
The Story of Chester Weger
Is the story of Chester Weger a case of wrongful incarceration? It appears to be. Listen in to his story today.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Is the story of Chester Weger a case of wrongful incarceration? It appears to be. Listen in to his story today.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Speaker 1Welcome to Stuff You Should Know, a production of iHeartRadio.
Speaker 2Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh and there's Chuck and Jerry's here too. And this is a true crime edition. We've got a pretty robust library catalog of true crime episodes. And this is no different because it's true crime and it's an episode.
Speaker 1That's right. A couple of pieces of business.
Speaker 3We want to thank Deb Clayton for the suggestion for this one, a case I had not previously heard of.
Speaker 2Thanks, Deb.
Speaker 3And issue a COA because this is true crime. It does feature a brutal murder and some discussion of sexual assault. So now you know, everybody.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Thanks for giving the COA, buddy.
Speaker 3Yeah, I figure people know if it's a true crime thing, but you know, you don't want children wandering into this.
Speaker 2No.
Speaker 1Unawares.
Speaker 2And being scarred forever.
Speaker 1No, we don't like to scar.
Speaker 2No, we don't. We'd like to heal. Chuck, heal.
Speaker 1That's right.
Speaker 2So, yeah, let's talk about this. We're talking about the conviction of a man named Chester Weeger, but. We can't really talk about that until we talk about the crime. So before Chester Wieger comes in, we want to go to Chicago. And it's a Sunday. And three friends, Lillian Oding, Mildred Lindquist, and Francis Murphy have just gotten out of church. They all went to Riverside Presbyterian together in, I think, Riverside, Illinois. And I think that's an affluent suburb of Chicago, I think. At the very least, it
Speaker 2was at the time, right?
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2Well, they decided that they were going to take a spur of the moment four day trip to picturesque Starved Rock Park in Oglesby, Illinois. I think it's about 90 minutes or something from Chicago. It's supposedly one of the most beautiful parts of Illinois.
Speaker 1It is very pretty.
Speaker 3I did look up, you know, they ended up taking a hike to St. Louis Canyon. So I look that up and it's gorgeous. And they were going out birdwatching. You know, they went to this lodge there and then decided to go out birdwatching because they were all Almost all 50. I think Oding was 50. Lindquist was 50. And Francis Murphy was 47, which is that's the age where you get into birdwatching. I can attest to that. And so they went for, you know, like I said, they checked in at the Starved Rock Lodge and went for that hike in St. Louis Canyon about a half
Speaker 3a mile away. And they never came back. I don't think we mentioned that they were married to some pretty prominent businessmen, some local like kind of big shot executives, it sounds like.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2Yeah. Like for Illinois Bell, like a higher up guy there for a bank and trust. I can't remember what the third one was, but yes, they were all connected leaders of their community. And these were their wives. So they were well thought of and prominent. But at the time they were just normal people. And when they went on this four day trip to go birdwatching, like you said, they We're pretty excited about it. It was like some time away. I think one of them had been taking care of her ailing husband after a heart attack. So
Speaker 2this is like some real time off. And so they go to this lodge. They check in. They put their bags in their rooms. They go have some lunch in the dining hall. And almost immediately, they go hit the trail to go to, like you said, St. Louis Canyon for a hike. I think it was about a mile each way from what I read. And evening fell. And I think Lillian Oding's husband was expecting a call from her and he didn't get one. So he tried calling and there was no answer. He tried calling the next morning,
Speaker 2no answer. Tried calling the next afternoon, no answer. And he's like, I've just had a heart attack. I can't deal with this. So he called his brother who called the lodge. And that's when it started to get kind of scary for everybody.
Speaker 1Yeah, because, you know, like I said, they never came back.
Speaker 3They checked in with some local law enforcement friends, kind of insiders, I think, to get a search started. But This is a couple of days later when they finally started searching, even though that doesn't really play into the case because they found the bodies very quickly. Very sadly, there had been a sort of a late snowstorm in the time that they went hiking and they found the body.
Speaker 1So they were covered partially with snow.
Speaker 3They were in a cave and they were side by side laying on their backs. They had been bound up with twine. Some of their undergarments, it appears, had been removed, and they were bludgeoned to death.
Speaker 2Yes. They also eventually recovered the binoculars they'd taken for birdwatching, broken in two. That's not easy to do. The camera, with its strap broken and the case smeared with blood. And then, most importantly, they found a tree limb that was about three feet long and I saw weighed 10 pounds. And it was covered in blood. And they said, we are pretty sure this is the murder weapon. But like you said, they had a bunch of snow. So they're like, well, we got to get rid of the snow. So they
Speaker 2used a weed burner to melt the snow. And they used brooms, too. And this is a triple homicide crime scene. And they were already kind of flubbing things.
Speaker 1Yeah, for sure.
Speaker 3I think initially, too, they thought the binoculars were a murder weapon.
Speaker 1Sure. And the camera as well. So.
Speaker 3They kind of had three things that they were investigating initially as weapons, but they were definitely, you know, died from head trauma. There was kind of no mistaking that. They also saw the tip of the finger of Murphy had been cut off. They did not find that. And I don't think they ever found that, did they?
