Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Software Freedom Podcast

Software Freedom Podcast artwork

SFP#26: Policy and EU: the need of long-term funding and the NGI case

Nov 18, 202432 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Join this new episode of our Software Freedom podcast in which Bonnie Mehring and Alexander Sander discussing current topics affecting Free Software in the European Union. In this episode we focus on the 27 million euros cut of funding of the Next Generation Internet initiative (known as NGI). Alex and Bonnie shed some light on the history of this European project and share the newest developments in this case. Join the FSFE community and support the podcast: https://my.fsfe.org/support?referrer=podcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Before we start with the podcast, we would like to say thank you to all of you who support the FSFE's work of money. Working for software freedom and producing podcasts costs money. Please consider supporting us with our nation under fsfe.org/donate and in the show notes.

Welcome to the software freedom podcast. This podcast is presented to you by the Free Software Foundation Europe. We are a charity that empowers users to take control of technology. I'm Bonnie Mehring and our guest for this episode is Alexander Sandar. Alex is a colleague of mine and he's also the senior policy consultant for the FSFE. In his work for the FSFE, he monitors the current happenings in the EU and pushes for

recognition of free software there. Today we will talk a bit about funding of free software and especially the case of the NLNet foundation and thereby the funding of the next generation internet. Through the next generation internet program, free software projects are funded by public money. But this funding was actually cut by 27 million euros. When this news reached the FSFE and Alex, we decided to take action.

About this and the latest developments, I will talk more with Alex in the next few minutes. So thank you very much Alex. I'm very, very happy to have you here at the software freedom podcast, especially since we do a lot together. So we do the EU packing for freedom competition for young teenagers, we occasionally work together on public money, public code and now we also do the software freedom podcast together. Thank you so much for making this possible and for finding the time to talk to me.

Yeah. Thanks for having me, Bonnie. And I'm also looking forward to talk to you and our community about this very important issue in the next minutes. Look really looking forward. So just to give everybody a quick interaction, could you tell us a bit more of what an Lnet is and what the next generation internet program is and what actually happened there? How did this cut of 27 million happen? Yeah. I will try. A lot of questions and it's also a bit complex with all the words, but I'll give it a try.

So first of all, you already said the next generation internet program. So this is basically a front which helps you come up with solutions that help people in the internet and here with a specific focus on free software, right? So because we know free software visits for freedoms to use, study, share and improve definitely helps to gain control over the technology you are using.

And that is acknowledged in this fund and thus this fund provides financial support to projects like Jitsi, Kripport, F1, PeerTube and other projects you might know. And here you can already see the money is not going to big tech, but rather to community projects, to small project, individual projects, projects by foundations. So it's about basically the core infrastructure that we are using every day when we are

going in the internet. So it's more small projects that are funded by the NGI. So the NGI project basically funds up to around 500 projects, right? So there are many projects around all of them pretty like on the size of Jitsi, Kripport, have tried stuff like this, right? So but you won't find any gurus or Microsoft's in this fund. All right. And also the next generation internet is part of a bigger program, namely the Horizon Europe

program. The Horizon Europe program is a research, the framework research program of the European Union and their money is distributed as a name says, obviously, into research projects. So here you can normally find pilot projects, one time projects, maybe sometimes project that go for a second term, a second one. But normally it's like a one project thing, then you have done your research, you found your results, and then you continue. So you see it's slightly different than what you have in mind when you were thinking

about like investing in encryption of Jitsi, for example. So that's also some kind of research, definitely, but it's rather investing in our core infrastructure. So you can already see that there is a slight issue with the frame of this funding. But however in the last years, it worked out perfectly. So in this next generation internet program, the Net Foundation, a foundation from the Netherlands,

they were distributing the funds to these tiny free software project that helped to improve their code. And by thus, we had way better tools than out there than before. And this should have continued until 2027, basically. And for this, there are work programs. So for every two years, the European Commission, together with the member states of the European Union, write on a work program to come up with a sketch, basically, to say what should happen, where should the money go roughly in the next two years?

