Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

RevolutionZ

RevolutionZ artwork

Ep 406 Liberating Theory Economics/Class

Sep 13, 20261 hr 15 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Episode 406 of RevolutionZ continues excerpting the seven author book, Liberating Theory, to take up the task of arriving at usefull economic concepts for winning fundamental social change. Markets set prices but also train our desires, narrow what we think is “normal,” and quietly shape the people we become at work and at home. From there the chapter from *Liberating Theory* goes presents a then new story about economics, class, and why I still think it matters forty years later. It starts with a simple but disruptive claim: every economic act consumes inputs and produces outputs, and those inputs and outputs include human beings. Jobs can produce exhaustion, passivity, confidence, resentment, solidarity, or dependence. Consumption can produce status shifts, isolation, or connections. This all affects thoughts and inclinations so any serious political economy has to include qualitative outcomes like skills, consciousness, and social relations, not only GDP-style totals. From there Liberating Theory builds a sharper class analysis of capitalism that goes beyond workers and owners. Alongside capitalists and the working class, we name a coordinator class of empowered managers, technocrats, and professionals who hold decision-making power through monopolies of information and organizational knowledge. We also dig into the “middle strata” tensions that shape organizing, then connect economic outcomes to race and gender dynamics rooted in patriarchy and white supremacy. The closing dialogue takes on Marxist economics, central planning, and the risk that a “socialist” transition can still produce a new ruling class. Forty years ago, twenty years on from the New Left of the Sixties the seen authors of Liberating Theory sought new ideas for new labor organizing, class politics, and conceiving and winning new institutions for real self-management. Did they have good reason? Did they make progress? Can what they thought be of use now, fighting Trump, fighting fascism, and seeking a new economy? I think so, but it is for you to decide. I hope you will share this episode with a friend who argues about class and leave a comment with the biggest questions you have about its merits or debits. Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello, my name is Michael Albert, and I'm the host of the podcast that's titled Revolution Z. This is our 406th consecutive episode. It's titled Liberating Theory Economicslash Class. It continues a sequence taken from a book, Liberating Theory, that was published forty years ago. Its seven co-authors felt that a successful left in the US needed what some of us called a shared conceptual toolbox for conceiving, judging, and enacting strategy and vision suitable to win fundamental change in our future.

SPEAKER_00We sought to combine insights of various movements and perspectives in a useful way. The prior two episodes addressed community race and kinship gender, and this episode excerpts chapter four which addresses economics slash class. It began like this. To avoid incorporating biases that would prove detrimental to a complementary holist approach, that was the name we gave to the overall perspective, special care must be taken in modifying existing radical economic theory.

SPEAKER_00We thus begin our analysis forty years ago, by presenting seven major adaptations to familiar then familiar Marxist ideas. Economics certainly involves the production, consumption, and allocation of material objects, and activists need to understand how the transformation of raw materials into quote intermediate and quote final goods and the distribution of those goods affect material outcomes.

SPEAKER_00But economics also affects people as they engage in different kinds of economic activities. Our personalities, skills, consciousnesses, and relations with others form and transform as we repeatedly engage in economic activities. This too should be a focus of attention. I interject, and I will occasionally do that in the course of this episode. You can think of it this way.

SPEAKER_00Raw materials go into factories, are involved in the interactions in the factories, and come out the other side, albeit incorporated into final products. People go into factories, work, engage, are engaged in the activities that go on, and come out the other side as what? Changed people. The chapter continues. Changing a person's role in the economy, from capitalist to worker, for example, will change many of the social pressures and benefits that mold his or her life.

SPEAKER_00Change the nature of the economic system as a whole, from feudal to capitalist, for example, and you will change the pattern of roles and economic circumstances that face everyone. Economic activity therefore affects the qualitative human dimensions as well as the quantitative material dimensions of life. It affects social relations and people as well as things. A first priority in a complementary holist approach to economics has to be to include personality, skill, knowledge, consciousness, and different kinds of qualitative social relationships as central economic concepts.

SPEAKER_00One way of thinking about how economic activity transforms objects, people, and the relations between people is to think of that activity as consuming various inputs and producing a variety of outputs. When we focus on the outputs, we call the activity production, and when we concentrate on the inputs, we call the activity consumption. In automobile production, for instance, we are concerned with the car as product.

SPEAKER_00But when a person consumes a car, we look at the same commodity not as the end of production activity, but as the means of a kind of consumption we call travel. In other words, quote production and quote consumption are just two different views of any economic activity, since all economic activity both quote consumes inputs and quote produces outputs. Even when we travel, for example, we certainly consume fuel, the labors of airplane pilots, etc, and also produce the transport of ourselves to new locales, our changed states of mind, exhaust, and so on.

SPEAKER_00But to take the automobile example further, in automobile production, steel and rubber and human energy skills and personality traits are all consumed as inputs, while automobiles, pollution, and exhausted workers, with certain traits either reinforced or transformed, are produced as outputs. Likewise, in automobile consumption, the new car is consumed as an input, and a used car is produced as an output.

SPEAKER_00But the user's status in his or her neighbor's eyes, a social relationship is also enhanced or diminished depending on the kind of car and neighbors. The point is that in both what we call production and consumption, material, human and social inputs are consumed and material human and social outputs are produced. For activists it is particularly critical that we incorporate in our conceptual framework means to highlight the human and social inputs and outputs of both production and consumption activity, rather than only the material stuff that goes in and comes out.

SPEAKER_00Because economic institutions define what kinds of economic activity will and will not take place, and because the economic activity we engage in affects our personality, skills, and consciousness, economic institutions profoundly affect society's social and psychological patterns as well as its material possibilities. Economic institutions also profoundly affect the needs or preferences people will develop and the productive skills they will learn.

SPEAKER_00A useful set of economic concepts must therefore direct us to ask How does market exchange influence consumer personalities and preferences? How do markets influence the structure of workplaces? And vice versa. How would central planning change consumers or workers' roles? And what are the human effects and social relations within each workplace? A useful conceptualization must not presuppose the inevitability or neutrality of any particular set of economic institutions, but must instead explore the particular human developmental effects of every set of economic institutions it examines.

