Welcome to the Redefining Plastics Podcast! Join host Justin Riney as he reconnects with long-time industry friend and resin buyer extraordinaire, Susan Estes. In this lively episode, Justin and Susan dive into Susan's extensive background in the plastics industry, transitioning from packaging roles to commodity management, and her current focus on polymer recycling. They discuss the nuances of procurement for virgin vs. recycled materials, emphasizing the critical need for diversity and leadership within the sector. The conversation also highlights the challenges brands face with recycled content and the impact of market dynamics on sustainability efforts. Tune in for an engaging and thought-provoking discussion that promises to challenge your perceptions and provide valuable insights into the evolving world of plastics. Susan Estes: https://www.linkedin.com/in/susan-estes-5722884/ Redefining Plastics https://www.redefiningplastics.com/ https://www.brvind.com/redefining-plastics https://rss.com/podcasts/redefining-plastics-with-justin-riney https://www.instagram.com/redefining_plastics/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/justin-riney-mba-67685940/ https://youtube.com/@redefiningplastics?si=KvG4dTvY1lALbwIm
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to Daddy's Podcast. This is the Redefining Plastics Podcast. Welcome to the Redefining Plastics Podcast. My name's Justin Riney. I've got an old friend. Old is not the right way of saying it. I've got a friend that I've had for a long time in the industry, somebody that I've worked with extensively and somebody that I find to be the best resin buyer that I've ever worked with. And I don't know if I've ever told you that directly, Susan Estes, but it's fact. Thank
you, Dustin. You just have a way about you where you can be tough, but then at the same time have great relationships with all of your suppliers. I think you would say most of your suppliers would call you a friend. And that's tough to do. It's really tough to do, to be strong, stick up for what you want. and then still maintain relationships. But anyway, all of that to say, Susan Estes, welcome. I know we've been working on this for a while, but why don't you tell people
that don't know you who you are, what you do, what your background is, and maybe a little bit about how you got into plastic. Well, first of all, thanks for having me. Like I said, I'm definitely nervous. Never done anything like this before. You'll be fine. I do love what I do. I love talking about what we're doing. I believe in plastics. I think it's imperative to have the appropriate material selection for all the right reasons. So again, appreciate the opportunity to say some good things about plastics and put it out into the world. But I'm a packaging engineer by degree
out of Michigan State University. I spent the first part of my career designing packaging for durable goods companies and secondary packaging for a couple of CPG companies. and really transitioned out of my packaging development roles into project management opportunities and then eventually into commodity management. And once I was in commodities, started in colorants, did some time in the steel industries and some wood and lumber commodities and eventually ended up in plastics and really haven't looked back since then. Been
in plastics specifically at various companies over about the last 15 years and just absolutely love what I do. I think it's brought together my passion for packaging. I think packaging drives a lot of resin grade development in the marketplace. So it feels like I can do all the things that I've ever been exposed to all at once. So it's honestly an honor to be participating in the plastics industry for about the last 15 years. I'm currently in more of a recycling role. I work for a recycler today in the rigid plastics
pet side of things. But throughout my career, I've been exposed to polyolefins, styrenics, and PET. Yeah, and that's how we met. You were my boss once upon a time, and one of the best that I've ever had. And we still have a relationship now. And what has that been, five years now since we worked together, roughly? Yeah, maybe been six yet. Yeah, because 2019, I think is when I left. But yeah, it's crazy how winding all
of our careers and lives are. Never thought I would be doing this. Did you ever anticipate me doing this when we were working together? You're a very passionate guy, so I could definitely see you, you know, spreading the word out there. Again, podcasts, I feel like you've grown significantly in the last couple of years, the exposure and the reach that you have, which has been exciting for me to watch, quite honestly. Yeah, and a lot of that is thanks to you. You put some connections in place, and ever since then... that's kind of grown from there. So I guess we can say redefining
plastics is thanks to Susan Estes. But yeah, there are a lot of different things I wanted to talk about today. So females in plastics. I had made a comment to somebody once that I was in a meeting about two years ago at my current company. And I was the only male in the room, which is not typical. That is very strange. But
I still think we lack having females in specifically leadership roles within the plastics industry or people that are really driving us. And I think we need that. We need the feminine touch to... improve what we're doing and how we're communicating. There are so many different reasons why. Yeah, great. From your perspective, why do you think that is? I think in general, diversity and thought
is critical. I think if you're going to get into a room, if you look around and everyone's got a similar background, looks the same, talks the same, you're probably not going to leave the room with what you hope to. So I just think that diversity and thought background approach is critical, especially when you're trying to move the needle like we are here in plastics. Yeah. Why do you think there aren't as many diverse people within the plastics industry? Just high level. Yeah, and I think part of it could just
be linked toward just who is participating in STEM type disciplines. Obviously, you know, if I think back to my college experience, I look left, I look right, I'm generally, you know, the one female in that mix. But I think as we focus more and more on getting females into those disciplines, you know, we're starting to see that shift. And I always gauge it when I go into a trade, into a trade show or a conference, I look around and I just kind of compare the mix of individuals today versus... 15 years ago when
I went to my first petrochemical conference, and that's how I tend to see whether or not we're really making a difference and shifting. Do you feel like we are improving? I feel like we are. I think certain commodities, I think certain suppliers are doing a little bit better about their mix and diversity. But in general, I think we've moved somewhat, but I don't think it's been significant. Yeah. And to be clear, I'm not talking DEI. I'm not talking like how do we benefit others over. I just want diverse viewpoints
and I want just a completely different perspective because I think right now what we've done in the past is not going to get us to where we want to go per your comment earlier of like when you walk into a room, you're not going to get out of it what you want. We're not going to improve how people view plastics if we just keep doing the same thing. And we need new thoughts and new approaches. So my main concern is how do we draw more diversity into plastics? Diversity