Speaker 2Not that I saw. Yeah.
Speaker 3So, you know, since they had their some of them had their undergarments either removed or disrupted, they. did a vaginal smear and did not find any traces of semen. So they basically initially said they were not sexually assaulted, but just put a pin in that.
Speaker 2Yeah, for sure. So this was a really, really big deal for a few reasons. One, this is a public park. It was one of the most beautiful places around. It was meant to be idyllic and peaceful, not the scene of triple homicides. It seemed to be random violence, which always makes a crime way worse. And then also, these were, again, very prominent women. So the attention of not just the nation, but the world was on this case initially. I think
Speaker 2the AP said it was the number one news story in the world at the time. So it was a really big deal. And when you have something like that big of a deal, if this case falls in your lap and you're you know, the district attorney or the sheriff, you have pressure coming down on you from all sides to get this solved and get it solved fast. And this was definitely one of those cases where, like, I can't imagine the pressure on the people to get this solved from every quarter. Yeah.
Speaker 3They put up a reward sum of the husbands did of 30 grand.
Speaker 1They pulled together 10,000 each.
Speaker 3And the hotel lodge added another five grand, which would be about 400,000 in modern day dollars, which is a ton of money. Um, and the LaSalle law enforcement team was pieced together from the County. There was the sheriff Ray, uh, Utsi, uh, attorney general Harlan Warren. And we'll remind you of these names as we go, because they become pretty prominent in the story, obviously.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And then had some assistance from, uh, a deputy named Bill Dummit and Wayne Hess. And they were big players as well. Yeah.
Speaker 2So they took the lead, but you said that the businessmen or the husbands had connections in law enforcement. And the guy that they contacted immediately called the chief of the Illinois State Police. So you also had all of the Illinois State Police involved, but these guys were leading this massive internationally recognized investigation. And so You know, the investigation early on was pretty sound. They questioned everybody. I saw that they found somebody who'd been seen in the park three days before, not even on the day. Like
Speaker 2they went to like that that level of canvassing and they performed a lot of polygraph tests, too. And even we did a pretty interesting episode, I think, if I remember correctly, on polygraphs back in the day. It's worth listening to, I think. But even at the time, this is 1960, the courts had recognized like those things are not reliable enough to admit as evidence. But you can use them to intimidate suspects if you want. And that's what they were doing.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3So they, you know, they tried it basically every every person who had been through that park recently and every employee at that lodge tried. got them in for the polygraphs. One of those people was a dishwasher, a 21-year-old guy named Chester Weeger. And he was, you know, his backstory, he was very much poverty stricken as a child. It was an eighth grade school dropout. When he was 12 years old, he was arrested on sexual assault charges. And
Speaker 3it's kind of dodgy over whether or not like that was a legitimate charge or not.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3Hard to find a lot of information on it. He was convinced to plead guilty for just getting probation. And like I said, he was 12 years old. He was just a kid. But he did go on to serve in the Marine Corps, was a big-time hunter and fisherman, outdoorsman. And he was married with a couple of kids, both under three years old at the time of the murders.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And some of that doesn't paint the best picture of him. But everything that I read, he was a really stand up guy. Very polite. He was very close to his family. His family was like they were they were in poverty, but they also knew how to live off the land. Like he was a he was not some shady dude is the impression that I have, even though on paper, in some ways, he seems that way.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I think the rape conviction was the biggest deal.
Speaker 3Had that not been on his record, he probably would have just kind of skated right through this thing. But obviously, when they saw that on the record, they were like, hey, maybe this is the guy. They kind of homed in on him and gave him a bunch of polygraphs. And at the time, the technicians were like, this guy doesn't look like he's lying.
Speaker 2No, I think six of them, he passed like with aces, right? Yeah. they kind of kept looking beyond him. Uh, and they looked into every clue that came. I mean, with that 400 grand in 20, $ 26 out there, they were getting tips every which way. Um, they found a set of keys. They tried to figure out where those were from. A car had been seen in the area. I think the guy who operated the lodge, his son said that he'd seen a car with two men talking to three women at one point. So they looked into that. Um, And
Speaker 2then I saw an article or somewhere, the Illinois Crime Lab, like the people investigating it were actually doing a pretty thorough job. But the Illinois Crime Lab flubbed so much stuff that it made the investigation just completely stall out. They did things like they reported that I think Lillian Oding's rings were missing, which certainly supported the idea of a robbery. Later on, they were like, Oh, no, we found her rings. They were in her glove. We just didn't check very thoroughly. That was pretty much par for
Speaker 2the course. It's just one example. Right. So by the time May rolls around, this happened in mid-March, they had spent twenty one thousand plus man hours on this case. And they still were just like completely they had no nothing at all to show for it.
Speaker 1Should we take a break?
Speaker 2We should take a break, Chuck. I think so. All right.
Speaker 1We'll be right back, everybody. All right.
Speaker 4So where we left off was a situation where we have three women that had been brutally murdered.
Speaker 3There was a man, Chester Weeger, who they were investigating other people, like you said before, but they seemed to be trying to finger him with the crime pretty early on. And Warren, the attorney general, was like, I'm going to start looking into this myself.
Speaker 1I'm not just going to run the show.
