Episode 409 is the next to last excerpt from the seven author book Liberating Theory. It presents a set of concepts and general observations about their likely mutual relations meant to inform activism better than past conceptions, including Historical Materialism. The authors--Michael Albert, Leslie Cagan, Noam Chomsky, Robin Hahnel, Mel King, Holly Sklar, and Lydia Sargent--observe that history is messy because people make it and each pivotal part of society pushes on every other pivotal part. They start with a simple belief: To pursue attainable, worthy aims with strategy that actually works, we need a theory of social change able to explain both stability and change without pretending there’s a single master determinant of each. The excerpted chapter breaks down two kinds of change that get blurred all the time: the daily activity that keeps core structures intact, or social reproduction, and the kind of revolutionary shift that alters defining institutions and lived experience, or social transformation. From there the episode considers a question that keeps recurring across movements: what counts as “real” revolution? Instead of treating the economy as the only sphere of life that matters, Liberating Theory emphasizes a four-sphere view of society--economic, kinship and gender, community and culture (including race and nationality), and politics and the state--and argues that fundamental change in any of them can be revolutionary. A key concept emerges and is in play when the dynamics of any one sphere actively reproduce the defining relations of one or more others. When "co-reproduction" is the case, when, for example, racism, sexism, class domination, and authoritarian power mutually reproduce one another, then “winning” in one sphere can get pulled back into old patterns by the spheres left untouched. We also consider how other interconnections impact how core characteristics can change or persist and why though precise prediction in history is limited, broad prediction is essential for activist planning. The episode addresses social theory, historical materialism, revolutionary possibilities, and building movements that don’t trade one domination for another. The authors felt they provided a sharp conceptual toolbox to engage with and either reject or further refine. So which will it be? You decide. Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello, my name is Michael Albert, and I am the host of the podcast that's titled Revolution Z. This is our four hundred and ninth consecutive episode, and it continues the sequence at excerpts from the seven author book Liberating Theory. This time the collective work addressed concepts for understanding history with the aim to next and finally address vision and strategy. This excerpt begins Can we ever understand history?
SPEAKER_00Can we explain this long running drama with its countless plots and subplots, past, present and future? Or can we only provide narrow pulse mortems of brief interludes? Can we conceptualize social change in ways which enhance strategy and program? Frederick Angles, one of science's great popularizers, described history's imponderability this way When we consider and reflect upon nature at large or the history of humankind or our own intellectual activity, at first we see the picture of an endless entanglement of relations and reactions, permutations and combinations in which nothing remains what, where, and as it was, but everything moves, changes, comes into being, and passes away.
SPEAKER_00We see, therefore, at first the picture as a whole, with its individual parts still more or less kept in the background. We observe the movements, transitions, connections, rather than the things that move combined and are connected. This primitive, naive, but intrinsically correct conception of the world is that of ancient Greek philosophy, and was first clearly formulated by Heraclitus. Everything is and is not, for everything is fluid, is constantly changing, constantly coming into being and passing away.
SPEAKER_00The Greek and Zen conceptions that Angels admires, while essentially correct, encompass too much and pinpoint too little to be analytically useful. At a point in time a society is certainly a single network, as these viewpoints emphasize, but in order to understand any society, we must conceptually divide it into finer parts, we have called the human center, institutional boundary, and four spheres of social activity.
SPEAKER_00Not surprisingly, the same need arises when we view any society's historical development. While we should begin by recognizing the integrity of the historical process, we must also define more focused concepts. To begin this process, we adopt a familiar distinction between two different types of social change, each of which we need to theorize reproduction versus transformation, social stability versus social change.
SPEAKER_00People constantly make their own history, including themselves and their social institutions. We act, we form expectations, and we find those expectations fulfilled or disappointed. Beginning with the obvious, we can usefully conceptually divide people's quote history making activities into two types. The first type generates human and institutional characteristics fundamentally similar to those of preceding periods.
SPEAKER_00Even when it changes second order features, this type of activity also recreates defining characteristics and patterns of the past. We call this type of change reproduction because even as it alters some attributes, it reproduces core human and institutional structures. The quote structural continuity of society's defining features results not from dormancy, but from human activity. Technology develops in ways such that the social relations of production reproduce.
SPEAKER_00Fashions and modes of child rearing alter in ways such that defining kinship relations remain. The other possibility for social change is that our activity creates human and or institutional characteristics fundamentally different from the characteristics of preceding time periods. Instead of recreating main defining structures while changing only peripheral characteristics, this type of transformation alters defining structures and creates new core characteristics fundamentally different from those of the past.
SPEAKER_00Political relations move from authoritarian to formally democratic. Defining community structures are replaced. It follows that both social reproduction and social transformation result from human activity. In either case, reproduction or transformation, outcomes must be explained and not taken for granted, since even social stability is produced by a particular kind of social motion. But having understood that much, we encounter more subtle gradations of understanding, where conceptual differences start to distinguish historical analysts.
SPEAKER_00How much change makes any characteristic quote fundamentally different versus quote fundamentally similar? And how much of the human center and or the institutional boundary must change quote fundamentally before we conclude that we have experienced a quote social revolution? Besides observing that these questions, like all others related to concept defining, can only be mediated by practical considerations, we agree with adherents of every other social theory we know of that it is useful to categorize many kinds of changes as consistent with overall social stability.
SPEAKER_00Things have certainly in some sense changed when a woman is selected as a candidate for vice president by the Republican or Democratic Party, when a progressive black presidential candidate wins a substantial share of the primary vote, when a wave of mergers increases monopolization of the economy, when the steel industry declines, when a right wing Republican defeats a liberal Democrat for the presidency, when abortion is legalized, when rock and roll arrives on the scene, when a voters registration drive adds millions of low income voters to the rolls, when a mass campaign of civil disobedience forces a shift in US policy toward South Africa, things have certainly changed, indeed, but only within the confines of overall social stability.
SPEAKER_00Such changes may occur in both center and boundary, but society's defining contours remain in place. I interject. Please remember. Please remember liberating theory was written forty years ago. So the examples that appear are generally not from our time in twenty twenty six, but from its time forty years back. The chapter continues.
SPEAKER_00Changes that involve qualitative transformation occur less frequently than system preserving changes, but have more importance from the perspective of social activists. A change in the kinship sphere that replaces one form of patriarchy with another or eliminates patriarchy altogether. A change in the community sphere, drastically altering relations between the races, such as the abolition of slavery or the dismantling of apartheid. A change in the economic sphere, in which the coordinator or working class replaces capitalists as the ruling class.
SPEAKER_00A change in political relations, in which representative democracy replaces monarchy or participatory democracy replaces one party bureaucracy. What distinguishes these and other fundamental changes is the characteristics of both the human center and institutional boundary change sufficiently so that the way that human activity is carried out in at least one sphere fundamentally alters. The social organization for carrying out the activity is changed, and the definitions of social groups and or social relations between groups that carry out that activity are transformed.
SPEAKER_00The change is experienced as a change in society's core characteristics and thus in the meaning and quality of life, for better or worse. But in addition to distinguishing between fundamental change and social stability, we must also decide how much social change must occur before there has been a social revolution. For traditional Marxists, only a fundamental transformation in the economic sphere constitutes a social revolution.