of thought, whatever, however you want to look at it. What do you think? Yeah, and again, I think a lot of it's exposure, it's visibility, it's, you know, things like when we're breaking the mold that Plastics News is highlighting so that folks are seeing more and more females in the industry. And I think there's mentorship programs and certain things that some companies are doing better than others as well. But again, I think it's just critical to give that exposure and visibility to folks that, hey, Plastics isn't
so technical that not everyone can do it. At the end of the day, we're in a market where we're adding value or adding convenience to products, we're making life easier for folks and, you know, females are the end users too. So in a perfect world, you'd want to have, you know, your end user mix be part of who's developing these, you know, opportunities. So I think we just need to continue to raise visibility. I think it starts with internships, programs, and colleges, but I think we have to go even further. I think it's
those STEM affiliations with larger companies at even elementary schools, middle schools, high schools. to educate folks. You don't have to think of plastics as something very complicated, but really just take it back to the basics and teach people about what it is. Show them what a car would look like if you took plastic out of it, for instance. Show them what it's an integral part of their every single day. And I think that's how you reach a larger audience and get more people excited about it. Show them what their gas bill would be if they didn't have - Sounds cool. We go back to those boats that people were
driving in the 70s and the 80s. I think something that triggered in my brain the comment about more women in STEM, I think that's part of it. But at the same time, if you look at me, I don't have a STEM degree. I don't have a STEM background. And I've fallen into this industry too. But I was given opportunities because of the way that I am and maybe because I am aggressive in this
side or the other, which in many cases can be looked at as a negative for women in business. So it kind of shuts down that opportunity to even get into procurement. Because procurement, if you get into that, you can do just about anything. You become, if you're good at it. You have to become some sort of a subject matter expert in whatever you're doing. And the easiest way to do that is just hang around people that are smarter than you. And I'm assuming you're getting the
same thunderstorm. I'm right back, because you're just right up the road. It's pretty loud. I don't know if you can hear it. I'm sort of in a dungeon. My office is like literally a closet in our house, so I can't hear it. So this is like the fifth house that you've lived in since I've known you. Yes. I have a house buying and a car buying problem. I'll admit it. Well, yeah. You just like the newest and best. I think that's what it comes down to. There's nothing wrong with that. I'm
a consumer. Yeah. Hey, we need more consumers in plastics. That's right. Because your point about having a nice mix of end users in our business. Because then we can know how to communicate to the people that are actually making buying decisions. Because right now, I've been arguing forever that the plastics industry is really good at B2B sales. Horrific when it comes to communicating with consumers. Like we are horrible at it. And
I met with Simon Mecheling last week, and he was talking about how even in his industry, Experts kind of took a step back because they didn't want to get involved in the fight. And that void left a lot of room for misinformation to grow. And I think that's kind of where we're at right now. So we kind of need to dig back in to those discussions. And we need people that think differently, that are making buying decisions to be a huge
part of driving that. So I'm real big on we need more diversity, specifically more women. But diversity in general, I think we need more of. Yeah, I agree. So we've had some experiences with some not so great leadership. Best. That we've run into. Of course. I want to jump into a conversation about leadership and kind of what
makes a good leader. And what makes a bad leader? Let's start there. What makes a bad leader? Because I think if you look at the negative, you can really define the positive. So we've had a lot of experience working for a lot of different people. We don't need to talk about specific people. In your mind, what makes a bad leader? For me, a bad leader is someone that you're hesitant
to follow, hesitant to, you know, really get behind and support. And I think there's something that gives you that sense, right, that you need to proceed with caution. And for me, that's kind of always been what's classified a, you know, a poor leader. because you have a trepidation to fully support, right? And I think if you're not fully behind what you're doing, you're probably not fulfilled at work. You're not doing your best work. You're not feeling heard. You're not seeing a clear path forward. And I think, you
know, those are things that become detrimental to your performance and to your overall happiness at work. I think if you add on to that, you're afraid to divulge information to those people as well. Yeah, there's less honesty. Yeah, I completely agree with you. Yeah. There's less honesty because you're not sure you can trust what will happen with your honest opinions. Yeah. Like that information might go and it might be used against you when in fact, you may just be sharing facts and those facts don't necessarily
fit the narrative that the leader wants and then that becomes a problem. So I've found in the past that several people that I've worked for I had to manage the information that I gave them. I had to tell them only the positives and sometimes don't even tell them the positives because then they may run with something before it's completely done and blow up negotiations. I just think that there's that back and forth communication that is huge and key and the trust factor. I think
he used the word trust and I think that is huge because to me that makes a great leader. It's somebody that you can trust, somebody that you know knows where they're going. And even if they make a mistake, they'll be the first person to own it. They'll be the person to say, this is my team, my responsibility. I own it. And I think there's a huge deficit in business today of people willing to take responsibility from mistakes. And I agree with you. And I think part of it
even goes back to diversity. To your point, you're obviously brought in for a reason, right? And you want to hope that part of that is because of your diversity and experience, thought, background, et cetera. And if you don't feel comfortable sharing your true opinion because of all of that history that you have, it probably feels like it's not as safe of a place to work as you'd like to. So I think that not being able to use your background also inhibits trust. in a relationship between an individual and their manager. So I
think that drastically impacts the success of the team. The amount of times that I've seen leaders come into a role that don't have experience in whatever role that is that they happen to be leading. Let's say it could even be a CEO for a company that's never done R &D. But then for some reason, that CEO feels like they need to influence how R &D is done when they don't even have any clue how it works, rather than relying on the people that you hired to lead