Speaker 3I'm going to actually start looking into this personally and doing some investigating. He went down kind of a dead end road with the twine.
Speaker 1That was used.
Speaker 3I think he was like, hey, this is the same twine they have at the lodge, which, you know, could tie somebody like Chester Weeger to it. But they couldn't get an expert to say like, yeah, this is definitely the twine. So that just ended up being a dead end. But kind of the point is Warren was really dogged about trying to get somebody at least on trial. Yeah.
Speaker 2And one reason, one big reason I saw is that that Illinois State Crime Lab that they used, it was his decision to use them, even though the state police were like, no, we we should use this FBI lab instead. So he was in the hot seat for that. And it was an election year and he was an elected official. So that's why he started doing it himself. And so, yeah. when like the twine, I think that was really the big thing that he was investigating when that didn't really go anywhere. He started looking at Chester Wieger again, like you said, and he got in touch with John Reed,
Speaker 2who had come up with the Reed technique, which I was, have you heard of that before? I hadn't heard of it, but it turns out I've seen it on every cop show I've ever seen.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, the Reed technique basically is like, Hey, I mean, I bet his advertising commercial was like this. It's like, hey, you got somebody you think is guilty. Send us in there and we'll make sure they say they're guilty.
Speaker 2Yeah. I mean, the whole thing, the whole it's like a step by step way of getting a confession out of somebody. And step one is assume they're guilty. Yeah, that's step one. And so like if you if you've ever seen like Law and Order, like Lenny. is like sitting there giving, like going through the scenario, saying like, well, you had to do this and you did that. And then you had no choice but to kill her, that kind of thing. That's the read technique. You're giving them all sorts of rope to hang themselves with and even giving them a narrative to say like, yeah, that's what happened.
Speaker 2Then you get it on paper and have them sign it. And now you have the confession, whether it's false or not. And that's the problem with the read technique. It's been shown to produce false confessions pretty consistently.
Speaker 1Who's Lenny?
Speaker 2Oh, Lenny Briscoe. He was, I don't remember his real name, but you would recognize him. It was the dad from Dirty Dancing.
Speaker 1Oh, okay. And what show was that?
Speaker 2Law & Order.
Speaker 1All right.
Speaker 2I got to check that out. My friend, you have a whole world just waiting for you of Law & Order episodes, a decade plus of excellent episodes just sitting there waiting for you. You're going to love it.
Speaker 3I feel like we've talked about this and I didn't realize at the time and they probably forgot that you were a fan.
Speaker 1Did you watch all of it?
Speaker 2Yes. It was one of those things where I'd be like, oh, this is the eighth time I've seen this episode. But they had number nine to it. It was just on all the time and they were all fun to watch. Because you just knew what was going to happen. You know, the formula wasn't the same.
Speaker 3I'm probably shocking a lot of people because I know that's a very popular TV show, but I never saw it.
Speaker 2You'll like it, I think.
Speaker 1All right. I'll check it out.
Speaker 3So at any rate, they bring in John Reed and associates to do what they do best. They started talking to some other employees and again, really were kind of homed in. And I imagine that they were told like, hey, we think this Uyghur guy is the guy. Can we make him the guy?
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3You know, I'm not I'm sort of speculating, but it seems like they had him in their sights from the beginning. So a few days into it, Reed brought him in and John Reed himself personally and others did like an around the clock, like a 24 hour try to get this guy to confess thing. You know, some of the details came out later from Uyghur that, you know, they put a gun to his head like an empty gun and like clicked it.
Speaker 1And we're saying awful things.
Speaker 3You know, you're going to fry if you don't admit this and we can get you out, you know, with less time and with like a 14 year sentence or so. on parole, if you admit to it, you know, all the sort of standard tricks.
Speaker 2Yeah. I also saw, get this dude, that John Reed was like, I think our polygraph is broken. So I'm going to give you a test and you just say yes to all the answers.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And luckily, Uyghur was like, I'm not going to do that. I also saw that throughout a 24 hour nonstop interrogation, he remained polite and he was steadfast. Like I didn't do anything wrong, but he wasn't, he wasn't shouting at him. He'd like, He just maintained his composure the entire time.
Speaker 1That's crazy.
Speaker 2I couldn't. I couldn't. That's why this guy was a stand-up guy in a lot of ways. I'm hoping that he was actually innocent because he does seem like he was kind of an amazing person with a lot of really principled beliefs. Yeah.
Speaker 3So not only did they interrogate him for the 24 hours, but they started putting him under surveillance for 24 hours a day. Like, you know, not quietly following him around, like an intimidation kind of following him around, um, you know, parked in front of his house, following him when he's walking down the street. So, uh, the attorney general's daughter, um, decades later shared that she found a note in his files that suggested that, um, basically they tried to get him to confess via psychological warfare, uh, which included the
Speaker 3stuff like the surveillance.
