Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Redefining Plastics

Redefining Plastics artwork

Rethinking Recycled-Content with Greg Janson of Triton Ties

Sep 23, 202550 minAudio

In this episode of the Redefining Plastics Podcast, host Justin Riney speaks with Greg Janson, President and CEO of Triton Group. Greg shares his extensive experience in the recycling industry, starting from his early days in his father's recycling business to his current endeavors with Triton Ties. The conversation delves into the evolution of recycling practices, the challenges of competing with low-cost virgin plastics, and innovative solutions like composite rail ties made from recycled materials. Greg emphasizes the importance of creating long-term demand for recycled plastics and calls for industry-wide collaboration to shift focus from just collection to demand-driven growth for recycling. The discussion also touches on policy implications, the need for educating legislators, and the role of capitalism in driving sustainable recycling solutions. Infrastructure is the future for recycled plastic materials. Greg Janson and Triton Ties https://www.tritonties.com/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/greg-janson-16a46631/ Redefining Plastics https://www.redefiningplastics.com/ https://www.brvind.com/redefining-plastics https://rss.com/podcasts/redefining-plastics-with-justin-riney https://www.instagram.com/redefining_plastics/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/samantha-ryan-%F0%9F%A6%85-77057322a/ https://www.linkedin.com/in/justin-riney-mba-67685940/ https://youtube.com/@redefiningplastics?si=KvG4dTvY1lALbwIm

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to Daddy's Podcast. This is the Redefining Plastics Podcast. Welcome to the Redefining Plastics Podcast. My name is Justin Riney. At this time, we've got an industry expert, a recycling industry expert. I'm going to give you that title, whether you want to take it or not. Greg Jansen, Triton Ties. We ran into each other at the Barrel Locker Recycling Conference, which was really well done. I love what you had to say. I agreed with everything

you had to say. So I wanted to bring you on to kind of talk about recycling in the U .S. But first, why don't you introduce yourself, who you are, where you came from, what you do now, all that good stuff. Yeah. So Greg Jansen, president, CEO of Triton Group, which also entails Triton Ties. A long time. Industry veteran. Like I've said before, I started in the industry in 1974. And people look at me funny because they're like,

you don't look like you're 80 years old. But I actually started in the industry when I was six. My father started a recycling company. I grew up working there, you know, through my youth. Spent a lot of time there. It was more of a traditional scrapyard and paper. metals, that type of thing, which eventually evolved into a full -scale single -stream sorting company. So when I was 18, I left the industry. I went to college, and some

guys grow up on a farm, and they want to be farmers, and some guys grow up on a farm, and they want to get as far away from the farm as possible. That was me. I didn't want anything to do with this industry. I wanted to serve by country in the Marine Corps, so I went to Purdue University on a Navy ROTC scholarship, was commissioned in the Marine Corps in 1990, and served for eight years as an infantry officer in the Marine Corps. I do want to be clear, I did not see any combat.

I came in right after Desert Storm, and I left before 9 -11. Just a lot of training, a lot of travel in the world, et cetera. So great time. Had an awesome time. When I was in the Marine Corps, I like to say that I got more than I gave. But I also got married in the midst of that to my college sweetheart. We started having children. We now have six children. Good God. Two is more than I can handle. Yeah. So they're all grown

now. My youngest are 20. They were twins. So that was interesting. So we're empty nesters now. But in that process, you know, you come to understand that really for me, being a Marine officer was really not a family man game. The mission comes first as it should. And so you spend a lot of your time gone. And I decided to leave the Marine Corps. My father was always recruiting me to come back into the business. And so I did in 1998. I came back into the business.

At that time, the business had evolved. into running more traditional, what we consider material recovery facilities. We then grew that business. We started building more MRFs, designing and building MRFs. And then at the end of the day, we were the largest MRF operators, commercial recyclers, residential recyclers in the cities of St. Louis, Louisville, and Nashville. So a lot of MRF experience. Did that for about 11

years. and more. But in 2011, we sold our St. Louis businesses. So we had a total of five Merck's, two in St. Louis, one in Louisville, and two in Nashville. We ended up selling those over the course of like three or four years to Republic Waste. We sold our Nashville operations to Waste Management. We eventually sold our Louisville operations to West Rock. And then we decided to invest in a new concept that we created that we called, or that we were one of the first movers in, I guess. what we call plastic recovery facilities.

So a material recovery facility is a local asset that typically serves about a 50 -mile radius. The plastic recovery facility was what we called a regional asset. So we built one in the Louisville market to kind of serve the Midwest. We built one in Atlanta to serve the Southeast. And then we built another one in Baltimore to serve the Atlantic, North. Northeast Atlantic coast. Right. Yeah. And then we also built a facility in St.

