Episode 415 of RevolutionZ has as its guest Paul Loeb who joins us after decades of work on citizen responsibility, civic engagement, and the hard reality of sustaining social movements in challenging times. An election rout in the U.S. Uprisings around the world. What happens next. Do we enjoy a bunch of victory laps that fade into burnout cycles. Or do we take the current moment's momentum and build durable power that can survives the immediate outrage to become sustained, strategic, activism? Paul Loeb joins us to talk about why outreach is not just “persuasion” but a way of building connection that changes what people hear, who they trust, and whether they stay involved. He presents concrete examples of how volunteering can swing razor-thin races, how unions can inoculate people against propaganda, and why strong movements need organizations that keep relationships alive after headlines move on. We also get into the tension between accountability and transformation. Corruption narratives can be powerful, but they can also slide into cynicism if they never point to the system that rewards corruption, the policies that would make everyday life better, or the institutional goals that can orient our efforts. From climate disasters as teachable moments to the Keystone XL pipeline fight in Nebraska, Paul looks at how coalitions form, how wins happen, and why movements way too often go home afterward. Paul brings in stories from his book The Impossible Will Take a Little While, including Norwegian teachers resisting Nazi control, Minnesota’s creative ICE resistance, South Korea’s rapid response to a coup attempt, and Nelson Mandela’s model of perseverance and human-to-human reach. How have people organized and won gains, but also how have people not sustained their efforts as far as needed? Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, my name is Michael Albert, and I'm the host of the podcast that's titled Revolution Z. This is our 415th consecutive episode, and our guest today is Paul Loeb. Paul has spent 50 years researching and writing about citizen responsibility and empowerment, asking what makes some people choose lives of social commitment while others abstain, and exploring how to find the hope to stay engaged despite all the frustrations and barriers. He is the author of Soul of a Citizen, Living with Conviction in Challenging Times, which has 175,000 copies in print between two editions, which I have to say is quite remarkable for a left book because publishers, not to mention mainstream media, are a bit uh, let's say, lax in promoting such activities.
SPEAKER_01And also author of The Impossible Will Take a Little While, Perseverance and Hope in Troubled Times, which has a wholly updated edition released this past October, uh, just last month. To see more about the new release, see theimpossible.org, a website, theimpossible.org. And Paul also has his own personal website at Paul Loeb, uh, one word, paulloebe.org. So, Paul, uh, welcome to Revolution Z.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, glad to be here. It's of course an interesting and hopeful moment here in the U.S. and in many, many other places around the world. There is, of course, a bone a bountiful recounting of recent events here and abroad, elections, demonstrations, and uh outright rebellions, pretty easily available. And so, at least for the most part, here in today's episode, I'd like to mainly ask about what comes or what will hopefully come next, and particularly here in the United States.
SPEAKER_01How do you think exciting and promising setbacks for Trumpism and fascistic trends can become sustained movements for positive new gains? Can this moment's sense of achievement and hope help not only overcome grotesque recent trends, but also get us beyond the business as usual that bred Trump? What do you think?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it is definitely hopeful. I'm at this, I was thinking because you and I had some technical problems before, and they're echoing my sort of week of frustrations. And the other day I was calling on a credit card problem, and of course, you go through voicemail hell, and you have to yell at the robot AI people, and then they cut you off for cursing, and you have to call back again. And it's I want a human, I want a human. And I finally get a human, and of course, they're not the right one. And I just like, but I'm talking to them, and they're like, in I think they're in Houston or something.
SPEAKER_00And I'm like, hey, and I said, I feel a whole lot better about Texas than I did to a week and a half ago. And and they laugh and they said, Yeah, we're making progress. And then and they, and then I have to call, but I have to call somebody else, and you know, because that's the way the credit card things are. And they're in South Carolina. And so I say, you know, feel a whole lot better about South Carolina than they did a couple of weeks ago. And they laugh.
SPEAKER_00I can tell this the second person's African-American. I don't think the first one was. Um, and they're like, you know, and they laugh. And so it is, it is, uh, you know, and and I then I had to go, of course, to a third person who ended up in the, I think, in the Philippines or something, and they didn't have, they didn't have an election. But it it really kind of brought home to me like how much of the the landscape has changed in a very short time. And and of course, it's the it's not just some accidental happening of history.
SPEAKER_00And some of it, of course, is all of Trump's abusiveness and overreach and craziness, and you know, I'm gonna fix things for you and make you know, make everything more affordable. And then, of course, he invades Iran and ICE is grabbing your neighbor off the street, et cetera, et cetera. But I I also do not think, I know that the ordinary people who are volunteering in the campaigns in every state in the country, they they turned a lot of it around. And so you would have had the opportunity, but you wouldn't necessarily have seen it realized if we just sort of left everything else up to the candidates.
SPEAKER_00And that's certainly, I mean, that that's kind of a common chord in my work, both Soul of a Citizen and The Impossible will take a little while, is agency and contingency and contingency on our action. So if we act, we have not guarantees of change, obviously, but possibilities of change. If we don't act, then those things don't happen. And and and so I think, you know, in asking your question about sort of both what's going to happen next and what should we do next, what what what I would go is that and this is I describe it, it's not directly from what I've done in the books, but it's the lessons of everything that's in the books.
SPEAKER_00And and and that is is that the say these next couple of years, I mean, there's certainly strategic questions, you know, which which bills does a new Democratic Senate or con and Congress try and push whether or not they're going to be able to get through, you know, the republic the filibuster in the Senate, and then Trump's veto. I mean, those are really important strategic questions. Who's the leadership? I just finished a piece on on why Schumer should, which I've written about before, but just you know, after reading, writing all these reasons a year and a half ago why Schumer needs to go.
