Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

TBD NYC

TBD NYC artwork

Jon Kalish's Bernhard Goetz Reports

Jul 11, 202634 minAudio

When a white man shot four Black teens inside a subway car before disappearing into a tunnel just before Christmas Eve in 1984, young reporter Jon Kalish was assigned to the story by NPR. When Bernhard Goetz turned himself on New Year's Eve, confessing that "I wanted to waste them all," what came next seemed clear to Kalish. Instead, the Manhattan district attorney struggled to even indict Goetz before a jury eventually acquitted him of all charges except for possession of an unlicensed gun. Four decades later, Kalish looks back on a shooting that left a wound that never fully healed, by a shooter who still lives in here, and how it was covered at the time - with “the celebration of a man with an illegal .38‑caliber revolver firing it again and again on a crowded train.”

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The signal it sends to people who are black is that they wonder whether or not this jury verdict is extending to white male civilians a right to kill or to maine black human beings without conviction, and in some cases, the public applauding it.

SPEAKER_21It's Lit MYC, the New Yorkers show about the ABCs of arts, books, culture, and death wishes. I'm Harry Siegel, and in this episode, you'll be hearing from John Calish, a veteran print and radio reporter who's contributed to NPR for decades about a trial he covered at the start of his career in a very different New York City and United States. Let's jump right in.

SPEAKER_05In early 1980, I became what they called a full-time freelancer at the New York Bureau of National Public Radio. I got the use of a desk, a phone, editing decks, and access to a recording studio. The bureau was located on 2nd Avenue, across from the Israeli consulate, and just up the street from the New York Daily News, where I made a number of visits to record the legendary newspaper columnist Jimmy Breslin.

SPEAKER_05The building NPR called home also housed the popular disco radio station WBLS, and the Bureau coexisted on the same floor as the Dalai Lama's Office of Tibet and High Society, the porn magazine, where phone sex originated. As the reporter in the Bureau with the least time there, I worked on stories that staff reporters were in no rush to claim. This included covering Orthodox Jewish Brooklyn and homelessness.

SPEAKER_05When a white man from Manhattan shot four black teenagers from the Bronx on a downtown two express train a few days before Christmas in 1984, and then disappeared into a subway tunnel before turning himself into the police in New Hampshire on New Year's Eve, giving a jaw-dropping confession. I jumped on the story, and as you'll hear in this episode, reported dispatches including one quoting a racial slur that wouldn't make it on the air today.

SPEAKER_05The shooting itself stunned the city, but the way it played out with the celebration of a man with an illegal 38-caliber revolver firing it again and again on a crowded train was nearly beyond belief to me as a young reporter, given the gunman's confession. More than 40 years later, it feels like my city has not healed from the five shots fired in that subway car. Here's an excerpt from one of the first reports I filed. It aired on NPR's All Things Considered January 3, 1985, the day Bernhard Getz was arraigned in Manhattan Criminal Court.

SPEAKER_14Bernhard Getz was returned to New York City today. The 37-year-old man was charged with attempted murder in the subway shooting last month of four teenagers who reportedly had asked Getz for money.

SPEAKER_10And I was going to draw the gun. But when I saw the look on his face, my mind was like from left to right. Okay. When I saw the look on his face, I made a decision. That was a deciding point because I knew what they were. I knew what their intentions were for me. And I snapped and I said, I'm gonna waste the money.

SPEAKER_05Getz's statement, which differed in some ways from the eyewitness testimony of passengers in the car, seemed to include elements of a revenge fantasy. Remarkably, that confession helped lead to a jury's decision to find him not guilty on every major charge in his criminal trial. Canty and the other teens were boisterous, but they later admitted that they were on their way to rob quarters out of machines at a video arcade in lower Manhattan.

SPEAKER_05Getz said during his taped confession that he reacted to Canti asking him for$5 because he was sure he was about to be beaten. Kanty told police he did ask for the money, because the four teens, who were all broke and had jumped the turnstiles to get on the train, needed some cash to start playing video games lest they draw suspicion of the arcade staff. Press reports mentioned that the teens were armed with sharpened screwdrivers, but it turned out that the screwdrivers, which they carried to Jimmy open coin boxes on the games, were not sharpened and were never visible to getz because they were in zipper jacket pockets.

