Episode 410 of RevolutionZ is the last excerpt from the seven author book, Liberating Theory. It urges that a political vision that only addresses one part of society is a blueprint for disappointment. It closes the Liberating Theory excerpt series by walking through a “humanist” or participatory society framework that treats economy, kinship, community, and politics as four interacting spheres, each capable of reinforcing or undermining changes in the others. To achieve socialism, feminism, anti-racism, or participatory democracy, the point is not to pick one label for everything. The point is to build institutions that generate solidarity, protect diversity, and make self-management real in all these realms. The episode moves from values to institutional design including participatory economics with balanced job complexes, self managing workplace and consumer councils, and allocation that avoids both markets and central planning. It then adds feminist kinship to end misogyny, defend reproductive freedom, break sex-based parenting roles, and reject ageism while respecting children and elders. Then, regarding community, it proposes intercommunalism and cultural self-determination without turning identity into biology or pushing Orwellian cultural homogenization. Finally, for politics, it goes beyond episodic elections toward participatory democracy that depends on broad access to information, debate, and self-managed options. Then the episode gets intensely practical to consider what strategy looks like in a world more complex than any simplistic simulation? The episode uses game analogies to show why tactics, programs, and strategy have to stay flexible and attend to consequences, and how a win-lose mindset can smuggle authoritarian habits back into liberatory movements. The episode then digs into how to think through activist choices and consequences in a sufficiently multi-faceted way to attain desired aims. It takes up matters of organization and issue interconnection to advocate “autonomy within solidarity,” and it concludes with a sharp and entertaining dialogue on cynicism, human nature, and whether despair is a form of self-protection or hypocritical denial. Will Liberating Theory's concepts and observations, as in this episode's examples, help activists think more productively about social change tactics, participatory organization, and movement alignment? This is for you to decide. What part of the framework do you most want to test in real organizing? If none, why is that? I hope you will let me know either way. Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello, my name is Michael Albert, and I am the host of the podcast that's titled Revolution Z. This is our four hundred and tenth consecutive episode and it continues the sequence that excerpts from the seven author book Liberating Theory. This time the collective work discusses vision and strategy. This is the last excerpt, and so it excerpts the final two chapters and their dialogues, and as a result, it is pretty long one of the longest I've done, I think.
SPEAKER_00The excerpts chapter begins Four sources of definition for society, not one or even two a human center and an institutional boundary, not an economic base and social superstructure. Accommodation, co definition, and even co reproduction between components all within an encompassing ecology and international relations, social stability or social transformation? Three potential ruling classes, not two.
SPEAKER_00Is all that and more just academic complexification? Or does it have simplifying implications for actual worthy workable vision and strategy? Definitive evidence about the worth of our new concepts can only come from applying them to three critical questions. What features and dynamics characterize our society now? Or does our vision of a more desirable future society? How do we expect to get from here to there?
SPEAKER_00Much has been written about the first question. While we hope that our wholest principles will inform further analyses of contemporary conditions, we focus our attention here on the latter two questions. Having argued so strenuously that societies are rarely, if ever, predominantly determined by their characteristics of one sphere, it follows that we should not limit our goals by visualizing a desirable future embracing less than four spheres. Moreover, we should not label our vision for all of society with a concept that historically resonates with an emphasis on only one sphere.
SPEAKER_00Socialism, feminism, intercommunalism, and participatory democracy are appropriate names for different aspects of a desirable future society. But why use an economic concept to describe all of society unless one is economistic? And why use a kinship concept to describe all of society unless one is well kinshipist? People justifiably distrust labels that reduce any of their priorities to peripheral concern.
SPEAKER_00Thus we will use the familiar labels as names for desirable ways of organizing particular spheres of social activity, but we will use the more encompassing term humanist to describe the overall society we envision. I interject from twenty twenty six, forty years later. Names weren't a strong suit for the book liberating theory. If you prefer, for the whole new type society, perhaps the label participatory society would be better.
SPEAKER_00Or maybe the name picked forty years ago will resonate. In any case, it is the substance behind names that mostly matters. The chapter continues. How does one elaborate a humanist vision? First we need to decide what core characteristics we want in both the human center and institutional boundary. Second, we need to develop a vision of how social activity could be organized in each sphere so that our favored core characteristics would be generated.
SPEAKER_00For example, what major governing institutions and decision making systems could be expected to generate the core characteristics we desire? What community institutions and rules for community interrelations would generate these desirable core characteristics? Third, we need to refine our vision of all spheres in light of an analysis of how the dynamics of each will affect the dynamics and characteristics of all the others.
SPEAKER_00Here we only outline approaches that will hopefully serve as a basis for further work by ourselves and others. How does one justify the superiority of one set of core characteristics compared to another? Where do humanist values come from? What core characteristics embody humanist values? We know that human potentials are sufficiently broad that a number of different reasonably stable social alternatives to our own are feasible.
SPEAKER_00Moreover, since the behavior patterns, desires, and values of citizens in any society are in large part formed by the core characteristics of the institutional structures people encounter, we know that reproductive dynamics between any society's center and boundary will promote values in their citizens that will tend to justify whatever core characteristics they daily encounter. It follows that if we ask merely whether people get what they seek in some society, we will get a yes answer in many cases where the society is nonetheless oppressive.
SPEAKER_00To have confidence in our evaluations we must ask instead, in what society will people seek and attain the most? Unlike philosophical nihilists who reject value statements or moral judgments and wonder why only whether citizens in a society support the society, we have to wonder whether citizens also maximally develop and fulfill themselves. Thus, while many different core characteristics are possible, not all equally fulfill human potentials.
SPEAKER_00And while all sets of core characteristics fulfill at least some aspects of human potential, not all sets equally promote all aspects or foster all forms of human development. For example, while a competitive, authoritarian system may display a degree of stability, indicating that human beings can adapt even to those conditions, this does not mean that there are no aspects of human potential that are denied by such circumstances.
SPEAKER_00If needs for social solidarity and self management cannot be fully satisfied for large numbers of people under competitive or authoritarian systems, such systems contradict those needs, even if people are not loudly proclaiming them. Other systems with different core characteristics that do as well by human fulfillment and development on other counts and better on this count are superior. To argue for the desirability of a particular set of core characteristics, it follows that we must show that they are compatible with the full expression of all important aspects of human potential, and that they do not thwart meeting any justifiable human needs for some groups because of how efforts to meet the needs of other groups are organized.
SPEAKER_00That is, we should determine which core characteristics allow for the fullest development of all important human potentials for all of society's citizens, and which core characteristics provide for the greatest fulfillment of all important human needs for all. As we see it, therefore, a general understanding of basic human needs and potentials combined with a more specific understanding of how these historically develop can justify the core characteristics that best promote all people's human fulfillment and development.
SPEAKER_00We also believe that no other logic can fulfill this kind of ethical imperative. Most simply, a humanist must ask, what characteristics must a society have for people to freely develop to their fullest potentials? Of course, no one can fully answer this question. No one knows enough about human nature or the ways it manifests itself in social circumstances to give a comprehensive answer reaching all sides of moral, spiritual, intellectual, and material life.
SPEAKER_00The best we can do without additional knowledge gained through the experience of actually building humanist alternatives is to summarize the collective lessons of radical movements to date in order to elaborate a few straightforward aims so profound that they can provide at least the rough contours of a humanist vision. We reject prejudiced notions which go against all that is known about human genetics to assert that all people are innately antisocial, or that men are misogynist, women passive, non whites witless, some people born to lead, and most born to follow, and so on.
SPEAKER_00Needs we focus on instead are one social solidarity, two, diversity of life options and outcomes, and three, collective self management that allows each person to partake in decisions in proportion to the degree that he or she is affected by the outcome. We believe these aims promote human potentials, reflect lessons from radical historical experience, and include many other more specific goals that different humanists might wish to promote peace, equity, trust, respect, material well being, democracy, and on and on.
SPEAKER_00How can equity, self management, solidarity, and diversity become the characteristics that permeate every sphere of social life? What institutions have furthered these aims in the past, and how might we alter old forms to enhance their ability to do so in the future? What entirely new institutions are needed? Our vision must inform as well as inspire.
SPEAKER_00We know economic forms are required to allow for production, consumption, and allocation, and we know that in most past societies these functions have been accomplished in ways that divided people into conflicting classes, causing great inequalities and hierarchies. To define a humanist alternative, we need to examine existing economic forms, for example, markets, central planning, private and public ownership, and hierarchical divisions of labor, to see how they preclude solidarity, diversity, and collective self management.
SPEAKER_00In light of these lessons, we need to elaborate alternative economic forms better suited to organizing production, consumption, and allocation in ways consistent with humanist goals. In earlier chapters, we made many claims regarding the ways capitalist and coordinator forms elevate either capitalists or coordinators, but not workers to ruling economic status. By compelling competition and destroying solidarity and by centralizing decision making instead of allowing workers and consumers to self manage their own economic activities.
SPEAKER_00A humanist alternative requires collective self management which organizes production to involve all workers in jobs that empower them equally in decision making, develop their potentials freely and fully, and allocate difficult and dangerous tasks equitably. Decision making by producers and consumers must be participatory as well as democratic. To these ends, we will also have to overcome the division of work roles so it no longer holds that some people primarily conceive tasks that others perform, while other people primarily execute tasks that they do not conceive.
SPEAKER_00Job descriptions need to be flexible, maximizing creative opportunities while simultaneously and equitably minimizing the monotonous, unhealthy, and dangerous work everyone has to do. A primary role of automation under these circumstances must be to constantly eliminate monotonous and dangerous production tasks, though jobs that people want to do could be preserved. While no one would be discouraged from specializing in any area of work, whether healthcare, teaching, woodworking, or whatever, the economy would be fluid enough to allow people to change jobs and develop new and varied skills.
