Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Redefining Plastics

Redefining Plastics artwork

Advancing Chemical Recycling Technology with Aduro Clean Technologies

Jun 3, 202556 minAudio

In this episode of the Redefining Plastics Podcast, Justin Riney sits down with Eric Appelman from Aduro Clean Technologies to explore their groundbreaking approach to advanced recycling. Discover how Aduro's innovative process can convert mixed plastic waste into valuable feedstock, potentially solving many issues in the recycling industry. They discuss the challenges and opportunities of advanced recycling, the economic and environmental impacts, and the importance of creating a holistic recycling system. Eric shares insights into Aduro's current projects, future plans, and the critical regulatory landscape affecting recycling today. Tune in to learn more about the technologies that could redefine plastic recycling and support a more sustainable future. Redefining Plastics: https://www.redefiningplastics.com/ https://www.brvind.com/redefining-plastics https://rss.com/podcasts/redefining-plastics-with-justin-riney https://www.instagram.com/redefining_plastics/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/justin-riney-mba-67685940/ https://youtube.com/@redefiningplastics?si=KvG4dTvY1lALbwIm Aduro Clean Technologies: https://adurocleantech.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Daddy's Podcast. This is the Redefining Plastics Podcast. Welcome back to the Redefining Plastics Podcast. My name is Justin Riney. I've got an interesting one again today. I've got Eric with Aduro and they are an advanced recycler and I've had several conversations with this company and I'm really interested in the technology and I thought it would be great to have Eric on to talk through what they're doing and how

they are doing things differently and how they could possibly solve some issues in the recycling world. So Eric, thanks so much for joining. You want to give a quick introduction of you, your company, kind of what you guys are doing, and then we'll get into the meat of the discussion. Thank you for having me to begin with. For everybody that has met me before, Eric Appelman. I'm 61 years old from the Netherlands. chemical engineering by training and have through a career that went through Unilever and then the chemicals branch,

a very large paint company in Europe where I was head of innovation, through to the Swedish Lidl multinational cash store where I was in charge of innovation, marketing and corporate strategy and an innovation campus in the Netherlands, I finally ended up with a truly exciting startup company from Canada, Aduro Clean Technologies. When we were at this innovation campus, we were just attracting all sorts of innovative companies

about the future of the chemical industry. And one of those tracks is obviously dealing with waste and also with circularity. That's what I did. Gentleman from Aduro came with something that I was really amazed about. Of these 60 companies, there were probably five or so that were really wowing me. And this was one. And if I had to sum it up in two little sentences, it was essentially hydrocracking without hydrogen. And that can

be applied to things like very heavy oils, which they had been doing for a long time, and also to plastics, which they had started to do about them. Essentially, it means you can break out all those polyolefin wastes that constitutes the majority of what we just toss out in terms of plastics into valuable, saturated hydrocarbon feedstock. I said this is absolutely one of the best things in sliced bread, not the best thing, probably one of those. When three years later,

I was on my normal rhythm of doing something else after six, seven years or so, I just bumped into the CEO and the rest is history. I really decided to vote with my feet in my wallet and join this extremely exciting company. Like I said, I've had several conversations with your company. Right now, you've proved out the technology in the lab. You know that it works. Now it's a question of establishing a pilot, correct?

Is that kind of where you're at right now? Yeah, a little bit further than that. We have of course done all the lab work with pots and pans and batch reactors, but we've also had since a little over a year now a semi continuous pilot. And of course you bump into all sorts of little issues as you would do, but I'm very proud to say that we are now able to easily run multi -day runs collecting really nice and elegant products confirming all the assumptions. So I would say we have sort of half a pilot plant. The next step we will

do is the fully continuous pilot plant and that is actually very important because since we are dealing with waste the world is full of surprises in whatever is in waste and especially in dealing with the residual side streams that is the next step we do. But the fundamental chemistry has been fully demonstrated and some of our equipment dimensions have even been demonstrated on industrial scale. Okay, so I ask every single person that comes on this show one question What do you think

of when you hear the word plastic? Wonderful material that does a lot of things better than any other material is doing and That is obviously more than one word already. Yeah But if I if you do allow me a few more words, we just need to think cleverly about what we do at the end of life. And so this is not the material that will go away. And as a matter of fact, if you do that, you would sacrifice massively on the sustainability field anyway. But we do have to

solve that starting issue, which is about, okay, when it's at the end of its life, what are we going to do with it? Fair enough. So I guess that takes us to the next question. Yeah. Can plastic recycling work at scale? Now, that is a very good question. And I tend to take it from a holistic scale. And because there are many different plastics, there are many different contaminants, there are also all sorts of composite materials like multi -layer films. And that is

difficult. And it also means that the ultimate solution is going to be an optimized system of multiple frequency. And that starts already with the whole collection and sorting. Collection sorting is maybe a little bit simple, but it is definitely not free. It is complicated. And why is it complicated? Well, you can of course pick out the nice bits, but you also have rejects.

