In November 2021 the FSFE has launched the new campaign "Upcycling Android". If you haven't already upcycled your phone or you are curious to learn more about the campaign listen to our new Software Freedom Podcast episode with the campaigns manager Erik Albers. Join the FSFE community and support the podcast: https://my.fsfe.org/support?referrer=podcast
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Software Freedom Podcast. This podcast is presented to you by the Free Software Foundation, Europe. We are a charity that empowers users to control technology. I'm Bonnie Mehring and our guest for today's podcast is Eric Alvers.
Eric works for the FSFE as a program manager for digital sustainability and he's a happy employee as he wrote in his self bio on the FSFE's website since 2012. Eric is largely involved in the FSFE's activity regarding software sustainability and thereby alter the FSFE's upcycling Android campaign. Welcome to the Software Freedom Podcast, Eric. It's nice to have you here. Thank you. Thank you for having me here and inviting me and yeah, I was waiting for this for a while and
now I'm happy that we finally managed to do this podcast. Me too. Why did you write that you are a happy employee? I was so distracted by this. I don't know how to say this in a better phrase but I was like, oh, he's a happy employee. Okay, I've built down already put this into the intro. Yeah, actually it's quite funny. I don't know because I mean at the FSFE, we have the freedom to self-describing ourselves on our page and I was just writing, I'm a happy employee because that's what is the
reality. But just recently someone else picked this up at a conference where I was, where the host was talking about me and presenting me and they were also picking this up saying, oh, Eric, I was just a happy employee of the FSFE and now you picked this as well. Oh, sorry, I didn't know that. No, actually it seems to me, I mean it's cool, it's like, yeah, as you say, it's definitely catchy. It catches your attention, yeah, it catches your attention.
And I'm wondering why is this maybe because I mean, normally I expect people to be happy in their work. I think that should be normal, but it seems to be to surprise some people and so on. I totally understand why you're happy. It's just that seeing it and seeing it written on a bio page, you know, I was like, why did he put in there that he's a happy employee, why is he not just an employee, but I love it. I think it's the best self-description I ever read.
Cool, thank you very much for this. Anyways, so let's make a happy podcast now. Let's make a happy podcast. So you have been involved with FSFE for quite a long time and I was wondering what are your first thoughts or the first thing you think about when you hear the term free software because I'm sure you have such a relationship with FSFE because of your long time working with FSFE and for the FSFE. Yeah, of course, I mean, since I spend like the last decade of my life basically on free software,
actually when I think about free software, I always think about the four freedoms. I think it's just the genius written down in four core rules giving users the freedom to work with software and to... So it's more the concept of free software and it's not so much the an actual software that is released and there are free and open-source software license or like you know what I mean, like I like the approach. Yeah, maybe I don't know, I think it's a little bit based on my studies because I was studying
political science and during my studies, I mean of course you have a lot of aspects regarding you know laws, philosophy and rules about how to create societies that work just fine. And so that's why I think it's such a genius and then you have... And I mean these are really common, also really complex topics and you have books, really large books about these topics of state philosophy. And in software you have the genius, you have these four sentences that basically defines
users freedom since over 30 years now and this is just, yeah, amazing, having this written down in such a dense rule framework. Yeah, okay, thank you very much for the insight. How did you get on both 50 FSFE? Yo, that's a good question and it's actually already a long time ago, so I don't think I can recall all the details now, but it started during my, when I was writing my thesis, I was studying
political science and I was writing a thesis about software patents. And when I was researching for the thesis, I found the... I mean, I was already aware of course of free software before and about the Free Software Foundation. When I researched for my thesis, then I found out, oh, there's also a Free Software Foundation Europe. And that Free Software Foundation Europe is actually having an office in Berlin and you can do an internship there. So, yeah, one, two, three,
and I thought, okay, cool, I'm anyway now finishing my study, so let's do an internship at the Free Software Foundation Europe. Yeah, I mean, we were having this talk about happy employee and I remember I was a happy intern and I think the others have thought that as well and so I was there at the right time and I was lucky, so I became afterwards a happy employee. Okay, I'm very happy. That's your happy intern and happy employee.
When did sustainability, like you have been working with the FSFE for quite a long time now since 2012, so it's 10 years now and when did sustainability become such an important topic for you and your work with the FSFE? I mean, I think there's two questions in here. So, for myself, I'm like, when did the topics sustainability become important? What's already during my studies? Well, I thought it's also very important, you know, to save our environment and to save the climate
and so I was really interested in how this could be possible, what can policies do, what has been done and so on. So, that's actually for myself a topic since the long time and then, yeah, of course, I'm also interested in free software since a long time, but yeah, at some point, I mean, I found that the way to merge these two topics, because they're actually very related to each other, I mean, like at one point, the German H&C for environment, they were looking for input on
software sustainability that was like in 2015 or so and that was, I think that was maybe the first time I was really thinking about, okay, what is sustainable software, what is software sustainability? And since then, basically, I cooperate with that H&C here and there and so I take deeper and deeper and found more and more relation between free software and software sustainability. And so now, these both important topics became basically one topic for me.
