Ever wondered how the pros polish that gripping thriller or heartwarming romance? Prepare to unlock the secrets of fiction editing with Siobhan from Motif Edits and our fiction lead, Rami, as they guide you through the art and craft of storytelling. We introduce the intriguing process of "murder boarding," aimed at empowering writers with constructive critique for their works-in-progress. Learn how to craft captivating novel openers, establish a compelling point of view, and choose the perfect tense to ground your narrative right from the start. Experience the tension and thrill that comes from masterful dialogue and actions. Our analysis of a scene with high school friends Rosie and Hadley will open your eyes to the nuances of character dynamics and genre expectations. Discover how simple changes - like replacing a coffee cup with a soda - can enhance reader clarity and immersion. Dive into the world of contemporary romance with us, as we evaluate dialogue and tone to bring characters like Friedrich to life, debating whether sharp or soft language best captures reader attention. In our final segment, we shift focus to the world of science fiction, dissecting a student’s narrative for insight into maintaining tension and clarity. We stress the importance of active, goal-oriented characters across genres, and caution against the pitfalls of passive protagonists. Plus, we explore the invaluable resources available at selfpublishing.com for fiction authors seeking to elevate their craft. Join us in this engaging episode of the Self-Publishing School podcast, where fiction takes center stage, and your writing journey gains a new, invigorating direction. Thousands of first-time authors have already turned their ideas into bestselling books with our guidance. You could be next. Book A Free Consultation Popular Free Resources: Download your 1-Page Book Launch Plan Nonfiction Book Outline Template Fiction Book Outline Template Follow selfpublishing.com Youtube Instagram TikTok Facebook Follow Chandler Bolt YouTube ...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Hey, chandler Bolt here, Welcome back to another special episode of the Self-Publishing School podcast. We're in the middle of the fiction takeover. Rami and the fictioneers have taken over the podcast for the month of November, so for NaNoWriMo, and this week we're talking about editing. So we've got another special guest. If you're watching this on the YouTube channel, you can see all three of us. If not, well, you'll hear us. So we've got Siobhan here, we've got Rami here and I'm going to pass it to Rami in just a second.
Speaker 1But Siobhan, she has a company called Motif Edits, works with a lot of our authors and our fiction programs that Rami runs, and this week we're talking about fiction editing, like you said. So week one was about seven figure fiction, learning from the trenches with Steve Higgs. Week two we talked about fiction covers. So really, really insightful episode. Hopefully you guys love that, jake Caleb, and this week we talk about editing. So we're going to keep working through kind of the core pillars. So with that I'll pass it to Rami, who many of you know has created all the fiction programs and the head of fiction here at Self-Publishing School has helped hundreds, if not thousands, of authors publish books.
Speaker 1So pass it to you, rami, you can tee up Siobhan, and let's roll.
Speaker 2Absolutely Well. Thank you so much. This is the part where I embarrass Siobhan, and so I'm pre-apologizing for that one. So, Siobhan, it was or is, I guess actually you're going to have to correct my grammar on this one was or is my seventh editor, right? So I went through six other editors before I finally found the one, and I'm never leaving Siobhan. This is a relationship for life, Siobhan, because you will edit everything I do forever, and since I have 60 books out, that's a lot of books that you have edited of mine.
Speaker 2So I'm sorry, I guess is what I'm trying to say here.
Speaker 3So I think that would be is.
Speaker 2So she is my seventh editor, okay, so. So, siobhan, I know you and I had talked about what we wanted to do on this call and I am going to let you name it, what you actually name it. But in the school, we have something that we refer to as murder boarding. Now, if you don't have a military background and or have never heard the term, no, we are not trying to kill anyone. What it is is, it's constructive feedback. But we're not going to hold back, we're not holding back any punches.
Speaker 2We're not holding back any thoughts. We're not holding back any punches. We're not holding back any thoughts. The goal here is to give you, to the minutiae, every little bit that you can improve about yourself in as constructive a way as possible, so that you can be the best version of yourself. And when we do murder boarding in the school, well, I asked Siobhan, who has murder boarded so many of my books, right, if she would murder board some of the students opening pages, because, let's be honest, that first page sells the book, right?
