"It’s a tour for people who like the nitty gritty of why we had so much sewage, why corruption led to the garbage being a problem for so long, what our policies were that caused this rat issue. It's an urban policy and urban planning tour with rats and some sex facts, including rat sex." Suzanne Reisman, author of Off the Beaten (Subway) Track, New York City's Best Unusual Attractions, joins host Amy Sohn to discuss her Garbage and Rats in New York walking tour, visiting an art star’s troll museum, and much more, including Eric Adams’ rat-eradication legacy.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02It's Lit NYC, the New Yorkist show about the ABCs of arts, books, culture, and rats. I'm your host, Amy Sohn. My guest today is Suzanne Reisman, a tour guide with the off-the-beaten subway track walking tours. She specializes in unique, unusual tours of New York City, including one called Sewage, Sex, and Sickness in the Five Points. Suzanne is an NYC licensed tour guide and is also a graduate of the New York City Rat Academy, the New York City Sanitation Foundation Trash Academy, and a member of the NYC Rat Pack, known as New York's Elite Squad of Dedicated Anti-Rat Activists.
SPEAKER_02I think it'd be better if it was anti-rattivists, but okay. She is also the author of Off the Beaten Subway Track, New York City's best unusual attractions. One of her tours is called Garbage and Rats in NYC, and that's a walking tour of Lower Manhattan covering 400 years of sanitation history. Suzanne, welcome to Lit NYC. Thank you so much for having me. So I learned about you from an item in the New York Times Metropolitan Diary, a column I occasionally enjoy.
SPEAKER_02You wear a headband with fuzzy rat ears on your rat tour so your group can find you easily. On a Sunday afternoon at the corner of Wall and Pearl Streets, you were telling your group about the city's first official garbage dumps, which I'm going to ask you about, when an older woman in a fur coat passing by interrupted you. Excuse me, she asked, but can you help me? I forgot where I parked my car. The woman, if she noticed your rat ears, had no visible reaction, nor did she have a vision uh any visible reaction to the fact that you were a tour guide in the middle of giving a tour to a group of tourists.
SPEAKER_02You said you could try to help her find her car. She said it's near a square that has black statues and a French cafe nearby. You thought for a moment and said, walk up Wall Street to William Street, then turn right. The French cafe is either on Liberty or Maiden Lane. You'll find your car around there. The woman thanked you and left, and you went on talking about garbage in New Amsterdam in 1657.
SPEAKER_01That's crazy. It is definitely the weirdest, one of the weirdest experiences I've had as a tour guide on the garbage and rats in New York City history walking tour. I mean, she really truly had no reaction to the fact that I'm wearing rat ears. I'm talking to a group of people about garbage. And when she said, Can you help me find my car? My first thought was, No, I'm not a psychic. And then I surprised myself because, in all honesty, if you're not going to remember where you parked your car, your best bet is to find a licensed tour guide and give them a couple of landmarks, and they are pretty likely to figure it out.
SPEAKER_02So Yeah, she was she was approaching you the way you might approach an officer. You were officious and official looking in just in kind of a different garb. You were basically in like a rat uniform instead of a cop uniform.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it is a little bit shocking how often people come and ask me for directions while I'm wearing my rat ears and carrying a tote bag with a little stuffed rat hanging off of it. No one ever comments on why are you dressed weird or whatever. They just kind of were like, Do you know where the stock exchange is? Yeah, I know where the stock exchange is. Continue up Wall Street, make a left on broad, you'll find it. And they're like, Oh, okay, thank you.
SPEAKER_02Are you a New York City native?
SPEAKER_01I grew up in the Chicago area and I've been in New York for about 32 years. So much longer here than I was in the suburbs of Chicago.
SPEAKER_02Did you ever take that? Um, it's sort of like a flow chart to like figure out whether you're a true New Yorker and you got a certain number of points if you were here on 9-11. I was here on 9-11. Um, certain number of points if you stayed throughout COVID the entire time. Stayed throughout the entire COVID time. And then I think you get a bonus for 10 years. Uh 32. This is good. Okay. I think you might be, it's a total of 10 points. I'm gonna ask you a little bit about being um a tour guide. What led you to this path, this interesting and kind of unappreciated career path?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I wrote my book, as you mentioned, off the Beaten Subway Track. It came out in 2008. And I will just say it is very out of date. So what breaks my heart about New York is the only constant here is really change. And so many of those wonderful places have closed over the last, my God, almost 20 years. But it's still a lot of fun. And I had a lot of fun researching it, going to all the different sites, writing about it. So one day I just kind of like mosied on into what was then it used to be the Department of Consumer Affairs.
