Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Software Freedom Podcast

Software Freedom Podcast artwork

SFP#58: Policy and EU: The city of Dortmund, a digital sovereignty model!

Nov 19, 202644 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In our newest episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie Mehring talks with Christian Nähle, Managing Director of Do-FOSS, an initiative promoting software freedom in the city of Dortmund, Germany. They discuss how citizens can influence their local public bodies and help build a more independent digital future. Join the FSFE community and support the podcast: https://my.fsfe.org/support?referrer=podcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello and welcome to the Software Freedom Podcast. Thank you so much for listening to this podcast, then without you and your support, this podcast would not be possible. This podcast is brought to you by the Free Software Foundation Europe.

We are a charity that empowers users to control technology. Today, I'm here with Christian Nähle from Dortmund. Chris is also the Managing Director of Do-FOSS, an initiative for free and open-source software in Dortmund. Hello Chris, thank you so much for taking the time, thank you so much for being here and it's wonderful to finally have you here on the Software Freedom Podcast. Thanks Bonnie, I'm glad to be here, thanks for having me. It's my pleasure, it's my pleasure, especially since we have been trying to schedule this

for ages. Yes, I'll let you do now that it's finally happening. Me too, but before we start with the current developments in Dortmund, I wanted to go back to the very, very beginning, like back to the roots and ask you how you came into contact with Free Software. Yes, let's take a short dive back into the history of Do-FOSS and also personal history of mine because the first time I got in contact with Free Software was through my friends,

friendship circles, and I remember how we were sitting on my couch and we're talking about Free Software and from there on, the fascination for Free Software really started for me and then at some point we wanted to be more engaged for Free Software and started shaping an initiative and from there on, we picked up the structured work for Free Software and that's been now over a decade ago, but it's been fun.

Oh wow, so that's quite a long time. Yes, it's been a long time and it's been also quite adventurous time in the Free Software world, but also very rewarding. What do you think about the current changes in regard to Free Software because there's a lot of while coding out there currently and a lot of things are happening in this regard as well. The two major points of discussion here, one thing is that Free Software was for me

always about the possibility of educating myself, of educating others, of being able to know and empowering myself from that point of view and this stays important, I think, if you externalize your own competence to somewhere, you lose a little bit this perspective on empowerment, on education, on understanding really thoroughly how something works.

And this is maybe the personal perspective on that and the general society perspective behind that is for me that we can see certain power shifts and this is something that free software was always supposed to also somewhat prevent to have to having certain singular organizations that have more power like Microsoft, for example, this is a classical example

maybe here or new companies working with AI and drawing in all the knowledge and drawing in all the competence and people would having a hard time to compete with this and in the end it means a power shift to singular structures that can dominate and that makes Free Software even more important today because we need educated people on the very important technological

development that digitalization brings to us and especially for me in the infrastructure. It's very important that we can maintain our infrastructure as a society and not be dependent on singular companies that might also not have the best interest for society in their mind. So I'm a little bit skeptical about the current development also with the vibe coding but

it's also a big motivation of strengthening the ideas of Free Software. Okay. I don't know, I just had to think about also that Free Software also has a geopolitical impact in the way that like it's everywhere it's in all our infrastructure and that's why I was like I found it very interesting how you I mean obviously I agree yes sure there are single market players that have a lot of dominance and that have a lot of geopolitical

power as well but also Free Software in some way also has some kind of underlying power. What do you think about that sentence? Yes, it's very important I think to really realize that Free Software is already all around us if there would be a button that could delete all the Free Software from our infrastructure from our companies from our schools then everything would break down and this is for me also

a motivation of wanting to strengthen Free Software production Free Software communities so we can organize ourselves better and really getting to a point where we as a society as a whole come into a stewardship for Free Software because we realize that it's everywhere and how important it is for us and that we need to quote an important sentence from the FSFE

that we need Free Software in order to have a free society. That's very true. Thank you so much for quoting us it's very much for teaching me the subject of the inside because that I learned from the FSFE really. Okay, well then I will take all the credit for that as the FSFE staff member. No only joking, only joking. I mean like also with the FSFE there are a lot of people actively working on empowering users to control technology and quite a lot of people writing a lot of good things

so if you haven't done so yet our dealers and I go and check out our webpage and yeah just have a look around what we do and what we all work on because this was a very good introduction I think to do for us because you also mentioned how important it is to like have Free Software valued and to have like be aware of all the Free Software around us so I wanted to ask you how you all start how do for us got started and yeah if you can give us a very short overview of

