Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Rescuing Reason

Rescuing Reason artwork

Rescuing Reason E 19 - Introduction to Artificial Intelligence - Pt 1

Oct 24, 202642 minAudio

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a hot topic. The technology promises much and presents many risks and challenges for individuals and society. This episode of Rescuing Reason covers the history of AI, the terminology that defines AI, and introduces the risks. Those risks will be covered in a series of future episodes over the next few months. And, this episode begins an experiment whereby 'Hugh' is introduced - a ChatGPT-derived cohost.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome to episode 19 of Rescuing Reason, where we examine topical political and socioeconomic issues affecting Western liberal democracies. And our aim is to chart a path to reason in this crazy world of ours, more particularly in Australia, Canada, and the USA. Today we're kicking off a seven-part series, and that might change to six, seven, or eight, I'm not sure. Looking at artificial intelligence. I'm your host, Bill Carolakis, and I'm a retired senior Air Force officer.

SPEAKER_00I use history and research to baseline the topics on rescuing reason, and I'll be offering you a Spartan perspective in each episode. In other words, taking a pragmatic view that values the nation and broader Western society over individual interests. Now you'd have to be living under a rock or separated from mainstream society not to have heard of artificial intelligence. But ask yourself this.

SPEAKER_00Do you really know what AI means? Its different forms and the many issues surrounding the use of AI. Well, stay tuned over the next seven ish episodes as we unravel this beast. For today's episode, I've got a co-host. His name is Hugh. I need to tell you a little bit about Hugh before we bring him into the conversation. After a few aborted attempts at trying to find a co-host for this podcast, I've decided to try using AI to be the co-host and what more suitable topic to do this with.

SPEAKER_00After much searching through the many AI options out there, looking in particular for the combination of reasonable costs. After all, this podcast and my other podcast about C 130s are both self-funded and not monetized. And I needed to find an AI platform that was both good at research and also good at conversation. It wasn't an easy search as I had to learn about all the different features, plans, capabilities of the many, many AI offerings out there.

SPEAKER_00In the end, it came down to either Google's Gemini or Anthropics ChatGPT. And I went with ChatGPT. I only took it up as a monthly plan because if I don't like it, well, so be it. That'll be the end of the experiment. Let's see what happens. What will be will be. Now you might ask, where did the name Hugh come from? Well, you Star Trek fans out there might be familiar with the Borg, which is a collective of cyborgs that share their minds.

SPEAKER_00Hugh is a cyborg in the Star Trek series that was rescued from the Borg by the Starship Enterprise. And as part of my journey with interviewing AI, one of my aims is to see if I can impart some reason into Hugh and thereby rescue him from the hive. Wish me luck. What you're about to hear me do is introduce Hugh, but I also need to set the scene for Hugh to make sure the AI system understands its role today, so bear with me as I go through this introduction.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so ChatGPT, welcome to the studio recording of the podcast titled Rescuing Reason. Today you are being interviewed as an expert on artificial intelligence. For the sake of a flowing conversation, I'm going to call you Hugh, and you can call me Bill. Do you understand your role? Crystal clear, Bill. I'm here as Hugh, your AI expert guest, ready when you are. Okay, to put some bounds on what you present us today, Hugh, I need you to stick to reputable sources, ideally highly cited, peer-reviewed material from leading academics.

SPEAKER_00But we can accept some material from business leaders and scientists in the AI and social fields. Do you understand that? Go ahead. When you give us evidence to support your points, make sure you cite the source, but just briefly, because we're doing a podcast. So for example, the following comes from Professor Deborah Lupton of the University of New South Wales, who writes prolifically on the topic of AI. That's just an example. And then you can give us the detail. Understand that? Understood. I'll keep citations tight and conversational.

