Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

TBD NYC

TBD NYC artwork

Michael Rohatyn and Peter Yost’ Drop Dead City

Nov 15, 202549 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The creators of the acclaimed new documentary about Gotham’s close brush with bankruptcy in 1975 sit down with Amy Sohn and Harry Siegel to discuss the film, the city that was, how its near collapse led to the city of today how Michael’s father Felix helped pulled it back from the brink with Big MAC, or the Municipal Assistance Corporation, and more.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04Mr. Ford proposes indeed to put a noose around our necks. We will not accept that fate without a fight.

SPEAKER_01We come up the city with a hub.

SPEAKER_02It's Lit NYC, the New Yorkers show about the ABCs of arts, books, culture, etc. I'm Harry Siegel, the FAQ NYC Podcast Network's executive producer, here with columnist, performer, and prolific book writer Amy Son. And joining us right now are Michael Rowan and Peter Yost, the filmmakers behind the new documentary Drop Dead City. A look back at when the city almost literally ran out of money in 1975, damn near dropped dead, and emerged from that crisis as a different place, one that got its finances back under control, perhaps at the cost of becoming over time a more financialized city.

SPEAKER_02Following widely successful limited runs across the country, DDC Drop Dead City is now streaming on Apple TV and Amazon Prime.

SPEAKER_04The story told in Drop Dead City is so complicated that the variety reviewer for the film, Owen Gleiberman, called it wonkish but gripping. If there's anyone who can unpack that complexity and make it sing, it's Michael. Michael is a son of the man who did the deal that saved the city, Felix Rowatin, the Lazard Frere banker who formed the Municipal Assistance Corporation or Big Mac as it was referred to in the tabloids.

SPEAKER_02So, gentlemen, welcome. Let's jump right in. Drop Dead City, which is full of really jaw-dropping and popping footage of 1970s, New York, feels like an ode to a different time. Labor unions were all powerful, it was possible to build a good life and buy a home on a city's salary, which are ideas that in some ways have come back to the fore with Merolech Mamdani's historic win and ambitious affordability agenda. But let's start with what happened in 1975, when it emerged rather suddenly that the city had been massively overspending its revenue, was borrowing against future revenue it didn't actually expect, the bank stopped buying our bonds, there wasn't any money left to pay bills, and municipal bankruptcy really seemed to be on the table.

SPEAKER_02And what led the two of you to revisit all that history now?

SPEAKER_00Well, Peter and I are friends from uh, you know, off of uh uh childhood uh rearing uh duties uh and we were at drop-off at uh our kids go to the same school. And um on the way home, one day he is, you know, uh in the documentary trade, uh and I say that with all respect. And uh it seemed like he had a little hole in his schedule and was kicking around for what's a good topic. And I had just been speaking with my ex the day before about isn't it interesting that nobody's maybe interesting is overstating it, but isn't it notable that nobody's made anything about this period of the fiscal crisis and I'm very connected to it, you know.

SPEAKER_00I have a deep nostalgia for that period and so on. And I had also just been spending time with a lot of these old timers from this cohort who had been I had just been to like a lunch and watched them kind of gather together to trade stories.

SPEAKER_04And was your father alive when you started working on it?

SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell, he was. He had Alzheimer's, so he had already started to go into decline. He passed away in 2019. And we tried to interview him a bunch of times, three times. Actually, the last time I tried to do it in French, because that was his last kind of cognitive space, and we couldn't we couldn't do it. The only beautiful story I like to tell of that is in all the interviews, you know, we a we finished the interviews saying, uh you know, what does New York mean to you? It's a pretty obvious meatball kind of final question.

SPEAKER_00And uh dad who had been really struggling, he was tired, but he he kind of lit up. And it's one of the last things in many people I think who are in decline that they still have their sense of humor even after the speaking cognitive kind of function has faded. And he said, he knew exactly what we were doing, what I was asking for. I need something. And he said, New York New York is everything.

SPEAKER_04Wow. So what was the Municipal Assistance Corporation and how did Felix Rowitan come to be involved with it?

SPEAKER_00So uh the Municipal Assistance Corporation was an a legal entity that was created by the state to supersede the authority, essentially, of the City of New York to oversee its affairs, to act as a reassurance to Wall Street that what had come out as an incredible, almost scandalous uh accounting uh narrative of mal of malpractice was being kind of dealt with.

SPEAKER_00And they were bringing in, so to speak, the adults in the room, and it was you know, it's still the legacy of it is of of of a of a an appointed group of people unelected who are being given authority over m the fate of millions of people. Not a success for democracy. But in uh in this event, as I often try to point out, my father revered government, he loved FDR, and you know, arguably he was kind of the right of anyone you could ask to do this, he was somebody who was not gonna come in and beat it all up and say, well, this is why we're not gonna do this and this and this.

SPEAKER_00But they tried to kind of create a a reliable product, and the Mac bond was something that they were gonna give to the banks to exchange in exchange for this other paper, as they call it in the trade, that was deemed unsalable. Uh and it's it's very complicated. It really does come down to trust, and the capital markets are all driven by trust. If if I I don't have to buy your bond, so you have to convince me that it's worth what you're telling me.

