Eric Goldwyn, one of the authors of a new report from the Marron Institute of Urban Management at New York University with a modest proposal to remap the city with 12 new projects, 64 new subways stations and 41 new miles of rail talks with Amy Sohn and Harry Siegel about that idea and much more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Free buses are not audacious and expansive. It will not be transformative to the city of New York in the way that subway expansion will be. Like if they built these 41 miles, like this city would be dramatically different.
SPEAKER_00It's lit NYC, the New Yorkist show about the ABCs of arts, books, culture, planning, etc. I'm Amy Stone, journalist and recovering press secretary, here with Harry Siegel, a senior editor at the city and the FAQ NYC Podcast Network's executive producer.
SPEAKER_01Joining us now is Dr. Eric Golden, a program director at NYU's Marin Institute of Urban Management, which just issued a report recommending vastly expanding subways in place of one of Mairam Dani's signature campaign promises, free buses. The plan's called a better billion, and the idea, it says, would also lead to as many as 165,000 new housing units in the coming decades, even without any rezoning. It's not cheap, a billion dollars a year for 40 years, but that's give-take what it would cost to run the buses without charging for them.
SPEAKER_01Eric's a clinical assistant professor at Marin's transportation and land use program. Unless you think he only cares about subways, he once wrote a plan for expanding Brooklyn's buses. Like Amy and me, we get to go first here because we were here first. He's also a native New Yorker. Eric, welcome to Bid MC. Eric It's good to be here. Thank you. Hey, let's jump right in. Why would expanding trains be better than free buses? And um, is there a chance that Mayor Mamdani is going to come around to that point of view and put his ample political capital behind this idea that presumably, or not presumably, as the report says, you you think would be a better use of that sum of money?
SPEAKER_01And we can talk, of course, about what's uh operating money and capital money and all that.
SPEAKER_02I I think that he should obviously get behind the plan because I think it achieves his goals better than his free bus idea. Um I think you know he swept to City Hall on a you know hopes and dreams of making the city affordable. Um and the key to affordability in New York City is housing. Um people are not moving out of New York City because the bus fare is$3. People are moving out because they can't afford the rent, childcare is too expensive, you know, those are the two biggest costs that households face.
SPEAKER_02And so what we thought is instead of you know focusing on the bus as being too expensive, how can transportation help solve this affordability problem? Since you're both New Yorkers, you know, when the subway was built in the early 20th century, it sort of ushered in a boom of housing construction between 1900 and 1940. Um, you know, my favorite stat is the population of the Bronx in 1910 was 200,000. By 1940, 1.4 billion uh million, not billion.
SPEAKER_02Um we're not that big of a city yet. And uh, you know, when you look at population growth in New York City from before subway construction, 1900, to about 1940 when it stops, I believe 90% of the growth in population occurred in areas adjacent to uh the subway. So it's uh an old formula in New York. Um subways beget development. And so if you want to make a dent in housing affordability, as as the mayor does, you know, he has said he wants 200,000 units of housing, uh, you need to have a plan that sort of unleashes that activity.
SPEAKER_02And we think that this is the best way to do that.
SPEAKER_01The challenge to me seems to be that he got elected on a bunch of very glib promises involving the word free, and now it's very hard for him to transition away from those. Um you were a member of his the Transportation Transition Committee. Um this report came out right after that was done and he came to office. Uh so just to go back to that first question, like do you see a potential path forward? And as the state and the MTA are not indicating their openness necessarily to the free buses plan, particularly as Mamdani's priced it in at$700 million, they're saying it'd be closer to like a billion or$1.1 billion to actually um make up for that uh revenue.
unknownTrevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So you know they just announced that this five-week trial for the World Cup would cost about$100 million. So if you multiply that by$10 to get to 50 weeks, because they're 52 weeks in here, you're at a billion dollars. So I think the math is we're we're pretty good on it being a billion dollars.
SPEAKER_01Um it's that trial, though, that they proposed that that hasn't been agreed to not at all.
SPEAKER_02It's just, but yeah, but they they sort of estimated that would be the cost. But to to get to your your question more directly. So, you know, the thing uh there are many things I really like about the mayor. One of them is that he's a believer in you know, government can do big things. Um, you know, at his inauguration, he talked about the need for expansive and audacious plans. We used those words in our report uh because you know, we saw it as a sort of a call to action for expansive and audacious plans. And we think that a better billion represents that better than free buses.
SPEAKER_02And then, you know, to your your your other question about is there any sort of chance of the mayor pivoting or shit, you know, picking this up. I think the other thing is that he has shown an interest in good ideas. I think he's a big subway fan in general, right? You know, his personal inauguration was in the City Hall subway station. Um, I've heard him talk about his favorite subway multiple times. And when he appointed people, everyone had to answer what's their favorite subway.
SPEAKER_02Um What's your favorite subway? What's my favorite subway? It's a really a great question. I'm pretty confident it's the Q-Train.
SPEAKER_00Um interesting choice.
