Throughout the history of the world, there have been many cases of what is known as collective hysteria - groups of people, usually young women, who all exhibit the same physical symptoms of non-existent conditions. Is it psychosomatic? Is it group think?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey everybody and welcome to the Stuff You Should Know Gets Weird playlist. This is another one of our quarterly playlists, everyone, that we compile because we found that people like us sort of grouping things and bucketing things and cataloging things into groups of 10 to 12. And I think we have 11 of them this time out. And we're getting started this week with the inaugural episode of the Stuff You Should Know Gets Weird playlist with our episode, What is Collective Hysteria? So please give a listen and enjoy it.
Speaker 2Welcome to Stuff You Should Know from HowStuffWorks.com.
Speaker 3Hey, and welcome to the podcast. I'm Josh Clark. With me, as always, is Charles W. Chuck Bryant. And Jerry's over there to the left. And that makes this Stuff You Should Know.
Speaker 4Got the A-team in the hizzy.
Speaker 3I call face.
Speaker 1What?
Speaker 3I'm face.
Speaker 4Oh, of course you're face. Look at you. I would be a combination of Murdoch and Mr. T, I think. Yeah.
Speaker 3Well, your hair is kind of spiky in the middle today.
Speaker 4Yeah. Jerry, I don't know what she'd be. I guess she'd be the leader. She'd be Hannibal.
Speaker 3Oh, yeah.
Speaker 4You know?
Speaker 3She's smoking a cigar right now.
Speaker 4And wearing a black glove.
Speaker 3When did you start smoking cigars, Jerry?
Speaker 4That's weird.
Speaker 3Very timely.
Speaker 4I said A-team. I don't want to slag off guest producer Noel. He's not exactly B-team. No. We'll just call ourselves the OGs.
Speaker 3Okay. Now that we have that established, we are the OGs.
Speaker 4That's right.
Speaker 3We need bowling shirts that say as much on the back. You feeling good?
Speaker 4I'm feeling nauseous and dizzy.
Speaker 3Oh, well, Chuck, did you happen to see somebody else who is nauseous and dizzy?
Speaker 4Well, Jerry was last week, and then a few more people in the office, so I just figured we all had the same thing.
Speaker 3All right. I'm going to diagnose this.
Speaker 4Okay.
Speaker 3It's called collective hysteria, also known, I think... more appropriately, is mass psychogenic disorder.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3I think when you add the word hysteria to this, it takes on certain dimensions that a lot of people could find very objectionable.
Speaker 3Yeah, but I think it has a definite gender-specific connotation to it from over the years. Like, women were supposedly very hysterical. So, the idea of diagnosing somebody as hysterical under any circumstances is kind of a tad amount to patting them on the head.
Speaker 4Yeah, here, nice lady, you're just a little hysterical. You just go calm down and bake something. Right.
Speaker 3Stop being crazy. No, mass psychogenic disorder instead is just kind of like, whoa, your brain just did something pretty neat.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And that is the case for mass psychogenic disorder, if you ask me. In this article, Chuck, written by Jacob Silverman.
Speaker 4Jeopardy champion.
Speaker 3Yeah, well, yeah. Yeah, he won on Jeopardy. That makes him a champion, right?
Speaker 4Yeah, I think so. He wasn't, like, the ultimate champion, but he won a couple of episodes.
Speaker 3Right, which is why they should have a word for, I guess, like, champion is, like, the one who won it all.
Speaker 4Ken Jennings.
Speaker 3Yeah, or Watson.
Speaker 4Who's that?
Speaker 3The IBM computer.
Speaker 4Oh, well, yeah, sure.
Speaker 3So Jeopardy winner Jacob Silverman wrote this article years back, and he did a pretty great job of citing... a, uh, contemporary outbreak of mass psychogenic disorder that had been going on around that time down in Mexico, down Mexico way in Chalco, Mexico at a boarding school there. Uh, it apparently was a girl's boarding school and the girls that went to school, they were ages 12 to 17 and all of a sudden they started, uh, well, there was an outbreak, a weird outbreak. There was vomiting, I believe,
Speaker 3trouble walking, um, There was fever. Yeah. That's weird.
Speaker 4Nausea.
Speaker 3And so the people running this boarding school were like, what's going on? This is not good.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And they had no idea. The girls went on Christmas break for 10 days, came back, and the thing just took off again like wildfire.
Speaker 4Yeah. 600 of the 3,600 girls showed these symptoms and nobody could figure it out. They did a lot of tests. They brought in people to like check out the facilities. Yeah. Because as you'll see, there's a trend there. You know, here in the West, they start to blame it usually on like environmental poisoning of some kind.
Speaker 3Right. You know, there's some sort of toxin present that has poisoned everybody.
