Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Rebuild:LA

Rebuild:LA artwork

Rebuild:LA Episode 044: Saving History from Wildfire with Headwater Economics’ Ryan Handy

Sep 30, 202543 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail The Palisades and Eaton Fires destroyed a lot of history. Will Rogers’s ranch home, Pasadena Waldorf School, Robert Bridges House, The Bunny Museum, Andrew McNally House, Theater Palisades, and The Zane Gray Estate are just a few of the thousands of structures lost in the fires. They all were touchstones in the communities where they were located. What does their loss mean to the Pacific Palisades and Altadena? What could we have done to protect them? And what do we need to do to protect other historic landmarks that might be in the way of the next megafire? We talk to researcher and urban planner, Ryan Handy, of Headwater Economics, about her new research on saving history from wildfire in this episode of Rebuild:LA. Resources: Loss of the Grand Canyon Lodge Protecting Our Past: Wildfire Strategies for Historic Buildings Urban Conflagrations The Cost of Rebuilding The Cost to Retrofit Nevada City, CA Retrofit Program Headwaters Economics Podcast Relocating Historic Homes in Altadena Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00In my work with communities, you know, we'll spend a ton of time thinking about subdivisions and residential properties, new and relatively new, but will completely forget their historic structures, which for many communities make up their downtown core, you know, their their tourism magnet, the cornerstone of their economy, the thing that puts them on the map. And we just realized that we should not be overlooking these because they do not have the benefit of, you know, decades of science and firefighting experience.

SPEAKER_00They just don't have really what it takes to survive a wildfire or even a basic house fire, the way that you know the home that you live in, assuming it's new and the home I live in do.

SPEAKER_01You're listening to Rebuild LA, a production of My Safe LA. I'm Cameron Barrett, and that was Ryan Handy with the nonprofit research group, Headwaters Economics. They've just released a study on historic structures and wildfire. So many people in Los Angeles County know firsthand the devastation and loss a wildfire can bring to families and whole communities. Part of that loss is history, whether it's the personal history of a family home and the cherished things left behind, or it's the lost history of an entire town when the touchstones of that community, like historic structures and neighborhoods, are wiped out.

SPEAKER_01Often the most vulnerable structures in a wildfire are the historic ones. And the policies meant to preserve the history of those structures, in Handy's opinion, are actually what are making them so vulnerable. Don't worry, Headwaters Economics has a plan. And Ryan Handy lays it out for us. It's all next.

SPEAKER_01Ryan Handy from Headwater's Economics. Thank you so much for joining us on Rebuild LA. Thanks for having me. I'm so excited about having this conversation with you because where I grew up, historic structures were not that rare. I'm from New England, and so it was pretty common to have conversations with people about what they could and couldn't do if they were even trying to paint the exterior of their home. Because if it was listed as a historic structure, there were certain things they had to do. But out here, it seems in the West, like things get kind of flattened pretty quickly after only a few decades.

SPEAKER_01And so it's interesting that you have done at Headwaters a study on historic structures and how important they are to communities and how important it is to protect them. And I'm probably butchering what Headwaters Economics actually does. So why don't we back up and you tell us about your organization, your role there, and this really neat piece of research that you have just published about wildfires and historic structures.

SPEAKER_00So Headwaters Economics is a nonprofit based in Montana. We have offices in Bozeman and also Helena, which is important to mention because Helena, Montana State Capitol, has a beautiful historic district that dates from the late 19th century and it's tucked up against some very fire-prone foothills. Headwaters does a lot of work around reducing natural hazard risk, specifically with flooding and wildfire.

SPEAKER_00We also look at how both of these types of disasters affect outdoor recreation economies. Although we're based in Montana, we work all over the country. Currently, I'm working in Hawaii. We've also done work in the Southeast and the East Coast of the United States. My job specifically is with wildfire. I am the co-manager of a technical assistance program called Community Planning Assistance for Wildfire. And we offer free planning assistance for communities that are dealing with wildfire.

SPEAKER_00So, how do you think about where we live and how we build in terms of wildfire risk?

