The Complicated Ethics of Ghostwriters & Celebrity Books
15 minAudio
Did you know the majority of the most successful nonfiction books, including Prince Harry's Spare and Phil Knight's Shoe Dog, were actually penned by ghostwriters? In this video, Chandler Bolt breaks down the hidden ethics behind celebrity books, exposing where the line sits between smart collaboration and outright fraud. Discover the 5-question test to keep your ghostwritten book completely honest, capture your authentic voice, and use a proven publishing process to build authority without misleading your readers. Follow selfpublishing.com Instagram https://www.instagram.com/selfpublishingcom/ Follow Chandler Bolt Instagram https://www.instagram.com/chandler.bolt/ Thousands of first-time authors have already turned their ideas into bestselling books with our guidance. You could be next. Book A Free Consultation Popular Free Resources: Download your 1-Page Book Launch Plan Nonfiction Book Outline Template Fiction Book Outline Template Follow selfpublishing.com Youtube Instagram TikTok Facebook Follow Chandler Bolt YouTube ...
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Spare by Prince Harry sold 3.2 million copies in its first week, and it's one of the fastest-selling nonfiction books ever. Harry didn't write it. A ghostwriter did. Here's the dirty little secret of the publishing industry. The majority of the most successful books that exist were ghostwritten. So is it cheating? Is it misleading? Well, it's more complicated than you think. By the end of this video, you'll know which famous books were ghostwritten, why it feels like cheating at times, when it is cheating, and the five questions that separate an honest ghostwritten book from a fraud. Then we'll run spare through those questions.
SPEAKER_00At the end, I'm breaking it all down. I'm Chandler Bolt, my company selfpublishing.com. Publishes about two books a day, including Ghostwritten Books for Founders and Experts. So I see how this really works from the inside. And spoiler, ghostwriting a book is not a bad thing if you do it the right way. Let's start with how common this is. So this goes way back to Nancy Drew. 80 million copies sold. This was written under the name Carolyn Keane, a name that was never a real person. So is that a ghostwriter? Is that a pen name?
SPEAKER_00Call it what you want. And it's not just old books. Here's some of the most popular nonfiction books that were ghostwritten. Obviously, already mentioned Spare by Prince Harry. 3.2 million copies. Trump, The Art of the Deal, that was also ghostwritten by Tony Schwartz, over a million copies sold and 48 weeks on the New York Times bestseller list. Shoe Dog, this is one of my favorite books ever by Phil Knight. I just learned recently that it was not written by him. Uncredited help from J.R. Moringer.
SPEAKER_00This was a multi-million seller and a staple of some of the best business books of all time. Can't hurt me, David Goggins. He had a co-writer named Adam. Scribe also tries to claim credit for that book, but it was Adam that wrote it. Never split the Difference by Chris Voss. All right, this was written by Tal Raz. Maybe you've heard some of his books. He sold a bunch of books. That book itself did incredibly well. Will by Will Smith. This is a this is a fun one. This is Mark Manson. I just ran into him on a plane the other day. I love his books.
SPEAKER_00He's great, but he ghostwrote that book for Will Smith, and it's a number one New York Times bestseller. I am Malala. This was with a co-author, Christina Lamb. Opened by Andre Agassi, another one of my favorite books of all time. I'm a big tennis guy. This was J.R. Moringer again. Did you catch the name? Turns out there's a pattern. That guy is behind three of those books, three of some of the most successful books of all time. He ghostwrited. Why is that? Well, top modern ghostwriters aren't hidden secrets. And the big name authors, whether it's a president or a professional athlete or anywhere in between, they ask for them by name and they have a process.
SPEAKER_00So if this is everywhere, why does it still feel dishonest? Or maybe why does it feel like cheating or this thing that you got to hide and not tell people about? And really the big question is where's the line? Okay, so the pattern here, obviously, yes, proven process, past credibility. That's what you need to look for if you choose to hire a ghostwriter or ghostwriting company to write your book. But where's the line between we credit them, we don't, this is okay, this is not. The fine line is the perfume test. Think about this. Nobody thinks that a celebrity made this fragrance, right?
SPEAKER_00Maybe they gave some input on it. Nobody thinks that they sewed their own merch. But I guess books feel different because it's feels like a personal creation. So this is when we move into the memoir, which I would say this is a little bit more gray area, but it's also very common practice. People care about it being your stories. We'll get to that in just a little bit. But who is the content and who's generating the content? If it's you and then a memoir is just the vehicle, if you will, well, then sure, that's totally fine. And then some people would say with fiction, the creative talent is the project. Uh so this is not okay.
SPEAKER_00I think the jury's still out on this specifically. Some really great and successful not fiction books were ghostwritten. Now, maybe the kernel of the idea or the storyline was created by the author, but then it was written, it was penned by an actual ghostwriter itself. This is when people get really pissed about ghostwriters. Either one, the creator has a whole brand on, hey, I did this myself, I did everything myself, and then they didn't write the book themselves. That feels kind of weird, maybe a little bit disingenuous. Right. But then I think the other part is when the book isn't good and doesn't read like them. That's what they want.