Speaker 4But they didn't find anything there. And eventually they said this is. what'd you call it? Psychosomatic?
Speaker 3Mass psychogenic disorder.
Speaker 4Okay. Mass psychogenic disorder.
Speaker 3But no, that is one of the names. Mass psychogenic disorder, collective hysteria, mass hysteria, or mass psychosomatic reaction.
Speaker 4Yeah. They're all saying the same thing.
Speaker 3They are.
Speaker 4Which is you're not, well, I was about to say you're not really sick, but that is not exactly true because that's one thing that differentiates this from something that's just in your head is you actually do manifest physical symptoms.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3There's this article written by a MD named Timothy F. Jones from the Tennessee Department of Health way back in the heady days of 2000, the year 2000, the future.
Speaker 4Wow.
Speaker 3And he writes that if you are experiencing mass psychogenic disorder, it is not just in your head. that the symptoms that you have are actually very real. Even though there's no toxic cause, they couldn't find some sort of environmental poisoning or anything like that, the symptoms are extremely real.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3It's just psychosomatic. It's just basically the brain has been tricked into causing this response.
Speaker 4Yeah, and this has happened. They've documented about 80 cases throughout history, and apparently the National Institutes of Health gets about two cases per week reported.
Speaker 3But, um, which is, I mean, like that's, that's way more common than, than you would think.
Speaker 4You know? Yeah. I would think there'd be more than 80. Cause I mean, these have happened. If you go back and look at, I mean, there's all sorts of crazy lists on the internet about these cases that date back to like the 14th century.
Speaker 3Medieval dancing mania was one of them.
Speaker 4Yeah. The dancing plague. Yeah. Yeah. That's in there.
Speaker 3Uh, the Salem witchcraft trials.
Speaker 4Sure.
Speaker 3Or the Salem witchcraft, I guess what led to the trials was, um, supposedly attributed to this kind of thing.
Speaker 4Yeah. One weird thing about this condition is more times than not, it affects females.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4And young females, even more specifically, teenagers or even younger.
Speaker 3Which is, as far as it goes right now, inexplicable. And it's kind of a prickly issue, you know? Like, again, you kind of come back to the idea of calling it hysteria. Yeah. The fact that it does tend to afflict women or girls more than boys is apparently one means of diagnosing psychogenic disorder, mass psychogenic disorder.
Speaker 4Yeah, that's like one of the first things they'll say is like all this sickness is happening in this place, this school, wherever. And the doctor will say, is it a bunch of girls? Yeah. And then that will clue them in that, hey, this might be what we're dealing with here.
Speaker 3But the problem is no one has any idea why. And there have been explanations of things like, I guess, this is girls' culturally acceptable outlet for raging against the patriarchy.
Speaker 4Sure.
Speaker 3Even if they don't necessarily feel that that's what they're doing, this is the symptoms of that. That's one.
Speaker 4Yeah. I thought this was a pretty interesting part. What article? Is that from Slate?
Speaker 3There was one called Mass hysteria in upstate New York by Ruth Graham was on slate. That was a good one.
Speaker 4It was a really good one. We'll get to that case in a sec. But I thought it was pretty interesting. In one part it says, and this is a quote from someone writing about something, it said, inform, if not in conscious intent, it is to protest the sexual repressiveness, rigid double standard of female teen culture. But they were writing about Beatlemania.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4Which is interesting because it sort of has a similar vibe Of young ladies being repressed, not having an outlet. And so they see the Beatles and they go berserk and faint and cry and scream collectively. Whereas boys, they're more prone to just act out if they're not feeling good. Girls are trained to keep things inward. And they also point out that ladies and young ladies are more prone to seek a doctor's help for something. They say that may account for the bias right there.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 4Like guys just won't go to the doctor.
Speaker 3Exactly. You have to be careful, though, in just diagnosing mass psychogenic disorder. You physicians out there who are listening that encounter a case like this, just by basing it on the fact that it is affecting more girls than boys, because there's at least one case in Great Britain where I think girls were afflicted by more than half, more than double the number of girls were afflicted by this. And it turned out that there were tainted cucumbers being served in the lunchroom.
Speaker 4Yeah. And everyone knows boys hate cucumbers.
Speaker 3So they didn't eat any. Right. But this is one of the issues with dealing with mass psychogenic disorder in that it looks and acts a lot like some sort of weird epidemic. That basically it looks like either something like bioterrorism. a rapidly spreading infection, or affection if it's fetal mania, and then acute toxic exposure. That's what it looks like. It's like one person gets sick. This is
Speaker 3your index case. And all of a sudden, everyone around them suddenly has the same symptoms.
