Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

TBD NYC

TBD NYC artwork

Episode 47: Elon Green’s The Man Nobody Killed: Life, Death, and Art in Michael Stewart's New York

Mar 5, 202546 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Elon Green talks with Rachel Holiday Smith and Harry Siegel about the direct line from the Transit Police beating Michael Stewart to death in front of horrified art students in 1983 to Eric Adams being elected mayor in 2021 - one that intersects with Madonna, Jean-Michel Basquiat, Spike Lee and Tucker Carlson.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02It's with NYC, the New Yorkers show about the ABCs of arts, books, and culture. I'm Harry Stigel, executive producer of the FAQ NYC Podcast Empire, and senior editor at the nonprofit newsroom the city, here with the city's managing editor, Rachel Halliday Smith. Hello.

SPEAKER_00Hey, Harry.

SPEAKER_02Hey. And we're joined right now by Elon Green, who's the author of The Man Nobody Killed, Life, Death, and Art in Michael Stewart's New York. The book's out on March 11th, and it's about, you can order it now, the fatal beating at the hands of New York's transit police of 25-year-old aspiring downtown artist, DJ, and model Michael Stewart, whose killing in 1983 became a huge story, front-page tabloid news, and a rallying cry for artists in the circle, including Madonna, Keith Harring, and John Michelle Basquiat.

SPEAKER_02Much later it helped inspire him to do the right thing, Spike Lee. Elon was last on the pod in 2021 to discuss his book, Last Call, A True Story of Love, Lust, and Murder in Queen, New York, which was adapted into an HBO series, also Last Call. It's great to have him back with another deeply reported old New York story as he digs into a past that, as Faulkner said, is never dead, is not even past. There's a ton happening in 1983 that's still reverberating now.

SPEAKER_02For example, early in the Man Nobody Killed, the book recounts a congressional hearing on police brutality days after Stewart's beating while he was still in a coma before he passed. Saying that, quote, when you are polarizing the city on a racial basis, then you are doing damage to the very fabric of the city, you have to be condemned. Police brutality, as Anna continued, is a false, phony issue.

SPEAKER_02It wasn't even a year later that a member of Dowtree's Church in Brooklyn, a young man named Derek Adams, who'd been beaten by the cops himself when he was a teen, was sworn into the NYPD, having accepted his reverence calling to infiltrate the department and change it from within, a story Adams has often recounted during his political rise.

SPEAKER_00All right, welcome back to the pod, Elon, and let's jump right in. Thanks, Harry. Before we get into the very serious and sort of dark parts of your book, of which there are many and they're very important, I wanted to focus on the really sort of fascinating and joyful world that Michael Stewart lived in, downtown New York in the early 80s. The book is full of all these delightful details in The Man Nobody Killed, where these larger than life figures pop in and make cameos. It's amazing. Like Basquiat just hanging outside of a club and lending Michael the money to get into the club, or Michael almost sort of spontaneously ending up in Madonna's very first music video, which I found to be so incredible.

SPEAKER_00Could you just tell listeners a little bit about Michael Stewart's life and how that downtown scene shaped his life and his death?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it it's a really an amazing uh intersection of all these different scenes. Um, and I think a lot of it is due to the smallness of the neighborhood at the time and the uh frankly like crappiness of the East Village, which meant that the people who were living there, it was a real self-selecting group. It was people who didn't want to pay a lot in rent, but knew that they could use the space for creative means.

SPEAKER_03And so it attracted, you know, incredibly uh you know creative filmmakers and artists and musicians, you know, famously so. And although Michael was not at the level of a Boschia or a Herring, um, you know, he was in that orbit because he worked at the Pyramid Club and was uh dating the same woman uh as Basquia, Suzanne Malouk.

SPEAKER_03And you know, as because of the smallness that I mentioned, you couldn't help but know everybody. Totally.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it really got had that sense. The intersection of all of these people was just amazing, and it really made me think about where those scenes exist in New York today, if at all. Because to me, I'm at a loss when I think where would he live? Where would Michael Stewart live today? And where does that type of scene exist in New York today? I don't know. Do you have an answer? Have you thought about that? Where is that?

