Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Redefining Plastics

Redefining Plastics artwork

Reaching the Lost with Dr. Chris DeArmitt of Phantom Plastics

Nov 14, 202448 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Dr. Chris DeArmitt and I talk about the lonely nature of battling with plastic detractors online, and what the industry needs to do to the change hearts and minds of consumers. Dr. DeArmitt has made it his personal mission to speak truths about plastics and was a major inspiration for this podcast. #truth #plastics #plasticstreaty #sustainability #recycling #climatechange #recyclability #podcast #science phantomplastics.com Founder of the Plastics Research Council Scientist

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Thanks for having me on the show. I really appreciate it. It's rare these days that people want to hear facts because fiction is so much more exciting. When you make up fiction, you're free to do anything, right? You can say anything. The world's your oyster. When you're talking facts, it's a lot more work to go and make sure that you're right and present the evidence and it's not as glamorous. Not many media outlets will actually cover facts because it's not as lucrative as covering fiction. I'm especially appreciative of the chance to show some science. Yeah. And as you can tell here, we've, we've been having a conversation

and I figured might as well hit record, uh, because there was a lot of good stuff going back and forth there. Some probably not for public airing, but, uh, the most part all good. But, uh, my name's Justin Riney. This is redefining plastics with me today. Most people, if you're on LinkedIn, you know who this guy is. This is Dr. Chris De Armitt. He is a warrior for plastics and been an inspiration to me. One of the main inspirations why I'm doing this podcast is he's been out fighting

with the internet trolls and NGOs, really anybody who's going to listen about plastics. Why plastics? And it's been really, really nice to see somebody speaking scientifically and directly. to all of the anti -plastic movement. So Chris, thanks for joining. Really appreciate your time today. Yeah. Like I said, thanks for having me on the show. Let's get some facts out there. Yeah. Actually, pro -plastic, as you know, Justin, I'm just pro

-fact. So I don't mind if people hate plastics, but as long as I hate them based on something that's actually true. The problem now is people hate plastics for things that are not true at all. And that's what bugs me as a scientist. Yeah. Yeah. So tell us about your work at Phantom Plastics. Yeah, that's one thing people don't get. They think I'm this professional lobbyist or something, and I'm not. My actual job is being a scientist. I've done that my whole career. I work in materials, mineral fillers, reinforcements, plastics, and some of the world's biggest companies

come to me when they have some kind of technical problem and I'm a good problem solver. I've got patents and all of that stuff. So that's my career as a plastic person, well, scientist, let's say, and I'm independent. If you look at my percentage of income, because everyone's always interested in that, from the plastics industry, according to NAICS code, it's actually zero. So there's no plastic manufacturers who are paying me. And that's my regular job. And then this whole environmental thing only sprang up, as you know, Justin, because

my kids came home from school, my two daughters, and they've been told stuff that was just outright lies by their teachers. And that infuriated me. I thought, how are we going to have a good future if we teach our kids nonsense? And I mean, we're here with insane property taxes in a nice area, especially for the good school district. And then to find out that my kids are being taught nonsense. That was just more than I could bear. So I went on a bit of a crusade and read four or 5 ,000 studies now to go and find the truth. Did it unpaid, as you know, it's a hobby. I did it. And then I shared it for free. So that's

where we are today. I appear to be the world's number one expert only because no one else is that stupid to read four or 5 ,000. Well, that, I think reading all of the studies and fighting with the internet trolls, I think you have to be a little crazy to do both of those things. And I think you and I are both cut from the same cloth there. Yeah. There's a bit of Don Quixote going on. Exactly. Exactly. So, I just saw recently that your book, The Plastics Paradox is now in

Spanish as well, correct? It's just recently published. Yes, that's the amazing thing. I'm actually writing the new edition of the book, so that's a breaking story and that's going well. The funny thing about the book was I don't actually care about waste or litter or life cycle studies. It's really boring stuff, but I do care about truth and the only way to solve a problem is to know all the science. So I went off and read studies on all of those topics. That was about 400 studies and to learn about things I didn't actually care about just to cover the whole topic and understand really what's going on. And then

when I finished, I was exhausted. I was convinced nobody would read the book and the exact opposite happened. People started reading it and then asking me to translate it to their languages. I'm like, I'm exhausted. I've spent enough of my own time and money on this stupid book. I'm sick of the sight of it. And now you're telling me to translate it. So I basically told them to get lost and I, or at least I wasn't going to do it. So now it's available in five different languages because people have gone on their own spare time and translated it themselves. And then I got other people to volunteer too. change it into a book. So I'm kind of surprised and

honored that people thought it was that valuable that they wanted to themselves translate it. So I think I saw on your website too that the book is free if people ask for it. Is that how that works? Yeah, it's free in all languages and there's no mailing list. You know how people want you to put in your name and your email address. It's a terrible marketing for me. I should have tens of thousands of people in a mailing list. I don't even have a mailing list. All I have is my inbox. So those are the people who've mailed me and that's all I know. So the book is free. You just click the flag that corresponds to your language at phantomplastics .com or at plasticparadox

.com. I think it may be only the English one at Plastic Paradox, but Phantom Plastics, you can just click the button and get the PDF. And so you and I, like we mentioned, are on similar crusades to kind of change the narrative around plastics, the why for plastics and kind of defend the materials honor, not because we're making a ton of money in plastics, but because it's the right thing to do. And it's, like you said, scientifically proven to be the best option.