SPEAKER_01The research that was produced just recently, and we will link to that in our show notes, what kicks it right off is the loss of the Grand Canyon Lodge. This is not uncommon, is it? That we are losing extraordinary historic structures because our wildfire risk has increased so much here in the West.

SPEAKER_00That's I'm glad that you started with the Grand Canyon Lodge because that burning this summer in July was really a catalyst for this particular research we did on how to reduce wildfire risk to historic towns in the United States. And the loss of this lodge, you know, it burned in what was really a conflagration in July on the north rim of the Grand Canyon. And it really stunned, you know, the wildfire world, the historic preservation world, and also just, you know, American families who took their kids on vacations to this lodge and have pictures in front of it.

SPEAKER_00It is like so many famous structures we have across the United States in national parks. And it was just completely obliterated extremely quickly. And the thing about this lodge that is so common with historic structures in the United States is a lot of what made it distinctive and special probably likely contributed to its burning down. It had an iconic wooden exterior that was restored in the late 30s after it had burned down earlier in the 20th century.

SPEAKER_00And if you read through, you know, national historic preservation documents, a lot of the things that we celebrate it for, its rustic lodge feeling, are the kinds of things that we typically don't want in buildings in wildfire viscaries. And so when this lodge burned, my colleagues and I really started thinking about why do we treat historic properties differently when it comes to wildfire? I mean, obviously we know we treat them differently because we want to preserve them. And we have a long history in the United States of taking really strong measures to ensure that these properties survive in somewhat of their original character and sense.

SPEAKER_00But it's come to the point where what you do to preserve an historic building is the opposite of what you should do to protect it from wildfire.

SPEAKER_01Oh boy. You need to drill down on that one. Tell us what you mean by that.

SPEAKER_00Wow, the exact opposite. Okay, tell us. Well, so I actually to talk about this more in greater detail, I'm gonna take you to another community that I've been working with that was also really inspired me to do this work. And this community um is in the Sierra Nevadas in California, as with many California mountain towns, it has um sort of what they call motherlode architecture. So architecture that dates from the gold rush. They have beautiful Victorian buildings with lots of ornate, you know, scroll work and porches.

SPEAKER_00And part of maintaining the character of this town is preserving the architecture of in the past, which was wood. They had wood-shake shingles on their roofs, they have wood frame windows, they have wood porches, they have wooden siding. And a lot of these communities in these areas of California also have very high fire risk, but they're kind of caught in this tug of war between how do we preserve our historic integrity while also reducing our wildfire risk. But the way historic preservation works in the United States, communities are strongly encouraged to use the same materials in their historic buildings that would have been used, you know, 150 years ago.

SPEAKER_00And those materials were wood. Um, but in the modern, you know, California, in the modern United States, we know that using wood siding on buildings can dramatically increase the risk that they will burn to the ground in a wildfire. So for our new homes, many communities, particularly in California, where you are, ban the use of what we call combustible materials on houses. You cannot put wooden siding on your home in California if it's a new home. You cannot use cedar shake shingles on your roof.

SPEAKER_00But if you have an historic home, you can. And in a way that that doesn't really make much sense. Like if we want to preserve the history for future generations, we have to almost fortify these buildings even more because they're so vulnerable. They have, I guess, you know, weaknesses that the modern home in California wouldn't have.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I mean, the Bel Air fire way back in the early 60s here in Southern California is what made us start thinking really hard about wood shake shingles. And they've been banned for many, many years here. But the the homes, the historic structures that were lost in the Palisades and Eaton fires, and I'm just going to list them off because it's it's heartbreaking. Will Rogers Ranch Home, Pasadena Waldorf School, Robert Bridges House, the Bunny Museum, Andrew McNally House, Theater Palisades, the Zane Gray Estate, and there are many, many more.

SPEAKER_01And I know there were thousands of structures lost, but these this is history lost. How could we have protected them and still maintained their historic character?

SPEAKER_00And so I'm familiar on a high level with those structures, and I can't, you know, speculate about what caused each structure to burn down individually. And I just want to note that in a fire like what happened in LA and urban conflagration, that amount of wind speed with embers will destroy and can destroy almost pretty much any structure, whether it has stucco on the outside or wood. Um, but we do know from fires like what you saw in the Palisades, also like what we saw in Hawaii, and also the um the campfire um in paradise.