Speaker 4Yeah, and it's, like you said, it's super dangerous to just dismiss that as, oh, it's all in your head, silly little ladies. You can't do that because what if it is something for real? But it's also a double-edged sword, as that doctor pointed out. You start ordering batteries of tests, and it can go both ways. It can, what the old saying is, if you order enough tests, you're going to find something.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 4So it can fuel that fire, but you also can't not run any tests and just dismiss it. So it's a very fine line that physicians walk when dealing with stuff like this, for sure.
Speaker 3Indeed. Apparently, study of mass psychogenic disorder has found that it's more prevalent in isolated communities.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And in situations where there are highly rigid, formalized, structured rules.
Speaker 4Like a Catholic school in Mexico.
Speaker 3Exactly.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Or, again, Salem, Massachusetts in the 17th century.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3You know, and apparently between 1973 and 1993, half of all the outbreaks of psychogenic illness took place in schools.
Speaker 4Oh, yeah.
Speaker 3So that's possibly in part due to kids being susceptible to it more.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3But also because of that rigid formalized structure.
Speaker 4Yeah, and there's also usually a top-down effect, like it'll start with a teacher or an older student, and then the younger students follow suit, which, if you're talking influence, would make sense for sure.
Speaker 3There was one very famous case. Apparently, there's not very many actual academic studies on this. Yeah. But there's one that came out of the New England Journal of Medicine that described a case in 1998 in Tennessee where a teacher... noticed some weird gas odor, a gassy odor.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Like the chemical kind.
Speaker 4Yeah, not like the guy on the front row tooted.
Speaker 3Right, exactly.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And she apparently started suffering symptoms. And all of a sudden, like 180 students and teachers had to go to the emergency room. The school was shut down for two weeks. They did all this environmental testing, couldn't find anything.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And finally- traced it back to a mass psychogenic disorder. That's what did it.
Speaker 4And then everyone, in most of these cases, we should point out, everyone starts feeling better.
Speaker 3Yes.
Speaker 4Like in Mexico and then the school in Tennessee, it's not like they went on to die or anything.
Speaker 3Yeah, so in the school in Mexico, these girls were at a boarding school.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3They were only allowed to see their parents, I think, like three times a year.
Speaker 4Yeah, they couldn't even call. It's like, it sounds more like a prison. Right.
Speaker 3No phone calls. They were allowed letters. When they went home, immediately their symptoms cleared up.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3The problem is that doesn't automatically say, oh, well, it's obviously mass psychogenic disorder. It could be an environmental toxin that they were being exposed to still.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3At the school and were removed from, but I think the... Definite prognosis is mass psychogenic disorder in this case.
Speaker 4That's right. What we're talking about is a sort of version of the nocebo effect, which we've talked about before, and we will get into that right after this break. So the nocebo effect, we talked about that in what?
Speaker 3The placebo effect.
Speaker 4Oh, well, that makes sense. Yeah. I was... Trying to be more clever. Thought we were more clever than that. Nocebo, I think we said in that other podcast too, is Latin for I shall harm. And that's basically, whereas you take a placebo thinking it's going to help you out, and it does help you out because the mind is powerful. The nocebo effect is thinking something bad will result. Like my teacher's getting sick. I think I feel a little sick too. And then, oh wait, my neighbor's feeling a little sick. I think I'm feeling a little sick too.
Speaker 3Or this drug trial that I'm on. I was told that I could, possibly get some sort of gastrointestinal distress. Yeah. And even though I've been given a sugar pill, I'm now going, yeah, because of my mind, because of the nocebo effect.
Speaker 4There was a famous experiment or case from 1886 where there was a woman who had a rose allergy and they showed her an artificial rose and she began to, I guess it was convincing, and she began to have her allergic reaction And they said, aha, it's fake. And you're faking. And she said, oh, well, I think I'm feeling better now. And supposedly that cured her of her real allergy to real roses.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 4I couldn't find a lot to back that up. But it is a story.
Speaker 3Yeah, well, no. I mean, it was in, I can't remember the journal.
Speaker 4Oh, it really was?
Speaker 3Yeah, it was a real deal thing. And I didn't get to the bottom of why. They presented this woman with a fake rose or whatever, but they definitely didn't. This definitely happened. Yeah. And even the author of the study was saying, like, this woman, she wasn't faking.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3It was like she had real symptoms. Sure.
Speaker 4Hives are hives.
Speaker 3Exactly.
Speaker 4You can see those.
