Feeling overwhelmed by complex breathing techniques and counting methods? In this episode, I share why your body already knows how to breathe - and why trusting that natural process might be more effective than any prescribed breathing "hack." 🎯 What You'll Learn: • Why I don't recommend counting breaths during self-regulation • How to use ONE intentional breath as a re-anchoring tool • The difference between coping skills and true self-regulation • How to connect with your body's natural breathing rhythm • When prescribed breathing might actually be helpful (and when it's not) This approach is part of what we teach in The Unstucking Academy - simple, natural processes without the psychobabble or woo-woo. ⏰ TIMESTAMPS: 00:00 - Introduction and Viewer Question 01:19 - Breath and Self-Regulation 03:06 - Intentional Breathing Techniques 04:49 - Mindfulness and Breath Awareness 06:34 - Unstucking Academy Overview 07:59 - Conclusion and Invitation 🔗 RESOURCES MENTIONED: The Unstucking Academy: https://StuckNotBroken.com/unstuckingacademy (Limited to 150 people - simple, step-by-step pathway without the overwhelm) 📱 Ready to practice self-regulation? Try the Stuck Not Broken app for free - https://www.stucknotbroken.com/app?src=podcast 🌸 Not sure which stuck state you're in? Recognize where you're at and join the free community here - https://www.stucknotbroken.com/stuck?utm_source=podcast&utm_medium=audio&utm_campaign=stuck-page 🤩 Ready to go deeper? Explore resources at every price point here - https://www.stucknotbroken.com/how-i-can-help-you?utm_source=podcast&utm_medium=audio&utm_campaign=how-i-can-help 🙂 Don't know the Polyvagal Theory? Catch up here - https://player.captivate.fm/collection/cce134e7-1550-4d33-8e56-738d344c63b0 This and other content produced by Justin Sunseri (“JustinLMFT”) (i.e; podcast, YouTube, Instagram, etc.) is not therapy, not intended to be therapy or be a replacement for therapy. Nothing in this creates or indicates a therapeutic relationship. Please consult with your therapist or seek for one in your area if you are experiencing mental health symptoms. Nothing should be construed to be specific life advice; it is for educational and entertainment purposes only. Justin Sunseri is a Licensed Marriage & Family Therapist registered in the State of California (#99147). Don't forget to subscribe to the podcast! When you do, you will immediately get the next episode as soon as it's available. What's better than having the next episode of SNB ready and waiting for you? (Nothing, that's what.)
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, I got a question from YouTube, or not from YouTube, but from somebody on YouTube who left a question in the comments that I want to address here. It's about, uh, flight fight shutdown, TRE exercises and what went wrong. Hey, I'm Justin Sunseri. I'm a therapist and coach who wants to help you live with more calm confidence and connection without psychobabble or woo woo. This is of course, uh, not therapy. Nor is it intended to replace therapy. The question I got here, I'll call this person Z. Z says, I used to
live in fight or flight response with severe anxiety and DPDR. So I did excessive TRE exercises, and now I feel numb. No more anxiety (flight or fight). And my head feels weird. Can you tell me what I can do to get back to fight or flight where I can do relaxation techniques again? Because now I can't do them anymore.
Also, can you shed light on what happened to me? I'm confused. So, um, no, I can't tell you what exactly what happened to you and no, I can't tell you exactly what you should do, but I can, I can approach this generally. That's what, that's my attempt here. I have some familiarity- familiarity. I always have a problem with that word- familiarity with TRE exercises. Um, I'm not a proponent of them. I don't know a ton, so take that for what it's worth. But the way that I approach mental health and trauma recovery,
I, I think is, is different. Rather than- this, this could be coming from a very, um, uneducated viewpoint- Rather than looking at our trauma as something that we need to resolve through some sort of prescribed movement, I look at it as we need to, well first build lots and lots of safety, and then, um, gently feel into our stuck defense a little bit at a time and relieve it a little bit at a time.
