Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Redefining Plastics

Redefining Plastics artwork

Unpacking California SB 54 with Joshua Baca of Resilient Partners

Apr 8, 202551 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of the Redefining Plastics Podcast, host Justin Riney welcomes back Joshua Baca, founder and CEO of Resilient Partners, for a deep dive into California's SB 54 and its impact on recycling and packaging legislation. They discuss the nuances of the bill, its implications for businesses and consumers, and the role of Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) in improving recycling systems. The conversation also touches on the broader landscape of recycling, federal and state policies, and the real-world challenges of achieving ambitious sustainability goals. Tune in to hear expert insights on navigating the complexities of recycling regulations and the future of plastic sustainability. Resilient Partners- Joshua Baca https://www.linkedin.com/in/joshuabaca/ https://www.resilientpartners.us/ Check out his Resilient Insights Newsletter and Podcast https://www.resilientpartners.us/podcast Redefining Plastics https://www.redefiningplastics.com/ https://www.brvind.com/redefining-plastics https://rss.com/podcasts/redefining-plastics-with-justin-riney https://www.instagram.com/redefining_plastics/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/justin-riney-mba-67685940/ https://youtube.com/@redefiningplastics?si=KvG4dTvY1lALbwIm

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Daddy's Podcast. This is the Redefining Plastics Podcast. Welcome to the Redefining Plastics Podcast. This is Justin Riney. We have our first repeat, repeat guest, Joshua Baca. So Joshua Baca is a resilient partner. He and I have done a lot of work together. We continued to do a lot of work together. And whenever I have questions on legislation, or any kind of advocacy stuff.

He's my go -to guy. So first off, thanks Joshua for joining. And I wanted to, for the people that haven't listened in the past, why don't you give a little explanation of who you are. Well, this has to be the record, right? Three times on one podcast. Thank you so much for having me. I'm Joshua Baca. I'm the founder and CEO of a company called Resilient Partners. We're a government and public affairs firm located in the greater Washington, DC area. And my background has largely been in government and politics. I worked on Capitol Hill for several years, presidential

campaign, agency world, trade association. And, you know, really the two things that probably make my credibility for the specific topic on this podcast was I was head of public affairs for the American Beverage Association, where I led their PET sustainability initiative and was head of the plastics division at the American Chemistry Council for several years as well too. So. That's a little bit about my background. It's a great day to be on. It's opening day baseball. It is. I know it's a big deal for you, for sure.

Oh, your Nationals. I'm a Nationals fan. You know, they're not probably going to win a lot of games, but I still get pretty excited about them. And my alma mater's playing tonight in the Sweet 16, so we'll see how that goes as well. So it's a good sports day in the Baca household, or at least for you. I don't know. I'm not going to speak for your wife if that's a good or a bad thing. You know, my wife's pretty good about this stuff. She roots for the nationals. There's no doubt about that. Maybe things I'm a little bit too obsessed with college basketball and

Texas Tech right now. But yeah, you know, I guess life will go on with her. So pretty supportive for the most part. And then you have your own podcast, which I've been on. And now you've been on this one three times. But a resilient insight for anybody that wants to learn a little more about advocacy world. Why don't you give just a little plug for that one? Yeah. The resilient insights podcasts were a little bit of a hiatus right now. We're getting ready to start season three this spring, but our first season really

focused on a variety of public policy issues that were defining the debates here in Washington. Our second season focused a little bit on the politics of the presidential campaign while we spoke to. political operatives across the country in the key battleground states. And the third one, I've got a few surprises that I'm looking on, but a little bit too soon to tell you what the third season will be about. But I'm looking forward to getting that started in earnest now that we kick into spring. Yeah. Well, good stuff. I always enjoy it. I learn something every time. And that's the goal of whenever I'm listening

to a podcast, I want to learn something. You can waste your time doing a lot of things. Might as well. gain something from it. 100%. You know, and I consume so much information via podcasts. Yeah. So I probably consume six podcasts a day, a variety of different topics from sports to news, sustainability to, you know, you name it. So it's a great platform to kind of educate niche audiences about specific topics, which I know we're going to do today. Yeah. And it's nice too, cause you can just kind of have it on in the background and in between calls, you just

hit. hit pause and move on to whatever I got to do, and then you can jump right back into it. It's great. I love them. I've been obsessed with them long before I've done my own. Yeah. Yeah, so kudos. Yours has come a long way over the last couple of months. Yeah, it's a lot of work, as you know, to set all this stuff up and to edit and make sure everything. But it's an obsession at this point, and it's my hobby outside of golf. So whenever I'm doing a hobby indoors,

it's probably making a video or a podcast of some sort for social media. But yeah, we've already talked about your take on what you think of with plastics twice. So I don't think we need to jump into that one again. So yeah, we were gonna talk today about California SB54 and then specifically EPR. as a vehicle to improve recycling for not just plastics, but for everything. And kind of

what that world looks like today, it's constantly changing, right? And keeping up with what's going on is hard. But you're our guy to keep up with this stuff. So I figured might as well let the audience know what you know. So why don't we start off with what is SB54? And then we can kind of break down what it is, what it's going to be, I guess, is where the next step will be. Well, the first thing I always say about SB 54

when you're reading the news is they call it an EPR law. And I like to say that it's not an EPR law. It's a packaging regulation bill or packaging regulation law with some EPR component. The bill or the law itself that was enacted in 2022. does a variety of things, but some of the main highlights are, one, it requires all packaging of material to be recyclable, 100 % recyclable by 2030. Two, it requires a 25 % source reduction in plastic packaging. And three, it creates a

