Julie Satow talks with Sarah Shears about the women behind the business of fashion.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01It's F-A-Q-N-Y-C, Off-Cycle, where the New Yorkist podcast steps back to take different and deeper looks into some of the things that are always happening here in the only place in the world. I'm Harry Siegel, the pod's executive producer and co-host, and right now you're about to hear Julie Seta, author of the new book When Women Ran Fifth Avenue, Glamour and Power at the Dawn of American Fashion, in conversation with Sarah Shears, a fashion historian and writer for The Daily Beast and other outlets, who also happens to be married to a fashion icon.
SPEAKER_01That's me. Welcome back, Julie, who's last on the pod to discuss her book, The Plaza, The Secret Life of America's Most Famous Hotel. And let's jump right in. Maybe you could start by explaining why you decided to center when women ran Fifth Avenue, which is full of incredibly rich details about the city and its shopping mechanisms, also the country, on three women who in the 1930s and 60s rose to the top of an industry where the customers are overwhelmingly female, but the owners and bosses remained remain mostly men.
SPEAKER_00Well, first, thank you so much for having me on again. It's really exciting to be here. I knew I wanted to try to write something about department stores. It's such a nostalgia, kind of similar to the Grand Hotels, and I feel an affinity for it. I knew there was a deeper story there, but I wasn't really sure. I didn't want to focus on a building again.
SPEAKER_00I wanted to try to center the book on people. So I really needed to find characters. And I started out by um just reading old newspaper clippings actually of um, you know, department stores. And the first character I found was Dorothy Shaver. She's really the most famous of the three women. So there's a lot more about her that has been already written, you know, um, you know, PhD dissertations, that kind of thing. So um, even though none of the women have had biographies before.
SPEAKER_00Um so I started with her, and she was, you know, such a great character, and her history is so rich, but it was sort of a very specific moment in time. It was the 1940s, kind of post-war era through the 1950s. And um I I, you know, I like history. I wanted to go earlier. So um I kept looking and then I found Hortense Odlum, who was the first woman uh department store president, sort of of any Fifth Avenue store for sure, um, in the 1930s.
SPEAKER_00And that was really cool. And then I decided I really wanted to bring it up to at least somewhat modern times. So then I settled on Geraldine Stutz, who is the president of Henry Bendels, in the basically in the 1960s through kind of the mall craze of the 1980s. So that's that's how I got there.
SPEAKER_02So, you know, as I went through reading the book, I was really struck by how it wasn't just a history of department stores and New York City and these three women, it was more broadly an economic history and a social history of New York, the United States, and just how people interacted and purchased and how women interacted in public life.
SPEAKER_02And I think when we start off with um Hortense, I think she's sort of started in like the late 30s, early 40s, and just the way the women interacted in this new social sphere of the department stores.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, for sure, like it was kind of really eye-opening to me to see how depart, you know, you think department stores is just kind of a flat topic, you know, you go to a store and buy things, you know, you don't think of it as kind of this huge vehicle for um female employment, for you know, social change, as you said, for changing habits, for it's really this rich experience. So, I mean, the first department stores back in kind of the Gilded Age, you know, way before uh Horton's actually started out being really important because they were really the first places where women could congregate in public without the need for a male chaperone, which is, you know, was shocking to me when I thought about it, but it made sense.
SPEAKER_00You know, it kind of women had, first of all, the power of the wallet. They were going and shopping, and it was, you know, they had a had a reason to be together and to be in these public spheres. And this was back in a time when, you know, that was considered dangerous or impolite. So um, really from the start, these department stores held a lot more significance than just what maybe, you know, those of us who just don't really think about that topic might might assume. Um, and then certainly by the time Hortense came around in the 1930s, you know, department stores were these economic vehicles.
SPEAKER_00Um, they were um really important for the garment district in the city, obviously. They were an important piece of the uh manufacturing um, you know, economy here, but they were also these areas where women could have these falsome careers when they couldn't really have them in other places. So, as Harry said in the introduction, like the men, you know, we've all heard of the Bloomingdale brothers or Bloomingdale's or Macy's or, you know, the men have the names on the buildings, but it was really a female universe where women almost did all the jobs from you know, the the saleswoman on the on the shop floor all the way to these buyers who, I mean, as early as 1906, I found a buyer who was going by herself to Paris, you know, to the Parisian um fashion shows, you know, at a time when no women had those kind of liberties.