Speaker 3I think they call it like a rose cold or something like that. You can get, you know, stuffy.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Your eyes are watering, your nose is running, that kind of thing. And what's interesting is some researchers have studied the nocebo effect, and they basically have isolated this chemical that gets released when the nocebo effect's going on. And again, we should say it's not just making your nose runny or releasing histamines or anything like that. It's pain, too. You can experience pain even though nothing's there to give
Speaker 3you pain just because of the nocebo effect. What they found was a, I guess, a hormone, I believe. Are you ready? I'm going to try this one. Cholecystokinin.
Speaker 4That sounds great.
Speaker 3Thanks, man.
Speaker 4I haven't looked at the word, but it sounds right.
Speaker 3Cholecystokinin.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Do you see it now?
Speaker 1Oh, yeah.
Speaker 4That's totally right.
Speaker 3I totally did. So it's a hormone, right? And it gets released, and it actually helps you experience pain. So it's a nasty little hormone.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3But they found in testing with the nocebo effect that if you block this, you can also block the nocebo effect. So that proves two things.
Speaker 4Does that block pain though? Yes. Like your pain receptors? Yes. So does that mean if you slam your hand in a door, you won't feel it?
Speaker 3If you can block this.
Speaker 4Wow.
Speaker 3Yes. So if you can block cholecystokinin.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3Yes. It will keep you from hypersensitivity to pain, I believe.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And this guy named Fabrizio Benedetti, who I think was also in the strokes, back in 1997. There was a Fabrizio, right?
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3He was testing out the nocebo effect and found that if he told people that he was giving them an injection, which is a pretty cruel test, but effective. Yeah. These post-op people who had just come out of surgery were given an injection and told this injection is going to increase your pain in 30 minutes. I'm sorry, we have to give it to you. It's part of the procedure. He gave some people an injection of saline and they reported an increase in pain.
Speaker 4And they all went behind the two-way mirror and laughed. Right.
Speaker 3They're like, what a chump.
Speaker 4Look at him writhing.
Speaker 3And then they gave somebody like the other group, the control group, a chemical, an injection that blocks that pain, but they were told that it was going to increase their pain.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3But they were given a chemical that blocks cholecystokinin and the nocebo effect didn't take place. They didn't report an increase in pain.
Speaker 4Even though they were told they would. Yes. Wow.
Speaker 3So this guy's saying like the nocebo effect is real.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Like when they say it's not just in your head.
Speaker 4Sure.
Speaker 3You're experiencing the same thing as if you were experiencing somebody stabbing you.
Speaker 4Well, what it is real, you know, that's when you have to start asking yourself those deep philosophical questions. Right. Interesting. Um, there's, uh, another case that's, have you ever seen the movie safe? The Todd Haynes movie with Julianne Moore?
Speaker 3No.
Speaker 4It's from like, uh, the mid nineties. And she played a lady that, um, started to have environmental sickness, um, just in the air. And she's got sort of like increasingly, um, crazy as the movie went on as far as scrubbing things and locking herself in her house and making her house a clean environment.
Speaker 3Sounds great.
Speaker 4It was good. And there's a true story, though, of a lady in London named Debbie Bird. She's a health spa manager that says that she's allergic to EMF, electromagnetic fields. And it's an actual thing now. You know, there's more than her claiming it's called ES, electromagnetic sensitivity, where she has... basically transformed her house. She painted it black. She said she's allergic to computers, cell phones, microwaves. She had her
Speaker 4house rewired to make it basically EMF free. She and her husband sleep under a silver plated mosquito net to keep out radio waves and covered all her windows with protective films. And she said she's feeling a lot better now.
Speaker 3So I saw that ES, electromagnetic sensitivity, that if you expose somebody to an electromagnetic field and then just tell them that you are and don't, they have the same reaction, which would suggest that it's nocebo.
Speaker 4Well, it's super fascinating because you see cases like this from that to like gluten sensitivity becoming a big thing now. And people, some people contend that, well, it's maybe a collective hysteria going on.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4If you think you're going to be sensitive to gluten, then you're going to be sensitive to things that contain gluten. And I'm not saying that, people, because that's a very hot topic.
Speaker 3Sure it is.
Speaker 4But some people have claimed that.
Speaker 3Well, we'll talk a little bit more about things that exacerbate the mass psychogenic disorder and the nocebo effect right after this. Stuff you should know. Stuff you should know. So, Chuck, back in 2007 in New Zealand, a drug called L-troxin. It was a pretty widespread drug in New Zealand. It's a hormone replacement drug. And it was the only one
Speaker 3that the government would pay for. So most people who were on this hormone replacement therapy were using L-troxin. And it had been that way for, like, decades.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3It was just an established drug. GlaxoSmithKline.
Speaker 4What was it for, though?
Speaker 3Hormone replacement.
Speaker 4Oh, okay.