And actually if your rejects don't go anywhere, you have not really solved it. It is costly because it is a dispersed thing. And what you also have to bear in mind is that There's not that many people who want to do things like plastic sorting. In my country, we are actually facing a situation that we have a shortage of anything, even hairdressers. And so I would imagine that a career in sorting

plastic waste is not from the top of everyone's list. And that is not because it's not a respectable job, but hey, that is not, it is hard. So I think we shall already start. how we can do collecting and sorting well. And then of course, and this is a quote I have from a waste management company's innovation leaders, yeah, we can unravel waste completely. But then that doesn't mean that you

make a profitable thing. And I think that is where it boils down to. It is to make sure that the whole integral thing allows collecting, sorting, doings, diverting that into various useful streams and dealing with what is left over after the end. All of that is complicated, but it has to pay its bill. That is where the complication is. Everybody has a good solution for part of the problem, but it does not necessarily make

the others. And I'll give you one example from the Netherlands where I live. And we have seen, unfortunately, and every month one sorting company going bankrupt. All very entrepreneurial people, very good people. Of course, you will lose a few when the industry is developing. But I think the heart of the matter is that all those people took in like thousand tons of something, and then they could find a decent home for about 200 of the kilos of those. or 12 tons. And that

could go into some mechanical recycling and this and that and the other. But the other 800 still didn't have a home. But they had made costs for a whole thousand. Yeah. And I think that is the problem. And then on top of that, if you do mechanical recycling, that sounds good, but the values have not been too high of that product. And that is for a variety of reasons. We can say mechanical recycling sounds very sympathetic. And it is. And I like it as well. But there are some issues because many people don't want to have it in

food contact. One polyethylene is not the other. And if you mix different ones, it normally makes a poor quality. And not even low density polyethylene is always the same because there is dozens of different grades in terms of melt flow. Here you see already how then the difficulty starts. And that is why And the value of recycling is sometimes disappointing for people. And especially now that there's plenty of virgin material and there is a much shorter way to just buy what

you need rather than try and work by jumping to all sorts of hoops to what you have. And I think that is the whole thing. It is just much more complicated than you had dreamt. Recycling is complicated. My last episode was trying to clear up some confusion around Recycling for people to understand what it is that recycling is and isn't and the the difficulty that that I see and the thing that that I When we talk

advanced recycling we get a lot of pushback Different organizations will call them non -governmental organizations NGOs that are anti plastics will attack advanced recycling for a multitude of reasons. Say it's expensive, it's high energy costs, things like that. And then they say things like, well, they're just going to cannibalize the feedstock that's already going into mechanical recycling. And what I hear you say, and what

I think the answer is, is we're talking complimentary. We're talking advanced recycling taking the material that cannot be easily mechanically recycled and making quality and products. The question then still becomes the cost. The cost is still high in my experience for advanced recycling. So how is your technology different? How are we going to solve for that problem? As a matter of fact,

the NGO example is the guys and girls are half right. And because yes, the current standards of chemical recycling is energy intensive, doesn't have the best of yields, and those all conspire, of course, also into the financial model in the end of the day. Where they're not right is that we should try and divert everything to mechanical for the reasons that I just mentioned, because mechanical recycling is just not working for

certain application, and it is not just working if you do not have a pretty pure material to begin with. Back to the cost question. There's basically two types of polymers that you can chemically recycle. One is PET. It's actually reasonably easy, but it is not only the chemistry job that you have to master, but it is also collecting it. PET is easy to collect. There's plenty of

it, and you can establish meaningful. chain to get that product back. And of course, the best end is going to mechanical and then the lower ends you can do by depolymerization. Next category is polyolefins. That is the only other category that I believe has the scale. And then maybe the subset of polystyrene, maybe we'll have a word about that later as well. Yeah, we can, we'll write on that code tail. Yeah, exactly. Because things like nylon or ABS or also they

are typically very small and niche applications. And there is a huge problem there is maybe not even a technical bit, but it's just getting a hold of it. Because it's even a more expensive polymer and it is only teeny tiny parts in a car and somebody has to plate it. So PET you can collect a big heap of and polyolefins you can also collect a big heap of. Now, there's actually only one chemical recycling technology for polyolefins, and that is pyrolysis, which consists of heating up stuff until it falls apart,

collecting the fragments, and then saying that there's sort of an oily mass, and then offering that to the chemical industry. And there are dozens. More than a hundred companies who have worked on variations of pyrolysis. They have done really good technical jobs. I admire them to overcome the challenges. But unfortunately, there is only one chemistry and it is not very good. And it is not very good because the product

that is made is not good enough to bring it back to the door of the chemical industry, which by the way is the steam cracker. You bring it to the steam cracker, the guys will say I don't want it like this because it's going to mess up my installation which is a one billion dollar plant that does millions of times a year so horrible thing to mess up with and what are the problems and the product is so -called unsaturated and that of course coping in that installation which

