Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Redefining Plastics

Redefining Plastics artwork

Exploring the Future of Bioplastics: PHA, PLA, and Composting Solutions -with CJ BioMaterials

Aug 5, 20251 hr 1 minAudio

Welcome to the Redefining Plastics Podcast with Justin Riney and co-host Samantha Ryan. In this exciting episode, we dive deep into the world of bioplastics with Leah Ford from CJ Biomaterials. Discover the ins and outs of compostable materials like PHA and PLA, their applications, benefits, and challenges. From the intricacies of fermentation processes to the role of composting in tackling global environmental issues, this discussion covers it all. Leah, with her 20 years of experience in the biopolymers industry, shares valuable insights on scaling bioplastics, addressing misconceptions, and the critical role of composting in reducing carbon footprints. Join us for an engaging and informative conversation about the future of sustainable packaging and its impact on our planet. https://cjbiomaterials.com/ https://www.closedlooppartners.com/research/unleashing-the-economic-and-environmental-potntial-for-food-waste-composting-in-the-u-s-a-guide-for-investors-policymakers-and-the-compost-industry/ https://www.redefiningplastics.com/ https://www.brvind.com/redefining-plastics https://rss.com/podcasts/redefining-plastics-with-justin-riney https://www.instagram.com/redefining_plastics/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/justin-riney-mba-67685940/ https://youtube.com/@redefiningplastics?si=KvG4dTvY1lALbwIm

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Daddy's Podcast. This is the Redefining Plastics Podcast. Welcome to the Redefining Plastics Podcast. My name is Justin Riney. Again, we have Samantha Ryan as the co -host. We've got an interesting one today. It's going to be a fun conversation, I think. A little bit outside of my wheelhouse, we're going to talk compostables today. And we've got Leo Ford. from cj biomaterials i will say

i used to buy from cj biomaterials and it's still outside of my wheelhouse i still don't quite understand exactly how all of it works but i appreciate you being on and i wanted to give the audience a little bit of a background on who you are and who cj is sure so um leah ford i'm the marketing director at here at cj biomaterial So CJ Biomaterials is a division of the company CJ Chilja Dong, which is a large South Korean lifestyle company. And they have verticals in

entertainment, logistics, food, and biology, which is where the biomaterials business sits. So the biomaterials business, we opened up a manufacturing plant in 2022 and have been putting out PHA polymers to the market since then. And for myself, I've been in the biopolymers industry for almost 20 years now, actually. Before I joined CJ about a year ago, I spent about 19 years working for NatureWorks. So very much on the PLA side

of the business. So my whole career is here. Yes. Yeah. So my background is obviously in packaging. So I do. have quite a bit of experience in biopolymers. So I want to make sure that we differentiate between the biopolymers that you're talking about and bio -based materials that are being used to make traditional polymers. So you're taking the fossil fuel derived, and fossil fuel is a misnomer, shouldn't say that, but everybody says

fossil fuel, so I'm going to run with it. So the fossil fuel derived feedstocks, you take those out and you use... use cooking oil or technical corn oil or something else to make the same polymers. That's not what we're talking about. We're talking about completely different types of material made completely from bio and then they're compostable either industrial or home compost. So I just want to make sure that the audience understands we're not talking about bio -based polypropylene

or something like that. We're talking PHA, PLA. What else is in there? Is that pretty much what you're focused on? There are some others. There are actually some other what you would consider biodegradable polymers that are made from actually fossil -based precursors, to use the language. So your PBAT, PBS, these materials do have a bio route, but they also right now are made with fossil fuel precursors. But they are readily

biodegradable, similar to PLA or PHA. So my area of expertise is definitely in the biobased biodegradable space, which is PLA and PHA, but there are more biodegradable polymers out there, which is actually really great because it gives us more polymers to work with when we're trying to design for compostability, biodegradability, these sorts of things. Yeah. So you're out there trying to make sure that you're matching up the polymer, in this case, the biopolymer. to the application.

So it makes the most sense for whatever the application is. Because I think there are a couple different things that I've always run into when I've been talking to legislators or I'm talking to big brands. And one of the big concerns about PLA, we'll just start there, is the lack of industrial compost. I know that's getting better. It's growing across the U .S., but there are still pockets of the country that don't have that. But I think

pH, just from my personal opinion, is a great solution because you can home compost. Because I'm a big home composter, and if we're taking packaging and it's going to be coming to the home and you're home composting, you just take the whole thing and you take it straight to your compost bin and you've solved the problem. And I think that's a wonderful solution. So not to say that PLA is necessarily bad if you've got an industrial composting. I'm just a much bigger

fan of home composting. That's just kind of where my head's at. But why don't you kind of walk through the differences in the... Yeah, that was going to be where I was going to jump. What's the difference? What makes one home compostable versus the other? Could you possibly home compost PLA in the right circumstances? I'd love to have that conversation because, like I said, I'm not an expert in this area at all. Composting is a super interesting field, right? Because commercial

composting, especially, and I'll just mostly speak for the U .S. market because it's different, especially in Europe and other countries. But in the U .S. market, composting as an infrastructure. really grew on the back of being able to compost like landscape clippings, right? And in that process, the reason that they have commercial composting is so that it gets hot enough to be able to kill weeds and seed so that when you get to the compost state and you're using it as a soil amendment, you're not proliferating invasive species, right? And as these compost

sites grew to start accepting food waste, the high heat temperatures like the 58 degrees C that you need in an... commercial compost environment, it's hot enough that it killed pathogens in meat, dairy, citrus, like it's needed to be able to create safe compost. And so I think it's important to know that commercial composting is not something that grew because of biopolymers. Biopolymers have designed themselves around commercial composting for food waste, because the value of commercial