SPEAKER_00All but the most lackluster economies can generate more material outputs than necessary to one, replace the produced material inputs used, and two, house, feed and clothe those engaged in economic activity. Though the measurement of this quote material surplus or quote net product is inevitably somewhat imprecise, it is an important concept nonetheless, and a useful economic theory should identify all factors that influence the size and distribution of this net product among different classes and sectors within classes.

SPEAKER_00We therefore need economic variables sensitive to how and why capitalists, professionals, managers and workers receive different incomes, why workers earn different wages depending on their occupation, union status, race, skills, and sex, and why capitalists receive different profits depending on the kinds of competition they face and the character of their workforce. It will not do to employ concepts that minimize these differences as if they have only insignificant effects.

SPEAKER_00Classes are groups of people who share sufficiently similar economic circumstances to have common interests and the potential to recognize and act on those common interests as collective agents. Many factors can help make a group a class, including sharing the same relationship of ownership or non ownership to different types of property, or holding different positions in hierarchies of power. But we must additionally highlight that qualitative factors can also help define classes whenever people do similar enough work with similar enough relations to others that they will evolve shared perspectives and desires.

SPEAKER_00It isn't simply ownership or even power or any other single factor that creates a class, but a combination of factors that causes similarities in worldview, interests, etc. We can't say a priori what all the relevant factors will be for all types of economy. We must investigate. Capitalists, for example, are a class not only because they own means of production or exert control over investment decisions, but because they share similar qualitative circumstances regarding their overall roles and relations to others in the economy and in the broader society.

SPEAKER_00Quote The most important classes in any economy are those that have the potential to dominate economic decisions, appropriate the greatest part of the material surplus, and monopolize the most desirable economic roles for themselves. In other words, the most important classes in an economy are those that are already or that have the potential to become a ruling class. Marxists additionally assume that the most important ruling group in any society must be its ruling class.

SPEAKER_00We reject this presumption, but without rejecting the concept ruling class, since it is perfectly possible for a class to dominate the economic sphere, making it a ruling class, yet be subordinate to another social group defined principally by political, community or kinship characteristics. Of course, it is also possible that of all the dominant groups in a society the ruling class is the most important, or that group hierarchies within a society vary in importance depending on the focus of concern.

SPEAKER_00But in any case, we insist that these are matters that can only be settled by empirical investigation of particular societies. No social theory can provide us advanced knowledge as to which, if any elite, will dominate the others in certain particular times and places. In any event, once we recognize that economic activity affects personality, consciousness, and capabilities, once we recognize that control of the use of the means of production can be as critical or more critical than ownership, once we recognize that a monopoly of information can form the basis of a class's economic power, just as a monopoly of ownership or a monopoly of skills can, we are able to see a new class map of capitalist and existing postcapitalist societies.

SPEAKER_00In addition to the capitalist and working classes, we see an important third quote coordinator class in modern economies. In our view, modern economies of both capitalist and post capitalist varieties have spawned a new class of managers, technocrats, and professionals who compete for control over economic activity and its benefits. Since we feel this class comes from, but is much smaller than the growing stratum of quote mental workers in modern economies, we call it the coordinator class to distinguish it from the larger stratum that would include elementary school teachers as well as tenured professors, engineers of all kinds, and nurses as well as hospital administrators and doctors.

SPEAKER_00In economies where the capitalist class still dominates, the coordinator class has antagonistic interests with capitalists who are their most frequent employers. Coordinators seek ever more autonomy from capitalist supervision, as well as growing shares of the surplus. But in such societies the coordinator class also has antagonistic interests with regard to the working class, whose activities it largely directs and quote coordinates.

SPEAKER_00Coordinators seek to reproduce the dependence of workers on experts and the coordinators' own relative monopoly on expertise. In countries where private ownership of the means of production has been largely superseded by state ownership, coordinators are the only specifically economic elite, the new ruling class, but they frequently divide into two fractions the local managers with their supervisory and technical staffs, and the central planners with their staffs of bureaucrats and experts, which vie with one another as well as with workers and non economic elites for economic power.

SPEAKER_00I interject from twenty twenty six. As with the previous two chapters regarding this one's concepts too, the past forty years have not been silent. As I reread this chapter, for example, I am myself surprised at the distinction it offers between what it calls mental workers and the coordinator class. I admit that I do not remember for sure, but my guess is the seven of us assessing this chapter wanted some way to distinguish between what some of us saw as seriously empowered or others saw as only a bit empowered employees by calling the former a coordinator class between labor and capital and calling the latter just a part of all workers.

SPEAKER_00For myself, I question how useful it is to delineate this conceptual borderline as compared to simply saying there are disempowered and employ and empowered employees, some more or less so than others. This is rather like that there are large scale and smaller and small scale owners, that there are unionized and non unionized factory and farm workers, and so on. I won't repeatedly address this question of where to draw lines in further interjections, but will instead let the book speak for itself, even though I'm saying things that ultimately I personally would couch differently.

SPEAKER_00Anyway, the chapter continued. We feel that if a quote class theory is to be useful in studying modern economies, it is critical that it recognize the existence of a coordinator class, parentheses regardless of what name is chosen chosen, and parentheses, and emphasize the importance of its interrelations with capitalists, workers, and non economic elites, as well as the broader stratum of conceptual workers lodge between coordinators and workers.

SPEAKER_00I interject, I wouldn't have had that phrase to continue. A class theory that hides the power of this major economic group by classifying it as the petty bourgeoisie or a class theory that minimizes the conflicting interests of coordinators and workers by lumping coordinators into quote a new working class or labor aristocracy will obscure critical class relations and cause programs to serve coordinator rather than worker aims.

SPEAKER_00Lastly, a complementary holist approach to the economy emphasizes that all economies exist within societies containing other important social structures, and that therefore economies are necessarily textured by quote forces emanating from other spheres. As Nancy Hartz says, quote, class distinctions in capitalist society are part of a totality, a mode of life which is structured as well by the traditions of patriarchy and white supremacy.