Louis to kind of take what those facilities couldn't handle or what they didn't recover and bring that back to St. Louis. And so that all happened between about 2011, 2016. We built all these and it was a great business up until about 2015. And we saw the fracking revolution really take hold. And what ended up happening is we saw this explosion of virgin capacity. It drove the price of virgin plastics down and basically made that

business no longer tenable. So we ended up closing three of those plastic recovery facilities. Some people call them secondary sort facilities, which is kind of a term that I prefer now. And we held on to our plant in St. Louis. converted that into handling what we call large mixed rigid plastic. So bales of larger buckets, pallets, large toys, that kind of thing, larger plastic products. And we put that through a very kind

of sophisticated mechanical sorting process. At the end of the day, we end up with a polyethylene heavy post -consumer regrind and a polypropylene heavy post -consumer regrind. obviously looking at that business, staring down the barrel of low virgin prices for a long time, we said, who's being successful in this industry? It really wasn't the reclamers, right? Reclamers were just kind of what I call whiling away in the salt mines, you know, and providing a commodity that

just kept getting, the prices kept getting lower and lower. But when we looked at who was really successful in this business, Whether it was ADS making drain pipe, infiltrator water technologies now owned by ADS making subterranean septic tanks and water filtration systems. Even the carpet guys, the PET guys making carpet, the Mohawks and the Shaws, etc. Or the KWs making polypropylene paint cans. They all had one thing in common.

They were buying scrap and they were making a part. A product, yeah. A product. So I like to say that they were buying by the pound and selling by the piece. Yeah. Right. That's a good way to put it. Yeah. And so when you're doing that, low prices are actually to your advantage, right? Because you can pass those on to your finished product and get more competitive or you can just increase your margin. Right. So if you look at that business, what you see is you see plastic, post -consumer plastic. replacing legacy materials,

not replacing virgin plastic, not really even being in the packaging business, although paint cans are a little different, right? But they were replacing steel paint cans. So, you know, ADS is making a polyethylene pipe replacing steel and clay. KW is making a polypropylene paint can replacing steel. Carver guys are making PET carpet replacing nylon or really like wool. Carpet. And ADS is replacing concrete in the water, in

the septic tanks and water filtration, stuff like that. So it became apparent to us if we wanted to survive in this business and thrive in this business, we needed to create a part, a piece. And we hit on the composite rail tie. Why composite rail tie? I've been curious about this. That's a great question. Well, one is, is it the current part would, you know, pre -assault soaked hardwood has a performance issue. So new

hardwood is not lasting as long as old hardwood. So the large railroads in the U .S. called class one railroads, when we think of them, these are the ones we think of, the Union Pacific, the Norfolk Southern, the CSX, the BNSF. they have a problem with wood and they know they have a problem, right? It's not lasting as long as it used to. So they have these things modeled the last 25, 30 years and in the high rot zones of the U .S., you know, the Southern Crescent coming

up through the Mississippi River Valley and then in the Pacific Northwest, these ties are being pulled out at 10 to 15 years and they're just mulch at that point, right? So... There was a problem that needed to be solved. And then the scale. So there's 20 million wooden railroad ties replaced every year in North America. 14 million of those are in the high decay zones, and about 9 million of those are in the accelerated

decay zones, meaning severe, high, or severe decay. So the scale was very attractive, right? So you're not... You're not seeding a niche market. You're feeding something that has the potential for massive scale, something worth investing in. Was that something you had familiarity with before you started this? Like you knew the railroads and you had worked with them in the past? Or is this just, no, you kind of found it? We kind of found it because we were looking at other companies that had tried to do it. Okay. So there

was what I call the first generation. Composite, and I use air quotes on that because they weren't really composite. They were plastic, okay? Companies like Integrico, Axion, other companies that are no longer here. So when we took a look at it, we said, if there's a problem that needs to be solved and they're making a product, why weren't they successful? Well, the reason that they weren't successful is the part wasn't strong enough.