SPEAKER_00Now there's a whole bunch of fresh reasons despite the massive victory. And so I talk about them and I disabuse the notion of him as the Zen master, and I just point out all the races where the money did, you know, where it was razor sharp and the money didn't arrive till literally five days before the election. And yeah, of course it helped a little bit, but hey, I gave my hundred bucks to Scott Collum in Mississippi in April, and because that's when it could have made the most difference. And if I could see that without any access to inside information, then maybe Schumer would have could have done something earlier than October 20th, which was when he finally logged in.
SPEAKER_00So those are really important. But I think that larger than any of that is the question of can we find ways to keep reaching out? So one of the things that is always true of an election is that it's sort of an opportunity. And you know, here it is, it's going to happen on that first Tuesday in November, and it gives you a reason to go knock on a door. It goes a reason to reach out to somebody, to talk to somebody, to have a difficult conversation.
SPEAKER_00And when that happens enough, good things occur. I mean, I in The Impossible take a little while. I tell a little story that's about the very sort of linear process of volunteering, which is um about 20 years ago. There is a, I'm not paying any attention to our, I live in Washington State to our governor's race, but it's election day. I call to see where I should volunteer. They assigned me to walk some precincts in a neighborhood uh across town, and I get three people to show up.
SPEAKER_00Uh, one who forgets it's election day, one who doesn't have a ride, and one who doesn't know what to do with an absentee ballot. And my walksheet has instructions to answer all three because those are pretty common things. And it ends up at the end of the day that it's 133 votes for our governor's race in a state of 6.2 million. So it's like, hey, I've gotten 150th. It's this extremely tangible impact that has a very linear result. In the phase we're now in, it's not quite as linear.
SPEAKER_00It's you have, if you can find ways, and that you know it really depends on the organizations that we're part of or that we create to have those conversations, then instead of people drifting away because there's not an election for two years, they're more likely to stay engaged. And of course, there's all the data that says if you're connected, you're more engaged. You're less likely to be vulnerable to mediation, to manipulation, you're less vulnerable to algorithms.
SPEAKER_00And so, I mean, to me, that's the the largest, the large, the very largest task is figuring out ways to connect. And again, that connection, I'm looking, I'm thinking about Brazil and uh the two the two elections just recently. And in the first one, I'm reading all the autopsies of why Lula lost. And what they are mostly saying is that the fabric of connection that carried him to power really got just atrophied, as well as social media manipulation.
SPEAKER_00Both things were true, but they complement each other. And union density was half of what it was when he first won. And Work the Workers' Party wasn't, it just wasn't as engaged and reaching out, and people just said, and it seemed to make sense to me, that that created a void that allowed Bolsonaro to take advantage of it. Then fast forward, whatever it was, I think, what, five or six weeks in between, it wasn't very long. And they just described some of it happened on social media with Lula's army, the the grew, the WhatsApp group that grew one of his allies in the parliament created and went from 60,000 to 11 million people.
SPEAKER_00But all of it was what it was about is about very specific asks, things could people could do. And at the same time, people were just like, okay, I will do anything, I will talk to anybody. And so you had this really intensely mobilized populace. Now, I'm not gonna, you know, I don't know what's gonna happen there after the election, but to me, it's the parallel is you've got this mobilization. Can we take the energy? And and it's harder because of the geography, and uh, you know, particularly in a blue state, uh there you have to figure out more creative things to do, but to find ways to keep reaching out to folks and and and engage them because that's that's what a builds power and b makes them less vulnerable to the manipulation.
SPEAKER_01So the uh the criteria, I suppose you could say, or the yardstick, is largely not not the the event on a day, but the impact of reaching out on uh increasing the numbers of people who have moved toward perhaps at the at the edge actually being involved, or being receptive even, or being less oppositional even.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_01I don't think most leftists understand outreach that way. Is is that sort of how you you see it? You're sort of sliding the whole electorate instead of the city. You're sliding the whole electorate.
SPEAKER_00No, very much, very much so. You're sliding the whole electorate, and you're you know, you're bringing people into connection, and suddenly it's it's not the it's not the stereotype caricatures that that the right, I mean the you know, be let's be realistic, the right has 24-7 channels to keep putting out the caricatures. And so something has to be an antidote to that. And obviously, strong electoral leadership is very helpful, but that's not everything.
SPEAKER_00You know, and so it's it's finding it out on the ground. And I remember this is I mean, I give this example connection, this is a while ago. Um, the right National Writers Union used to be part of UAW for a number of years. And so I was getting the UAW magazine, UAW United Auto Workers, and they mentioned a survey. So this is a while, this maybe have been 20 years ago, even, but it was a survey where they compared gun owners in Michigan and their voting to who are non-union and gun owners who are union.
SPEAKER_00So two groups. They both, they're both hunters, they both have their guns, they both care about their guns. The I can't remember exactly, but it was like a 27-point difference between the union gun owners and the non-union gun owners because the non-union gun owners, they got the gun lobby for propaganda and the dems are going to take your guns and all the rest of that stuff. And they fell for it. The union gun owners is like they got stuff from their union, they got different messages about economic power, about you know, rebuttals to the to the lies and caricatures.
SPEAKER_00They didn't fall for it. And it just really struck me because again, it's the same the same broad group of gun owners, but but that phenomenon of being in the union just changed everything.
SPEAKER_01I want to uh maybe try and shift us a little bit. There is, for example, reaching out and affecting the whole population, the whole electorate around who should be in office. But there's also reaching out, let's call it, affecting the population about what anybody in office should in fact be doing. Yes. And then even more than that, there's reaching out about extra-electoral dynamics, about the policies that we should be advocating and the changes in structures that we should be advocating.
SPEAKER_01Right. And and uh I think they're not the same. Yeah, they each they each certainly affect the other, but they're really not the same. And so I wonder what you think about the tendency, or what looks like the tendency to uh, at least for the elected officials and maybe for a considerable part of the, let's call it, critical writers and activists, to hone in on um impeachment and uh uh holding Republicans accountable and that sort of thing, as compared to actual policies or building infrastructure for, say, when uh a good candidate wins in 2028.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean I think you know, I've been thinking about this, and they're different, to me, there's different kinds of roles. Yeah. And it does seem particularly, and again, this is this veers from the topics of the impossible, take a little while, how to how to sustain all of that. So we would, I definitely want to talk about you know about that because it's like whatever you're doing, you've got to be able to have the sense of hope, the strength of perseverance to keep on to do any of these kinds of things. Um, but in terms of answering it, I do think that the corruption narrative is very powerful.