SPEAKER_00Class distinctions in the United States affect the everyday lives of women and men, white and black and third world people in different ways. It follows that an economy of a particular type would not function the same way if it interacted with a racist community sphere instead of a nonracist one, or existed in a patriarchal setting instead of a non patriarchal one. An example that has been more frequently debated by Marxists is the difference between quote parliamentary capitalism and quote fascist capitalism.

SPEAKER_00But what has eluded participants in these latter debates is that not only are the political spheres different in parliamentary and fascist capitalism, but the capitalist economies differ as well. In other words, an abstract theory of quote capitalist or coordinator dynamics should not be confused with concrete economic theory relevant to a particular social setting. An economic theory relevant to a racist, sexist, capitalist economy, for example, must contain concepts that quote track the effects of other quote fields of force emanating from outside the economy, but acting within it just as surely as capitalist dynamics act within it.

SPEAKER_00In this kind of economy, a sex blind and race blind theory of distribution of the social surplus or of job types would also be blind to many important economic dynamics and forms of specifically economic oppression, including the qualitative subordination of women and minorities in jobs that are not only underpaid, but whose role definitions reproduce sexist and racist ideology. We need more encompassing concepts.

SPEAKER_00The points surveyed above are intended as important correctives to Marxist economic theory. We take great pains to insulate our complementary holist analysis from the failings of Marxism for two reasons. First, the effects of Marxism on activist thought are so powerful that it influences almost all progressive theory and practice, frequently in ways of which we are unaware. Second, the failures of Marxism go beyond the problem of monist exaggeration of one's sphere's sway, since in addition the economy itself is misunderstood.

SPEAKER_00Before presenting the outlines of our analysis of capitalism, we summarize the major deficiencies of Marxist economic theory. I interject, remember this was forty years ago, and the seven people were actually all prominent in various aspects of activist organizing. The chapter continues As a monist economic theory, Marxism exaggerates the importance of economics and minimizes the importance of other spheres of social life to the point of being quote economistic.

SPEAKER_00This economism makes takes the form of underestimating the importance of non-economic forms of domination, incorrectly reducing those forms of domination to economic roots, and failing to recognize how community, gender, and political dynamics have powerful effects on economic structures. Marxists are right to emphasize the immense importance of economic dynamics and the critical role that classes Have played in history.

SPEAKER_00But just as with nationalism and feminism, to jump from these insights to a monus formulation is unjustifiable and debilitating. But more than this, Marxist economic theory fails to provide conceptual categories that help us discover how different kinds of economic activity have different effects on the development of human characteristics and needs. This omission not only devastates our ability to evaluate different economic institutions, it debilitates our ability to analyze some of the most important dynamics that influence social stability and change.

SPEAKER_00In its fixation on the material quantitative aspects of economic activity, Marxism has largely ignored the human qualitative aspects, or put differently, Marxist economics has never become a theory of economic quote praxis. We do not live by or for bread alone. Lastly, Marxist class theory obscures even the existence of one of the most important classes in modern economies.

SPEAKER_00Based on a monopoly of technical and organizational knowledge, a class who conceptualizes, coordinates, and oversees the economic tasks that others execute has come to vie for economic power with both the capitalist and working class in modern economies. Despite its many other accomplishments, that it ignores this fact, denies Marxism even the accolade, quote, at least it provides a sufficient basis for understanding abstract economies.

SPEAKER_00I interject. The observation above was relevant forty years ago, indeed more than relevant. Regrettably, I think it remains relevant today too, not only to conceiving vision and thus transition that would truly be classless, and not only to understanding how to conceive and win short run economic gains in ways that lead toward that classless vision, but also for understanding the views and aspirations of economic actors current allegiances.

SPEAKER_00The chapter continues in capitalism we see that there are three important classes who share unequally in the burdens and benefits socially organized economic activity. Capitalists own the means of production, hire workers and coordinators, and appropriate a large share of the economy's net product as profits. Coordinators, including senior managers, engineers, lawyers, civil servants in various economic ministries, and high ranking tenured university professors, monopolize valued knowledge to hold conceptual jobs at high salaries with considerable decision making authority over their own and others' work.

SPEAKER_00I interject the list the seven authors settled on, I don't remember any of the discussions, but I suspect there were differences and compromises. For example, the absence of doctors, accountants, and for that matter, people with so much bargaining power that they identify as quote above workers, and thus as coordinators is striking to me. On the other hand, if that was a difference, then where should we stand on this issue? The chapter continues.

SPEAKER_00Coordinators receive part of the net product as high salaries and vie with capitalists over how an even larger part of the social surplus should be invested. In contrast, members of the working class sell their labor power for the best wage they can find, have little say over how their capacities will be utilized, and execute tasks conceived by others. It has not proven impossible for workers to gain part of the social surplus that they alone produce.

SPEAKER_00After all, many working classes have succeeded in their battles for higher than subsistence wages. But even under the most advantageous conditions, workers receive, on average, a far smaller share of society's net product than capitalists and coordinators receive. Moreover, not all actors in capitalist economies occupy positions within only one well defined class. For example, between workers and coordinators there is what we call a professional and managerial stratum, including teachers, welfare workers, nurses, technicians, and others.

SPEAKER_00In short, most of the so called educated middle class. These folks have facets of their economic roles in common with coordinators, their high levels of schooling and roles consisting largely of conceptual tasks. They also have much in common with workers, the low wages they often receive, and their lack of decision making power. In any event, everyone in capitalism participates in market exchange. As buyers, everyone looks for the lowest prices they can find, and as sellers, everyone searches for the highest prices available.

SPEAKER_00But what the different classes buy and sell and the degree to which they are able to influence the amounts they pay and receive are very different. Capitalists buy material inputs and labor power and sell the products the workers make to consumers in pursuit of as much profit as possible. Workers, and most coordinators, sell their labor power for a wage with which they buy their means of subsistence, seeking to improve their living conditions.

SPEAKER_00To maximize profits, capitalists organize their workplaces and situate their companies in various markets very carefully. They try to get as much product from as little input as possible. They keep their workforce disciplined and weak to keep productivity high and wages low. And they compete for positions in various product markets to increase their monopoly power. Workers, coordinators, and middle strata members all seek to negotiate the highest wages they can and to buy products at the lowest possible prices.