SPEAKER_00Right? You read Matthew McConaughey's book, you want it to be him. You read Dave Portnoy's book, you want it to sound like him. Here's where I win. Using a ghostwriter was never the cheating part, but hiding it is. Now I'm not saying that you got to put them on the cover or anything like that, but just be upfront about it. Now, ghostwriters know the deal. They're paid professionals who sign up for it. They know that their name is probably not gonna be on the cover. Maybe they're mentioned in the credits, but they're not doing it for the credit, they're doing it to make some money and to write a great book and to be a conduit for other people's stories.
SPEAKER_00So this is the who not how idea. Anytime you run into a problem in your life or in your business with a book, ask who not how. Because if you figure out the who, well, the who are ghostwriters, they've written a bunch of books successfully. Well, then I can just pay them for a shortcut. So, what does it look like when it's done correctly? Well, I'll I'm I'm kind of peel back the curtain on our ghostwriting process and how it works. Now I'll be up front here. This is not for everyone. I don't talk about this often because we're very selective about who we work with and we've got very limited slots. So it's probably not a fit, but this is at least what you should be looking for when you go through the process.
SPEAKER_00So for us, it starts with the clarity call. We get clear on the book idea, the audience, where it fits in the market. You hand over everything that you got. So videos, podcasts, recordings, blogs, ideas, all that stuff on that clarity call. And then we also, most importantly, get super clear about the outcomes that you're trying to drive with the book. You got to be clear on that. We want to be clear on that so that we can help you win. Is the goal to generate a bunch of business? Great. Let's reverse engineer it to do that. Then we move into the outline that you approve. So we shape the frameworks, the chapters, we create an outline, and nothing gets written until you sign off on that outline.
SPEAKER_00This is really important because if you don't do this, well, then you're gonna end up working with someone who just writes a book that you're like, what? You wrote 15 chapters on this? Like, what is this? Is not at all where I wanted to go with this book. That's why we approved the outline up front. Next is chapters in your voice. So we've got a dedicated writer on our team who drafts chapter by chapter backed by that outline, backed by your voice, your concepts. We synthesized all that stuff. So we know that we're you're we're writing on message and in your voice.
SPEAKER_00And then we refine this chapter by chapter. That's the really important part. So we'll write the first chapter, send it to you for feedback and approval. Then we'll use that to write the next few chapters. Okay, now send it back to you. Then we'll use that to write the rest of the book. That flow is really good because you catch things early. The horror stories that I hear from people who hire a ghostwriter, and this is really common. It's actually hard to not go down this path. Is I hear from people who say, I hired a ghostwriter. A year later, they gave me the manuscript. It totally sucked. I scrapped it and rewrote the whole thing. That's very common. Well, why does that happen?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's because they skipped these first three steps and they just went straight to, okay, cool. Yep, we'll just do a little intro call, maybe a couple interviews, and then we're gonna go in our lab and we'll see you in a couple months. It's a horrible process. Do not hire someone if that is their process. The last step of the process is editing and production. So we go through multiple rounds of editing, developmental editing, copy editing, proofreading, all that stuff. Final approval, that's really important. We lock the manuscript and then we move into production. So that's the formatting, the cover design, ISBN, all those important things.
SPEAKER_00And then I would say that's the book is done and ready to launch. But this is where we move into launch mode. And this is a lot of people just they just give you a ghostwritten book and they're like, yeah, cool, the launch, that's on you. I would say that's a big thing that differentiates us, is we align it with your goals and then we come alongside you and make sure that the launch is a success. Hey, quick interruption: if what you're hearing right now is making you think about your own book, don't let that feeling pass. We've helped thousands of authors turn that exact feeling into a published book that builds their authority in their business. If you want to be next, come find us on Instagram at selfpublishing.com and send us a DM with the word ready.
SPEAKER_00Our team will reach out, we'll learn about your book, we'll map out exactly the path forward and what it looks like for you. We'll create a custom plan, DM us ready, find us on Instagram, and let's get back into the episode. So no matter who you work with, that's our process, right? But just make sure that you work with a company or a ghostwriter that has an established track record. So they've helped publish a bunch of books, right? In our case, we've published over 8,000 books. We've gotten a bunch of people results. So make sure that when you're looking out there, hey, they've done it and they have a process and you feel confident that they can capture your voice, your story, help you achieve your goals.
SPEAKER_00But then once you've done that, maybe you've hired a ghostwriter, you choose to do it. Well, then you're probably asking, hey, how do I do this in a way that is ethical, that is honest, that is above board? At least I hope you're asking that. Maybe you don't care about that. In which case, definitely don't work with us. But so the five question tests, this is these are just questions to ask to keep it above the line. So first is whose story is it? I want to make sure if if you're hiring a ghostwriter, it's your story, it's your life, it's your ideas, it's your expertise. Because if it's somebody else's, well, then they should just write that book about themselves, right?
