Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

TBD NYC

TBD NYC artwork

St. John Frizell’s Gage & Tollner

Jan 9, 202651 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

An iconic restaurant in Fulton Mall became an Arby's, before it was revived amid the pandemic. St. John Frizell, one of the stewards of Gage and Tollner joins Lit NYC hosts Amy Sohn and Harry Siegel to talk about the craft of the cocktail, the business of Brooklyn, the nature of the great good place, and much more.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01When Grey Goose enters the scene, now it becomes like they created the ultra uh premium or the super uh premium category. So they were like, we're gonna be more expensive than absolute, which is from Sweden, where they have a history of making great vodka, and we're gonna make it out of French wheat. First of all, what is French well, like when I think of France, I don't think of rolling wheat fields. And also France does not have a history of making vodka, but but the guy who invented it, Sidney Frank, who is also the guy that that basically took Jaegermeister from being a German like DJ Stef and made it a like an LSU like party shot, like SEC party shot.

SPEAKER_01Like that that was that was a feat enough. And then he went from there and and created uh Greg O's. And yeah, and then and then we were off to the races. Then nothing mattered anymore. Nothing made sense. You didn't have like your brand didn't need to be grounded in any sense of history or anything. It just you just make it up completely.

SPEAKER_00It's with NYC, the New Yorkers show about the ABCs of arts, books, culture, et cetera. I'm Harry Siegel, a senior editor at the City and the FAQ NYC Podcast Network's executive producer, here with my co-host, journalist, performer, and prolific book writer, Amy Sohn.

SPEAKER_05And joining us right now is Sin Jin Frizzel, one of the stewards of the revised Gage and Tolner, a unique restaurant and bar smack in the middle of the Fulton Mall in downtown Brooklyn. It's an incredible space with a unique history. It was the third interior in the city to be landmarked and the first commercial space after the New York Public Library and Grant's tomb. But Gage and Tolner, the most famous restaurant in Brooklyn for more than a century, kind of shut down in 2004.

SPEAKER_05We'll talk about what we mean by shutdown. And then in 2021, Stin and his partners began its revival. St Jin, welcome and let's get right to it. It's January, and the hospitality business is slow as people pretend they're gonna keep their New Year's resolutions. What's the history of Gage and Tolner and how does it intersect with your history?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, getting into dry January now. It really, I mean, it's for restaurateurists, I think it's like a it's a it's a relief. Like it's the the holidays are so crazy. And then to come out of it to January is like you know it's gonna be slow. Hopefully you've planned for it. Hopefully you have some money socked away to get through it. But it's uh yeah, it's a slow, it's a slow month. It's a time for uh contemplation, for future planning, and uh yeah, for all that.

SPEAKER_05And and the in the intro, you know, we I put um So is is the reason it's slow in January because people aren't drinking, they're on diets, and they're trying not to spend money? And and also is there like a fourth thing?

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell It's just like the restaurant the restaurant industry is so crazy. It's like, why do all the pigeons, you know, get up and start flying at the same time? It's like that's like the way it is with restaurants. I mean, I could give you explanations all day, but one of like the tropes of restaurant working and especially restaurant ownership is people love to talk about why it was busy on Monday. It was busier this Monday than last Monday. Why is that? Oh, because it was, oh well, it was raining last Monday, or oh, there was the problem with the trains, or like there's the we can, you know, prognosticate and go back and hash up the past and try to figure it out, but we never will.

SPEAKER_05So tell us about Gage and Tolner. I'm I guess I'm kind of irregular because I live in Brooklyn Heights and I'm so glad to have a place that's the 10-minute walk from my apartment. It's a long storied, amazing tale. Yeah. Just tell us a little bit, you know, how we got from what is it, 1879 to the current incarnation with you and your partners.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So we'll start in 1879. So uh Charles uh Gage opened a place called uh Gage's at 302 Fulton Street, which uh is gone now, but uh 302 uh Fulton Street would be in the middle of uh Cadman uh Plaza now. Um he operated there for a number of years. We're still trying to figure out exactly when he moved a block uptown to uh 372 uh Fulton Street. But he was uh joined in uh business there by Eugene uh Tolner the year after he opened, uh and they ran it uh together until the early 20th century when it was uh bought by another uh team.

SPEAKER_01I think it was in 1910, but they they like loved each other. Eugene uh Tolner liked his uh partner so much that he named his son Gage. So there was a Gage Tolner running around uh Brooklyn for a while. But they were like very close friends. Eugene uh Tolner tried to retire when they sold it in 1910, but he came back to work in 1911 when one of the owners died, actually in the basement of the restaurant, and they um they uh carried him out through the the basement hatch uh to the street so as not to uh disturb the diners.

SPEAKER_01But the the surviving uh partner didn't know how to run a restaurant, he was you know just the money guy. Uh so uh Tolner came uh back to work and worked there until his uh dying day. He was uh he was actually on his way to work when he uh passed away. I think he was in his his early 80s. Then the uh the restaurant uh passes to the Dewey family in 1919. They operate it for about 70 years. Then uh it goes through two more changes of ownership before it closes in 2004.