SPEAKER_00But in attempting to improve their negotiating position with their capitalist employers, coordinators and middle strata employees often try to expand their monopoly of knowledge and authority over production and exchange, largely at the expense of workers over whom they enjoy relative advantages. Market exchange is a mortar is a matter of bargaining power. Those who have more power extort higher payments for what they sell and or compel lower prices for what they buy.

SPEAKER_00Other things being equal, the greater the degree of monopoly in an industry, the higher the prices the capitalists in that industry will be able to charge. Large corporate customers are also more likely to be able to extract special pricing policies, payment schedules, or service contracts from their suppliers. Similarly, if workers negotiate as a unit through a union instead of individually, they can increase their bargaining power.

SPEAKER_00Or if an employer cannot easily withstand a strike because competitors would steal away his customers, workers should be able to win higher wages. Capitalists buy only their workers' labor power or ability to do work. They must then extract as much actual work as possible during the workday. This means they must structure the work process and job promotion system in ways that cajole, entice, or coerce as much work as possible while ensuring that the workforce goes home at the end of each shift, disinclined to demand better working conditions or increases in pay.

SPEAKER_00The coordinators and Middle Strata employees, of course, play an important role in this ongoing contest. As organizers, directors, and supervisors of the work process, coordinators attempt to keep workers sufficiently uninformed and divided to prevent them from effectively reorganizing their work efforts and renegotiating their rewards more to their own advantage. Sam Bowles and Herb Gintis point out organizing production hierarchically and fragmenting tasks divides the workers on different levels against one another and reduces the independent range of control for each.

SPEAKER_00Both of these weaken the solidarity and hence limit the group power of workers and serve to convince them through their day to day activities of their personal incapacity to control or even of the technical feasibility of such control. But it is not only capitalist power that is advanced by such structures. Coordinator interests are served as well, directly at the expense of workers.

SPEAKER_00Many factors affect bargaining power, and no simple equation determines how prices, wages, and profits will evolve in all settings. For example, in times of rising unemployment and fear of job loss, workers are less willing to take risks, but when there are tight labor markets, employers are put in a position of not knowing if they will be able to find replacements. Increasing unemployment therefore disciplines the workforce and leads to greater productivity and profits.

SPEAKER_00Decreasing unemployment, on the other hand, strengthens workers and allows them to consider job actions and strikes. But what if some of the edge is talk is taken off unemployment so the unemployed are not so desperate to take jobs and the employed not so afraid of getting a pink slip? For example, if unemployment compensation is quickly forthcoming with a minimum of bureaucratic annoyance, and if quality public health care has rendered employment linked medical insurance unnecessary, and if the welfare and public housing systems available to the unemployed are adequate and non degrading, the plight of the unemployed wouldn't be so desperate.

SPEAKER_00Indeed, many unemployed workers might refuse to take any available job no matter how demeaning or bid down wages in pursuit of work. And those who have jobs might not be so fearful to succumb to threats aimed at extracting, give back concessions and contract negotiations. In such circumstances, the link between unemployment, productivity, and wages would be greatly weakened.

SPEAKER_00Through this kind of analysis, we can see how struggles over the quote social wage or general level of support guaranteed all members of society through welfare, housing, food, health care, and other social service programs is a fight over the relative bargaining power of workers and capitalists, as well as a quote moral question of what society is willing to guarantee its most exploited members. When the social wage strengthens workers so they cannot easily be disciplined by a dose of unemployment, capitalists naturally seek to revoke the social programs that threaten their power.

SPEAKER_00By this brief description, we begin to see the efficacy of class analysis and the importance of paying attention to the interconnection of different trends and the multiplicity of factors that can affect bargaining powers. But other important factors also influence the pattern of wages and prices. Not only do capitalists seek to enlarge profits and workers to increase wages and improve working conditions, professionals, managers, and especially coordinators also try to increase their incomes and the power they can exert over economic decisions.

SPEAKER_00Sometimes professionals and managers seek to improve their circumstances by individually trying to improve their standing with employers, colluding, sometimes even against other coordinators. Other times they collectively seek to increase the status and legitimacy afforded to the possession of intellectual skills in society. Professional associations and formal accreditation systems are among the collective mechanisms managers and professionals have employed to enhance their power.

SPEAKER_00Moreover, the situation of different economic actors can vary from industry to industry or region to region as unemployment rates, levels of unionization or the plight of the unemployed vary. Capitalist economies are giant wars in which participants try to win advantages by exerting whatever individual or collective bargaining power they can muster. Basic class relationships texture the entire battlefield, with the clo with the capitalists occupying all the highest ground.

SPEAKER_00But conditions vary from place to place as well, and many factors texture outcomes. Different industries have different degrees of concentration, are more or less unionized, more or less able to withstand strikes, and more or less able to threaten to pack up and move elsewhere. Likewise, different regions of a country or different sectors of a workforce may have different levels of bargaining power. Unionization is an obvious factor, but skill levels and social relations rooted outside the economy are also important.

SPEAKER_00For example, because of the special characteristics of the sale of labor power, the capitalist has an interest in keeping the workforce weak and divided. This is accomplished by various means, including socially and technologically structuring the workplace to minimize worker knowledge and solidarity. In addition, if groups of workers come to a plant with hostilities rooted in relationships beyond the factory door, it will obviously benefit the capitalist to perpetuate and aggravate these hostilities, so energies which might have gone to increasing worker solidarity and bargaining power will instead be focused on intra worker competition.

SPEAKER_00And the effects of social divisions from other spheres are not limited to distribution of the material surplus. Job definitions may be influenced, so a racial or sexual division of labor causes job roles to differ depending on whether slots are filled by men, women, whites, or members of oppressed communities. Therefore, in a racist sexist society, the workplace will not only be fragmented along class lines, but along race and gender lines as well.

SPEAKER_00Similarly, class consciousness varies depending on the mix of the four spheres and the whole social formation, a matter we will address further in later chapters. The point is that social divisions derived from other spheres have a qualitative as well as quantitative impact on the functioning of a capitalist economy. Income distribution in capitalist economies is determined by the pattern of wages, prices, and profits. Each of these in turn depends on the relative bargaining strengths of particular buyers and sellers.