SPEAKER_00A change in ruling class and in the quote mode of production is for Marxists a social revolution, whereas equally drastic changes in state, cultural, or kinship relations are not. For these Marxists, drastic changes in the quote superstructure may contribute to a social revolution, to be sure, but only if they culminate in a change of the mode of production itself. And while feminist anarchists and nationalists are slightly less insistent on making analogous claims, in practice too, they tend to view quote social revolution as a semantic term to be applied only when there is a fundamental social change in their favored sphere.
SPEAKER_00Of course, the assumption behind the claim of each of these schools is that the dynamics of their favored sphere are at the root of all society's most important characteristics and tendencies. Therefore, unless these change, things pretty much quote, stay the same. While recognizing that definitions themselves can be neither quote wrong nor quote right, only more or less applicable and useful, we remain critical of these conceptual choices because they promote all the errors we warned of in our earlier discussions of monism.
SPEAKER_00Instead of defining social revolution as a fundamental social change in only one particular sphere of social life, we think it is more useful to define the term to refer to a fundamental change in any of the four deciding spheres of social life. We must then investigate the prospects for change in each sphere in any society and whether spheres are likely to change alone, in tandem, or only collectively as a whole.
SPEAKER_00Marx himself gave us the most succinct formulation of the more monist quote historical materialist view. At a certain stage of their development, the material forces of production and a society come into conflict with the existing relations of production, or what is but a legal expression for the same thing, with the property relations within which they have been at work before. From forms of development of the forces of production, those relations turn into their fetters.
SPEAKER_00Thus begins an epoch of social revolution. With the change of the economic foundation, the entire immense superstructure is more or less rapidly transformed. The problem that this quote historical materialist definition of social revolution is not that the economy is less influential than Marx thought, but that there are at least four influential spheres, not one, which define and texture society and one another.
SPEAKER_00The quotation would be just as compelling if we substituted any of the other three spheres of social activity for the economy while changing the appropriate references. Recognizing this, we can further see that during periods of social stability, the four spheres can change at different paces and be more or less in or out of sync in their motions, though they will all move only within limits set by society's core characteristics. Insofar as spheres accommodate or code define, reproductive changes in any one can easily percolate into others.
SPEAKER_00A changing pattern of intercommunity relations may affect norms within factories or alter political alignments. A change in industrial structure may provoke changes in school curricula and the family, or vice versa. But as long as none of the core characteristics of a particular society change, as long as there is no fundamental social change in any of the spheres of its social life, it has only ongoing social stability. On the other hand, the kind of revolutionary transformation described by Marx above can evolve for any of the four spheres from either what Marxists call internal contradictions within any one of those four spheres, or from disruptive dynamics between them.
SPEAKER_00The economy can rupture due to its own motions and internally develop contradictions, or due to changes in another sphere which disrupt its functioning and cause its classes to intensify their struggles. And vice versa. To the extent that spheres accommodate and code define, fundamental changes in one can provoke fundamental changes in others. A revolution in political forms can, but won't necessarily engender a subsequent revolution in culture or vice versa.
SPEAKER_00The point is that historical materialism and all other monist orientations must be replaced by a view of historical change that one sees at least four essential spheres of social life instead of one. Two, sees fundamental change in each sphere as equally deserving of being considered revolutionary. Three, sees accommodation and co definition as two way streets between all spheres and subspheres of society, so that to the extent that interrelations between spheres are strong, both non fundamental and fundamental change will quote percolate from one to others.
SPEAKER_00Achieving this much yields a theoretical framework able to help us organize our thoughts about history in ways that provide us with explanations of contemporary and past events and hypotheses about future possibilities. But if one believes the interconnections between spheres and societies are often very strong, it is tempting to generalize further. Thus, if a society's spheres are strongly co defining, a revolutionary change in one will generally have to produce revolutionary transformations in all others, or eventually experience a kind of counter revolution itself, as the co reproductive forces from other spheres reestablish old core characteristics in the sphere that had changed.
SPEAKER_00I interject. It sounds a bit complex, I guess, but the idea is actually pretty simple. If the goings on in a particular part of life, kinship or economy or uh cultural and community relations or the state are strong enough that they co-reproduce the dynamics of other spheres, in other words, what goes on in the economy is such that it kelp co-reproduces, it reproduces what what the characteristics are of kinship and likewise for all the other pairings, then the changes that occur in a sphere will also uh tend to foster changes in other spheres.
SPEAKER_00And as well, changes in a sphere that fail to c to affect another sphere may leave that other sphere impacting back on the first and reinstituting its old ways. A change in kinship without a change in economy may cause or may yield a situation in which the economy's tendency to reproduce sexism reverts what had occurred in the kinship sphere.
SPEAKER_00I hope that's clear. It's probably would be clearer to be read and thought about, but I'm trying to convey it in this uh podcast format. The chapter continues Given this sort of interaction, which may or may not operate in any particular society in any chosen epoch, for a revolution to be successful and remain successful in any one sphere, it would have to be accompanied by or somehow unleash a still more cyclysmic change throughout all of society, a change fundamentally altering all spheres and all characteristics, not only one.
SPEAKER_00Or a more optimistic way of saying the same thing would be to note that if in some society the co reproducing connections between spheres were strong enough, revolutionary change in any one of them might generate strong pressure for compatible revolutionary transformations in others. Sometimes old, largely unchanging kinship forms can come into conformity with a newly revolutionized economy through only modest alterations.
SPEAKER_00Other times, economic revolution may spur a subsequent revolution in kinship relations as well. But what if new economic forms are incompatible with old but intractable kinship forms? Then if social stability is to be reestablished and if kinship forms won't alter to conform with the newly altered economic forms, the economic forms will have to alter again or even revert to their old shapes.
SPEAKER_00This is one among many possibilities of the same sort that Marxists and all other monist theories tend not to or even refuse to recognize, not only for economics and kinship, but for all spheres in all directions. Since such relationships vary from societies to society, in tune with social conditions in each, we can't sensibly generalize about the likely strength of such mutual interconnections, nor about the likelihood that old spheres interconnected to the one that undergoes a revolutionary change will always drag it back, or vice versa, that a transformed sphere will always drag old ones forward.
SPEAKER_00What happens will vary from situation to situation. There are many paths other than ours that go beyond historical materialism. And while these approaches are often motivated by desires to overcome many of the same monus weaknesses we have discussed, this does not immunize them against new mistakes or the familiar problem of quote throwing out the baby along with the bathwater. Here, before further elaborating our own alternative, by way of motivation we mention a few examples of flawed attempts to go beyond the failures of historical materialism.
SPEAKER_00One response to the economism of historical materialism has been to deny the existence of critical contradictions in modern capitalist economies. Such approaches might argue that post-Keynesian economic reforms, such as fiscal and monetary policy, incomes policies, profit sharing, labor participation at some levels of corporate decision making, and indicative planning or quote industrial policy, can smooth out capitalism's main problems.