SPEAKER_01In paradise, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00That there are certain measures you can take that will probably dramatically increase the likelihood your home is going to survive. And so these include not having combustible material on the outside of your home. So no wooden deck, no wooden siding, a class A roof that's not made of wood. Also, there are minor changes to buildings that you can do and that gets into some like wonky building details like your vents and stuff like that. Also, having a solid buffer around your home can really increase the chances that it's going to survive.

SPEAKER_00So we're talking about, you know, having nothing, no plants, no furniture, no wood piles within five feet of your home. So our zone zero that everybody's up and arms about here in California, yeah. Right, exactly. Your zone zero. So these are all things we know to do with modern buildings. Um, but we don't do them with historic buildings. Um, it's very rare to have uh materials on a historic building changed to be something that was not originally a part of their construction. So even if you want to replace like a wooden siding on a historic building, most communities have regulations that require you to replace it with a similar material.

SPEAKER_00So, your question about how do we preserve these buildings without sacrificing our historic integrity. There are a few tricks to this. First of all, there are some really good materials on the market now that are not combustible, like wood, um, but they preserve the look and the feel of a wood panel. And I think this is important because how historic buildings look is really a big part of their contribution to the to like the built environment, as we call it, and like a community culture and sense of identity.

SPEAKER_00So, in my perspective and the research that I have done, embracing these materials that will reduce fire risk, but preserve the feel of historic building can go a long way to protect them. There are other things you can do, like you know, dealing with your your windows. You also can take basic steps to adjust the vents in these historic buildings that will have no visible impact, but could really prevent embers from getting inside the building. And another easy fix is you know, doing that that zone zero around an historic building.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01Okay. So you took us back to uh a place um that is at high risk in the Sierras. In fact, the way that you described it to me, all I could think of was your typical Hollywood Western set. Yeah. Just yeah, just that that perfect, very traditional look. And also uh bringing in our our conversation about all the historic structures that that were lost in the Palisades and Eaton fires. So you're saying that we can take these structures and we can retrofit them without losing their historic value.

SPEAKER_01So it's okay to bring in an asphalt tile and redo that roof as long as it looks like Cedar Shake.

SPEAKER_00Yes. That is absolutely that is absolutely okay. But in order for this to be okay, this change has to start with community regulations. Most communities uh regulate historic buildings with an historic preservation commission. They use their planning departments, and these are where these changes have to be acceptable and where they have to happen, which is pretty low, you know, granular, granular level.

SPEAKER_01So this is at the the the the local level. The state is not gonna come on down from high, or the federal uh uh government is not gonna come on, it's not gonna set these standards. We have at a community level have to set these standards?

SPEAKER_00So there is a federal role in this, and I'll get into that in a minute, but I have a good example of a community-level retrofit program that comes from California. It comes from one of the communities in the Sierras that looks like a Hollywood Western set. Um it's Nevada City, California, um, which is in Northern California, I believe. And they just passed a retrofit ordinance, which you may be familiar with in California, as you just mentioned. It's basically an ordinance that requires existing buildings to be brought up to current wildfire standards, since the wildfire regulations in California only address new buildings.

SPEAKER_00So the retrofit ordinance, though, in Nevada City is a big deal because most of their town is historic. They don't have a lot of new development. So the retrofit ordinance over time will have triggers that essentially require people to update and fortify their homes. The triggers are simple things like you know, pulling a new building permit or doing some new landscaping or getting a new roof. And over time the triggers will increase, the regulations will increase.

SPEAKER_00I'm happy to provide you a link to the ordinance, but this is a really good example of how historic communities on a micro level can start protecting those buildings.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that ordinance would be fantastic. We'll link to that in our show notes as well. What I'm hearing is that there's a way to do this, but it ain't cheap.

