Geographer, cartographer and urban explorer Andrew Lynch, the chief operating officer of QueensLink, joins Amy Sohn and Harry Siegel to discuss the group’s vision to transform the borough for the better by extending the M train from Queens Boulevard to the Rockaways on a railway that’s abandoned for 60 years while surrounding that with new parks and trails, how he got involved in this crusade, and much more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00By restoring train service on the abandoned Rockaway Beach branch, Queenslink will help connect the borough with rails and trails. This vision calls for extending the New York City subway's M train south from Queens Boulevard to Ozone Park with four new stations along the line. The M train would then continue south to the Rockaways alongside the A train, replacing the trended shuttle. What's more is the right-of-way has space for 33 acres of new community parks with over two miles of walking trails and bike paths.
SPEAKER_00The Rockaway Beach branch also parallels Woodhaven Boulevard and the Vanwick Expressway, two dangerous roads notoriously choked with traffic. Together, we believe this vision will truly reconnect communities across the borough.
SPEAKER_02I'm Amy Sohn, and I remember when the Clark Street station had elevator attendance. I'm here with Harry Siegel, a senior editor at the city. And joining us now is Andrew Lynch, Chief Operating Officer of Queenslink. Queenslink is a nonprofit that wants to get the MTA to build a subway and parkway along the Rockaway Beach Branch Railroad, which has been abandoned for over 60 years.
SPEAKER_01It would include four new stations with transfers to the A, J Z, EFR, and the 7 trains, and the LIRR. And it would also create up to 33 acres of new parks and protected bike lanes along the right-of-way. Andrew's group said it would provide subway access for at least 47,000 daily riders. Andrew, you come from uh upstate New York by way of Boston. Correct. You're an alum of Hunter College with a BA in geography. Yep.
SPEAKER_01Nice. And for over 20 years, you've run the blog Vench, Nuke, and Rogan, where you use photography and cartography to explain the urban condition. Right. Ah. That's great. I've always needed the urban condition explained. And you've got the uh future MBTA and future NYC subway series, which are pretty awesome, looking at past and future plans for expanding mass transit in Boston and New York.
SPEAKER_01Yay. So welcome to LIT NYC. Let's jump right in. Yeah, thank you. Yeah. What is Queenslink and how did you get involved with it? And all of that. All of that.
SPEAKER_03You gave a pretty good introduction of Queenslink. This is a project that is not new to us. Um the idea to turn this line into a subway was first floated in the 1920s. And when the city built the Queens Boulevard subway line, the EF MR, uh, they actually had an idea to connect it to the Rockaway Beach Branch and built tunnels in that subway that are unused to this day for this extension.
SPEAKER_03In 1950s specifically, uh there was a fire over the trestle that spans Jamaica Bay, the still Long Island Railroad line. And at this time, Long Island Railroad was trying to divest of money-losing lines like a lot of railroads were. So they decided to sell it to the city. Uh the city picked it up, and none other than Robert Moses was responsible for rebuilding that trestle. So when you take the A-train down to the Rockaways, those bridges were built by Robert Moses. One of the few things he did for mass transit.
SPEAKER_03The problem was at the time they didn't have enough money to build the entire line. They only had enough to connect it to the A-train, which was sort of the most the closest existing subway line. The idea to connect it further north, that was still there, but they didn't have the money. By the 1960s, the MTAs created to prop up the subways and they came in with a big expansion plan. And then the financial crisis hit and everything was sort of like, you know, abandoned. When the uh Port Authority decided to build the air train, they looked at using the Rockaway Beach Branch, decided they didn't want to go through the hassle of it, so they built it over the Van Wick Expressway.
SPEAKER_03And ever since that the MTA, the city, no one has really taken it seriously. It's not about getting to the airport faster, or it's not just about that. It's not just about a few new stations in central Queens. What does this do for the network that we have, this interconnected network, one of the most complex transit rail networks in the world? Well, in the south, you have low capacity because the way the A-train is split up so much. And so you have low levels of service, very long wait times, uh long travel times.