SPEAKER_00Whatever the focus of people's labors, a critical point is that they will have job complexes such that the range of tasks that they do will be comparable in its combination of empowering and rote conceptual and executionary skills to those of other workers. Second, workplace dynamics must promote solidarity by helping workers make decisions not only in light of their own needs and capacities, but in light of those of other workers and consumers.
SPEAKER_00By the same token, consumers must evolve their preferences not only according to their personal needs, but also in light of implications for other consumers and for workers who produce what they consume. Allocation mechanisms must not centralize decision making in the hands of capitalists, managers, technocrats, or a handful of central planners, nor can allocation be carried out via a system that competitively divides economic actors, pitting each against all others.
SPEAKER_00Not only private ownership of the means of production, but both markets and central planning will be ruled out as destructive of humanist goals. Some type of participatory planning will have to be developed and perfected. Third, since unequal income distribution sustains class divisions, income will have to be allocated equitably, even though individuals consume different goods and work at different job complexes according to different time schedules.
SPEAKER_00The economy would provide equitable, balanced job complexes for all who want to work, a shorter standard work week, comparable income for all, and free comprehensive health services. Though the task will be difficult, why aim for less than humanist institutional forms designed to allow society to effectively produce, allocate, and consume goods and services in ways that foster solidarity, diversity, and collective participatory self management.
SPEAKER_00I interject from twenty twenty six. The seven authors obviously settled on a kind of succinct summary of participatory economics as the book's economic vision. I wish I could remember and convey how that occurred, but forty years is a long time and I cannot. The rendition has changed somewhat over the years, deepened and refined, to clarify essential aspects and why they are worthy and would be viable. But the essence is here, albeit very loosely.
SPEAKER_00I was particularly surprised that there seemed to have been some squeamishness about addressing income remuneration, but that no doubt reflected differences about that matter. The chapter continues Kinship institutions are necessary for people to fulfill their sexual and emotional needs and raise new generations of children. But most societies have elevated men above women and children, oppressed homosexuals, and warped human sexual and emotional potentials.
SPEAKER_00In a humanist society, we have to eliminate socially imposed gender definitions so that individuals can freely pursue their lives as they choose, whatever their biological sex, sexuality, and within reason chronological age. But how? In earlier discussions we attributed the maintenance of patriarchy to several causes, including, but not limited to the division of childbearing roles along male, female, mother, father axes.
SPEAKER_00Reproductive freedom, the right to have children without fear of sterilization, economic oppression, or other injustices, and the right not to have children through unhindered access to birth control and abortion is a fundamental precondition of equity between women and men. But more is necessary. First, a critical characteristic of feminist kinship will be child rearing roles that do not divide tasks by sex.
SPEAKER_00There must be support for single parents, couples, and multiple parenting arrangements, including lesbian and gay parenting. Parents must have easy access to diverse child care options, including high quality personalized daycare, after school programs, workplace daycare, flexible work hours, and parental leave options. But the point is not to free parents by turning over the next generation to uncaring agencies. Instead, sustained, highly personalized and rich interaction between children and adults must be enhanced while distributing the responsibility for these interactions as equitably as possible.
SPEAKER_00Second, though there will continue to be great variations in how people organize their time and see themselves at different periods of their lives, ageism would have no place in a humanist society. Adults will certainly exert guiding influence over vulnerable children, since to be a child means in part to be incapable of completely governing one's own life. But even while protected and taught, children will also be respected and encouraged to voice their perspectives, which they will have freedom to develop with their peers and without undue interference.
SPEAKER_00Likewise, seniors will be encouraged to maintain an active life with full or partial retirement from work, guided by personal considerations and abilities, not economic dictates. The interface of perspectives molded in different times as seniors, the middle aged and children encounter each other will become one more vehicle for each to learn from the different experiences of others. Third, a humanist vision will embrace a liberated sexuality, which respects people's often changing choices and inclinations, whether homosexual, bisexual, or heterosexual, monogamous or non monogamous.
SPEAKER_00Moreover, beyond respecting rights, the exercise and exploration of different forms of sexuality by consenting partners provides a variety of experiences that can benefit all. In a humanist society without oppressive hierarchies, sex will presumably be pursued for emotional, physical, and spiritual pleasure and development. Experimentation to these ends is not something merely to be tolerated, but to be appreciated. In general, to offer a viable, attractive vision, feminists and humanists will have to elaborate liberatory visions of primary living groups, child rearing and sexuality.
SPEAKER_00But while such a vision will have to be comprehensive enough to provide compelling images and attractive possibilities, it should also leave room for experimentation and growth as we move into a new kind of future. I interject. I am surprised the kinship vision didn't explicitly address mothering and fathering, even if by implication it did make clear that parenting should not be predicated on sex or procreation only. I am only guessing again, as with economics, that among the seven authors there were perhaps some differences on this issue.
SPEAKER_00The chapter continues Intercommunalism We know that community forms give people a sense of who they are and where they fit in society and history. However, most community forms have also imposed the heavy prices of genocide, racism, jingoism, religious persecution, and ethnocentrism. The seemingly simplest alternative to the existence of many communities which confront one another with racial, national, religious, and ethnic hostility might be to integrate everyone into one comprehensive community group.
SPEAKER_00Likewise, the simplest solution to communities having internal attributes, destructive of solidarity, diversity, and collective self management would seemingly before. To redefine the culture of this one large community to make it satisfactory. But reacting to the negative interaction of diverse historical communities by attempting to eliminate those communities and their cultures through cultural homogenization is a disastrous policy. It is not only internally inconsistent, since it heightens exactly the community antagonisms it seeks to overcome, but even if it could be implemented, such a vision offers little variety and cultural self management.
SPEAKER_00In fact, cultural homogenization is an Orwellian nightmare. What then is a truly humanist alternative? First, promoting diversity requires that a humanist approach to community relations emphasizes the need to respect the multiplicity of community forms by guaranteeing each sufficient material and social resources to reproduce itself indefinitely. Reversing the homogenous agenda, humanist community policies will identify cultural subgroups and help them preserve and develop their own particular solutions to life's quandaries, not by imposing on them, but by ensuring their access to means of expression and the opportunity for free development.
SPEAKER_00Second, a humanist approach to community will emphasize that communities are not genetic or biological, but social and historical. Their forms will be diverse and memberships variable depending upon people's commitments, not on skin color or parentage. This is not to say that there will not be Italian black or Jewish communities. It merely clarifies that such communities will be cultural forms whose members belong by virtue of their beliefs and practices, not their quote, lineage.
SPEAKER_00Of course, being from Italy or having had an Italian upbringing or having immersed oneself in things Italian are the practices that give one an Italian culture and Italian community membership. But this is not due to genes, it is due to choice, and the same will hold for religious, ethnic, and racial community affiliation. To be black implies having been immersed in black culture. Someone whose skin is black but who has never experienced black culture is not necessarily a member of the black community, nor will having black skin elicit a presumption about one's culture or hostility from non blacks.
SPEAKER_00Moreover, someone whose skin is white but who has been brought up in and has adopted the cultural allegiances of the black community, for example, could be a member of that community. These recognitions will greatly facilitate the potential for mutual respect and for mutual learning among communities. Third, at the same time that a humanist approach to community will recognize and preserve the integrity of diverse community definitions, a humanist approach will also be sensitive will also be sensitive to the need for community definitions to be internally humane and supportive of individual and group freedoms.
SPEAKER_00People will be free to enter and leave cultural communities in accord with their own best understandings and desires. Moreover, cultures could be subject to criticism, but not intervention from without, though the right of their members to dissent and leave will be socially protected. Spirituality will likely flourish, though in many new forms as a result of changes both in our approaches to religion and in the character of the society in which our communities will be embedded.
SPEAKER_00But atheists will retain their right to criticize religious believers and vice versa, though neither atheists nor the religious will be able to deny the others cultural rights. But if a religious community denied a member the opportunity to leave and practice atheism, or vice versa, there would be intervention to protect the individual's right of cultural descent and choice. In short, under humanist intercommunalism, different cultural and spiritual institutions will be preserved and the right for them to persist will be respected.
SPEAKER_00Each will alter, no doubt, owing to changing understandings of the role and character of culture that evolve from liberatory internal dynamics, as well as influences from other social spheres, which help erode sexist, classist, and authoritarian definitions. At the international level, as a direct extension, intercommunalism will mean respect for self-determination and commitment to non intervention. Next, we know that the political sphere is a necessary means of providing overall social coherence and mediating social disagreements.
SPEAKER_00But we also know that most governments to date have created hierarchies, imposed regimentation, repressed freedom, and inflicted harsh crimes against their citizens. When we think about a humanist alternative, we must think in terms of new institutions which not only respect democratic advances that have occurred to date, but expand upon that base to promote a still higher degree of social participation and decision making.
SPEAKER_00We must go beyond electoral forms in which participation is brief and episodic, to conceive of structures in which popular oversight and participation is continuous. Further, we have to think not only in terms of a pluralism of contesting options, but also in terms of a pluralism of chosen outcomes. Expanding democracy means recognizing that there is no single right way to conduct social life since various alternatives can all embody valid goals and whenever possible, diverse options should be implemented.
SPEAKER_00We will not always automatically presume a single best way to do every imaginable task, but will instead experiment with diverse options. We will also have to pay attention to the obvious but often neglected fact that participatory democratic decision making forms are useless unless all citizens have access to informations and means of voicing, arguing for, and organizing around their ideas and social proposals. Democratic decision making is impossible if what people can propose is determined by a few who control access to information and ideas, thereby molding even what it is possible for people to think about.
