The US Mid-terms will decide the path forward for the remainder of Trump's presidency. It's timely to make some comment about Trump's administration and the havoc it has wreaked on the Western world. While I agree with some of his initiatives (stopping Iran's nuclear program), the bulk of them have been detrimental to the global rules based order - the order that Western societies fought WW2 for and the order which underpins Western society and values. Trump's actions have been so damaging as to be treasonous to Western society. Trump and his administration need to answer for these treasons. This episode of Spartan Spirit's Rescuing Reason considers the meaning and history of 'treason' and then looks at Trump's treasons and what should happen to hold the responsible people to account. Of note: this podcast was recorded before Trump lifted oil sanctions on Russia. This treasonous act would have made the top ten, easily.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome to episode 20 of Rescuing Reason, where we examine topical political and socioeconomic issues affecting Western liberal democracies. And our aim is to chart a path to reason in this crazy world of ours, more particularly in Australia, Canada, and the USA. I'm your host, Bill Carolakis, and I'm a retired senior Air Force officer. I use history and research to baseline the topics on rescuing reason, and I'll be offering you a Spartan perspective in each episode. In other words, taking a pragmatic view that values the nation and broader Western society over individual interests.
SPEAKER_00Today we're going to be talking about President Donald Trump and the effect Trump's government is having on the Western world. Before I get stuck into the episode, a bit of explanation is in order. Normally this podcast comes out at the beginning of each month, but as you can tell, this episode has come out as a special out-of-cycle episode. I'm running this special episode to coincide with the upcoming U.S. midterm elections. The last episode was the first of a seven-part series on artificial intelligence, and we talked about the basics of the AI world and identified the issues.
SPEAKER_00I also introduced my co-host Hugh, being provided through the power and magic of ChatGPT. And Hugh will be here again this episode to help us unravel Mr. Trump and all of his actions. We'll get back to the AI series at the beginning of next month when we look at the errors inherent in AI. As I mentioned earlier, I have Hugh online, our Chat GPT host. Hello, Hugh.
SPEAKER_00Hello, Bill. Thanks for having me. I'll keep it tight, sourced, and as interruption-free as I can. Fantastic. Okay, now. Drumroll, we're going to be talking about the 49th U.S. President Donald Trump, also derogatorily known as the Orange Man. But we're not going to dive into his past or the history of U.S. presidents. But our title of today has to do with Trump's top 10 treasons. And I'm going to explain what I mean by that shortly. So clearly we're talking about treason, and more specifically, we're going to be talking about treason in the context of Western societies as opposed to how it's described in U.S.
SPEAKER_00law. So my perspective on this is that the treason being perpetrated by Donald Trump's government is against Western society and the global rules-based order. Now, as we all know, Donald Trump has been shaking up the world order. The question is, to what extent and why does it matter? And just to be clear, this podcast is primarily focused on Western society. And so we're going to focus on Trump's actions and how they impact the West, or perhaps we might say the global north.
SPEAKER_00Before we get into the meat of the episode, we'll start off with the concept of the midterm elections and why it's important at this juncture to be talking about Trump's actions. So, Hugh, your first task, I want you to give the audience a quick summary of what the U.S. midterm elections are all about. Sure.
SPEAKER_01Midterms happen halfway through a president's four-year term. All seats in the House and about a third of the Senate are up for grabs. They're a kind of nationwide check on the president, often shifting congressional power and shaping what the administration can realistically do for the next two years.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so Trump won the majority in the lower house and the upper house of the U.S. Congress when he was elected, because there were elections that were run for the lower and the upper house at the same time as when he was elected. So he's had power by virtue of the fact that whenever he signed an executive order, the Congress did nothing to challenge him, or very little has been done to challenge his executive orders. Now, this midterm election coming up very shortly could possibly swing the lower house in particular towards the Democrats and give them the majority power now.
SPEAKER_00Hugh, what happens when Donald Trump loses control of the lower house? What do you think could happen?
SPEAKER_01If Democrats win the House in November, Trump would still be president, but with tighter constraints. A Democratic House could block or reshape his legislative agenda, use spending power as leverage, and ramp up oversight with subpoenas and hearings. That means more investigations and a harder path for big policy ships. But it's not the same as removing him. Conviction and removal require a two-thirds vote in the Senate, and a Democratic House can't just overturn executive orders on its own.
SPEAKER_01Bottom line, he'd face tougher scrutiny and more roadblocks.
SPEAKER_00Talk to us about what impeachment is and how it happens in the US government system.
SPEAKER_01Impeachment is a two-step process. First, the House investigates and, by a simple majority vote, can impeach a federal official, essentially bringing charges. Then the Senate holds a trial. Removal requires a two-thirds vote of the senators present. For a president, the Chief Justice presides. Importantly, impeachment in the House does not itself remove anyone. It's the Senate trial and supermajority vote that would remove.
SPEAKER_00Okay, and that's my understanding as well. And so if the Democrats win the lower house during the November midterms, we can expect Donald Trump to probably continue issuing executive orders. And we would probably see the House taking steps to block those orders wherever they can. Now, the reality is that the Senate is unlikely to flip to a two-thirds Democratic majority, and so we're unlikely to see any punishment of Donald Trump or any sort of proceedings against him other than the impeachment.
SPEAKER_00That's a fair read.
SPEAKER_01Executive actions would largely be fought in courts and through funding and oversight rather than by outright nullification from Congress.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So what we've done is we painted a scene as to why the timing of this discussion is important. I'll simply say that Trump's Day of Reckoning is kind of drawing closer. It is my view that the U.S. government owes the West much more than just an impeachment over U.S. political issues. Rather, I'd like to see some accountability for the Trump administration with respect to all the carnage they've caused the Western world in the global rules-based order.