SPEAKER_00The implication is that if these methods could be scientifically applied by knowledgeable technocrats insulated from politicians subject to partisan pressures, they would render the economic quote contradictions of capitalism obsolete. While there is much to be learned from these arguments, particularly by Marxists who continue to pursue the chimera of a falling rate of profit or an inevitable crisis of underconsumption, the struggle over control of work process and distribution of its fruits will continue at least as long as capitalism does.
SPEAKER_00Claiming to master the economic sphere of modern capitalism, heralding a quote, end of ideology, or minimizing the economy's importance by adopting a non economic form of monism, such as radical ph feminism, are both mistaken correctives to historical materialism. It does no good to, quote, transcend Marxist analyses by denying the importance of economics instead of recognizing the importance of other spheres as well.
SPEAKER_00Or by denying the importance of classes instead of recognizing the existence of other agents of change as well, or by denying the progressive role of workers instead of seeing that their role is complex. Another attempt to transcend Marxism is represented by Andre Gors, who holds that the economic sphere is centrally important, but argues that the industrial working class can no longer act as a progressive agent of history. If the future requires so much technological and social restructuring that industrial jobs and the relative status of industrial workers must be undermined by any desirable form of progress, then along with Gors, one might reason that industrial workers will be initially inclined to protest such transformations, not propel them.
SPEAKER_00Although there is certainly considerable insight in this analysis, regrettably Gors accompanies it with a thesis that the workplace itself must always be marred by a lack of self management. Gors can only see the dawn of a new day in society's other spheres of life, not at work. But this is tantamount to unnecessarily tying one's hands before undertaking battle. An alienated economy means an alienated society. Still another possibility, propounded by many social democrats, for example, is what we might call neopopulism.
SPEAKER_00Advocates rightly criticize Marxists and other monists for being too narrow and intellectually elitist in imposing a single focus on all analyses. But neopopulism's critique of Marxism does not extend to Marxism failure to identify the existence of empowered employees who can seek to become a ruling class by monopolizing knowledge and skills, and indeed, this is because neopopulism actually serves coordinator interests.
SPEAKER_00In order to remain invisible, while co-opting traditional workers and other social agents to programs elevating coordinators, coordinator intellectuals must elaborate conceptual frameworks which literally deny the importance of class differentiations of any kind by highlighting the idea of populist community of anti-capitalist actors. Since the aim is to have a coordinator run economy with workers confined to disempowering roles on the one hand or unemployed on the other, there will be considerable attention given to enlarging welfare rights to avoid great poverty and attract allies.
SPEAKER_00But worker power over the economy won't be on the agenda. And at the same time, parallel attitudes regarding racism, democracy, and sexism will also be watered down versions of genuinely liberatory views. For example, we can anticipate that progressives identified with the coordinator class will extol the importance of democracy, but ignore or downplay the development of genuinely participatory alternatives compared to unaccountable electoral models that elites can control and benefit from.
SPEAKER_00We'll decry sexism, but see the need for childcare or maternity leave, primarily as relating to women, will decry racism, but construct their economic alternatives in settings dominated by white men. Of course, advocates of this approach will claim they are seeking change to enhance the enri the interests of all of society's poorest and most oppressed peoples, as reformists generally do. And indeed, if enacted, many of their programs will have some of this sort of impact.
SPEAKER_00But first and foremost, this orientation will foster economic advance for coordinators. Those of us engaged in social theory building should take a cue from other scientists who regularly replace outmoded theories with superior alternatives. Any new theory must explain the successes of its predecessors. We cannot sensibly deny the importance of the economic, kinship, community, or political spheres and drop any of these from our conceptual framework, or deny the importance of oppression based on race, class, gender, or authority, and drop any of these issues from our activist programs.
SPEAKER_00Theory should not extrapolate from a particular situation to all situations without being sure the leap is warranted. Social theorists who see that under certain circumstances pressures on industrial workers, for example, tend to inhibit the likelihood of their grasping progressive options, should not then jump to the conclusion that henceforth industrial workers will play a secondary role in social change. The fact that some set of circumstances makes a particular social group unlikely to take progressive action today doesn't mean that group will not play a progressive role in other circumstances tomorrow, and in no way justifies a leap to the claim that the group is no longer an important historical agent.
SPEAKER_00What more does our own conceptual choice complementary holism say about these matters? We know that history is a single flowing pattern of interconnected changes, yet to think about it in manageable chunks, we need to abstract component parts. Many of the stabilizing and destabilizing forces of history operate on a constant and more or less unconscious basis. The dynamic that induces individuals to choose to behave and develop in ways sanctioned by existing social roles in order to benefit from the fruits of social discourse operates constantly, though this is seldom focused on by those under its influence.
SPEAKER_00Similarly, the disruptive forces of strong human needs that cannot be adequately met by people consigned to oppressed roles and dominant relationships continuously foment daily acts of individual rebelliousness, the causes of which are frequently lost sight of by the perpetrators of oppression. Some of the stabilizing and destabilizing forces, on the other hand, emerge from the conscious behavior of social groups, organized as agents of histories and working for the maintenance of existing social relations or for their transformation.
SPEAKER_00In assessing the possibilities of historical change in any society, complementary holism looks at all these factors and tries to assess their relative strengths. In our conception, a society will tend to remain stable whenever a rough conformity exists between center and boundary and between the four defining social spheres. The state produces personality traits that help reproduce core economic relations and vice versa.
SPEAKER_00The economy runs with only minor contradiction and accommodates hierarchies born of kinship and community relations. Community reproduces itself and class hierarchies, and so on. Under these conditions, changes will occur along a stable trajectory. Within limits, people will expect and be capable of what social institutions require of them. Each defining sphere's field of force will be in rough conformity with the character of consciousness and institutions in all other spheres, and all changes will be constrained to preserve these harmonious relations between spheres.
SPEAKER_00Under these conditions, the dissipative systems within society and the dissipative system that is society itself will certainly undergo continual alterations, but their main contours will reproduce without major change. Revolution, on the other hand, becomes possible when destabilizing forces within or between spheres cannot be resolved without altering at least one of society's core characteristics. Kinship generates adults ill suited to economic roles.
SPEAKER_00The economy's contradictions cause people to challenge not only work but also political forms. Community conflicts spread as cultural relations demand and provide people with personalities contrary to what other spheres require in order to stably reproduce. Basic institutions are changed, core characteristics alter. In sum, society has four spheres that share time and space with each other and minimally accommodate or maximally code define one another when society is not in a state of crisis.
SPEAKER_00Of course, sometimes crises do occur and also initiate revolutionary transformations. Yet our point is that in the absence of revolutionary change, the failure to minimally accommodate for an extended period implies that a society would remain in a state of crisis for that whole period. We make no claim that crises can't happen, nor that they must always end quickly or always provoke revolutions which lead inexorably to new periods of a changed stability.
SPEAKER_00Revolutionary struggles, conscious and unconscious, can last decades, and moreover, sometimes societies can enter a period of great upheaval which doesn't induce a revolutionary period at all, only a period of great disturbance and contradiction. Regrettably, and this, as in other matters, history offers no answers to the question, quote, what's inevitable. It does, however, allow some interesting answers to the more tractable questions of quote what's possible and even quote what's likely.
