Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

The Burning Archive

The Burning Archive artwork

The Other Europe: How Europe Chose Freedom, Truth and Unity in 1989, But . . .

Oct 9, 202624 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In 1989 peaceful revolutions reunited East and West Germany and Eastern and Western Europe. It was year that Europeans chose freedom, rejected socialism, bound democracies in an ever closer union, and embraced “living in truth.” It was also the year that USA strategists armed the Gates of Europe to expand NATO ever eastward. Thirty-six years later the fabric of the Velvet Revolution is stained and torn. Did Europe choose freedom and truth in that heady year, or did 1989 make Europe into a vassal of the Atlantic Ring of Power? Read it all at https://jeffrich.substack.com This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jeffrich.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome everyone, it's Jeff Rich here from the Burning Archive at jeffrich.substack.com and I'm talking to you today about the other Europe, how Europe chose freedom, truth and unity in 1989 and then lost them to gain the Atlantic Ring of Power. In 1989, peaceful revolutions reunited East and West Germany and Eastern and Western Europe,

SPEAKER_00or at least most of Eastern and Western Europe. It was the year that Europeans chose freedom, rejected socialism, bound democracies in an ever closer union and embraced living in truth. It was also the year that USA strategists armed the gates of Europe to expand NATO ever eastward.

SPEAKER_0037 years later, the fabric of the Velvet Revolution is stained and torn. Did Europe choose freedom and truth in that heady year? Or did 1989 make Europe into a vassal serving the Atlantic Ring of Power? Welcome to the fourth and final post of my other Europe series.

SPEAKER_00Timothy Garton Ash, the British liberal historian and journalist, was a witness, participant and celebrant of these events, especially as the Velvet Revolution unfolded in Prague. These days, he writes on Substack, with deep concerns about the future of Europe. Ash was certain, however, that... 1989 was some velvet morning akin to 1848.

SPEAKER_00Human character, at least as it is realised in political life, would disappoint him. On the 20th anniversary of 1989 in 2009, Timothy Garton Ash wrote, quote, 1989 was the biggest year in world history since 1945. In international politics, 1989 changed everything. It led to the end of communism in Europe,

SPEAKER_00of the Soviet Union, the Cold War, and the short 20th century. It opened the door to German unification and A historically unprecedented European Union, stretching from Lisbon to Lynn, the enlargement of NATO to decades of American supremacy, globalisation and the rise of Asia. Well, of course it did not change human nature, Timothy.

SPEAKER_00Why would a supposedly serious scholar so muddy the waters? Or was it too? To create a new other to Europe, the menacing Russians, in order to shepherd the fearful and vengeful former members of the other Europe into that US-American offensive alliance, NATO. And other questions occur to the inquiring mind. Did the Cold War end?

SPEAKER_00Did history itself not return? What of Britain's departure from the EU in 2016? And how did Europeans outside Timothy's well-paid circle of Anglo-American intellectuals really feel about decades of American supremacy, globalisation and the rise of Asia. Especially when NATO proved to be a case of American militarised debt trap diplomacy

SPEAKER_00and the USA sabotaged Europe's energy supplies from Russia in the service of its NATO crusade in Ukraine. In my reading, 1989 made Europe but did not change everything. When the Berlin Wall fell, the western third of Greater Europe, the USA and Russia invaded Eastern Europe and set its sights on implementing Churchill and Truman's unthinkable operation to colonise Eurasia via

SPEAKER_00the expropriation of the Soviet states and the co-option of China into Neil Ferguson and Henry Kissinger's vision of Chimerica. The Berlin Wall fell, yes, but then the sinkhole of Europe opened. For 25 years, the Atlantic elites partied on the safe edges like it was 1999. They partied in freedom in the Garden Party of Europe until the war

SPEAKER_00in Ukraine exposed post-1989 Europe. As American occupied territory. And European culture looted to become an American trust fund of Western civilization. Can Europe remake itself outside the American invention of the West? In this week's essay, I dip into three stories of this transformation.