Okay. So why wasn't it strong enough? Well, they were trying to compete with wood on price. In order to do that, you have to have low material costs. So they were making a part. We use a measurement called MOR or modulus of rupture. You put this thing on a rack, you put pressure in the middle with a cylinder and you measure how much, how many PSI it takes to break it in half. So that's called MOR. These ties were breaking at 2 ,500

MOR and oak breaks in about eight or 9 ,000. Okay. So when they put them in mainline track, they weren't lasting. So the entire value proposition is, look, these are going to last add longer, longer than wood. In our case, they need to last significantly longer than wood, right? Make it worth the investment. Exactly. So we decided early on that we were going to make a tie that was. that was going to last four to five times longer than wood and introduce that at a price

point where we could make money doing it and that price point is higher than wood but it's a life cycle economics so in order to do that we had to use glass fiber so we had to use virgin glass fiber into the tie which is a not a new technology right The glass fiber bonds with the plastic, spreads out the surface area. And so it can take much more pressure, much more wear

and pressure and last. And so that's what we did. We introduced glass fiber into the tie and we saw a tie initially at about 7 ,000 MLR. And that was with a company called Evertrack, which we co -founded in 2017. We left that company in 2019, sold our shares, waited out our non -compete and started Triton Ties. Okay. With

the knowledge that we gained working on Evertrack, we introduced a different process. that respected the retention of the length of the glass fiber. So we have a process that maintains the length of the glass fiber, which allows the tie to be stronger than that 7 ,000. So the Triton tie, our strongest tie, is called a G3, and we are at 8 ,500, 9 ,000, even 10 ,000 MOR. So to answer

your question, we knew about... the problem by researching these other companies. We changed the formula to make it stronger than hope and then introduced that to the market. And now we're approved by all of those railroads that I talked about. We're approved through their labs and in track on mainline track on those railroads. So now the drill is how do we gain traction with this product? The problem is, is that it is more

expensive. And so you're trying to get a customer that is used to annual budgets. You know, people are comfortable with the problem that they know. Yeah. Right. I understand that. So we're trying to get people to think a little differently from a budgeting standpoint that, hey, these are going to solve your problem, particularly in your severe decay zones with the Triton tie. And EverTrack is still making ties, and they make a good tie. And there's one other company. There's about

three of them. It's kind of a triopoly at this point. There's about three companies that are approved. And we're all now in R &D and trying to reduce the weight and get the price down and stuff like that. But the bottom line is the product works. It's a great product, and it sucks up a lot of recycled plastic. So what do you say to people that say that's downcycling? Because you and I talked about this. We both hate the term downcycling because downcycling is, that's a conversation in plastics, but nowhere else. Yeah. So I've never understood that concept,

to be honest with you, because, I mean, let's just take a product that's been very well accepted into the market, which is the drain pipe. All right. So you have a drain pipe. Okay. It's made out of, let's just say in this case, the example that we're going to use, let's say it's made out of 100 % TCR, fractional melt HDTE. Okay. You're going to make this part. You're going to put it in the ground and it's going to last for a hundred years. And when you pull that part out, you can wash it, grind it, grind it, wash

it and reuse it. Yeah. Again. Now how that's downcycling. I don't know, because let's take that same material, ACV fractional melt, and say by some act of God, you know, Procter & Gamble is going to make their Tide bottles out of this now. Let's say we somehow overcome the color issue. Yeah. Or they do a full label wrap with their orange label or whatever, and it's a black bottle or a light gray bottle or a dark gray bottle. So then that goes on the shelf. Everyone's

happy because it's product A back to product A. And then it goes into the waste stream. It's got a 10 % chance of actually getting recycled. And it's only that reuse of that plastic is only lasting for 90 days or six months or whatever. Yeah. And it's only got a 10 % chance of getting recycled. So to call that better makes absolutely no sense to me. Right. I agree with you. Yeah. I'm on the same crusade you are. So I just think that there's this, and we're going to get into

this. i think that we have a a uh a view of circularity that is uh ultimately not able to be achieved right so we call something circular if it's the same product going back to the other product the reality is is that there's very few materials where that can happen given performance issues given cost issues given color issues So there's very few products that can happen with PET, clear,

okay. HDPE natural, not going back into a milk jug. No. So, you know, it's really only PET. Yeah. From a plastic perspective, you can say the same about glass and aluminum and everything. Yeah. Yeah. So it's like saying that if you don't turn a steel pipe back into a steel pipe, it's not recycling the electric. It makes no sense. They're using it for an I .B. They're using it in a car. or whatever Nucor does, that somehow that's not recycling. So I really think that,

and what's funny is, is that we, you know, the industry created that term. It's like, we're fighting ourselves. Yeah. Right? It doesn't make any sense. We're good at that. And so, yeah. And so, you know, I mean, I'm on a crusade to basically say that, you know, I don't call taking, you know, post -consumer plastic and turn it into durable goods. I don't call that downtime. I call it real cycling. Yeah. Because when you

really look at what is actually driving even the limited demand that we have, particularly in all of things, it's almost exclusively durable goods. Yeah. So we need to get rid of that term. What we need to do is we need solutions that work, right? At scale. That's what we need. And you've talked about already, like... 2015, there was a big drop in resin prices. There's a big drop in resin prices right now. So we're kind

