Philip T. Yanos´ `Exiles in New York City: Warehousing the Marginalized on Ward's Island´
48 minAudio
Clinical psychologist Philip T. Yanos, the author of "Exiles in New York City: Warehousing the Marginalized on Ward's Island," talks about host Amy Sohn about growing up in a place a stone’s throw from Manhattan, Queens and the Bronx that’s been used over decades to house the mentally ill, the homeless and migrants - and that’s now connected through landfill with the sports fields of Randall's Island.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01It's lit NYC, the New Yorkist show about the ABCs of arts, books, culture, institutionalization, etc. I'm Amy Sohn. My guest today, Philip Yanos, is author of the 2025 book Exiles of New York City: Warehousing the Marginalized on Ward's Island. It looks at the history, legacy, and future of this island, a stone's throw from northern Manhattan, the Bronx, and Queens, that for nearly 200 years has been a dumping ground for the city's mentally ill, homeless, and in more recent years, migrants.
SPEAKER_01Phil lived there for about 10 years in the 1970s with his parents and brother when his father was a psychiatrist at what was then called Manhattan State Hospital. The family lived in a cottage rented from the state. Later, Phil was a volunteer at Manhattan Psychiatric Center in the early 1990s. He writes in the book, Ward's Island stands out among North American and European urban settings as a single geographic location in which so many institutions for marginalized persons are located next to each other.
SPEAKER_01I have not been able to identify a comparable setting located on an island in any other major urban center in America. Today, if you're driving a car from Manhattan to LaGuardia on the Triborough Bridge Overpass, you actually go right over Wards Island. But most people, many people have never heard of it or its history. To complicate matters, many people now refer to what's actually Wards Island as Randall's Island, even though Randall's Island is separate and connected to Wards by landfill.
SPEAKER_01And we will get into that. Phil is professor of psychology at John Jay College of Criminal Justice and the Graduate Center at CUNY. He is also the author of Written Off: Mental Health Stigma and the Loss of Human Potential. Phil, welcome to Lit NYC.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much. It's a huge honor to be on the New Yorkist podcast as a New Yorker.
SPEAKER_01You open your book with the story of Carlos, a patient of yours in 2013 who is diagnosed with schizophrenia and living in Manhattan Psychiatric Center on the island. You go to visit him and you walk on the RFK Bridge, the Triborough Bridge, in August, and you look around you and you notice all of these teens and 20-somethings with glitter on their faces, and you realize that you've chosen to go to Wards Island the same day as the Electric Zoo Festival at Icon Stadium on Randall's Island, which is going to take place for a hundred thousand electronic music kid freaks.
SPEAKER_01And you find yourself thinking about this strange juxtaposition. These kids are like obsessed with electronic music, and and you're going to Manhattan Psychiatric Center. So tell me about that day in your own words.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Well, um, it's not that I hadn't heard of Electric Zoo or that I have anything against um electronic music. Um uh but it really was such an odd combination of things, being that I was going to visit somebody who was being detained, you know, in this place that's uh very drab uh and very institutional looking, and that I had this personal history uh connecting me to. Just realizing that people who were going to the festival didn't know uh anything about the people who were living on the island right next to where they were going to be partying, you know, is really something that struck me.
SPEAKER_02And that's why I decided to open the book with that um with that story.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell And tell me about Carlos's story, because it's it's an interesting parable about what has always seemed to me like these contradictions around treatment of mental illness, where some of the steps that you might be taking to be good for you then cause you to have to lose other housing and in the long run are actually not good.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So um uh obviously certain details about his story are uh changed to protect uh his identity. Um but basically he was somebody who lived in um independent scattersite housing um in the community. Scatter site housing is uh the housing first model is when you uh rent apartments in the general community and you sublet them to people who have uh special needs. Um and uh they pay a portion of their fixed income toward your rent, but you uh have a it's subsidized.
SPEAKER_02So if you uh make uh a thousand a month in a supplementary security income, SSI, uh then you would pay uh 30% of that toward your rent,$300. And because he was having this increase in symptoms that uh led to him being transferred to the state hospital, where you stay for usually a minimum of six months, he lost his apartment and he lost his treatment team in the community, and he had to had to kind of start over when he left. So um that's really kind of what was sad about it.
SPEAKER_02And uh it's not that he didn't benefit from the treatment, he did, but it also harmed his life circumstances in other ways.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Did you find out what happened to him?