Speaker 2And so now Siobhan offers murder boarding as a service, or what do you actually call it?
Speaker 3Murder boarding. Yeah, it's become so ubiquitous now.
Speaker 2That's awesome, I love it. All right. Well, I know you had a a presentation, so why don't you take it away?
Speaker 3okay, um, thanks so much for having me on. This is really exciting for me because you know I've been working with students with from the school, um, for years now and um, I'm just very excited about both spcom as well as um helping write the best books possible. That's always been basically the reason I got into editing. So let's dive in. I'm going to share my screen, okay, can you all see this?
Speaker 2Yes. I'm going to play Okay Is.
Speaker 3Is that you're seeing that? that looks perfect, yep um, yeah, so, um, basically, what I'm going to be talking about today is these openers to great novels. We're going to be looking at them in three genres thriller, romance and sci-fi, um, and then we're going to be looking at student submissions in each of those genres and, um, the original submission and then how I think it might be stronger and why. So, before I dive into the three genres, I think it's really crucial here to cover the four elements of what I call a killer opener, keeping with the murder board theme, and the first of them is point of view and tense.
Speaker 3So readers many of them who are not trained as writers or to know how to write or read like a writer, are not thinking about this consciously, but they do have subconscious expectations for getting answers to these things right away when they open a book. Expectations for getting answers to these things right away when they open a book, so, very quickly, they want to know whose head we're in, what POV and what tense we're in. So this typically is first person or third person for POV, and then typically present tense or past tense.
Speaker 3There's obviously more options than that, but these are the most common.
Speaker 2I would just like to interject on one point. I don't care who you are, never write in second person, it just doesn't work, that's it.
Speaker 3There you go. Okay, that's right, rami has told you never write in second person. It obviously doesn't work well for selling books usually. That's right. And the second thing they're looking for is grounding when are we? Because when we open a book, we could be anywhere. We could be on Earth, we could be in outer space, we could be inside a whale's belly. We just don't know until the writer gives us the answer. And so we're kind of floating in this formless void.
Speaker 3Um, the third thing and this is the thing that's in basically every single good opener is raising questions in the reader's mind. You want to raise intrigue so that they can only get those questions answered, that that source of intrigue answered by reading on. Um, and so there's two types of questions you can raise good ones and bad ones. So a good question is if in your first line someone's in a hurry, the point of intrigue is where are they going and why are they in a hurry? This is a question they can get answered by reading on and it keeps them inside your story.
Speaker 3Bad questions create confusion. So between the first and the second line we might change POV entirely or change tense, and this might confuse readers. They might say well, whose head are we in, what tense are we in? And in this way they feel outside the story. They're not in the dream of your world. So you never want to confuse readers with questions like that. You want to keep them inside your story. This is crucial. And then, lastly, this ties in with questions.
Speaker 3Often a way of creating questions is creating tension, bringing up problems. So not all of these have to be in every great opener, or especially the first line, like you'll see a lot of great first lines that only have one or two of these. Some have all four, but the one that you pretty much always are going to encounter is raising questions in the reader's mind. So, with these four elements in mind, let's go through some great openers.
Speaker 3We'll start with thrillers. So I picked the Silence of the Lambs by Thomas Harris. I picked great openers to books that were made into movies or TV shows. This is one of the greatest movies in my opinion. So the opening paragraph goes Behavioral science. The FBI section that deals with serial murder is on the bottom floor of the academy building at Quantico, half buried in the earth.
Speaker 3Clarice Starling reached it, flushed, after a fast walk from Hogan's Alley. On the firing range. She had grass in her hair and grass stains on her FBI Academy windbreaker from diving to the ground under fire in an arrest problem on the range. So, thinking about those four elements in that first line, we get a great sense of grounding Right away. We imagine this building, the bottom floor of the academy building at quantico, half buried in the earth.
Speaker 3It's a wonderful visual. Um, and so we, right away, we feel this kind of sense of realism of being there on the ground.