or of compostable packaging, right, is diverting food waste away from landfill. Because the EPA has shared that, you know, 58 % of the methane emissions that comes from landfill comes from food degrading. So that commercial composting environment is ideal for the safe composting of all of those food scraps. And you're right. To date, I think the last data point I saw is that only 4 % of the food waste generated in the U .S. every year is sent to compost. And so there's a ton of opportunity. So we need commercial

composting infrastructure. If we are going to be able to tackle food waste and the rate at which that's been growing is tremendous. You look at a state like California, which has a statewide organics diversion mandate where they have to take the food scraps out of landfills. That spurred a lot of growth and pressure on the commercial composting industry there. In Minnesota, where I am in the Twin Cities, the metro area has had certain carbon reduction targets. And the only way to get there was to start taking food scraps out of landfill. So we've had the

proliferation of commercial composting here just to be able to hit those food waste diversion climate targets. And biopolymers have been, if you will, like molding themselves around how this legislation has been going and about what's happening with food waste. So I think that's important context because sometimes I hear, especially just for PLA, like, well, it needs a special environment. Like food needs a special environment, right? I would not invite. most home composters to be composting meat scraps in their backyard, right? So I think that's important to know that

I think there are places and times where home composting and commercial composting need to overlap and be compatible. So with that being said, you're right, especially in areas where commercial composting doesn't have access yet, we're actually seeing a proliferation of different types of levels of composting, even between home and commercial. There's, you know, community composting, small drop off sites like community gardens are starting to do composting. So we're seeing like access to being able to compost food

scraps grow at a kind of a nice spectrum of levels from just you at your home to a large, you know, commercial composters serving a municipality. And the certifications that have developed kind of around compostable packaging. have similarly molded themselves around these environments. So when, you know, OWS was getting started trying to create lab tests to certify products for compostability, they're like, okay, what does it take to compost

banana peel and dairy scraps? Like, how do we create lab conditions that mirror that so that we know if there's a safe food composting environment, biopolymers will go away too. And that's kind of how those first standards and certifications for how fast you need to biodegrade, disintegrate, and at what temperatures were designed for. They weren't designed around the properties of biopolymers. It was designed around what we need to do to make food safely compost. So I think that's helpful because I think that's also a different framing

than what a lot of people expect when it comes to how we certify. And as home certifications have grown, there's a great home certification. From TUV or TUV, depending on how you say it, out of Europe. TUV is usually what I've always said. TUV Rhineland is typically what I say to people. Exactly. So their certification is based on a standard that was developed in France, right, where they looked at how do people home compost? What are reasonable home compost conditions here? And other organizations now are working to expand

home compost certification and try to develop. eventually an international standard for home compostability like we have for commercial compostability. So because the thing is, is home compostability is so variable, right? Here in Minnesota, where I am, like composting through the winter is very different than if you are in Arizona or if you're in the southeast, right, in South Carolina, where it's a lot wetter and warmer because moisture as much as temperature is incredibly important for the composting process. So I think that there's.

Some challenges with designing products meant for the home compost environment because it is so variable and we don't want products to fail in that environment. Right. There's nothing worse than looking in your compost bin and seeing something that's not composting. Like you accidentally put something in there you shouldn't have. Digging that out of there is not fun. And save for personal experience. Exactly. Oh, gosh. Especially if you're doing vermiculture and you have to go through the worms. Right. Like that's always a special bit of fun. I'm not good on that. I'm

a little squeamish at heart. So that's not my it's not typically what I like to do. We do it when we have to. Exactly. Right. I'm a huge proponent of compost. I think composting is one of the easiest things that people can do to lower their carbon footprint because you are dead on. The amount of methane that comes out of a landfill because of food waste is massive. It's like 14 % of the entire U .S. emissions of methane is

food waste. Higher. It's like a third. Yeah, it's huge. Well, yeah. Because that was an EPA data point from like 2022. Okay. But the big thing that I think a lot of people don't understand is one third of all food produced in the U .S. just gets wasted so if we don't take care of that in the right way so not only do you have the carbon emissions for making the food like growing it watering it all that kind of stuff

then you've got the end of life portion of it that's a problem too and i like the idea of trying to piggyback on a system that's already there so yeah taking packaging to a system that's already existing Makes a ton of sense. And I think we should do more of that. So what do you think the target markets are for you? I know the food packaging makes a lot of sense. Are there any other markets out there that to you make a lot of sense for your types of materials? Absolutely.

Absolutely. For a really nice combination of the amorphous PHA that we make and PLA, you can make really beautiful nonwovens, right? And nonwovens are used in... a wide range of hygiene applications, wipes, baby diapers, etc. And what we are sort of just getting to in the biopolymer space is not just what are these good for when you want to compost something, but also what performance properties do they have that are a unique advantage over incumbent material? Because for the same

reason, right, you use polystyrene versus polypropylene versus PET, PLA and PHA have a similar different suite of properties. So where can those be leveraged to a performance advantage, even beyond, you know, the fact that it's bio -based or compostable? And nonwovens is a really interesting space to do that. Because if you make a really nice nonwoven with PHA and PLA, you can get something that's very soft, very similar to your incumbent polypropylene, but you can actually outperform polypropylene

in terms of fluid management. So when they're testing these nonwovens for divers, they call them insults. And so if you insult the nonwoven multiple times over time, it does a less efficient job of removing moisture away from the skin and dispersing it to the super absorbent polymer beneath. So we're talking PLA diapers. You could. In essence. Yes. Yeah. So you can create like this nice, the part that touches the skin to be incredibly efficient at taking moisture away, which reduces the incidence of diaper rash and

