Debunking Myths and Addressing Criticisms of Plastics
43 minAudio
In this episode of Redefining Plastics with Justin Riney, Justin embarks on a unique journey of opposition #research, examining what #environmental #ngos say about #plastics, particularly in the context of the ExxonMobil lawsuit in California. He discusses various viewpoints, exposes perceived #misinformation, and reacts to videos from Yellow Dot while exploring the nuances of plastic recycling. The episode delves into the complexities of recycling systems, the facts behind plastic waste, and the industry's efforts to improve recycling technologies. Join Justin as he passionately #defends the plastics industry and calls for better #communication and #collaboration to create a #sustainable future for plastics. All views expressed in this podcast are my own and are not affiliated with any company or organization.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to Daddy's Podcast. This is the Redefining Plastics Podcast with Justin Riney. Welcome to Redefining Plastics. I'm Justin Riney. Could do something a little different today. Wanted to check out some videos from other, we'll call them environmental NGOs, called Opposition Research. And I get a feel for what those that are anti -plastic, those that are well -funded. And those
that are very loud are out saying about our products and what we could possibly do about those. I'm going to play them along. I'm going to listen, probably pause and intermittently talk about my feelings about what they're saying. And then it's going to probably be somewhat like a reaction video, but we'll see how this goes. This first video is from Yellow Dot. Yellow Dot is an organization started by Adam McKay, former writer or head
writer on SNL. I got to give them to him. Some of these are pretty funny. I've seen a few of their videos so far, but this one is specific to the ExxonMobil lawsuit in California. Obviously there's some misinformation. I'll let you be the judge though. I'm going to just play it through and we'll listen. Beauty is a world filled with promise and hope. A world with delicious, clean drinking water. A table full of loved ones laughing at Thanksgiving dinner and no government interference
in our nation's incredible corporations, allowing them to continue putting profits over everything, including the wellbeing of every citizen on earth. But unfortunately for us, there's someone out there who wants to be a good guy. a virtuous guy who wants to hold corporations accountable for the lies that they tell. That man is Attorney General Rob Bonta of California. So we'll get into this in a little bit, but there's been a lot of noise about this lawsuit. Who knows where it's going to go. I don't see a lot of legs for
this, but at the same time, California obviously has deep pockets and so does Exxon. I think Exxon came out with a very strongly worded response to this, and they were very direct in what they thought of this lawsuit. They had a lot of very specific details on why they disagreed. And I thought it was possibly one of the best public facing statements to come out of any plastics organization in a very long time. But when you
look at California, California obviously is a beast unto itself. Whenever you see a lawsuit like this, this is politically motivated. Rob Bonta is trying to make a name for himself. Gavin Newsom isn't going to be the governor of California forever. And I think he's trying to put himself out there in the running. He makes a lot of friends on the progressive side of the California Democratic Party when he makes statements like this. And he put the lawsuit like this out there. It's not surprising. Rob recently filed a lawsuit
against ExxonMobil for conducting what he calls a decades long campaign of deception to convince the public that all plastic is recyclable." All plastic is recyclable. Whether or not it's being recycled depends on your municipality, depends on the infrastructure. Government needs to help. Public private partnerships are needed. We have to work together to... solve the infrastructure
problem, sortation, collection, bailing, and then the end markets where we come in as an industry where we can buy all that material back. There's nobody out there that's saying that a hundred percent of plastics are being recycled. But all thermoplastics, polyethylene, polypropylene, polystyrene, PET, ABS, what have you, any thermoplastic is recyclable. It is inherently recycled. It may not be recycled at the rates that we want
it, but the industry is spending a lot of money to fix this. And these kinds of messages and these types of videos are just really not helpful. They're counterproductive. They get people to recycle less. Less participation means less recycling of paper, glass, metal, and plastics. But 1970 was the truth about plastic pollution and recycling, but it never seemed important to share with the world because you don't want the facts. You want
to feel good about yourself. We made you heroes. Mr. Good Guy says we've created deception proofs that sound legitimate and promising to hide behind. How do we respond to that accusation? Nuh -uh. It has the name solutions in it. Solutions are a good thing. I mean, Yes, in 1988, we did use a plastic industry front group to promote a misleading version of the - I think that last, that last screen there, it's a scam. Yeah, I've been hearing
this a lot and specifically when you talk about California with 343, their state bill 343 and the fact that they're trying to ban the chasing arrows. I don't think anybody looks at those numbers to be completely honest. I had a conversation with some friends of mine that are highly educated. They are well intentioned. They really want to recycle and they want to be a part of the solution. And they don't even know what these numbers are.
