heavily, or is this actually the alcohol causing the depression? And the only way to really clarify that is a period of sobriety where you can see do the mood symptoms get better or not. Sometimes if someone's had, you know, they've had depression their whole life and alcohol came later, then it's very obvious. But I think it's important to note that alcohol actually can cause anxiety and depression symptoms and make worse, you know, symptoms that people already have, even if in the moment it feels like it's giving reliefs.
SPEAKER_00It's interesting that you mentioned having a break because I was gonna ask you about this. A lot of people love, you know, sober October or dry January. And I often wonder about the benefit of that, but you're saying sometimes it can provide a like a good set point, like, you know, before and after for that person. But I found, I found it interesting uh because I was thinking, well, I wonder what alcohol sales do in February. And there was a numerator report that dry January participants spend$4,000 a year on alcohol compared to everyone else spends about$1,300, which I'm like, oh my gosh, that is a big difference.
SPEAKER_00So ironically, it means that the people who participate in these sober challenges are the core customer for alcohol companies. So it kind of makes me wonder for the general public, maybe not your patients who are actively striving towards that sobriety finish line. I wonder for the rest of us, for those moderate drinkers, what does that say about those sobriety challenges?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's really interesting. And, you know, you always worry about sort of setting up for like heavy drinking or a binge in response to this period of deprivation that people go for a month without drinking and then they're sort of off to the races and drinking even more heavily in February. And the data's a little mixed. There have been different studies country to country, but I think the the benefit of someone wants to participate is twofold. One, it's just an opportunity to be curious. So even if you don't go the whole month without drinking, maybe you try, you know, only drinking a couple days out of the week or trying to just better understand the role alcohol plays in your life, or taking a break for a month and seeing how you feel.
SPEAKER_01It's sort of like keeping a food journal. Like it forces you to be more mindful of something that maybe you hadn't been sort of aware of, what were the associations between your mood and drinking? Are you drinking because you're sad, or are you drinking because you're in a social situation? It's actually pleasurable and you're building relationships with people. So I think that that opportunity for awareness actually is an intervention in and of itself. And then certainly it's kind of a litmus test to see do you feel better? So if you're wondering, like, is alcohol making me feel tired or giving me brain fog or is it interrupting my sleep, or is it causing my skin to look terrible, or am I gaining weight because of how much I drink?
SPEAKER_01Or, you know, is my mood worse because I'm drinking? You know, month isn't for some of those things, you'd need to see longer than a month, but in a month, you actually can see a fair amount of change. And so sometimes that can be both helpful, kind of clarifying for someone whether alcohol is causing negative responses in their body, but also, you know, it just gives this moment of pause and reflection. And then I think the last thing is if you're worried that you may have problems related to alcohol, you know, in terms of like actually meeting criteria for alcohol use disorder, one of the criteria is trying to stop and not being able to.
SPEAKER_01And so there is a little bit of a test there that if you kind of say that you want to stop and you find actually you're thinking about drinking all the time and you're not able to cut back or stop, that may be cause to be a little bit more concerned about your drinking and actually talk to a professional about it. So I think there are layers where these kind of sobriety challenges can be helpful. But I mean, for someone who is clear that alcohol, they're drinking in those lower risk drinking limits, alcohol is not causing a problem in their health. There's certainly no imperative to do a sober month challenge. And I think importantly, if you do it, just like if you sort of go through a period of healthy eating, you don't want to undo all the benefits by then, you know, doing the exact opposite, sort of eating everything in sight for a month, you're gonna erase any benefits you saw from that time of sobriety.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Well, that would be very logical, Dr. Wakeman.
SPEAKER_01And if only we all worked that way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, sometimes it doesn't work that way. I was doing some research on um sex addiction a while back for an episode, and I learned something really interesting that for many people, the reason that they categorize their sexual desires and their drive in the category of addiction is due to moral incongruence. A lot of these folks are from strict religious communities, and so the, you know, desire to masturbate would be a sin.