skin irritation. So I like to say that by the time I am an adult, I would like my PLA, PHA adult diaper so that my daughter never has to treat my diaper rash. Because that is not cool. That's one target market you can head to that depends, people. Exactly. So I want to talk about some of the, we'll call them misconceptions because I'm sure that's what they are. Yeah. But this

is just what I see. And I would love you to correct me where I'm wrong. Does that make sense? Let's do it. Kind of where we're going. So I go to Starbucks today here in Charlotte. And I get a coffee, which I don't do. I always take my own. But we'll just say. Yeah. It's a PLA lid. What do I do with it? Where does it go? I have no idea what to do because right now in Charlotte,

there's no pickup for yard waste. There's no pickup for compostables because I have friends that live in Los Angeles and they've got a bin that's for composting. So they put their stuff in their compost. So in a place where you don't have those kind of services, what do you do with these materials? Do you send them just into the trash? Like I live in an apartment. I live in an apartment building. That's another good place. We don't even have like a recycling chute. I hate that. My old building did, and that was

the first building I ever lived in that had a recycling chute. I need to talk to the management of your facility. But this, yeah, this recycle, we do separate like cardboard, but I think that's mainly so they don't deal with it in the dumpster. But we only literally just have a trash room with a trash chute. So even if you recycled, you'll have to have. Management all over Tampa because really I've lived in probably six different complexes and one had a recycling chute in all of them. So I guess that's a good example because here I literally only have a trash chute. Yeah.

So what do you do if you're in Sam's apartment? What do you do with your PLA lid? I'm just curious. Can you clarify PLA and then you said P? Polylactic acid. Okay. And then what was the other one? PHA? Lactic acid. Think the sour stuff on your candies. Okay. Yeah. Or it's used in yogurt. Your muscles make it when you work out, right? The lactic, like that's, yeah. And then you get to the point where your legs are burning and you can't stand up anymore. It's because you

have a buildup of lactic acid. Okay. I'm familiar now that you put it that way. Yeah, I'm not because I'm sedentary. But yeah, I think it's a good question. What do you do if you don't have a ready outlet for an industrial or commercial composting package? Yeah. You know, step one, if your building or home or city isn't providing it, is definitely to look for a local community drop -off site because private community drop

-off is growing. like gangbusters right now because the other part of composting to note is that compost is a valuable product in and of itself it really is i bought it before i started doing it myself it's expensive yes it is it really is but it can you know double the output of your home garden right like i put it in my garden bins it does a beautiful job um cities buy it to remediate land when they're doing construction to like prepare roadways and manage water runoff when they're building new roads so Compost is

an in -demand product, so community composters and private composters are also springing up because it's a business opportunity. So step one, see if somebody's taking advantage of that business opportunity in your area. Step two, if there is no drop -off, you put it in your trash. But the good news is, is if you put it in your trash and a PLA, PHA goes to a landfill, it is inert. Well -managed landfills are managed not to generate methane. We know that's not always the choice, or that's not always the case with

food scraps. But all of these products, they're just going to sit in the landfill and not do anything like everything else in the landfill. Because a well -managed landfill, not even the newspapers break down, right? We've all seen the stories of pulling out the old newspapers. So it's not the ideal end -of -life scenario. But for some, the fact that they've used a bio -based material in the first place is valuable. PLA compared to the conventional polymers has a carbon footprint about two thirds less than conventional polymers. And our PHA does as well.

Is that like a cradle to gate or is that cradle to grave? Field to factory gate. So all of the agriculture feedstock inputs with growing sugar source. Biogenic sources as well. I just want to make sure we're on the same page as far as, because LCAs, people can look at them completely different or PCFs. So I just want to make sure that we're aligned on what are our boundaries and how are we factoring it? Because if you are

looking at biogenics, I can see how that would be. So if you include the carbon uptake by the agricultural feedstock source, but you also include all of the inputs, whether it's water, fertilizers, all of that. to be able to produce that agricultural source and go through manufacturing the polymer. And then when the polymer leaves the gate, that's where I can make that claim. When it comes to converting biopolymers, honestly, in the research that we've done, it's pretty equitable if you average it across the board. Like it takes roughly

the same energy to thermoform a PLA container as a P1, you know, because these are still fundamentally polyesters. So there's a bit of a wash in the converting step. And then you're right, LCA, when it comes to end of life, is a whole another story, right? And that's different per region and that can be hyperlocal. But all that's to say is if you do put your PLA or your PHA in a landfill, it's not going to hurt anything. You've used a bio -based source and you use something with a lower carbon footprint. So for when that

is important to a brand, a retailer, a consumer, that's kind of its value. Ideally, though, we will build out more and more systems to be able to handle these things. But, you know, the same issue is with, you know, if that was a polypropylene lid, like it too will just go sit in the landfill. It's the same situation. Exactly. I agree there. It's not what we want. And even in like traditional polymers, we don't want our products to end up there either. And so it's the same problem, just

in a different space. Absolutely. Your solution for the end of life isn't necessarily recycling because that's not what you're building your materials for. You're looking to make compost, which is a great resource. And it is something that we need more of. Yeah. For us, we want to reuse it. And if we can reuse it more than once, that makes it great. That's a great circular story. Both of these products have circular stories. It's just a completely different image. You're

not going package to package. You're going package to growing tomatoes or something like that, which I'm all for if we can do it more. And in certain parts of the country, do a really great job of collecting this stuff and taking it to the commercial. Because that was always a concern I had is what do I do here? Because in Charlotte. We do a lot of recycling really well in Charlotte and we do a lot of collection of trash really well. I never knew what to do with any of the PHA or not PHA. I know what to do with PHA. It goes