SPEAKER_01This was 2009. And I just, you could go in and take the test. I did not understand normal people study for it, but I just walked in, I took it, I passed. I happened to have just written a book about New York, which was incredibly beneficial. And the woman told me at the testing center that she said, Oh, you were so close to getting a special star. You only needed to answer three questions more correctly. Being the perfectionist I am, I'm like, Well, can I take the test again? She was like, No.
SPEAKER_01She's like, people don't ever pass on their first try. You should just be grateful for how well you did. So I did get my license back then and I did a couple of tours on and off, but really I've been working in nonprofit social service administration since the 90s, late 90s. And it was hard. It's like where my heart really was. My passion was helping New Yorkers in all communities around the city. But in recent times, you know, it's just really hard times. And I thought, well, if I'm gonna survive in these crazy times, I need to do something more fun.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, why don't I always love walking tours on weird topics when I'm somewhere? Why don't I think about doing some fun tours? And my brain went somehow immediately to the book Rats by Robert Sulvan. Who's been a guest on this show? He is kind of my hero, I'm not gonna lie. Uh, I read the book when it first came out. At the time I read it and I thought, God, you know, rats so disproportionately impact lower income communities.
SPEAKER_01And it, how could I work on this topic somehow? And then fast forward like 2025, I was like, I think there's a tour in this book. And I reread it and immediately as I was going through, I'm like, I see the route. I know this is an outline, and I know I need to do more to get the facts. It can't just be about rats because the garbage is what brings the rats. If we don't have the garbage, we won't have the rats. So you can't give a good tour without understanding that the garbage is really the root of our rat problem.
SPEAKER_01And our garbage problem is a problem going back 400 years.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's that's yeah, it's it's an interconnected ecosystem. Isn't there an organization that's like the kosher, like the awesome tour guide licensing group?
SPEAKER_01So you get your license from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. Once you're licensed, you can become a member of the Guides Association of New York City, which is an amazing group of tour guides, super um interested in promoting quality, ensuring that guides are educated, supporting other guides, and making sure it is a tough way to make a living in a lot of the way the world has changed. You know, we don't a lot of guides used to make a living on those buses doing the bus tours, and they have been replaced with recorded audio.
SPEAKER_01The website is g-anyc.org, and they have a thing called hire a guide. So you can type in, like, I'm on a tour of Harlem, and it'll show you all the guides who do that. You can read their description, reach out to them. So going back to your book, what was that book about? Yeah, it was about a hundred places that I thought were kind of unusual, like off-the-beaten track. And I had been really into the idea that other Americans outside of New York would just hop in their car and take a little road trip places, see some weird stuff, like you know, the giant shoe in Pennsylvania or the big TP in upstate New York.
SPEAKER_01And I was like, I bet we have stuff like that in the city, and you could do like a subway road trip and could you give me an example of some weird thing that was in that book?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's that's no longer here. No longer here. This breaks my heart, but the troll museum was by far one of my favorite places in all of New York City.
SPEAKER_02Was that Jen?
SPEAKER_01Reverend Jen, yes.
SPEAKER_02It was I used to perform at a at a performance space with her. Wait, really? Yeah, she wore those troll ears. Yes, I used to go all the time also. I used to perform at Surf Reality. I don't know if you ever. I used to go back there too. I totally used to go.
SPEAKER_01Did you know the Elvis, the fake the Elvis guy who did he do open mics? He did, and he would once in a while get into a snit and once he threw a folding chair at someone. Ooh. Yeah, her art star stuff was amazing.
SPEAKER_02You know, at a certain point, you don't remember if you experienced something or if you heard other people talk about it.
SPEAKER_01So the Troll Museum was in Reverend Jen. She's an artist, uh painter, performance artist, actress, movie maker. She's on, I think, the sixth-floor walk-up of a building on the Lower East Side. Her apartment was pretty tiny, and most of it was dedicated to troll dolls that she had designed costumes for. She had backstories for all of them. You made an appointment. She always told you not to show up anytime because she could be having sex, uh, and you didn't want to interrupt that.
SPEAKER_01So you make an appointment, go upstairs, and she tells you all about the trolls. She had a dog, Reverend Jen Jr., who is a living troll, she said. It was really, really amazing.