SPEAKER_01People assumed forever, and uh it became a uh TGI Fridays. But like you say, it was a landmarked interior, so there was little they could do with the interior. They had to leave those uh beautiful arched mirrors, the the brass uh chandeliers. Then it the when the Fridays uh closed, it became an Arby's. It was an Arby's for a year. I do have a lot that I remember. Yeah, yeah. That was weird. That was weird.

SPEAKER_05That was really weird.

SPEAKER_01And then uh that closed, it became like a costume uh jewelry shop, and that this is when things really start to to fall apart. So now uh the renters of the space put up these false walls in front of the mirrors so you couldn't see them anymore. And track lighting above, so you couldn't really see the chandeliers, although they're kind of poking down from uh the um track lighting. And yeah, it and then it changed hands multiple times to the point where I think the first time I went in there was probably 2010 or something, and it was um it was basically like a flea market.

SPEAKER_01Like there was a lot of different vendors set up. There was a jewelry shop in the far back where the kitchen is now. There were, you know, puffy jackets here and there. Someone uh told me there was a fortune teller back by the women's bathroom. Um and then upstairs, you had when we took over this space, the uh tenants upstairs had just uh vacated, and that was a hair salon where the Sunken Harbor Club is, a nail salon where the dolphin bar is, and then the third room, what we call the Edna Lewis room, was uh divided up into a uh tattoo artist and a place to get uh grills uh for your teeth.

SPEAKER_05Amazing. I mean, I kind of wish I kind of wish I'd hung out there then.

SPEAKER_01You could really walk in there and walk out with like a whole new look.

SPEAKER_00Let's start with a a whittle about your wife, and we we can even start before the uh uh the hospitality and restaurant businesses and and how how you get there, and then we'll connect the two streams.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, sure. I uh I grew up in New Jersey, I kind of came of age in uh New Orleans, went to um Tulane and started working in restaurants there um, you know, as a uh dishwasher and then as like a banquet server and stuff, and really just kind of fell in love with that life and never got too far away from it. You know, I took other jobs and stuff, but always sort of had a coffee shop job or a bar job or something. And um, yeah, moved to New York in '99 and decided to try something totally new.

SPEAKER_01Went into uh publishing, got really lucky, ended up at uh Bone Epetit Magazine in 1999, um, worked there until uh 2006.

SPEAKER_00He was telling me before that uh, you know, you you you're there, you're in the service industry, you're doing you're doing all right, and like like building life for yourself. You have friends who in New York and like the dot-com bubble is going, and suddenly they're actually making money money.

SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah. All all my friends like lived in New York and weren't making serious money. Right. And so you know I was trying to eke out a living as a decorative painter in uh New Orleans. That's you know, probably my life I f I forget about a lot. But yeah, but that was that's what I was uh doing, and I was broke. And um like in New Orleans, it it you know, historically, at least at the time in the 90s, it was very easy to get by on very little and but very hard to actually make enough money so that you could travel, so that you could buy a house, so you could, you know, do the things that that you want to do.

SPEAKER_01So I was uh doing the former. I was uh just getting by. And I was like, let me try to get a real office job and see how this goes. And yeah, the uh dot com bubble was bubbling, and um that meant that the all the offices in traditional media had kind of emptied out. Like everyone had left to go work for a website. And uh yeah, I just kind of walked in uh uh to Bonapet and just you know ended up there, left, came in as a freelance uh copywriter and left as the uh promotion uh copy director.

SPEAKER_01We we could do a whole show about working at Condian Est in the early uh 2000s. This is they had just moved to uh four Times Square. You know, they had the uh cafeteria by Frank Gehry, Joanna Winter in the elevator, Sy New House in the Elevator. I felt like I was in like a sweet smell of uh success. I'd just look out the windows, Times Square was there. I mean, it was fabulous, but it was also like it was also hard. I had a uh panic attack in uh Bryant Park. I was just eating my lunch. Who didn't?

SPEAKER_01But I I just was there uh, you know, eating my lunch as I was wont to do, and all of a sudden I couldn't breathe. I thought I was, you know, going into anaphylactic shock, and then you know, got to the hospital and they were like, you had a panic attack. And I was like, what's that? And it got me thinking like maybe this is not the right position for me long term. And also like looking at my boss's job. I didn't want her job, I didn't really want to move up in the company, I didn't want any more responsibility. And I kept thinking about my days in uh New Orleans, where where you worked as a team in a restaurant and people got along and you and you had a drink at the end of the day, and you and you looked forward to seeing each other, and and that was not the Kanye Ness environment.

SPEAKER_01Like the Kanye Ness environment, I liked a lot of the people that I work with, but it was not known for its sense of uh camaraderie.

SPEAKER_05Aaron Ross Powell It's not quite a network uh moment, but you had something approaching uh and I'm mad as hell and I'm not gonna take it anymore, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, something like that. So I I was getting really into uh cocktails at the time. So this is where my life really starts to take the shape that it has now. In uh 2000, a friend of mine lent me a copy of a book called The Uh Gentleman's Companion by uh Charles H. Baker Jr., and that kind of changed my life. This was an American writer who traveled around the world three times in the 30s and 40s, and um wrote about what he ate and drank. He was kind of like the first like Anthony Bourdan type.

