The famous blue people of Kentucky are no longer blue. But why were they like that in the first place?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, everybody, winding it down with a couple of more here from me, at least, with the Stuff You Should Know Gets Weird playlist. Have you ever seen The Blue People? There's a thing where, I'm not going to spoil it, but let's just say there's a thing that happens where people's skin can turn blue. And this is the episode called What's the Deal with Blue People? And no, not David Cross and Arrested Development or.
Speaker 2The Blue Man Group.
Speaker 1Welcome to Stuff You Should Know, a production of iHeartRadio.
Speaker 3Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark, and there's Charles W. Chuck Bryan over there. And Jerry was just here. She said, peace out, suckas. And this is Stuff You Should Know, of course.
Speaker 2It was nice of her to log on to say goodbye.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2No, we're just kidding, Jerry. She's been busy lately.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2That happens.
Speaker 3It totally happens in this busy go-go world of 2021. Almost 2022. The double deuce.
Speaker 2This year has just flown by.
Speaker 3It really has. I think mercifully, because this is going to be part of the lost years when we look back, you know?
Speaker 2Yeah, it felt like 2020 took 18 years.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2And somehow 2021 has just like been in a snap.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I don't know what's going on.
Speaker 3I don't think anyone does anymore, Chuck, so don't feel bad.
Speaker 2Can we shout out the people and sources that helped us along for this one? Well, our buddy Dave Ruse wrote an article for How Stuff Works.
Speaker 3Ta-da!
Speaker 2And I found a great article from Wired. I forgot how much I love Wired. That's from Mallory Pickett. And BBC News, ABC News, NPR, Morning A Dish, which is always a fun listen. National Library of Medicine here in the U.S. And then, as always, I feel like it makes appearance in every episode, jamaicahospital.org. That's right. Surprisingly helpful.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Maybe not surprisingly.
Speaker 3I wonder, is it Jamaica, Queens or Jamaica, Jamaica?
Speaker 2Oh, you know what? I was thinking Jamaica, Jamaica. It may be Jamaica, Queens. Yeah.
Speaker 3Should I Jamaica scene? Jamaica, Queens?
Speaker 2My neighbor across the street neighbor is from Jamaica, the country. Mm-hmm. And I feel like a heel now because I was like, hey, that hospital website's great, Pat. She's like, what are you talking about?
Speaker 3She's like, okay, great. Glad you like some random hospital website. Oh, boy. So we're talking today. You went and found some medical stuff. That's why you went to look at JamaicaHospital.org, I'm guessing, because we're talking about a really interesting condition and actually a few kinds of conditions that have something– unusual and common, and that is that the people who suffer from these conditions have blue skin. Blue skin. You heard it here first, everybody,
Speaker 3even though this really first started hitting the presses in 2008.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, you didn't hear it here first. I mean, this is all over the internet, but we're talking about not the Blue Man Group, but the Blue People Group of Kentucky. It's a family that is, I guess it's pronounced Fugate?
Speaker 1Mm-hmm.
Speaker 2It's not Fugate?
Speaker 3No, that's Italian. He was from France.
Speaker 2Well, that's a spoiler.
Speaker 3Oh, is it? I'm sorry. I take it back, everyone.
Speaker 2You know, it's not a spoiler, but for some reason, when I saw that, the original Martin Fugate was from France. I'm not sure what part of France, but I was like, huh, that's surprising. I was like, I don't know why it would be.
Speaker 3Yeah, he could have come from anywhere in the world and he would have been like a completely overlookable person. I think totally lost to history had it not been for the rare, rare genetic mutation that he happened to carry with him. And even that wouldn't have gotten him into the history books, Chuck. Even that wouldn't have. Instead, it took Martin Fugate to happen upon against all odds. To have found a wife who he was not related to,
Speaker 3who was a total stranger from a totally different country, who also happened to have that same rare genetic mutation. And when the two get together, kapow, blue kids start popping out.
Speaker 2That's right. He came over from France to Kentucky, to the Blue Hills of Kentucky, ironically.
Speaker 3Oh, wow. I hadn't thought about that.
Speaker 2In 1820. And like I said, he was from France and he was an orphan, so he didn't know a lot about his his family as far as whether or not any of them were blue, I guess.
Speaker 3No. Or if so, he wasn't piping up about it. Yeah.
Speaker 2Maybe he just kept it quiet. But he did marry a redheaded American named Elizabeth Smith, and they headed on over to Troublesome Creek near Hazard County in Kentucky and set up a homestead there. And it is a, I mean, one of the doctors from one of these articles said, you know, it's maybe one in a 100,000 chance that you even have this genetic mutation. And he said, but, you know, once you start, I guess there's no other way to say it. Once you start inbreeding, which can
Speaker 2happen in the 1800s in the ruralness of Kentucky, he said that can go down all the way to like one in eight chance. And that's exactly what happened.