$500 billion mitigation fund to clean up plastic waste in the environment. Along the lines with that, it applies fees to packaging via what would be a traditional EPR system where those fees are applied to packaging. You know, the consumer brands are typically the producers who pay the fees. And, you know, those fees are usually eco -modulated based upon a variety of pieces of criteria, recyclability, the use of recycled content, carbon footprint, you know, you name it. And you use those fees to collect, sort and

process more material, you know, largely try to improve the recycling system. There are some components of SB 54 that do that, particularly via the fees, but there's also a lot of confusion and a lot of angst over some of the broader pieces of the legislation and how those are going to be regulated and implemented. What's very unique about SB 54 compared to other EPR bills is that you typically require a producers or require the producers to come together. and create a

producer responsibility organization that oversees implementation of this. In this capacity, the regulators actually have a much stronger role than a traditional EPR where CalRecycle is overseeing much of the regulation, much of the implementation, with the producer responsibility organization known as a circular action alliance playing, I would say, as more of a supporting role in ensuring fees and other things are collected and processed through the system. So it's not your typical EPR bill. I know some people want

to talk about it as an EPR bill, but I think it's very first, the very first thing that's important to do here is to set the baseline. This is a packaging regulation bill. And this seeks to regulate packaging, particularly plastic packaging. And along the way, there are some EPR components. But the other thing I tell people is not all EPR systems are created the same. So this EPR system. does things that are very different than say what they do in Europe or in Canada, where there's bans and limits and

regulations and source reduction and a whole bunch of other things. So it's not traditionally how you would, you know, it's definitely not how I would design an EPR. Me either. Yeah, I agree. And so, but we are dealt with the law now and the major development that has occurred is that Governor Newsom has stepped in and kind of put a halt to some of these regulations and I know we're going to get into that, but that's kind of the state of play right now, where we stand in regards to SB 54. Yeah, really the only thing that's already been enacted within the

law is the EPS food service ban, right? There's all that stuff. It's going to be completely rewritten per Newsom. And so it confuses people, right? What do we do with this? How do we prepare for something that It seems like the conversation changes every couple of weeks of, well, it looks like they're going to do this, but now it looks like they're going to do this. And it's just, it's very similar to the tariff conversations that I'm having a lot right now. And toward these

and everything else where it's just a lot of uncertainty and it's really hard to run a business when you're uncertain. I think you hit the nail on the head. I mean, it is a very comparable debate to the debate going on regarding Kara. So there's a lot of uncertainty that's going on. California is a major market. Companies are not going to design packaging specifically just for California. They design packaging nationwide and ship it into California. And so what happened in California is going to have precedent setting actions across the nation. And we're seeing that

happen already with other states trying to be ambitious to enact EPR laws similar to California. The good thing is that Some states have took a much more moderate approach. Places like Colorado and Minnesota and Oregon have moderated their approach to EPR. It's more of what I would call that something that looks like a traditional EPR. Places like New York and Washington state and some others are debating things that could be even more ambitious than SB 54 in California. Yeah. There's a lot of uncertainty right now. If you're a business that's impacted in California,

You're probably throwing your hands up in the air right now trying to figure out what the next steps are. Yeah. And I think that's what everyone is trying to decipher today are like, what are the next steps or what does this mean? Yeah. And who knows when it's actually going to go into effect. It was supposed to be 2028, right? That's the next rate and date. And now I can't imagine that they're going to be able to hit that date if they're going to rewrite the entirety of the regulations. What do you think is driving that? Why do you think? this is happening right

now. Well, there's a couple of things that I think are driving this. Politics are playing a major role here. I think there's no secret about it that Governor Newsom has aspirations to run for president someday. He started his own podcast where he's talking to the MAGA crowd. He's taken a much more moderate tone on some issues in the state. But, you know, analysis that came out of CalRecycle itself showed that implementation of SP54 would cost the state $36 billion. and the average household about $300

a year. And so at an era of high inflation prices and inflationary concerns and economic concerns and stock market concerns and recession concerns and you know, you name it, I think he's rightfully looking at the political tea with leaves here and seeing that this could come back to haunt him. And the main thing he said in regards to the delay of the regulations was that it had a significant impact. The cost had a significant impact on small businesses and consumers. And

so it's hard not to read that the analysis conducted by CalRecycle, the agency responsible for implementation of this law, is making him pause for the moment and asking them to go back to the drawing board. And I think that's the right decision. That's a lot of money for a state with a lot of money at an era where consumers are rightfully concerned about the economy. Yeah, the idea that the packaging has to be 25 % recycled, just from a recyclability standpoint and recycle rates, there's not a lot of materials out there that meet 25%. Like glass

