Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Redefining Plastics

Redefining Plastics artwork

The Truth About Chemicals- with Simon Maechling

Jul 15, 20251 hr 6 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Are you on a journey to go "chemical free?" Do you think that chemicals will kill you? You will not want to miss this episode. Join hosts Justin Riney and Samantha Ryan as they welcome chemistry expert Simon Maechling to the Redefining Plastics podcast. Fresh from a holiday break, the trio dives into widespread misconceptions about plastics and chemicals. With humor and insightful anecdotes, Simon debunks myths surrounding everyday chemicals, the misunderstanding of toxicity, and the erroneous belief that 'natural' always means 'better.' They shed light on the critical nuances of scientific literacy, the importance of dose-response relationships, and the fallacies driven by social media. Whether you're a science enthusiast or just curious, this is an engaging discussion you won't want to miss! https://www.linkedin.com/in/simon-maechling/ https://x.com/simonmaechling?lang=en Redefining Plastics https://www.redefiningplastics.com/ https://www.brvind.com/redefining-plastics https://rss.com/podcasts/redefining-plastics-with-justin-riney https://www.instagram.com/redefining_plastics/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/justin-riney-mba-67685940/ https://youtube.com/@redefiningplastics?si=KvG4dTvY1lALbwIm

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Daddy's Podcast. This is the Redefining Plastics Podcast. Welcome to the Redefining Plastics Podcast. My name is Justin Riney. We have Samantha Ryan again. And we are back from an extended trip slash time off for the fourth. And hopefully everybody had a great time. I know, Simon, you're out there in France. You're not exactly celebrating the the fourth, but glad to have you here. I've

been following your work on LinkedIn for a very long time. And so I've been quietly stalking your posts for probably the last two years. And I just always love what you have to say. I would put you as an expert in chemicals and understanding how all of these things work. And really happy to have you here, Simon. Mechling? Yeah. Ah, see? I did it right. I'm very impressed with

myself for the first time. But yeah, happy to have you here. Why don't you tell us a little bit about who you are and what you do, and we'll just run from there. Yeah, thanks. Thanks so much for the invitation as well to talk a little bit today, to have a chat. So I probably have the least French accent for a Frenchman. And maybe I'll just say, you know, my father's French, my mother's English, and so that's where my nationality and my accent come from. And I liked how you introduced it, so I would also say I'm an expert

in chemistry, so my PhD is in organic chemistry, and so I studied that for a long time. And I've been working in the chemical industry for the last 20 years, specifically in Big Ag. bio -crop science, in R &D, in chemistry, in the crop protection division. I think that leads to the conversation of you are not a plastics guy. I am not a plastics guy. I am not a plastics expert. That's not the purpose of the conversation. This is a plastics

-centered podcast, but I think you and I are on similar crusades. I am not a scientist. I make that very clear to everybody I talk to. So I don't have opinions on things. I go off of what experts say. And so when you say something, I take that as there's an expert speaking, so I'm going to take that information. There are several other people that I run into like that, but I don't come to my own conclusions when it comes to science because I don't know what I'm doing or talking about. Not everybody on the

internet feels that way. A lot of people on the internet. feel like they have a PhD in chemistry and have very loud voices and say things authoritatively and it drives me insane. And I know you are also fighting those same battles. So that's why I wanted to talk to you. I wanted to talk to you about just the understanding of chemistry by the layperson and the lack thereof. And then just the understanding of Like causality, I think

is a big thing, like just understanding correlation and things like that. You had a great post yesterday that I reposted about correlation and causality. Why don't you start there? Why don't you talk through kind of where your head was at when you put that together? Because I immediately reposted that. Yeah, thank you for that. And I'll come back to that before I do. I mean, cats are a great way to teach science. OK. And I'll come back to that comment a bit later. And I want to start on the sort of chemistry journey and

some things which are really important to me and why I started talking on social media. LinkedIn is the platform we're talking about around chemistry and some basic science, because I noticed in conversations with my family, my friends and the famous Saturday night barbecue, I noticed that there was some general misunderstanding, miscomprehension or lack of understanding around some certain basic chemical or scientific concept.

And I really wanted to share them because I'm so passionate about my subject and what I do and what I've done in the lab. And I'll start with these basic concepts that may or may not have been forgotten by many people. The first one being that all matter consists of chemicals. And I had a conversation maybe just 10 minutes ago on another platform. H2O, so some people may call it dihydrogen monoxide, there may be other names going around for it, it's called water, is a chemical and described by a chemical

formula. The same way that ethylene, C2H4, is also a chemical and a very useful chemical in your industry, the plastics industry, for making polyethylene, which is a plastic which you know much more about than I do. And so the first principle which I've realised that people have just kind of forgotten is everything, all matter is made of chemicals. The second one, which is equally important and also being forgotten, is that all

chemicals are toxic. at a defined dose. And this may sound scary the first time you realise it, but if I break it down a little bit and give some examples, I may try to bring away some of that fear. We mentioned water. Water is also a toxic chemical. It's called drowning. When you have too much of it around you or in you, if you drink too much it can also cause toxic

reactions to you. And so to have a scientific discussion on chemistry you need to understand all matter is chemistry. All chemicals are toxic at a certain dose. And then the most important concept and the most difficult for most people to understand is is the dose that makes the poison. And so if I'm not drinking lots of water, then I'm not drowning. If I'm not being exposed to lots of water, I'm not drowning. The same for

any other chemical which we could mention from a long list of chemicals, and I'm sure we'll mention other ones later on. And so I started this journey with these three basic concepts in mind, is how can I help the layperson, the social media guru, the keyboard warrior? understand these three simple scientific concepts. Yeah. And I'm sure it's as frustrating as it is for me talking to legislators about what I'm dealing with because they are in the same boat of the