SPEAKER_00And we've seen globally how it takes down dictators because two things have happened. One is everyday life for everybody else is getting worse, and it a train station collapses because it was built on a shoddy, sweetheart contract without inspection, or um prices rise, or there are some shortages of whatever it is that people need in their day-to-day lives. And so things are harder, and then at the same time, the cronies are getting rich.
SPEAKER_00I mean, one of the one of the pieces, which is going to sound as the The Impossible Will Take a Little While, is a collection of global global essays. Um from people who've inspired me to keep going. So it's Howard Zinn and it's Alice Walker and Desmond Tutu and Nelson Mandela and Vlakov Havel and on and on and on. One of the newer pieces in this new edition is Alexei Navalny.
SPEAKER_00Um, because, well, an ally of mine at a movement voter project great group said, This is going to sound really weird. I was reaching out for ideas, and she said, it's gonna sound really weird because we know he died in Putin's prisons. But I think that you should at least check out Navalny's autobiography because it's really uplifting. And it's like, okay. I mean, that sounds very weird, but I'm reading it and he's saying things like, Hey, somebody must have read George Orwell.
SPEAKER_00He's saying this from prison. Somebody must have read George Orwell's 1984 and thought, cool, guys, we can do this. Let's do it here. And oh, they care so much about me. They've got somebody standing next to my bed so I don't run away in the middle of the night accidentally. They they care about me. So on and on on. It's, I mean, my wife is literally sitting next to me. Why are you laughing so hard? What are you reading? And it's like, oh, I'm reading the prison memoirs of Navalny. And, you know, so it's it actually is it's a really uh it's a really powerful excerpt about both strength of will, but also scathing defiant humor.
SPEAKER_00But the reason that Navalny was poisoned and then jailed when he comes back to Russia, twofold. One is he's trying to mobilize people to vote against Putin in the most remote regions of the country. Um, I actually met somebody from the town where he was poisoned. Um and two, he's really focusing on the corruption. And so they did a documentary called Putin's Palace about this just immense vacation retreat of his paid for by the oligarchs, because you know, I think billions of dollars that were just with huge screening rooms and swim, multiple swimming pools, and great halls.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it's sort of like all of Trump's fantasies, but enacted in Russia, and just describing it. And and people didn't like the idea of those huge amounts of money being spent on it. Or they looked at some of his allies and their lavish vacation homes in Montenegro and the Spanish coast and on and on. And so they their calling out the corruption was powerful, and that was why they you they went after Novelney so hard.
SPEAKER_00So and I think so. I think we have to do the same thing um and call it out, but we also have to do you know, for for the people who are in office, and this really, I mean, I'm really excited about some of the new folks, um they have to and we have to help them raise specific issues on the agenda that say, if you pass this bill, it will make people's lives better. And if you're resisting this bill, you're gonna be held accountable.
SPEAKER_00And then at the same time, which is I think the third thing really that you're phrasing is how do we end up with the framing that allows, that gets out in the culture that allows the people who are in elected office to push through a bill that is really actually beneficial and powerful and changes some things. You know, and to me, they all they all work together. I mean, you know, an example of the, I guess I call it a negative example, is um with climate change. And this has been just a pet peeve of mine for years.
SPEAKER_00It's like you have a climate disaster, and we have them just every day. And to me, you need elected officials getting in there and saying, this is climate change, and we better change it because this is happening and it's happening again, it's happening again. And on gun violence, that finally started happening. The first response was don't politicize tragedy. And then they started realizing that this is the teachable moment. So we better talk about it now, because this is when people are willing to listen and actually got some progress.
SPEAKER_00And we needed, you know, the same thing absolutely needed in terms of climate change, which is these are the moments people are willing to listen to start talking about them. And so, you know, so that's a case of elected officials, because they were just during the Biden administration, I mean they that the bill that basically is pretty much totally turned overturned by Trump and by the by the Republican bills, big bad bill. Uh, it did some absolutely landmark stuff on climate change, but At the same time, they were just being silent about it publicly, and plenty of teachable disasters were happening, and they just didn't, you know.
SPEAKER_00I mean, you when you have the city of paradise burning, it kind of writes its own script and you don't take advantage of it. You know, and not in any kind of unethical way, but just simply to point out this is what happens. Paradise is burning, and then Hawaii is burning, and I can't even, you know, and then the Texas floods and on and on and on. I mean, just it's constant, but if it isn't amplified, it goes away. So I think there's a common it's a dialectic between the grassroots movements and the elected officials, and it's putting stuff on the agenda so people can actually say, oh yeah, this would we need to act on this.
SPEAKER_00This would make it better.
SPEAKER_01See, I want to um let's go back to the corruption as an example and then and then go forward again, because I do think that there's more than one way to talk about most things or to do do, you know, to engage in activism about most things. Right. And corruption, for example, um, what does it really teach? Uh we shouldn't have a grotesque, violate, you know, personally grotesque violator, criminal, thief, etc.
SPEAKER_00in all enriching themselves, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and that's seems to me to be the sort of message, and the solution is get them out. And there's no larger context in which, or there might not be any larger context. It's different if when you talk about corruption, uh, not you, but when you know, right when activists talk about corruption, they do it in a way which also addresses the source of the behavior.
SPEAKER_01What is it about? Is it because these people have bad genes and just dump them, get rid of them, or is it because there's a structure and there's uh incentives and there's a system that breeds this sort of thing, and even breeds components of it in ourselves, you know, where we look out for ourselves and not so much for others, and so on. And so I'm wondering, I mean, to me, for instance, corruption as an issue works as a as a uh uh an attractor, so to speak, to move people who are well away from activism, they're well away from, they're not particularly engaged, they're cynical, etc.