Speaker 3Yeah. I was surprised it was even one in eight, but there's some little fluke of genetics that, um, that you have to When you're talking about probability and genetics, it's a little more difficult than half and half.
Speaker 2It's not straight math.
Speaker 3Yeah. So apparently Martin himself possibly had a little bit of blue to him. His wife Elizabeth had no blue to her. She apparently had very, very pale skin and bright red hair. But when the two got together and those two genetic mutations donated... their mutations to that specific gene, the kids that they had were like irresistibly blue. Like there was no confusing. It's not like, yeah, Martin's kind
Speaker 3of blue. Have you ever noticed? Maybe he needs to breathe more deeply. This was like straight up blue kids. I've even seen them described as dark blue, not even a bluish hue or tint or tinge, dark blue skinned children.
Speaker 2Yeah, four of seven were blue. And it's funny you said that she was not, the mother was not blue tinted. But I imagine like before they knew about genetics and inbreeding, if she would have been a little blue, that might have been a reason to get together. You know what I mean?
Speaker 3No, I don't.
Speaker 2Explain. Well, blue man happens to meet blue woman and they're like, geez, there's another one like me. And, you know, we've been sort of, you know, sort of embarrassing and maybe we're cast out a little bit. So let's hitch our wagons together because there's probably nothing wrong with us having kids, right? Because medical science hadn't known that at that point.
Speaker 3It's a story as old as time, Chuck.
Speaker 2But it was just complete happenstance though.
Speaker 3Right. Yeah. So and I wonder also, like it was significant to me that they pointed out that his wife, Elizabeth Smith Fugate's skin was almost translucent. It was so pale because I wonder if she donated that to her children, which allowed the blue to really shine through even more.
Speaker 2Oh, maybe.
Speaker 3It's possible.
Speaker 2Like the ultimate recipe for blueness?
Speaker 3Exactly. And they actually became known as this blue family. And they were not particularly proud of their blue skin. I think they were a little freaked out about it. I think that their neighbors may not have particularly treated them well. And so they already lived in like a pretty isolated part of Appalachia. But they took pains to actually isolate themselves even further. And one of the consequences of that was something you touched upon that that meant that their son married their aunt and cousins married cousins,
Speaker 3even if they were way too close to be marrying. And so one of the products of this intermarriage was an entire small regional population of blue families or families who have blue children or blue family members because these neighbor families were were still blood relatives of the fugates who initially settled this area and just started reproducing through inbreeding.
Speaker 2That's right. And the condition that they had is not a skin condition at all. It's actually a blood disorder, like you mentioned. And it's called medemoglobinemia. Is that pretty good?
Speaker 3Wow. So it's not meth? No. Okay. Oh, I'm glad you said it first then.
Speaker 2I actually took great pains today to look up. Between this and the other episode, we're recording pronunciations.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And when you look at medemoglobinemia, that is 17 letters of, it's a mouthful of letters.
Speaker 3Yeah, pure hell.
Speaker 2It's really one of those that I looked at over and over and just could not get it right in my head until I, you know, went and looked it up on the internet. And I was like, oh, it's not so hard.
Speaker 3All right, let me try. Let me try. Medemoglobinemia.
Speaker 2I think it's more of a T than a D.
Speaker 3Okay. What about a B? Do you want me to try that one next?
Speaker 2This is like the worst acting audition ever.
Speaker 3Let me give you another one. What's my motivation here?
Speaker 2To get through this episode.
Speaker 3Okay. Fair enough.
Speaker 2So we're going to touch a little bit on melanin throughout this episode, but you remember melanin from our, I think, pretty good episode on sunscreen and suntans, right? And this is, you know, special cells in the body and the skin make melanin, And melanin is responsible for coloring your skin. And there are all kinds of different melanin disorders, whether you have too much or too little, whether it will make your skin lighter or darker, or whether or not
Speaker 2it happens in patches. I had a friend in Los Angeles with vitiligo.
Speaker 3I have a friend, too.
Speaker 1Oh, you do?
Speaker 2Which leads to patches of light skin on the body. Isn't that what Michael Jackson claimed to have had, too? Yes. Was that verified?
Speaker 3I don't know.
Speaker 2I don't know either.
Speaker 3I really don't know.
Speaker 2I just remember there was a big stink when that came out, and everyone was like, yeah, right.
Speaker 3Well, the reason why it was like, really? You got vitiligo? Because it's usually patches, like the melanocytes, the melanin-producing cells just kind of poop out or crap out in an area, and it leaves patches without pigment. Not your entire face without pigment, but who knows?
Speaker 2Well, I think his... I think what he said was that he bleached his skin to match the light patches was his reasoning.
Speaker 3Oh, well, that's fairly reasonable. You know, if you're self-conscious about vitiligo and you have a ton of money, you could do something like that.
Speaker 2Who knows?