SPEAKER_00In the last chapter, when we were analyzing societies and as interconnected social networks, we introduced the concept of codefinition. Now we introduce the parallel idea of co reproduction to help understand one possible kind of causal force at work in historical development. Spears co-reproduce when the dynamics of one reproduce the defining relations of another or others. For example, in a racist society, economic relations will co-reproduce community relations if daily economic activity reproduces racist relations just as it reproduces class relations.
SPEAKER_00Of course, co-reproduction is but one theoretical possibility concerning the relationship between social spheres, and only empirical investigation and activist practice can reveal whether or not this relation pertains in any particular place and time. But we should also note that since spheres must all occupy the same social space, and since human consciousness tends to repel cognitive dissonance, co-reproduction is a likely possibility.
SPEAKER_00It follows that trying to overcome racism without addressing the economic sphere in a society in which economic relations co-reproduce community relations would be an incomplete and probably fruitless strategy. Likewise, trying to overcome authoritarianism without addressing sexism in a society where gender relations co-reproduce political relations would be similarly short-sighted. In either case, and these are but two examples, co-reproductive influences would make it practically impossible to transform one sphere without simultaneous, compatible changes in the other.
SPEAKER_00Thus strong co-reproduction makes a shambles of the idea that movements can overcome racism while downplaying sexism, overcome classism while fostering authoritarianism, and so on. Co-reproductive connections of oppressions are deadly indeed. One way to think about these intricate patterns is to realize that rates of change within and between spheres may differ. As events transpire, spheres may get out of sync with one another.
SPEAKER_00Interactive forces among the spheres then tend to pull them back towards stable conformity, usually by evolutionary transformations of each. Different spheres never stop moving in and out of synchronization, nor do they ever attain a perfectly harmonious conflict free form. Just as Prigogene's dissipative systems move on an evolutionary trajectory as a result of complex flows of energy, materials and information, so spheres in a society continually alter in a reproductive way due to internal contradictions and contradictions with other spheres in both the human center and institutional boundary.
SPEAKER_00Societies are always changing. During periods of social stability, fluctuations quote level out. In revolutionary periods, however, certain fluctuations, which may have their basis in different aspects of social life, are magnified until the whole character of society may leap from one stable path to another. There is no single cell of society from which all change emanates. Instead, each cell interacts with and exists as part of all the others.
SPEAKER_00To say this is not to embrace ignorance, but to recognize how complex history is and how multifaceted our conceptualization must be. In our theoretical framework, a society could undergo a number of different types of revolution. Hypothetically, if co reproduction were weak, a society could have an economic revolution with no other fundamental changes, or a kinship revolution with no other fundamental changes, or a kinship and political revolution with the economy and community largely unaltered, or maybe a community and economic revolution with kinships and politics largely unchanged, and so on.
SPEAKER_00Moreover, there could be different types of revolution within each sphere. A revolution might lead from a capitalist economy to a coordinator economy, or from a capitalist economy to a true worker self-managed, classless economy. Or a revolution could replace procedural democracy with a single party bureaucratic state, but it might also transform the polity from a procedural to a participatory democracy. And the abstract or theory of history allows many logical possibilities.
SPEAKER_00In reality, we know things often become less flexible. Certain theoretical possibilities may be virtually ruled out and in particular societies, in which the strength of co reproduction between spheres delimits the type of revolutionary processes that can reach a new stability. And if we seek revolutions that eliminate core forms of domination instead of reformulating them by exchanging one dominating group for another, the possibilities open to us may be highly constrained indeed.
SPEAKER_00In our own study of the United States, we have come to believe that here, although many types of non liberatory revolutionary change can conceivably occur, intricate co-reproducing relations constrain liberatory options so severely that relatively few are feasible. We believe the oppressive core characteristics of the United States, racism, sexism, classism, and authoritarianism are now so mutually reproductive of one another that to fully eliminate any one, all will have to be overcome.
SPEAKER_00Institutional and consciousness relations have become so entwined that each of our society's four core characteristics now reproduce within every sphere instead of only within the sphere of their origin. The American family reproduces class domination, authoritarianism and racism, as well as sexism and heterosexism. The U.S. economy reproduces authoritarianism, sexism and racism, as well as class division.
SPEAKER_00The dynamics between races in the US reproduce authoritarianism, class and gender oppression, as well as racism. And political activity in the US reproduces sexism, racism and class domination as well as authoritarianism. Each sphere reproduces the defining forms of all four. We can conceive of an economic revolution creating technocratic coordinator economic relations in the US, which would change the nature of class oppression, but not eliminate it, and in doing so remain compatible with only moderately reformed relations in the community, kinship, and political spheres.
SPEAKER_00And as a matter of fact, in our opinion, this is the most probable result of many variants of social democratic and what we have called neopopulist efforts in the US, should they ever prove successful. To take another example, if liberatory child rearing, socialization, and sexual practices began to be carried out in the kinship sphere, but community economic and political life continued to be organized as it is at present, there would be a profound social contradiction.
SPEAKER_00Young adults would be unprepared to submit to and engage in racist, capitalist or authoritarian forms of domination. And the sexist dynamics, pervasive in other spheres in the US, would constantly threaten new kinship practices. In other words, there would be intense pressure for the kinship revolution to revert or for other spheres to begin transforming. Indeed, we see this happening today with the so called post feminist generation's reassertion of the primacy of motherhood over career, among other things.
SPEAKER_00I interject. Please keep in mind this was written forty years ago. So comments about then current trends are here about trends that occurred four decades ago. The chapter continues. One way to think about all this is to say, quote, all right, if changing one sphere requires changes in all of them, let's determine which we can change most easily, change it, and then worry about pulling along the others, end quote. This, in essence, is what moists tend to do, choosing the economy, for example, or the state, family, or culture, and then, depending upon how mechanical they are, either asserting that the rest of the spheres of social life will automatically fall into line on their own, or that this may take some time and struggle, but will nonetheless be a lot easier than if any attempt had been made to address all issues in the first place, since such attempts would have been divisive and diverted energies from their most efficient allocation.
SPEAKER_00This is the quote weak link approach to social change, and in some situations it can make perfectly good sense. It does not ask which sphere's current relations are most oppressive, or which dominated groups have the most righteous moral claims, or even which have the greatest anger. It asks how can we win fastest? However, if a society isn't a mesh chain in which there is one important link which, if we pull it hard enough, will ultimately necessarily cause the whole thing to come undone, then this approach becomes suspect.
SPEAKER_00Indeed, if, as we think, our society is a kind of fabric with four complex interwoven patterns, each of which has the capacity to redesign or regenerate any of the others, each of which can act as a source of incidents able to initiate major change, mold the texture of changes, and modulate the size to which changes grow or are limited in their influence, then the weak link approach becomes suicidal.