of in that same situation right now where virgin pricing is so low that I don't care if it's post -industrial, post -consumer, whatever. Recycle content's tough right now. Right. Yeah, the recycling content is very tough. And, you know, I mean, everything leads with price. And it's not going to get any better. We're the cheapest place in the world to make virgin resin. I grew up in the 70s, in the early 80s, and I would have never dreamed that we would be the largest producer

of oil and natural gas in the world. And so what that drove is, that drove what appears to be a somewhat irrational investment in virgin capacity. So it's oversupplied and the price is just, I'm talking about wide spec. I mean, that's just being dumped onto the market. Virgin oversupply is not projected to turn around anytime soon. So we're going to be in this environment for a long time and we need to realize that and we

need to get our head around that. The industry really hasn't come to grips with two major factors that affect demand. One is this material cannot go to Asia anymore. Yeah, national sword. Right. And we are going to be in this very low virgin resin price for a long time. You know, I think ultimately grappling with these issues in a capitalist

economy where you have to outperform, you have to be able to deliver a positive bottom line impact is ultimately going to be a good thing. Because when we were exporting all of our difficult -to -recycle materials, mixed bales, that type of thing, when you're exporting your challenges, you're exporting your innovation. And now that we have to grapple with these problems ourselves, we're going to innovate our way out of it. I have a lot of faith in the entrepreneurial spirit of America that we will innovate our way out

of this problem. Your presentation, obviously, it's got some coverage afterwards on Plastics News. I saw that. And apparently mine's supposed to go on there at some point, too, which I'm a little nervous about what I said. But we'll find out once he publishes it. But the crux of your argument was we can solve recycling in America if we look at infrastructure. Like how do we

take these long life products, like you talked rail ties, you talked pipe, you talked all these other things that are being made out of things that break down and you make it out of plastic that is designed to be around for a very long time. We're actually using it for the purpose that it was intended when that was intended when it was first created, right? So why don't we do that? What is stopping us? from doing that. You know, I mean, I talked about, you know, I

talked about the genius of plastics, right? Plastics is a wonderful invention. It's a genius product because it's incredibly adaptable. It can be engineered into a lot of different things. It's incredibly durable, right? I mean, you can take LDT and you can make, you know, you can make bags out of it. You can make solid parts out of it, HDT, polypropylene, you know, it's going to be around forever. which is a good thing, okay? It's durable. And so these are the properties

that drove what I call the first wave of innovation in packaging, in plastic use. So you saw, you know, plastic bags replacing paper bags. You saw plastic cans replacing steel cans. You know, you saw all of this innovation in plastic packaging. But that's also part of the problem. We have then said, okay, well, if virgin plastic can go into this application, then recycled plastic should also be able to go into that same application.

And the reality is, is that we don't collect these products, these packaging products individually, right? We don't have, you know, 15 bins where we put only the HDTE box set. We collect the mix. And there's a lot of reasons we do that. A lot of them are related to Hall or economics. Again, we go back to efficiency. We go back to money. So they collect them mixed. That means that they're processed mixed. That means that they're sorted mixed. And so the reality is, and I like to say, like, I'm a huge breakfast

guy. I love breakfast. I love getting egg scramble. And in my egg scramble, I've got maybe seven or eight different ingredients, right? I got egg in there. I got some sausage. I got some ham. I got cheese. I got jalapeno peppers. I got onions. I got green peppers. So that's the way single stream is. Everything is mixed. Now imagine if somebody told you, you've got to take that egg scramble and you've got to separate all of those ingredients exactly. And that piece

of sausage cannot have one piece of egg left on it because we want to turn that back into a sausage product. And you're going to sell it to touch other sausage products. Exactly right. Right. And so that's, that doesn't work. Yeah. And so then we're like, well, you're just not processing it properly. Okay. Well, let's just say that I do get that Tide bottle separated from that entire single stream mix. And I've got only Tide orange and there are companies that do that. Okay. And I've got only Tide orange.

And so now I can, I can sell that back. Or even let's just take a yogurt truck. Right. So I got a white yogurt cup and then I got to put that through FDA approval, which can't even happen with polypropylene. Right. But let's just say it can. And every time I have to throw another step of sorting, another step of processing, another step of washing, I add 10, 16 cents. Right. So now I have a product, let's say, that can go back into that package, but it's a dollar

a pound as opposed to virgin that's 45 cents a pound or 40 cents a pound. We're seeing companies that are grappling with that now. SureCycle is making a really nice polypropylene product, but it's very expensive. So I say that we have to reimagine how to recycle the genius of plastics. But first off, I say, look, plastics are good. They're not evil. We just have to find the right use case. So you need to find applications that

can take a bit of a mixed. olefin product for that pet i'm dealing with all of this because the other thing is great about olison at the end of the day you can shred everything and sink float it and the stuff you don't want is going to sink and the stuff you do want is going to float so you know we need something that has that can take a little bit of a variance in melt flow that can handle some polypropylene in the polyethylene that can handle ldpe and the hdpe and that what i is what i call infrastructure