SPEAKER_02I haven't. I haven't uh heard because he was no longer a client of our agencies. And at one point he called me on my phone uh sometime after he'd been discharged just to touch base, but that was the last time that I talked to him.
SPEAKER_01So the number of people that are living on Words Island now is what?
SPEAKER_02Um the best estimate I can give comes from the 2020 census, right? So that's a few years old, but it was it was about uh 1,300 at the time.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell And that's from a peak of around 8,000 at Manhattan State Hospital, I think you say?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Right. So the hospital itself had 8,000. I think that um there were those folks were not able to freely come and go, right, um when the hospital had that many people. But um I think the population of the island was a lot higher um in the 80s when the shelter was much larger, and the census of the hospital was much larger as well. So it has come down, uh, but it's still over a thousand people. And most of those folks are in the shelters, in the community residences, um, in the residential substance use treatment program, um, you know, other settings where they can come and go, you know, you know, between the island and the city.
SPEAKER_01Talk a little bit about the history of Wards Island beginning with the 1840s. And can you explain to me why were remote urban areas so popular for the treatment of the mentally ill?
SPEAKER_02Well, so to start with Wards Island, it started before um the location of the uh New York City Asylum for the Insane, right, which opened uh there in 1871. But what really uh started it was um the immigrant uh asylum and refuge, right? And uh what I uh recount in the book is this story of kind of um, you know, uh 19th-century NIMBYism, where uh the city planned to open this immigrant refuge in Astoria, right?
SPEAKER_02Not yet part of New York City, but close to it. And uh it's said that the resident local residents went and destroyed it, you know, in the middle of the night. So they kind of spoke with their torches and their clubs or whatever other instruments they used to destroy this place, and the city then um immediately rushed to buy the land on this remote island that was reachable only by ferry, um, and with designs on buying the whole thing so that they could use it to put whatever institutions they needed to without community opposition.
SPEAKER_02Um the location of an asylum uh for the quote insane in a remote location was consistent with the standards of the time, which was that places should be located uh, you know, I think at least three miles outside of an urban area. And for a lot of cities, that meant it was somewhere on the fringe, and eventually the city expanded out and it was kind of no longer on the fringe. Um so like St. Elizabeth's in Washington, D.C. is in uh south uh east DC, and uh the city has gradually moved in that direction, but it's still a pretty remote part of D.C.
SPEAKER_02Um but New York being the way it was bounded, you know, as as at that time is only Manhattan Island, you couldn't put things that far away. So the uh extra islands in the East River became um the play way to go with that. So Roosevelt Island was a big part of it, Black Bell's Island as it was called at the time, and then Ward's Island was the next one.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell And the weird thing about the name Wards Island is you know you think of a ward of the state, but of course it was named after these two brothers who were Jasper and Bartholomew Ward, and they initially uh were real estate developers.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Yeah, yeah. So they were merchants and and they um bought a lot of property and they had this idea that um it could be residentially developed. And so they helped set up a ferry and they built this wooden bridge, and uh it just didn't work out for them. Uh and uh it didn't pan out into a residential type place. It was just too long to get to the city, I guess, in those days.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell So Words Island was also a potter's field beginning in 1850, um which is a burial ground for people who could not afford uh burials, right? Right. And what were some of the other marginalized groups in its history um who lived there?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Right. So there was the inebriate asylum, right? Uh so it started with the the immigrants, right? And then it was the inebriate asylum, uh, then it was the New York City Asylum for the Insane. And then later on uh it became a location of uh of the first kind of major shelter outside of uh the Bowery, right? Um, and that was in 1980. And then um in the 70s, um, it also the Odyssey House opened, uh, which is a residential substance treatment program.
SPEAKER_02And um uh uh it's also been the location for a children's psychiatric hospital. So kind of I think the most places that it's had was probably sometime in uh the early 80s when there was still the children's hospital there, there was Odyssey house going on, and the shelters it opened as well. Although there's still a large number of people who were living there now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and our listeners may be interested to know that Scott Joplin was housed there in 1917 for syphilis, which he ultimately died of.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01And old dirty bastard of the Wu-Tang clan was housed on Ward's Island, I think, in conjunction with the criminal justice system.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell He was transferred there um and he was at Manhattan Psychiatric Center. Uh he was there for a period of months, um, and not much is known about it. But if you do watch the um Wu Tang documentary, uh there's a scene where he's being picked up by his family in front of Manhattan Psychiatric Center um after he was discharged. So he was transferred there after he got out of um uh a you know jail system.