So in this work program, that was exactly, yeah. And that work program that was released during the summer break. And when I say released, it was publicly released, but it was basically released towards the member state with the European Union, but it was not released to the public. In this work program, we have seen that there is a cut of this budget for free software. 27 millions that we expected to be there, haven't been there.

So there was simply nothing. So we figured this out with a leak. And then we got active because we have seen during the summer 27 millions that had to be assigned to free software projects, right to do these Gizzi project script, and so on and so forth, the examples I mentioned for the next two years, they have been cut. That was the situation in the summer, and then we started to work. So this leak reached our ears, and we decided to work, but how did you feel at the moment

when you noticed, oh my god, okay, where are the 27 millions, where have they gone? Yeah, I'm not sure if I can like publicly say what I really felt, but let's put it like this, I was pretty upset, yeah, and also I was, to be honest, I didn't expect it, and I haven't seen it coming because in the beginning of the year, at first, then the largest free software conference in the world, which is happening in Brussels, always the

first week and in February, there we invited to commission in our death room to talk about this NGI funding, and there they presented a study where they showcased how important this NGI funding is, how good this funding is, how well everything works, and how important this is not only for the tools itself and our consumers, but also for the European Union, right, so all in the studies, they presented there, showed how important and how good this funding is.

It was in the beginning of the year, and then during the summer break, there was this budget cut, so I definitely started to call people, I was asking around what happened, and then I figured out, wow, they shifted the money towards AI. So instead of bringing these 27 million euros into free software and build, they decided they wanted to shift it towards AI, and the argument was pretty much as these funds are made for research, they want to shift the focus to research since the whole European

Union, basically you know the debate after the AI Act is now shifting towards this password and all the money should go into AI. So that's the problem we faced, and that's also what I then quickly figured out and where we have been a bit upset and see the need to talk. All right, so they decided to shift the money around and what did we do, what happened then? I mean, it was not only us who figured this out, I mean also other communities, also

beneficiaries have figured out that there was an issue, and one of the first reaction was that in France some free software communities came together with an open letter, and they addressed the European Commission on this, and they wanted to get the funds back, but it was pretty much like on this specific 27 million funds, but I figured out that also with the argument that the Commission came up, that they said, hmm, research, we need to shift

our priorities, I have seen that we have a larger issue here, so I have seen that we need to move the funds also away from the horizon Europe into something, so away from research into something which is core funding, which is sustainable, which is something where it's not simply happening that the Commission is sitting there in a summer break, and they are, we cut this funding, there should be a possibility to publicly debate this, to have some more visibility on this, and so that is why we asked our community to also contact

the Commission directly on this, so we called on our community to call pretty much the president of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, and write your emails on that, coming up with the argument that first of all these 27 millions mean some projects might even die on the way, right, so we can't improve them, it's also bad, but also that we want to move the funds away to something core funding, and people did this, so people were reaching

out to the European Commission based on our arguments, letting them all individually created, so it was not like a standard letter they used, but they reused our arguments, so we put it in a way that we helped them to cut up this individual letters to the Commission, and this led to the situation that the Commission also reacted, so in the first place, also when journalists asked them on this, they didn't have any saying on this, they didn't wanted to speak publicly about this, but due to the open letter from France and our activity

from the FBI on contacting the Commission directly, there were some movements within the Commission, and they reacted, and by that we got contact to a head of unit being in charge of the program, and by that we started basically in dialogue with the European Commission, and this led to the fact that they at least acknowledged already at this time that was then August September, and that they at least want to try to make sure that they will try to sprinkle the money still towards free software projects, even if it's

not in there anymore. However, I mean, this is just a vague statement, rather than nothing for sure, but it is still vague, as it doesn't give us really a chance to say like, we can monitor this or how much is this like in euros, for example, so there was not really a chance for us for oversight, so and by that we continued, and followed up with the reaction, yeah, try to stay in touch with the European Commission, but also in the meantime we went

to the European Parliament, and try to find members of the Parliament that will come up with amendments in this direction to change the text of this funding so that we can get the money back and that they basically asked the Commission to reintroduce these 27 million, so and the European Parliament did, so there have been members and the Parliament who came up with these amendments, unfortunately they didn't found a majority since the Conservatives