SPEAKER_05Daryl Eugene Cabey was in a special education program when he dropped out of high school in the spring of 1984. He was good at breakdancing but wasn't gainfully employed and already had minor run-ins with the police. When Darrell was just seven, his father was crushed to death trying to stop someone from stealing his truck. His mother was raising her five sons in the Daniel Webster homes, part of the Claremont Village Public Housing Project in the South Bronx.

SPEAKER_05Shirley Cabey had a job as a food service worker at Manhattan State Psychiatric Center on Ward's Island. From his bed at St. Vincent's Hospital in Greenwich Village, Darrell told her, I'm sorry, Mama. I'm so sorry. I visited Mrs. CB at the family apartment in March 1985.

SPEAKER_25This is morning edition. I'm Bob Edwards. One of the young men shot by Getz, Daryl Cabey, remains in a New York hospital. Getz's bullet shattered CB's spinal column and inflicted brain damage. John Kalish paid a visit to Cabey's mother at her home in the South Bronx.

SPEAKER_04Shirley Cabey is 38. She doesn't look old enough to have a 19-year-old son. In the living room of her cramped apartment, she said it was no fun for her and Daryl's grandmother to visit him in the hospital, especially when he was comatose.

SPEAKER_22We talked, we touched, we, you know, we talked to him like he was, you know, awake and understood what we were saying. And um It was sad, you know, it was sad to see him there, no tubes everywhere, and not knowing, you know, if he was gonna come out or if he was gonna make it.

SPEAKER_04Daryl Cabey has spent the last three months at St. Vincent's Hospital in Greenwich Village, just a few blocks from the apartment building where Bernhard Getz lives. Hospital officials refused to be interviewed about CB's condition. A spokesman said CB has shown some neurological improvement since coming out of the coma with significant brain damage, but it's too early to tell how much he'll improve. Daryl CB is a high school dropout who reportedly liked angel dust and breakdancing. Last year he was charged with burglarizing a community center, but pleaded guilty to criminal trespass and received a conditional discharge.

SPEAKER_04He was also indicted for armed robbery last year and was supposed to stand trial in January, but the subway shooting has postponed his day in court. KB's lawyers say he will never be well enough to face the armed robbery charges at a trial. Shirley KB concedes that she should have kept closer tabs on what Darrell was doing with his life, but she says her son was not a bad kid.

SPEAKER_22No teenagers are angels. All teenagers do their little thing. One way or the other. You know. Teenagers, children, even adults. All of us have done things. We're not perfect.

SPEAKER_04Shirley Cabey was shocked by the public support Bernhard Getz received for shooting her son and three other young black men. She couldn't believe it when Getz's supporters sent death threats and hate mail. One Christmas card addressed to Daryl Cabey, the crippled nigger, said, May you be confined to a wheelchair for the rest of your life. Another letter warned, If you dare testify against Bernhard Getz, you will regret it. Beware, there is another nut out here who just may harm your family. Shirley Cabey took the hate mail and placed it between the pages of her Bible.

SPEAKER_05Hate mail was sent to the families of the other shooting victims. Lawyers for the wounded teenagers were also threatened. Scott Greenfield, who represented Troy Canti, got 97 death threats. Here's a phone interview I did with his partner, the late Howard Mayer.

SPEAKER_04Can you describe some of these death threats that Canti has received?

SPEAKER_15Well, it's not limited to my client, but it also involves his parents, his mom, his dad, his brothers and sisters, as well as me personally. It started when we filed a civil suit basically by saying that they're going to kill me, Mr. Canti, Mr. Caby, in spite of the fact that Mr. CB is in the hospital in comatose condition.