Speaker 3Who knows?
Speaker 2Should we talk about skin color or should we take an awkward Michael Jackson break?
Speaker 3I think we just did. But the point is this that I think you're making, Chuck, is that Changes in, like, your skin color typically have to do with a lack of or an overproduction of melanin, right? That's right. What we're talking about, metemoglobinemia, right?
Speaker 2Yep.
Speaker 3Is actually a blood disorder. It has nothing to do with the skin. It just shines through that super translucent skin that we have.
Speaker 2Right. So what's going on here in the body?
Speaker 3Oh, yeah.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 3So, you know.
Speaker 2Are you surprised I'm asking you to do this?
Speaker 3I'm a little surprised. I thought we maybe tag-teamed this one. But okay, okay. So, you have like a pinkish hue to you typically. Thank you. Being Caucasian because there's not a ton of melanin that's blocking the blood supply underneath in your tissues. It's kind of shining through. And your blood is red. And the reason it's red, Chuck, is because?
Speaker 2But the reason why blood is red? Well, remember in school they teach you that your blood is blue until you get cut and then it hits the air.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's not true.
Speaker 2And then it turns red. That's what you hear on the playground in elementary school.
Speaker 3From dumb kids.
Speaker 2But that is not true. And I bet you anything kids are still spreading that mistruth on the playground.
Speaker 3Yeah. It's got some staying power for sure as far as rumors go.
Speaker 2And you know what? My dad will sue your dad for all the money he's got. Did you guys threaten lawsuits?
Speaker 3Sure. We were very litigious.
Speaker 2Kids did, though. It was very funny.
Speaker 3We were like little Puritans in Salem town.
Speaker 2That's right. So blood is red. That was the question, right?
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 3Why is blood red? Right.
Speaker 2Because, I don't know, we've talked about this before, but it's because our red blood cells have hemoglobin. It's a protein. And it gets its red color from something called heme. It's a compound that has an iron atom in there. And that iron atom is the key. That's what binds with oxygen and allows red blood cells to get oxygen all over the body. And that's sort of what makes us tick.
Speaker 3Yeah, it definitely is. I mean, that oxygen is super important. So we want to have super red, rich hemoglobin blood, right? Our bodies also produce something else called metemoglobins, I guess is how you would pronounce it. That is not how I've been pronouncing it in my head. But these metemoglobins are basically the same thing as hemoglobins, but they have a different kind of iron attached to them. The iron they have is like there's really no other way to put it. Well, actually, there's plenty of other ways to put it. But one way you could put it is
Speaker 3that it's rusted. It's oxidized iron, which means that it's missing an electron that it would need to bind to oxygen, which means it's useless for transporting oxygen through the blood. So if you have a bunch of metemoglobin built up in your blood, your blood can reasonably turn blue. You also may have some problems breathing because you don't have any oxygen in your blood. Although that's not true, I'm sorry. You would be able to breathe perfectly fine, but it wouldn't clear up necessarily the lack of oxygen in your
Speaker 3blood because it's on a blood level rather than something to do with your lungs.
Speaker 2Yeah, that was my one question because... doctor after doctor has confirmed that metivoglobinemia doesn't present any health issues. But how can that be possible that your blood is having trouble carrying oxygen through your body and it doesn't matter?
Speaker 3I had a really hard time with that too. And the best I could come up with as far as an answer, which is not definitive, but the best I could come up with is that there's a threshold where your blood will turn blue, where you have enough metemoglobins in there that it's blue, but there's not so many metemoglobins that you're actually having trouble with your oxygen in your body. So it can turn blue long before you actually suffer from the effects of low oxygen. Does that
Speaker 3make sense?
Speaker 2Yeah, I guess that makes sense. And isn't the threshold... To turn your skin blue, like a really low percentage even?
Speaker 3Like 1% of metemoglobins. If your blood is 1% metemoglobins, you can start to turn blue, right? So it doesn't take very much, which means that you have 99% of the globins in your blood are hemoglobin, which means you're still able to get all the oxygen you need. You just have maybe a little less than somebody else. That's my best guess from what I saw. And I... I think at this point in our understanding of metemoglobinemia, it's as good as anybody's.
Speaker 2Well, that sounds like a perfect place for a break.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2And we'll be right back to talk a little bit more about this and other interesting blood conditions right after this. Thank you.
Speaker 3So, Chuck, we were talking about metemoglobinemia. And the reason, like I think one of us said earlier, that the body naturally produces these things, these metemoglobins. But we also produce an enzyme that can convert excess metemoglobins into hemoglobin. And it's got a doozy of a name, which I just love. May I take this one?
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 3This enzyme is called reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide cytochrome B5 reductase. One of the great all-time names.
Speaker 2What's its nickname? Sparky?