And the rail tie is a good example of that. So if those 14 million rail ties that are in the accelerated decay zones were replaced with composite ties every year, that would increase the recycling total by two and a half billion pounds a year. That would increase the recycling rate by 50. We would increase 50 % more plastic than we're doing right now. And that's one product. That's just one product. One product. Another product,

pallets, returnable pallets, pooling pallets. So if you go behind a Walmart or if you go into a Costco and you look at what all the product is sitting on, they're all sitting on primarily blue pallets that are pooling pallets, meaning that all the retailers, they... They rent these pallets and they move among the entire supply chain. So it's ubiquitous. It touches everybody, okay? Well, those pallets are made out of wood. Now, there's 120 million of those in circulation

in North America, those blue pooling pallets. If over time those were changed to 100 % post -consumer, and I guarantee you that we can make a 100 % post -consumer, that is virtually indestructible. Now, we may have to use some glass fiber. That's great. But let's just say that that pallet weighed 70 pounds. Well, if you do that math, that's 7 .4 billion pounds. And those are going to have

to be replaced. And those are going, you know, eventually they are going, some of them are going to crack and they're going to have to be replaced. And so again, that's another huge market that could suck up a tremendous amount of post -consumer plastic. with a spec that is in reality to how plastic is recovered. So those are just two examples, and we're at almost 10 billion pounds. Yeah. Just right there. Well on your way to solving the problem. I mean, we could innovate. Guardrails

could probably be made out of post -consumer plastic. Certainly guardrail posts could be made out of post -consumer plastic. Utility poles. Look at all the wooden utility poles. that are rotting and that are crooked, you know, we could make those out of post -consumer plastic. There's ways to do that. We just have to unlock our mind. We got to get onto the innovation chain and figure out how to use this material. So what we're doing now, I'd like to say, is that we're trying to

jam a recycled plastic square peg into a hole made specifically for Virgin, into a round hole, Made specifically for virgin plastic. Yeah, virgin plastic, paper, whatever. It doesn't work. Yeah. So that's kind of my pitch, yeah. No, and honestly, and that's why I wanted to talk to you because the entire time you were talking up there, I was like, yes, yes, this is exactly right. And I think I even made the comment when we were doing the roundtable afterwards that plastic

is held to a completely different standard when it comes to recycling than other materials. Because let's just look at glass, for example. Glass in the U .S., very little of that stuff has actually ended up back in a glass bottle again. Like most of that's in asphalt or aggregate or something like that. If that happened in plastic, you know, the uproar that people would have. But for some reason with glass, it's fine. And like, why are we having different debates for plastic versus

glass? You know, I think one of the reasons is, as I think about this now, I've never really thought of it that way before, but the glass industry doesn't fight itself, right? So you don't have the glass industry saying sand is bad, right? Yeah, I get it. The plastic industry, we're fighting ourselves because we've bought into this notion that virgin plastic is bad, right? Virgin plastic has changed our lives for the better. It touches everybody in the globe.

We have an end -of -life problem, right? It's not that plastic is bad. Again, plastic is a genius material. I was talking to my marketing folks, and I kind of hesitate to say this because this guy was an antagonist, but the whole idea in Wall Street where it's like greed is good, right? Well, I mean, you know, I'm not saying that greed is good, but I'm saying that that mindset of, you know, I think it's good. Let's apply it. In applications that replace inferior

materials. Yeah. You know, instead of apologizing for what recycled plastic is, and let's acknowledge that it's not virgin. We acknowledge that it's not, it's not virgin. Okay. But packaging that comes from virgin plastic makes the best recycled plastic there is. So plastic is good. Recycled plastic has certain properties that allow it to outperform legacy materials. So instead of apologizing to what recycled plastic isn't, let's

promote it for what it is. Agreed. I mean, Mother Nature created an end -of -life solution for wood in that it decays. Why are we seeing wood in things like marine applications, wooden pylons? Again, utility poles. Anything where wood's got to sit outside for a long time, it's a loser. Yeah. You know, now wood inside a house that's going to be covered, et cetera, two by fours, whatever. It's great. Right. But I mean, trucks figured this out a long time ago. Everybody got