contains typically a lot of oxygen from the incidental contamination with a little bit of PET in there nitrogen from the weight of nylon, silicon, and so it's not good enough. So you have to treat it. Now, there are wonderful presentations out there, and it's actually always the same story. It is a very expensive hydrogenation process that goes into four steps with each different

expensive catalysts and catalysts that, by the way, are also sensitive for impurities. very high pressure processes to an extent up to 200 bars. Oh, by the way, you need hydrogen as well. And so you also need a hydrogen plant and hydrogen is not cheap. So instead of having one plant, you have three and a pyrolysis plant, an upgrader as it is called, and a hydrogen plant. And I was talking to some people that buy these goods and say, I'm happy to buy this pyrolysis oil, but I give you a $500 discount per tonne because

that is what I have to invest to upgrade. Well, that doesn't really help. And so that is expensive. If you go a little bit back to the paralysis process itself, it's a very high temperature process. And because of that high temperature, you do convert part of your input into char and into light gases. And those light gases are not useful because it's already cracked too far. And it's a little bit different depending on the feedstock, depending on your process design. It's probably safe to say that between 10 and

20 percent of your original carbon is lost. It doesn't help. Even more problematic, it's lost as fossil carbon emissions, which you have to pay for. So it doesn't help either. You can overcome that trouble to some extent by doing more aggressive sorting upfront. and taking out the oxygen containing polymer like the PET bottles and so on. And that was reasonably good, although you're never able to avoid the upgrade. But if you then do all

that sorting, suddenly you discover that you are in the domain of mechanical recycling. Yeah, you're starting to cannibalize. The same thing that the NGOs were saying, that you're starting to cannibalize mechanical recycling. And that is not good. Actually, I spoke to a waste management lady here in the Netherlands. That's another one that I just mentioned. She said, I don't want to make paralysis feedstock because I have to divert perfectly good mechanical recirculate in order to make the specifications for paralysis. And that is, of course, not wise to do. And even

then, hey, so and that actually means that paralysis feedstock is a reasonably pure polyolefin, at least 90 -95%, which costs you three, four hundred dollars. Okay, three to four hundred dollars in, then you lose 20%, so we have the feedstock cost of about five hundred then. We have to do five hundred dollars for the after treatment. That is already a thousand dollars lost, and then you still have to build your plant and pay your guys and deal with the energy bill and the

residues. This doesn't sound like a winning proposition even though this is beautiful hydrocarbon feedstock that we bring to the cracker is today worth quite a bit. But that is probably also not going to last. So this is a huge problem and then I have not even mentioned that okay if we then can maybe handle 20 percent max by mechanical recycling mind you it is below 10 at the moment and and

maybe then this paralysis is fighting for the same turf and maybe a little bit more, let's say 25%, then you have 75 % left. And what are we going to do about that? And mind you, there is another reason, and this is what I got back from a purchase at a large petrochemical house. He said, well, it's all good and well. and you know what I can upgrade paralysis oil and yeah I'll give them a discount because else I cannot pay for that but my real concern is that it might in the end of the day be too little to bother

because if I have them maybe a few miserly hundred thousand tons here and there then that does not help me I need that whole hundred percent coming back so It's a bit amazing actually to me that so many people have pursued the same piece of chemistry with incredible creativity and impressive creativity to optimize the process. But actually staying married to that imperfect chemistry.

That is different for Aduro if you allow me to explain a little bit. I would love to because I want to understand it. We also boil the polyolophin to pieces. But we do it at a lower temperature because we're using a catalyst. That helps. And that already means that we have less losses to char and gas. But the real trick is that at that temperature we can let happen in the very same reactor another reaction. It is aqueous reforming

of some organic hydroxy components. You can forget about that, but what it does It generates hydrogen radicals in situ. And those immediately react as soon as you have broken hydrocarbon into two hydrocarbon radicals. And what you make is an alkane, a saturated component, which is precisely what alkyl allows. And that means that I do not have to upgrade that molecule anymore to remove

the unsaturation. And we do that pretty effectively. Of course, you know how it is with radicals. They are like small kids. They go everywhere. But we are able to tackle at least 90 % of those highly calmer radicals. In our process, we'll contain and deliver less than 10 % of unsaturated elephants. And that is pretty good for a cracker. And that you can easily blend away to very high proportions. And by the time we are passing that

blending ratio, I will probably be 300 years old or something like that, because that is very, very large. So that saves you massively. You can actually just, if that would work for all the components, you can pocket the $500 for the upgrading. The other thing, because our process uses a bit of water, and I use the word aqueous reforming. If that water is present in the reactor, it will also hydrolyze, break up any contamination of PDT or polyamide. And it will break those