people that you're talking to. I don't have the tools though to help those people understand as well as you can. So what I've found myself doing recently is just regurgitating what you say. to legislators when I'm talking to them, because it helps. It really does help, because just the framework, I think, is the part that people are really struggling with, just understanding. Because these are some big concepts that we're talking through, and people are... Let me be

careful on how I say this. Most people want to do the right thing. Most people are trying to make the best decision with the information that they have. So that typically comes out... As in my world, well, there's microplastics everywhere, so we need to ban it all. Okay, I understand. I have empathy for that thought process, but that's only part of the picture. There's so much more to it. And I know in your neck of the woods

and what you're dealing with, it's very similar. And similar in people are talking about. We need to have organic. We need to have this. We need to have that. It needs to be chemical free. You know how many times I've seen packaging that says chemical free? It's just insane to me that anybody could put that on packaging and get away with it. But what do you think about that when you see that kind of stuff? Yeah, I mean, the chemical free one is one that I really enjoy

when I notice that, the chemical free one, because no matter is chemical free. You can argue this all day long. It comes down to a simple fact that all matter is chemicals. And so this is one thing which I think it gets me on my soapbox. And I love to take the opportunity to talk about chemical -free, people that talk about chemical -free, chemical -free posts is one thing that I love to discuss with the public because it's just not true. And then while we're talking about

chemical free, you mentioned the microplastic situation, which is again, I'm not an expert on microplastics at all, but I do want to lay out the parallel discussions that we have on pesticides, which we're using crop protection and pesticide residues. And so microplastics, at least to my understanding, are very small particles found in stuff, detected in whatever's being detected and published. residues are very similar pesticide residues and the parallel is

that we're talking about very small quantities or very small concentrations of material that is detected and quantified. I think that's where these two worlds really come parallel because both suffer from the same fear -based marketing which is basically around detection equals danger, which is not the case. So Sam from your perspective coming like your generation I think personifies

this way more than anybody else that just There's a it's very black and white in my experience within you can correct me where I'm wrong, but The amount of people that I've talked to that are Gen Z or even younger That'll say well, it's there. We need to get rid of it all because it's killing us. Just the general misunderstanding of what the heck is going on in the world. Are

you experiencing that when you're talking to people? No, when I'm talking to people, I feel like just because my generation or even just people my age are so massively absorbed with social media. And I think the issue is, and I mean, I'm not going to say that I don't, I'm not an expert even in class, like an expert in plastics. and much less of chemicals. So I just kind of live my life by, I do what I eat, what I want. I like what I want. I'm not really, I mean, I'm not really worried about, I mean, I've

made it this far. So, but I think the issue really is, is that, like I said, like, I'm probably guilty of this is like, you see something on TikTok or somebody, sometimes it can even be AI, like you can literally tell AI to say quite literally anything. And they'll explain, I just saw, something about oatmeal being so bad for you. And my sister drinks oat milk, so I sent it to her. And she was like, that is not true at all. And I'm like, oh, I believed it. They

got me. And that's the problem, right? That is the crux of this conversation. And right after I saw that video, I was like, I mean, I don't drink oat milk, but I'm like, no, I'm definitely not drinking oat milk, Feen. That's what I saw. Well, it's gross. That's the first problem. Like you shouldn't drink milk. That's the only reason not to drink it. Chemicals are not, oh, milk is a big no. But I think that the big issue is social media, maybe not AI as much because if

you are kind of smart, you can tell it's AI, but can literally say anything. And then you're like, oh, that sounds like it's right, especially for somebody who's kind of uneducated, especially in chemicals like I am. So I don't hear people ... talking about it as much except for online. And that's where it's super believable. Well, your generation doesn't even talk to each other. You're texting. Right. Except unless it's online. Because after I saw that oat milk thing, I went to the comments and it was like, that's not true. And I'm like, well, who do I believe here? I

don't know either of you. The oat milk sellers were all on there. I'm like, you could be lying. You could be lying. That's why I'm like, I just don't care. I'm going to drink whatever regardless. I do think that it's just become even worse now that you can really say anything and anybody will believe it. And the only way you could really know, I guess, is if you get a degree in chemicals. Get an expert opinion. Listen to people that know what they're talking about. How hard is

that? It does make sense to me, obviously, that it's always the amount. because obviously things like you said there's chemicals and everything and that's just it's so silly and people I always think of like moms when they look at the bottom of things filled with chemicals and I'm like well they don't just because I have wondered when you read ingredients or something and I don't recognize half the stuff and I'm like why would they even like what's the point like preservatives and all that like why is that in there for but I mean it doesn't change my mind about it but

It's always like, it's in there for a reason. Like it's not, you're good. Like you're gonna be fine. And this is exactly what both Simon and I are fighting with. Yeah, like you're gonna be cool. Like don't think about it. Just do it. I think the only thing maybe you can clear this up for me, Simon, because I am a dog mom, pesticides on like leftover, if it was like a pest control. Is that toxic to dogs if they're smaller because

they'll get bigger doses? Because it's not like a human taking in that amount. You mean like in yards and stuff like that? You only spray like stuff? Not a bad question. Because it's the amount of dose, but since it's a smaller being, the dose can be worse. This is a really good question, Sam, and thank you for doing it. I'm going to take a small detour if I can to get there because I want to just talk about the benefits of pesticides when it comes to pets. So I have two schnauzers. One is about a kilo,

the other one about nine, nine and a half kilo. And one of the real benefits of insecticides is I treat my dogs preemptively. So I treat them with a pill, a tablet, which they take. and it protects them from ticks. You know ticks, yeah. So ticks, just very briefly, the ticks will latch onto the dog's skin, they'll draw blood. While they're drawing blood, they'll insert, so before they suck, they push, they spit, if you like, a small analgesic, so something to stop the pain

the dog doesn't notice. And when they push in this liquid, there can be diseases, viruses transferred from the tick to the dog. And so the insecticides, what they do, they work very quickly. And the idea is that very quickly the tick, the insect, will die before all of this happens. It will suck a little bit before it pushes and it will die instantly. So there's less transfer of disease for the dog because tick -borne diseases are a real problem with family pets, especially in

rural areas, countryside areas in the springtime. And so I want to start with the benefit of using spot on or tablet insecticides for our pets to avoid the pets getting sick or the pets getting ill. So there's a real benefit from using modern technologies to stop diseases, in this case for our pets. That wasn't your question though. Your

question was really around exposure. And so what you're saying is, is there a risk, because we need to talk about risk, is there a risk when my pets are in a yard after a pesticide has been used, et cetera, et cetera. And so it's about exposure. And so when we're talking about risk, which is very different to hazard. So I don't know if I can just take a quick second. That's a good start. Yeah. We will. Hazard and risk.

