Amy Sohn talks with Harry Siegel about how the American government's original anti-sex law, suppressing as obscene information about birth control, created the mechanisms used to this day to suppress unpopular thoughts.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01It's with NYC, the new name of the New Yorkist Podcast Empire's show all about the world past politics. I'm talking today with the one and only Amy Stone. Hello.
SPEAKER_02Hey Eric, it's good to be here with you.
SPEAKER_01It's good to have you. Amy, as uh some listeners will know, uh wrote the female trouble column for the late and occasionally lamented New York Press, and then the Naked City column for New York magazine. She's also the author of 13 books, most recently, The Man Who Hated Women, Sex, Censorship, and Civil Liberties in the Gilded Age. That man, of course, was Anthony Comstock, whose infamous Eponymus Chastity Law of 1873 remains on the books and came up in this election year with speculation that the Trump administration could use that so-called zombie law, demand medical and surgical abortions, miscarriage care, or even contraception.
SPEAKER_01Amy's book, though, isn't so much about Comstock as it is about birth control in many ways, and many of the brilliant sometimes bonkers women who cross paths with the self-styled anti-obscenity crusader and friend of women, and how those women suffered for those encounters. We're going to talk today about two of those women, Ida Craddock and Sarah Chase. But first, here's Adam Camara with the brief message.
SPEAKER_00The City, the hard-hitting nonprofit newsroom where journalists, including FAQ NYC's own Katie Honan and Harry Siegel, cover New York City, is having its year-end membership push, and it could use your support. The work is free for everyone to read, but it isn't free to produce. If you're ready to pitch in, you can do that at thecity.nyc slash give 2024. And in December, your gift will be doubled by newsmatch thanks to a generous local donor. So each dollar goes twice as far.
SPEAKER_00That's thecity.nyc slash G I V E two Zero Two Four. Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, Adam. And thank you, everyone, supporting the city. And thank you, Amy, for coming on. Let's jump right in. So I like to ask Triple Deckers, do you want to tell listeners how you came to write this book, which was published in 2021, and really is a hell of a read, a little about what it's about, and if it feels any different after Dobbs and Trump.
SPEAKER_02Wait, what was the triple? So uh why did I write it?
SPEAKER_01What's it about? Some some summarize years of your work.
SPEAKER_02All right, all right.
SPEAKER_01Um and and and the book was published in 2021. And the last changed in the world since then. So thinking back about it.
SPEAKER_02Aside from the fact that my book is having a renewed, renewed sales three years after it came out, how do I feel about that? Yeah. Um, so I started the book, I think, in around 2016. And I was doing a film project. I, you know, like many writers in New York, I had to support myself doing other things besides writing books. And I was working on a project that dealt with women and insanity, which is one of my favorite topics. And I began thinking that I wanted to write a nonfiction book that dealt with women and insanity.
SPEAKER_02And so I found the story of Ida Craddock, who we're gonna get into in a little bit of detail later. Um, she was a woman who hallucinated a ghost husband, but was also an absolutely brilliant writer, thinker, feminist, and kind of a role model for me. And I initially thought that I was gonna write the story about Ida Craddock's battle with Anthony Comstock, which I saw as a little bit of like a cat and mouse, almost like a lay Miz type tale.
SPEAKER_02And I realized it wasn't quite enough for an entire book. So then I thought to myself, who were the women that Anthony Comstock went after? And pretty soon I knew about Victoria Woodhull and I knew about Margaret Sanger and Emma Goldman, but other books had been written about those people. So I decided to research the lives of a bunch of very, the New Yorker called them weird, weird women who were prosecuted under state and federal Comstock laws. It is interesting to write a book um and have it be sort of prescient in a way that you don't want for political reasons, but might be good for your book sales.
SPEAKER_02It's a bit of a strange um predicament to be in. I was as surprised as anyone about Dobbs. I guess I guess the way to frame that was I was devastated by Dobbs as someone who was born the same year that Roe v. Wade passed. And I knew that these themes would continue to be relevant, you know, government control of women. Anyone who's an observer of abortion law knows that over the past 15 years, states have been clamping down on women's rights, and we basically have a two-tiered system right now.
SPEAKER_02But I think I was so surprised that there would be literal talk of reviving this zombie law, and that suddenly I would be asked to go on podcasts explaining who Anthony Comstock was.
SPEAKER_01Well, you're gonna have to little of that and also explain for listeners who don't know what what the Comstack was and the federal law are.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so what I like to do is actually start with Anthony and then say what the law was about. So I'm gonna give you a couple of fun facts about this guy. He had red mutton chops covering a scar that was left behind after an irate smut dealer stabbed him in the face on the way to the Newark jail. While crossing the street in New York one day, he was nearly run over by a mail wagon. He shook his badge at the horse and said, Don't you know who I am?
SPEAKER_02I'm Anthony Comstock. He bragged of causing suicides, 16 suicides, as a result of going after booksellers, um destroying their livelihoods.
SPEAKER_01What kind of booksellers?