SPEAKER_03So it's very frustrating if you live in southern Queens and the Rockaways. And in the north, you've got the Queens Boulevard line, which is congested, which you know, the express trains are packed, the local trains uh are literally limited. You can't run any more local trains, uh, even though there's extra space for it. And so we look at this and say, all right, you can kill two birds with one stone with this project. Extend the M train south. That opens up unusable capacity that's on that line, where you can extend the G train back to Forest Hills, which is something that has been in the news recently.
SPEAKER_03A lot of people want that. So this allows for that to happen. Then in the South, you're um creating uh higher frequencies on existing lines. So you can more people would take the uh the M train down to Howard Beach as opposed to the E-train to Jamaica to get to the air train. So that reduces congestion in Jamaica. So this is kind of like spreading the load a lot, and we don't think that the MTA has considered that. So the way that Queenslink formed was there's this group of transit advocates down in the Rockaways.
SPEAKER_03They saw the potential for this line and they heard rumblings that there was this other group that eventually became uh the Queensway, the Friends of the Queensway, that were interested in turning this line into a Highline style park. And they said, you know, if they do that, if this land is turned into a park, we're never gonna get it back for trains. So they started they uh what's known as Queen's Rail, and their pitch was just reactivate it in some way. Um the way I got involved with this is in 2017 there was a debate between Rick Haran, who is the executive director of Queens Rail, and Travis Terry, who's the director of Friends of the Queensway.
SPEAKER_03It was hosted by the Queen's Chamber of Commerce, and it was, you know, one side versus the other is pretty much what you think. At the end of it, somebody asked, Do you think you could do both? And they both said no. And I was an outside observer. I had never been involved with any type of advocacy ever. But I had written about transit and I'd I'd understood sort of the history of rails to trails. And I just said, you know, this doesn't make any sense to me. One of the things I learned about when I lived in Boston was when they built transit in the 70s and 80s, they there was this big pushback against highways, so they got the money from the highways, used it to expand mass transit.
SPEAKER_03They also built parks and they built bike lanes alongside of the trains. I think there's this sort of misconception in New York where if we can't do it here, we can't do it anywhere. And that really limits us. New York exceptionalism is a double-edged sword. And as an outsider, I saw this and I said, All right, let me see if if I can put this together. And I just wrote up a blog post. I just looked at Google Maps and I just said, all right, here's where you can put this, this, and this. And a year later, Rick reached out to me and said, I'm putting together a task force. I want to see if we can do this.
SPEAKER_03We reached out to the Friends of the Queens Way who wanted nothing to do with us. And that's why we decided to go off on our own and develop uh what became Queenslink.
SPEAKER_01I think about rails to trails. I think about, you know, uh like semi-abandoned places in the Catskills and whatnot. Um But you do you want to talk a bit about what that is and how it relates to Queens and some of the transit deserts there? You know, as a Brooklyn person, I I look at the map there and I'm like, my God, there's just big swathes without trains. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03I I don't think even a lot of people who are born and raised in Queens understand how big it is. So the Rails to Trails program started, I guess, 70s, 80s. There were a lot of abandoned rail lines around America. As highways took over, cars took over, a lot of these lines were just left abandoned. There was no use for them. And what ended up happening is this program called Rails to Trails, where the government would come in and uh land bank all of these rail lines. One day, you theoretically the state or whomever could come back and say, okay, we want to reactivate this rail line.
SPEAKER_03So it's not just uh we're a nonprofit, we're going to buy this land. It's we're nonprofit, we are going to have the right to uh clean up this land, build a bike lane, operate this, maintain it, but it's still owned by the state. It's still technically in the future would be able to revert back to an active rail line. The problem with that is once people get their nice bike paths and parks, they're not going to want to give them up.
SPEAKER_01So if I think about uh you know the expansion of the queue and the second avenue thing, this is most of a century in the making because you have to dig these gigantic, very expensive tunnels. And if I'm hearing you right, what you're saying is Queens, which has no north-south train, has the capacity, like there's rail there for that train, and there's almost a race, a very long-term race, as it turns out, between let's just make this into a park or a nice thing or whatever, and let's actually get some transit there.
