This week I interviewed Nel Bonilla about the concepts of empire that underpin her analysis of the “imperial cage” that is NATO 3.0. The world is surely becoming more multipolar, but does that mean the grip of empires on our lives is any less? “We should be intellectually honest enough to recognize that a shifting balance of power is not the same as dismantling the imperial cage.” (Nel Bonilla) Watch the interview on YouTube and read Empire: A User's Manual at https://jeffrich.substack.com This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jeffrich.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello everyone, it's Jeff Rich from the Burning Archive at jeffrich.substack.com and this is my post from the 29th of August, 2026, How to Break Down an Empire to Leave the Imperial Cage, Nel Bonilla Conversations and Empire, a User's Manual for Survivors of the Bunker State War. And you can read this of course at jeffrich.substack.com.
SPEAKER_00This week I interviewed Nell Benilla about the concepts of empire that underpin her analysis of the imperial cage that is NATO 3.0. The world is surely becoming more multipolar, but does that mean the grip of empires on our lives is any less? A quote from Nell Benilla. We should be intellectually honest enough to recognize that a shifting balance
SPEAKER_00of power is not the same as dismantling the imperial cage. And the YouTube video of the interview is available. The link to the YouTube video is available in the post. Do share and like and subscribe to the Burning Archive YouTube channel and share the video to help boost it and like and comment on the video to boost it in the algorithm.
SPEAKER_00Nell Benilla on NATO 3.0's Imperial Cage. The topics we discussed were Nell 1, Nell's approach to writing in a multipolar world and making senses of changes not seen in a hundred years. Two, the advantages of conceptual awareness over naive realism in diagnosing world systems. Three, Nell's assessment of the multi-layered cage of NATO 3.0.
SPEAKER_00Unveiled at the Ankara Summit. Four, the domestic consequences of NATO 3.0's perpetual war. Five, the structure and remarkable resilience of Western empires. Six, resistance to empire, the model of decolonization and China or BRICS alternatives. Six, Seven class and empire and the need to rethink elites versus the people debates.
SPEAKER_00We discussed several of Nell's recent essays during the conversation, all of which are indispensable for understanding how the USA led world system operates and how it may be at the same time both disintegrating and reassembling. They include, and there's links to all these articles in the post, NATO 3.0, the transatlantic cage and the rise of the bunker state, multi-polarity in a multi-layered cage, where has all the class analysis gone?
SPEAKER_00I have had the pleasure of interviewing Nel twice before, and there's links to the YouTube videos in Iran, the West trapped itself in the bunker, Nel Benila, and China is trapped in an imperial world that is not collapsing anytime soon, Nel Benila. And I recommend that you do. And I will be continuing this conversation in a series that explores some of
SPEAKER_00the frontiers of thinking about the world systems and models of multipolarity. I am very much looking forward to learning from Nell during these conversations, including her deep knowledge of Latin American history, politics and culture. And there's a link to Nell's paid offer on Substack, The General's Silence, The People's Song, A Companion Guide to Latin American Resistance in the Post.
SPEAKER_00Empire, A User's Manual. During the conversation, Nell and I discussed both concepts in the history of empires and indeed the theme of decolonisation that is the base rhythm of so much of my writing this year. And I've got a link to one of my early long reads. This year, a brief history of decolonisation since 1776. It goes without saying that there is a sprawling regime of intellectual debate over
SPEAKER_00the concept and history of empire. Some pretender republics, like the USA, refused the sobriquet of empire, preferring instead euphemisms like hegemon, great power, leader of the free world or architect of the post-1945 liberal rules-based international order. As a result, the strategic culture of the USA, including the various forms of international relations,
SPEAKER_00realist theory, struggles to admit its colonising past and imperial plans. Many USA-affiliated historians play along with this narrative of history in which the old world of European Empire was Disappeared after the new world of nation held sway. But the best historians are not so easily fooled.
SPEAKER_00The doyen of historians of empire, John Darwin, wrote that, quote, after 1945 US-American Governments assumed huge new burdens all around the world and wove a web of alliances to help in their upkeep. The result was the creation of an American system, imperial in all but name. That's from After Tamerlan, The Rise and Fall of Global Empires 1400-2000 by John Darwin.
SPEAKER_00We all still live in that imperial cage, but exits may be appearing. The cage expanded mightily after 1991. The bars of the cage twisted grotesquely as the Atlantic elite turned with nihilistic venom on European and other allied partners, including Australia. After the financial crises of 2008-2014 and the populist-nationalist backlash from 2016,
SPEAKER_00The torsion applied to those iron bars by Washington's latest old, mad, blind, despised and dying king, and there's a link in the post to the poetic reference I'm making there, however, may bust the bars and release the prisoners. And there's a quote from Mark Carney, Prime Minister of Canada on the 22nd of August as part of his breaking off of negotiations with the USA on punitive tariffs and a link to an article on it.