SPEAKER_02Dirty, smuddy booksellers that used to sell their books right around this office where we're sitting right now, uh, throughout the financial district, modern day financial district, on streets like Warren Street and Ann Street. And you know what? There's still some good bookstores around there, and they're sort of remnants of, I think it was because these streets were very narrow. This was a place that young men could go to both buy smuddy books and of course to purchase sex. Now, I mean, there's a whole other thing about sporting sporting culture, but let's let's get back to Anthony for a second.
SPEAKER_02Um he decoyed people, he had uh fake names Jay Beardsley, Frankie Streeter, E. Edgewell, Frank Lee, spelled L-E-A. He was kind of this weird punster. And he was someone who lived very large in the American imagination. You know, books have compared him to Jesse Helms. I feel that he loomed larger in the American imagination than Helms did at the time.
SPEAKER_01So, real quick, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, he was like a celebrity.
SPEAKER_01You were talking about smut, and this comes up, and you know, uh belly dancing women uh in Chicago and New York and things like that. But it you're also talking sometimes about uh women's health advice.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01What is uh the Society for the Suppression of Vice? Okay. And and and who's he entrapping? How's this working? Let's let's let's get to all the things.
SPEAKER_02Well, should we so so let me let me I gave you my my fun facts about him?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um I'll tell you a little bit about his life, and then I'll tell you what the Comstock law is. Beautiful. I mean, in brief, what the law is, it was the first American law to criminalize the mailing of contraception and abortion, as well as this is really important, information about contraception and abortion with steep penalties and fines. It was not the first federal obscenity law, but it was the first to link obscenity in the popular imagination and in the political discourse with birth control, which had not been done before.
SPEAKER_02Anthony Comstock was born in 1844 in Eukana, Connecticut. He, at the time, it was a very agrarian town. Uh, his mother, Polly Lockwood, was a direct descendant of the Puritans. They worshiped at the congregational church. I usually say strict congregationalist, but I'm like, is that redundant? I mean, I don't, I don't know that there's another kind of congregationalism at that time. He misbehaved sometimes at school, and some people have posited that his animosity toward women came from the fact that he was punished by being asked to sit with the girls and wear a sun bonnet.
SPEAKER_02When he was 10 years and 10 days old, he came home from school to find, as he put it, the loveliest mother that ever lived dead. His mother, Polly, had died of a uterine hemorrhage following the birth of Anthony's younger sister Harriet, who was either her sixth or eighth child, we're not sure. Um what's incredible about the story, if you think of it in kind of a Freudian way, is that he experienced this deep trauma, the loss of his mother, and then all it did was turn him into someone who sort of doubled down on the idea that women's highest obligation was to be fruitful and multiply.
SPEAKER_02That dying in childbirth, rather than being an event that might cause him to have compassion for women's bodies, compassion for the dangers of repeated pregnancies and childbirth, this caused him to commit his whole life to religiosity and the idea that was called the Victorian ideal. Women at the time were seen as the anchor of the family, the wife, the mother, the voice of morality.
SPEAKER_02And so just to fast forward a couple other things in his life, he enlisted in the Civil War after his brother died at Gettysburg. His service, very uneventful. Um, mostly what he did was like he poured out his whiskey ration instead of giving it to the other guys, like to drink his whiskey, which is like it's annoying enough that like that's just annoying that he didn't drink whiskey, but then you're not gonna let anyone else have it. Um, he came home to his bunk at one at one time and he found a trash fire literally set on his bed because they just hated him so much.
SPEAKER_01Um he had a personal war.
SPEAKER_02Yes. Do you uh he he masturbated constantly? And his Civil War diary contains these excerpts where he basically says, you know, I fought with Satan, I fought and I fought with Satan and I failed. And then a couple days later he'll say, I fought with Satan and I succeeded. And then he'll go back to failing very quickly. And it's clear that he was documenting his failed attempts not to masturbate. Like any 19-year-old, he was just really not that successful.
SPEAKER_02And he moves um to Connecticut briefly after the war to try to make it as a dry goods salesman, but he's not very good at it. And he kind of has a series of dead-end jobs. By this point, his father had the farm had been foreclosed on, his father had remarried and moved to England. And one day, Anthony's like, you know, he's kind of like a slacker, like like a Gen Xer trying to make his way. And he sees a friend of his, a cousin of his mother's, who was from a very prominent family.
SPEAKER_02And he's like, dude, like, I can't get a job. Like, what am I gonna do? And the guy gives him five bucks and says, go to New York and make something of yourself. With that five dollars, he arrives at City Hall. He arrives at City Hall with a dollar and 45 cents left in his pocket, and he finds a boarding house on Pearl Street, very, very close to where we are right now. And all the other guys in the boarding house are going out, enjoying the period that's beautifully chronicled in the book Low Life, playing billiards, whoring, smoking.
SPEAKER_01By FAQ guest, Lucy Sun.
SPEAKER_02Yes, there you go. And uh a book that was very influential on me in writing this book. And they're going to pretty waiter girl saloons where all of the uh waitresses are prostitutes. And I'm I'm going to use the word prostitute because I feel that it's authentic to the time period. Um, the women who sold their bodies for sex at this time were not living in Portland, Oregon, with lower back tattoos, having a feminist take on sexuality.