SPEAKER_00You know, I we have a lot of research in Headwaters Economics about the cost of retrofits. Um, our research has found that retrofitting homes is not materially more expensive than normal building materials that you would use for a home. Um, we have broken down those costs based on the element of the home, um, which I can provide for you as well. And the good news here is that a lot of the retrofits you can make to historic buildings that would preserve them are actually some of the cheapest and the most effective.

SPEAKER_00So it doesn't have to, you know, to preserve your historic building, it doesn't mean you have to do a whole-scale, you know, rebuild or completely cover the siding of the building or do a whole new roof. There are simple interventions you can make that will make a difference. And I would actually put the the zero to you know, the zero zone, zero non-combustible zone as one of them. I know it's not necessarily simple to remove landscaping, but in terms of cost, it's one of the lower ones and it is one of the most effective.

SPEAKER_00If you look at some examples of homes that survived the conflagrations in Lahaina, um, those homes had a zero to five, you know, within five feet of the home, non-combustible zone. They had nothing around their home.

SPEAKER_01Interestingly, the famous Miracle on Maui. The famous Miracle on Maui. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00That home I'm thinking of, um, from what I have read had that buffer around the home because of termites, which is also a concern for historic structures that are wood-based. Um, and so these buffers can exist for lots of other benefits outside of just reducing wildfire risk.

unknownAaron Powell, Jr.

SPEAKER_01I if we're a homeowner and we have something historic, then there are ways to retrofit that that are not as that are that are affordable. Um even if we're a homeowner that doesn't own a historic structure, there is a lot of stuff that people can do there that are is not super expensive. But then there are other things like the double glazing of windows. That sounds to me like something that a historic structure could get away with because it wouldn't change the look of that historic structure, but that is not exactly cheap.

SPEAKER_01So stuff like a new roof and double glazed windows and that kind of thing, that can get into the higher ticket items.

SPEAKER_00I'm not saying that all of the interventions you make are cheap. There's really a scale. You can kind of triage what people can afford and what they cannot. In the research that we did, we came up with uh a table and a matrix of interventions from the least invasive to the most invasive. And the most invasive, like a new roof, new siding, yeah, those are expensive. Um, but I do know that historic buildings do require new roofs on occasion and roof repair.

SPEAKER_00And if you're gonna do it, you should seriously consider doing a class A non-combustible roof. Of course. It may be costly in the moment, but it may also mean that your building is around for another year or another few decades. And I guess that's where the rubber meets the road here for me, is that the goal of historic preservation is to keep these buildings around for future generations. And unfortunately, a lot of their construction means that they will not make it if the wildfires continue to spread in severity and frequency, like we've seen them do, particularly in the West.

SPEAKER_01It certainly seems like that is our future. Wildfire is a definite reality in our future, yeah. So we've talked about those historic structures that might be owned by individuals, but then there's a lot that are owned by municipalities or state or even federal governments. Is this the political will to spend the money and save these structures at a government level?

SPEAKER_00I'm glad you brought this up because it brings us back to what role the federal government plays in this, which is really the most defining and most important role. In the United States, the federal government has established standards for uh preserving historic structures. It's a pretty long-term, but it's something like, you know, the Department of the Interior's standards for the treatment of historic properties is essentially a book that tells people how to preserve historic structures. It was written in the 60s and has been updated in certain ways since then.

SPEAKER_00It's pretty minimal and it's pretty hard to update it. But the federal government realized a couple decades ago that when these standards were written, no one thought about how to preserve historic structures from flooding. So they decided to go in and adapt the standards to allow communities to make changes to buildings to protect them from flooding. The federal government knows that this needs to happen for wildfire. The process of a policy change is a slow one. But I did talk to some uh federal historic preservationists from my research and confirmed that the federal government's intent is that communities should allow these buildings to adapt and that they should be making changes to the buildings that we may have considered inappropriate in the past.

SPEAKER_00But these changes will preserve the buildings. So now I guess to get more to your question of you know, what role does the federal government play? All local communities adapt their historic preservation regulations based on what the federal government has laid out. So if we want change to happen at the ground level, it's gonna have to happen at the top first. Okay, and there are across the United States many uh federal historic buildings that are you know owned by the government, local government, federal government.