Speaker 2So, um, There were a couple other things that came forward that investigators had kind of brushed off earlier. There was another state park that there were a couple of robberies and a sexual assault in one of the robberies that they were like, hey, let's try to pin this on Wager 2 because we can't get anything else to stick. So they did one of these things where they did a lineup, a police lineup, but a photo array. And they chose people. Every other person besides Wieger's picture looked
Speaker 2alike or similar. They were all much older. He was clearly meant to stand out. And so he did. Like the victim picked him out in that photo array. For the other one, they did the same thing. The victim picked him out in that photo array too. And we should say this was three years before the Miranda rights were established.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2But it was also after– Cops had been it had been outlawed beating people with a rubber hose. So they had moved on to psychological tactics and shady stuff. And that's what they were doing. And finally, now they had witnesses who could point to Uyghur and say, this guy committed this crime against me. And now they could hold them even more. Yeah.
Speaker 3And, you know, Uyghur actually said they did beat him with a billy club. And, you know, I don't think we mentioned the FBI would eventually get involved. There's actually nothing like physically tying him to this crime.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3But the FBI gets a buckskin jacket of his. They were like, hey, they're human blood on this thing. They couldn't make a match. You know, this is 1960. So they didn't obviously have the resources that we have today. And some of Wieger's co-workers at the lodge supposedly said that they saw scratches on his face the day after the murders. But they didn't include that in the first round of questioning.
Speaker 2Right. So, I mean, you're starting to see a picture come through, right, where all this stuff just kind of seems fishy. And then when you compare it to what Uyghur said they put him through for these interrogations and even setting aside what he said happened in the interrogations, the fact that they were carrying out 24 and eight hour marathon interrogations and that memo was found, it does seem like they were using some underhanded tactics against him. Which kind of makes all this stuff that suddenly came
Speaker 2up as evidence or even circumstantial evidence just quite suspicious. Right. Yeah.
Speaker 3And, you know, I will I will say it now because it's coming up. But there was a little fact in here that's just one little sentence that really blew it all wide open for me. And I wonder if you had the same reaction. So when we get there, I'm curious if you're going to say the same thing.
Speaker 4All right.
Speaker 2So.
Speaker 3And this is a big part of this case. The attorney general lost his bid for re-election that November. Yeah. So he's a lame duck and he wants to go out with a bang. So before his term ends, he's like, you know what? I'm going to get this guy. And on November 16th, 1960, Hess and Dummett, the deputies, picked up Wieger at his apartment and drove him to the courthouse for more interrogation.
Speaker 1And Sheriff Utsi got a justice.
Speaker 3Of the peace, like the people that marry people that, you know, like have a last minute desire to get married on the courthouse steps. Like a circuit judge is supposed to get this kind of warrant issued. He got a justice of the peace. Clearly somebody he just knew that he knew could sign off on this thing.
Speaker 2Yeah, the justice of the peace was the local grocer. Not the person that is supposed to issue warrants for a triple homicide kind of case, right? So that in and of itself, it's like, come on. How did this stuff stand, right? Well, we're about to get to the part where we explain how it stood or standed.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And we should mention triple homicide plus warrants. They did pin those two crimes on him from the Matheson State Park from six months previous.
Speaker 2Yeah. Two armed robberies and one of them involved a sexual assault, too. So, yeah, he was in big, big trouble. But they interrogated him again. I don't remember if this is the second or the third time they put him through a marathon interrogation. But there was something that I think Dummit, the deputy, kept saying, which was, if you confess... You're just going to they're going to go easy on you because you confess. They're going to give you a life sentence. You're going to be up for parole after
Speaker 214 years. You'll get out and that'll be that. If you don't confess, you're going to get convicted and they're going to execute you in the electric chair. That was basically the main theme of this this next eight hour interrogation. And then to kind of pile on, they brought in his wife and his parents to, I guess, talk to him and say, you know, confess. And that's not what they did. In fact, Herschel Wager, his father, asked the sheriff to stop questioning him because he wanted to go
Speaker 2get a lawyer. Again, this is before Miranda rights existed. So that didn't actually have any effect. It was just the sheriff ignoring that. And the questioning continued.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And eight hours into this interrogation, just before two in the morning. Uyghur confesses. And the next day they make a big show out of it. They get the press involved. They bring him out to the canyon where the murders happen and said, tell your story, Chester. And on camera, Chester said, you know what? I was at the canyon. I was looking to rob somebody. I grabbed, you know, either the camera or the binoculars that they had. They fought me back. And then, and this part gets super fishy. He said, then I convinced them to keep going further
Speaker 3into the canyon so I could get out of there and escape. Tied him up with twine and Murphy broke free from the twine and attacked me with those binoculars. So I hit her with this tree limb here, dragged her back there and killed the other two with the tree limb and then took their undergarments because I wanted to make it look like they had been sexually assaulted.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2So apparently under this story, he, killed Murphy with the tree limb and the other two women waited around for their turn. So one of the other things, besides from him saying like he talked them into going further into the woods with this guy who had already attacked them, he was not a big guy. He was very slight. He was not tall. And it's three healthy women could have probably, I don't know if easy is the right word, but they could have almost certainly overpowered him. Like if
Speaker 2they had attacked him, He probably would not have come out on top in a way that he could have bound all three women separately. You know, so there was that was a big that was a really hard to believe story that he gave.
Speaker 1Your Honor, I object. Speculation.
Speaker 2Right. Yeah. Sorry about that, everybody. That's what I would say if I were a lawyer. I'd say sorry about that, everybody. Sorry. Well, there was an objection.