SPEAKER_00We must develop rich means for information dissemination, popular debate, and sharing of new ideas. To discover how best to attain such ends, we must analyze the dynamics of information flow and debate as well as related structures of decision making to see how existing forms of each impede or propel true democracy. We must then develop alternative forms which overcome traditional obstacles to greater participation while getting the decision making job done in an effective fashion.
SPEAKER_00A humanist vision of governing forms must also therefore incorporate many dimensions of institutional life if it is not to risk undermining itself by ignoring the full array of variables that affect whether people can really manifest their wills in social decision making. I interject. I believe reading this material that the authors were in sum being quite cautious to not over propose details or even broad features, which could be received or perceived as over prescribing a vision that needs to emerge from collective practice.
SPEAKER_00If so, I anticipate that they would want to add some commentary now, forty years later, about how to fill out the vision sufficiently for it to efficient effectively guide practice suited to arriving where participants intend. The chapter continues If we take all these insights simultaneously, we have a kind of research program for developing a humanist vision. First, develop detailed images of possible economic, kinship, community, and governing forms which escape the classist, sexist, racist, and authoritarian norms of the past to accomplish their essential social functions in ways that instead promote social diversity, human solidarity, and collective self management.
SPEAKER_00We have discussed some means of accomplishing this much already. Second, refine these separate images into a whole social picture in which all the parts overlap in a consistent and mutually reinforcing fashion. The idea here is a bit more subtle. In contemporary US life, we know that each sphere creates a core characteristic which then helps define relations in other spheres as well. The same can occur in any future society.
SPEAKER_00Spheres necessarily accommodate and can certainly co define and co-reproduce. If men and women are treated equally by future kinship relations for stability, they must also be treated equally in the economic, political, and community spheres. And we can ensure this for our vision by simply incorporating that each sphere accommodate to the conditions of equity and participation that other spheres establish. But additionally, each sphere in our future society will contribute to producing the skills, dispositions, and personality attributes that we all develop, or that we each develop.
SPEAKER_00If one sphere promotes attributes that contradict another sphere's operations, or if one sphere requires people with certain inclinations, though other spheres impede the expression of those inclinations, conditions will be unstable. So if we want to use our concepts to create a workable societal vision, we must be sure that humanized economic, community, kinship, and political spheres promote dispositions, talents, inclinations, and or preferences that mutually reinforce one another.
SPEAKER_00And to assure this, we have urged that each sphere in a humanist society should co-reproduce the core characteristics every other sphere produces solidarity, diversity, and collective self management. Thus, we incorporate a high level of harmony into our vision precisely by our choice to have each sphere promote the same basic values. Third, recognize that though a vision developed in this fashion will provide a degree of clarity about what we seek to attain, an essential prerequisite to trying to develop strategy, it will nonetheless need to grow and alter as we learn more from our experiences.
SPEAKER_00Our tools are powerful, but they can only give us insights when coupled with knowledge of human potentials and needs. These we must continually elaborate through our effort at attaining change and then at working and living together in new ways. All right, so far so good, but what about strategy? How do we attain our aims? I interject. Remember, Liberating Theory was published in nineteen eighty six, forty years ago. I hope, however, that what we find in its discussion of generally applicable strategy feels like it could have been written today, in twenty twenty six, forty years later.
SPEAKER_00The chapter continues Tactics are ways of behaving that can be used with slight variations in many different situations and circumstances. Programs include sequences of tactical steps combined into patterns suitable for attaining more complex goals. Strategies are combinations of programs entwined into complete scenarios for attaining desired ends. Tactics, programs, and strategy can vary in focus, structure, breadth, and intent.
SPEAKER_00How do we arrive at them starting only with theory and information about our surroundings? Activists seek social change against forces and actors who work to preserve existing core characteristics. As a result, activists need strategies that account not only for complex circumstances and many means of acting, but also for opponents with opposed aims. This may lead social activists to consider the general problem of quote winning via developing effective quote competitive strategies.
SPEAKER_00There is both an advantage and a price for thinking about revolutionizing society in this way. We'll consider useful lessons first. Consider tic tac toe. Each player in turn marks an X or an O in any of nine boxes arrayed in a three by three square. The first to get three marks in a straight line wins. In any turn, you have a variety of precisely indicated choices. The first time you go, there are nine, then seven, and so on.
SPEAKER_00The initial conditions are simple two players, one using X's and the other O's, and an empty nine by nine array. At each move we reach a new state of the game marked by the presence of another X or O in the array. Any good player follows a strategy that includes a step by step description of everything that should be done no matter what specific state the game enters. Indeed, it is because every encounterable state of the game can be analyzed that the situation is simple.
SPEAKER_00Now consider chess. Each player has a set of sixteen pieces of six different types eight of one type, the pawns, two of three types, the bishop's knights and rooks, and a king and queen. The players take turns moving according to unchanging rules on an eight by eight array of sixty four squares. Winning can only occur by capturing the opponent's king, though draws can occur in various ways. Compared to tic tac toe, the initial conditions and rules of chess have been significantly enriched.
SPEAKER_00Now sixteen places are placed on a much larger board and have far more complex ways of interrelating. Unlike for tic-tac toe, and despite libraries of strategic volumes, no chess player, until AI arrived, is able to never lose, much less always win. In chess, there are so many possible paths for the struggle to follow that it is impossible to enumerate what to do in every conceivable situation.
SPEAKER_00We can describe various types of opening or end game or special situations where the king is in a certain particular position and we can present various patterns of moves for dealing with each, the tactics of chess. Moreover, at any time during a game, we can plan to accomplish some strategic aim by stringing together a few tactical forays to hopefully attain a new state of the game more favorable to our intentions. We might try to improve our pawn position, for example, or to open files for our rooks, or to trade the opponent's good mobile bishop for our own hemmed in knight.
SPEAKER_00But we cannot confidently pre plan the whole trajectory of a game. Over the board, one is always looking for a path toward an improved position. Seeing a possibility of gain, one tries to envision a sequence of tactical maneuvers to accomplish that gain a step at a time. In turn, a sequence of gains accomplished by such plans will hopefully yield a position from which one can pursue a final victory. We can make chess even more complicated by imagining a multi-game match between two opponents in which the first combatant to win more games is Victor.
SPEAKER_00Now, many additional factors having to do not only with board positions, but with psychological dynamics of momentum, exhaustion, emotions, and the spirit of the opponent and skill of his or her advisors affect one's calculations. The state of the game at any time includes the current score I have won three, my opponent two, and there have been six draws, as well as the changing moods of the players, their changing attention span, attitudes toward one another, and health.
SPEAKER_00Should I work hard to salvage a difficult position to gain a draw? Or should I conserve strength for the next game? Should I try for a problematic win that I may lose? Or should I settle for a draw and anticipate that my opponent will grow weaker in succeeding games? Can I mix up my opening tactical choices to put my opponent off guard many games from now? In other words, in addition to the playing rules, now the complexities of an opponent's long term mood, strengths, and weaknesses bear on the match.
SPEAKER_00With this enrichment, the analogy to the complexity of social strategizing becomes stronger, though far from exact. If we now switch our attention to basketball and put ourselves in the position of a coach, the situation becomes still more complex. As for chess, any one basketball game has far too many possible trajectories to chart them all in advance. Now, however, there is the added problem that an effort to enact a certain tactic, for example, slowing the pace of the game by employing a certain defensive set might not come off.
SPEAKER_00Your players might fumble their assignments. Unlike a chess knight, which will never fail to go where its coach tells it to, now it isn't only the coach who can tire, but also the players. Nothing in a basketball game is certain because the players are now human and the playing board is social. Strategies become exceptionally complex, requiring attention to changing states of the strengths and weaknesses of one's own team and each of its members, of the opponent's team and each of its members.
SPEAKER_00The clock, the changing score, the score in games if it is a series, momentum, bench strength, how players should be rotated and matched up with opponents, and even how hometown and opposing fans will react to the effect and the effect their enthusiasm will have on play. There can be tactical alignments, defensive and offensive strategies, and well planned programs for special purpose of the game. Even the dynamics of transportation between cities, the treatment of player ailments, and the effect of the moods and skills of the referees can be pivotal.
SPEAKER_00As a last leap, now imagine coaching a super basketball team with millions of participants, playing rules that can constantly alter, multiple goals that are themselves flexible, opponents who can become allies, and vice versa, referees who are often members of competing teams, fans and players who can join or leave the action at will, and thousands of playing fields with complex rules for how results on each affect action on others.
SPEAKER_00This approaches the complexity of trying to be strategic about attaining specific social changes in the real world. From the exact science of tic-tac-toe to the complex analytics of chess, to the immense difficulty of the human equations of super basketball, we come to the Herculean complications of historical struggle. At best, we can make probable assessments. The initial conditions themselves are more complex than the whole of any other type of game.
SPEAKER_00The changing states of social struggle involve endless permutations of multiply entwined factors. The array of possible tactical choices stretches without limit, so that understanding even just the major effects of each possible choice on different possible states of the game is quite difficult. Often even agreeing on what a victory is can be a matter of great debate. The link between theory and strategy is complex indeed.
SPEAKER_00Yet the art of creating strategies for social change will be conducted with more or less intelligence depending on whether or not one has an effective means to think about relevant particulars and their interrelations. We can play a move at a time, ignorantly, or we can We can play with a plan conceived in light of the best analyses we can render. Our strategic artistry can be informed and it had better be if we are to succeed.