SPEAKER_00We cannot accept what they've offered and we will not give what they've asked. They asked too much and offered too little. There is at least an opening, even though the USA's sadistic guards still stand over the imperial cage. To make the most of that opening, leaders and citizens of the world need to stop being bedazzled by
SPEAKER_00the US-American strategic culture and its mystification in many forms of its imperial domination. Nell Bonilla's work helps you do that. And there's a quote from Nell's article. By demystifying what the US-led empire is planning and attempting to implement, we reclaim our shared horizon. Understanding the architecture of NATO 3.0 is the prerequisite
SPEAKER_00for effective counter-planning and the creation of counter-institutions at scale, institutions capable of finally breaking us out of this multi-layered cage. That's Nell Bonilla in NATO 3.0, the transit Atlantic cage and the rise of the bunker state. So does quality global history when cleansed of US-American institutional bias.
SPEAKER_00While reflecting on the conversation with Nell this week, I consulted the Oxford World History of Empire, Volume 1, The Imperial Experience, edited by Peter Fibigdar, Bang, C.A. Bailey, Chris Bailey and Walter Scheidel. It contains an opening essay that brilliantly surveys the complex, contentious field of sociological, historical and geopolitical writing on empire.
SPEAKER_00The chapter title Empire, a World History Anatomy and Concept Theory and Synthesis by Peter Fibiger-Bang provides two synthesizing schemas that can reorient your thinking about empire. And here in the post I have an aside for you to rethink the Roman Empire in World History. As an aside, especially for readers keen for a better history of Rome and the West,
SPEAKER_00about which so much nonsense spews every day. Peter Fibiger-Bang published in 2025 a book, The Roman Empire and World History, Key Themes in Ancient History. This leading scholar reframes the story of Rome, the empire, the USA still compares itself to. Here is how the publisher summarises the work. Quote, How do we fit the Roman Empire into world history?
SPEAKER_00Too often the empire has simply been conceived of in terms of the West. But Rome was too big to be squeezed. . . . . .
SPEAKER_00It was a world before East and West. The book traces surprising cultural connections and societal similarities between Rome and the other vast empires of Afro-Eurasia. Whether we look at war-making, slavery, empire formation, literary culture or intercontinental trade and rebellion, Rome is best approached in its Afro-Eurasian context. That's from the blurb for Peter Fibber-Jabang, The Roman Empire and World History.
SPEAKER_00Four Forms of Empire The article surveys both Western and non-Western concepts of empire and endorses a minimal definition proposed by Michael Doyle, Empires, 1986. Empire is a relationship, formal or informal, in which one state controls the effective political sovereignty of another political society.
SPEAKER_00Such relationships extended long before 1492 and did not disappear in 1945 or 1991. Any Australian who unwillingly through AUKUS hosts the USA's nuclear submarines or is subjected 24-7 to syndicated media from Washington DC or witnesses
SPEAKER_00the regurgitation of USA sourced talking points by local ministers and media identities, Knows one state in this world still controls the effect of political sovereignty of my island home's political society. Using this definition, the Oxford World History of Empire distills the many theories of empire into four themes which were sown in J.A.
SPEAKER_00Hobson, Imperialism, a study. From 1902. And flowered far afield ever since in texts by Lennon, Wallerstein, Schumpeter, Gilpin, Gandhi, Aaron, Weber, Mann, Saeed, Mackinder, Kennedy, Ludwig and more. It is a remarkable synthesis. The four themes are, one, an economic strategy to monopolise markets or empire as capitalism.
SPEAKER_00Two, a form of aristocratic or, as Nell would say, Ruling strata, class, interest or empire as leadership privilege. Three, an ideological system and mode of identity formation or empire as identity and culture. And for an expression of interstate competition or empire as international competition and geopolitics.
SPEAKER_00These themes crystallize in specific historical. The result is a bewildering range of views on this contentious word. Peter Fiverger Bang remarked, the arguments will not stop anytime soon. Quote, Empire has been too important and many cited a historical phenomenon to allow
SPEAKER_00For consensus to develop or for the various approaches to fuse. No false prophet should convince you there is a predictable pattern to how empires always behave. But Peter Fibbage's Bang Simple Synthesis provides you a user's manual to how empires work. And I will return to it in my conversations with Nell and other writing.