SPEAKER_05A grand jury indicted Getz on weapons charges, both for the gun he used in the shootings, and two more guns he turned over to a neighbor after the shooting and before he surrendered to police in New Hampshire. But the grand jury declined to hand down indictments for assault, attempted murder, or reckless endangerment. The New York Post called the first grand jury's decision a victory for common sense and self-defense. Manhattan DA Robert Morgenthal presented the case to a second grand jury after granting immunity to two of the teens so they would testify.

SPEAKER_05Their testimony was deemed new evidence justifying the seating of a second grand jury, which did indict Getz on the more serious counts. Here's Morgenthal talking to reporters after the Court of Appeals, New York's highest court, affirmed the second grand jury's indictments in early July 1986.

SPEAKER_19When somebody used deadly force, their action is going to be judged by the reasonable man's standard. But it's not enough to say that they reasonably believed that their life was in danger or they were about to be robbed. The jury will judge their conduct by how a reasonable man would have acted in similar circumstances.

SPEAKER_05The Getz case was front-page news not only in New York but around the country. After word came that Bernie Getz had turned himself into New Hampshire police, the New York Daily News referred to him in January of 1985 as the Death Wish suspect on its front page. That was ten years after the first of the five Death Wish movies had graced the silver screen, and now Getz was enmeshed in pop culture history. He became a hero to some and a genuine household name.

SPEAKER_05The comedian Joan Rivers offered to pay Getz's bail. Thugbuster t-shirts were sold. A Bernard Goetz board game was marketed, and a performance artist named Otto von Werner recorded a rap song titled The Saga of Bernhard Goetz. The cover of the 12-inch vinyl single proclaimed the tune was controversy you could dance to.

SPEAKER_02I haven't wavered in my support of Bernard Goetz since meeting with him and feeling that I know him a little bit. Is it your contention, sir, that a good part of the public is going to be rooting for Mr. Getz in this trial? There's no doubt in my mind that the people who have followed the case, and that includes just about everybody, and certainly everybody who listens to my program and calls the program, have been rooting for Bernard Getz in large numbers.

SPEAKER_05Getz was given a huge television audience to plead his case thanks to 2020's Barbara Walters, who joined Getz for a meal of Chinese takeout at his 14th Street apartment prior to taping an interview in March 1985.

SPEAKER_13What do you expect of people in a situation like that? I think perhaps the only people who will understand why I fought so savagely are those people who have already been victimized by violence.

SPEAKER_05Columnist Jimmy Breslin lambasted Getz in the pages of the Daily News. As lawlessness was applauded, Breslin wrote, We in New York arrived at the sourest of all moments when people become what they hate. I recorded Breslin at his office off the city room at the New York Daily News.

SPEAKER_07Would they cheer so loudly if it was a white kid shot? I don't think so. Would he have shot four white kids? I don't think so. There's definitely a racial edge to this as far as you're concerned. That's all there is. Somebody asked me before, is it beneath the surface a racial thing? Beneath the surface, I mean it's up in the sky. What is it you're telling me? If the man did it and his life was in danger, I'm very sorry for him that he had to shoot these four kids to defend himself. I'm very sorry for him. If he was not in danger when he shot them, then that's another matter.

SPEAKER_07And I I wonder why he ran away. I wish he had stayed and we would have had a proper investigation. They were putting the bull on the guy with the four black faces on a white, that's pretty obvious. No question about that, I don't think. They they seem to say that themselves. I don't think there's much question that these young men were not behaving as if they were on the playing fields of Eton. They were in a subway car and they were not behaving. No question. And they asked the guy for five dollars. That's a little tough, you know.

SPEAKER_07Perhaps they asked the wrong guy who then performed the wrong act.

SPEAKER_05The bullet that entered Daryl Cabe's body punctured both of his lungs and severed his spinal cord. CB developed pneumonia in both lungs and went into respiratory arrest. The lack of oxygen caused him to slip into a coma, which resulted in permanent brain damage. This included significant memory impairment. His doctor later testified that he didn't expect KB to live. Despite heavy security at the hospital, Jimmy Breslin managed to walk into KB's room and interview him on November 26, 1985.

