Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Rebuild:LA

Rebuild:LA artwork

ENCORE EPISODE! Rebuild:LA Episode 027 - The Hard Truth About Zone Zero with Dr. Travis Longcore

Jul 7, 202653 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail On the first of September, the new Rebuild:LA will premiere. We’re entering into the scary world of video and will be bringing you the next crop of leaders, visionaries, and doers who are helping to Rebuild LA. Until then, we’re queuing up our most popular episodes and updating them where we can. So welcome to our first encore episode. The Hard Truth About Zone Zero first aired on May 30, 2025. The guest was Dr. Travis Longcore, an Adjunct Professor at UCLA and the co-chair of the Environmental Science and Engineering Program at the UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability. He serves on the Los Angeles County Environmental Review Board and is a vocal critic of Zone Zero. In 2020, California passed Assembly Bill 3074, which established Zone Zero - an ember-resistant zone within five feet of homes in High and Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zones. And since that Bill passed, Californians have been arguing about how to implement it. State Fire Officials say it’s necessary to help fight the state’s increasing wildfire risk. Dr. Longcore and thousands of others say Zone Zero is impossible to implement or regulate, and won’t do much to prevent wildfire. Now we go back in time to May 30, 2025, and the fight over Zone Zero. New Resources: California Board of Forestry & Fire Protection Draft Rules Is My Home in a High Fire Hazard Severity Zone? MySafe:LA's Take on Zone Zero Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00You're listening to Rebuild LA, a production of My Safe LA. I'm Cameron Barrett. Last week we wrapped up our fourth season with our 80th episode of Rebuild LA. Our podcast was born of the January 2025 firestorms. Over the past 18 months, we've interviewed survivors of the Eaton and Palisades fires. We've talked to home designers, fire chiefs, community leaders, environmentalists, politicians, and nonprofit leaders.

SPEAKER_00And always we've asked those many experts how best to rebuild LA. Because while the fires took thousands of homes and thirty-one precious lives, they also took Los Angeles' confidence. Our belief in our first responders' invincibility, our understanding that we could withstand anything that nature threw at us, our trust in our leaders to protect us, our federal government to provide for us, and our insurance companies to cover us.

SPEAKER_00The past year and a half has been a wake-up call. And Rebuild LA has been a witness to that awakening. Now it's time to retool our approach and rebuild our podcast. On the first of September, the new Rebuild LA will premiere. We're entering into the scary world of video, and we'll be bringing you the next crop of leaders, visionaries, and doers who are helping to rebuild LA. Until then, we're queuing up our most popular episodes from the last year and a half, and we're updating them where we can.

SPEAKER_00So, welcome to our first Encore episode. The Hard Truth About Zone Zero first aired on May 30th, 2025. The guest was Dr. Travis Longcor, an adjunct professor at UCLA and the co-chair of the Environmental Science and Engineering Program at the UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability. He serves on the Los Angeles County Environmental Review Board and is a vocal critic of Zone Zero.

SPEAKER_00Now, back in 2020, California passed Assembly Bill 3074, which established Zone Zero. It's an ember resistant zone within five feet of homes in high and very high fire hazard severity zones. Since that bill passed six years ago, Californians have been arguing about how to implement it. State fire officials say it's necessary to help fight the state's increasing wildfire risk.

SPEAKER_00Dr. Longcorps and thousands of others say zone zero is impossible to implement or regulate and won't do much to prevent wildfire. Now we go back in time to May 30th, 2025, and the fight over Zone Zero.

SPEAKER_01In the most recent Order Forestry uh meeting, they showed a uh a conversion of a home in Auburn, California. So it's sort of a suburban environment uh that they implemented Zone Zero on, and they proudly demonstrated it. And they're like, and so to do this, we had to cut down 10 redwood trees and a black oak tree. Um and then and it was at the cost of I think it was$13,000 for just the vegetation portion. And then they did some home hardening and other things, and so the total cost was was in the 20,000s.

SPEAKER_00You're listening to Rebuild LA, a production of My Safe LA. I'm Cameron Barrett, and that was Dr. Travis Longcorps talking about compliance with Zone Zero, the state law requiring the reduction of ignitable materials within five feet of your home. Longcorps is an adjunct professor at UCLA and co-chairs the environmental science and engineering program at the UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability. He spent the last 28 years serving on the Los Angeles County Environmental Review Board and has seen his share of brush clearance and defensible space rules come into effect.

SPEAKER_00But he's concerned about this latest one. Zone Zero was passed into law in 2020 and has been awaiting implementation as the state tries to hammer out the details. And oh boy, is the devil ever in these details? Longcorps knows the proposal intimately and knows if implemented, it could bring a whole lot of hurt to homeowners from, in his words, Chino to Chinatown. This episode is not to be missed. Zone Zero is next.