So, it started with yourself and your personal life and your interest in sustainability and then you brought us into the FSFE and made it also an important topic for software sustainability. Exactly. I noticed that it might be good to explain a bit more about what you understand under sustainability, because I get the feeling that you also have sustainability on a hardware approach, like most people might think about just like, okay, reuse your devices, put free software
on your mobile phones and stuff like that, you know, to be able to use them longer in a safe way, but also to also explain a bit more what software sustainability actually means, because it also means that you can use it for a longer time and also that it's very important to have efficient software, right? So that software is not taking up too much energy or power while computing. Yeah, exactly. I mean, you already covered several aspects of software sustainability.
I mean, the first one, I think that's one that is the easiest to follow and to understand, and the most obvious one, the relation between the software and the hardware lifetime and hardware reusability. And I think this is also a topic we cover most today and we will dig deeper later when we talk about the absiting Android campaign, because this is very in the heart of there, of this campaign. But yes, so there's a relation between the reusability of software and the
reusability of hardware. So this is one of the sustainability dimensions that is what I call an external dimension, because here the software has basically an effect on the hardware. And the hardware is made of natural resources. So the way I can use a reuse software has an effect on how I can use and reuse my natural resources. And then there's the internal I mentioned that you also already introduced quite good. So the question of how long can I use a software?
The question how long is it possible for future generations to reuse a software? And this is also very important, because if you think about setting up infrastructure, for example, I think this is now this for example, this decade now will be a decade where we set up a lot of public software driven infrastructure that most people call something like smart city, smart agriculture,
everything that is related to normally too smart is driven of course by software and we build up large architectures. So here's the question of course there's also a question of control, but it's also a question of sustainability. So is it will it be possible to adapt this infrastructure to the needs that I have on local level? Can I reuse this in the future or can I reuse this on another in another city, all these kind of things? This makes the internal sustainability of software
the reusability of it in short. And the efficiency like the last sector you were mentioning, I mean this is something that is still very in the very beginning of us understanding the efficiency of software. I think it's too early to make clear conclusions now about what software is more efficient than what is less efficient, although there has been just recently given out it's also
interesting and there has been given out the first blue angel for software efficiency and it has been given to a to a free software program, Okular, the KDE Okular universal document reader. But it's very interesting that it finishes though it's very interesting that definitely for the other sectors we were just talking about like the internal dimension of how long a software is available
and how is it usable and the aspect of how long is the hardware available and usable. For both free software is key for sustainability that is the point we currently at the free software foundation Europe want to help people to understand this. Why did you choose mobile phones? Like I'm quite sure there's a lot more out there but yeah
why? I mean there are some arguments that really yeah that are really in favor of choosing mobile phones for the topic because the first point is I don't know I have no curiosity but it's like 80% of humankind or something has a has a mobile phone so this is something people they use it in a daily life so everyone knows what we talk about. Second many people are annoyed like you buy a mobile phone today and two years later you have to buy a new one because the software doesn't run anymore
like the way you want it to run or you cannot get this new train the application on your phone you don't get support anymore so like when when I talk to people and I explain them software of solace sense with their mobile phone basically for now everyone understands it so that makes it very easy you know to also talk people who who do normally not care so much about the deeper topics of a software but also I mean most humans on the planet have a mobile phone the numbers are really
crazy I mean this this case so high like we produce 1.5 billion smartphones every year and 1.5 billion smartphones and all of them including all the resources and the energy that you need to produce them like we need 80% of all energy for mobile phones we use in the production of the mobile phone and only 20% in through all the time that we use it so if we can and that's
now my point so if we can somehow try to bring down the production numbers of mobile phones by using it a little bit longer like using it just one year longer it has a really because it gets why there's a really big effect on the environment and on the resources that have been used to produce new mobile phones exactly this brings me to the question how could people use their mobile phones longer I think this is kind of the core of the campaign like of the upcycling Android campaign
so how and yeah how can people do that it's actually quite easy you can install a free software operating system and you can keep using it so that's the sort of answer okay and the long answer so let's start with the free software operation system that people can install I think we used to call them customer arms but in our talk before we did the podcast you also
mentioned that we shouldn't use the term customer arms anymore can you dive into this a bit yeah you can still say customer arms but the the customer some I mean many people think okay there's there are customer arms and that's it but there's more than just customer arms that was the mortar point like okay what is the customer arm a customer Android itself is developed by Google and the main components of Android they are published under a free software license so what is not
published as free software is all the Google stuff all the G apps and some call libraries and so not everything is free software but a large part of the Android operating system is published under a free software license under the MIT license so there are communities out there who take that code reuse that code and publish a customized version of Android so that's why it's