down into their molecules. And those are very small molecules. And because of the very nature, you can easily separate them from my product. And that means that the oxygens and the nitrogens that come with those polymers find an elegant way out to the door. and do not contaminate my product. So my product is not containing so much unsaturation, a lot less. It does not contain oxygen. It does not contain nitrogen. And as a matter of fact, I can probably do without any

upgrading at all. So let me try to speak this back to you, just to make sure that for the people that are not chemists that are listening to this, ultimately what you're saying is you can take that mixed waste stream that other advanced recyclers are having to sort down. So they're having to take out the polyamides, so the nylons and the PETs and what they would consider contaminants. You can take that in your system and when you

put it into your system, you're using a lower temperature process. And what comes out of that is a cleaner pyrolysis oil that could then be diluted at the cracker that's going to have a much easier time being put back into the cracker process because it's 90 % versus what has to be hydro treated. Today, the paralysis oil has

to be hydro treated to get to that same purity in order for it to be used at the cracker. That's ultimately what we're talking about. So you're removing the hydro -treating and a couple other reactions within the process, which is cost every step through. Yeah. Okay. So that's why I call it hydro -cracking without hydrogen, when I met him the first time, because you don't have to bring hydrogen gas. You don't have to build a factory for that. You do not have a separate treatment for that. And that's the way you save

that $500 a ton. Plus, thank you for picking me up. If you can actually live with the leftovers of mechanical recycling and are happy to take 10 % PET and 2 % polyamide and a few others, you probably kind of look at feedstock that's free because nobody has a destination for it. Exactly. It's either they're having to truck it to the landfill, which is a cost to them, so you can pick it up on site free. Yeah. In

Europe we have to burn it. Well burning waste is four or five hundred dollars a ton as well and so you avoid all that cost and then by the way you do not lose so much to char and gas and you generate less emissions so it is all along that you make this process a lot more attractive. And probably we will need a little bit of sort of cleaning to get rid of a few things, but that is a completely different order of magnitude compared with that upgrading. We have now in the Netherlands two upgraded, one by Shell, one by Sapik. They are of course wonderful plants,

but they are big, big, big capital items. And yeah, they have to be filled. That is another little detail. That's also why people are concerned about the availability of problems. So this will all be different. But I think the most important factor is probably that we take a bite out of the leftovers of sorting or mechanical recycling. And we may be, and I do not know the precise number, but as long as it is about 80 % polyolefin,

I'm actually kind of happy. Yeah, I can process that. Yeah, and of course, decontamidants do not suddenly become great hydropower. That would be too good. And they will end up as a waste and they will have to be dealt with, insinuated or something like that. But at least we squeeze out a very large amount of polyolefin, if this works right. So you're saying that, what do you have, what do you think the yield is? Like if

we're getting into some IP, fine, but yeah. No, if you put in 100 kilograms of polyolefin into our plant, and that has also to do with some really interesting process concept, which unfortunately is IP, I can't talk about it. But we are able to at least generate 90 % yield to higher counts. And the total amount of charge may be 1%. and it's very very little and there's a little bit of gas and it depends how well you recover and

some of the gases are actually still good for cracking but you do have to make an effort to recover them. That's an economical question. But our yield is more than 90 percent of the polyolefins. As soon as you start to put junk in there, it's probably going to be junk as well when it comes out. But at least we're almost refiners in that sense. So what do you need to scale this? Like what is it that you require in order to make this a reality? At this moment

we have a process concept that I absolutely love. My tongue is itching to tell you more about it, but I'm not allowed to. But it is a very nice simple process that in one pass converts almost all the polyolefins to a desirable product. That's also a difference with match of the pyrolysis. It's a higher temperature, so it's almost like a horse that wants to run too quick and you have to stop a little bit early to suppress the gas formation. But it also means that you end up

with still a lot of half converted material that you have to recycle or you have to sell it as a low priced wax or something like that. We are actually able to push a very vast majority to a sellable product. So a sellable high value product. So that is an important thing. We have that design. As a matter of fact, we have tested the various elements in our semi -continuous site. Now we're going to build that for a fully continuous operation. As I said, I'll be humble.

I'm sure we are going to run into some strange fouling issues and all that. That is also what all the colleagues have done and dealt with. It's waste after all. But I actually expect pretty straightforward conversion and scaling. But we have already started to think about the next phase, which is a commercial demonstration. We are talking about where to put that and what it would look like. a couple of years for that one and then we're done and then we should be

able to do it. And the beauty is because the process is also simple. It doesn't have a lot of recycle loops and because recycle loops make me nervous if I think on 30 feet stock because it is an opportunity for all sorts of garbage to accumulate in the process. That is why it is nice. It is one single step. It also uses to a large extent equipment that is available. It is standard produced for other purposes. So you're not talking about unique reactors that