SPEAKER_02I'm pretty confident. And I will say, when I was a kid growing up, and you probably will all know this, the Q-train didn't really exist. Um, you know, so like when I went to high school, I went to high school in Brooklyn. And so I would take the NR through the Montague Street tunnel, and then all of a sudden, this Q-train comes back, and I'm like, whoa, this is incredible. I can get to see all my friends who live in Brooklyn, because I I grew up in Union Square where the Q train stops, in like half the time that if I were like connecting to the F or, you know, whatever it was.
SPEAKER_02Um so for me, it it it holds, you know, um special significance. But then also you can get to Coney Island, you can get uptown, and maybe one day we can get even up to 125th Street in Broadway.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Can you uh just talk a bit about these expansions and what this new map would create? I touched on that in the intro, but it it would really would be a different city at the end of this 40 years with all these lands.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah. So I mean the the big motivation was not just drawing lines on a map and you know geeking out over subways, but it was also about building housing and so extending the subway in places that haven't seen subway uh construction that represents sort of the build-out of those boroughs. So Queens, for instance, you know, in 1940 its population was about one and a half million, maybe 1.4 million. Um, it's grown by over a million people since then.
SPEAKER_02There've been no new subway construction. There's been some extensions, but you know, there's no north-south subway in Queens. I don't know. Maybe we could solve that problem. Um, like we we looked at an extension of the, you know, there's this Interborough Express project connecting Brooklyn and Queens, very exciting project, really very supportive of it. And we're thinking about extending it to Astoria. And as we were looking at it, we're like, well, how do you do that trip now? And it's like, there isn't really like a single bus that that sort of solves that that problem for you. You know, the Queens grid is it's like a whole other animal to sort of resolve.
SPEAKER_02And so, you know, we thought that would be really interesting. Uh Co-op City in the Bronx is built in you know, post-1940. 50,000 people live there. It's surrounded by highways, uh, Bay Plaza is there. It's just like they really could use a subway. So let's extend the six train. Um, and then we looked at where the you know the busiest buses are because that's like a good proxy for where you should build your next subway. Um, and you know, going cross town on Fordham Road in the Bronx. You know, there's no east-west subway in the Bronx.
SPEAKER_02And so we thought that would be really exciting. The BX12 is the busiest bus in the Bronx. Um, Utica Avenue in Brooklyn, another very busy bus route, another project that's been sort of like in the hopper since 2nd Avenue subway as well. And, you know, I'm sure both of you are sort of familiar with the Utica line. As you get to that part of Brooklyn, it's very low density auto-body repair, industrial sort of area. And so what a subway would do is I don't know if you are totally familiar with like some of the redevelopment like along Linden Boulevard uh by Junius Street.
SPEAKER_02But it's like you see six, seven-story buildings going up and just like a lot of interesting development that would provide housing. And this is sort of I think the magical key to unlock that potential.
SPEAKER_00Utica is one of the most beautiful stations in the system. I love it. Yeah. I love the mosaic. And it's one of those stations that feels kind of open.
SPEAKER_02Well, it was built for more trains.
SPEAKER_00Is oh that's why? Well, yeah, is it underutilized?
SPEAKER_02Well, there's um sort of a above the the platform, there's um, if you look at the up in the ceiling, there's like a cutout uh for tracks running above it.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell That's crazy. Okay, I'm putting that on my list next to Jacob's ladder having been shot underneath the Bergen Street G F train. Uh folks living in Borham Hill, Cobble Hill, next time you're on the F and your train goes through Bergen Street, look out your window and look down. And you can see these abandoned tracks where uh one of the great uh Vietnam Adrian Line movies, although I think it's the only Vietnam Adrian Line movie uh starring Tim Robbins was shot.
SPEAKER_00So there was a great article about um your plan by Stefanos Chen in the New York Times, and he asked a couple of advocates what they thought of your plan. Danny Perlstein of the Riders Alliance said we should do both. Okay. Kate Slevin, RPA, Regional Plan Association, basically said it's really hard to get money. I mean, she she I took it as shed your plan and sort of said the pot's not that big, let's let's use a cheaper idea, even though your idea is that the case is not a good idea.
SPEAKER_00But does it cost a billion dollars a year to be able to do that? Yeah, you know, even though that idea is I don't know. Her uh what how did what did you make of her quote?
SPEAKER_02I love Kate.
SPEAKER_00No, no, yeah. I'm not I'm not trying to God damn. Are you you should run for office? The reason I'm asking you this is it seemed that both Danny and Kate were being very careful not to shit on the mayor's free buses. That is totally in keeping with who they are and what they do for a living. They are advocates that have to remain in his good graces. They are thrilled that we have a transit mayor. Absolutely. And the last thing they're gonna do is go on the record and say this is a better billion.
SPEAKER_00But you you can say that.
SPEAKER_01I can. That's true. And I did. There's a possibility to get something done that is maybe a decent use of an awful lot of dough. And it seems like in the transit world, lots of people are are saying it's so hard to get anything done, why fight the existing thing? And you're offering a different thing.
SPEAKER_02I am why dream big. I mean, uh as as the mayor said, audacious and expansive. What he represents is a break from the past, an exciting, bold future. Free bus is, you know, just it's it's just not a transformative idea. Um and I think even the data from the bus pilot, I think some of it is encouraging, but it it you know, it did not spur development, it did not change people's, you know, um, commuting patterns, um, it didn't take cars off the road.