SPEAKER_02Tell me one thing in that book that does still exist.
SPEAKER_01On 23rd and 6th Avenue, we still have the New York City Masons headquarters. And that whole building is comprised of dozens of lodges, all designed in some kind of theme rooms. There's also a Masonic museum up at the top. Uh it's totally fascinating. You know, Masons, very mysterious. It's kind of cool to walk through their spaces and see all the symbols and all the interesting things.
SPEAKER_01So people can still buy your book, right? You can. Okay. I'm not gonna discourage it. Okay, but I will say don't expect a lot of the places to be open. Well, that's I mean, okay. It's a fun book to read.
SPEAKER_02New York, New York, like you said, New York is is always changing. And and I think it was Colson Whitehead, the novelist, who wrote the the totally paraphrasing that the mark of a true New Yorker is being able to say what used to be in places. Who comes on your tours? What's the breakdown of American, non-American, and how has the makeup of people on your tours changed? Oh, perhaps since we got this current president.
SPEAKER_01Uh it's actually very ironic. So I started doing them in about, I think in April 2025, May 2025. And it was a lot of New Yorkers and a lot of Americans. Like I'm always surprised by the number of people from Texas and Utah, which strikes me as a funny demographic. Ohio, I get a lot of people from Ohio, Florida, and of course California, because that makes sense given they're so big. Uh last year I had very, it was like 85% Americans, and I'd say of that, over 50% were New Yorkers.
SPEAKER_01Really, it's kind of, I mean, to be honest, it's a tour for geeks. It's a tour for people who want to know. Yeah, you're not going to be able to do that.
SPEAKER_02You're talking about the rat one specifically?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the garbage and rats.
SPEAKER_02It seems like the five points one might be a little sexier. I'm assuming some of the things that's a lot of people.
SPEAKER_01It's still a tour for geeks. Uh it's still a tour for people who like the nitty-gritty of like why, you know, we had so much sewage, why corruption led to the garbage being a problem for so long. Um, what our policies were that caused this rat issue. It's a it's an urban policy, an urban planning tour.
SPEAKER_02Have you seen a fall off in international tourists in the last couple of years?
SPEAKER_01So I expected to, especially given how small my numbers were. But I actually have had more international tourists this year, which makes almost no sense to me, given the numbers being down thanks to this delightful administration. It's terrible policies. Uh, but no, I actually have had more foreign tourists. My fellow tour guides say significant decreases in tourists from Europe, from Canada. And in my case, I've had almost double the amount.
SPEAKER_01But I think it's because it's people who are just coming no matter what, and they're kind of just unusual people and really into weirder stuff, and the people who really want to come for, you know, your typical things like Statue of Liberty, Empire State Building, which no, great. I'm super excited people want to do that. I think they're more scared off. I think it's the people who are kind of like, well, I'm used to weird stuff and dealing with problems who are interested here.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so you're saying the uh international geeks um quotient quotient is up. Do you get a lot of questions about Mayor Mam Dani? It seems that people internationally are interested in him.
SPEAKER_01I get a fair number of questions. I got actually a lot of questions. Weirdly, I got more questions, I think, about Eric Adams than I got about Mom Donnie. Um, but I do get questions about Mam Donnie. I mean, people are genuinely curious. Like, he has all this vibe and like sort of a person of the zeitgeist, and so they kind of want to know what what we think, what he's doing. Um so yeah, people do want to know. Do you stop at City Hall? We end at City Hall, actually.
SPEAKER_01That's the end point of the Garbage and Rats tour. And do you make a living giving tours? Well, I wouldn't call it a living. Uh it's uh what I do, it's my I'm also a writer. I've been working on a novel actually about a tour guide who stumbles in it's a cozy mystery about a tour guide who stumbles in onto a body during her tour, and then she has to solve the crime. Um, so I'm working on that, but I'm also I do the tours, uh, and I am uh believably fortunate enough to be married to someone who is supportive and can cover our bills, and I have his health insurance.
SPEAKER_01Otherwise, I I really couldn't do this.
SPEAKER_02You were talking a little bit about um the history of sanitation and corruption. I know you can't give your full tour. We should say that we are recording very close to where you give your tour, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes, I start basically up the street, up Pearl, you're right off Pearl Street, basically. I start right up the street on the corner of Pearl and Wall Street. And the reason I start there is that is where our city's sanitation, first sanitation policies actually took place. In 1657, the Dutch West India Company basically got sick and tired of how filthy and foul the city was with people throwing all their waste pretty much wherever, including in the canals.