SPEAKER_01Is that a fair way to think about that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think so. Um obviously New Yorkers are pretty jaded against the MTA based on past projects that took too long and cost too much. But you know, when you really dig into the differences between these two projects, Second Avenue was a Herculean undertaking. The reason that this is so important is because it's the last basically unused right-of-way, rail right-of-way in the city. This is still a multi-billion dollar um investment. But all you're not needing to build these, you know, 20-story deep tunnels underneath Manhattan and below these stations.
SPEAKER_03I mean, part of the reason that Second Avenue was so expensive was they had to mine out these stations. That's not what we're proposing here. Um the earth is softer, the tunnel is shorter, uh, there's only one, let's call it, underground station that we're proposing, um, and everything else is above ground and would tie into an existing above-ground line, the A-train, down to the Rockaways. There are bridges that are 25 feet in the air, and there's earth embankments that are as tall as a three-story building. This is not your you know, a little dinky path in the woods.
SPEAKER_03This is a big piece of infrastructure that takes up multiple city blocks. It's it's like 100 feet wide. So what we're saying is anyone who doesn't think you could do both with this uh just lacks vision or is intentionally trying to prevent transit.
SPEAKER_01So these two guys you may have heard of, um Donald Trump and uh Zora Mamdani, I believe it's pronounced. Both of them seem very interested in getting things that have languished for decades here done, from Penn Station redesign to this revival of sunny side yards. I know, right? It's like an interesting moment for for things that have been talked about for a long time. You have a decade now of professional grind in this project.
SPEAKER_01Uh are you speaking with the uh Mamdanian administration and looking at like the city, state, and the feds, where are they at in terms of interest or receptiveness to this project? And which ones of them matter most?
SPEAKER_03Sure. So previous mayor Eric Adams uh was a supporter of the Queen's Way. He had given them$35 million in the city budget, and he, you know, we we never had good luck trying to talk with him. Uh Zoran Mamdani, I actually met a couple years ago. We we were releasing a report, we were holding a rally up here at City Hall Park, and we invited him and he came. And I'll be honest, I did not think there's the next mayor of New York City.
SPEAKER_03I was like, oh, okay, here's this young progressive guy, I'll take all the help I can get. But he had passion. And so when he announced he was running for mayor, I was like, oh, this is this is interesting. I wonder if he still is into this. And from various accounts from people that we have talked to in his administration during the election and during the current administration, even though it's only been two months, um, and then things he said on the campaign trail, he's still a supporter.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell And with uh Trump and Hokel and you know the MTA runs the trains, and that's the state, although it's you know nominally an independent authority, like have you reached out to them? Do you have a sense of where where people are at with this? What are your hopes? I think about this with with IBX because it was so you know, this was like sort of a de Blasio vision and it's going to connect to all the trains, uh, but it's city right of ways. So the question of who has the authority to get something like this done, and that gets complicated and bureaucratic.
SPEAKER_03Oh, absolutely. Um and what complicates this further is this land is owned by the city of New York, all of it. So when Queenslink was started, uh we were in 2018, we knew the MTA was looking a feasibility study on reactivating the line. It was the first time they had really looked at this project in decades. Well, 2019, all of a sudden we hear the study is done. It's all there, it's just sitting there. And so we were able to bug the board, and for some reason they released this study.
SPEAKER_03And we looked at it, and it was it was done by uh Sistra and AECOM, two well-known um engineering firms, and it proved that this it was feasible to reactivate this line. They looked at subway service, they looked at a long-hour railroad service. They they even uh contended that some of the land along it could be used for parks. So we're like, great. Then we look at the cost, and uh going back to what I was saying before, this is you know three and a half miles long, it's mostly above ground. They said it would cost eight billion dollars. Second Avenue subway didn't cost eight billion dollars.