Speaker 3GlaxoSmithKline.com. I think just those, there's no welcome involved, changed just the outer, the inner qualities of it, like the shape of the pill, the color. And I think that's about it. But the active ingredient was exactly the same in 2007. And when they released it, all of a sudden, some reports of bad side effects were starting to trickle in. And the government was like, wait, what's going on here?
Speaker 3It got a little bit of media attention and more reports started trickling in.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And then the media attention grew and the reports grew and grew. And apparently the reporting of adverse effects of L-troxin increased 2,000 fold in a year and a half.
Speaker 4Because of the look of the pill.
Speaker 3Because of the look of the pill.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3They went back and studied this and they found that in areas where there was more reporting about these adverse effects being reported for L-troxin, the more adverse effects were being reported in that area. And that kind of reveals one of the risk factors for mass psychogenic disorder is the media. It's actually spread through the media most easily.
Speaker 4Yeah, they have a point, though. I mean, I know in this article, too, it points out that pills that are blue and green are usually associated with drowsiness. Pills that are orange or yellow are are not, and I don't know if that's why they market it that way or if it's the opposite, is we just see it that way because of products like NyQuil and DayQuil. But the one that makes you sleepy is green and blue, and the one that keeps you awake, or not keep you awake, but doesn't make you drowsy is orange.
Speaker 3I thought about it. I think, I mean, what do you associate with, like, daytime, sunrise, yellow, orange, red?
Speaker 4It totally makes sense.
Speaker 3What do you associate with nighttime? Like, something tranquil, like blue.
Speaker 4Oh, yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, scotch amber. Uh, yeah, you, I mean, you think of, uh, that's what I, I, I think it came from, I think the pills came after the association rather than the other way around.
Speaker 4Yeah. I think I even, like when I get a prescription for something, when I see the pill, I make a judgment on it before I've even had it just by saying, wow, look at that thing. It's heavy.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4That's a horse pill or that's a capsule with, uh, you know, powdery stuff inside that's different than the chalky one. It's you. I think you just make an association. I don't think I have any preconceived notions on what a larger pill will do to me.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 4Or a capsule will do to me other than a tablet. But I think it's interesting, though, how you make these judgment calls.
Speaker 3But without even thinking about it.
Speaker 4Yeah, totally.
Speaker 3You know, I mean, like you probably don't sit there and look at a pill in your hand. You just take it and just make some sort of almost unconscious judgment. judgments about it.
Speaker 4Yeah, it may remind you of another pill that helped you that you're not even remembering.
Speaker 3Exactly. So that would be placebo.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3That's great. Nocebo effect poses a lot of problems. For instance, there was a study, I think, in the 90s that found that women who believed that they were prone to heart disease were four times likelier to die of heart disease than than women who didn't believe they were prone to it, even though they had all the exact same risk factors, basically the same risk factors. There was nothing differentiating these women aside from a belief that they were going to die from heart disease or a belief that
Speaker 3they weren't. And that led to a four-fold increase in deaths from that, just basically from a belief is what it suggests.
Speaker 4Yeah, well, it's sort of like the, I know it's kind of cheesy, but the PMA, the positive mental attitude, I think we've all know someone who walks around saying, oh, so-and-so's sick. Oh, I know I'm going to get it. I just know I'm going to get sick. Or, you know, I just know I'm going to get cancer because it runs in my family. I think that has an effect on things.
Speaker 3I have to agree. I know some of our more skeptical listeners are pulling their hair out right now, but I totally agree with you. When we did our show in Toronto, on the way back, Yumi and I flew out of Buffalo. And I was feeling a little down, but like at the point where I feel like you can talk yourself into staying healthy.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3Positive mental attitude, I guess is what you call it. But we were leaving right at about dusk and the sun was just beaming through the windows and illuminating every single microbe, visible microbe in the air. I could see them like just going into my nose and my mouth. And I'm like, I couldn't stop. Like I couldn't I was like, I'm not going to get sick. I'm not going to get sick. And man, did I ever get sick.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3But I noticed that right when we took off and no, you know what it was? Somebody shut one of their, um, their, uh, window covers. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 4The shade.
Speaker 3Shade. Exactly. Is the word that I was looking for. Somebody shut their shade and I couldn't see it anymore. And I immediately started to feel less symptomatic.
Speaker 4Wow. Immediately.
Speaker 3It was like turning off a light.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And I still got sick. But I was just drowning in basically what my brain was interpreting is like being assaulted by foreign invaders, which I am all the time.
Speaker 4Sure.
Speaker 3But I normally can't see them.
Speaker 4Yeah. Well, I do that all the time when I open my the curtains in the bedroom and I'll see in the morning, I'll see that stuff in the air. And I just think, oh, man, that's what I'm walking around.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 4Breathing in. Breathing.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4Dog hair and cat hair and. Emily hair.