those. And if you put the right people in place, you shouldn't need to get involved in that. That shouldn't be something that you do. And there's so many instances of people that I've seen come into an organization and try to put their stamp on. Like, this is my organization now. Then they start meddling in things that they don't understand. There's nothing more demotivating. I agree. And to your point, it's the trust piece, but it's also the empowerment. When you're not empowered
by your leader to do what you were brought in to do, that's even worse for your team because you're taking away their power. The one thing that I can say about when we work together is I was thrown into a role that had no definition. And that was perfectly fine by me. I like that. That gets me excited. I can build something here. And the nice thing about working with you is you understood that I knew what I was doing in
certain areas and you just checked in. Say, how are you doing? Can I be helpful? Can I be supportive? What do you need to get things done? That is the best way to possibly lead people. I don't need to have weekly check -ins because if people get to know me, they understand that if I have to constantly explain what I'm doing, I get very bored, very quick. And then I'm like, I got to go. I got to go do something else. I got the wander list. Do you like the new car and the new house? I like the new job every couple of months. Yeah. No, I'm a little bit guilty of
that too. Yeah. But you're fun to manage. To your point, I just, obviously you should be, I think a good leader tailors their management style to each employee, right? Like I brought you in because you were an expert in films when we worked together. I was thrilled to not have to know and really understand online direction on films. I could leave that with you and know it was safe. And, you know, I think to your point though, you know, someone who needs to know all the details and get in the nuance of your commodity strategy, you know, that's just not, you know.
the level you were brought in at from my perspective, you were obviously capable. I didn't need to micromanage you. I think the expressing the strategy up the chain makes perfect sense. I get that. Like, hey, let's put together a strategy presentation. Let's show you what I'm looking to do. Now let me do it. Or if you've got comments while we're going through that presentation, you want to maybe tailor and shift some direction. Great.
That's a good time to have that conversation. It shouldn't be six months in. You have no clue what's going on in the organization. Hey, this isn't the way you should negotiate this. You should do it this way. And I'm like, you don't have any experience in this space. You don't even know how these suppliers work. You don't know how many suppliers we could possibly have. What are we doing here? The amount of times that I've seen that drives me insane, which is one of the main reasons why I don't do procurement anymore. to be completely transparent, because
I'm a go -getter. Here's the plan, everybody okay? All right, I'm going 1 ,000 miles an hour. Procurement people don't like that, in my experience. You were okay with that. You were the exception to the rules. But you were also really great at getting key stakeholder buy -in. You could understand where you needed to get the buy -in from operations and other functional groups in Go. You understood that certain things needed to be done. You weren't maneuvering recklessly,
so to speak. Again, you were brought in. Some people may disagree with that. Well, they're not here. I always found that I was borderline reckless at all times. But I think that's what makes me good at what I do, because I can say what's on my mind without... trepidation without being scared of the reaction. Sometimes it's a bad thing, though. I have to learn to tailor
my message up the chain sometimes. Yeah, but again, sometimes we've got to push the needle, right? If we don't pressure test something to see if it works, we'll never change. So I think sometimes you need folks on your team that put you into that more uncomfortable situation. But I had a mentor early on in my career that told me, you know, I don't care how you do it, because you and I have different styles or different people, et cetera, but I need you to get it done. And don't be afraid to fail was also something he said to me. Because he's like, whatever you
do, if you mess something up, I got your back. And that comfort level, that gave me confidence to try new things and figure out who I was as a procurement individual. And I think that's something that I've tried to carry on as I have, you know, new teams and new individuals to mentor because for me, that was so critical to who I became as a buyer. So was that maybe one of your first leaders in procurement? It was. It was your first? Honestly, that first leader is so
key when you get into a new industry or you get into a new role. within the current industry, because I had similar experiences. I worked for a guy at Sanoco. I'll shout him out. He's not there anymore. It's Topan Group now or whatever the heck it's called. David Kip, I worked there and he was great at just saying, hey, we put you in this role because we needed somebody that was going to be aggressive. We need somebody that goes and gets things done, but we need to make sure that we maintain relationships. Go
do. And it's okay to ask questions. It's okay if you stub your toe. Let's just make sure that if we're making huge decisions, everybody's involved. And I took that to heart and I've worked like that ever since. And it seems like you also had a really good leader early on that mentored you and helped you get to the position that you're in right now. So maybe... part of this is we just have really bad middle management and plastics,
and it's driving out potential other thoughts and other diverse backgrounds because they want to make everybody the same. And what do you think about that? Yeah, I think it's possible. And also, when I reflect back on my early years in procurement, for about 18 months, I was really told to participate in meetings with commodities that weren't mine and just listen. So at some point, it's kind of weird, right? You feel like you're in all these meetings, but you're not really participating. But what you're doing is
learning the language that's used when you're talking about commodities. You're understanding how to build relationships, et cetera. So I felt like for about 18 months of my career, I wasn't really adding value. But looking back, I was taking it all in. And I think some things that we don't do now is have the opportunity to really listen, grow, have a mentor, and understand the space that we're in. I think we're often thrown in and told to get, you know, 5 % to 7 % savings in year one, rather than really digging in and
understanding what we're doing and why we're doing it. Yeah, like we're lacking coaching early on and time. I think time is a commodity that we're really running short on because most people are running really lean right now. So you got half the people doing twice the work, and they aren't able to take the time to have those meetings like you're talking about. Because one of the first things, I don't know if you remember, the first thing I say to everybody that hires me