is not recycled at 25 % in the state of California. Nope. Like thin gauge paper is not. OCC is. So any of your cardboard is recycled at that rate. PET bottles, EPS transport packaging, all of that's going to hit the 25 % statutory rate. But everything else is going to be banned. So what are you going to do? How do you run an economy if you can't move stuff around? And that's going to be an interesting part of all this. Do they

look at that again? Do you think that they're going to revisit the rates and dates, or are they going to more revisit... timing and exclusions or call outs for small businesses. Well, one of the things that's pretty clear about the law is the rates and dates are set statutorily. So there's actually no requirement for regulations around rates and dates right now. You know, the things that they're debating in regards to this are costs for consumers and for small businesses. It's going to be who pays the $500 billion mitigation

fund and very specifically. Brands don't want to be the only ones carrying that cost. They think that resin producers and converters and other folks within the value chain should have to contribute to that $500 billion. I'm sure they do. Yeah. And it's a lot of money for them to carry. And then the third thing I think that's really kind of at play here is what is the definition of recycling and getting very specific around that. Do things like chemical and advances, chemical or advanced, depending on who you talk to, you

know, if you talk to some folks, you use advanced, you offend them, you know, chemical or molecular recycling as others call it, which is probably the more technical term, but the debate is really around whether or not those technologies are going to count and whether the law explicitly banned them or left the door open for them to be included. NGOs are arguing that the law explicitly banned them. If you read the law itself, it's. Kind of ambiguous to know whether or not those technologies are going to be allowed. And so there's a lot left to be interpreted via regulation

as to whether or not that's going to count. Now you might ask yourself a couple of questions like, why does that matter? Well, you've already made a great point, which is, you know, think about all the food packaging in particular that we use that material is to be 100 % recyclable by 2032. That's going to require the use of more recycled content. To produce food grade content, there are limits today when it comes to mechanical recycling. And food grade recycle content can be produced via advanced recycling processes. And so even to reach the high rates and dates

of 2032 and 2028 and the different milestones that kind of come in between them, you know, you're not probably going to achieve those rates and dates slowly on mechanical recycling. You know, mechanical recycling is going to work great for your PET plastic bottles and your high density polyethylene milk jugs and detergent containers and things that are already robust in a mechanical recycling process that have robust end markets that are being collected, sorted and processed today. But you know, when you think about other

materials, small formats, films, flexibles, foam, rigid containers, food containers, you know, a lot of those things today. have limits to how they can be recycled mechanically, either because they are contaminated with food, or they are difficult to recycle via a mechanical process. You limit a lot of those things via an advanced recycling process. So, that is a huge debate that is happening. There are two sides to this. If you are a consumer brand company who has made

commitments to achieve these recycling goals, You're probably understanding that you can't achieve that simply via a mechanical process. If you are a chemical or an advanced recycler, you're probably, you know, have invested billions of dollars to get to this point, whether you're Eastman or Exxon Mobil, or any of the other ones who are big players in this space right now. And so California is a major market to make this a reality and NGOs don't want it to count. And so the back door to that kind of really goes

back to your points. If these aren't going to count. we're probably going to end up with a ton of bans at the end of the day. Yeah, because I almost look at this ostensibly as a plastic packaging reduction bill from the spirit of it and how it was written. I agree with that. The actual execution and the regulations and the statutory requirements for rates and dates, there's going to be a lot of unintended consequences from that where The assumption was the recycle

rate for other products were going to be much higher than they actually are. And as you and I well know, it is very difficult to establish recycle rates in any state for any packaging material and format. Just because I don't have subpoena power. You don't have subpoena power. I can't go to these recyclers and tell them, you have to give me this data. And the law doesn't provide for that either. So there's no way that anybody what's in their best interest more than

likely to participate, but half the time they don't want to participate because it's proprietary for them and they don't want to get involved in it. So it's going to be a mess. Yeah, be a huge mess. And it continues to be a huge mess. And I think governor Newsom putting his foot down for lack of a better term here is a positive first step. I mean, There has to be noticeable change in his tone or there is noticeable change in his tone from when he held this as the most progressive anti -plastic landmark legislation

when he signed it into law to not saying it costs too much. Exactly. You know, one of the things that you see some of the NGOs saying is, well, we'll bring the anti -plastics ballot back. Well, I would be ecstatic to run that campaign. You know, $300 of additional cost on consumers per year to meet these goals plus. $36 billion in additional costs to the state. The campaign had to write themselves in this capacity, right? Right now, yes. It's an easy win for anybody that's against it. Yeah. And so I think that

the threat of a ballot initiative can always come back. I think that's even a higher threshold and unlikely to happen. What I think is likely to happen or what should happen and what is more likely to happen. is the legislation has areas where it's poorly written and the legislature need to go in and fix those things to make it more clear and pass additional legislation to provide greater certainty to some of the businesses that are going to be operating in the state of California. That would be a logical outcome here. But whether or not that actually happens, I think