SPEAKER_01But was he transferred there because of something related to his mental health?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it was for mental health issues, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And he had this incredible uh way of describing Words Island and his experience there.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I don't I don't think it was it Hellhole or Hellhole Hotel is what he said. Aaron Ross Powell the Hell Hole Hotel. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01You say that there's evidence that immigration is a risk factor for schizophrenia, and that immigrants are 1.7 times more likely to develop psychosis than native-born populations. This was really staggering to me. I I thought that this was genetic.
SPEAKER_02Sure. So um this is a very consistent finding. Um and uh it's not something necessarily that members of immigrant communities want to hear that they're at higher risk for these types of conditions, but it's something that's um pretty consistently supported. And the mechanisms of it are difficult to explain because when we we have this vulnerability stress model for the development of these mental health conditions, and uh we we know that there's some combination between genetic predisposition and environmental stress that leads to the expression of these conditions, but we can never really pinpoint it to one stressful experience.
SPEAKER_02Um the only thing I can say is, and speaking as a child of immigrants myself, that uh when you're an immigrant, you're constantly worrying about fitting in and how what you're doing is perceived by others because you're uh you're aware that you're different. And so that kind of process uh and the uh experiences of exclusion and being told that you're acting strangely or you're not um doing what people are supposed to do in that experience is something that uh is not that different from the kind of self-doubt and persecutory kind of ideas that people have when they're experiencing psychosis in the early stages.
SPEAKER_02So that's kind of how I understand it. Um but it's it's a very consistent finding. And we know that it's not due to misdiagnosis, we know that it's not due to um differences between that group and their home country, right? So you compare the rates people in their home country um and in the um country they immigrated to, you don't find uh that it's higher in the home country. And it's one of the reasons why immigrants were so overrepresented in the state hospital system for its entire history, um, as I talk about in the book.
SPEAKER_01Can you talk a little bit more about that? I mean, so you're saying on the one hand, the incidence is higher, um, but you think that some of these people were wrongly diagnosed and correctly diagnosed as being mentally ill when they were just struggling to become new Americans?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Well, that's hard to know, too. Um that is possible. Um we certainly know that immigrants uh this isn't in the in my book, but we know that immigrants were uh mislabeled as being uh unintelligent, right? Um, you know, uh my my uh you know immigrant bat uh ancestors and probably yours were labeled as morons by um you know people who conducted psychological testing on Ellis Island and those places. Um and uh that was uh something that was a misuse of psychological tests, right?
SPEAKER_02So perhaps some of it was misunderstanding, but um a lot of it was also um genuine uh distress and nobody there really to pick up the pieces for the person. Uh maybe because they were here living alone. You know, a lot of immigrant groups, men came by themselves first, working to send money back home, and they didn't have a lot of social support. So uh there was no one there to kind of help them, you know, recover, and they ended up in the public system.
SPEAKER_02Uh so there are stories like that that that I've seen. Um so some of it was that. Um, and some of it was also um, you know, uh w one of the patterns that happened with state hospitals was that uh people who dis who had developed dementias and um conditions related to stroke, right, so elderly people, uh ended up in the uh public uh uh state hospital system um in the early part of the 20th century. And about up to 50 percent of the um population of the state hospitals was made up of elderly folks who we would never think of sending to a state hospital nowadays.
SPEAKER_02So there were probably a lot of instances of that as well, especially with families, you know, like during the Depression, uh didn't have the resources to keep their elder relative who was developing dementia or post-stroke syndrome at home. And um, then they went into the state hospital system.
SPEAKER_01In so many ways, the history of Wards Island is the history of perceptions of mental illness over over time. Another thing I was really struck by in your book was there was this idea after the Civil War that freedom was stressful, and that because of this, black Americans had higher rates of insanity.
SPEAKER_02Right, right. It was a very racist assumption, right, that um that being allowed to be free was going to cause um greater stress, right, and that it was gonna lead uh to higher rates of insanity. Now, the part of it that has a grain of truth is that the racial discrimination that ensued, right, could contribute, right? So we know that um uh racism is a contributor to um higher rates of psychosis among uh ple people of African descent.