They don't pay attention to the numbers and that's a problem. The numbers are there for a reason. We need to understand. what the polymer is so we can figure out how to sort them. And it's helpful for the consumer if the consumer even knows these numbers. And we don't do a good job as an industry of even talking about what the numbers are and why they're important. Nobody says chasing arrows means 100 % recyclable. Paper is not 100 % recyclable. Glass are 100 % recycled.
There's nothing that is 100 % recycled because there's not enough infrastructure out there to do it. And there's no collection in rural places like West Virginia, Alaska, places in Montana. So this idea that the plastics industry has been saying for 40 years that these chasing arrows means this product is recyclable is just patently false. Nobody is saying that. I don't know of anybody in the industry that is saying, Hey,
that's a number two or a number one. So that is recyclable. Nobody's saying that because there are applications that use either one of those, which are highly recycled materials that aren't being recycled today. So I think this whole, it's a bait and switch with these types of arguments that you get. It's not helpful. It's painful. To be honest, I spend a lot of my day job with
this type of opposition research. I just get more and more and more frustrated the more I watch this because they're taking little bits of truth and twisting it and it makes it seem like we're all out to get you as a consumer, the entire plastics industry. that you all associate with recycling. And maybe the front group did add a convoluted numerical system and put the
onus on the American public to figure it out, tricking you into thinking that if the symbol is on a product, it is in fact recyclable. So yeah, maybe we greenwash a little bit, but we do it for you and you love it when we do it. Our little marionette. So next time you're sorting, recycling, and wondering if it's a load of BS. Make sure to thank the real heroes, ExxonMobil. See, and that's back to the whole premise of my entire diatribe here. This is the problem.
Gen Z has heard this same message their entire life. Plastic recycling is false. It's a fraud. So they don't participate. And since they don't participate, it's a self -fulfilling cycle where we're not actually collecting The material that we want to collect and we're not recycling to the rates that we want to, because nobody's participating in the system anymore. People, there's 71 % of people say they participate every day. 45 % or less, depending on the study that you look at,
actually participate in recycling. It's this kind of stuff that's driving it. And it, to be honest, it's effective. It's emotional. It is. connecting with consumers on their level. And the thing that we do, and we don't do it very well, is we connect with each other. We get together as a plastics industry and we talk about the benefits of our products, but we never talk about that stuff publicly. And if we do talk about it publicly, we hide and we say things that are
like, oh yeah, we're fully recyclable now. We're working to... Further the circular economy. All good things. Yes, we should be talking about all of these things, but we shouldn't hide. Our products are great. They, they're used for a reason. Let's talk about those reasons. I just, I don't get, I understand not wanting to get sued. I get that. But at some point we have to stand up to stuff like this and say, that's not
accurate. ExxonMobil did a good job. That came out and they had a statement. I'll probably pull it up here in a second. And they were very forceful in their response to this. So here's a tidbit of the ExxonMobil response. For decades, California officials have known their recycling system isn't effective. They failed to act and now they seek to blame others. Instead of suing us, they could have worked with us. to fix the problem and keep
plastic out of landfill. That's only a part of it. I couldn't find it on their website. I think they didn't exactly want this to be front and center on their news release, but those are facts. I don't think they're necessarily blaming California or the states directly for plastic waste. What they're saying is, hey, we've been trying to work with you guys. We want to be a part of the solution. We want to help. Alleging that the
oil giant misled the public about the recyclability of its plastic products. Joining us right now is California Attorney General Rob Bonta. And Rob, thank you for coming in today. Thanks for having me. Honored to be here. Explain the basis of the lawsuit. The lawsuit is basically the state of California suing Exxon Mobil for a decades long campaign of deception in which they tried to convince the world, including California, that the recycling of plastic products, including single -use plastics, is sustainable. It is not.