what do for us is and how it all started back in 2014 I guess yes 2014 is starting year for our initiative as civil society initiative from from some aspects it's a little bit hard to imagine because nowadays I think the discussion about Free Software is much more prominent than it was 12 years ago and we as a group we were just fascinated by the properties of Free Software that we

just can use that we can share these were very important motivations for us because we didn't have that experience with proprietary software and we saw so many positive aspects about that that we just started to wonder how about our city administration if it's so positive what we know about Free Software why doesn't our own city administration does not use Free Software

in a conscience and strategic way and back then where we try to start a dialogue but there was no one really to answer our call because it was not viewed up as a as a strategic topic in the administration which is also a common phenomenon at that time in administrations and so we had to build up a dialogue with our administration with the political parties in the

city about this topic and in the beginning Free Software was for us definitely a solution but we also realized that many people don't feel a problem about proprietary software so we started to really work out first the problems to then be able to come up with a solution and we did that as a civil society initiative so we did that as citizens of our city and I like

the title of the citizen because I think citizen is the most important title anyone can have in a democracy even more important than Prime Minister Chancellor or for the city administration Lord Mayor so we really got just engaged in the civil life of our city how did the city react to that as you already said they probably did not think a lot a lot about the problems that come along with non-Free Software and probably did not really see a lot of

advantage in using Free Software back in 2014 so how was the reaction then yeah was a little bit tough to really get engaged in a productive dialogue like I said having a solution when someone else does not have a problem you don't really find a dialogue partner and if you then start talking about problems it's nothing necessarily many people want to hear that they are having a problem and yeah they don't even know that problem and that they should have a problem you know

and if they have a problem we also have a solution so it was a little bit tough to pick up the dialogue on that but we managed its piece by piece so you can imagine that city administration has so many departments has so many topics going on and we really tried to break down Free Software discussion into little pieces that being able to be handled by the functions a city administration

has like for example the city administration has somebody employed who works on data protection so we went up to this person and said look with Free Software where you know what the source code is about you can ensure on a technical level that data protection is guaranteed it's a stronger and better guarantee than relying on contracts where we have already examples where these contracts

are breached like an all the time also and we want to be able to really go on a level where we can say an equality review that a certain software is only actually doing what it's supposed to do and this argument makes a lot of sense for somebody who works in data protection so there we had one of our first allies for example and then we just went on through the administration

and then we started collecting more and more pieces but you did that as sorry for cutting in there so you did that as citizens right and you just asked the administration if they have some time to meet you or how did you get into contact with them yes we did that as a citizen and it's the usual business of a city administration also to respond to their citizens

in everyday life you're usually a little bit more distant to the city administration but people you know for example is usually your mayor your lord mayor and so we also in the very beginning we had the idea we will go to the lord mayor explain to him in a very calm talk our ideas and then he will see it's all very rational and that makes sense and that he should implement that so simple was our first idea but then we realized okay he may even listen to us

but then he will ask his professional departments on what to make of it the city administration endorsement employs 11,000 people so of course the lord mayor doesn't know everything he has his own people to to work out certain aspects and if they are not on board with an idea he will also not be on board because he would never give an order saying I want everything to be done in Free Software when his own technical department is not convinced of this so with this we

realized we have to work our way from the bottom to the top and not from the top to the bottom and that's what we did especially in the first years and there the processes were a little bit slower until finally developments picked up please okay so you basically formed this network how did you approach the people did you trust send them an email or how did you start that dependent really email phone contact personal visit that's what we did

wow I really loved that so I think it's really intriguing and absolutely I like 100% agree on that that most of the time the lord mayor does not really know a lot about Free Software technical powers some do some don't I mean like they all have the different expertise and they also rely on their advices and as you said on their stuff so I think it's a very smart move to build up a network around them and to see what's happening then yeah and I mean that sounds very good to

hear that from you definitely and I can give one more example on that because at that time we were the city of Munich was for Free Software a certain standard in the world of city administrations and in Munich that's the big difference to Dortmund in Munich there was this lord mayor who was very convinced about the idea of Free Software and he did it up to the

bottom approach and once he was gone as a person the whole idea also somewhat crumbled and this is something that also was a little bit more prominent in the news about our around our founding time and there we realized this and said our approach might be different and we are going to have an own approach on this and this is why I think today the whole Free Software idea grew

into the city administration from Dortmund from the bottom and has become quite stable in this and it's not about a single person who might leave for one reason or another it's with it's implemented into the structure of the administration and that makes me very very happy because that really shows me that the whole work was worthwhile so it's very sustainable yes yes that's a good

term for it thank you all right so I mean like that 12 years ago that we are talking about and you started to perform this network 12 years is quite a long time what has happened over those paths in this past decade we can even call it a decade right yes it's a little bit more than a decade and it's been quite the journey because it has adventurous aspects it has drawbacks it has some

milestones but city council of Dortmund voted on a strategy for keeping or making the city administration more independent on the basis of Free Software and this is the first time that there is really comprehensive strategy leading the way forward and giving the city administration a

really strong basis for the future development and now we can really pick up the work first of all congrats wow that's a that's a major step and basically this is down to your work so really really amazing how did you feel amazing amazing because in this in this session of the city council basically all the previous work focused in and now we have before and we have an

after and before we tried all this positivity about Free Software for public administrations and now we can really pick up the work and there is independent dynamic within the city administration to drive this topic forward so from a citizens point of view we as a group had a very positive democratic experience and what makes me especially happy is that the vote the city council

took was unanimously so every party was for it there was no one abstaining there was no one against it and this I think is very important because we are in the end talking about project here transforming towards Free Software and it doesn't take well on shift in legislation we want a certain continuity in the work this is a short break for our own cause thank you for

listening to the software freedom podcast working for software freedom and producing podcasts money please consider supporting us with a donation on the fsfe.org slash donate and in the show notes but I'm very very curious to see what will be happening in the next 12 years in Dortmund I wanted to know as well if there were some other political shifts like you already mentioned

Munich we are I mean like was there anything else in this on the way that you say apart from the digital sovereignty debate that had an impact on how the public public bodies see your work for free software so I think if I characterize Do-FOSS it's also been about growing relationships of trust because the general idea that a city administration has I think or one of the major ideas

is to bring stability and continuity to society and I think this is very valuable often when people in a public debate look at it in administration they say are not so innovative not so quick on certain things a little bit dusty and yeah that's absolutely true and that that might be also true for certain aspects but I think the general task of the administration

is to be not very exciting because it should be actually somewhat boring if you will because you want every day is the same thing you want the schools to open you want the roads to work the traffic lights should function and all these kind of things like the city administration has to boot the society every day newly and people expected to work in the same way as they knew it yesterday like just functioning in a certain way and this is I think very important

for for from the point of view of the city administration and they don't want a new idea every week and if you and I think we as an initiative we also somewhat managed to establish ourselves as a partner that came to stay that wants to help create this continuity this stability and we had growing relationships that formed also a trust in working together and I think this

was on a very personal human level also a very important factor to our success that we did not just demand something from our administration but that we said we as citizens want to take on also somewhat of the responsibility and we want to help organize the necessary knowledge which you don't yet organize as an administration but we can feel that gap until you can manage better

on your own and I think not only demanding but really trying to see the needs of the other that also was an important part of our work which we grew into. So basically to facilitate all the communication and to like organize all the information and all of that that sounds quite time extensive how did you manage to do that? That was quite time extensive so because we are so curious for Free Software and what might come of it and we want to

have also responsible impact for our city, for our administration, for our society that I think gave us a certain level of energy to really follow through but it was always and still is more than a time consuming hobby. It's really something you somewhat have to want and we wanted it and we still do we still we're still hungry to see progress. Wow okay really we impressed now by

you and all the people in Dofus this is like wow really impressed. There we have a mutual feeling because I experience the same from the FSFE community for example. Oh wow thank you so much that's very kind. I really like this episode already because you have already given me so many compliments. Or the FSFE. It's true. Imagine us sitting here trying to imagine now we can create an initiative like this that can succeed and then you hear about there is a foundation

that takes care of Free Software. No we didn't have contact yet with them but they do a lot yeah let's try to check him out and learn more about them. This was my first introduction to the FSFE so we really drew a lot from the FSFE and self-determination is one example for that. Wow that's really amazing it's really we kind to hear such things as well because sometimes you work in your silo and it's really nice to see that it has some impact and that it's actually

reaching other people out there and that they do great work with all the resources. Yes yes so take take that along and pass the word along please. I will I will don't worry. All right but let's pass forward to 2026 this year. Yes. The FSFE was responded at the D Vodoo. It's very funny name by the way DiWoDo. Yes we abbreviate in Dortmund we abbreviate everything

with Do. That's also a solution how we came up for the name of Do-FOSS because we wanted to identify with the city we we have just to give you two three examples on that we also have organic regional potato in Dortmund and of course we call it Doteito. No. Oh wow okay. Yes but DO-Tato and we have a call center in Dortmund for the city administration

that is called DO-line and so oh my goodness I didn't know that it reached so far but I find a potato story really okay. It's tasty as well so if you ever come to doortment I would be happy to serve you some Doteitos for sure. I will take you up on that word. There's a packet say it's tasty. Okay all right I will link it in the show notes if there is some links. There is there is of course. All right maybe I can order them. Let this you have to go

to the market actually so you have to really visit us but I think with all the Free Software progress there might be even a good reason for you to to visit someday soon. I would love to be enDortmund. I would love to see the city. I have never been so far but it's seven idea one after on on my list. Okay yeah then let's pick it up on that later and it's similar with the Rodeo because that is in German it's called the Digitale Woche Dortmund. Woche means week so

the digital week in Dortmund and it's a program from the department for economic development and it's basically big networking week for Dortmund and the region for the IT industry. Okay so I guess there are a lot of talks and a lot of things happening then they are growing this week right? Yes it's a very vibrant week and it's bottom-up concept so you can just

put your idea of what to do into the framework of the DiWoDo and then say this is a way we want to partake. Wow that's really cool like that everybody can actually participate. Yes I think I think so too and it fits the idea of Free Software as well so it was intriguing to me as well to be able to work bottom-up and that's also something we did by founding the open source

factory. Maybe it's worth mentioning on the software freedom podcast that you know there's this debate going on about the right wording Free Software, open source software. This is something as a debate we internalized into Do-FOSS by saying we want to talk about FOS and the F stand in the beginning so freedom is the most important factor here but we understand open source

also within the definition of Free Software and I think that's the most important thing and here were other actors also at play and so the term of the open source factory came along but what it basically is and I think that's the key also here is the question how do you make local economic policy because if you like at a state level you may have access to

high values of money a couple of million and say I want to now make a grant for a certain topic and I just put five million on it for example and then let's see what's happening this is how you make this economic policy from a state level but municipal level does not have that and so we need to think differently about economic policy on a local level and what if I want to summarize the

success of Do-FOSS again is that the administration now that it sees the not only the value of free software but also the growing necessity for Free Software the administration is ready to buy we need Free Software and especially the administration is made up of specialised procedures we have so many yeah that's what I wanted to ask you as well I was like all those specialised

procedures that's something that's always on my mind because it's a for German municipalities to give some background here to our listeners who are not from Germany this is a huge issue because like obviously for every procedure you have specialised procedure you have like an administrative software that's kind of working on that and for a lot of our municipalities this is a huge issue because most of them run with Microsoft so I'm like wondering now I'm

very happy to hear that you're ready to buy so that's what I was wondering the time like how is the city how does the city want to address this problem open source factory we need so if the city administration if they want to procure something it only makes sense if on the other side there can be a production answer so if you want to procure something nobody produces

then the procurement will fail and the question is how do we get all the specialised procedures we need for the everyday administrative business when they don't yet exist so we need to create some kind of context in which this production can happen and the idea of the open source factory is as a local economic policy that we want to strengthen the city with its

universities with companies we already have with networking events with open sourcing the software policy of the administration so companies know how they should produce new specialised procedures for example and that we can just rely on being able to produce what we need for the Free Software administration so you basically plan to rebuild all of them

is there are there other people involved are there are some municipalities involved in there as well or is this something that is just happening with the open source factory now this is some like I think the general concept I already explained so I think everywhere could be an open source factory if you want to think about how to implement it in a local economic policy we also for sure need more than one city that is willing to engage in the production of

Free Software so it's an open source concept if you will and please please adopt it make it better and share your insights and let's get better and together on this we develop together with the city administration certain public structures for example there is a municipal open source board which consists of about 20 cities working together in this and this board is facilitated by

the senders which is from the federal government and joined by the German states to reduce and to offer Free Software to public bodies and with this facilitation which is also supported by the Kage ST the communale the mineshaft stellar for for for vitals management which is

a specialised body for municipal issues and there the KGST and the senders they are very professional high ranking bodies in the public administration world and with this we want to multiply our insights we want to address an inter commune of common issues we want we want to address common issues via that and we want to strengthen

and open source community and open source ecosystem wow that sounds like you do have a lot of partners alongside you there that are supporting their ideas well so it's even it's like this whole network that you have worked around there like with their municipality when you got them convinced to vote under strategy and to say yes we want Free Software in the public bodies so it's wow

yes I think that's that's been a core work of Do-FOSS to organize the competence we already have and to make them somewhat go into a common direction and this is also now a very important for as a next step what could happen next like let's maybe take also look forward somewhere if it's all right with you yes absolutely okay then I just want to shed a light on that we have 11 000

municipalities in Germany that's quite a number yeah that's quite quite a number and most of them are quite small and if you have a small municipality it might be that you don't have the necessary resources to invest into a quality question like we have with Free Software and they won't be

able to act on their own really just because of the lack of resources especially money-wise and then you have a lot of middle-class cities maybe they have some resource maybe not a lot and then you have large cities Dortmund as an example and so if we want to go forward and I think we want to have Free Software administrations not in 2050 we want to have them more early for

various reasons we want to be able to ensure that our society can boot every day in the future too so we need some like looking at the resources we have at hand we need to come up with a certain strategy because we won't be able as as a country to change 11 000 municipalities out of like at once in a parallel way so we need certain municipalities I think that lead the way that go ahead

that invests certain resources maybe also through grants and that they make everything they build available to everybody else so that they could follow in these in this yes and we need to we just need to strengthen the accessibility to Free Software and to the concepts for society as a whole and what we have now build instructors that really workable

that we have a prospect on exactly that there's a lot of work also ahead but we don't have to use up our energy anymore in single initiatives we can we have really structures that are able to work out certain synergies to make to to move along together and to also pull behind us who doesn't

have the strength to to follow on their own I'm very much looking forward to see what will be happening and how this will all play out and I mean obviously I would love to see that all municipalities use Free Software so I'm very very curious to see the outcome there over the next years we definitely have to do a follow-up podcast episode on that and see what has been happening with the founding of the open source factory is there I mean like you gave us a really good

overview of all what's happening in Dortmund is there something that we have not yet touched up on but that you would like to mention for sure and I think it's a Free Software it's also somewhat the story of my life so I could talk on it for ages but what I would maybe like to pass along as final thoughts is stay curious stay hungry for the topics stay hungry for the necessary change and

let's really engage in a dialogue together on how we and with the resources we have attend come to a strategy which moves the topic along in a time that is decent that's a very strong closing bird I believe that as a closing word because I very very much like it and I like yeah I can absolutely 100% agree on that yeah then if we if we already agree the two of us

if maybe we serve find some others who might as well and maybe we can even organize a workshop on the prospects of Free Software strategy for society as a whole and like the public money public code campaign of the FSFE which also had such an amazing impact on society maybe we can create something similar that puts together all of our organizational capacity that would be

very nice for me and also meet very interesting people along the way well we will first do our produce this episode and see what will be happening and we I hope we stay in contact and I hope that there is a lot more exchange in the future as well we sure will thanks so much Bonnie for organizing this podcast and for having me thank you Chris for being here thank you so much for taking the time on a Friday this is very very kind of you thank you so much no worries talk to you soon bye bye bye

this was the software freedom podcast if you liked this episode please recommend it to your friends and rate it stay tuned for more inspiring conversations that explore the importance of software freedom and its impact on our digital lives this podcast is presented to you by the Free Software Foundation Europe we are a charity that works on promoting software freedom like of the initiative "Public Money? Public Code! and if you like our work please consider supporting

us with a donation you find more information under fsfe.org/donate thank you so much bye bye

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. SFP#57: Policy and EU: Why everyone should care about procurement!

    Oct 15, 202656 minAudio

    It is Podcast Friday! For our regular episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie sat down with Alexander Sander, FSFE's policy consultant to talk about procurement as its rules for the public sector is currently...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. SFP#56: Policy and EU: All about the DNA

    Oct 9, 202631 minAudio

    Fall is finally here, and so is our next episode for the Software Freedom Podcast! In this episode Bonnie Mehring meets with Dario Presutti, FSFE's project manager working on different policy and legal topics. Together,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. SFP#55: Policy and EU: Meet our Danish local group from Aarhus!

    Sep 17, 202644 minAudio

    The Software Freedom Podcast for September is out! In this episode Bonnie Mehring meets with Carsten Agger, the FSFE’s Danish Coordinator. Together, they talk about the Free Software community in Denmark, digital...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. SFP#54: Policy and EU: Keep Android Open, what is the FSFE doing?

    Aug 13, 202635 minAudio

    The Software Freedom Podcast is not going on holiday this summer! In our 54th Bonnie Mehring meets with Jithendra Palepu to learn about the Android Developer verification and how it may affect the Android operating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. SFP#53: FSFE is turning 25! Come and celebrate with us!

    Jul 9, 202618 minAudio

    Times goes by… Did you know the FSFE was founded in 2001, 25 years ago? Of course, we have planned something for our silver anniversary! We are dedicating a full episode of the Software Freedom Podcast to talk about the...

    Credit the people on this episode