SPEAKER_05An explosive Breslin column reported that KB had confirmed the 14s were, in fact, in the process of robbing Getz. KB appeared confused during the brief encounter, Breslin wrote. Later during the trial, a doctor testifying as a prosecution witness said patients with K.B.'s type of brain damage tended to say what they felt people wanted to hear. When the column appeared, Breslin declared, They're all lousy, referring to Getz and the four teenagers.

SPEAKER_05A member of the press corps covering the story said that you needed a scorecard to tell the victims from the perpetrators in this case. Assistant D.A. Gregory Waples, now retired, after 30 years at the U.S. Attorney's Office in Vermont, told me during a recent phone interview that he took Breslin's column in stride.

SPEAKER_09At that point, nothing particular about that case would flabbergaste me because people were making things up and surprises were happening every day, whether they were true or not. To my mind, it was just another headache.

SPEAKER_05Barry Shrek, a professor at Cardoza Law School who would go on to co-found the Innocence Project and serve on the O.J. Simpson defense team, told me before the Goetz trial began that KB's alleged confirmation to Breslin that a mugging was in progress would help Bernhard Goetz.

SPEAKER_08It's one thing to say I just looked at them, and I'd been through this one time before, and I just knew that it was going to be happening again.

SPEAKER_05For many New Yorkers, Breslin's KB column validated their conclusion that Getz was justified in shooting the four teenagers, while others in the city remained critical.

SPEAKER_20The legal system, the lawyers, and the judges have created a state of high crime.

SPEAKER_23I remember when it happened, I didn't much like the fact that he ran away, but I haven't really got a lot of the facts. It's the kind of thing where you get so bombarded with stuff, you stop thinking a whole lot about it.

SPEAKER_16If those kids were trying to assault him, then he, I think he should have retaliated. But I just hope justice prevails whichever side. You know, if he was in the right, then he should get off. If not, then he should suffer the consequences.

SPEAKER_03I think it was good he defended himself, but then he shot a kid in the back is kind of disgusting.

SPEAKER_17I ride the subways a lot, and I get scared when I ride the subways late at night and people come up to me.

SPEAKER_04Can I say how you feel about gets?

SPEAKER_03I don't know. He's a nut, you know, he's crazy. I think he's not a safe person, really, to have running around with guns and shooting at people.

SPEAKER_12You know, believe me, if you were gonna get mugged, you would have to do something too. Okay? Let me go in a rush.

SPEAKER_05When jury selection began on March 23rd, 1987, I rose early to take the D-train from Midwood, Brooklyn to the court on Center Street near City Hall. Every morning I stood with a steaming cup of coffee on the Avenue J platform to start the ritual of my 35-minute ride. Jury selection dragged on because many potential jurors said they had been mugged. One afternoon after the lawyers had finished for the day, Bernard Goetz walked uptown to his apartment on West 14th Street.

SPEAKER_05I joined him for part of the walk.

SPEAKER_11The Daily News wrote an editorial yesterday, and I think they completely missed the point. If they're going to criticize the criminal justice system for being impotent in my trial, they should really criticize the system for being impotent in protecting the public. People have horrendous records and are put right back out on the street. Do you still worry about being mugged? Of course. It's a fact of life in New York.

SPEAKER_05As the trial began on April 27, 1987, Assistant D.A. Wayples, the lead prosecutor, knew he had a tough fight to win convictions on the serious counts against Getz, who many New Yorkers identified with or even seen as a sort of folk hero. Daryl Cabey was home after more than a year in the hospital. Over the course of the next eight weeks, the jury heard from more than 40 witnesses. Witnesses and watched the defense stage a reenactment of the confrontation in a subway car with four much larger guardian angels portraying the four teens who were shot.

SPEAKER_05Defense lawyer Barry Slotnik referred to the teens as vicious predators and called them a wolf pack. He put a psychiatrist on the stand to testify as an expert witness on the human nervous system in the biological response to fear. The psychiatrist told the jury that human beings can go on automatic pilot in moments of great fear. This sort of adrenal response, he testified, means a person has no conscious control over what is happening.