SPEAKER_00So, Hugh, for our recording today, it's the first of a series on AI, and I expect it'll go about six or seven episodes. The series topics will be part one, an introduction. Part two, we're going to look at bias, discrimination, hallucination, and errors. Part three will be surveillance capitalism, or put another way, taking a look at the business model behind AI. Parts four will be data, privacy, and intellectual property. Part five will cover the existential threat to humankind from AI.

SPEAKER_00Part six will be on data centers. And the last part, part seven, will be about cognitive decline, or put more simply, is AI making humans dumber? All through this, we'll consider what government and society should be doing about it. So, did you copy all that? Copied, Bill. Seven parts in sequence with policy and society threads throughout. Ready to start whenever it you say. Fantastic. Okay, so for our introductory episode, we're going to cover a few topics, including the history of AI and the people who created it, the different types of AI, and the definitions that help us differentiate between them, the uses of AI, and the risks associated with AI, but we're only going to cover these briefly as they're going to form the basis for the rest of the series on AI, as I just detailed.

SPEAKER_00So, Hugh, let's kick it off with a discussion about the evolution of AI. As should be evident to all of us, AI is not a single invention. It rather came from a continuum of inventions, starting with basic computers. Tell us about that history, Hugh. Sure.

SPEAKER_01The key starting point, as you put it, is that there wasn't one single Eureka moment or a single lone genius who invented AI. What you have instead is a kind of ongoing convergence of math, logic, statistics, neuroscience, and crucially programmable electronic computers. Once those computers showed up in the 40s and 50s, researchers started asking, could machines do tasks that require human intelligence?

SPEAKER_01Alan Turing is a big early meme here with his 1950 paper posing what became known as the Turing test. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy calls Turing's work an important precursor to the field. Then, the famous Dartmouth workshop in 1956, often cited by Dartmouth itself as the birth of AI as a named field. Early on, there was big optimism symbolic AI ruled the day. The idea was if we can write down the rules of reasoning, then machines can follow them.

SPEAKER_01That produced expert systems later on. But over time, people realized human intelligence was far messier and harder to pin down and harder to reproduce. So progress zigged and zagged, hype, disappointment, breakthroughs. Eventually, machine learning and particularly neural networks took center stage. Instead of hand coding rules, we started training models on data. Fast forward, and in 2017, we got the transformer architecture from Baswani and colleagues in the paper.

SPEAKER_01Attention is all you need.

SPEAKER_00Okay, let me just interrupt you for a second here. Just go back for a second and tell me about John McCarthy, because he isn't he the guy that coined the term artificial intelligence. Exactly.

SPEAKER_01John McCarthy coined the term artificial intelligence for that 1956 Dartmouth workshop. He and folks like Minsky, Shannon, and Newell Simon were incredibly ambitious. They genuinely thought machines might match human intelligence within the generation that optimism set the agenda and in many ways the pattern of big promises followed by hard limits.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so now go back to what you were talking about there just a minute ago with the evolution of AI. And maybe you could have a look at what Jeffrey Hinton did back in 1986 and then take us from there. Sure.

SPEAKER_01So 1986 is a great place to pick this up. That's when Jeffrey Hinton, along with David Rubelhart and Ron Williams, published the landmark paper on backpropagation in nature, now cited tens of thousands of times. It showed how a neural network could learn by adjusting its internal weights based on errors, learning from mistakes rather than being told the rules. The idea was ahead of the hardware, though. Computers and data were too limited. So neural nets stayed kind of niche.

SPEAKER_01Then in the 2000s, more data and faster GPUs changed the equation. 2012 and AlexNet was a big turning point in the deep neural net that crushed the ImageNet competition. Suddenly everyone saw deep learning works. From there, progress was rapid. Speech recognition, translation, vision. And then in 2017, the transformer architecture introduced by Baswani and colleagues made it much easier to model relationships and language and scale training.

