Ep. 367: What if We Could Understand Animal Language?
52 minAudio
What if we could eavesdrop on animals …. Using AI? Sara Keen, PhD, is a behavioral ecologist, electrical engineer, and Sr Research Scientist at Earth Species Project, a non-profit leveraging AI for interspecies understanding. In this episode, you’ll hear actual audio clips from Earth Species Project Research, learn about animal naming conventions, regional accents, the spider communicating with vibration, the ethical considerations & why the goal is to listen over two-way communication. If you liked this episode, you’ll also like episode 254: DO WE *NEED* SHARKS? Audio clip credits: Orcas: (Credit: By Raincoast Conservation Foundation, taken under SARA Research License XMMS-2-2022P) Elephants: (Credit: ElephantVoices) Birds:https://earthspecies.org/2026/08/20/birdcode-scaling-zero-shot-sound-event-detection-for-bioacoustics/ Guest: https://www.earthspecies.org/ https://www.facebook.com/earthspeciesproject https://www.instagram.com/earth_species_project/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/earthspecies/ Sponsors: https://www.historicpensacola.org/about-us/ 2:44 Behavior as the Rosetta Stone 3:31 Chickadees: the town criers 4:52 Interspecies communication 5:49 Orcas & dolphins 6:50 The anthropomorphizing trap 9:19 Listening as the goal 10:02 What the orca boat trip changed 11:45 The orca audio clip 14:30 They're watching us too 15:02 Dolphin names 16:10 Signature whistles explained 17:16 Dolphins & ethics 18:14 Dolphin spy history 19:28 Where's the ethical line? 20:40 Animal surveillance 21:40 Why two-way communication is risky 22:57 The ocean as a sovereign nation? 26:11 Orca boat attacks: playing? 27:47 Do animals have humor? 28:05 Do animals swear? 28:43 Past & future tense 29:34 Do animals talk about humans? 30:04 Elephant research: something new 32:06 The elephant audio clip 33:14 Dogs, cats & button boards 34:40 Animal regional accents 36:00 Humpback whale slang 36:30 Jumping spiders 38:29 Spider Morse code 39:37 Why does this work matter? 40:22 The big why: awe & wonder 41:14 What do we owe them? 41:33 Listening as the remedy to ego 45:08 Aza Raskin & the tech bro paradox 45:39 De-centering ourselves 46:13 Awe without losing yourself 47:14 Aza's three laws of technology 48:30 The AI race & guardrails 49:20 What comes next for ESP Request to join my private Facebook Group, MFR Curious Insiders: https://www.facebook.com/share/g/1BAt3bpwJC/ Follow me in all the places: https://www.meredithforreal.com/ https://www.instagram.com/the_curiousintrovert/ meredith@meredithforreal.com https://www.youtube.com/meredithforreal https://www.facebook.com/curiousintrovert
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Our social media feed is full of talking heads all wanting our attention. But what if the most profound conversation happening on Earth isn't between two humans? What if it's between a mother dolphin and her calf? A crow and a stranger from another city? Between a dying elephant and her herd. We've spent centuries assuming that because we can't understand what animals are saying, that they aren't saying much. But my next guest is part of a team investigating the contrary. She's a behavior ecologist, electrical engineer, and senior research scientist at Earth Species Project, a nonprofit leveraging AI for interspecies understanding.
SPEAKER_03Today she's going to help us rethink the natural world around us as we ask the question: if language is uniquely human, what happens when it isn't? This is the Curious Introvert Podcast with me, Meredith. Around here we explore taboo questions and societal blind spots. Please welcome the woman inspiring awe and wonder with data and waveforms, professional animal eavesdropper, Dr. Sarah Keene. Thanks for being here. Hi, so good to be here. You didn't know that you were a professional animal eavesdropper, but now you know.
SPEAKER_03I like it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03When I think about language and I think about like, okay, I'm going to learn a language. Like right now I'm learning Greek and I've got all these little pieces of paper I taped all over my house with the picture of the thing. And just trying to get myself, you know, acclimated to it. But first on the list is always hello, thank you, bathroom, and more beer, please. These are very important. And I'm so I'm wondering from a language learning perspective for animals, is it kind of the same?
SPEAKER_03Are there these certain benchmarks or low-hanging fruit that you go after first?
SPEAKER_00Okay, that's such a great question. Yeah, I think there are some universal contexts that we expect to observe in different species. So that's kind of what we're looking for at the beginning. There's a lot that happens with parent-offspring communication, specifically mother offspring. So we're looking for like begging calls, asking for food, or you know, young chicks in the nest calling, requesting worms. Greetings are very common. I'm really fascinated personally by greetings and like farewells, trying to find examples of that.
SPEAKER_00Greetings are much more commonly observed. Maintaining contact when you can't see each other. And then I think another really common one is if somebody finds something valuable or interesting to others, like a patch of really delicious food, what they call recruitment calls, where you're telling everybody, come over here, like I found something great. So yeah, I think are the sort of holds that we're looking for right away. And once we start to map those out in a different species, then we can begin to understand like the variation in their language or what other patterns might be observed.