SPEAKER_02And look, if people that already use the bus use it more frequently, like I don't see that as a bad thing. Like I think that's fine. Um, you know, other people have sort of dismissed dismissed that sort of data point, but it's 30% ridership growth for 1% slower buses. You build a subway like IBX where the ridership projection is 200,000 riders a day, and you start, you know, lay layering those numbers on across some of these other lines, uh you're you're talking about way more than 30% more bus ridership.
SPEAKER_02Um and you're talking about, you know, expanding this the city's you know tax base, you know, new new development, all that kind of stuff because our budget keeps just getting bigger and bigger. We gotta we gotta put some more dollars in there.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Your plan is as much a housing plan as it is a transit plan.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Um that didn't really come up in that article.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Mamdani has pledged 200,000 new units of housing in 10 years to go along with fast and free buses. Your report, a better billion, talks about how housing development has historically traced the route of subway extensions. You were talking about this a little bit earlier, Eric. Can you give us some concrete examples of a way in the 30s and 40s that um subway came first and then housing came in response to it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean look, I think the history of the Bronx in general is one where it went from like, you know, a nature reserve and sort of, you know, I don't know, Governor Morris's estate and like, you know, rich people like summered there in the 19th century, even. And then with the introduction of the elevated trains and streetcars and then the subway, it very quickly turned into like, you know, the Grand Concourse and like urbanized and big buildings.
SPEAKER_02I think, you know, the Grand Concourse is like the largest concentration of like Art Deco buildings in the Bronx, definitely, uh maybe in the country. I think one of the things that's been most striking, and I actually be curious what you all think. Um, so I'm from Manhattan. The idea that the South Bronx would have a skyline is unfathomable. Green Point, Williamsburg, going towards Queensborough Plaza, distinct skyline, right? Like tall buildings that you see uh when you look across the East River.
SPEAKER_02Um, downtown Brooklyn. I spent a lot of time at the Fulton Mall as a kid. You know, it's it's unrecognizable. So in the 60s, New York was looking at developing like a master land use plan for the city. And they published all this stuff and they debated it and they ended up not doing it. And someone, you know, apocryphal or not, I don't know, but they're like, the master plan of New York is the subway. Like that's where you do the building. And all the skylines I just mentioned all adjacent to the subway.
SPEAKER_02And so I I think you know, we want to focus our energy building, you know, dense housing near, you know, fast and speedy transit. And I think that's the other side of why subway is better than bus, is that subway is faster. Um, it saves people real time on their commute. Um, you know, even if we get the butt the bus going faster, which I am very supportive of, it's not gonna be going, you know, 35 miles per hour.
SPEAKER_02So you can't really trade off, you know, distance and time in that way. And like that's what a fast subway gives you. It's like I can move a bit farther out, and like, you know, they're gonna build some new housing by Queens College. Like I can maybe live there and get into my job in Midtown or wherever, um, in the same amount of time if I had lived in like Long Island City or, you know, whatever it is. And so that's why the emphasis on subway, and that's why, you know, subway suburbs, as they've been called, sort of are not suburban in sort of the American sense of the suburbs.
SPEAKER_02They're they're high density because you can get a lot of people there. They're very high capacity.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell So separate from your plan, there are these new Metro North stations coming. And that's been a big development spur in the Bronx. Yep. As well, and having it as less of a near co-op city bastard. Yeah. Yeah. Um for for you know people from north of the city and all that. Look, part of the argument for buses, politically speaking, is, you know, it's still the MTA, you're still dealing with the state, but that the mayor has closer control because the the mayor's control of the streets.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And they're they're able to do some of this. And some of these jerry-rigged projects that we've seen, and the IBX sort of fits into this, that it's not quite a train, but it is. Um you can feel all this. Uh people take the ferry and then find out that they have to transfer it, even though that fare is subsidized, right, that that uh it doesn't link up with the rest of the system, all those parts. That all seems like part of the argument for stressing buses. A mayor necessarily wants to think about the things he has a little more control over, and there are all these interlocking levels of government.
SPEAKER_01The whole point of the MTA is so that the mayor isn't to blame, you know, for for raising the nickel fare. Trevor Burrus, Jr. That's right. Is there some way potentially, politically, practically, to break through some of that? You know, it's striking to me that it's it's you know, some nerds at NYU respectfully who are coming up with this big, ambitious plan and that there aren't planners inside the government. Andrew Cuomo very much liked to talk of himself that way. Aaron Powell The Builder. Yeah. But you know, we have this new merit sort of broken through these old elites, and it seems to me like the old elites had dropped the ball on some of this what's the big vision?
SPEAKER_01What are we doing over the next 50 years or 40 years?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell And I'm gonna circle back to Amy's question about the quotes. And I think the thing to me that is surprising is that people have a pretty dim view of what we can do, right? No one is saying like I would if if if someone else put out this plan and someone came to me and asked me about it, I'd be like, well, you know, maybe this project I don't like or that one I don't like, but I fucking love that someone's proposing something big.