Speaker 2Um, in virginia, quantico, virginia, right um and also sorry, just it also ties the serial killer, the terminology half buried.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 2And it's funny because I know that Chandler talks a lot about in in entrepreneurial spaces, right, and the nonfiction space is about embedding. Right, like you're, you're embedding these concepts, you're embedding, you know what's coming, you're embedding this in. In fiction, embedding is often done by language choice, where the language choice directly ties to the bigger issue or the theme, or you know, in this case it's the serial killer. We are dealing with multiple serial killers, half buried, like you know.
Speaker 2What do serial killers do? They bury their, their you know not evidence. Uh, what do you call their victims? Right, you know. So, yeah, it works really well this is.
Speaker 3I'm glad you brought that up, because this is something I wanted to touch on with regard to thrillers, um and, and that is that thriller readers are expecting this sort of language. This gets them excited right In the first line. We have serial murder, we have FBI, we have half buried. It's not a coincidence or an accident that Harris included the term half buried in the earth. We can imagine not just a building, but a body.
Speaker 2Because we're talking about serial murder yeah, I mean sorry. Just that one word is so great because it also implies simultaneously someone who's in real trouble, right, like someone who's about to die because you buried the dead right, while simultaneously giving hope and that's also a thriller. Expectation is that the hero is going to save someone. We know people are going to die, but someone's going to get saved. So that's the half buried. There's the hope and the despair in just that one word.
Speaker 2Right, it's great yeah.
Speaker 3Great point, yeah, and so you can see that language in other parts of this first paragraph too. You know we see under fire, arrest problem, firing range flushed. You know she's in a rush as well, and so we get lots of tension in this first paragraph and questions why is she in such a rush, why does she have grass all over her, and what's going to happen at the behavioral science building dealing with serial murder? And then the last thing I'd love to point out here is you know, one of the reasons Clarice Starling is often called one of the greatest heroines is because she's simultaneously vulnerable and a badass.
Speaker 3And you see that even in this first paragraph, clarice, you know, is a very specific woman's name, right, and we see in the movie that she's very small, right, we don't get that in this first paragraph, but we know she's wearing her FBI academy wind breaker. She's just a trainee, um, she's a woman, but she's like, really a badass. Already. She's got grass everywhere, but she doesn't even mind, she's, she's got somewhere to be, um, and so you really get a wonderful little portrait of her in this first paragraph.
Speaker 3I already, already, am compelled by Clarice. Okay, so I'm going to move on to a student submission in this genre. So this student writes under the pen name, gp Schumacher, and she writes psychological thrillers, which Silence of the Lambs is sometimes called, and this was a book that she's currently writing, and this is the very opening two paragraphs.
Speaker 3It goes the military are you crazy? Rosie put down her coffee cup and stared at her friend who sat across from her at their high school cafeteria table. Why the heck would you want to go into the military, hadley? Hadley took a sip of her own coffee, then gave her friend a serious look, because not everyone is as genius as you are. The average person isn't guaranteed a full ride, scholarship to college, and certainly not to an Ivy League school. So she's actually doing some things well here. Um, right away, we have a sense of grounding, we know where we're at um, and we also have, um, these two characters kind of at odds a bit.
Speaker 3Um, they're having a conversation where you know one is calling the other crazy. Why the heck would you want to do this? Um. So there's some questions raised, some some tension, that grounding not totally clear. On POV, we do have a clear sense of tense, but I do have some suggestions for how this might be stronger. So I'm going to show you now the revisions I made. So, with my revisions, this now reads Rosie Mullins.
Speaker 3I gave her a fake last name. I don't know if this is her last name, but Rosie Mullins lowered her soda and stared at her friend seated across from her at their high school cafeteria the military. Are you crazy? Why would you want to enlist Hadley? Hadley sipped at her own soda. She set the empty can down with a hollow clank. Not everyone is a genius like you, rosie. Most of us don't get a full ride to college, and certainly not to Brown. So why did I make the changes I made here? First, I really wanted to focus more in on creating a sense of tension from the beginning.
Speaker 3You know, based on the silence of the lambs we get so much tension in that opener and I wanted to amplify the disagreement between these two and also this question of why Rosie hates the military. I wanted to draw all that out. So in order to do that, I utilized her internal thinking and I also had Hadley set the can down with a hollow clank. I made that action do more work in terms of creating tension and then I sort of modified Hadley's dialogue to also get the contention between them.