SPEAKER_00Understanding the importance of developing program and strategy, learning to account for complex circumstances and opposing forces, and becoming facile at combining tactics into programs consistent with overarching strategic aims are all positive lessons we can take from our quote gaming analogy. But there is a downside of this analogy that we have to be aware of as well. Conceptualizing strategy in terms of winning and losing, as in chess, basketball, war, etc, tends to harmonize with macho authoritarian, instrumentalist, and reductionist approaches common to oppressive norms in our societies.
SPEAKER_00By promoting this theme, we run the risk of reproducing the very psychological and behavioral traits that we are, in fact, trying to undo. The solution cannot be, as some suggest, to deny that we have hostile differences with people who oppose change or who minimize the degree of conflict necessary to attain a better world. But a self-conscious approach that recognizes that attaining a new future involves ways of thinking and acting that won't be valued within the new future so attained is salutory.
SPEAKER_00It can help us guard against problems that arise from incorporating our opponent, or at least the psychology of our opponent within ourselves. But there is also a more positive step we can take. It is important to learn the lessons of strategy to participate equally and effectively in defining the direction of our movements. But having become proficient strategists, we need no longer use only competitive analogies. We can, for example, begin to think in terms of quote building a new future in a complex context where sometimes there are shortages of means, where project participants don't always get along, where there are factors that oppose our progress, and so on.
SPEAKER_00Instead of quote competition, which serve to graphically reveal many skills, quote creation can become our central metaphor. The trick is to attain this more positive thematic mindset while retaining the skills of strategic thinking and the abstract methods needed to develop good strategies. In this way, we can preserve the positive lessons to be had from thinking carefully about competitive strategies while we jettison the elements of their personality that contradict our broader values.
SPEAKER_00To become strategic about social change, we must envision a trajectory of change from what exists to what is desired and develop a flexible agenda of tactical and programmatic steps that seem likely to help propel history down that particular path. Furthermore, we must update our strategies regularly in light of changing states of the struggle and new lessons learned about tactics, the board, the players, and the goal. Activists must one identify potential allies and identify obstacles which will hinder progress toward humanist goals.
SPEAKER_00Two, analyze available forms of organization and tactical options in light of effects in different circumstances. Three, continually update evaluative surveys of their own of our own and our opponents' strengths and weaknesses. four, envision a sequence of general steps from the present through a variety of intermediate states to a final goal, and describe how tactics and programs can help propel desired changes at each stage.
SPEAKER_00The image of society as is and as desired comes from theory, and so too does the analysis of likely effects of tactics that can be employed in organizational forms that can be used in different contexts. And to be sure, different theories yield different bases for further strategic thought. Variables considered, tactics used, and plans unfolded depends tremendously on the type of conceptual framework brought to the problem of understanding and positing intermediate goals.
SPEAKER_00The power of having even a simple broad strategy as compared to functioning step by step, guided only by immediate reactions can't possibly be overemphasized. Yet nothing in this says that one's style has to be stark, joyless, and automated. The US Marines needn't be our model, and can't be if we want to retain the integrity of our values and maintain sight of our goals. The mindless solidarity of thousands of hands and feet moving in unison to a drill master's chance would subvert the kind of harmony we seek.
SPEAKER_00Having the discipline to create and implement strategies doesn't preclude trying to incorporate joy, sharing, solidarity, and even playing directly into the process of creating a new society. Quite the contrary, given the kinds of personalities we need to foster, if we are to be able to design to define and enjoy these new societies, these quote tactics will have to be part of our effort. Perhaps for some, the analogy to building a complex structure in harsh circumstances as a team and with camaraderie and aesthetic balance can dispel the aura of militarism that being strategic and trying to win tend to raise.
SPEAKER_00Or for others, maybe highly planned out, clever teamwork, such as was exemplified in the movie The Sting, can provide an alternative model. But whatever one's taste, the need to be strategic and to simultaneously retain and even expand our humanity is paramount. The steps of developing a specifically humanist strategic orientation are considerably more complex than those a Marxist, anarchist, feminist, or nationalist typically employs.
SPEAKER_00For the humanist must deal with four spheres not one, and not only must a path be envisioned from contemporary to future relations in each sphere, but the methods of pursuing liberation in each must be harmonized so they reinforce one another. On the one hand, the primary goal and struggle related to each sphere is overcoming the basic defining causes of that sphere's own centrally oppressive forms and developing alternative humanist structures in their place.
SPEAKER_00In the economy, we want to replace capitalist forms with socialist ones. In community relations, we want to place racism and other oppressions with intercommunalism. In addition, however, humanists focusing their work in a particular sphere must also overcome oppressive manifestations that pervert that sphere from without, including the sphere's own tendencies to reproduce the domination characteristics of other spheres, and vice versa.
SPEAKER_00We cannot have strategies regarding community that contradict strategies regarding kinship, which in turn contradict those relating to the economy or the state. We cannot aim to overcome the roots of racism in community interfaces while we ignore factors capable of reproducing sexism that emanate from the economy, kinship, or state spheres. Partial struggles must combine into a comprehensive strategy to transform all society.
SPEAKER_00So a humanist activist operating principally in the economy must assess the different kinds of economics related consciousnesses of participants depending on their class and also their community gender and state related affiliations? What kinds of consciousness tend to reproduce oppressive economic relations? What kinds tend to disrupt economic norms and engender humanist alternatives? What forms of activity and modes of organization will impede the former and propel the latter?
SPEAKER_00What types of demands, if one, will yield new states of the workplace, consumer, and allocation struggle conducive to winning still further victories because seekers of change will be stronger owing to better knowledge, clearer commitments, or possession of better organizational vehicles or material means with which to win further gains. Having developed answers to these questions, activists can then envision a trajectory of demands, means of struggle, and organizational forms that would lead toward, for example, worker self management through council control over workplaces, consumer councils governing consumption choices, especially for collective goods, and participatory planning for allocation.
SPEAKER_00But in addition, activists will also have to determine the likely effects of choices made within economic struggle on struggles in other spheres and mediate their choices to accord with the goal of moving forward on all fronts, not just one. Similarly, regarding community, kinship or the state, given the goal of intercommunalism and end to patriarchy, or establishing participatory democracy, activists must ask what kinds of organizing will promote consciousness and commitments and alignments able to foster their immediate goals.
SPEAKER_00For example, what kinds of organizing and what demands, if one, will strengthen community, gender, or political identification, yet simultaneously diminish the forces of racism, sexism, or authoritarianism. The humanist activist thus has to envision a scenario of unfolding events which progressively increases the numbers of people who wish to transform society and their access to means for doing so, along all four axes at once, concentrated efforts to win reforms, such as wage increases, improved daycare, affirmative action, shop floor council control over health and safety, community based economic development, rent control, gay rights legislation, voter registration, and child rearing leaves for men as well as women must be formulated to enhance the consciousness of potential change agents, weaken opponents of change, and strengthen the position from which movements will confront status quo forces in the future.
SPEAKER_00Similarly, forms of organization and methods of struggle, autonomous community movements, electoral parties and campaigns, projects around single issues like freezing nuclear weapons or to create battered women's shoulders, and abortion clinics, organize affinity groups, or use petitions, teach-ins, sit-ins, or other forms of civil disobedience must all be formulated and reformulated to strengthen the means activists have to introduce forward looking reforms and to clarify and enhance their long range programs, maximize liberatory consciousness, open up possibilities for those who are not yet working for change, and negate oppressive forms tied to old ways of being both in the movement and outside it.
SPEAKER_00I interject. Most activists I think will say okay, sure, but the hard part is to actually keep it in mind and not forget that each step matters. The chapter continues to outline the main contours of a humanist strategy, we need to address each of the four spheres in turn, and then discuss the ways that movements and programs relevant to each can combine to form a comprehensive strategic approach. The defining mode of domination in the community sphere in the US is racism.
SPEAKER_00The defining humanist goal is intercommunalism, which includes preserving and enriching diverse communities, guaranteeing intercommunity rights, and fostering learning between communities, the potential creators of liberatory change regarding community relations, to include everyone repressed by racism, ethnocentrism, and the denial of spirituality, but principally those communities who are the direct targets of racist domination, blacks, Latinos, Indians, Asians, etc.
SPEAKER_00Whites who transcend their cultures to develop hatred for racism and a love for cultural diversity will be strong supporters of intercommunalism. Whites who prefer to defend their community advantages will be opponents. Obstacles to creating intercommunalism include the racism and ethnocentrism of currently dominant communities, internalized feelings of inferiority and intercommunity hostility of many currently dominated communities, and the pervasive biases of not only community and cultural, but also of kinship, economic and state institutions all in favor of exacerbating community oppressions.
SPEAKER_00One facet of community strategy must be the formation of autonomous community movements organized to advance the dignity of their respective cultures and also to refine their cultures by rejecting oppressive, sexist, authoritarian, and classist elements they may contain. This will involve programs to diminish and finally remove racist structures in society, to challenge and finally undo racism reproducing attitudes in oppressor and oppressed communities, and to develop procedures to ensure the perpetuation and enrichment of diverse cultures in ways promoting humanist and not racist, sexist, classist, or authoritarian values.
SPEAKER_00The Black Power movements of the sixties were archetypes that can teach us much, though by humanist standards they also had faults. They rightly sought to understand, respect, and elevate community cultural forms, and at their best to refine community cultures to overcome at least some internal oppressive weaknesses. They did little, however, to increase modes of intercommunity discourse and learning. In the future, at the same time as communities reform and strengthen inwardly via techniques similar to those used by predecessor Black Power movements, they must also pursue programs that will build positive relations between communities.