didn't want to earmark the money, but they said, so they didn't want to give it precisely to free and Open Source software or free software, but they rather want to say we want to invest in digital, so to say, so that's why this amendment didn't found a majority, but still right, political costs were rising, people were talking about this, the debate was happening, and all of the sudden there was then also the consultation on the digital euro program,

so another program to add to the complexity, right, and the digital euro program is a program which was introduced in light of the corona crisis, in order to move funds into the digital solutions we needed during the corona crisis, but also in the aftermath, as people understood, we need to invest in our own technology, in our own tools, and this is a good idea to do this free software, and let me quickly cut in there, there are a lot of programs around now just to give

this wrap up and some overview, so we have the horizon Europe that is actually intended for research where the NLNet foundation and the next generation internet program are situated at, so this was the funding that was going to free software project, and this was the funding that was shifted then to AI during the summer break, and then we have the digital euro program which is absolutely independent of the horizon Europe, correct? Exactly, and this was introduced

during corona, so what was the focus of the digital euro program? It doesn't matter so much to be honest, it only matters that the digital euro program runs until 2027, which means, and there will be a reform or like a renewal of the digital euro program very, very soon, it will happen obviously until 2027, so that from 2028 onwards, we have a new digital euro program, and digital euro as said was basically in the first place introduced to fix corona,

one could say this is done, so now we need to look forward and see how can we prevent a situation happening again like corona, and there we say we need to invest in the core infrastructure, and that's why we do believe that the digital, the next digital euro program, which needs to be set up, which needs to be discussed in the next two years, this should be the new space for this core funding, and there we also need some new criteria, and we also need some

some more oversight other than that we have seen in the horizon Europe and in the NGI program, so basically what we want to do or what we are asking to commission is to come up with a sustainable long-term funding for free software, which should not only focus on research, and therefore we had the idea to move it to the digital euro program. However, I'm also fine if they come up with a own completely new budget, but since it is very difficult to come up with completely new

things, it's better to shift things into existing ones, and that's why we are asking for a reform of the digital euro program, and part of this reform should be that we introduce a sustainable long-term fund with dedicated oversight and overview for SMEs in Europe, for micro-ender prices, for communities, for charities, and individual developers for foundations might so, for all these

projects that have been financed in the NGI before to move this into the digital euro program, but it's better oversight. What did we do then, like how did we take action basically? Yeah, and for this, the European Commission from time to time runs public consultations, so whenever they evaluate or whenever they come up with something new, they ask the public on their takes, and here also just slightly after the summer break, the European Commission opened a

consultation on the digital euro program, and there we took part in this consultation, and there we asked for this sustainable long-term fund. We said this fund need to be open to individual developers for communities, as I just said, and basically all of these demands are just outline. Basically, these kinds of demands we moved into this consultation and asked the Commission to act accordingly, and also we asked our community to do the same, so we published

our answers to this consultation, we were outlining what we see, how our arguments could be reused, and we basically asked our community to take part in this consultation, and to follow these arguments and to basically ask for this sustainable long-term funding, and normally these consultations attract some experts, some lobbyists, maybe from time to time,

individuals, but normally only a few people take part, but after the consultation was closed, we have seen nearly 800 people took part in this consultation. This is completely outstanding. To give you some context, maybe just a few weeks ago, there was a consultation on AI and the European Commission released the press release that 400 people took part, and this is really outstanding, and I can tell you there was no press release on this consultation where 800, or nearly 800 people

took part, but you can see, right, so we really managed it to shed a lot of light on this consultation, many people took part, and just of today, as we are talking, and so basically today is the 13th of November, the results have been published of the consultation, and it is pretty clear that people were following basically our call and asked for this sustainable long-term funding, and what is even more important, they did this on an individual basis, not by copy and paste,

what we did, but they came up with their own words, and this underlines not only the knowledge in our community, and also the, yeah, basically the courage to take part in such a consultation, which is not very common, and also to come up with their own words, since they see the problem, and then they can describe the problem pretty well in their own words. We have a very, very good answer to the consultation now, and the commission released a report where they clearly said that