SPEAKER_00And the minute there's any doubt about that, and it dries up, and what happened in New York was short-term borrowing was where that hurt. So it wasn't even like, oh, I'm not gonna lend you money to build that bridge. I'm not gonna lend you money to get through your payroll for next week. So the crisis was just magnified when, as we show in our film, one day they put out an auction for bonds and nobody bid on them. And that was that. So they had to find an alternative, and Mac was that alternative.

SPEAKER_04So one reason this film is more gripping than wonkish is the amazing archival footage of NYC in the 70s, like the two men holding a sign on a trash-strewn street during the sanitation strike after garbage men were laid off. If you think we have rats in City Hall now, you ain't seen nothing yet. How did you find all this footage? And like what's what's the process like for finding stuff that doesn't feel like we've seen it before? Because I think what struck me, you know, like I saw 40 Deuce by Paul Morrissey, you know, some of these images are are familiar to us, depending how big like movie nerds we are, but the your footage felt so fresh.

SPEAKER_04I felt like I wasn't seeing any of it. I hadn't seen any of it before.

SPEAKER_03Well, it's true. You uh um almost certainly had never seen virtually any of it, because by definition, it was garbage. It was stuff that had not been aired in most instances because the way it worked, 1975 was more or less the last year that the news, the local news, shot on film. So that's kind of aesthetically very much to our benefit. It's a great thing. Instead of kind of crappyish, I mean there's a mood to it, but 80s-ish video, this was very cinematic just in its nature, even when you're looking at kind of banal news stories.

SPEAKER_03So you had that as kind of a a baseline. And then because this was 50 years ago and some of it very, very obscure, local news on a daily Tuesday, what's going on? People didn't know that it's necessarily a historical moment. Um, much was um trashed in the first place, and we kind of found things that had never been cataloged before just on shelves. And then when they did air things, they um edited that into final pieces, and those exist. But the reels that we actually found were the outtakes essentially.

SPEAKER_03So stuff that never in most instances made it to error, so that when you see those guys with the signs, or I like my sign is my favorite sign is the system sucketh, yeah, which is I think is a fairly concise and elegant distillation of the sentiment of the moment andor of today.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell We should also mention we have an amazing uh archival producer, Frauka Levin, who is kind of a li-library whisperer. She kind of knew who to talk to and kept coming back to us with stuff that, of course, we didn't know what we were getting, so it made our editing harder because suddenly now we want to put that rather than that. And a lot of the joy and tedium of cataloging this stuff is you watch it all and you take notes, and it's like there's a little bit of this, there's a little of that. And then the other joy and tedium is to just make sure you get as much of it into the film as you can.

SPEAKER_00And so the film's quite rich for that reason.

SPEAKER_03Aaron Ross Powell And our editors, um Don Clesey and Anna Oster just did an amazing job too, and you know, with that. And Michael has a very good sense of humor, despite this experience. Trevor Burrus, Jr. And so it was in the minutiae of finding those little moments that kind of made the difference, I think.

SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell I just um not to be a hype man for you guys, but you'll feel this from from the Do your worst very opening shot. Oh, yeah, nice. Which is uh as you're explaining this all being on film, going through the stuff that didn't air, it uh both both hits some of the big themes that the movie is going to go into, but captures all that and and start you off, I I've seen a lot of archival footage, and this was all just sort of new and fresh and vivifying to me in a really helpful way.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell I say one one little thing about that opening shot. Glad you brought it up. Yeah. I don't think it's giving any away to the audience. Aaron Powell I was trying not to spoil what was doing. No, no, I know, but I'm just gonna do this anyway. So two things about it. First of all, it's an outtake of a newscaster, and the broadcasters don't want you to use that. Like it's very that's typically off limits. So we actually had to go back and ask them for that, and we had to contact the man who's still wonderfully with us in San Diego to say, you know, it would help if you would just sign off on it, and he was kind of like, I don't know why you need this, but okay.

SPEAKER_00Very funny guy. Um but it only dawned on me like a few months ago that you know how you're trying to you when you make a movie, you you o The great movies always start out with a sequence that somehow is the meta story in that one sequence. And ours is this journalist trying to get the story right and he can't. And that's because it's a very big, difficult story to tell. And so like we had it. It's like it's completely conveyed in that first sequence. We also had an incredible soundtrack, and we we got ourselves a million-dollar soundtrack with A-list songs from 1975, mostly, all of them kind of thematically connected to the scene.

SPEAKER_04Did Bob Dylan give you the songs for free?

SPEAKER_00This is where I'm going. All right. So we were like in all these stories, over ten years you meet a lot of people. There are these good government people in New York. There's a group called the CBC, you've probably heard of them, Citizens Budget Commission. And they are the ones who approve the mayor's budget every year before it goes to Albany. And one of them is a lawyer named Ed Wallace and uh very straight, charming guy, and he said, I would love your movie. How can I help? And I was like, Well, Ed, do you know anyone in the publishing music business?