Speaker 3It has no nickname. You have to say the entire thing every time. And so this enzyme, reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide cytochrome B5 reductase, is actually capable of converting the iron from its ferric state in metemoglobin's into its ferrous state, which is capable of binding with oxygen, like the kind that's found in hemoglobin. So for all intents and purposes, reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide cytochrome B5 reductase is capable of
Speaker 3converting metemoglobins into hemoglobin, and most of us are able to do that. But if you're like a fugate and you have that rare genetic condition where both parents donated that mutation to you, And you develop metemoglobinemia. But there's some reduced amount of reduced nicotinamide, adenine, dinucleotide, cytochrome B5 reductase, which means that metemoglobins that you naturally produce are able to build up and accumulate in your blood. And when they do that, that's how you start to turn blue.
Speaker 3That's how you cross that 1% threshold.
Speaker 2That's right. And this is one of the rare times where you can actually have a genetic condition that's Pretty easily solved. And in this case, it's just a pill. And the guy who figured this out has sort of an interesting story in his own right. His name is Madison Cawine or Cawine? Cawine?
Speaker 3I'm going with Cawine.
Speaker 2Cawine?
Speaker 3Cawine. Cawine. I'm going with Cawine.
Speaker 2C-A-W-E-I-N. Cawine.
Speaker 3Although I like Cawine. That doesn't sound like it'd be tasty, but I'll bet it gives you a pretty good buzz.
Speaker 2He was the grandson of a pretty famous at the time poet out of Kentucky, and Madison was the third of the Madisons. And this is just a side note, very sad and interesting. His wife was poisoned and murdered by poison in the 1960s, and no one was ever caught and charged with a crime. And it kind of remains one of Kentucky's... you know, sort of biggest cold cases.
Speaker 3Wow, I did not see that one coming.
Speaker 2Yeah, he and his wife and this other couple were out drinking all night, supposedly, like just got... sloshed and at a key at a country club um he madison didn't even make it home i think he stayed the night there but the other man uh the the man from the other couple drove his wife home apparently just dropped. They had another nightcap and she woke up dead. Well, didn't wake up dead. She died. And they thought it was just, you know, alcohol or some natural cause. But
Speaker 2then they found these two like little needle pricks in her. Wow. Where they think she was, I guess, given a shot to pass out and then poisoned. And I can't remember the poison. It was some sort of like acid or something.
Speaker 3Wow.
Speaker 2But yeah, really, really interesting. Neither here nor there as far as this goes. But That's the sad story of Dr. Madison Cowwine's wife.
Speaker 3Was he a suspect? Because I would have suspected him.
Speaker 2I don't think so because he wasn't even there. That's the first thing I thought. But apparently it was pretty verified that he slept it off at the country club, I guess.
Speaker 3Crazy. Because, I mean, one of the things that he became famous for, if not the thing he became famous for, was injecting people with some fairly weird stuff.
Speaker 1I know.
Speaker 2Isn't that weird?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3It is weird.
Speaker 2You're not buying it.
Speaker 3Nah, I don't want to, like, cast aspersions on somebody. I don't know enough about the story, but that's just very odd, especially... You're like, judging.
Speaker 2From this 90-second story.
Speaker 3Right, exactly. I can conclusively solve this case. I've seen enough law and order to know that the husband almost always did it.
Speaker 2Well, that is probably true, but probably not in this case. But at any rate, he was a hematologist at U, at University of Kentucky.
Speaker 3Mm-hmm.
Speaker 2And he heard about these people throughout the world and really wanted to kind of get to the bottom of this when a couple of them, well, I don't think these were Fugates, but Patrick and Rachel Ritchie, I guess, you know, it happened in some other family. I know that Combs is.
Speaker 3We knew a Combs from Kentucky. We had a friend that we worked with for a little while.
Speaker 2Oh, really?
Speaker 3He was never, he never struck me as blue. Yeah.
Speaker 2He never struck you as blue.
Speaker 3But I wonder if he is related to the Combses.
Speaker 2Well, who knows?
Speaker 3Which would make them buy somehow a Fugate. Because again, these families in the Fugate area were all, if you went back far enough, Fugates.
Speaker 2Right, exactly. All right, so these people walk into his office and what happened?
Speaker 3So here's the thing. They didn't walk into his office. He went and found them. I read an article about him and he became maybe a little obsessed with finding these people, wanted to know what the heck was going on. So he actually went out in the woods and and would wait for them and every once in a while would see one and he'd chase them telling them to stop. And of course they would run off. So he figured out another way to do it. He moved to Hazard County near Troublesome Creek and he started asking around at clinics, like had anybody ever treated a blue patient? And he
Speaker 3finally struck gold, blue gold when he spoke to one nurse at a clinic that said, yeah, this, this one woman came in with blue skin and she was really self-conscious about her skin. She came to the back door and, was really just kind of meek and embarrassed. But yeah, we've treated a blue person before. So Cowane basically hung around this clinic until more blue people came in. And this is where he met the Ritchie siblings. Yeah.