called custom ROM these are the custom ROM there's a lot of out there one of the more popular ones is lineage or s lineage or s is popular because it just runs on so many different phones and it's out there since a while now more modern versions are graphino s cardics or s e yeah they're quite a lot of customer arms exactly many more I cannot I cannot list all of them here so
and the good thing about custom ROMs let's say the good thing for the user is if you install a custom ROM it's very close to your Android system so you are already used to the system that's not a lot of burden for you to learn something new but there's also the there's also a lot of communities more and more who want to offer a full GNU Linux operating system on mobile phones
because the Android itself is also based on Linux kernel so the mobile phones are easy to run the Linux kernel and so it's also basically easy to run a GNU Linux system but of course you have to change the whole interface is because of course you have a touch screen you have a very tiny screen so and maybe you don't want to do the things you do with a normal like with your laptop when you run a GNU Linux system you maybe want to I don't know they are of course customized for mobile
use and phones and although they are still in in the beginning so you can use them you can normally do most of the stuff that you want to do with a phone you can do with them you can not necessarily do everything there's sometimes issues with drivers so you don't get to work some component of your phone but I think this is a question of time and I'm really looking forward to
let's say I don't know time saying time is always difficult but let's see how the development goes to three years something to having GNU/Linux systems that I can run on my mobile phone on my computer as well and then I can really nicely interconnect these devices and shrink them and you know I mean that would be my favorite choice once it's developed and I see that coming so that
gives me actually a lot of hope here um so you have started the upcycling Android campaign to rise awareness about this important topic of sustainability and reusing your mobile phones under a free software yes yes um could you give us an overview of what has happened during the last months and what was your biggest success with the campaign?
I mean the publication itself was a quite a success so it has been picked up by media not only not only technical media but also larger news science and local newspapers and I don't know we had a really big success in in bringing out the first message about the campaign and of course then based on that of course a lot of reactions people writing us saying that's cool or can we
give a talk here or there so that was that was basically a huge success and the generally the campaign is very well received we we have a lot of people interested in the topic itself and in the workshops we are doing so that can be seen as a challenge and says and I think one of the key stones that we now achieved was publishing an open letter so together with um initially 38
organizations meanwhile there's around 50 organizations who co-signed this open letter we published an open letter in that we demand for key aspects for more digital sustainability that lead to more digital sustainability and we demand this in the up for the upcoming discussions surrounding the European equal design criteria so the European equal design
area is a framework that says how products have to be made in order to be sustainable and to be recyclable to be reusable and these things so you have to follow these criteria in order to sell your product in the European Union because it's basically the baseline of how your product has to be sustainable and the current regulations they say no word about software not a single one and so
they are and they are from 2008 or nine or so and now the European Union in the next two years is going to redefine them with several legislative initiatives and this is exactly the point where we want uh where we want to drop in and um of course explain how software relates to the longevity of hardware but also like um give give help on what exactly can be changed based on that finding to
have more long lasting electronic products and uh yeah this is again made not only a lot of publicity but also i mean it's the first time for us that there are organizations really large organizations from who care about the protection of environment and large organizations who care
about the right to repair and large organizations who care about free software that form an alliance and come up together with four core demands for a more sustainable digital society and i think this is a really huge success and will help us so much in the upcoming discussions on the equal design and making some things right hopefully okay um are individuals also able to
sign your letter or is it just organizations no for now it's just organizations because i mean yeah what we want to achieve is we want to show politicians we want to show them there's a huge European civil society who supports these demands and uh having talked so much about these demands now the four demands that we came up with every uh so every user has the universal right to install
any software any device so that's the first demand that we have in this whole letter the second is the right to to choose your online service because we especially like um with the internet of things or smart environments private smart environments i have devices and i have an online service connected to it so for example i have my smart whatever heating and there's an online provider who who regulates then to heat my living up or down then once the online service
stops we have this problem now more and more the at some point the online service says okay that's not economic for us anymore we just stop the service then all the devices are also lost because they are not able to connect to another device so i as a user must have the right to choose my online service because this will also help a lot to you know having the possibility to reuse my device whatever online service i want to choose so it's not about the manufacturer to decide which online
service i can use with my electronic device it's me who should choose it then the interoperability of devices that's the third one right exactly so that i'm not bound to uh like a product family of a specific um manufacturer so once i buy the i don't know the smartphone the smartphone from one manufacturer i also have to buy the computer from that and i have to buy the fridge from that and i
have to buy the toaster from that just in order that all these devices smoothly integrate with each other and connect with each other and exchange information no they should exchange information based on open standards so i can choose the most whatever i'm looking for the most yeah and the fourth demand is the demand to publish tools drivers and specifications of any device under a free software license because this is crucial for the you know for the