SPEAKER_00If we attack weak links, we may alter one pattern only to find that having ignored the others they have successfully undone all our work. Perhaps they will not exactly reproduce the old pattern we altered, but they will mold it to fit within the oppressive forms they still prescribe. The societal fabric will settle down to a new form with the four patterns compatibly entwined, and if three remain oppressive, the fourth will too. Our economic revolution against capitalism might not be rejuvenated to the old form of capitalism, for example, but instead channeled into a new class stratified form that we have elsewhere labeled a coordinator society.
SPEAKER_00But it will not become socialist. And similarly, our feminist revolution may create new kinship forms, our community revolution may create may transform cultures, or our political revolution may create new governing methods. But none of these revolutions will lead to the To optimal liberatory results without changes in other spheres as well. When you shine a laser through a hologram, a three-dimensional image which has been stored in the hologram earlier is projected. Remarkably, if you break the hologram into small pieces and shine a laser through any one of them, you get the same complete image, only a bit less sharp, as when you earlier used the whole hologram.
SPEAKER_00US society behaves a little like a hologram in exactly those areas most critical to problems of social revolution. Each sphere, like the hologram's pieces, contains the totality of defining core characteristics and can project and can potentially project them into any new reorganization of society in which that sphere remains largely unchanged. There is a tendency among activists to sometimes exaggerate what their theories can hope to accomplish so that people come to believe that they have discovered the truth about this or that.
SPEAKER_00Often sectarianism follows. In order to get a better grasp on what a historical theory can and cannot hope to achieve, and on some attributes it needs to have, to consider similarities and differences with Darwin's theory of natural selection might help. In natural selection, evolutionary change derives from the cumulative effects of chance accidents in an ecolog in an ecological environment which quote selects for fitness. Biological mutations within an organism's genetic structure propel anatomical changes which in turn reduce or improve the organism's capacity to give birth to new offspring of its own type.
SPEAKER_00As surprising as it seems, the initiating accidents occur randomly in no particular pattern at all. What gives species evolution the appearance of following a master plan is not an interrelatedness of causes among the triggering accidents, which does not exist, but the after the fact channeling effects of the process of natural selection within a complex environment. In societies, we know that changes arise everywhere from countless causes.
SPEAKER_00Most often, whether any particular change takes root depends on whether it conforms to its social environment. In this analogy, society as a whole provides an overarching social niche. Be they relatively small, like the invention of a minor new technology, or large, like the restructuring of gender relations owing to a revolution in kinship forms, to persist, changes must fit or redesign and then fit their surrounding social niche.
SPEAKER_00Of course, this analogy is inexact. In natural evolution, true laws of motion operate, which allow us to make mathematically precise statements about the frequency of mutations, the likelihood of any mutation taking hold, the time for the spread of change through a species, etc. Yet because the initiating mutations of natural evolution are purely random, despite these understood laws of motion, few before the fact testable predictions prove possible, only explanations after the fact.
SPEAKER_00According to some schools of philosophy, this characteristic relegates Darwin's theory to a subscientific shelf in the panoply of intellectual disciplines. Natural selection is a theory which, like complementary wholism, is incapable of alone making many testable predictions. Elaborated further to create a derivative theory, like population genetics, natural selection can lead us to predictions, of course. But then elaborated into a specific theory of capitalist economic forms, complementary holism will also lead us to predictions.
SPEAKER_00Even without refinement, both approaches can explain events after the fact. Make revealing claims about intellectually conceivable occurrences which are not, in fact, immediately practically conceivable, and make informative claims about the probability of certain possible future occurrences coming about. Referring to skeptics who are uncomfortable using the word quote theory when referring to social history, we will use it in roughly the same way a nineteenth century Darwinian would have used it when referring to natural history.
SPEAKER_00But beyond this, the similarities in these two frameworks are minimal, and it is actually the differences that can help us understand historical theory's potentials better. In social history, fewer, if any fixed laws of motion operate. One can't make general statements about the frequency of changes or their rates of taking root, since the consciousness of human actors makes most uniformities in the way history unfolds temporary. Further, in societies the link between quote social mutations and lasting changes in the social niche are more bidirectional than the link between biological mutations and changes in the ecological niche.
SPEAKER_00And what's worse, recognizing both that social conditions can create social mutations and that consciousness plays a role in defining social conditions, in societies it follows that the initiation of quote mutations is not totally random. Chance is one factor in the motion of social relations. But in history there is no impermeable barrier between the organism environment complex on the one hand, and the incidence of social evolution revolution engendering mutations on the other hand.
SPEAKER_00The former can cause, mold, and even consciously contour the latter, which in turn needn't be random, but can be aimed to particular ends. We can consciously cause social mutations which in turn either fit or fail to fit our social environment. Indeed, this is the aim of social activists. Ironically, with less in the way of scientific laws of motion, social history permits more than biological history in the way of predictions about possible future events.
SPEAKER_00The initial context only channels biological evolution, but it can provide a predetermined goal for social changes, a goal whose influence we can perceive and at least partially understand, allowing us, therefore, to sometimes predict with some measure of confidence the likelihood of specific future outcomes coming to pass as a result of actions we may take. There is, however, an additional rough similarity between natural evolution and historical evolution, which makes precise predictions nearly impossible in both.
SPEAKER_00It is a characteristic also common to the weather, to the flow of waterfalls, the shape of clouds and snowflakes, and perhaps even to the cosmology of the universe and the dynamics of most real phenomena. That is, in these realms, very small changes in initial circumstances can lead to very large changes in outcome in relatively proximate futures. A difference of a half a degree in temperature over New York on Thursday can mean the difference between sunshine and rain over Toronto on Friday.
SPEAKER_00A fragment of a twig wedged between two rocks at the top of a waterfall can cause the molecules flowing over the falls to wind up in completely different positions with respect to one another than they would have had were the twig fragment not there. The smallest variations in atmospheric conditions can lead to huge variations in the shapes of clouds and winds. And likewise, the tiniest tiniest variations in a mutation in one generation can lead to the difference between a species existing and not existing just a few generations later.
SPEAKER_00And then in the event the species has a marked effect on the social ecology to dramatic differences in the whole of nature, still a few generations further on. And similarly, tiny changes in where, how, and when individuals and institutions act can sometimes trigger huge alterations in this pace and shape of historical patterns. Such volatility renders precise prediction impossible in all these fields of study, precisely because we cannot know the position of every twig or the inclination of every actor at the outset.
SPEAKER_00But that does not mean that useful predictions and analyses are ruled out. Indeed, this quote chaos factor causes us to have to understand quote prediction in the case of weather, history, and other such phenomena in a cautious way. Moreover, we choose the word quote chaos with care. Recently, physicists have begun studying this type of phenomena to discern what kinds of patterns exist in the development of quote chaotic systems, and perhaps these studies will provide further analogies and insights that can help others enlarge and refine the perspective set forth here.
SPEAKER_00In any case, since we cannot know all the fine details of historical or atmospheric initial conditions as they might exist at any moment, we cannot possibly perfectly predict all outcomes at some later moment. Moreover, since the variations that can result from small changes in quote initial conditions are great for most historical processes, history's quote chaos factor, sometimes our errors will be great despite the most intelligent analyses.