SPEAKER_00And so then they they still do it despite their understanding that it's a sin, and therefore, ah, it must be an addiction. And I'm wondering how much that moral incongruence dynamic plays a part in your world in in drinking.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think I mean morality is is very subjective to that point. It depends on the the norms and customs of your culture, of your community. And so that that's true with alcohol too. You know, there actually can be the opposite. There can be an incongruence if your entire social setting and relationships are based around heavy alcohol use and you decide to stop drinking, that's really hard. There's an incongruence there between sort of the accepted norms in your community and what you're doing for your health. So I think anytime there are deltas there, it's challenging. I think with alcohol, unlike other stigmatized drugs, like alcohol is a drug, it is every bit as harmful, if not more, more harmful than other drugs, but it is socially accepted or more socially accepted, generally speaking, than other drugs.
SPEAKER_01And so because of that, people often are not wrestling with the same moral incongruence that they would with, you know, more stigmatized type of drug. And so I think, you know, often the social norm still is that alcohol is, you know, widely available and acceptable. And so I don't think people have that same sense outside of certain religious groups or cultural groups where any alcohol uses them as a sinner is incongruent with the beliefs of their culture.
SPEAKER_00How much of what we experience as a pull towards alcohol is just what I've heard people call an alcohol puppy in the brain, meaning that uh strong and repeated reinforced association between pleasure and alcohol or relief from pain and alcohol.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there are powerful neurotransmitters and pathways in your brain that are happening when you drink. And different people have differing amounts of activation in those systems, which is part of why some people are more at risk of developing addiction than others. But generally speaking, you know, the reason we feel pleasure when we drink is sort of the end stop of pleasure for any substances, dopamine release is the brain releasing dopamine, which is a feel-good hormone that also teaches you to pay attention to something. So it's sort of signaling to the brain this concept of salience, which is the idea that you associate things. So this idea of like, oh, I drank that glass of wine and I feel relaxed and more connected to my friends, or I, you know, felt more comfortable in that first date.
SPEAKER_01And so you're creating an association there. And so that can, that's normal. That happens with many, many things in your life all the time. There's your sort of brain is constantly making associations between things. But that is particularly powerful in the con in the construct of addiction, where over time the brain, that sort of salience, that idea of pay attention to alcohol, this is the thing that's going to make me feel better, becomes kind of outsized and outpaces everything else and actually outpaces sort of normal, healthy, reward-seeking behavior like relationships or food or sex or other things where there's a reason behind that salience.
SPEAKER_01I think the other thing that they're showing with alcohol is it actually activates your endogenous painkiller system. So in the brain, people have probably heard of the concept of endorphins, which are endogenous opioids in your brain. So endorphin is an amalgamation of the words endogenous and morphine. So it's like your brain's morphine system. And people hear of that with like runners high or other things, this idea that your brain releases these, these pain-relieving and feel-good hormones. And for many people, alcohol actually triggers release of their endogenous opioids that estimates that system too. And so not only you're getting a dopamine release, but you're actually getting sort of a painkiller relief when you're drinking.
SPEAKER_01And so that also then, of course, causes pleasure and relaxation and positive feelings. And that's the way one of the medications we use to help people either stop drinking or reduce the amount of drinking that they're doing actually blocks that opioid system so that it tries to block that reinforcement of this sort of pleasure and reward of alcohol use has a medicine called Naltrexone that people are hearing a little bit more about than I think they used to. But it's interesting when you first hear about it, it's sort of like, well, why would an opioid blocker work for alcohol use? But it's really the blunting of that sort of reinforcing cycle of, oh, I drink and I see all these amazing feelings from drinking.
SPEAKER_00So if someone is trying to just moderate their drinking, would that be a viable option for them? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And we're there's, I think, more attention to that than there used to be. So niltrexin is a medication that's been around for a long time. And in part, I think due to a lot of separation of addiction from the rest of medicine, the fact that many people, even if we talk about addiction as an illness, really think that this is an issue, sort of bad behavior. And we have lots of, I think, thoughts that people should just have willpower and sort of knock it off. And so very few people with alcohol use disorder ever get treated with medications, even though we have really effective medications that can help people either stop drinking or cut back on their drinking.