SPEAKER_00And their process for adapting these buildings to wildfire is no different from what a city council would do in a small community. It's just a question of, as you said, do we have the political will? I think that depends on the community. I think a lot of communities in California, unfortunately, have seen the consequences of wildfire and of not adapting your buildings to wildfire. And I have seen some communities have the political will to do this and some don't.

SPEAKER_00And so that's part of the reason why we did this research is to begin this really difficult conversation of what does it mean to Preserve an historic structure in the environment we live in now. And it means something different than it meant, you know, 60 years ago when these guidelines that we follow were written. How has it changed? It has changed in that we are dealing with climate hazards on a level that we haven't seen in the past, you know, 50, 60 years.

SPEAKER_00We're experiencing, as I mentioned earlier, wildfires at a severity and a frequency that we hadn't seen. These urban conflagrations that we've been seeing in Colorado, California, and Hawaii are relatively new in their intensity and their spread. You know, we live much more densely now than we used to. I will say though, even as we have to adapt historic structures to this sort of new environment, this new normal we're in, there was an error made 50 and 60 years ago.

SPEAKER_00It's not like we didn't have floods and wildfires, you know, in the 50s and 60s. We just didn't think about historic preservation guidelines that took that into account. And in fact, most American cities have long histories of climate-related disasters that we had to learn to adapt to. And I address this in our research. In the town where I live, Helena, Montana, the capital of Helena, our city symbol is a fire tower.

SPEAKER_00And that's because the town of Helena burned down, you know, like nine times in the 19th century. Um, and the city seal used to be a phoenix because Helena saw itself as rising from the ashes, right? And eventually they figured out like burning and rising from the ashes is not a good cycle for us. Maybe we should build something that's not going to burn down, and instead we're going to be vigilant. And this is not unique to Helena. We all know there were massive fires that destroyed um big cities in the United States.

SPEAKER_00Yes, yeah. Um, Chicago, Chicago, right here. San Francisco. And all of those fires changed how we built. And changed, they developed fire departments were born of great urban conflagrations in the 1950s.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. And I think we're kind of in a similar moment now where we've been building one way for a really long time, and we have to shift how we build. Um, and that's more of a you know, a conversation about modern building techniques. So we're talking historic structures here, but just remember that these historic structures are kind of frozen in time. And some of them are frozen in a time before we even had modern basic building codes.

SPEAKER_01We have an opportunity right here that you just talked about. The fact that the great Chicago and the great San Francisco fires uh birthed the modern fire service and the modern fire code. Um, well, these massive mega fires, these wildfires that rip into areas and create an urban conflagration and take out whole neighborhoods, whole communities. While it's devastating and brutal and awful to think about the death and destruction that was created, there is that opportunity to rise up and to do better in the rebuild.

SPEAKER_01What do we have to do to make it better?

SPEAKER_00At Headwaters, we focus pretty much exclusively on what we call the built environment, which is a nerdy way of saying, you know, our homes are our facilities, our public buildings, our cities, basically. And our research has shown that most of the damage in wildfires is actually caused by homes burning each other down. When they burn, as I'm sure your listeners know, spew these little embers or sparks that catch each other on fire. And the elements of homes that are particularly flammable are part of the problem.

SPEAKER_00We've tried, especially in California, to change these building materials to prohibit the use of materials that are more likely to burn a home down. And we have started to require elements that will reduce the risk of a home burning. As you mentioned, like double-pane windows, simple, you know, um, not having redwood decks or replacing like the panel of your deck that's nearest your home, making sure we don't have wood fences that connect to our home where a fire can literally run along the fence and light your home on fire.

SPEAKER_00These regulations we recognized have to apply to any new construction that's the most politically feasible path. Some communities like California have been successful with a retrofit program, which is basically applying these measures to older homes. But the one type of structure that we continually see being exempted from these new regulations to reduce wildfire risk are historic structures.

SPEAKER_00In my work with communities, you know, we'll spend a ton of time thinking about subdivisions and residential properties, new and relatively new, but will completely forget their historic structures, which for many communities make up their downtown core, you know, their tourism magnet, the cornerstone of their economy, the thing that puts them on the map. And we just realized that we should not be overlooking these because they do not have the benefit of, you know, decades of science and firefighting experience.