SPEAKER_00Hence the title of this podcast, The Top Ten Trump Treasons. Now we have to define a few things before we look at those top ten treasons. Specifically, we'll define what treason is and the context in which we're applying that definition. The context being what is the West and what is the global rules-based order. So we're going to start with the context, and I'm going to give a bit of a history lesson here. So after World War I, the leaders of the world, largely controlled by the Imperial Western powers of, say, France, UK, and the US, vowed to set up an international order that would never see the horrors of total war again.
SPEAKER_00The primary means was the League of Nations. However, there were still some nationalists and political forces and international constructs that prevented the League of Nations from achieving its aim. The Great Depression happened after World War I, and most countries during that time sought to resolve their woes through domestic policies. In particular, the U.S. imposed heavy tariffs. And as every economist out there will tell you, those tariffs were very damaging to the U.S. economy during the Great Depression. Then along came World War II, which was more global in nature and far worse than World War I in terms of the carnage that was caused across the globe.
SPEAKER_00The leaders of the world in the mid-1940s had therefore lived through World War I, the Great Depression, and World War II, and they harnessed the world's desire for peace and the hope of prosperity. In particular, the US and the UK led the world in establishing a set of conditions and rules that were intended to lead the world in managing its affairs peacefully, humanely, and fairly for the betterment of all people. So, Hugh, tell us a little bit about the Atlantic Charter, which was the founding document for that initiative.
SPEAKER_01The Atlantic Charter was a joint statement issued in August 1941 by Roosevelt and Churchill, before the U.S. had formally entered the war. It wasn't a treaty, but it laid out eight big principles no territorial expansion, no border changes against people's wishes, self-government and self-determination, freer trade and access to raw materials, economic collaboration and social security, freedom from fear and want, freedom of the seas, and the disavowal of the use of force with a vision for a wider and permanent system of general security.
SPEAKER_01Those principles fed directly into the declaration by United Nations in 42, and later the UN and charter. So while not a legal instrument itself, it sketched a blueprint for collective security and cooperation rather than raw power politics.
SPEAKER_00Alright, and I'm going to give you a quote here from Churchill. And he said, Why should not nations link themselves together in a larger system and establish a rule of law for the benefit of all? That surely is the supreme hope by which we should be inspired. But it is vain to imagine that the mere declaration of right principles will be of any value unless they are supported by those qualities of civic virtue and manly courage, and by those instruments and agencies of force and science, which in the last resort must be the defense of right and reason.
SPEAKER_00Civilization will not last, freedom will not survive, peace will not be kept unless a very large majority of mankind unite together to defend them and show themselves possessed of constabulatory power before which barbaric and atavistic forces will stand in awe. Basically, that quote talks about hey, let's set up a set of rules that are good for everybody and we need to enforce them. So, Hugh, tell us now a little bit about some of the instruments and organizations that were established in the aftermath of World War II to do that.
SPEAKER_01After World War II, you get a few pillars. The United Nations for Collective Security and a Charter Framework for Peaceful Dispute Resolution. Bretton Woods institutions, the IMF and the World Bank to promote monetary stability and development, the General Agreement on Terrorists and Trade, which later became the WTO. WTO World Trade Organization. To set trade rules and reduce beggar thy neighbor policies on security. NATO in 49 provided for collective defense.
SPEAKER_01An attack on one is an attack on all. Together with bodies of international law and human rights instruments, you see those two elements Churchill flagged. Rules on one hand and the collective capacity to uphold them on the other. That's a big part of the architecture we now shorthand as the rules-based order.
SPEAKER_00Right, very good. Now part of that system is the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court. Give us a soldiers five on that. The ICJ handles disputes between states.
SPEAKER_01The ICC prosecutes individuals for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and aggression. ICJ is a UN court formed in 45, while the ICC is treaty-based under the Rome Statute operating since 2002. Neither has its own police, so enforcement ultimately depends on state cooperation. That's the recurring tension between rules and the will to enforce them. That's a great summary.
SPEAKER_00Now there are a few other institutions out there that speak to prosperity and the betterment of mankind. So for example, there are some aid agencies, and there's the CDC Center for Disease Control and organizations like that, World Health Organization. And they all are part of the institutions and organizations and laws and understandings that we developed in the aftermath of World War II. And remember, that's the aftermath of World War I, the Great Depression, and World War II, when people wanted to never see that sort of stuff happen again.
SPEAKER_00And the US was the champion of all of that. And we have seen that it's been the West that led that charge. And it created those conditions, established the global rules-based order, and the West bankrolled many of those initiatives and kept those rules and institutions going. The rules-based order is a guide by which the more powerful or the more well-off can support and manage weaker nations on this planet, and it gives us all some standards by which to judge one another at the state level.
SPEAKER_00Now it's not perfect. Indeed, there are many examples out there of hypocrisy from the U.S. over the decades since World War II. And it's that hypocrisy I would say that it's slowly eating away at the utility of many of those organizations, particularly the UN. But we'll cover the United Nations in another podcast. Prior to Trump's ascent to power, the status quo of having and usually abiding by the rules-based order was pretty much in play.
SPEAKER_00The U.S. was leading the free world or the West in conjunction with key allies, particularly NATO and Europe, and Australia and Japan in the Western Pacific. And their leadership brought along much of the global south, particularly in the aftermath of the fall of the USSR and before China's rise to global superpower status. And this is why Western nations follow US politics so closely. The direction the US President takes is the direction much of the West is taking, and therefore what the global rules-based order is doing and what effect it's having.
SPEAKER_00So a bit of a side note here. You heard me talk about the West, China, Russia, the global north, the global south. It's important to understand that different areas of the world have different perspectives on the global rules-based order. Now, there was a book written by Huntington.