is, I'm not going to talk much for six months I'm here. I'm going to listen, and I'm going to figure out what's going on. And once I figure out what's going on, then I will start to interact. And a lot of that comes back to early leaders that I had were like, we know that you know what you're talking about. You don't need to run every conversation that you're in. And so I really took that to heart and I was like, okay, now I should just sit back and listen and learn rather
than feel like I have to prove that I belong here. And I think that drives a lot of people away because that, hey, you got to hit five percent year one. Right. That makes it so you kind of have to start hit the ground running and really drive projects without learning what it is that the company does. Why is the company buying what they're buying? Who are the players that you need to be involved with? Who are those stakeholders
that we talked about earlier that you've got to sell? Because there's so much internal selling and procurement. It's like 90 % of the job. I was going to say, I think they're more internal selling than external for sure. I say it a lot. The people that are really good at procurement should be really good at sales if they are given the opportunity because they have learned over
the years how to sell and soft selling is entirely necessary because you have no authority. and procurement. You have to convince everybody else to go the direction that you want to go. Half the time, you're asking people to change things. And change is hard for people. And if you can convince them to change it by explaining to them how it's going to make their lives better, you'd be a great salesperson. It's usually the way I look at it. And to your point, you're asking individuals to make changes that they're not
being measured for. Their bonus isn't going to be bigger because they helped you with their project, et cetera. So developing that credibility with all your stakeholders is critical. But again, to your point, when you're under pressure to deliver 5 to 7%, it's sometimes hard to stop and build those relationships. But long term, I do think that's how you develop the relationships you really need to. It's the only way to succeed in those kind of roles, specifically in big corporations where you've got 50 plants that you're having
to interact with. You've got to learn the regional leaders, the national leaders, all the way down to the local level. You've got to learn all of these people. You've got to understand what they want, what's driving them. And I think that's key. That's the only way to make any of this work. I was going to say, but your strategy on listening those first six months, I think what you learn when you're listening is there's a lot of folks that you're going to engage with as a procurement person that don't know what they don't know. So the things they think they
can have at the plant level, they could probably have those and even more than that. Once someone actually takes the time to see where they're struggling and say, hey, we could do this, this, and this. We could have vendor manage this. We could have supplier support here. Those are things they might not even know if there's, you know, a procurement person that's not taking the time to be on the floor and see where they're struggling. And I do think that's where you could separate yourself by really listening. I think humans as a whole, I think in the pace we're living
right now, sometimes we forget to listen. I'd say most people, most people forget to listen. Thank you. Just look at my LinkedIn feed. The people that comment before they actually take in all the information. The amount of times that I see people comment on a post that's a link to something, and the comment is actually agreeing to whatever the article says, but they're bashing the link. I'm like, you obviously didn't take the time to read it. Because everything you just
said is exactly what that article said. And I understand we're busy. But at least take the time to understand if you're right. It's that hard. It really isn't that hard. Time management is tough. It is. I'll tell you, I used to have a very nice setup where I didn't have to really worry. The kids were all taken care of. I was able to just work, work, and work. Probably to
my detriment. I'm a bit of a workaholic. But now that I don't have that safety net and the amount of time that goes into shuttling kids around in the morning and trying to figure out who's picking them up, how are we going to do that in the middle of a busy job? I can only imagine a single mother that doesn't have any support, but would be great in whatever role if they've got a bad manager. that's just micromanaging
where that person is all the time, how difficult that would be and how hard it would be to be successful when really doesn't matter where they're sitting or what they're doing. If they're good at what they do, they'll get the job done to your point earlier. Hey, you got a different style, get the job done. That's all that matters. And I think there's a lot of that. It was easier when it was like, lockdown, COVID, everybody was at home. Now everybody's thinking, you know,
for some reason they think that people need to get back in the office because apparently they aren't being as productive when all of the data I've seen says people were more productive when they were working from home. Yeah. So it's like this knee -jerk reaction to old school management styles that is just going to demoralize the heck out of you. entire workforce. And there's no learning that happened. It's so frustrating to
me. So I worked for a company, I'm going to shout them out. So Trademark, they went 100 % remote after COVID. And they even got rid of their headquarters because they saw that this is the right way to lead, this is the right way to run our business. And the people that work there are so much happier now. The people that are there are more productive because they don't have to come in every single day. They're saving an hour round trip every
day driving to and from an office. And they do a really good job with teams, meetings, all hands, stuff like that. So you don't need that. You don't need a physical place to go into. That was a complete aside, but it just popped into my head. But I think there is a gratitude that goes with that, right? It feels like you're being given the opportunity to have an hour back in your day, which is huge. Yeah. Especially, you know, now that I'm a parent, I see how important that is. Yeah. Like, with the age that our kids
are, because our kids are around the same age, if I'm gone for a week, I feel like those kids are completely different when I come back. Like, they've grown. and they're talking differently, they've got different phrases that they're using, and like, where did this come from? Like, how did this happen? And I'm not even being gone for five days, and it's like you're a different person. So for a parent, it's huge to be able to be at home with kids, and the family piece
of business used to be huge back when there were pensions, and it's like you were loyal to that one company, and you stayed there forever. That company became like family. And now it's just like family doesn't matter to a lot of big corporations and to bosses because that's like a detriment to getting things done, being productive. When in fact, the main reason, the only reason why I work, it's not money. I don't care about that.