have to be handicrafted for you in a faraway country. And you can start assembling it tomorrow if you wanted to. So pretty quick. Of course, we are going to run into surprises. But as I can see now, and also partially helped by the learnings of the colleagues in Parozes. and we are probably able to take big steps through that whole upscaling process. So are you looking for partners right now within the industry? Where

are you at? Are you looking for investment? What's the next step for Adura? Well, maybe first, we are actually a public company. So we are on the ASDAQ and we have a market cap of about north of 150 million. So we have been able to attract capital, which also allows us to chart our own path. We have always been very open to working with industrial partners. And because, of course,

it is for financial help, but it's maybe even more to keep us honest and make us aware of what the industry really wants. And this is not a hobby thing. We have to make it. what people want to buy. It has been very very successful and we would like to expand that further and so we would if tomorrow one major petrochemical house or an EPC contractor would knock on my door I would embrace the person says hey we want that. Also because you can do things that we can't do and so we are looking for partners.

Our commercialization model is one of licensing. Because I foresee that the world is going to need thousands of these plants, which is partially dictated by the logistic nature of plastic waste, because it's basically everywhere. It is not that you hit one hole in the desert and out comes a mammoth tank of oil. You have to collect it and transporting fluffy waste is not the most efficient thing to do. So I foresee that we will have an armada. of plans that maybe are 10, 20,

maybe 50 ,000 tons per hour, and then take advantage of local availability. So we will also be very much willing to work with people that would like to build, own, and operate, and that have the deep pockets to build them, that have the operational excellence that we, of course, don't have, and that would say, hey, we would like to adopt your technology. OK. And I'm assuming those conversations are happening now. Obviously, that's proprietary. I'm not going to ask you who you're talking to.

Yeah. What we do see is that companies have become a little bit uncertain of late. Yeah, the economic environment. Yeah, but I think the instability of the... of the economic climate and international rules is not helping. It makes companies risk averse. Low oil prices do not help. It makes the alternative routes more attractive. But there are, however, some undeniable things. Extended producer responsibility is going to be the tool

of choice to handle the plastic problem. And we have it in Europe and it says that everybody who markets a plastic article has to put a penny or two in a collective pot, which is then used to deal with it. And we have it in Europe and we have it in Canada, where there is no significant investment coming up in a not -for -profit institutions that are going to do that. But it is also in countries as far away as the Philippines, what I heard recently, where they say, hey, guys,

we may not have the biggest petrochemical power ourselves, but what we can do is oblige the the consumer good companies, to pay for the plastic that they put on the shelf. And then they will do with that, they will do the collection, they will do the sorting, and then they obviously have to find a home for the well. So EPR is very strong. That is going to be a very strong push. Also coming is minimum recycle content. And in Europe, it's going to be something like, and

don't quote me for the number, but 30 % in certain applications by 2030. in 2030. So rather quickly, all those people that make polymers have to find sources of circular carbon. And then there is also emission tasks. In Europe, we have just brought the waste incinerators under the ETS scheme, where you have to pay for emissions. And those are some very powerful mechanisms and

financial mechanisms that is going to happen. So on one hand I see a bit a little bit disappointing because people are a little bit holding back compared to two years back or so. On the other hand, you can also see and tell from people's behavior that they have not lost it out of sight. It is just maybe a pause or a delay or whatever else and everybody knows that something has to happen. So you bring up EPR. EPR is obviously a hot topic in the US, which is where I'm based.

My issue with several EPR laws that are floating around out there right now and how this impacts you is advanced recycling is not considered recycling in California in SB 54. And then if you look at the Oregon law, that law is written in such a way that says that in order for it to be considered recycling, your carbon footprint actually has to be less than mechanical recycling. Are either

of those concerns for you? Are you out there advocating, trying to make sure that laws are reasonable to make sure that this material is accepted within these schemes? You are right that the two schemes that you quote, they will not make a very attractive playground for advanced recycling. But worse, they will actually not allow those states to reach the recycling rates that they want because it's impossible. If you

just realize that 50 % of all plastic is used in food packaging and mechanical recycling and food packaging doesn't sound a good thing. As soon as this has been in the bin it can have any contamination and nobody can control them. So on that side you lose already half of the outlets. On the other side for all the reason we just quoted. there is very little actually my hypothesis is that if you look at mechanical recycling it's probably only going to work with

post -production waste where you really know what you had and then maybe with one or two really large streams like the PET bottles and maybe HDPE rigid plastics that is a sizeable but that is just not nearly enough that is just a fraction of the total But this debate is known. We had it in Europe. This year, there is a very high likelihood that this year the European Commission

is going to recognise that chemical recycling is also recycling. And that the mass balance principle will be allowed. And that comes from the deep realisation. I actually was talking to one of the highest civil servants in that domain and he said this is the only way to come even near. a target that is impressive. It has to happen. So I suspect that in Europe it will be this. We have already in the PPWR and the packaging waste regulations made things like