SPEAKER_03We raised a little bit of money and we went to a an independent transportation consulting firm and we said, we only have this much money. Can you just tell us what this means? And they came back and they said, here's how they lied about this cost. What they said to us is like, if the MTA had wanted to build this, they would have used this one algorithm to calculate the soft costs. Instead, they just multiplied it by four because they wanted to make this look bad. They wanted to make this look so expensive that no one would touch this. And as time went on, we were able to file a um freedom of information request through the MTA, and after years of back and forth, we actually got working documents of this report.
SPEAKER_03And lo and behold, whose name do you see all over it? It's Andrew Cuomo. Andrew Cuomo's in every memo for all the meetings, Andrew Cuomo's office, the office of the governor, kept asking, is it possible to have parks and trains along this thing? And in early drafts of the report, they actually called out Queensway and Queen's Rail together. That was taken out of the final report. And so what I believe happened was Andrew Cuomo wanted this built as a park and a park only, and had his finger on the scale the entire time.
SPEAKER_03And then I'm not gonna mention any names here, but in our discussions with people at the MTA and formerly at the MTA, it came out that someone w had been contacted by the office of Andrew Cuomo asking specifically in 2018 that this report not come out. They did not want this built.
SPEAKER_02For some reason, this whole thing is reminding me of when Ben and Jerry's was starting to get into grocery stores, the Hagenda's company got very upset. I'm pretty sure I know why the Hagenaz company was upset about Ben and Jerry's. And so they went around to all of the grocery chains and said that if the groceries carried Ben and Jerry's, that Hagen-Daz would no longer supply to those groceries. And Ben and Jerry launched an information campaign.
SPEAKER_02Can you tell that I've been on the Ben and Jerry's tour in Vermont? And I actually remember this, they'd be so proud of me. Ben and Jerry's did an information campaign called What's the Doughboy Afraid of? Because Pillsbury at that point was the corporate parent of Hagen Daws. I'm sensing this kind of analogy where Queen's Way is very threatened and intimidated by Queen's Link. It seems like you've taken the attitude, let's collaborate, let's do both.
SPEAKER_02Why are they so threatened by your plan?
SPEAKER_03These are people that are too smart to say what they're not saying. So what aren't they saying? Aaron Ross Powell What they aren't saying is, you know, we don't want something that will harm our neighborhood. And what we're saying is you we can design this so it won't harm your neighborhood. And if you're willing to meet us halfway, you can have everything you want.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell They've made a lot of analogies to the Highline, but one thing that really distinguishes the Highline from the vision for Queen's Way is that the Highline is very close to subways.
SPEAKER_03Aaron Ross Powell Correct.
SPEAKER_02So if Queen's Way happens, how how do people even get to the way?
SPEAKER_03Aaron Powell They drive. When they first started with this project, um they got no indication from the MTA. Even to this, I'll be honest, even to this day, the MTA is not indicated that they're willing to do this project, which is why we're here. Um and so they just sort of took this viewpoint of like, all right, it's never gonna happen. Let's just do this. My viewpoint is if you think it's never gonna happen, then it will never happen. You have to think it's gonna happen. Um there's too much benefit for the entire borough.
SPEAKER_03And what we have spent at Queensland years doing now uh going through the community is showing them how both are are feasible. Um and we uh fully acknowledge that parts of this right-of-way could be built with parks today, as long as the the proper design is taken into consideration so that you know we're not building something today that would have to be destroyed in five years or ten years or something like that.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Ross Powell Andrew, you uh you said earlier that this MTA study that you guys got said this would cost eight billion dollars. I believe your group also says that QueensLink would pay for itself. Right. Like as you see it, what would this cost and how would it pay for itself?
SPEAKER_03Right now we're thinking around$4 billion in today's dollars. The way this pays for itself is the economic value of time saved, the economic value of better health, of better education. I think the obvious is uh housing development. The new stations would provide, I think, like 6,000 units of housing throughout the three and a half miles. When you put it all together, it's not just about what does this do for Forest Hills? This connects two parts of the borough that are disconnected.