I work because I want to take care of my kids. That's the only reason why I do any of this. And people just don't understand what motivates. Anymore and yeah, just there's just a huge lack in good leadership and it just it frustrates me because there's so So much unlocked potential Joe in our workforce that if people were just If they were empowered like it used the word empowered earlier Yeah, if they were empowered how much better this industry would be and it's
it frustrates the heck out of me yeah, any other comments on on workforce and leadership? No, I think you nailed it. I think we just need to continue to be better. I think we need to listen more. I think we need to be more considerate. I always used to believe that I was a very empathetic leader to the folks on my team that had children, but until you're actually a parent, you don't really know what those individuals need. So I think Again, the flexibility is important. You
can get the job done in a lot of different ways. And I think as our industry grows, I hope to see more of that. To your point, I think we need to celebrate the companies that have figured out how to do the hybrid schedules and make it work. I do think that FaceTime's important. Don't just get on the phone calls, but get on the video calls and then you can see the nuance and you can see individual spaces. I do think you grow relationships more. when you can see the non -verbal. Yeah, I'm always on video on every call
that I'm on. And I'm like the only one. And then one day somebody pointed out that I'm like 75 % of everybody's screen is just blackface. Oh, that's funny. I don't think anybody needs that. No. But yeah, I think I wanted to transition to plastics in general. Because when we got to know each other, we were both in virgin plastics. So just traditional polymers, polystyrene, polypropylene,
polyethylene, flexible films, all that stuff. And we both transitioned over the last couple of years into more sustainable rules. So you are leading the purchasing for an organization that makes recycled products. the primary focus. So I want to talk about the differences between procurement for each of those different businesses, like those types of businesses, because it's completely different, right? It's completely
different. Yeah. So what I always find funny is, well, that person bought PET in the past, they can handle recycled things. It's not even close to the same thing. It's really not. You got like three suppliers that you deal with when you're buying Virgin. It's all formula based. And then you go to buying PET like Arpet and you're like, holy crap, there's so many different ways I can buy this. I can buy strapping grade.
I can buy bottle grade. I can buy all this different stuff. I could buy this regrind, I could buy it as solid -state pellets. There's so many different things that go into understanding how to manage recycle, but certain companies, I think, can't differentiate the two. They manage them the exact same way, and they fail constantly. So what do you think the biggest differences are between procurement in a traditional... virgin business
versus the recycled focused business? Yeah, I think the biggest, I can't say it was a surprise. Obviously, in my last role before where I am today, my team was responsible for fueling two recycling centers on the flexible film side of things. But I think the biggest change when you're really just focused in the recycled markets is how opportunistic those suppliers and those markets tend to be. and how fragmented they are. It's really easy to manage relationships when you
have three suppliers of polyethylene, like you said. Obviously, there's more than three. Yeah, there's obviously more than three polyethylene suppliers that you're probably buying from if you're a large buyer. But, you know, when I think of bail suppliers right now for me, it's like almost 300. So when you think of that tail in a traditional procurement environment, how do you manage that? How do you manage your critical suppliers? How do you really force rank some of these suppliers on quality and other metrics? And really, because of the nature of the recycled
industry right now, you're surviving on razor -thin margins. So you're running lean, yet you're managing a supply base of hundreds of folks on your largest commodities. So for me, that's been the biggest challenge. I believe that you know, relationships matter. I think you need to invest in them. I think you need to understand what each party needs. But when you've got that many suppliers and it's a team of two, you really can't dedicate the amount of time that you're used to on building those relationships. So you have to learn to navigate those relationships
differently. And for me, that's been the biggest challenge. It's incredibly fragmented. It doesn't feel like it's as loyal. I think that's starting to shift. I think as the market evolves and brand owners get more involved, the whole value chain is going to look different in five to seven years. But right now, I still think we're in that evolution. It's almost like you're speaking a different language than virgin petrochemicals. Yeah. And the brands, I think, are the most clueless out
of all of the people involved in that marketplace. And they're well -intentioned. But they make things so much harder. They make it so much worse. And if they would just stay out of it and let people that understand these markets manage them, things would be way better. That's just not the way things operate. But I think trust, too, is huge there. Go ahead. Definitely. No, and I was going to say, I think the challenge is we need the brand owners because I think they can provide
a lot of the funding that's needed to launch some of these opportunities. you know, again, if you're not taking the time to really understand the market fundamentals and what's driving the price, then you're always going to have a disconnect and you're going to continue to see recyclers and folks in the middle, you know, go out of business because the economics just aren't there. The amount of times that I have conversations with people are like, well, why can't we just sell more recycled content? Like, well, first off, brands aren't actually buying it because of multiple different reasons. Typically, these
days, The conversation I have is, well, inflation and none of our customers are going to pay for more. And okay, but then all these guys are going to go bankrupt in the interim, and then we're going to be starting from scratch. Again, when the market does turn, because the market will turn. It will get better, but nobody's going to be well positioned to take advantage of it because everybody's getting so lean to deal with the trough that we're in right now. It's a really tough space. My opinion on the biggest difference
between Virgin and Recycled is picking winners, I think, is very hard. There's so much trust involved because whoever you're buying your bales from, for example, if they're not good at sorting and there's like a 1 % plus Contaminant in there and you don't really know it at first that will