SPEAKER_00Because I if you like the movie, we can't we're we're not gonna be able to pay for those songs. He saw a rough cut and we were using a lot of fancy songs. He said, Well, I'm friends with Bob Dylan's manager, and a guy named Jeff Rosen. He said, I have lunch with him and I love this guy. I'd love to show him the movie. And we showed it to Jeff, and Jeff loved it, liked it. I don't want to speak for Jeff, but we had a Zoom with him and he said, How can I help? I was like, of course, I need help. See if you can do you know anyone at these publishing places? And he said, well, the best way to do this is do you have any Dylan in the movie?

SPEAKER_00And I said, no, because why would we have Dylan in the movie? You know, that's a little a bridge too far. And also, not 1975, we're trying to stay in this tone. He said, well, find a Dylan song, and I'll give it to you for a great rate, and you can leverage all your other prices down. And we found a Dylan song from 1975, live recording off of Hard Rain, that we built that montage out of. But we did that after basically the film had already been completed while we're trying to pay for the music licensing.

SPEAKER_04And wait, I just have to throw this in. So so Jeff Rosen, in my first novel, I was so young, this is like the mid-90s. I quote Bob Dylan. So I was quoting, I think it was It Ain't Me, Babe. And I sent it to the publisher. They said, well, you know, try to get the rights if you can. But they were very pessimistic. Jeff Rosen writes me back in like a week. Great guy. They gave it to me for nothing.

SPEAKER_00Great guy.

SPEAKER_04And so it says special rider music at the front of my novel, just like it says at the front of your uh in your end credits.

SPEAKER_00Totally. Amazing. He's a good guy, yeah. And a good New Yorker.

SPEAKER_04Trevor Burrus, Jr.: So, Michael, I want to talk to you about your father, um, Felix Rowatin, was born in Vienna in 1928 to a Polish-Jewish father, an Austrian mother. You said he loved FDR. He came to this country in 1942, so that makes sense. It was really formative. It was his early years in the United States. How did he come to care so deeply about New York City?

SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell, you know, I that is a really good question. I mean, I think that says a lot about him and also about New York. I think he was he was an only child. He was sort of trained to be a physicist, he was going to be in the sciences, and then he was sent to work at Lazard for a summer job, and came under the sort of the mentorship of this very complicated, difficult banker, Andre Meyer, who's a sort of a famous guy in the industry, and um and was formed by this guy.

SPEAKER_00And the nature of investment banking, he was a young banker. When I grew up, it was not a high-flying business. He lived in a during these years, he lived in a really crummy hotel. My parents had separated. He lived in like the uptown Chelsea hotel with a we slept on the couch, roaches, the whole thing. Glory days, I will say. And um but it wasn't a big money job. And being rich in those days, in any case, you were still a New Yorker.

SPEAKER_00Like now I feel like rich people have a place here, they have a place over their banks, have a place here, a place over their newspapers. There's no Metro Desk at the New York Times. Thank God for the city. Like the nature of being powerful or from the class, the elite class. In those days, you were still a New Yorker. And I actually think his love for the city grew immensely just from this experience. And so he loved meeting the labor guys. Investment banking, he was always like in the 60s, that was kind of the beginning of mergers and acquisitions and of distressed companies that needed restructuring and blah, blah, blah.

SPEAKER_00And so he kind of got into that. But it's a business of egos, it's a business of people with you know who are hiding things, who are, you know, it's negotiating with big personalities. And then you go to the next level where you're dealing with unions, and these are like incredible characters. They're very sophisticated and smart, and they're playing you, and they're playing each other. And I think he just was enchanted by it.

SPEAKER_04So I'll just ask one quick follow-up to that, which is it seems like you had a good relationship with him because you chose to make this movie, and people who have really messed up relationship with their parents, I don't know if they want to. Yeah. But what was it like, you know, if if he died in 2019 and a lot of the making of this film was after that, just watching this footage and you know, seeing him and kind of his public persona, was it was that emotional for you?

SPEAKER_00It was. I mean, for Peter for us, it was also really important. I didn't want it to be a movie about him. I thought that would really that wasn't something I wanted to spend time making. And I those are not the movies that I really like to watch. So that was really difficult. Like how do we make it and not make it that? And so in the proportional kind of like how much room do we give him? And I think by many accounts of many of the people that were his cohort, we underrepresented him.

SPEAKER_00He comes in the last third. Um I think he was kind of the the hero of the whole drama of I mean, I can't even really say that. He wouldn't like me to say that. But in any case. So that was a dilemma. I don't want to we didn't want to overdo it. We also didn't want to kind of spoil our interviews where they're talking to Felix's son. We very often Peter would do the interview first and I was sort of lingering back, or whatever, or I would make the interview happen, whatever. I'll just say a couple of one more thing, which is I actually think we honored him for his something that was not maybe like who was what what you know what was his role in terms of the achievement, uh, but honored him for his wit and his intelligence and his acumen.