SPEAKER_01And he's uh talking to uh, you know, a largely white upper class audience, but he's like he's exposing them to these foods from all over the place, from uh Bali, from India, from uh Colombia, from Mexico. Like, and you could like his passion for this stuff just really comes across on the page. And I wanted to know everything about him. So I started to research him, eventually ended up writing a story about him for the Oxford American, and it's still the only sort of feature-length biography about this guy.

SPEAKER_01But I was like, I want to follow in his uh footsteps, literally. So I quit my job and my wife and I traveled around the world. We went to China for a month and went to South America for five months and just kind of uh, you know, saw what there was to see. And at times I was literally going to the restaurants, the bars, and the clubs that uh Charles Baker went to. And if they didn't exist, that was interesting too. Like what had changed, why had it changed? But it was really fascinating. The sort of the the poorer the city or the country, the more likely those places would still exist, like the old, uh the old like hotels and the members' clubs and uh things like that.

SPEAKER_05Stjin, I found a quote from you online. You were talking about Charles Baker, and you said some people feel a lot of his drink recipes are terrible. And while, yes, some of his drinks are not as good as others, that's not what you should be paying attention to in his cocktails. It's not just about what's in the glass, but the experience, what's going on around you. Baker was really good when it came to the context of a drink. Drinks should be built for an experience, the times we live in, and the events in our lives.

SPEAKER_05Wow.

SPEAKER_01That's that's a a good quote. No, and that's that's like that's absolutely right. I mean, there there is like I do not obsess over uh the cocktails, over uh cocktail ingredients as much as some people do. I obsess a little bit, but I would rather have a bad drink in a good bar than a good drink in a bad bar. And uh Baker really did understand that. He a lot of his recipes get lost in translation. You have a feeling that you know he wrote it on a napkin while he was at the bar, and then he he got back to like the hotel, and you know, some of it had blurred a little bit, and he didn't really know what it said anywhere.

SPEAKER_01Uh yeah, a lot of those drinks don't work right out of the box, but the stories that go along with the drinks always work. It's always like he's always in the middle of like uh some adventure and and meets some you know fascinating person. He's got a great story about uh going to the Raffles Hotel in um 1923 and having a uh Singapore sling, and like Richard Halliburton is is there, and Frank uh Buck of uh Bring Him Back Alive is there. And like just like it's just a world you just want you just want to be there with him having that drink.

SPEAKER_00I'm thinking about Mom Dani's inaugural speech he just gave, is a lot of this was actually built around the globalized foods that are here. Yeah. And th that that that was in some ways the smine of the uh speech and and and street foods and uh law vendors and this part of things. Um and and it strikes me that we're all old enough, but if we have any younger listeners, that there was a point where the whole world wasn't just coming here and all the information about what was everywhere else in the world wasn't entirely here.

SPEAKER_00And if you get the itch and are are curious about this and really want want to see how this works and how people eat and drink and and have their hospitality in different places, uh you your options are you you get there or you get little scraps of this second hand or from old accounts, and that's that.

SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah, I mean, yeah, I love the fact that uh there was uh so much food in in that speech, and also like throughout his whole campaign. He's always uh talking about like where he eats and and uh food really is that thing that can bring people together and to uh to sit down and share a meal with somebody is still really significant, you know.

SPEAKER_05So you traveled in the footsteps of Charles Baker.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And uh yeah, decided to make cocktails sort of my my vocation in life, and uh got a j well, really wanted to work at a new bar called the Pegu Club.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, okay. The timing of you coming back to the city was around when Audrey is it Audrey Saunders was getting it going?

SPEAKER_01Yes, and she was also a big Charles Baker fan. So I I knew that from uh a profile that Pete Wells wrote about her for food and wine. I think it was in uh 2006, and it was when she was still running the bar at the Bebelman's bar, but she was about to open Pega Club, and the whole story was about uh Charles H. Baker uh Jr. And I was like, oh my god, somebody else knows about this guy, and somebody else is interested.

SPEAKER_00Working some of this out and having a fastidiousness about this took some time and research. If you start getting interested in cocktails, figuring this out and finding the history, it doesn't all just just flow to you. Right. There's not an AI, obviously, to synthesize it. Like this becomes a big sort of investment of your time and energy in some ways, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and there's not like a short form uh video of someone explaining everything to you. Yeah. I mean, the the what existed were some old books that you could that you could find in old bookstores, physical old old bookstores, and a few online forums, like uh eGullit, if you remember that, from the early uh 2000s, and um drinkboy was another one. I mean, these are like like they're legendary now. Like the and the the people that I met in those forums, like I still talk to now.