SPEAKER_01Those people might be aroused and get angry, but if that's all that happens, it's not worth much. And it goes back to the original question: how do you get from people responding to corruption or wildfires or floods and so on at a moment, or even from Black Lives Matter, which was gargantuan in the US, right? But then not that long later, it was gone.
SPEAKER_01Not completely gone, but comparatively, you know, vastly reduced. How do you how do you not have that fall off? Or what do you have to do to minimize that fall off and keep going forward? And because you've set that up as the as the criteria, uh, you know, as the measuring stick, but I'm not sure what you do with it to sustain it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, a couple, I mean, a couple thoughts. One one is that if you talk with folks who are not enormously political, one of the challenges is they'll say, well, they're all corrupt. You know, that's just the way it is. It's, you know, and there's some truth in it. Uh, so they're all corrupt, so there's nothing you can do. It's just that's a system corrupt. I mean, Trump fed on that very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very, very so I think part of what you have to do is to talk about, I mean, like, well, the ties with the fossil fuel industry or the Saudis.
SPEAKER_00Um, I mean, I don't, you know, I don't understand why the Saudis aren't the Saudis are such a reprehensible regime in so many visible, obvious ways that you ought to be able to paint them and say, look, this is this is who they're hanging out with. This is really what you would like to live live with? I don't think for so for most folks. So I think when when you can target money, I mean, I was thinking of uh one of the stories in The Impossible will take a little while, is uh by my friend Mary Piper, the actually a best-selling psychologist.
SPEAKER_00But in this particular case, she's just somebody who lived in Nebraska, lives in Nebraska, and the Keystone XL pipeline was coming through uh Nebraska. And it was gonna take the oil from the tar sands and in uh in Alberta, which is about I think it's four times as impactful on climate as regular oil because of the energy that it takes to extract it, and you have to cut down the arboreal forest. So it's it's just really bad news.
SPEAKER_00And then if it leaks, it's a disaster, and the pipeline was gonna jeopardize the aquifer. And here's where the sort of corruption came in is that TransCanada was the company building the pipeline, and they had basically bought everything that was viable in Nebraska. So what that meant is they'd reserved ads on every single small or large media outlet. They had gone to every elected official near the path and said, hey, you know, we might want to store some equipment in your backyard.
SPEAKER_00Could we give you some money? And it was all, you know, it was all legal, but uh basically, can we give you some money? Bribe you. And every PR firm, and they they they really had sort of planned it out and well-thought-out campaign. And my friend Mary and a few other people, um Jane Klebe, who's now I she's, I think she's I think she's the chair of the Nebraska Democratic Party now. She was with something called Bold Nebraska. Uh, maybe a half dozen just met and had a potluck.
SPEAKER_00And it's like, we don't really know what to do, but let's have some soup and some bread and some chili and whatever it is that they had, and talk and figure out maybe some of us have some ideas. And they keep brainstorming, they start reaching out to different communities and involve all the people and groups. And they ended up um making a there was a rancher rock rib Republican who looked like John Wayne, uh named Randy, whose land was in the path. And he's like, I'm not gonna sell this as my family land, I'm not gonna get bullied.
SPEAKER_00And so they wisely, because Nebraska's a conservative state, made him the symbol of the campaign rather than the liberals from Lincoln. And they did life-size cutouts of him with his phrase, I will not be bullied, and then the slogan, We Stand with Randy. And it just kept growing and growing and across, again, across very diverse political lines. And the moment when they knew they had a chance was when uh Trans Canada had bought the ads, they were buying ads everywhere.
SPEAKER_00And so one of them was on the Jumbotron for the Corn Huskers football games, and the ad goes on, stadium, 85,000 people, erupts into booze. And it was like, oh, we might win this thing. They don't really, those people don't like it. We've done, we've we've achieved something, and and eventually put enough pressure. There was civil disobedience to the White House when Obama was there, Obama block ends up blocking it. Uh, Trump sort of tries to revive it, Biden blocks it again, and then they just the pipeline votes give up essentially.
SPEAKER_00And so, to me, what are they doing? They're illustrating, we go back to corruption, they're illustrating the sort of the root alliances of money that are causing what is just you know a disastrous project to theoretically roll forward. And in their highlighting of it, and they're reaching out to other people, again, very diverse people, they end up building a coalition that defeats it. So, so I I I I love that moment and I I I find it very inspiring.
SPEAKER_01But not to underplay or to discount that whole process that you just described, but there's still the issue, I think, of how processes like that, which take on some issue and which uh develop some momentum and maybe even win regarding that issue, uh, then go home.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And uh versus fitting into a larger hole.
SPEAKER_00What? Versus fitting into a larger hole.
SPEAKER_01Right, which is uh versus sustaining other projects, supporting other projects, being supported by them, and having someplace where you want to go. Earlier, you mentioned that you thought hope was a factor. To sustain involvement, and I think this is valid, to sustain involvement, you have to sort of have a feeling, informed also, you know, rational, but but a feeling, hey, it matters. Right hey, it might go beyond what I'm doing, it might be part of something bigger.
SPEAKER_01And so instilling that, I suspect, requires discussing that bigger thing in a way that resonates with where people are at. Yeah. And that seems to be what we're not that great at, and haven't been that great at you know, for a long, long time.
SPEAKER_00Well, and I think I mean to me it's a cut it's two things. It's it's it's it's the larger vision and its mechanisms of connection. I go, one of those stories that it's actually a story from originally in Soul of a Citizen and then developed it more in The Impossible will take a little while, is I go into the Rosa Parks story because everybody theoretically knows the story. I mean, like, oh yeah, the lady on the bus. Uh I mean, you know, if you go into any third-grade classroom, and they probably know heard of Rosa Parks. But the story, part of the story that's not discussed is her 12 years with the NAACB before that stand in the bus, her going to Highlander Center for trainings, the mentoring of the youth section, including the young woman, Claudette, I can't remember Colvin, who who refused to move the back of the bus, but they decided to wait and do somebody who's sort of the quote pillar of the community, and the the local black college of people like Joanne Robinson who were organizing the boycott, or the Edie Nixon, the sleeping car porters union activist who got King involved.