SPEAKER_03So is behavior kind of the rosetta stone for unpacking each species' language and understanding what they're saying?
SPEAKER_00I think so. That's the way we're going to get our insight. And it's behavior as an interactions between two individuals. It could be interactions with the environment around them, with other species. But yeah, even though we're using advanced technology for automating as much as possible in our recording and analysis of data with AI, at some point I think you do have to sit down and actually watch animals if you're studying animals, and that you'll develop some intuitions and hypotheses that you can test in your studies.
SPEAKER_00So behavior, how we get our clues as to what that might be.
SPEAKER_03You said recruitment calls. I couldn't help but think about my chickadee friends. I'm a bird nerd, which you are too, I assume. I mean, you graduated from Cornell. Like that's where your PhD is from. That's what my Merlin app is from. And me and my Merlin app are BFFs. And the chickadee birds in my backyard, we have observed that they seem to be the announcers. There's new food, there's new food. And then the other birds, other species even, will come and they seem to respond to their calls.
SPEAKER_03Have have we learned anything about interspecies communication through the AI research?
SPEAKER_00Yes, absolutely. And a lot of that happens by like just identifying which species is vocalizing and looking at patterns of timing, like if chickadees tend to vocalize first, are there responses from, say, nuthatches or other bird species? And it's really interesting that you picked that out because we just did a study recently where we were analyzing data that people have recorded on their cell phones and uploaded to these public citizen science databases. And we did find this pattern where we saw that chickadees tended to be the ones that were sort of initiating contact or conversation with other species and that they're almost like leaders in some sense of these mixed species groups.
SPEAKER_00And it has me thinking a little bit about just like the flow of information through the world around us. So much of it is really invisible to humans, but like hearing the birds call gives us that bit of an insight. And I think chickadees kind of are like the alarms, and they'll call, and then you'll have a wave of other species, and that information propagates like across the ecosystem, across levels.
SPEAKER_03That's so cool. What about marine species intercommunication? I remember being on, I think it was in California, and I was on a whale watching thing near San Diego, and we saw dolphins hanging out with the whales. I mean, they were, and they were big whales.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. That happens all the time, socializing together and listening and reacting to each other's signals. It was interesting. I was just on an orca research boat a few weeks ago where we were off the north coast of Vancouver Island and we were kind of motoring around and observing orcas opportunistically. And we had a microphone in the water, so we were also listening to them as we were seeing them from the surface. And when white-sided dolphins come around these groups of resident orcas, they get really quiet.
SPEAKER_00And I think what's going on is the dolphins are almost like annoying them or distracting them in some way. And so they're trying to get them to go away, and they're like, oh, just don't talk, don't give them any reason to stick around. And then if the dolphins go away, they're a chatty again. And so it's almost seen as a form of encouragement, maybe if they continue to vocalize and speak.
SPEAKER_03That's so funny because that's totally how we anthropomorphosize dolphins. Like they're the chatty cheerleader animal that's like, hey guys, what you doing? What are you up to? What is that? Where are you going? Have you been there before? You know, we kind of make them little cartoons in that way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And so I do worry about anthropomorphizing too much. Like we could be projecting our own views of the world onto these other species. I think it's helpful sometimes, though. Like we do share a lot of similarities, especially with other mammals and thinking about family relations or wanting to form groups that are stable across our lives. And so some of the perspectives does transfer. It's just something we have to be really thoughtful and careful about. And that comes up a lot when we're studying communication, especially because we bring in so many of our own beliefs of like what a conversation looks like or what intelligent discussion looks like, even.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's so true. In some way, giving animals human qualities based on our observations can help with the goal of getting people to care about animals, because we care about things that are most like us.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I I guess I hesitate to answer because that's almost a fundamental limitation of our human perspective, is that it's really hard to relate when something isn't as similar. Like we don't immediately understand expressions of joy or fear or any other kind of emotions if they're not expressed in a similar way, which kind of gets us to this goal of like translating or being able to understand and interpret other species. So I have two minds about it.
SPEAKER_00I see the benefits, and I think it helps people relate, but also I want to be able to respect other species for their uniqueness and novelty and not be focused on, you know, human exceptionalism is like humans being our standard of what existence and consciousness and intelligence looks like and being more open to it manifesting in different ways. And I think that's a process that's going to take a long time and just like more exposure and time with other species and deeper understanding.
SPEAKER_03I can see where you're of two minds about it because on the one hand, it's an easy on-ramp to environmental ethic for those that have zero. And on the other hand, it can encourage that human exceptionalism that you talked about.
SPEAKER_00Which is ultimately what we're trying to get away from. I think. Like we're we're trying to increase our sense of wonder and awe at the world around us. But yeah, that's a funny thing about so much of the animal communication research being done today is that the suggested pathway to that is like understanding another species language, which gets us back to this really human way of viewing the world.
SPEAKER_03But there are lots of ways to absorb awe and wonder. And one of them is through hearing the actual vocalizations. And you yourself said that the way that you understood Orca's changed on that trip. Can you share about that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess. So one thing I think a lot about is human language has infinite flexibility. We can combine words in different ways to describe anything that's happening or any idea we have. And then when we're listening to another species, or you're going through sound clips of orcas, hearing all the different calls they make, one of the first things that I thought was like, wow, there's a pretty limited repertoire, at least of the signals that we hear really often, these whistles, they're making the same calls over and over again.