Speaker 3Second, I tightened the writing. The original had some extra words and I think it reduced some of the power of the writing. All these great openers that you're going to see, they are tight, they do not have one extra word, and so this is such a crucial piece of advice always look to where you can tighten your writing. It will greatly amplify its power. Third, I didn't do this here because I didn't see really opportunities, but I suggested to this writer to incorporate suggestions of physicality or violence In the Silence of the Lambs opener we talked about.
Speaker 3Right, we have so many mentions of serial murder. Have buried um firing range arrest problem, like we have all of this suggestion of violence. Right, and that's what thriller readers are reading for. Is that the possibility of violence? When is it going to come right? And so you're kind of always foreshadowing that in thrillers. Um rami, do you have a thought?
Speaker 2I see you, yeah yeah, I have so, so much. Yeah, I mean one of the mistakes and this is something that I'm always talking to with new writers all the time right, I, just I, I, probably I I must say this like three times a day when I'm coaching, which is just you know, it is imperative that you're setting up the expectations, and the thing is is like I don't care what you want to do with this book, if you're not meeting the genre expectations, it's not going to work, and so, for example, in Thriller, the genre expectations is physical violence.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2And there is always some form of well, I don't even want to say, because you can argue that, like legal thrillers have less physical violence. There'll still be some, but you know, there's a lot of courtroom tension and courtroom battles, but there is two people who are at battle with each other and the stakes are life and death. They're not, they're not, they're not like. The stakes are who gets to own the cat? Right in the divorce, the stakes are life and death. Right, someone is going to either actually die or metaphorically die in in in a thriller.
Speaker 2That's one thing. But then the other thing that you did, which I thought and I and if I'm, if I'm like, like stealing your mojo here I apologize, siobhan the one thing that you did, or there's a lot of improvements here. But there's one thing in particular that I wanted to point out. That is like I really understated genius. Right, you changed. You changed it from coffee, the coffee cup which why do I need a coffee cup to soda, and, and I think the reason why this is so important is because they're in high school, and the, the, the, the, the vision that a high school student is, especially in a high school cafeteria, are drinking a coffee is jarring, especially to an older reader, right, like you know, as an older reader, the idea that a coffee would be in high school was like a non-existent thing.
Speaker 2I don't know what these young you know millennials do, quite honestly, like, that's the, you know. But in my day there was no coffee in the school, all right, unless you're in the teacher's lounge. And, and so I think it is. You know, that idea of, like, bad questions create confusion. The confusion can be created by anything right and simply saying a coffee cup in a high school cafeteria when, well, it seems that they're students and not teachers, right?
Speaker 2Um, that creates just enough confusion for someone to be like, oh my, sorry, I'm gonna shut up in one minute, but I'm gonna. I will raise a, and so shavonna and I have actually co-authored a series together and one of the two series together. That's right and one of the do you remember the hercules criticism? For right.
Speaker 3So uh, remind me okay.
Speaker 2So in the opening scene of the book that had all the right elements, hercules, cupid and two other full-grown adults uh, get into a mustang and drive off. They're being chased by a ghost dinosaur, if you remember this, and mortality bound, right, yeah, right. So that was definitely a Jim Butcher shout out on our part, and I got feedback that was like what the hell's wrong with these people? They clearly don't know what a Mustang is.
Speaker 3I remember now yeah.
Speaker 2Hercules is, is you know? You describe him as the size of arnold schwarzenegger. Arnold schwarzenegger could not fit in the back of a mustang right and they also.
Speaker 3I gave it four doors, I think yeah, yeah, or something like that yeah, it was like how many doors was in question?
Speaker 2yeah, so these points of confusion. Like you, we genuinely never bothered to look up what a Mustang looked like. We both at the time didn't own cars. I do now, but I didn't then, and yeah so, anyway, these points matter is, I guess, what my point is.
Speaker 3So that's exactly it. Yeah, those are bad questions. The coffee and the um the mustang are both questions that hold those readers. I pulled me out of the story with the coffee and um the mustang, out of this, out of the story for that other reader yeah um, so that's a that's a really great point.