And you've got a new venture that was just announced, the Plastics Research Council. Can you tell us a little bit about that, the non -profit organization, and kind of what you're going to be doing with that? Yeah. So I've been doing the silly crusade on my own for years now, five years. Two people came up to me at ink for that was in Ottawa where people were talking about This plastic pollution and so forth. It's not actually pollution But anyway, they're talking about it and two people came up to me of all of those people who had been following me and Said we want to fund a

proper Effort to get the facts out because I have all this bit all the data but it's just me in my spare time as I said I've been working for five years unfunded in my spare time was juggling with my real job and You can't do that properly i mean these people that were up against they are literally got millions and millions in funding if you look at who's member of some of these organizations they're just marketing people don't even have a scientist in many cases. They're just out there paid millions to spread misinformation about plastics and we know who's paying them to cause a lot of those public record.

And so when you go up against people well funded and professional marketing people you have to have some money and some professional marketing people so the idea behind the plastics research council was. To have some funds to pay a professional marketer or marketers to get the facts out better than i can do on my own to massage the message to be more patient than i can be i'm a scientist like here the facts deal with them yeah right so and that's richard dawkins kind of approach but it doesn't work with everyone. So that's the idea behind it and nobody's taking a salary

in case any all these other NGOs are all getting fat off of donations and telling more birds. Where is we're doing it all for free and i'm really honored to have such a world class team of independent scientists as professors from all around the world not just plastic particles and catalysis and chemistry. We got a toxicologist got a life cycle analysis expert so i'm really honored to have a team of world class scientists who are behind this message i've seen the science and seen the source of all checks out. Can i like to thank all of those people on the websites

of plastics research council dot com. And at the moment we're in this phase where people have asked me to do it. We've got a great team and we're just waiting for donations to come in to get to the point where we can really make an impact. Awesome. I look forward to supporting that effort. I think anything we can do to support your good work, I'm all for. So I think the next section of this conversation is kind of the meat of what I wanted to talk about. And I'm calling this Reaching the Lost. regarding the plastics

narrative. So this idea that you're an evangelist, right? You're a plastics evangelist, whether you want it to be or not, at this point, that's kind of what you're known for on the internet anyway. And so I wanted to kind of talk a little bit about how you got there and what you're doing. So your work on LinkedIn, it was a major inspiration for this podcast, like I said. How do you get the energy to fight these battles? With people

that are not receptive, I think is the easy way to put it, and they're scientifically illiterate, but they are very vocal about their beliefs. How do you deal with that? Yeah. Well, there's a number of things. You know the movie, The Blind Side, where they say he tasted 98 % positive for protective instincts. So we all have certain things that we're... Stronger in and less strong in, and I'm a crusader for truth. I mean, I say negative things about plastic. If plastic comes

out as the worst solution, I save that. And there's examples in the book. So that's what gives me the energy. We cannot make a better future based on things that aren't true. If you make decisions based on stuff that's not true, you end up making things worse for the most part. And that's exactly where we are now. So we have a lot of people who are utterly convinced of their opinions. And this is the funny part. There was a study by pew and it's in the new version of the book. So if you look up how much confidence do the public have in the media, right? It's really, really low. So this is a funny thing. And then

you ask them, well, where do your opinions on plastics come from? And like a hundred percent of their opinion comes from media articles and headlines, right? They've never read a single scientific study in their whole life. And this is the best bit, right? And then they tell me I'm wrong. And you're like, well, hang on a minute. One of us has never read a single study and the other one's a professional scientist. Who's read four thousand studies or five thousand studies unpaid and then shared it for free which one of us you think. You're more likely to be right not to not to say that the experts always right but. Is the person who's never read a single study really entitled to the arrogance the sheer

arrogance of these people the delusional idea that they have the answers on these topics when they've never actually checked any of the facts and they're relying on a source which they themselves don't believe it. That's the irony of the whole thing so. I don't know where I get the energy from, but it's probably, I'm a crusader for let's make a difference, let's make a better world. And so that's probably the driving force. I've written two books and both times I was really angry about something. That's usually a pretty good driver. I think emotion is a good driver for anything, right? So specifically our base

emotions, anger, love, happiness, whatever. I want to make a point on that exactly what the NGOs do they show us pictures of turtles and whales and they play on people's emotions to empty their pockets. And the other side of the emotion is. The time for emotion is after you know you're right if you engage your emotions too early you end up going really fast in the wrong direction and that's what i see people doing now. Some of the people who care the most are passionately going in exactly the wrong direction with their cotton bags and their paper bags for

example. So that's a real shame that the people who care the most are doing the most harm because they didn't check the facts before they before they engage their passion. And after time, they don't even know where to find the facts, right? I think that's that's a big deal. I think I've said this multiple times, not continue to say it. Our industry does a really bad job of talking about the benefits of our products. And I'm in the industry. I'm not an unpaid consultant like you. So I have to take the blame here. And the fact that we've just done a really bad job for