SPEAKER_00And so automatically I think that must be a limit in some kind of boundary around what could be expressed or like the possibility space there. And I know there is like variation within a signal type and other ways of like conveying information or meaning. But I started to think more about things like timing and repetition of signals and how just thinking about bird song, for example, you'll hear a bird sing the same few notes over and over and over again in the spring.
SPEAKER_00And the goal isn't just to like repeat themselves, it's more to induce a feeling in whoever is listening or evoke some kind of response. And so I started to think that there could be something like that happening with the orcas. And this emerged through conversation with the biologists who were living on the boat, too, of just thinking it could be timing or alternating, saying the same signal amongst different whales or repeating with more emphasis each time. So in that sense, I started to think about them differently. I also trying to think how else my view changed.
SPEAKER_03Well, I have a I have an orca clip. We can play it. It might it might inspire your memory. Okay.
SPEAKER_03I love that. That is so cool. I'm inspired. Just it's so the breaths in between are so neat. But I mean, what do you learn from listening to that? I guess what do you learn by listening? And because of the AI, how do you unpack that?
SPEAKER_00So as we were taking that recording, we also had somebody on the boat who's a professional photographer flying a drone looking down at the orcas. And so we could see this like live stream, watching them under the surface of the water, seeing what they're doing. And as they're making all of those sounds, they're often reacting to each other. And the group will be changing directions or changing behaviors or doing things like sharing a salmon that they're eating together. So in that sense, you start to really see how signals could correspond to meetings or different situations.
SPEAKER_00I think it gave me a real appreciation of their social bonds too. Like these are family groups that stay together for their whole lives and they must know each other so well and have such a deep familiarity. And you could hear it in that recording a little bit, but one thing that was really audible were motors of boats that were sailing around Vancouver Island. And at one point, a cruise ship went by when we were recording and the sound was deafening. Like you just hear this roar on the hydrophone, and we had a speaker set up on the boat.
SPEAKER_00So we were all listening to it. And the orcas kept vocalizing and they actually swam up around the cruise ship. So I think like even though the volume of the motors is making it harder for them to communicate, they were really curious and they, in some ways, seemed a bit habituated. So it brought up questions of like, have they adapted in some sense to get around this, what we call masking, this drowning out of their communication, or are they just not able to behave the way they usually would and they were stopping to look at the humans that are sort of interrupting their day?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think it's probably a lot of the latter. Like, we're definitely not helping them by being out there.
SPEAKER_03That's interesting. Because we are so centric to ourselves, we think, oh, look, there's an orca. Very natural. No one's saying that's bad, but we don't often stop to think that the orcas are like, hey, look, there's some humans. Let's go take a look.
SPEAKER_00Yes, one of my coworkers was saying that too. It took really being out on the boat for a while to see we're not just reacting to the animals, they're reacting to us too. And it goes both ways, and we're for sure modifying their behavior just by being out there.
SPEAKER_03So that's the thing we have to account for, also. Oh, I love that. Okay, so talk to me about dolphins because you've got some new dolphin research.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So we are collaborating with some researchers who have a long-term study of dolphins in Sarasota Bay. But what they're able to do is actually put tags on dolphins and sometimes do this with pairs of dolphins that are swimming next to each other. So they're getting a recording from each individual, and they're able to sit on the boat and observe what the dolphins are doing, get audio of what each is saying, and then start to understand how they're navigating the world together, how they're solving problems, how they're playing or having social interactions.
SPEAKER_00And this is really kind of the one of the big bets we're taking that I think is a really good approach. Like we're correlating use of different signals, certain structures or sounds that are made with certain situations. And if we have enough data, we can start to see these patterns of like, okay, every time these two dolphins are playing, they use a certain call. And so that must have some kind of function for that situation. And there's been a lot of work done on dolphin communication in general, and it's really focused on whistles, in particular signature whistles, which are almost like dolphin names.
SPEAKER_00So when a dolphin is young, it will kind of invent or come up with its own unique whistle that it adopts for its whole life and it will make it over and over again when encountering new dolphins or in different social situations. And it's kind of like a name tag. Like they are saying, I could say, I am Sarah over and over again. And it doesn't totally make sense when you think about human naming conventions. The dolphins do this, and then if they want to get the attention of another dolphin, they will mimic that other dolphin's whistle.
SPEAKER_00And so it's almost like saying, like, hey Meredith, listen to what I have to say, or somehow like making them know that the message is intended for them. So that's really interesting and incredible. But we're trying to look beyond these signature whistles as well and start to map out the functions of the rest of their vocabulary.
SPEAKER_03Dolphins are so interesting because there's, you know, they're so intelligent. And so I think when it comes to interspecies understanding, they're definitely, whether they want it or not, the poster child. Because, you know, it's not just now, but in the past, all of these animal experiments have been done on dolphins to try to either understand what they're saying or get them to speak English. In fact, when I was at the spy museum in Washington, D.C., I learned about the US government trying to make dolphins spies.