And then, if our body wants to move, then we move. I've been doing, uh, I do live skills practices in the Untucking Academy. And, um, one of the ways I ended, or actually also in my, I do a, I'm doing a, just finished up a, a cohort called, uh, Stillness to Sympathetic. It helps someone come outta shutdown and emerge into sympathetic activation, actually, which I think has a lot to do with what's being asked here. But in this, this cohort, in our mindful practices, I didn't
tell people how to move around. I didn't give them any prescribed movements. Instead, we felt- we anchored into safety- and then mindfully felt into, uh, stuck defensive activation into immobilization. And then- to wrap up the meditation and the brief pendulation exercise- and then to wrap, you know, we asked our body what would feel good right now. And then we moved in a way that would feel good.
So it was a small cohort. One of the people, she stretched out a couple times. I think the, um, the final time we met, she did this like swimming motion. The other person grabbed a pillow and squeezed it. Um, these are not movements I can predict. I don't know what the right movement is for anybody. And again, this may be a very uneducated place to speak from and I apologize if it is, but the TRE exercises- I believe are more prescribed, like do this movement.
And if I'm wrong about that, I apologize. I've looked into it, but not heavily. So it's fundamentally at odds with, if I'm understanding it correctly, it's at odds with the way that I do things within the Unstucking Academy. So let's get back to Z's question. Z had fight or flight. Plus D-P-D-R-D-P-D-R-I would guess comes from a severe or significant enough shutdown state. This is where- shutdown brings dissociation.
So if we are in a depersonalized, derealized sort of state, that must have some degree of dissociation to it, and that comes from shutdown or freeze. So if somebody has fight or flight and shutdown down, they could alternate between- betwixt the two. Uh, they could, but that would probably more look like shutdown down to fight, shut down to fight, shut down to fight, uh, or yeah, it could maybe,
it could be like shut down to a brief flight and then to more anxiety. And that's where someone gets stuck and so they go back down and, you know, shut down to fight, to flight, to fight to shut down, to fight to flight, to fight to shut down. Maybe it could be something like that. Or it could be where they have both of these things active at the same time, so they have shut down and fight flight, maybe more of a flight active, and that would result in a tense kind of freeze state that is just sort of lingering chronically.
Maybe this underlying sense of panic, um, that just kind of is always there. Or maybe an underlying sense of anxiety. If it's more freeze, I would lean more toward panic, but an underlying intense anxiety definitely could be there. Um, just to understand what could be going on in general. There could be maybe someone with, with, uh, fight or flight and, uh, DPDR has lingering freeze or they have shut down to sympathetic shutdown to sympathetic.
So, knowing that is very important and why I don't like the prescribed sort of method of well just do this movement or do, you know, go jump in a cold pool or whatever, do this sort of breathing method. That's why I don't like this stuff, because knowing what state you're in is, is more helpful than just sort of throwing at, throwing these skills at at somebody. So someone who's in freeze, or let's say someone who's in shutdown, let's say they're going from shutdown to sympathetic.
Someone in shutdown is way less likely to do any sort of movements. They need very small, and maybe TRE has small movements built in that are good. And I don't, I don't know. Um, but for the way I work with someone in shutdown, we, instead of trying to get into fight activation or trying to work our way outta shutdown, we actually would connect with the shutdown. We would let it be 'cause it's there anyways. So let's mindfully connect with it. And if- once we mindfully connect with it, then self-regulation can
happen naturally as long as the safety state is, uh, strengthened enough. So that that's shut down. So that to, I guess that to keep that in mind because someone has shut down throwing some sort of movement at them is not necessarily helpful unless it's tailored to what their body wants and probably is a smaller sort of movement. For someone in flight fight, they have more capacity to do what, you know, whatever movements they have more range of movement probably, but they're
probably gonna be more on the tense side. Not like freeze, but their willingness, their playfulness when it comes to movements is gonna be smaller. So, yeah, they might be able to roll around or something like that, but they're probably gonna be thinking, this is stupid. Why am I doing this? Or, um, this isn't working for me. It works for everybody else, but it won't work for me. And if that's true, they're not gonna benefit from the movement. I don't think, and I have no idea if TRE builds in how much mindfulness is built into it or how much safety is expected.