SPEAKER_02Like, you know, we have 12 projects. I don't care. Get rid of all 12, do another 12. It doesn't matter to me. Like how many new stations do 12 projects.
SPEAKER_01How many new 64 stations? 64 miles. 41 miles, 12 projects.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's that's a lot. Right. So it's like if you look at the MTA's 20 years needs assessment, the last 20 years needs assessment, the only subway stuff in there is the Second Avenue subway. A lot of the research that that we do is about the high costs of subway construction and trying to bring those down. And so we thought it was like a neat combination of our expertise in that stuff and like the real world application by applying it to New York as like our laboratory.
SPEAKER_01New York is so unique and special that it costs like three times as much to build a mile here than anywhere else in the world. Trevor Burrus, Jr. Right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And Eric, you say there's three reasons for that. One is the cost of labor. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_02Oh, oh. There are many reasons. But yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Why are subways so damn expensive?
SPEAKER_02Trevor Burrus, Jr.: So the I mean the the big issue, and the MTA has started to attack this is you know our station sizes. So for Second Avenue phase, you know, you talked about the Utica station, but you've been, I assume you've been to the Q the new Q-train stations. Like they are very large, very overbuilt, a lot of volume. Um, and you know, building underground is the most expensive way to build. And building in Manhattan, uh, you know, on the Upper East Side is like a pretty expensive place to do it.
SPEAKER_02So, you know, the stations for 2nd Avenue, they have 600-foot platforms, you know, uh standard 10-car train. Um, but the station boxes, so the total volume that had to be excavated, the length is, you know, a thousand feet, fourteen hundred feet, and sixteen hundred feet. So much larger than those platforms. And if you go to like Astor Place or you know, uh Wall Street, anything down over here, like the station boxes are essentially just the platforms.
SPEAKER_00Why'd they build them so big?
SPEAKER_02So they built what's known as back of house space. So all this space for the people that operate and maintain the subway. So, you know, from your track maintainers, your HVAC, elevator escalator, you know, the train operators themselves, conductors, um, and they all have um, you know, locker rooms, workspaces, changing rooms, bathrooms, eating facilities, all underground. It was asked for. And, you know, when you ask me for things, I'd be like, yeah, give it, give it, I'll take it all.
SPEAKER_02And there wasn't necessarily the the check on the ask to be like, well, that's like gonna be really expensive. Um and so for phase two of Second Avenue to the MTA's credit, you know, they they were like, well, we really need to like rein that in. And so they they announced that they have a billion one point three. Rebillion in savings just from reusing some of the old tunnel, you know, from the earlier iteration of Second Avenue, scaling back the stations, specifically the back of house space. So 77% of the construction costs of phase one of Second Avenue were in the stations.
SPEAKER_02And that's why we focus so much on that, because billions and billions of dollars were spent on those stations. But yes, we do have high labor costs, it's true. But more alarming is we have relatively low labor productivity. Um, so it takes us a long time to build things with our expensive rates. So, an example I'll give. So if you're using a tunnel boring machine, which is the machine that you know makes the tunnel, um you need to dig a really big box because these machines are like 400 feet long. They're really big.
SPEAKER_02Um and so for Second Army Phase One, it took them three years to build this launch box. When we looked around the world at other places, they're like, you can do that in six months to a year. And so if you have labor costs that are 2x and then you're taking three to six times longer to do something, those things multiply. And all of a sudden you're like, oh, that's why it's six times more expensive. That's why it's 12 times more expensive to do anything.
SPEAKER_00Isn't it also that we use consultants when we really don't need to? Because I read this book called The Big Con.
SPEAKER_02I read that book too.
SPEAKER_00And she's pissed.
SPEAKER_02She is pissed.
SPEAKER_00And a lot of what she talks about is that though consultants are used in Europe, the percentage is much lower, around 25%, and they tend to be, but she they are used for infrastructure projects there. We use them not only for infrastructure, but for, you know, an Adobe 11-page report. Can we ever s break free of our consultant addiction?
SPEAKER_02Well, so you know, going back to the first things we were talking about, we essentially stopped building subways in 1940. And so why would you maintain that expertise at your agency, right? If you're not building new subway, you don't need to have like a station engineer. You don't need to have a, you know, tunneling expert, because it's like, what's the point? But then if you're like, I'd like to start building subways again, and you haven't maintained that expertise, and you don't have that expertise, you have to find someplace to get it. But the thing is with expertise, is that like you need to be able to manage that expertise, which means you yourself need to have expertise.
SPEAKER_02But like for me, I've been doing a lot of research and I've been doing some AI stuff. And I'm always the way it's pitched to me is like, this will mean you have to like read a lot less. And I'm like, cool, I like that. But then I'm like, I don't understand what the hell this is saying to me. So I have to like still do all the reading, but then I get to direct it. And then it's like actually quite powerful. So I view the consultants as sort of like a proto AI. But the thing is, like, if you don't have the expertise to manage the proto AI, like you don't know how to say, that's good, or do this thing, or do that thing.