SPEAKER_00And what I loved watching, and what I really appreciated over the time of making it is really like the arc for him over a very few months of starting out as somebody who was kind of bashful and was thrown into this, like brought in by the governor as a kind of a as a just like a rookie. Like I need somebody from Wall Street who's got credibility, who's a Democrat, and who's good with broken things. And David Burke, who was a counselor to the governor, instrumental in the story, also, also not in our film, regrettably.

SPEAKER_00Uh David Burke said, I I know that Felix Rowatin is talented and let's call him. And Governor Carey was brilliant with finding good people. He was just like that was one of his incredible virtues. And also then listening to them and taking their uh you know, their counsel. And uh and to watch him go from being the newbie to like within three months just totally having his groove, like going in front of the mics and understanding the ecosystem of the reporters and they want something and I need a good line.

SPEAKER_00And and he loved that and he was really good at it.

SPEAKER_03But I also I also think um and coming in with a a little more uh uh objectivity than, of course, Michael given his his father. That was something we spoke about, obviously journalistically, filmmaking-wise, interpersonally, very much in you know, of course, from the beginning and wrestled with. Um and I had always actually been as a geeky kid growing up in Buffalo, not in New York, um, but an admirer of your father, um, and uh as somebody who had just been an intellect who had been a refugee, who had given back to the city and had also written for the New York Review of books.

SPEAKER_03Or Peter was reading the New York Review books in high school. I was, I was a complete geek. But um This is my guy. Yeah, exactly. No, but I'd always been like, who is this guy who can like run Lazare Frere and write like really rigorous intellectual pieces and give back to the city and look at our versions of that today. I mean, and I'm just thinking of it as you're speaking now. In a sense, he's sort of the anti-Trump, right? In a way that he's not grandiose, even if you see him in the film, he's very understated, and that was something we had to wrestle with with the film, where we didn't want him, we didn't want to underplay his role.

SPEAKER_03But actually what he did was very subtle. And the more we looked into it, and a lot of it was kind of behind closed doors, and it was bring it was actually bringing people together. He was lifelong friends with Victor Gottbaum, you know, the major union leader. Tell me how many, you know, uh Wall Street suit types today, or whatever the really rich guys are hanging out their entire lives with the union guys on Sunday night having Chinese food because they love each other. You know, they he brought together seemingly disparate parties, but that's not something that you did on camera screaming on footage.

SPEAKER_03It's very subtle. And so we I personally, I'll speak for myself and I think Michael would agree, but I actually see arguably some of the restraint that it's not a hagiography, it's not a profile, but the existence of this entire solution is a testament, and the complexity and the subtleness is a is a testament to the work that he did.

SPEAKER_02So speaking of subtlety and restraint. Right? So the title Drop Dead City, of course, comes from the iconic Daily News headline for the city drop dead. Uh the tabloids were huge then, and they were all over this. You know, the Daily News had a two million. Circulation. It was really everywhere, one of the biggest papers in the country. But the film also spent several minutes on another iconic cover, very subtle, for the uh infamous Fear City campaign.

SPEAKER_02Right. I actually wrote a daily news channel about that back in 2015. Oh, we might have read it. You know, which was 40 years later, right? And uh the New York Post was crusading about de Blasio supposedly bringing the city back to the bad old days. It's like, well, let me tell you a little about the bad old days. And there's this booklet that off-duty cops are passing out, like at the airport in the bus terminal, telling tourists that in essence, the city was a death trap and giving them advice like never go out after dark.

SPEAKER_04Oh yeah. And I I have a framed um the cover of the pamphlet in my apartment. And I also worked for Mayor Adams as a press secretary for almost three years. And I had it on the bulletin board behind my desk. And if it was like a really I said, Welcome to Fear City, and it was like a really high-stakes call, I took it down. It's like I don't know. Because I came into the administration right after Omicron. You know, it's 2022 when a lot of that was kind of being revived.

SPEAKER_04But but anyway, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell So do you guys just want to tell listeners and people maybe don't remember 1975, haven't seen the film yet, just just a bit about what that campaign was and uh how it played out at the time.

SPEAKER_03You want to Rob briefly and then you can do a bit. The Policeman Benevolence Association, which uh they've never been shrinking violets, in my understanding, and they certainly weren't in the 70s, um, were representing the cops. And along with other unions in the city, they were going to the mat um because the city was going to be making cuts, and they actually, for the first time, were making cuts and laying off cops, which just literally didn't happen in this city.

SPEAKER_03And so at various points, the the cops shut down the Brooklyn Bridge with protests. Um they when when they laid off cops, they would take their guns away, and so they would stage protests. We want our guns back. You know, it was all very, let's just say it wasn't understated. It was playing out in the streets and it was playing out loudly in the streets. And they eventually hit upon this solution or seeming solution to create fear, um, fear city in these pamphlets that they distributed um at train stations and on the streets, often with press around to film them doing it.