is to be determined. Logic and legislation don't always go hand in hand. Do you know that? Very well. Those two words don't rhyme. Exactly. I completely agree. Cooler heads need to prevail. We need to, in my mind, the rates and dates either need to be extended or they need to be reduced. And I'm not saying that I want less recycling. I just think that we need to make it realistic. In the same way that we had, what, five... Six

years ago, every major brand came out and said there were gonna be so much percentage recycled content and they're going to reduce their plastic consumption by X. And then they realized after a while that that material and market doesn't exist yet. So how are we gonna do this? And I think that's what they're running into now in California. They're saying, how are we gonna make this work and make it so it's not? just going to lead to huge increases in costs, huge

deforestation efforts, because if everything goes to OCC, there's not enough recycled cardboard to meet demand for California. So you're gonna have to do more virgin cardboard, at least in the short term, until they build up the capacity. So there's some things here that I think they can do to stretch it out. Make it less onerous and then make it so it's actually reasonable and feasible into the state. And those rates and dates would need to be reset by the legislature.

Exactly. I don't think they couldn't be done via regulation. So there's an opportunity for the legislature to come through and see, you know, some type at the time, I guess, to take a step back. There was no pragmatism in the room. I was involved in a lot of those debates, was working on the issue extensively. Pragmatism was not. part of the debate. They want to be cutting edge, right? They want to be the leading edge of anything sustainable. And I think to be fair to them, their thought process, at least

when I'm talking to NGOs and legislators in California, it's we want to make it ambitious because we really want to drive change. And I get where they're coming from. And I think their hearts are in the right place. But putting the heart to the head, that part. just never, never occurred in this process because there weren't enough experts involved. Yeah. Well, I mean, what are those rates and dates based on? They're not based upon science. They're not based upon market conditions.

They're not based upon whether or not they're existing end markets. You know, part of the debate is this whole notion that if we could just spend a lot of money to collect material, everything will be good. Well, there's multiple steps in an integrated recycling process. It's not just collecting the material. It's processing it. It's getting it through a reclaimer. It's making sure there's a robust end market at the end of it. The reason they call it a circular economy is because there's multiple steps in that. So, you know, and so right now I think a lot of lawmakers

want to live and die on the fact that if we could just collect most of this stuff curbside as well, that everything will go on. Well, that's not going to work for something like EPS transport packaging, which is doing largely B2B or B2C. You know, you buy a Whirlpool washer, they come deliver it to my house, they unpack it, they take it, they set it up, they take the packaging back. They probably run it through their systems there, through something like a densifier and reuse their material. And we had to make sure

that that counts, you know? So I think that the thing that's really at stake here is the recycling system is in desperate need of innovation. And I don't even just mean that. in the context of advanced recycling. I think it's just a need of innovation and how we collect material, making sure we give consumers the maximum amount of opportunities to recycle the stuff they do. That we're thinking through how we develop robust end markets and that we're leveraging all the types of technologies that exist today. Whether that's, and it's multiple, right? It's mechanical,

it's dissolution, it's advanced recycling, it's molecular recycling. It's, you know, among those, those are a suite of technologies, whether it's pyrolysis, gasification, methanolysis, you name it. We should have all of those technologies at the table and they shouldn't be limited right now. There's so much noise and there's like, no matter what you say in California, like we are for more plastic recycling. I don't think there's any question. We want more of it to happen,

but we got to count what's actually being. recycled to your point today. Because the data that's out there and that's being thrown around, like I've talked about this a couple of times, there's 9 % recycle rate for plastics globally. That includes durable goods, that includes stuff going into cars, planes. We're not talking just packaging. And on top of that, if we're only allowed to claim the stuff that truly goes to a consumer

like your neighbor. If we can only count what goes to your house or your neighbor's house or their neighbor's house, that's disregarding hugely beneficial markets that are out there right now that are collecting material at the end of their useful life, which meets the FTC Green Guides regulation as being post -consumer. We got to be able to count that. And I think we just need reasonable people. to look at this and let's figure out how we can increase it. Because you

and I both agree, plastic recycling is real. We need more of it. It's happening. Yeah. And we want to support more of it. And we are doing that. You and I together within our trade organization, the Polystyrene Recycling Alliance, we are focused on this. But we need people to work with us. And we need the public -private partnerships like we talked about. What adds up for a healthy dose of reality of pragmatism here is when you're running for president. Exactly right. So suddenly your progressive bona fides take a back seat

to being much more pragmatic because the reality of it is, you know, having worked for politics, what resonates in California is not going to resonate in places like Ohio and Florida and North Carolina and Pennsylvania and a lot of the places that decide presidential elections today or where those early primary states are happening. And so. You know, not only is it something to run around the neck if you were to run the anti -plastics ballot initiative, but you know, on a campaign, you campaign through Des Moines,