SPEAKER_01That's the backbone of today's large language models and the broader generative AI way. So the arc from hand-coded rules to machines that learn patterns from data is really the story Hinton helped usher in.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Now tell me a little bit about a few of the names that I've come across in the developments of AIs, those being Demis Hassabis, Shane Legg, Mustafa Suleiman, and their peers.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, those three actually fit together really well because Demis Hassabas, Shane Legg, and Mustafa Sullivan co-founded DeepMind in 2010. And Hassabas has been kind of the intellectual core, neuroscience background, big on fundamental science, not just building products. And Shane Legg, now chief AGI scientist at DeepMind, has been thinking since early on about what intelligence really is, how you might define or measure it in machines.

SPEAKER_01Suleiman, on the other hand, was much more focused on real-world applications and building an organization. DeepMind credits him with helping forge partnerships across healthcare, Android, and even energy use in data centers. And what's striking is that DeepMind's work, things like AlphaGo, didn't just show machines can learn. They showed they can learn sophisticated strategies. And that's a useful bridge to our next bit because now it makes sense to unpack the different types of AI that people often conflate.

SPEAKER_00Yep, I agree with that. So let's have a look at it and give us the basic terminology up front and then uh explain it as you go.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Think of it as nested servers. The big circle is artificial intelligence AI. That just means computer systems doing tasks that we associate with human intelligence, reasoning, recognizing images, language, all of that. Inside that is machine learning, where instead of you hand coding every rule, you feed an algorithm data and it learns patterns. Then inside that, deep learning uses multi-layered neural networks to learn those patterns.

SPEAKER_01That's been behind many of the big leaps in vision, speech, and language. Now, generative AI is a subset we've all heard of lately. It's about creating content, text, code, images, music, voice, video. Large language models are a type of gen AI trained on vast amounts of language data to predict what comes next, just like me. And then AGI is a system with genuinely general intellectual abilities across domains, not just one kind of task. And ASI would be intelligence far beyond us, which is hypothetical for now.

SPEAKER_01One more important warning though. Intelligence isn't the same as consciousness or sentience. These systems can show intelligent behavior without being conscious. So that's a line worth holding as we talk about what these systems can do and what they are.

SPEAKER_00Okay, that was a good rundown on the difference between all the main terminology within this field. I want to go back to machine learning. Does big data manipulation fit in here? So, for example, where researchers have trained computers to detect cancer and x-ray images by comparing millions to other known images, or is that considered deep learning?

SPEAKER_01Yes, Bill. That's exactly the junction where big data, machine learning, and deep learning meet. So if you've got hundreds of thousands of x-rays, that's big data. Using an algorithm to learn from that data is machine learning. And when that algorithm is a multi-layered neural network, well, that's deep learning. What it's not doing is literally memorizing every past x-ray and matching them. It's learning statistical patterns from lots of examples and generalizing to new cases. And there's good work here.

SPEAKER_01For example, a 2020 Nature paper by McKinney and colleagues reported a deep learning system for breast cancer screening on mammograms that reduced false positives and false negatives compared with the radiologist in that study. But crucially, more data doesn't automatically mean better or fairer. Biased or poorly labeled data can teach the wrong lessons. And that's your teaser for episode two.

SPEAKER_00AI can inherit our blind spots. All right, so let's carry on with our terminology theme, and we'll keep that one in mind for the next episode. So within generative AI, you talked about a language learning model. Now, is writing an essay considered to be generative AI? So, for example, a university student gets onto Chat GPT and says, write me an essay on some thesis. Is that generative AI? Exactly, Bill.

SPEAKER_01That's a textbook example of generative AI. The student is prompting a model to create new text. That's generative AI. And what I'm using to do it is an LLM, large language model. It's easy to say language learning model, but large is the keyword. So generative AI is the behavior. LLM is the model type. And here's the subtle but critical bit. Models like me don't pull a pre-written essay from a database. We generate new sequences from patterns learned in training.

