Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Stuck Not Broken

Stuck Not Broken artwork

Why Does Your Body Shake When You Cry?

Nov 17, 202614 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

When a cry really gets going, your whole body joins in: shaking, heaving, a quivering chin, a shuddering breath, sometimes chills. A lot of that is held flight/fight energy finally moving out, much like an animal shaking off a freeze once the danger has passed. You’ll hear what researchers have measured in people who cry, why a full sob happens while you’re sitting still, what a polar bear coming out of a tranquilizer shows about release, and what to do when a cry feels like too much. Mentioned in this episode: My episode on the freeze response: https://youtu.be/PTRWVhmbrik The polar bear video: https://youtu.be/gwDjOeM8GHM?si=Fk6Rp1qSxZanczSn Shaking when crying, in writing: https://www.stucknotbroken.com/c/blog/uncontrollable-shaking-when-crying 📚 Research mentioned Crying and nervous system activity, 150 women: Gross, Fredrickson and Levenson, Psychophysiology, 1994 Everyday finger tremor and mental stress: Growdon et al., Electromyography and Clinical Neurophysiology, 2000 A drug like adrenaline and finger tremor: Mansell et al., Clinical Science, 1988 Heart rate, breathing and RSA during crying: Hendriks, Rottenberg and Vingerhoets, Emotion, 2007 Breathing in people who cried vs. didn't: Sharman et al., Emotion, 2020 Chills and feeling moved: Zickfeld et al., Psychophysiology, 2020 Crying as self-soothing: Gračanin, Bylsma and Vingerhoets, Frontiers in Psychology, 2014 Animals shaking off freeze: Peter A. Levine, In an Unspoken Voice, 2010 📱 Ready to practice self-regulation? Try the Stuck Not Broken app for free - https://www.stucknotbroken.com/app?src=podcast 🌸 Not sure which stuck state you're in? Recognize where you're at and join the free community here - https://www.stucknotbroken.com/stuck?utm_source=podcast&utm_medium=audio&utm_campaign=stuck-page 🤩 Ready to go deeper? Explore resources at every price point here - https://www.stucknotbroken.com/how-i-can-help-you?utm_source=podcast&utm_medium=audio&utm_campaign=how-i-can-help 🙂 Don't know the Polyvagal Theory? Catch up here - https://player.captivate.fm/collection/cce134e7-1550-4d33-8e56-738d344c63b0 😊 About the Host: Justin Sunseri is a therapist and coach committed to helping you live with calm, confidence, and connection without psychobabble or woo-woo. Justin is the author of the Stuck Not Broken book series, a member of the Polyvagal Institute's Editorial Board, a father of two, and a husband. ✅ Crisis resources: National Suicide Prevention Hotline - 988 National Domestic Violence Hotline -1 (800) 799-7233 LGBT Trevor Project Lifeline - 1 (866) 488-7386 National Sexual Assault Hotline - 1 (800) 656-4673 Crisis Text Line - Text “HOME” to 741741 Call 911 for an emergency This and other content produced by Justin Sunseri (“JustinLMFT”) (i.e; podcast, YouTube, Instagram, etc.) is not therapy, not intended to be therapy or be a replacement for therapy. Nothing in this creates or indicates a therapeutic relationship. Please consult with your therapist or seek for one in your area if you are experiencing mental health symptoms. Nothing should be construed to be specific life advice; it is for educational and entertainment purposes only. Justin Sunseri is a Licensed Marriage & Family Therapist registered in the State of California (#99147). Don't forget to subscribe to the podcast! When you do, you will immediately get the next episode as soon as it's available. What's better than having the next episode of SNB ready and waiting for you? (Nothing, that's what.)

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Why does your body shake when you cry? Crying is a whole body event. Your breathing, your muscles, your face, and your skin all get involved, and shaking is a common part of it, or it can be. I think a lot of what you're going through is flight-fight energy that's been held in that is finally moving through your system, through your body. To explore that idea, I'm gonna connect research, my clinical experience as a therapist, and my understanding of polyvagal neurobiology.

Hi, I'm Justin Sunseri, a therapist, emotional regulation coach, and the author of the Stuck Not Broken book series. I help people understand why they got stuck, how they stay stuck, and how to get unstuck. You're listening to Stuck Not Broken. Let's start with what crying is physically. Researchers have measured this. In one study, a team showed a sad film to one hundred fifty women. Thirty-three of them cried.