SPEAKER_00Autonomous community movements formed to help communities develop their own cultures, visions, and programs in relative freedom from outside forces must additionally diminish hostilities between communities instead of exacerbating them. It will not be argued that the responsibility for promoting good intercommunity relations lies only with racist communities who usually impede such relations. For though the justice of such a view is obvious, the strategic logic is not.
SPEAKER_00Just as culture will be celebrated internally, it will also be respectfully urged outwards toward other communities, and in particular, from organized movements of oppressor communities toward one another and also toward the white oppressor community beyond. Communities will make overtures to learn from others and not to denigrate them. Racism will be criticized and attacked, but not communities themselves. In this, as in all things, humanist activists will want to progress toward humanist aims, not simply to be quote right or to exact a quote justified retribution that leads nowhere.
SPEAKER_00To develop a community focused strategy, we will have to develop a rich understanding of the kinds of consciousness that tend to reproduce racist intercommunity relations in both their oppressor and oppressed forms. Then we will need to assess how different ways of expressing demands and insights, speaking, writing, organizing, and structuring our movements affect these forms of consciousness in different situations and for different constituencies. In light of this, we can assess tactics for how movements can improve the balance of forces favoring intercommunalism as compared to those favoring the maintenance of racism, ethnocentrism, religious persecution, and cultural denial.
SPEAKER_00All sorts of tactics and programs, including revitalization of traditional cultural practices, demands for genuine affirmative action, enhancement and enforcement of civil rights legislation, formation of community groups and caucuses inside organizations, demands for media access, movements against police brutality, institutionalization of black studies and other community studies programs, demands for media access by oppressed communities, marchings, teachings, civil disobedience, and proposals for intercommunity celebrations and meetings to share cultural traditions will be combined into agendas of change aiming to create states of struggle closer to anti racist, pro-intercommunalist possibilities.
SPEAKER_00It will not be the case, as it always has in the past, that the onus for quote smooth communication between different communities will rest solely on those who are oppressed. There will be efforts by black Latino and other pressed oppressed communities to communicate in ways that whites can better perceive. But the more urgent priority will be the reverse, an effort by oppressing communities to learn enough about other cultures to be able to understand their modes of expression, or at least to know when they are not understanding and how to ask for clarification without leaping to defensive conclusions.
SPEAKER_00The aim will be a steady strengthening of autonomous community movements tied to one another by steadily maturing networks of intercommunity communication and respectful sharing of one another's cultures. Milestones along the way to intercommunalism may include creating specific community movements, winning community control over certain media resources, elaborating ties between different community movements, enforcing informative affirmative action legislation, elaborating forms of cultural interchange and celebration between and among different communities, and creating a larger intercommunal rainbow coalition.
SPEAKER_00One additional critical point is that beyond working to ensure that community sphere programs and organizational forms impede racism and promote intercommunalism, it will also be critical to ensure that minimally they do nothing to reproduce sexism, classism, and authoritarianism, and maximally that they help counter those other forms of oppression. Community movements cannot be organized around authoritarian hierarchies, in ways elevating members of dominant classes to community leadership, or in ways promoting sexist patterns of male dominance or female submission or homophobia in the movement, without sacrificing both humanist extra community and community aims as well.
SPEAKER_00But to attain these ends, activists with a community priority will also have to have a holist orientation and allegiance. We will discuss the organizational means to promote this integration of movements after addressing all four focuses themselves. The aim of kinship strategy is to overcome sexism in all its forms throughout society and to promote an alternative feminist vision of gender relations, sexuality, and child rearing as a part of the encompassing project of creating a humanist society in all spheres of social life.
SPEAKER_00Accomplishing these ends will certainly involve building an autonomous women's movement, gay and lesbian movements, and young people's and older people's movements. In turn, each of these will struggle against sexism, homophobia, and ageism, and for an alternative feminist vision of kinship relations. Each will function in part autonomously from other social actors to escape the influence of oppressive behaviors common to men, heterosexuals, and adults, and to freely discover their own identities and liberating alternatives to domination relations.
SPEAKER_00Moreover, as each of these movements fights against specifically kinship-centered oppressions, each will also struggle to undermine the means by which kinship relations reproduce other forms of social domination, and vice versa. Will include demands for reforms like the Equal Rights Amendment, affirmative action, legislation protecting children, the elderly, and freedom of sexual preference, and reproductive rights, as well as efforts to confront and overcome male sexist behavior and existing sexist structural relations in primary living groups and throughout society.
SPEAKER_00But additionally, positive programs elaborating new conceptions of gender roles, new definitions of sexuality, and new ideas regarding how people can conduct the functions of primary living groups, nurturance, child rearing, and the sharing of love and affection, and preparation for death will also be proposed. Demands for access to media and educational institutions to criticize old forms and to project new visions will be important, as will efforts to oppose the crimes of rape, battering, child molesting, gay bashing, and other sexist physical abuse.
SPEAKER_00In general, movements focused primarily around overcoming patriarchy and fostering positive feminist alternatives will also have to deal with overcoming classist, racist, and authoritarian forms that exist within kinship institutions. Moreover, as kinship-centered movements elaborate demands and propose strategies for moving the state of the kinship struggle closer to humanist ends, they will have to recognize that women, old, and young people all come from different classes and communities, and that even their and that even their kinship concerns must be addressed differently.
SPEAKER_00The women's and gay liberation movements of the late sixties and seventies offer a clear image of many of the facets of behavior that will be combined in humanist feminist movements of the future. The major change will be a growing recognition of the connections between kinship focused work and work in other spheres, and thus a growing theoretical and organizational sensitivity to the need for kinship focused organizing to also address issues of race, class, and authority in ways respecting the independent character of their causes in other spheres and the importance of the effects on kinship relations themselves.
SPEAKER_00Unlike some gender focused movements of the past, however, humanist feminist movements certainly won't celebrate biological differences between genders or people with different sexual preferences, nor work to advance primarily white middle class women. As with the community strategic orientation discussed earlier, the target will be sexism, homophobia, and ageism, much of male behavior and ideology, heterosexual behavior and ideology, and parental and elders' behavior and ideology, but not all men heterosexuals, parents, and adults.
SPEAKER_00Again, creating a better society, not the desire to be right or to exact retribution will be the watchword of strategic planning. A kinship centered strategy will involve combining a host of different kinds of programs related to strengthening the self-images of women, gay men and lesbians, and countering sexism, homophobia, and ageism among men, heterosexuals and adults. Along the way, demands will be adopted, tactics employed, and means of organizing and of organization chosen on grounds of their strengthening feminist consciousness and style, countering opponents of kinship change, and opposing racism, classism, and authoritarianism.
SPEAKER_00Some milestones along the way toward creating liberatory kinship relations may include, for example, the elaboration of self-conscious, humanist feminist women's young people's gay and elderly people's movements and their unification into a grand anti patriarchal coalition. The parallel development of men's groups for fighting sexism and promoting male participation in mothering, the establishment of women's centers, rape centers, sex clinics, and sex education centers for children, the winning of equal rights amendment like legislation and of workplace demands concerned with accommodating women and men with children, and winning of comprehensive affirmative action programs.
SPEAKER_00An additional critical point is that beyond working to ensure that kinship sphere programs and organizational forms impede sexism and promote feminism, it will also be critical to ensure that minimally they do nothing to reproduce racism, sexism, authoritarianism, and that maximally they help counter these other forms of oppression. Kinship movements cannot be organized around authoritarian hierarchies or in ways promoting racist patterns in the movement without sacrificing both humanist extra kinship and kinship aims as well.
SPEAKER_00But to attain these ends, activists with a feminist priority will have to also have a wholeist orientation and allegiance. As mentioned earlier, we'll discuss the organizational means to promote this integration after addressing all four focuses themselves. The contemporary U.S. economy is capitalist, and the humanist economic goal is participatory socialism. To accomplish its aims, a new workers' movement will therefore have to find ways to struggle for collective self-management of production and consumption and for participatory allocation that constantly furthers all other dimensions of historic of humanist struggle as well.
SPEAKER_00The movement would draw on the full gamut of consciousness raising techniques, publications, rallies, teach-ins, petitions, boycotts, work stoppages, strikes, marches, sit-ins, and civil disobedience, all used in subtle combinations to strengthen working class solidarity and win reforms that improve the position from which workers are able to seek further gains in the future. Immediate focuses of economic activist attention will certainly include wages, rents, and prices, but also quality of goods, allocation of resources and monies for investments, levels of employment and inflation, workplace and consumer health and safety, and self-determination of job definitions for all workers.
SPEAKER_00In addition, however, class-focused movements will also have to recognize that workers come from different gender, race, and political backgrounds, so that economic programs, outreach, and workplace organizational forms must take account of these differences and counter not only classism, but also racism, sexism, and authoritarianism. To promote socialist economic attitudes, struggles that increase income will begin to be linked to efforts to demand that owners hold down prices and improve goods and services in the interests of consumers.
SPEAKER_00Struggles for expanded and secure employment will be linked to struggles for guaranteed income, democratic control of social services and investments, and conversion of plants away from military production. Workplace organizing will extend from efforts to improve work conditions and safety standards to struggles over the definition of job complexes, the quality of products, the rate and volume of production, the division of labor by class, race, sex, and age, control over pension funds and employee stock and worker management and ownership.