SPEAKER_03This doesn't just help people in the Rockaways that have the longest commutes in the city. This helps people in Astoria or Sunnyside that want to get to the airport faster, that want to go to the beach and spend money. If you don't drive, you have to take, you know, trains, buses, it takes hours. What is the value of cutting that time in half? What can you do? What is your benefit to your health? If we if we do the traditional way where we get 50% from the feds, that means the city only has to come up with two billion dollars. The city budget is$120-something billion dollars.
SPEAKER_03$2 billion over the course of 30 years is nothing.
SPEAKER_01Do you want to talk a little about how you got to New York City and Queens and uh how you got interested in the first place in abandoned train lines?
SPEAKER_03Aaron Ross Powell Right on. So uh my like I said, I'm originally from upstate New York. My dad worked for the state historic preservation office. He was a historic preservationist architect. And so as a child, um I spent my vacations going to you know 17th and 18th century buildings, which is exactly what a 10-year-old boy wants to be doing. Um but that gave me kind of an appreciation of history that you can interact with. You're not just reading about it. So when we moved to Boston, Boston to me, coming from Albany, is a real city, relatively speaking.
SPEAKER_03Any any place that has trains that run underground is a real city to me. So, and Boston's rich with history. Um shout out to the big dig. Absolutely. And specifically with the big dig, you know, I was I was walking around downtown Boston one day with a friend, and he pointed out there's a hole in the ground because downtown Boston during this time was literally just one giant construction site. And by the end of it, they had just sort of been like, all right, you know, throw a fence up and call it a day. And so So we we climb into this hole and it's not like a little man hole cover.
SPEAKER_03It's you know you can drive a truck through it. And we're trying to like see what's into this darkness. All of a sudden a train comes by, and I realize I was basically in the subway. And as I look closer, I realize I'm in an abandoned subway station from the original first subway in America. I knew what it was. I was standing there. And that's I was like, yo, we gotta, we gotta do this more. Like, this is awesome. And I was like, you know, there's that abandoned line we cross all the time. Like, let's go walk it, you know, like stand by me stuff. So I just got hooked instantly, and I had just gotten a camera, so I'm like, all right, I'm gonna start taking pictures.
SPEAKER_03What year are we? Um what was this, 2003? We'd we moved to Boston in 99, graduate high school. I was in college for industrial design, and that's when I sort of pivoted towards like urban planning. I was like, oh, you can cities are these like vast designed or not designed, you know, organisms. And that that just got me so fascinated.
SPEAKER_01And 2003 is a cool year for like just dudes checking out train tunnels, right? It won't be No No words.
SPEAKER_03There was uh it was an innocent time on the internet, which is such a weird thing to think. When you there were just so many places where you could just take pictures and post them and you know people would find them. I had already decided, all right, I I don't want to do uh industrial design, I want to study something else. There wasn't really much left for me in Boston. It's a fun city, but it's a small city. And that's when I looked, I started looking around. I was like, where could I study urban planning? I looked at Hunter and they had a good geography program.
SPEAKER_03And I was like, I like maps, I'll study that, you know, it'll be easy, and then I'll go into urban planning. Um so that's what brought me to New York was to finish college. And obviously, that you know, like in my mind, New York is full of abandoned subway tunnels and like, you know, dark days, the mole people in the the Freedom Tunnel over there. The uh Highline was still abandoned at that point. So that was like the first place I went was the Highline.
SPEAKER_01It was so fun before anyone was there. I also spent some time up there before it was a park.
SPEAKER_03I don't hate what they did with it. It's it is better than what it was. The thing that I've always loved about urban exploration is you go you find these places that you're in the middle of this you know metropolis with eight million people, and you are alone and you feel alone. And it is so interesting. Um sometimes it's very dangerous and you you f feel that instantly. But especially like up on the Highline.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Indeed, the piers used to have that. The Highline before was the Highline had that. Uh the the the I'm thinking about the West Side Piers in Manhattan, I'm thinking about the waterfront in Williamsburg, there's something beautiful about those empty or semi-empty spaces. But as as with Queensway, there's this question and challenge of what's if you open up one usage, what what what other ones are you are you losing or that possibly get sunk? That's correct.
SPEAKER_02Trevor Burrus Was there a moment when you saw the Rockaway branch?