SPEAKER_03And it was, as you said, um I don't know how many, how many bullet points? It's a good question, Peter. We should count we should count that, Michael. But I don't know. Yeah, 20, yeah, 20, 20 things not to do. Do not leave things in your hotel safe because somebody will steal it. Do not in any circumstance ride the subway, do not X, Y, and Z, you know, straight on down the line to basically put fear in the in the minds of tourists. Um I think locals were kind of like WTF. They weren't really buying it, and we have some great footage in the film of kind of Man on the Street.

SPEAKER_03Have you heard about this campaign? Not really, who cares? It's overblown. But then tourists who might have heard it differently. But anyway, it just um speaks to the kind of the desperation that the cops felt and also the degree to which they were seemingly willing to kind of throw the city under a bus out of that desperation.

SPEAKER_00The other thing that is also, though, that when you when you lay off union members, they're no longer in the union. And the weird nature of accountability to a union chief is if you're making deals with the city and your membership is seeing you let a bunch of guys go, whose back are you really backing up here? These other guys are not going to vote for you. It's total conflict of interest, right? It's like I'm not saying that that's what was happening, but that's what was is happening in our film.

SPEAKER_00So you're also seeing the cops turn against their own union guy. So Ken McPhee was this worn-out kojack, you know, cop guy, credit- all these guys, the language, the voices, as I'm sure you l noticed, like the way people talked, is totally He's saying that to you because you have more of a New York acting than I do. You're right. You might be right. You might be right. Trevor Burrus, Jr. Just slightly inflected. Anyway, Ken McPhee was the trying to govern over these cops who are getting laid off and hold it together, and the guys who are on the bridge are basically going wildcat on him, and he can't control them, and that doesn't look good for anybody.

SPEAKER_00Same happened with the with the um garbageman strike, sanitation strike. And striking for a city union was illegal in any case. So that was not even so these were actions. They were protests, they weren't even called strikes.

SPEAKER_02So many of the players you feature in the film passed away in recent years. Um Mayor David Dinkins and uh Congressman Charlie Wrangle, we were lucky enough to have both of them on the podcast actually for extended interviews a couple hours before before they did. Uh Gabe Pressman, the newscaster, has got this great story about how all the uh TV guys and the cameramen were carrying guns around at the time. MTA chairman Dick Ravich, City Controller Harrison Golden, PR Powerhouse, Koch Advisor Howard Rubinstein, and lots of others.

SPEAKER_02So do you just want to talk a bit about when you started shooting them and uh some some sense that you were on a clock to uh get some of this history down?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh we didn't even really know what we were going to ask them, and which is terrible uh uh business model for documentary filmmakers, and you you kind of want to go in with a bit of an idea and a script, and we didn't. And so we but what we came out with almost immediately were not just a kaleidoscope of stories and angles and points of view, but also these amazing characters. Even the talking heads to us are just like have a certain charm that you don't you're you're not seeing people like that, unvarnished, really candid with us.

SPEAKER_00Um and uh Yeah, and then we were really lucky to get them before they many of them pass away. And I'm really glad we did.

SPEAKER_04Let me ask a quick follow-up to that. So I I don't know much about documentary filmmaking, but you know, there's this kind of a standard interview format, and it seems like you've got what the person's saying and sort of how charismatic they are. How you cut it, you don't know when you're sitting down to interview them, you know, how what what you're gonna be using to break it up and to illustrate it. But then you also have the setting. And one of the things I loved was they're each filmed in a in a slightly different environment. They're very, it's very desk heavy. These are guys of a certain age.

SPEAKER_04If they were alive, they'd be, I guess, in their 90s now, some of them. And um like how do you, when you come in and you meet the subject and you probably don't have a lot of time to set up, like how do you decide where you're gonna pose them? Because you want them to be comfortable, but you also want variety. Like, how does that work?

SPEAKER_03Well, I think, and this is something that Michael pushed hard for, and I think rightly so. Um, and then once we got going, it became really fun to do. I mean, uh one cliche of documentary filmmaking is um, you know, kind of go with what's there because you know the old truth is stranger than fiction notion. You know, sometimes when you're trying to force things anyway, it can you can be making problems and in the whole thing can end up feeling false. And so on that simple adage here is like we came in and if it was a cluttered apartment of an elderly person but with great spirit that felt like New York and even gave you glimpses of of maybe furniture that was a few decades out of style, as it were.

SPEAKER_03We wanted to kind of embrace that, not in a mocking way at all, but in the kind of a celebratory, like we're getting a glimpse of you know, this apartment, this apartment, this lifestyle, this lifestyle, and that cumulatively, again, it would add up to something, we hope. And so I think that worked. Um and we really, I think er there's a style just in documentary now, especially if you look at streamers, you know, the average Netflix thing, you know, they're kind of very glossy, um, and they'll even rent spaces and there'll be incredible depth of field and fancy multi-camera shots, and you know, they'll take, you know, one sees this all the time.

SPEAKER_03And it consciously or unconsciously just feels canned. And we wanted, because it was the nature of the story, I think, as Michael said, the people were really authentic. They were being as honest. I mean, everyone's always spinning everyone, but I think there was a truth that underlay what people were conveying, and we wanted the visuals to kind of reflect that as well.