SPEAKER_00What a theory can do, however, is help us chart rough potential trajectories of overall developments, whether of history or of weather, and discern their relative probabilities and to some extent illuminate how our own activities, seeding clouds, waging social struggles, developing new institutional forms might affect those probabilities. The task of a theoretical framework oriented to help us to understand history in order to change it, then is to assist in the limited but crucial undertaking of pinpointing as precisely as we can those kinds of dynamics and relationships that will most often be critical to A initiate macro changes in society of a type important to our lives.
SPEAKER_00B channel and texture such changes so they persist or fade away, become localized or spread. C modulate such changes so they refine outcomes minimally as in historical evolution, or transform them dramatically as in historical revolution. The point is to use theory to create visions and strategy that we can implement. That we must be cautious and never presume to think that we have all the answers in no way means we cannot take informed initiative to improve our society.
SPEAKER_00When trying to determine whether a society is likely to undergo a revolutionary change, any analyst develops a set of guiding questions. One way to appreciate the difference between theoretical perspectives is to compare the guiding questions or research programs they employ. A complementary holist approach poses the following kinds of questions. What is the character of the four defining spheres of social life and how does it affect people's ability to fulfill their various potentials?
SPEAKER_00What distinctive social groups are defined by the organization of social activity in each sphere? And how do these groups interact? What contradictions exist within and between each sphere? And how do these contradictions affect class, community, gender, and political struggles? What factors influence the power of competing groups as they pursue their interests? And how do the dynamics between spheres affect the self-consciousness of these groups? How do events and struggles tend to reproduce or undermine core characteristics?
SPEAKER_00How does the undermining of core characteristics in one sphere affect society's other spheres? And finally, what reproductive and destabilizing dynamics are at work between the human center and the institutional boundary? The complementary holist agenda requires an analysis that stresses the interactive effects of four fields of influence, without assuming a priori the influence of any one of these fields, some priority ordering of their importance, or some fixed form for their interaction.
SPEAKER_00However, this does not imply our concepts are amorphous since they direct us to examine dynamics within and between particular spheres in very specific ways. Does our approach increase the probability of a more comprehensive understanding? Does it avoid subordinating the concerns of one group to those of another? Will it facilitate a fuller solidarity among those with a common interest in social change? Or does it merely add steps to historical analyses for little additional insight, confusing a muddled picture with a fuller one?
SPEAKER_00While it isn't a virtue to present a motion picture of reality with no central concepts or organizing principles to guide analysis and prediction, it is also no virtue to claim to have uncovered the essential tension while ignoring or misunderstanding other critical relations. Complementary holism can yield concrete results only when applied to particular societies, historical problems, visions, and issues of strategy. We believe our concepts of center and boundary, core characteristics, accommodation and co-reproduction, stabilizing and destabilizing dynamics, and our newly defined conceptualization of four critical spheres of social activity provide a set of conceptual tools that can help activists with a wide range of priorities tackle the difficult problem of building increasingly powerful social movements in the years ahead.
SPEAKER_00It is not the only set of concepts one can usefully use to try to create social change, but we think it is one set of concepts particularly suited to the purpose. Only time will tell. I interject from twenty twenty six. That ended the chapter proper. The We, remember, is the group of seven authors, myself, Leslie Kagan, Noam Chomsky, Robin Hennell, Mel King, Holly Sklar, and Lydia Sargent. As I read the material, I was impressed, and I hope you, hearing it, were as well.
SPEAKER_00To me, this little book delivered what it claimed, a conceptual toolbox designed to help activists avoid mistakes of the past while effectively handling conditions of the present. Next step is vision and strategy. Having not read this seven authored material in almost forty years, I have encountered it as you have. I can see that it is a lot in one go, so it is available on Z Network as text to ease careful consideration.
SPEAKER_00I wonder what effect it has had on you, and I apologize for the fact that I and the six other authors didn't push harder for it forty years ago. I am honestly not sure why we didn't scream out this needs attention. Pre writing, I am sure the motive for doing it together was a belief not only that the result would be much better for the collective input, but also that the fact of the seven authors would propel attention. But that didn't widely happen.
SPEAKER_00And I now think wrongly, we too modestly said, Okay, that's the verdict, no use pursuing it more. I think we should have. Hell, I think some publisher should do a re-release of it now. Anyone? At any rate, here's the dialogue that followed the chapter presented this time that discussed history. Coho, our complimentary wholest participants, started it off by saying The point is that historical materialism and all other monist orientations must be replaced by a view of historical change that sees at least four essential spheres of social life instead of one, sees fundamental change in each sphere as equally deserving of being considered revolutionary, and sees accommodation and code definition as two way streets between spheres, so that fundamental and non fundamental changes will percolate from one to others.
SPEAKER_00Morlin, our Marxist Leninist participant, comfortable on his own turf, reacts first, as usual. I think you have really lost it this time, Coho. You cannot point to any inexorable processes regarding kinship, authority, and community that lead inevitably to revolutionary contradictions. Why don't you finally admit that economics deriv directs historical developments? Accumulation causes contradictions that rupture old forms and auger new ones.
SPEAKER_00Other social dynamics, as I have stated, are important primarily in terms of their effects on economic occurrences. Nate, our nationalist participant, interrupts. Stop right there. I admit I can't point, I can't point to a single process that recurs repeatedly in all community spheres in the way that you pinpoint the accumulation process. But I can point to many social struggles where nationalist operation aspirations played primary roles, or a combination of religion and nationalism.
SPEAKER_00What about South Africa, Iran, China, India? Marlin, just a minute here. Racial and national dynamics operate to texture economic dynamics, which alone set the stage for change. Anna, our anarchist participant, interrupts. Wait a second, Marlin. Even in the Soviet Union, it was Lenin's political party that played a central role in determining that change would be bureaucratic and statist, not socialist. Marlin interrupts. But the state was not the basic motor for change.
SPEAKER_00Sophie, our socialist feminist participant, interrupts. Hold the phone, Marlin. Your evidence only proves that economics is causally relevant, not that the other spheres are irrelevant. I think we should look more closely at relations between gender and class. We could certainly find some laws of motion in that relationship which would help us understand historical change better than the continued assertion of economics alone as the basic motor for change. Rad Fem, our radical feminist participant, adds There's no question in my mind that the motor force in history is the striving of men for power over women.
SPEAKER_00Marlin responds, that kind of blindness simply proves my point. What evidence can you possibly have for that statement? The Russian Revolution? That what kinship laws of motion occurred there? Don't make me laugh. Koho reacts. You each make the other laugh at your respective monus claims. I think, Marlin, that your point can never be proven. What evidence do you have of a revolution brought about by the forces of production bursting social relations of production?
SPEAKER_00Your formula hasn't been verified anywhere, anytime. Where is your evidence that in China or Cuba, for example, or even the Soviet Union, growing forces of production ran up against constraining social relations and that caused their revolutions? Marlin reprised, I might say the same to you, Koho. Where are the laws of motion in Kohoism? Koho, I repeat, Marlin, in what revolution have federing forces brought about revolutionary change?