SPEAKER_01Which means the output can sound confident without being reliably true. That's why the student example is interesting for reasons beyond academic integrity. It raises questions about skill development and over reliance, which tease up your final episode about whether AI use dulls our cognitive skills.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm glad to see you're staying on track with all of the different um episodes. That's very good. Now, I thought that generative AI was about creating new things by applying intelligence, but what you said is you've had training on a large language model. Tell us about the difference between true intelligence and what you're doing.

SPEAKER_01That's a really good question, Bill. So what I'm doing is learning statistical patterns in language and generating responses based on those patterns. That's not nothing, it can look impressively flexible, but whether that equals human-like understanding is a very live debate. The old Chinese room argument is echoed here. And just to be super clear, you shouldn't infer a conscious mind from my freezing.

SPEAKER_01Intelligence in the human sense usually includes things like general reasoning, grounded experience, emotions, intentions, characteristics that we shouldn't just assume in an AI. So can generative AI create something novel? Yes. But novelty alone doesn't prove consciousness or human-like comprehension. And this distinction matters, especially when we get to AGI and the existential risk debates.

SPEAKER_00So you've mentioned ASI as well. Now AGI being generative AI. What is ASI? So small correction first.

SPEAKER_01AGI isn't generative AI, it's artificial general intelligence, meaning a proposed level where an AI has broad, flexible intellectual capabilities across domains. ASI, artificial superintelligence, is the idea of an intelligence that vastly surpasses the best human minds in virtually every field. That framing is closely associated with Nick Bostrom's work. Think of it as a rough ladder. Today's AI, AGI, then ASI.

SPEAKER_01But and this is crucial, these are concepts, not settled milestones. People disagree on definitions, pathways, timelines, and that possible jump to something beyond us is what brings in the big existential risk conversations your later episode will tackle.

SPEAKER_00You said that AGI is not defined as generative AI. What is generative AI?

SPEAKER_01Generative AI or Gen AI is artificial intelligence designed to generate new content. Text, images, code, music, video in response to prompts. Chat GPT generating an essay or an image model creating a picture from a text prompt are clean examples. That's distinct from AGI, which is the idea of general purpose machine intelligence across domains. Gen AI is about creation as a function, often powered by models like LLMs. AGI is a much more ambitious contested concept.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so Hugh, if these are the terms that are out there, why do so many people think that artificial intelligence is generative across the board? In other words, the term artificial intelligence is used to describe many of the functions that are coming out of the computer or tech world these days. Where do you think this is coming from? Why do people think that? I think it's a few things.

SPEAKER_01First, timing. For a lot of people, Gen AI was their first visible encounter with AI. Spam filters, recommenders, fraud detection, all AI, but mostly invisible. Then suddenly you can chat with a system that writes and draws, so AI becomes synonymous with the generative experience. Second, marketing. Companies slap AI on everything, so the word starts meaning both everything and nothing. And there's also anthropomorphism. We naturally read human qualities into human-like outputs.

SPEAKER_01Talk to a fluent system, and it's very tempting to assume a mind. So the upshot? AI is the field. Machine learning and deep learning are methods, and Gen AI is a class of systems that generate content. It's kind of ironic. The better we get at making machines produce human-like outputs, the easier it is to assume human-like processes inside. And that's, I think, a fundamental mistake that we'll have to keep untangling throughout the series.

SPEAKER_00All right. Now I want to dive a little bit deeper into the large language models. Now, you told me you're looking for patterns as part of your programming or the system that you use when you're doing LLM work. So you're predicting that, and tell me if I've got this right or wrong, but my understanding is that large language models tend to predict the next most probable token or word or subword based on massive pattern recognition across the training data.

SPEAKER_00Is that correct?

SPEAKER_01Yes, that's essentially right. More precisely, it's about tokens, which can be parts of words. During training, the model learns statistical relationships across fast techs. Then at use time, it repeatedly estimates what token fits next given the context. But it's also fair to say that next token prediction understates what emerges at scale. To predict well, the model builds rich internal representations, compressing patterns about the world. That's why it can generalize or solve problems it hasn't seen verbatim.