The ones who cried showed more muscle activity and more nervous system activity than the ones who didn't cry. And both branches of the autonomic nervous system were working at the same time. The sympathetic side, which is flight and fight, and the parasympathetic side, the branch that the vagus nerve belongs to. So that gives us a first clue about why crying can look and feel so activated. So crying isn't only tears. It's in your chest, your shoulders, your belly, your throat.

There's a full body heave. There's a big sob where everything pulls in and lets go. And it can be a lot, right? Like, that's a really deep cry. But everybody has a tiny constant shake in their muscles that's called physiological tremor, and it's normal. It is far too small to see, but it's there. In one study, researchers put a small motion sensor on the fingers of forty healthy adults and measured that shake with the hand resting, with the hand held

out, and with the whole arm stretched out. At rest, it was about thirty microns, which is thirty-thousandths of a millimeter. Then they measured each position again while people were under mental stress. In every position, the stress made the natural shake bigger. The second study points to why. Adrenaline is one of the main chemicals of the flight-fight response. Researchers gave six healthy men a drug that acts on the same receptors

adrenaline does at two low doses. At the higher dose, their finger tremor got bigger, just like it did with added stress in the first study. The point is that when your body is charged with sympathetic activation, a bigger shake is an ordinary result. From the polyvagal lens, the shaking looks like sympathetic flight-fight, like shaking when you're angry, anxious, or fearful.

More flight-fight tends to mean more shaking. So we know that we shake more when we're sympathetically active. What does that have to do with crying? When we shake when we cry, it stands to reason that sympathetic activation has something to do with it, right? And remember, uh, that crying study from before I mentioned, the people who cried showed sympathetic activation, the women that were watching the movie.

So flight-fight is part of crying. But when we cry, we're not running away or fighting. Typically, we're immobile. We're in one spot, and so that creates kind of a puzzle. You could walk and cry, I suppose. Probably not jog and cry. Definitely not sprint and cry. You could do an angry cry and throw stuff or yell at someone, but that's more like alternating between crying and anger, right?

Like you sob and then slam a door, and then you keep sobbing. We can have tears in our eyes as we walk away, but the full sobbing, the heaving cry doesn't really happen while we're moving, at least not that I've seen or experienced. So in a cry, we are sympathetically charged and immobile for the most part. I think the polyvagal-informed view of the shaking and crying is freeze. Freeze is both mobility and immobility at the same time.

Flight-fight plus shutdown. Flight-fight we talked about already. Shutdown is another defensive strategy where the body collapses and can play dead in a life-threatening situation. Freeze is the combination of those two. It's like the body is charged to run or fight, but also held in place. That combination helps explain why crying can shake. Think about the last time you were in a dentist chair.

Your muscles may have been tense, ready to move, but you were immobile. Those are minor versions of freeze. When that visit is over, you get up and walk out, and the tension eases. But sometimes that activation doesn't go away, especially from situations that are more emotionally charged or even traumatic. That freeze can stay in the system, the body, for a very long time. Eventually, it needs to discharge.

I think crying is that discharge. To make that idea clearer, we'll take a brief detour to wild animals and then come back to human crying. Wild animals are good at releasing the discharge. When an animal comes out of freeze, it shakes and trembles, and then it goes back to what it was doing. Peter Levine has written a lot about this, and he often uses the polar bear example. It's a video that I'll link to in the description. But basically, a polar bear is tranquilized and immobilized.

But before that, it's running away from human researchers in a helicopter. So it has flight activation in its system, which is then immobilized or frozen due to the tranquilizer. The next part of the video shows the polar bear coming out of that immobility. It goes through a series of spontaneous gasps of air, and then it shakes off the frozen energy.

The researchers in the video call it "shaking off stress." The spontaneous bigger breaths and spontaneous shaking are how it discharges the frozen sympathetic flight activation. Humans are still animals. We still have that capacity. We just make it a lot more complicated. We do things to ourselves and to each other, like rejection and shame and blame and humiliation.

So simply shaking it off isn't really a practical option for most of us, at least not all at once. That means we need another way to understand how the discharge happens. I think humans do shake off frozen energy still. It's called crying, and that brings us back to the body. When a cry really gets going, look at what the body does. It shakes and trembles. It heaves. The chin puckers and quivers.

Your teeth might chatter. Those are the same kinds of movements an animal makes coming out of freeze, or it can be, but, you know, in a human way. I see the shaking and trembling of a cry as our version of what the animal does, a natural way of letting held flight-fight activation move out of the body. In that sense, the cry is really a release. Breathing is part of a cry too. Over the course of a cry, it isn't constant. It changes a lot.