Speaker 3So your lungs are just chock full of it. So one of the problems this poses, Chuck, for physicians is that we expect doctors or we want doctors to be transparent, to not lie to us.
Speaker 4Yeah, we've talked a lot about this lately, I feel like.
Speaker 3Yeah. We've talked a lot about diseases. Some of our hypochondriac listeners have been like, please stop talking about diseases because now I've got morgulons. I'm going to have like some sort of toxic exposure.
Speaker 4Toxoplasmosis.
Speaker 3Yep. And then very soon, leprosy.
Speaker 4Spoiler.
Speaker 3So the problem is, is if you tell somebody that's going into surgery, hey, by the way, Um, you know, you, you might have trouble walking.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3You might feel nauseous for the next six months. You like all this stuff that could be associated with, which we demand from our doctors.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3It's been shown that if you are fearful or in despair going into surgery, that's associated with longer healing times and a higher risk of postoperative infection.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Right. So if you have the nocebo effect where doctors are saying, Okay, if I tell somebody, and it's been proven time after time that in drug trials, people who are still are given placebo will drop out of drug trials because they're experiencing these negative side effects, even though they're given the sugar pill. So if you're a doctor and you know that you are telling somebody something that ultimately may end up harming them, and yet you've sworn an oath to do no harm, you've got a conundrum
Speaker 3going on right now. And that's what the nocebo effect poses. It's the problem the nocebo effect poses for modern physicians. Like how much should they tell you? If you're going to tell somebody that they're going to feel nauseous for six months, even though they probably won't, should you tell them and give them a chance to basically have the psychosomatic symptom?
Speaker 4Or tell them they're going to feel great.
Speaker 3Well, that's another one. Somebody says the solution to this is just frame it differently.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3Like, don't say there's a chance you're going to have nausea for six months. Say half of a percent of patients who go through the same procedure that you're about to go through have nausea for six months. 99.5% don't.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 3You're giving them the same information. It's just framed more positively.
Speaker 4Yeah. And that one doctor who wrote the article on collectivist area said what he recommends is not naming the illness. He said that can help out because as soon as you give something a name, then... It just instantly, you know, you have something you can call it and everyone's calling it that or the media picks up on it. Right. And it's a thing.
Speaker 3Yeah. And that's actually, again, one of the risk factors in the spread of mass psychogenic illness is the larger the response, the emergency medical response to it. Yeah. And then hence the larger the media response to it, the larger the outbreak tends to be. It's called line of sight exposure. Yeah. Just knowing somebody is sick or seeing somebody sick can give you the same symptoms.
Speaker 4I'm sure if you see a news story that all the other news agencies are running that says there's been some weird chemical leak in the air in Atlanta, people are going to start walking around and coughing and saying, I'm not feeling so good. I have a bitter taste in my mouth.
Speaker 3There's microbes everywhere.
Speaker 4Well, here's a case from that article you sent that I think is super fascinating. The one in upstate New York. Because it is not a rash or a cough or nausea, it is Tourette syndrome. A 16-year-old young lady named Lori Bronwell, what year was this? A couple years ago?
Speaker 3Yeah, not too long ago. I think 2012.
Speaker 4In Corinth, New York, was... At her school's homecoming dance and lost consciousness. This is after she had headbanged at a concert.
Speaker 3Sorry, man. I thought you were going to leap out like the best part.
Speaker 4Yeah, she was headbanging at a concert. I wish I knew what concert that was so bad. Me too.
Speaker 3I didn't find it anywhere.
Speaker 4Apparently passed out there and had passing outfits. Involuntary twitching and clapping started, twisting her hair, fluttering her fingers. Hey, hey, hey. Starting stuff like that. Yeah. And the doctor said, you know what? You've got Tourette's syndrome. So Tourette's syndrome is, we've had a podcast on it.
Speaker 3It's a real thing.
Speaker 4It's not psychosomatic. But since that time, 14 other students along with her, 13 girls and one boy started exhibiting at Leroy Junior High School. I'm sorry, Junior Senior High School started coming down with Tourette's.
Speaker 3Right, which is not contagious.
Speaker 4It is not contagious at all. Erin Brockovich got on the case, famous environmental activist. And she said, no, I think this is, got to do with this train derailment from 1970 that dumped cyanide all over this town. And I didn't see where they found any legitimate effects.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3Again, that's the confounding thing about mass psychogenic disorder is that it is still possible that there is some weird toxin in the environment that is causing this. Like maybe there was exposure to cyanide that got in these people's brains and all gave them Tourette. And if you stand back and look at it, you're like, Tourette syndrome isn't contagious. That doesn't mean that you can't all come down with Tourette syndrome from exposure to a toxin. It's just still, it's this X factor that's out there that you can't
Speaker 3just necessarily rule out with confidence.