Hey, it's editing Justin from the future. Um, I was editing and I wanted to input a little thought into here. So I touched upon shutdown and maybe someone who has sympathetic flight fight and how they may respond to prescribed exercises. But someone in freeze- I wanted to touch upon this real quick because someone in freeze has flight, fight active, but also shut down, so they're mobile, but that mobility is frozen. It is immobilized by the, uh, shutdown aspect of what they're going of the freeze.
So they're mobile, but also immobile asking this person to do some sort of prescribed movement if they lack the safety to benefit from it- and again, I don't know TRE so, but if I asked someone in, uh, freeze to do some sort of movement that- their system may not have the capacity for it because the immobility aspect of the freeze is too strong. And so I could totally see this person really struggling with any
sort of movement ba- mindfulness, movement based kind of stuff. Someone who's in freeze I think could definitely be triggered deeper into shutdown or even deeper into freeze. Someone in freeze who is successfully uh, removed the shutdown, the immobility of their freeze still may not be at a place where they can handle any mindful movement because their safety state's not where it needs to be. There's a lot of pieces that come in- that's why I hate to
prescribe stuff- there's a lot of pieces that come into this. So someone in freeze who, let's say the, they've been able to connect with the shutdown immobilization, and now the mobilization, the flight fight is now ready to be released. That can be extremely, uh, difficult. That can be a lot, especially if their safety state can't handle it. Think of it as like your foot is on the brake and the gas at the same time, but not a little bit. It's like floored. So someone who has their foot on the grass and the brake at the same time
and they're flooring it- when you take your foot off the brake, what happens? You're, you're gonna spin out, right? You're gonna maybe shoot forward, you know, uh, outta control. So same thing, it's a metaphor, but same thing when it comes to freeze. We don't want that person to be spinning out or shooting outta control when their immobility comes off. It has to be a little bit at a time with the safety state active, alright? Editing Justin is going away now. Bye. Um, if I were doing something like this, I would really wanna make sure that my
client is anchored into safety first. And then listen, ideally listen to whatever movement their body naturally wants. But if it was a prescribed sort of movement, I, I would really want my client anchored in safety and then mindfully feel the experience of the movement. But I'd be more concerned with what's happening, not, not completing the movement. Like if, if the goal is to like roll around on the floor and I'm making stuff up, I don't know what the hell- I don't know what TRE does. Um. But if the goal is to like roll around, I don't care if they roll around the
right number of times or in the right way, I'm way more concerned with what's the experience of rolling around? So as soon as their brain says something like, this is stupid and this doesn't work for me, that to me is far more important than completing the movement. I would want them to pause. Let's, let's, let's notice what that thought, what the feeling is that's dri- driving that thought. What's the emotion driving the thought? And let's just kind of be with that emotion. If we can be with it and then balance it out with more safety, then we can
go back to the exercise if needed. But that, that's how I work. I am, I'm more concerned with what's the present moment experience of whatever the thing is, and let's focus on that present moment experience, because that is the portal to, to actual self-regulation, not just doing things here and there that kind of feel better, but don't really last. And again, I have, I don't know about TRE, I'm not saying I'm, I'm not trying to dis TRE lot of people love this stuff and I'm happy for you. But just the way I work is, is a lot, is fundamentally, I think, a lot different
than what a lot of the other things are. And that's okay. So Z says, my head feels weird. Uh, I, I'm not gonna comment on that. What can I do to get back to fight or flight? The way that I would work is, um, and I'll, I'll give you the annoying answer. The annoying answer is don't try to get back to fight or flight. The annoying answer is, let's connect with whatever's happening in our body right now. And if the body's ready to get back to fight or flight, it will. I know that's the annoying answer, but that is the answer. I'm sorry to say. It is.
And not just, this is not for Z, this is for all of us. It's totally okay to not be content with where you're at. I think it's a good sign. It's totally okay to want to get into sympathetic activation if you're in shutdown. Absolutely. It's totally okay to wanna have more safety in your life. Heck, yes. But you- I don't believe we can truly get to more safety or work our way up the polyvagal ladder until we have mindfully connected with what we have in the present moment, and what we have in the present moment might be a lot of collapse.