SPEAKER_01And they said that there's going to be five official garbage dumps starting from 1657, and you needed to use them. Pearl Street at that time was the waterfront. The East River came up to Pearl. And so the garbage would accumulate in these piles. And as the river was flowing out, you know, we'd push the garbage in. Miraculously, it would float away. We'd say goodbye in Dutch, which I keep meaning to look up how to say and forgetting to do that. Goodbye, garbage. But unfortunately, it wasn't miraculous. Some of that garbage sank and silt built over it, and we start landfilling.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and actually, 33% of Lower Manhattan is landfill that starts out as garbage that we've been dumping for 350 or so years.
SPEAKER_02Have you ever seen that really cool photo of Battery Park City in like the 70s and the people sunbathing? Talk a little bit about how corruption had to do with sanitation, and then from there, get me into the rats.
SPEAKER_01So as the city did not continue to deal with garbage, so the, you know, the Dutch are here till 1664, the English come, they bring a little more people, they bring some more animals, they bring a little more industry, they don't bring more sanitation practices. Then we have early America, New York, not really doing very much to clean up. Our population is growing and growing and growing. And by 1850, we have 500,000 people living in New York, moving up to the Lower East Side, five points higher up on the west side.
SPEAKER_01And it's in 1853, our little medical community estimates two-thirds of the people who died that year died from diseases that would have been prevented if we had better sanitary conditions in the streets and in the city. And they basically beg the city to do something. The problem is it's run by Tammany Hall. So a corrupt political machine uh that is not particularly interested in doing things just for the sake of good. And they don't really see a way to profit from that.
SPEAKER_01So they don't do anything for another, let's say 15 or 20 years when they do realize, okay, like this is beyond the pale. Uh, let's figure something out. I know we will have these contracts, and we will have people who have a horse and a cart get this lucrative contract. We'll tell them to go around, pick up the trash, uh, they'll take it straight to the river, dump it off the side of a pier or a wharf, right into the river. And the thing is, for them to get this contract, they're gonna give us a bribe or a kickback.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and we don't particularly care what they do. The truth is, if they do the barest minimum and then kick off to the pub, as long as they meet me, the politician there and buy me a drink, I'm totally cool with it. And that just continues through pretty much most of our history. The turning point comes in 1894 when a reform candidate, William Strong, wins as the mayor. And he does believe corruption has made the city filthy literally and metaphorically.
SPEAKER_01And when he takes office in 1895, he does hire people who have qualifications in sanitation and who care. And that is the first time since the Dutch arrive that we truly clean the city up. So and how do rats figure in all this? So the Dutch bring over a rat when they come. It's the black rat. We don't have that rat anymore. That rat is a climber. Its instinct is to go up to trees, attics, roofs. It's also known as a roof rat.
SPEAKER_02Uh can I just say I'm loving your Chicago accent right now? Every time you.
SPEAKER_01I don't even hear it. Anyway, yes, so these rats, also known as the roof rat, um, not in New York anymore, because the brown rat comes with the Hessian mercenaries hired by the British to fight the war on their behalf during the Revolutionary War. They bring the brown rat. The brown rat outcompetes the black rat. But if you really think about where the black rat's habitat is, trees, attics, roofs, we're not that rat did not have a long time to make it in New York. We were gonna get, you know, kind of out develop it anyway.
SPEAKER_01Uh, but the brown rat comes during the Revolutionary War. Uh, it's a war. Streets are filthy. Brown rats' natural instinct is to burrow, to go down into the ground. They really love our parks, our tree beds, all of that. And during the Revolutionary War, you know, we've dug trenches to fight the war. And that to rats is basically like a luxury condo. So they're super excited. They move right in, there's all the food they could possibly want with all this filth lying around. They write letters to all their friends at home.
SPEAKER_01Hey guys, this is like totally the promised land. Come on over. And as New York grows, and it is growing from the 1800s on, all these ships are coming in, bringing these brown rats. Um, brown rats, again, only rat you'll see here in New York, also known as the Norway rat, Norwegian rat, sewer rat, street rat, subway rat, pizza rat, wharf rat, water rat, whatever. Whatever rat you see in New York, it's a brown rat.
SPEAKER_02You are a member of the NYC Rat Pack. What is that?