tired of having to worry about their cedar deck and having to, you know, power wash it and, you know, scrape it and recondition and all this stuff. They got tired of that. So they introduced a product, a lot of which is plastic, that replaced that. We need to do that at scale. at the industrial level. And it's interesting because I'm on LinkedIn a ton. And whenever there are people that are bashing plastics, the one caveat, the one thing

that they always throw out there is like, hey, I love my plastic deck. Yeah. Right. Yeah. And that's not even circular. You can't even recycle that, right? I mean, it's 50 % wood flour. So going back to why we have this problem, for whatever reason, the plastic industry, we're fighting ourselves. And the petrochem still threatens, so they don't really, they kind of say they support recycling, but they really don't. I mean, they do in some regards, but there's just a lot of greenwashing, obviously. There's a lot of virtue

signaling, but there's not a lot of real solutions. I think this pooling pilot idea makes total sense because it allows all of these retailers and all of these brands to participate in the circular economy. just by virtue of the logistics. Yeah. But yeah, we're fighting ourselves and we need to stop fighting ourselves. And what we need to start fighting is we need to start fighting wood. We need to start fighting concrete. We need to start fighting steel. And we need to

do that together. You know, I had a slide in my presentation of that classic scene from Raiders of the Lost Ark where he's facing the guy that has the sword and he's flipping the sword around and he's thinking, oh man, you know, Indiana Jones is in trouble, and he just pulls out a pistol and shoots the guy, right? So, you know, don't take a knife to a gunfight. You know, you need to take a bigger gun to a gunfight. And if we all get together in the plastic industry, the entire thing, from burgeoning all the way down to recycling, and we pool our resources

to go against these other materials, I think we could get somewhere. And I agree. And I think the other part of your discussion. That really, I'd say resonated with me because I talked to a lot of recyclers and the biggest concern they have is where's the demand? Yeah. What's the long -term viability of me investing in recycling? So you had some interesting thoughts on it. So I'm curious if you want to just kind of break

down like where your head's at when it comes to markets and demand. So I'm a demand hawk. I mean, I've been all about demand since we got into this business. In the paper business, my history was primarily in the paper business. And in the paper business, we had long -term contracts, 20, 25 -year contracts. We had paper mills co -investing in our recycling facilities. Why? Because they needed the product. Right. And yeah, because they were under pressure before

plastics was. Yeah. And so and it made economic sense. And so the drill was not where the hell am I going to move this material? The drill was how do I get more right? How do I get creative? So so demand drives recovery. And in the in the cardboard business, because we had these very large contracts that we had to meet volume goals on, we went out and started recovering cardboard. We. We created a commercial single stream front loader routes where we were servicing businesses

that were never able to recycle before. You know, putting eight yard containers behind Dollar General stores and, you know, fast food places and schools and things like that where they could put all of their recycling into one bin. But the majority of that was cardboard. So, you know, we went from when I started, I think my company at that time was called QRS. I started in St. Louis. We did about 1400 tons. of cardboard a month. When we sold it to Republic, we were doing 11 ,000 tons because the market pulled the creativity,

right? So demand will pull creativity. So, you know, what I like to tell people is that, you know, we don't need, you know, financial support and grants and things like that. We need long -term contracts. With that long -term contract, you can then go to your bank and you can say, I have this contract, guaranteed sales. I need to build this in order to recover the material. So the impetus does not exist to mine the post

-consumer waste stream. We know the plastic is there because we know how much virgin is being produced. But the economic impetus does not exist. The economic motivation does not exist to mine that product. You look to take a farmer. A farmer's not going to plant a crop and harvest a crop that he can't sell, that they can't sell, right? It's just common sense. Recycling is the same way. So demand has to pull recovery. Recovery cannot push. Supply cannot push demand. It doesn't work that way. Demand has to pull supply. And

when we get those long -term contracts, again, if you can just imagine how much recovery would be unlocked with, say, long -term contracts. filling molders that were making this pooling pallet, for example. Yeah. You can imagine how much of the entrepreneurial spirit would be unleashed to go figure out ways. I would be trying to find a way to collect stuff. Everybody would. I mean, everybody would be figuring out bigger and better ways of mining the waste stream to get the polyethylene and the low -density polyethylene, the polypropylene that's needed to fill this demand. Yeah. So,

you know, I mean, I've been on this demand. You know, I had a breakfast before the Bear Locker, before my presentation at Bear Locker, with a friend of mine at APR, Steve Alexander. And, yeah, I've been on the APR board. I've been very involved with APR. And I think APR does a lot of great work. Association of Plastic Recyclers. Association of Plastic Recyclers, right. And Steve and I were talking about this, and he's like, you know, because I've been on them for a long time, saying you guys are focusing way

too much on supply. And not on demand. Agreed. And Steve's like, you know what? You're right. As much as I hate to admit it, you're right. And we need to focus more on demand. And they're doing that. Yeah. Right. That was his speech the day before was all about demand. All about demand. Right. And so, I mean, it's foundational. Right. If you do not have the foundation of demand, you do not have an industry. You don't have a business. Yeah. So we got to find those demand. We have to find that demand. And now you've got