Speaker 2So he started to dig into their family a little bit. It became pretty obvious to him that it was a genetic disorder. And he started digging around other stories around North America and found an Inuit population in Alaska who had who had the same condition. I'm just going to call it this condition now.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 2I think we've said it enough.
Speaker 3Sure.
Speaker 2Or at least I have.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And he said, well, you know, these people were interbreeding a lot because they were very remote as well. And so he said, I think we understand the problem here. How do we fix it? Yeah.
Speaker 3I don't know if he, where he got this idea is But he used something called methylene blue, which was already like in wide use. It's used to stain tissue because it affects some cells differently than others. It was a malarial treatment, which malaria can actually produce metemoglobinemia. I'm suddenly having trouble saying it because we haven't been practicing lately. And what it does is it goes in. And it
Speaker 3interacts with the reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide cytochrome B5 reductase and basically gives it a boost and helps convert all of that excess metemoglobins into hemoglobins in patients with metemoglobin anemia. And so I don't know where he got the idea, but he tried it and apparently injected the Richie kids with it and they stopped being blue, like almost on the spot.
Speaker 2Yeah, like minutes later, they returned to a, you know, a standard color. And I mean, they were overjoyed. Like, could you imagine being like this your whole life, getting a shot? And looking in the mirror a few minutes later, you're like, oh, my gosh, it's like it's gone.
Speaker 3It's actually really sweet because they were very self-conscious, the whole family. I mean, this family like retreated to the woods to like people didn't know where they lived. And they lived like five miles away from them and knew that there was this blue family still had no idea where they lived. It was like that's how far they retreated from society because they were that self-conscious. So, yeah, I'm sure is a pretty joyous occasion for them.
Speaker 2There's going to be a movie about this at some point, right?
Speaker 3I can't believe there's not. There's a very famous interview with Kyle Wayne in a magazine called Science 82. And there's also a really famous painting that somebody did. And it was just kind of lost to history who did it. And I read this article. I can't remember what it was on. But this person tracked down the artist, the initial artist, and got to see like the original because it's been scanned so many times. It's really lost a step. But the original is apparently really something to see.
Speaker 2Should we say the quote that Coane had in that Science 82 article? He said, and they walked into the office, he said, they were bluer than hell. Very Kentucky.
Speaker 3Yeah, totally.
Speaker 2All right. So over time, Fugates started moving away. Like some of the younger population of the family got out of Hazard County. And it's so hard not to make Dukes of Hazard jokes. I've been just sidestepping the whole time.
Speaker 3You've been doing really great.
Speaker 2Thank you. But they started to move away over time. And basically, you know, that's going to stop the interbreeding and that's going to make fewer and fewer blue babies. And as of 2012, I think some were still blue, but not today.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think now that there's a treatment, an easy treatment, because they don't even have to be injected anymore. Like if you're blue and you don't want to be blue, you just take a methylene blue pill once a day and it goes in. Apparently, once you excrete it out, the methylene blue You go back to being blue. So you have to take it daily. But I'll bet there's members of that family now, and I'm just guessing here, but that are proudly blue. Now that they know that they don't have to be blue, some of them I'll bet make a choice to be blue as kind of
Speaker 3like a pride in their family heritage. I'm guessing here.
Speaker 2Well, the thing I saw that there was one, and that was the one in 2012 that was still blue.
Speaker 3Like by choice?
Speaker 2I think so. Yeah, just didn't take the pill.
Speaker 3Gotcha.
Speaker 1Gotcha.
Speaker 3Wow, that's neat.
Speaker 2But not today anymore. So this is not the only way you can get bluish or any, you know, I guess silvery skin is another thing that comes into play here with this next disorder. And this is one called argyria. And some people are bluish, some people are silver. If you've looked up, you know, blue people or silver people online, you have no doubt seen uh paul karrison they called him papa smurf and he is all over the internet
Speaker 2as one of the more famous cases of egeria.
Speaker 3Yeah and he uh was he kind of emerged as i don't know if a cautionary tale is right because that was not his purpose um but he he also he he whether he meant to or not he served as a cautionary tale about taking colloidal silver Because that is what turned him blue. And it didn't just turn his skin blue. It turned his mucous membranes blue. So if he like flashed his teeth, his gums were blue. The inside of his mouth was blue. The inside of his nose was blue. He was blue. Blue in hell,
Speaker 3as Kyle Wayne would probably put it.
Speaker 2That's right.
Speaker 3And he did it because he saw an article about how silver ions basically restored some cut flower back to life again. And he thought, well, that'd be really something to do. to see what it can do on a human body.