SPEAKER_01Yes. So the NYC Rat Pack was started by our last administration. Like ironic, so ironically, anti-rat, uh, given their own corruption.
SPEAKER_02You know, I used to work for Mayor Adams.
SPEAKER_01I did not. Fascinating administration, I will just say that. I actually think the work Adams did on rats and trash was the best work Adams did on most, and they did a lot of good stuff on housing and things like that as well. But the rat focused. It really was his legacy. It was one of his legacy. Well, it's hilarious given that his brownstone had a rat infestation problem that took multiple rounds to clean up. But the I think the Rat Czar was a good idea.
SPEAKER_01I know she was kind of controversial, but rat mitigation in the city is complex. We have multiple city agencies with different roles. We have the Department of Health, we have the Department of Sanitation, we have NYCHA, we have the Department of Education, we have the Parks Department.
SPEAKER_02I'm now remembering, I had just started working for the for the Adams administration when I saw the listing, the job listing for the Ratzar. And I it was written by former Deputy Mayor for Operations, Mira Zoshi and one of her staffers. And I'm just gonna read a little bit because it is one of the best job descriptions ever written. Do you have what it takes to do the impossible? A virulent vehemence for vermin, a background in urban planning, project management, or government, and most importantly, the drive, determination, and killer instinct needed to fight the real enemy, New York City's relentless rat population.
SPEAKER_02They were having a lot of fun with alliteration here. If so, your dream job awaits. The ideal candidate is highly motivated and somewhat bloodthirsty, determined to look at all solutions from various angles, including improving operational efficiency, data collection, technology innovation, trash management, and wholesale slaughter. Despite their successful public engagement strategy and cheeky social media presence, we know that's a reference to pizza rat, right? Yeah. Rats are not our friends. They are enemies that must be vanquished by the combined forces of our city government.
SPEAKER_02Rodents spread disease, damage homes and wiring, and even attempt to control the movements of kitchen staffers in an effort to take over human jobs. Crazy. This is 2022, like kind of forecasting AI. Cunning, voracious, and prolific. New York City's rats are legendary for their survival skills, but they don't run this city. Suzanne, can you finish it?
SPEAKER_01We run the city. New Yorkers.
SPEAKER_02New Yorkers. Okay, we'll do it again. It's it's we do. Okay. Oh, yeah. All right. But they don't run the city, Suzanne.
SPEAKER_01We do.
SPEAKER_02You got it.
SPEAKER_01So what is the rat pack that you were a part of? So the rat pack, it was a, I think it was a great idea, and it's still going on. So it basically you took the Rat Academy. That is an online or in-person course offered basically five times a month by the New York City Department of Health and mental hygiene. It's about two hours long, goes through everything about rats, their habitats, their biology, their sort of motivations, honestly. And then what we as citizens can do on our end to help with this quite intractable problem.
SPEAKER_01Um, after you take that course, you do a rat walk and you kind of put into practice what you learned in the course. So looking for rat burrows, thinking about what you would do to deal with that situation. Um and then the final component is doing a public service project. I was super fortunate and able to do a rat mitigation project in the park outside of Yankee Stadium, which I always mispronounce, but I think it's McComb's Dams uh park.
SPEAKER_02I'm a Brooklyn girl. I don't know. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Uh and what was going on was the vendors at Yankee Stadium did not want to pay for sanitation to pick up the leftovers, and they were sneaking out after games late at night and dumping all their leftover food in this park that children had baseball diamonds and all this, and these poor kids are trying to play in this god-awful rat-infested park. So we did mitigation. We looked for the burrows. Um, we worked with the park staff, with the uh pest control people, and we're um putting dry ice pellets into the burrows.
SPEAKER_01Dry ice is a great solution for anybody who sees rat burrows in your neighborhood. Get some dry ice pellets from a restaurant, supply store, or even Amazon. Uh, you scoop out a bunch of the pellets, find a hole, any hole, put the dry ice in, and the smoke has carbon dioxide. So if you do that during the day, it's gonna go through the tunnel where the rats have their nest. They're less active in the day. They'll be sleeping, maybe up to 12 rats in the nest.
SPEAKER_01They will suffocate instantly, which is significantly less cruel than the poisons which are you a vegetarian? No, I'm not a vegetarian. You said that very authentically. I know, but I don't, you know, I'm sorry. The thing with the brown rats is they're really, really smart and they're really adaptable. And it sucks that we have to kill them, but because it's our fault, we have such a bad problem. If we could contain our trash, wouldn't you say containerization is another mayor Adams legacy? I'm just gonna say amazing legacy because we know in the communities where they piloted containers, rat sightings dropped 60 to 70 percent.