Speaker 4Yeah, and I believe in that case too, those 14 students didn't end up with Tourette syndrome.
Speaker 3That was a good episode, man. Loved Tourette syndrome one.
Speaker 4Yeah, that's an oldie.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4Oldie but a goodie.
Speaker 3And it all came from headbanging.
Speaker 4That's how it started.
Speaker 3That mess.
Speaker 4At a Nickelback show.
Speaker 3Yeah, because Corinth is near Canada. Canada doesn't let Nickelback out any longer.
Speaker 4Oh, really? Are they caged in there? Yeah. Nice. There's another case of the toxic lady. Did you hear this one? In Riverside, California, a woman named Gloria Ramirez.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4She was dubbed the toxic lady in 1994. She had cervical cancer and was being treated and all the medical staff started to get sick that was treating her. This sounds gross, but they said her body exuded a garlicky, fruity smell, and her blood had flecks of what looked like paper, which sounds kind of like Morgulans, actually.
Speaker 1Nice.
Speaker 4You like that?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4And they said that most of the people that got sick while treating her were women, more women than men, and they all took a blood test and came back normal, and the health department said, Mass hysteria.
Speaker 3So that's funny because I looked, I remembered that story and I was like, I wonder if that was mass hysteria. And I looked it up and I found that no, it was an environmental toxin.
Speaker 4Oh, it was?
Speaker 3That's what I found.
Speaker 4So they called it mass hysteria at the time and then later found out?
Speaker 3I think like a year or two later, she was using some sort of salve or something on her skin. And they think that it interacted with her biochemistry and really did produce toxic gas.
Speaker 4She said it may be this fruit garlic salve.
Speaker 3Right, exactly.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 3That's interacting badly with my pancreas.
Speaker 4Oh, well, this list needs to be updated.
Speaker 3Dude, that is a fascinating case. It is. People got really sick from that.
Speaker 4I think I remember hearing about that, too.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4Well, I'm glad they found a real cause in that case.
Speaker 3From what I understand. But that's the point. Right. You can say, well, obviously, women were more affected than men.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Right? Well, is that because there's more women in the nursing profession and there were more nurses in the room?
Speaker 4Yeah, maybe.
Speaker 1Maybe.
Speaker 3There's a lot of different things you have to take into account before you just write it off. Sometimes it is real, like sick building syndrome.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3That's a tough one because after the OPEC oil embargo, apparently people started designing buildings to be more airtight. So your ventilation system was really important.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And these buildings haven't aged necessarily very well. So the ventilation system is not doing what it's supposed to any longer. And so they think possibly that's leading to what we know as sick building syndrome, which is malaise.
Speaker 4It's when you don't feel good when you go to work.
Speaker 3Exactly.
Speaker 4Which is everybody.
Speaker 3But some studies have found like, no, that is the better predictor of sick building syndrome.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3Is job stress or job dissatisfaction. Yeah. If you have a building full of people who don't like their jobs, you're going to have a building full of people with sick building syndrome. But if you go on to say like a local government's website or whatever, and you look at, Sick building syndrome. It's treated as a real thing.
Speaker 4Yeah. Well, it definitely affects your gastrointestinal like stress does.
Speaker 3Also, apparently it can set off bouts of asthma.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3Which is another reason why they think it might have something to do with like volatile organic compounds in the ventilation system. Or new carpeting, that kind of stuff.
Speaker 4Yeah. Off-gassing, man. You smell that stuff when you open up a new product, right?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4There's also the dancing plague, which we mentioned briefly.
Speaker 3Tell me about it.
Speaker 4Frowtrophia. July 14th, 1518, went out on the streets of Strasbourg, France, and started dancing, even though there was no music, and dancing like a maniac for three straight days. And all these people started dancing with her, saying this is a good time. It said within a month, 100 people were dancing with her and couldn't stop. And hyperventilating, hallucinating, some dropped dead of heart attack and stroke and exhaustion. And the authorities said, let's just hire a band. And let
Speaker 4them dance it out.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4Because they've got the hot blood is what they called it.
Speaker 3All right.
Speaker 4And so they did. And a lot of people died as a result. It said 400 people in the end were struck. I don't think they died, but were dancers.
Speaker 3Right.
Speaker 4And then it just stopped. And that's when they blame, a lot of people blame on ergot poisoning, which we've mentioned before.
Speaker 3I always go with ergot poisoning.
Speaker 4Yeah, back then.
Speaker 3Those people were clearly tripping on something.
Speaker 4They got the hot blood.