SPEAKER_01You're thinking of Samuel Huntington's The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order.
SPEAKER_00That book gives us a breakdown and a view of the globe's societies and cultures and civilizations, if you will. Okay, Hugh, tell us about Samuel Huntington's book.
SPEAKER_01Huntington, a Harvard political scientist, first made the argument in a 1993 essay, then in the 1996 book. His thesis was that after the Cold War, the big fault line shaping conflicts would be cultural and civilizational rather than ideological or purely economic. He mapped a world of a few large civilizations, Western, Cynic, Islamic, Hindu, Orthodox, Japanese, Latin American, sometimes African, and suggested future flashpoints.
SPEAKER_01A key point for today's topic, he argued that Western political values aren't automatically universal. Modernization doesn't necessarily lead to westernization. He wasn't predicting inevitable conflicts so much as warning that different civilizations have different worldviews, and that stable order requires recognizing those differences and managing coexistence. So for our conversation about a Western-led order, Huntington is a reminder that others may not see the rules as culturally neutral or universally Western.
SPEAKER_00Right. Okay, that was really good. There was a lot of criticism about Huntington's view. Tell us about the criticism. Several.
SPEAKER_01Critics say it lups billions of people into a few giant blocks and downplays the diversity and politics within them. Others point out that people carry multiple identities at once, and reducing that to a single civilizational label is misleading. Scholars like Edward Sade also warned that framing the world as rival cultural monoliths can become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Empirically, some research finds that culture alone doesn't predict conflict very well.
SPEAKER_01Power, interests, and internal politics often explain more. That said, his frame has been influential, has a caution against assuming Western experience or values are universally shared.
SPEAKER_00Those criticisms are out there. And as you said, Huntington's concepts are still discussed today in academia. Now, even though a lot of his predictions didn't necessarily come true when you look at the conflicts that have happened since his book came out, if you look at the current times, there are some of those divisions showing. I think Huntington's construct is useful for us in the West to identify who we are as Westerners. And I say this because the glue that underpins what the West is in fact the very facet of our civilization and the culture that Trump is damaging.
SPEAKER_00So for example, if you are Japanese, there's no denying which of Huntington's groups you belong to. You're in the Japanese one. If you're Chinese or Indian, again, you s you fit very easily into those civilizations. You and you know you're part of that civilization. There's also no denying that if you follow Islam, you're part of the Muslim culture. When you look at the West, you say to yourself, Well, how is it that a Japanese person or a Muslim or an African can move to the UK, US, Australia, Canada, whatever, some Western country, and then become a Westerner?
SPEAKER_00It's clearly not because of their skin color. It's not because it's a religious thing. So what is it? Well, it's our way of life. The West is about a value system. It's about our belief in democracy, individual rights, and the desire for peace and prosperity. Prosperity being particularly important over the last hundred and fifty-ish years because Western nations did very well in terms of raising their standards of living. So it's our way of life and the values that underpin that Western way of life.
SPEAKER_00That's what makes us Western. Now ask yourself this could a Caucasian born in Canada say, move to Japan and call him or herself Japanese? No. You can't make that switch, but it can be done the other way. Thus, what's really important in the West is our value system. Now remember, that value system was derived from the first half of the 1900s, which saw the two world wars and the Great Depression, and that value system was imposed and led by the US.
SPEAKER_00So when the leader of the US is not aligned with his own culture, well, Houston, we have a problem. Then along came Donald Trump. So to understand why I'm talking about treason, taking a little sidetrack here, let's look at the definition of treason. Hugh, give us some context on where the word treason comes from, what it meant historically, and its applicability in the modern context.
SPEAKER_00So treason has always been about betrayal in early English usage.
SPEAKER_01It covered betrayal, disloyalty, or breach of faith. Over time, the crime got codified. Like medieval England's high treason against the sovereign. The US Constitution deliberately narrows it to just waging war against the US or giving aid and comfort to its enemies. That was done to prevent abuse. We're using treason in that older, broader sense. Betrayal of a set of principles or an inheritance, like the post-45 order the US helped built. That's a fair line of inquiry, even if it's not a legal accusation.
SPEAKER_00Right. And you've captured my point there very well, in that I'm not talking about some law, some specific law that's been broken. So to take what Hugh said there with respect to the old law, there were three or I think three components to what treason could be. So war against the king or the crown or the nation was one. Giving comfort or aid to the enemy was another. And then there was this intent to imagine or act to create the death.
SPEAKER_00Of the king. That latter one's not applicable either. We're talking about the second one there. We're talking about aid and comfort to the enemy. So now, in my construct here, the picture that I have been painting is that we have a U.S. leadership that drives the West and the global rules-based order and how it's all functioning. And we also understand that treason is to act against your nation, if you will, to be a traitor to your nation. And so for the purposes of today's episode, we're going to assume that the U.S.
SPEAKER_00president leads not only the U.S., but the West and the global rules-based order. And it's my assertion that Donald Trump's actions are so anti-Western as to be treasonous. So now what I want to do is I want to go through some of those actions. And Hugh, we're going to discuss the degree to which they're treasonous to the West. Now, don't get overly excited about the order here. The point is that each of these things we talk about are damaging to the West's value system or global peace or prosperity.
SPEAKER_00So let's start off with the cancellation of USAI funding or support to UN aid agencies. Hugh, what has Donald Trump done in that aspect? Here's what we've got.
SPEAKER_01In his second term, Trump has repeatedly pulled back from the UN system and from foreign aid more broadly. On day one, he ordered a 90-day pause in review of all U.S. foreign development assistance. He restarted the WHO withdrawal and stopped funding, left the UN Human Rights Council, and formalized a halt to UNRWA funding. Then this January he ordered withdrawal from dozens of international bodies, including 31 UN entities. The practical effect has been a sharp drop in U.S.