SPEAKER_00They just don't have really what it takes to survive a wildfire or even a basic house fire, the way that, you know, the home that you live in, assuming it's new and the home I live in do.

SPEAKER_01There's a group, and we're going to try and get them on a future podcast, that has started taking historic homes in other parts of uh Southern California, um, homes that would have been demolished and thrown into a landfill, and are moving them and suggesting that they get moved specifically in this article to Altadena. And Altadena is a historic town. Uh the history that was lost when specifically Altadena burned is is devastating and heartbreaking.

SPEAKER_01Um and what's going to happen if all of those lots are rebuilt is going to be a very different Altena than what we lost. And I think that this group is trying to bring a little history back to the rebuild. And so they're taking, for example, a 1911 craftsman-style home out of Hollywood, and uh it's already been bought by a couple who lost their home in Altadena, and it is being moved onto their lot in Altadina and rebuilt there, which sounds beautiful and wonderful, and a way to recapture the history that was lost.

SPEAKER_01But what I'm hearing from you is this could be a very dangerous structure to put back in a fire path.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and you know, when I think about that, also I wonder how those types of structures fit into the regulatory environment in California. You know, it's not a new home, but it's an old home and a new place. So California has done a lot of really good work to address the built environment and require standards that will reduce the risk of homes burning down. I wonder where homes like this fall.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00You know, are there measures that these homeowners are going to need to take to reduce wildfire risk? I don't know. Their neighbors who are building homes brand new will have to require, will be required to follow more stringent standards, I suspect. And that is part of the concern and part of what California has tried to get ahead of is we don't want these patchwork environments where, you know, one home is built to stricter standards and the one next to it is not. And we can really reduce wildfire risk more effectively if we do it at the community scale, which means every home, more or less, whether it's historic or new, has to follow some basic standards to reduce wildfire risk.

SPEAKER_00I do want to talk about this initiative that you mentioned, though. It's really interesting to me to think about how to rebuild a sense of history. That's part of why it's so important to repla to protect these historic structures, is because once they're gone, they're gone. And they're not just losing a building, they're losing an identity, um, an economy, a cultural touchstone that is irreplaceable. And I also want to mention here that historic structures don't have to be things on the, you know, they don't have to be just Will Rogers' house.

SPEAKER_00They don't have to be on the historic registry. They can just be an old building in the community that has played an important role and that is beloved or is the home of a beloved resident. They don't have to be official, they don't have to be regulated. And there's a whole, you know, fabric of history that we lose when these fires happen, and it is not always acknowledged by the historic preservation community or the lists that we keep of historic homes.

SPEAKER_01It makes me think of places where um history is even more relevant and even more uh obvious, and that's uh Europe, for example. And uh European wildfires are growing in severity and frequency as well. Can we learn anything from our European friends?

SPEAKER_00Oh boy, that's a good question. Uh uh I do not I do not work in Europe, and we do not do work in Europe. Um, and I think they view us as a leader when it comes to addressing the built environment. And I've actually had calls with European planners and firefighters asking us for feedback on how we regulate how we build and where we build in relation to wildfires. The one thing that I think we can take from the European context is they are actually much more aggressive, at least in France, I know they are, about how they regulate historic structures.

SPEAKER_00I know that the aggressive control of what you can and can't do to historic buildings, like you know, what paint colors you can use, like you mentioned in the Northeast, is often really off-putting and really difficult for people and is often a disincentive to preserving a historic structure or registering it. I think though, what we can learn from Europe is that these historic structures create this beautiful sense of place that a modern building doesn't always capture. And the sense of history offers something unique that becomes a tourism draw, it becomes a part of the economy.

SPEAKER_00And so thinking about the value of these buildings beyond just, you know, them being another building or what they look like, and taking steps to ensure that they really are, you know, sustainable over time and that they can continue to be in our community and serve it in different ways, if that answers your question.