in the bin in the back. I don't know what to do with the PLA. Yeah. So I looked it up. There are four composters in the state of South Carolina last I checked. So yes. So there should be a drop off program. I use drop -off locations and programs all the time. Here in Mecklenburg County, just north of me, they actually have EPS drop -off, so expanded polystyrene. Oh, nice. So whenever I get a package delivered, I throw the EPS in the back of my truck, drive it to Charlotte on

my way to take my kids to the mall, drop off the EPS, feel pretty good about life. Yeah. So if I can do the same thing with all these PLA lids that I'm getting. Yeah. I think that. That's a really important question we have to ask ourselves is with any of these systems, right? And I think it's equally true for all drop -off programs is that's a lot of extra labor, right? It's really shifting the burden of dealing with waste to the consumer. And I don't know about you, but I don't have a lot of extra time in most of my

days. And I'm super attuned to these issues and hyper aware of all my materials and have more information than the average person to figure out where they should go. a lot of time and effort. And I think that if we're going to make a real impact in terms of collecting and recycling or composting things, we have to have convenient infrastructure. And we have to shift the burden not always onto consumers and try to take it back to a system solution. And that's where conventional polymers have some advantage. It's that with

their presence in the market and their scale, it's easy to deploy infrastructure because you know the material is available. When it comes to biopolymers, that's not necessarily the case. And over the last 20 years, we've seen a bit of a chicken or the egg scenario. Like, do we put compostables out there before the composting infrastructure is available? But what's going to help drive the infrastructure if we're not composting things? Right. And kind of that back and forth. You kind of have to you have to have a critical mass in order to make this thing work.

I agree with you. I have been. somewhat critical of PLA in the past. I've had some issues with some materials that I've used in previous jobs. I'm sure a lot of those things have been resolved by now because we're talking 10 years ago when I was doing this. What I really am excited about is more the PHA home compost. The idea to me

is if you could get the right kind of moisture and oxygen barrier, wrapping your fruits and veggies in a PHA bag or something like that makes a ton of sense to me. Because then you can just take the whole bag, put it directly into your hope composting with all the waste scraps from like apples or whatever. Yeah. And then you can just compost it all right then and there. That seems like a really convenient, great solution

if we can get people to compost. And that's another thing. Folks, if you are not composting at home, please do that. It's not hard. It really isn't hard. If I can do it, anybody can do it. Because I literally can't do anything. And I can do that. So please, please compost. It's a big deal. I'm off my soapbox. I agree. And don't just buy a countertop dehydrator. Oh, God, no. That doesn't work. Just get the spinny bin on Amazon. It's

like 60 bucks. You build it in like 30 minutes. And then you just put stuff in there. You spin it. You add some water. You keep it out in the sun. It works. Yes. Literally, if I can do it, anybody can do it. Absolutely. So PHA. Yes. How do we scale? Because I've always seen PHA as almost a... It's a fringe material now. It's something that I think is growing. And I think there's a lot of applications that it could be useful for. Because I'm a plastics of traditional

polymers guy. But I don't necessarily think traditional polymers are fit for everything that we're using them for. I'm going to say that right now. I think there are certain things that are better suited for other material. And if we can compost it, great. Let's do it. But how do we scale PHA in a way that it makes sense where we can we can really tackle some of these big issues? Yeah. You know, I think about like the things that

go into scaling PHA a lot right now because, you know, conventional plastics and with your background, correct me if I have any of it wrong. But I mean, those really scaled and came to market like when natural rubber went into a shortage around World War Two. We needed synthetic rubber alternatives, right? Metal and rubber. Yeah, exactly. And so coming up with lightweight solutions that would help military applications at that time was a high priority. And afterwards, we were left with competency, capacity and capability.

And we're like, what is what are we going to do with these plastics? And then you get the invention of saran wrap and Tupperware and like all these different ways to use plastic. But there was this. Huge initial investment that kind of created that particular industry. And biopolymers coming to market, it's a really different environment. I mean, it wasn't until 2017 that there was really kind of a global flip in how people perceived plastics and became worried about them at the consumer level. And around

that time, Europe passed their single -use plastics directive. You had the video of the turtle with the straw up its nose. Which wasn't a straw, by the way. It wasn't a straw? No, no. It was a worm. But anyway. Okay. I mean, regardless of what it was, it really galvanized a certain attitude, right? And created very different market conditions for biopolymers to come to market. But scaling them is in a very different place

than when conventional polymers came to market. They weren't displacing anything. And to a certain extent, biopolymers have to displace some of the incumbents that we have found. You know, packaging does really great things for food shelf life, for example. We want to keep doing that. And so biopolymers have to find their way in. They have to do the job in the same way or even better in some cases, because if you really want to win in this market, because let's be clear, PHA is going to be more expensive. Yes, for now.

And your traditional polymers. So you're going to have to have either a company that's really committed to composting, like your Whole Foods or people like that, I would assume, would be huge into this. Or you're going to have to do something better than the materials that exist today to justify the cost delta. So to me, I think that's the bigger issue. Because like the story, I love the story. Let's do more of it.