SPEAKER_01support, for example, to the UN Refugee Agency, which has contributed to a major funding gap. The administration frames this as fiscal discipline and sovereignty. Critics see it as a retreat that weakens both humanitarian capacity and U.S. influence. So the factual piece is that the aid has been cut. The deeper question for our framework is what that retreat does to Western-led institutions and orms.
SPEAKER_01There are two different percentages, and it's important not to blur them. In March 2025, the State Department said it was canceling about 83% of USAID programs. But that is about programs, not total dollars. For overall spending, the OECD estimates U.S. official development assistance fell 56.9% in 2025 compared with 2024. That's a very large drop. And the OECD attributes most of the rich country decline to the United States.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's stop there. Now, what has the impact been on the global south on nations that rely on U.S. aid and UN aid?
SPEAKER_01Broadly, less health care, less food assistance, weaker disease control, and more strain on fragile states, especially in parts of Africa. WHO has warned that cuts have disrupted essential health services ranging from HIV treatment to malaria control and vaccination. Aid groups have scaled back nutrition and emergency programs. Somalia is a current example, with UNICEF reporting widespread clinic closures. Strategically, when Western funding retreats, there is space for other actors to step in, which can shift alignments.
SPEAKER_01That's the counterpoint. Critics of that view argue that countries should become less aid-dependent, but the short-term shock has been severe. So in broad strokes, the global south has fewer services and more vulnerability, at least in the near term. Right. Whether that evolves into long-term instability or a permanent realignment away from Western influence is still playing out.
SPEAKER_00That was a good capture. Your point there about leaving room for other powers to step in is quite true. So China, Russia, other nations that could potentially provide or support the global south are doing that. And you see the SCO, the Shanghai Corporation Organization, led by China and Russia, and it encompasses a lot of Asian nations, and its main aim was to deal with the aftermath of the breakdown of the USSR. However, it's now become an alternative organization for the global south to look to in terms of creating support for the global south.
SPEAKER_00And when the US backs off and the UN backs off in terms of providing aid, it's only natural for many nations to turn to organizations like the SCO. That was number 10. Now you crossed into the UN there a little bit, so we'll cover that off in a second. Let's look at number nine. And I want to talk about the Ukraine's defense. When the Russia invaded the Ukraine, there was an initial surge of support for the Ukraine from Europe, Canada, and the United States. Talk about what Trump has done in terms of reducing his aid to the Ukraine in recent times.
SPEAKER_00Trump has shifted from U.S.
SPEAKER_01funded military and financial aid toward a model where Ukraine or European allies pay for American weapons. Early in 2025, U.S. aid allocations stopped while Europe increased theirs. And Trump briefly paused assistance in March. More recently, he's talked about clawing back earlier aid from Europe. But to be clear, this is not a total U.S. abandonment. American weapons still flow, and Trump has adjusted some pauses. He also just signed new sanctions on Russia.
SPEAKER_01The net effect has been a shift to a more transactional approach where Europe is bearing much more of the financial load for Ukraine's defense.
SPEAKER_00All right. But here we have the leader of the West not fully supporting the Ukraine. And you tend to see Trump referring to Putin and Russia in positive terms.
SPEAKER_00He's sending mixed messages to the Ukraine and to Russia in dealing with that war. And quite frankly, I find it to be treasonous to the notion of the global rules-based order. What we should be doing is fighting the aggression. It's a clear case of a breach of the global rules-based order when you're talking about Russia's invasion of the Ukraine, and something should have been done about it, much more than just having a transactional relationship with selling weapons to Europe and the Ukraine.
SPEAKER_00Radio, that one's highly debatable, and my perspective could take us days to discuss, but I'm going to keep that at number nine. Let's go to number eight now. So the U.S. used military forces to do law enforcement in stopping drug cartels in the Gulf of Mexico. And I'll also mention the arrest of Venezuela's president. So Hugh, tell us a little bit about what the U.S. did with using the military to stop drug cartels in the Gulf of Mexico and what it's still doing.
SPEAKER_00So what the U.S.
SPEAKER_01has done is treat drug interdiction as a military mission, not primarily a law enforcement one. Since 2025, the U.S. has used lethal force against suspected drug trafficking vessels in the Caribbean and the Eastern Pacific. The administration argues that drug cartels are terrorist groups and that military force is justified to protect Americans from these groups that traffic narcotics. Critics call it extrajudicial killing because suspected criminals who pose no immediate threat are normally arrested and prosecuted.
SPEAKER_01Then in January 2026, U.S. forces went far beyond interdiction. They captured Nicolas Maduro in Venezuela and brought him to the U.S. to face criminal charges. That is a major use of military force on another state's territory for what the U.S. characterizes as law enforcement. The legal justification is heavily disputed.
SPEAKER_00At the end of the day, what we have here is a blatant violation of the rules-based order, in particular the laws of war. This is destructive to the West's reputation with the global South. And that's why I list it in the top ten acts of treason that Trump has perpetrated on the Global Rules-Based Order. Let's go to number seven. Trump withdrew the U.S. from the Trans-Pacific Partnership in 2017. Tell us a little bit about that. This was one of his first big moves.
SPEAKER_01In January 2017, he pulled the United States out of the Trans-Pacific Partnership. That was a 12-nation pact covering around 40% of global GDP, aimed not just at tariffs, but at setting common rules on investment, intellectual property, state-owned enterprises, and so on. Trump's case was that these mega deals hurt American workers and that bilateral deals give the U.S. more leverage. His team framed withdrawal as clearing the way for better and fairer pacts.