SPEAKER_01Like we developed uh friendships online, and then later we would meet in person at events like uh Tales of the Cocktail, which is an annual uh convention in uh New Orleans. And uh and I remember being in New Orleans and meeting a lot of the like, what's your handle online? Oh, it's oh oh I know you. We were talking about this. I mean, it's like it really uh uh it was it was a fun time because the cocktail world was really small. I mean, now it's really big. Like, you know, the cocktail revolution happened and like we won.

SPEAKER_05So you trained under Audrey.

SPEAKER_01I trained under Audrey, yeah. So so I started working at uh Pegu Club, and that was like a dream come true for me. Again, it was like sort of it was a lot of sort of uh being in the right place at the right time. That's how I got the job at the magazine. And the job at the magazine kind of led to the job at uh Pago Club because Audrey knew I was a writer. I was doing some uh cocktail writing for Epicurious in like the early days, and there was so little uh cocktail writing out there that the people who read it were really paying attention.

SPEAKER_05What was the craft cocktail movement? And what did Pago Club, which was on West Towiston Street for somewhere between 10 and 15 years, I think. Um, what did that have to do with it? Like like what what is craft cocktails and how would we explain this maybe to people who um have never known anything else?

SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, who have never known anything else? That's a good question because yeah, those uh people exist and they're they're of of uh legal age now. They can they can go to uh bars and drink. So if you went to a bar in the 90s and um and ordered a Manhattan, chances are they wouldn't be able to make it for you, or they would leave out the bitters. There's only three ingredients in a Manhattan. There's whiskey, there's sweet vermouth, and there's uh bitters, but a lot of bars didn't have the bitters. They drink were just unaccustomed to making these uh drinks.

SPEAKER_01They could make you a martini. That would be uh pouring uh vodka into a shaker with some ice, kind of sloshing it around a little bit and then spilling it out into a warm martini glass and then handing that to you. You could get those, but like like Negronis, completely unknown, old fashions, um made in a completely different way than they are now. I like there's yeah, there's so many drinks that you that any bartender should be able to make now that are just part of the lexicon that were just um completely forgotten at the time.

SPEAKER_01So you got you got martinis, you got up like a wet Manhattan on crappy ice with a bright red cherry in it that tasted like nothing. And now you can go and get a Manhattan that's either on the rocks or it's up in a chilled uh glass. It's got a really nice uh cherry in it, the whiskey is good, the vermouth is good, it's kept in the refrigerator so it doesn't go bad, and there's Angostura bitters in it. I mean, it's like oh, and also in the 90s, a lot of things revolved around sour mix.

SPEAKER_05So oh boy, that was my entire 90s. That was my drink, whiskey sour. And I got sick all the time. It's terrible because it was so sweet, right?

SPEAKER_01Whiskey sour, kamikaze's margaritas, all of these things were popular and they all had sour mix, which usually came out of a gun. So you would have like a citric acid solution um with some fruit uh flavors in it in a bag somewhere in the building, and then it would be piped through like maybe 30 feet of like plastic uh tubing to a little uh gun that also had your 7up and your coke in it and your sour. Mix would go in, you'd throw some triple sec in there, some uh tequila, which would, you know, might be really bad.

SPEAKER_01You'd shake that up, that's some margarita. So the other thing that uh the cocktail revolution did is it reintroduced fresh uh juices to the bar. Um and that uh is the way that uh cocktails had always been made up until a certain point in uh like the mid-century 60s and 70s, and then it was all sour mix, and then then things like uh fresh lime juice and fresh lemon juice uh started to uh reappear.

SPEAKER_05Aaron Ross Powell So when people came to Pago Club in like it's heyday, I I I'm very sorry. I never made it. I I had a baby in 2005, so maybe I was just like out of the mix for the exact period of time that it was hot.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell The room was big and dark and sexy and low seating cocktail tables everywhere. Um and I it was so dark that if when I was working at the bar, I couldn't see anyone out there. It was just a black void. But it was like the you know, the that that kind of vibey lounge electronica from the mid uh 2000s that was playing, mixed in with a few kind of old-timey jazz uh uh songs, but it was upscale.

SPEAKER_01The the servers, who were all young women, all wore these kind of kimono-like um robes that were they were really cute. And the guys behind the bar, and they were all guys until the the last years or the last year that I was there, um, wore vests and ties and rolled up sleeves and just like looked really good, these long aprons. So it was like a it it was a classy place. The thing that Audrey uh Saunders was uh famous for was her attention to detail.

SPEAKER_01No one could craft a drink better than Audrey. She was the absolute best. And when we developed a new drink for that bar, it went through iterations. And when I say it went through iterations, I mean like 40, 50, 60, 70. Um, we would dial things in so precisely, we'd try, if it was a rye whiskey drink, we would try every rye that we had available to us. We would, if it was a lemon juice uh drink, we would try it with lime, we try it with grapefruit, we'd try it with the combination. We would move ingredients up a quarter ounce, back a quarter ounce, and just keep trying different things until Audrey thought it was right.

SPEAKER_01And that uh could take weeks or months. In my case, I finally got a drink on the menu after like working on it for months. It was actually it was a Charles H. Uh Baker Jr. drink called the Remember the Main. Uh which is all which is a whole nother story. Uh I was so happy that I had this uh drink on the menu. And this crowd of guys uh came in uh one night. They were all kind of uh crowd around the bar, suits and ties, obviously had just come from a uh dinner, and they were like partying, partying, partying.