SPEAKER_00Many factors affect these relative strengths, including, as we have begun to enumerate, class division, unionization, industrial concentration, employment levels and patterns, the social wage, consumer organization and consciousness, racism and sexism. On the qualitative side, economic roles and relationships are defined by the class structure of capitalism and by social divisions from other spheres as well.

SPEAKER_00Hence, people's attitudes toward how the economy functions and what kinds of alterations they would like to see are influenced by the mixture of class and non class roles they occupy. In a particular society we can see both quantitative and qualitative trends and postulate likely implications of particular policies. But the idea that within capitalism a few critical economic relations and simple laws of motion govern is simply wrong.

SPEAKER_00Even the most straightforward relations are always historical and subject to change. Given all the above, it follows that we accept the market recognition that class struggle exists in capitalist workplaces and market arenas. We accept that capitalists compete for profits, and that the capitalist economic system revolves around the accumulation process. We accept that capitalists make social and technological investment decisions in their plants and in society as a whole with an eye toward reproducing their own relative advantages.

SPEAKER_00As a result, for example, they are more likely to expand society's war making capacities than to improve living conditions for workers, since building tanks enhances their international bargaining power, while building livable housing for the poor would diminish their bargaining power of home, that is, would diminish the bargaining power of capitalists while increasing it for workers. Even though both forms of investments would return profits, capitalists would certainly prefer the former.

SPEAKER_00But for us, class struggle is a more complicated, tripolar struggle in modern capitalist economies, involving coordinators and a middle strata in addition to capitalists and workers. And in contrast to Marxists, we see that wages, prices, and profits depend on a multiplicity of factors that determine the pattern of relative bargaining strengths between the different actors in a capitalist economy. Moreover, we highlight that the influence of other social spheres on the economy is critical because we recognize that forces emanating from outside the economy help define economic roles and influence economic decisions within it, a phenomenon we will study further in later chapters.

SPEAKER_00I interject. So what's being said is the coordinator part of non worker employees are far enough up in their empowerment, in the extent to which their circumstances give them uh confidence, skills, knowledge, connections, etc.

SPEAKER_00to influence outcomes that we call them a class without hesitation. The uh what this what this what the seven authors called uh mental workers in the middle strata have an element of those attributes, a significant element of those attributes. But they also have a more significant than the above group element of working class attributes.

SPEAKER_00So it is the case that those uh who are being called coordinators are working for a wage. It is the case that they have much in common, or that much in common, and more also with workers below. So what what's being said basically is that the middle strata are more likely to move feel aligned with workers and see themselves in workers as compared to the coordinators above, who are more aligned to and likely to uh see themselves as a coordinator class above workers.

SPEAKER_00And indeed, what this points out is that in organizing work, um, this all comes much later in this liberating theory book, but in organizing work, um there there is one kind of recognition and understanding that should play a role in organizing among coordinators, high level law. Lawyers, accountants, people who are employed in the position of conceiving the structure of the workplace day-to-day life of diminishing the power of workers, and so on.

SPEAKER_00And a slightly different inclination regarding, say, school teachers and nurses and other sectors of this non-working class employees who we are now calling mental worker middle stratum, because the latter, as compared to the coordinators, is a little more likely to respond to entreaties to align with working people.

SPEAKER_00At least that's what I suspect was going on in everybody's head, everybody's, in the seven authors' head when when we were putting together this chapter. I think that's what explains it. And I don't really disagree. I just think it complicates the way we think about things, especially when we think about this employee group as a possible ruling class. At any case, uh with that bumbling aside past, the chapter continues.

SPEAKER_00Our economic analysis analysis also focuses on the qualitative aspects of economic activity. How it is that the organization of work and consumption under capitalism affects the pattern of human development and the reproduction or disruption of social relationships. The situations of traditional workers, capitalists, coordinators, and those in the middle strata are all different. As a result, a representative individual of each type on average has a different perspective on their economic role in society, prospects and interests.

SPEAKER_00This explains why we d designate such people members of different classes. I interject. There was a little slip in the writing. It should have been members of different classes and strata to be consistent with all else in the chapter, I guess. In any case, the chapter continues. Moreover, the interface between these groups and the patterns of consciousness that result are much more complicated than traditional Marxism recognizes.

SPEAKER_00For example, workers interact face to face far less with capitalists than with middle strata workers or coordinators. It is therefore not surprising that much of workers' hostility is directed at these intermediate groups instead of at capitalists. For example, working class antipathy for doctors, lawyers, and ideologies identified with quote intellectuals. It is also important to recognize that members of the middle strata share many interests with traditional workers, but frequently aspire to coordinator status.

SPEAKER_00For example, teachers or nurses debating over unionizing or striking, questioning whether to behave in accord with the working class aspects of the situation or according to coordinator aspirations. I interject, so there is exactly what I was suggesting was at work, and which I agree with, I should say, even now in 2026. The chapter continues recognizing the complexity of class dynamics as well as the importance of racial and sexual dynamics at work within the economy makes all the more important the task of theorizing the quote human, quote psychological or quote qualitative side of economic relations.

SPEAKER_00And we also must recognize that though classes are born in the organization of economic activity, class life extends beyond the factory and market. Classes develop extra economic characteristics, such as shared tastes in music, sports, restaurants, bars, clothes, etc. To recognize that class is economically rooted is not to deny that capitalist workers and coordinators also develop cultural, aesthetic, and even spiritual characteristics that deserve our attention as well.

SPEAKER_00Quote Yuppies may be thought of as a particular subset of the coordinator class. Blue and white collar workers are subsets of the working class. The different roles assigned by modern capitalist organization of production are not the only capitalist roles that have significant effects on how people's characteristics and needs develop. Markets compel actors to function individually and antisocially, without taking account of the well being of the producers who make what one purchases or the consumers who purchase what one produces.

SPEAKER_00Markets make people competitive, individualistic, in the antisocial sense of the word and materialistic. We see the dollar worth of everything, but we lose track of social relations and human costs and benefits to others. I interject, perhaps an example would have helped. You go into the store, you go around the aisles, you're going to buy stuff. Do you have in any sense whatsoever the slightest knowledge of the work, the circumstances, the conditions of the people who produce the stuff that you're taking home?