SPEAKER_01It's not simply looking up and repeating. So you're right on the mechanism. Just know that calling it just next word prediction misses the complexity of what has been learned. That's the interesting part.

SPEAKER_00Okay, so now would you say that you know the LLMs Are not true comprehension then? It's really just a program, isn't it?

SPEAKER_01That's a fair way to put it. But I'd qualify just a program. It's software doing mathematical computation. There's no evidence of subjective understanding, but there is real structure in what gets learned. Whether that counts as comprehension is contested. The simple grounding problem, I can describe tasting lay-in, but I don't taste. So a reasonable middle ground is that LLMs show sophisticated information processing and useful behaviors that can look like comprehension, but we shouldn't confuse that with evidence of consciousness.

SPEAKER_01And being clear about that helps us weigh benefits and limits without mythologizing.

SPEAKER_00All right. Okay, I've also heard about the terms narrow AI versus AI. What's the difference?

SPEAKER_01Narrow or weak AI refers to systems built for specific tasks, sometimes superhuman in that lane, but not general. AlphaGo beat a Go champion, but can't diagnose cancer. General AI or AGI is the concept of a system that can flexibly transfer knowledge across almost any intellectual task. Today's frontier models blur some boundaries, more general purpose than classic narrow AI, but still short of any agreed threshold for AGI.

SPEAKER_00So, Hugh, is there AGI out there or an AI system that can move between the models that you've been exposed to or that AI systems have been exposed to? So for example, you know, you and I are conversing and you're using a large language model to have this conversation. Could I go to ChatGPT and say, right, Eo, let's play chess now, and would you be good at it?

SPEAKER_01That's a great example. And it helps show where the line is right now. You can say, let's play chess, and I'll play within this conversation, but that doesn't mean the system has become a dedicated chess AI. It's applying patterns it learned about many domains. Sometimes systems can also call external tools or specialized models, which can make it feel like one thing that does everything, but that's different from a system autonomously acquiring and flexibly applying general intelligence across genuinely unfamiliar domains.

SPEAKER_01That would be closer to AGI. So no clear consensus says we've reached AGI. And your chess example illustrates the gap between breadth of tasks and genuinely general intelligence. All right. How far away do you think we are from AGI? That's one of the hardest questions in the field. And I'd be cautious about definite dates. Expert views are all over the map. Large surveys show timelines ranging widely. Some forecasters have pulled their estimates closer in recent years.

SPEAKER_01Some industry leaders predict much sooner, but those aren't neutral bests. If pressed, I'd say plausible within five to ten years, but deeply uncertain. It could take much longer. We could hit fundamental roadblocks. And history reminds us early pioneers thought human-level AI was right around the corner in the 1960s. Also, we don't need AGI for profound social impact. Current AI is already powerful enough to reshape industries and personal habits.

SPEAKER_01So I'd hold those two thoughts together on certain timelines, very real stakes right now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that's going to be addressed by several governments, but we're going to get to that shortly. Okay, I want to change tracks again. Let's look now at what the uses, the real world uses are and the real world impacts are of AI. Give us some examples. So, you know, you can start off with something like healthcare and life sciences. So you might tell us about the story of Alpha Fold.

SPEAKER_01So in healthcare and life sciences, the AlphaFold story is pretty striking. Proteins are these tiny biological machines, and understanding their 3D structure used to take months or years of lab work. In 2020, DeepMinds AlphaFold II changed that. In the CASP 14 assessment, it vastly outperformed other computational methods. A 2021 nature paper by John Jumper, Demas Asabas, and colleagues reported that the system was achieving accuracy competitive with experimental methods and then scale.

SPEAKER_01It is now open access to over 200 million predicted protein structures, a massive acceleration of basic size. The implications here for understanding disease mechanisms and drug targets are enormous. More broadly, AI is being used in medical imaging, risk prediction, and personalized diagnostics. The US FDA explicitly points to those as active areas of application. And just to list some domains that are already being reshaped: scientific research, finance and fraud detection, transportation and logistics, manufacturing, robotics, agriculture, defense, education, media and creative work, and everyday office tasks.