Speaker 1We're podcasters, so we get to talk about our opinions. All these years later.
Speaker 2That's true. Hey, a good lawyer can fit an opinion in and you don't even know it was an opinion. That's how slick that lawyer is. And that's the lawyer you want. And you can tell who can do it because they wear shark skin suits.
Speaker 1That's right. And because you've seen it on Law and Order.
Speaker 3So they asked Chester Weger why he dragged them under, you know, into that cave, basically. And he said, well, I saw an airplane, like a red and white airplane, and I thought it was a police plane.
Speaker 1And police were like, yep, we had a plane overhead. It checks out.
Speaker 2That's the weirdest part, though. He said that he saw a plane and they confirmed that there was a plane over the park that day that matched the description of the plane he saw. I think for people who think he might be guilty, I think that's the tidbit that makes them think that.
Speaker 1Well, not me. And I'll explain why right after this.
Speaker 4So OK, Chuck, lay it on us.
Speaker 2Why?
Speaker 3I think that they were clearly trying to get him to confess. They knew that they had a police helicopter that they could like prove had been flying over there. So they were like, tell him that that you were afraid that there was this police like they fed him everything to say.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3And it was like, tell him about this police helicopter, because then it would look like, yep, look, we have a flight log right here.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1Seems obvious to me.
Speaker 2That's because that's the one piece that kind of doesn't fit the narrative that they were they had overpowered him and coerced him into a false confession.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Of course, that that makes the most sense that they fed him that line, too. Right.
Speaker 1I mean, it seems like.
Speaker 2Yeah, for sure. The reason it stood out to me is because nothing about the coercion up to that point seems to have been that sophisticated. You know what I mean?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, I guess I don't think that's sophisticated.
Speaker 2Oh, OK. I think it's like the New Yorker guy, Eustace. I can't remember his last name. That's how sophisticated it seems to me.
Speaker 1All right.
Speaker 2All right.
Speaker 3So he gets indicted, like we said, on those three counts, plus the one six months earlier in the other park. He gets a public defender. And the next day he's like, hey, listen. I didn't do this. I wasn't at the canyon. They threatened me to sign this confession. And they fed me all these details, including that airplane.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2So there's a new state's attorney.
Speaker 1A new sheriff in town?
Speaker 2Well, no, the sheriff's the same, but the state's attorney's the same. Harlan Warren, like you said, lost his election. I saw largely because of his opponent, is pointing out how the case hadn't been solved, right? So the new guy, Robert E. Richardson, was kind of inexperienced. He took over the lead prosecutor role in the trial, but he had an assistant, Anthony Recuglia, and he had never handled a murder case before. Now suddenly he's helping with a triple homicide.
Speaker 2And they did something pretty shrewd, I think. They only filed charges against him against Uyghur in the murder of Lillian Oding. And the reason why is that they figured that if there was a mistrial or an acquittal, they had two more shots at getting him on a murder rap. I thought that was pretty clever.
Speaker 1Yeah, and I think fairly standard.
Speaker 2I wouldn't have thought of that. I would make a terrible lawyer. Sure, I could rock a sharkskin suit, but I don't think I would actually be that great in the courtroom.
Speaker 1No, you're not. Neither one of us are attorneys in making, you know? No. In making? In waiting? Is that what I'm trying to say?
Speaker 2I don't know if that's what they call them. Attorneys in waiting?
Speaker 3I don't know.
Speaker 1You know what I mean. We're not cut out for it.
Speaker 2There you go.
Speaker 1I was trying to be fancy.
Speaker 3So they tried to get, you know, the public defender tries to get the confession thrown out immediately.
Speaker 1That's not going to happen.
Speaker 3Like I mentioned, there's really not a lot in the way of physical evidence tying him to the scene. So the confession was really all they had. So they weren't going to let them throw that out. And then Recuglia, the assistant, I guess- D.A., or at least he was assisting on this this job in 2010.
Speaker 1Many years later, he was like, you know what?
Speaker 3What Weger said out there and how he described these killings, like none of that really made any sense. I didn't think it was very believable, but he admitted to it. So, you know, that's all that mattered.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2He said that was enough for me.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 2So Weger took the stand to defend himself. He was there for three hours. I can't imagine getting grilled for three minutes, let alone three hours on the stand.
Speaker 1You would crack so fast.
Speaker 2Yeah, totally. I'd be sweating through my sharkskin suit. Yeah. That's three. He stuck with the story the whole time. He kept saying like the deputies had threatened him into confessing. He was worried about losing his life. Yeah. And he had also that sexual assault charge against him when he was 12 or 13. He said that he had been told that he would get off on probation if he admitted to it. And that's why he admitted to it. Yeah. This is, you know, he'd gone through this before.
Speaker 1Crazy.
Speaker 2Yeah. So despite that, after 10 hours of deliberation across, I think, two days, the jury came back and they said guilty, guilty, guilty of just one murder. But they said it three times. Yeah.
Speaker 3And this part I don't fully understand. Like you sent that stuff that said they sentenced him to life in prison is like. would be harsher for an avid outdoorsman to live his life like in a cell than to be put to death. Yeah.