years talking about our products and the fact that they are a lower carbon footprint in 90 plus percent of applications. If you look at certain studies, we're not good at this. We have great marketers, but the marketers are great at marketing to converters and brands. They're not good at marketing to consumers, I think. And maybe that's unfair, but that's just kind of what I've seen. And we're jumping, you're right. I think it's like we go away. Everyone

asked me, why didn't they do something? I think, I think they all thought this isn't true or go away. And the other thing is I think that many of them thought that the trade associations, they pay millions and millions and millions of dollars to would do something. And to be fair, some of them are really good. Like I'll mention the PVC pipe association and the PPI and the EPS association. Those are three that really do a good job. Um, but there are, there's one, especially large. one, probably the one that gets the most money and is expected to do the most. And their board members and their members call me and say, why are they so pathetic? Why

are they not spending our money on what we're paying them to spend it? Can't you help them, Chris? They literally beg me to help these people. And it's ironic that I have the data, but they have the money and, uh, and these people literally get in front of Congress and have no answers. Um, it's, it's really sad to watch. So I think that's another aspect that, um, the people who were supposed to have done this job didn't take their job seriously. So we're jumping around a little bit, but like I said, I want this to be conversational. So I'm 100 % on board with just wherever the conversation takes us. So we

talked a little bit about the emotion that's kind of driving this conversation. So it's an emotional conversation and a scientific one. The doctored photos, I know you've done many posts and you've got an article out there on your website that talks about the doctored photos. of the sea turtles and eating the bags and then the EPS cup. And the fact is that that artist was very clear that that was a doctored picture

to show the connection between plastic waste and the sea turtles, which you rightly point out plastic waste is not really packaging when you look at the large majority of it, which It's great that you're pushing that out there. But this has almost become part of the collective consciousness now and where people think sea turtle, they immediately think plastic waste. And there's a ton of emotions with that. Can

we really use facts and science to combat that? Or do we have to do kind of what you're doing with the Plastics Research Council? Hit more at the emotional strings rather than just facts. Well i guess it's as you know we're talking about reaching the consumer in the consumers not one personality is not one kind of person so. My experience is the number of people you can reach with my approach which are here the facts if you really care please look at them that's about two or three percent of people. And i heard it is a famous quote from the. George burn it sure

he said. 2 % of people think 3 % of people think they think and the other 95 % would rather die than think and that is exactly what I experience every day Most people claim to be passionate, but they won't even spend three minutes to look at evidence They're just so sure based on nothing and that's that's a shame So you're up the answer is we definitely do need a varied approach because we're trying to reach a broad array of different people And my approach is not that effective. It's like here are the facts. Please please take a look and Not many people that logical it takes

a lot of mental energy to overcome your pre existing opinion and that's why the plastic industry is made a huge mistake as a thing called the. The illusory truth effect so they scientifically proven that if somebody lies to you enough times the lie becomes the truth it sounds like it's true even though it isn't no matter how smart you are doesn't protect you. Can we allow that to happen without five or ten years of just lie up to lie up to lie pictures of turtles with bags which don't exist there's a photo shop two hundred percent of the photo shop. And yet this is what people equate some plastics and bags

with when if you were worried about turtles just to put in the fact here. I'm the latest scoop of what's in the gyro it was point zero three percent. Cups and bags and straws zero bags one straw and a couple of bottles. And the other 99 % was fishing gear, which actually entangles turtles and whales and does harm to animals. And what are we proposing to ban and regulate? We're talking about the bags, which there was zero of, one straw and a couple of bottles, which have never caused any harm to anything in any study I've seen. Whereas the nets, which are

99 % and do cause proven harm, and we're ignoring those. There's literally thousands of people flying to South Korea to talk about The straw on the bag that doesn't exist and totally ignore the thing that is causing a problem the 99 % and that's the kind of thing that drives me nuts as a scientist if you're gonna make a difference You know spend three minutes to look at the science and make sure that you're focused on the right stuff I always want to get a cartoon made of a guy smoking a cigarette and his house is burning down and the fire brigade comes in and Puts out his cigarette because that's the problem right

and ignores the house and you're like no no the fire is over there And I'm not trying to distract people away from the plastics thing, because there is plastic in the ocean. It shouldn't be there. But for goodness sakes, if we're going to make laws and spend money and spend time and fly around the world, thousands of people to go into South Korea, let's actually make a strike for justice and focus on something that matters. Yeah. So we talked a little bit about this, but who do you feel like your actual target audience is on LinkedIn? Are you going direct to the consumer? Are you trying to talk to legislators? Who exactly

are you really driving it. I don't know. I've never thought about it. That's how rubbish I am as a marketer. So I am somebody who thinks that as a scientist, my job is done if I've put good science out there. And I want to be clear. People say, hey, this is this is Chris's stuff. None of this is mine. This is four or five thousand studies from other people. Not one of them is mine. All I'm doing is quoting word for word what the science says, literally copied and pasted with no speed and with a pretty picture so people don't fall asleep. And that's it. So I don't