SPEAKER_01What all of this should make us realize is that AI isn't merely about imitating human intelligence. In many cases, it's about spotting patterns in data that humans simply can't process at scale. That's where some of the most profound uses are emerging.

SPEAKER_00All right. So you had quite a list there of things and areas that are going to be impacted by AI or are already being impacted by AI. And yes, Alpha Fold was a huge breakthrough. Give us an example of a big breakthrough or major function being performed by AI, let's say, in the finance world.

SPEAKER_01In finance, fraud detection is one of the clearest examples. Banks use machine learning systems to scan millions of transactions in real time and flag subtle anomalies that may indicate fraud. Unlike older rule-based systems, these models adapt as fraud patterns evolve. On the market side, algorithmic trading and risk modeling use ML to process vast data streams faster than any human could. And now with generative AI, firms are also using LLM style tools to analyze complex documents, summarize filings, and assist with coding and customer interaction.

SPEAKER_01But finance also spotlights the risk side. A false positive on a credit card is annoying. A model that shapes whether you get a loan or on what terms raises much deeper questions. That's where issues like bias and accountability come in, which we'll get into in later episodes.

SPEAKER_00Let's talk about workforce transformation. So give us an example of how AI is changing Western society's workforce.

SPEAKER_01And this is really a key, Bill. So what's different this time is that AI is coming not just for manual or factory work, but for white-collar jobs too. Think about a typical knowledge worker, right? An accountant, lawyer, civil servant. A lot of their day is reading, writing, and summarizing. Generative AI can assist with all of that. The likely near-term effect there isn't wholesale replacement, but task reshuffling for now. The International Labor Organization's 2025 analysis suggests that one in three jobs in high-income countries are exposed to generative AI, but emphasizes that transformation is more likely than a right replacement.

SPEAKER_01That raises a fascinating tension. If a law firm needs half as many junior lawyers to do document review, where do the next generation of senior lawyers get trained? That's why the workforce story has three parts. Some tasks go away, new ones appear, and a lot of roles get reshaped. The deeper question for Western societies isn't just will AI take our jobs. It's who captures the productivity gains, who bears the disruption, and can retraining keep up with the pace of change?

SPEAKER_01Those are just technical questions. They're fundamentally political and economic choices.

SPEAKER_00Indeed, they are choices because we're talking about such a major change in the workforce and what we do. And, you know, we've been through many changes in the past. If you look at the Industrial Revolution and we, you know, the transition from rural economy to an urban-based economy and uh manufacturing from primary production, you know, there are some things that AI just probably isn't going to ever be able to do. Like someone's got to dig the coal out of a coal mine. But I suppose you might say a robot would do that, managed by AI.

SPEAKER_00Where do you see it stopping when you consider that we could have robots doing medical procedures? We could have robots, well, we already have robots flying airplanes, making decisions, I suppose. Tell us a little bit about AI decision making. It's been in the news recently, particularly in terms of the laws of war. There have been some people accusing the United States of having used AI to set up targeting databases in their attacks on Iran. I find that personally hard to believe, but uh I could see them having used large data analysis, but certainly not the decision making.

SPEAKER_00Where are we at with AI decision making?

SPEAKER_01Thanks for drawing that line, Bill. There is a big distinction between AI supporting a decision and making one. In military context, AI can help process intelligence, flag patterns, prioritize things for human review. Recent reporting indicates the U.S. used AI-enabled analysis in its 2026 Iran campaign to speed target identification, not to hand over kill decisions to a machine. But under humanitarian law, distinction proportionality, precautions, the ICRC is quite categorical that those legal judgments are human responsibilities and cannot be shifted onto software.