SPEAKER_00And there's a picture, by the way, of Angela Merkel from in 2008 in the post there. So three stories of this transformation. The unconventional Czech writer and dissident who became a conventionally Atlantis president in 1989, Baslav Havel. The East German Angela Merkel who found freedom in 1989 and whose chancellorship of Europe makes her the key political figure of post-1989 Europe.

SPEAKER_00And the European Union itself, whose story of integration, exit, challenge and subordination since 1989 contains more possibilities for the future than most believe. Book Recommendations, Merkel, Havel and Embattled Europe. Biography is one of the best ways into history. Autobiography is one of the best ways into leaders' minds, if, that is, they write it themselves.

SPEAKER_00This week I offer recommendations for both in a leading historian's assessment of a progressive alternative for Europe. Angela Merkel has written her biography, Freedom, 2024. The Australian political scientist, John Keane, wrote a biography of the central yet hard to pin down figure of 1989 history. In Eastern Europe, Václav Havel, A Political Tragedy. In 6 Acts 1999, John has a Substack as well, if you would like to check out his work.

SPEAKER_00And I've got a link to Professor John Keane's Substack. In the post. My third recommendation enables us to reflect on some of the contemporary challenges for Europe as a civilisation state in the current world. Conrad H. Jarosz embattled Europe, a progressive alternative. 2021. Jarosz is a distinguished historian of 20th century Germany.

SPEAKER_00I referred to his work in my responses to Babylon Berlin and to Neil Ferguson and Jordan Peterson on The very Anglo-American interpretation of the German question. Conrad Jarosz embattled Europe. Among the micro-community of commenters on geopolitics and world affairs on YouTube and Substack, I take a minority position. I defend Europe from the trash talk that is especially common among the

SPEAKER_00The American affiliated community. Europe has its problems, but it has many strengths and many aspects of its social model and political system are far more attractive to this antipodean exile than American pioneering rhetoric. I discuss some of the intellectual origins of the binary contrast of free USA versus shackled Europe in my American world history tour.

SPEAKER_00And I have links to my posts, Greater Europe's Western Frontier and Europe after the post-war world order in the post. Conrad Yarosh, Embattled Europe, a progressive alternative, presents a similar case that Europe is. Not a hopeless case. The European itself contains more possibilities for the future than most believe. Embattled, Europe presents a historically documented defence of the contemporary history.

SPEAKER_00European model. Compared to the USA, Jarosz argues, Europe has three advantages over its Atlantic partner. First, it has a more truly democratic election system which engages citizens and demands Politicians leave the bully pulpit to build coalitions. Second, Europe has more robust welfare states, even after the demands by a succession of USA leaders that Europe act like

SPEAKER_00the frontier gunslingers of the American free market. He does not quote this statistic, but readers of Emmanuel Todd and this Substack know that Europeans live on average four to five years longer than the Americans of the Wilder West. Third, Europe shows more peaceful international behaviour than the USA. Being more peaceful than a state that has been at war for all but 17 years

SPEAKER_00of its existence, however, is not a high bar. Europe's way of life is better, despite the screeches of a thousand podcasters and hillbilly harangues of J.D. Vance. The United States could learn a thing or two from its, quote, European vassals. Jarosz provides stories of the transformations of 1989. He writes, quote, An enormously important reconfiguration of Europe

SPEAKER_00whose implications are still being worked out. The upheaval of 1989 to 1991 ended seven decades of ideological competition between the liberal capitalist and dictatorial communist blueprints for modernity, thereby concluding the Cold War. As we know, however, it also ushered in a new Cold War that has now become a permanent attrition war. Yarosh wrote his book in 2021 in the faith that, quote,

SPEAKER_00Joseph Biden as American president in 2021 offers an opportunity to engage in a renewed transatlantic dialogue about progressive solutions. How wrong can you be? Despite this blind spot, Yarosha's book is a welcome corrective to the distorted histories and predictions of Europe in the West and Perhaps it is time for Europeans to broaden their dialogue