Yes. But then when it comes to the cost of it, I think that's where we're running into a lot of problems. And this is the same issue we're having with recycled materials right now. Just let's be clear. Recycled materials are more expensive than traditional polymers. And because of that, brands don't want to pay it because they say that people don't want to pay more for any. And I'm assuming you're running into the same kind of conversations like, hey, we've got a new widget that solves this problem. It solves end of life

for, let's say, food packaging. Yes. But it's going to be more expensive. Exactly. Are we going to do this? I know. Yeah. So there's I think there's a few ways to look at economics. Right. As a manufacturer, we think about the economics of our manufacturing. Right. And so how can we drive cost out of. And fermenting PHA, right? And fermenting to make PHA. Why don't we talk a little bit about how you make PHA? So then we can talk about the like the cost structure

around that. Sure. I think that makes sense because we talk PHA a lot on this so far. And I don't think a lot of people even know what PHA is. So why don't we kind of take a step back on like what is PHA? How is it made? And then that we can transition into. why it's going to cost me. You bet. So PHA or polyhydroxyalkanoate, it's actually a... I try to say that all the time. I'm so happy you did because I struggle so much with that word. No problem. I practiced when

I joined CJ, right? PHAs are actually a naturally occurring polymer. So they were, if I recall correctly, first observed in around the 1920s. is scientists observed that little bacteria for example would create and store energy in the PHA polymer molecules inside their cellular body. But it wasn't until much later and a lot more research that we were able to figure out this is actually a polymer we could make things with.

So this occurs like every day out in the world. There are microbes that are making PHA the same way we make fat to store energy. They're making PHA to store and access energy. When we make PHA at scale, we have the ability to encourage those microorganisms to make a lot of PHA. Right. And so that's our fermentation process where we take sugars and you can get you can make PHA from so many different feedstocks you can use. sugars, you can use oil, you can use methane,

you can use food scraps. There's a ton of different feedstocks that can be used to encourage microbes to grow a lot of PHA in their cellular bodies. The type of feedstock you choose, its repeatability, its quantity, or its quality can directly affect the type of polymer you create. Because unlike PLA, where if you got PLA from two manufacturers, you can for the most part, sub them in for each other. With PHA, there's over 150 different monomers that you can use to create different types of PHAs. So they are not all the same. And there's

a lot of different ways you can design PHA for different functional properties. So, and every PHA manufacturer out there has kind of their own special flavor of PHA that they create. You know, for CJ, we have an amorphous and a semi -crystalline version. Other people create different versions of PHVs. Like the alphabet soup can get large when it comes to PHAs. So the semi -crystalline, sorry to interrupt. No, it's okay. What kind of application are you using semi -crystalline

in? Because I can imagine like if we're talking just PET, like crystalline PET is going to be used more in like microwave trays and things like that. But then amorphous is going to be in your water bottles. So when I hear those two things, I'm trying to figure out, all right, if you have a semi -crystalline PHA, what is that going into? I'm just curious. Absolutely. So the word semi -crystalline amorphous definitely

means very different things when it comes to PHA properties. So like the amorphous PHA, you don't make anything from it directly. It's really an additive. to PLA. You can use it as an additive to other PHAs, PVATs. It adds really rubbery ductile properties. It can help PLA compost faster. There's a lot of like cool things you can do, but you don't really use amorphous PHA on its own. Semicrystalline you can use on its own or compound with other things. So semicrystalline

is what has been available on the market longer in terms of PHAs. So you can You can compound it with other things to make fibers. So it has somewhat more of a crystalline structure than the amorphous one, but it's probably more similar to PLAs in that regard. But it's not the same as what you would take for crystalline PET to be able to microwave it, for example. Yeah, I'm not sticking it in an oven is ultimately what

you're talking about. Exactly. All right. Sorry for interrupting. No, that's okay. I was just curious. Absolutely. So there's just there's all these types of PHA that are out there. And when you choose a feedstock, you can get different types of PHA. And that feedstock to fermentation relationship is really important when you're considering economics, right? An accessible feedstock, something that you can access repeatedly that has repeated quality is really important for creating high quality PHA. And I think that's

where the market struggle has been to a certain degree is like, how do you match up? a feedstock with PHA in a way where your economics can chase down the conventional incumbents. And once you fed the sugar to those microbes and they've grown PHA in their body, that's when you take them to what we call downstream processing and you separate the PHA from those cellular bodies. And that process is also really important when it comes to maintaining the quality. So this is a very different process than if you're going

to make PLA, which involves, you know, fermentation, yes, to lactic acid, but then it's, you know, a high heat distillation process to be able to get to the polymer. It's very similar to a petrochemical process. PHA is really about how good are you at fermentation and how high quality is a feedstock that you're putting into that fermentation process. So to a certain degree, it's simpler, but also repeated biological fermentation is not an easy process and one that's seen a lot of focus and

scale because we do this for pharmaceuticals they do that for other industrial ingredients like industrial beer industrial fermentation at scale is a really big industry and technology and so when we're chasing down the economics for PHA it's going to really focus on that as the manufacturer but We also think about economics in terms of, right, how fast can you run these materials? Like, you know, line speeds, efficiency in conversion, that's real money. And so we need

to work closely with equipment manufacturers, converters, to be able to develop not just a good process, for example, for injection molding PHA, but are there changes to equipment that we can make to be able to run these things at... line speeds similar to the incumbents. PLA, having been on the market a lot longer, is starting to see this, like Reifenhauser is launching machines for nonwovens with inherent capability to run PLA nonwoven. Bruckner has announced being able

to do PLA biax films with a higher stretch ratio. So these conversion technologies need to scale as much as the manufacturing does to be able to chase down those economics. And then... The big question, of course, is end of life. Like, what are we willing to pay for that? It's that as much as we value moisture barrier, where in creating a polymer or a package should the cost for end of life sit? And that's what's kind of spurred the extended producer responsibility discussion and extended producer responsibility