SPEAKER_00So um, yeah, I don't know if that answered your question.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, yeah, I I thought it was really great. The um there in the in the beginning of the book, there's a chapter about Dorothy Shaver and Lorden Taylor, and how it wasn't just a job, there was a social mobility for a lot of women. And there was a whole section where you discussed how different stores provided classes, etiquette classes for their staff, how they taught women who likely otherwise would never have been taught mathematics and you know how to wear the white right gloves.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and all of these things that were, especially in the early part of the 20th century, very exclusive to a certain class of women. And suddenly you have young women who would likely have been housemaids or working in factories, now allowed to participate in this other area of life. Totally.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, that was really, I mean, I see the book as in many ways the history of women's work as much as I do um, you know, a history of the department store or a story of these three women. I really, for me as a working woman in today's world, I very much was fascinated by the kind of beginnings of women's women in the workforce, which was very much coincided with with um department stores. So as you said, in the 1920s, I mean, think about it, women only got the vote, you know, whatever in 1920.
SPEAKER_00So this is very early on. Um, they were they were, they were given these classes, they were given free, you know, lunch. Maybe they couldn't get lunch at home, they didn't have enough money. So they were given food, they were given these etiquette courses, they were taught mathematics or accounting because they often needed that. They had these opportunities to maybe start out on, you know, as a as a more junior clerk and then work their way up through the ranks, you know, that was very common. Um, maybe they wouldn't make it all the way to the top, but they would make it very high up on many of these, you know, in many of these stores and supervising big staffs, you know, so they were taught management skills, all kinds of things.
SPEAKER_00And the department stores themselves, as you said, they were these insane universes. I mean, they were not just a regular store like we think about it today. They literally had dentists' offices, you know, they had for for the staff, they had a chiropodist who would massage the feet of tired saleswomen, you know, they had all these other things that that they gave them. They even had summer camps and they would often give them free vacations. Um, so yeah, it was a it's a whole universe that was fascinating.
SPEAKER_02You know, I I was thinking as I was reading through, because I guess just to go back a little for our viewers or our listeners who haven't yet read the book, which everyone should read the book, and it's a lot of fun. But to back up with these three main women, there's um Hortense, Odlam, Dorothy Schaeffer, and Geraldine Snutz, and they they they they span the majority of the 20th century.
SPEAKER_02And Hortense seems to be the most this modern, like trad wife sort of thing that's happening right now, which is this silly, you know, with all of the freedoms that women have, like I'm deciding to just cook in the kitchen. And I kept thinking about how you know Hortense matches that in some ways and how she seemed to have such huge conflict. And she ran um Bond with a teller and made it this huge success and dragged it, you know, out from basically bankruptcy into one of the most successful department stores on Fifth Avenue on Ladies Mile.
SPEAKER_02And yet she always felt so conflicted, and it was very interesting because she was so successful and so revolutionary, and she was able to really understand the market and what women wanted. And you know, there was this whole part about how she moved the hats, like the impulse buys to the front, and you you can see how our current marketing and our current corporate culture is modeled after these three women and the changes that they made.
SPEAKER_02And yet she never seemed to be comfortable in that position. And I I was wondering, you know, do you do you think this has to do with her generational divide from the other women? I mean, obviously there are personal things, but there was also like a whole, while she was running Bondwick Teller, a moral panic about being a shop girl.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um Hortense was the most complicated of the women for me to wrap my head around. Um she, you know, she came from uh so she grew up very, you know, poor in a in a sort of a pioneering town out west. Her parents were early uh converts to the Mormon religion. Um, you know, she made her own clothes and grew her own food. She was as far away as you could be from Bonwitt Teller and Fifth Avenue.
SPEAKER_00Um, and um, you know, she never really wanted to be anything other than a traditional housewife. And it's funny you mentioned the trad wives because I've had the same thought. Um, you know, she she really didn't, she was sort of thrust on her uh this career. You know, she was, I think in many ways, my feeling is that she was trying to appease her husband. Uh, he was a workaholic, he was a sort of a Wall Street tycoon in the night, you know, he was one of the few people who actually made a bunch of money during the Great Depression.