Speaker 1But was this at a time where juries were deciding, were sentencing?
Speaker 2I guess. And I don't know if that was just Illinois state law or what, but that's what I saw.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2I saw it in a, I think the Chicago Tribune magazine did like a really long, exhaustive article on this a few years back. And I think that's where I saw that. So I'm going with that guy.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And, you know, we leaned a lot on that. So hats off to the Chicago Tribune magazine. Sure.
Speaker 1And if there are any experts in early 1960s Illinois state law, let us know.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2Criminal law, not civil.
Speaker 1Yeah, not civil. Although I have a few questions there, too.
Speaker 2Sorry. Is there a will you're trying to crack?
Speaker 1Don't ask.
Speaker 2So get this. This is this is terrible. Harlan Warren, the original state's attorney for LaSalle County. That's how you say it in Illinois. He claimed $ 11, 500 of the reward money, about $ 125, 000 worth today. It was his job to prosecute this guy. I guess because he took up his own cause and investigated the twine that was worth $ 125, 000. I would think that you would automatically be ineligible from taking
Speaker 2part of the money, wouldn't you? Ding, ding, ding.
Speaker 3This is the one that stood out to me. The two deputies each got five thousand dollars as well.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3So to me, this this this is everything I need to know about this case, that the two deputies and the and the attorney general got reward money for this.
Speaker 1A ton of it.
Speaker 2I figured it was the police plane sighting. That was the one that blew it open for you. This is it, huh?
Speaker 1No, this is it. These guys made money off of this.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's just wrong. Even taking away like the optics of it. Yeah. You know, people in the corporate world would say, this is like, it seems just immoral at its face.
Speaker 1Yeah, for sure.
Speaker 2But they did. They got that money. And of course, Weger appealed the conviction immediately. And I saw that he was basically pretty confident that like justice would prevail. And it turned out Time and time and time again. If Chester Weeger was innocent, as he definitely seems to have been, justice did not prevail over and over.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3In 62, the Illinois Supreme Court denied him a new trial. They didn't consider the case in 1971. The U.S. Supreme Court decided not to hear the case in 1977. In 63, backing up a bit, the county dropped the charges for those other crimes from the other state parks six months later. Because they're like, you know, he's in jail for life now. Six years after he's sentenced, this is one of the saddest parts. He tells his wife, he's like, you know what?
Speaker 3I'll grant you a divorce. Like you need to move on with your life.
Speaker 2Stand up guy.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2And good for her, too. She hung in there for the first six years until he said that, too. So I think she was going to go the distance.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2In prison, he really kind of took advantage any way he could of the time that he had there. He got his GED. Remember, I think, like you said, he dropped out in eighth grade. He excelled at bookbinding, which is pretty awesome. I'll bet that's kind of a neat little craft. And he also studied history, philosophy, read the Bible. He taught himself oil painting. Sadly, he would often paint woodland scenes, which... That just kind of hurts right there.
Speaker 2And his sister stood by him from the moment he got convicted to, you know, to the very end. So she even helped him with his petitions for parole over the years, too.
Speaker 1Yeah, for sure. Great sister.
Speaker 3He very sadly missed his parents, like deathbeds and funerals. When he became eligible in 72 for parole, it sort of started that Shawshank Redemption thing with Red where They're in there and they're like, hey, you know, all you got to do is admit this thing and express remorse and like maybe we'll let you out. And every single time he's like, no, I didn't do this. I'm not going to admit remorse for something I didn't do. And that Recuglia guy was always on the other side arguing like,
Speaker 3don't let this guy out. And then in 2002, that same guy, Recuglia, admitted to a local paper that, hey, by the way, there was some evidence that we didn't share. which is highly illegal, by the way, that Oding had been sexually assaulted because he gave the story of like an attempted robbery and that he faked like they had been sexually assaulted.
Speaker 1So we just kind of I guess we just kind of buried that.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2I mean, that's just that's insane that they didn't immediately give him a new trial in 2002 or overturn it or do something after that became.
Speaker 1Yeah, for sure.
Speaker 2But nothing happened court-wise or legally with it. But that admission apparently got a lot more attention than I think Recuglia had expected it to. Because, you know, this is a local paper. They also found over the years that there had been some hairs that had been found inside Francis Murphy's glove. And astoundingly, both both hairs had their roots intact, which strongly suggested that they had been pulled out. Yeah,
Speaker 2probably by her, probably during the struggle that ended her life. And luckily for Chester Weeger, he ended up with a new public defender in 2004. Her name is Donna Kelly, and she was adamant that he was innocent and very capable and dogged. So he was she was just the kind of public defender he needed. Just, you know, 40 years too late. Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean, I think she this is a pretty well-known case of like potential miscarriage of justice. So I think I saw that Donna Kelly like wanted to get on this case. So she was like, he's not the guy. We have these hairs. Can we get some DNA tests done? There were on that the hairs and the blood on the jacket. And the county was like, hey, you know what? We we basically treated that evidence as a show and tell. whenever journalists and students came through. And so the judge
Speaker 3was like, nah, you know what? Because of that, it's probably too likely to be tainted. They had several governors throughout this whole time that refused clemency petitions that people were like rabidly signing up for. Kelly filed one in 2004. And in this one, Weger changed the story. He was like, you know, that alibi, I don't think we said initially, he said he was in the basement of the lodge writing a letter. He said, no, actually I was with my coworker, Stanley, And we had driven into Oglesby so I could get a haircut. And the barber was like, yeah,
Speaker 3Chester Weger came in that day to get a haircut. And he said, I told this story to begin with to the investigators, but I changed my story because they talked to my buddy Stanley because he was a suspect as well. And he was like, you know, I guess he got scared and he wouldn't back him.