Speaker 2I want to be a fresh daisy.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3And he wasn't the only person experimenting at the time. Like apparently for a while it was an over-the-counter drug. We've been using silver for a very long time. But he was somebody who used it every single day. He was drinking like a 10-ounce drink of colloidal silver. He figured out how to basically make his own colloidal silver potion. And he also rubbed it on his face too. And so in very short order, he started to turn blue because that is definitely a consequence of using silver too much,
Speaker 3of overexposure to silver.
Speaker 2That's right. And this can happen if you work in like a silver mine or something.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2Like it can be one of the side effects of mining in silver mines.
Speaker 3I also saw that in the old time, not even that old, but just pre-digital photography processing, photograph processing, you could.
Speaker 2Actually Old timey?
Speaker 3Yeah, you know, the 80s.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3You could actually develop argyria from exposure to the silver dust that was used to expose photographic plates. I think prior to the 80s. I don't know when they stopped using that.
Speaker 2I don't either. I spent a lot of times in dark rooms... as a kid because of my dad. Because you were bad? Yeah, go in there, turn on that red light and sit there and think about what you've done. No, my dad was an amateur photographer. Well, I guess semi-professionally sold stuff, but he did his own developing and I learned how to do it and did it some through high school and then kind of quit doing it. It was a lot of fun though. Dark rooms are very like peaceful places.
Speaker 3Is that right?
Speaker 2Yeah, just, you know, they're dark obviously. Sure. And you're in there for, long period of time and it's just very nice usually by yourself but unless you're in a teen romance movie and then you know the cute girls in there.
Speaker 3With you I well I always associate them with the the murderer finally coming into focus and they happen to be standing right next to the the photographer is developing it so to me dark rooms are very tense scary.
Speaker 2Okay like as it has the as the photo paper like comes into focus yeah Oh, very tense.
Speaker 3It shows the calls coming from inside the dark room.
Speaker 2That's right. Where were we? Okay, so what causes this is an excess of silver ions in your body. And when they're exposed to light, they react by forming dark deposits on the skin that end up looking silverish. And the bad news about this is Once you've got it, it's there. You can't take a pill and get rid of it.
Speaker 3No, it's irreversible. We don't have a way to remove excess silver from the tissues in the human body. And that's all it is. It's just, it builds up. Normally the body can excrete, you know, small amounts of silver that we're exposed to from like, you know, touching silver or snorting silver, that kind of stuff.
Speaker 2What?
Speaker 3You know, uh, Like we pee it out, we poop it out and we get rid of it. But if we overcome that threshold and our silver ingestion exceeds our ability to excrete it, it starts to build up in the tissue. And so if you're drinking your own 10 ounce colloidal silver homebrew every single day, you're going to overwhelm your body's ability to excrete silver very quickly. And it's going to build up and build up and build up. And pretty soon you're going to be blue or silver blue.
Speaker 2That's right. And if you look up images of kerosene, you're probably also going to find pictures of Stan Jones, a libertarian politician in Montana, who around Y2K said, you know what, I think things are going to go south and we're not going to have any antibiotics. So I'm going to start making my own again, colloidal silver solution and drink that stuff. And then there was a teacher in Brooklyn too named Rosemary Jacobs, who very sadly, I think got nasal drops with silver when she was a kid.
Speaker 2And she was sort of, not sort of, she was very silver for life.
Speaker 3Yes, she was. So these people, again, have proved to be cautionary tales to most people who are like, oh, that's what happens if you take too much silver. I'm not going to take colloidal silver supplements over the counter or anything like that. I'm just going to steer clear of silver altogether. Because one of the problems is there's not a lot of peer-reviewed evidence, if any, that suggests that silver has any beneficial effect when taken internally, right? It is actually antimicrobial. It's pretty clever to use silver
Speaker 3like in the pre-scientific days. But there's nothing that says like, yes, if you drink a colloidal silver homebrew, it's going to have any effect on your life or your health. And in fact, it might actually turn you blue. Despite this, People still take colloidal silver pretty frequently. Apparently, Alex Jones touts it. Gwyneth Paltrow touts it. Dr. Oz touts it. And that's, you know, if it's not actually harming you, there doesn't seem to be any harm from it, aside
Speaker 3from potentially irreversibly turning blue. But there's a larger harm that I saw chucked to society in general, in that silver is an antimicrobial of last resort that is... they're figuring out how to use it against antibiotic-resistant bugs like MRSA. Silver will get in there and even kill MRSA. But that silver resistance may be developed in bugs by all these people taking colloidal silver supplements and drinking colloidal silver,
Speaker 3you know, homebrews and stuff like that, that it's actually creating silver-resistant microbes, which is not a good thing for anybody.
Speaker 1Interesting.
Speaker 2All right. Well, let's take our second break.
Speaker 3Good. Yes.
Speaker 2And we'll talk a little bit more about colloidal silver right after this.
Speaker 3All right.