this is a calling demand from people taking part in this consultation. They also see that, and they also write it, that we, yeah, did the call on this, and they refer to our block posts, news items, where we were writing about it, but also other than that, it clearly shows that people gave individual answers that they took a lot of time and efforts to take part in this consultation, to tell the combination, we want this sustainable long-term fund, and I think that's

already a success in itself, so I want to use this opportunity here to thank everyone who took part in this consultation. This is super, super helpful, because with this, we can create a lot of pressure towards the commission, but also do you remember states to really come up with such a fund? This is a short break for our own cause. Thank you for listening to the Software Freedom podcast. Working for Software Freedom and producing podcasts costs money. Please consider supporting us with a donation on the fsfe.org/donate and then the show notes.

So this is now being discussed, or what are the next steps here? Yeah, I mean, I've definitely, and I also would like to say thank you to everybody who participated. This is like, I'm sorry, I just quickly passed over it as he, no, but it is truly remarkable, and it is amazing that people actually care about free software that much that they sit down, write their arguments down, and think about it, so I'm,

I also find this very touching that it's not something that people take lightly, but they want to support. Indeed. And it definitely helps in the political process. So it helps us to create pressure to always bring up this argument, since we can always say, look back in this consultation, there was a clear demand by the public to do this. And also, you have acknowledged this in your own analysis afterwards. So I mean, what's happening now is

in the second, probably nothing other than we analyze this, we discuss this, and it's definitely a long-term game, right? So it's not an activity. You can a bit compare it to our public money, public code campaign, right? So where we asked public administrations to invest into free software, rather than proprietary software, when they do procurement processes. Also, this is a long-term game, which goes step-by-step where we see progress, not every day,

but we see progress, right? And also in the last years, we have seen progress, and that's the same as the funding. So it won't be that we get from one day to another, is we billions of euros to invest in our core infrastructure, but it will rather be a step-by-step thing. And for these steps, this consultation helps, and the consultation is definitely a major step. In this, since we can directly go to the commission, we can directly demand from them. Also,

members of the European Parliament can table with questions of this, thereby the reports about it, media, and by that, we publicly need to discuss, right? So we need to rise the political costs, so to say, so that this is a really a topic that they need to take care of. And this worked out, and this will continue to work out if we continue to work that closely together with our community. I'm really looking forward to this. There will be a few more moments in the next months and years

where we will definitely reach out to us, to our community, again, to help us here, since this public pressure really, really helps. And in particular, in the European Union, you can debate with the people you can discuss. There are no, we set majorities, they are flexible, you can fight for majorities, and the more we bring in these good arguments, but also showcase that it's not only FSFE, FSFE arguments, but these are arguments for the European Union, right? The more likely it is

that we get sufficient funds that are so heavily needed. So just to give also some context here, I heard at some point that the European Union and the parliament and all the institutions, this is a very democratic process, actually, so that people can interact and can also make their voices hear it. What would you say to this? So is this something that is happening

here as well? It definitely helps. I mean, we are not the ones who can automatically vote, but we are the ones who can create pressures on these votes, and we can shed light on these votes. And for my experience, I can tell you the more light on that debate is and the more a topic is publicly debated, the more likely it is that also decision makers that do not really work in this space, listen to the argument and make up their own mind. And this is what I mean with

fighting for a majority. So there is nothing like what we know, an example from the member states, right? So that you have basically governments deciding also more or less what to do next, since they have their maturity. In the European parliament, there is no such clear maturity. It's moving in every vote. And by thus, you can fight for such a majority to introduce such funds. So it definitely helps if they see citizens care because they are their voters. And also other

than that, we also have seen that there are many other entities, basically, also the market is asking for such a fund. So it would not only help citizens or consumer. It will also help the European market and also European administrations and governments to come up with tools where they have control over their technology. And as said, we are discussing digital solidarity. And I really do believe that digital solidarity is not achievable without free software. So if

you don't have the four freedoms to you study, share and improve for your software, you won't have digital sovereignty. And if you can make this point, and this is also on point, an documentary race in the consultation and connected even better, the better people understand. And from the last years and last debates, I can tell you the knowledge around free software is rising every day in the European Union. And these debates also help to rise this