EPR. in seven states and potentially growing. And that's, I think, inordinately focused on collection. Well, states are starting to figure out where's this going to go, right? If it was focused on demand, collection would have a way of taking care of itself to fill that demand. So the issue though, because I agree with you, let me start off with that. If we were to tell the legislators, You're focusing on the wrong

side of the equation with EPR. You know what they're going to do? The wrong way. They're going to make it for packaging. They're going to say packaging needs to have a certain percentage of recycling. And as you know, that's just going to make everything more expensive right now specifically and probably even for the foreseeable future. So how do we get in front of these people that are making these regulations and then talk about the infrastructure piece? How do we get this? to be something that is, it's an okay conversation

to have because even the NGOs still don't like plastics. They want plastics gone and they don't like the idea of us recycling it into a durable good, even though you and I both just agreed that that's the right thing to do. Like, how do we change that narrative? Like, how do we get people to be on board? I mean, you know, I think it starts with education. So I think that we have to be willing to do things like this. We have to be willing to get the message out there. We have to be able to speak intelligently

with facts about why downcycling is a myth, why it's damaging to the cause. We got to be able to speak intelligently about the realities of what's possible. Okay. You know, you're not going to turn. a yogurt cup back into a white yogurt cup. It's not going to happen. So what else could be used, right? Even if it was said in a way that like, look, maybe you guys want to look

at this as an interim solution, but we have to generate demand now based on what's possible, okay? So it's not even that maybe the economics don't work. It may not even be possible, right? yeah so so you know we've got to educate we we have to actively seek these legislators out we've got to get on their calendar we have to sit in front of them and we have to know what we're talking about right we can't we can't come in

half cocked and and you know start start throwing accusations around or start you know speaking emotionally We just have to do it from a business perspective. We got to get them to understand that if they embrace this, they can become their own engine of circularity. Take the interstates, for example, right? The interstate is just a massive maintenance project, as we all know. It's a continuous maintenance project, okay? Well, what can we use in that continuous maintenance

of the interstates, for example, made out of post -consumer plastics? The states have... They have control of that budget, right? State procurement regulations, you know, they have control of that budget. So I think it's education. I think that it is discussions. It is getting beyond, you know, the greenwashing. It's getting beyond the vilification of plastics. And I think that's probably the best. And it's making products that

do actually work. Yeah. And work better. And work better. Yeah. so yeah you know i mean we look at four pillars with products that we need to get behind you know one is is that uh they need to be better so we we call that stronger all right they need to be able to deliver a positive bottom line impact so we call that strategic we got to be stronger they need to be strategic they need to be better for the environment we call that sustainable and they need to be able to be done at a volume that can move the needle

so we call that scale So those four S's, stronger, strategic, sustainable, and scale. Those are the products that we should be talking about. I had somebody that wanted to talk to me about using recycled plastic in pickleballs. Like, yeah, you know what? I don't know. The more old people play pickleball, that might scale pretty quick. It's like, man, I mean, come on. But that is, to your point, it's a small thing. But you're not going to make a stronger product. It's not

going to be stronger. It's not going to be strategic from an economic standpoint. It might be more sustainable and it's not really done at scale. So, I mean, we can use those four pillars as a litmus test and maybe we can get by with three out of the four. But, you know, I think that when we're hitting a home run, it's going to be all four work. Now, I will admit that that's strategic. The reason I call it strategic is because it might be more expensive up front. but you have to look at it from a lifecycle standpoint,

right? I mean, if somebody's replacing a guardrail post every 15 years, and if you put a composite one in there, it can last 50. Well, you know, do the math. Just extrapolate. Right. It's got to be strategic. But I think that's what we have to do. I typically give everybody that comes on just... Couple minutes at the end, talk about whatever else we haven't covered today, things that you're really interested in, things that you want people to know that we maybe not have covered. So floor is yours, whatever you want

to talk about. Yeah, so I've been thinking a lot about EPR lately, you know, and I've been thinking a lot about the fact that there's money going into this system, right? And so, you know, we have these PROs out there and then we have the legislatures. And so I think it goes back to that piece. Okay, so we have this pool of money. Everybody involved in that has a fiduciary responsibility to wear that. That can be used in its most effective means. So I think that we have to really consider using portions of that money to stimulate demand, right? And that