It's a lie. That's a deception. Only about 5 % of plastic waste in the United States is ever actually recycled. 95 % goes to landfill or into the environment or oceans, rivers, or is incinerated. And the idea behind it was if the public was convinced that Uh, their single use throwaway consumer lifestyle, uh, was supported by recycling and that it was environmentally friendly. They would buy more and more and more, and it would drive the profits of ExxonMobil up, up and up.
And so that's the idea, but it's based on a lie. It's illegal. We've sued them in court and we're here to hold them accountable. Oh, there's a lot to unpack. Um, so the 5 % recycle rate. Yeah. Well. Plastics need to be recycled more. I think that's clear. We need better recycling. We need better infrastructure. It's not necessarily these products are not recyclable. It's that the collection
and everything else that goes along with recycling just doesn't work at scale in a lot of these areas. So what we need to do is we need to be talking. about what's next, what's that breakthrough technology. Advanced recycling could be in a very major way to take all of the films and the other hard to recycle products and get them recycled. So yeah, I think the highest I've seen, the EPS
transport packaging is very highly recycled. in the US, over 30 % more than likely, or around 30%, depending on what numbers you're looking at. PET bottles, just under 30%. There are success stories out there. The difference between PET bottles and steel cans, for that matter, not that big. And actually PET bottles are more recycled
than steel cans in some areas. So this idea that plastics need to be singled out is utterly ridiculous. I think there are so many issues that are out there. And the fact that everybody seems to be focusing on plastics when we are the lowest carbon footprint out of all of the packaging materials, we're lighter weight. So when it's actually sent
to a landfill, that's less material to a landfill. And it's a very wonderful scream pause here for the attorney general, but they act so superior. Like they are smarter than everybody else. Like they caught the industry in some sort of lie. Industry is not lying. The industry is saying our products are recyclable. Yes. It may not be recycled at the scale that we want it to be
today, but we're willing to invest. We're willing to put our own money, our own skin in the game. Please work with us, California, New York, New Jersey, United States government. We want to be a part of the solution. Let us be a part of the solution and stop throwing stones. And I think that's the biggest thing to say about all this. It's a little, I've had a hard time getting my head around the details of this. I'll tell you what ExxonMobil, the statement that they put out in response, they say, for decades, California officials have known the recycling system isn't
effective. They failed to act and now they seek to blame others. Assuming us, they could have worked with us to fix the problem and keep plastic out of landfills. The first step would be to acknowledge what their counterparts across the U .S. know advanced recycling works. To date, we've processed more than 60 million pounds of plastic waste into usable raw materials. keeping it out of landfills, we're bringing real solutions, recycling plastic waste that couldn't be recycled by traditional methods. So I honestly am trying to understand where the breakdown and what the
problem is. You referenced the Department of Energy's numbers back from 2022 that said 5 % of recycled stuff actually gets recycled. The rest of it winds up in other places. Exxon, I think its plant in Bayfront is 8 % average that you're seeing on some of these things. They say the rest of it, they break down into fuels and raw materials that can be used to remake plastic. Explain to me where the problem is, because I know that there have been lots of problems with recycling, where we all separate our recycling
and then it gets commingled and put back together in other places. What did Exxon do? Yeah, so I think it's pretty simple, pretty straightforward. ExxonMobil lied. They lied. to the world. No they didn't. They had a particular image makeover challenge with respect to the fact that their plastics that they wanted to sell more and more of were being found in waterways and on beaches and the public was in an uproar and so they needed to fix that. So they lied and said it's okay these items are being recycled and they tried
to play. All packaging is littered. Plastics flow. And so we are more front and center. To try to make the argument that plastics are littered at some sort of obscene rate compared to other packages is ridiculous. And so the argument then is, well, is the argument that the paper breaks
down in the environment? What about paper cups that have plastic liners. What about cardboard that has plastic liners on it? Whenever you want to replace plastics, you have to replace it with something. And it invariably comes back to paper. And I don't have any problem with paper. I love paper. I use a lot of paper products on a daily basis. I have no issue with it. They're great in some applications. But carrying liquids? Not