SPEAKER_03So it's funny that you say that because when I moved here and I started doing research, what's abandoned, what where can I go? See, I never actually went out there. And it wasn't until I had heard about this debate and I had the idea you could do both. That's when I first went out there, and I saw how big it is. It's three and a half, three and a half miles is a lot. Um and it's got different parts because it was built at different times. The embankment in the north is huge. Then it's got this narrow little chasm through Woodhaven.
SPEAKER_03And then in Ozone Park, it's this. It was built last. It was built in the 40s. Um it's like a concrete and steel viaduct, and the space underneath the tracks is now used for small businesses, um, mostly like light manufacturing. And so that's when I was the the the spark went off. I was like, oh, you can do so much with this. You know, it it's more I have been on a lot of abandoned rail lines that are like out in the boonies, and there's not much to talk about. It's it's a path through the woods. This is a completely different animal.
SPEAKER_03As so as someone who moved here, sort of having watched mm you know movies about New York in the 70s, and you think, oh, it's it's all it's run down, there's all this abandoned stuff. Um, there really isn't much abandoned left anymore. Um capitalism abhors a vacuum, I guess. And so a lot of the tunnels or existing lines, people have these ideas that there's all these abandoned tunnels underground. There really isn't that many. There's a couple.
SPEAKER_02So, Andrew, you're a bartender.
SPEAKER_03That's right. People don't know that about me.
SPEAKER_02And you do all this on the side.
SPEAKER_03That's correct.
SPEAKER_02Like how many hours a week do you spend on Queenslink stuff?
SPEAKER_03I oh 20, 30 hours a week.
SPEAKER_02So do you know what monomania is?
SPEAKER_03No.
SPEAKER_02Well, it kind of means exactly what it sounds like. It's thinking obsessively about one thing.
SPEAKER_03I don't I don't know if it's obsessive when it's this constructive. Um the re So I became a bartender because I needed money and the girls were at the bar, and it just made a lot of sense. So once I sort of got on my feet, I realized like, oh, I just need to bartender a few nights a week and I can have the free time to do whatever. Queenslink really helped me focus on what what do you really care about?
SPEAKER_01What do you really want to do? So you're going to a bar for work, this like I don't know, 13 years ago. Yeah. And then you're sneaking out to have fun with map making and urban planning.
SPEAKER_03Yes. It it it is a bizarre. When I was in college here, I realized the things I wanted to do weren't done here. And if I wanted to do them, I had to figure out how to do them on my own way. I had an internship at the Port Authority, which was very eye-opening, uh, in their planning department. I remember there was a guy sort of like my dad's age in the next cubicle next to me. And every day he was on the phone talking about the cross harbor rail tunnel. And I just thought to myself, like, if that's my future, I will kill myself. And it's one of the reasons I became bartender.
SPEAKER_03I was like, I need to get away from this. I just need like distance and I need to fit I need the time to figure out what I want to do.
SPEAKER_01Are you familiar with the 1952 Akira Kirosawa movie Ikuru?
SPEAKER_03I am not. I all Kirosawa movies uh are on my to-do list right now.
SPEAKER_01Start there. It's the one about an urban planner who's like, if I have to stamp one more of these fucking things, I'm going to die. And it's basically like the superior version of It's a Wonderful Life. All right.
SPEAKER_03I have homework.
SPEAKER_01I love this.
SPEAKER_02So are there any similarities between transit nerds and uh uh artisanal beer drinkers?
SPEAKER_03Um I would say there's a bit of an obsessive quality uh in both and a lack of hygiene.
SPEAKER_02Okay. All right, this is great. The founder of what was initially called Queen's Rail, Rick Haran, he has accomplished some stuff. He got the A-train service improved, he got shuttle service improved in the mid-90s. We're talking a time Harry and I were going to high school when I mean you just said MTA and and and people just hated it. It was there was a a sense that it was wasteful.