SPEAKER_03I don't know, but part of the reason I don't know is because I am not 23 anymore. I mean, when I when I was, I was living in Williamsburg and uh, you know, paying, I think it was$700 a month for a bedroom on the north side uh of Williamsburg. And I don't know where that is now or or if it still exists.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, neither do I. And I should say I am not 25 anymore, and perhaps I don't know about those things because I have moved on from that stage of life. That is fine, but I really was at a loss. I was like, man, there's there's just not that many pockets of New York that are affordable and filled with artists anymore, but that's another story. Um, so I want to move into the the nuts and bolts of of what happened to him because um I want to remind people of of the the who, what, where, one, why of this story, because I like to think of myself as an informed New Yorker.

SPEAKER_00I know a lot about things that happened around Stewart's death. You know, the Bernie Goetz case was happening around in the same year. A lot of people know about that. That's notorious. I know a lot about that, but I had never heard of this story. I'd never heard of Michael Stewart's story. And I don't know why that is. I don't think it's because of a lack of reading or awareness on my part. I think it's just gotten lost. Um, do you agree with that? And why do you think that is?

SPEAKER_03100%. Um, you know, the only people that I talked to that had, you know, really vivid memories of the story and of the particulars were people involved. Now, if you lived in Manhattan at the time and you were reading the news, then you you also knew about the story. I mean, it really did um permeate the consciousness of New Yorkers at the time. Um, I talked briefly to Fran Liebowitz about it once, and she said, you know, everybody from you know my age remembers the Michael Stewart case.

SPEAKER_03The trouble is most of us are dead. And I do think that there's some truth to that. You know, the the people who for whom the the story mattered have have passed. And I think part of you know why it seems surprising now that people don't know about the story is that it was so much bigger and there was so much more going on than it really seemed at the time. You know, when I would explain to people close to the story, whether it was the lawyer for the cops, um or or you know, people who were close to Michael, or people in the prosecutor's office, like all these things that I had learned, including about you know bombings that had happened in response to, uh, in response to the case, nobody knew anything.

SPEAKER_03And part of that is that, or maybe lar a large part of it is there was so much going on at the time. There were so many police brutality cases, there were so many bombings going on at the time that you know, if you looked at the what happened to Michael in its various, you know, discrete pieces, there wasn't really anything extraordinary about it. You know, only in retrospect is you know the role of Madonna really interesting.

SPEAKER_03Back then, you know, everybody knew Madonna to such an extent that I eventually thought it was weird if someone didn't have a Madonna story for me. Love that.

SPEAKER_00Um could you give people just the the Cliff Notes version of what happened to him? Just the the brief synopsis uh for folks who had never heard of this, like I had not. Sure.

SPEAKER_03Um you know, late at night, early in the morning, September 15th, 1983, um Michael Stewart, a 25-year-old black man, aspiring model, uh DJ artist, gets dropped off um at the First Avenue, 14th Street subway, where he uh plans to take the train home to Fort Green, Brooklyn, where he lives with his parents. And uh allegedly a transit uh policeman named John Costick um catches him defacing the subway wall and uh takes him into custody.

SPEAKER_03Um one thing leads to another, he is you know loaded into a vehicle and uh driven uh to the precinct, District 4 in Union Square. Uh, but before he is able to be booked, um he makes a run for it. And eventually, surrounded by 11 transit police, he is beaten in full view of I would say at least 30 freshmen at Parsons uh as well as others.