common level of understanding around free software. And that's also in itself very, very good. So we have a public debate. We can bring out our arguments. They are understood. Also we have from the Commission a study saying that these funds are needed. And also we have a new empowerment already some allies and tabling amendments in this direction. So it is a bit like an encrowing thing. So I wouldn't say we have this majority today. But since we started in summer,

where there was basically nothing, what we achieved in the last months, I have to say this is really, really impressive. And this is only doable thanks to the help of our community. So without the participation of our community, we couldn't debate with this. So we couldn't be so confident in all debates. How we are today and this definitely helps us to give us power in the debate, to give us status in the debate. All right. Thank you so much for the update. And yeah,

taking us through this whole process and talking to me about what has happened, what will happen, or what might happen in the future. And yeah, I'm really looking forward to hear more news about this in the coming months. Maybe. But before we close, if you want to stay updated on this, feel free to join our mailing lists, but also sign our public money public code campaign. By last, you will also get updates and you will be around those if you like. If you click the

tick box that gets emails and information about it, when we are running such campaigns and when we are asking our volunteers to step in and also port us here to help us. Because as said, there will be more of these moments, there might be more consultations, there might be more moments when we need to call the you can parliament to vote in a specific direction. And where we asked our community to help us with a mail or a phone call or whatever. So and if you want to be around those that get emails and get information on this, how you can help us please sign up at our mailing list,

go to fsfe.org, sign up for the newsletter and then you will be informed about this. I think this will be super helpful if you want to join the activities. And as said, it's a long term game, so there will be definitely more news on this and then not only in the next months, but I guess three years. Also linked in the show notes, the newsletter. Yes. So with this, I would say thank you very much, Alex. Thank you very much for taking us through this process. And yeah, as always,

it was a pleasure to have you here. Thanks for having me. It was fun. I hope it's not too much, not too complex and still interesting. This is true. And also I think it's a very complex topic. So I think this really helps to understand and to go through this process again and to understand all the interactings and after different programs actually there. So it was a pleasure for me as well.

With this, I would say goodbye and thank you very much. Thank you. Bye bye. This was the Software Freedom Podcast. If you liked this episode, please recommend it to your friends and rated. Stay tuned for more inspiring conversations that explore the importance of Software Freedom. This podcast is presented to you by the Free Software Foundation Europe. We are a charity that works on promoting Software Freedom. And if you like our work, please consider supporting us with our donation. You find more information on the fsfe.org/donate.

We depend on your support. Bye. That was my question. I wanted to ask you all. I wanted to ask you how can others help to secure continuous funding of Free Software. But that was a great idea. I'll see you in the next one.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. SFP#58: Policy and EU: The city of Dortmund, a digital sovereignty model!

    Nov 19, 202644 minAudio

    In our newest episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie Mehring talks with Christian Nähle, Managing Director of Do-FOSS, an initiative promoting software freedom in the city of Dortmund, Germany. They discuss how...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. SFP#57: Policy and EU: Why everyone should care about procurement!

    Oct 15, 202656 minAudio

    It is Podcast Friday! For our regular episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie sat down with Alexander Sander, FSFE's policy consultant to talk about procurement as its rules for the public sector is currently...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. SFP#56: Policy and EU: All about the DNA

    Oct 9, 202631 minAudio

    Fall is finally here, and so is our next episode for the Software Freedom Podcast! In this episode Bonnie Mehring meets with Dario Presutti, FSFE's project manager working on different policy and legal topics. Together,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. SFP#55: Policy and EU: Meet our Danish local group from Aarhus!

    Sep 17, 202644 minAudio

    The Software Freedom Podcast for September is out! In this episode Bonnie Mehring meets with Carsten Agger, the FSFE’s Danish Coordinator. Together, they talk about the Free Software community in Denmark, digital...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. SFP#54: Policy and EU: Keep Android Open, what is the FSFE doing?

    Aug 13, 202635 minAudio

    The Software Freedom Podcast is not going on holiday this summer! In our 54th Bonnie Mehring meets with Jithendra Palepu to learn about the Android Developer verification and how it may affect the Android operating...

    Credit the people on this episode