SPEAKER_00And King was, you know, in his first congregation, very reluctant, made tons of excuses. I'm new here, I'm young, I'm you know, just getting started. And that, you know, the collective action of everybody allows that buscoit to leap into history. Um so it's the question is have we been building equivalent groundwork, or does that, you know, deteriorate? I mean, in some cases, you know, just the maintenance in hard times.
SPEAKER_00I mean, again, I'm thinking about the NAACP chapters in Mississippi and South Carolina that were not giving, you know, and Georgia, of course, that you know, weren't weren't giving up, were continuing on. And then suddenly the organizing that they're doing, the outreach that they're doing leaps to a different level and becomes part of a process that, you know, uh helps flip the uh political uh, you know, the flip a senator or governor.
SPEAKER_00Um you know, so absent that infrastructure, could those campaigns have succeeded? But I also, yeah, I think the answer is no, but I also think that that there's not enough of that infrastructure. So that's part of it. And then the question is, of course, what people are fighting for, which was sort of what you were asking. And I guess part of the challenge to me is how do you how do you translate what you're fighting for so that it's not a, I mean, the Democrats are very good at the laundry list.
SPEAKER_00And it's not, I don't know why people call it a laundry list. It doesn't really sh they should call it a shopping list, because I don't think anybody makes a laundry list. They just throw there, and they always use the phrase, but what do they do? They just throw their clothes in the washing machine and then take them out and put them in the dryer or they hang them or whatever they do. But show but people make shopping lists, so let's call it the shopping list. And they're good at that. Here it is. It's completely uninspiring. And, you know, some of it passes, some of it doesn't.
SPEAKER_00So, how do you do the principles? I mean, I've been one of the things that again, this campaign is so free is fresh in my mind. And what I realized is I've I had it's not like I've listened to all of the candidates, but you know, I've seen clips from most of the ones, you know, were successful, the new ones, and or listened to them. And I've liked the fact that they somehow managed to stop talking in that sort of consultantees cliche.
SPEAKER_00They just sort of talk like regular human beings. And the down, I mean, call Scott Collum, and I admit to um spending much of the last period since election day obsessively refreshing the vote counting totals on Mississippi as each batch of ballots comes in. Um but he's very down to earth. And you know, is there a vision of justice? Clearly. But he's also very, very down to earth.
SPEAKER_00And I don't I think part of it is that the candidates, but it's also for the rest of us who are the political activists and organizers, it's like there's a sort of suit of protect certainly a suit that people put on of candidate. You know, it's talking a certain way. Certainly that's true for activists too, I think. And it's very tempting. It's like, hey, you know, we got it, we know all this stuff, and we stop listening. We forget how to talk. So I think that's part of, I mean, does that solve the grand the grand vision of social change?
SPEAKER_00I don't know that it does, but I feel like but it's a it's a part of it. But it's a part of it, yeah. But it's a part of it. Yeah, it's it's it's a start. And it ain't and it anchors it. I mean, then that's what I felt like. I mean, I was listening to Adam Hamilton, you know, maybe the most conservative in some ways. You know, he was a Republican until relatively recently, but he was really good. And he was just sort of talking in human terms about critical issues.
SPEAKER_00It reminded me of, who I do know a little bit because he lives in Seattle, of Rick Steves, who, you know, he was a becomes a travel guru. He's a he's just like a good Lutheran. And and but when you talk, whatever the issue from the Iran war to Gaza to whatever, he just expresses his feelings about it in human terms, and people can listen and hear it. Um and so I think that, and you know, those those last couple examples, I guess, are coming from religious traditions, but it doesn't have to come from that.
SPEAKER_01Now, and if you if you ask, well, why is that not the norm, so to speak, among progressives and leftists? Um, you know, it's not obvious, but it's an important question because it ought to be the norm, you know, to say what you feel and to hear what other people are feeling and be able to uh to communicate with it. We're back to the outreach question. Um, you know, oftentimes you get the feeling that activists become comfortable with a certain number of fellow activists, let's call it, yes, and talking to people who feel like they do and think like they do, and not comfortable with encountering uh different views, especially ones that are critical, and yet that's what you have to do to outreach.
SPEAKER_01I mean, unless what you're talking about is outreaching to your roommate. I mean, you know, that that's what you have to do.
SPEAKER_00And or to the people on social media who you, you know, who already agree. Same thing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Same thing. And uh, you know, so that's an important uh component. But let me ask you another sort of sliding over a little question. You're not you, uh you know, the uh a person is progressive, activist, involved, right, confronting the current moment, right, and thinking about what to do. And so one option is what you were describing in the form of infrastructure that can sustain and reach out and that is uh you know is is sustainable.
SPEAKER_01Right. And another task is say to add your voice to okay, um, attacking the slugs um and uh seeking them to be uh prosecuted or removed from office, or another thing that you can add your voice to. Yeah, yeah, another another thing you could add your voices to is pushing for the single issues and the the possible things and doing it in the way that is easiest.
SPEAKER_01So for instance, you could you could come out for a wealth tax, right, or you could come out for a wealth tax plus an enforceable restriction that you know the targets of the wealth tax can't escape it. Right. If they try to escape it, their property is nationalized. Right. Okay, two different things. You you can do the former in a way that only talks about Elon Musk as an asshole, right? Or you can do it in a way that talks about the system and and that points toward further things to to seek instead of going home.
SPEAKER_01You know what I mean? And this is this is the distinction I'm trying to draw, uh, perhaps poorly, but trying. And uh what's your thought in line with that on what should be the role of DSA over the next two years?