Speaker 1Up on it.
Speaker 2Yeah. So he went back to his original alibi. This 2004 petition for clemency is also where he said that he had had a gun held to his head by Dummit, who pulled the trigger, and that Yutzi hit him with a billy club and some other stuff, right? So you would think this is kind of a slam dunk, especially considering everything that just seemed fishy from the outset. And Rod Blagojevich was like, I got too many of my own problems. I can't even read this clemency petition. I'm assuming.
Speaker 2So he denied it in 2007. But because of this clemency petition and all the new stuff, and because it was such a well-known case, a lot more public attention was drawn to it. And so more and more people are starting to kind of beat the drum and get involved to try to get this guy to get his conviction overturned.
Speaker 3Yeah, including maybe a surprising person that's entering the chat, David Recuglia, Anthony Recuglia's son. You might be thinking he took up for his old man.
Speaker 1No, he didn't.
Speaker 3He thought Chester Uyghur was innocent. And he met with him and started shooting video about the case. And there was an HBO documentary in 2021 about these murders that I was really hoping to see before that I couldn't. I wasn't able to. But a lot of that footage ended up in the documentary. So I thought that was a pretty interesting twist.
Speaker 2Yeah, for sure. Because he had been raised to think of Chester Uyghur as the boogeyman by his father. So that is, I mean, just a To be able to admit that not only you were wrong, but your father was wrong, too. That's amazing. So in 2019, Uyghur had his 24th request for parole. And despite still not expressing remorse or saying that he had committed the crimes, this time by a vote of nine to four, they let him out. In 2020, at age 80, he went in
Speaker 2when the crimes were committed. He was 21.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 3So after that, he, you know, he was out, but he you still want to prove you're innocent. So he continued to fight for that. He had a couple of pro bono attorneys and Andy Hale and Celeste Stack. And they actually got permission, you know, that the bloodstains and the hairs and stuff, they were finally able to run those through modern DNA bases.
Speaker 1And they were like.
Speaker 3This stuff is pretty well preserved, like they're in protective slides. It looks like they were pretty well taken care of. And the findings were as of three years ago, using genealogical databases was like, hey, these hairs came from a family that had several brothers living at Starved Rock at the times of the killing. And these guys are all dead by now. And they wouldn't reveal like who the family was or which family member that they came from. But they were basically like this kind of proves like to us. that he didn't do it, because these were
Speaker 3not Chester Wieger's hairs.
Speaker 2Right. And in fact, I think in June 2025, they ruled that the DNA evidence weren't enough to get the guilty verdict thrown out. And so he filed another motion to reconsider, and the judge said, no, again, no. And so very sadly, Chester Wieger died of cancer when he was 86, I think in the last year, maybe in 2025. And what makes it even sadder is that he had said during interviews that he didn't want to die while
Speaker 2people still thought that he'd killed those women. And he did. He had gotten out of prison. A parole board said, we believe you, at least. And a lot of people in the public had. But officially, he was still convicted of at least one of those three murders and assumed to have committed the other ones because he was convicted of the first one. He served 58 years in prison, which apparently is the all-time record, which is a dubious record if there ever was one.
Speaker 3So did you see that the parole board thought he was innocent? Or was it just, you know, time served, you can get out now?
Speaker 2That's a good question. I assumed that they had changed their mind about his guilt. That was my take, but I'm just guessing. I just surmised.
Speaker 1Okay, because in Shawshank, they let Red out. They knew he did it.
Speaker 2I don't remember that movie quite as well as you do.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3You know, he goes in at the end, Morgan Freeman, and he's like has that big speech about I could come in here and tried out the same old lines and all that stuff.
Speaker 1And and they let him out. Huh.
Speaker 3He talked about being a dumb young man who did the crime and he's not that guy anymore. And so they gave him clemency.
Speaker 2Was that the first time that he had ever admitted it?
Speaker 1No, I don't. Actually, I don't know. I haven't seen that movie in a long time. That's a good question. We'll investigate this further.
Speaker 2Well, let's pause here and go watch it real quick and come back and finish.
Speaker 1Well, there were.
Speaker 3Some interesting and some kind of wacky ideas about other theories over the years. The one that I find interesting and potentially true, who knows, is that these prominent husbands, as it turns out, were working with the Chicago Crime Commission, which was fighting organized crime. And LaSalle County was a very mobbed up crime scene. And there were two witnesses that actually testified that people affiliated with the Chicago mob told them that this was a paid hit and a
Speaker 3judge dismissed it as hearsay.
Speaker 1So to me, that's sort of a big one.