SPEAKER_03And 13 days later, dies uh uh after being in a coma at Bellevue Hospital. Um and even before he died, um his cause, you know, his his death uh and his beating had become uh a huge cause uh in New York. And it was very quickly the most notorious and most paid attention to act of police brutality in the city's history.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um I want to just take a quick detour to talk about those Parsons students, because the time you spent detailing what they saw was really one of the most riveting parts. Um and the descriptions of what they all collectively remember, particularly, I don't want to spoil anything, but some of these details just really stick with you. The the way that um Michael's body was loaded into the van, they all remember the same thing that he was just thrown, you know, like a sack of potatoes, um, that that was really seared into their minds.

SPEAKER_00How did you find them to talk to them again? Um, and you know, how much do they or have they been affected by what they saw back then?

SPEAKER_03So as far as finding them, I mean, luckily this was an exceedingly well event, you know, I don't believe in spoilers really. Like eventually this does go to trial. And as I, you know, the trial was covered by Jimmy Breslin and Murray Kempton and Isabel Wilkerson. And so the names of many of the witnesses are all were already in the papers. Um, but once I started calling around, I would hear, you know, and I would hear about more of them.

SPEAKER_03Eventually, uh there would be reports, you know, that came out because of investigations ordered by the city and the state. So there'd be more names in there. Uh, I would also be given names of witnesses who didn't cooperate with the district attorney's office. Um, you know, ultimately, the the real numbers, probably around 40 uh people who saw what happened or heard what had happened, you know, depending on what side of the dorm you were on. Um as to the degree that this affected all of them, I would say without exception, these students were radicalized.

SPEAKER_03Because at the time, uh not a one of them had anti-police, uh, had an anti-police bias, had a skepticism of law enforcement. Um, this includes, you know, the two black students uh that I interviewed. They were sort of just as uh, I would say their feelings towards the police were just as uncynical as anybody else's in the dorm.

SPEAKER_03These were 18-year-olds who had never spent any time in New York City. And the assumption that they were under as they were watching this beating was that, well, whoever it was really deserved it. Not one of them called the police, right? On the police. Not one. And and I didn't belabor this in the book, but it's it's very interesting to me that, of course, the this is a little bit of a tangent, but you know, the term bystander effect came out of the Kitty Genovese case, where the story uh planted by Abe Rosenthal of the New York Times was that 38 uh, you know, people watched the uh killing of Kitty Genovese and nobody called the cops.

SPEAKER_03And of course, that was bullshit. However, this is a case uh where it really was the bystander effect, and not a single person called the police um as they were watching Michael being beaten. And ultimately what it came down to was that as you know, one of the witnesses said to me, can you even call the cops on the cops?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. I mean, and the fact that they were freshmen, I mean, it's like, um, how can you expect these brand new people um who have no experience with New York City or with maybe police to, you know, uh take ownership over the situation and to try to get some accountability for what's going on in front of them.

SPEAKER_03Um yes, and and and and as I was as I meant to say, what they saw and then eventually endured with the trials um and the grand jury radicalized all of them. I mean they many you know, decades later had about you know the most sort of jaundiced cynical view uh of law enforcement and of the criminal justice system generally, as anybody I've ever talked to.

SPEAKER_00Well um speaking of the law enforcement system, I wanted to talk about um the medical examiner in this situation um who drew some of the most um intense anger from kind of everybody um who were pissed about Michael Stewart's death. And he was really um controversial. There were multiple investigations of him around this case. Uh there were allegations of a cover-up by him.

SPEAKER_00And I wanted to ask you about him, what you think of his role there, but more broadly, sort of how much we can ever be angry with or um, you know uh, you know, take blame to medical examiners when there's a controversial killing like this.

SPEAKER_03Well, so you know, Elliot Gross is is an interesting case. He was uh he was somebody who was pretty good at one part of the job, which was the the science part of the job, and he was really bad at the other half of the job, which is communicating. Because, you know, if you're the chief medical examiner of New York, that is part of the job. And um, it wasn't always part of the job, but the uh, you know, after John Lennon was killed in front of the Dakota um, you know, Ed Koch's office said, you you know, you're gonna have to start talking to people when they when it when enough of them call.

