Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Burning Archive

The Burning Archive artwork

The Migration Shock & Resentment of Lost National Cohesion

Sep 5, 202627 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

I have been thinking this month about three paired issues: migration and de/colonisation; the imagined cohesive nation and social fragmentation; and illiberalism and ressentiment. Several months ago I scheduled the topic of migration for this month’s Long Read. The news cycle has not let me down. From Ceuta to Saxony-Anhalt, even down here in Melbourne, banshees scream warnings of cultural death by migration. This Long Read reflects on how colonisation is inflected through two fundamental human experiences: migration and social differentiation. Read it all and become a paid subscriber at https://jeffrich.substack.com This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jeffrich.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello everyone, it's Jeff Rich here from the Burning Archive and I'm talking to you today about the migration shock and resentment of lost national cohesion, part of my monthly long read on decolonisation and migration. Part one, you can read it all at jeffrich.substack.com. Thanks for listening either at Substack or on the podcast.

SPEAKER_00I have been thinking this month about three paired issues, migration and de-slash-colonisation, the imagined cohesive nation and social fragmentation, and illiberalism and And resentment. Several months ago, I scheduled the topic of migration for this month's long read. The news cycle has not let me down.

SPEAKER_00From Ceuta to Saxony and Holt. Even down here in Melbourne, banshees scream warnings of cultural death by migration. This long read reflects on how colonisation is inflected through two fundamental human experiences, migration and social differentiation. We are colonizers and colonized.

SPEAKER_00We are people on the move who displace and distinguish ourselves from outsiders while craving some communal identity. It is a piece assembled in fragments, but two questions generate the reflections. How do the legacies of decolonisation manifest in the migration debate? And how do ideas of nation and cohesive identity block us from understanding

SPEAKER_00the deep history of human migration? Two ethical stances shape what I have written. First, we should not fear the migrant or the stranger within. We should make the stranger a guest. We should acknowledge we all came from somewhere else. Second, in a tangled interdependent world, we should not stand behind the banners of nations or civilizations.

SPEAKER_00We are all Creoles now. And I will publish this long read in two parts as well. This first part is for all subscribers. The second part, coming early next week, will be for paid subscribers. In 2026, the theme of my monthly long reads is decolonization. Become a paid subscriber to dive deeper into world histories and cultures.

SPEAKER_00And there's a subscribe button post in the article. And if you're listening on the podcast, why not head over to jeffrich.substack.com and become a paid subscriber now. Upcoming interviews with Malin Laruel and Tariq Cyril Amar. This weekend, an election in the German land of Saxony-Anhalt is expected to lead to the AfD,

SPEAKER_00forming the first far-right government in Germany since the 1930s. Their success is driven by resentment at migration and the new illiberal politics. Next week, I will be talking to two expert historians on the meaning of these events, both right here on Substack, and I recommend them both. Tariq Siru Amar is a historian who I have interviewed previously,

SPEAKER_00and his Ninth Wave Substack and podcast includes regular reports on the thing about Germany, including... German earthquake incoming on the upcoming German elections. And Marlene Laruel is Professor at Luiz University in Rome and Director of the Illiberal Union. Illiberalism Studies program at the George Washington University.

SPEAKER_00She writes Vivitopia, a Substack on political imaginaries, lived ideologies and our political futures. She's one of the world's leading experts on illiberalism and Russia. I will post these interviews to Substack and YouTube. Don't miss them. Resentment and Migration. The rebel right party, one nation, challenged for pole position in Australia on a surge of scapegoating of migrants.

SPEAKER_00And I've got a link to some of the comments. Polling data in the Post. This weekend, One German Land votes with migration top of mind on whether to convert the Alternative for Deutschland into a party of government. In Spain, Vox calls for a Christian Reconquista through an expulsion rebranded as Remigration. In France, Rassemblement National proposes to fine Muslim women for wearing a headscarf.

SPEAKER_00Little Britain spews nonsense about civil war and peasant rebellions and its influences are amplified by the USA's delusional oligarchs. Occupy Mars conquistador Elon Musk and doomster of the Antichrist Peter Thiel. Whether or not Europe is burning, the USA's Nero's are singing silly collapse songs to light the flames of hate.