So hazard basically means, is there a potential of harm? And if I give you some examples of what a hazard is, a hazard would be me standing at the edge of a cliff, making a TikTok video. There is a potential for harm because there's a cliff and there's something I could fall over. But what I could do in order to mediate this potential, this hazard is put up a fence. And so by putting

up a fence, if I'm walking backwards whilst filming and the hazard is I could fall off the cliff, if there's a fence there, the fence would stop me. And so I'm... turning a hazard into a risk, and I'm sorry, the French word keeps coming back. I'll get the English word in a minute. I'm mediating the hazard. And I'm making the cliff edge safer for social media fans, TikTok gurus, et cetera, when they're doing the film. The same occurs for almost everything that we do in life. So

just spending a little bit more time on risk. Getting into a car is a risk. We generate, we control or reduce that risk by wearing a seatbelt, by having airbags, by having simple things like indicators to indicate to other drivers that we should be going left or right at a certain time. So each moment of our lives... Nobody uses those, by the way. They do in France. It's a different argument. Some of them do in France. Don't start with your French drivers. So we have

all these risk mitigation measures that we use in our daily life to avoid problems. And so coming back to your question on exposure, is there a risk of my pets being in the yard? Well, all pesticides are regulated. They're heavily researched. They're heavily regulated and they're heavily controlled. And there will be on the label, there will be instructions for what's called a post application interval. which will basically say after application, avoid going to the area for

X period of time, which could be an hour, a day, a week, whatever it says on the label. And that's your safety net in terms of is it safe afterwards? Well, let's read the label and we'll wait that specific period of time before my dog goes into that area, into that field or wherever it is, in order to avoid any unnecessary risk. And that's usually based on like the smallest possible pet that would go in there. That's the time frame.

It's based on an enormous number of parameters. And yes, it will be based on a highly sensitive species. Like a little hamster. For example. It could be. So when you're walking down the street, Sam, with your dog, and you see a sign that says, do not walk on this yard until 10 a .m. That's something we should listen to. Don't walk on the art until 10 a .m. Yeah. Exactly. That sign I should actually take seriously. Yes. Exactly. Thank you. Yeah. But it's a good question

because it drives at the bigger discussion here because people will say, well, we need to go to organic pesticides. There's some arguments to be made that there are some pesticides that can be made organically using naturally occurring But it doesn't work as well. I don't know about you. I've tried. I had a dog once that had a reaction to the Simperico type stuff. So I had to do natural stuff for him just because I was

worried about other things. And this also is my stupidity of chemistry because I just lumped them all in and said, we had problems with one, he's going to probably have problems with all of them, which not true. But that's just a fear I had. And that's what's driving 99 % of all of this. It's fear -mongering, fear cells. They say sex cells, fear cells just as much. If you look through my LinkedIn feed, it's typically

NGOs that I follow that are anti -plastics, or plastics people, or other chemistry people that I enjoy reading. And 90 % of my feed is plastics are gonna kill you. Plastics are killing us. And that's like, I understand. I would even go so far, sorry to cut you off, but I would even go so far to say that plastics have saved countless numbers of lives. Yeah. And again, I'm on your turf, and that's so huge. Yeah, yeah. But if

you look at the use of plastics in terms of sterilized instruments in hospitals, Being able to keep the bags of blood and all the things that you know about I'd say actually optics plastics have saved an account this number of lives Yeah, and the fact is that nobody wants to talk about that. They want to talk about microplastics. I think there's just And correct me if I'm wrong, but There's this big movement towards natural. Yeah in the world is everybody assumes that if it's

naturally occurring, it's better than synthetic. And it's my experience that there's just as much danger in the natural world as there is synthetically. What do you think about that? Am I onto something there? Am I way off base? No, you're completely onto something here. And this is what I call the... appeal to nature fallacy. So the belief that natural is naturally good and synthetic is naturally bad. Anybody who smokes weed talks

like that, just for the record. It comes from the earth. It's safe for me. And this myth is a myth, which it's the most common fallacy I come across every single day, the appeal to nature fallacy. And it's a fallacy because some of the most, I'll begin here, so some of the most toxic compounds known to man are natural substances. The most famous one is botulinum toxin, which is the most toxic, one of the most toxic substances

we know. And yet people inject it into their face to get rid of their, their wrinkles or to make their lips botox. Exactly. And this, this appeal to nature fallacy is is especially interesting when it comes to keyboard warriors fighting their natural corner, because of course computers aren't natural. Neither is the internet. Neither is electricity. And I go on and I go on and I undersea cables taking signals. So all of these things,

none of these things are natural. Yet there seems to be... a desire by certain groups to bring in fear and synthetic equals bad, natural equals good, which is on itself not true. And even so much so, I'd go a step further. I'd say it's thanks to technologies like plastics, crop protection products, fertilizers and genetics, that today we live longer than ever before. A life expectancy

today is roughly double than what it was 100, 150 years ago. Let me just sort of say 70, 80 years old today is now normal, whereas 100 years ago it was roughly average life expectancy was half. So all of these synthetic, unnatural technologies have led us to live longer, healthier lives. What do you think causes all this? Why do you think there's such a drive? towards this thought process. I wish if it needs to be thought itself.