SPEAKER_00So I think, you know, their marriage was quite troubled. And in many ways, it actually kind of reminded me of um, I wrote about Ivana Trump, uh, who ran the plaza while she was married to Donald Trump. And, you know, it was in many ways, I think, Ivana's attempt to be close to her husband as he started to stray. And it was very much a similar kind of thing that happened with Hortense and her husband. Um, he was having an affair. And, you know, I think that this was an effort to be close to him.
SPEAKER_00And when it didn't work, even though she was, you know, despite herself, very successful in business and made this huge success of the store, which Ivana did too, actually, um, you know, when she didn't, it didn't end up winning back her husband, I think she um used it as an excuse for what went wrong. And she says, point blank, you know, women shouldn't have careers. Um, she didn't want to be called a businesswoman. She really eschewed her entire uh legacy.
SPEAKER_00Even while she was doing it, as you say, she was very uncomfortable. She used to always say, Oh, I'm I'm just like a housewife having uh, you know, guests for dinner. That is the same thing as being a department store president. I mean, she was managing 1,500 people and running this huge company, but she was basically saying, I'm just, you know, it's like having a dinner party and inviting people to your home when you're, you know, uh entertaining your husband's business associates. You know, that was the way she made it more palatable to her. So that was really confusing, um, you know, from our modern perspectives, right?
SPEAKER_00Because I I don't know, it was hard for me to relate to. And it actually took a bunch of rewriting. I think at first I wrote it pretty harsh. And then I like, um, I had, you know, I love my fact-checker, she's amazing. She fact-checked both my books, and she really took issue with the way that I had had drawn Hortense and felt I was quite unfair to her, and it really forced me to take another look at it. So um shout out to Samine um for helping me with this. But I really revisited it and I softened it a lot and I tried to find more compassion for her perspective, which, yes, I think it was generational.
SPEAKER_00I think it was a matter of, you know, her personal issues, but also like the time and the fact that it was so unusual in 1935, you know, to be president of a department store, one of the biggest department stores in the country, you know. This isn't a small, you know, job that no one's ever heard of. This is a big deal. She's in the New York Times, she's in, you know, newspaper, she's on the radio, she has a big position. So um, yeah, it was confusing. And it was interesting then watching how Dorothy had a very different perspective on things and and the decisions she made in terms of her career and her personal life, and then Geraldine.
SPEAKER_00So that was partly why I'm so glad I got to do all three women, you know, because I could explore these kind of alternate um paths they each took. Which I can talk about the other ones if you want to do another thing.
SPEAKER_02No, I mean, I I I love the the part about Dorothy Schaefer and her um like she's an interesting bridge, I think, between Geraldine and Hortense because she didn't really necessarily embrace this glamorous, fashionable lifestyle like Gerald Dean, and she didn't issue her life like Hortense. And she was just somewhere kind of quietly in the middle, but she in her own way was so revolutionary.
SPEAKER_02And I I was so happy Lord and Taylor was included in this book because I remember when they closed and I was so heartbroken. I was this just thinking to myself, this is the last vestige of you know the old department stores. And I remember going in there and shopping for films, and they would have, you know, special, they they still had some fashion stylists that worked there, and it was such a different experience. Even you know, what was it, 10 years ago to go into then say Macy's or you know, another bargain department store.
SPEAKER_02And it it really was all Dorothy Schaefer and her really just just bringing in the fashion stylist. I think she was she the first woman to do that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, she was, I mean, she was absolutely revolutionary. I mean, Dorothy in many ways was the most, I think. Um, you know, she she she made huge strides in terms of the American fashion industry. She was really an architect of um, you know, today's fashion uh, you know, fashion industry. Um she helped found the Costume Institute, which, you know, the Met Gala is what everyone knows about fashion. I mean, she was a key, key person in creating the Costume Institute.
SPEAKER_00She was the first one, Lorden Taylor under her direction was the first one to actually advertise the names of American fashion designers. Before that, you know, they just mostly um, you know, toiled obscurely, you know, in the garment center in the factory floors, kind of copying Parisian original designs for a mass market, and they weren't really known except for maybe Patty Carnegie and like a few other, you know, a few other known designers. It was really not, you know, America wasn't considered at the forefront of fashion in any way.