Speaker 3Um, the last thing that I would note here is you know, with the choice I made to give rosie a last name when we introduce her? Uh, is you know with the choice I made to give Rosie a last name when we introduce her is a meeting thriller expectations? Right, the first time we meet Clarice, we see her as Clarice Starling and it lends a certain thriller gravitas. You know, like that, this character will be fighting for their life. There's just, yeah, it's just a thriller thing for their life.
Speaker 2There's just, yeah, it's just a thriller thing. Yeah, yeah, actually, on that point, sorry to interrupt again, but, um, do you? We won't out him, just in case he doesn't want to be out. But you know jd kirk, right? So he's an indie author who switched genres from sci-fi to thriller and he's seven figures and, uh, I don't know if you know who he is, but you've met him, we both met him. Anyway, when he was researching the thrillers, he literally that point of the last name, first name, like it, was something he brought up where he not only researched that, that expectation of a full name, but also the expectation of the kind of full name, right, you know, and it, you know, kind of getting that you know, middle America, right, like down to earth, right, generic, you know that kind of thing.
Speaker 2Like you know, these details do matter. So Mullins is a perfect last name.
Speaker 3That's actually something I thought of without really realizing. I thought of it is like what's a generic middle America name that I could give her. That's so true, it's very cool. Yeah, okay, so if, with your approval, I'll move on, are?
Speaker 2you happy Okay?
Speaker 3So the next one is romance. So I decided to pick a romance that is really popular. This one has 43,000 reviews on Amazon. That also got made into a movie. I picked one that is contemporary romance because the student submission is also contemporary. So this one's called the Hating Game by Sally Thorne, and the opening paragraph goes I have a theory Hating someone feels disturbingly similar to being in love with them. I've had a lot of time to compare love and hate and these are my observations and she goes into the observations and the next paragraph is long so I didn't include it.
Speaker 3But this one, I think, really exemplifies a couple things. Right, we have the four elements of a great opener that we've examined. Clearly, we have a very strong voice here, a POV, that first person, and it's really clear narration. But we also have a very distinct romance voice. Romance first person voices tend to be very sharp.
Speaker 3They tend to be witty, incisive. They just carry you along because there's a lot of kind of monologuing that happens as they're describing their life, and so that is. I think one of the most crucial elements in contemporary romance is getting that voice down really well, because typically that's going to be carrying you along through the novel. Of course, there's also the other parts of the romance formula, the plot.
Speaker 3That's crucial as well. The happily ever after. But when it comes to this, opener voice is so, so potent. Yeah, go ahead.
Speaker 2It's also a voice that clearly demonstrates that love is a choice, right like right. So it's because, because, like contemporary romance, in which the person can't like, is forced to be in love, right like right, it's not like an active action to, you know, meeting the person and like the dating and all overcoming the obstacles and all that. But you know, you're kind of in like that 1800s, like you know, damsel in distress kind of era is, is not you know?
Speaker 2So this person clearly feels like someone who's in control, like she's not going to just needlessly get swept away until she is right, until it's just overwhelmingly this is what's going to happen, right.
Speaker 3So that's a great um point there, because it draws on one of the biggest sources of tension in romance, which is they. They basically have to have a huge reason why they would never be with this person, and hating them is about as big a reason as it gets. So it's like readers will be wondering how does one overcome this hate to be with someone? That's why enemies to lovers is so, so popular. So here's a student submission.
Speaker 3This is also contemporary romance. Um, she calls it spicy. Um, so it's okay if I curse. I hope it's not I won't, that's fine okay, um, okay. So, uh, this is victoria benoit, I think that's how you pronounce her pen name. Um, chapter one starts with the male, pov Friedrich. Just a few passes around the room and then we'll go. Okay, I turn to look up at the man next to me. I would generally be considered tall, if not standing next to my best friend who towers over everyone in the room.
Speaker 3He leans to the side slightly to hiss at me this is your last night of freedom. We should be living it up, not crammed in some stuffy ballroom with these fucking vipers. Okay, so clearly this person has a strong sense of the edginess of contemporary romance. She calls it spicy, right, and there is spice already in these first two paragraphs, particularly that last line there paragraphs, particularly that last line there. One thing that I had trouble with is, personally, I couldn't tell who was speaking right away.