I do too. I'm trying to figure it out myself. That's why I'm asking. I feel like it, I mean, from what I see, it's like the natural side of like wanting to be completely like clean of everything. I mean, I see it all over like social media. Like beauty products. It's all, yeah. It's like, I was talking to a friend of ours the other day because we were talking about how much money we spend. And we're like, well, we just want to keep up with the trends. Like you see trends on TikTok and you want to like, for some reason, like even if you don't like it, like you want

to be it, like you want to do it too. And there's been a, this is like a whole nother side, but this new thing with like, uh, people online are losing a ton of weight and they're selling their courses, but like they've been on Ozempic the whole time. And it like comes out and people are like, what the heck? You've been lying. So it's like, people will say that like, oh, I'm on this snap. I did this for so and so months and this happened to me. And it's like, like I said, people literally will be bullied anything.

It's all BS is what you're saying. Well, no, I'm not saying it's all BS, but I'm saying maybe that's why people think this way is because people pour them all of these, whether maybe for some people it's true. And maybe because I'm sure like for some people, they do natural things. And of course, your body is going to change, but they might lie. for monetary purposes or to go viral, and then everyone's like, well, I'm going to do that now, and I'm going to do that now because this person got these results from it, or they feel like this in the morning, or now they can walk 20 ,000 steps in 1010. I

don't know. Well, but that means they're tapping into the ethos of the whatever society that you're in. So that means that they're tapping into something that already exists. So that's the part that I'm trying to figure out. And I think And this is just me spitballing you. We have become so inundated with technology around us and specifically younger generations spend so much time indoors that they don't go outside. And so there's just

this huge disconnect between actually being in nature and wanting, having that desire, that human desire to actually be in nature because that's where we ... grew up as a species and I think that's driving a lot of this because nobody's ever outside and they figure that if they just Change some products that they're buying or eating or consuming then all of a sudden they're gonna be in touch with nature Yeah, when all they have to do is step outside. Just go for

a freaking walk and Go for a hike. No, that's just be outside. Yeah, I don't know. What do you think Simon? I think that we're starting to get somewhere here on why there is this appeal to nature. Why do people think that having, we mentioned chemical free, my other hate is the made from 90 % natural products label or however many it is, Sam, on your shampoo. 90 % derived from natural ingredients. I don't even know. I just buy what I like. You're not the target

market. No, I whatever makes my hair soft is good for me And I like those ones because because we could sit here and argue that crude oil is natural And so it is derived from crude oil is natural Yeah, so these these marketing labels which which are there which which we fed daily through our feeds and in and on the television and We're convinced that buying these is better because of this and I think we're making some ground here Look, I think there's a desire and perhaps an unconscious desire to this return

to nature to be more natural, you know, natural setting, natural food. I heard a lot of times as well. And these are all like city dwellers for the most part that are really pushing this. And when you look outside, like I was in Houston a couple of weeks ago, it is wall to wall concrete. Yeah. And I wanted to be in nature after two days, I'll tell you that, because I didn't see nature the entire time I was there. Yeah. I think we're getting somewhere on this, but again, I don't know why and how this came about. Thinking

as a chemist or thinking of everything around me as a chemist, I mean, some people see a computer, I see polyvinyl chloride, I see an aluminum water bottle next to me, I see cellulose in the brochure, some other plastic cloths, and I sort of see the world broken down into different elements, different chemical structures sort of around me. It's difficult for me to answer your question on why we think natural is better, because none of the settings I'm sat in today are natural.

And when I go home in my house, none of it's natural. And neither is my garden, because it's a small garden that I tend to myself. So it's like the AstroTurf back there? No, I've got 20 square meters and four tomato plants. Oh, all right. Fair enough. And they're all genetically modified, I would assume. And that's another thing. So I came out of the agricultural industry, and so it really pisses me off, this genetically modified... So GMO, GMO free. I couldn't, for

the life of me, figure out the GMO part. But it's like everything is genetically modified. Humans are genetically modified. When two people mate, that is genetic modification. What comes out of that is just the offspring of putting two creatures together. It's the same thing we're talking about with, we're not adding in just a bunch of crazy stuff into this. It just, it drives me insane. It literally drives me insane.

The acronym GMO or the phrase genetically modified is absolutely useless as a descriptor and it really highlights the... the uselessness, for want of a better word, of what this descriptor is. And I think genetically engineered is a much better term that we should use where there's been an intervention to put a gene from a jellyfish into a whatever, into another species, like a

plant, to make that plant fluoresce. Genetically engineered is a much better descriptor to use. So GMO is just a useless term. Yeah. Because as you've correctly said, sexual reproduction is a form of genetic modification. Yeah. We're just talking about breeding. That's all we're talking about with these things. And this is just the one thing that is crystal clear for me is acronyms sell. The small acronyms, because people don't have to understand what it really

means, and they see it and they think, danger. And that's exactly what your post the other day was about is you just, you think there is a danger in whatever it is, and so you run with it and you make buying decisions, you make life decisions. Some people wrap their whole being around, I am not going to do this thing because I'm so afraid of it. And it just, it shocks me. Exactly.