SPEAKER_00All right, you don't or can't answer that one. Let me try another. Let's suppose that growing forces encountering frozen relations could become important. What if what you say were true for developed capitalism? That there exist intrinsic economic dynamics which push developed capitalist economies inexorably toward revolutionary upheaval. Why are we then to deduce that only economics can move societies with capitalist economies?
SPEAKER_00Or that only changes in economics could bring about other liberatory social structures. Marlin, I repeat, Coho, you take your holism so far that nothing precise remains. Koho, but I don't claim to know precise laws of history. Indeed, there are no precise always operative laws in the sense that you mean. We can say interesting things about how the four spheres will interact no matter what specific contours they may have. We can know what general kinds of conditions are possible between spheres or inside spheres.
SPEAKER_00We can discover that all societies Societies of a particular type will always embody certain traits. But we can't say, for example, that every society will inevitably undergo such and such a pattern of development, or even that every capitalist economy or patriarchal kinship sphere will always follow such and such a trajectory. Other spheres may interfere, and their own circumstances are variable as well. Marlin interrupts.
SPEAKER_00Like I said, no laws of motion. Coho, you may not like it that we can't enunciate universal laws, but postulating violated laws doesn't improve the situation. Sophie, I can agree with that. Why enshrine inaccurate laws? Even if we analyze certain intrinsic characteristics of a particular type of economy or state, we can't say with certainty that those characteristics will always operate in real societies.
SPEAKER_00Morlin, but why must we believe that the best we can come up with is general assertions about accommodation and co reproduction and nothing more? C C our Council Communist participant answers because while we can analyze specific societies to determine what historical pressures and trajectories operate in them, we can't do it for all time and for all societies equally or the same ways or with the same results. Coho I would go even further.
SPEAKER_00I would say that any theory that treats history as if there is a built in, unchanging economic script is a theory that ignores that the rules of historical development are themselves historical. Marlin in disbelief are you calling me a historical? I have to reject I have to interject. I am currently laughing while I read this. CC continues. I think she is. Nate, I like the way this discussion is going. Sophie, me too.
SPEAKER_00Anna, I wonder why. Rad Fem, I'm not sure I do. Plury, our pluralist participant, adds, fits in with my thinking. Coho, insisting on this point. In every field of study, scholars develop theories that operate on many different levels. They make general theories about the behavior of solids, liquids, and gases. They make more specific theories about compounds in general, or about particular compounds, or about molecules in general, or specific molecules, or elements in general, or specific elements, or atoms in general, or specific atoms.
SPEAKER_00Radfem, science again. I interject, laughing again. Koho responds, we can theorize about qualities of all languages, or of all languages of a specific type, or of a particular language, or about all structures of a particular type within a particular language. C but history is at a higher level of complexity than chemistry, biology, or even linguistics. History involves all those things as well as living organs, thinking beings, and elaborate networks of institutions and ideologies.
SPEAKER_00Coho. Still, the analogy can help. When we theorize general classes of things like all compounds or all languages, we only discover broad possibilities and make predictions about ranges of possible outcomes. When we need more detail for more precise results, we lower the level of abstraction and discuss particular compounds or languages. Then we discover more exacting relations, which allow us to predict with greater precision and detail.
SPEAKER_00And the same is true for societies and history. Sophie, I see what you mean. We can theorize about societies and history in general, or we can look at specific societies like the US or wherever. We would name the basic spheres in any society economic, kinship, community, and political, and we would use those spheres to theorize about society in general and about specific events that happen in a particular society. About evolutionary and revolutionary patterns as they emerge in both particular societies and whole epochs.
SPEAKER_00Nate adds, for example, looking at the community sphere, we can talk about religion in general, Catholicism in general, the Catholic Church, the Church in Nicaragua, a particular parish, and so on. Marlin, unimpressed, replies. You want me to believe that in the US, the Soviet Union, China, Cuba, or any other country, there are non economic dynamics that significantly affect evolution and even the prospects for revolution? Where is your evidence? Koho, there is probably no evidence that will convince you.
SPEAKER_00If I state that the formation of the working class in England was differentiated along gender lines because sexism produced in the kinship sphere caused both male workers and male capitalists to struggle to embody in the same relations in the economy, partly to defend gender privilege, as well as partly to use gender hierarchies to support class hierarchies, you would probably reply that no, gender divisions were produced only to divide the working class and had purely economic roots.
SPEAKER_00If I described the Soviet Union as a society that from birth was a social formation with a dictatorial, bureaucratic state, a technocratic economic structure, an initially fragmented community sphere fraught with racism and push toward homogenization, and a kinship sphere with the nature of sexism altered but patriarchy intact, you would disagree. You see the Soviet Union as a society that had a socialist revolution in the economy that was subverted by capitalist encirclement, illiteracy, and poverty, where I would say it is neither capitalist nor socialist, but coordinator, and I would highlight the other spheres as well.
SPEAKER_00We have such different pictures of things, Marlin, that I think you will never accept my evidence. But for all your quote weight of history and the past predominance of your well developed economic theory, can you even explain the struggles among coordinators, coordinators and workers, coordinators and central party, bureaucrats over planning and markets in the Soviet Union? For that matter, how could it be that political phenomena overrode the economic forces in the Soviet Union to give us a dictatorship?
SPEAKER_00Nate adds When, Morlin, have you ever adequately explained religious and cultural persecution or the positive dimensions of spirituality and power of cultural identifications? Sophie, the limited access of women to positions of political influence. Radfem, the distortion of sexual potentials. Anna Stalinism. Koho continues The question of what constitutes sufficient evidence to justify giving up an established, widely held perspective is difficult.
SPEAKER_00Is the experience of the Soviet Union evidence enough? What if that experience combined with our theory of the coordinator class can counter any Marxist claim that Leninism serves the working class? I think we have a plausible, workable conceptual alternative. I think complementary holism gives us insight. I think complementary holism gives us concepts that help understand things that Marxism ignores. But not only that, its concepts help us know that these are important areas of consideration in the first place.
SPEAKER_00Complimentary holism aims to give a generalized theory of the operations of history that will help us to limit the ranges of historical outcomes. It makes it possible to theorize certain types of institutions, economies or markets, communities, colonialism or specific cultures, dictatorial states or parliaments, communes or nuclear families, to then make predictions about general and more specific social dynamics. And it can help us theorize about trajectories of development, how social spheres interact and change, and how force fields radiate throughout society.
SPEAKER_00Isn't that enough to warrant giving it a practical chance? Marlin, Adamant, I'm not giving up. Your methods give no priorities, no guidelines of focus. Going back to our early and ever popular stew analogy, you've got a lot of vegetables, meat, and potatoes floating around in a gravy, with no way to decide which gives the stew its main flavor, which to eat first, what to add later. My concepts allow me to enjoy the stew even though clearly the dominant flavor comes from beef if it is a beef stew.
SPEAKER_00Lamb if it is a lamb stew, etc. Sophie, I will never understand, Marlin, why you cannot criticize your own theory. You argue for a set of laws of motion of some abstracted part of society, which you then say will tell us all the important things we need to know about all of society. Pluri, I think, Marlin, you have made a strong case for the rest of us to simply get rid of the Marxist framework. Rad Femm, I agree. Talk about fetters. Neopop, no problem for me.