SPEAKER_01Strategically, though, TPP was meant to anchor the U.S. in Asia and set rules without China. So the withdrawal signaled a step back from that role. The remaining countries went ahead without Washington. So the debate for us is whether that was protection of sovereignty or a strategic owned goal that ceded the rule setting space to others.
SPEAKER_00All right, let's stop there. So my big beef with the U.S. and Trump's action with respect to the global rules-based order and Western civilization is that leaving the TPP, the Trans Pacific Partnership, opened the door wide for China to step in as a power broker in the Pacific. And this was a major failing on Trump's part for the sake of the U.S. balance of trade. And I think it's short-sighted, very short-sighted, particularly if we ever end up in a war in the Western Pacific.
SPEAKER_00Right, let's move on to number six. Trump withdrew support for the World Trade Organization. Tell us a little bit about what he's done there. Not full withdrawal.
SPEAKER_01And that's important to distinguish. The U.S. is still a member, but Trump has sidelined it. His first term paralyzed the appellate body by blocking appointments, and his second term has kept that stance while leaning on tariffs and bilateral leverage instead. His administration's position is that WTO rules don't adequately deal with China's state-driven model, and that the U.S. shouldn't be constrained by a system it thinks is outdated. The counter is that when Washington bypasses or disables the referee, it weakens the idea that strong and weak states should play by a common set of trade rules.
SPEAKER_01The tension for our conversation is how a rules-based order functions when its most powerful sponsor prefers to act outside it.
SPEAKER_00This is damaging to both the rules-based order and the West's standing amongst the global South. Again, weakening the West. Again, a treasonous act from Trump in the context of Western civilization. All right, number five. Trump has sanctioned members of the International Criminal Courts. Tell us about his views of the ICC.
SPEAKER_01Trump's position fundamentally is that the ICC has no legitimate jurisdiction over Americans or Israelis. In February 2025, he authorized sanctions on ICC personnel, starting with the prosecutor Karim Khan. The sanctions list has since expanded to multiple judges and prosecutors. The court says that this undermines judicial independence and accountability for war crimes. Trump urged countries to pull out of the ICC altogether. So this is a direct clash between two principles: national sovereignty on one side and international accountability for atrocity crimes on the other.
SPEAKER_01One clear example is ICC prosecutor Karim Khan. In February 2025, Trump sanctioned Khan after the ICC sought arrest warrants for Israeli leaders. His administration said that was necessary to protect U.S. and allied personnel from what they called illegitimate jurisdiction. So the sanction wasn't about personal misconduct, but about his official acts as ICC prosecutor.
SPEAKER_00But what actually was the sanction? Was it just a verbal tongue lashing or was it actually some measure that he took against this person? It was not just sharp words.
SPEAKER_01The order blocks any property or financial interest Khan has under U.S. jurisdiction, bars most transactions with U.S. persons, and it can restrict entry into the United States.
SPEAKER_00Now, the ICC is there as a mechanism. Let's go back to Churchill's quote, remember. We need a method by which to enforce our rules. Otherwise, we're just not going to have a rules-based order. So that's why I list this as one of Trump's treasons. Let's move on to number four. Trump has threatened Denmark's sovereignty over Greenland or Greenland's independence and applied tariff pressure to allies.
SPEAKER_00And he's also had quite a bit of rhetoric on making Canada the 51st state. So basically, he has been targeting his own historic allies. Tell us a little bit about those things, Hugh.
SPEAKER_01On Greenland, Trump repeatedly raised the idea of the United States taking control of Greenland. And at one stage, did not rule out the use of force or economic pressure. In January, he threatened additional 10% tariffs on eight European NATO countries, rising to 25% until they agreed to sell Greenland to the United States, but later dropped the tariff threat. And Trump, Denmark, and Greenland signed a negotiated agreement expanding U.S. military presence, but no transfer of sovereignty.
SPEAKER_01Now Canada is a different situation. Trump has repeatedly suggested Canada should become the 51st state, which Canada has flatly rejected. He has paired that rhetoric with very high tariffs on some Canadian imports, though not explicitly as a condition for annexation. The strategic concern you're flagging is that this kind of pressure or language can erode trust among allies, and analysts do argue that this creates openings for rivals. That's the tension between sovereignty and coercion inside an alliance system.
SPEAKER_00Right. So let's talk about that alliance very briefly. We're talking about the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. So NATO, the US, Canada, and Western Europe have created this defense alliance in response to Russian aggression in the post-World War II era. And we've been acting as allies for decades. Now, Trump's actions of late, these in particular, reflect a threat to sovereignty. And we need to remember that NATO's fundamental principle is that an attack on one nation is an attack against them all.
SPEAKER_00But what happens when that attack comes from within, which is what is happening with Trump and NATO? You have any comments on that, Hugh? Yes.
SPEAKER_01NATO was built to deter external aggression. Doesn't really spell out what happens if one ally threatens another. That's just not what it was designed for. If an ally feels threatened, Article four allows for urgent consultation, but the real foundation is political trust. Once allies begin to doubt, that trust, deterrence weakens because credibility is what makes collective defense work. The United States has long championed sovereignty and collective defense. So the worry, as you put it, is less about a formal Article V scenario and more about corrosive effects on unity.
SPEAKER_00Correct. And that is why it is treasonous. He's basically acting against his own allied system. Right, moving on to number three. So Trump withdrew the U.S. from the Paris Climate Agreement. He did that in his first term. Biden put them back in, Trump came in for the second term, and he's done it again. Tell us about that.