Speaker 3I wasn't sure whose dialogue that was, if it was the main character or the best friend, and if I have trouble with something, I usually assume that other readers some may have trouble with it too, because I don't represent all readers, but I certainly represent some, I think, and so that's what makes dialogue very challenging as an opener. So what I did. This is just, personally, how I would strengthen it. Many books open with dialogue very successfully. This is my revision.
Speaker 3What a nest of fucking vipers. I lean toward my best friend to whisper just a few passes around the room and then we'll go. Okay, between the two of us, we tower over everyone here. He hisses at me this is your last night of freedom. We should be living it up, not crammed in this stuffy ballroom with these powdered sycophants, all right. So why did I make these changes? First of all, in the original the best friend was the sexiest guy in the room. The best friend was the one who delivered the fucking Viper's line.
Speaker 3He was the tall one line. He was the tall one, um, and he just he got to deliver like he hissed, like he just got to do all the sexy stuff, um, and. So in my revision it's the main character who is the sexy one. He gets to deliver the viper's line, um, he's just as tall as his best friend. Um, um, and and, and. So now it's there's more focus on him and him being desirable to the reader, basically, yeah.
Speaker 3And then I added powdered sycophants as a replacement for vipers. But you know, insert insult here. Two, remove any potential sources of confusion. Dialogue opener was a source of confusion for me that raised bad questions for me, so I removed that as a source of confusion. Three sharpen the voice, as I mentioned, with that great Sally Thorne opener, a sharp, incisive, first-person voice is really going to carry your book and so you want to make sure that you really punch them with that voice, like you get readers in the solar plexus and then you just don't let go Go ahead.
Speaker 2I have a question though, so and I'm curious. Actually, just this is like I don't know the like, I don't have an opinion or an answer to this, but when you say what a nest of you know fucking vipers, why not an ellipsis? Why a period?
Speaker 3I personally. I mean okay. So I should say that, like, all my choices are choices that I would personally make, and the reason I would personally make that choice is I really like punchy first sentences. Like short, declarative first sentences really have a lot of power to me. That's how, pretty much how, I open all my books, and so that's my choice there.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3You would add an ellipsis.
Speaker 2Yeah, I would. I mean, as you probably have seen in my books, right, I always like to give that sense of lingering thoughts right the lingering thought and so because I really like the way you changed it and I like, for a lot of reasons, that first sentence and having the swear word in the first sentence is extremely jarring. I remember watching an interview with I can't oh my God, I think it was Tony Robbins actually and and so I never really watched anything of Tony Robbins actually and and so I never really watched anything of Tony Robbins or anything, and he and I.
Speaker 2But I had this vision of this guy right, like this guy, like what he was and what he did and stuff. And he, he gets on the in this interview and he's swearing every three words. Right, and I'm going, that's not what I had in my head. This guy would be like right, you know, he's supposed to make people's lives better, but he's saying lots of potty words. Why is he saying the potty words? And I'm just very confused by this. And then in the interview he actually said, like addressed, why he swears and he goes.
Speaker 2Swearing is a great way to get someone's attention because it's often extremely unexpected. And not only is it unexpected, it's such an emotionally charged word that if then, when you throw in that emotionally charged word, you're literally telling people to care.
Speaker 3Yeah, that's a great point.
Speaker 2Yeah, and then I, and so I, because it really was that like dissonance between what I was expecting him to sound like and then what he actually sounded like is very different. Anyway, so I love the first line for that reason, because you're forcing people to to think about or to to decide to care. That's great.
Speaker 3Go ahead.
Speaker 1I think we have. We have one more genre after this, or is this the last genre?
Speaker 3One more.
Speaker 1Okay, cool, let's do that. And then I want to have a couple minutes for some questions. Okay, more general fiction editing and, especially as a newbie, nonfiction person.