minimum recycled contents that is already coming and I expect this year already that supportive legislation will be there that allows chemical recycling but it will be strict. So for instance If during your whole recycling process you have to burn 25 % of your input to power your process, that will not be good. And so it will be stricter. As such, I sympathize with the NGOs because it should indeed be that you have a decent yield,

that you do not burn it, that you do not have to push about 30 % of the stuff away as engine fuel or bunker oil. And that is what you want. You really want the real thing. And that is, I think, why our technology is so important, because it will push very high yields into proper plastic feedstock. So that will be true. What we also saw in Europe is that that same debate that led to the California regulation, we had it as well. And everybody thought naively. that

mechanical recycling could take care of everything. And now we learn, and actually I just learned a couple of new things just weeks ago, we just realized it is not going to be easy. And it might actually be a more costly way. Of course we could make a lot of road sign poles from very low quality plastic. Well one, they don't wear out very quickly and so we do not have a market that long. but also the value of that plastic is way too low to sustain recycling. In the end of the day,

you cannot pay recycling with good intentions. And it must be hard to lose something. Yeah. And you need end markets. You need people that are willing to buy it. And I think that's where recycling has just any recycling. Mechanical, chemical, advanced, whatever you want to say. That's where we run into a lot of problems, because people aren't willing to pay any sort of premium. And by people I mean brands, big brands. Those are the folks that are responsible for this.

They need to be engaged and they have to buy the material. Yeah, by the end of the day plastics are so incredibly cheap and that is basically the mastery of the petrochemical industry. It is super efficient. And even if it would like double the cost, you might not even notice it as a consumer. But you are right. In the end of the day, the bill has to be paid. And we shall not, well, what you may call, arrogantly say, yeah, well, then we have to pay a little bit more. Because it's good if you have a nice job

and make good money. But there's a lot of people out there who don't have that and who literally earn the penny counts. So I think there there are a lot of different ways we can go in this like we can run down the advocacy front and just the Like the California is a whole can of worms that we can run down like you had mentioned Kind of offhand and I think it's important that There's not enough Mechanically recycled material to

hit the recycled targets in order to sell packaging into these states. And I've been saying that for a long time. I was in the packaging industry at the time when all of the brands started coming out with, hey, we're going to be at 20 % PCR content by 2025. And the CEO of the company that I worked for at the time came to me and said, we need to run some numbers to see if this is even possible because we got to figure out how

we're going to support our customers. And I started digging into it, and I realized very quickly that even if one of the CPGs hit the 20 % content for all of the packaging that they buy, that was more than the PCR that was available within the entire country. So what is California going to do if they need 30 % recycled content by 2028? How are you going to do that? How are you going to take the biggest, the most consuming state

in the U .S. and hit these numbers? I just don't see how it's possible. No, no. In a perverse twist at this moment, we in Europe are actually importing mechanical recipe from places like India. Yeah. And which is partly feasible because of course, low labor costs for pretty poor conditions. But that is not something to be particularly proud of. You just have to find robust solutions. And we will also not be able to switch all the

plastic packaging to one single grade. And because you will have too much compromise on food preservation and all that. So let's... 2028 is ridiculously short time for that. And what is important is you do need a grown up debate, a science -based debate. where you just face facts. I think that is important. And on one hand, I think there is a reason to be sometimes skeptical, because

people have praised existing chemical recycling technologies as being very good, but if you dig a little bit deeper, it is a little bit less favorable. On the other hand, we should also, on the side of regulators, engage and shed the maybe dogmatic feathers a little bit. It is not easy matter on the other hand if you have someone that explains it honestly and clearly then you shall be able and for me that is also reason why I joined this company. I can see this working.

I could see a situation which is similar to the case that I just explained to you before this on the Thai waste collection system. I think we should be able to say, okay, here comes all the plastic waste. We pick out the low -hanging fruit, that may be about 10, 15 percent. We send the whole rest into a decent chemical reduction, chemical recycling process, which the Adura one could be a very, very strong candidate. And then we just turn it as much as we can back. But be honest and be critical and be also willing as

an industry and also the regular say, well, this is not going to work. and no time for dogma here. Completely agree. I think we need to be engaged with the NGOs. I think we need to be talking to each of these states and regulatory bodies. The mass balance conversation in Europe, I'm very aware of and I think that's huge if we can get the European Commission to accept that because you and I both know it doesn't work without mass balance. You have to have it. But it's actually

funny because that is the first country where it has been recognized. It happened just last week in the UK. You know that they brexited away from us, but we're still friends. And as a matter of fact, them being a little bit smaller in the whole of Europe, they are able to take some good steps and they have recognized both chemical recycling and the mass balance principle as a way to circularity. And as such, you can probably see them as a little bit of a bellwether for what is going to happen elsewhere in Europe. Okay. So what other things are out there that