SPEAKER_00beyond the transatlantic ring of power and embrace a different kind of dialogue in a multi-civilisational world. Václav Havel and Political Tragedy. John Keane's biography of Václav Havel issues the fairy tale of the playwright-made dissident-turned-political-leader Václav Havel, A Political Tragedy in Six Acts 1999, is an intriguing book, if now perhaps a little dated and maybe superseded by more recent biographies

SPEAKER_00of Havel. Havel is a tragic figure in Keane's account. Quote, My democratic form of tragedy turns its back on talk of unchanging human nature. It also rejects the bias of classical tragedy towards fixed hierarchies of worldly power whose victims were to play things of aristocracy. The political tragedy that follows is simply the sad but inspiring story of an individual whose astonishing life was pushed and pulled,

SPEAKER_00twisted and torn by all of the tumultuous forces of a century. Thankfully, which is now past. But Keane's dictum expressed the buoyant liberal democratic optimism of the 1990s. History would have its revenge. That is the thing about history. The past is not dead. The past is not even past. Harville has long fascinated me,

SPEAKER_00both his writings as a dissident and his reflections on his experience in power, a very unusual fate for a dissident. Keane presents the saintly dissident who taught the world a different way of power, more velvety than the bloody 20th century. History since has not been so kind to this optimism and triumphalism. Harville himself wrote an intriguing autobiography to the castle and back,

SPEAKER_00published in English in Another Fateful Year for Europe, 2002. I rate it as among the best of autobiographical writings by a political leader. If you can get a hold of it, it is well worth a read. There is much more to Harville than is presented by keen Timothy Snyder or Timothy Garton Ash. His great essay, The Power of the Powerless, contains ominous anticipations of Of the troubled Europe that Europe would make

SPEAKER_00after 1989. I discussed it in this video, The Power of the Powerless in the Empire of Lies, Baslav Havel and the West. And there's a link in the post at jeffrich.substack.com and go to my YouTube channel, The Burning Archive YouTube channel to find it. You might also like to check out my podcast discussion of Havel from one of my earliest podcasts, which you can link to via Substack or Spotify,

SPEAKER_00The Parallel Polis and the Power of the Powerless from July 2021. Yeah, five years or more ago. Which discusses that important idea of the parallel polis. There is also a good documentary showing for Australian readers on SBS On Demand. That showed, called The Art of Dissent. It documented how dissidents rebuilt society after 1968 in Czechoslovakia.

SPEAKER_00And included scenes of Havel during the events of 1989. You will also be able to judge for yourself the extent to which Timothy Garton Ash latched on to Harvard and the memory of the 1989 revolutions for his own self-promotion. Angela Merkel and the Chains of Freedom. Angela Merkel's freedom includes some brief reflections and observations of the events in 1989.

SPEAKER_00She recalls how in Eastern Europe in the late 1980s, it was not only the model of the West, but the great reformer Mikhail Gorbachev who inspired change. Gorbachev and his wife Reza were in turn deeply influenced by participants in the Czech Spring. Their ideas transformed Europe, even if we hide his contribution in the West today, especially in the USA. Merkel wrote, Ever since Mikhail Gorbachev had become General Secretary of the Communist Party of

SPEAKER_00the Soviet Union in 1985, and the buzzwords glasnost and perestroika had been on everyone's lips, events were set in motion throughout the Eastern Bloc. By 1989, Merkel was a young scientist who would travel occasionally to the West as a result of Gorbachev's glasnost ideas seeping into the hard line East German regime. She recalled returning from a trip to West Germany for research on 5th of November 1989.

SPEAKER_00Quote, The day before, hundreds of thousands of people had taken part in a demonstration in Berlin. There was a buzz throughout the country and great changes were on the horizon. It was scarcely possible to concentrate on scientific work anymore. Four days later, all travel restrictions were lifted and the Berlin Wall began to be dismantled. Merkel could barely believe the news and her mother was so adapted to the routine

SPEAKER_00of life in restricted East Germany, she barely paid attention. But Merkel took her new freedom and joined the procession, leaving the communist world behind. Soon after, she became active in politics and made her choice of aligning with the Christian Democratic Party under the man who unified Germany and With Gorbachev's help, Helmut Kohl, she would ultimately rise to become Chancellor and serve as