SPEAKER_02They were prostituting themselves because they were extremely poor. And wages for women, wages for men weren't very good either. But women worked as milliners and they supplemented their wages with various forms of prostitution. And it's been called a combination of tricking and treating. So tricking is straight up selling sex. Treating would be things like going to dinner with someone that you don't really like and maybe giving him a little bit of what he wants so that you can get a free meal.
SPEAKER_02The point of all this is when Anthony Comstock came to New York, it was pulsing with sex. It was a place for young men. It was called sporting culture. They went to sporting houses. I had a statistic here that some insane percentage of men in New York were between the ages of 15 and 30. Like you, that it was a young man's town. And there was just an incredible amount of prostitution. There were all these dirty books.
SPEAKER_02Um, some of the book titles you could find on streets like Nassau Street and Warren Street and Anne Street were Lord Kay's Rapes and Seductions, uh, the writings of Paul Decock, spelled K-O-C-K, and my favorite women's rights convention. And these were a combination of written and visual works that were actually like pretty, pretty steamy. I got, I gotta say, there were some group scenes.
SPEAKER_02He told me to be family friendly. I'm going, I'm going to try. Okay, yes. So it was in 1860, 46% of the men in New York were between 15 and 30. So that just gives you a sense of all this. And basically what was happening was Anthony was from an agrarian town in New England, like, you know, like many people, men and women coming to New York City at this time, he basically just freaked. And he's like, I cannot deal with all the sex. What winds up happening at the same time? A fairly new organization called the Young Men's Christian Association is thinking to itself, how do we solve the problem of porn and smut?
SPEAKER_02How do we solve the problem that these young men from congregationalist families are coming to New York and basically losing their minds? And so they began to think, what if we created a home for them? What if we created a building where you could have a gymnasium and a library and a place to sit and talk about the Bible with other men? Lo and behold, we get the first YMCA in New York at 23rd and Fourth Avenue. And you have this confluence of wait, was that the YMCA song?
SPEAKER_01Or that was my readition.
SPEAKER_02No, because I was gonna say it's not how it goes. Um you have the person and the time period uh colliding to alter women's reproductive rights for more than a century. Fast forward to Anthony Comstock. Um, he starts going after dirty booksellers. And he was he was such a scold. Like one of my favorite stories is like the first bookseller he tried to get arrested, he goes to a cop and says, you know, this guy in his store um is selling these dirty books.
SPEAKER_02What does the cop do? He tips off the bookseller. The guy doesn't get arrested. What does Anthony do? He goes to the guy's precinct and he gets the cop fired. This is the kind of person that he was. So he basically becomes a freelance vice hunter and he starts going after these booksellers. And he soon realizes that almost all of the dirty books sold in present-day financial dis are published by only a couple of guys. And he decides that if he can buy the plates, the actual book plates, he can basically end the obscene book trade, which, you know, its locus was in this neighborhood for the entire country, because this is where the books were being printed.
SPEAKER_02So he decides to write a letter to one of the big whigs at the Y to ask for money so that he can buy the book plates and put these guys out of business. But his handwriting is so bad that when this letter arrives on the desk of Robert McBurney of the YMCA, Robert McBurney writes Anthony Comstock back and says, Your handwriting is so bad, I can't read this letter. Can you please rewrite it and send it to me again?
SPEAKER_02At which point Anthony rewrites the letter and sends it. And a meeting is swiftly arranged between Anthony and a guy named Morris Jessup, who was a banker and a founder of the American Museum of Natural History. Can you call him a mocher if he's a Baptist? I'm not sure. Can we say he's a we was a Baptist mocher?
SPEAKER_01We don't have a million here to decide on it.
SPEAKER_02And so he meets Jessup, and Jessup, you know, hooks him up with his other friends at the Y, whose last names might uh have meaning to some of your listeners. Dodge, which was copper, Morgan, which was banking, and Colgate, which was Vaseline and toothpaste and soap. Um, toothpaste may have come later, I'm not sure. But they wind up giving him a salary to go after these smuddy book dealers.
SPEAKER_02And then within a couple of years' time, they decide that they want to try to change obscenity law. So they wind up stiffening obscenity law first in the state of New York and Albany, and then coming up with this idea to change federal obscenity law. And that's when Anthony starts going on trips to Washington, all financed by these guys. And in March 1873, uh, President Grant signs the Comstock Act into law, which criminalizes uh contraception and abortion sent by mail.
SPEAKER_02Abortion sent by mail means abortifacients, which are items that cause abortion, but also abortion ads. One thing that I think you'd be fascinated by, Harry, is you had abortion ads in mainstream newspapers. They were called the Penny Press. And so people who think of, you know, you and I kind of grew up in the era of the alternative press, and you know, we remember the sex ads and the village voice. Um, I think what many Americans might not understand is that it's actually been written that abortion acts essentially, abortion ads essentially paid for the Penny Press.
SPEAKER_02They were in the Herald and they were in the New York Times. And so Anthony wanted to, in this law, he wanted to make it impossible for the abortionists to advertise. And almost immediately after the law was passed, uh, I think he was he was 26 or 27 when it was passed, you saw these ads disappear um from the newspapers. And there was an immediate impact on women's ability to um get abortions.
SPEAKER_02Again, children are always going to get them, but what happened was it became much harder to find them. Um, so that's a little bit about the comps.