SPEAKER_02And like, yeah, go look into that. Like, tell me the lyrics to that song, you know, tell me when you know someone was born or what high school they went to, like as you search the internet. And it's like, that's not really how a consultant should be used. Like they should be have a clearly defined task, they should have a clear schedule, and they should be managed by a subject matter expert who's like, you're doing this correctly, you're doing this incorrectly, or let's pivot and do this thing instead, or you know, that kind of thing. And oftentimes we don't have that expertise in our agencies to guide it effectively.
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell So you think part of that is just that there was so much entropy from, say, the 1930s, 40s into now that we we did not invest in the idea of internal expertise?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Well, so the MTA in the in the in the early 80s sort of re revamped itself and created uh what's known as a capital program management team that was there to like fix stations and build new fan plants for ventilation to like get us into like you know the 20th century. And what happened was those people that were hired in the 80s start retiring by the late 90s, so like in the early 80s, and instead of replacing them, we the MTA created what's known as MTA Capital Construction, sort of a standalone agency that was in theory supposed to take over all the capital construction stuff going on at the MTA.
SPEAKER_02It didn't totally do that. Um, but they did get Second Avenue. And so basically when MTA Capital Construction was created, it did not have a huge staff, but it did have a huge remit, right? So, like if you think about when phase one was being built, we were extending the seven train, we were redoing um Fulton Street Station, East Side Access. There was like$20 billion in projects. And I think MTA Capital Construction had about 120 people working there full time. They got some support from those old timers at CPM for sure, but you know, you just you didn't have expertise in the construction management.
SPEAKER_02Because that's the other piece of all this, right? Is like you have all these contracts going during construction, and you, the client, you need to make decisions about, okay, we have a conflict, like what do we do? And being like, I don't know, let's study it. Let's look study it instead of making a decision, which is very common. Um, you know, decisiveness is quite valuable in capital construction.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell You just want to talk a bit about what happened in this city that was private companies initially, and the city itself, and then the city taking over the independent lines, and then we get to like 1940 and suddenly no more new train lines.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Right. Well, so you know the history of the subway is fascinating and not well understood. Like people often point to it as the like sort of apotheosis of private sector innovation. But what people miss is that it was publicly planned. The Public Service Commission in New York City did a lot of the design work, especially during the dual contracts, they did the construction management. It is true that private industry did the construction, which is how we do it today. And then there was a concession agreement for you know 99 years or whatever it was to IRT and BMT.
SPEAKER_02But the planning and the expertise, like the chief engineer at the public service commission made like 600, the equivalent of like$600,000 a year in today's dollars. Like we had a massive entity that was doing sewers, subways, all the underground stuff. Um, and like that does not exist in this city or in any American city.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell Why did the expansion end? There's a 40-year period of a rapidly expanding subway system. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but the population has continued to go up.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell The population goes from like four million to seven and a half million from 1900 to 1940.
SPEAKER_01And now we've got about a million more people, so a much slower rate of increase since then, but basically very limited expansion of the subway system. I'm just why why why did the this period of expansion come to an end? And as you're offering this plan for a new period of expansion.
SPEAKER_02Trevor Burrus, Jr. Well, so you know the traditional tension is between maintenance and capital construction. And so, you know, after those 40 years, the stations start to fall into disrepair, the rolling stock needs to be replaced. And so it's like, well, do I spend my money on that or on expanding the system? And as you know, the fare has been locked in at a nickel. And so while the subway was like a huge moneymaker, you know, in 1915, by 1940, it's kind of like, you know, like we need to raise the fare, you know, we we need to do some stuff.
SPEAKER_02Um, and so the other part of it obviously is there's the war and there's a limit on how much you know iron and steel you can get, um, which is actually part of the delay on 2nd Avenue. Um if I'm not mistaken, they took down the elevated on 2nd Avenue, like some of that metal was used for armaments, but maybe that's an old wives' tale, I'm not sure. Um and then you know, I think 1950, or no, maybe it's 1960, so the 1950s is the first decade in New York's history where the population does not increase.
SPEAKER_02Um and then 1980 is the the second. And so you have like this rapid growth of the suburbs, um, the surrounding suburbs in New York.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell So are we after a long period of stability and then some managed decline and austerity in different ways. That's part of this plan, the idea of having a growth vision for New York again.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah. I mean that's absolutely what the plan is. The plan is a growth vision for New York. That's what's been missing in New York, is there has not been a coherent idea of how you actually grow the city. And I would argue that the subway is the center piece of that and has been, you know, for over 100 years. And so if we want to see the city grow, and I know there's new technology and all this exciting stuff, but none of it is high capacity the way that the subway is, right? Like a full subway car can hold like 2,000 people.
SPEAKER_02And like if you're running that full subway car like the L train, you know, every you know, two to three minutes, you're talking about, you know, 2,000 people moving through the city. And then that you can get up to, you know, if it's 30 trains an hour, it's 60,000 people. You know, it's like that's an enormous number of people per direction, per hour. Um, and like you understand, oh, you know, there are two and a half million jobs in in, you know, south of 60th Street. The only way you can get those people to those jobs is if you have a very high capacity transit network like we do have.
SPEAKER_02Um and so it just seems that like we need to like lean into our strength rather than sort of ignore it.