get you excited when it comes to plastic recycling? Is there anything else that you're seeing is kind of a shift in the environment or shift in the conversation that's going to be helpful for these kind of technologies? No, I think I raised APR, I raised the regulatory side. Those are incredibly important. We will require for the

implementation also some people with deep pockets. What is interesting today is that chemical recycling is a bit of a in between technology and the waste management companies typically do not like to do it because it's chemical and they are much more into transporting things and maybe a bit of sorting but chemistry is a little bit of a tricky and dangerous activity and I understand that. For the big petrochemical houses, they

are of course used to build multi -billion dollar capex projects. that process literally millions of tons of feedstock and make a highly predictable output. And we don't understand feed streams. We don't understand the recycling market. They're very skilled in fossil feed streams, but the whole intellectual hard wiring is not there to handle an armada of small plants with waste that

is, and then maybe do 10, 20, 30 ,000 tons a year. So that is not a natural comfort zone there either. And what we need in between, either that one of those two sides step up and you see that there's a couple of waste management companies that actually do venture into chemical recycling and there is a couple of petrochemical houses that do admirable steps. And I really like them and there's a couple of, I think Lionel Wiesel, Borealis, they do make steps. But others wait

a little bit. I think we do need to fill that gap in between. There's also new groups emerging of companies that want to build that armada of plants. They're often technologically agnostic and they will take whatever suits them best and that's actually healthy. I think that category, the operators in between, that is an area that is a little bit underpopulated right now. It would be very good if something happened there.

All right. Anything else that we haven't covered today that you wanted to highlight? Maybe what the company is doing or anything like that? Yeah, we are of course also, it's a platform what we do. And as I told you, we started out with breaking up very heavy bitumes or even residues from distillation. And that's how we actually invented it. What I'm myself asking is now, we've also discovered

we have a very elegant way to break up styrene, polystyrene, where we break it up not in styrene monomer, as some people do, but in a mixture of toluene, ethylbenzene and cumene. Sorry for being a little bit chemical. No. So for people that don't understand, ethyl benzene is the main feedstock to make styrene, which then is the main feedstock to make polystyrene. But we also make some side products, but those are actually

very common ones as well, because toluene is also a very sought after feedstock. And cumene is how you make phenol and everything that comes from that. So very interestingly, where This could be an alternative way of doing polystyrene recycling in very high yields, where all of the product is useful. You're preaching to the choir here. Anything we can do to increase polystyrene recycling, I'm happy with. No, and I said that is one thing, but it is a generic platform, so

we can do a variety of things. and also the whole bitumen upgrading. I actually like a lot the upgrading of residues as well, also from oil distillate, because that helps us to become more sustainable in the end of the day, making a better use of what we have, recycling things, reusing things. I think that is our big thing. Thinking of others, yeah, for us it is of course now just running, because like everything in scaling,

The chemical industry is a slow process, not because we are slow. But because we have to operate safely, we are building some process at a high temperature, high pressure. You don't want to go bang, and you do not want to emit anything. That is nasty. That is why our processes are slow, just like in the medical industry. And that is, of course, for us as a company who started a little bit later than the others, because most paralysis people started already in 2005 for an entirely different reason. And those days we were scared that we wouldn't have enough fossil carbon, believe it or not. But we started a bit

later, so it is a run. We have to move aggressively forward. But at the stage for where we are now, I can actually basically very clearly see the path that we have to go through. That is our obsession right now. And for the rest, I do really hope that we will find the possibility to work with petrochemical houses, EPC contractors, waste managers to realize that, hey, this is not only an insulated chemical process, but it is potentially

even the window that opens to making a feasible recycling system. And because the point is, if your mechanical recycling doesn't work, the whole thing collapses. Your chemical recycling doesn't work, the thing collapses. If your sorting doesn't work, the thing collapses. And all bricks in the wall have to be in place. to make a proposition that is viable. We need a holistic recycling system. That is a very, very important thing.

A very important thing. So with the polystyrene conversation, let's say, because polystyrene is obviously a smaller percentage of the packaging market. So you're talking max 3 % based on the numbers I've seen. If polystyrene rides along with polypropylene, polyethylene, and PET in your process, is the output still going to be ethylbenzene, toluene? So that's the kind of offtake that you're going to need? Yeah, if it

sits there, if it's 4%, then you will have 4 % of that. And here, I think polystyrene is precisely at the edge. We have the streams that are much bigger and easier to collect. olefin PET. By the way, also tire rubber fits there. By the way, we can also - You get the styrene out of the tires. We can also now, we can actually handle tire rubber as well. And so tire rubber pyrolysis is a very, very messy process. We make a lot of gas. And if we do our own process on that,

we get a lot of liquids and basically much higher yields. But that's another thing that we'll do when we have time. But polystyrene is a bit on the edge. Like, okay, there is still a sizable amount of it. you could reasonably collect it, but of course we have with foams, we have a little bit more the issues of the flame retardants, but if you would be able to collect sufficient quantity of that, then it probably would warrant to process it separately. I think with polystyrene,