know who my audience is, but I have, I have gathered a big following. I mean, I've reached hundreds of thousands of people on radio, on TV, through podcasts, through the book in five languages. And this has become like a second job for me. So it is reaching people, but I don't really know who the target demographic is. I guess it's anyone who's anyone who genuinely cares enough to spend three minutes looking at facts. That's my target audience. And it's a small one. Yeah. And I get that, right? Because for me, it's more

of an existential concern for plastics because I'm in the industry and this is my chosen profession. I love the industry. It's been great for me and I feel almost indebted to it to protect the future of it because I do think it's a great product. I think it's the best product for the applications that they're used for. So this is quickly turning from a crusade that I'm doing part -time to, there's a lot of people that want to talk about this. Just since I've done my first two podcasts,

I've had 20 different phone calls of people wanting to be on the podcast. I've had a bunch of different things. There's this pent up desire out there within the industry to fight back, but nobody's ever known how to do it. Or maybe they weren't crazy enough like us to actually do it. I feel like there are days where I'm getting through, I'm getting to the consumer, but I don't know if it's having a desired impact. How do you feel

about your efforts? Do you feel like it's having the desired effect? I do have some insights there. First of all, it's wildly exceeded my expectations. Nobody knew about or read my first book. A few people did, including the CTO of Procter and Gamble, and she loved it, and Cathy Fish, and other people. The president of covest row at the time i read it so but i didn't think anyone would read this one and. It's ended up making a really big impact so i'm one of the one of things i'll say is that. Large corporations like

yours are handcuffed they're full of politicians and lawyers who will make sure you never say anything and that's one of the reasons that the plastic industry hasn't. Managed to get the message across you got a hundred people telling you what not to do in a big corporation that's why i'm not in a big corporation. And so that leads onto two things. How am I bold enough to say the things I do? And A, because they're right. And B, because I don't have anyone to tell me not to like you do. And another thing that that leads onto who is the most effective at fighting this battle. And I'll tell you who it is. It's family owned

companies, privately held companies, because these are the only companies I see. And I'm not talking about small companies. The companies that have done the most in this area are companies that are. Let's say five, one to $5 billion a year in revenue. And who say hey this is right let's do it because it's right they don't ask anyone they click a button they make a donation. I know companies that have printed thousands of copies of my book for free right and just give them out in different languages. I went to one company where all the offices were full

of copies of my book in five different languages that they gave to you know politicians and reporters anyone who would listen. So there are people out there doing it but it's not the really big companies because their hands are tied. And, uh, it's the smaller ones. So maybe some of these big companies can donate to the plastics council, plastics research council, um, as a way of having somebody who is allowed to talk, do the speaking for them. We'll see if that happens or not. Yeah. I could not agree more on the smaller. And when you say small, you think, like you said, like

a real small business, we're talking the one to 5 billion range, the converters, the plastic converters, the family on businesses. There's one that comes to mind. I'm not going to throw the name out there because I don't know if they're going to like me doing that. But we just started the Polystyrene Recycling Alliance that's going to be focused on expanding polystyrene recycling in the Americas, specifically because we're under a lot of threat. We talked a little bit there about the Global Plastics Treaty and we'll get more into that because I know we both don't like

that effort at all. But there are a couple smaller family businesses in that organization that are truly living this out. They are fighting and they are evangelists like us because they don't have the overseer. And I think you'll notice whenever you listen to any one of my podcasts, videos online, anything like that, I will never mention who I work with. That is the one thing that I do. I want to make sure that I keep that separate. I think anybody can look and see who

I work for, but this is my opinion and not theirs. And I feel empowered enough to be able to say what the truth is and to try to expand your reach, right? Because I think what you're saying is important and I want other people to hear it. Well, let's say some things about expanded polystyrene because I've done a deep dive into that and I've met some of the companies. I'm not forbidden from talking about company. So Atlas molding, Atlas roofing, for example, is one of the ones that I'm really impressed with because they're

really out there. They have an incredible amount of recycled material and they've been doing it for years and years. So it makes their blood boil when people say it's not recyclable and the expanded polystyrene association as well. I mean, it is recyclable and it is recycled in huge amounts. So that's one thing to say. Another one is when you look at life cycle studies, which is the only way to know what causes more impact or less impact. For plastic packaging, plastic comes out as the least impact solution in 93 % of cases studied. So you can be against plastic if you want to, but that means four times more

waste, three times more CO2, and two times more fossil fuel used. If you think that's a wise choice, then you go right ahead and do it. I don't mind. But do it knowing that that's the consequence of your action. When it comes to people who don't have a life cycle study in front of them, the easiest way to know what's greenest is to just see what weighs the most. When you can do the job with less material that means it's usually greener because there's nothing there and if you look at the polystyrene is ninety eight percent air is only two percent material. And this is the problem with the p .s. it's too efficient you see a giant block of material and

you think wow look at all of that waste or all of that literal or all that potential pollution that could get out into the environment but it's only like. Tiny tiny amount of actual material and so it's like an optical illusions like david copperfield is. Fool you into thinking that this is giant piece of polystyrene when you're really looking at a block of air with a tiny bit of plastic holding it together. And so that's it that's the second thing to be aware of it's often the greenest solution because of that it's hardly anything there because it saves heat and weight during transportation so it ends up being net