SPEAKER_00the leading political leader of Europe from 2005 to 2021. Angela Merkel undoubtedly made contemporary Europe. Some say her departure in 2021 removed the only Western statesperson capable of preventing the war in Ukraine and security. A civil partnership between Europe and Russia. Without 1989 and the young conscientious scientist choosing freedom and the West,

SPEAKER_00Europe would be a different place. Let me quote Merkel's reflection on this year that made her choice for freedom and that made... Quote, I had brought down the wall. Here I had grown up. Here I had tried to skirt around the obstacles set up everywhere by the state like

SPEAKER_00a skier on a slalom run. I had tried to make the best of the situation, always to remain curious and enterprising, to do no one any harm and to push myself to the limits of my capabilities wherever possible. I knew the parameters inside out. I had been very lucky. When the wall came down, I was 35 years old, still young enough to start afresh. I had no idea exactly how things would unfold.

SPEAKER_00But one thing was beyond doubt for me. West Germany's structure could not be reformed from within. She chose freedom and celebrated the value throughout her book. Yet her idea of freedom was very European, not American libertarian. It was the kind of freedom celebrated in its own way through Merkel's East German past.

SPEAKER_00Quoting Merkel, true freedom is not only freedom from something, from dictatorship and injustice, but shows itself in responsibility for something, for one's neighbour, for the community, for our common good. Concluding thoughts on Europe and modernity. There is much wisdom in Merkel's reflections on her life,

SPEAKER_00and it is a valuable corrective to many of the caricatures of Merkel in the Anglo-American media, especially in the alternative media. Her reflection on true freedom, responsibility for something, helps us to integrate Jarosz's democratic modernity, Havel's power of the powerless, and Merkel's way of making the European community. Responsibility for something is the great contrast between Europe's social model and

SPEAKER_00the transatlantic libertarian model, now hallucinating on uppers with the tech bros and nihilist supremacist oligarchs. And Václav Havel said something very similar about how to practice politics as a powerless person with no foothold or status in the system of professionalised, manipulative politics, democratic or post-democratic. He wrote, quote, I favour politics as practical morality,

SPEAKER_00as service to the truth, as essentially human and humanly measured care for our fellow humans. And it was this kind of practical morality that led Harveld to write of Lech, Valesa and all the others who made Europe unique. In 1989, quote, It is becoming evident that politics by no means need remain the affair

SPEAKER_00of professionals and that one simple electrician with his heart in the right place honouring something that transcends him and free of fear can influence the history of his nation. Or indeed of the other Europe to become within the greater world. Thanks for reading, Jeff.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Your Invitation to the Burning Archive Live Conversation

    Oct 30, 20265 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit jeffrich.substack.com You are invited to my Monthly Live Call with paid subscribers will be Saturday 31 October at 8:00 AM Melbourne time (+10 UTC). This is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Other Europe: 1848 and the Rite of Passage of Liberal Modernity

    Oct 3, 202631 minAudio

    When you think of Revolution, what year and place in world history do you see in your mind? Is it Philadelphia in 1776? Paris in 1789? Petrograd in 1917? Prague in 1989? Or the revolutionary spring in Europe of 1848?...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Other Europe: Istanbul and the Crossways of Civilizations

    Sep 26, 202627 minAudio

    In the second of the Other Europe series, historian Jeff Rich narrates the stories of the Other Europe hidden behind the myth of the Great Schism between the Western and Orthodox churches, and in many eyes,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Other Europe: The Pagan North and the Ragnarök of Climate Change

    Sep 19, 202623 minAudio

    In 540 CE a volcano erupted at Ilopango in today’s Guatemala. It changed the course of European history. This is how the story of Ragnarök began. Not with a Roman whimper, but a Central American bang. Welcome to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Illiberal Imaginary of One Cohesive Nation & Interview with Marlène Laruelle

    Sep 12, 202635 minAudio

    This week the world has debated illiberalism, migration and nostalgia for national political communities. I spoke with one of the world’s leading experts on these issues, Marlène Laruelle, historian, sociologist, and...

    Credit the people on this episode