SPEAKER_01Um, and uh they saw the remember the main and they went nuts. They were like, look at this! There's a remember the mane on the menu. And I was like, this is interesting. How do these guys know this drink? And um they ordered round after round, and then when the guy put down his his card at the end, it was like William Randolph Hearst the Fifth or something like that. So yeah, after a time at Pago Club, I was like, it's time to open my own place.

SPEAKER_01And that was Fort Defiance, uh located at um on uh Van Brun Street in uh Red Hook. Um it was a beautiful little uh corner bar restaurant, and yeah, it was open all day. It was open in the morning, it was open at night. It was kind of modeled after. I was thinking about like cafes and bars that you see in Europe where you might go for an espresso in the morning and then stop by for like a glass of wine to read the newspaper at the end of the day. And I really wanted it to serve as both of those uh things.

SPEAKER_01And you talk about the philosophy of hospitality. At some point early on, somebody had introduced me to the work of Ray Oldenburg, who wrote a book called The Great Good Place, where where he kind of he invented the term the third place, which you hear a lot now. Um, and I think uh like the idea has kind of gotten watered down in uh popular culture. But for him specifically, it was a place that was in between work and home that would sort of act as the third leg of the stool of your life.

SPEAKER_01You know, if you if you take away that place, there's too much pressure on work or home for things that you need to live a uh good life. You need, you know, friends outside of work and your house. You need novelty, you need to be introduced to new things, you need uh companionship, and and and if you're looking for those things exclusively at work and home, like it's not gonna, it's not gonna work out. Um and I think that I think that for Defiance really did that.

SPEAKER_01It was a neighborhood spot. People would run into each other, um, they would meet there and realize that they lived on the same block or they lived around the corner and or that uh you know they their uh kids went to school together or or whatever. And and it really did function like that. And that was its main function to kind of to help to knit the community together. I didn't really think about the business side of it that much. When we got um flooded by Hurricane Sandy in 2012, the restaurant was only about three years old.

SPEAKER_01And um and it was hard. I mean, I was I was uh behind the bar. Uh I started off four nights a week. I was uh closing the bar, sweeping and mopping the floors every night, and also trying to operate the restaurant as the as the general manager and owner. And that was turned out to be unsustainable. And then by the time we got flooded, I was then I had to make a real decision. Like I could walk away from this, like I've been washed out, like I lost a lot. It's gonna take a lot of work to put it back together, or I could just, you know, pull down the gates and walk away.

SPEAKER_01And and um You came from New Orleans and you get flooded out of New York by the world. Yeah, I know. I know. Uh but but it it made me actually pay attention to the business uh side of things. And I learned how to like what a business was all about. I I really didn't know at that point. And uh yeah, going through the flood and the reconstruction uh from the flood really, you know, was a uh it was a uh crucible experience, you know. So then cut to, you know, 2015, I get divorced, right?

SPEAKER_01Go through this this rough breakup, and uh and it lasts for four years. There's a there's a trial and everything. I mean, it's like it's brutal. And then when the final judgment is handed down in uh 2015, I walk out of the uh courthouse on Cabin Plaza, the the uh Supreme Court building, and my lawyer and I are like, well, we need to get a drink to celebrate the end of this. And there was no place to get a drink except for a Mexican place called Rocco's Tacos, which was across Adams Street, Rocco's uh tacos being a a Mexican chain out of West uh Palm Beach, Florida.

SPEAKER_01So not the most authentico Mexican experience, but they did, you know, tableside uh guacamole, and I got uh a prickly pear margarita, and it was fine, but it wasn't what I wanted, which was an ice cold martini and for someone to treat me like a human being. And uh um, and uh I at that moment I was like, okay, well, the divorce has left me penniless. Um Fort Defiance is doing fine, but I'm never going to be able to make the kind of money that I need to make to pay these lawyers, to pay these court fees, to pay uh child support and everything else.

SPEAKER_01So I need to do something else. Like I need to add to what I'm uh doing. So at the time, we were doing a weekly tiki event called Sunken Harbor Club. This is uh something that we started in 2011. It was started by a uh bartender named uh Zach Overman, who took a long time to convince me that tiki drinks were worth drinking and worth making. Sunken Harbor Club was a pretty successful weekly party. And I was like, let's find a brick and mortar home for this thing in downtown Brooklyn, where there are no good bars currently.

SPEAKER_01And I started looking in 2016 or 2015 actually, and then in 2017, I had dragged my uh partner Ben along and um to look at some spaces in the neighborhood. And the realtor showed us one, and it was one I was excited about on a previous visit, but on this visit, it was raining and the rain was coming through the ceiling, and I was like, okay, well, this isn't gonna do. Um and uh she said, Well, I've got something else, but it's too big.