SPEAKER_01It you've you've given me something that um is is very optimistic. And it it comes from all of the survivors that we've spoken to on Rebuild LA who had homes in the Palisades and had homes in Altadena. Um, one thing, one true line in all of those conversations is the pride that these residents took in their identity of being an Altadinan or a Palisadian, and to know that the world is watching us and is taking cues from how Southern Californians from Los Angeles County folks are going to rebuild their communities.

SPEAKER_01Um I hope gives our survivors a sense of pride as well in that we're being looked to to do the right thing and then to teach other communities how to do it.

SPEAKER_00I think they also can create a sense of, I mean, history's being rewritten in both of those communities and the stories of, you know, new homes being built as part of their history. And they also can recreate a sense of history in their architecture, even with new buildings. And we actually reference an example of this in the research that I did. Um, Santa Fe, New Mexico, which is my hometown, has a historic town center. But in order to broaden the sense of the historic, they have written their city regulations such that they required different types of architectural elements.

SPEAKER_00They may not be old, like the home I grew up in was not old, but it looked old. And so as these communities rebuild, they can think about you know what look and feel mattered to us and how can we create that with modern building materials and with new ordinances and codes.

SPEAKER_01And safety measures like zone zero and defensible space and home hardening and all the other good stuff. Yeah, absolutely. Are we building in the wrong places? Or is wildfire in your research a reality no matter where we build these days?

SPEAKER_00This is a great question. We actually have a podcast here at Headwaters Economics that I host, and we had an episode where we addressed this. You know, is there anywhere that's safe from wildfire? And when when you rebuild after a wildfire, do you leave or do you stay? And I'm not going to weigh in on whether or not you know people should leave or stay, but I can say something about wildfire risk. It is very pervasive and widespread. And it exists in places that people would not expect it to be, particularly now in these urban conflagrations that we're seeing, uh, wildfires are spreading to areas that we may not have thought of as being wildfire prone before.

SPEAKER_00You have to remember that when these fires burn with gale force hurricane winds, they spit these embers, as I said, which are what, you know, catch homes on fire and burn them down. They spit embers miles in front of an actual flame front. 90% of the homes that burn down in wildfires burn down because of embers. I'm mentioning that here because I don't think you can escape wildfire risk in a certain place. I don't think it's necessarily reasonable.

SPEAKER_00We talked about this in our episode of the podcast with a couple of my colleagues. You know, if you tell people to go somewhere safer, where do we tell them to go? Another pivotal piece of insurance of uh research that we've done at Headwaters that has influenced my thinking on this is studying what are the ingredients of an urban conflagration and what other communities are at risk of them. And we did a study, we kind of looked at some of the key factors of a conflagration like we saw in LA and studied where else in the United States these are present.

SPEAKER_00And they're present in places like Biloxi, Mississippi, Hutchinson, Kansas. They're in Iowa. You know, Biloxi, when I think of Biloxi, I think of hurricanes. I don't think of course urban urban conflagration. So our approach is not necessarily to not build in a landscape, but to build smartly in a landscape.

SPEAKER_01We will definitely link to that podcast. Uh this sounds like a conversation worth worth hearing.

SPEAKER_00I think your listeners would appreciate it. And it also, I think, makes an argument for rebuilding a community like Altadena, where it was. You know, our research has also shown, our economic development research has shown that communities tend to recover better when they recover in place. Um, and that there are a lot of factors that go into what recovery looks like. And a lot of things look, I guess, are more successful when you are rooted in a place that you were before, even if it doesn't look like it used to, and a lot of what defined it is gone.

SPEAKER_00But that that podcast episode is definitely worth a listen.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. What didn't we cover? Because this got a lot, we went a lot wider than just a historically listed structure and how to protect it in the future. Is there anything else that our listeners should know about history and maintaining it in the face of our increased wildfire risk?

SPEAKER_00You know, I wanted to cover some things from our research. We have some basic sort of, you know, next steps for community. That'd be great. We've talked to you about how historic structures are really at risk. And I kind of want to answer the now what question. Yeah, yeah. What comes next? I think our top recommendation is one for the federal government. The federal government needs to issue guidelines for the adaptation of historic buildings to wildfire. As I mentioned, they have done this for flooding. Uh, I know that historic preservation experts with the federal government have this on their radar.