SPEAKER_02But it wasn't because people were free, it was because now they were going to be uh mistreated in a new way in this allegedly free state that they were in.
SPEAKER_01You mentioned Blackwells Island a little earlier. Um I wrote about Blackwells Island in my book, The Man Who Hated Women, which is about birth control in the 19th century. And Blackwells Island was where a lot of women were sent at one point. At one point it was the women's workhouse. Um as you mentioned, Blackwells Island is present-day Roosevelt Island. Um talk a little bit about Nellie Bly's 1886 expose of Blackwells Island and what that had to do with changing treatment regimes at Ward's Island.
SPEAKER_02Well, what it really resulted in was the closure of the uh women's asylum, right, on Blackwells Island, um, which you talked about in your book and which Stacey Horn talked about in Damnation Island. There was uh the workhouse, uh there was the penitentiary, and there was the asylum. So um perhaps it was the same time, but it led to the closure of the women's asylum, and that meant that the population on Wards Island was uh going to expand because all of the uh folk the women uh were now going to be moving to uh Wards Island where the men had been.
SPEAKER_02So that was one result of it, is that it led to an expansion of the population of Wards Island. Um, another was that it just meant that the institutional focus was shifting upriver, basically. Um it also meant that there was more scrutiny because uh after that bombshell um report, um now there was more attention being paid to the very poor conditions that people were living in. And uh a result of that, uh eventual result of that was that the state took over the asylum.
SPEAKER_02So it was New York City Asylum for the Insane and then became Manhattan State Hospital.
SPEAKER_01Robert Moses is reviled today, and I think many people don't get that you don't get the great things about the New Deal and LaGuardia without Robert Moses, and that for every horrendous uh you know, prospect expressway, you also probably have a playground that's courtesy of Moses. He plays a very large role in um having had this vision of Wards Island as a park, and of course that has reminiscences today, now that we have private school kids playing soccer in lacrosse.
SPEAKER_01So talk a little bit about Robert Moses' vision and what happened. How long did Wards Island Park, as it was then called, uh how long did that exist and what's the legacy of that today?
SPEAKER_02Well, it was it didn't really start with him. It started with the Regional Planning Association's recommendation, right? That uh Wards and Reynolds Island be used as parkland. But he was the one who could put all the pieces together to make it happen. And he combined it with the Tri-Borough Bridge idea, which came about with New Deal funds. And um he was like, well, I could build my highway overpass and we can turn it into parkland. But um the trick was that the institutions had to go uh from his uh perspective because he wanted it to be all parkland.
SPEAKER_02And he was successful um with that, with Randall's Island, which had a children's hospital on it, uh, and he was not successful with Manhattan State Hospital, which even though the laws uh laws were passed that it was going to be closed by 1943, it never came to be, and it's still there now. So um his park development was successful in that they did build sports fields and picnic grounds. Uh it wasn't successful in that people didn't really use them. You know, like when I was living there, uh as you mentioned at the beginning, um we were pretty much on our own there.
SPEAKER_02There weren't people coming to hang out. And play on the island. So it was kind of like it was a hidden gem, I guess, in that sense. Now it has a lot more usage. So the Randall's Island Park Alliance, which has put a lot of money into upgrading facilities, kind of has been able to realize some of Moses' vision for this beautiful place being a place that people are actually using. But Moses didn't get to see that in his lifetime.
SPEAKER_01This is so strange. I mean, you were living in this beautiful space. You were surrounded by the stars, greenery, you had this little yard, but you write in the book that your friends didn't come to visit you that often. Tell me what it was like in the 70s and tell me about the blackout in 1977. You you and I are not that many years apart, and I have memories of July 1977. You experienced the blackout on Wards Island.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So uh just in general, I would say it was um a nice childhood there. We did have some local friends. There were a couple other families that lived there and that we played with. Um, you know, we played sports. We it wasn't enough kids to like put a game together, but you could do play catch and stuff like that. Aaron Ross Powell, Jr.
SPEAKER_01Were these other families who had uh parents working in Manhattan State Hospital?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, that's right. So like our good friend uh was he was the son of uh an ambulance driver for the hospital. And so and then there was another set of friends who were the kids of the Protestant minister in the chapel that um used to exist there, um, that no longer does. So those were the kids that we hung out with and played with. Um but uh yeah, it was relatively isolating. Um maybe, you know, that impacted me, and you know, I'm I'm not the most outgoing person.