SPEAKER_05Here's Barry Slotnik.

SPEAKER_06It took about two and a half seconds for Mr. Getz to empty his weapon. There were certain instincts that occur to people. They move very quickly. This was all, as every witness has said, in rapid succession.

SPEAKER_05Slotnik elected not to put Getz on the witness stand.

SPEAKER_06I made the decision not to call Bernard Getz because I felt that the true, unobtrusive, honest, real Bernard Getz has been presented to the courtroom in an audio and a videotape.

SPEAKER_05Slotnik didn't answer a question about whether he expected Getz, who was eventually sentenced to six months, to serve any jail time for the gun possession conviction.

SPEAKER_06I certainly hope he can continue living in New York. All he wants to do right now is fade into the woodwork. This has been a terrible chapter in his life.

SPEAKER_05By 1984, he had four handguns and had begun carrying an unlicensed weapon at all times. Friedman made recordings of Goetz while he was on the lamb and used them to write a New York magazine cover story titled My Neighbor Bernie Getz. Slotnik called her a potential accessory to the crime of gun possession, which Judge Stephen Crane allowed to be considered in his charge to the jury. Prosecutor Gregory Waples had thought a conviction on these ancillary weapons charges was a slam dunk.

SPEAKER_09I thought it was kind of a no-brainer. But then the jury just came up with this odd rationale, which to my mind only explains how much of an uphill climb I had to persuade people to use common sense in this case, and I seemed to have betrayed my boiling by and large. If they weren't going to convict on those charges, it beggars the mind how I could successfully persuade all twelve to convict on any of the far more serious charges.

SPEAKER_04Did the jury come to the conclusion that Canty and the other three were going to rob or assault Getz?

SPEAKER_24If a conclusion was made, is that that is the conclusion that we couldn't consider?

SPEAKER_05Juror Mark Leslie was a martial arts teacher who also trained actors for fight scenes when he was selected for the Goetz jury. After the trial, he wrote a book about his experience serving on the jury. In an interview after the verdict, Leslie spoke of the impact that knowledge of Goetz's 1981 mugging, which also involved a confrontation with an African-American teenager, had on the jury's thinking.

SPEAKER_24Would a reasonable person with his background and that gun available to him at that time think that there was a reasonable possibility that deadly force was present? It's not that we decided that there was an implicit threat.

SPEAKER_05That's what Leslie said immediately after the trial. Earlier this month, I spoke with Leslie for the first time in more than 40 years. In a phone conversation, he explained that the issue of who had dominion over the weapons while they were being kept in Friedman's apartment was crucial in the decision. In hindsight, we did not fully understand the legal definition of dominion as it related to those guns, he told me, and should have found him guilty of the additional possession charges.

SPEAKER_05After the verdict, Manhattan DA Robert Morgenthal praised the jury and insisted that the message of the verdict was very limited.

SPEAKER_04Are you surprised or shocked with what they've come up with?

SPEAKER_19Uh when you've been in the business as long as I have, you're not surprised or shocked by anything. But I I think that uh it was a good jury. I I think it uh it was a fair trial. Took the jury a little more than three days to reach a decision, and and I think it was a fair decision based on uh their perception of the case.

SPEAKER_04Is this a personal uh defeat of sorts for you, Mr. Morganstal?

SPEAKER_19Not in any way. I think that uh the important thing was to bring this case to trial and to let a jury decide, and that's what's happened.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, does this send a message of any sort out to people?

SPEAKER_19No, I think this case just turns on its own facts. I don't think it carries any uh broad message except the fact that somebody uh who carries a gun, which is unlicensed on a subway train or anywhere else, is going to be prosecuted and may very well be convicted.

SPEAKER_05In a TV panel discussion dissecting the Getz verdict just after it was delivered, Les Payne, an African American editor and columnist at New York News Day, said he saw the jury's acquittal of Getz on the attempted murder, assault, and reckless endangerment charges as a threat to the city's black inhabitants.