SPEAKER_03And I thought, wow, that's really incredible that that was an actual serious experiment that went on. But it does bring up the ethics part of it. If we succeed in interspecies communication with dolphins and other animals, how do we know that bad actors aren't gonna wanna, you know, make the dolphins spy slaves or something like that?
SPEAKER_00I mean, that's not a ridiculous proposition if the government has tried to do that before. And and really, humans have a pretty horrible track record of developing technologies like this and exploiting other people, other animals. So I think it's a real risk, even just thinking about the orcas we were just talking about. You can imagine if we started to understand the meaning of different orca calls, you could manipulate wild whales into coming closer to your whale watching boat by playing the correct signals to them or something like that.
SPEAKER_03Which I have done that in Colorado with my Merlin app. I'm I'm I don't know, I'm confessing now. But we were on a hike in a really, I don't remember what the name of the area was, but it was really populated. It was like paved, it was very nice. We were going around some big rock. And I thought I saw, I think it was a magpie. It was something like I don't see a lot here in the Florida panhandle. And so I looked up magpie and then found the call, turned my phone way up and then played it.
SPEAKER_03And the magpie came, sure shit, came out of the woods and it started dancing around. And we were like, oh my gosh. And then I felt that and then I turned it off. But I mean, the temptation's there. And obviously I succumbed.
SPEAKER_00Yes, and I've done that too. And that's kind of a classic birding technique, too, is like you do this pissing sound or something like that to make the birds perch on a branch and come close to you. So, okay, so then that gets into ethics. Like, where do we draw the line of what is satisfying human curiosity or serving even for entertainment versus what is somehow serving the other species? And what you did, I think is fine. And I think it's interesting to understand what other species react to. And then I guess the line there would be something like if you're stressing out the animal or you're causing them to not eat because they're sitting there waiting for you to play another sound from your phone.
SPEAKER_00But once we start to talk about actually applying some of the tools Earth Species Project is developing, like if we did have recorders out all the time recording whales across the globe, that's almost a form of surveillance. And the whales did not consent to that. And then so the responsibility is with us to decide that it's okay to do this kind of recording and to use that data for something that would benefit them.
SPEAKER_00And then I have pretty strong feelings about this. There's a lot of conversation in the media right now about having conversations with other species, like two-way communication. And there are certain organizations that have even created prizes trying to give a lot of money for research groups that show they have done this. And that end goal of having a dialogue with another species, I think is pretty hard to justify ethically. Like if another species wanted to interact and communicate with us, they would, and they do all the time.
SPEAKER_00And this isn't so if we just manage to do this using AI, I don't really see it helping them any more than like typical traditional conservation measures would. Where I think we're going to get benefit is if we start to better understand how other species are like using their resources, their environment, navigating the world, what kind of instincts or senses they have, ways of perceiving their surroundings and how they're reasoning and problem solving in those settings.
SPEAKER_00Because that's really intelligence, like how they're overcoming challenges. And so I think right now the way I see it is these organizations, like like me and the work I'm doing, we have to be really careful with our data. And make sure that if it's available, there are really strict guardrails around how it's used. We don't want people training AI models that are just like chatbots essentially to talk to other species. And I guess we want to have some kind of guidelines for how it could be applied.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I what else occurred to you when you were thinking of ethics? I'm curious.
SPEAKER_03Oh, I don't know. Like if we succeed in multiple marine species language understanding, for example, whether that is two-way or if it's more of a, you know, ethnography style of studying them, just listening and not interacting. I I kind of wonder if from that we will understand the hierarchy of the marine animal kingdom, you know, and if that would begin to cause us to see the waters as a sovereign nation run by the animals.
SPEAKER_00That's really interesting. So we would understand their social organization and then respect those rules and try to not interfere with it. Oh, I don't know if I've heard anyone suggest that before.
SPEAKER_03I mean, because when you think about it, I mean, it's like an it's it's an it's kind of like another planet. You know, when you go scuba diving, you're like, oh my gosh, I feel like I want another world. It's really cool. And there's the little cracks and pops of the reef, and everything is communication and you can hear, oh, the dolphin. Like I was, I was snorkeling a couple of weeks ago, and we were out at the artificial reef, and I had had my head underwater for a while. So I'd become accustomed to the baseline of sound.
SPEAKER_03And then I heard something change and I couldn't put my finger on it, but it reminded me of when we were in the Florida Keys and we saw a shark. Because right before we saw the shark, we heard some sort of like electrical, like it just sounded something was different in the in the reef in the collection of sounds. And I and I went up and the lady was like, hey, there's a dolphin coming your way. And I went down and there was the dolphin. And I just thought, oh wow, that's really cool. And so it kind of contributes to my thinking of the underwater world as another planet.
SPEAKER_03And if we just plopped our little selves on another planet, we would have to kind of abide by their rules and talk to their people, you know.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I really like that. It makes me think about, yeah, like when you go to another country, understanding the norms and learning how to not be rude and what is acceptable or not, like humans are absolutely not thinking about that at the moment. Well, I mean, we're we're trying to be quiet and just listen. But yeah, I think so much could be learned from it, especially when we're looking at interactions between different species or how they communicate.