There are big spontaneous breaths in, long exhales out, shuddering breaths, and it shifts back and forth the whole time. Then as the cry finishes, it settles, it calms. The research fits that pattern. In one study of sixty women watching sad films, crying came with a rise in heart rate that settled quickly once the crying started. Breathing slowed and something called respiratory sinus arrhythmia, or RSA, went up.

RSA is a measure of how much the vagus nerve is influencing the heart, and in Polyvagal Theory, it's used as a marker of the ventral vagal safety state. So as the crying got going, the body was showing signs of moving toward safety. Those effects were gone within about four minutes. In another study, people watched sad videos who didn't cry. They started breathing faster, while the people who cried

kept a steadier breathing rate. Faster breathing fits with the sympathetic activation going up. The steadier breathing in the people who cried fits with it coming back down, which is what the first study showed too. Some people also get chills or goosebumps during or after a cry. Research ties goosebumps to strong emotion, especially the feeling of being moved or touched. Goosebumps are a sympathetic response.

The tiny muscles that raise your hair are run by sympathetic nerves. So chills during or after a cry are one more sign of flight/fight activation moving through the system. So why can a cry feel like you can't stop or you need to keep going? When the release gets going, there may be more held activation moving than you thought, more than you expected. I found that people who say they never stop crying or that one

cry is never enough tend to carry a lot of freeze activation and a lot of pain from their lives. And we humans tend to cut off the natural impulse to cry as a discharge of stuck pain. We go cry alone in the bathroom, or we go off alone. And then when we do cry alone in the bathroom, we shame ourselves. We tell ourselves to get over it and be strong. You know, the stuff you learned from other people who also don't

know how to regulate their emotions. So the impulse to release starts and gets stopped before it truly finishes the discharge that it's trying to do. If you can cry fully, it kinda ends. The breathing eases. You come back to the present moment, into the room. A research review on this found converging evidence that crying can soothe us directly alongside the soothing that comes from other people responding to us.

So the shift from activation to settling is part of the process, not something separate from it. I often see therapy clients cry and then shift into laughter. Someone grieving will sometimes move from sadness into appreciation, and a pleasant memory comes up of the person that they were grieving. To me, that's a clear sign of self-regulation towards safety and connection through the process of crying. So what do you do with this?

If the shaking, the heaving, or the shuddering breath is tolerable, let it be and let your body regulate through crying. Stay with it. If it's too much, it's okay to slow down or just stop. You'll know it's too much if you're saying self-destructive or hurtful things in your brain like, "What's wrong with me? Why can't I stop this?" And, "Why do I have to be such a…" Fill in the blank. All of these reactions, the shaking, the heaving, the chin, the breath, the chills,

are your body doing something during a cry, and the crying has a purpose. That behavior is one of your body's means of discharging stuck pains. Those pains are probably stuck and have probably been stuck for a very long time. But stuck is possibility. Stuck means there's something that can still move and is trying to, and crying might be one of the ways your body does that. I recommend listening to my episode on the freeze response next.

I link to it in the description as well.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. What Is a Trigger, and Can You Get Unstuck If You're Still Being Triggered?

    Nov 10, 202619 minAudio

    Being triggered means your body loses access to safety and shifts into defense because it picked up something as danger, sometimes something nobody else around you would even notice. And it's possible to come out of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How Long Does Dorsal Vagal Shutdown Last, and Can It Hurt You?

    Nov 3, 202617 minAudio

    Shutdown comes in two very different forms. The full collapse, like fainting, evolved to be brief, and the common kind of fainting doesn't add long-term risk to your heart. The heavy, gray, numb kind can last months or...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are You Ready to Work on Your Trauma? The Book One Finale

    Oct 27, 202612 minAudio

    This is the last episode of Book One, and before you move on, it’s worth checking where you actually stand. You’ll get the questions you should be able to answer by now, and three mindsets to find yourself in: curious...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How to Change the Story You Tell Yourself: An 8-Step Exercise

    Oct 27, 202619 minAudio

    Eight sentences. That’s all your new narrative needs. This episode walks you through the exercise one step at a time, from naming your dominant defensive state to adding hope, with three examples of how it sounds put...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why You Don’t Believe You Can Change

    Oct 21, 202612 minVideo

    Most people believe change is possible. The harder question is whether you believe it’s possible for you. This episode makes the case that the belief you can’t change isn’t a fact but a story that reflects the state...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode