Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Software Freedom Podcast

Software Freedom Podcast artwork

SFP#16: Free Software in France with Hugo Roy

Sep 8, 202235 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie Mehring speaks with Hugo Roy about his long involvement with the FSFE. Hugo is also very active in the French Free Software community and gives us an overview of the standing of Free Software in France. Join the FSFE community and support the podcast: https://my.fsfe.org/support?referrer=podcast

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to the Software Freedom Podcast. This podcast is presented to you by the Free Software Foundation Europe. We are a charity that empowers users to control technology and I am Bonnie Mehring. Our guest for today's episode is Hugo Ra. Hugo works as a lawyer in Paris and is mainly active in IT law, data protection and

free software licensing. Hugo is also a longtime volunteer of the FSFE since 2008. In his work for the FSFE, he has coordinated the France FSFE Group. He has joined the legal team and is still a member of the FSFE's legal team and he has also been part of the FSFE's translated team. So he was quite active in a lot of teams in the FSFE. Apart from the FSFE, Hugo has also been active in many other tech organizations like French

data network or the data rights. Welcome to the podcast, Hugo. I'm very glad to have you here. Thank you, Bonnie. I do have a first question. The question is, what are your first thoughts associated with free software? What I think the first thoughts that I associated with free software were really about the impact that technology is having in our lives.

So it was not focused about free software, but free software was more a response, a way of viewing the problem of the interaction between technology and society. And society becomes increasingly technological, software is everywhere. We all carry in our pockets a computing power that is equivalent to the computing power of mankind globally 50 years ago. So that's just crazy when you think about it.

And so that's really where free software came from for me in terms of ideas. However, in practice, just a very, I think the first time I realized free software with a thing as a concept was when I looked at all the programs I was using to play around computers basically.

And all these programs that were giving me the ability to play with technology, they were free software. And when I realized that they all shared that characteristics, I started to look into what free software was and that's what led me to the thinking of the increasing importance of technology in society and in everybody, every individual's lives. And you believe that should be all free software, right? No, I mean, I think free software is really a building block

to general freedom and just enabling effective rights in our society. So I mean, there's no question for me that it's essential without free software. I mean, if we try to live in a society where free software doesn't exist, whereas there is no such concept, we would be in trouble because without free software, there's a very limited technical ability to check the on the power of the developers.

And especially with proprietary software, you have a tendency for centralizing the power in the developers hired by a big company. And so free software has a response to that, it's more competition, it's more accountability for people providing software, whether it is to individuals or companies. And it's giving you know more ability for our society to check on what software is doing in our lives. So it's essential without it.

We would not be where we are today, we would be in a much worse situation. And I say worse because obviously free software is essential, but it's not enough. And we need a lot more than that, unfortunately the situation is not so simple. Software is not the answer to everything, it's part of the answer. But if you look at the situation today in our society, obviously there's still a lot

of work, a lot of work that must be done. Okay, quite some fascinating thoughts for the first thoughts about free software. How invited you to join the FSFE? I think I was looking at basically organizations that were active to defend free software, to push or free software. And I was looking at which organizations are the most effective and seem to be the most

interesting work. And you know the, at the time, so this was around 2008, something like that. So free software for National Europe was only seven years old at the time, something like that. Which in 2008 seemed pretty established already. And FSFE was doing a lot of interesting work, but also was doing something unique at the time.

It was getting involved in the lawsuit for the European Commission against Microsoft on the anti-trust lawsuits. And so basically the lawsuit was about how Microsoft was using the monopoly power that they had on the desktop and leveraging that power into the server market to push for companies to adopt Microsoft solutions in the server market. And one of the problem that free software was facing in that market was interoperability,

which is a very easy way to say in English and very glad I chose that word right now. Anyway, interoperability that was of course very important to enable choice, competition and to prevent a lock-in. And Samba was a free software solution that was designed to technically give the ability of interoperability in the server space to fight against the lock-in for Microsoft.

And free software for National Europe was there to support the Samba developer, the Samba project, and to support this project in Europe in the lawsuit against Microsoft. And that was a very important piece of work to support free software in this lawsuit. And this work, nobody else was doing it. And it was very effective. It's not very popular, it's a lawsuit and everything. But it was interesting to me to see this organization doing this very effective work, not for

the spotlight, not for nobody will thank the lawyers for doing this work because it's like the CSAT means, if you do the work, nobody sees it, it's only if you don't do it, that people start complaining. But if he was doing that, and the quality of the work was really impressive to me. And that's what I thought, okay, that's where I want to put my energy. So he joined. Yeah, so I joined and anything is, you know, at the time I was quite young and I was studying

political science, and I was as fairly out of high school, you know, but you already had the interest at law. Yes, yes, I had, but you know, my interest in law really came from free software because if you look at free software, if you look at the philosophy, basically the view of the problem of the world that free software gives you, you know, understanding the power of the developer. What is the power of the developer? It's not an immediate thing to understand for everyone because when you use your cell

phone, when you use, I don't know, an email service, it's an enabler. It enables you as a user to do so many things that to think, okay, technology enables me to do things, but it may not only be doing that to understand that is not so obvious. And free software gives you the keys to understand that this ability that technology gives you is also a huge enabler of power for the one providing you this technology, designing this

technology, making the choices of what you will be able to do and not be able to do technically. It's a huge power and when you mix that with software being used in government, with software being used in infrastructure, when you see that, you're like, okay, this is a huge responsibility and should it be just left to the developers or should it be more of a social and political problem that we should solve in a way and free software is a response to that. It gives you a solution, part of it at least and that's also what drew me to think, okay,

what can the law do about these two? Because at the end of the day, free software is using the law, you know, copy the left software licensing. These are legal tools that the free software movement grabbed for this political purpose. And so thinking, okay, the law is also a tool that you can use to better regulate technology, to better protect user rights, to better think of the framework between civil rights for environmental freedoms and technology. So that's what led me to think about the law and, you know, again, in the legal field,

you have so many things you can work on. I mean, I started on software licensing because I wanted to help the developers of free software to manage the legal issues to help them not be hurtled by the legal issues I wanted to enable them. And, you know, from there, I also started working more on privacy, take the protection, which is an important field in law, especially in Europe, that also gives you keys to understand the importance of computers and processing of personal data.

And so, you know, that's what led me to study law and political science and then to become a lawyer. And FSCV was a huge enabler in that life for me because at FSCV, I was able to meet the people working on the antitrust lawsuit. I was able to meet the best software licensing lawyers in the world, you know, try to imagine I'm a 19 year old guy and I'm being said to Amsterdam by the FSCV to be part of organizing

the most important software licensing conference in the world for open-source and free software. That's where you have the people from, of course, the NGOs, but also from the companies that are the biggest contributors to free software and the biggest founder for free software. That's where you, you know, you meet the people who draft the licensing that is used the GPL, the Apache, whatever, you name it. So you meet these guys and not only guys, fortunately, it's getting better at the time mostly

guys. And so you meet this person and that's where the legal community, that's part of the legal community was thinking of, okay, giving the legal tools for free software to thrive. And I was able to meet these guys and to have wonderful discussions and a lot of help. So FSCV was just great in enabling me to go that down that road. Oh my God, quite a happy memory, or? Yeah, of course, and a lot of happy memory.

I mean, the community, of course, when you start and you see the organization from the outside, it's not always obvious, especially in 2009 because, you know, I think we did a lot of work now to better communicate about the community behind FSCV, you know, but at the time, it was different, it was a different community, it was a different organization, but the community at FSCV is just great. I mean, I love it, it's really open and welcoming, it's really, and you have a lot of things

you can do. I wanted to mention that earlier, but the first thing I did at FSCV before I was in intern, I joined the translators team because that's very easy to do if you know how to read and write in English and French, you joined the French translation team, and it's just great because you contribute, it's, it's, everybody is so thankful that you do that. Nobody sees the translation part as being non-important or minor, quite the contrary. We value it so much because we know it's important to get the message out there, and

we know translation is not easy. It's super interesting if you're, if you're a linguistic nerd because I think it's very interesting to start looking into the languages, the differences, how they work, to understand, but it's, it's seen, I saw it as a small contribution to get started, but it's valued immensely, and you know, it's, you look at many people, I think a lot of people started at FSCV through the translation team because it's, it's very, you know, and it's so useful because when you start doing the translation, well, you also read a lot

about the work that is being done, and you learn about what the FSCV is doing. And so it's, it's like a double win, you contribute, and you learn a lot. And actually when you translate, when I, when I translated the stuff on the FSCV website into French, I realized, okay, wow, they do so much great work, I mean, there's so much going on here. We saw little resources, I mean, you know, so that's, that's just the community that I was able to meet there is, yeah, a lot of very good memories, and the European vibe, you

know, I'm meeting so many people from Germany, Sweden, Italy, Spain, Slovenia, you know, I mean, what else, Romania, when I was in intern, there was a person living, who was a Romanian, who was living in Spain and enjoying, and you know, this, you know, so many nationalities and communities, it's just, I mean, I love it, it's really, everybody, it's an international organization. It is, it is.

Yeah. No, I do love this as well, I do get a very happy feeling from your happy feelings about the FSCV. Oh, yeah. Yeah. So it just made you stay with the FSCV for such a long time then, or? Yes, and you know, you look at the FSCV timeline, for instance, that Max put together, you see all the most important events that the FSCV, how it sees itself and all the actions.

You look at the yearly report. These latest years I've been busy with, you know, with other things, with other organizations and obviously with work. And so, of course, I've done less in the latest years, but, you know, when I look at what other people are doing in FSCV, you know, it's just, I just feel very proud, even though it's not what I'm doing, I just feel very proud that I contributed at some point to that organization and to see that where it is today, it's just, yeah, it's just great to see

that. Because, yeah, I've been a part of it. Yeah, and also just, you know, seeing that it's still, I think, doing things in the right direction, it's good that it's better at communicating what it's doing and, you know, there's so much to do in this area that, yeah, it's important that we keep on doing it. The mission is not accomplished yet. Okay. And in this regard, I would like to go over to my next question.

We have already touched a bit that there's quite a legal framework around FSCV and I would love to get an introduction from you, how the sticker framework for FSCV is in France. So yeah, I know that in 2012, you had a circular eye roll. It's a French word and my French is not very good. I do speak it a bit, but yeah, so please excuse my pronunciation. Yeah, yeah.

No, that's fine. Yeah, I always think Prime Minister at the time, something like that, oh, yeah. So yeah, I mean, the legal framework in France, so I mean, obviously the legal framework for developers, meaning copyright, patent, et cetera, is more or less, more or less the same in France as everywhere else in the European Union. So that's a good thing. However, I think on this side of things, France is maybe a bit lagging behind compared to

Germany, for instance, if you look at the number of established decisions in courts in France, it's not as good and as well understood as it has been Germany, for instance. I didn't like the law enforcement. I mean, I mean, in civil courts, how to apply the law to enable free software to enforce software, free software license compliance for the judges to understand where the free software licenses are about, how they work, how they should be applied, the understanding

in the community, it's, you know, it's not as good as maybe some other countries in the European Union, even though in theory, it's more or less the same. Now the other side of it also is the legal framework in terms of policy. So more in terms of what the French government and the French state, the official institutions are doing to, you know, go in favor of free software to, you know, to support this wonderful

ecosystem that we have in France and in Europe of people doing the work to develop free software. In this area, France is doing a lot of positive steps, but it's maybe still lacking a clear political vision in favor of free software. It's getting there, your statements, you have more and more statements from officials who are going to support free software to say it's a good thing, and for sure the situation

is much better now than 10 years ago, I mean, now we can find a, I don't know, an official Twitter account of some French government institution who may retreat the free software foundation Europe account and maybe say, okay, look at this, a campaign from the FSFE. So this is something we would not have 15 years ago. So you have a lot of positive things to look at. But I think it still lacks a bold political stance. It's not there yet.

So I don't want to give a, you know, there's still a lot people can do. So if anyone who's listening to this wants to, you know, push, if a free software in French policy, I want to, you know, kick the owner's nest and yeah, there's still a lot that can be done. And in this area of the FSFE has not been as strong as it has been in other countries. So I think it needs, yeah, there's still a lot to be doing.

And I think the political momentum in France is more in favor of free software now than it was before. So it's the perfect opportunity to see and to get work done. To be completely transparent, I'm not going to be the one doing it because, you know, I mean, the time of my life where, you know, free time is not something I had as much now as a party. It's very valuable to have some free time.

Yeah. So, so, you know, yeah, I do understand quite good. What would be the ultimate goal for you that politics would do for free software? I will, I mean, I think, you know, there are a few things. For instance, I wish that the people in the ministries and in the political positions

would stop buying the silly arguments that some of the French proprietary software industry or non-French proprietary software industry are pushing against the software. Like, I've heard so many ridiculous legal arguments, you know, used as excuses for not doing political stuff. Like an example, I, you can hear in terms of public procurement, you can hear arguments like, oh, no, we cannot favor free software because it would break equality in a public

procurement process. And that is an argument that has been put forward, which is first, not in line with decisions from the conceded data, from the courts, which are the relevant, the relevant courts in that field. And second, it's a fundamental misunderstanding of what free software is about. Free software is not about a different technical solution. It's not about enforcing a business model. It's not about supporting a side of the industry against another side.

It's completely stupid to look at it this way because if you look at proprietary software nowadays, they use turns of free software too. The proprietary software companies would not be there today without free software. They all use it. Microsoft today is one of the biggest contributors to free software, whether we like it or not, that's the reality. So, you know, when you have a politician buying the argument that they should not push too much in favor of free software because it would be supporting one side of the competition

against the other, that's really not the way to look at it. It's just a fundamental misunderstanding because it's not about business models. No, it's not about technicality. It's about, yeah, it's a requirement. You can totally say that the software needs to do A, B and C. Exactly. That's totally different, right? You can say in your procurement that, okay, I want to buy a solution. I want to get services or software, you know, you define what you want, but when you define

what you want, you have the technical requirements and you also have the legal requirements. In the legal requirements, if your requirement is, I want something that has been audited by the security community in this area or whatever, you know, you want the legal procurement could be, I want the ability to, you know, to have unlimited right of copy of the software because I want that in, that's how it would work for us.

That could be legal requirements, which per se could exclude some other legal requirements, but that happens all the time. You know, you always have to set some legal requirements and then the set of framework for the software. Exactly. And free software can be, of course, you're not going to put a requirement that says, oh, I only want something that is using, I don't know, some, you give some name of company or whatever because these are a free software company, of course, you're not

going to do that because it would be silly. No, but nothing prevents Microsoft from going to a public procurement and offer a free software solution for that procurement, nothing prevents them from doing that. And in reality, a lot of their offers in certain areas would be full of free software. So, you know, that's, it's a very complicated matter. I think you really have to edit it at some point. So maybe I can give you a shorter answer right now. Yes. Go ahead. But yeah, in public procurement, yeah, it's too complex.

I don't think it works. It's okay. I did like your explanation quite a lot and yeah. And back to the situation of like the free software in France. And very, you think the League of Framework purpose of best heading in France, like we have all this organizations like Italy, for example, which somehow also connected to the government and yeah, it's doing also great work for free software.

Yeah. I mean, in this area, let's say that we've been lucky that some very smart and some very, let's say dedicated individuals have been able to go at the right places in government at large to push for the message. And so today, you know, we have in organizations like et al-ab, we have the blue hats. So it's like the developers and hackers who are making the French public institutions

more able to contribute to free software, they enable them to use free software effectively, contribute back, et cetera. So that's very important. And well, to be fair, there's a lot of good open data movement in France in the last years. There's been a lot of work in that area. You know, you have people who, for instance, sued to obtain the right to obtain the

source code on software used for public decision making, things like that. So tremendous work that pushed the barrier back to give more room and more space to people who can't do free software in government. And that's where we are, a lot of steps that, you know, once about the time, we're getting there. And, you know, a lot of people who are doing good work there.

Yeah. Hmm. Okay. And in general, what would your summary be about how the League of Framework situation of free software is? Like after we covered all those parts of it, we'd say it's a good standing for free software in France or we say, there's still a lot to improve. And what would those exact points be? I mean, for sure, it's better now than it was 10 years ago.

A lot of positive signs that free software as a thing is not seen as some fringe idea. It's in the mainstream. That's very important. You have some small policies in favor of free software. You have some teams getting hired to support free software in the French sector, in the French public sector, etc. So, you know, a lot of improvements. But in the face of the challenge that free software is about, these are baby steps.

It's welcome. We have to start somewhere. And we have to be patient at the end of the day, FSFE was founded in 2001. So 21 years ago, that's nothing. Even in terms of technology, it seems like a very long time because we're used to having a very fast-paced change in technology. But when you look at legal, when you look at policy, when you look at shifting the ideas in the ideology and the economy, you know, in all of these, you have a lot of power.

You have a lot of money of people who would not want free software to succeed. And so it's a very, you have to be patient, you know? So I can't be pessimistic about it. I mean, baby steps are very good. It's much better than nothing. And you know, it's being patient. Of course, I think we lack, yeah, we lack a bold stance from policy and too many times

I hear legal excuses being used to defend a status quo position. Some of the examples I've given are the public procurement where they would say, oh, no, we can't do that because it should be a distortion of competition where it's not. So that's one part missing and the other part, I think, is really a strategic vision for the IT economy that realized that free software is an asset and should be a core asset in the

strategy. Today, it's not, and it's a bit, I think it's sad. Okay. Thank you very much. You're welcome. Dan, thank you very much for the introduction into the legal framework of Free Software in France. And I would like to close with my favorite question. As you probably know, we have to allow free software day every year on the 14th of February. I'm a huge fan of the campaign.

And yeah, on this day, we encourage people to say thank you to Free Software Projects or to people who are working behind Free Software. And yeah, I would like to ask you which project you would like to say thank you to or to which people would like to say thank you to. I'm trying to think, for example, because, you know, we've been doing I Love Free Software for so many years now that I'm running out of, so I have to repeat myself now.

So I'm a bit trying to find new ones. You know, I think, yeah, I think I will choose a Calix OS. So Calix OS is an Android based operating system for mobile computers, basically, that is built to give as much privacy to the user as possible. And I chose this project because, you know, it's all the bits that enable us to use Free Software

and to have privacy at the same time and security. And of course, all of that without depending entirely on Google, you know, because I think it's very important that the work they're doing, because I mean, first, I don't know if you've tried Calix OS, but the installation setup is one of the most accessible and simple I've ever seen for a non, you know, for putting Android based operating system on your phone.

You know, we've been doing that for some years now in the Fsefi, you know, helping people to take control of their data on their phone and on their mobile computers and to get rid of the Google sign of things and to replace it with a still Android based, but with Free Software on top of it. And you know, it was, you know, it was hard several years ago, you know, we had to have these parties, right, to help people get together and help each other do that, which was great to meet people, but at the same time, you know, we had to do that because it was scary,

it was complex, complicated, people would be afraid to break their device, to avoid the rarity, et cetera. But Calix OS, wow, that was so easy, I just loved it. And it was so easy, not just to install it, but to have all these systems, you know, it comes with microG, it comes with Afterroid, you know, all these things are already integrated when you install it. And so, you know, it's really to use, it's, you know, it just works. And that's what we want, you know, as user who are very busy with other things, we may

not want to spend an entire week and installing a new operating system, or whether I, I may be, if I want to install the operating system for the weekend, maybe I want to install some obscure operating system on some obscure device, and maybe not on one of the most important devices I have today. And so, Calix OS enabled me to do that. And, and you know, it's such a strategic area, the mobile device because it's such a central device in the lives of people in France and in our societies here.

So yeah, I think, I think I owe it to them to, to, to say thank you. Thank you, you go for your drive. Thank you, Bonnie. Thank you very much for inviting me. It was nice to have you. This was the Software Freedom Podcast. If you liked this episode, please recommend it to your friends and rate it. Also, subscribe to make sure you will get the next episode. This podcast is presented to you by the Free Software Foundation Europe. We are a charity that works on promoting software freedom.

If you like our work, please consider supporting us with our donation. You find more information on the FSFE.org/donate. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. SFP#58: Policy and EU: The city of Dortmund, a digital sovereignty model!

    Nov 19, 202644 minAudio

    In our newest episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie Mehring talks with Christian Nähle, Managing Director of Do-FOSS, an initiative promoting software freedom in the city of Dortmund, Germany. They discuss how...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. SFP#57: Policy and EU: Why everyone should care about procurement!

    Oct 15, 202656 minAudio

    It is Podcast Friday! For our regular episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie sat down with Alexander Sander, FSFE's policy consultant to talk about procurement as its rules for the public sector is currently...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. SFP#56: Policy and EU: All about the DNA

    Oct 9, 202631 minAudio

    Fall is finally here, and so is our next episode for the Software Freedom Podcast! In this episode Bonnie Mehring meets with Dario Presutti, FSFE's project manager working on different policy and legal topics. Together,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. SFP#55: Policy and EU: Meet our Danish local group from Aarhus!

    Sep 17, 202644 minAudio

    The Software Freedom Podcast for September is out! In this episode Bonnie Mehring meets with Carsten Agger, the FSFE’s Danish Coordinator. Together, they talk about the Free Software community in Denmark, digital...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. SFP#54: Policy and EU: Keep Android Open, what is the FSFE doing?

    Aug 13, 202635 minAudio

    The Software Freedom Podcast is not going on holiday this summer! In our 54th Bonnie Mehring meets with Jithendra Palepu to learn about the Android Developer verification and how it may affect the Android operating...

    Credit the people on this episode