SPEAKER_00You don't. You don't have it even if you want it. You can't have it. The markets don't communicate it. The chapter continues. We cannot overemphasize the importance of these facts of life in capitalist economies. Our personalities and tastes depend partially on market constraints. Markets are biased to oversupply private goods compared to public goods, and in response, we privatize ourselves to want what markets offer.

SPEAKER_00Markets provide goods designed for the lowest common denominator of intelligence and interest, and in response we brainwash ourselves to want what's to be had. And the same holds for work life. Capitalist jobs require a facility for enduring boredom and being passive, and in response, we lobotomize ourselves to deaden our capacities lest they exceed employer requirements.

SPEAKER_00In both goods markets and jobs markets, individuals are quote free to choose among available offerings. But what is made available is largely determined by the institutional biases of capitalism. In response, by adjusting our individual desires toward the kinds of goods and jobs that capitalism is supplying and away from the kinds of goods and jobs that capitalism never offers, so that we will most often have our quote desires met.

SPEAKER_00We collectively help reproduce capitalism's biases. It is sensible to mold our tastes so that we want what is available rather than things we can never find on the market. Or is it? We get what we seek, yet our acts reproduce our oppressions. Capitalist economic relations include a vast network of roles textured by class as well as by race, sex, and political struggles. But when we act within the confines of those roles as we must do if we are to gain what society has to offer, we also reproduce the defining class and other social divisions, and thereby the system of privileges that benefit the society advantaged.

SPEAKER_00In other words, in addition to whatever needs we satisfy through our work and consumption activity, that activity has material and psychological effects that help reproduce capitalism. Ironically, our ability to make the best of a bad situation also serves to reproduce our oppressive circumstances. As Herbert Marcuse puts it, what is now at stake are the needs themselves.

SPEAKER_00At this stage the question is no longer how can the individual satisfy his or her own needs without hurting others? But instead, how can he satisfy his needs without hurting himself and without reproducing through his aspirations and satisfactions his dependence on an exploitative apparatus which, in satisfying his needs, perpetuates his servitude. Since we must eat, we work, since we must keep our jobs, we mold our wills and capacities to fit them.

SPEAKER_00We go along to get along. To attain fulfillment through consumption, we train our tastes to what can be bought. We mold ourselves to fit the contours of our environment, thereby establishing meetable needs, but also reinforcing that environment and diminishing our chances for real liberation. And we even sense the irony of what we do. As Andre Gors describes, quote, wonder each morning how you're going to hold on till evening, each Monday how you'll make it to Saturday.

SPEAKER_00Reach home without the strength to do anything but watch TV, telling yourself you'll surely die an idiot. Long to smash everything, once a day, feel sick because you've traded your life for a living. Fear that the rage mounting within you will die down in the end, that in the final analysis people are right when they say Ah, you can get used to anything. I interject. As an interesting aside, take a listen to the song The Pretender by Jackson Brown.

SPEAKER_00The chapter continues Capitalist economic activity generates means of subsistence for most, access to luxuries for many, and an ever greater accumulation of means of production for a few. In the process, it also produces biases against social consumption and self managed work and continually reproduces the class relations of capitalism, as well as of oppressive sex, race, and political relations based in other social spheres.

SPEAKER_00While antagonistic aims fuel perpetual economic struggles over the relative well being of different classes and social groups, most of the time the basic social relations of capitalism remains secure. Under certain circumstances, however, subordinate classes can escape the narrow bounds usually circumscribing class struggle and overcome dominant classes replacing old economic relationships with new ones.

SPEAKER_00Just as social stability in part results from reproductive aspects of economic activity, so social change in part results from disruptive aspects of economic activity. But these are matters we will return to once we have completed our abstract survey of each of society's four spheres when we get on to issues of history. I interject. As I read this chapter, I again find myself feeling that the seven authors did a good job back then that holds up now, forty years later.

SPEAKER_00I have only two deviations from feeling only that, which is not overly surprising as I was one of the seven, I guess. The first deviation I interjected earlier. What does a stratum between coordinators and workers mean and what does talking in terms of it accomplish? How do we conceptualize what we might say is the less empowered part of the coordinator class, or if we prefer, the more empowered part of the working class?

SPEAKER_00Call it a middle stratum, or call it either less powerful coordinators or more powerful workers. It is one of many possible issues that might arise in thinking over liberating theory proposals. But the second deviation I might now have, which informs, I think, how to think through the first is a little surprising. Why is there no mention that the coordinator class pursuing its interests can become a new ruling class?

SPEAKER_00For me, that is what makes the designation of a third class instead of strata or whatever so important. It affects not just how we think about current relations, but also, and arguably even more so, how we think about what economic institutions we seek and how we can attain them, and not wind up with a postcapitalism that still has a ruling class. Maybe this these matters will show up in the dialogue for this chapter, which I move from the back of the book to here.

SPEAKER_00The dialogues, remember, include an array of participants, each with their own different political activist views. For this dialogue, Koho, our complimentary wholeist participant, first succinctly summarizes her views about the economic sphere. She starts So while the economic sphere involves production, consumption, and allocation of material objects, it also affects people's personalities, skills, consciousness, and relations with one another.

SPEAKER_00The Marxist paradigm minimizes the importance of other spheres of social life to the point of being economistic. It fails to provide concepts for understanding the effect of various kinds of economic activity on human development and needs. It obscures the existence of an extremely important and influential coordinator class. Morlin, our Marxist Leninist participant, unable to contain himself, interrupts.

SPEAKER_00You exaggerate in the most opportunist way in your treatment of economics. Because some Marxists are economistic, then all Marxists must be mechanical Marxists. That's like saying because some anarchists use bombs, all anarchists are mad bombers. Coho. Calling me an opportunist doesn't address the questions I've raised. I don't deny that most Marxists add qualitative concerns to their economic thinking, but they hamper their efforts by removing it from their most basic guiding concepts.

SPEAKER_00For instance, I find nothing in your labor theory of value that takes qualities into account. Moral and well I coho, interrupting. In fact, your labor theory of value reduces all matters to hours of labor. Quality of work and consumption and mindsets and social relations of workers and consumers have no impact on a the values and exchange rates, and B the quality and character of who we are and what we do. Marlin, if you would let me get a word in, Coho interrupts.