SPEAKER_04So the 70s was different from today for so many reasons. And I think one of the things that struck me about this film is there were all of these both powerful and smart New Yorkers like your father who rolled up their sleeves to save the city. Dick Ravich, Felix, Ira Milstein, and Jackie O'Nassis, who's not in the film, but it turns out 1975 was also the year that she saved Grand Central Terminal. So you had people who had like influence, but they were part of civic life.

SPEAKER_04Labor leaders like Victor Gottbaum of DC 37, who I didn't know was a friend of your father until today. Um why were there so many personally wealthy and you know powerful New Yorkers in the 70s who really cared deeply about the fate of the city? And did you find any common thread? I mean, one that I saw was that they're all born around the Depression.

SPEAKER_00You know, that's a great question. And I don't know that I can really give you a great answer. Uh to some degree, the people that were here were the people that remained. Uh a lot of people did move out to the suburbs. A lot of the powerful people were living in Greenwich and in wherever. So uh if you were a person of power, you might very well be a union leader, because those are the guys that were still here. I'll say one little story.

SPEAKER_04But you but you mean still here in 1975? Trevor Burrus, Jr. That's what I mean. Like people had left.

SPEAKER_00So the people that remained were kind of a smaller group. In fact, the city was just emptier anyway. So the city was dangerous. And I I told Peter and Jerry and Jerry that we would go to all of these people in every interview, because I'm so nostalgic for this time. I was 12 years old. I ran around everywhere, it was dangerous, I got beat up and mugged and everything. Um I told Peter and because you know, you go to these interviews and you want a little bit of a framing device that we're gonna do the same question with everybody, and then we're gonna have something that we can work with through the film.

SPEAKER_00I said, we're gonna ask them all, what's the worst thing that happened to you in 1975? They're all gonna say, I got mugged, my car, my whatever, and we're gonna immediately we're gonna hit them with, but if you could go back there today, would you do it? And they're all gonna say yes, and nobody said yes. Because if you had anything to lose in 1975, you did not, you were not having fun. If you were if you had a job, if you had a pension, if you were in charge of a person with a job and a pension, if you were like stuck holding the bag, those were very stressful times. So everybody loved the memory of it as a glorious like war time kind of in the foxhole.

SPEAKER_00But if you had no responsibilities, if you're a kid, if you're an artist, if you're, you know, if you or if you're somebody who's trying to do something new and and where affordability, there was nobody here. And the city was weirdly, to me, a safer place than it is now. It's so congested, it's so crowded. I worry for my kids from the point of view of just getting caught up in it at every intersection. It's just mobs of people. And in those days it was way I mean, I I don't it wasn't tumbleweeds, but it was really much quieter.

SPEAKER_00And so all to say that if you were a person of like that you were going to become a person that was gonna be kind of like part of the civic story.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, you could say macher.

SPEAKER_00If you were a maher, uh you there were fewer of them, and you found each other. That's kind of my feeling. Like a lot of these guys, Aaron Milstein, they were just counselors. Howard Rubenstein, he was just he wasn't on the payroll. He was just a friend of the mayor.

SPEAKER_04And this mayor He wasn't making$260,000.

SPEAKER_00I you know, I could very well be wrong. He might have been getting a little something, but I doubt it. I I I honestly don't think so.

SPEAKER_02So just real quick, even going back to the uh late 80s, early 90s, I I felt this in the film and looking at 75, I did have this sense coming up like New York was ours.

SPEAKER_00Yes, totally.

SPEAKER_02There was a sense to that and uh how busy it was, and then you know what it was like late in the summer when all the all the rich people left and no one knew was coming. And you know, I'm looking at the crowds on Bleaker Street last night. Like, who are all these people? Right. It's too crowded here. Totally. Trevor Burrus, Jr.

SPEAKER_03Well, there's there's so much more tourism, obviously, now. So it's uh you know, it's it's the front and the back of being a quote unquote global city now. I mean, obviously it was a big city, it was a central city then, but it was a local city, as Michael said before. Aaron Ross Powell, Jr.

SPEAKER_02Well that was the question I was leading to there is exactly that. So if you have this class of people who did remain, who were really invested in the place and had some of its character and felt responsible for it and part of that fabric, is there any parallel class in New York City now, do you two think? I know this is outside the frame of the film. That's interesting.

SPEAKER_03I wonder, I mean, I what do I know? I mean, as Michael said, you know, p if you have the means, then you have a house here and and Vale and there, and you just kind of jet off to wherever. I think in the middle class, I think it's a very exciting moment. I mean, we'll see which way this goes. But you know, I think will there be a groundswell? We saw it in the election, though, how this will or won't translate is an open question. But the people who want to become engaged in a common civic project, in a shared kind of collective notion, at the heart of this film, uh to my mind, is the question of what does a government owe society or what or its people, right?