SPEAKER_03Um but you know, with Gross, a lot of what happened to him was, I think, certainly in hindsight, a victim of um bad journalism, but also people's uh desire to find somebody to blame. And, you know, he was pushed into making a statement uh, you know, right after the preliminary, uh, right after the autopsy.

SPEAKER_03And he was very clear to reporters that the results he was giving were preliminary and that further testing would be done uh prior to you know a final conclusion about what had killed Michael Stewart. Uh but when you know the the the what uh what happens unfortunately is that once he comes out with you know his revised opinion, people view that as a flip-flop, which it wasn't.

SPEAKER_03It was merely a sharpening of his opinion. Now, down the line, he does actually change his mind about what uh you know caused the death of Michael Stewart, but it's because you know, further tests and uh you know further uh consultation had been done with experts. And I think what strikes me as tragic about what happened to Gross is that as a public, we want somebody like him to know upfront immediately exactly what has happened to the person who has been killed.

SPEAKER_03Instead of lauding what he did, which was to ask people that he felt were more qualified than himself uh to give their opinion about certain aspects of the case, and which eventually shaped his final conclusions, uh, which he he gave during the trial. And you know, and I don't think there was anything wrong with that. And you know, Elliot Gross was certainly an imperfect medical examiner and made a lot of mistakes over the years, and and certainly made mistakes in the Stewart case, uh, in including, you know, not you know, revising the cause of death uh, you know, on Michael Stewart's death certificate when he should have.

SPEAKER_03But I don't think that you know understandable mistakes should be equated with malice.

SPEAKER_00I I have to say I really um felt the frustration of what I'm sure people felt at the time reading all of his input, because I don't know, you watch you watch crime shows and you want the medical examiner to like cut somebody open and do the autopsy and then be like, this is what killed them. And right.

SPEAKER_03Um and and and and the thing, and and the truth of the matter is that while from the outside, the the chief medical examiner of New York or the chief medical examiner of any major city, you know, looks like it would be a prestigious position, um, in New York at least, it's you know pretty poorly paid. I don't know if he was making$60,000 a year, and you know, you're being overworked, you're handling far more cases than uh budget will will really allow.

SPEAKER_03And, you know, I find the fact that he could even take the time to personally oversee any autopsies kind of remarkable when you consider how many people were being killed uh in New York in any given year during that that you know those decades.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, the scale of how many homicides they had to deal with or deaths in general was staggering. I think people do forget, um especially people who weren't here at that time.

SPEAKER_03Um and and and and I should say with with Ellie Cruz, you know, my feelings about him changed over the course of working on the book because when I began work, I assumed that what I was reading was true. And I thought, oh, well, this guy covered up, you know, the the cause of death, and eventually I'm going to find out how exactly that worked. Uh and then, you know, every time I I got another uh you know government.

SPEAKER_03Ordered report, including, you know, one that was directly investigating his office, the conclusions were totally opposite of what people actually believed. And part of why, you know, that that myth essentially that there was a cover-up in the medical examiner's office really upsets me is that it completely overlooks the fact that there really was a cover-up, except it was on the police side when Internal Affairs was told that there was this beating in Union Square, and they very firmly decided to do exactly nothing about it.

SPEAKER_03Now that's a cover-up.

SPEAKER_02So, Elon, a lot of this gets picked up and understood in bits and pieces at the time. And, you know, I'm thinking about this a lot. Like, we're journalists in our daily work, like we're dealing with a first draft of history. And it's a messy first draft. And the more of a given thing that's happening, it's a lot happening nationally and locally right now, the harder it is to zero in on any any one thing, any one death, for instance, or murder.

SPEAKER_02You know, there were, I don't have the numbers in front of me, but 1983 there were 1400, 1500 murders in New York. Uh police shot many, many, many more bullets and killed many more people than they do now. And you have the space in this book to unpack a lot of this. Uh, and as it's happening at the time, and as this very young man, right, who's just sort of forming and figuring out his life, is uh beaten up, tossed into the back of a place, ends up in the hospital, dies uh weeks later, um, gets to the medical examiner, has his eyes removed.