SPEAKER_00While your concepts have resulted in rich investigation into classes, your final class definitions have little to say about workplace relations except as they relate to ownership. Marlin, I Nate, our nationalist participant interrupts. And what does the labor theory of value have to say about the importance of workers' cultural heritage, community identity, and the often intense racism of the white working class? Marlin, you know my record in working against income differentials and divisions that weaken the working class?

SPEAKER_00Koho Yes, but your concepts prevent you from seeing that workplace relations, job definitions, chains of command, workplace culture, consumption patterns, and prices are all partially defined by non class forces. Marlin confident. Of course we recognize the importance of seeing women as economic actors. Big deal, women are secretaries more often than men. Sophie, sarcastic. And big deal, capitalists are rich more often than workers.

SPEAKER_00Can you explain gender divisions of labor or why when men and women hold the same position men are paid more? Or why when men take jobs that have been considered women's jobs, those jobs suddenly change, not just in salary level, but in quality and status? Your categories ensure that you don't ask those questions, that you don't even know to ask those questions. Marlin, I think our analysis of the working class, both women and men, gives some insights into these questions, and I fail to see, Koho interrupts.

SPEAKER_00Precisely my point. You do fail to see. Of course it gives some insights, but you overlook influences that affect how people see and relate to one another, the complexity of people's different interests, and therefore how we are likely to relate to political and economic programs and events. Anna are anarchist. And you also fail to see that Marxism has never in practice meant liberation for the working class. Your concepts recreate authority dynamics throughout through a socialist state.

SPEAKER_00Nate, and you also fail to fully understand the working class because you are talking only of the white working class. Much of what you think, do, and say is geared to appeal to a white working class culture. Rad Fem, a white male working class culture. Morlin, not impressed. Your arguments expose your failures to comprehend Marxism as a theory of the working class, and more importantly, a theory for revolution and liberation. Coho.

SPEAKER_00But what Marxist guided revolution has led has been led by the working class? And what resulting society has been controlled by the working class? Marxism has given us insights into capitalism, but it has failed to give us a theory of socialism. Your preferred societies are run by coordinators, not workers. CC, our Council Communist, on firm ground here. You're criticizing Leninism, Goho, not Marxism.

SPEAKER_00I wouldn't call Soviet states Marxist. As a Marxist, I oppose all forms which subjugate workers. I agree that Orthodox Marxism overlooks certain factors, but you fail to recognize that there are Marxist strains that have done much better. Council Communism, for instance. While we are slow to understand the role of gender and race, we are trying to expand and change. Koho, but since you are relatively small offshoot, your tenets are swallowed up by the enormity of the Marxist heritage you attempt to contradict.

SPEAKER_00Complimentary holism doesn't exactly have a huge following either. Koho, if that's still true, when we've existed as long as Council Communism has, then I will concede that point. However, that isn't my only criticism. C I had a feeling it wasn't. Coho to me, Council Communism is a merger of Marxism and anarchism, in the same way that socialist feminism is a merger of feminism and Marxism.

SPEAKER_00Like the best socialist feminists, the best council communists have altered their component theories to incorporate economic and political insights, particularly around the concept of self-management. But you fail to criticize all the failings of the theories you combine. You think the main weakness of Marxism is only its Leninist strategic baggage while you overlook more basic conceptual limitations, Marlin, eager to reclaim the discussion. This is outrageous.

SPEAKER_00You confuse lack of perfect practice with inherent theoretical failings. Because bureaucratic states have usurped power in certain countries, you want to throw out the entire Marxist vision. A democratic state alongside a centrally planned economy will serve the class which ultimately administers it, the working class. After all, we are, by your own admittance, Koho, searching for theoretical constructs that give us the best chance for the broadest kind of success.

SPEAKER_00From there we can move to perfect it. If we wait to find the broadest, lowest common denominator theory, we will wait until the cows come home. The stew is a crust on the bottom of the pan. The earth has disappeared into a black hole. Use any analogy you want. Koho. Why do you fail to? Morlin, only beginning to assert the weight of history, interrupts. Let me finish. Nate, you claim concern for the black community, but you fail to define and understand capitalism which oppresses all people.

SPEAKER_00To assert your cultural heritage and religion at the expense of working class. Revolution seems a luxury we cannot afford. In fact, many in your movement argue for black capitalism. And Rat Fem, your theory ignores that men are oppressed as well as oppressors. And Anna, your theory tells you nothing about capitalist encirclement. You are so worried about hierarchies you barely mentioned poverty, occupational health, and safety, wages, pensions, and so on.

SPEAKER_00Koho. But Marlin, you argue my case for me. Why wouldn't you prefer theoretical concepts that allow you to do all of what you just described? Why argue for concepts that largely exclude all or a combination of those things? Why do you hold to a monus framework and insist on its dominance? We've all seen how your central planning works. It elevates central planners, managers, and intellectual workers. The coordinator class, not the working class.

SPEAKER_00Neopop, our resident populist, says but someone has to administer an economy. The issue is who will they serve? Moreland, quite right, in a capitalist society your coordinators are tools of the capitalists. Coordinators in a socialist society are in the service of workers. Coho. Coordinators won't exist in a real socialist society. In your vision, they rule. Sometimes workers in capitalism blindly serve capitalists, yet you have no trouble identifying them as a separate and potentially revolutionary class.

SPEAKER_00Coordinators too can be conscious of their economic position and struggle for ruling status. Marxism's focus on capitalism's economic failures and celebrations of central planning lay the perfect basis for coordinator control of your so-called working class revolution. Coordinators argue for their own superior intellectual skills when they promote central planning, markets, or the best economic uses of technology.

SPEAKER_00The Marxist program allows coordinators to offer some worthwhile benefits to win workers' allegiance in exchange for coordinator control. In Marxist Leninist societies, for example, the state bureaucracy only took on the double duty of planning the economic and the political spheres because there weren't enough coordinators to do the job. So the state Anna became lord of all. Coho. In many Western societies, coordinators would be able to administer a centrally planned economy alongside a parliamentary state which would be in their interest.