SPEAKER_01Sorry, long answer, but there's so much with with Comstock, and the book keeps going through. It's a pretty wild life, but I do want to make sure that we get to these women. I'm thinking that we can start with Sarah Chase, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, let's talk about it.
SPEAKER_01Um, who who, by the way, called Comstock at one point uh an autocrat of Vaseline and Vice.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. That's why I was bringing up the Vaseline thing. So uh just to sort of frame her story a bit, um there was a there were really two pathways uh for different. Kinds of women. Wealthy women could get what was called physical exception. And that means that they could get abortions provided by their doctors. Women who were not wealthy, you know, basically had to go underground. And it was much more dangerous for them.
SPEAKER_02When Sarah Chase, who was a homeopathic physician, who I'll tell her story in a minute, called him an autocrat of Vaseline and Vice, what she was describing was the fact that Samuel Colgate's company had had a Vaseline ad that said if it was mixed with salicylic acid, it could essentially prevent pregnancy. And so you had this total hypocrisy and double standard, which was that Colgate, who was a very high-up member of the YMCA, was literally marketing Vaseline as, you know, when mixed with this other substance as a spermic, as something that could help prevent pregnancy.
SPEAKER_02And then at the same time, women like Sarah Chase were being arrested under the Comstock Law. So she was um she was born in Broome County, New York in 1837. She married another homeopathic physician. They were both educated at the Cleveland Um Homeopathic Institute. Let me see if I can get this right because all those homeopaths will call you and say that I got the name the Cleveland Homeopathic Hospital College.
SPEAKER_01And real quick, you mentioned she's from upstate New York. Upstate New York. Yeah. And also there's the New York Society, I think, the suppression of vice. So it's it's the center of the thing and the fight against the thing. At least New York is first.
SPEAKER_02That's totally. And also, I we we never got into this because you you asked me about the Society for the Suppression of Vice. After Anthony um got the Comstock Law passed, he was appointed the perpetual uh general agent of the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice, which was a privately funded society in which private citizens assisting in obscenity arrests could actually get a portion of the fines. So it was this very strange thing.
SPEAKER_02He was he was a special inspector to the to the United States Postal Service, um, but he was also an officer of this privately funded vice society.
SPEAKER_01And and um so if Sarah Chase ends up sending information in the mail to IP freely or whatever actual pseudonym.
SPEAKER_02No, what happened, what happened was, Harry, she comes to New York and she starts selling vaginal douching syringes. Um, you know, she came from this homeopathic background. She was a feminist, she was a suffragist, and she had she always maintained that she did not provide any abortions. But um, just to break it down and be the first person on this podcast to explain vaginal douching syringes, which is an honor, I'm really happy to have.
SPEAKER_01Advertisers.
SPEAKER_02A syringe was an item in every woman's toilet. Um, it was a hygienic item that was very inexpensive, and you could get it at drugstores. But when you put various substances in it following intercourse, you had actually a pretty good chance of spacing your children uh wider apart in years. There was one study that estimated that women who douched following intercourse had children spaced twice as far apart as those who did not.
SPEAKER_02So by 19th century standards, it was a pretty good contraceptive. Sarah Chase would go around to places like the Packer Institute, which is one of my alma maters, and churches in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, and talk to separate groups of women and men about subjects like masturbation and what she called voluntary motherhood, this idea that we needed to control overpopulation. And like we could go on about this forever. But what was really interesting is there were sort of voices on the right and the left believing in what they called scientific or voluntary motherhood.
SPEAKER_02She wound up publishing a journal that she called The Physiologist and Family Physician. And she would give sex lectures in her house on West 33rd Street, um, and then sell vaginal syringes out of a out of a store she operated on 111 West 11th Street, um, educating about things like female diseases, um, and and again, this concept of family limitation. So what happens? One day she's in her house on West 33rd Street.
SPEAKER_02She had a lot of borders. Um, and this guy shows up and he says his name is Mr. Farnsworth. And he's got, wouldn't you know, red mutton chops, maybe mutton chops that he's grown to hide a scar on his face. And he starts asking her, Do you sell vaginal? You know, I don't think he said vaginal syringes, but he asks her about syringes and have this whole uh interaction. And then at one point, she says, uh she says, uh syringe is what every woman should possess as an adjunct to her toilet.
SPEAKER_02And any druggist has a right to sell them. I would not be afraid to sell one to Anthony Comstock if he should want one. What does Mr. Farnsworth say? I am Anthony Comstock and I have a warrant here for your arrest. He he summons uh a patrolman and a reporter, and they raid her house, ransack everything. They find six syringes. Sarah Chase is arrested and taken to the tombs where she's held on bail. And then, like, this is the kind of thing Anthony Comstock does.
SPEAKER_02While they're raiding the house, Harry, he finds this pamphlet called Feticide. And this is a pamphlet that Sarah has written that's basically saying abortion is terrible, abortion is bad. I don't believe in abortion, but I do think that in very extreme circumstances, it should be up to the woman to decide whether she wants to keep a pregnancy. Anthony Comstock goes to the reporter and he says, I found a pamphlet in her house called Feticide. And then he adds the subtitle, Why It Should Be Done.