legislation. And for good or ill, that's going to factor in a lot when it comes to economics. And right now it's something that. As we're thinking about scaling, if we wanted to build another factory or something, we need to know what's going to happen with EPR in this country so that we are focusing on applications that are cost advantaged in that system, that we know where biopolymers or compostables have a role to play. And so EPR is trying to look at how do we assign responsibility for the cost of end of life? Because

if you wanted to make something from polypropylene today, you do not have an incumbent cost to pay for. What happens to it? If it goes to a landfill, that's fine, right? If you buy PHA, you're inherently buying something where end of life is baked in. We've already given you another pathway if you buy a pound of polymer. For polypropylene, that's a little bit different. And so how do we look at valuing inherent biodegradability properties as much as we do moisture barrier or crystallinity

or impact strength or something, you know? alongside. And so I think it kind of the economics are going to shift what we value. And EPR is kind of focused on helping us do that. So, I mean, nobody wants to build a business solely based on legislation because that is tricky and difficult, as I'm sure we are all experiencing in this industry. But the intentions are there to try to balance out those systems. Right. And how do we make room for polymers to come to scale? You know,

our plant, we have about 15 ,000 KTA in our PHA plant. And you compare that to, I don't know, what's an average polypropylene or polystyrene plant? It's like a billion tons. Like it's humongous. But yeah, the traditional polymer production massively outscales you. No question. There's no question about that. I think my main concern about this whole thing is. How big of a scale do you think this could actually get to? Do you

think PHA just long -term becomes a replacement for a great majority of traditional packaging in plastics? Or do we think it's going to be a niche market because you're going to have certain people that really care about this and certain people that don't? I don't know. I love the idea. I want to see more of it. I honestly don't see much of it. I don't think I've seen PHA draws or lids or anything like that here. I would love

it. I'd buy it. Yeah. Because then I'd just throw it directly into my composting. Yeah. I'm just curious what your thoughts are. It's still very new PHA coming to scale. And so probably one of the most visible products made with PHA is a food service wear product under the Fade brand. So if you've ever seen like those marine blue straws and things like those are made with PHA and probably have the most visibility on the

market. But you're right, it is still very new. And I think that's, you know, kind of what everybody's betting on is how big is this going to get? The thing I feel most confident about is that food packaging, if we are really going to get it out of landfills and frankly, we need compost in this country because we are a huge agricultural. country, right? A huge part of what the U .S. is really great at and has land for is agriculture. But although we have a problem with depleting soils in this country, and we are looking at

like, you know, 50 more years of good harvest based on current soil quality, and it takes millions of years to create new soil. And compost is an incredibly valuable way we can protect our agricultural capabilities in this country. I think that the pressure to compost food waste will come not just because we want to get it out of landfills, but because we're going to need compost to uphold a really important industry in this country. And with that, I think we can leverage compostable

packaging at its best to make it convenient and easy for consumers to get as much food waste as possible and food scraps into compost. And so in that space, I could absolutely see it becoming dominant. And, you know, kind of in the way like you can make a lot of lovely beverage bottles from other things besides PET, for example. It's very technically possible. But having just PET bottles is very helpful when it comes to the recycling stream. 100 % agree. We can have a

thought like that for, and this is, you know, out there and will take time. But if we had all of our food packaging be compostable, that helps us make it. easy for consumers you don't have to decide you're like this touched food into my compost environment our compost infrastructure will grow to be able to run these materials will have capacity for them like that's the part I feel confident about so when it comes to making PHA at scale I really see compostable food packaging

is really driving like a key part of that industry I don't know that we're going to be seeing like PHA in cars anytime soon um but Like I said, we're still at the very early stages of what we think these polymers can do. A good example on the PLA side, when NatureWorks built its first PLA plant and opened it up in 2002, the words 3D printing were not a thing, right? And for the first 10 years of the business, it was not a market to be looked at or related to any sort

of quantity. Now we know 3D printing at desktop scale. It's all using PLA. It's a huge market for that material. And we never would have seen it coming, right? It was a whole new thing. And so my question is like, what is the next 3D printing that's out there for PHA and for biopolymers? A really interesting example is PHA is fully miscible in PVC. And it can be a very interesting additive for PVC applications, making it easier to actually recycle PVC. And so we are we've

just kind of been getting started, like talking about that, creating some development projects in the market. But if we could use a biopolymer, not just because it's bio based or anything, but because it increases the recyclability of PVC, which has unique use cases that we are not prepared to substitute other materials for at this time, that would be incredible. And that could be a huge market. So I think there are some. unusual spaces we haven't fully explored or quantified yet for where these biopolymers can go. Yeah. I think most people, if they tuned

into this, they would just assume that I would be like, no, we don't want composting because we want plastics. More plastics, please. Like, no, that's not my goal. My goal is to protect my industry, yes. But we don't need to be in everything that works. I'm going to say that. I don't care. I don't care if that pisses off everybody in the plastics industry. Sometimes we're making things with our products that we shouldn't do. Somebody sent me a picture once of, I think it was an avocado wrapped in plastic.