SPEAKER_01But this medication, altruxone, is interesting because it can also be used just to moderate your drinking. And so there's a thing called the Sinclair method, which is named after a scientist by the name of Sinclair who studied it, which is the idea of actually pre-medicating before an event where you're tempted to drink more. So if you know that whenever you go to happy hour, you walk in intending to drink one or two and you leave having drunk five or six, and you just like once you start drinking, it's really hard to stop. What Sinclair studied is actually taking this medicine before you're in a situation like that.
SPEAKER_01And what happens is you drink, but you just don't get the same pleasurable effect. And so it's not like you get sick, but people, you know, patients will describe to me this sense of like, oh, I had a glass of wine. I just like didn't have that urge to want another. It didn't feel that good. And so that can help reinforce people's if they have an intention of trying to cut back or not drink in a heavy manner.
SPEAKER_00So is that something that the average person could just talk to their regular doctor about without fear? Because, you know, there is a lot of stigma around drinking and as you said, like willpower and all of that. So if someone is just trying to stay in the moderate zone and they're finding that it's difficult, but they're just not ready to do the cold turkey thing, do you realistically do you think that they could just say, hey, doc, I heard that there is a medicine that helps me do that? Or would that like, you know, trigger some sort of cascade of responses from that person's medical team that would be, you know, undesired?
SPEAKER_01So in a perfect world, absolutely you can and should say that to your primary care doctor. You know, any doctor can prescribe that medicine. You don't need like special training or a special license or anything like that. And primary care doctors are often sort of the trusted healthcare professional that people know over time. And there have been lots of studies that patients actually feel most comfortable talking to their PCPs as opposed to some random other person or specialist about their alcohol use. And so I think absolutely you could say to your primary care doctor, you know, I'm realizing I'm drinking more than my goal. You know, I've heard about these lower drinking limits.
SPEAKER_01I want to try to keep it to one drink a day or two drinks a day. And I find in certain settings, you know, I'm I I tend to drink more than that. And I've heard there's this medicine that can help people cut back and I want to try it. And they should be able to prescribe that. There actually are now these companies, online companies that are doing sort of direct-to-consumer consultations, kind of similar to the whole industry with GLP ones around weight loss. And I think that so that can be an option too for people if they either don't have a primary care doctor or feel like they're not able to talk to that person. To me, it's sort of a sad testament of medicine that we've so failed to address substance use as a part of health, that there have to be these like pop-off valves that are separate for people to find care.
SPEAKER_01And I actually think that talking to your doctor is an important part of changing the system and normalizing this, that that's part of how doctors change their practice, actually, especially when we've been in practice a long time, is they realize they have to get with their times that their patients need help with different things and there are treatments that they can learn how to prescribe them and how to offer them and make them a part of their practice.
SPEAKER_00Well, I find it interesting that you were talking about the intersection of behavior and medicine and what we consider disease, because in my non-medical brain, those things are always connected and always linked arms with one another. And so if a medicine could help a behavior which equals a better health outcome, then that feels like an obvious choice. I I think where I have trouble is the all or nothings of alcohol in our society, where people are saying it's 100% a disease, I inherited it, and it is always if someone has the same problem I do, it is 100% a disease.
SPEAKER_00And or it's a hundred percent behavior, and you just need to buck up and you know make that change. And I don't know, that black or white part is is tough for me. I I found this study actually, I think that you would find interesting. It's it was an experiment, actually. It was South Dakota's 24-7 sobriety program. You probably already have you heard of this. Interesting. I haven't heard of it now. Oh my gosh. Okay, this is kind of cool. I I would love to see our town experiment with this, but I don't know how all that stuff works. But the participants were required to take twice daily breathalyzer tests.
SPEAKER_00The participants were people who got DUIs.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_00So they had to take a breathalyzer test twice a day. And if they failed or skipped even just one test, they went straight to jail, like and stayed there overnight. And it was very swift. So they did this from 2005 to early 2017 with over 30,000 people. And they accumulated over 5 million days without a detected alcohol violation, over almost a million breathalyzer tests recorded, 99.4% passed, which is really cool because like there was a strong and swift incentive because earlier you were talking about how strong that association becomes.