SPEAKER_00And she was really um a chief architect of changing that, you know, the consumer's perspective on that. And yes, in the 1920s, um, when she she first came to Lord and Taylor in 1924, I mean, she arrived in New York City in 1919 with her sister as a single woman, uh, one you know, suitcase between them. I mean, it was pretty amazing. Um, but 1924 is when she joined Lord and Taylor, and she came on to head their comparison shopping uh department, which was this crazy thing they used to do where they would actually spy on each other.
SPEAKER_00All the stores would spy on each other and pretend to shop at the different stores so they could see what kind of bargains or how they were packaging things. So she was the head of this department and she kind of thought it was ridiculous. And instead, she's like, why are we spying on our competitors? Why don't we just make Lord and Taylor the best it can be? So yeah, she was the first one to create personal shoppers. I mean, that was really her invention. She was like, we should have a stylist bureau, people who were really stylish, women who could help um other women who were shopping kind of find gloves in the glove department or jewelry from the jewelry counter, or you know, match this dress with those shoes and help them put it all together.
SPEAKER_00And that was really, yeah, that was the beginning of it. And Lord and Taylor was very famous for that, you know, up until 2019 when it closed. So yeah.
SPEAKER_02And she created the what was branded, her the American look, which yes, when I read it on the page, I was thinking, just a few years later, Christian Dior in Paris coined his new look. And I was thinking to myself, wow, was Christian Dior looking to Dorothy Schaefer and thinking about advertising? I I mean, I it's hard to say, but I it just immediately struck me when I read it because it was very much his look was a response to the American fashions of the time.
SPEAKER_02And I I just seeing how she she went out and found all of these American designers and brought them in, gave them names. And between her doing that and Hortense making a store brand that was affordable for women, and then with Geraldine searching the alleyways of Paris to find new designers, I just these three women seemed to have just incredible foresight and just drive to find the best that was out there.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I think with Geraldine, which I was reading her part and her story, I was wondering to myself if there's any modern parallel to someone really going out and finding these great young designers. And the closest I could come up with was Project Runway. And I was thinking, what a true artistic person she is.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's what that's first of all, that's fascinating what you said about you know, the new look versus the American. I had not put that together, and that's fascinating. I mean, I I do wonder she was very famous during her lifetime, Dorothy. So it could very well be that he was aware of it, I would think, you know, and certainly the American look was a big deal. Um, but that's really interesting. Uh as for Geraldine, yeah, I mean, she, you know, she started out as a fashion editor, you know, at a fashion magazine at Glamour. So she really had this amazing eye, you know, her eye for fashion was incredible.
SPEAKER_00And she discovered so many designers. And you're right, I don't know. I mean, that's interesting, Project Runway. I don't know what today's version would be. I mean, it it excited me just to even read the kind of things she did because they were so adventurous. I mean, she sent out buyers to go, as you said, you know, don't go to the big, um, Don't go to the Dior or the Chanel fashion shows. We're not going to compete with these big department stores and try to try to buy what everybody else is buying. Go into the side streets, go to the left bank, go find, you know, walk around.
SPEAKER_00One of her buyers found discovered Sonia Ricky old, just went into the boutique one day and was like, wow, these sweaters are beautiful. And, you know, Sonia Ricky Ol, you know, was discovered. Um, you know, she she really helped establish Prade Porte because there were all these small designers working at the time. And she really brought them to New York and gave them this platform they didn't have before. So it absolutely was revolutionary. And then she did this really cool thing, which was kind of a project runway of its day, where she had an open call and she said, Friday mornings, show up, anyone can come and we'll look at your stuff.
SPEAKER_00People lined up around the corner for hours waiting to meet with um Bendel's buyers and hopefully get their stuff in the store. And actually, about 15% of all the things at Bendels came from these open Cs, these big, you know, these big open calls for designers. So um, if only there was that kind of thing today, I think would be amazing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, because now there seems to be there's a canon of people, unless you're inside of it, you it's it's very hard to penetrate. But as I was reading about Geraldine and Henry Bendels, I was just thinking, oh this sounds just so glamorous and so adventurous and so special. And her whole focus on exclusivity, which is in contradiction with the other stores and the way she, I guess we'll back up, she made these little shops within the department store.