That's the dumbest thing I've ever seen. And there was a Coke can that was wrapped in plastics. That was the actual dumbest thing I've ever seen. Why? It's already in a metal can. There's no reason for that. So there are certain uses that our products are going into that it shouldn't be. And I think that... If we have true competition, I'm fine with true competition. I'm not fine with blanket bans that drive us to certain packaging types. I think the free market should work. If

your products are better for the application that they're going to go into, by all means, let's use them. And I will use them personally because I think composting is the right thing to do. And we need to do more of it. I am 100 % on board and I would love to see the success. I do worry about the cost and I do worry about the ability to scale because it is somewhat of a batch process. And so how do you get that to be big enough where you can actually make an

impact? And that's the part that I worry about. And I'd love to stay close to this. And as you guys scale, I'd love to hear more about and to continue the conversation on how do we How do we make polymers better? It doesn't necessarily need to be fossil -based polymers. It could be any polymers. And biopolymers are just that. So anyway, I love what you're doing. I really hope that it continues to grow. So typically

what I do on every episode is I give the guest. The ability to talk about anything that we haven't covered, anything that you're really burning on that you really wanted the audience to hear, anything like that. Floor's yours. There's so many things. That's opening a dangerous door. I've been in this industry a long time. But just to build off something you just were talking about with bringing fermentation to scale, I mean, that's one of the reasons that CJ specifically

got into this business. is CJ has a lot of expertise and capability specifically when it comes to fermentation, right? CJ traditionally is not a huge petrochemical plastics company, but what they're great at is fermentation. And so being able to drive the cost out of that process, address those issues with batch fermentation that you were talking about is something that CJ is uniquely positioned to do. And so to have... a company of that scale and capability get into the PHA

market and see the opportunity, I think is really going to be interesting and help drive it forward, right? This isn't bench scale technology or bench scale labs that we're working with. Like their ability to do fermentation, it crosses pharmaceuticals, food ingredients. You know, they have a huge lysine fermentation plant in Fort Dodge, Iowa. And so I've seen it. I've been by there. Excellent. Yeah. So like as companies like this think, you know, what am I good at and what opportunities are out there? I think that that's really going

to drive it forward. It's not, you know, square peg, round hole. It's really leveraging things we've done in other industries for biopolymers. So I think that's really going to help address our skill, especially in terms of manufacturing. But, you know, one one topic we haven't talked about yet, which might be fun, is the topic of microplastics, because there are there. It's a complicated topic. Right. And the idea of identifying

microplastics, you know, what is a microplastic? What does persistency mean? What is the impact to human and environmental health? How are you measuring that? I mean, that's that's starting to play into legislation. And it's a very real. topic that we need to address, right? And so I think that, you know, for biopolymers, there's, we've seen it kind of go both ways, like polymers that have inherent biodegradability are not going to be persistent over time. We know that eventually

hydrolysis or biodegradability straight from microbial organisms is going to take these polymers apart at a rate that's, you know, decades faster than conventional polymers. But I've also seen the science struggle to be able to appropriately identify material, what's in them, and what even is a microplastic, and how are we measuring not just presence, but risk and hazard. And so I

think that's kind of a wild card for how we're looking at materials right now, because I've seen The science field a little bit all over the place to me. Yes. In some regards. I could not agree with more. Because I'll see studies that'll say microplastics are killing us. Here's how it's affecting all your health. But then the studies that that is referring to usually is this GCM test that showed that there was microplastics in the brain, which actually couldn't tell the

difference between plastic and lipid fats. So like how much of it was actually. microplastics, if any, and what was fat. So there's just, the question is, are microplastics a problem? And I think the answer to that is maybe. I don't think anybody really knows. And I will say right now with what I've seen, I don't see it as a real danger. I think it's something as an industry

that the plastics industry has to deal with. They're going to have to deal with at least the messaging and the fear mongering. Because right now we're getting just bashed for it. And so we have to deal with that. And I think a company like yours is right there in a pretty prime position. If you're scaling something that is talking about biodegradation, it's a pretty good time to be doing that. Because of just the fear and hysteria.

Because I saw there was a, I hate quoting the onion, but I'm going to do it because the onion is not really funny anymore. But said that microplastics, like the 1000 thing on your list that you should be concerned about today. It's kind of true because like, what is it really doing to us, if anything? And I haven't seen anything. And I'll be the first to say. If I do see some sort of concrete

link between microplastics and a problem, I only have one reputation and I'm not going to just start dying on the hill. If the hill is not worth dying on, I'm not going to die on it. Absolutely. Yeah, it's a tricky question because likewise on the biopolymer side, I've seen... newer academic studies that are like, oh, well, are bioplastics even any better, right, in terms of microplastics?

And they've done some studies with earthworms or other small organisms, and they're like, oh, we put bioplastics in the soil and the microbiome changed. It's like, yes, it did, because that's the point of biodegradability. You added a different material in there. Of course that's going to happen. Nature can respond. Those microbes are going to multiply and they're going to take it apart and then the biome will go back. And like so that is the point of the lack of persistency.

But sometimes I think we lose the plot on what we're looking for in terms of these materials. And it's like you want it to be biodegradable, but you want no actual natural response to these materials if they enter the environment. Right. And nobody's trying to design anything that's going to encourage consumers to litter. Nobody thinks that's an end of life path. Nobody advertising like, please litter me because it'll biodegrade. Yeah, nobody wants that. It's a backstop, like ready biodegradability in the environment for

a lot of materials is a backstop, unless it's something that's supposed to be used in the environment, right? Like a biodegradable mulch film or in fishing nets, things like that. OK, but yeah, it's just it's very interesting to see the science on microplastics evolving. As easy as we may think we have it when we make a biodegradable polymer, there's a lot of fear that we're going to make a regrettable substitution. And the concept of regrettable substitution comes up a lot in the biopolymers space, right? In California right

now, there's a ton of confusion on what's even going to be allowed. I hear nothing but... complaints about SB 54 and how that applies to compostable packaging. Because I talked to a lot of the packaging companies and they're worried that it's going to make it so none of these packages are even allowed in there. And unintentionally. I think the law was written so poorly that it's actually