become a huge problem later on yeah, but it's tough to find these things because You've got you have to trust at times that what you're being told and what you're being sold is the same and it's it all is gonna work out and It doesn't always work out because as you know better than most recycled content The quality changes week to week because it completely is dependent on the inbound material. Like if you have source
controlled stuff, that's great. It's out of facility. You know, there's only one stream of material going in. You know, that's all being collected right there. I can buy all that. I know exactly what I'm getting. But if you're getting it from Murph, who knows what the accent. You got to really trust that the people know what they're doing. For sure. And you've got consumer patterns. You have seasonality. you have reduction in hand sorting when the market's at a low. So they're pulling people off the line that would typically be pulling things out of the stream. So as the
market moves down, you see worse quality, worse impact to your yields. And again, just the whole picture becomes pretty dismal once all of that happens. So to your point, at least when you're buying a virgin pellet, you know what you're getting all day every day. You're getting it from an ISO certified supplier. Recycling is just it's just it's different. It's art and science combined Yeah, brands will always come to me like I need a data sheet on this PC No Not gonna
do that because I am NOT gonna stand by what Somebody else is selling to me when I know it's gonna have variance in it. I'm not gonna tell you this dream is a certificate of analysis, this is exactly what it's gonna be every single time. It's just not gonna work like that. You have to have some variance in your process or the ability to vary your production process in order to take recycled content. And if you're this thin on your window for your operating tolerances,
don't buy PCR. Just that simple. If you don't have the ability to move, you're gonna fail. with PCR. So I think education of brands and customers and even internal stakeholders. So I work for a resin producer. Resin producers are not very good at the recycled content. We're really good at making virgin pellet. We're really good at that. Yep. People don't see the difference
between And they could not be more diametrically opposed. I don't know how many times I have the same conversations. These things are so different. And we're looking to manage them in the exact same way that we've always done. And it's so frustrating to sell internally on these things. Because I've got this weird role where I'm kind of in procurement, kind of in sales, kind of in advocacy. 50 other things. That's perfect.
Do you like a new role every two years? I do. I do. It's great. But it gets really frustrating when you're trying to express to people what is needed for success in this space. Because there are so many variables. It's like every day is something different. be expecting loads and then there's an unexpected shutdown at whatever facility that you're buying from. And then they're
like, well, how come you don't have any kind of backup? It's PCR. Yeah. What are we talking about? There's one company that has that one spec of that stream that when you blend it all together, you get to what you need. I don't have a backup option. That has the scale that you need. I think scale is always a challenge too. Yeah. I can buy from 50 different people and then blend it and hope To get to the spec that you want and then I'll have backup But that doesn't
seem like a very good idea. That's gonna increase cost I think and everybody's saying they don't want to pay for it. Exactly It's this weird place that we're in right now because everybody's talking I want more sustainable products But I'm not seeing the buying habits change yet I don't know. What do you think about all that? I've been rambling now. No. And I agree with you. And just going back to the data sheet, I've got folks that I work with, oh, bring in this data sheet. And I always throw that flag. Yes, there's a data
sheet. But what we really need to lean into is what's the demonstrated performance that we've been getting from this particular supplier on this stream over a certain amount of time? Because there's a lot of data sheets out there. I guess maybe this is the caution to buyers, right? I've seen a lot of data sheets that are pretty irrelevant in the recycling space. So you just need to do your diligence upfront, keep suppliers honest, et cetera. Because there is a shift for all the things that we talked about, seasonality, swapping
streams, maybe not letting you know, et cetera. So demonstrated performance is key. And I think the challenge also is I always think of the triangle when you're specifying materials. The engineers and operations always want what's at the top of the triangle. But at the end of the day, if all you bring in is the top of the triangle, you don't have enough material to fuel your plants. So learning how to be flexible and run all this stuff at the bottom of the triangle, I think, is how these converters and recyclers are going to win. Because if you're not flexible, you're
out of the game. Because at the end of the day, every day, it's different. It's a different game every day, really. And it's such a long supply chain too. So you have to almost buy these things well in advance of when you're actually going to need it for production. And you almost have to sit on inventory more than a lot of companies are comfortable with because of the variation in inbound streams, variation in production quantities and quality. So you really have to be able to
adjust on the fly. And you have to take some risk. If you're going to be a player in recycled content, you have to have some tolerance for risk. Because you're going to have to buy material without knowing if you're going to have a home for it. And the market changes quickly. I know we're not tied to any kind of index, but that index does kind of drive buying behavior because where markets are now for Virgin is so low that it's very difficult to sell PCR. Yeah. And Justin,
I think both of us have worked for converters and brand owners enough in the past to know that oftentimes when the market is where it is now, you see sustainability goals kind of take a backseat to profitability. And I think that's just always a wild card or a risk. There's just a lot of brands that are talking big. They're doing the PR side of sustainability, but they're not actually buying. And it's driving a lot of investment. in recycling, which is good, but if there's no
end market, what's the point? Like, why are we doing all of this if nobody's gonna buy it in the end? Like, there's always gonna be industrial, like post -industrial streams, I think we're always gonna have a home because they're typically cheaper, even cheaper than you can buy wide spec right now if you get the right streams. The PCR content, because it has so many hands that it has to go through. and it gets so much more expensive, that's where I think we're going to have problems.