negative for impact because it's saving so much heat and weight. Compared to other materials and the other thing people don't realize is. polystyrene actually does degrade and biodegrade so they think it lasts forever in the environment and that's wrong to study after study after study showing insects for example converting polystyrene into co2 and water just like a leaf would. So again this is another area where the facts are on the side of that particular material has been well studied for decades and not one single person knows about it. Yeah, and I completely agree

that Atlas and the EPSIA in general, so Betsy at the EPSIA, she is also an evangelist for plastics and a very good one at that. I've got a ton of respect for that group. But yeah, even rigid polystyrene, it allows you to make these products thinner and lighter than even other polymers. And then specifically, More than paper and metal or whatever else you're going to replace it with.

So banning those products is counterintuitive, right? It's not scientific. It is not logical. It is emotional. And that's the biggest struggle that I have on a day to day basis. How do I get through to the people that only think emotionally? And the bad thing is that's most of the legislators that I deal with. I talk to a lot of legislators and They are listening to the emotional outcry of a small portion of their constituents. And

that's what's driving this conversation. So how do you think we can get through to those folks to show that plastics are actually needed to decarbonize? If you want to hit your climate goals, you probably need more plastics. How do we get that message to you? There's a couple of things to say there. So one company, a privately held company in the revenue range that I mentioned and said, okay, I've had enough of this. I'm going to fund sending a copy of your book signed to every member of Congress. And that's happened. Right. So that's a start. And then another company

said, Hey, let's do the same for the Canadian government. So those books went, I signed 535 copies in a weekend. Um, and then I signed another a hundred and something for the Canadian government just last weekend. So this, that's one thing we can do. Companies can. get out there and at least make sure who knows if these people can read right i'm not a big fan of politician or if they will read it i think is the other exactly i'm sure they'll have the cleaning lady read it for them or something but anyway. We're trying to make an effort trying to at least give them a chance to see some facts and this is the danger of lying to the public right because if you lie

to the public they buy stuff that increases harm and they vote for stuff that makes things worse. And the politicians, let's face it, they're going to be tempted to just do whatever the public ask them for. And that's the point I make in the first edition of the book and it will be in the second one too. That's the danger of letting lies spread. We end up making things worse and instead of better. And there's a big misconception as well that people think that this is a new area. It hasn't been studied. We don't have the solutions. And that's what the second edition of the book is about. It's going to show that we do have decades of studies and we do have the solutions that work. It's just that people

aren't doing them right now. They're instead talking. They have huge meetings with tons of people and none of those people have the facts in front of them. Yeah. I've been involved in many NGO meetings and it becomes very clear very quickly that there's not a single scientist in the bunch. And a lot of them are making very impactful decisions and statements that a lot of people listen to. There are certain NGOs, I think, I don't want to throw any of them specifically out there because I'm not looking to get sued this week, but I think you can think of who I

might be speaking about, but those people will say very demonstratively that microplastics are killing us, that plastic pollution is clogging the ocean. And you rightly point out that plastics are only 1 % of the materials that we're using. So why do you think these environmental NGOs are so focused on plastics? Well, just look at their pocketbooks. Look at their bank accounts.

And for example, it's very hard to prove when somebody's motives are what you think they are or to work out what their motives really are. But we don't have to prove it because literally the former president of Greenpeace left, these two books are behind me. He literally said these people gave up on the environment decades ago and now they're just telling lies for donations, including the plastics lies. And the other ones have gone, hey, look how much money they make from it. Let's do the same. Because the stuff they say just isn't true and when they do say something that's proven to be false, they never take it back again. If somebody was genuinely

virtuous and genuinely cared about the future, they would take back something that they'd said if it was proven to be wrong. Like more plastic than fish by 2050. That's been proven wrong again and again and again. Like we eat a credit card or plastic a week, it would take 20 ,000 years to eat a credit card or plastic according to the best independent study. But they've never withdrawn that either. So this is how we can tell. Or at least infer whether these people are genuine. Do they say things that are accurate? And when they're caught out saying something that wasn't right, do they correct the record? I've corrected my LinkedIn post before when I

got new or better data. I went meticulously through about a hundred posts because I got new data for the amount of the carbon dioxide created by plastics. And I went through to correct everything I'd ever said and update it in the new book. Didn't really make a difference, but still the number was was wrong. I wasn't happy with it and I wanted to be factually correct, but these people don't have any moral compass and they don't have any virtue and they don't have any desire to make the world a better place. And it's very apparent and other ones you don't even have to work it out because. For example, if you type in Michael Bloomberg beyond plastics,

he funds beyond coal. So he's a billionaire, right? If funds beyond coal, beyond petrochemicals, uh, beyond plastics is the latest one. And some other ones as well. And that's a matter of public record. He's out there proudly saying, I'm going to fund a group that attacks plastics. He's not saying I'm going to fund a group that helps the environment. I'm going to fund a group that's whose job it is to say bad things about plastics. Because they're a nonprofit, they can call any journalist they want and get airtime because the journalist assumes that they have the virtue, but they don't have the virtue. Their agenda is clear in the name. And there are other similar