SPEAKER_02Maybe being in that kind of isolating place impacted me in that way. But I found it to be uh a nice way to grow up and you know being in the city but also being out of the city at the same time. Um the blackout was memorable because uh I remember we were watching TV, I think it was the Yankee game, was on, and then the TV just kind of went on the blink, and then suddenly all the lights were out in the house. And I think the thing that struck us was that when we walked outside to see what was going on, that we saw all the lights were out in Manhattan.
SPEAKER_02And that's when we could see the stars, you know, which uh we had never really experienced in New York City, um, you know, with the light pollution that is such a big part of how we, you know, experienced nighttime here. So that was memorable because I'd never seen that many stars, you know, and definitely not here.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell And the cottage that you lived in, what era was that built in?
SPEAKER_02Uh I'm pretty sure it was built in the 20s. It was built to accommodate um staff that they wanted to keep on the island in case there were emergencies, you know, when it was still reachable only by ferry. Um and there were four cottages, and we were in cottage four. So um none of them are standing any longer.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell And you went to private school in the city?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Yeah, I went to a parochial school on the Upper East Side. Um and there was originally there was a van that would take kids to um schools, and um then they stopped doing that, and then uh my parents had to drive me. But we didn't take we took the bus sometimes, but we didn't take the bus very very much.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell You also talk about uh a famous scene in the French connection starring Gene Hackman as the legendary Popeye Doyle um being shot on the island. The scene that takes place there is about busting a heroin distribution ring.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And how how accurate was that to what was really going on on Ward's Island?
SPEAKER_02Well, there was definitely no heroin distribution ring that I'm aware of there. But I think what the movie was taking advantage of was this idea that it was a wild place and someone could establish a hangout there. And there were dramatic scenes of a shootout right by the kind of the pillars of the train overpass, right? So the Amtrak, Amtrak trains and freight trains also run over the island. Um so there's kind of the shootout, the culminating shootout happens there.
SPEAKER_01And you rem you say that your dad was kind of excited by the filming.
SPEAKER_02I remember him talking about it. Um you know, as I do the math, um I was quite young when it was filmed, but I remember taught him talking about it. So that's how I kind of have that memory that he went and watched them do it. I do specifically remember going to see the filming of The Godspell, which I don't mention in the book, but that was a movie, a 70s movie that was sort of a Jesus Christ superstar type movie set in New York City. Do you remember it by any chance?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell, I think it's called Godspell, not The Godspell. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_02Okay, Godspell, right. So a musical, um, and there's a a culminating scene that was filmed on Wars Island, and I definitely saw them filming that.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell You were talking about RPA Regional Plan Association in 1926, I think was when they came up with this vision. And when I was reading your book, I saw 1926, but I read it as 2026. And I was thinking that some of these ideas, they're all so cyclical, right? I mean, Governor's Island is a relatively recent um re-imagination of another island, and and Regional Plan Association is still putting out reports about increasing transit access and expanding um open space.
SPEAKER_01When you were talking before about Moses and overpasses, his conception was that people would want to drive to a park, right?
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01And that was tied into his just his belief in the automobile as sort of modernity, right? Like so what did this mean in terms of physical access to the island? How how do you get to Words Island today? And what does transit access have to do with why it's been such a difficult space for some of these groups?
SPEAKER_02Right. So before the highway was built, um, you know, with an off-ramp that you could get down to the island on by a car, uh you could only get there by ferry, right? Um and so as soon as the highway was built, uh he installed a public bus. And uh that bus uh is still running today, and basically it uh goes back and forth between the islands and 125th and Lex in East Harlem. So that's been the way to get on and off the island if you don't have a car.
SPEAKER_02Um he did decommission the ferry uh probably because he wanted the ferry landing to be used for the uh FDR highway, which is it was right there where the FDR runs. He did create a footbridge that runs from um East Harlem, uh 103rd Street uh to the island, and you can walk over that. Uh interestingly, um in the beginning you weren't allowed to ride a bike on it. Uh now it's a very popular uh bike route to take onto the bike paths that have been improved on the island.