SPEAKER_00The signal it sends to people similarly situated, people who are black, is that they wonder, and I along with them, whether or not this jury verdict is extending to white male civilians, a right which we sometimes believe that police already enjoy, and that is the right to kill or to maine black human beings without conviction, and in some cases, as with Getz, the public applauding such an attack.

SPEAKER_05James Ramsur died at age 45 in a drug overdose that was labeled a suicide. He died on the 27th anniversary of the shootings. Barry Allen was in and out of prison and drug rehab before he passed away in 2021. Troy Canty, the one who approached, gets on the train, is still alive, but wants no contact with the press. That leaves Daryl Cabey.

SPEAKER_18Daryl Cabe's in a nursing home somewhere in upstate New York, paralyzed from the navel down, and that's permanent. He's got brain damage, and that's permanent. He's cared for in the way that a paralyzed child would be cared for.

SPEAKER_05That's Ron Kuby, who, along with his partner Bill Kunzler, won a$43 million civil judgment against Getz on CB's behalf in 1996 after a trial before a largely black Bronx jury.

SPEAKER_18When Bill Kunzler and I filed this civil case back in 1985, we made it very clear to Shirley C. But it was important to Shirley Cabey that there be some trial in which the truth is told, where Bernard Getsu does have to testify, and then all of the evidence will come out. And we had that trial in 1996.

SPEAKER_18The important thing was it was a very different and truthful story that was told in 1996, the lies of the first trial. That he himself admitted that he decided to open fire because he didn't like the look of Andrew's face, that he wanted to murder all four of these youth, that he shot Darryl Caby in the back, and that he was fundamentally a vicious white racist.

SPEAKER_05Bernhard Getz filed for bankruptcy in 2000. He's now 78, and still lives in his apartment on West 14th Street. In the years since the trial, Getz, far from fading into the woodwork, ran for mayor and public advocate, crusaded for animal rights, was busted for selling weed, and weighed in for reporters on the cases of other men charged with the deaths of others after quote-unquote standing their ground. Darryl Cabey will be 62 this summer.

SPEAKER_05Efforts to reach his siblings were unsuccessful. Troy Canty reportedly became an automechanic and lives down south. For Lit NYC, this is John Calish.

SPEAKER_21Lit NYC is a project of the City Reporter, a nonprofit newsroom serving the people in New York. I'm Harry Siegel, the City Reporters, editorial director for audio. The podcast receives support from the Charles H. Reven Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, and from PNT Network, an independent bookstore, cafe, and event space on Manhattan's Lower East Side, with the podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use. This episode was reported and recorded by John Kaelish and edited by John and me.

SPEAKER_21Thank you, listener, for making it this far. Be safe, be kind, and we'll be back soon with more.

SPEAKER_07Thrilled by someone who shot and then ran, thrilled by a 19-year-old kid being shot, and then enraged when they learn that you're gonna have to pay for him for the rest of his life. And he could live, supposing this one young man with a severed spinal cord, lives in a wheelchair, he has no feeling from the belly button down, he'll live in a wheelchair for 50 years in a nursing home or a hospital at uh$35,000 a year, which is a million seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars of taxpayers' money. If he lives the 80s, 19, a strong body, he might be able to do it, it would cost two million two hundred and fifty thousand dollars.

SPEAKER_07The public went nuts when they heard those figures. On the other hand, if you caught him and put them in jail, it would cost you forty thousand dollars a year.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. From the Club to the Flophouse in Wang´s World

    Nov 13, 202628 minAudio

    As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Life, Death and the World in the Confines of One Subway Car

    Nov 9, 202659 minAudio

    Harry Siegel and Nicole Gelinas talk with Anand Giridharadas, the

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Joel Feingold’s Gotham

    Aug 21, 202649 minAudio

    Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Sam Roberts´ Art of the Obit

    Aug 14, 202633 minAudio

    New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. R Sikoryak´s Declaration/Emancipation Illustrated

    Jul 17, 202643 minAudio

    For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...

    Credit the people on this episode