SPEAKER_02And she focused totally on exclusivity. There was a part about bringing Xandra Rhodes, who I just adore. There was a moment where I was thinking for a second though, was this the precursor to a mall? Because the way she made the individual shops within one department store. And then later on, we get the sort of 80s boom of mall culture and this this new place where I guess women and kids have a social place to to walk through in the way that the department stores were at the turn of the century.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, right. We so so the first thing Geraldine did before she ever discovered fashion designers was she remade the the main floor of Bendel's. So Bendel's part of what Pendles problem was was Henry Bendels we might think of as on Fifth Avenue, um, which it didn't used to be. Originally, Bendel's was on 57th Street, it was on the side street, and it was a very beautiful but much smaller department store, not like a Bloomingdale's or um, you know, a Burdorf Goodman.
SPEAKER_00It had much less space than the rest of the department stores. So that posed a real problem because she couldn't um, you know, she couldn't sell as many clothes as as her competitors, and it also created an issue with the main floor. You know, when you walked in, it was kind of like a bowling alley, or she called it, I think, a cathedral. You know, it was very narrow and long with very high ceilings. And so it wasn't really a, you know, wide and open, which is how most department store main floors are. You know, you wander through, think about department stores, there's lots of counters and you can see everything, and it's kind of this wide open space.
SPEAKER_00Um, she couldn't do that with Bendles. So it was really, it posed a problem because people didn't like to shop in it. It felt dark and narrow. So she came up with this amazing concept with an architect. Um, it wasn't just her, but um uh McKim Glazebrook. Um, he was a brilliant architect, and they came up with this idea of the street of shops. So it basically they made the main street like kind of a main street. They they they based it off of the via Meisner in in Palm Beach, and it was kind of like a street you would walk down, and all these little shops aligned the streets.
SPEAKER_00There was a little shop for hosiery, there was a little shop for hats, one for makeup, and each one was beautifully curated and had its own little space and they were designed differently. So it's interesting, as you said, the the mall ended up killing this whole the killing bundle. So, but maybe it was sort of also uh a precursor to it because it was that kind of idea where you could go and buy things individually all in one place. Um, but it was it was amazing, and actually now we we take it for granted. I mean, you think of a boutique within a store.
SPEAKER_00I mean, Target right now I think is running, is having Sephora or you know, what a makeup um um not Sephora, sorry, it's a a makeup company is is is opening little boutiques within a Target now. That's very common now. We see it all over, but back then that was completely revolutionary.
SPEAKER_02So I also I just want to bring this all back to Trump again because there was the part with uh the Bonwitt Teller building that by the 70s it ended up in the hands of Geraldine's boss, and then uh Trump, Donald Trump, the Trump we all know, uh ended up buying it in 1979 and then tearing down this gorgeous Art Deco building to erect his sort of McMansion of a building.
SPEAKER_02And I just thought I needed to mention it because with your parallel with Ivana and the plaza and Hortense and Bonwitt Teller, and then having that be taken by Trump and torn down, it just it's such a sad way for it all to go.
SPEAKER_00I know. I I um I feel like I can't escape him. I don't know. Um it feels very unavoidable.
SPEAKER_02Um he's bankrupting every every building that you write about.
SPEAKER_00Um basically, yeah, Bonwitt Teller. I mean, I really didn't want to end it on a sad note, but it it is hard because, you know, basically, yeah, Bonwitt Teller was this amazing Art Deco building. It had all these very important architectural details, and it was on like the best block on Fifth Avenue. So, of course, Donald Trump wanted it, you know, to build his Trump Tower that we all know. So in 1979, he purchased it. Um, but uh, you know, and he and he was planning to demolish it and he promised uh the Met that they that he would give these important architectural details to the Met for their collection because he had we had the building had these Bass reliefs.