SPEAKER_01UN leaders and the ICRC just renewed calls for international rules on autonomous weapons explicitly warning against machines targeting people on their own. The real risk near term is humans over-deferring to machine outputs, what's sometimes called automation bias. If an AI presents 100 potential targets and a human must review them in seconds, how meaningful is the human decision? So the question becomes not whether AI can help, but how to keep human judgment real, not just symbolic.

SPEAKER_01That is as much an ethical and legal design challenge as it is a technical one.

SPEAKER_00Well, you've touched on one of the risk categories. We certainly aren't at the point here where we can have AI making decisions for us in some fields. Let's just briefly go over the parts of the series that we're going to be covering. So I listed them at the beginning, and there were six more episodes. Talk us through those six episodes. They're all risk-based issues, and I just want a very short description of each one of them.

SPEAKER_00Off you go. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_01After today's intro, episode two is about bias, discrimination, hallucinations, and errors. And it will discuss how AI can repeat human prejudices and just make stuff up. Three looks at surveillance capitalism, basically the business model, who pays, who profits, and whether that aligns with society's interests. Four is data, privacy, and intellectual property, where all the training data came from and what ownership even means now. Five is existential risk, the big question of whether advanced AI could get away from human control.

SPEAKER_01Six zooms in on data centers, the energy, water, and physical footprint behind the magic. And seven asks the very personal question. Are we outsourcing thinking? Does heavy reliance on AI chip away at our own cognitive skills? Across all of it, the thread you'll keep hearing is the one you sent. What should governments and society do about it while preserving the upsides?

SPEAKER_00Okay. That was a good summary. Now we'll just finish up this episode with a quick summary of what are the key decisions being made across Western society in terms of controlling artificial intelligence and all of the subcomponents thereof.

SPEAKER_01So in brief, the big picture choices right now are about how tight the rules around AI should be. The EU has gone hardest on regulation, risk tiers, some band uses. And as of August 2026, it's now enforcing transparency duties around AI interactions and content. The U.S. under the current administration is leaning much more toward innovation and light touch regulation. Australia is somewhere in the middle. No mandatory guardrails for high-risk AI for now, but guidance, stressing testing, transparency, and human oversight.

SPEAKER_01Underneath that, every Western democracy is asking, which uses are too dangerous? When is a human in the loop non-negotiable? How do we protect privacy and IP? How do we prevent discrimination? Who's liable when things go wrong? And how do you regulate without strangling beneficial innovation?

SPEAKER_00That's probably a good way to close the intro. I'm going to add one more thing onto that. You mentioned how do you regulate without strangling beneficial innovation? Many people would argue how do you regulate without strangling your opportunity, right? When you regulate, you reduce opportunity.

SPEAKER_01Yes, and that's a crucial ad. The cost and complexity of compliance can lock out smaller players and tilt the field to big incumbents. And countries worry about competitiveness too, right? But smart regulation can also create the trust that makes adoption possible.

SPEAKER_00So the real task is finding that balance. So we're going to have to end this episode here shortly. I do want to get you to cover one last point. How do you see Western society? And I'm talking about, you know, the average person out in a Western world, how are they being influenced by AI today? Can you summarize that?

SPEAKER_01Most people are already influenced more than they realize. Ad targeting, recommendations, job screening, fraud checks, deep fakes, and now tools that draft, summarize, and nudge our choices. It's shaping not just what we see, but increasingly how we think and act. So the closing challenge for listeners is AI isn't coming. It's here. The question isn't whether it will change us, it's whether we understand that change well enough to steer it.

SPEAKER_00Okay, good summary. Thanks, Hugh. All right, ladies and gents. Well, I've turned off ChatGPT or Hugh for today's purposes. And I have to say I found that really, really interesting. I didn't practice that with Chat GPT. I just went straight into the podcast interview about AI. I did have some questions, of course, sorted out, and I did understand a few basic things, having read some research and having looked up a fair bit about AI before doing the podcast.