SPEAKER_02Um and of and of course, service was was frustrating and difficult. Rick also founded the nonprofit Gateway Bike and Boathouse, which is a free public kayaking program in Jamaica Bay that some of our listeners, I'm sure, have taken advantage of. Rick looks to me from his photo like he might be late 60s, early 70s.
SPEAKER_03Early 70s.
SPEAKER_02And a bunch of the people that work for Queenslink are younger than you. You're 40. Did this sort of happen organically because transit just got really cool like in the last 10 years? And then also, how do you keep bringing in new generations of people? You know, you were 31 when you got involved, you're 40 now.
SPEAKER_03Rick man, Rick has inspired me so much. He is he is eccentric in the best possible way. He biked from Rockaway Beach with a buddy to Rockaway Beach, Oregon, because after I think it was either 9-11 or Sandy, something like that. Um, Rockaway Beach, it was probably Sandy, uh, Oregon, like sent resources to New York and they wanted to do this and thank them. So, like, and he did that like two years ago. Like, you know, like he's 71 now or something. Um so it's just you can't do this project with normal people.
SPEAKER_03Like you we all have to be a little weird. I don't know exactly what has inspired so many people. I just had an idea and we put it out in the world and it has just grown. It could be the conviction that I have about this, as a new generation comes along, they want a different type of world. They want a world that isn't beholden to the car. Um when I talk to kids in their in high school or in their 20s, they understand transit, climate change, all these big picture things that when I was their age, I was like, no, I'm playing video games, you know, like I'm watching MTV.
SPEAKER_03Like this is stuff that I figured out later, and these kids know it instantly now. Um it kind of scares me a little bit, but I look at myself now as like, all right, I've got to take this passion, I've got to guide it. We have so many new volunteers right now, it my mind kind of spins.
SPEAKER_01Um big shout out to MTV for becoming terrible and no longer playing music videos and thus seeding a generation of bored people without music videos uh to watch who got into urban planning.
SPEAKER_02Never thought of it that way, but I'm gonna hit you with another expression. Some people know more and more about less and less until they know everything about nothing. Other people know less and less about more and more until they know nothing about everything. Do you ever feel like you just it's too much? You care so deeply about this and you've cared so deeply about it for all these years.
SPEAKER_03Um I don't feel like it's too much. It's in a weird way, it's actually why I like having been a bartender is that when I go to work, it's just when I'm I'm I'm there. And when I go home, I'm doing whatever else. Like there's a divide. Everything else is just this like itch that I gotta scratch. Everything that's on my website is there because I wish someone else had done it and nobody did. And I just had to figure out how to do it. Um, this sort of curiosity. I I need to take time and just be like, whoa, we got this far.
SPEAKER_03This is really cool. I can't believe we've come this far. I can't believe this has really happened. Um if I live to a hundred, there's gonna be a million things I've never done, but I'm gonna be grateful for the things that I have.
SPEAKER_01There's an Isaiah Berlin essay called The Hedgehog and the Fox, and he's riffing off of this Greek poet Archilicus, who said the fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing. And Berlin writes there's a great chasm between those on one side who relate everything to a single central vision and uh those on the other side who pursue many ends, often unrelated and contradictory. Like, you saw these tracks and I'm like we could have this thing, and you're saying it's uh, you know, a lot of this is uh the journey and the friends we made along the way.
SPEAKER_01But how cool would it be, you know, to uh uh take your grandkid 50 years and just hop on this line, get out to the beach.
SPEAKER_03I want what uh what I want at the end of the day is when this is built, I want New Yorkers to take it for granted. I want people to take this and never think about it. One of the stories my grandmother told me was that her grandfather was an Irish contractor on the original IRT subway. And he helped build, I think it was the one train and and I found some contracts, he built the seven or something. And through the the w the work that I do looking at history, I find these stories, I find these people.
SPEAKER_03And you know, everybody knows Robert Moses, but there's a million other people out there that help build this. So what's next for Queenslink? We got a busy year ahead of us. We're about to release uh cost-benefit analysis um and uh report looking at other benefits of the project. We need to get up with the the new mayor, Zo Ram Amdani, again, and try to work out a sort of a blueprint to move forward. Uh we want to work with the MTA because eventually we need the MTA to see the benefits of this, and we need to work with them if we're gonna move this to the next level.