Iowa for, you know, the nomination, the ad rights itself for Governor Newsom supporting something that increased costs on everyday goods for consumers by $300. And that's a lot of money today. I think consumers are like in this stuck in the middle. Everybody wants to recycle more. I don't know anybody who doesn't want to recycle. I just don't think they're wanting to bear the burden of additional costs. Now. You will hear from supporters of SB 54 that this was going to ultimately eliminate the costs with rate payers and all that sort

of stuff. But the own analysis from Cal recycle doesn't show that, you know, it shows that it's going to cost consumers is going to cost the state. So, um, the authoritative voice here is saying that. And it's contradictory to what a lot of NGOs and supporters of SP54 are saying. We know recycling is real, and plastic recycling is real, but it needs to expand, and we need to be better at it. What is holding back plastic recycling in the US, in your mind? How much time do you have? We got as much time as you want,

but how long are people going to listen is the question. I mean, there's so much that's holding back plastics recycling today. I mean, first off, Let's just start with some of the basics here. You have over 9 ,000 recycling jurisdictions today that recycle and tell you to do 9 ,000 different things. And so, you know, in some of the work we're doing, you know, we see recycling rules that say we take one through seven, but we don't take styrofoam. And styrofoam is part of six or whatever. It's confusing. There's a

significant amount of confusion today. around what is considered recyclable, what is not considered recyclable. So, you know, streamlining that 9 ,000 jurisdiction should be a federal priority. Now, the federal government doesn't need to come in and create a federal recycling system, but some standardized rules via something like the EPA would be a positive first step to streamlining the 9 ,000 jurisdictions to making sure that more plastics get recycled today. The second thing is, you know, a ton of people today still

don't have a blue bin at their house. TRPs doing some work in that. And there's a lot of other great organizations out there that are pushing that. Great organizations have done great analysis on that. I think it's somewhere you could fact check me later, but you know, something like 40 % of Americans still don't have access to a blue bin. I mean, that's crazy. I know where my mom lives in New Mexico. She wants to recycle, but they only give her one bin. There's no recycling available for her. So that largely plays out in areas with rural. populations where it's densely

populated, you know, where there's big gaps. You have recycling blue bins in a variety of locations and like big cities. But as you get further out of the city, the center of the city, recycling becomes a little bit more difficult for you. I think the third thing is that while everybody needs a blue bed, you don't have to live and die by the blue bed as well. There's a lot of other ways that you can recycle material. You know, you could do store drop -offs, you could do. Look at the great work Cyclix is doing in Houston and in the Fort Worth area. Secondary recycling facilities. Secondary recycling facilities.

Give consumers the ability to put everything in a bag and drop it off somewhere. I would do that. I know a lot of people do that. Put all the plastics in a bag and drop it off somewhere. The fourth thing is technology hasn't kept up. And so it's hard to sort material today when we have single stream recycling here in the United States. It's easy to sort your PET bottles in your high density polyethylene jug, but it's very difficult to sort everything else. And all that other stuff is ending up in a landfill.

The fifth thing is we need chemical or advanced recycling to scale up faster and making sure that there are more companies and more technologies in the marketplace that can recycle more of the hard to recycle plastics. And maybe the last thing that I would say that's holding back plastics recycling is innovation. We need to think about the use of robotics and AI and secondary sortation and a variety of different things in that regard to help really bring the recycling system into the 21st century. Now, critics of what I just

said will tell you, well, a lot of that exists, but it doesn't exist everywhere. At scale, it doesn't. Yeah. There's a lot of great pilot projects and I'm not throwing cold water on those pilot projects or those proof of concept projects, but. We need that innovation to be happening at scale and that requires money. Exactly. That's where EPR, if designed correctly, could infuse a healthy dose of resources into the system. Can it actually fill those gaps? Do you think? Yeah. Yeah, I think it could, you know, but if

you design EPR systems like you do in California, where it become much more of a regulatory system as opposed to a financing system. You know, you're kind of defeating the purpose of yourself. I mean, I, I don't know the data I've run in front of me, but I know when we were debating SV 54, most people in California have a blue bed. It's not the issue of a blue bed right now in California. You know, a significant amount of the population have a blue bed in California. And so clearly that tells you something in this debate of like,

okay, where does that, where does that money need to be going and where should we be making those investments? And so if a significant. percentage of the population in California has a blue bin that it's where we don't have a collection problem. We have a processing and a sortation problem and a technology problem. Well, we have a participation problem. We have a huge participation problem, but that goes back to what I said about the confusion that exists today. Consumers don't know what to put in the blue bin. I had this conversation last night with my wife. We ordered Chick -fil -A and the delivery bag came. Diet Coke's in

the foam cup. fresh food packaged up correctly? Does the container that the sandwich go in the blue bin? Can we put the cup in there? The bag, yes, because it's paper. What about the Chick -fil -A sauce and the little things? Is that waste or recycling? And you spend a lot of time in the plastic industry. You don't know, and you're not alone. Most everybody is asking those same questions every day. They are truly engaged.