SPEAKER_00Like it starts out as an alcohol puppy and it grows into a mastiff. You know, those little paws, they grow into a big old animal and you can't, it's like you've lost control. You didn't realize this is what it was going to snowball into. And so it was interesting to me that this experiment had a had a big consequence to kind of counter that. And it led to a 12% reduction in DUI arrests and 9% reduction in domestic violence arrests. So overall, it reduced the risk of death by 50%.
SPEAKER_00And I thought that was so cool, but it it definitely pushes back a little bit on the alcoholism is 100% a disease narrative. And I'm wondering if it might be better for everyone if we could find some sort of compassionate middle ground where we don't need to be overly attached to labels and instead, as you were doing, taking a more personalized approach and like, okay, well, what what can I do? What can be done? But but from a systemic point of view, I thought that was fascinating.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, I think, I mean, there's so many layers then to what you just shared, but I I think first the idea that Like most chronic health conditions, addiction is a mix of sort of behavior and biology. And that's true for diabetes. That's true for heart disease. That's true for cancer. That's true for addiction, where there's some element of your individual risk that you're, you know, inherit. And that can be like roughly half or or so of the picture. And then there's like what you're exposed to, the circumstances that you're in, your health-related behaviors, what age you start drinking, how often you're drinking.
SPEAKER_01And so there's always this intercepting interplay between behavior and biology. And, you know, same thing with diabetes, where someone, you know, is born. If everyone in your family has diabetes, you're going to be at greater risk, but that's not a done deal. There's many things you can do to prevent diabetes from occurring. And same thing. Some people have no family history and, you know, develop diabetes. And so I think there are very few things that are totally binary. And certainly in the realm of substance use, most things are an overlapping mix of behavior and biology. And again, that aligns with other chronic illnesses.
SPEAKER_01You know, the DUI literature is interesting because mixed in that group is probably a whole hodgepodge of people who actually have addiction and people who are just drinking at a heavy level. And so again, if we think of that as a spectrum, it's not sort of this all or nothing of either you are, you know, have alcohol use disorder or alcoholism, or you have no problems with alcohol. It's there's a whole spectrum in there that we've been exploring and beyond that of drinking in ways that are really beginning to cause problems in your life. And many people with their first DUI, they may not yet actually have the kind of compulsive loss of control characteristics that we see with alcohol use disorder.
SPEAKER_01And so that's a time when there is more choice involved in terms of sort of decision change. So you're you've got like a mixed population there. But I think the other two things that I'm struck by what you say, one is, you know, I always say to our fellows who I'm I'm teaching or our teams that it really doesn't matter why we as professionals think someone should make changes to their alcohol use. Like the only thing that matters is that they think their life is going to change in a positive way if they do. And so in that context, if you don't want to lose your license or you don't want to go to jail or whatever it is that you're facing in your unique circumstances, like that is a very salient motivator of making change, especially if you're drinking in a way that's unhealthy and don't necessarily have this sort of compulsive loss of control that we see with addiction.
SPEAKER_01You know, the flip side of that coin is the very severe end of the spectrum of people with severe addiction, you know, sometimes even facing terrible negative consequences like jail or losing their kids or losing their job, people just are not able to make changes. So there is, you know, shades of severity in there. And then the last thing is that one of the most sort of effective interventions from a behavioral standpoint for all types of addiction is something called contingency management, which is actually positive incentives for behavior change. So this would be things like if someone has a negative drug test or if they engage in treatment or show up to see their therapist or their doctor, they actually get positive incentives or rewards.
SPEAKER_01So sometimes these are like vouchers that support a healthy lifestyle or other entering a raffle to win something. And it can sound kind of weird at first of like, well, why would that work? But actually, we do this across lots of different areas of health. So if you have a health insurance plan where you get money back if you join the gym or go to the gym a certain number of days of the year, or you get sort of a rebate for any pro-healthy behavior, that in essence is positive contingency management, trying to change people's behavior with positive rewards. And some of the concept of why that works with addiction is that when someone gets to the degree of having addiction, often they have a lot of things that have fallen apart in their life.