SPEAKER_01And and we said, Well, let's let's have a look. And she literally just walks us over to Gaion Tolner and pulls out the keys and opens the door. And I was like, I could not believe it. Like the everything that that whole flea market uh situation had been cleared out. I I'd never been in there where you could see the whole room, where you could see the mirrors.

SPEAKER_00Describe the whole room, just for folks who haven't been there.

SPEAKER_01So walking into Gage and Tolner, like I describe it like that day, as it's like walking into a cathedral. The room seems to stretch on forever. There's mirrors on either side, there's a mirror at the far end of the room that kind of doubles the length of the room uh visually, and you have these beautiful brass uh chandeliers that hang from the ceiling in these ornate uh patterns. I mean, it's just it's breathtaking. So uh what was supposed to be like a thousand square foot uh cocktail bar with like 20 employees turned into a, you know, an enormous oyster and chop house with a hundred employees and with a tropical bar upstairs.

SPEAKER_01And uh yeah, that's what we do now. Aaron Ross Powell I mean, look, the the first thing I did after we walked into that room was go to the library and try to pull the Gage and Tolner book because surely uh a restaurant that was around for 125 years, surely someone wrote a book about it.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell It's one of the most iconic places, at least in in Brooklyn for a long time.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell Yeah. And I mean nowadays if a restaurant makes it two or three years, there's a book about it. And like so sure surely there had to be something. So there wasn't. Um there was not much I found in the public library in Manhattan, and it wasn't until I went to the Brooklyn Historical Society, now called the Center for Brooklyn History, where I'm uh going after after this, actually, um where they had just been donated 13 boxes of ephemera from the Dewey family, who if you remember ran it for 70 years.

SPEAKER_01So the the So Trudy Dewey had passed away recently, and her kids had uh donated all the stuff that they saved for 70 years to the uh the Brooklyn.

SPEAKER_05Historical Stadium. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01So they they were still actually sorting through it and uh cataloging it all. But then I started to get the boxes of stuff. And now I'm I'm in the beautiful uh the Othmer uh library at the uh Center for uh Brooklyn History, and I'm going through these boxes and pulling out these documents and photographs and stuff that they actually handled. And that's where I was able to kind of put together like the history of the restaurant. So they had clippings of the restaurant going back to 1919, menus galore, uh, and you know, photographs of the staff and the owners and stuff.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it's just it's totally, totally fascinating. It started off as like uh just an oyster house, and I'm pretty sure you would just get oysters there in different preparations. But when they moved uptown to uh 372 uh Fulton Street, they added uh chops, they added uh chicken, they added um salads, uh that sort of thing. And there were there were if you look at the old menu, I should have brought you one. There are there are hundreds of items.

SPEAKER_05We can put it in the in our show notes.

SPEAKER_01Oh yeah. So it and the the fun thing about the menus there is the earliest we have is I think from 1919, 1920. And then you look at the menu from 1979, and it's very similar. So it's like really not much had changed in those 60 years. There's still hundreds of items on the menu. Now the interesting thing about what it was like in 1919 is when you read about the restaurant as it's being written about in the 1920s, they're referring to it as like a throwback place.

SPEAKER_01That like, oh, it's like a step back in time. So in 1920, they're writing about uh gauges as like this throwback experience.

SPEAKER_04See, that's amazing, right? It's like retro was always a thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And it was then. And they're like the writers are like uh decrying the latest restaurant fads. They're like, oh, all these all these new restaurant fads. I just like an old-fashioned place like uh Gage and Tolner.

SPEAKER_05It is an expensive restaurant. You have a seafood platter with caviar for$290, Beef Wellington for two is$147, Bonin Rib Pork Chop is$56. We just elected Zora and Mom Donnie on an affordability platform. How I mean, I know that this has gotcha. This has gotcha. I know that you you you guys are charging what you need to to make this continue to function.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_05But it's mind-blowing to think about, you know, even just a portion of a meal being th three digits.

SPEAKER_01Gation Tolner was um pretty much always a fancy restaurant. Um and you know, uh if it's a fancy restaurant, it's gonna have fancy restaurant prices. And by fancy, I mean like it's staffed. Like we we have that money goes to our staff. Like the the the money that we charge, um labor is by far the biggest like expense on our profit and loss. The the food takes a lot of people to prepare.

SPEAKER_01Um the people who are serving it have uh have uh support. So there's like this the the server that you see, there's the server assistant who's also working, there's the reservationist, there's the host, there's the there's just so many people involved in keeping that place running the way that it does and providing the the level of service that we aspire to. I mean, honestly, like the I I was thinking about prices on menus earlier today, and I was uh thinking like it's the the menu prices are high.

SPEAKER_01Look, I'm not gonna I'm not gonna argue with you, but it is amazing that we've gotten to a point in our society where to pay$45 for an entree is considered really high. But still, you're sitting down in a restaurant that you know is paying rent, the heat's on, the lights are on, you're looking at a menu of 40 different items, you're selecting your favorite, and then somebody, somebody in the kitchen unseen, prepares this item for you to your specifications, brings it to your table, you eat it, and then and then you you leave and everyone and it gets uh cleaned up, and you never have to think about it.