ideal. That should not be where paper is. Paper straws. I don't know about you. I hate paper straws. I don't typically use straws, but if somebody put a paper straw in something that I was using, I would have a big problem with that. So I think this idea that plastics are littered, everything else isn't, it's just insane to me. And these are the kinds of arguments that you hear from the other side. Plastics are everywhere. They're in the environment. Yes, they are, but
so is paper, sore cans. Just look at any street corner. There is a shopping cart full of cans somewhere. You know why they're full of cans? It's because they have a collection and a redemption system. So there's a value to it. So that is a solution. How do we incentivize Americans to
recycle? You have to give them a reason. And you have to prove to them that these things work. And this is counterproductive. This is doing the exact opposite. So people trust the system less and less and less. It's the blame on the consumer to put their items in the blue bin. It didn't matter if the items were put in the blue bin. But it's not just the consumer. Even if you put it in the blue bin, there's a lot of problems that come with, you know, starting from that moment on, there are lots of breakdowns in the system. If you haven't washed the plastics, they can't be recycled. We've had garbage company
CEOs who come on and talk to us about that, trying to educate the public on those things. If it gets mixed back in by the people who don't want to deal with it from this level on, on and on. I mean, it seems like there's a lot of breakdowns. Is there any point that plastics... If ExxonMobil knew that, they shouldn't have lied about it and said it was recyclable and that the items were being - It is recyclable. It's just not recyclable enough. No, it's not. And I'll talk about - Yes, it is. And he's going to make the argument that they're burning plastics. And it's
the same thing that folks like Beyond Plastics use. It's this idea that pyrolysis is incineration and pyrolysis is not incineration. It's raking. It uses heat, yes, extreme heat to break polymers down into monomers and other feedstocks. Yes, it does that. But then it becomes a like version PCR product that is then food contact approved to go right back into packaging. It's exactly
what they've been asking us to do. And when we do it, then they come out and say... Well, you're just lying to the consumer. No, no, we're not. You're misinformed. And the lawsuit that you put together comes directly from an NGO. And it's very clear who was behind it. And they aren't experts on this subject. And it makes you look foolish. And they're about to tear you a new one here a little bit. of an old lie. Let me
talk to you about their statement for a second. I don't hear in their statement a denial about the myth of recycling. I don't hear that. I do hear a complete failure to take accountability in their statement and complete deflection to others. Let me be clear about this. This case is to hold ExxonMobil accountable for their actions. They have hurt California and Californians billions of dollars worth of damage to our environment, to our people. And their answer in their statement is to point the finger at California, the people
that they hurt. Come on. Infest in your systems. Here's what that plant does. It doesn't recycle. It's an old technology. They're just heating up the plastic waste. Most of it turns into transportation fuels that are burned once and emitted into the air to the harm of our environment and our planet. That is not plastic recycling. Plastic recycling is turning plastic into more plastic. That's not plastic going into landfills. I think this is going to be interesting too, because there's been a lot of argument in advanced recycling
and kind of how the industry can approach this same issue that they're going to get into here. Talking about fuel exemptions and whether or not taking plastics and taking it back to fuel is an acceptable process to say that it's recycling. That material is not going to end up in a landfill. It will be reused. So technically it is recycling. But as an industry, we decided not to push that
because we want plastics to plastics recycling. That's really what our focus is. We want to take plastics and have that become plastics again, and then make new products. The hosts here on SquawkBox are going to talk about, you know, is it such a bad thing? for these plastics to become transport fuel. And I think it's a good question. I don't know if it is. I don't know if that's a bad thing or a good thing. All I
know is it's not ending up in a landfill. It's not ending up in the ocean. We need transport fuel anyway. It's keeping us from extracting more oil. So what's the problem here? I don't want to claim that as fully circular. economy and fully circular system plastics to plastics, I'm not going to make that claim. But at the same time, is it such a bad thing? So it's an interesting thing to think about. Using it in other ways. I mean, is your point that we shouldn't have plastics or we shouldn't have fuels? My