SPEAKER_00Boy, that's a complicated one because I I know. I mean that's the point. Yeah. Um I mean, because I like I'm trying to remember the guy, but there was this article that I really loved called it was basically called the two DSAs. And it described how there's, you know, the sort of vibrant New York City DSA and Detroit and some of the other cities were just, you know, all energizing, doing all those kinds of things of reaching out.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00And then there's a sort of workers' world-influenced sectarianism in some of that national leadership that's just toxic. And I mean, I'm gonna be, you know, since you're asked about it, I was a member for years. And then when I and I spoke at one of their, I think it was their youth section, I was the speaker and that kind of thing. And then when the Ukraine war happened, when Russia invaded Ukraine, I read this statement basically apologizing for Russia. And I think, what the hell? So I email a couple of the people who I still knew and said, like, what the hell?
SPEAKER_00And they're like, Yeah, well, we feel the same way, but this is by this committee and this national leadership and whatever. And I was just like, Well, I'm sorry, I can't, you know, it's not like you agree with you have to agree with every stand, but this just was a moral watershed. And I'm like, you know, I'm sorry, I'm with Ukraine. And and that's that was the last time I've been a member of DSA, which of course was right, well, it wasn't before it started taking off, but it was, you know, the the the the the largest level of expansion came afterwards, mostly through, you know, genuine grassroots stuff that is, you know, admirable, like you know, the camp mom donny's campaign and stuff like that, and you know, Rashid Tab Lee and you know that.
SPEAKER_00So I think I think the what I hope the role would be, and then and I've had these conversations with friends of mine who some of them have stayed, some and fought, and some of them aren't, which is just like do you wanna do you wanna make I think you have to rein in that craziness. I mean, it just because it does, it just dishonors the organization, and then you Have to kind of support the genuine outreach, which is pretty inspiring and pretty amazing.
SPEAKER_00Uh, and and you just have you know, and it's kind of a personal choice of you know whether you you stay inside or you or you don't. But anyway, that's my thought on one thing I do want to mention, you know, what again, because we've we've had this amazing conversation, 95% of which hasn't been from the book, but in some ways that's kind of fun because I've been mostly talking about stories from the book and all these podcast interviews and media interviews, and like, hey, yeah, this is all these other things that come up. So it's it's it's a really great and rich conversation.
SPEAKER_00But I was thinking about the importance of the past in understanding like how to respond in the present. And one of the things that that I, in the new edition of The Impossible Will Take a Little While, that I do is I talk about the Norwegian resistance to the Nazis. And Norry gets occupied. The we if we know the word quisling for traitor, Vidken Quisling is the founder of the Norwegian Fascist Party who's put in charge of running the country.
SPEAKER_00And they tell the teachers basically, here's what you got to teach, and um, you got to enroll the kids in the equivalent of the Hitler youth, and on and on. And what was really interesting to me is that the Norwegian teachers, you know, in a conquered nation that didn't defeat it militarily, simply refused and said, We're Norwegians, we will teach our values. And so 11,000 out of 14,000 teachers signed a um public letter to a public letter to the government saying, we are not going to do this.
SPEAKER_00We're gonna teach as we always had. I mean, just direct resistance. And then they didn't know what to do, and they threatened them with firings, and but you can't fire every single one of them, and 90%, 80% had signed this, and so they send 1,100 of them up to labor camps and concentration camps, and they still don't buckle. And eventually the Nazis cave, and um Quisling has a he talks at a high school on the outskirts of Oslo and says, You teachers have ruined everything for me.
SPEAKER_00We could have had our own country, and you know, now we can't, and and he jails the people there, but then the ones who weren't there that day say you gotta jail us too. And basically the Nazis back down. Now, here's what's really interesting, which is that happens what, 80 years ago. Then Ice comes to Minnesota. Minnesota has, you you know, most people know, lots of Norwegians. It was their center for immigration. And they have grandparents and great-grandparents.
SPEAKER_00And because this is a story that is not particularly known in the US, but in Norway, people know it because it's something to be proud of. So the uncle, you know, great uncle so-and-so, great-grandfather so-and-so, have told the story. And they start framing, it's not to say that it's the only stream that's feeding resistance. They learn from Chicago. I have a section in the book of the Chicago resistance to ice uh in The Impossible will take a little while. Um, they learn from Los Angeles, Portland, the other cities where ICE has come in.
SPEAKER_00But they also add this other twist, and they they explicitly frame their activism in the lineage of the Norwegians. And you don't usually see yarn shops being the centers of resistance, but a yarn shop basically said, here are the hats that the Norwegians made that then as defy to defy the Nazis, and here's the pattern of it, and I'll we'll put it online and sell it for five bucks with the money going to ICE resistance.
SPEAKER_00And they sold a hundred thousand patterns for these hats. And I was doing a Substack live with uh Hajida Lee, and you can this the way that format works, you can see the comments rolling by. And as I'm talking about it, these people are saying, Yeah, I knitted five of those caps. I knitted some of these caps. Yeah, we wore these caps over here. And what what I love is that it's a because none of I mean all the things we're talking about are critically important, but they all presuppose that people continue to stay involved, because if they aren't involved, we can't do any of that.
SPEAKER_00So I what I love is the way that Nelson Mandela talks about the multiplication of courage, is that we have an event from 80 years ago and then multiplies the courage of people in Minnesota resisting ice. And and I think that theme comes through in the same way when uh one of the other sections in The Impossible take a little while is how the South Koreans stopped their coup two years ago.
SPEAKER_00Uh and the people didn't follow it much here, but they basically, the president declared martial law, banned unions, strikes, pro uh organizations, parliament. I mean, they're just martial law dictatorship. And but the parliament had the right to reverse it. So they sent troops to grab it, drag everybody out who was there was 1020 at night, um, and block others from coming. And there's this race where the parliamentarians are live streaming from their cars or taxis, heading in, just saying, gather the parliament, protect the parliament, and 16,000 people make it there.