going to make some of the solutions to the problems illegal. Which makes no sense to me. But that's California. That's what Californians do. They make things more complicated than it needs to be. And they have unintended consequences all over the place. So it's going to be interesting to see how that plays out for plastics and bioplastics and biomaterials and biopolymers. How is all of that going to play out? Because you talked about EPR. It's going to be a game changer. And

if EPR is done wrong. It's going to cause a lot of problems. California SB 54 is EPR done wrong in about every possible way. Yes. I applaud them for trying to make a step change and really be aggressive and make things better. Yeah. But you've only made things a hell of a lot worse. Yeah. That's really where we're at right now. Absolutely. Yeah. There's a lot of conflict between SB 54 and, you know, the other bill we look at a lot is EB 1201. which is the labeling law related

to compostables that was going to make it difficult to sell compostable products there. And that's because, you know, that bill was looking at, it said that to be labeled compostable, you had to be listed on the accepted material list. On like so many percentage different. Yeah, under the National Organics Program, right? And so being able to expand the definition of what's allowed in organic compost is an important topic in discussion that we're having right now. And questions around regrettable substitutions, it's

coming up in that debate, right? That's where we're talking about, are these materials safe? You know, there's a lot of questions, rightly or wrongly, about the toxicity of biopolymers, like what could be in them. A common one is biopolymers can't perform. They melt in the heat. They brittle. They break. I mean, you name it. And you have to add crazy additives to be able to make them work. And that is not true these days. And also, we can't add a ton of additive to any biopolymer

and, one, make money. Because any time you add something to a polymer, that's increased cost. Nobody is looking to increase cost. Of course. Right? We've got, like, three additives in my day job, in the products that we make. And everybody's like, well, there are thousands of additives. And I was like, no, we have three. And the reason why there's three is because we don't want it to be more expensive. The hell are you talking about? Thousands. Oh, but to your point of the melting, I saw a LinkedIn post the other day.

There was a cup. It was a Starbucks lid that was labeled PLA that had melted. And this guy was going off about PLA. And I was thinking to myself, who knows who the manufacturer that was? It looked like it was imported. Who knows if it was actually PLA? There's just so many different scenarios here that somebody sees a picture and then they jump. to conclusions. That's a problem for biopolymers and traditional virgin polymers and recycled content. That's a problem for everybody

because one image is going to drive this conversation way more. And there was a study recently that I saw that even if you retract a story, once that story gets out there and becomes viral and everybody believes it. It doesn't matter if you retract it. It is now common knowledge. And that is fact. And fighting against that once it gets out in the world, it's tough. And that's what

I'm dealing with every day. And I'm sure you run into the same problems. Like, how do you fight that? Yes. It's really hard. It is really hard once there is a negative connotation to whatever to change hearts and minds. Yep. But I really. Really wish you the best. And I hope that CJ continues to grow in this space and that PHA becomes something that can scale. And PLA, too. I don't have a problem with PLA. I like

the idea of the home compostability more. And I would love to see that scale and succeed because I think that is a huge win for everybody if it does. Sam? I know you haven't talked much on this one, but anything from your end? No, don't apologize. That was definitely, I think, the most I've learned since I've been on the podcast, to be honest. Because I've told Justin many times that sometimes I get nervous coming in because

I'm like, I don't know what you guys are talking about. And I didn't really know what you guys were talking about a lot of the time. But that's also helpful because I'm learning the entire time. And this is something that I literally knew nothing about. So, yes, I was quiet, but I was listening because I just didn't. There's really it's hard to add when you don't know anything. I appreciate your time because I really this is something that if I wasn't here today, I probably would have never looked into or learned about. So I appreciate you taking the time to talk about

it. And the more you do these, the more you get that knowledge base. Yes. And then you'll. You'll be the one yelling at me to shut up. Hey, I got stuff to talk about. Which is hopefully soon. But yeah, Leah, thank you. No, thank you. I really appreciate us getting together here. And for Leah and for Sam, Justin Reine, Redefining Plastics, thanks so much. And everybody have a great day.

You want to learn more about the plastics industry, recycling, check out these other videos. Please like and subscribe.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Scaling Dissolution for Food-Contact Recycled Polypropylene with IPL Schoeller and PureCycle

    Nov 3, 202629 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney sat down with Melissa Vettleson (Sustainability and Materials Engineer at IPL Schoeller) and Christian Bruey (Director of Sustainability and External Affairs at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Are Plastics Sustainable? with Patrick Krieger of the PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 27, 202632 minAudio

    Justin Riney hosts Patrick Krieger, who is the Senior Vice President of Sustainability and Policy at the PLASTICS Industry Association. In this conversation, they dive deep into sustainability, plastics, and creating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Recycling Collaboration, EPR, and Building End Markets with PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 20, 202630 minAudio

    This was the third episode recorded at the National Plastics Conference (NPC), and the NPC Live podcast studio onsite. Thanks again to PLASTICS for having Redefining Plastics at the conference and all of their support....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. NAPCOR’s PET Bottle Decarbonization Roadmap with Husky’s Jolene Milne (NPC Live)

    Oct 6, 202624 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney speaks with Jolene Milne, a sustainability analyst at Husky Technologies and member of NAPCOR, about industry collaboration to combat misinformation about plastics and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EPR, Data Gaps, and Change Management with Christine Yeager at National Plastics Conference Live

    Sep 23, 202632 minAudio

    We had a blast with this interview at the National Plastics Conference on-site podcast studio, "National Plastics Conference Live." Christine Yeager of CSY Impact dove deep into extended producer responsibility (EPR),...

    Credit the people on this episode