SPEAKER_02He just completely made it up. And so then she winds up talking the papers and saying that she's, you know, uh the syringes are for health purposes only. And what was really incredible about this story is she winds up suing, she winds up making a claim against Anthony for false arrest for$10,000. And the sheriff arrests Anthony Comstock. The only example I could find in all of my research of where he himself was ever arrested. And it was really kind of an astounding example of her pushing back uh on him.
SPEAKER_02She never, you know, they they dropped the case against him. But what's one of the saddest things about this story, Harry, is this woman, you know, when he first uh had her arrested, it was 1878. He was still going after her like another 20, 30 years later, after um she she had been imprisoned. And one of the reasons people hated him so much is that he went after like older women. And also he was a dog with a bone. He could never ever get over anyone.
SPEAKER_02And he kept decoying people and and you know, tricking them. And so he was really widely, widely reviled. The reason I like her story is she was sort of an example of women who were operating outside of traditional medicine. Um, and and there's they were called irregulars. There was this idea of regular physicians who would be like a more traditionally educated and typically male physician. And then there were irregulars. These were the practitioners who tended to provide abortions.
SPEAKER_02They were self-taught. Why were they self-taught? They couldn't get into medical schools, they couldn't get into medical societies. And so one of the really chilling effects that we're also seeing now in the era after jobs is when you restrict abortion, you also take away um the livelihoods of women providers, largely women providers. And that's that's also happening today.
SPEAKER_01So before we get to Ida C. Craddock, I do want to say the book has sort of incredible narrative momentum. And then there's an epilogue at the end filling in some of these stories, and and the the aftermath with Sarah Chase in her own career, and then with Comstock, is pretty incredible. Like she gets uh she goes to prison again, she's uh pushed out of medicine largely, although that's still what she ends up listing on her death certificate.
SPEAKER_01Comstock keeps coming at her, as you were saying, and I thought maybe you you could go through that for a second before we uh we move on.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so she was actually sentenced to the state prison for women in Auburn, New York. Funnily enough, they make very good beer in Auburn, New York, right now. I've had a I highly recommend the prison city. Um, but Auburn was known for for having this prison for women. Now, she was sentenced there um because she had assisted a woman who had come to her following a botch, and the woman had died under her care.
SPEAKER_02And so there was a whole case. And so she wound up being in her in her 50s or 60s when she was first in prison. She's released. Can you do this, Matthew? Yeah, she's released at the age of 62. She decides to stay in Auburn and give sex lectures, but she supports herself doing needlework for families. She winds up moving to Pennsylvania. She gets a letter requesting a syringe. She mails it. The writer of the letter turns out to be a deputy marshal.
SPEAKER_02Comstock helps the deputy marshal track her to Elmora, New Jersey, where uh she's arrested in 1900 in her early 60s. In Newark, she's held on$2,500 bail, charged with being a fugitive from justice. And he just keeps going after her and after her. And he he kept this logbook of all of his uh, of all of uh everyone he went after, which you can you can now read and you can see his like really freaky handwriting. She winds up moving to Kansas City, Missouri with her daughter and her son-in-law, and she abandons contraceptive sales and lectures, instead, making art pieces out of human hair.
SPEAKER_01Who among us has not?
SPEAKER_02And she she died. There's actually a renewed, you can go hear lectures all about this, but you know, the that sort of subset of people that are obsessed with death. Um, you can hear like lectures about art pieces of human hair. So it's it's actually having a renaissance area. She, yes, as you pointed out, on her death certificate, she lists physician. And there was this great, yeah. So it was, I mean, it was it was like and she was selling syringes, right?
SPEAKER_01That she was calling Comstock syringes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Oh, we we I don't know. We skipped the best part of we skipped the best part of the story.
SPEAKER_01Go back to the best part.
SPEAKER_02All right. So Sarah Chase, after Comstock um has her arrested, as I said, she was publishing this sort of health journal called The Physiologist and Family Physician. What does she do? She decides to name a vaginal douching syringe, the Comstock syringe, and to sell it in the pages of her journal for$5. Um, he then has her arrested again for mailing the issue of the journal that that names a douching syringe out of him.
SPEAKER_02I think you're looking for the for the ad. She she called it um improved female syringe, the Comstock syringe, especially adapted to purposes of cleanliness and the cure and prevention of disease, a necessary adjunct to every lady's toilet. I mean, and so this is just an incredible example. And then what wound up happening was uh other publications like hers also started uh calling douching syringes, Comstock syringes. And there was one, um, a free love journal out of Massachusetts that had an ad that said, uh, if Comstock's mother had had a syringe and known how to use it, what a world of woe it would have saved us.
SPEAKER_02Um and yeah, and yeah, great example of using language as a form of rebellion.
SPEAKER_01So the the book is really about these sex radicals, as you call them. And I'm not sure all of them, or I'm I'm pretty sure that many of them would would certainly did not and would not, and they didn't know each other seen eye to eye. Um I also think that that the person I would want to get marriage advice from may not be somebody who was married to a ghost and was also a target of Comstocks.
SPEAKER_02Harry, Harry, I had a sex advice column in New York Press while I was writing an autobiographical column about all the trouble I was having with men. And so you would, in the same issue, be able to read, you know, how I had behaved terribly and not knowing what to do, and then flip forward a couple of pages and have me be telling you, you know, what you should do on a date.