SPEAKER_00You know, because again, it's like starts at 1020 at night, and they help the parliamentarians climb over the walls, push through the soldiers, and eventually they get enough core of a quorum to have a vote and eliminate the martial law. People then stay, it bills to a million people outside demanding impeachment and um and and trying for what they're doing. And Yun is now in jail for life, uh, as his and his minister, defense minister and interior minister have lengthy sentences too.
SPEAKER_00Now, a couple of things are interesting in this. One is that there was disaffection in the troops. So you had people literally deployed in charge of the troop of a troop bus. And they said, Yeah, we went to the parliament, we stayed in our bus. We told we're gonna stay here, we're not gonna go in. Somebody's in charge of taking helicopters taking off, and he's like, sorry, airspace is too crowded, can't take off. Somebody's in charge of issuing ammunition, and he's like, Oh, I'm sorry, got to keep a reserve of ammunition at the depot, can't give you any ammunition.
SPEAKER_00And then in my favorite, um, a group was designated to shut down the servers that uh power the electronic voting of the parliament, and they stop for ramen noodles instead, and you know, at a convenience store, and they're eating the ramen noodles and they're not at the parliament, you know, at least eventually they get there. But in that critical period, they're eating ramen noodles. And one of the things that was very interesting to me, and this goes back to like to the Norwegian teachers, is that people kept talking about the Guangzhou Massacre, which was, gosh, I think it was 1989.
SPEAKER_00I may have the wrong date. Um, but basically, this is what happens when a dictatorship consolidates. We don't want this to happen again. Therefore, you know, they're telling this to the soldiers, you know, don't go there. They're telling this to each other, this is why we're acting. And so it's a way of allowing the past to strengthen the present. There's a really great documentary on those events. And somebody says the past may have, we always think that we're trying to save the future.
SPEAKER_00In this case, the past may be saving us by giving us the vision of what we have to stand up for.
SPEAKER_01Again, uh, these examples are of course instructive about things that can be done and the impact they can have. But we're talking in most of them, or in a lot of them, about reacting against something, removing something, stopping something, etc. We're not talking about changing the system so that it is worthy, doesn't generate the incredible injustices, but more to the point, does generate uh liberation.
SPEAKER_01And I still feel like that's the I mean, you know, there's a difference between let me just uh Trump and you know his cohort and and puppeteers uh were in one sense impressive is the wrong word to use. I don't know what word precisely to use, but they approached the possibility of running the government with an attitude, we're going to deconstruct and reconstruct it to our far more revolutionary in some sense, a despicable sense in their case, right, uh, than we are when we think about these things.
SPEAKER_01Right. So, you know, we just don't it's that law, and and how long did it take for them to generate that? Quite a while. And quite a few people focused on that, concerned about the day-to-day, I guess annoyances that they didn't like, you know, slightly higher taxes or whatever. But primarily concerned about how do we make the world the way we want it? And we don't do that.
SPEAKER_00And even you're saying they felt large.
SPEAKER_01They they went large, yeah. They when from the first administration to the second administration, my impression was Trump and Co. said, you know what, in that first administration, we couldn't do all that we wanted to do. We couldn't even do much of what we wanted to do. And the reason was these structures of government, as well as out in the society. And when they got in, they they tried to attack culture, schooling, education, religion, everything.
SPEAKER_01Everything. And to and to literally dismantle the government and rebuild it.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01When was the last time that the left in the United States had that kind of attitude?
SPEAKER_00And I think Clinton Johnson Great Society probably is the last time.
SPEAKER_01Well, maybe the 60s partly had that attitude, but you know, I was not that much, um, and not very well conceived. But in any case, um one of the factors might be that they thought they could do that. In other words, the Republicans and whatever it was, Project 2025, you know, Project Nazi. Um they felt, you know, we can do this.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01Um, it's worth our time and our effort because we'll win. Or we can win. They were confident. They had a degree of confidence that I think we lack at some level.
SPEAKER_00They're also very focused on gaining power, and we're not and and we're sort of afraid of power. So yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, and we don't want to gain power from the top like a dictatorship. Right, right. But we do want to, let's call it, gain participation by the population, which yields the outcomes that suit the population. Right. You know, so it's different, of course. Yeah. But um I feel like what's the what is the aspect in the person that distinguishes between the person who gets aroused by uh whatever, Black Lives Matter, me too, occupy what the hell was it?
SPEAKER_01Um Wall Street, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Um uh or get rid of Trump. Right. Or whatever it may be. What is the difference in the person who is active and who has that hope for a time, right, and the person and keeps it and the person who doesn't keep it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I'm not criticizing the person, but I'm saying we need to understand that because that that's what we need to overcome.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think some of it is really um looking at the systems of power. I was looking, I guess I'm thinking there's a book called If We Burn, uh Vincent Bevins that I came out a couple of years ago, and to sort of looking at the sort of spontaneous left uprisings and then sort of why they often fizzled out and just in some cases, in one in the case of Brazil where he was working uh as a journalist, uh very much contributed to Dilma being taken out of office and bull and the Bolsonaro allies laying the ground for him.
SPEAKER_00Um so I I think that it I think it has to be again we have people have to figure out what are they gonna be able to build that's durable. I think that that's because otherwise you are just buffeted by the winds. And and that's to me, I mean, so the challenge is because that's hard, you've got to be able, and this is where the impossible will take a little while, comes in, you've got to be able to come up with the sources of hope and strength to keep doing it, because it's not going to be that easy.
SPEAKER_00I mean, both of us have spent all our, you know, we're we're getting we're getting older in our lives, and we spent all of our li adult lives and even near adult lives working for these things. I mean, you and I connected, I think you were at South End Press, you know, it was, I mean, it was literally 50 years ago. And and we're both young activists. No, we're not young young activists, but we're still engaged, you know, which is good. And and but I think finding the ways to continue acting and transmitting them to others is key.