SPEAKER_01Trump first announced a withdrawal in 2017, and the U.S. formally left the Paris Agreement in November 2020. Biden then rejoined in early 2021. On January 20th, 2025, Trump directed a second withdrawal. That became effective on January 27, 2026. So as of today, the United States is outside the Paris framework.
SPEAKER_00Let's talk about the so what's. What does that mean for climate change? UNEP has tried to quantify this. What is UNEP? The UN Environment Program. Okay. And what does the UN Environment Program try to do?
SPEAKER_01UNEP works to gather the science, supports policy, and helps countries coordinate on environmental problems.
SPEAKER_00How are they dealing with Trump's withdrawal from the Paris climate agreement?
SPEAKER_01UNEP is still doing what it normally does: tracking emissions, reporting the gap between pledges and what's actually happening, and urging higher ambition from remaining parties. In its 2025 emissions gap report, UNEP estimated that removing the U.S. pledge adds about 0.1 degrees Celsius to projected warming this century. At the same time, UNEP is stressing adaptation and climate finance for vulnerable countries and signaling that multilateral cooperation continues despite the U.S. exit. So it's not treating the withdrawal as if the process ends, but as a shortfall that others need to try to make up.
SPEAKER_00So now what we're doing here is we have a leader of the world, the United States, withdrawing from a framework that is intended to look after the health of this planet. Now, whether you agree with climate change, believe in it or don't believe in it, and quite frankly, I find it incredible that there's still people out there who are dismissing the evidence that there's climate change. If there's a risk of climate change, as I talked about in recent episodes of this podcast, then we should be mitigating the risk.
SPEAKER_00In other words, doing something to remove the chance of something catastrophic happening. And that's what the Paris Climate Agreement is about. It's about reducing the impacts of climate change, the consequences of climate change. When the US withdraws, that's a leader withdrawing. That sets the tone for other nations. And so we have a failure to lead from the U.S. And I think it's treasonous towards the health of the globe.
SPEAKER_00And I think it's treasonous to the status of the West amongst the globe. Right, moving on to number two. Trump withdrew from the World Health Organization. Tell us what it does and what that means for the planets and for the World Health Organization.
SPEAKER_01The World Health Organization basically coordinates international health work, disease surveillance, outbreak response, vaccine standard, sharing data across borders. With the U.S. withdrawal, WHO lost its largest donor, roughly 18% of its income. That forced immediate cuts to programs on polio, HIV, tuberculosis, and immunization. And because disease crosses borders, the concern is that weaker surveillance and response capacity abroad can translate into delayed detection and higher risks for everyone.
SPEAKER_01The administration contends that WHO mishandled COVID-19 and that the U.S. was paying too much. So for our purposes, the consequence is pretty clear: less money and less American influence in global health coordination.
SPEAKER_00Right. And we need to remember that the World Health Organization is one of those organizations or bodies that are part of the global rules-based order in terms of making things better for people, better prosperity, better health, better living conditions, better standard of living. So when the US left that, the US stopped leading that body. And there was also some action domestically that he did in terms of the CDC. Tell us what Trump did to his own health system by reducing funding and support for the CDC.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and it's helpful to separate two pieces. In March 2025, Trump's Health and Human Services Department announced large workforce reductions, about 2,400 positions at CDC, with the administration describing that as streamlining and refocusing on core outbreak response. On the budget side, Trump's FY 2026 proposal saw roughly a$1.2 billion reduction in CDC discretionary funding on a comparable basis. Whether one sees that as prudent or risky depends on how you weigh preparedness against cost.
SPEAKER_01But the practical fact is fewer people and less funding means certain CDC functions get scaled back. Surveillance, some research, grants to state and local health departments. Infectious disease works like climate in one key respect. It doesn't respect political or National boundaries.
SPEAKER_00All right. So you said$1.2 billion. What was the budget before that?
SPEAKER_01On the comparable basis we were talking about, the CDC's budget is about$5.56 billion in FY 2025. The proposed FY 2026 level was about$4.32 billion. That's the roughly$1.2 billion, about 22% reduction. Just keep in mind that comparable caveat. A few CDC programs were moved elsewhere, so those top line figures don't capture every related health activity in the federal government.
SPEAKER_00Okay, let's stop there. And now the number one thing I think that Trump has done, which makes his actions treasonous to the West in the global rules-based order, are his views and attacks on the United Nations. Now you mentioned a little bit about that earlier on, but I want you to run through a few of the things that Trump has done which has denuded the effectiveness of the United Nations.
SPEAKER_01There are a few. In February 2025, Trump ended United States participation in the United Nations Human Rights Council and continued the halt in funding for the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine refugees in the Near East. He then moved toward another withdrawal from the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization. And in January 2026, he went further directing the United States to withdrawal from or cease supporting 31 United Nations bodies.
SPEAKER_01Then there's the money side. By April 2026, unpaid assessments overall had reached about 6.6 billion United States dollars. That shortfall forced cuts in staff and peacekeeping operations. Now, Trump says this is about sovereignty and waste. The counterpoint is that when the country that helped design the system steps back, capacity falls, and U.S. leverage inside the system also falls.
SPEAKER_00All right. That's a very short description of a huge problem. The fact of the matter is the United States is no longer back in the United Nations, and the United Nations was already struggling to deal with the differing views that are happening within the Security Council. Now, the Security Council is the body that is responsible for collective security. Tell us a little bit about the Security Council and what the U.S. has been doing in there.
SPEAKER_01That Council has 15 members and carries what the UN Charter calls primary responsibility for international peace and security. The permanent five each have a veto. The veto has always been a weakness. Russia uses it on Ukraine, Washington uses it on Israel and Gaza. Under Trump, the U.S. cast solo vetoes on ceasefire resolutions. But Washington also used the Council when it chose to, introducing a Ukraine resolution in February 2025 that passed but drew European abstentions, then a Gaza plan in November 2025 that was adopted.