SPEAKER_00The manual ought to be used with the narratives of real empires of world history, living and dead, and not with the mechanical schemas of abstraction. The manual shows the dimensions of Field of Empires, but, and this is an extended quote from the Oxford World History of Empire, but how these different dimensions and basic characteristics
SPEAKER_00of imperial power worked out in shifting combinations over time. Can hardly be expressed satisfactorily in a simple abstract model. To capture the rich variety and changing weights of phenomena. To weave the different threads together and reveal historical development. The only viable strategy is narrative pursued at different levels of generalization. That's a quote from the Oxford World History of Empire, Volume 1, The Imperial Experience.
SPEAKER_00The second volume of the Oxford World History of Empire provides those narratives by leading historians of the imperial phenomena that stretch from the Bronze Age to the 20th century and spread across every continent and ocean. I will continue to share these stories with you on the Burning Archive. They will enlighten you, unlike the cartoon comparisons of every empire with the rise and fall of Rome.
SPEAKER_00Nine Lives of Empire. But now let me list the eight phases of empires in world history. This user's manual sets out, quote, to take a global view and determine the predominant orders and trends that In the long world history of empire, from the perspective of the four key theoretical parameters of protection costs, elite formation,
SPEAKER_00cosmopolitan culture and military rivalry, Each phase of empire is accompanied by a world map, which I will return to and share over time. The eight phases are 1. Bronze to Iron Age, the Near Eastern invention in quote marks of empire, 3rd millennium to 300 BCE. 2. The Classical Age,
SPEAKER_00culminating in In the formation of large world empires on the margins of Eurasia, the Mediterranean and China, 323 BCE to 600 CE. Three, the ecumenic turn, eclipse of the old world and the rise of Islam, 600 to 1200. Four, the Mongol moment. The rise of Genghis Khan and the Central Asian Steppe followed by regional reassertion 1200-1450.
SPEAKER_005. Another world, the separate but parallel path of imperial formations in the Pre-Colonial Americas. Sixth, the Great Confluence. The culmination of Universal Empires and the conquest of the New World. Agrarian Consolidation and the Rise of European Commercial and Colonial Empires, 1450-1750. Seven, the Global Turn. The Age of European Colonialism, Subjection of Old Agrarian Empires.
SPEAKER_00To the European-led world economy and nationalist secessions, 1750-1914. And eight, the 20th century, the collapse of colonial empires and the rise of superpowers. The story continues beyond the margins of this book into the 21st century. But how will that ninth life and its map unfold?
SPEAKER_00After a century of decolonisation, some of us may live in post-colonial societies, but none of us have as yet dismantled the imperial cage. What will be the story of empire in the 21st century? The degeneration of one superpower into a saturnine bunker state that ate its children and its allies.
SPEAKER_00The rebirth of global empires as elite competitive multipolarity. The subjection of the old Atlantic empires to the Chinese-led world economy. An equanimity and comity of great states rarely seen in world history. Will we flee the Imperial Cage or will some old, mad, blind, despised and dying Emperor collapse the walls of the bunker with
SPEAKER_00a grandiose delusion of limited nuclear war and bury us all in the ashes and ruins of all the world's civilisations? I do not know. History neither repeats nor predicts. My hope is that within a decade or two, we all live in a less US American and less militarized world.
SPEAKER_00But that will not happen, I fear, without a violent confrontation with an empire that has brought 250 years of endless wars and contempt for strangers. We can cross the threshold of the imperial cage that Washington built, but only if the world outside of the USA confronts the monster their minds made master.
SPEAKER_00I hope my writing and conversations with Nell Benilla can make that happen. Thanks for reading, Jeff.
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit jeffrich.substack.com You are invited to my Monthly Live Call with paid subscribers will be Saturday 31 October at 8:00 AM Melbourne time (+10 UTC). This is...
In 1989 peaceful revolutions reunited East and West Germany and Eastern and Western Europe. It was year that Europeans chose freedom, rejected socialism, bound democracies in an ever closer union, and embraced “living...
When you think of Revolution, what year and place in world history do you see in your mind? Is it Philadelphia in 1776? Paris in 1789? Petrograd in 1917? Prague in 1989? Or the revolutionary spring in Europe of 1848?...
In the second of the Other Europe series, historian Jeff Rich narrates the stories of the Other Europe hidden behind the myth of the Great Schism between the Western and Orthodox churches, and in many eyes,...
In 540 CE a volcano erupted at Ilopango in today’s Guatemala. It changed the course of European history. This is how the story of Ragnarök began. Not with a Roman whimper, but a Central American bang. Welcome to the...