SPEAKER_00Resentment of the migration of strangers into the high mat, the sub-German word for homeland, inextricably tangled with decolonisation, pollute the airwaves, both mountains. Mainstream and Alternative. Schaele's Resentiment is in the air, poisoning the global hive mind just as it did at the start of the 20th century crisis of the world.

SPEAKER_00And here I have a quote from German philosopher Max Schaele from his book Resentiment from 1913 on the eve of World War I. The ressentiment is a self-poisoning of the mind which has quite definite causes and consequences. It is a lasting mental attitude caused by the systematic repression of certain emotions. Emotions and affects, which as such are normal components of human nature,

SPEAKER_00their repression leads to a constant tendency to indulge in certain kinds of value delusions. The emotions and affects primarily concerned are revenge, hatred, malice, envy, the impulse to detract and spite. The liberal and illiberal Wests spiral into the nihilistic abyss.

SPEAKER_00There's a link to my article on Emmanuel Todd's theory of nihilism in the West. Revenge, hatred, malice, envy, the impulse to detract and spite because they have poisoned their minds with horror stories of mass migration and the miscegenation of the nation. The grand strategists of the West have long squirmed when confronted by the inconvenient facts of migration which cross borders in their mental maps

SPEAKER_00of national or civilisational identity. In 2004, the Clash of Civilizations guy, Samuel Huntington, wrote Who Are We? The Challenges to America's National Identity, which argued immigration, particularly from Latinx. He threatened US America's waspish national identity. White Anglo-Saxon Protestant.

SPEAKER_00He just forgot the differences of the Spanish legacy and the European immigrations from the 19th century as Felipe Fernandez Armesto graciously argued. I've got a link to my article on America is a Hispanic nation in the post. Migration invites the question of who belongs to my precious nation or civilization state.

SPEAKER_00It reminds the believers in identity in one nation that they live among strangers who they displaced by war, empire, colonization and its aftermath and the globalization of goods, ideas and labor. Indeed, they depend upon these outsiders. Migration history and identity.

SPEAKER_00More piercingly still, history reminds the resentful natives that they are migrants too. There's a quote, Bill, the deepest irony is that humanity itself would not exist without migration. Human history is above all the history of movement, encounter, A mixing and transformation among peoples from different regions of the world.

SPEAKER_00The very civilization that today builds walls was created by those who once crossed them. That's by Biljana Vankovska from her article, Sayuta, as a moment of reflection, what the crisis revealed about our world, 7th of August, 2026. The deep, long history of humanity is a story of migration and its frequent travelling companion, colonisation.

SPEAKER_00This story emerges when you let go of the shallow, short histories of national identity which so dominated historiography until the 1980s and still dominate all schools of international relations. When you let go of the mirages of nation and civilization, you stop building walls of identity and traps of resentment. As Biljana Vankovska writes, you instead build bridges between differences.

SPEAKER_00You let the poison of exclusion seep out and make the stranger a guest within you. You learn to love plurality, which is the antidote to the noisy minority who preach belonging to one nation. History teaches this lesson, but so too, I long believed, did living in the society of Australia.

SPEAKER_00We are a micro world of humanity's story of migration. Near to one third of the country was born overseas and half have a migrant parent population. It is part of the Australian way of life. The Australian migration story began long before 1788 and was shaped between 1820 and 1920 by the age of mass emigrations from both Europe and Asia.

SPEAKER_00After 1945, successive waves of increasingly diverse economic, humanitarian and refugee migrations turned post-colonial white Australia into a successful multicultural society comfortable in its own skin and mixed Creole soul. Or so I long believed.