SPEAKER_00Do you think that he came up with fast and free buses, which of course he came up with as a pilot before it became a campaign promise, because it felt small enough to be achieved, or alternately that it felt like a a signal to working class people as a way of saying, I I see you, person that rides the bus, which is a different profile of a person that rides the train a lot.
SPEAKER_02So I mean, the thing about the free bus is that it's so appealing versus our subway plan is that if you have the money and the approval, like you can do it tomorrow. Like it's it, there's no there's no time lapse, right? Like, you know, every in New York it's famous to have a groundbreaking. Technology subway had like 10 different groundbreakings, you know. Um, you know, I think Babe Ruth was at the original groundbreaking. Um, and so my only point is that like I I think from a political standpoint, like you I the appeal is quite obvious.
SPEAKER_02And I think same thing with ferries, honestly. Like you can get a ferry in the water pretty quickly. Building a new subway is gonna take you some time.
SPEAKER_00You're saying he picked it because he thinks it's achievable.
SPEAKER_02I'm not I'm not saying that's why he picked it. I don't I don't know exactly why he picked it, but I but I I think the salience of it is pretty clear. I I think if you look at any sort of research on people's budgets, there's always it's always housing, education, childcare, uh food, transportation. Like these are the and if you look at his plans, he has an answer for each of those things. The thing that that I'm pushing against is that like those things actually are not fitting together in a coherent way, the way that his created it.
SPEAKER_02He understandably like ran a campaign, was like, I got a boom, I got a plan, I got a plan, I got a plan. And what we're saying is we can actually combine some of these ideas to make a better plan. Like I think what I'm so excited about about a better billion is that we are taking the initiative on affordability, and we're taking you know the initiative on housing and on transportation and s on those two issues, and we're tying it all together in a much more powerful way than the you know the campaign did.
SPEAKER_00Totally agree. I mean, s city of yes for housing opportunity, the buzz line was like uh a little more in every neighborhood. It was it was so timid, you know, and it was obviously that it was buttoned up that way to make people not feel to make people not feel scared that people different from them would suddenly be living in a garage behind their neighbor's house. And I personally think that the timidity of that language, although it had a political purpose of getting buy-in from certain communities, it reflected this kind of bifurcated or piecemeal approach to these problems.
SPEAKER_00So not only is City of Vest for Housing Opportunity only going to be about housing, but the way we're gonna sell it is it's just a little. And a little here and a little there, it'll add up. And what you're uniting here, which is that track leads to housing, I think is important. And you know, we'll never know the reasons that in the Adams administration we did not have a transit mayor. We didn't. So the th and and we happened to have some really great and wonderful smart people on housing, like Maria Torres Springer, but it was just housing.
SPEAKER_02What Harry was saying earlier, you know, the MTA is created as the state authority to take the responsibility away from the city and the mayor to so that he or she doesn't have to deal with raising the fare and all that unpleasantness. And, you know, obviously in the de Blasio Cuomo tete tets, it was, you know, Cuomo's MTA, de Blasio's MTA, who's MTA? Like most people have no idea who controls the MTA. Like I don't, like I know I do, but I I don't have the I don't have the presumption that most people are like, you know, dialed in on this stuff.
SPEAKER_02And I I think because of that, right, it's very easy to just be like, yeah, yeah, let the state do its thing. Like I don't care. Like I'm gonna like focus. I have enough stuff to worry about, right? Like I got crime, I got schools. But what I think was refreshing about uh Imam Dani was that you know he was talking about transit and talking about speaking with the buses, and you know, like he the transit is like the lifeblood of this city. Like every anyone who lives in New York, it's like the one service that touches all of our lives on a daily basis.
SPEAKER_02And the idea that a politician would be so tone-deaf to not talk about that is mind-boggling. And so I think, you know, to Zoran's credit and his like political acumen, it was like this is a thing that like everyone's gonna understand and people will get excited about, and I'm gonna own it in a way that like no one else, for whatever reasons, is willing to like get into. And I I I think that the city could have more control if it put up more money, but it's loath to do so, right?
SPEAKER_02You know, one of the stats that's like the most staggering is like right before the depression, uh, when Jimmy Walker was mayor, the city spent like in 1929 dollars, like$100 million a year on like subway construction. And then, you know, like in the Giuliani years, like he never they never gave a hundred million dollars to the MTA for the capital program. The current capital plan is$68 billion, something like that, the five-year plan. Like the city's contribution is maybe$2 billion. You know, it's like it's a it's a small, small piece of it. And so if you want the MTA to look more like what the city wants, you know, you gotta put up or shut up.
SPEAKER_02You know, like it's just that simple.
SPEAKER_00So Harry and I are from Brooklyn. You are from Union Square.
SPEAKER_02My dad is from Brooklyn. I don't know if that changes anything.
SPEAKER_00Well, clearly he did well because he was from Brooklyn.
SPEAKER_02That's the dream of Brooklyn. He doesn't understand why people want to move to Brooklyn.
SPEAKER_00In Manhattan, when you were growing up going to school in St. Anne's, um, and you would go back into Manhattan, did you did you refer to it as I have to go into the city?
SPEAKER_02No, I I I don't say the city.