SPEAKER_01If there's one thing that ridders of such uh I don't know, maybe it's guys can over uh the the ability of of people to split their minds and to absorb both those pieces of information from the same source is incredible. But I believe you have never been married to a ghost. And we do have a a sort of remarkable uh and that that's really only a a part of uh somewhere it's a small part of her story, but but uh I don't know where to start. Do you want to jump in with Ida Craddock?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, she's she's amazing. So um so Ida Craddock uh was born in 1857 in Philadelphia. Um her father was a cannabis dealer. Um, don't all your troubles start when your dad's a cannabis dealer. And uh and her mother's uh uh, I think a Presbyterian, um, very involved in sort of women's clubs and that kind of thing. Um and Ida is absolutely brilliant. Her parents sent her to uh Friends Seminary, which is still a highly regarded um Quaker private school in Philadelphia, and she's like at the top of her class, super, super brilliant.
SPEAKER_02And she decides she wants to be the first woman to be educated at the University of Pennsylvania. And she winds up trying three times to try to get in. And each time, even though she passes all the exams with flying colors, they reject her solely because she's a woman. She's now in her late 20s, hanging around Philly, living with her mother behind a partition in the living room that she calls the cubicle. And she just doesn't know what to do with herself. She's just absolutely brilliant. So she starts hanging out at the Ridgway Library and reading these books about her two obsessions, which were religion and phallic symbols.
SPEAKER_02And she becomes this sort of lay scholar of world religions. Um, and she winds up um fighting with her mother so much. Basically, she says to her mom, like, I want to have a salon, an intellectual salon in the house. Her mom's like, no way. By this point, her mother was widowed. And I just like, screw this, I'm moving to San Francisco. I mean, you can see why I was so drawn to her story because it has so many of these modern elements, you know, this 20-something in in her case, Stamy just because of pure sexism, she just happened to be born a few decades before co-education.
SPEAKER_02Um, and then she's a bright person who just doesn't know what to do with herself. She can't figure out how to apply herself. She moves to San Francisco, she's doesn't have a lot of money. She meets this banker who and and and like works for him. I think she like tutored his kids or something. And he says, I'm going to Alaska. Do you want to come along with us? And they go to Alaska and she starts seeing all these phallic symbols, these totem poles. So she like writes an essay about it and a folklore magazine. And then she begins um experimenting with a Ouija board.
SPEAKER_02And through the Ouija board, she discovers this ghost named Soph, who was the ghost of a man who had been a friend of her mother's, who she had met as a teenager and who had died of, you know, I think it was pneumonia. Um, and she marries the ghost in the borderland, and soon after that goes to the Chicago World's Fair, like so many Americans, in 1893.
SPEAKER_02And she goes to watch the belly dance. And there were a couple of different belly dances at the World's Fair, and she sees the women moving their hips in this very orgasmic way. And she goes back home. By this point, she's now living with her mother again in Philadelphia, and she writes this essay for one of the New York newspapers about how belly dancing can be a marital educator. And at the time, the belly dance was extremely controversial, so controversial, in fact, that Anthony Comstock had also visited the World's Fair to try to have, they were then called the, as they were called, the Oriental Dances shut down.
SPEAKER_02And I believe that Ida and Anthony were in the same performance of the same belly dance on the same day. And if I had written this as a novel, that's the way that I would have begun it. And he catches wind of her article defending the belly dance. She's sort of on his radar. It's an incredible story that goes on for decades. But Ida Craddock reinvents herself as kind of a freelance um sex educator.
SPEAKER_02She she gives a talk at a German Masonic temple where like everyone's cheeks were totally red at the end of her talk. And she she would talk, she was very strange. She would talk about like phallic symbols and world religions. And she winds up dubbing herself Mrs. Idacratic and publishing a series of these marriage manuals, which would give you advice on what to do on the wedding night. I mean, one thing you have to think about, Harry, is like so many young people did not have any information at all.
SPEAKER_02Could you imagine the terror you would feel on your wedding night? Not even know basic things about your own body and what's going to happen. She would publish these very, I don't, I guess you can't call them chaste, but you know, she would give advice what should a woman do if let's say the man's anatomy is not compatible with the woman's anatomy. Um, she suggested Vaseline as a lubricant, um, as well as Cosmoline. I mean, she was really dedicated to helping young people.
SPEAKER_02And she winds up kind of jumping around to different cities, being arrested in Chicago, Philadelphia, and DC, with different outcomes in each one. One of my favorite parts about her story is when she's arrested in Chicago, there's Clarence Darrow as her lawyer, who at the time was going through his own divorce and who was really a very open-minded man who was sort of uh interested in defending medical and sexual language.
SPEAKER_02And what does Clarence Darrow, the attorney of the damned, tell her to do? Take a plea. So she's lucky enough to get Clarence Darrow as her lawyer, but he tells her to take a plea. She gets out of Chicago and she winds up moving to New York City, to West 23rd Street, the tenderloin, and taking a room in a fifth floor walk-up and giving these um sex lessons where she would explain male continence, which is a method where the man orgasms without ejaculating, um, were really pushing the bounds of family, family friendly on the show.
SPEAKER_01And one of the This is where families come from when there is ejaculate.