Speaker 3But what it sounds like you just described is basically how Tom Hanks invented jogging in the 70s.
Speaker 4Yogging?
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 4Oh, yeah?
Speaker 3He just started running and people started following him.
Speaker 4I wish that part had been cut out of that movie. Oh, really? Yeah, I thought that it was a weird thing that should have been on the editing room floor. It really kind of derailed things for a while for me. Yeah. I don't think that movie's aged well, though.
Speaker 3I haven't seen it in forever.
Speaker 4Other people say, though, that it was Sydenham's chorea. a disorder linked to strep throat and rheumatic fever that causes dance-like twitches. And then, of course, modern medical historians say it was mass psychosis.
Speaker 3I would go with that one.
Speaker 4Yeah, but back then it made more sense, though, when during the Salem witch trials and before they knew anything about medicine and you could just say you got the hot blood or you're having the fits.
Speaker 3Or the devil's possessed you.
Speaker 4Yeah, exactly. These modern cases are the ones that really freak me out because so much is explainable now.
Speaker 3Here's the thing, though, Chuck. We've always explained it with something that comes easily to mind. So back in the day before science and medicine, it was the devil possessing you. And don't think that people weren't freaked out when they thought that the devil was there in town possessing people in the same way that you're freaked out by the idea that it's cyanide in the soil from a train derailment from 1970.
Speaker 4Or beetle mania.
Speaker 3Exactly. Which is the deadliest of all the manias. But it's just as real.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3To the experiencer. And it all comes down to people just basically being sick of the establishment and letting loose for a while.
Speaker 4Don't want to go to work. Nice. So I'll dance.
Speaker 3You got anything else?
Speaker 1No, sir.
Speaker 3If you want to know more about collective hysteria, which is the name of this article, type those words in the search bar at howstuffworks.com and it will bring it up. And I said search bar, which means it's time for listener mail.
Speaker 4I'm going to call this episode on grief. We got a lot of great feedback and they continue to roll in. Hey guys, just stumbled upon your podcast through my tune in radio app. Uh, I guess that's a mini plug. We're available there now. Um, I've devoured almost all of the 600 plus shows. I may be a new listener, but I'm already a lifelong fan. So why I'm writing in guys is I lost my twin sister back in 2010. Uh, it was a rough time because as a fraternal twin, me being the boy, uh, I looked at her not
Speaker 4only as a sister, but as a mother and friend, too. Long story short, I wanted to comment on the Grief show some time ago. I've dealt with my grief through my artwork. I'm a small-town artist from Johnson City, Tennessee, and I rarely can get noticed or any attention with my art. I wanted to share my new piece I've just finished after listening to how comic books work. I'm a huge fan of Marvel Comics, and I hope you both enjoy this. And he sent this really cool... I think it was like every member of the Marvel Universe had to be in this picture that he did.
Speaker 3I didn't see that one.
Speaker 4It's really, really neat. Just jam-packed full of Marvel comic heroes and villains. So Josh and Chuck, thanks for the inspiration laughs and getting through every day at the office. P.S. My twin Jessica passed away from epilepsy, actually. A condition called SUDEP, Sudden Unexplained Death of Epilepsy. My mother is trying to raise awareness because November is Epilepsy Awareness Month. So if you guys wouldn't mind mentioning this on the show, she would be so happy for that. Also, an epilepsy show would be cool, too. Not a lot is discussed
Speaker 4about it. And that is Jason Flack. And Jason, I wrote you back. That is heartbreaking about your twin sister.
Speaker 3Yeah, it is.
Speaker 4Very sorry to hear that. And we will definitely do a show on epilepsy. And since this is November, though, people should go out and find out what they can during National Epilepsy Month.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4We'll follow up with the show. I don't know if it'll be in November, but we'll get to that one for sure.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 4And thanks for that piece of art. And if anyone's interested in a great comic book artist from Johnson City, Tennessee, I could do a lot worse than Jason Flack.
Speaker 3Jason, thank you very much for sharing that with everybody. That means a lot to us. If you want to share with us and all of our listeners out there, you can tweet to us at SYSK Podcast. You can join us on Facebook.com slash SubYouShouldKnow. You can send us an email with attached artwork to StuffPodcast at HowStuffWorks.com. And as always, join us at our home on the web, stuffyoushouldknow.com.
Speaker 2For more on this and thousands of other topics, visit howstuffworks.com.
Buffets are every kid’s dream - until they grow up enough to realize how gross communal spreads of food shared with strangers actually are. Then the dream is dashed, for most of us at least. Learn about the golden age...
Turkeys are a very interesting bird as it turns out. Which may be why many people are leaving it off their Thanksgiving table this year. Learn all about them right now in this classic episode!