SPEAKER_02Uh, when you have a preliminary cause of death, all this happens. And then by the end of this year, you have a terror group, so to speak, the UFF, that's blowing shit up in his name, and like tying this to what's happening to black and brown people in Central America, as I think we mentioned very briefly earlier, you know, Spike Lee picks up on what happened here and a different telling of the story. Uh and so a guy's life becomes a story in Do the Right Thing.

SPEAKER_02Like, as you're going back and looking at how this was covered in real time, and then trying to do not a first draft, tell the story in full. What what what stands out to you about that, about how it was understood and processed, what was honest and true about his life, and people, Madonna doing, you know, shows for the family and things like that. And and what just with the pace of events was misunderstood and washed away?

SPEAKER_03Actually, for the most part, the reporting was excellent. Um it really was mostly the you know, the the biggest mistake really was that sort of willful misunderstanding of the preliminary autopsy. But once you get past that, uh the quality of the journalism around the case was was actually really good. I mean, even the you know, initial version of what had happened that was put out by the spokesperson for the transit police, which was utter horseshit, and you know, characterized Michael as like basically a violent uh coke fiend, was not widely believed.

SPEAKER_03You know, and and you know, Murray Kempton in particular makes a point of saying you can't really believe what the police say in the aftermath of an incident like this. I mean, I was sort of shocked at how modern a lot of some of the response felt.

SPEAKER_00I I feel exactly the same way, actually. Many of the um quotes, speeches um from the protests, from the family's attorneys, from some of the Jamie Breslin columns you were quoting. Um just felt like they could have been ripped from today. Uh, they could have been ripped from the Black Lives Matter protests in 2020. It really depressed me, to be honest, to read all those things and think, God, we we haven't progressed at all since the 80s.

SPEAKER_00I mean, it's just it's like the same stuff over and over again. Um actually, that brings me to a thought, which is um are are there you did a lot of interviews for this book. I you can tell. I mean, the depth of reporting isn't very, very good. There's snippets in there that are great details, but you can tell there was a four-hour conversation below the surface there. Um, and I want to ask, in those conversations, were there any um pieces of solutions thinking around police accountability that you wanted to share?

SPEAKER_00Were there any genuine sort of silver linings from this or kind of moments where someone said this thing or this approach or this moment felt like something that would actually hold police accountable um in the future? Because spoiler alert, um all of the people involved in this case were not um convicted of what happened here. Do you have an answer to that?

SPEAKER_03Well, the short answer is no. Um, you know, for a while when this was all happening, it looked like that idea of omission liability might be a way to prosecute police. And I think you can actually draw sort of a fuzzy straight line between the prosecution of the police in New York in 1985 and years later the prosecution of Derek Chauvin and others and the killing of George Floyd.

SPEAKER_03They don't call it omission liability, but it's more or less the same idea behind the charges. However, I also wouldn't read that much into it. I mean, you cannot possibly look at the landscape of law enforcement prosecutions and think we've made any real headway. I mean, I don't think you have to look really any further than you know, the agency set up uh or the office set up by Andrew Cuomo, the special prosecutor, to deal with um uh you know police uh violence and come away thinking that this was at all a success.

SPEAKER_03Now, a lot of this you know should be laid at the hands of grand juries who are still reluctant to indict police. Uh I think that there's probably a greater willingness on the part of you know prosecutors to do this than there is on the part of grand juries. And, you know, while Saul Walkler may believe that any sufficiently skilled uh prosecutor can indict a ham sandwich, that's only true if the grand jury is willing to do so.

SPEAKER_00I kind of loved the the process part of the book where you talked about the grand jury and the characters on the grand jury for this case. But just as a New Yorker who likes to know things, I just enjoyed sort of seeing how grand jury works because I actually got called for grand jury recently. And um, you know, I have no idea what I'm in for.