can be done through, obviously, capital expenditures or grants for CapEx. But I think that we might want to consider, can it be used to bridge that gap between maybe plastics that are more expensive up front, but are going to deliver some type of a life cycle economic value. I don't know what that financial mechanism is at this point, but I think that that discussion needs to start, right? Can we help these companies with that

initial investment and then maybe recoup that investment from them over time? I think that that's because there's a pool of money. And if we're just putting that pool of money, focus mainly on recovery, again, we're not going to, supply is not going to push our way into demand. Demand has to pull that. I completely agree. I mean, I don't love the word subsidy, but I think that some form of a subsidy. Right. I mean, when you look at how much money goes to the wood

industry, you look at how much money goes to the virgin production, right? And government subsidies. We need to get some of that on the post -consumer plastic side focused on demand. I think that's kind of what's been on my mind lately. So if you talk to any legislators, and I do that a lot, and it can be painful, but for the most part, they assume that if you collect it, people will come. And their understanding is not enough plastics or anything is collected,

and that's why it's not getting recycled. They don't even think about the downstream. But, I mean, you can look at the EU right now and all the reclamers that are shutting down. And what we can look at, you know, we often look at Europe and we think that they have it figured out. The reality is that they don't. And it's a bit of a warning is that, you know, if you incentivize collection and processing without having incentivized demand first. then you're just going to be putting,

you know, good money after bad. Yeah. And then you're just going to be collecting more material that's going to be shipped to the landfill. Yeah, like let's say, I mean, I think polypropylene bales are selling for five cents a pound right now. I think colored polypropylene bales are selling for like two or three cents a pound. Yeah. So what happens if we double that collection? So now what, they're selling for a penny a pound? Half a cent, yeah. There's nowhere for the material to go. Yeah. Right. So, I mean, they really shouldn't even think about collection until we handle the

demand piece. Agreed. You know, because the demand will catch, the supply will catch up, but it's got to be pulled by demand. So, yeah, I think that we just, we really need to think about this smartly. You know, there isn't a, I call it an American solution to a global problem. I mean, capitalism can be very painful, but ultimately. it creates a solution that is economically sustainable. So when we think about sustainability, it not only needs to be environmentally friendly, it

needs to be economically friendly. Or it's just, you know, all of a sudden, you know, all of a sudden Republicans get in power or whatever and all that stuff maybe goes away. So it has to be sustainable environmentally and economically. Agreed. And I'm going to reiterate what I said to you when I met you in person. Absolutely loved what you had to say there. I completely agree with everything you've said today. And I think that your point about we need to communicate

this better. Everybody in the plastics industry has the ability to talk to their local legislators. They have the ability to talk about the demand side, specifically if you're in recycling. You should be talking about this to anybody that will listen. We need more demand. And we're not going to solve the problem until we have these conversations. Realistic demand. But I know you had a hard stop, but I really appreciate you coming on. This has been a great conversation. Greg Jansen, Triton Ties for Justin Riney. This

has been the Redefining Plastics podcast. Thank you so much. Thank you, Justin. I appreciate the opportunity. You want to learn more about the plastics industry, recycling, check out these other videos. Please like and subscribe.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Scaling Dissolution for Food-Contact Recycled Polypropylene with IPL Schoeller and PureCycle

    Nov 3, 202629 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney sat down with Melissa Vettleson (Sustainability and Materials Engineer at IPL Schoeller) and Christian Bruey (Director of Sustainability and External Affairs at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Are Plastics Sustainable? with Patrick Krieger of the PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 27, 202632 minAudio

    Justin Riney hosts Patrick Krieger, who is the Senior Vice President of Sustainability and Policy at the PLASTICS Industry Association. In this conversation, they dive deep into sustainability, plastics, and creating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Recycling Collaboration, EPR, and Building End Markets with PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 20, 202630 minAudio

    This was the third episode recorded at the National Plastics Conference (NPC), and the NPC Live podcast studio onsite. Thanks again to PLASTICS for having Redefining Plastics at the conference and all of their support....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. NAPCOR’s PET Bottle Decarbonization Roadmap with Husky’s Jolene Milne (NPC Live)

    Oct 6, 202624 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney speaks with Jolene Milne, a sustainability analyst at Husky Technologies and member of NAPCOR, about industry collaboration to combat misinformation about plastics and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EPR, Data Gaps, and Change Management with Christine Yeager at National Plastics Conference Live

    Sep 23, 202632 minAudio

    We had a blast with this interview at the National Plastics Conference on-site podcast studio, "National Plastics Conference Live." Christine Yeager of CSY Impact dove deep into extended producer responsibility (EPR),...

    Credit the people on this episode