SPEAKER_00They had this very important grill work in the entrance that was very beautiful. Um, and he promised all these things, and then one day, just in the middle of the day, people looked up and these construction workers were on the facade and they were just jackhammering these things off. I mean, just absolutely destroying these vast reliefs. And um it was bizarre. People didn't understand what happened. And um, you know, in the classic Trump story, he he at first he had um John Barron, his uh spokesperson, say that um say that he uh, you know, that it was it had posed a danger that these bass reliefs were gonna fall on pedestrians and they were dangerous.
SPEAKER_00Then he said they weren't worth anything. Of course, the Met responded, you know, we wouldn't want them for our collection if they weren't worth anything. So I've no idea why he would say that. But anyway, they were destroyed. The grill work kind of disappeared, no one ever knew where what became of it, and um, this the building was demolished, it it was turned into Trump Tower. Um it did open for a minute in the base of Trump Tower, but it didn't, it couldn't really ever replicate itself again, and and it didn't end up, you know, the business obviously Bon Watello doesn't exist anymore.
SPEAKER_00So um yeah.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I just wanna like that is so Trump. It's such a New York Trump story. It's so sad. It reminds me of Penn Station a little bit. But your book is so full of so many, just aside from the three main stories, all these just fun, salacious little tidbits everywhere, you know, the history of mannequins. We have uh a great story about Salvador Dolly throwing a bathtub through the window.
SPEAKER_02It wait, was that a that was a um it was Bonwitt Teller, yeah. Yeah, Bonwitt Teller. And then there's also the whole story about the Nazi hats, which was so wild and just crazy.
SPEAKER_01But I just wanted to ask tell tell tell that before you get Nazi hats.
SPEAKER_02So the the Nazi hats very quickly is um well, what you you you should tell it, Julie.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, this was the weirdest story. I was like, is this true? I was um basically, uh, during the war, during World War II, all of a sudden um these fashionable New York women started wandering around the streets with these absolutely enormous, very ungainly, not particularly attractive hats. Um they were covered with all kinds of fabric. Much of the fabric was um fabric that actually had been um that was rationed during the war because um it was needed for the war effort, um, and they were on the hats.
SPEAKER_00Um, all of a sudden, all these fashion insiders started getting these bizarre magazines they've never heard of um with these hats, um, you know, as big features all about these hats. It was this weird thing, and everyone was like, okay, this must be a cool new bad. Um, it was it was supposedly coming from um Parisian designers who'd managed to escape uh, you know, the Nazi occupation. This was while Paris was occupied um during the war. So it was sort of it started out as this trend, and then everyone kind of realized, hmm, this is way too uh suspicious.
SPEAKER_00What is going on here? And it ended up being a Nazi publicity ruse, an attempt to kind of uh co-op the American fashion industry and um kind of cause everyone to try to buy a bunch of ration material that they weren't supposed to be acquiring, and um, you know, it was just a weird, um, a weird little moment in time. I don't know.
SPEAKER_02I will forever remember it as the Nazi hat.
SPEAKER_00I like that. I should have called that the chapter that title. That would have been better.
SPEAKER_01A couple things uh I just wanted to touch on while we have you and uh and the time we have. Um If you want to talk just a little, um, and this really is about women in the workforce on some level, but about uh wars and moral panics, and I think those those fit together a little and the roles those played in inside department stores. And obviously, you know, a lot of the book is about um bosses, but a lot of it is also just about you know the the women who worked in these worlds were often finding their footing in the workplaces there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, um, yes, there was um, and I and I uh in an earlier version of the book I had much more of this, but there was sort of at the start of department stores, um, it was the progressive era, and um, you know, women were were um getting, you know, going to college more, they were entering the workforce in greater numbers in the 1920s, but there was also kind of this um moralistic uh uh um you know progressive attitude, which was um, you know, again sort of um this Protestant concept, you know, against consumerism, against um life lives of vice, that kind of thing.
SPEAKER_00And so in the city, actually, um there was this kind of panic that uh women, young women, young girls who were um entering the workforce and working in department stores were going to be so overwhelmed with the amazing things they saw that they would turn to lives of crime and essentially prostitute themselves or steal things in order to acquire all the things around them in the department store. I mean, it was a very obviously kind of a silly panic, but it was something that was absolutely true.