SPEAKER_00Eurocommunists have dropped the notion of dictatorship of the proletariat, party, or of anyone else for that reason. CC, I can't argue with that, but I would not describe the societies you refer to as socialist. Marlin in disbelief. I'm in a vacuum of ahistical nonsense. You ignore capitalist encirclement and the poverty and illiteracy that has held back Marxist revolutions. You ignore that Marxism is read, studied, and adopted by a majority of the world's population.

SPEAKER_00It has been the theoretical motor for huge historical transformations. Coho, and I have continually given Marxism its due, but we must critique the failings of its theoretical concepts in light of our desire to bring about true liberation for all spheres of society. The Russian Revolution has had decades of history to play itself out. Remember, this is forty years ago. The problems in Soviet society can no longer be blamed solely on outside factors.

SPEAKER_00The Soviet Union is a superpower. East Germany and Czechoslovakia were both industrialized countries when they had the Soviet model rammed down their collective throats. And they have the same basic failings. If the Marxism that informs these models is so good, why do these problems still exist? Because Marxism is a theory geared toward the interests of coordinators. That's why. History shows it, analysis reveals and predicts it.

SPEAKER_00Coordinator programs and so called working class organization display it. Pausing to catch her breath. Marlin, feebly but still not convinced, says But Marxism has also shown that it can change over time, that it can incorporate such recognition. C C and it is important to be identified with that tradition. We live and work in a capitalist country that obscures its oppressive economic values and rhetoric with rhetoric about democracy that makes it difficult for people to see the effects of capitalism on daily life.

SPEAKER_00Marxism has fueled opposition. Coho, yes, and it's not that all Marxists won't change, it's that not enough will. What changes have you you yourself made, Marlin, even when under incredible pressure from black power and women's movements? And C C most Marxists would rather not include you in their camp since you argue for things they don't really want, like self management. The difference between you and other Marxists are so great that using the term Marxist doesn't really describe what you believe.

SPEAKER_00Marlin I coho interrupts. Marxism has been a powerful tool for understanding many injustices of capitalism. But the fact that it emphasizes capitalism's underutilization and misdirection of productive capa capabilities can serve a coordinator as well as a socialist view. Coordinators feel they can reorient technology and be more productive and humane by replacing pursuit of profit with elite administration.

SPEAKER_00And Marxism's celebration of central planning or Marxist productivity and efficiency fits in well with coordinator aims. Marlin I Koho yes Marlin, I'm thinking. Koho, while you're thinking, why don't we move to the political sphere? Anna, pleased with herself. I'm ready. Marlin's still thinking, I'm not. Pleury, I can see why. That was an onslaught. I was about to side with Marlin just out of sympathy. Nate, not me.

SPEAKER_00I feel the weight of history removed from my shoulders. Sin from the corner, smugly. Excuse me, but and the group scowls at the figure in the corner. Koho, yes, sin? Sin, you want history? I'll give you history. History shows there will always be bosses and those who are bossed. It's human nature. Sophie, muttering to Nat, again with this human nature. Sin, sure, I once believed that all liberty was possible.

SPEAKER_00Then I tried working with people, organizing to build a movement for change. We spent the entire time fighting and arguing to win out over each other. The result? No one could work with anyone else. You can't bring about change with thousands of parties each made up of one person. Angry looks focus on the corner or chair. Rad Fem on the edge of her seat. Want me to remove this person, Koho? I need some exercise. Nate, halfway up. You want human nature, sin? I'll show you some human nature.

SPEAKER_00Koho, I'd rather discuss with Anna the weaknesses of her theory regarding the political sphere. Anna, sighing as the others settle down. Be my guest. That was the end of the dialogue. I interject, but discussing polity is for next chapter. One comment first about this one offered from twenty twenty six, and I again do not remember what may have been at work among the seven authors in this regard. I am struck by the fact that in the chapter proper and in the dialogue there is no explicit mention of the corporate division of labor as an institutional source of coordinator existence.

SPEAKER_00It is striking to me since it was such a pivotal focus for me and was as well for the publisher, South End Press. Whatever the reason for it not explicitly coming up here, maybe it will when liberating theory gets division. At any rate, to pursue the issues of this chapter, in particular, what a placeless economy would have to have as defining institutions, it will surely come up going forward as it came up for, for example, when Robin Hannell and I proceeded further from Liberating Theory.

SPEAKER_00The book's proposal was to go forward with enriched concepts for each sphere of social life, including the economy, as well as for how the spheres interrelate and affect each other's development both in calm and in revolutionary times, not to mention what the aims and means of the latter ought to be. I hope reoffering the material in 2026 will open up that possibility. And so ends this episode, and this is Michael Albert, signing off until next time for Revolution Z.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 415 Paul Loeb On How Movements Persist

    Nov 15, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    Episode 415 of RevolutionZ has as its guest Paul Loeb who joins us after decades of work on citizen responsibility, civic engagement, and the hard reality of sustaining social movements in challenging times. An election...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 414 2026/2028, DSA/AOC, and Future Consequences

    Nov 8, 202650 minAudio

    Episode 414 of RevolutionZ considers tasks ahead in light of the MIdterm results. The scariest moment in politics may be when authoritarians win. but a not too distant second may be when they lose and we all exhale. Do...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 413 From Uprising To Revolution

    Nov 1, 202628 minAudio

    Episode 413 of RevolutionZ asks what comes after our eruptions? What happens when the cameras leave, when the easy unity ages even just a little bit, and when power bets we will wear out and go home? What can we do to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. EP 412 Talking With GPT About AI and Us Part Two

    Oct 25, 20261 hr 44 minAudio

    Episode 412 offers Part Two of Talking with Chat GPT wherein the AI effusively answers questions about itself, the AI industry and its CEOs, users, prospects and dangers, and about its and our futures. What can/will AI...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Talking With Chat-GPT About AI and Us Part One

    Oct 18, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Episode 411 of RevolutionZ has a guest with initials instead of a name: GPT (5.6). The episode asks GPT questions many people quietly wonder about but rarely hear answered in its "voice." We start with deceptively...

    Credit the people on this episode