And the big one at the moment, I don't know if I can say it online, but PFAS. Oh my God. As an acronym. For what? People call them forever chemicals. Have you ever heard anybody talk about that? Do you have a non -stick pan in your house anywhere? Teflon? Yeah. People assume that because these things are... staying around forever, which is a misnomer. Let's just be clear. These are

not actually forever chemicals. There are some PFAS chemicals that can be dangerous at high concentration levels. Yeah. We agree. But using a non -stick pan is not going to kill you. It's not even going to make you sick. That's what I'm saying. I've made it this far. Wouldn't people know that by now? I've used a non -stick pan for... You know how much time, money, and effort went into checking Teflon to make sure that it

was approved for food contact? Right. Like you would think they'd check up on that. Yeah. And let's be real. The FDA doesn't always get it right. There are some chemicals that we find out later have some side effects that we didn't know about. But this is a highly regulated industry. And that's the thing. People just assume... So, Simon, we're not talking about the companies that we work for, but people assume that the companies that we work for are out to lie. And

that is really what it comes down to, that we're just looking to make money, and because of that, we're gonna say whatever it takes to sell our products. When in fact, I was on a call today where I was pretty much telling people, I wouldn't do that. I don't think that's the right thing to do for your company. I go out of my way to tell customers what it is that they need and help them find solutions to what they need. I know you're doing the same because if we don't keep our customers happy and we just start selling

them a bunch of stuff, eventually they're going to come back and be like, well, this didn't work for me. And you told me it was. And then we're not going to have that customer anymore. And I mean, I'd go even one step, totally agree. And I'd go even one step further. I mean, I buy my food and groceries at the same place as Joe Bloggs does down the road. I don't have a secret entrance to a supermarket. Yeah. You're eating this food too, yeah. Of course. And so I'd even go one step further to say, you know, as a scientist, I don't wake up in the morning and think, oh,

let me do some dangerous things today and see what harm I can cause. You're like the mad scientist. Exactly. That is not me. I am not the mad scientist. As a scientist, I wake up and think, well, how can I use my skill and knowledge base? to help make something better, more efficient, improved in a different way? And how can I use this to help improve what we're doing and make it better? And you mentioned the FDA, and yes, I would try to argue as well that the proof that the scientific

method works is because there have been discoveries that some things didn't turn out exactly as said in the past. and we've learned from that, we've made a hypothesis, we've tested the hypothesis, we've got a result from that testing which says, yes this is okay, up to all the knowledge we have today, this is okay for this use or this context, and then we find something new and then the FDA says, well actually we've got this new thing, we need to stop that and move to this

one because this one's better, or improved in a certain way. What really gets me on my horse? is when there are pushes from groups of people for a blanket prohibitional ban on something, when the evidence tells us still today, 40 years later, this is still safe to use with all the new data we've collected in the last 40 years, it's still okay under these conditions. Yeah. That's my daily life right there. Where do you

think... Because when you talk about like the nonstick pans, the first question that comes to mind is like, because usually when people worry about or start talking that that's bad for you, they come from a situation that may have occurred from it. So where do you think that idea stems from? Because I don't know, maybe I'm just not up with the times, but I've never heard of a situation where somebody got sick from a nonstick pan. So I'm wondering like, have you ever seen the movie Aaron Brockovich? No,

I don't know but I know is that the pool There's like that swimming. No, no, no, this is Julia Roberts and she's a lawyer and she's suing. Okay, I think it's PG &E in Okay in California or something like that. It's because there are chemicals that were not handled properly and they were in high concentration and not Collected in the way that they should have been and because of that people take that information and think any amount of

that is dangerous and is going to kill me. When in fact, what it is, it's like there's a huge concentration of that material that was going into the groundwater. Any chemical like that would be a problem. At high concentrations. Yeah, you shouldn't do that. There's a reason why we store things in the way that we do, transport them in the way that we do. It keeps everybody safe. Because you have to transfer some of these materials which on their own in huge concentrations

can be dangerous. Mm -hmm. But once you put them together in small doses, they're not dangerous anymore. They become a different chemistry product. Yeah. And it's not necessary they become a different chemistry. Well, you know that, yeah. I take your example. I'll make it concrete. I mean hydrochloric acid. HCl is the chemical formula, very dangerous, very corrosive, needs to take a lot of precautions in transport, in use and in disposal, yet we

have it in our stomachs. And I don't get eaten from the inside by the hydrochloric acid sitting in the stomach, digesting my food because it has a purpose. And so it's really concentration. So again, we come back to the concept of dose making the danger or dose making the poison. Yeah. So in my world... A lot of people talk about the danger of styrene. I don't think there's really any conclusive evidence that shows that it is any more dangerous than any of the other

feedstocks that go into plastics. Now, I'm not going to sit there and just drink liquid styrene. That would be a bad idea. But when you polymerize it, then it becomes a different chemical structure. And then there's no residual styrene. And then so that means whatever's contacting your food is technically a different material than styrene. But then everybody thinks styrene, polystyrene, dangerous, bad. In fact, it's not. Yeah, you're

absolutely right. And you wouldn't drink a bottle of washing up liquid or you wouldn't drink a bottle of bleach or detergent or pure alcohol. You wouldn't drink a bottle of pure distilled water either for other reasons that we can go through. I've done that on accident. It's not good. Your comment is absolutely right. Styrene and then polystyrene is a completely different chemical structure. And it's one that we as in the chemistry world, we would call that absolutely inert or essentially inert because it's been

polymerized. There's no more reactivity left in the bonds. And so it becomes an inert structure. And that's two completely different chemicals. Yeah, and it's not gonna hurt anybody. But try telling that to a legislator that just had an NGO in there the day before saying styrene is gonna kill all of your babies. And they do this. These are the kind of conversations that are happening out there because it's scientifically illiterate people got a piece of information