SPEAKER_01And that that entree costs you$45, like that's like of like 10 billable minutes of a lawyer's uh salary.

SPEAKER_05You and I are both divorced, so we're just thinking about this in terms of our retaining.

SPEAKER_01What are we talking about? Like, this is like the the dining experience you can have in New York is a remarkable bargain as far as I'm concerned. And and you can eat dinner from a different country of the world every night of the week for a whole for a whole year and like and not and not have any repeats. It's like it's um so yeah, that's what I have to say about prices.

SPEAKER_05You should specify um your employees get health and pension, right?

SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell, we do we don't do a pension, we do a 401k, so we do uh 401k with matching um and we and we do offer health insurance. Yeah. And we and and we also offer uh pet insurance and uh and some other things.

SPEAKER_00Having just been in this industry for a long time, going back to both this philosophy of hospitality stuff, but then building up uh a staff and a functional place and the sort of service you want customers to have and finding employees who can sort of steadily provide that, you know, like a good bartender is preparing a complicated drink, watching seven other interactions happening at once, listening to my bullshit story or extremely long question, and has to triage and prioritize these.

SPEAKER_00All at once. Like, oh, the the the that that really is interesting, Harry. Hold on a minute. You know, I I didn't even notice you. I got to walk over there, you know, is doing all the things sort of simultaneously. But if you want to talk a little about all that, that'd be great. Trevor Burrus, Jr.

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah. I mean, look, to to in any uh business, you have to, as the the owner or the manager, you have to provide the kind of service to your employees that you hope your employees provide to your guests. And and so we we really did get into this with, again, with a mind to the history of the restaurant. Now there was a tradition at uh Gajon Tolner where where the waiters would wear they would wear insignia on their sleeves uh that would indicate how long they had worked there.

SPEAKER_01So um a bar meant one year, a star meant five years, and an eagle meant 25 years. And there were guys waiting tables there that had two eagles on their sleeves. I mean, it's like it's incredible. I have not seen anything like this outside of New Orleans. Like you mentioned, um, like my waiter at Antoine's, if you live there, you you get you get a waiter, you inherit it from a friend of yours or from like you you have someone's number you can call to get a uh table.

SPEAKER_01If you if you call the main line, this is the way that used to work in the 90s. I don't know if it works exactly this way anymore. But um but and my waiter got the job from his uncle, who um and that's just the way that that worked. Now uh, sorry, what what's Antoine's? Oh, uh Antoine's is a really old restaurant in uh New Orleans, opened in the 1860s. So one of the one of the few restaurants in America that's actually older than uh Gage and Tolner. Now, this is uh something the wait staff and the kitchen staff at uh Gage and Tolner were black from the opening until the staff integrated in like the 70s.

SPEAKER_01I do know that it was a good job, you know. To to be a waiter at uh Gage and Tolner meant you were working inside, you had regular hours, you weren't going to a shape up every day, and you had um like respect in the community. And and it was a job that you wanted to work at for 50 years, and it was a job that you wanted to hand down to your nephew or to your son, or to keep it in the family.

SPEAKER_05Aaron Ross Powell And we have a little audio of a waiter at Gage and Tolner. We think it's 50s, 60s.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, Leon uh Gaskill. He um he was the first waiter that we know of to hit the 50-year mark there. And yeah, he's he's got a like a remarkable life story. And uh seemed like a really cool guy. He I mean he waited on uh Diamond Jim Brady and uh Lillian Russell. I mean it's crazy to think about.

SPEAKER_05You were talking about these sort of service industry jobs once being long jobs.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_05I feel like it's hard to find good bartenders now. And by good, I just mean that experience that Harry was just talking about. You know, this experience of Amy, it's nice to see you. Um it's such a magical thing to feel known. Yeah. You know, like the cheers, the television show. And I'm wondering I feel that way at your place. I feel that way with Gary. I think he's just the epitome of he has this very, very natural warmth that comes through.

SPEAKER_05But he he is also very busy. And it is hard to have more than a smattering of small talk. Right. It's just not really possible. So I guess what I'm sort of wondering is like number one, where else should I go to have that experience? And and and how uh has the service industry changed in such a way that that that experience, you know, may be dead on some level?

SPEAKER_01Well, I do think you're right in in that uh bartenders are busier. Now, to some extent, that's my fault. I gave them all these uh complicated cocktails to make. I mean, we really do try to streamline things to make it to make it easy. I mean, specifically for that reason, to to to give the bartenders the time that they need to make uh connections with uh the guests who are sitting at the bar.

SPEAKER_05Does that mean batches?

SPEAKER_01It does. Yeah, yeah. Um for a lot of things. Not everything is just being uh poured out of a bottle, but yeah, we we combine ingredients uh ahead of time, especially for the really uh popular drinks, you know. Um like the the uh dirty vodka martini, for instance, which we sell more of than anything else.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But um, yeah, where to go, you got me. If you find a place, you you you let me know.