Speaker 2Really, I found that one the least believable because they were bludgeoned with a tree limb, which obviously is just a handy murder weapon. So if it was a contract killing, I don't think that they would have just been beaten with a tree limb. You know what I mean?
Speaker 1Unless they were trying to make it look like it wasn't a contract killing.
Speaker 2I guess, but yeah, I guess.
Speaker 1That's what I thought.
Speaker 2The one that stood out to me the most was that the son of the Starved Rock Lodge operator at the time, the guy who had said that he'd seen two men in a car talking to three women on a road in the park years before, after Donna Kelly presented her initial arguments that started to blow the case open back in 2005, he killed himself. He shot himself. It was just two weeks later. And even Donna Kelly said in the press that she found that exceedingly suspicious.
Speaker 2But on the other hand, he had been diagnosed with cancer a few months earlier. And people who knew him had said that he had been talking about the fact that he had cancer now. And so it was clearly on his mind. So who knows? There doesn't seem to be any good answer for who did it aside from probably what Andy Hale said. that family that Andy Hale apparently is one of the only people who knows hair turned up in that DNA test.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2It's weird to still not be like, okay, everybody know it was not the mob. It was this, there was this family, but I also get, if you can't say it was this specific member of this family, you wouldn't, you know, that's why you wouldn't release the family's name.
Speaker 1Yeah. Plus they had passed away. So, you know, that's not too cool to do either.
Speaker 2No. Well, that's Chester Wieger. It's not fully fulfilling. I'm glad that he got out of prison, but I hate that he died like six years later, which is just it's just a sad story, man. There's not really a good ending to it.
Speaker 1No.
Speaker 2Well, let's not even try. Let's just go to listener mail.
Speaker 1All right. This is about motion smoothing.
Speaker 3Hey, guys, out of the 13 years I've spent listening, I never thought my first note would be about the rage inducing topic of TV motion smoothing. Chuck mentioned how much he hates it on hotel TVs in the Nickelodeon episode. I couldn't agree more. The soap opera effect is getting out of control. I have zero shame when I'm not at my house to take control of the remote of friends and family members and strangers as they watch in confusion as I navigate the multitude of menus to turn off that abhorrent feature.
Speaker 1It's so frustrating. And I'll just stop watching.
Speaker 3TV if I don't have the ability to do anything about it. And by the way, Travis, I'm with you, bud. When I was at my in-laws years ago and They would put on movies with this. I would just read a book.
Speaker 1In the same room. Can't do it. But Josh, you're not alone.
Speaker 3Those same people who let me do my little song and dance, updating their TVs to the way things should be also said they're confused, claiming they just don't see a difference. My working theory is that this is the cilantro of the TV frame rate world. You're either violently one side or the other, and there's no in between. Anyway, thanks for keeping me entertained all these years. Had I not been on a cruise for the solar eclipse this year, Super cool stuff at sea would have been high on my list of to do's. And that is from Travis Bolinas in Boise, Idaho.
Speaker 2Thanks a lot, Travis. That was a great email. I think you should quickly describe what the heck motion smoothing is to people who don't know me.
Speaker 1Yeah, it's a setting that comes.
Speaker 3A lot of TVs come out of the box like set to this for some ungodly reason. But it's they change the frame rate. of the original product that it was shot in to, I guess, smooth it out. And it ends up looking like this hyper real, like a soap opera, like you are in the room with the highest def camera, like with.
Speaker 1Them as you're shooting it.
Speaker 3And it doesn't look like, you know, something that somebody filmed at 24 frames per second any longer.
Speaker 2I remember the first time I saw that, it was like there was a person standing in the box that was the TV. Like you could go up to the TV and put your hands on the outside and look in and see their feet or something like that. But I got used to it so quickly. I don't know. I don't remember what it was like before that.
Speaker 1Are you sure your TVs are still set to that?
Speaker 2I don't know. I'll have to check. I looked the other day and I was like, I can't find the setting. And then I think I fell asleep before I could.
Speaker 1Text you that. Yeah.
Speaker 3As listeners are falling asleep now. Different manufacturers have it listed under different things. So, hey, next time I'm over there, I'll check it out for you.
Speaker 4All right.
Speaker 3Great.
Speaker 2Thanks, man. Well, if you want to get in touch with us like Travis from Boise did and let us hear you vent your spleen, we love that kind of thing. You can send us an email to stuffpodcasts at iheartradio.com. Stuff You Should Know is a production of iHeartRadio.
Speaker 1For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, visit the iHeartRadio app. Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your favorite shows.
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Buffets are every kid’s dream - until they grow up enough to realize how gross communal spreads of food shared with strangers actually are. Then the dream is dashed, for most of us at least. Learn about the golden age...
Today Josh and Chuck get into the super cool job of sign language interpreting.
Yes, clouds have weight - and a lot of it, too! Find out why and how you can guess the weight of a cloud right from the comfort of your own backyard!
Turkeys are a very interesting bird as it turns out. Which may be why many people are leaving it off their Thanksgiving table this year. Learn all about them right now in this classic episode!
Are there any cuddlier amphibious mammals than manatees in the heavyweight class? No, there aren’t. And what makes manatees even better is that their demeanor and approach to life exactly match how they appear - gentle,...