SPEAKER_02But clearly he was thinking people were gonna drive, um, and then the bus was there, you know, just as kind of a backup. And you know, it's not a frequent bus, it's not a bus that really you can rely on very well. It's you know, I I'm I'm in that neighborhood every week for uh for one of my jobs. And um yeah, there's still c quite a bit of activity, and there there are people who are um under the influence of substances, you know, uh hanging around. So I don't know what came first, if the substance activity was there uh before the bus or it um started to it was attracted to the bus stop.
SPEAKER_02Um I think in terms of timing, it's more likely that that happened uh because the sort of the explosion of of drugs didn't really start until the early 60s, and that maybe that location was selected um because of the number of people who would be coming off, you know, who who had something to do with the hospital.
SPEAKER_01One other thing we should mention is that um for just about a hundred years, a hundred years next year, um Wards Island was also home to what today is called a wastewater resource recovery facility, but it's just a wastewater treatment plant. Um that's the eastern side of the island. So it's fascinating that um this same place that was a dumping ground for all these populations of people is also one of one of the largest sewage treatment plants in New York City.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I think it gets to this idea of different purposes for this space that seem incongruous. A wastewater treatment plant is not something we want to think of our children um playing nearby. And yet it it seems to go along with the idea that the island is a place for uh disreputable people or people and things that are unwanted. It's literally a place to treat shit and we treat these individuals, these people like shit.
SPEAKER_01You talk a little bit about the strange contradiction uh of the private school kids now playing sports on parts of Ward Island. Talk to me a little bit about how that evolved over the last, I think, 10 or 15 years.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so the story actually starts in the um late 80s, uh when um some schools just kind of on their own started to use fields um for sports programs that they had. And um then it kind of got formalized in the early 90s, and this Randalls Island, it was originally it was a Randalls Island Sports Association and then became Reynolds Island Parklines, um started to uh put in money to improve the quality of the fields.
SPEAKER_02And I think it just speaks to the fact that there's just not that much uh, you know, not many sports fields in New York City, and this is close enough to a lot of the schools. Many of the schools are located on the Upper East Side, and it's pretty quick to get there by bus from the Upper East Side. So it was kind of a marriage of convenience. Now, the naming thing I think comes from this idea of kind of rebranding. People have negative associations with Wards on or they had them, right? Maybe people don't even remember it anymore.
SPEAKER_02Um, and therefore calling it Randall's Island allows uh them to kind of give it a new sheen that would make it more appealing to folks to go there.
SPEAKER_01In the 1980s, homelessness really came to the forefront. It was an issue that really came to define Mayor Ed Koch's mayoralty. Um there's legacy legislation around right to shelter that came out of that era, 70s, 80s. How did Words Island come to house homeless individuals in the 1980s? And what did Ed Koch think of it?
SPEAKER_02Well, how it happened is that um there was legal pressure brought by um lawyers who worked for the Legal Aid Society and ended up founding the Coalition for the Homeless. And um they brought a suit that led to um the Callahan Consent Decree, which we still operate under now, which sort of gives a right to shelter in New York City, which is pretty unique in the United States. And um the immediate order was that space had to be created to house more people than were being accommodated by the Bowery shelter.
SPEAKER_02So um the Keener Building was one of the buildings that was sitting vacant on the island, and uh it was immediately repurposed as a shelter. And why was it selected? I think that Mayor Koch was looking for a place that was not going to arouse community opposition and that he could get access to quickly. And since it was on city land, um, you know, he he had control over it. He just had a few um, you know, constituencies to talk to, and one was the state hospital.
SPEAKER_02And so there's a story of a clandestine meeting between Koch and uh uh Dr. Kaz, who was the director of um Manhattan Psychiatric Center. I I think it was still Manhattan State Hospital at the time. Um, and they talked about it, and Kaz was like, yeah, totally fine, you can do it. So the only ones who really complained were the Manhattan Children's Psychiatric Center directors who were worried about kids being exposed to some of the folks there. So that is where it started, and then once it started, it just got bigger and bigger and bigger.
SPEAKER_01I want to get into your ideas for the future of Wards Island. You spend about 30 plus pages of your your book, which is a pretty short book on your vision. There are many conflicting ideas about what we should do with mentally ill people and the extent to which they are dangerous to themselves and to others. And I just want to know how you're how you're thinking about all of this and what it might have to do with this administration.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Yeah. So I was writing the book before um Mayor Mandani was elected or or was even a candidate uh that I knew of. Um so uh his election is an opportunity as I see it uh for this at least some of what I'm proposing to happen. I know he is a uh a student of New York history. Uh if you're listening, uh Dani, uh you know, I'd love for you to uh to read the book. I know a copy has been sent your way.