Speaker 2So you mentioned earlier that, uh, kind of in passing that colloidal silver had been used pre, you know, mainstream medical science coming on board. And it's really true. And they were kind of onto something in that, like you said, there were, there are some antimicrobial properties. So people like Pliny the Elder, Cyrus the Great, they both touted the use of silver. Monks in the Middle Ages used silver nitrate to treat ulcers and burns. And it was used a lot. It's kind of in a way, before we
Speaker 2had real antibiotics, one of the first antibiotics.
Speaker 3Yes. Again, externally, it messes up microbes, and we're not exactly sure, even still today, what the mechanism is. The guesses are that it somehow penetrates the membrane of bacteria and prevents it from replicating properly. or it does like some one, two punches on enzymes that the microbes need to survive, but that it will leave your human skin cells alone. It just attacks microbes weirdly, bacteria specifically. So yeah,
Speaker 3it was like an early antibiotic, and it actually stayed in use for a long time Nowadays, you'll find it in like wound dressings. Sometimes sutures will be coated in silver. Replacement joints, artificial joints will have some sort of silver component to it to protect against infection. But we were using them internally for a really long time, up until the 60s even. I think babies got like silver eye drops when they were born, which I had not heard
Speaker 3of until, you know, yesterday.
Speaker 2I had neither. Yeah, silver nitrate. to prevent eye infections. But then they found out it can actually cause eye damage and burn the skin. So they really worked on just sort of... What's the word I'm looking for when you make something less potent by mixing it with water?
Speaker 3Dilute it?
Speaker 2Diluting it. Right on the tip of my tongue.
Speaker 3You did it.
Speaker 2No, you did it. So they learned how to dilute it. But the problem with diluting it in a formula is... it wasn't an exact science. Like they didn't know exactly how much silver was still going to be active. And so, you know, you couldn't really use it as a medicine anymore because it was either too weak to do anything or it was so much that you risk turning blue. So eventually they just scrapped it as a medicine and said, I think in 1999, the FDA said, this isn't a medicine, you can't advertise it as such. So they said, all right,
Speaker 2we'll just say it's a supplement.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2And just move it to the shelf, you know, four feet away.
Speaker 3And the FDA said, no.
Speaker 2And that's what happened. And you can still get this stuff. That's where, you know, that's why Gwyneth Paltrow uses it. Yeah.
Speaker 3And I mean, like, again, it's one of those things where it's like, yes, it makes sense. Silver has antimicrobial properties. There's probably some microbes in your body you don't want. So take some silver and see if it works. But again, there's just not any peer-reviewed evidence that backs this up. That's not necessarily to say that it doesn't work just because there isn't peer-reviewed evidence that backs it up. Doesn't also necessarily mean in the same breath that there's plenty of peer-reviewed evidence that says it doesn't work. I'm not suggesting anybody take this stuff. I'm just saying there's not
Speaker 3peer-reviewed evidence to back up that it actually does anything. And if you do take it, again, you risk permanently, irreversibly turning blue.
Speaker 2Yeah, and I should point out, I don't know anything about Gwyneth Paltrow's current usage, but her appearance on Dr. Oz in 2013 was when she touted it. She may have given it up. Who knows?
Speaker 3Who knows? Paul Karasaw never gave it up, though, Chuck. He died in 2013 as well, same year that Gwyneth Paltrow outed herself as a silver user. Yeah. And Paul Carisson, he apparently used colloidal silver, that homebrew he made, up until the end. Like he never stopped, even though he apparently retreated from the public eye because he was tired of being treated like a freak or a weirdo and had some rough years toward the end, apparently after he went public. But he still kept up with the colloidal silver,
Speaker 3although that doesn't seem to have been linked to his death. He was also a really heavy smoker for many years, and he suffered a heart attack and a stroke.
Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, I guess his point was probably, well, I'm already blue. Yeah. Like, why stop now?
Speaker 3Can't get much bluer. So, what else you got?
Speaker 2Well, I just thought we'd wind it up with this little kind of sidebar. This doesn't really have anything to do with being blue or silver, but I thought it was an interesting find that They basically determine there's something called repigmenting that has happened to people to go their skin both darker and lighter that has nothing to do. And it's funny, this article kept calling it intermarriage. What they mean is, you know.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2What they mean is having sex and having babies of two different skin colors. But they keep calling it intermarriage, which I guess is, you know, very sweet.
Speaker 3It's just such a lovely way to put it.
Speaker 2It is. But they know that repigmenting happens regardless of intermarriage. But what they found recently is that this has happened a lot faster than anyone thought. And we're talking about 100 generations or as little as 100 generations, which is a long time. But over the course of human history, it's not that long.
Speaker 3It's potentially. Yeah, it's not that long. Usually a generation is chalked up at about 20 years. So we're talking as little as 2000 years. That groups that were once lily white went back to being dark and groups that were dark can turn into a lily white population. And that it's just basically more evidence that race is strictly a social construct. Skin color has nothing to do with anything but the amount of melanin that our genes tell our bodies to produce, which is triggered by the amount
Speaker 3of UV exposure that we have over something like 100 generations. Right.