They're trying to do the right thing. At least I hope they're trying to do the right thing because sometimes I don't know if there's money involved, but they're trying to do the right thing and they're trying to protect people. But they're going in the wrong direction or running the exact wrong direction. Yeah. And if I can, I'd like to say a little bit about why I'm so serene or not panicking or not worried about... all the chemical exposure that we have on a daily basis because a lot of these chemicals especially when

we talk about synthetic chemicals I've mentioned previously they're tested and they're regulated and in order to bring something to the market that's regulated it needs to go through a thorough battery of tests not just in vitro so very sensitive tests in a lab setting under lots and lots of control conditions at a high concentration to see if there's any effect in a petri dish. But there's also done in vivo tests. So using models

or different animal models in order to determine is there a toxicity for mammals, eventually for humans or other non -target organisms at different doses. And so when it comes to toxicity, this is very, very well studied and very, very well measured. in order to determine at what point does this become a danger? At what concentration? And is it likely that the population is exposed to that concentration? Yeah. Are they going to

be drinking out of the Roundup? Hopefully not. You never know. At that point, that would be very dangerous. But people are people and people don't like to read directions. They don't want somebody telling them how to do or what to do. Exactly. It's the same for a bottle of bleach or a bottle of alcohol, a bottle of gin, a bottle of washing up liquid. I hear bleach does well with COVID. I've been told that if you ingest it... I wasn't planning on going down that, but

you've opened the door now. No, I'm probably going to cut that part, but I don't need to piss people off. If that was said by anybody who may or may not have been elected as a president in the United States, if that was said... The reaction that the scientists in Europe had was just one of shock. It's like, how can you say such a stupid thing to the general public? And of course, when a person of influence says these things, there is always an effect. And I don't know, but I do ask the question, did incidences of bleach

poisoning increase or decrease after that statement was made? Let's check it. I think somebody can do it. There's a lot of money out there right now to do this kind of stuff. But I think you're touching on an interesting point, because I think, and I'm probably going to piss some people off with this, but I'm going to say it anyway, I think the people that are influencing us are becoming dumber. And so those people that are driving where culture goes are not as intelligent

as they used to be, and specifically when it comes to science. And so these people are loud? I don't know if you've seen the Ricky Gervais when he's hosting the Golden Globes and he tells all of the famous people, you went to less school than Greta Thunberg, so please don't get up there and tell us what to do with politics. That's the kind of stuff that I'm talking about with science though, because you get these people on there that are, they say things in very authoritative ways, this is what you need to do to be better.

And then half the time they have no clue what they're talking about. They don't have the expertise. And they're driving people. And people are following them. Yeah. Absolutely. All right. So I'm not alone in thinking we're becoming dumber as a society. And we're having less critical thinking about what we're told. And I think that's also an important factor. And I think AI could play a positive role here in terms of critical thinking.

optimistic that by having tools like AI will help us be, help us fact check better information that we have. I'm hoping. Yeah. I don't even use Google anymore, honestly. Just chat GPT? Yeah, so quick. I've never used it. I don't even know how to use it. Really? Yeah, you're going to have to teach me one of these days. Oh my God, it really is good. I saw another social media post that it was Grok fact -checking his creator, Elon Musk, online. And that's a good

point because that's what these machine learning tools are supposed to do. They're supposed to take all of these diverse streams of information and distill them down and just focus on facts. And if that's what machine learning is doing and it's not... driven in a certain direction based on the zeitgeist of the culture, then I think we're in okay shape. My worry is you're going to get politicians involved and they're

going to have opinions and they're going to start censoring what comes through chat GPT because it's whatever. And that's when we get into danger with that kind of tool because then it's not talking facts anymore, it's talking opinion. So that's my big worry. Honestly, I applaud you first and foremost, because I know how challenging it can be fighting with keyboard warriors. It's very difficult. I've actually come to find that

a lot of my biggest detractors early have become pretty close at this point, because I think like you, we have opinions and we have facts, but at the same time, We're not just towing company lines. We're going to say what's fact and what isn't, even if it's not necessarily working out in the best interest of the industry that we come out of. And I think that kind of honesty and transparency really helps with engagement

and will really help win these type of discussions. Because if we're the first ones to say, yeah, that's not great. We shouldn't do that. But here are the facts about the bigger picture that you need to be aware of. I think if we do that, then we can really make changes. Do you feel like you're making a difference? Yeah, it's a great question and I do feel that I'm making a difference. And there's two reasons that I'll give you why.

The first reason on why I feel there's a difference being made is for a long time, years, I don't know, for a long time. I think that as an industry, we stayed far too quiet. And we left a vacuum, we left a void, and that void and that vacuum was filled with stuff. Welcome to the plastics industry. Stuff, welcome to the pesticides discussion. That was filled with stuff. I call it BS, so

bad science. And it was filled with this BS. And as an industry, as a scientific community, we didn't venture outside of our labs, of our offices, and say simple things like, actually, what you've just said isn't correct. You know, here's epidemiological data for the last 20 years, and it explains to you why. I know you can't understand it exactly, but, you know, let me show you the highlights of this prospective study.

that looked after, that followed thousands of people over a period of time. And I think we stayed quiet and we left that vacuum to be filled. I think part of that though is people in your line of work typically are not that great at communicating with the public, taking those very high level things and distilling them down into something that just anybody can understand. And I think you do that well, which is why you've seen success. And I think we're getting better at doing that, explaining these difficult concepts

in simple language. And so, yeah, the first reason was I think we're filling this void. And the more that scientists come out of their labs and talk, and it's not even about challenging, it's just about bringing evidence and saying, actually, this is wrong what you've said. I'm seeing more and more people doing it. I think that's positive. So there's a few people started and then more and more people join and then some more people join. And so we're having this... Can I say snowball type effect? I really feel at the moment. More and more scientists, industry and independent

scientists, are coming out and discussing. It's the first reason. The second reason is one which surprised even me, is I've received messages, direct messages from people thanking me. I didn't know that, Simon. I didn't understand it was so complex. I had no idea it took so long and so much research in order to achieve. in order to do this science or to do this research. And so they're the two things which really give me hope for the future, that there is a place for science in society. And I think that's one of

the things which drives me is my desire to bring science back into the everyday life of the citizens of the world. Well, how do we change the illiteracy part of it outside of social media? I'll candidly say I took one year of physics in high school and got out of all science because I took an AP class so I didn't have to take science in college. That was the only science class I had

after my eighth grade year. It was just the one. Didn't have any chemistry. I never took a chemistry class in my life. So I couldn't even tell you outside of what I've picked up working in this industry and hanging around much smarter people than me. Do we need to push more on the sciences in school? Do we need to make that more mandatory that people can understand these things? Is that where we're missing out? What do you think? I