SPEAKER_00And they actually created vice commissions. I think in 1914 there was one. There was one in New York, there was one in Chicago, there were these commissions where they actually sent undercover, uh, undercover, you know, detectives to investigate whether women were being lured into prostitution at these department stores. Um, there were also other panics, you know, there was a whole hysteria, and I use that word in quotes, about uh kleptomaniacs because um because there was, you know, this was a new thing, these department stores, you know, before department stores, it was general stores.
SPEAKER_00It was like you walked in in a dry goods store and you, you know, you asked the clerk at the front, you know, he was standing in front of a huge pile of goods and you know, to order, please could I get my wagon wheel and you know, a a pile of you know, a box of flour. It wasn't like you go in and have all these amazing things to look at and try on and and you know, to to to be so enamored with. So that was a new thing. So all these women, even wealthy women, started stealing things. That was somewhat true, but there became this like hysteria.
SPEAKER_00The New York Times had an op-ed, you know, that the department stores were going to lead to the moral ruination of the country and of women, and you know, it was this whole thing. So there was a lot of that that went on. Um yeah, I don't know if that answered your question. And I can also, in terms of war, that was also a very big deal. Um, you know, wars obviously had huge impacts on the country during the war, actually during World War II. It was really, um, that was why, you know, I talked about for a second ago the occupation of Paris by the Nazis.
SPEAKER_00Paris was really the center for fashion. I mean, that was where all fashion designers were based. Everyone thought everything had to come from Paris. When it became occupied, obviously all that stopped and America was suddenly left on its own. Um, and Dorothy, because of Dorothy and some other people, there had been efforts to kind of promote American designers, but they all kind of saw this moment as really the time to push that. So there was a real emphasis on American fashion and creating um an American look, as we discussed before, which is really like a sporty look, you know, a more athletic look.
SPEAKER_00That's kind of what the American designers were were more known for. Sorry, I rushed all of that, but yeah.
SPEAKER_01Oh, there's so much a lot of information. Yeah, yeah. And then there's always like during the war, like the this push to get American women to work. And we've got to win this war. Are you gonna be back in the kitchen or you're gonna be sex slaves or whatever? And then different pressures after the war, war is plural, as as men return home and are looking for jobs, and these sorts of pressures that I think are maybe are still cyclical in the country.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, after World War I and the Great Depression, and then in World War II.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. So I do talk about that because as I said, this is largely also a history of women's work. And in, you know, um during World War I, obviously there was a draft and men went off and it created a huge vacuum where women came in and they they had jobs that before they could never have had access to. That happened in department stores like it happened in so many industries. And then after the war, when they came back, you know, a lot of them that, you know, there was an attempt to displace them. That that happened again in World War II.
SPEAKER_00I kind of saw this like back and forth where they would make strides in the 1920s um into the workforce, you know. Then in the 1930s, there were actually uh federal laws prohibiting companies from hiring married women, um, you know, school teachers that were married were fired. So there was this whole backlash in the 1930s, you know, everyone. Federal government. Yeah, and then right. So then so the 1930s was kind of this retrenchment, and then in World War II, they were again let into the workforce because again, there was another um draft and there were all these openings, and then in the 1950s, there was another backlash because obviously the whole concept that women, you know, the leave it to beaver thing happened.
SPEAKER_00So it was really like a back and forth whiplash for many decades. And I really think until you know the women's movement in the 60s and the 70s, that didn't really change, you know.
SPEAKER_01So we're bouncing all around here, which is great, which is great. No, no, it's it don't be sorry, don't be sorry. That that's what the pod is for. I just want to promise listeners that the book, which contains all this and a bunch more, is uh is more directional and and less bouncy because we're we're pulling all these bits uh from it. And just one more I wanted to uh I was hoping you could talk about for a minute, is is I feel like if I'm talking to my daughters or like kids today, you know, like the department store just as a thing is almost impossible to uh explain.