SPEAKER_00In fact, there should be a policy brief about this very issue coming out probably within the next year. All communities should look for that and take their cue from the federal government. The second thing that communities can do is don't exempt historic properties from hazard safety related land use policies. This is so common and has been common for a long time. When a community is writing a new building code or wildfire regulation, you should make those apply to your historic structures.

SPEAKER_00We have tips on how to do that in our research, which I know you're going to link to. Another thing that's really important, it's going to sound so basic, but know your wildfire risk. And I say this because wildfire risk is changing, it's spreading. And as we just discussed, it's now in areas where no one really expects it to be. You know, places in the southeast, yeah, the east.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01Um Tennessee and New Jersey just exactly wildfires. Right.

SPEAKER_00We'd major wildfires. So understanding that you are at risk of these is kind of key to addressing the problem. Um, and then the other thing I really want to encourage communities to do is know your assets. You know, what what is what buildings are valuable to you? Why are they valuable? What makes them valuable? And even if these aren't on a state, federal, or local registry, that doesn't matter. Just having a written definition of what these structures do for your economy or your culture is really important.

SPEAKER_00One, because it will help you decide to protect them and understand what you need to do to protect them. And also it will give you a sense of what's important in the event that your community does burn down, like Alta Dina did, and help you sort of guide how you want to recover and what you want to look like in the future. And then the final thing I want to say, um basic, you know, fire-resistant landscaping practices that we use for our homes, our new homes, these can really help historic structures. And they are one of the easier things that you can do.

SPEAKER_00It doesn't require any building changes, but it can mean, you know, survival or not during a wildfire if you follow them.

SPEAKER_01Well, there it is. There is our to-do list. And I hope everybody uh took some notes and and uh now has a checklist that they can they can mark off. Ryan Handy from Headwaters Economics, thank you. I can't uh thank you enough for being with us. I've learned a great deal. It was great to talk to you. Thanks for having me. Rebuild LA is a production of the Safe Community Project. It's produced by Cameron Barrett, David Barrett, and Chris Neville.

SPEAKER_01Our gorgeous theme song and closing credits music were composed by Michelle Sutter. Help our podcast and our nonprofit continue the work we do by taking just a few minutes to rate, review, and subscribe to our podcast. And if you'd like to learn more about the work we're doing to rebuild LA, or even to lend a hand, go to our website at mysafela.org.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Cameron Barrett Host Feed-stated
  • Erik Blank Host Feed-stated
  • Rebuild:LA Host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Chris Nevil Producer Feed-stated
  • David Barrett Producer Feed-stated
  • Ryan Handy Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Rebuild:LA Episode 101 - Returning Home to the Palisades

    Nov 18, 202644 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail This week on Rebuild:LA, host Cameron Barrett chats again with Erin Kyle and Caroline Nick. Both women escaped the Palisades Fire with their families and lost their homes. And both are returning to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Rebuild:LA Episode 100 - Gimme Shelter

    Nov 10, 202640 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail When a disaster strikes, there's complicated, mission-driven work to care for survivors. In the immediate aftermath, it’s all about the basics, and one of those basics is shelter. This week, host...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Rebuild:LA Episode 099: How to Build a Resilient Home...FAST!

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Altadena has always been an alternative community. Historically, a place where people of color could escape racist redlining in LA County, Altadena has brought a small-town feel to one of the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Rebuild:LA Episode 98: Can a Native Garden Save Your Home From Wildfire?

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail This week, we’re wrapping up our series on native plants by bringing you two experts who can help you plant a native garden. First, we meet Erik Blank, the head gardener at the Theodore Payne Foundation...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Rebuild:LA Episode 097: Is LA Doing Brush Clearance All Wrong?

    Oct 20, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail On this week's episode of Rebuild:LA, host Cameron Barrett continues our series on native plants when she asks biologist and Loyola Marymount professor Dr. Demian Willette if LA is doing brush clearance...

    Credit the people on this episode