SPEAKER_03Like, do we know anything about why, especially marine species, perform what we interpret as altruistic acts, like a dolphin helping a tired animal get to shore, or the whale that protects the snorkeler from the shark, or stuff like that? Do we have we learned anything?
SPEAKER_00Gosh, I don't know. I that's not an area I'm an expert in. Like my intuition would be that like there is a capability for first of all feeling pain, having a subjective experience, and then understanding that other individuals or other species have that as well, and attempting to assist in some way. And maybe it's learned from their own experiences reacting with other whales or dolphins. But I think there's something that they're reacting to where they're like, this is a person or an individual in distress, and I went to change that and they're doing what they can.
SPEAKER_00I know, especially when we're talking about within species, there's a lot of theory about like, oh, it's better to help your relatives because then you're kind of indirectly passing on your own genes. But I think it gets really interesting when animals that are not related help each other. That's kind of a lot more relevant to most of our human lives too.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And it's relevant. I mean, this is kind of like the opposite, but like the orcas who are attacking random boats, you know, like that that's relevant for the person in that boat. And it would be interesting to learn more about what they are saying when they're going to go do that? Why is there this collaborative effort to attack a boat that doesn't provide food that wasn't presenting a threat to you? Do you know what I mean? So I guess on on stuff that's kind of in that category, is Earth Species Project at all, from a research standpoint, able to reverse engineer and find maybe an answer to those problems by going, okay, we know orcas attack these boats in this part of the ocean.
SPEAKER_03Let's let's put a boat in that part of the ocean and get a microphone in the water.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's what we're eventually going for, maybe not necessarily with the boats, just because we're not studying the orcas there, but trying to recreate these naturalistic situations and almost make it an experiment where we have a prediction about what's going to happen in this exact context, and then we we set up the scenario and see if it plays out. I was talking to an orca researcher recently about the boat attacks, and their theory was that the orcas are playing and they're just having a good time.
SPEAKER_00And I think what that brought up for me is like, well, play is really interesting too. Like humans have different forms of play, and it would be fun to kind of get a better understanding of how that occurs in other species and not just play, but also more communication-based things like jokes, or do they have an equivalent of rhyming or like other kinds of word play? And I think they must, and I think we're just completely missing it right now because we're oblivious.
SPEAKER_03Oh, I want to know a dolphin joke. I need to know a dolphin joke. Also, do animals swear?
SPEAKER_01They have to, I would think. Like there must be like you said this podcast talks about taboos. There must be taboo topics of things that are like less acceptable to say. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's oh, I really like that as a study area too. I've I have kind of a short list going of things that would be interesting. I said farewells before saying goodbye. I think that's kind of fascinating. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03What about past and future tense? Are there any animals that will say, tomorrow I will do this? And hey, remember when Bob really messed up that, you know, food hunt we had? Stuff like that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's evidence that orangutans have a way of doing a past tense, and it can indicate that something happened, not now, but previously. And I think this is Adriano Lemera, who's a UK-based researcher, who's found that orangutans can talk about encountering a predator the day before. And that was kind of a scenario where they set up a fake predator going close to their nest. I and that's like that's a pretty big deal because in general, talking about language, there's sort of this very human-centric definition of what is language, and there's a list of characteristics that language has to consist of, and it's it's all about setting humans apart from other species and having like past tense or ability to reference things that are not present is one of those qualifiers.
SPEAKER_00And if we're showing that other species can do that, it kind of like overturns what we think language is.
SPEAKER_03Do animals talk about humans?
SPEAKER_00I think parrots have been shown to have names not just for each other, but also for other things in their environment, like inanimate objects, other parrots, but also humans or other like things they interact with. So they're definitely an example. But I think they all must have some way of indicating that people are present, if if that's a thing that happens in their lives.
SPEAKER_03What is the data showing as far as some of these more novel insights? Because I'm just, you know, spouting out my curiosities to you, but I'm sure you've come across some more, maybe not like benchmark insights from the AI interpretation of animal language, but something that more is in that novel understanding category.
SPEAKER_00There's a fun one from a study that I just finished up working with African elephants. And so elephants communicate with these very low frequency rumbles. Some of them are kind of below the range of human hearing, so you need a really good microphone to record them. And most of the time, it's not just one elephant rumbling, it's several elephants all rumbling simultaneously and they're overlapping one another. And we had this really big archive of recordings from a researcher that has dedicated her life to studying elephants and collecting data and following them around the savannah.
SPEAKER_00Joyce Poole, who's brilliant. And we were studying these rumble choruses, and we found that there's this pattern of convergence where towards the end of the course, all the elephants start to kind of resemble each other. Like their rumbles sound more the same. And I think that's cool because humans do that. Like we mirror each other and we kind of like use the same pacing or words or even like accents sometimes in conversation.