SPEAKER_00Networks of neighborhood councils will raise demand about local investments and tax, housing and employment patterns, which will connect with worker struggles and vice versa. These sorts of linkages will provide a solid basis for consumer worker community coalitions. The forms workers will use will allow them to communicate their ideas to one another, strengthen their commitments, develop solidarity, and propose and fight for their programs, and will include unions reformed by struggles to make them steadily more democratic, anti sexist and anti racist, and egalitarian workplace and community councils.
SPEAKER_00One important dimension of economic strategizing will be recognizing that being anti capitalist is not enough. A positive stance must be adopted not only for the humanist movement to attract adherents, but also for it to avoid adopting a non socialist approach which can wrongly win workers' allegiances if careful attention isn't paid to coordinator class machinations and how they manifest themselves in economic struggles.
SPEAKER_00All sorts of middle level employees and intermediate strata, and at times even coordinators will be welcome to humanist movements, but it will be critical to ensure that humanist movements and their union and council organizations have working class aims as their constant priorities, even as they also oppose racism, sexism, and authoritarianism. The elitism common to coordinator programs and technocratic visions will have to be identified and combated, just as the exploitation and alienation common to capitalist forms are.
SPEAKER_00One important focus of humanist socialist activism will be the definition of work and of divisions of labor in contemporary society, and the alternative definitions we seek in the future. Humanist economic movements will have to propose and pursue these aims in ways countering the current information and skill monopolies of coordinator and middle strata workers, even as humanists also seek to attract people in these positions into opposition to capitalism and support for socialism.
SPEAKER_00And of course, one additional critical point is that beyond working to ensure that economic programs and organizational forms impede class rule and promote participatory socialism, it will also be critical to ensure that minimally they do nothing to reproduce sexism, racism, and authoritarianism, and maximally that they help counter these other forms of oppression. Economic movements cannot be organized around authoritarian hierarchies in ways elevating members of dominant communities to economic leadership, or in ways promoting sexist patterns of male dominance or female submission or homophobia without sacrificing both humanist extra economic and economic aims as well.
SPEAKER_00To attain these ends, activists with an economic priority will also have to have a holist orientation and allegiance. We will discuss the organizational means to promote the integration, this integration after addressing the last of our four strategic areas. The defining mode of domination in the U.S. political sphere is authoritarianism. A U.S. humanist movement will seek to replace it with participatory democracy. Accomplishing this will require the careful combination of short and long-term programs, progressively increasing people's abilities to develop their own policy attitudes and means for participation in decision making, as well as increasing the range of policy alternatives and promoting power sharing among diverse constituencies.
SPEAKER_00An anti authoritarian, pro-participatory democracy movement will have its own electoral and non-electoral tactics and organizational forms, emphasizing new visions and new means of developing, debating, and implementing policy alternatives, and of struggling to gain adherence. At the same time, however, the efforts of governing focused movements to win reforms of existing state relations and develop ever more widely shared and deeply rooted anti-authoritarian attitudes will occur in the context of parallel efforts to ensure that political forms don't reproduce race, sex, or class hierarchies.
SPEAKER_00Landmarks along the way might include making the judiciary more representative, establishing universal voter registration, guaranteeing public campaign funds, and free media access to all political parties, abolition of the death penalty, overhaul of sentencing procedures, and massive prison reform and alternatives to prison, divorcing military spending from the profit motive and cutting and reprogramming the military budget to serve strictly defensive non interventionist objectives, overhauling the currently racist and restrictive immigration law and respecting sanctuary for political refugees, strengthening freedom of information legislation, decentralizing political political control at all levels, and establishing the principle of power sharing, whereby minority views can also be implemented implemented where possible.
SPEAKER_00And predictably, an additional critical point is that beyond working to ensure that political sphere programs and organizational forms impede authoritarianism and promote participatory democracy, it will also be critical to ensure that minimally they do nothing to reproduce sexism, classism, and racism, and maximally that they help counter these other forms of oppression. Political movements cannot be organized around racist hierarchies, in ways elevating members of dominant classes to political leadership, or in ways promoting sexist patterns of male dominance or female submission or homophobia, without sacrificing both humanist extrapolitical and political aims as well.
SPEAKER_00To attain these ends, activists with a state priority will have to have a holist orientation on allegiances. We'll discuss the various organizational means to promote this integration of movements in the following section. But first, note that in each of the four spheres the same kinds of considerations will guide us as we conceive and later refine strategies. First, we identify constituencies and seek to determine how their views support or oppose progressive change in their sphere and in society as a whole.
SPEAKER_00Second, we assess our means, including tactics, forms of organization, and styles of organizing. Third, we propose programs for organizing advocates of humanist transformation and improving their knowledge, skills, commitment, and numbers, and for winning reforms that will improve their abilities to act in ways leading toward radical change. Along the way, we continually re examine tactics like participating in elections, doing civil disobedience, or struggling to win particular workplace or household demands to see whether pursuing them will lead us into a new situation with a still better balance of forces for further advance.
SPEAKER_00We thus pay special attention to how alternative courses of action may affect the strength of our institutions, the number of people supporting change, the strength of our opponents' institutions, and the social field of action on which we must all operate. Yet as hard as strategizing in any one sphere is, the real problem, as we have repeatedly noted, turns out to be effectively accommodating the strategies in each sphere to one another in ways propelling them all toward shared success.
SPEAKER_00There are good reasons why advocates of strategic agendas who emphasize change in one particular sphere of social life rarely trust one another. History in the US is laced with examples of quote class analysis meaning the analysis of the situation of white working men. Quote gender analysis meaning the analysis of the situation of white middle class women with children and so on. There have been many different struggles for social change in the US, and for the most part, communication between progressive forces at work on these have been sparse and hostile.
SPEAKER_00Many factors have helped cause this lack of solidarity, some of which are obvious, and many of which can be easily extrapolated from earlier discussions and from the dialogues associated with each chapter. Here we would like to discuss possible ways forward. Here we would like to discuss possible ways forward. I interject. So forty years ago, the seven authors wrote saying often quote we will, movements will, etcetera I guess we felt all these strategic steps based on new concepts were in some sense on the agenda.
SPEAKER_00Well, some were, to an extent, but not too many. I can't help but wonder what would have been the consequences if for each year in the past forty these ideas were at the core of movement efforts. At any rate, the chapter continues Movements that are primarily focused on oppressions rooted in different spheres of social life can align with one another for at least four reasons. First, one might feel that members of another movement can be won over if only overtures are made.
SPEAKER_00This is opportunist. Unity in this instance has no purpose other than to siphon off activists from one movement, for example, a community movement, to another, for example, an organized, economically focused Leninist party. Second, movements can feel that alone they cannot succeed, but in coalition their strength will be sufficient to deal with first one movement's concerns, then the others. This is tactical. It involves a borrowing of one another's troops on a 50-50 basis, as when women's movements and black civil rights movements align first on voting rights, then on the ERA, or when disarmament activists help anti nuclear ecologists and vice versa.
SPEAKER_00The problem is, all too often the vice versa never happens, and unity is transitory and shallow in any case. Third, movements can recognize that they have a common enemy, so that by assisting one another's efforts, their own efforts will be aided as well, as when anti-interventionists make overtures to groups fighting racism, or when those opposing chemical warfare try to ally with those opposing toxic waste dumping. This is strategic, and alignment develops on the basis of deep motivational ties, and though this has many virtues, the basis of alignment is usually so immediate that only the most blatant sorts of connections are accounted for.
SPEAKER_00Finally, fourth, movements can align not only because they can benefit from one another's victories since they share a common enemy, but because they recognize that they themselves are essentially different facets of one still larger movement, all of whose parts must relate positively to one another if the whole and any of the parts will succeed, not only in defeating a shared enemy, but in gaining interdependent aims and creating a new liberatory society.
SPEAKER_00This is principled and holist. Historically, these four types of allegiance escalate in power as one moves from the first to the fourth, though the fourth has rarely, if ever, been widely operative in social life. Yet the fourth autonomy within solidarity type of alignment is the most important and also the reason for being of the conceptual approach proposed in this volume. Complementary holist concepts propel, justify, and inform a strategic approach of the fourth type.
SPEAKER_00Monist alternatives promote alliances of types one and two and occasionally allow alliances of type three. The complementary holist humanist strategist must not only develop strategies relevant to each sphere, but also an understanding of how these partial strategies interrelate. We have already suggested that within each sphere there will be autonomous movements, coalitions, specific forms of organization, specific demands, diverse tactical options, complex programs, and strategic agendas.
SPEAKER_00Now we need only add that each perspective will need to be aligned with one another at a higher level. Of course, activists with their own priority focus in each separate struggle will also involve themselves in organizations and events centered in other focuses. Feminists will not only confront primary kinship relations, but also sexism in the economy, community, and state spheres. And they will do this not only from the vantage point of their own kinship focused organizations and movements, but also because they will be members of women's caucuses and plant and able to.
SPEAKER_00Councils, for example, fighting not only for economic games, but also against sexism. And similarly, workers primarily concerned with matters of workplace democracy will also relate to community struggles, not only directly through their means of economic expression, but also since they will be members of communities and community movements themselves. Likewise, blacks organized to promote intercommunalism will fight racism, not only in their cultural work, but also in the kinship sphere, because they will be members of community caucuses in women's, gay, elderly peoples, and youth organizations and coalitions.
SPEAKER_00The idea will be to promote autonomy in the context of solidarity. Movements will retain their integrity and manage their own destinies regarding their priority oppressions. Yet they will also function in the context of one another, crossing lines to battle residues of oppression within the left and also providing aid to one another whenever needed. Within each movement, there will be caucuses to allow members of other movements to readily influence policy to ensure strategic connections.