SPEAKER_01There's a prominent urban rodentologist, his name is Dr. Bobby Corrigan, and he always says, no food equals no rats. And that's the truth. And even composting has helped with that, which is sort of contradictory to how you would think, but pulling food scraps out of regular trash and really containing it in those bins that are harder for rats to get into because people tend to truly close the lid on the compost bins, that also blocks their access from food.
SPEAKER_02So let's talk about your tour, sewage, sex, and sickness and the five points. I I wrote a book about um New York City in the Gilded Age dealing with birth control. Oh, okay. And so I I uh overlap with your tour just the tiniest bit. Um, but there was this bartender named Gallus Mag, and she would bite off the ears of unruly um bar patrons and her teeth. With her sharpened teeth. Do you believe that? Yes. Yes, I do. And she kept them in jars behind the the bar.
SPEAKER_02What was some of the what was some of the sickness around five points?
SPEAKER_01So for sure, you got measles, uh typhus, diphtheria. That was a I mean, this is truly sad. That was a pretty big killer of children in that area. That area had a death rate for children that was almost double the city average, um, given how dirty it was. Cholera outbreaks, the cholera outbreak of I think it was 1832, 49, and 66 all started in five points. Um basically you had outhouses right next to your water pumps in these courtyards, also surrounded with filth.
SPEAKER_01Syphilis and gonorrhea also were the two most common treated ailments at New York hospital um in that area. So those were the sicknesses you would often see down there, um, unfortunately. But yeah. Is that because there was a lot of prostitution in the area? Yeah, that was from the prostitution for sure.
SPEAKER_02I did a show a couple weeks ago with uh someone who wrote a book about Ward's Island, an author named Phil Yanos. And um, it turns out that Scott Joplin um died of syphilis. And you know, it's I think in our they now call sexually transmitted diseases sexually transmitted infections. And so there's been a real change in our culture in terms of how we perceive them. Many of them are perceived as livable, and of course, so many of them are treatable, but you go back and you just realize how how how many people died of sylphulis and gonorrhea.
SPEAKER_01Like no good cures or medicines. Like you could get treated with mercury, but that left you deformed, uh, or surgery, but that left you deformed. So prostitutes were hiding for sure that they had that because once they got quote unquote treated, they were not going to be able to work. And if they couldn't work, they couldn't feed themselves or their families.
SPEAKER_02Do you have any statistics about um the number of prostitutes in New York City around the 1860s, 1870s?
SPEAKER_01It was estimated, and I think this is too high, but I think there were estimates that as many as 50% of the women um in New York in those times would work at least part-time as prostitutes. Just because you could not support yourself other ways. Like you work in the garment trade, it's a seasonal business. You know, once the coats are made for autumn, there's no work left for you. And a lot of women had to turn to prostitution, unfortunately.
SPEAKER_02And also extremely low wages for women. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Like you can make 85 cents a week in garment work or maybe 50 cents per trick at the lowest end.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there's a great book called something like tricking or treating that gets into that because the line between um paid sex and sort of a grayer version of paid sex um wasn't always clear. And so, for example, you might go um to dinner with a man and he would expect something in return because you were you were so poor.
SPEAKER_01Oh, look, the more things changed, the more they stayed the same.
SPEAKER_02I was I was just just thinking about that. Um I know in your tour there were there's an inflection point in 1897 and five points. What happened?
SPEAKER_01It basically gets raised that no longer they tear down the area known as Mulberry Bend, um, which Jacob Reese had called the foul core of New York City slums, a pig sty of humanity. Um, and that really was part of his, he was a big crusader on how awful tenement life was and how unhealthy it was and what these horrible conditions people lived in. I mean, he was also a horrible racist, but that's another story. And through his efforts when How the Other Half-Lives came out in 1890, it really shocked people to see like this filth, this sewage.
SPEAKER_01The New York legislature, I think in 1887 had passed the Small Parks Act to try to seize private land to create parks in these extraordinarily dense areas. And of course, they weren't very successful initially because the landlords had a good lobby, just like sort of today. Uh, but after how the other half lives came out, people really turned against that. And so they were able to get um all those properties seized. They tore it tons of tenements down. It's now uh Columbus Park and where all our courts are, um, at like Center Street, all of those areas um today.