Speaker 2And so if your family lineage moves from a place that has lots of UV near the equator to a place that doesn't have much daylight or vice versa, your body is going to adapt and melanin production is going to change. And over time, your entire family's skin color can change.
Speaker 3Yeah, because we actually need UV, right? But we just need a certain amount of it. If you have too much You can get skin cancer. Apparently it can have reproductive issues. If you get too little, it can also have issues on your bone because we use UV to produce vitamin D, which we use for strong bones, bone density. So our bodies have figured out how to kind of adjust depending on that UV exposure by producing or slowing down melanin production. That's it.
Speaker 2Pretty amazing.
Speaker 3Pretty neat. But it is surprising that it's, Well, actually, it's not that surprising that it can happen over 100 generations or 2,000 years because the body is very responsive to its environment. We adapt very easily. So that's not particularly surprising, although it is neat.
Speaker 2Yeah. I mean, it surprised the scientists. I think they just thought it was quicker than they anticipated.
Speaker 3So if you're a racist, just stop and think that somewhere down your family line, there is a white person or a black person. Ha ha.
Speaker 2Or in the future.
Speaker 3Yeah. That's true.
Speaker 2That's right. So take that.
Speaker 3You got anything else?
Speaker 2I have nothing else.
Speaker 3All right. Well, if you want to know more about blue people or colloidal silver or pigmentation, go start reading up on it on the Internet. And thanks again to all the great sites that you found in putting this really good episode together, Chuck. And since I complimented Chuck's episode putting together skills, it's time for Listener Mail.
Speaker 2I'm going to call this one of the many... Thanks we got for the M, not NRA, but the Mr. Nah episode.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 2This is one I think for both of us like we were super stoked to do and like in retrospect very proud of.
Speaker 3Yeah. We're stoked.
Speaker 2We were super stoked, not just stoked.
Speaker 3Bruh.
Speaker 2Stoked plus. There's no way to say stoked without sounding like a bro. No.
Speaker 3No way at all.
Speaker 2It stinks, too, because I'm not a bro, but I do like saying stoked.
Speaker 3That's fine. Just say stoked. Be loud and proud like the last remaining blue Fugate.
Speaker 2So this is from Mark, and it was a really long one that I'm going to sort of summarize the first part, is that Mark works in healthcare information technology and had a rough go of it over the past couple of years, like so many people, working alone and listening to our show, which he said helped quite a bit, losing some close friends to COVID.
Speaker 3Man.
Speaker 2And seeing all this up close and personal. So Mark had a tough time. So he says this, after working for almost two years on the COVID-19 problem, the last thing I wanted to hear was your podcast about Mr. Nah vaccines. When I saw the topic pop up on my player, took a deep breath and decided to listen anyway. I knew almost everything you shared on the podcast, but became enthralled in the recap of this amazing story. To my surprise, I was again brought to tears by, with a recognition, one that you two share, of these brilliant
Speaker 2helpers who use their gifts for the benefit of all humanity. At the risk of making you blush, you two are part of those helpers. You presented this Mr. Nah episode with a childlike curiosity and relatable simplicity that anyone with doubts on taking the vaccine would reconsider. I can't believe that I have to say this, but facts help, and fact-sharers are helpers. I might also add that letting go of any biases to let your curiosity grow Curiosity to take hold is heroic. And that is from Mark, and boy,
Speaker 2I'm going to read that one another hundred times today.
Speaker 3Yeah, just print it out and fold it up and keep it under your pillow.
Speaker 2Yes, thank you, Mark. He wanted his last name to be withheld, but appreciate the work you've done, Mark, and hang in there.
Speaker 3Yeah, same to you, Mark, and that was very high praise. Thank you very much for it. It means a lot to hear something like that. One other thing, though, Chuck, that Mark reminded me of, that people with metemoglobinemia actually can blush blue.
Speaker 2Oh, so they get bluer?
Speaker 3Yeah. Isn't that neat?
Speaker 2I guess that makes sense.
Speaker 3Thanks for that too, Mark. Even though you had no idea you were setting us up for it, you did. So you're just basically an altogether great person. If you want to be a great person like Mark and write in to let us know whatever you want to let us know, we want to hear from you. You can wrap it up and spank it on that bottom until it's blue in the face, and send it off to stuffpodcasts at iheartradio.com. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio.
Speaker 1For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Buffets are every kid’s dream - until they grow up enough to realize how gross communal spreads of food shared with strangers actually are. Then the dream is dashed, for most of us at least. Learn about the golden age...
Turkeys are a very interesting bird as it turns out. Which may be why many people are leaving it off their Thanksgiving table this year. Learn all about them right now in this classic episode!