SPEAKER_00That's not your book. They're not ghostwriting your book, they're just writing slop or they're writing some random book that's not about you. Second is how involved were you? Now, you don't have to be crazy involved, but your concepts do, right? So did you shape it? Did you approve stuff? Did you give them the actual raw materials or have them mine for raw materials? Well, if it's predominantly your story, cool. Maybe it takes you five hours, maybe it takes you 50, maybe it takes you 500. I mean, that would be pretty bad ghostwriter, but uh, you know, depending on how long it takes you to get there. But is it the kernel of the idea, the main stuff, is it you?
SPEAKER_00Now, question three here is will you own every word? I think this is the most important question. Are you willing to put your name on this book? If the answer is no, well, then you probably shouldn't publish it. Now I get it. Some people just say, hey, this is just a calling card for me. This is just a credibility thing for my business. You know, it doesn't need to be that good. Sure, if that's your take, go for it. But for me, I want to say, am I willing to put my name on the line? Like my name on this book. And then four, are you faking a skill? Like if you want to tell your story, great. But if you're posing as something that you're not, or you're teaching on things that you haven't done, what are you doing?
SPEAKER_00No one's gonna read it, no one's gonna want that book because you haven't done the thing. And then the last thing is, would readers feel lied to if they saw the process? If yes, credit the writer. Again, you can just put it in the acknowledgments of the book. You don't kind of put it on the cover, but you just keep it above board and and don't I don't want to feel embarrassed about it. You shouldn't feel embarrassed about it. Be straightforward. Let's go back to the beginning of this video and run spare through this five question test. So whose story is it? What's his? How involved was he? It's his life and his words through a really good ghostwriter.
SPEAKER_00Will he own every word? Well, yeah, he did. His name's on the cover, so that's owning it. And he took the backlash from the book itself. Is he faking a skill? No. He told his story, he didn't claim to be a novelist, and I think it's you know, pretty well understood that someone helped him write the book, right? It's pretty straightforward. And then would readers feel lied to? No. I mean, again, pretty understood that he had someone write the book for him. So I would say spare passes this test. Now, if you want to pass the test, it's no different whether you're a CEO or president using a speechwriter, you using a ghostwriter to communicate your ideas through the written word.
SPEAKER_00The most important stories often belong to people who don't have the time or the writing skills to tell them. That's why ghostwriters are so important. Think about all of those books that we've never had the benefit of reading, being inspired by, being encouraged, learning from. If there wasn't a great ghostwriter behind the scenes, making sure that the story was told well. Books change lives, and a ghostwriter is how more of them get written. Celebrity bestsellers also fund the industry, which keeps the door open for a bunch of new authors. So the cheating was never the ghostwriting, it's pretending that there wasn't a ghostwriter in the first place.
SPEAKER_00If you've got a story worth the book, a ghostwriter can be a really great option if you've got the budget. They can help you get the book done better and faster and higher quality in the process. So if you're serious about hiring a ghostwriter to help you write your book, click the link in the description. You can book a call with our team. Spots are extremely limited. We only take on one client a month in our premium ghostwriting program. So again, may not be a fit, but click the link. We we're happy to map out your book, your goals, and see if we can help you in the process. I hope you enjoyed this video.
SPEAKER_00I'd love to hear from you in the comments which book on the list surprised you the most and which one should have credited the writer. Let me know in the comments. For me, shoe dog, that was the big surprise. I freaking love that book. Although I would say open is another one. Just two great books. When I found out that they were ghostwritten, I did not care. The book was great. All right, so comment below, let me know which one you like best. If you want to learn more about ghostwriting, and if you're wondering why most ghostwritten books fail, watch this video.
SPEAKER_00Small percentage are the massive successes, the biggest successes, but most of them don't do well. Watch this video next to find out where.
A new book gets published every eight seconds, and most authors get buried in the stack. Here are the nine new rules of writing and publishing a book in 2027. We dug into the data on what's actually selling: print vs....
After 12 years and helping over 8,000 authors publish their books across 91 countries, Chandler Bolt reveals why he is officially shutting down Self Publishing School. In this candid video, discover the three biggest...
This book brought in $7 million for my business in the last 12 months. In this video, I break down the exact system to use a book to double your leads, sales, and referrals. In this video: - How to come up with a book...
Why do a small sliver of ghostwritten books become massive bestsellers while the vast majority completely flop? Chandler Bolt dives deep into data from thousands of author consultations to reveal the 9 fatal mistakes...
Most books don't even sell 100 copies. Here is the proven path to sell more books and reach 10,000 copies starting from zero. Many authors struggle to get traction because they lack a clear roadmap. We are breaking down...