SPEAKER_01So it was slum clearing. That's what basically ended some of the tenements. The buildings were in horrible condition themselves. It was quite easy for the rodents to get in. You had outhouses that basically had no roofs or had a lot of holes in the floor, and vermin were living in those areas as well. So it the garbage, again, the density of the people, the lack of garbage collection. Five Points was known as having the most filthy streets in New York City. I think it was in the 1860s, and it wasn't connected to the sewer system until much, much later than other parts of the city as well.
SPEAKER_01And you would think this would also be inexpensive to live in, but actually it wasn't. It was quite expensive to rent in that area. The reason people did it is, you know, racism. People did not want to rent to Irish, Italians, Jews, Chinese people. But even if you wanted to leave, you really couldn't. You were really stuck in that area, paying these exorbitant rents to live in the worst conditions.
SPEAKER_02Are you following some of the debates about development in Chinatown today? Yes. What do you think?
SPEAKER_01With that prison, it's I think it's an awful idea.
SPEAKER_02I gotta tell you a Chinatown story. So my last name is SOHN, which can often be a Chinese name or Korean name. And I have a friend who's a photographer named Harvey Wang, who's also from Eastern European immigrants, but happens to have the last name Wang. Yeah. In the 1970s, he was looking for an apartment and Chinatown was very inexpensive. So he called a number of a Chinese landlord and said that his name was Harvey Wang. And the landlord, of course, at the time would only rent to Chinese people.
SPEAKER_02Um, so hearing that his name was Wang told him to meet him at a particular corner to see the apartment. When he saw that Harvey was actually uh a Jewish man, um, he just burst out laughing and rented Harvey um the apartment anyway, just because he thought it was so funny. That's amazing. That's amazing. So you have such an interesting exposure to different kinds of people being a tour guide. Being a tour guide is such a generous act. Um, when I see tours, there's this inherent vulnerability that tourists have, this really open curiosity and this love of New York City that I find incredibly moving.
SPEAKER_02I'm moved by tourists that they want to come here and that they want to learn. And especially when you see um, you know, language barriers and them really straining to understand.
SPEAKER_01It's interesting. I love the way you describe tour guiding. To me, in a way, it's kind of a selfish occupation where I can just talk about things I love and am super passionate about to a captive audience who paid me for it. Um, but it's true, it is an incredible privilege to meet people from all over the country, all over the world, all over the city who have this curiosity and are excited to find out more. And it's a privilege to be able to do it.
SPEAKER_02Suzanne, thank you so much for coming on Lit NYC. Oh, thank you again for having me.
SPEAKER_01This was wonderful.
SPEAKER_00This episode of Lit NYC was hosted and produced by Amy Sohn. The statements made and views expressed are solely the responsibility of the podcast, which is a project of the City Reporter, the newly renamed nonprofit newsroom serving the people of New York. Harry Siegel is the City Reporter's editorial director for audio. Lit NYC is always free, and you can subscribe at Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and wherever podcasts are found, or listen at thecityreporter.nyc. If you like what you're hearing and you can help keep it going, please join us at thecityreporter.nyc slash give spring.
SPEAKER_00That's the cityreporter.nyc slash give spring. The podcast also receives support from the Charles H. Rezen Foundation, from Jamie Rubin, and from PT Knitware, an independent bookstore cafe, and event space on Manhattan's Lower East Side with a podcast studio that can be freely reserved for community use. A special thank you to our guest, Suzanne Reisman. Be sure to check out her tours at Off the Beatonsubway Track.com. And thank you, listener, for making it this far. Be hungry, be happy, and we'll be back soon with more to gnaw on.
As his first career retrospective opens at the Bronx Documentary Center, photographer and filmmaker Harvey Wang sat down with The City Reporter's Harry Siegel to discuss capturing an ever-vanishing city, what it’s like...
Joel Feingold, the researcher who worked with the late historian Mike Wallace on the final two books of his epic Gotham trilogy, including the newly published Gotham at War, visits Lit NYC to talk with Harry Siegel...
New York Times obituarist Sam Roberts talks with Harry Siegel about his new book, Are They Dead Yet, writing about the dead on deadline, and much more.
For the last decade, artist, animator, illustrator and performer R Sikoryak has been putting America’s founding documents into conversation with iconic images and characters from comics and cartoons. That started with...