point is ExxonMobil shouldn't lie. If they are telling you, look at their own statements. They say we can turn any piece of plastic into another a useful piece of - They can't. You can use, they don't do that. The Department of Energy has said the reason they think it's only 5 % is because there's no demand for the recycled plastic. I'll show a good point. They can produce this if there's not demand for it and people who want to use it, what do you do with that? ExxonMobil knew their items aren't being recycled. That's what they should have said. They said the opposite. They are being recycled. They told people that they're not being recycled. They're
being recycled. If they're being burned down and put into fuels - That's not recycled. It's being recycled and not lining up in the way of the rivers that you're saying. Their advanced recycling program certifies circular, meaning a plastic bottle goes to the recycling system and comes back as a plastic bottle or another plastic product. They don't tell people that 92 % of what they quote unquote recycle turns into jet fuel or transportation fuel. Again, your point is that we shouldn't have plastics? Your point is we shouldn't have plastics? That people should be allowed to use them? My point is ExxonMobil should not lie. They should not
lie. And so people can make their own decisions. If people know that their items are going to go to landfill, the oceans, the rivers, into turtles' noses, they're not into the Great Pass, then they should know that. The point is that they're burning it down. It's not going into turtles' noses and into riverways. I understand we have a problem with too many plastics winding up in those places. But you're saying that the recycling plant's not doing that. If the recycling plant is burning it down. They're not dumping any landfills. Is that what you're arguing? Well, let's talk about it. Here's the capacity of their so -called advanced recycling, 1 % of their own plastic production. The other 99 % does not go
through advance. Yeah. We need to scale. The industry has to scale these technologies. This is, you know, he made the argument earlier that the technology has been around for 40 years. You know, yeah, in some way, shape or form, but we are really invested as an industry. to improve upon those technologies and make them work. And I know that they work. I've seen them work. And I know that that's happening consistently. So the idea that we're lying about it and only 1
% of ExxonMobil's, yeah, right now, but they have plans to build four paralysis plants. at multiple of their production facilities. And they're really leading the way on a lot of this stuff. And the other thing that I think is ridiculous is he's using a nameplate capacity for a world scale reactor and saying, or multiple world scale reactors and saying, well, you know, only 1 %
of that nameplate capacity can be recycled. But a lot of this stuff can go into... durables. We're not talking packaging. We're talking all plastic production at that Exxon facility. So it's a false equivalent to try to say only 1 % of their products are recycled. Yeah, but some of those products are still in the economy. They aren't single use plastics. So if you want to make the argument about single use plastics, get some numbers together and talk about it that
way, but this is... This is not a true comparison. It's not apples to apples. It's recycling. It does go to landfills. It does go to incinerators. It does go into our environment. It's a very tiny amount of what they are actually doing, and they're not actually recycling. And they only turned 8 % through advanced recycling into recycled plastic. They need to add virgin plastic to even turn it into something useful again. It's a sham. Advanced recycling... So if it goes into jet fuel... We don't need to add virgin
products back into it to make it usable. We need to add virgin back into it to make it cost effective. So Becky Quick earlier in this video said that the lack of demand per the EPA is why PCR is not scaling and there's not enough recycling. It's a valid point. So if, if we could find a way to get consumers to pay the extra cost that would be associated with collecting, sorting,
bailing, transport of these raw materials, these PCR materials from one location to another, that's way more expensive than using pipelines to take ethylene and benzene to make whatever products that we're making as an industry. Of course it's going to be more expensive. And of course somebody is going to have to pay for that. And the idea that we have to add Virgin in there to make it
usable is patently false. We have to add Virgin in there to make it cost effective. Your that doesn't count for anything for you or it or it does in these percentages that you're providing Yeah, that's the biggest we're we're talking about here. So I recognize you're saying 1 % this or it becomes another 90 % of something the question is are you saying the 90 % is showing up in landfills are you saying that if it shows
up in jet fuel or some other kind of Recycled way that you know, you're discounting that well any by the way, you could say look I just wish that they said publicly that it was it was going to jet fuel as opposed to The idea that it's recycled all into bottles. I just think we just need to decipher what you're saying. When you're saying they're lying, do you know what I mean? Yep. They're lying in different ways. They are saying that they're recycling, that essentially 100 % of US plastic can be recycled. That was the myth that they wanted to perpetuate. It can be. Exactly right. It can be. It's not been.