They will say, all right, I don't know what to do with this one thing. And it's confusing. Yeah. I think we do a pretty good job in recycling. Our recycling bin is full most weeks, but there are a ton of cans that we drink a lot of sparkling water in the house. We drink a lot of, our daughter consumes a lot of format or our food and small packaging formats that come into stuff. Or we assume that stuff can go in the recycle bin. We know that film doesn't get taken in our recycle bin. We, we do our best to try to drop it off

at our local Wegman when we go, but we're not always the best when it comes to that. We started subscribing to Home Chef just to make our cooking life a little bit easier. There's a ton of packaging in there that says it's recyclable, but I don't know if it's supposed to go in the blue bin or not. Yeah. In your municipality. It might be a municipality. The rules and the, and the guidelines and make it really difficult to have. robust consumer participation, despite the fact that I think most people wanna do it. Yeah, I think if you would ask the majority of Americans, they

say, I think it was like 70 plus percent say that they either are active or want to participate. So I think everybody would really, because it's not hard, right? All you gotta do is separate it. You gotta wash out a couple bottles and cans, make sure there's not a bunch of sticky stuff in there, but it's really not that complicated. to do the activity. It's complicated in knowing what to put where. That's the complicated part. We have a single stream because we have single

stream recycling. That's what makes it challenging. It gets prohibitively expensive if you do multi -stream, but that's a different argument altogether. That's a totally different animal. I'm not advocating for multi -stream recycling. The single stream does present some unique challenges for us because we're trying to keep costs low, but it does create consumer confusion when it comes to that. So we both agree that EPR can solve the gaps. Do you think it will in the States where it's being

enacted? I think it's going to vary on a state by state basis. I remain skeptical that California will ever be fully implemented to the effect that it needs to be. In fact, my personal belief on California's SB 54 is that. The complexity of it will become so complex that it'll just fall under its own weight. And the result will be a ban on everything. How you actually operate a modern 21st century economy with bans on all products. It's going to be really hard to ship fish across the ocean and paper bags and keep it fresh and strawberries and avocados and a

whole bunch of other things that come from that part. I remain skeptical about that. I think places like Minnesota and Colorado have a greater chance of seeing that be successful. And in recycling. I agree. Completely agree. Oregon, I think, well, initially I was skeptical about it. I think it's come a long way in its implementation as well. And so I put that as a third state that could be done correctly. Look, there's some crazy stuff that's being debated in places like California,

or excuse me, in places like New York that would be worse than what's passed in California. And so, to me again, it just would be another market collapse in many ways. The other thing about this that's important to keep in mind up here is you're going to run into a wall on the amount of states that implement this. They're going to largely be democratic, blue -leaning states that enact these types of laws. And you're unlikely going to see this in Republican states. I don't see Republicans. Tennessee, maybe. Tennessee

would be the one. I know Gary Cohen and that group are working very hard to make it happen. And they've worked on it for years. Yeah. But in places like Florida and Texas and some of these large markets, I just have a hard time seeing Governor Abbott or Governor DeSantis signing a law that does this. Yeah, we're talking increasing bureaucracy. It's more legislation. I just don't see any Republican governor backing the process.

Now, it may get pushed through and there's enough internal pressure within a state like Tennessee to make it happen. But I think other red states, like I live in South Carolina, no shot. There's no way that that's gonna happen here. I live in Virginia and maybe there could be a compromise with a Republican governor and a Democratic legislature, but even that's a long shot. So you run into a wall where maybe on a good day, you have 10 states enact these things, maybe a dozen states.

I don't know if we'll see one enacted this year, maybe New York, maybe Washington. So you're going to hit the limit pretty soon. And what's going to be left here is. for a further system that's broken and convoluted and complex with varying degrees of rules across states on top of varying degrees of rules around the 9 ,000 recycling jurisdictions that exist. That's going to make it really difficult. So it's going to require, to me, the solution has always been you need

a push and a pull. You need federal action. You need state action. You need private sector investment. You need innovation and technology. To me, those are the four pieces of the wheel that would make this work. I don't really think you need a big cash infusion from the federal government, but some guidelines would be great. Recognizing and defining what recycling is, benchmarking data. The EPA does not benchmark recycling. Just rules for how to track data and how to collect it and what data we're even looking for, I think. Just

harmonization. would be great. Who's the authoritative voice today when it comes to recycling data? Private, private groups, not the government. And private groups have the ability to influence the database upon what's beneficial to their members. So you need a third party, independent government enacted voice to set those harmonization roles and have robust data and benchmarking that serves as the authoritative voice here. And we don't have that today, you know? It's all complicated, right? So I think we've seen there are some great

success stories for EPR and the expansion of recycling wherever they're enacted. Yep. Do we think this is the best way to expand recycling? Or is there another way we're not talking about right now that maybe would work better? I wish I had a better answer to it, but I don't really know. EPR had come on the scene over the last couple of years as being the end all be all cure all to everything. I think at the time when it did, it had a lot of promise and then it became

complex and convoluted. I think you just need an all of the above approach here. You need bottle deposit systems. You need EPR. You need private sector investment. You need store drop -off. You need more investments in curbside. You need. clarity on the rules of what can be recycled and what cannot be recycled. So I think EPR is a piece of the pie, but not the entire pie. Could not agree more with that. So you and I were both recently at the plastic recycling conference,