SPEAKER_00When you walk down the street, are you more annoyed by bad walkers, meaning walkers who have no clue of who's around them, or bad passers?
SPEAKER_02Oh.
SPEAKER_01Bad passers.
SPEAKER_00Same, Harry.
SPEAKER_01All these fucking people learn to walk. How do you feel about the map? The new map? And uh how important was the map for you when you were a kid? And honestly, without the map, like like there were bus maps, but the bus maps were fucked, and that was part of why no one took the buses, is you either you already already know or you can't figure out how to get from A to B.
SPEAKER_00Where did you even see the bus maps?
SPEAKER_01It's on the bus.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the front.
SPEAKER_00There used to be on the on the front, right. But then you're already you're already on the wrong bus.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's true. Um so talking to like my friends who are my age, they hate the new map. You know, and I I don't I I I kind of like the new map because I I like that it shows all the lines separately. Like I think that's like a nice I think it's clean and I think it is sensible. For me as a kid, like yes, the map was the end-all be-all. Um, and I would be like, what is this middle village?
SPEAKER_00Are you in favor of Manhattan appearing to be directly north-south when we know that it's actually pitched?
SPEAKER_02Uh I think that for the sake of you know communication, it's okay. I'm okay with that.
SPEAKER_00Eric, you and I met on a transit nerd trip. We went on a bus to Hornell.
SPEAKER_02Hornell, that's right.
SPEAKER_00To look at a train manufacturing plant. I gotta say, I mean, I was definitely the hottest person on that trip. I mean, whoo, boy. Um, but I got to meet a lot of great guys, very friendly, very friendly. It was basically like a 10-hour bus trip each way to then look at trains. Somebody on that trip in the transit nerd world uh told me about this thing called numtot and then numtinder. NumTot is new urban memes.
SPEAKER_00So have any of your students told you that they've been dating on NumbTinder? And have any of them met anyone? Because we're recording this the day before Valentine's Day.
SPEAKER_02I am not aware of any students meeting up that way. But what I will say is that there is a very deep interest in these things. And like whenever I go to talks or give a talk, I'm surprised that like so many people turn up and so many people are like, you know, just deeply interested in this stuff. I mean, again, the way I've I've talked about the subway, I think is pretty normal, and I think all people should feel that way about it, because like it is transformative and amazing. So I I get it. I get why why it makes sense.
SPEAKER_01I predicted a lot of this not so great century that uh as people started communicating on phones and got online, that this was gonna fundamentally change the nature of street crime with things like drug sales and prostitution. Sure. Felt good about that. Saw the robot future coming, wrote some of these things, talked about them, got them. But my big thing I was really confident about was that uh buses were gonna become awesome because the maps were gonna be less important.
SPEAKER_01So instead of buses being secret or local knowledge that otherwise were difficult to ride, work out where you were going, that they were gonna be remarkably accessible, the fixed costs are much less because the streets are already there and all that. Why was I so wrong about that?
SPEAKER_02Because they're slow and unreliable. Like the the thing that people look for in transportation, right, is reliability and speed. And you know, like so I wrote my dissertation about dollar vans in Brooklyn. Um so the book, the vans on Flatbush Avenue, it just follows the B-41 bus. Like it doesn't actually do anything any different. What it does do is that it skips a bunch of stops where, you know, you know, people of West Indian descent don't live, right? So like you can go from Atlantic to church without stopping, which is incredible. You have a guaranteed seat, it's faster and it's more reliable.
SPEAKER_02And like, so I, you know, I like timed it all out, like and compared it to the bus. And like, just like the bus's reliability is so bad that you have to basically on the B41 to go end to end, add in an extra half hour because maybe it'll be stuck in traffic, maybe it won't come on time, you know, just like whatever it is. And like if you're trying to go to school, like you can't be a half hour late. Like you're trying to go to a job at Atlantic Terminal, you can't be a half hour late. But to your sort of one of your other points about the fixed costs is that like it's just a much lower capacity vehicle than a subway, right?
SPEAKER_02So even our our articulated buses, like the select buses, I think it's maybe like 60 people maybe. It's just like that's you know, and you need one driver, right? So like you're paying that salary. Um whereas a subway, you could, if you can move 2,000 people for the cost of a driver and a you know, an engineer and a conductor, um, you know, your per passenger costs are are are quite a bit lower.
unknownTrevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_01I got one more big question for you. Please. You don't really need conductors anymore. We have hole lines like the L without them. We don't have stationed people anymore. There's an efficiency and scale set of things that come with that, but there's also real issues with lost knowledge and expertise that going back to AI, you solve some of these problems, but then you don't end up with anyone who knows shit about it. About Chinola. And these are actually not jobs that travel or transport very well.
SPEAKER_01So educating its own workforce is a big thing for the MTA. And it needs to be reliable so it doesn't lose its knowledge. But those people don't really have a ton of other jobs they can go into from there.
SPEAKER_02So we did this report on the conductors, and sort of there was a bill passed in Albany that was going to mandate them. And we were just like, that's not a good idea. And we just made a list of train operations all over the world. And I think only 6% of the the projects in our survey, which was not necessarily comprehensive, it was 400 projects, had to, you know, both a conductor and a an engineer. And the rest, you know, the n other 94% are either one person or zero people. And so the the movement is towards automation. Um, but I think what is real and what we are constantly talking about the subway is like the issues of disorder and fear and so on and so forth.