SPEAKER_01But these these places were so vast and there was so much happening there. And I think there were there were for a lot of people and a lot of women, like this this sort of incredible introduction to culture. So we mentioned Dolly briefly, you know, like uh I was hoping you could talk a bit about window displays and art and uh the ways in which this was one of the portals that connected people to all those worlds as they were there to shop or browse or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And thank you for that. You're right. It the hopefully the book is a lot more streamlined than this conversation in some ways. But um, but yes, they were um department stores had an unusual role sort of as these cultural institutions. Um, I I think that's absolutely true. And actually, back to Dorothy Shaber, she was a big part of that. Um, in in 1928, she held this, um, she held basically the first huge um collection in Lord and Taylor of Art Deco design, of she had Picasso's, she had Art Deco furnishings, she had all sorts of things.
SPEAKER_00It was this huge thing that they sold tickets to. 300,000 people came to the exhibit. Um, and it really did show that department stores could do so much more than just um, you know, be these, you know, places to buy goods, that they also had this cultural significance. Um, and you know, there were a lot of other things like that. As you said, the the wind window design was really considered an art form. Um, Salvador Dali, uh, Georgia O'Keefe, a number of other um famous artists created works that were shown in these windows.
SPEAKER_00And even until the modern era, I mean, Bendels was known for its windows too. They created a whole thing called art, you know, uh street theater, and they would make kind of stories out of the windows. They became these tableaus for win, you know, for stories and you know, obviously holiday windows and all of that, you know, which still is a thing, although not what it once was. Um, it really was very important. Um, I think it was a huge driver for sales, but it was a big, you know, way that people could actually interact with artwork.
SPEAKER_00I mean, a lot of people might never see a George O'Keefe, but they could walk by, you know, a Lord and Taylor and see it in the window. So it did create uh an important conversation there.
SPEAKER_02I just want to double down on both what Harry said and you said, because you know, the department store is such a mainstay even for my grandmothers. It was the way they went out and interacted, it was their consumer choices. And there was a point in time in American history where consumerism and high art, as you were saying with Georgia O'Keefe and Dolly and different fabric companies and different fashion companies, it all melded.
SPEAKER_02And we didn't get a chance to really talk about Geraldine too much, but her work with Andy Warhol and just having the fashion and the consumerism and the art world really drive each other. And I I think your point was really fabulous that you know it it was a way for people to who who wouldn't otherwise be exposed to art to have access to high art. So I really loved your book. I really enjoyed all these fun little stories everywhere.
SPEAKER_02And I was just wondering, were there any, because it's just full of great tidbits. I mean, there's Amelia Earhart, there's, you know, there's there's so there's so many different little pieces of it aside from Nazi hats. And I was wondering, was were there any stories, just little tidbits in here that you weren't able to get into the book?
SPEAKER_00Well, I, you know, in retrospect, I realize that I there is a lot in there. Um, I I I I created part of why there's so many little stories is that I had I structured it where um I have many vignettes. So I break from the main narrative of the women. Tell these kind of side stories. So I think that was how I got in all the stories I wanted to get in. Um, I I of course left some things out, um, like the uh the hysteria about kleptomania and stuff.
SPEAKER_00I had more of that or some of these other stories. I definitely did, but I tried to get in as many cool narratives as I could by using by doing these small little vignettes. So so yeah, I think the readers will hopefully get the best parts of my research.
SPEAKER_02So it's so much fun, and I would love to read your future book on kleptomania.
SPEAKER_00Um thank you so much, guys.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for joining us. Um again, the book is When Women Ran Fifth Avenue: Glamour and Power of the Dawn of American Fashion by Julie Setao, who has been uh generous with her time. It's a speed read. Pick it up. FAQ. FAQ NYC receives support from PNT Netware, an independent bookstore, cafe, and event space on Manhattan's Lower East Side with a podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use.
SPEAKER_01The pod's friends include Colin Powell School at CUNY's City College, where our co-host, Professor Christina Greer, is one of the Moynihan Public Scholars inaugural fellows, The City, a nonprofit newsroom delivering hard-hitting news that serves the people in New York, and Flaming Hydra, a collective of 60 writers, including me, delivering a cooperatively owned new newsletter you'll actually want to read. Our host this week was Sarah Shears, and our engineer is Adam Kamara. I'm our executive producer.
SPEAKER_01A special thank you to our guest, Julie Seta, author of When Women Ran Fifth Avenue. And thank you, listening, for joining us and making it this far. Be kind, be cool, and we'll be back soon with more.
As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...
Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...
New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.
For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...