It can't be. It's not technical or financially feasible. Advanced recycling, they're so -called wonder recycling. approach only recycles 1 % of the plastic products that ExxonMobil creates. Into other plastics, and then you need divergent plastics. I understand that. No, no, no, no, not that. Of all of the plastics that ExxonMobil produces from their product, only 1 % goes into the advanced recycling process at all. And of that 1%, 92 % becomes mostly transportation fuel. So the other 99 % of what ExxonMobil produces
in plastic and what the world produces in plastic, advanced recycling doesn't touch. It's back to where we were before, where 95 % of it goes into the landfill. Exactly. Even if he's right, let's say he's right, that only 1 % will go to advanced recycling. That's better than it ending up in the environment, in waterways. It's a solution. Is it a perfect solution right now? No. To improve
upon it. We need to reduce costs. We need to make it more. We need to find a way to create the demand on the backend where people are actually going to pay for the additional costs. And if we can do that and we have the pull through, we can do more of this. But it's still better than ending up just sitting in a landfill. It's being taken back to and for the attorney general here. It's either going onto jet fuel or it's
becoming plastics again. Either one of those is a better option than ending up in a waterway. Let's admit it into the air or transportation fuel and becomes part of our - So your point is we shouldn't have jet fuel? My point is ExxonMobil shouldn't buy and they shouldn't - You flew here though, right? We travel. I guess what I'm trying to understand is there's one percent piece, so there's 99 - You're saying the 99 % is going to jet fuel or you're saying the 99 % is going to the ground? 99 % of what ExxonMobil produces
in plastic is not touched by advanced recycling. That's only one piece of recycling. There's such a big recycling industry out there. That's talking about just one technology, one facility. We're talking about multiple advanced recycling facilities and the entire mechanical recycling industry that exists globally right now. That is recycling and it is recycling at scale. We'd like to recycle more. That's why we're talking about advanced
recycling, to solve problems, to solve the hard to recycle flexible films or small formats or other things that cannot be traditionally handled through mechanical recycling. His argument is we shouldn't do that, or we should tell people that only 1 % goes through advanced recycling. Those are two different things. We're talking two different things here. And he's talking out
of both sides of his mouth and he looks like a fool. And I don't know if he completely understands how bad he looks in this interview. jet fuel or something else, which by the way, I think some people would find acceptable. Maybe if they if they disclosed it that way and you're saying they don't, I understand that. Or are you saying it ends up in a landfill? If you're saying it ends up in a landfill and that they're they're lying about that specifically, that is actually a bigger lie or a bigger problem. The 99 % is
a lot of percentages, I'm sorry. OK, the other 99 % is. Is where 95 % of the 99 % goes into landfill. the environment or is incinerated. Okay. So you're saying most of it is going into landfill. Yes. And they're not telling us that. Correct. That's what you're trying to say. And their reliance on advanced recycling touches very little of actual plastic waste. Most of it turns into jet fuel. I know you might have a different view of that. There's stuff too. 95 % of the plastics they make, Exxon themselves, doesn't go back into recycling. That's another
good argument. So why is Exxon getting sued here? I'm not advocating for anybody else to get sued. I'm just saying Exxon's a big name. It's a massive producer of plastics. And I think that's kind of why California wanted to make a big splash. Like I said, Rob Bonta has designs. Newsom is not going to be the governor of California forever. He's trying to get his name out there. And what easier way is there to get elected in California?
than being seen as the green candidate, but also in the Democratic party. I think that's really what all this is coming down to. It's to shame this kind of stuff. It frustrates me to no end because you can throw any statistics you want out there and you can talk about things abstractly in numbers. But we haven't talked about anything in this video that actually means anything. other than when Kernan calls him out for saying, hey,
you flew here and you're complaining about jet fuel, which I think is great. So there's another one of my favorites. Beyond plastics, they are a well -intentioned group. I think they truly
do think they're making a difference. They're led by an academic who used to work for the EPA. And their goal is to remove plastics from packaging. And honestly, if you're... reading anything that they have written is just to ban plastics altogether. And run into this kind of messaging all the time where packaging just ends up in a landfill. So
this kind of video is talking about bottle to bottle. This is some industry shill that they have put out here in claymation and now they're going to show what really happens to the bottle, at least according to them. Well, you know, we sometimes turn it back into new bottles. Sometimes it goes here. But don't worry, only 92 % of plastics end up here. 27 plus percent of P .T. bottles are recycled. So that's patently false. If you're
wondering what to do with that empty bottle, just put it in your nearest recycling bin and it'll get sent here to us. So we can, um, try our best to recycle it. This image, these kind of images just really, they poke at that emotional image of the sea turtles with the straw slash eating a bag, the doctored photos that are out
there, and the idea that plastics are being dumped directly into the ocean in America. You know, and it may be that in some areas where there is no waste... management system. People might be dumping plastics directly into the ocean because they don't have another solution. And that's what this global plastics treaty could have done. They could have solved for that. And really, when you look at it, when you look at the statistics, most ocean plastics are actually fishing gear.