which I know I love it. It's my favorite show of the year. I get to see a lot of people that I haven't seen in a long time, learn stuff, get a feel for what's going on in the market. I will say though. I was a little concerned at the scale of the show this year. It seemed like people had pulled back a little bit. The companies used to send a contingent, let's say, of six or seven. This year it was two. And I saw that a lot. So what was your experience like at PRC this year

and just your overall impression of the show? I thought overall the impression of the show was great, but I agree with your assessment. It seemed like it was a little bit smaller than usual. But I think that happening across trade shows, to be honest with you, there's a client I'm working with that has a separate conference that they're working on that has nothing to do with recycling, also happening at Nashville Harbor. And I'm getting emails from folks saying, what you just said, we normally send 10 people. We're going to send one or two this time. And I think that just has to do with market uncertainty,

economic uncertainty, costs. I mean, getting out of plane today is not cheap. Registration fees to put on these conferences is not cheap. The programming, I think, is always good. There were some great updates in there around SP54, some truth -telling around why some folks weren't achieving their ambitious recycle content or recycling goals. I thought that was really good. Open conversations are great. There was a really good open conversation. I think what I found intriguing about it is in years past, it was very much about ambitions. And this year it seemed

very much about realities. And I found that to be refreshing in that regard. We've got to move away from making commitments and ambitions to showing progress and living in reality. And I thought the show and some of the programming did a good job of doing that. Well, great. I know that I spent the first half of the week this week at AFPM, and I will tell you, and for those that don't know, it's America's Fuel Manufacturer Association, Petrochemical Manufacturing. The

real one at the trade association. Yeah, too many acronyms to keep track of all this stuff. But every conversation I had was tariffs, port fees, and economic uncertainty. So it was a nice change of pace going to plastics, recycling, and talking about some positives. There are some concerns about lack of growth, but I did want to touch on a little bit because I've got the expert on different things when it comes to politics. Yeah. I want to get a feel from your perspective.

What do you think is going to happen with all these tariffs? Is this all posturing or do you think that there's the possibility that any of this is actually going to happen? I think some of it will get enacted, but I think it's going to be separate by sector. Small pieces of it. Yeah. The auto tariffs that were announced today seem to me, whether you agree or disagree with them, it feels like that's the path we're going down where it's going to be more of a sector by sector approach. I have a hard time imagining the market is going to tolerate broad -based tariffs over a long period of time. The president

himself measures a lot of success based upon how the stock market is going. And the markets have not liked this idea of broad -based tariffs and uncertainty right now. Consumer confidence is down. Spending concerns are down. Economic uncertainty exists when you're laying off a lot of people within the bureaucracy. Whether or not you agree bureaucracy should be cut, that's totally... It's a lot of people losing their jobs. A lot of people losing their jobs. I think the cumulative effect of this over a period of time will probably result in a scale back of some of the tariff, but I don't think they're

going away. I think they're going to be a lot of sector by sector tariffs on things like steel, automotive, aluminum. I read copper today is another one that's kind of coming along. So I think that's probably where we're going over the next four years. he is trying to spur growth in American manufacturing again. I get from a high level what he's doing, but the one thing that I find interesting, and I know you aren't

exactly an expert on the topic of the port fees, we discussed that the other day, because not a lot of people are talking about this, and it's a pretty big deal, because we're talking about, for those that aren't aware, It's anywhere from a million to a million and a half for every port call. So if a ship is going from China to the US, there's a million dollar fee, at minimum, that would be placed on that inbound ship. And

it's every single port that it calls. Every place. So you could go from the Texas port to the Louisiana port. On your way to China and you're gonna pay the million bucks each time exactly. So you're talking about increasing cost of goods exponentially Exponential and the I guess the target is if your fleet of Ships or ocean -bound vessels is more than 23 percent. I believe I don't know if that's the exact number but it's a 20 something percent is Chinese made which is like the entirety

of boat production over the last 10 years has been made in China because we don't even have the assets to make them here anymore. And he wants to spur more manufacturing of ships, but that's going to take a long time. So that could be 10 years of pain or however long he's in, the Republicans are in power, but it just, I understand the idea, but it needs to be practical. Same conversation we had about SB 54. I understand

the idea. We want more recycling. Great. Let's do more recycling, but let's make it reasonable. It's the same stuff with tariffs and. Same stuff with tariffs and port fees. And look, I think there's a broader conversation to be had, which is competition with China. And I think it's a good conversation to have whether or not we are competing with them. And, you know, are we relying on them too much? Yeah. A healthy conversation to have. You don't need tariffs to do that though. You don't need tariffs to do that. There's a lot of other ways to incentivize the growth of

manufacturing here in the United States. Chips and Science Act was a good example of that where we saw a national security concern that too many of our chips that go into our automobiles, our computers, everything we use, everything, a smartphone, you name it, chips are being manufactured in China. That's a national security concern. So we came together. We're going to spend money and we're going to invest in science and research, and we're going to build more of those factories here in the United States. I think that's a great way to do it. And so how do we do those things for shipbuilding and steel and manufacturing

and some of that other stuff? Those are worthy, pragmatic, thoughtful debates that we should be having. And I don't think that we're having enough of those debates today. Completely agree. The discussion needs to happen. We don't need to cause chaos in business and planning in order to get to that discussion. We could just talk to each other. It's really not that hard. But the problem with it is everything is so polarized

today. If you're not for the tariffs, you're not pro -manufacturing. If you're not, if you're pro -tariff, you're this. Everything becomes a label and polarized. one of the most pro -manufacturing domestic manufacturing guys you'll find on the planet. I do believe we should be building more stuff here in the U .S. Do I think tariffs are the right way to do it? I've got a few concerns about that. I'm not entirely certain that's the right way to do it. It's a tax that will eventually be passed on to consumers. American consumers.