SPEAKER_00Moreover, the fact that many activists will be members of many movements will create further linkages and lines of communication and shared lessons. Finally, movements with different priority focuses will all be part of larger encompassing forms that will respect their autonomy even as respective strategies and needs are assessed to promote the simultaneous advance of each. The encompassing holistic conceptualization of society and change will support these organizational steps and also evidence the need for people with different personal priorities to learn from one another and support one another for tactical and strategic reasons and to promote collective advance.
SPEAKER_00Moreover, since we all have community economic, political, and kinship lives, even though one or another may affect us more pressingly due to our specific situation or background, we will all begin to have an interest in each facet of struggle and especially in the ways they interconnect due to the ways spheres of social life co-reproduce. The meshing of strategies into encompassing plans for the development of the whole left will occur at every level, in movements, organizations, campaigns, educational activities, outreach through the left media, etc.
SPEAKER_00It is precisely this linking of insights and their connection within holistic perspectives that will become the highest priority of these types of interchange, even while the integrity of each perspective remains an equally first rank concern. This is not the place to discuss the details of organizational forms. For example, the types of blocks that will align specific movements into larger holistic networks, nor for hazarding guesses about timetables of progress.
SPEAKER_00The work of developing a viable strategy remains. Our immediate point is that the complementary holist framework is the only one that can produce flexible analyses capable of meeting the agendas of each autonomous movement and to develop and sustain their unity. It is a place to start as we retain our separate identities yet struggle to attain a new society that is liberating for all. So ended the vision strategy chapter of liberating theory.
SPEAKER_00But on the same topic there follows the associated dialogue. Koho, our complimentary wholest participant, has just finished describing her thoughts on vision and strategy. As the others are busy making notes, gathering their own thoughts together, Sin, our cynical participant, takes the momentary lull as an opportunity to set Koho straight on the question of human nature. Sin, rising to stand near the window. No one regrets more than I having to say these things.
SPEAKER_00My entire life has been wrapped up in social change. For years I've read, written, and organized in the area of international relations. I've seen radicals become fascists. I've seen comrades become apolitical bourgeois intellectuals. I've participated in meetings and events where the internal debates destroyed the spirit of almost all the participants. I appreciate your efforts, Coho, particularly your sketching of such comprehensive guidelines for developing visions of a new society and strategies to pursue.
SPEAKER_00But I had visions once too. So did many others. I believed fervently in the possibility of a liberating society. I fought for it. Now I look at countries I supported, like China, and it just seems hopeless. Koho, but the Chinese never created a humanist society, or even just a socialist economy. Sin, but they tried. Koho, so did the Russians. You don't seem as bothered by their failures. Sin, so I'm a slow learner.
SPEAKER_00Koho, perhaps. Or perhaps you were able to see that the Leninist failures were no more proof of the impossibility of a liberatory society than was the failure to create one in the US after our after our revolution or in France after theirs. Sin, the US Revolution wasn't aimed at creating socialism. Coho, the Russian Revolution wasn't aimed at creating socialist economic relations or humanist relations in all four social spheres.
SPEAKER_00It sought an authoritarian state, a coordinator economy, a homogenized community sphere, and a patriarchal kinship sphere. The leaders, at least, got what they sought. So did the leaders in China. Sin, that's nonsense. Soviet activists believed in a better world as much as we do. They gave their lives trying to win it. Coho, of course, I don't deny the integrity of the activists. They did desire equity, but their leaders actually instituted social forms which had contrary implications.
SPEAKER_00Sin. Maybe there was no alternative. In China the Maoists certainly sought democracy. Koho, perhaps, in the end, but for too many years they used centrist organizations which reproduced domination relations. Their challenges to sexism, state authoritarianism, and class oppression were minimal. Their myopicultural politics corrupted their community life as well as their attempts at democracy. Sin, that's not entirely true.
SPEAKER_00During the years after the revolution, many struggled to understand and create alternatives to coordinated dominance, but they failed. Marlin, our Marxist Leninist participant interrupts. You wear your pessimism like a crown of thorns. Look at what existed in China before their revolution. Starvation, violence, degradation, deprivation. Their achievements were immense, unparalleled in history. Nate, our nationalist participant adds.
SPEAKER_00And what about Cuba? Some of the African nations. There have been profound changes that have improved the quality of life in countries around the world. And in the US too. Koho, in any event, why should the failure of the Chinese and other revolutions to meet goals they never intended to meet, goals that we think they should have met dissuade us from the possibility of a revolution that creates what we want? Sin, in spite of what you say, it still seems that no matter what we do, we will never get what we want.
SPEAKER_00The final outcome is always corrupted. Either human nature ensures that some will rule and others obey, or unknown forces preserve domination even though they let us alter the forms that domination will take. Coho So your hypothesis is that people are innately evil in ways that preclude creating a humane society. Sin it makes sense to me that ex that explanations to our problems may lie with human nature.
SPEAKER_00Nate, is it Darwin's theory that makes you believe that or history? Sin both. Koho, but there is nothing in biological understandings of how evolution contours organisms to suggest that a species would wire in a trait that runs counter to its own perpetuation. People might have capacities for aggression, since these could have been useful during our evolution, but it's hard to see why they would come to innately turn those aggressive tendencies against one another.
SPEAKER_00It's infinitely more likely for evolution to have given us dispositions to seek to live peacefully in search of friendship, solidarity, continuity, assistance, and defense against other species. Greed against other species might make sense, but sociability within a species would be more conducive to genetic success than infighting. Sophie, our socialist feminist participant, reacts, but even Coho talks of the survival of the fittest.
SPEAKER_00Anna, our anarchist participant adds, true, but survival of the fittest doesn't mean everyone kills off everyone else. In fact, it usually ensures that within a species there will be a disposition toward mutual aid. An appeal to evolution doesn't give us evidence for a genetically evil human nature. Sin, then look at the evidence from history. Coho yes, if we assume innately evil people, we can certainly explain Hitler.
SPEAKER_00We can explain exploitation, concentration camps, lynching, slavery, rape, and saturation bombing. But can we explain the good that people do? Sin, circumstances sometimes stifle our antisocial inclinations or even cause our greed to produce sharing. Coho some people do good things because institutions and environments select sociability over innate greed? From what we have said about society's institutions, they would be more likely to exaggerate our dispositions to Nate, Burn, Marlin, Lude, Rad Fem, our radical feminist participant as rape, Anna, our anarchist participant as rule.
SPEAKER_00Koho, I think your innate antisocial genes thesis makes it very difficult, almost impossible to see why there is any good at all in the world. Your view of human nature leads to a world of unrestrained evil. Sin. But if people are instead innately social, inquisitive, and creative, as you hypothesize, then how do you explain exploitation, genocide, race hatred, and imperialism? Coho. That's what theories of histories reveal, by showing that what happens throughout history depends on interrelations between quote innately good people or innately okay people, or innately uh uh diverse people, complex environments and social institutions.
SPEAKER_00Evil is not inevitable in all times and places. It is produced and can be replaced. Sin Suppose I could accept your argument that there is no compelling evidence for believing that human beings are basically so antisocial that a humane society is biologically impossible. It still wouldn't increase my hopes. Dominating ways are so entrenched that every effort to eradicate them only transforms them into new forms. Pluri or pluralist participant commiserates.
SPEAKER_00It's sad, sin that your belief in the inevitability of injustice has become such a bedrock faith, almost part of your personality. Sin perhaps your optimism is just blind faith, and my pessimism is based on reality. Coho no, I think many people are cynical about human nature or social possibilities because a cynical viewpoint serves them well, not because they have lots of good arguments and evidence on their side. Sin but there is historical evidence in favor of the view that we can't create a good society.
SPEAKER_00No one ever has. And now maybe we've been on the wrong road too long to get off. Coho. People said we couldn't fly, but now they take f take it for granted. But you are right that no one can prove we can win a better world short of doing it. But I have good arguments for why it hasn't been done yet that can give us hope. The fact that you don't want to hear them, that you choose a pessimistic option is a rationalization. Sin for what? I'm miserable this way.
SPEAKER_00Koho, people who believe in a better way of life know that the way we live now is criminal. Denial of freedoms, death by starvation and exploitation, denigration of people's capabilities are everywhere. If you see that these outcomes are socially produced, then you understand that every person who dies as a result was effectively murdered. Once you accept the possibility of attaining a humanist alternative, you have to be a terrible hypocrite, coward, or cynic to live passively with the contrast between what is and what could be.
SPEAKER_00Sin. I don't get the point of this. Coho. If you only know enough to think that people are evil, or if you convince yourself of that, no matter the contrary evidence at your disposal, then these daily murders are horrible but inevitable. You have no responsibility, no complicity. Sin. So we should all sing the International and believe in the goodness of human nature triumphing over evil? That's so pathetic. Coho, I'm not suggesting it. It isn't that people should leap to believe in the goodness of human nature.
SPEAKER_00It would be masochistic for people to wallow in guilt over complicity and crimes against humanity unless you felt you could do something about it. If you don't see any way forward, then as a strategy for getting by, it is probably most sensible to interpret the injustices as the flip side of progress and make the best of things. Sophie, I know people who will be moved to tears by the profound humanity of certain characters in novels or movies, or by people in history.
SPEAKER_00Even people they know. Then they'll read about some atrocity and proceed to denigrate all humanity as greedy monsters. Koho, illogical, but not crazy. Sin, but that's not me. I've actively supported movements for social change. I want to act, but I can't anymore. I don't think we can succeed. Koho, but why rationalize this inability by calling it people innately evil or by appealing to inevitability? Sin, you tell me.