Speaker 3All right, we'll go more quickly through this last one. Oh, I think I have a typo, is that right? Andy WEIR? Yes, yes, ok, no typo, we're good, ok. The Martian I know this is a favorite of Rami's. Ok, so it begins. I'm pretty much fucked that's my considered opinion Fucked Six days into what should be the greatest month of my life and it's turned into a nightmare.
Speaker 3So I have a lot of thoughts about why this is working well For one we have, you know we're utilizing that simple declarative opening line and we're combining it with the potty mouth, as Rami called it. And it's not just a simple line, it's its own paragraph. In fact, all four first lines are their own paragraph, which really draws attention to itself not just through that fact, but all the white space we're creating here, and it creates this momentum, this interesting rhythm that we're getting.
Speaker 3This interesting rhythm that we're getting. It's a monologue, essentially similar to what we saw in romance. We have a very sharp voice, and I think that's so important for this novel, right? Because this is an astronaut who gets stranded on Mars and he's all by himself, and so a lot of the novel is carried by his monologue, him talking. He's not even sure if it's to anyone, it's just to himself, maybe, and so he has to have a great voice.
Speaker 3But also, we are made a very important choice here to make him funny. Someone who monologues and isn't funny is in a tragedy, and this is not a tragedy. This is well, it's a comedy, but it has a lot of great tension and high stakes. Any thoughts here before I move on to the student submission?
Speaker 2on to the student submission. Uh, no, not really I. I I love this book and, if you ever want to like, if anyone's not read this book, it is amazing, so that's my only time for a reason.
Speaker 3Yeah, he does a really great job too. Um, with the opener especially, I would say um. So this student submission submission is also in sci-fi, but this one is alien invasion. It's from a student who's writing under the pen name, mj finn. His original submission uh goes, the planetary defense grids. Alarms blared through the city's calm networks, filling the middle of the night with a sense of urgency overlaid with fear. A swarm of cryomech assault vehicles, swarm kites, had been detected streaking away from the enemy high stone.
Speaker 3The initial trajectory placed them landing on the planet's dark side within three hours. Okay, so this student clearly really knows his genre. He's quickly getting in all of this sci-fi language. The aliens are invading immediately, like in the first paragraph, and there's a wonderful sense of grounding and tension. Like it's as high as the tension can get. The problems are great. I do, though, have suggestions for how this could be stronger.
Speaker 3Here's my revised opener. In the deep of the night, the planetary defense grid's alarms activated for the first time, blaring through the city's calm networks. A swarm of cryomech assault vehicles, swarm kites, had been detected, streaking away from the enemy high stone. They would land on the planet's dark side within three hours. Okay. So why did I make these choices? One, I wanted to tighten the writing, especially that first line or the first paragraph.
Speaker 3And why? Because that first line was doing too much on the nose work there, right, like. So we got the. What was it? It was like overlaid with fear and urgency, and that's implied, right, if we're hearing alarms at night, then there's urgency to that and we're probably going to be fearful. So that's all implied, like. We just took that out. And lastly, I wanted to up the ante with this, so I added the alarms activating for the first time.
Speaker 3And in this way, we don't know how it's going to work. This may be the first invasion I don't know if this is true for his opener. I just threw this in because I wanted to make this as high stakes as possible, even more so, and so that was my student revision. And then I'll just move on to my recap of everything real quick so that it all comes home.
Speaker 3So good writing is good writing is good writing. It's always true that great writing is going to be compelling. Remember those opener four elements that are powerful and help readers sink into your novel. They are POV, intense grounding, questions and tension. Secondly, a different dimension here is knowing your genre and meeting reader expectations in your genre. So, each genre that I covered, there were different reader expectations that I pointed out with those.
Speaker 3So, thrillers, it was physicality and violence. Romance, it was a strong voice and the main character being the sexiest one in the room. And then, um, sci-fi, um, it was having basically sci-fi language very quickly, um, immersion in that sort of language in that world, um, and that's it yeah, that's everything what what's hilarious is.
Speaker 2Mj Finn is my student and the other two students are probably with other I mean not probably most certainly with other coaches as well. And so, when you were kind of talking about MJ Finn's stuff, I went, oh yeah, yeah, I actually know this whole. I know what the whole story is about. I know everything. I helped, I helped to plot it out at one, because, uh, you know, when I have a many like new students will always work on a plot line with me, and then he's not a new student, though, he actually someone who's kind of been with us for a while.