SPEAKER_00And it doesn't always happen in the elephants, it's it's just the situations where there's some kind of coordination as a group, like where they're deciding where to go next or like they're making a plan together, potentially. We think that could be what's happening. So also, it just like for me, it changes the way I think about a conversation. It's not people taking turns talking one at a time, they're all talking simultaneously, and there's like in the moment dynamic coordination, and that's how they're conveying information.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's so cool. We have that clip actually. Let's let's play that. So I think these are different elephants calling right now. Yeah, and so I think what that was, having seen that clip before, is a greeting.
SPEAKER_00So when elephants have been apart and they come together, they're they're saying hello. And sometimes the greetings get really interesting. They're very excited. So you have trumpets and like kind of growls, and they're very expressive. So it's like, what's up?
SPEAKER_03Like it's like that. Okay. Totally.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And then they also have one that our collaborator has named like a little greeting, which is when you're already you've already been together for a while in a group and you just kind of go up to somebody and say, like, oh, it's good to see you. Like a very personal acknowledgement that you're happy they're there.
SPEAKER_03That's so cool. Okay. Well, what about domestic animals? We interact with them a lot, you know, dogs, cats, stuff like that. Is there any research about their communication either with each other or in an attempt to talk to us?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there definitely is. So there are people out there who are designing like kind of communication devices for pets. Like you've seen these button boards for dogs, maybe where they're training the dogs that each button means something. They're working on doing some controlled experiments where they could like publish their findings from that. And my understanding is that cats are only meowing at humans for humans' benefit. Like they wouldn't necessarily be doing that if it were only cats hanging out, at least not the way they do when we're around.
SPEAKER_00And so it's a way to get our attention and tell us they need something or or want us for some reason. So I mean, I think this communication is happening all the time nonverbally, too. Just thinking about when a cat comes and rubs against your leg or something like that. So we're still we're getting an understanding of them. But from what I understand, like it's very early stages with decoding their vocal communication.
SPEAKER_03Hey, you know what's crazy? YouTube told me that only 3% of those of you who watch are actually subscribed to the channel. No matter where you enjoy the show, if you want to see me again, consider hitting subscribe or follow and turn on the notifications for new episodes. Okay, back to the show. Do animals have regional accents? For example, uh cardinal here in the south. Does it sound like Paula Dean, you know, bird style versus one in the Midwest?
SPEAKER_00Yes, they do. They completely do. Because I mean, so many of their songs are learned, or like birds learn what calls to make by listening to others. All the songbirds do. And so you're going to just kind of like learn from whoever you're around, and eventually, because of random copying errors, you end up sounding different if you're on different coasts.
SPEAKER_03I mean, that's just like a human language. That's just exactly the same.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And there's been some really cool research where they look at like migration when a bird leaves one population and moves to another part of the country. And they've shown that sometimes a bird will like just adopt the new accent, maybe so it fits in better, or maybe it wants to retain its individuality and so it keeps using its old songs. There's a really cool example from whales, like humpback whales have this amazing song. And in different oceans, whales are singing different songs.
SPEAKER_00And all the humpbacks in a population will sing the same song every year. But what seems to happen is that I think when they go south and they mix with other populations, like when they're all in Antarctica together, coming from different oceans, they hear snippets of other whale population songs and they learn those, and you get this kind of pattern where you have this whole like movement around the globe of songs going from one population to another, and it's just like slang words getting popular among humans.
SPEAKER_00Like you hear something you like and you start to use it, and then everyone in your friend group is using it.
SPEAKER_03This is so fascinating. But not everything is like a vocalization, right? Like, well, I mean, sometimes the cetaceans they're communicating either above or below our human hearing. But there's also my friend and yours, jumping spiders, they have a totally different way of communicating. And I think that research is so fascinating. Talk about what we've learned through Earth Species Project about jumping spiders.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, jumping spiders are incredible. So there's a professor at Berkeley that I worked with who has spent their career studying jumping spiders and many different spiders. Their name is Damian Elias. And so jumping spiders are really diverse. There are hundreds of different species, and they're very tiny, they're about the size of a pencil eraser. But if you get to look at them up close, they're beautiful. And I'm not even a big fan of spiders, but I think they're amazing. Like they have these really beautiful colors and they don't hear airborne sound, they only sense sound through whatever surface they're standing on.
SPEAKER_00And so it's like substrate-borne vibration, is what they call it. And to send a message, they'll do this tapping and they'll tap with their legs or feet, they thump their abdomen, they do like these dances almost. They call them songs and dances, where they're combining all these different sounds in a particular order that has some kind of meaning to whatever other spider is listening. And if they're standing on a leaf versus a stick or some kind of other surface, the sound will travel differently or have different characteristics.
SPEAKER_00So they will choose surfaces that best suit what kind of communication, how far they want the signal to go. And so I worked with this professor at Berkeley who has a kind of a recording studio in his lab on campus where he has these spiders standing on a surface and he points a laser. It's called a laser vibrometer. He points a laser at the surface they're standing on, and he's able to measure how much it vibrates when they do their dances and their thumping. And then we can basically treat that signal as it's a time series just showing how much vibration happens at each microsecond.
SPEAKER_00We can kind of treat it like a sound file, and we process it the same way we process other audio data. We train AI models to recognize, we call it a spider repertoire. So, like all the different sounds or like notes a spider can use in their song. We have models that recognize those, and then we can see the combinations they're used in and even recognize what species it is just based on the different signals that they're using. But I don't know, just imagining that like I know.