think it's part of the equation. There's not one magic silver bullet here. I think, yes, we need to encourage, continue to encourage people to go into sciences. to continue to encourage education. For me, the other part of the pillar is the trust part. Not everybody needs to be a football player. Not everybody needs to be a scientist. Not everyone needs to understand how, I think, one of your games you have is baseball, I think. Yeah. Which I sort of describe as boring cricket. I don't know if you know cricket, the

sport. Cricket's pretty boring. I'm going to throw that out there. Cricket is a game which lasts five days. Two teams. It's like baseball, but more exciting because you get to drink for five days. Well, you can drink for five days, just go to five different baseball games. You can do that too. And I think trust is a key thing we need to work on is societal trust of society, of scientists, of experts. I think that's a real pillar we need to work on is trust as well. I

think there is a big gap in trust with any institution, specifically in younger generations. My generation and below, I think there are more and more people that don't trust the government, that don't trust institutions of any kind, churches, schools, whatever, because they've been told that if you do this, this, and this, it's going to lead to X outcome. and X outcome isn't happening for them. So they just assume they've been lied to

their whole lives. And so now they've thrown everything into doubt. Not everybody's like that. Look, Sam's been successful, but the rest of her generation really struggling to find work after getting out of college. There's just this huge gap in any sort of trust with any authority that I think has become pervasive. And because of that, when scientists or anybody, just like a Fauci, I know we don't want to get political

and this isn't about coronavirus or whatever, but this is like, I don't even care if the guy is crooked or whatever, but just nobody trusts him at this point. And everybody just assumes that he was lying. And I don't know. I don't know anything about coronavirus or any of that science. But I do know that I can talk to anybody on the street, and 50 % of them are going to say, yeah, that guy was full of it. And they don't have any clue. They don't know anything

about the science, but they have strongly held convictions that the guy didn't know what he was talking about. And I think it's just a perfect microcosm of what's happening in the world today when we talk science, because there's a lot of people that think they know, but they have no basis for any of these things that they're saying. So yeah, I'm happy that you have hope because there's part of me every single day That's just like I think we're lost and I don't see how we're gonna come back from this Yeah, I agree and I

think I don't know if I'll sort of say this before we may want to cut this out what I'm about to say. All right is What can we do as citizens of the world? I mean, what can we do? I can completely understand. I apologize you two being US citizens why a lot of people in the US have lost trust in the government, in the current administration, or the previous administration, or the one before that, completely understand. We're sitting here in Europe, watching what's happening over there, and most of it we can't believe. You know, did

he just say, did he actually just say that? We're a sideshow, yes. Did he actually just do that? Did he just change, no, tariffs, and anyway, we're watching, and what can we do as citizens is really... at least in Europe, is to really focus on evidence -based discussion and evidence -based dialogue, and to listen to people that have expertise on the subject. And how do you know somebody has expertise? Because in my opinion,

they will be the first person to say, I'm not an expert on that topic. That's a great point. I can't tell you how many brilliant people that have well -founded positions that usually started off with, this is what I know now that could change tomorrow, because it's constantly evolving. And being okay with the possibility that your opinion may be wrong is a good place to start. Like that humility of knowing, and I've said

that on this show a lot, it's like, right now, I don't think microplastics are the big concern that everybody's making them out to be. I could be wrong. There could be studies that come out in 10 years that show a distinctive link between cancer and microplastics, and then I'll have to take back everything I said. And I will willingly do so because I like to live in the light. I like to live in the truth. And if the truth says

this, I'm not going to lie. I'm not going to argue with it. Let's just roll with it. I have strongly held opinions and beliefs, but... I could be wrong about all of them. That humility, I think, is lost on a lot of people. What do you think, Sam? I haven't heard you in a while. I know. I was listening about what you just last said, and I was trying to think how I kind of, because I've said a lot, how I just kind of do my thing. But I also, because I try, not that

we're talking politics, I try to stay out of, you know, I just kind of do... what I do, and then like, but I do have opinions, but I, I don't like talking. No, we know you have opinions. I've heard your opinions. But I think when it comes to the space of, like, again, I think it all stems back to what I said before. And I know that, Simon, you kind of touched on this too, is that like anything anybody says, like about the, something about drinking bleach about COVID,

it's like, someone said it who is influential and people trust people, some people, and then they'll go do it. So I think for me, it's more, it's like I have beliefs, but at the same time, it's more so I don't even know if it's a belief or I'm just unsure. I just don't know. And I just continue to learn. Good place to be. You know what I mean? Like, I don't even have something where I'm like, well, I believed this. Or maybe I don't even know. And then something happens, and I'm like, oh, I don't really think that.

But when it comes to being a fact or not, I just keep getting humbled. I just don't. It's a great place to be. I haven't spent, yeah, I don't really spend a lot of time on things that maybe they are serious, but I just try to be so, just like, live like a, I'm just living life. I try not to worry about things. which is perfect because I am constantly learning. But it's nice that it's not crushing anything that I've spent my whole life believing because then I'm more so

just getting educated rather than getting my belief kind of turned around. It's more this is this and then I'm more learning from that and then that becomes kind of what I believe. But like I said, it's not like one thing that I have stuck in my brain that I am like this is this and this is this and I know it. It's more so I'm just learning as I go, but I really got to find reliable sources. Being less dogmatic is the best place to start. Just kind of doing what I do and then learning as I grow older and