organizations where the agenda and the solution is clear in the name, irrespective of the facts. And that's a problem too. You wonder if Mr. Bloomberg there has shorted Exxon, Chevron, and the others, and if he's trying to make a little extra money off of it. Well, the funny thing was I've got a LinkedIn post called Oops, because it's called Bloomberg's Blooper. So you can look that up. And the reason he said he's against plastic is he thinks that they're creating global warming

and that they're using fossil fuel. If you look at the data, plastics reduce fossil fuel and reduce greenhouse gas compared to other materials and on a net basis as well. If you count in how much lighter cars are, airplanes are lighter, trucks are lighter and insulating homes and preventing food waste. If you add that stuff together, plastics are net fossil fuel and CO2 negative. So that means this billionaire is so smart that he's spending millions of his money to fight against the very thing he believes in. And that's another example about people with insane amounts of,

I wish I was so rich that I could spend tens of millions of dollars fighting against myself. That'd be tremendous, but unfortunately I'm not in that position. And unfortunately, nobody's tapped Michael on the shoulder and said, Hey, you might want to check your facts before you act. Yeah. I don't think anybody's calling him out on it, right? There's nobody within the industry that's going to attack him. And that's the other thing that a lot of these conversations go out into a vacuum and they're unchecked and nobody is challenging them. at a high level, it's all just us grassroots out here fighting. I think

the Don Quixote, that's excellent. I'm going to use that from now on, tilting at windmills, just not getting anything. And windmills are nice and green too, so it's a nice analogy. Exactly. So we talked quite a bit already about the nature of plastics and the low carbon nature of plastics and how it actually is enabling decarbonization globally. And we also talked a bit about the

global plastics treaty. And so it has failed, right? It's failed to solve for climate change issues. If anything, it's going to increase climate issues. What do we think is going to happen? If these high ambition countries get their way and we actually see elimination lists and production caps what do you think the fallout for this will be. What is a couple things one is i was worried about that too and then a friend of mine who's very very smart said don't worry these people just push papers around and make declarations

and nobody follows them so don't don't panic chris because whatever these. Idiots decide in the clothes room whatever they sign it will never happen so that was kind of reassuring. But it is it is true i mean. The analogy i always like to think of analogies because science is boring for most people imagine you got five kids called paper plastic. What have you whatever cotton and wood or something and you decide to only punish the one who behaves the best. Right what kind of parent would you be and that's exactly what we're doing i'm not saying plastic so perfect no kid is perfect either but to only punish the

one that does the least harm is totally unjust and counterproductive and that's not how the world should work imagine you got another one is. Imagine you're a serial killer and a bank robber and a guy with a parking ticket in the dock at the court. And the court said, let's let the serial killer and the bank robber and all the other serious felons, we'll let them go and we'll punish this guy with a parking ticket and make an example of him. And that's exactly what's going on. It's not the plastics cause no harm. It's the idea of penalizing and making

more expensive the greenest option we have is just driving people to things which cause as i said for on average four times more waste three times more fossil fuel twice as much. Three sorry three times more carbon dioxide and two times more fossil fuel on average. Is is increasing harm in ninety three percent of cases so that's just dumb. That's what we're doing and the thing is imagine if i can come up with this on my own you can go to google right now typing lca for life cycle analysis bag. You would have a study from Clemson, which shows that plastic bags are

the greenest option. There's 30 studies in the world and they all agree. So I'm not talking about some hidden tome of knowledge here that nobody can find. The World Wildlife Fund could have found it if they wanted to. Greenpeace could have found it. Our governments could have found it. Why have our governments and all these other people with unlimited interns and our taxpayers' money has never occurred to them in 30 years to type LCA bag into the search bar in Google? I mean, this is really pathetic. It's just, uh, what's the word for it? Um, incompetence. Yeah. Negligence. Negligence is probably a great word

for it. So I've, I've had many a conversation with NGOs, uh, we'll call them, uh, grocery brands and different things. And I invariably will come back to carbon footprint, LCAs, and they push back and say, well, that's only part of the story. Well, what other part of the story do we need to talk about? Are we trying to decarbonize or not? Yes, we have problems with waste in this world, but it's not just plastics. Everything

is litter. And that's the part that I don't think is quite getting through to them because nobody's putting any exposés out there about hands that are dumped into the waterways because they're sinking to the bottom and nobody sees them. And everybody can see the plastic floating on the top. So it kind of puts a bullseye on us. So with that in mind, it's actually good because the plastic being on top means the sun gets to it and the bacteria it degrades faster than the other materials which sink. Well, that's helpful for my argumentation going forward because I

haven't used that one. But with all of this in mind and this idea that there's a plastic waste crisis, what can society do to better handle the plastic waste issues? I know you said earlier that that's not really your domain that you focus a lot on, but I've seen Several things that you've thrown out there for ideas on how to solve that. And, and I think they're great. I just wanted to give you an opportunity and talk through that. Oh, thanks. So, well, let's start with the supermarket.