It's not even plastic packaging. And this idea that there's going to be more plastic in the ocean than fish, and I don't even remember what year it was, that's Not true either. It's just, nobody is there to hold these folks accountable. They can say what they want because it's an NGO and nobody is going to come out and directly attack it. Saying that what we say as an industry is a lie. And I'm not advocating for us to go
out and just start attacking environmental NGOs. Quite the opposite. I want to work with these folks. I want to show them. that these things work and I want to change hearts and minds rather than fighting with them. And maybe I'm, I'm hopelessly naive, but I truly do think that if we work together and we communicate with these people in a way that they can understand. We can make changes here because if we don't, we're going to just keep getting kicked by these organizations and
consistently. And it's actually really good marketing. And it's catchy, gets a ton of views. And there's a bunch of money in environmental NGOs that are anti -plastics. Because it's a message that sells. And you know why? It's because there's no alternative message out there. Our industry has not done enough to counteract this. Plastics Industry Association has done a good job. Recycling is
real. That's great. It actually is pretty compelling. The problem is consumers are not getting that message. C suites are, different organizations are, but the consumers aren't getting that. Consumers are seeing this. The consumers are seeing TikTok videos. And you know, we're going to have a hard time with that forever because people can see our waste. when it's not handled properly, when
it's not disposed of properly. People can't see the metal at the bottom of the ocean. They can't see all the other packaging materials that are thrown in into the environment because it just, it's not as visible. So plastics has a bullseye on it. But we have to be better about talking about why plastics, why do people use plastics? And that's the whole point of Everything that I'm doing here is why does it even matter that
we're recycling? Why does it matter that we're trying to make this circular? Why does it matter that I'm trying to protect the future of plastics in any small way that I can? It's because it's a better material for all of these packages than everything else. Yes, we need to be better about the end of life, but we got to stop. shying away from going right to the consumer and saying, you use plastics because it is more convenient
and you think it's not being recycled today and it's a pollution issue, micro plastics, whatever. Let me show you. And not just in a grocery store where there's a bottle that says a hundred percent recycled content. People don't believe that. We got to stop with that. We actually have to show them that we are recycling. We have to be better about how we talk to the consumer. Otherwise they're going to eat our lunch forever. So I think that's probably enough for today. I went
through several of these videos. I get very frustrated after a while of watching these things, but if you like this, let me know. Give it a like if you do. If this is something that you're interested in. I'm more than happy to do more of these consistently and then maybe bring in some other voices to kind of have a conversation about these videos. But I thought these ones were just kind of on the nose right now with everything going on with the global plastics treaty and everything else. So yeah, I appreciate you taking the time to
watch today. This has been Redefining Plastics. I'm Justin Riney and good night.
At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney sat down with Melissa Vettleson (Sustainability and Materials Engineer at IPL Schoeller) and Christian Bruey (Director of Sustainability and External Affairs at...
Justin Riney hosts Patrick Krieger, who is the Senior Vice President of Sustainability and Policy at the PLASTICS Industry Association. In this conversation, they dive deep into sustainability, plastics, and creating...
This was the third episode recorded at the National Plastics Conference (NPC), and the NPC Live podcast studio onsite. Thanks again to PLASTICS for having Redefining Plastics at the conference and all of their support....
At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney speaks with Jolene Milne, a sustainability analyst at Husky Technologies and member of NAPCOR, about industry collaboration to combat misinformation about plastics and...
We had a blast with this interview at the National Plastics Conference on-site podcast studio, "National Plastics Conference Live." Christine Yeager of CSY Impact dove deep into extended producer responsibility (EPR),...