SPEAKER_02Um but so uh basically the idea is that uh we could create uh permanent affordable housing on the island. There is uh a lot of um unused space that's occupied by an under-census hospital currently. Um it is public land, um, so it would cost money to build, but we wouldn't have to buy the land. Um the housing could be affordable uh and it could be mixed to uh be for formerly homeless people and general community members that are low income, and that is a model of affordable housing.
SPEAKER_02And that we could also create amenities for life to be more um, you know, livable there. Um and then one of the things that we haven't talked about yet is that there are no amenities on the island. There are no stores, there are no um libraries, there are no banks, there are no restaurants, there are no diners, nothing, right? So for the over 1,000 people who live there currently, everything that they're gonna buy has to be bought somewhere in Manhattan getting off the um the bus.
SPEAKER_02So what I'm proposing is that a community be created and that uh public transportation improvements would follow from that, um, and of course that would be necessary in order to allow people to get to work and and other places, but they would also have more there for them. Uh the other part that I propose is this creating a museum, uh you know, a museum of mental health, and this is something that um uh there is no museum of mental health in New York City, and it would be an important uh addition to our um museums, and it would allow people from other parts of the city to have a reason to come.
SPEAKER_02The businesses would also give a place uh for people who are going there for sports and other recreational reasons to uh have somewhere to go to eat, and that would allow them also to interact with the residents.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell You interview people for the book, um some of whom really like the serenity of this place that feels of the city but not in the city. And they've talked about um appreciating being in nature, appreciating being able to see the sky. But you also talk about how cut off they are from the kinds of community experiences like buying your groceries, even going to a drugstore to get your own medication, that kind of thing, that help make people feel like they're a part of society and also give them independence and like skill building.
SPEAKER_01Um your idea for some of these institutions like libraries and um groceries is also that they would be staffed by people who are in treatment? Or talk talk a little bit about who those workers would be?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell Yeah. So um in Italy, right, um uh there are no state hospitals in Italy um any longer. And so Franco Pasaglia was this kind of um radical uh psychiatrist who uh led the closure of the first state hospital in Italy. And uh the idea was that after people were let out of the state hospitals or asylums, uh they would work in local community businesses, and that was the Italian social enterprise model.
SPEAKER_02So it doesn't have to be staffed exclusively by people who have mental health conditions and uh are living on in one of the apartments, you know, with subsidies coming from that, but that they would uh be among those, right? And that's inherently destigmatizing, you know, that you're going somewhere and you don't know who who has mental illness, who doesn't, you know, but you know some people do. And that helps to break down those assumptions around what a person with a mental illness looks like or how they act and things like that.
SPEAKER_02There was this experimental ward um in the late 50s, you know, in early 60s when deinstitutionalization was kind of starting where they allowed people to go out and come back. So it was kind of um different than what we would imagine now, where we think of, well, if you're in the hospital, you can't you know come and go.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell Yeah, that was that was incredible. It was sort of this golden era of uh a concept of more openness, but it seems like it was just a tiny little blip. It was like a couple of years.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah, it's really hard for me to know. Uh I guess what I would say is it's a golden era in terms of optimism, right? Uh that there was this belief that it was going to work. And it coincided with the invention of chlorpromosine, you know, what started the antipsychotic medication revolution. So those things were going on at the same time. But there were so many other things that happened at the same time, too, right? So the drug culture exploded, there was a lot more crime started to happen in New York City.
SPEAKER_02So all those things kind of coincided, and it didn't turn out the way that folks hoped it would.
SPEAKER_01You talk a little bit in the book about some of the um both cognitive behavioral therapy treatments and then also things like hydrotherapy and um and a different conception of sort of how to handle mental illness. How do you see um medicine versus non-pharmaceutical treatments for severe mental illness? Do you feel like they can go hand in hand? Because I I came away from the book feeling that you're very skeptical of medication, but maybe I'm misreading what your intent was.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I I think medication um can be very helpful and um you know it can go hand in hand with the psychological treatment. So um we don't you know think of uh things precluding taking medication. Um it's just not um a cure-all, right? Um and uh for a for a while, like when I was volunteering there, uh the pretreatment approach was largely just give people medication, wait for them to get better. Um it's evident that the hospital doesn't do things like that anymore.