SPEAKER_00Events over the last few years, the COVID shutdown of borders, the cancel Russia campaign and Ukraine war, protests against South Asian migration, conflict over the Israel-Palestine issue, The Bondi Beach terror attack, the Royal Commission into Anti-Semitism and Social Cohesion, imported illiberal nationalist media influences have delivered to Australia

SPEAKER_00the same migration shock. Stirring panic across the world. But I will not be panicked by illiberal spite into choosing a single national or cultural identity. I am happily Creolised. I use this concept, Creolisation, which I discovered by Marlene Laroel's essay, The Invention of Two Frances When Politics Empties Identity Rushes In,

SPEAKER_00Which discusses the French left's adaptation of Édouard Glissant's concept. And to quote Édouard Glissant, Traité du Tout-Mont, the trait of... Treatise on the whole world from 1997. I call Creolisation the meeting, the interference, the shock, the harmony and the disharmony between cultures in the realised totality of

SPEAKER_00the earth world. I accept my displacement on this post-colonial migrant home. I do not fear migration. My hunch is most Australians, despite the polls, do not fear it either. What I fear is the resentful repression of the harmony and the disharmony of cultures by a noisy minority who believe in single,

SPEAKER_00nostalgic national identities. Fear and the Migration Shock. The Migration Shock is a grand purr. In Migration Panic at Ceuta, Civilisational Identities and European Peasants Wars, which explored how decolonisation conditioned how migration was weaponised in Ceuta

SPEAKER_00in 2026. I pointed out how fear was more important than any conspiracy theory about the invasion of that small Spanish enclave. To quote from the article from a couple of weeks ago, the deeper story is fear, fear of migrants,

SPEAKER_00fear of strangers, fear that a flash mob the size of a small football crowd represents an invasion. That exposes allegedly borderless Europe. Fear of interdependence and our need for strangers like all those irregular migrants in Spain or Mexican workers in the USA who did a dirty work others avoid. Fear that society is fragmenting in ways that make impossible

SPEAKER_00a single cohesive identity for Europe or Australia or the West or any other imagined political community. Fear that entanglement with other cultures will undermine the invented tradition of Western Civilization. I wrote the piece without realising quite how much support for anti-migrant rebel right parties in Europe and here in Australia had surged.

SPEAKER_00I began to wonder afterwards whether the grand purr of migrants masked a deeper fear, the loss of communal identity. Contemporary societies may be too fragmented to cohere. Social cohesion may not be the right goal for any nation anymore, and certainly not if dictated by a majoritarian ethnic culture.

SPEAKER_00A better goal may be the coexistence of plural social imaginaries, Marlene Lareal's term. We can all agree to disagree without trying to erase our differences. But to do so, we will need to tamp down the fear, loathing and incitements to violence. We will need to relearn how to talk civilly with and about strangers.

SPEAKER_00But the liberal and illiberal West have taken an exclusivist turn in recent years. We don't talk to the strangers within. We deplatform and re-migrate them. In the old metropolises of greater Europe, discomfort with interdependence on migrant strangers grows like a cancer. Old covenants of harmony in diversity have shattered.

SPEAKER_00On the right there are shrill screams of remigration and reconquista to expel the invasion of Northampton. On the left, discomfort manifests in other ways, such as a touching faith in national sovereignty, or a preference for the absolute truth of class over other forms of belonging,

SPEAKER_00or a barely concealed contempt for outsiders beyond the left bank pail. Like Hindu or Hindu nationalists or Zionists. In the opportunistic centre, technocrats tweak migration numbers and political operatives exploit ethnic voting blocs in their games of electoral politics.

SPEAKER_00The nation no longer coheres, not in blood and soil, not in tradition or assimilation, not in multiculturalism or strength in diversity. The Western imaginary of migration has become a tangled mess. The exaggerated Ceuta European migration crisis was not a surprise to me.

SPEAKER_00For years I have observed the discomfort with multiculturalism and demonisation of mass migration across the political spectrum in Europe and the USA. But what really shocked me out of complacency was how the Murdoch media in Australia led the charge around the world to exploit fears of migration and fan flames of resentment. Then, after long ignoring it,

SPEAKER_00I noticed One Nation's 2026 surge to attract one quarter of Australian voting preferences. What the hell was going on? I am still unsure, not dazed, but dismayed and confused. There are many superficial analyses of this surge of anti-migrant feeling focused

SPEAKER_00on electoral politics. Too few commentators demonstrate Biljana Bankowska's wisdom to reflect on the deeper roots of displacement, diaspora and empire. Quoting from Ceuta Asimovic, The West creates the refugees then builds walls to keep them out. This is not a crisis of migration. It is a crisis of Western imperialism and its consequences.