SPEAKER_01They may have lost relationships with family, they may have lost their work or their housing. And that stuff takes years to rebuild sometimes. And alcohol is a very powerful source of relief as we've covered. It's something that gives you immediate escape from the challenges of daily life or your pain or your suffering or withdrawal. And so you're essentially asking someone to discount the sort of immediate reward of drinking for these very abstract long-term rewards of like, well, if you just stay sober for two years, maybe you'll get your housing back. And that's really hard. You know, you're sort of saying no to this thing that can immediately make you feel better for this concept that maybe things will get better down the road.
SPEAKER_01And so part of contingency management is actually giving people a positive, immediate good thing for doing the sort of healthy behavior that that is a part of supporting their recovery, like not drinking. And so, so there certainly are ways in which sort of behavioral interventions like that can be helpful.
SPEAKER_00You said something interesting in another interview. You said the opposite of alcoholism isn't sobriety, it's connection. As we close, can you unpack that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, I think we we focus so much on sort of is someone sober or not? What is their drug test show or their alcohol test show? Really, addiction is a disease of isolation. People often are isolated from relationships, from connection with people that bring hope and meaning and purpose to their lives. And as powerful as an incentive as negative things happening to you can be, you know, the idea that you want to escape the pain of ongoing alcohol use disorder. Actually, one of the biggest incentives is a sense of hope that your life could look better, that people care about you and believe in you.
SPEAKER_01And those connections are a powerful vehicle for getting there, but are also sort of the reward that comes along with that journey of recovery. And so whether you find that through support groups or through engaging with a doctor or a nurse or a therapist, you know, that connection is often the thread that is so powerful in helping people get to a place where they they think their life could be better if they were to make changes to alcohol.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think that it's neat what you're doing to help kind of facilitate that that connection. You know, the very you seem very hands-on, personable with your patients and with your approach at educating the public. So I appreciate you taking time to do that with us. Can you can you tell people where they can find your book and any sources of ongoing research or educational material that you have?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, first, thank you so much for saying that and for having me. So my book is called Treatable, and it is coming out January 5th. And you can pre-order it now on my website, drsarahwakeman.com. You can contact me through my website or follow me on Instagram, also Dr. Sarah Wakeman or on LinkedIn, and I would be excited to connect and really hope people enjoy the book and can hear more about these topics there.
SPEAKER_00Well, thank you again. This was great. Thank you so much, Meredith. Thanks for listening. Since you've made it this far, I'd like to invite you to be part of my private Facebook group. And there I post content that I don't share anywhere else. You can talk to me directly, and I even do occasional giveaways. Search MFR Curious Insiders on Facebook or click the link in the show notes. If you liked this episode, you'll also like the one with the sober scientist who answers the question how do you know if you're an alcoholic? That's episode 265.
SPEAKER_00And stay tuned next week for a remastered favorite asking if political parties are just cults. Until then, keep it curious.
Is a child actor different from a child influencer? What happens when the kid grows up & doesn't want their picture everywhere? The world of family influencers is one we all know, but what are the impacts of on the...
Could the “thinning of the veil” be something happening in a specific part of the brain? What does that tell us about the brain and the nature of consciousness? Jeff Tarrant, PhD, is licensed psychologist,...
Why is sex ed in public schools such a hot topic? Jon Zimmerman, PhD, is and public school teacher turned historian currently teaching history at University of Pennsylvania. He’s also the author of Too Hot to Handle: a...
What if we could eavesdrop on animals …. Using AI? Sara Keen, PhD, is a behavioral ecologist, electrical engineer, and Sr Research Scientist at Earth Species Project, a non-profit leveraging AI for interspecies...
Do subsidized marriage & reproduction work? What happened to “earth is overpopulated?” Elizabeth Nolan Brown is Senior Editor at Reason Magazine, a libertarian magazine that promises to exist outside the left/right echo...