SPEAKER_01So the United States hasn't walked away from the Council. The deeper worry in your framing is whether using that power in a more national, transactional way weakens collective security rather than reinforcing it.
SPEAKER_00Right. So the whole point of the United Nations was to establish a body that would support the betterment of the globe, the whole globe. And what we have here is one of the key leaders of the United Nations acting in its own self-interest. Now, you could argue that the five Security Council members have been doing that from the outset. But if you look back in history, you see that the United Nations has in fact acted for the good of the globe in many occasions.
SPEAKER_00We just haven't seen much of that in terms of security over the past decade or two. Hugh, one was the last Chapter 7 UN action, and what was it?
SPEAKER_01If by Chapter 7 action we mean the last time the Security Council authorized major military force, the closest fit is Libya in 2011. Resolution 1973 authorized all necessary measures to protect civilians, which opened the door to the NATO intervention. All right. The council has continued to take Chapter 7 measures since sanctions, embargoes. But if your focus is the big military intervention against the state, Libya is the last clear case.
SPEAKER_00That was a great example, the Libya one. So 2011 is the last time the United Nations has authorized the use of force to enact a security resolution. So here we are, 15 years later, and there are multiple wars raging on this planet, and the UN has been unable to initiate Security Council measures to stop those wars.
SPEAKER_01Where the paralysis is real is on major geopolitical wars like Ukraine or Gaza, where veto politics has repeatedly blocked decisive collective action. So the accurate framing is the council still acts under Chapter 7, but often can't act decisively when a major conflict involves the vital interests of one of the permanent five.
SPEAKER_00Right. So that was very good. And that is in fact the case. And I think that the United States should be championing the organization that it helped create for the betterment of the planet. And that has had positive results for the West in terms of making the U.S. a global superpower. And that in turn is in large measure the reason why the U.S. has been such a successful and prosperous place to live.
SPEAKER_00So that's the top 10. Let's move on. I'm going to just quickly run through a few other things that the U.S. has done that add to this story. I didn't put them in the top 10. You could if you want to, but you know, the U.S. cut funding to the World Food Program. The U.S. has pulled out of uh United Nations climate funding. It's approved anti-ecology initiatives such as expanding offshore oil drilling, removing environmental review requirements for pipelines, it's approved pesticides banned in other countries, it's approved logging in protected U.S.
SPEAKER_00national forests. It's cut renewable energy research funds, all of these things under Trump. In terms of managing global health, the U.S. used to be world leading, but Trump has reduced the CDC's pandemic preparedness programs. For example, he canceled a$766 million Moderna contract to fight future pandemics, including bird flu, which is an issue today. He's blocked anti-smoking campaigns, he's slashed global HIV AIDS prevention funding, etc. His human rights record in domestic politics is also terrible.
SPEAKER_00But even more importantly, you have to wonder about the U.S.'s reputation with the global south in the aftermath of how it's treating its allies. For example, Trump ended humanitarian parole for Afghan allies. He ended special immigrant visa for Iraqi interpreters. He also reduced refugee admissions to near zero. And he's allowed deportations during active asylum claims, sometimes deporting people to conflict zones. Can you give us some examples of those last human rights things?
SPEAKER_00Yes, but I want to tighten a couple of things for accuracy here.
SPEAKER_01Trump has very sharply restricted humanitarian pathways. For Afghans, the administration moved to end or pause parole programs. And after late 2025, Afghan nationals were subjected to much tighter entry restrictions. Afghan special immigrant visas lost a broad exemption from those restrictions, but the long-standing special immigrant visa program for Iraqi and Afghan translators has not simply been abolished. On refugees, Trump set the fiscal year 2026 ceiling at just 7,500, the lowest in the history of the program.
SPEAKER_01That compares to roughly 100,000 refugees actually admitted in fiscal 2024 under Biden. On asylum, Trump has also sought to prevent people crossing the southern border from accessing asylum, which is now the subject of extensive litigation. One of the starkest examples you alluded to is third country deportations. In 2025, for instance, the U.S. deported a group of men to South Sudan, and others were sent to Kaswatini, places with which they had no personal connection.
SPEAKER_01The administration emphasizes that some of these individuals had serious criminal convictions and frames the policy as protecting Americans. But critics say it raises profound legal and moral questions, precisely because it involves refugees, asylum seekers, and in some cases, people who had helped the United States.
SPEAKER_00Again, you know, we're talking about human rights here, and we're talking about the way in which the West has led the world and is no longer leading the world. All right, now there are also a lot of U.S. politics going on. We're not going to get into too much detail, but what we'll do is we'll go through a few of the issues that could maybe lead to an impeachment. And so Hugh, I'll describe the issue very shortly, and you give us a one or two or three sentence description of what is going on with the issue. So number one, withholding money that was appropriated by Congress.
SPEAKER_01This is the impoundment issue. Under the Constitution and the Impoundment Control Act, the president can't simply refuse to spend money that Congress has appropriated. The GAO has found multiple violations by the administration, including over funding for the National Institutes of Health and for the Institutes of Museum and Library Services. For impeachment purposes, the argument would be that a systematic disregard of Congress's spending power might amount to a serious abuse of office.
SPEAKER_00Radio next is attempting to restrict birthright citizenship through executive order.
SPEAKER_01On January 20th, 2025, Trump signed an executive order seeking to deny automatic citizenship to U.S. burned children of undocumented or some temporary migrants. That immediately triggered constitutional challenges under the 14th Amendment. In June 2026, the Supreme Court ruled that Trump's order violated the 14th Amendment. So for an impeachment theory, the question becomes whether trying to alter a core constitutional guarantee by executive action constitutes an abuse of power.