Speaker 2Um, but I know that he had called me about this particular book. It was like can we talk this through as, like you know? So, yeah, awesome.
Speaker 1That's awesome.
Speaker 2This is great.
Speaker 1Siobhan, hey, I want to, if you want to unshare your screen and then we can do our final kind of thoughts here. And so, guys, if you, if you missed it, um, you can. You can see a bunch of visuals that will probably make this make a lot more sense. Uh, on the youtube channel, on the video version of the show, um, we're pretty much at time here, but maybe we got. I'll ask one question and then, rami, if you want to ask one question, then we'll wrap. I guess for me, siobhan, I'm curious, first time fiction authors biggest mistakes that they make in the editing process, or just biggest things.
Speaker 1That is kind of like you don't know what you don't know that you would impart to people who are listening or watching.
Speaker 3I would say that the thing I see most often is people overwriting um, that they 90% of people tend to write too much Um, and then they can pull it back and make their writing a lot more powerful. Basically, with all three of those examples I showed, I pulled back and then the writing popped. So that is, I would say, the most common thing.
Speaker 2Nice, and then I think if I were to ask a question along those lines. It's like, so when the overriding is kind of dealt with, what is the kind of mistake that you find, like outside of the overriding that just tends to reverberate throughout the story? Like, where do young writers kind of, where does the story fall apart for them?
Speaker 2Like, where are the points of danger for a young writer? If that makes sense.
Speaker 3I would say the biggest point of danger, the thing that will make or break your story developmentally and by that I mean your big picture stuff is having a character who is passive or doesn't want anything, like in the Clarice Starling Silence of the Lambs opener. She's on the move, like in the first paragraph, she's in a rush, even though she has grass all over her, and already she's dynamic, already she's intriguing. And a good rule of thumb is to give your character a goal in every scene, whether it's big or small.
Speaker 3Have them moving towards something, and this is always going to make your writing more compelling and stronger. And it's when your characters don't want anything, when they're just passive. Then the writing immediately becomes less interesting.
Speaker 1Thanks, I love it. I know you guys could probably talk for hours and hours on fiction editing and I know you talk about it a lot in the courses and stuff, Rami, and so I guess my last question for you, Siobhan, would be where can people go to find out more about you with you.
Speaker 3You're editing all that good stuff, yeah, so um I can be reached at my website, motif M O T I F editscom. Um, or you can email me directly, siobhan, at motif editscom.
Speaker 1Love it. Uh well, guys, if you're interested in checking out more about what we do at self-publishingcom, you can go to selfpublishingcom, forward slash fiction. You can book a call with the team there. They'd be happy to chat with you and walk you through. You know your goals for your book challenges, how we might be able to help all that good stuff. We also have a ton of fiction training, webinars, blog content all that stuff from rami on selfpublishingcom and on our other sites and publishing school. So if you're looking for good fiction training, feel free to check that out or book a call with the team at selfpublishingcom forward slash fiction and come back next week.
Speaker 1We'll be diving into more fiction stuff as part of the fiction takeover. Thanks y'all. Thank you so much.
A new book gets published every eight seconds, and most authors get buried in the stack. Here are the nine new rules of writing and publishing a book in 2027. We dug into the data on what's actually selling: print vs....
Did you know the majority of the most successful nonfiction books, including Prince Harry's Spare and Phil Knight's Shoe Dog, were actually penned by ghostwriters? In this video, Chandler Bolt breaks down the hidden...
After 12 years and helping over 8,000 authors publish their books across 91 countries, Chandler Bolt reveals why he is officially shutting down Self Publishing School. In this candid video, discover the three biggest...
This book brought in $7 million for my business in the last 12 months. In this video, I break down the exact system to use a book to double your leads, sales, and referrals. In this video: - How to come up with a book...
Why do a small sliver of ghostwritten books become massive bestsellers while the vast majority completely flop? Chandler Bolt dives deep into data from thousands of author consultations to reveal the 9 fatal mistakes...