SPEAKER_02They have like a very active rehabilitation approach. But um that's kind of what things devolved into after the invention of these um medications, was like, well, that's what we're going with, so we're just gonna give people medications and you know wait for them to get better. And then it was in a very stagnant, stagnant environment where people were wearing pajamas all day, watching TV, smoking cigarettes, and that doesn't, you know, medication suppresses symptoms. It doesn't turn people's lives around.
SPEAKER_02Uh you have to do other things to kind of help that happen.
SPEAKER_01Did you talk to your kids about living on Wards Island?
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Sure, sure. And they've you know found it to be quite boring and of course have taken them there. And the the one uh child who's mo been most interested in is my older son who just got a degree in urban planning. And uh, you know, uh we went on a bike ride and I showed him different things, and then he kind of really got it, and he sort of helped with some of the uh designs for some of the ideas. So we have a website that we've created together. Um That has some of the kind of urban planning uh designs, uh maps and and other kinds of uh envisionings of things that I talk about in the book.
SPEAKER_01When you look at a place like Governor's Island, that's probably now coming up around 20 years old, I'm thinking, and you see the way that it moved, this is in my recent lifetime, from a place that had like punk rock mini golf and trails that felt like there was nobody around for miles to now glamping with$300 a night, um uh bungalows. Um, do you feel like the story of islands around our city is just destined to be a story of real estate grabbing?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that is definitely a risk, and it's one that I am hopeful would not happen on Wards Island. Um I know that probably people are thinking that's gonna happen on Rikers Island after it's closed, right? Um, you know, I've I've worked there too. That's that's a lovely place, too, right, in Long Island Sound. So um, yeah, I think that we have to put protections in place to keep these resources that we have um for uh people who need them the most.
SPEAKER_02And so that's why the the vision that I have is one of kind of restorative justice and prioritizing those people who have been put there with no resources and no support and saying, let's give you something really nice. And uh you get to have this and have um you know prime access to this parkland too. And other people can come and they can enjoy it too. But you know, this is something that is yours primarily and you deserve it.
SPEAKER_01Phil Janos, thank you so much for coming on Lit NYC.
SPEAKER_02Thanks again for having me on the New Yorkist podcast.
SPEAKER_00This episode of Lit NYC was hosted and produced by Amy Sohn and engineered by me, Noah Smith. The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of the podcast, which is a project of The City, the nonprofit newsroom serving the people of New York. Harry Siegel is the city's editorial director for audio. You can subscribe to Lit NYC at Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and wherever podcasts are found, or listen at thecity.nyc. The podcast receives support from the Charles H.
SPEAKER_00Revson Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, and from PT Knitware, an independent bookstore, cafe, and event space on Manhattan's Lower East Side, with a podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use. A special thank you to our guest, Philip Yanos, author of the new book Exiles in New York City, Warehousing the Marginalized on Ward's Island. And thank you, listener, for taking this trip with us. We'll be back soon with more.
SPEAKER_01I was wondering when you were researching this book, did you ever go into that room that just has an electric chair sitting there while you're researching?
SPEAKER_02I've never been into that room. No, I spent a lot of time in the municipal archives, I spent a lot of time in your public library, went to the um New York Academy of Medicine library, but I didn't and New York Historical Society, but I didn't go there.
SPEAKER_01So basically, you only went to the most beautiful like research settings.
SPEAKER_02Sure, sure. They have the stuff that I needed. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. It sounds it sounds I guess John Jay didn't have what you were looking for for this.
SPEAKER_02I like going to the library there when I need like to get away from my office and stuff like that, but I I've never gone there. So now I'm gonna have to find it.
SPEAKER_01Well, if you go into this, it's this tiny research room like the size of the room that we're sitting in. And you know how they're always watching you because they want to make sure that you're not stealing the papers and the librarians are are like the character and the music man, you know, kind of staring at you. And you're sitting there already feeling self-conscious, and then every few minutes you look up and and there's this this electric chair just just sitting there. Wow. It's it's a little, it's it's definitely the weirdest archive research experience I've had.
As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...
Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...
New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.
For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...