SPEAKER_03We need to get some engineering work done. We still have a half million dollar federal planning grant that we've got. And so there's a lot open to us right now.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Is the next step convincing the MTA to build this? Like would they have to be the ones to build this?
SPEAKER_03Ultimately, yes. Uh the MTA has to build this. They're moving forward with the IBX. The IBX right now is slated to in the north end at Roosevelt Ave, which is an express stop on the Queens Boulevard line. All the trains stop there, the seven trains stop there. It's one of the most congested stations. It always has been since it opened. It was just poorly designed. Now we're talking about building this in this new link between Brooklyn and Queens, and it's going to end right there. Tens of thousands of more people are going to use that station every day, and there's no room for them.
SPEAKER_03And so our pitch to the MTA is the only way you can move more people is figure out a way to get more trains on these tracks. And it just so happens that you've got an uh about 50% unusable capacity on the local line. And the reason for that is the single track at Forest Hills that they terminate all those local trains on, you just can't move any more trains through it. Other higher capacity lines use two tracks or three tracks. And just the way the whole thing is operated is is inefficient. If you build a branch off of the local, which is what we are proposing, and have these trains come down to the Rockaways, you open up that capacity at Forest Hills.
SPEAKER_03If there is a delay if trains get backed up, this happens every day, basically. Um, you can use this as a release. So you can turn trains around and send them back up. This is vital to the operation of a congested line. Everything else is gravy.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell I want to come back to monomania because I think that monomania is underestimated. Um for some reason on this show, I feel like we get a lot of monomaniacs. We partly have people that are coming in talking about something that they've worked on a long time. I I know that a book that I'm writing is successful when I start dreaming of my characters. They're in my subconscious. Do you think that this single-minded focus that you have on this, if this winds up not getting built, um how will you feel about all the the sweat and tears that you've put into it over really coming on, what, nine years?
SPEAKER_03When I decided to get involved with this, I said to myself, it's not whether you build this or not. It's what you learn on the way. I was a bartender and I knew I didn't want to be a bartender the rest of my life. And I knew that I would meet the people I needed to meet to get me where I wanted to be on that journey. And I I believe that has happened. The late Robert Duvall, one of my Apocalypse Now is one of my favorite movies. And he has a line in that that everybody knows, which is, I love the smell of napalm in the morning.
SPEAKER_03But what people don't know is the next he says a few more words and then he wistfully looks in the distance and he goes, one day this war is gonna be over. And that's my favorite line. Because it's not about, you know, like the end of the war, it's about the battle. And that's all I care about. I'm gonna be sad when this is built.
SPEAKER_01Andrew, thank you so much. Thank you. This conversation's been a pleasure. Good good luck with the next six months and six years and six decades. Yes, thank you so much. It was my pleasure.
SPEAKER_02FAQ.
SPEAKER_01Wit NYC is hosted by Amy Sohn and me, Harry Siegel. This episode was produced by Amy and engineered by Noah Smith. If you liked it, rate us and review us wherever you get your podcast. The show is a production of the FAQ NYC Podcast Network, which is made possible in part by support from the Charles H. Redson Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, and from PNT Network, an independent bookstore, cafe, and event space on Manhattan's Lower East Side with the podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use.
SPEAKER_01The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of the podcast, which is a project of the city, a nonprofit newsroom delivering hard-hitting investigative journalism that serves the people of New York. A special thank you to our guest, Andrew Lynch of Queenslink. To learn more about Queenslink, including the history of the Rockaway Beach Branch, find out about events, or volunteer, visit theQeenslink.org. And thank you, listener, for making it this far.
SPEAKER_01Be easy on yourself, kind to everyone. Go listen to Muddy Waters singing to Trains Running, and we'll be back soon with more. Mapmaker, mapmaker, make me a map, find me a line, fix me a track. Look in your map now, and make me a north south Queens connecting line dot dot. Yeah.
As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...
Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...
New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.
For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...