You might have to remind me of the second part of the question. The supermarket people, they actually into, cause I thought how dumb are these executives who are replacing plastic with paper? They're always like, we replaced a hundred tons of plastic. I diverted this amount of material from the landfill. No, you didn't. That stuff's not getting recycled either. Exactly, exactly. So anyway, I thought how dumb are these executives? They can't be that dumb. So they interviewed these supermarket executives and they said, oh yeah, we know that it increases harm to replace plastic, but we do it because our consumers want it. And there's a report on that literally saying

that. So that's where that's going. And what was the second part? Plastic waste. So yeah, 0 .4 % all waste and 13 % of what goes into a landfill according to the EPA. And the funny thing was that Landfill waste used to go up and up and up every year with population and wealth and then it went flat all of a sudden. And scientists are scratching their heads. Why did it go flat? It used to go up all the time. So they analyzed the data and found out that it's plastics that have made the amount of waste going to landfill stop going up all the time and plateau. They

call it a decoupling. And the reason is that on average, one pound of plastic replaces four pounds of other material like paper, metal or glass. So Although plastic was mushrooming, because it was starting from zero in the olden days and increasing rapidly, it was actually replacing far, far more other material and reducing materials, reducing impact and reducing waste. And that's the lesson that I'm pointing out in the second edition of my book, which is completely rewritten. It's not a rehash, it's from scratch. And that is saying that these NGOs only ever point out

one side of an equation. They say, How much co2 is created making plastic and they say oh it's the second percent of all co2 comes from making plastic and they never mention making cars lighter making planes lighter making trucks lighter preventing food waste and all the things where plastic reduces co2 so to know the net effect of something you have to know that the one side of the equation of positives and the negatives and you put them together and work out what's the net effect and they never do that they only talk about the negatives because that's what make people angry that's what make people donate and that's what make that's what enriches them. I go running all the

way to the bank based on these lies and misconceptions and so that's a big part of it is not to say raw plastic but it's intellectually dishonest to ignore the positives of something in equation and only talk about the negatives i wanted to know. Whether you were in debt or not and i said oh. Justin's got a thousand dollars on his credit card and you're like, yeah, but I got a hundred K in the bank. Whoa, whoa, whoa. We don't count. We don't count by a hundred K. We're only going to look at a thousand dollars of credit card debt. That would be really dumb and dishonest.

And that's not how maths works, but that's how NGOs work. Yeah. So I know you've talked a lot about, uh, fines for littering and, uh, I think you, you spent quite a bit of time talking about like redemption systems. Cause to me, The easiest way to solve any kind of plastic crisis or any kind of waste issue at all is you have to give Americans specifically a reason to do something. And really what drives Americans more than anything?

Money. So you have to have some sort of a redemption system or on the other side, a negative impact if you just toss this stuff out the side of your car. because really that's the only way you're going to solve this stuff. You have to incentivize because only 40, I think the most recent numbers I saw, and you can correct me if I'm wrong because you're the expert here, 43 % of Americans actually participate in recycling. And it's just adding to this issue because all of these NGOs for years

have said that this stuff doesn't work. Recycling doesn't work. It's all going to the landfill anyway. And to your point, Maybe that's not a bad thing. It's less than paper and less than glass. What do you think about just that thought process? How do we go about this? There's many things to tackle there. One is even the plastics companies are getting this wrong. I literally see Borealis, for example. It's a real nice polyolefin company. Squeaky clean plants. I visited them many years ago. You can eat your dinner off the

plants, the factories. Even they are out talking about plastic pollution. Scientists have proven that this pollution they're talking about is actually litter. And what happens is this, somebody drops a piece of litter here, it goes along a stream or gets blown somewhere. Somebody picks it up somewhere else and goes, oh, look, pollution. But it's just litter that move. Scientists have proven that. They call it the archaeologist study of where is this pollution coming from. And as soon as you realize that that pollution is the wrong word, we have to use the right word. Pollution is associated with big bad industries. They say

that Coca -Cola is the number one polluter, and that's a lie. And the courts have determined that's a lie, right? The judge said this is ridiculous claim. If some of their customers drop litter on the floor, that's not Coca -Cola's fault or PepsiCo's fault. That's a legal fact and a scientific fact. So once you realize that it's litter and it's down to human behavior, you have the solutions. And that's what the second edition of the book is about. Once you correctly diagnose the problem, it's litter, which is caused by people's behavior. So eighty one percent of it is dropped intentionally they literally watch the person drop it on purpose.