SPEAKER_03Um, but yeah, I knew I I knew nothing of the process going in. And I was very lucky that one of my early calls about it, uh, just because he happened to represent one of the a couple of the people in the book, was to Ron Kuby. And, you know, Kuby, uh, when I asked him about the grand jury, what a grand jury was, he said, Well, do you want the long version or the short version? And I said, Well, the long version. And so for the next half hour, uh, he gave me basically a seminar going back to, I think it was like the 1700s, on the history of the grand jury and how little it had changed over the years.

SPEAKER_03And yeah, that was the kind of thing that blew my mind. And I should say, there wasn't a single day that I worked on the book where I didn't at some point say to myself, holy shit. Because there are just details on every page that I could hardly believe.

SPEAKER_00Truly. Um, it's chock full of just moments where you say, like, I can't believe that person, that character in is there, or like made an appearance, or that thing happened. Or um, one of the things that I actually had to stop reading and Google when I saw it was when Tucker Carlson made an appearance. Um, can you briefly explain to listeners like what that moment was and how you actually made that connection with sort of the rise of him and yeah, so uh, you know, not that long after Michael Stewart dies, uh, you know, I think maybe within a year, um, there's a case where, you know, an elderly black woman named Eleanor Bumpers uh you know has is behind a a few months on her rent.

SPEAKER_03And so the city orders her eviction. And in the course of the eviction, she is shot to death uh by people, you know, in an emergency uh services uh officer.

SPEAKER_00And this was in public housing, correct? Yes, yeah, it was NYCHA.

SPEAKER_03And um it it is immediately just a a huge case because of the optics of it, you know, she's she's uh an unhealthy, I think, you know, 60-something uh year old woman with very poor mobility. Um yes, she was holding a knife, um, but she was also, you know, by all accounts quite mentally ill and you know didn't want to be evicted.

SPEAKER_03Uh but anyway, the the the case uh you know gets just huge attention. Um uh Aussie Davis, I believe, shows up at her funeral. And I'm still not clear how I found this. I think I was looking for just in general, the public response to the case. And I find this story, all credit to Business Insider, uh, they wrote a story what about what they considered to be Tucker Carlson's origin story.

SPEAKER_03And it was about how when he was at prep school uh at you know Sunday, uh I think Sunday chapel service, uh, people started talking about uh the Eleanor Bumpers case. And uh a black student, you know, asked his classmates, you know, does anybody here believe that you know Eleanor Bumpers deserve to be shot to death? And uh nobody raises their hand except for one kid, and it's Tucker Carlson.

SPEAKER_03And I remember reading this story and and being really confused, uh, not because of what Tucker Carlson did or what he believes, but because I hadn't read it before. And I went back and I looked to see if this had just gotten a lot of attention and I missed it. Uh, but no, it had come out and sank like a stone. People just hadn't noticed this story. And yeah, I um Yeah, it's history history doesn't often hand you a kicker like that.

SPEAKER_00And it was a kicker to a chapter, and I just my jaw dropped. I had to put down the book and Google it. And I found that business insider story because I just it was one of these moments in there are many in the book where um, you know, you see these intersecting lines of people that we're still dealing with in the media landscape and still dealing with in politics who were very intertwined with this period, um, and that the Eleanor Bumpers case happened right at the same time as Michael Stewart's killing. And those things were very much on the mind of many, many people in the book.

SPEAKER_00And um, it was just an amazing kicker.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I I think that if you were living during that period, I don't know that you would naturally put together uh the Stewart case, the Bumpers case, and Bernard Getz, but uh they were real trifecta.

SPEAKER_02Absolutely. I have a question about this. So uh owner of Bumpers was by pretty much all accounts like a nitro tenant, an older woman, someone didn't need to be blasted with a shotgun, uh, but also like uh an EDP, like an emotionally disturbed person. Like she wasn't paying rent because she said maintenance work wasn't done, but she wouldn't let the maintenance people in. She said people are coming through like the windows and the walls.