SPEAKER_02And, you know, as I'm sure you both remember, there was like a big fight about token booth clerks. And like in the 70s and 80s, there was like also a lot of attacks on token booth clerks. So I think there was maybe an understanding that that's a dangerous job, and maybe we should like, you know, try to not have as many people doing that. It was and also the cost, of course, was was it was a driving force.
SPEAKER_01But if like then it's sort of dangerous not to have somebody there who's like eyes on the street, shout out to Money Train, just while we're talking about all this.
SPEAKER_02But yeah, I mean my thought is move to the move to Opto, move the conductors into the stations. You know, if you go to like London or Paris, like that's what they've done. Like London at every train station, like there's a person in a vest that you can like talk to. Like what we've put in our stations are people at gates that you can't talk to. People still have questions, like uptown and downtown. Like, you know, I train my whole life to understand the northeast corner of whatever. Like the nomenclature in the subway system is baffling. Like, I don't like whoever came up with it is a fucking sadist.
SPEAKER_02Um, like it should be much clearer. Uh, it should be much more user-friendly.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02Um, and like it shouldn't be like as a 13-year-old being like, I will master this system because like I need to like feel proud of something.
SPEAKER_00Um and uh But you were saying, you were saying opt- you're talking, what does Opto mean?
SPEAKER_02So the I in that's one-person train operations. Oh so there you just have the engineer, there's no conductor in the middle of the train. When the TWU was fighting, that's the union that represents the the workers of the subway, fighting for this bill and fighting against, you know, the the governor vetoed the bill. You know, they were like, well, you know, like the conductor's there for safety and is there for like this thing and for that thing. And, you know, there was not like actually a coherent answer as to what the conductor does. The conductor, honestly, what the New York Times and everyone else should do is make the video of what the conductor does.
SPEAKER_02Conductor just they push the button um, you know, to close the doors. I mean, they look out the window to make sure that everything is is clear, but you know, it it's a job that can be automated. If she had signed that bill, we would have to have it for forever two person train operations. So, you know, as we're building Interborough Express, what we should be doing is building an automated train that runs every 90 seconds. How'd you give into the train? I'm from New York. I mean, it's it's look, you know, my dad's from Brooklyn, I'm a Mets fan, my grandmother's born in the Bronx.
SPEAKER_02You know, it's sort of like and I live in Manhattan. So it's sort of like in order to get anywhere, you gotta be on the subway. And I think, you know, once I get got to high school, it was just like the most liberating thing ever. Like you could go anywhere, like everything was possible. And then people that are not from New York, I'm kind of just like, uh you miss this like amazing thing. Oh, totally. Um, like you could go everywhere, and um I just think that is such like an amazing thing. And I you know, like I have young kids and they're really into the bus currently.
SPEAKER_02Um but you know, I just I can't wait for them to sort of realize that they can just like go do something without me or their mom and like have an experience and see something different. And it's just like that's the most amazing thing any human being can experience. Like, it's just like it's a it's awesome.
SPEAKER_00Eric, thank you so much for coming in uh for talking to us about your plan, a better billion, and really excited to hear what else the Marin Institute comes up with as we continue in our new mayoral administration.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. F-A-Q.
SPEAKER_01WithNYC is hosted by Amy Stone and me, Harry Siegel. I'm also the executive producer of the FAQ NYC Podcast Network. This episode was produced by Amy Stone and engineered by Noah Smith. If you like the show, rate us, review us, wherever you get your podcasts, email us at withnycod at proton.me. That's with NYC Pod at Proton.me. The show is a production of the FAQ NYC Podcast Network, which is made possible in part by support from the Charles H. Revson Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, and from PNT Newware, an independent bookstore, cafe, and event space in Manhattan's Lower East Side with a podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use.
SPEAKER_01The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of the podcast, which is Project of the City, a nonprofit newsroom delivering hard-hitting investigative journalism that serves the people of New York. A special thank you to our guest, Eric Goldman of the Marin Institute at NYU. Their plan, a better billion, is available at transitcosts.com. And thank you, listener, for making it this far. Be easy on yourself, kind to everyone else, and we'll be back soon with more.
SPEAKER_01Why did the seven train connect to the L?
SPEAKER_02That would have been a great sound. I've always been curious about that. It would be a great idea. Because the tail tracks on the seven actually like go down to 23rd Street. Yeah, they're like almost hugging. No, no, I it's a thing that I once proposed. Um did you? So like when they were shutting down the L train, or they were talking about shutting down the L train, yeah. It was like an idea that like since you're shutting it down, like use that time to also connect to those tail tracks and like solve the bottleneck at Eighth Avenue.
SPEAKER_02Um but they didn't end up. They didn't shut it down. Yeah. And uh, but like that would be the whole thing with the subway is that like since it's this 24 7 thing, you never have these opportunities without like being hugely disruptive. And then obviously they were gonna do something very disruptive. So it's like just like get a lot of stuff done.
As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...
Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...
New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.
For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...