SPEAKER_02And one of the incredible things, you know, it's like I Harry, I used to write, you know, my column in New York Press, and all of the mail that I got, the mail that people wrote into the newspaper was saying what a uh how they would never want to date me. But then I would get these other letters that they would send to me personally, care of the newspaper. I got a headshot, a guy sent me his headshot, they would send me their uh their measurements, you know, various measurements of their body.
SPEAKER_02And so one of the reasons I related to Ida Cratic's story is she, in this, what I believed to be a very pure, pure interest in helping people and some very weird religious beliefs, um, these guys would come to her apartment for these sex lessons and they would hit on her. And she had this diary filled with stories of how, you know, uh men would try to touch her. And she would say, you know, look at my, look at my chart on uh, you know, the astral plane.
SPEAKER_02And and and she was actually able, in her sort of sternness and her librarian esque qualities, um, really able to sort of browbeat these guys into behaving. Properly. She seems never to have been sexually assaulted, not in a way that she's written about. And I think she was just constantly frustrated because she was, when she was living in New York, she was incredibly poor. She used to pray for sex clients, and she called it ringing up the central telephone of the universe.
SPEAKER_02So many of us at early stages of our writing careers rang up the central telephone of the universe.
SPEAKER_01She wanted to give advice to her sex clients based on her beliefs. Well, she she remains married and intimate with, she said. Oh, yes, Mrs.
SPEAKER_02Mrs. Ida C. Craddock. Yeah. And one of the weird things about her being married to this ghost was in the in the radical circles, um, a lot of them thought she was crazy. And so people couldn't uh, you know, it's mostly men in these, in these free thought circles, although there were some women, they sort of couldn't reconcile the fact that her marriage and sex advice was really quite sound. It was all very, very good and logical advice with the fact that she was married to a ghost with whom she had really mixed sex.
SPEAKER_02Uh one of the jokes that I always make uh uh about the sex with a ghost is that like sometimes she didn't have an orgasm. And if I were gonna have sex with a ghost, like I would think it would, by its nature, just be completely perfect. But like so many women, even women today, sadly, she was very obsessed with different kinds of orgasms. And so she had this Freudian belief that uh that a vaginal orgasm was superior to a clitoral orgasm. I mean, this was like crazy.
SPEAKER_02So she moves to New York, she's living in the tenderloin, right? And she had mailed, uh, when she first moved to New York, she had mailed a bunch of her pamphlets to Anthony Comstock and said, Can I continue to sell these in New York? Now, if you look at it like a novelist, it seems as though at this point in her life, she was in her early 40s, she'd been arrested in multiple cities. She had known about Comstock for years and written about him.
SPEAKER_02It seems almost as though she was baiting him to come after her. Why would you say, I have arrived in your city, Mr. Comstock? Please read my books and tell me whether I can mail them. And so he writes her back and he says, No, you can't. And I've heard that you've been arrested in Chicago. And she's so poor that she keeps hand selling them to her clients. And the day after she had sent Anthony uh her pamphlets to see if she could sell them, she receives a request in the mail from a guy named Frank Lee in New Jersey.
SPEAKER_02And Frank Lee requests a particular pamphlet of hers. And she sends it out. And just a couple of days later, there's a knock on her door at 134 West 23rd Street, apartment number five. And who should it be but Anthony Comstock himself? And he goes to her bookshelf and begins rifling through her sex books and sex pamphlets, and he begins to whistle the belly dancing song, which goes like this.
SPEAKER_02A song that was actually written by Saul Bloom, one of the Jewish promoters of the Columbian World's Fair, who had improvised it on a piano the first time that the belly dancers had performed with such an incredible story of all these different characters. And she realizes that he's whistling the belly dancing song as though to taunt her. And when he hands her the warrant for her arrest, she sees that the handwriting, arrest warrant, matches the handwriting of um not the first guy that had requested the pamphlet, but a recent letter she has received from a young woman, an underage woman who wants to read her sex books, to whom she refused to sell them.
SPEAKER_02And he winds up getting on the subway because she was underage. She never wanted to, she never, she didn't believe that uh her information should be known by by any minors. And so he winds up, Anthony rides with uh rides with Ida on the on the subway. Um I I I was it to it was either to the Ludlow Street jail or or a jail around there. And it's it's just an incredible story. She winds up um being charged under the federal and state Comstock law, hiring a uh the the Bill Kunzler of his time, this sort of free speech lawyer who doesn't know what to do with her.
SPEAKER_02And she winds up meeting a really, really terrible end uh at the age of 44, um, on the eve of her sentencing. And and so, yeah, I mean, it's just just crazy. I think one of the things I like the most about the women in my book is they were almost all unmarried, and they were all a little bit crazy.
SPEAKER_01So the heyday, if you want to call it that, of Comstock's career is sort of at the beginning of the Gilded Age, um, which comes from the book Mark Twain co-wrote. You know, and it it's uh it's not the golden age, it's the gilded age, it's it's a thin surface over this. And you know, as the the book gets into it, and you just have this sort of coincides with all of these new uh restrictions on what can get uh advertised, communicated, sent through the mail and express, and things that had been sort of uh personal decisions and at the margins of the culture but that were there start uh receding and jumping ahead to uh what's maybe this gilded age we're in.