Whenever i say that i will how can you blame the person for the litter. Who else am i supposed to blame but you got a new garden drop a candy wrapper and blame the candy wrapper you have to be a you have to be a moron to do that i mean that's just so ridiculously unjust it's beyond words right and yet that's what people are claiming so that the courts luckily got that right and they also ruled that. Gun manufacturers can't be responsible if you buy one of their guns and go and shoot somebody with that's that's the act of the person we have to get that right because as soon as we do we know that solutions to let our education deposits as you mentioned and finds

that's what is proven to work. And we know that it's dropped intentionally we know that it's not really pollution so all the solutions are there and not one of these people having these discussions of flying around the world is aware of them and the ones who are aware of it are the people who are. Maybe not inclined to act upon it because they make a living from these perceived problems. Yeah. So we've been talking now for about 45 minutes and I know you're busy and I want to take up a ton more of your time, but I want you to be able to tell the audience

how they can get involved, how they can get involved in this fight, how they can make a positive difference and maybe how they can reach you, how best they can reach you. Yeah. That's the number one question I get after my keynote talks people are blown away to see the facts for the first time Plastics industry people are proud of their jobs again because at the moment they're ashamed of their jobs. They can't get new Undergraduates. Yeah, the amount of people that have told me hey you work for the plastics industry Isn't that like working for a big tobacco? No, no, no, no, not

even close in it. It's frustrating. But anyway, I'm sorry Yeah So the answer to your question is this, people don't want to read a lot. You need to have the facts, but only in the background, right? That's in the book. It's on the website. I've site hundreds of studies where you can click the link. It's all. So the thing to do is go to phantomplastics .com and click on the plastic and environment tab and the tab itself, not the dropdown thing. Just click on that. There's a one page summary with a video with a picture of some flamingos there. You'll know more than any of your friends about plastic and the environment. You can read the page in five minutes. You can see the video in 20 minutes and you will be an

expert. You will have the answers to Every aunt and uncle and grandma and teacher who asked you this and go out and get the facts and point them to the website that's the number one thing you can do that just that one page of people saw that. They wouldn't be doing stupid stuff that makes things worse to support me personally because i've done all this unpaid the only thing i do that is paid is when people pay to fly me somewhere. To go and give this talk in person because after all it's free in the book is free on the website is free and i think you want me to. leave my job and my family and come and talk to you, then

it has to cost money. So that's the only thing that's keeping me financially able to keep going as an individual. And then if you want to help market the message out, then that's the Plastics Research Council. That's where we're all working unpaid. We have a team of just fantastic experts in all subjects, and we want to be able to get marketing out. We need to get in front of the media. We need to get some commercials out there. We need to have somebody who can massage the message and reach the emotional people that I don't know how to reach. So those are the three ways you can help. Thanks for asking us a question.

What about any other parting comments? Any other topics you wanted to highlight today? Anything else going on in your world that you wanted to throw out there for the audience? I think that's it. I'm pretty excited about the new edition of the book. If anyone has any ideas of things you'd like to see covered, then write to me. Please make sure people are aware of my linkedin post make sure that people that you know are as afforded there so they can see the facts everything's well documented as i said. One thing i didn't

bring up earlier and because you were saying what can americans do what motivates people this is the sad truth about plastics in the environment they studied why are people talking about bags and straws which make no difference to the environment. The things you can do to actually help the environment are fly less drive less and eat less meat. Those are the three main things you can do. Nobody wants to do any of those things. So they talk about straws all day long. And that is the real problem here. People want to feel good about themselves. They want to feel virtuous. They want to look good to their friends, but they don't actually want to do what it takes to be

a good person. So if you're out there and you're listening, stop pretending to be good and actually be good. That's why it's happening. Virtue signaling in the US is at an all time high. over the last five years, and I don't see any signs of that slowing down. But anyway, Dr. Chris De Armitt, thank you so much today for the time. I really appreciate the conversation. Like I said earlier, I love your work. Keep on fighting. I'm going to try to support you in any way that I can.

And I'd love to at some point have you back on again, talk some more about all these topics. Looking forward to it. Thanks, Justin. All right. Thank you, sir. Thanks to the audience.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Scaling Dissolution for Food-Contact Recycled Polypropylene with IPL Schoeller and PureCycle

    Nov 3, 202629 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney sat down with Melissa Vettleson (Sustainability and Materials Engineer at IPL Schoeller) and Christian Bruey (Director of Sustainability and External Affairs at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Are Plastics Sustainable? with Patrick Krieger of the PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 27, 202632 minAudio

    Justin Riney hosts Patrick Krieger, who is the Senior Vice President of Sustainability and Policy at the PLASTICS Industry Association. In this conversation, they dive deep into sustainability, plastics, and creating...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Recycling Collaboration, EPR, and Building End Markets with PLASTICS Industry Association

    Oct 20, 202630 minAudio

    This was the third episode recorded at the National Plastics Conference (NPC), and the NPC Live podcast studio onsite. Thanks again to PLASTICS for having Redefining Plastics at the conference and all of their support....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. NAPCOR’s PET Bottle Decarbonization Roadmap with Husky’s Jolene Milne (NPC Live)

    Oct 6, 202624 minAudio

    At NPC Live, Redefining Plastics host Justin Riney speaks with Jolene Milne, a sustainability analyst at Husky Technologies and member of NAPCOR, about industry collaboration to combat misinformation about plastics and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EPR, Data Gaps, and Change Management with Christine Yeager at National Plastics Conference Live

    Sep 23, 202632 minAudio

    We had a blast with this interview at the National Plastics Conference on-site podcast studio, "National Plastics Conference Live." Christine Yeager of CSY Impact dove deep into extended producer responsibility (EPR),...

    Credit the people on this episode