SPEAKER_03This is so cool. Like spider Morse code. Next time we have a jumping spider, my husband will get excited. Oh, there's a jumping spider. And so we'll we'll see if it will kind of play with us and like go from one hand to the other. Next time, I am definitely gonna be like, hello, my little friend, and like Morse code on the base of my palm to see if it like responds or something. I don't know. I'm conducting animal experiments over here. This all this stuff really tickles my inner animal nerd, obviously.
SPEAKER_03But for the broader audience, why is this work important? Especially because AI uses natural resources that the animals need.
SPEAKER_00Oh gosh. Wow, that's a great setup for the question because we do have to justify everything we're doing. Like every bit of compute we're using is using up energy. So I think there are a few big whys. The one I want to go to first is just like if we understand the world, we understand how other species communicate, we're getting insight into how they evolved, like how related they are to other species. So, like processes of evolution on our planet.
SPEAKER_00We're understanding how they use the different parts of the ecosystem, what they rely on, what they need for their survival. Hopefully, that's helping us do better conservation work or identify threats. I mean, really, what we're going for at Earth Species Project is the awe and wonder angle of just being amazed at the complexity of communication in other species and what it reveals about their family structures or how their societies are formed and maintained. So just appreciating that other species have rich lives that we might have kind of relegated to human existence in our minds and kind of inspiring curiosity and respect for that, and and bringing up the question of like, okay, if we understand that other species are this complicated or intelligent or advanced, like what should we do for them?
SPEAKER_00Like, what do we owe them in a sense?
SPEAKER_03Well, it's very anti-ego, which reminds me of something that the co-founder, Aza Raskin, said. He said that listening is the remedy to ego. And I wonder, I don't know, a scientific research, that whole community, since I've started the show and talked with, you know, lots of amazing scientists like you, I've learned that unfortunately it is wrought with ego, that there's infighting and politics and hierarchy is part of the unofficial hope of Earth Species Project to shift out of that, both in the broader population, but also in the scientific community that's delivering the message.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it absolutely is. And I think that's something we're going to become a lot more explicit about in coming years because it has been so much a part of public conversation lately, is talking to other species, for example. And I really like the comment about ego. And it also reminds me of something that one of the other founders said his name is Brit, where he thinks humans should work on becoming better listeners. And it's kind of really radical when you think about like, especially academics, your whole career is developed around like saying things and having people listen to you to just turn that on its head and be focused on understanding and not talking.
SPEAKER_00It's just taking a big in-breath. And like it's so easy to only exhale or only put things out in the world. And that just tunes you out to your own effect and what you're doing to others around you. So yeah, I love that description of it being about having less ego and decentering ourselves. Like I that seems really to be a big part of it too, is just how it's an innate thing.
SPEAKER_00Our view of the world has us at the center, but that's really not how the planet functions. And I think sometimes we need to like get a better understanding of what's happening around us to really see that that's the case because we can understand it theoretically, but it's not real until we actually see an example.
SPEAKER_03That's such a good point because that's like listening to those clips and being in nature, it helps you understand these things that sound so elementary, like, oh, everything's connected. You're like, okay, cool. What else you got? But when you feel it in a visceral way, it is transformative. I mean, it's like, I mean, we're on like, we're in mushroom terms. Trip territory, I feel like. You know what I mean? For transformation.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I feel like that's exactly the mindset. Like there's so many great psychedelic analogies.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, that is such a thing that's associated with psychedelics, I guess, is becoming more aware and appreciative of the world around you.
SPEAKER_03So I think it's completely anyone who's done ayahuasca had, and that's not me yet, but anyone who has has said like the message of we are one with the earth is so strong, you know. And that's part of why I have been following Earth Species Project for a while, is because I find, especially when Aza, you know, is out doing podcasts and stuff, I find him so interesting because he has the potential setup for a total tech bro.
SPEAKER_03But he's using tech with incredible researchers like you in order to create something that's a deeper meaning, but also like harder to put your finger on. And that's a challenge I think worth worth trying. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And and I think he does embody that. Like he he is curious. And I he started this organization. I've I've been at for a few years, and I think that's something we really try to hold on to, that and just being like playful and open. And yeah, going back to your ayahuasca analogy, I think people often describe that as something that's very kind of heart-opening or like brings you a feeling of love and appreciation for everything around you. And that's exactly what we're trying to accomplish as well.
SPEAKER_00And the barriers are not seeing past ourselves. And so just opening ourselves up to these possibilities of like other forms of intelligence, like information that we can't even perceive, like types of like society structures, conversations that have completely like different structure and patterns. So it's all part of this like shifting our view of the world, and just not realizing that we're not, I guess, yeah, realizing we're not uniquely special.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, you can still have wonderment and appreciation for yourself and others with knowing you're not the center of the universe. In fact, I think I I read one of your goals is to have a more integrated relationship with all species on Earth. Is is that a don't take this the wrong way, is that a realistic goal for Earth Species Project?