SPEAKER_00And looking at the systems and thinking large what could change, recognizing I mean Jonathan, there's a piece, a great piece by Jonathan Kozel in The Impossible, Take a Little While, and he just it's about our school and the Bronx and just the tenacity and persistence of the kids in the midst of all this violence. And and he distinguishes between the events that like a police shooting that just you know that stirs outrage, and you know, and it's the outrage is important, and then he talks about the ordinary dying, because there's a kid down the block who gets gunned down the next week, and it's not quite as linear, but it's still a system that sets it up so that some other kid who's just as desperately poor ends up killing him.
SPEAKER_00And so it's it's trying to figure out what are beside, and this goes back to something you were saying, not just in the dramatic moments, but also in the sort of ongoing moments that are less less dramatic. How do we recognize? Because I think people feel the daily insults. I mean, again, every time, every time I'm on hold, we started this conversation, to a credit card company, I completely understand why people elected Trump. I want to burn it all down.
SPEAKER_00I want to kill all of them. I mean, it's just like my you know, my wife's, you know, I'm cursing upstairs. My wife's, can you please be quiet? You know. And, you know, because these daily, and it's part of the, you know, it's part of a structure of daily humiliations that the majority of folks now face because it's financially beneficial to the institutions that we nonetheless have to deal with, like our credit card companies. So I think it's figuring out a way to take that and say, hey, you know, there could actually be a little bit of a, I mean, it's not how to describe it, it's not like, oh, that's never been thought of.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I'm thinking of credit card companies and I'm thinking of Elizabeth Warren and the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau. I mean, it was a pretty amazing, you know, institution that got initiated. But the question then is, can do you, and I think we didn't, was did the organizing happen on the outside that really says, this was pretty amazing. How can we extend its reach? How can we extend its power in a way that benefits all of us? So sometimes something does read, oh, hey, it got passed, great, but then it just sort of stands on its own and it doesn't have the those institutions can't but that by themselves do that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's ultimately a difference between um being active, let's call it for a minute, being active out of anger at some extreme violation, right? And active day to day, and being active at uh out of desire for something, right in recognition that there's better. And it isn't the unusual, exaggerated pain that's the real issue.
SPEAKER_01It's that it's all pain and it's all the time unjust, right? And it doesn't have to be, and here's the way it could be otherwise.
SPEAKER_00Right, and here's the better, and here's the better way that it could be. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. All right. Well, we're over an hour. Um, do you is there something that you would have liked to have uh addressed, which you now could, or is there anything that you'd like to close with?
SPEAKER_00Or maybe maybe close with Mandela. I mean, maybe close with Mandela because I just when I put the impossible to will take a little while together. And what happened is I'm speaking around the country on Soul of a Citizen. People are keep asking me where to find hope, what sustains you, how to keep going. And I thought, well, I'll just go to the people who inspire me and I'll go through my bookshelves and make a big pile on the living room table and see if I think I've got a book in there. And then, of course, commissioned pieces and found pieces and the rest.
SPEAKER_00But Mandela was probably Mandela and Howardson were probably the first two pieces that I pulled down. And, you know, his story of being 27 years in a South African prison and not giving up, maintaining his strength, maintaining his dignity. And I love the way he found they found little ways to resist. So they're denied newspapers, and they see a guard wrap his sandwich in the newspaper and discard in the trash.
SPEAKER_00They grab it, smuggle it under their shirts in a coded script on toilet paper, pass a story that might inspire each other cell by cell. It just, to me, it's such a powerful moment because it says at the point that we're beaten down, we have far more latitude, and yet they found ways to act. So I think that's to me, that's that it's such a critical foundational story. And in the new edition of The Impossible will take a little while, I added a story by one of his guards who became a lifelong friend, and just how an 18-year-old Afrikaner farm boy, told this is a dangerous terrorist, starts listening to him and talking with him.
SPEAKER_00And Mandela reaches out and asks him about his family and does he play sports and just what's his life like? And that creates a lifelong friendship. So I think it's that human-to-human reach, and it's those finding ways to act, whatever the circumstances. And you know, that's the impossible take a little while. And if people want to, the theimpossible.org goes to the same place as paulloeb.org, but it's a lot easier to spell.
SPEAKER_00So that's why that's why I use it. So that's all right.
SPEAKER_01Well, um we'll see what uh comes of the moment that we're in in the moments to come. And uh uh hopefully uh we'll see something new uh and uh sustained and large uh emerge uh in the US and also in many other places in the world that uh in some of those places they're well ahead of us, I think, on that on that uh trajectory and other places not.
SPEAKER_01But maybe uh we can see what happens.
SPEAKER_00Well, and we inside we all inspire each other.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh so I want to thank you, Paul, for uh being here today and tell people again there's a there's a website. What's the website again? Polo.org, right?
SPEAKER_00So the the one the one to the one to go to, because it'll go to the same place, is theimpossible.org. Okay. And that's easy to spell. So yeah, and that's easier to be easier than trying to spell my name.
SPEAKER_01So okay, so theimpossible.org. And all that said, this is Mike Albert signing off until next time for Revolution Z.
Episode 414 of RevolutionZ considers tasks ahead in light of the MIdterm results. The scariest moment in politics may be when authoritarians win. but a not too distant second may be when they lose and we all exhale. Do...
Episode 413 of RevolutionZ asks what comes after our eruptions? What happens when the cameras leave, when the easy unity ages even just a little bit, and when power bets we will wear out and go home? What can we do to...
Episode 412 offers Part Two of Talking with Chat GPT wherein the AI effusively answers questions about itself, the AI industry and its CEOs, users, prospects and dangers, and about its and our futures. What can/will AI...
Episode 411 of RevolutionZ has a guest with initials instead of a name: GPT (5.6). The episode asks GPT questions many people quietly wonder about but rarely hear answered in its "voice." We start with deceptively...
Episode 410 of RevolutionZ is the last excerpt from the seven author book, Liberating Theory. It urges that a political vision that only addresses one part of society is a blueprint for disappointment. It closes the...