Every time we have a market trough like this, how many people go bankrupt? A ton of recyclers go bankrupt. And if we don't have somebody that's guaranteeing that they're going to buy it in the trough, we're never going to grow this space. So brands are going to have to step up and say, we're going to buy it no matter what. It's gonna make our products a little more expensive. Maybe we're gonna have to eat some margin But if they truly want to be sustainable they can do it. They just have to actually Pony up when it comes
down to it and I don't think they're going to Yeah, I think some out there are doing a little bit better than others But to your point Justin, you know recyclers going out of business doesn't really help anyone because those companies and those inverters on the value chain have invested dollars in time to get those qualifications in place And now they're starting over too. So they've lost time. And how many people, how many other people are going to invest hard earned capital into the recycling space when all they have to do is look at a 20 year window of the market
and see all the different names that come and go. I don't think there are a whole lot of people that are really excited about investing in recycled and like a Murph or Perf or anything like that because of just how difficult. it is for a lot of these companies to stay afloat when the market gets down like it is right now. And a lot of people use this as like the negative of like plastics recycling in general. But this isn't just a plastics problem. Like the amount of paper
mills that I've seen that have gone that have been shuttered because there are more efficient plants out there or there's just not as much demand right now. This is not just plastics. This is recycling as a whole, sustainable products. But anyway, you were going to say something and I talked over you. I remember. Yeah, I do that all the time. It probably wasn't going to be that interesting, whatever I was about to say, because typically it's not. But yeah, I think
there are solutions to all of these things. I don't want to... make it seem like it's all doom and gloom. Because I think there are people out there that really want to make a difference. I think you're one of them. I think there are people all over the place, like the brave guys, direct polymers. There are so many people that are out there that are well -intentioned that want to make a difference. And I think if we empower those people, we can solve a lot of these. But we really need the brands to come through. And I don't think any of this works. if consumer
-facing brands don't buy PCR. I go on all the time talking about, I don't think there should be a difference between post -consumer and post -industrial. It should all be looked at as recycled content in my mind. I don't see the... I understand why people look at it that way, but only 7 % of recycled content comes from curbside. That's just nationally. And so when you look at it, I think the reason why people look at post -consumer
is because they assume that the post -consumer means it went through curbside. When in fact, most of the time that post -consumer that they're buying did not go through curbside. There's a lot of reasons for that because single stream, everybody dumps everything into one bin. It's a dirty process. You're not gonna get very clean material on the outside. It's not ideal for you in your production. It's not ideal for anybody. And that includes paper, glass, everything. I'm talking just recycling as a whole. Curbside is
not as important as I think a lot of people make it out to be. I think we need to increase it and we need to do more of it. That's great. Let's do more of it. Folks like TRP are out there trying to make it better. Recycle content should be recycled content. Are we diverting material from the landfill? I agree. If we can do that, if we can look at it that way, I think we solve for a lot of problems in recycling. Because people are able to blend all this stuff together and reduce their overall costs and then sell it into
markets that make sense. What do you think? I agree with you. And I think sometimes we focus on post -consumer because it's more tangible. I think because people put it in their single bin at the end of the day, they understand it coming out of there, going into new things. you know, being into the world again. But I think the post -industrial piece is critical. But separating out recycled content, PI versus PC, again, I think it's maybe making things even more complicated for consumers to understand. But at the end of
the day, I agree with you. We should be putting the right materials, you know, post -industrial and post -consumer into the right applications. And if it's ending up outside of a landfill, that's the win. Yeah. So I think if we were really being honest, post -consumer going back into packaging, probably not the best outlet for that. What makes more sense is taking that post -consumer and selling it into an industrial application,
but then cost becomes prohibitive because you've got so many different hands that that post -consumer's gone through. And I think we just need to focus on, let's get as much recycled content of any sort. into all of our packages. That should be the goal. 100 % diversion from landfill should be the goal. And right now it's not. And right now I think we're incentivizing the wrong thing. And I'm very willing to have debates with people
that think I'm wrong, and that's fine. But this is just my experience and what I'm seeing and why I think we're failing to grow recycling right now. And I tend to agree with you. I think sometimes, you know, we're trying to have a particular story or to meet a particular narrative to show consumers how we're moving the needle. But there's so many different ways to skin that cat to make sure that this material is ending up outside of a landfill. Yeah. And to be clear, I want more
post -consumer recycled content. That doesn't mean I want to say, hey, let's just give up on curbside collection. No, let's expand that. Let's keep growing that, but let's find a way to incorporate cheaper recycled content like PIR in with the post -consumer to cost average it down to make it make sense from a financial perspective. And then you can sell it to brands because then the brands can't say, well, I can't pay more because of inflation. They're like, no, I can sell it
for Virgin or less. Now what's your argument? Exactly. And I think if you've got more PI in the stream, you're probably cleaning things up for some of those converters too, because PI tends to obviously be cleaner. So it could be a win -win. But again, we have to think of it and approach it differently. I think outside the box. We've got to stop with this all -encompassing focus on the only recycled content that matters is post -consumer. OK. Why? I just want to understand.