SPEAKER_02When they get in, there's like, you know, uh like cancer shit in her bathtub, things like that. Um and uh, you know, these police are not coming there to shoot her, whatever the unit was at the time that was supposed to be specially trained. Uh, but but but you know, there's a naked old woman there, and they shoot her with the shotgun. Um Michael Stewart.

SPEAKER_03She wasn't naked at all.

SPEAKER_02I think she was. I I'm pretty sure. I'm pretty sure she she she was initially when they entered, just just from my recollection of the case. But let's not stop there. Okay. So Michael Stewart, right? This is this young, like ambitious, uh, uh like around the scene with all these artists, kids like found a job for a while at the pyramid, is around the these people are moving up in the world. He's handsome, um, he's uh, you know, got a a girlfriend sort of in common to to briefly go through something with Basquian, and he gets beaten up with witnesses there very badly by the police.

SPEAKER_02He gets thrown like a sack of potatoes, but he doesn't die right there. And so by the time he does die, you got the medical examiner involved, the grand jury, and so on. You have all of these sort of technical questions, if you will. Well, how how did the injuries that were put on him by the police relate to his killing? And early on, they're saying he's a felon, there's all this coke. Um he was an EDP. Um uh he he he was crazy the else we could have done that seems absurd, uh, but there's no context or backdrive for that.

SPEAKER_02And this also has echoes of what happened with Eric Gardner, where suddenly a chokehold becomes a very technical thing. And did that have anything to do with him dying? And was the cartoid van involved, and all of this stuff? And and I just wanted you to sort of go through those echoes and how something as plain as this kid who does not seem emotionally disturbed, who does not seem like a felonious, dangerous person who needs to be taken off the street, who is maybe doing graffiti in the trains, ends up getting beaten up by all these officers, and then and then this all ends up being being questioned and conversed about in these very strange and interesting ways, where he's an EDP, uh, he's a he's a he's a danger, and maybe he just died from a medical event.

SPEAKER_03Right. And so I made a choice, you know, early on in the book to show what had happened to him from the perspective of the students. And the reason I chose to do that is because I believe that what they say happened is almost exactly what happened, you know, with the exception of like some pretty understandable errors, you know, like, you know, mistaking an emergency services vehicle for an ambulance or something like that.

SPEAKER_03Um and the point I wanted to make to the reader was I am telling you what has happened to Michael Stewart. It's quite simple. He was beaten into a coma by transit police, he did not pose a threat, he was 140 pounds soaking wet. Um, he did not have a weapon, and there were 11 police. Do the math. Now, I wanted that to be up front because later on in the book, when this goes to trial, you know, lawyers, uh defense lawyers are going to spend page after page trying to make you doubt what you know.

SPEAKER_03And whether it's the Stewart case or the Eric Garner case, they these are actually pretty simple events that I think people with um not the most pure motivations decide to make more complicated than they actually are. Sometimes people just get beaten to death. Did that answer the question?

SPEAKER_03I think so.

SPEAKER_00So, Elon, setting aside the nuts and bolts of what was at trial and the criminal aspects of this, I was super fascinated by the cultural impacts of this uh situation, Michael Stewart's life and death, all of the artists and makers and creators around him. Um can you just speak about what the cultural impacts were of this story and sort of the biggest reverberations in that world that came from this?

SPEAKER_03So I don't want to overstate any of this because obviously I don't think there was a tremendous impact on the way the city functioned. Like I don't think there was an impact on law enforcement. And to the degree that there was, I think it was a negative impact. One of the things that Ron Kuby said to me when I asked him what I he thought the legacy of the Stewart case was, is he said, you know, what had happened to Michael Stewart was so obvious.

SPEAKER_03Everybody knew what had happened. And so once the police were acquitted in his death, it sent the message to law enforcement that they could do anything and get away with it. And the message was received. Now, so I think that is one impact, you know, a cultural impact. But if we're talking about, you know, pop culture, um, you know, most famously there's the Jean-Michel Basquiat painting uh defacement, which eventually is exhibited at the Guggenheim in 2019.