reusability of devices and for the repairability so yeah okay um so now we have talked a bit about the campaign and about the open letter and what you're doing with the campaign and how it's going so far so i was wondering you also mentioned the workshops could you elaborate a bit more the workshops as like those workshops are for people who want to flash their mobile phones and to unlock the bootloader right exactly so coming back from the open letter we want to achieve that
everyone has the right to install any software any device but this is currently not the case because we talked about it manufacturers try to prevent me from doing it so it's sometimes a bit tedious and difficult to install a free software operating system on your mobile phone and that is why we set up the workshops in the first place so we can help users doing it users who are interested who have their phone and they want to keep using them longer
they can come to the workshop and they can find help we have trainers there and they help people installing such a free software operating system the an explain of course also how it works of course people who are interested in so they can later on you know they can do this by himself they can maybe even in the best case they can even help their neighbor or they can tell other people and say hey where to find help and what if i just want to support upcycling Android like
if i'm not interested in doing anything else but i or if i already have done everything else and i also want to support the campaign how could i do this i mean every campaign lives by the word you know that people spread about it so if you like the idea about upcycling Android go to upcyclingAndroid.org you will find a lot of information material you find videos that you can share we have a campaign video but we also have
recorded talks about the topic and so on so you can share the material you can share the campaign you can talk to people so this is always i think one of the most important things to do but also read it take it by your heart and i mean upcycling your own phone i mean that's that's really an interesting thing to do and in the end it will make a lot of fun
you will learn a lot about your phone about sustainability you will also find a lot of help with people like if you are new to the topic go to a repair cafe maybe or to a hackerspace or to one of our workshops find some help do it by your own and this way you will learn a lot and yeah and get to know people who are also you know interested in topic and yeah that's how the
community grows now i have my last question for you so i'm so sure that you know the campaign i love for a software day i have been working on this campaign for i think two years now and like a very nice campaign and i love it because it rises in the air it's my second favorite it's my second favorite campaign i have to admit your second favorite of course oh my gosh what's the first one after upcycling Android or maybe it's vice versa i cannot say that maybe they
are on the same level okay oh my gosh i'm so glad to hear this because i think it's such an important campaign because it rises awareness of all the people that are behind free software and that are working so tirelessly throughout the year for our freedom yeah and it's always celebrated on the 14th of february and i wanted to know who you would like to say thank you to is there a special project that you would like to say thank you or maybe are there many special projects so every year
i have this problem this is a really difficult question because there's just so many uncountable projects i would love to think and i do think today i choose Macedon i'm using Macedon since i don't know for around four years now or so or those who don't know it so Macedon is an application in the in the fediverse so it's basically like
it it feels a little bit like the proprietary twitter so you can write short text messages and attach a picture but it's free software and it's federating that means there's a lot of servers out there who connect with each other and who shared information and i think it's i just completely love the whole idea about decentralizing architectures and this is such a nice example of decentralized architecture that people can use to exchange and talk and share information
and i have super nice discussions there i really love the community and it's really fun because just recently i mean since the big billionaire um allows to want to buy twitter there's a huge rush now on Macedon i hope that this will be you know it will stay like it is and all the people will enjoy it as we do it for now until now
and it shows but it shows that i mean people want to communicate this is a really basic human need that we have and yeah Macedon gives us the way to communicate in freedom decentralized federated with free software and that's why i really love it okay then thank you very much Eric for your time and you're inside into the upcycling Android
campaign yeah thank you very much again for inviting me and having the chance to talk about the upcycling Android and yes for everyone interested now please go to the website upcycling Android.org and find find more information and material this was the software freedom podcast if you like this episode please recommend it to your friends and rate it also subscribe to make sure you will get the next episode this podcast is presented to
you by the Free Software Foundation Europe we are a charity that works on promoting software freedom if you like our work please consider supporting us with a donation you find more information on the fsfe.org/donate bye bye
In our newest episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie Mehring talks with Christian Nähle, Managing Director of Do-FOSS, an initiative promoting software freedom in the city of Dortmund, Germany. They discuss how...
It is Podcast Friday! For our regular episode of the Software Freedom Podcast, Bonnie sat down with Alexander Sander, FSFE's policy consultant to talk about procurement as its rules for the public sector is currently...
Fall is finally here, and so is our next episode for the Software Freedom Podcast! In this episode Bonnie Mehring meets with Dario Presutti, FSFE's project manager working on different policy and legal topics. Together,...
The Software Freedom Podcast for September is out! In this episode Bonnie Mehring meets with Carsten Agger, the FSFE’s Danish Coordinator. Together, they talk about the Free Software community in Denmark, digital...
The Software Freedom Podcast is not going on holiday this summer! In our 54th Bonnie Mehring meets with Jithendra Palepu to learn about the Android Developer verification and how it may affect the Android operating...