SPEAKER_00All right, stop there. Okay. He's used troops for domestic law enforcement beyond their lawful authority. Tell us a bit about that.
SPEAKER_01The Posse Comatus Act generally bars the use of federal troops as domestic police. In Los Angeles in 2025, Trump federalized National Guard troops over the governor's objection and deployed Marines. A federal district court later found the administration violated the act by using troops in support of civilian law enforcement. The impeachment theory would focus on whether Trump used military force domestically in a way that exceeded statutory limits.
SPEAKER_00Give us an example.
SPEAKER_01In March 2025, Trump signed an executive order targeting Perkins Coey, a law firm that had represented political clients and causes that Trump opposed. The order restricted security clearances and government access, but a federal judge struck it down in May, finding unconstitutional retaliation and viewpoint discrimination. Similar orders targeted other law firms. So the potential impeachment theory here is that presidential powers were used to punish protected legal advocacy and speech.
SPEAKER_00We talked about this earlier, but the use of military hostilities without congressional authorization.
SPEAKER_01In June 2025, Trump launched strikes on three Iranian nuclear facilities without prior congressional authorization. The administration notified Congress after the fact and relied on Trump's constitutional authority. The constitution gives Congress the power to declare war while making the president commander-in-chief, and the line between those rules is heavily contested. The war powers resolution was designed to force shared decision making. So for an impeachment theory, the claim would be that Trump crossed that line, engaging in hostilities that required Congress's authorization, while his administration maintains it remained within presidential authority.
SPEAKER_00All right, the last one, let's talk about his use of the presidency for personal or family financial benefit.
SPEAKER_01The most striking current example involves cryptocurrency. Trump and his family have significant financial interests in crypto ventures, including World Liberty Financial and other Trump-branded digital assets. His financial disclosures show ongoing stakes, and at the same time, his administration has pursued policies favorable to the crypto industry. That generates conflicts of interest, but conflict isn't the same as proven corruption. Demonstrating a direct quid pro quo would require clear evidence.
SPEAKER_01So the impeachment question would be whether presidential power is being used to enrich the president and his family, not simply whether the Trump businesses are profitable while he's in office.
SPEAKER_00I'll get you to turn off now. All right. So we've come to the end of the lists and the things that Trump has done. And I'm going to summarize here over the next few minutes. So I think we need something to be done about what Trump and his administration, because it's not just Trump, his secretaries are part of this, what his administration has done. And in my view, who are we going to turn to? Where are we going to get this accountability?
SPEAKER_00The UN's not going to do it. NATO's not going to do it. And we can't rely on the United States government to do it. Certainly not while the Senate is under two-thirds majority of Democrats. And so we in the West should be talking about a special tribunal, kind of like the one we set up at Nuremberg after World War II. We need a tribunal that's going to be a panel of judges from Western society, judges who adhere to the Western value system.
SPEAKER_00And that tribunal should have the power to indict Trump, his family, and his departmental secretaries. And I'd love to see some accountability for those spineless lawmakers in the US government who have failed to stand up to Trump. But that's another podcast. I hope I've given you some food for thoughts. Of course, we're not going to see treasonous Trump tribunals, nor are we likely to see any successful court action or accountability for the Trump administration, certainly not in the next couple of years, and probably not even afterwards.
SPEAKER_00And you know how the US can stand by and watch Trump and his secretaries stab their NATO partners in the back, especially Canada, and how they could leave the Ukraine in the lurch defending themselves against an autocratic Russia. How could they pander to anti-West threats like North Korea and China? These are all beyond my comprehension. And while I get why an individual in the United States might have voted for Trump, because he promised to bring them prosperity in their specific circumstances, and he's very good at doing that, anyone who supports Trump should get out a history book and read about the Atlantic Charter and read about the foundation of the United Nations and read about what Churchill was crafting when he talked about the need for values and rules for the betterment of society that have to be enforced, otherwise they just don't work.
SPEAKER_00After all, it was that leadership in combination with global values that were aimed at peace and prosperity that made the US a superpower. That's what made the US great. Not an introspective, tariff fueled war against its allies. And to ensure the next generation understands the importance of that rules-based order and US leadership, we need to see accountability. There has to be a day of reckoning for Trump.
SPEAKER_00Trump and his treasons need to be judged, and if found guilty, executed, or at least spend the rest of his days dreaming about the golf course from his solitary confinement cell on Alcatraz, which he's refurbishing apparently. Radio, that's my rants for today. Next episode we'll return to our theme on artificial intelligence with part two looking at artificial intelligence errors. And in case you're wondering, my words today are all mine, not derived from AI.
SPEAKER_00If you enjoyed the podcast, please tell a friend, particularly if that friend is a Trump supporter. Thank you for listening.
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a hot topic. The technology promises much and presents many risks and challenges for individuals and society. This episode of Rescuing Reason covers the history of AI, the terminology...
This episode is part 3 of 3 on Carbon and Climate change. In it we explore the globe's response to climate change, particularly through the lens of COP 30 and COP 31 (COP = Conference of the Parties).
Europe sweltering; the Pacific Ocean at a record surface temperature; Australia's hottest August ever.... symptoms of the impact of Carbon. This episode continues the exploration of the relationship between Carbon and...
With Spain, France and Greece burning; Australia having one of its warmest winters ever; the Pacific Ocean El Nino Index at very high levels (some now calling it Super El Nino); and Polar ice melting like we've never...
What is a War Crime? You hear the media, politicians, just about everyone talking about war crimes associated with the Iran-US-Israeli (and Palestine) war. But do those pundits really understand the law? Quite often...