I become more in this space and even this conversation made me learn about as silly as the dog pesticide thing is. I'm a recent dog mom, so I'm freaking out all the time. I never even thought about that, and now I feel like I've just learned so much even just by listening. So that's kind of how I try to go, is that I just live life. It seems a little premature maybe, but... No. And then I just learn as I go. Honestly, more people need to do that. More people need to just go

with the flow. I try not to worry about the things that aren't super, super like that deep or that serious that I need to worry about. Not that it's not serious, but it's like eating something with... chemicals in it like you're gonna it's just to me it's not that yeah, you're gonna be good like following Experts is important Knowing the source of the information that you're consuming. I think is another big thing Yeah, and I think

that's what I could be doing better for sure is where I'm finding my information Again, it's not like I'm looking for but I mean you scroll into talking God forbid five seconds of my attention is captured and I'm sitting there locked in. And then I believed the oat milk thing. So it's like, I think that I need to, I'm like so gullible. It's like, tell me anything and I'll believe it. I mean, I'll probably forget it the next day. Like, like I said, if they say that about oat milk, sure, I'll go drink it. Like it's not something, but I think that's something that I definitely could improve on is where I'm getting

my facts and kind of what's behind it and what studies are behind it or education so that I can really follow those and kind of. maybe not change the way I live my life, but at least be a little bit more aware of the things that I'm doing and what I'm surrounding myself with. So I think that's a good place to be, first and foremost. I think more people need to look at the world with a sense of awe and understand that they don't know everything. And it's okay

not to know everything. It's okay not to be an expert on everything. You don't have to act like you are. It's okay to ask questions of people that know more about a subject. I think we've lost that as a society. People think that you have to be a winner or you have to have these strongly held opinions and you have to, this is what I'm basing myself on. I am a natural person or I am this or I am that. It's okay not to be an expert. I'm just living. Exactly. We need more people to do that. If I like this product

more than this one and this one happens to be natural. Yeah, cool. If it doesn't then that's fine, too It's more so just I think what and that natural is probably BS too, but well we can get into right later You know what I'm saying? Like if it happens to be a little better, that's just coincidental at this point Yes, so I did a disservice to the listening audience here Typically, I asked the same question to every single person that comes on the show We're gonna have to wait until the very end of the show. But what do you

think of when you hear the word plastic? What's the first thing that comes to mind? I mean, the first thing that comes to mind is polyvinyl chloride and polypropyl ethylene are the two most plastics which I have at the forefront because they're the ones that I'm looking at right now in my computer on my iPhone, on my monitors. And when I hear the word plastic, the first thing that I think about is its contribution to helping us live longer, safer lives. That's a great answer. It's a thought exercise I do with everybody,

because I'll have people that are anti -plastics on here, and they'll say cancer, it's killing you, and all this kind of stuff. So typically what I do is let the guest have a couple minutes at the end of every episode to talk about anything that's really top of mind for you that we haven't covered, or anything that... Doesn't even have to be related to this discussion just whatever's something's burning that you want to talk about And we've covered lots and lots of topics that

I'm I'm really passionate about We began by talking about chemistry and three basic scientific principles, you know, all matter is chemistry all chemistry is toxic It's the dose that makes the poison. We've also discussed really briefly Concentration and how important that is and not to not to succumb to the fear mongering of reading we found parts per billion or parts per trillion of a substance in something and not to succumb to this fear -mongering that presence equals danger because

we know it's the dose that makes the poison and after that I think the important messages that I'd like to share is really There are people trying to con you and trick you in the world by generating this fear and saying, stop buying this, buy that, stop using this, use that, we have to ban this. Exactly, it's marketing. BS is bad science. And so really, I don't think

everybody needs to be an expert. Everybody needs to ask questions when they're worried. I think my real hammer home message is really... The regulatory authorities are there and they're not trying to kill you. These substances are regulated and controlled. And thanks to modern technologies like plastics, pesticides, fertilizers, genetics, the list is very, very long. We actually

live longer, healthier lives than we ever have before. I think that is an excellent... Excellent way to end this. Simon, this has been a blast. I knew it was going to. I knew we were going to talk about a lot of different things, and we're going to be all over the place. But you distilled it home for us right there at the very end. So Sam, anything else to add on your end? I love this conversation. And this is something that I wasn't expecting to talk about. But I'm

glad we did, because I don't know. a ton about plastics, but I really don't know anything about chemical. So I'm happy to say that I'm signing off knowing way more than I did when I signed off. So I appreciate the knowledge that you brought and your time. This was a fun conversation. Thank you. For Samantha and Simon, this has been the Redefining Plastics podcast. My name is Justin Reining. Thank you all so much for joining. If

you want to learn more about the plastics industry, recycling, check out these other videos. Please like and subscribe.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Scaling Dissolution for Food-Contact Recycled Polypropylene with IPL Schoeller and PureCycle

    Nov 3, 202629 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney sat down with Melissa Vettleson (Sustainability and Materials Engineer at IPL Schoeller) and Christian Bruey (Director of Sustainability and External Affairs at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Are Plastics Sustainable? with Patrick Krieger of the PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 27, 202632 minAudio

    Justin Riney hosts Patrick Krieger, who is the Senior Vice President of Sustainability and Policy at the PLASTICS Industry Association. In this conversation, they dive deep into sustainability, plastics, and creating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Recycling Collaboration, EPR, and Building End Markets with PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 20, 202630 minAudio

    This was the third episode recorded at the National Plastics Conference (NPC), and the NPC Live podcast studio onsite. Thanks again to PLASTICS for having Redefining Plastics at the conference and all of their support....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. NAPCOR’s PET Bottle Decarbonization Roadmap with Husky’s Jolene Milne (NPC Live)

    Oct 6, 202624 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney speaks with Jolene Milne, a sustainability analyst at Husky Technologies and member of NAPCOR, about industry collaboration to combat misinformation about plastics and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EPR, Data Gaps, and Change Management with Christine Yeager at National Plastics Conference Live

    Sep 23, 202632 minAudio

    We had a blast with this interview at the National Plastics Conference on-site podcast studio, "National Plastics Conference Live." Christine Yeager of CSY Impact dove deep into extended producer responsibility (EPR),...

    Credit the people on this episode