And so, the way I work is let's mindfully connect with the collapse. Let's give this permission to be. And if we can do that then and remain anchored in safety; if we can mindfully and deeply feel what it's like to be collapsed, then self-regulation will naturally unfold as long as you're anchored in safety and you're mindfully tracking and following the natural little sensations and impulses. And we can use skills like balancing and pendulation. I teach all that inside the Untucking Academy. Uh, but that's how I, how I would do these things is- let's not worry
about getting to where we need to be. Let's just be where we're at. If we can connect with where we're at, the body will take you to the next place. It will, I promise. But it requires a lot of safety and that is the, I think that's the piece that people know, but skip over. They just want the thing. Just tell me the thing. Tell me the skill, tell me the exercise. Tell me the movement. Tell me the breathing technique. And I just get me out of the state that I'm in. And I don't blame anybody for feeling that way or thinking that way at all. But there's no hack. There's no shortcut here.
I don't believe, actually, I'm pretty darn sure. There is no shortcut. So the sooner that you can focus on and prioritize safety, the sooner you can do even small safety practices every day, I would argue, and what I see in myself, what I see in my clients, the more success you're gonna have. The safety state is the foundation for everything. The stronger safety state you have, you'll be able to do the more difficult
stuff that I'm saying, like mindfully allow and feel shut down, or flight and fight, whatever it is that's happening in your system currently. Z and everybody else, uh, listening, if you are interested in the Unstucking Academy. You can follow the link in the description. The academy is, you can probably tell it's different. We do things differently. I don't have a prescription for you. I don't have a hack or a stimulation or, um, I don't know, whatever. I, I don't have a special thing for you to fix yourself and get better.
That's not the way I think or teach, and that's not the way we do things in the Academy. So if you're curious about learning more, you can go to, uh, stucknotbroken.com/UnstuckingAcademy, stucknotbroken.com/UnstuckingAcademy. It's a very small community. It's limited to 150 people. I want to keep it that way. I don't want. Lots of people. I don't want hundreds and thousands of people in there. I want it to be a small, contained, um, intimate experience. I want people to get to know each other.
I love the fact that I have people globally connecting with each other. And they kind of arranged their own little, you know, one-on-one meetups just to kind of talk. We call it the Stuck Buddy Program. But the, the Academy's different besides the small community and the live practices and whatnot, I have something that I think is really unique called the Unstucking Pathway. I used to have a whole bunch of courses and stuff, and you, you're probably enrolled in other things that have that, and that's fine.
I'm sure there's great information out there, but rather than a whole bunch of courses, I got rid of all that and now I have one Pathway. I call it the Unstucking Pathway, and it takes you from learning the Polyvagal Theory very simply, very clearly, all the way to unstucking and mastering skills like pendulation and balancing and normalizing and validating, and how to recognize obstacles as they come up when you try and use these skills and what to do about that. It's this long, it's a pathway.
It's a long pathway, uh, but it has very small, very concrete, very practical steps. The lessons in it are each under 10 minutes. And the steps, you can do these every day, um, in very small bite-size ways. I, I cr- I designed this to reduce the amount of friction as much as I possibly could; to reduce your overwhelm as much as I possibly could. So, if you're interested, it's stucknotbroken.com/UnstuckingAcademy. Otherwise, thank you for listening to this episode, Z Thank you for the question.
When a cry really gets going, your whole body joins in: shaking, heaving, a quivering chin, a shuddering breath, sometimes chills. A lot of that is held flight/fight energy finally moving out, much like an animal...
Being triggered means your body loses access to safety and shifts into defense because it picked up something as danger, sometimes something nobody else around you would even notice. And it's possible to come out of...
Shutdown comes in two very different forms. The full collapse, like fainting, evolved to be brief, and the common kind of fainting doesn't add long-term risk to your heart. The heavy, gray, numb kind can last months or...
This is the last episode of Book One, and before you move on, it’s worth checking where you actually stand. You’ll get the questions you should be able to answer by now, and three mindsets to find yourself in: curious...
Eight sentences. That’s all your new narrative needs. This episode walks you through the exercise one step at a time, from naming your dominant defensive state to adding hope, with three examples of how it sounds put...