SPEAKER_05I've always felt like I'll have a bartender who loves me for a year and then he'll just become in a really bad mood for like six months. And I of course I always think it's probably going through a divorce. Seriously. But then if you wait it out, if I just I just don't go there for six months and I come back, then suddenly he's like in a good mood again.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. You got a girlfriend.

SPEAKER_00With everything Amy was just bringing up, and as we were bringing things toward our close, are you happy or sad having this successful restaurant and bar operation? I think didn't seem like a sure thing right when it opened, not to have more uh competition right there. Would competition help make for more of a scene? How are you thinking about all that? And you know, you said the uh the cocktail warriors won.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Where are we at? All right, so let me tell you this that that when we saw Gage and Tolner, when we walked in and had that moment, you know, I knew I was going to do everything I could to raise the money to to get this place open. It was not easy and it took a long time. But I do also know that during that time the landlords were actively shopping it. So there were other restorateurs, big names. Like if you think about like the bigger players in New York, they probably got an invitation to walk through there at some point.

SPEAKER_01Trevor Burrus, Jr.

SPEAKER_00Bigger than Arby's, finesse.

SPEAKER_01Bigger than Arby's. Uh and they didn't they didn't see it. And they decided not to do it because they they you know, for various reasons, Spice spoke to one and he was just like, yeah, I didn't see it, I didn't see the neighborhood, I didn't I didn't want it didn't want to reopen something old, I'd do new things, I want to do something new. So the the when when we opened, I thought everyone would get over their aversion to downtown uh Brooklyn. Downtown Brooklyn has nothing but new construction.

SPEAKER_01There's tons of people moving into the neighborhood. There's the there's the Paramount uh theater is doing uh so well. There's Ace Hotel that's around the corner. There's there's like there are things City Point, yeah, the Alamo uh uh draft house. Like and there's just towers, towers, towers, and cranes.

SPEAKER_03I guess you've seen an awful lot of changes here in this area of Brooklyn over those years. What was it like in 1944?

SPEAKER_02Right in the right, all the fleet of the elevator zone, over the free.

SPEAKER_01It's like this is where people are moving. And it's also the second uh densest uh transportation hub in the city outside of uh Times Square. And operating in Red Hook for 15 years, believe me, operating across the street from a subway stop is better. So why why aren't we surrounded by new bars and restaurants right now? I don't know. And uh I'm confused by it and I wish it wasn't that way. So if you're uh a restaurateur and you want to open uh downtown, give me a call.

SPEAKER_01The the downtown uh Brooklyn uh partnership were were really, really useful in uh in uh getting uh to know the neighborhood and the different landlords there. I'm sure they want you to come down, so yeah. Give me a ring.

SPEAKER_00Syndrome, thank you for joining us. Um there's so much more we could talk about, why young people don't drink. So I hope January business is good and that you'll come back and we'll uh keep this conversation going. I would love that.

SPEAKER_03F AQ.

SPEAKER_00Lit NYC is hosted by Amy Sohn and me, Harry Siegel. I'm also the executive producer of the FAQ NYC Podcast Network. This episode was produced by Amy and engineered by Noah Smith. If you like the show, rate us, review us wherever you get your podcasts, and email us at LitNYCPod at Proton.me. The show is a production of the FAQ NYC Podcast Network, which is made possible in part by support from the Charles H. Revson Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, and from PNT Netware, an independent bookstore, cafe, and event space on Manhattan's Lower East Side with the podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use.

SPEAKER_00The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of the podcast, which is headquartered at The City, a nonprofit newsroom delivering hard-hitting investigative journalism that serves the people in New York. A special thank you to our guest, Sinjin Fazel, co-owner of Downtown Brooklyn's Gage and Pulner, and the Sunken Harbor Club on its second floor. And thank you, listener, for making it this far. Be kind, be easy, and we'll be back soon with more.

SPEAKER_05And Sin Jin, can you leave us with the correspondence cocktail?

SPEAKER_01With pleasure. Uh, it is an ounce and a half of rye whiskey, uh, three-quarter ounce of sweet vermouth, three-quarter ounce of lemon juice, half ounce of homemade grenadine, which is just a pomegranate syrup, and a dash of Angostura bitters. Shake that uh with ice, pour it into a highball glass with ice, top it with soda, garnish with an orange slice or a cherry if you prefer. Yeah. A delicious wintery punchy drink.

SPEAKER_05And then the the grenadine, like, how do you how do I make my own grenadine? Or like, you know, what how do I do that?

SPEAKER_01Um add add uh sugar uh in equal parts to uh pomegranate juice.

SPEAKER_05Okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. From the Club to the Flophouse in Wang´s World

    Nov 13, 202628 minAudio

    As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Life, Death and the World in the Confines of One Subway Car

    Nov 9, 202659 minAudio

    Harry Siegel and Nicole Gelinas talk with Anand Giridharadas, the

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Joel Feingold’s Gotham

    Aug 21, 202649 minAudio

    Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Sam Roberts´ Art of the Obit

    Aug 14, 202633 minAudio

    New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. R Sikoryak´s Declaration/Emancipation Illustrated

    Jul 17, 202643 minAudio

    For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...

    Credit the people on this episode