SPEAKER_00Coho, well, some people rationalize due to wanting to operate in mainstream society, to make money or whatever, by denying the efficacy of being radical. Ordinarily, the one time leftist turning to journalism or running for office, or otherwise trying to be comfortable in the midst of humanity's crimes will denigrate her or his past as utopian childishness. Trying to make it in society is rationalized as a newfound maturity about what's possible.
SPEAKER_00Sin Once again, that's not me. I have no desire to work in mainstream society to prove that I am a mature person. Plury, but you argue that it proves you are a realistic person. Sin, yes, because it does. Koho, perhaps, but maybe there is something about the tasks required to be effective activists that you don't want to admit are needed or that you don't want to do. Sin, perhaps I don't want to spend my time on earth in a losing battle constantly looking at pain and suffering that I can't put a stop to Koho First, as a feeling person who has had the opportunity to learn what is really going on, can you find sustenance in maintaining injustice and degradation or in looking the other way?
SPEAKER_00Would you have felt better watching the Vietnam War on the six o'clock news? Could you have said to yourself, quote, since I can't know positively that any action I take will literally stop the war, I won't act at all, even though I know how evil it is. Or quote, since evil will always dominate, why bother? There will be another war and another and another, end quote. After all, no group of people in the US had ever previously stopped the government from waging a war it wanted to wage.
SPEAKER_00It seems to me that even if the odds were against stopping the Vietnam War, that it was better to take a shot at it than give up. But second, we did help end the war. You did have an impact, and there is no compelling reason to think we can't have an effect again and again, not only on individual horrible policies, but once the great mass of people are involved, also on their underlying causes. Sin abstractly, I suppose I can agree that maybe the roots of my cynicism lies in rationalization rather than hard evidence.
SPEAKER_00But that still doesn't make me want to rush back to the barricades. In fact, I feel paralyzed into inaction, pained and depressed by both choices. Coho. But opposing oppression doesn't have to mean a lifetime of suffering. How can we persuade others to work for a better world if we live lives of pain and suffering, isolation and boredom? We don't have to ignore culture, music, personal relationships, food, beauty, humor, and sports. Even interesting work.
SPEAKER_00In fact, involvement, community, purpose, and a sense of humor can enhance our abilities immeasurably. Neopop, our new populist participant who feeds who finds sin a lost cause and has had enough, says speaking of abilities, and while I appreciate your efforts to lift sin's spirits, I really do have to get back to my work, and which I am indispensable. Marlin, eager to discuss Koho's presentation on vision and strategy.
SPEAKER_00Speaking of interesting work, your discussion of participatory planning raises many points which I would like to discuss at length. Rad Fem, rustling through papers to find visions chapter. Speaking of personal relationships, your notion of extended families could be enhanced if we Nat waving papers interrupts. Speaking of art, I was impressed by your arguments for diversity, although your hopes for Sophie arranging charts on the floor interrupts.
SPEAKER_00While I would like to consign your notion of fields of force to the dustpin of a Hollywood Star Wars while I would like to consign your notion of fields of force to the dustpin of a Hollywood Star Wars cutting room, I do like this business about co definition and co reproduction. We should apply it even more generally. C our console communist participant, rising and stretching, says I think this economy vision and the concept of equitable job complexes is very good.
SPEAKER_00But how Rad Fem, rereading the kinship vision section, urges on the question of sexuality, you clearly aren't familiar with issues of erotiphia, which Nate, on the edges of his seat, interrupts. When it comes to religion, you have a way to go. Clearly you've never had a religious day in your life. But if we elaborate, Marlin, taking a few volumes out of the bags he happened to bring along, pronounces, mind you, Koho, I don't agree with your methods, but I think I could assist you in enriching your analysis to provide a deeper and more comprehensive vision.
SPEAKER_00Soho, frowning, adds the label complimentary holism, it's all wrong. It's Nate, White, Radfam, Male, Marlon, middle class, anna religious sounding, anna religious sounding, plurry, a mouthful, neopop, inefficient, C C strange, Sophie, dumb. Comments are beginning to fly fast and furiously as the group gets involved in the vision and strategy sections. Then a familiar voice from the corner quiets them down.
SPEAKER_00Sin tentatively, still holding on to the cloak of cynicism that has become a security blanket. Excuse me, I just wanted to say, without being too negative, that this vision chapter is somewhat naive and utopian. While I had been planning to leave for an appointment, I could stay a few minutes more to help provide a more realistic look at the possibility. Anna? Minutes? This is going to take longer than that. I have quite a bit to contribute to Koho's limited vision around hierarchies and decentralizing political forms.
SPEAKER_00forms, which she obviously has a little experience in. Sin on the verge of sliding back into the depths. I guess I could stay another hour. Sophie, only beginning her critique. Hours? We're talking about days. Nate weeks. Radfam months. Sin aghast months? Plury, a year maybe, Nate, in fact we need another book. This one is too long already. Sin getting frantic another book? Sophie, as a matter of fact, I have a few friends who would enjoy participating in further discussions of vision and particularly strategy, and who could provide insights into the kinship arrangements.
SPEAKER_00Rad Fenn, since I am outnumbered around questions of sexuality, I know some people who could enlighten the discussion around sin worried. More people Nate, exactly my thoughts with regard to racism and the discussion of community. Anna, my thinking also around hierarchies. I know some people who could really assist in the sin fighting off a returning cynicism. More people? Are you kidding? I can see it now. A hundred people in this room all arguing.
SPEAKER_00Sophie not a hundred, more like twenty five. Marlin, eager to get on with it. Now that we've agreed that we need more people and another book and let me say I can contribute in that department, I want to say a few words, Coho, and our remaining time together about the reductive nature of your strategy discussion where you equate strategies for economic revol where you equate where you equate strategies for economic revolution with a game of tic tac toe C C well said, Marlin, I really must object to the notion of strategizing a working class revolution around a chessboard.
SPEAKER_00Pluri and basketball? Am I supposed to organize my people into sports leagues and then explain how each offensive play is really a plan for revolution? It's so Anna interrupts, opportunist, not to mention the competitive win lose mentality it suggests. I really want to discuss this entire notion of strategy as you've presented it, Coho Koho, who couldn't be happier glad to, Anna. Clearly this is a stumbling block for many of you. You are equating analogies with actual practice, since I think strategy is extremely important and I am hoping we can refine it in the next book you have been talking about.
SPEAKER_00But I do think that we need to understand what I'm getting at in my sports games analogies, if I may demonstrate Sin, demonstrate? Surely you don't expect us to play Koho, drawing on a large pad of paper. Now as I said in my presentation, there are simple strategies draws tic tac toe, and there are complex strategies Doris draws basketball playboard. Now let's say that Nate, Radfem and Sosi are the offense and Plury, Neopop and Morlin are the defense.
SPEAKER_00The group gathers round clearing chairs and making notes on the backs of pages. Koho in a basketball strategy we are working with Nate, yes, we got that part Rad Fem. Tie in the analogy with some actual political strategies, Koho Anna, and let's have examples Sin still in the corner chair, speaking without convection conviction almost as a question This isn't gonna work. Koho, oh but it is We continue on with the discussion and we discuss many more as our arguments develop and Koho's strategy board becomes increasingly complex.
SPEAKER_00So ended our last excerpt from the book Liberating Theory I have to say I hope you enjoyed hearing it as much as I enjoyed reading forty years after helping to write it. On the one hand I found the dialogues provocative and I admit in the case of the last one quite humorous. I had to edit the recordering numerous times to remove my laughter lest it get in the way. That may be more true for me than others because I recognized Lydia's deft and caring editorial hand all over the exchanges.
SPEAKER_00But humor aside, I read this, I guess, the way you all will if you read the articles on Zenet. I was trying to get the points but also to simultaneously consider whether recent decades bear them out or disprove them. I feel it has been the former about ten years ago I began work on a book now titled The Wind Cries Freedom. It has eighteen future revolutionary activists and one interviewer who convey their experiences in the next American revolution.
SPEAKER_00So the book is me sort of conveying almost like channeling that content so folks can read it. I mention this here because as I read chapters from Liberating Theory for episodes these past few weeks, I thought could those future revolutionaries have been acting on shared vision and strategy that emerged from refinements and extensions of liberating theory. In fact, when the book was written ten years ago and then rewritten intermittently for the past two years, I hadn't looked back at the joint work by myself, Leslie Kagan, Noam Chomsky, Robin Hinnell, Mel King, Holly Sklar, and Lydia Sargent.
SPEAKER_00And yet to my eyes the lessons from the future revolutionaries while going further and including much more personal content seemed to me rather natural extensions, sometimes improvements, but never denials of the earlier views. That has been a bit eye opening. At any rate all that said, this is Michael Albert signing off until next time for Revolution Z.
Episode 415 of RevolutionZ has as its guest Paul Loeb who joins us after decades of work on citizen responsibility, civic engagement, and the hard reality of sustaining social movements in challenging times. An election...
Episode 414 of RevolutionZ considers tasks ahead in light of the MIdterm results. The scariest moment in politics may be when authoritarians win. but a not too distant second may be when they lose and we all exhale. Do...
Episode 413 of RevolutionZ asks what comes after our eruptions? What happens when the cameras leave, when the easy unity ages even just a little bit, and when power bets we will wear out and go home? What can we do to...
Episode 412 offers Part Two of Talking with Chat GPT wherein the AI effusively answers questions about itself, the AI industry and its CEOs, users, prospects and dangers, and about its and our futures. What can/will AI...
Episode 411 of RevolutionZ has a guest with initials instead of a name: GPT (5.6). The episode asks GPT questions many people quietly wonder about but rarely hear answered in its "voice." We start with deceptively...