so the stuff that doesn't have flame retardants is typically the transport packaging that's collected at your distribution centers, and that stuff's being recycled mechanically now. So that's the other thing. So then you would be competing with... If it can be mechanically recycled, if you can use the polystyrene peanuts again and again and again, please do. That's a weird idea. Well, I'm not talking about the peanuts though. I'm talking about the block and shape, the molds. Yeah. Perfect stuff. Also the polystyrene cups,

styrofoam cups, and the yogurt cups. Interestingly, you can rather easily separate polystyrene from other plastics because it's more on the heavy end. So you might be able to separate. And if you would be in a position to collect sufficiently large quantities of that, I think it might actually even be more clever to tackle it separately with the technology that we have at Aduro. Because then you are able to convert it with very high

yield to a very precise set of components. Which is always a good idea. I like it. Anything we can do to increase polystyrene recycling, I'm all for. I do that. We should actually have a talk about it because I think this is interesting. Also because it's relatively easy because if you make styrene monomer, you just have it and it is not the safest product. So you probably have to do it close to where you want to use it again. What we make is probably a little bit easier to handle as well. We can do it in a distributed fashion. Well, I know you're having conversations

with the polystyrene and recycling alliance. So that's the right group to have the conversations. But I think I will connect you to my day job as well. Because I think that's a good conversation to have. But Eric, anything else you wanted to add today? I always give everybody an opportunity to talk about anything that they want to when they come on the show. What do you mean for the next time? I think that that whole holistic side is important. I would like to also talk to waste

management companies. They are actually stepping up. And also these EPR organizations that have to take care of different countries, solve it in a different way. But I think that is a group of people, they have some funds because they get substantial money for EPR. And I think they should also support the development of the right technology because it is not all clear and they will only be successful if everything finds a home. And if you talk about a holistic discussion,

I think it is important and it's a little bit maybe a sign of the times that we try to fortify ourselves in certain sometimes ideological positions. I think we have to overcome it and let the rule of science speak. And the last thing is, yeah, I think all actors have to take their responsibility and try to make it happen. That will be very, very important. Well, Erik, I really appreciate the time today. I think this has been highly educational, even for me. And I feel like I'm

tied in to a lot of these conversations, but just the hydro treating part and kind of understanding all of that, I think is, it's key. And I wish you... a ton of luck. Because I think, even if the technology is great, you still need a little bit of luck, right? You got to have the right partners come along. You got to have. Yeah, so there is funding and sometimes everybody can buy share, by the way, that's how you help us. And there is funding you have to have be there at the right moment. And we all know that that's

life and we but you also you earn your luck. That's what was my statement always when I talk to people who worked for me. and work hard, go out, be humble, and be willing to accept that, hey, there might be a clever idea around the corner or a good suggestion. I think that is very, very important. That's also very much how the company is. Then in the end of the day, I think we're going to be there. Maybe we shall actually make a date for a year from now and see where we are. I love it. I love it. And I'm going to hold you to that. We'll definitely bring you back and kind of talk about where everything's

going. Thanks again. This has been the redefining plastics podcast. My name is Justin Riney, Eric at Aduro. Thank you so much and everybody have a great day. You want to learn more about plastics industry, recycling, check out these other videos, please like and subscribe.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Scaling Dissolution for Food-Contact Recycled Polypropylene with IPL Schoeller and PureCycle

    Nov 3, 202629 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney sat down with Melissa Vettleson (Sustainability and Materials Engineer at IPL Schoeller) and Christian Bruey (Director of Sustainability and External Affairs at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Are Plastics Sustainable? with Patrick Krieger of the PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 27, 202632 minAudio

    Justin Riney hosts Patrick Krieger, who is the Senior Vice President of Sustainability and Policy at the PLASTICS Industry Association. In this conversation, they dive deep into sustainability, plastics, and creating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Recycling Collaboration, EPR, and Building End Markets with PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 20, 202630 minAudio

    This was the third episode recorded at the National Plastics Conference (NPC), and the NPC Live podcast studio onsite. Thanks again to PLASTICS for having Redefining Plastics at the conference and all of their support....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. NAPCOR’s PET Bottle Decarbonization Roadmap with Husky’s Jolene Milne (NPC Live)

    Oct 6, 202624 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney speaks with Jolene Milne, a sustainability analyst at Husky Technologies and member of NAPCOR, about industry collaboration to combat misinformation about plastics and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EPR, Data Gaps, and Change Management with Christine Yeager at National Plastics Conference Live

    Sep 23, 202632 minAudio

    We had a blast with this interview at the National Plastics Conference on-site podcast studio, "National Plastics Conference Live." Christine Yeager of CSY Impact dove deep into extended producer responsibility (EPR),...

    Credit the people on this episode