SPEAKER_01And you know, uh Trump, I'm not trying to get into those sorts of politics at all, but you know, he uh you know famously when he was explaining that like glitz is one level above guilt, and this is what you need to have to uh to draw people in with the the surfacings and the sparkles and so on.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And uh I would love uh your thoughts now past uh the utility for sales um on uh what resonates from uh these women and the sort of bravery it took to have any of these ideas, you know, like like you were taking chances and uh with the law and with your social standing and so on, just just by by being in these worlds, and what doesn't does not seem parallel to you with the moment we're in now in a very different world with a wide open internet, yeah, and um all sorts of questions about uh about the decisions women should or should not be able to make well with with with uh with their bodies and fertility and all of that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, one thing that distinguishes the the women in my book is none of them have the right to vote. And they all were writers before they were anything else. A couple of them were nurses, self-educated physicians of various kinds. Um, people don't know that both Margaret Sanger and Emma Goldman were nurses, and that was where their sort of birth control awakenings happened was treating poor women on the Lower East Side and seeing them dying of botched abortions.
SPEAKER_02Um so these women used writing as a political platform, and they did it at a time when they had no political voice through the vote. Um I think another thing that distinguishes them and made me passionate enough to want to write about all of them is they were actually middle-aged. You know, they were middle-aged women without children, which might explain why they were so productive. Um, a lot of them were able to devote their lives to these political causes because they um did not have families to care for, um, which has sort of a new resonance in the era of talking about uh childless cat ladies and the role of non-mothers in society as uh having an important an important role to play, perhaps because they're not burdened by marriage and childbirth.
SPEAKER_02But Harry, something that I I wanted to say when you were talking about this sort of gilded, gilded era, you know, people often ask me, like, did he really hate women? Like, did Comstock really hate women? And of course, the truth of the matter is no, he saw himself as a a friend of women. I mean, if you were to ask him, he would say that he was saving women by helping them avoid abortion and these, you know, this the terrible life of prostitution and and and abortion.
SPEAKER_02But what he did, um, you know, whatever his intentions were, his true intentions were, and his true feelings about women, in being the vessel for this law that branded birth control as a form of obscenity and really tainted it in the public's mind at a time when it really was not tainted, um, is he created a belief system, which is sometimes called Comstockism or Comstockery.
SPEAKER_02And that belief system, which was about something much broader than what we would call today, like women's bodily autonomy, but on sort of the structure and role of different people in society and the way that society needed to be organized to continue to function as it had in the past, is in creating this system, he then, and I mean this quite literally, he created the law that was later used for things like the Alien Exclusion Act, various anti-anarchy acts.
SPEAKER_02People don't realize that some of these same laws that we're all wondering, um, whether they may be resurrected during Trump too. These laws, which were passed around the turn of the century following the McKinley assassination, New York law in 1909, the Smith Act, which came a couple of decades later and was used to prosecute communists and socialist workers, all of those laws were revisions of the Comstock Act.
SPEAKER_02So the same law that criminalized the mailing of birth control and sexual, you know, various forms of sexual speech, that was what they went back into when they wanted to criminalize dangerous speech. And I think that that's something that's so important to know is that it gave them the grounding to begin to suppress political thought and unpopular thought. It all came out of uh this anti-sex law.
SPEAKER_01This is, I think, the prehistory. My brother is writing a book about this of modern information control, which in a lot of ways dates to just after the period you're talking about and builds on that with the uh uh with the uh um the espionage act of 1917, and then uh and that remains on the books and parts, and then the Sedition Act of 1918, both of which, among other things, controlled what you could say and what you could send through the mail.
SPEAKER_01As we went from a society of people talking to one another with basically that much range, to a much more connected and then electronically connected society where you could really start to uh assert more control over information. Amy, thank you again for coming on and taking all this time. Everyone should check out the book, Censorship and Civil Liberties in the Gilded Age, and more generally, pretty much anything Amy writes.
SPEAKER_02So great to be here with you and talk about it. FAT.
SPEAKER_01FAQ NYC is made possible in part by support from the Charles H. Refson Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, and from PNT Netware, an independent bookstore, cafe, and event space on the at its lower east side with a podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use. The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of FAQ NYC. The pod's friends include The City, a nonprofit newsgroup, delivering hard-hitting news that serves the people of New York. If you'd like to pitch in to keep that work going, head to thecity.nc slash give 2024.
SPEAKER_01All through December, your gift will be doubled by news match thanks to a generous local donor making holiday magic happen and turning one dollar into two dollars. You can help at the city.com, a collective of 60 writers delivering a cooperatively owned new newsletter in a different voice each day that you might actually want to read. Our host this week was me, Harry Sigal. I'm also FAQ NYC's executive producer. Our engineer is the inimitable Adam Kamara.
SPEAKER_01Special thank you to our guest, Amy Sohn. Pick up the man who hated women, sex censorship, and civil liberties in the Gilded Age. Thank you, listener, for making it this far. If you like what you're hearing, please subscribe, spread the word, write a nice review at Apple or Spotify. Just tell a friend. Thanks, be kind, be cool. We'll be back soon with more.
As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...
Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...
New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.
For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...