SPEAKER_00It is that and it is also a rebel yell in the social imaginary. Expressing resentment at migration has become a form of rebellion against the professional managerial class and liberal speech codes. As Marlene Laravel argues in Who Owns Rebellion... Anti-establishment, transgressive politics has moved from left to right.

SPEAKER_00Quoting from Who Owns Rebellion, the contemporary writers learn to offer something different. Permission. It invites people to say what they have been told not to say and to enjoy the act of breaking a rule. At least some of them. This is a sharp reversal from a traditional right once associated with censorship and moral regulation. Part of its appeal now lies in making transgression feel pleasurable again.

SPEAKER_00All of these explanations help quieten the panic. So too does taking a longer term, deeper perspective, the deepest you can take, look. Part 2 of this monthly long read will take you on a tour through that deep history and share my vision of how we can overcome the new ressentiment and build bridges

SPEAKER_00between islands of estranged societies. Thanks for reading, Jeff. But P.S. Do check out these videos and guest appearances during the week on Jamal Thomas, CIA Chief's secret Moscow mission. He was picking up bodies, Dr. Jeff Rich. And on Peacemonger with Ian Proud,

SPEAKER_00US vassals, why perfidious Britain and post-democratic Europe can't end the Ukraine war. Ian's title, not mine. Jeff Rich. Ian and I discussed my article this week, The Urgent Need for a Peace Plan for Ukraine. There's links to all of this content in the And on the Burning Archive, do check out my videos, Space, the most important decision of the 20th century.

SPEAKER_00And my clip from my interview with Nel Benila, NATO 3.0, The Empire Strikes Back Against Its Own. And from the archive on the themes raised in this piece, check these earlier essays. World Crisis, Social Progress versus Social Fragmentation from July 2023. Goodness, three years ago. And my island diaspora home from 17th of April 2024, two years ago.

SPEAKER_00And from earlier this year as part of my slow read of poetry in a time of war and trauma. Dislocated identities in migration and history. Where I introduce you as part of my series of slow readings of poetry in our time of war. And I introduce myself to the poet Mina Alexander, 1951 to 2018, and her wonderful poems. Do check them out. Thanks for listening. And do head over to jeffrich.substack.com

SPEAKER_00and become a paid subscriber or become a member at my Burning Archive YouTube channel. Bye now.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Your Invitation to the Burning Archive Live Conversation

    Oct 30, 20265 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit jeffrich.substack.com You are invited to my Monthly Live Call with paid subscribers will be Saturday 31 October at 8:00 AM Melbourne time (+10 UTC). This is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Other Europe: How Europe Chose Freedom, Truth and Unity in 1989, But . . .

    Oct 9, 202624 minAudio

    In 1989 peaceful revolutions reunited East and West Germany and Eastern and Western Europe. It was year that Europeans chose freedom, rejected socialism, bound democracies in an ever closer union, and embraced “living...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Other Europe: 1848 and the Rite of Passage of Liberal Modernity

    Oct 3, 202631 minAudio

    When you think of Revolution, what year and place in world history do you see in your mind? Is it Philadelphia in 1776? Paris in 1789? Petrograd in 1917? Prague in 1989? Or the revolutionary spring in Europe of 1848?...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Other Europe: Istanbul and the Crossways of Civilizations

    Sep 26, 202627 minAudio

    In the second of the Other Europe series, historian Jeff Rich narrates the stories of the Other Europe hidden behind the myth of the Great Schism between the Western and Orthodox churches, and in many eyes,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Other Europe: The Pagan North and the Ragnarök of Climate Change

    Sep 19, 202623 minAudio

    In 540 CE a volcano erupted at Ilopango in today’s Guatemala. It changed the course of European history. This is how the story of Ragnarök began. Not with a Roman whimper, but a Central American bang. Welcome to the...

    Credit the people on this episode