SPEAKER_03It's a rather extraordinary painting that was cut out of the wall of Keith Herring's studio, uh, where he had painted it in October of 1983. Um there's you know a music legacy with Michelle Schacht uh writing a song about the case. Eventually uh Michael and Eleanor Bumpers are name-checked in a song by Lou Reed. Um and so, you know, in dribs and drabs over the years, uh Michael's case shows up in art and in music.

SPEAKER_03Um but certainly not to the degree that I think it should. With with that said, I don't really think there should be a hierarchy of uh the victims of of brutality, whether whether it's administered by the police or anybody else. Uh but but Michael Stewart should be far more well known for what he could have been in life than what he was in death.

SPEAKER_01F A T Lit NYC is made possible in part by support from the Charles H. Revson Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, and from PT Knitware, an independent bookstore, cafe, and events base on Manhattan's Lower East Side with a podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use. The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of Lit NYC. Our hosts this week were Rachel Holliday Smith and Harry Siegel, who's also the FAQ NYC Podcast Network's executive producer.

SPEAKER_01I'm our engineer, Adam Chimera. Thank you to our guest, Elon Green, author of The Man Nobody Killed: Life, Death, and Art in Michael Stewart's New York. And thank you, listener, for making it this far. If you like what you're hearing, please subscribe and spread the word. Be kind, be cool, and we'll be back soon with more.

SPEAKER_03Harry, so it's funny. I uh I tried like hell to talk to Eric Adams when I was working on this because I was gonna ask. Ellis Ellis Hennikan, uh, you know. Who the great transit reporter from the era, he and I were talking about it. And he he said, you know, Eric Adams was an amazing source because he had no filter whatsoever. And he's like, you get him talking, he won't shut up. And, you know, it seems to me that like the thing about Eric Adams that always gets underplayed or just overlooked entirely because of the merger of the police forces in in 94 was that he was a transit cop.

SPEAKER_02And as he's doing these ridiculous surges with these guys going underground, but they're just standing on the platforms and clusters and all that shit. It's all a flashback to the merger. I really want to talk to Bradd about this and whether there's some case that we'd be better off having a separate, non-second rate transit uh police that was actually trained to do that, but you're dealing with different shit and different EDPs and circumstances and all this stuff.

SPEAKER_03I mean, one of the things, we didn't get a chance to talk about this, but one of the things that like blew my mind was learning about what life was actually like for transit cops. Yeah. And like once you realize once you realize that Eric Adams, you know, patrolled solo and had shitty equipment, it kind of explains a lot of his behavior in a way that him being a city cop doesn't. It's a huge difference.

SPEAKER_03And I think I got him on the phone once, but it just was I wasn't able to interview him. Yeah. Uh but yeah, there really are just so many incredible aspects to this case. Like, I was so blessed with material and people willing to talk to me. I mean, getting the judge on the phone and have him say that the case was wrongly decided, oh my god. And the judge is not wrong.

SPEAKER_03You know what it was is that like people had been thinking about this for decades, and because nobody called them, like nobody people were just like sitting with their thoughts for years. I mean, all the witnesses when I called them, you know, at some point in the conversation would say, like, what took you so long? Like, they all knew the importance of what they had seen and participated in.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. From the Club to the Flophouse in Wang´s World

    Nov 13, 202628 minAudio

    As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Life, Death and the World in the Confines of One Subway Car

    Nov 9, 202659 minAudio

    Harry Siegel and Nicole Gelinas talk with Anand Giridharadas, the

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Joel Feingold’s Gotham

    Aug 21, 202649 minAudio

    Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Sam Roberts´ Art of the Obit

    Aug 14, 202633 minAudio

    New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. R Sikoryak´s Declaration/Emancipation Illustrated

    Jul 17, 202643 minAudio

    For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...

    Credit the people on this episode