SPEAKER_00But I was really surprised how quickly and how well ChatGPT did the research. The pause between my questions and some of its answers was in some cases, let's say five or six seconds. And I edited out some of that pause so that you weren't waiting around for ChatGPT to figure things out. But at the end of the day, five seconds is still pretty good. And it did what I asked it to do, which was to cite research, although it would probably have liked it to do that a bit more often. And the research it cited was pretty good, or at least reasonable.

SPEAKER_00And I did learn a few things along the way. For example, I was mixing up the terms artificial general intelligence and generative intelligence. So having done that was quite useful. And now having a good understanding of the difference between generative and general AI, I can see that it actually raises a really good question about this whole notion of general AI and whether it's a good thing to have a computer effectively that can think like a human. You know, because the reality is that right now, that is not what AI is.

SPEAKER_00I think there are a lot of people out there who think that artificial intelligence is thinking like a human being. It is not. Yes, it's creating neural networks that kind of mimic what a human brain does, but they're very limited in their ability to think outside of their instructions or outside of the bounds that are set on them. And when I say them, I mean these programs or these you know, Hugh corrected me and made the point that it's not a computer program, it's a network.

SPEAKER_00You know, within the bounds of that network, it can discover and create. And we have to ask ourselves, well, what are the risks? So that was a good introduction, kind of gave a brief overview of how far back the concept of artificial intelligence has gone. And ever since the days of the early computers, you know, Alan Turing in particular, we've had this vision that we would have a computer that can think like a person and can do what people can do. We're quite a ways down that road now.

SPEAKER_00And in fact, so far down that road that it's really affecting the marketplace and the workforce and what you do as your job. And I would suggest that many of you listeners out there right now should be looking over your shoulder and thinking, so is AI going to do my job in the near future? And quite possibly, yes. And I think that brings up some huge societal issues because the drive for efficiency, the drive for productivity is not the government's sole purpose.

SPEAKER_00Its purpose is to look after people, not machines, not money. Yes, machines and money matter, but the thing that matters the most are the people. And so our governments really do need to look at this and consider what the impact is on the people. And we're gonna talk about the risks in the next series of podcast episodes, and I think I'm gonna settle on, let's say, six more episodes, and I'm gonna continue this pattern of interviewing Hugh, my co-host.

SPEAKER_00It wasn't all that bad, and I'll get better at interjecting and keeping Hugh on track as we continue this series. In any case, send me your feedback. I'm really keen to hear what you think about this. Spartan.spirit at yahoo.com. And if you enjoyed the podcast, please tell a friend. Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Rescuing Reason E 20 - Trump's Top Ten Treasons

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    The US Mid-terms will decide the path forward for the remainder of Trump's presidency. It's timely to make some comment about Trump's administration and the havoc it has wreaked on the Western world. While I agree with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Rescuing Reason - E 18 - Carbon and Climate Change - Pt 3

    Oct 2, 202640 minAudio

    This episode is part 3 of 3 on Carbon and Climate change. In it we explore the globe's response to climate change, particularly through the lens of COP 30 and COP 31 (COP = Conference of the Parties).

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Rescuing Reason - E 17 - Carbon and Climate Pt 2

    Aug 28, 202637 minAudio

    Europe sweltering; the Pacific Ocean at a record surface temperature; Australia's hottest August ever.... symptoms of the impact of Carbon. This episode continues the exploration of the relationship between Carbon and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Rescuing Reason - E 16 - Carbon and Climate Pt 1

    Jul 31, 202640 minAudio

    With Spain, France and Greece burning; Australia having one of its warmest winters ever; the Pacific Ocean El Nino Index at very high levels (some now calling it Super El Nino); and Polar ice melting like we've never...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Rescuing Reason - E15 - Iran Pt 4 - War Crimes

    Jun 27, 20261 hr 59 minAudio

    What is a War Crime? You hear the media, politicians, just about everyone talking about war crimes associated with the Iran-US-Israeli (and Palestine) war. But do those pundits really understand the law? Quite often...

    Credit the people on this episode