SPEAKER_00I left Marxism behind some time ago. Marxist class analysis has become a handicap to the movement for social change. Class analysis, any kind of group analysis promotes dissension and tension. Coho. Now hold on. It is one thing to hold that some of Marxism's central concepts are flawed. But why overreact and reject all the insights Marxism provides? That is going way too far. We need to improve Marxism and incorporate its positive lessons, not reject it whole hog.
SPEAKER_00Neopop, our neopopulist participant differs. No, I think we need to reject it because we need to unite people, not fragment them. We need to respect differences and value all sides of polarities. There are many different kinds of work, so why not value them all? The same for cultures and kinship roles. All you're doing, Coho, is expanding the number of correct political lines people must argue over. While Marlin would only criticize us for having the wrong line on the economy, you would criticize us for having the wrong line on just about everything.
SPEAKER_00Why not simply propose a liberatory model, a liberatory program that opposes all important oppressions and invite everyone to support it? Koho, the danger of complimentary holism becoming just another batch of lines, as you point out, is real, although I have never claimed that people should think, act, or look alike. Quite the opposite. Perhaps you were dozing, but in any event, your solution to the dangers of sectarianism has tremendous problems which I think cannot be corrected.
SPEAKER_00Neopop, I might have known. Coho, let me put this to you as a hypothesis. One approach to the fourfold core characteristics in our society is to analyze them from the perspective of those who are oppressed along each axis and then propose alternative visions which are fully liberatory for all. Another approach, however, starts with the supposition that what is needed is to eliminate certain specific ills so that a particular group, rather than all groups, might benefit.
SPEAKER_00My claim is that whenever the group in this second approach is one of those at the bottom of the hierarchy of the oppressed, liberation will be impossible without pervasive liberatory changes in all spheres of social life. But if the group is not one of those at the bottom, but rather, for example, the coordinator class, then activists engaging in elevating this class to economic supremacy could choose a politically effective program conducive to that more limited end.
SPEAKER_00And I claim that decades ago, the best choice for a champion of coordinator interests was Marxism Leninism, since Marxism could deflect attention from coordinator aims, even while it helped coordinators organize other sectors to join the coordinator defined project. But nowadays, almost any sustained thinking about classes reveals coordinators as important historical participants, and so Marxism, which highlights class analysis, no longer serves coordinator needs as well as it once did.
SPEAKER_00It leaves too much possibility of people noticing the role of coordinators, even as it tries to prevent this. A better ideological choice in the eyes of some coordinators, is to adopt some kind of populism that rejects all class analysis in favor of quote unity. Of course, the Marxist infatuation with markets and central planning for allocation can be retained, though coordinators will also want to emphasize the value of parliamentary democracy, which of course benefits them most of all.
SPEAKER_00CC It sounds to me like in current situations you put the economy first. Radfam, I knew it. Nate, I suspected it. Coho in analyzing the program of a specific class, yes, but only because I see an emerging political program serving the economic interests of coordinators under the guise of a popular front. Neopop, who said anything about the economic interests of coordinators? I offer constructive criticism, and you label me an obscurantist enemy.
SPEAKER_00Marlin, join the club. Coho, if what I said applies to you, then I plead guilty of labeling. Changing society is not the same as having a friendly chat. A great deal is at stake. But I think I was only suggesting the dangers of an approach which, for whatever reason, says that classes are no longer relevant historical actors. There are even some who now argue that because work is inevitably boring and regimented, we should give up revolutionizing it and simply diminish the number of hours we spend working while increasing the amount of leisure time.
SPEAKER_00Oppressions in the economic sphere remain as they were, we just suffer them for a shorter period of time. This not only risks losing any chance of attaining liberation in other co defined and co reproduced spheres, it ignores that work freely undertaken is a critical element of a fulfilling life. Moreland, sensing affirmation. So you admit the need of working for working class leadership in struggles to change history. Coho, of course, because I see that history has a critical economic component.
SPEAKER_00But our movements must also be led by those whose interests lie in the elimination of all forms of domination. Sophie, you know, while I don't agree with Neopop's approach, I must say that I am getting nervous again. I can easily see where your concepts, coho, can sound very plausible, flexible, and inclusive. Everyone understands and is sensitive to everyone else. But what if the person or a group of people using the theory are black people whose experiences differ from each other but who locate themselves in the community sphere?
SPEAKER_00What makes them sensitive to the other spheres? Because they've studied and understood the theory? Maybe. But they haven't understood the experience of white women or women in the garment industry? Nate. And the same would hold true for white women in the kinship sphere. What increases their sensitivity to community? They don't live where I do or suffer in the same way. Why would they incorporate the principles of co definition and co reproduction in a way I would applaud? Rad Fem, what would make those concerned with sexual preference issues incorporate experiences of black auto workers, and vice versa?
SPEAKER_00Anna, what would make those addressing state power feel that any changes in that sphere were codependent on other spheres? Plury, it just seems so impossibly complicated. Coho, it's true that it requires a great deal, but we are talking about changing society. We can spend our energy branding people with simplistic labels and manipulating people's words and programs in sectarian ways, or we can listen critically to familiar approaches, decide that they are less desirable than they might be, and openly and carefully develop new and better beliefs and goals.
SPEAKER_00Anna, back off. You've already convinced me. Nate, I don't know. Radfem, if I thought men would actually Sophie, I'm getting there, Koho. Should I tell you about my thoughts on vision and strategy for a liberatory society? Nate, why not? Sin are a liberated society? That ought to be good. Koho rus Koho rustles through her papers as the others wait equal eagerly. And so ends the dialogue and chapter length look at concepts for understanding history.
SPEAKER_00Do they match up not only with past history but also with current practical needs? If not, well, why not? What faults do you see? But if so, then what is to be done about this approach to history? Should it get our support? For one thing, it certainly diverges from what is called historical materialism. Will advocates of historical materialism's concepts reject or support liberating theories alternatives? Maybe they will correct them somewhat, or maybe they will entirely reject them.
SPEAKER_00Might they even support them? However harsh or hospitable reactions to these comments may be, I hope I will hear them. And all that said, this is Michael Albert, signing off until next time for Revolution Z.
Episode 415 of RevolutionZ has as its guest Paul Loeb who joins us after decades of work on citizen responsibility, civic engagement, and the hard reality of sustaining social movements in challenging times. An election...
Episode 414 of RevolutionZ considers tasks ahead in light of the MIdterm results. The scariest moment in politics may be when authoritarians win. but a not too distant second may be when they lose and we all exhale. Do...
Episode 413 of RevolutionZ asks what comes after our eruptions? What happens when the cameras leave, when the easy unity ages even just a little bit, and when power bets we will wear out and go home? What can we do to...
Episode 412 offers Part Two of Talking with Chat GPT wherein the AI effusively answers questions about itself, the AI industry and its CEOs, users, prospects and dangers, and about its and our futures. What can/will AI...
Episode 411 of RevolutionZ has a guest with initials instead of a name: GPT (5.6). The episode asks GPT questions many people quietly wonder about but rarely hear answered in its "voice." We start with deceptively...