SPEAKER_03And it's sort of an film about ideologies, essentially. I mean, all these other things and the specifics are very true, and New York is New York, and hopefully it's colorful and entertaining, but really it's an excuse to engage this question of kind of we're at this moment, 1975, and again we're revisiting it arguably today, when these big ideological questions are coming to the forefront.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Ross Powell Can I I just want to add because I I can't help myself ever the I think the other you were saying earlier, is it because they were all born in the depression? I think public service has been so degraded these days, like by House of Cards, popular entertainment. Nowadays, if you want to be a public person and you're a private individual, you can be Mark Cuban and you own a basketball team and you're on the Shark Tank, or you're Donald Trump and you're a billionaire and then you become the president.

SPEAKER_00You're a reality star. You can find an a way in front of the lens and to be to feel relevant. In those days, I think there was a nobility to public service and there was also an appeal. It was there was some glamour to it, as I'm gonna actually step forward. This is gonna make my family proud. This is gonna make my community proud. This is this is exciting. And I'm I'm always reminded of the example of the English in the 1920s after World War I, this was the age of polar exploration.

SPEAKER_00There were no wars. So if you wanted to do something that showed valor and courage, you were you became a polar explorer. You had to find a place to stand out. And I think being a civic leader or being a counselor, and I'm gonna really help, was a little bit like that to that generation. And this generation, I don't think anyone is encouraged to go into public service as a Frank Capra, like that's where you can make a difference. Trevor Burrus, Jr.

SPEAKER_04Well, Zoran Mamdani's portal transitioned 2025, got 25,000 resume submissions. That was minimum.

SPEAKER_02They're up to 50 now. Oh, is it up to 50? Yeah. Amazing.

SPEAKER_04So we may have an influx, and I imagine a lot of those people are in their 20s and 30s. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And I actually think even among some older uh folks I know who were reluctant to vote for him, um, I think there's a really good case to be made that the in the wake, whatever he can or can't accomplish in this term, um, I think the inspiration that he might provide and the people who might get off the sidelines, like people who are in their 20s or 30s who otherwise might do something else, but might be drawn to do these this kind of civic work, I think could be huge.

SPEAKER_03And who knows, you know, the next generation as well is coming up and being inspired by him. So I think that's really significant.

SPEAKER_00We did it. We did a screening for the Office of Management and Budget. If you can imagine anything more fun than that for this movie, and it really was totally fun. And there were a lot of young people in that organization even now. I think there are actually a lot of young people in government. But it's fabulous that there are now going to be that many more who are drawn to it.

SPEAKER_04And you know, so I want to close with there was an incredible quote from your dad at the end of the movie. He says New York is still an enormous part of this country, and ultimately the federal government has to realize that you cannot have an industrially advanced culture without having thriving urban centers. I was so struck by the way that he phrased this, right? These two ideas, industrially advanced culture and thriving urban centers. It was it struck me as very sophisticated.

SPEAKER_04He he understood something about the importance of cities just as cities. And now, of course, we're seeing a lot of polarization between suburbs and cities, you know, red states and blue states, our our system of representation kind of punishes cities in a certain way. And so I what do you think he was getting at when he said that? What was he talking about?

SPEAKER_00I just think that's my father right there. I love that it's the last thing he says. It's elegant, it's very thoughtful, it's a little bit abstract. You know, I was telling you that I had asked him for that, like, what does New York mean to you? as give us give me that line, give me that last line. The reporter asks him that question, and he delivered it. So I see it in a lot of ways. I see it as like incredible generosity to the reporter. I'm gonna give you a really good statement right here.

SPEAKER_00And I think it's it is the ultimate thoughtful expression of the problem. It's like you have to have these cities, they're messy, they're complicated, they're built on conflict, they're disputatious whatever, and you need to have them work well. And we are now living in this unbelievable polarized, like demonizing of cities. I have to say that our I feel like one of the hidden surprises in our film was to find Donald Rumseld and Dick Cheney there at in the Ford White House, driving policy toward the red states in the middle against the coastal elite states and demonizing and sort of like vilifying the edges for the benefit of the flyover states, so-called flyover states.

SPEAKER_00They drove out Nelson Rockefeller, who was Ford's vice president, who was the genial head of the New York Republican establishment, and they turned to Bob Dole, who was the no nonsense guy from Kansas. So the whole kind of didn't start in 1975, but I feel like the kind of formalizing of the strategy really, you can say, began with Ford saying, we need to we're gonna turn on New York. This is valuable to us, this political theater, and we're going to we're gonna earn our presidency from the Middle States.

SPEAKER_00Closing question, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Getting bailed out, and we haven't really touched on, and the film goes over clearly and it's great as explainer, but I think very briefly, the reasons the city so urgently needed to get bailed out, right? And and the controller, Golden, says, wait a minute, I've I've I've just started looking at the books in a basic way, and these numbers aren't matching up and all that, but this follows a decade of massively increased spending.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Right? And then suddenly the the the someone looks and uh the the money's short and there's this panic. The city does get bailed out, and does this in some sense and saved, change New York City from one that had been accountable to New Yorkers to one that was accountable to its lenders? I'm thinking about uh Bloomberg's luxury city and the sort of response to what we're having now.