American consumers, myself and you, will be paying that tax. And it's the same thing that's going to happen with SP54, $36 billion. is it's going to be passed on to the consumer. And that's the cost that that's going to take to implement that. I think we need to be debating policies today that decrease costs on consumers, not increase costs on consumers. I agree with that. Recently, on different social media, there is a speech video of Ronald Reagan that's been floating around. Have you seen that? Oh, yeah. Talking about how

tariffs are stupid and we should not do that. And it's counterintuitive and things we should not be. entertaining as a superpower. I just think it's so interesting how much the Republican party has changed, even since my childhood. Makes it harder and harder to defend. But that's - The Republican party today is not Ronald Reagan. No, it's nowhere near. Nowhere near. It's a vastly different party that is - And it's upsetting, I guess is the easiest way to say it. It's a different time. I worked for some relatively

moderate members and - candidates in my lifetime who, you know, if you look at their voting records and their positions were deemed pretty conservative, and then for the most part, would not win in today's political environment. No. No. You just, you're not. So you almost have to fight with people. You gotta, I'm wearing the R or I'm wearing the D on my shirt. That guy has an R or a D or a girl. I gotta fight with that person because they're diametrically opposed to me. When in fact, we're not that... These political parties

are not that different. And we should just be talking to each other more. That's a completely different two -hour, three -hour conversation. Is there anything else that's on your mind that people that are in the plastics or packaging world need to be paying attention to that they aren't paying attention to? Yeah, one thing I'd make a plug for myself is I do also a resilient insights newsletter that comes out once a month, which is great by the way, for everybody that's coming out today at 3 .30. It will be posted

on LinkedIn and delivers via email. I do a deep dive on SB 54 today on my newsletter. So encourage people to go to resilientpartners .us and sign up to get it or find resilient partners on LinkedIn and you'll see it there as well too. Or you can find me on LinkedIn at Joshua Wabaka. where I will share it as well, too. But there'll be a deep dive, a lot of what we talked about today in greater detail as well. Great. Then obviously I'll put all that in the show notes so people can find you that way, too, if anybody is still old fashioned and actually looks through those.

I do read the show notes, Brian. I do, too, but not very many people do. Yeah, I think it's because we do podcasts. Exactly. Anything else that we haven't covered today that you wanted to talk about? That's all I got, brother. Thanks for having me on. Hey, always appreciate it. Always appreciate the work that you do for me and my day job and all of the collaboration that we've done over the years. We've made some really big things happen, and a lot of that is due to your effort. Thank you. I want to make sure that anybody

that knows me, if you have an issue with whatever business, from a policy perspective, Joshua's your guy. Thank you, brother. You should definitely reach out to him. And we're going to continue using you because you've been invaluable to me. I appreciate it. But anyway, this has been the Redefining Plastics podcast. Thank you to my guest, Joshua Baca. And everybody have a great night. If you want to learn more about the plastics industry, recycling, check out these other videos. Please like and subscribe.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Scaling Dissolution for Food-Contact Recycled Polypropylene with IPL Schoeller and PureCycle

    Nov 3, 202629 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney sat down with Melissa Vettleson (Sustainability and Materials Engineer at IPL Schoeller) and Christian Bruey (Director of Sustainability and External Affairs at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Are Plastics Sustainable? with Patrick Krieger of the PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 27, 202632 minAudio

    Justin Riney hosts Patrick Krieger, who is the Senior Vice President of Sustainability and Policy at the PLASTICS Industry Association. In this conversation, they dive deep into sustainability, plastics, and creating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Recycling Collaboration, EPR, and Building End Markets with PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 20, 202630 minAudio

    This was the third episode recorded at the National Plastics Conference (NPC), and the NPC Live podcast studio onsite. Thanks again to PLASTICS for having Redefining Plastics at the conference and all of their support....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. NAPCOR’s PET Bottle Decarbonization Roadmap with Husky’s Jolene Milne (NPC Live)

    Oct 6, 202624 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney speaks with Jolene Milne, a sustainability analyst at Husky Technologies and member of NAPCOR, about industry collaboration to combat misinformation about plastics and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EPR, Data Gaps, and Change Management with Christine Yeager at National Plastics Conference Live

    Sep 23, 202632 minAudio

    We had a blast with this interview at the National Plastics Conference on-site podcast studio, "National Plastics Conference Live." Christine Yeager of CSY Impact dove deep into extended producer responsibility (EPR),...

    Credit the people on this episode