I want somebody to sit down and explain to me why that's more important than any other recycling that's happening in this country or globally. And so far, nobody's been able to explain it to me. Maybe I'm just not smart enough and somebody needs to come along and educate me, which is fine. I'll admit it. I'm not the smartest guy in the world. So if somebody has an idea, anybody that's listening to this, if you think this guy is such an idiot, he has no clue. Please reach out to me and have a conversation. Maybe don't
start off with, hey, this guy's such an idiot. Let's have a decent conversation. But I'd want to understand why there's this all -encompassing focus on just PCR. Because I just think it's counterproductive, and it's not helping anything. But anyway, I'm off my soapbox. I get on my soapbox quite a bit. OK, you're very passionate. Maybe I should cut back. I should get off my soapbox a little bit more. Let you talk more. I have
you on the show and then I talk the whole time. No. I've done my share of talking. We're almost at an hour. See? You see how quickly that goes? It actually did go by really quickly. Yeah. And I feel fired up. I feel excited. So that's good. So, perfect. So, typically the way that I do this is I start off with this question. I've been really bad the last two episodes now. What do you think of when you hear the word plastic? What's the first thing that comes to mind? Opportunity. I love that. I think that's a first. There is
a ton of opportunity. A way to make things better. There's so many different things. And for me, I think the reason why, Justin, throughout my career, I've worked at all types of different companies, but I've worked at a company that extended the shelf life of food packaging. And that allowed children and families and remote regions in Africa to get food because the shelf life was longer than it ever had been in the past. That's meaningful to me. And I worked at a company where they make trays out of polystyrene
and PET that medium is put into and, you know, small vaccines are made on. So again, children are getting cancer vaccines that potentially couldn't have before that. So I see plastics as an opportunity to change the world and change the way we do things and make things better for people. Yeah. We've got our problems, but I think overall it's a pretty awesome product when you look at it just holistically. I wish we'd talk more about those things, you know, the good things
that plastics are doing. That's what I try to do. We need more people to do it. I think that's key. We need more louder voices that are well -educated on the subjects to step up. and have these kind of conversations. In a vacuum, the loudest voice is going to win. Well, a vacuum you wouldn't hear because there's no oxygen. You get what I'm saying. I do. When there's a
gap, there's a power gap, whoever is the loudest is going to win hearts and minds. And that's what's happening right now. And we're going to keep losing volume. market share. Recycler is going to keep going bankrupt if we do not solve for some of these big issues. And we have to be honest with ourselves and with others about the problems first, or we're never going to get anywhere. So I always give every guest an opportunity
to speak about whatever's on their mind, whatever you've got going on that you really want the world to know about. And if there's nothing, it's also fun. It's just whatever's on your mind. I think, you know, again, just excited to be here. This is my first podcast. Was very, very nervous about it, but it felt good to just have an honest discussion with you. So thanks for the opportunity. On my mind, you know, continues to be just the markets in general. You know, what's going to happen with with tariffs, what's going to happen, how is that going to impact
supply chains, what's going on with freight. Obviously, anytime you're in a sourcing or supply chain role, I think these are the things that always keep you up at night. But obviously, there's a lot of things in the air right now for folks in sourcing supply chain plastics, commodities, et cetera. So I think we all just need to be patient, do more listening, and see what tomorrow brings. Yeah, I love that because people think procurement is cost savings, cost savings, cost
savings, cost savings, cost savings. That's it. Really, no amount of cost savings that you make will ever make up for running a plan at once. I agree. So supply assurance is really number one. But nobody's ever... Yeah, you're never bonused on that though. There's no way for that to be quantified. Did you run me out of material? Yes or no? That's pretty much it. But I honestly think that that is the number one thing of running
a business. And you can save yourself to death if you don't have the right partners, because you can save a ton of money. But the first time that they don't perform? you're out of a job pretty quickly. And I would pretty much guarantee that folks won't remember how much you saved in year one, two, three, but they will remember if you shut a plant down. Oh, yeah. And they will hold that against you for the rest of your life. Yeah, absolutely. I was lucky enough to always find solutions to everything. I never
ran a single plant out once. That is by the grace of God. Yeah, that's the grace of God, though. That's not necessarily anything I did. Just got lucky, because it happens to everybody. Eventually that's going to happen. So if I go back in procurement, like the first week that I'm there, I guarantee you. You're due. You're due for an audit. Let me add a point. Yeah. Anyway, Susan, it is always fun talking to you. It's always good seeing you. We ran into each other at PRC and we were both running opposite directions. I know, it was awesome
though. You live right up the road here and we never see each other. That makes me sad. So we need to solve that. problem here pretty soon. We'll get the families together. But yeah, it's good seeing you. Really appreciate you taking the time. And if anybody needs to know more about PET recycling or just wants to get to know Susan, I'll put Susan's information in the show notes. And she's an excellent resource. So I appreciate it. And for Susan. For Susan, this has been redefining
plastic. If you want to learn more about the plastics industry, recycling, check out these other videos. Please like and subscribe.
At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney sat down with Melissa Vettleson (Sustainability and Materials Engineer at IPL Schoeller) and Christian Bruey (Director of Sustainability and External Affairs at...
Justin Riney hosts Patrick Krieger, who is the Senior Vice President of Sustainability and Policy at the PLASTICS Industry Association. In this conversation, they dive deep into sustainability, plastics, and creating...
This was the third episode recorded at the National Plastics Conference (NPC), and the NPC Live podcast studio onsite. Thanks again to PLASTICS for having Redefining Plastics at the conference and all of their support....
At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney speaks with Jolene Milne, a sustainability analyst at Husky Technologies and member of NAPCOR, about industry collaboration to combat misinformation about plastics and...
We had a blast with this interview at the National Plastics Conference on-site podcast studio, "National Plastics Conference Live." Christine Yeager of CSY Impact dove deep into extended producer responsibility (EPR),...