SPEAKER_00I mean, so I think it's phrased that way because in general, we want to do no harm and we want to make conditions better for all species. We're only able to study a handful at a time. So we're quite limited in how much deeper we can go with our understanding at a single step. But we are trying to build tools or or put ways of thinking out there that like let humans start to do that more broadly. I mean, but that's it's a big goal, and it it isn't just a few people doing it.
SPEAKER_00It kind of takes a societal level of change. And so that that is a big part of our effort is just like trying to change minds.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. I want to end with something else that Asa brought up because it kind of circles back to I think ethics and the real world, which is, I don't know, I hate saying that, but I think you know what I mean. Because you and I are like, yeah, then earth and you know, animals and oneness, and you know, and then it's like, and we're back. And we're back to the real world where, you know, people don't all have a robust environmental ethic.
SPEAKER_03And we as humans have real needs. We have real needs to eat animals, you know, some of us. We have real needs to put gas in our car and make, you know, make our community work. And so Aza said that there's three laws of technology. And the first is that when you create it, you uncover a new level of responsibility. The second is that if the technology creates an advantage, there will be a race towards that advantage.
SPEAKER_03And the third is if you don't coordinate, that race will end in tragedy. So I wanted to ask you what those laws look like in practice at Earth Species Project as you begin to decode animal language.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so there's a lot of effort in the research community right now to create some kind of agreed upon standards or rules for what is okay to do, like when you're studying animals, when you're recording them, what you do with their data. So we're trying to draft and put out our suggestions for those best practices in the world, I think, and also model them. Like a big way we do that is trying to actually take what we learn in these projects and turn them into some kind of real conservation impact.
SPEAKER_00Like, okay, we understand whales are communicating about these things and they care a lot about using this specific part of the world. Like, all right, so let's try to do something where we're slowing down the speed that ships can have when they're going through the maximum amount of noise they're exposed to. So, yeah, trying to actually like have some real outcomes from the research beyond just learning more that benefits other species. And I I guess I hope like clearly we're in the middle of this AI race that he described. Everyone's pushing forward.
SPEAKER_00I think we're trying to be careful with the amount of compute we use or how big our models are, all of that. But also just like put an example out there of a way to use AI that is not evil or not not like exploiting others, or frivolous. Yeah. Yeah, not even necessarily bad. Yeah, just try to give a few good examples of that. It is a little bit of a nascent field, though. So a lot of these norms or like agreements among researchers don't exist yet.
SPEAKER_00So we're just trying to be a part of the conversation and put forward our ideas about what we should do when we're operating in this role.
SPEAKER_03Well, I appreciate it. I think it is obviously very cool, but I also have a sense that it's very important. And I I really love getting your newsletters because I feel like I'm okay, what are they doing now? Okay, you know, and they're very detailed and they have like recordings sometimes attached to them so you can listen and interact. And in a way, it makes me more present when I'm just in my natural environment. And that doesn't really matter for, I don't know, research or like the bigger picture, but it makes my lived experience better.
SPEAKER_03And I think for that, it matters, you know, to me. So thank you. Appreciate it.
SPEAKER_01That's so great to hear.
SPEAKER_03Tell us how we can stay in touch with Earth Species Project. And if you have any hints that you can drop about what's next, I wouldn't mind hearing those too.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we're at earthspecies.org and you can sign up for a newsletter. We also have social media so you can follow us from the website. We're hoping to do more work with elephants in the future. And we're also going to continue working with crows, carry-on crows that live in Spain, which are amazing and brilliant and do all kinds of cool coordinated behavior. And yeah, expand our work with orcas too, maybe going even beyond the British Columbia population.
SPEAKER_03Well, that's exciting. I look forward to hearing it. Thank you so much, Sarah. Yeah, thanks. Thanks for listening. Since you've made it this far, I'd like to invite you to be a part of my private Facebook group. In there, I post content that I don't share anywhere else. You can talk to me directly, and I even do occasional giveaways. Search MFR Curious Insiders on Facebook or click the link in the show notes. If you liked this episode, you'll also like the one with the host of Shark Week asking if we actually need sharks. That's episode 254.
SPEAKER_03And stay tuned next week when I talk with a Sex Ed historian asking, should Sex Ed be taught in school? Until then, keep it curious.
Is a child actor different from a child influencer? What happens when the kid grows up & doesn't want their picture everywhere? The world of family influencers is one we all know, but what are the impacts of on the...
Could the “thinning of the veil” be something happening in a specific part of the brain? What does that tell us about the brain and the nature of consciousness? Jeff Tarrant, PhD, is licensed psychologist,...
Why is sex ed in public schools such a hot topic? Jon Zimmerman, PhD, is and public school teacher turned historian currently teaching history at University of Pennsylvania. He’s also the author of Too Hot to Handle: a...
Do subsidized marriage & reproduction work? What happened to “earth is overpopulated?” Elizabeth Nolan Brown is Senior Editor at Reason Magazine, a libertarian magazine that promises to exist outside the left/right echo...
Why do we shrug at grown men in body paint at a football game but cringe at an adult in Mickey ears? Are we judging an entire community by the loudest 1% the algorithm shows us? AJ Wolfe is a writer, speaker,...