SPEAKER_00Trevor Burrus, Jr. Yeah, yeah. Well, I I think that's the great question. And I hope that our film we really wanted to be agnostic about why. Arguably, there I I we feel like there were six really terrible things that happened all at once, and if you could take any one of them out of the equation, maybe this wouldn't have happened. I'm going to rattle them off to you and you can speed me up. The high interest rates, the high cost of labor, good union contracts, terrible accounting in City Hall, cynicism in the White House, white flight, and immigration of needy people coming into the city.

SPEAKER_00If any one of those things had not happened, Happened or I think you would might have had a different story. Terrible for the liberal society and the liberals among us, that the legacy is, oh, it's because New York spent too much. Well, if New York had spent too much, but the management had been better at spending, if the banks had done a better job, oh, I think I left the banks off. I think I have seven. Anyway, if the banks had done better due diligence at looking at the underlying risk, but the unions arguably had done really what you're supposed to do.

SPEAKER_00You play your best hand, you bring your best team to the field, and you get your best contract. The banks did not do what you're supposed to do. I mean, they made money, they did what they did for themselves, but they did not play their role and execute. And it is a kind of a generational story between Harrison Golden and A-Beam. One of the great things about this movie, and I'm really pleased about, we haven't talked about this, Peter, or in a while, whatever. We've talked about everything, Lord knows. But there's no corruption that we found.

SPEAKER_00It wasn't like A. Beam went into retirement in a big giant mansion somewhere. It wasn't that. I'm sure people, you know, there was some scandal. But it was generational, it was a dignified older man coming into a job that he was not, he just it had outgrown him. And a younger man who's a technocrat, the early version of the guy with the computer. And there was a clash of people between them.

SPEAKER_00Nobody had ever challenged the mayor publicly, which by the way is why the banks were like, what is going on here? We'll come back when you guys have this figured out. Aaron Ross Powell And the mayor had just been the controller. Aaron Ross Powell And the mayor had just been the controller. So and in fact, when we're looking for our movie and like what's our line and what's our story, we found that A-Beam was our story. And I've I've talked to many of the people in the movie since. And there a few times I've heard, like, why did you go with A-Beam? I mean, this is not a guy who was uh but A-Beam is the guy that you feel for.

SPEAKER_00He comes in, it's the biggest day of his life. I'm the mayor. And immediately all of the stuff that he hadn't done right or he should have known, and he's holding the bag, and now it's being taken away from him and the downward spiral. And you can see it on his face. He actually you totally I relate to him.

SPEAKER_03We worked on the film for so many years, and it's gratifying to see that just as we're releasing it now, it arguably couldn't be more relevant. I mean, this is fifty years essentially to the week when this all went down, and with the shift that's happening in New York City, I think a lot of the ideas that are at the heart of this movie are surfacing again daily in the newspapers. And we're literally going to be seeing how we choose to move forward as a city over the coming weeks and months.

SPEAKER_03So I genuinely think that this film we've we've Schumer has come, the present mayor has come, uh Lander has seen it. You know, like we've shown it to lots of people at City Hall. We want the new mayor. I think we'll be seeing it shortly, we think, we hope. Um, and we hope that it actually will inform the way that people are making decisions going forward, because we've wrestled with a lot of these questions before in pretty dramatic ways.

SPEAKER_02FAAQ. Lid NYC is part of the FAQ NYC podcast network that's made possible in part by support from the Charles H. Refson Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, from PNT Network, an independent bookstore, cafe, and event space on Manhattan's Lurry side with the podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use. The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of the podcast, which is headquartered at the city, a nonprofit newsroom, delivering hard-hitting investigative journals and the service to people in New York. This episode was engineered by Noah Smith, who was hosted by Amy Sohn, who also produced this episode, and co-hosted by me, Harry Siegel.

SPEAKER_02I'm also the FAQ NYC Podcast Network's executive producer. A special thank you to our guests, Drop Dead City Filmmakers, Michael Roden and Peter Yost. The film is now screaming on Apple TV and Amazon Prime. And thank you, listener, for making it this far. We'll be back soon with more. Good day, goodbye.

unknownCool.

SPEAKER_03Awesome. Still in awe of that read at the end.

SPEAKER_04How'd you do that?

SPEAKER_03Do you not normally do it that fast? I usually do actually do it slow.

SPEAKER_02I was just still doing you going into your meeting? No, I missed the meeting already.

SPEAKER_00Oh no.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. From the Club to the Flophouse in Wang´s World

    Nov 13, 202628 minAudio

    As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Life, Death and the World in the Confines of One Subway Car

    Nov 9, 202659 minAudio

    Harry Siegel and Nicole Gelinas talk with Anand Giridharadas, the

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Joel Feingold’s Gotham

    Aug 21, 202649 minAudio

    Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Sam Roberts´ Art of the Obit

    Aug 14, 202633 minAudio

    New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. R Sikoryak´s Declaration/Emancipation Illustrated

    Jul 17, 202643 minAudio

    For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...

    Credit the people on this episode