SPEAKER_00Zone Zero is a pretty contemptuous uh topic from the state level all the way down to folks that are trying to figure out how to save their homes uh when the next wildfire rips through our area. And you're um an expert on it. You've only been talking about, learning about, studying about, researching about zone zero for what, how many decades now?

SPEAKER_01Well, been paying attention to uh to the issue for a long time, getting started with some real actual research myself, uh actually now, but uh well aware of what's going on and and been dealing with it on the policy side uh for many, many years.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, let's get a little bit of your background um because you have um a really interesting and um multi-tiered background that makes you pretty uniquely qualified to be looking into zone zero and moving forward into the research that you'll be doing um in the next few months um in the aftermath of the uh Palisades and Eaton Fires. So um UCLA Adjunct Professor, start me there.

SPEAKER_01Yep. So I'm an adjunct professor in the Institute of the Environment and Sustainability, and I co-chair the Environmental Science and Engineering Professional Doctorate Program, uh, which is uh designed for people who want a doctoral level education but aren't necessarily going to go into academia and are out in the uh yeah, in the applied world, um, but bringing a uh a research and uh rigorous uh lens to that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and you also um are on the environmental review board, but that's not the only board that you've served on. Can you tell us a little bit about some of the work that you're doing to make LA a safer, more sustainable, and more beautiful place?

SPEAKER_01Sure. Um, so I've served on the county's environmental review board uh since the 90s. Uh we look at all the development that's proposed in the coastal zone of the Santa Monica Mountains that isn't in the city of Malibu, so the county portion of the coastal zone. Lots of fire issues there over the many years. Um I'm uh the president of Los Angeles Audubon Society, and uh, which is of course bird conservation organization, and uh the Urban Wildlands Group, a science director. We've done a lot of restoration and uh research.

SPEAKER_01Um we pioneered some of the work on the effects of artificial light at night on on ecosystems, but we also have applied projects uh doing butterfly conservation, restoration, um, etc., over the over the years. So that's a few things keep you busy.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And you know, it's funny, Los Angeles to me, having not grown up here, is um it's a vast cement, you know, it's it's the urban jungle in my in my experience and all the other places that I've lived. This is probably the most paved uh place that I've ever lived. So it's really interesting to know that there is so much environmental study, so much um environmental sustainability uh taking place in this vast city.

SPEAKER_00It's it's all of a sudden kind of heartwarming.

SPEAKER_01So uh my wife Catherine Rich and I, our whole purpose around the Urban Wildlands Group was this recognition that there is nature in the city and it needs to be protected and people need to know about it. Uh, but it as somebody who moved here from away as well, uh, it does take time to see it and understand it and recognize what the seasons are. Um, you know, that's not immediately obvious to somebody who grew who grew up on the East Coast. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you and I are both from um from uh nearby places in New England. And and yes, we're used to vast changes in season, but there are seasons here.

SPEAKER_01Oh, absolutely.

SPEAKER_00And they and they are changing thanks to climate change. I mean, our our winters uh come later and last much uh a much shorter amount of time, and and the rains that we've come to depend on and the snow and all is is really changing a lot, hence uh one of the many reasons for the for the firestorms in January. Um a lot of uh conversation around zone zero uh before before those fires and absolutely after those fires. And that's what we're here to talk about because I know there's a million things we could talk to you about, including wildlife.

SPEAKER_00Um, and so we might be begging you to come back on to talk a little bit about uh the wildlife in the county of Los Angeles and how these fires affected that. But for now, we're gonna stick with Zone Zero because uh there's been a recent kind of um speeded up policy uh movement uh in the state about um solidifying zone zero and passing it into law. Can you give us the background of zone zero, what it is, and the background and and and where we now stand in uh in May of 2025?

SPEAKER_01Sure. Well, I mean, so the law has already been passed. It was AB3074 from uh Friedman in 2020. And basically what it says is that the uh the state's guidance around defensible space uh will include an what's called an ember resistant zone in the area zero to five feet. It's called zone zero because there's already a zone one and a zone two, and so to fit that in, they had to go zero. It doesn't mean because people will fix this in their head, it doesn't mean, as it was written, zero vegetation.

SPEAKER_01Um, you know, it's so it's kind of a tricky thing here. Okay, it's it's an ember resistant zone where the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection and Fire Marshall are supposed to consider the elimination of materials that are likely to be ignited uh by embers in this area right around the home. So likely to be ignited, um, ember resistant zone. So that was passed in 2020, but it had language in it that said it will only go into effect upon the finalization of a rule by the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01And this had not been finalized. Um, my suspicion is because it's a really tough thing to do, because you're talking about telling people in their very closest personal spaces how they should be living their lives. Um, however, when the fires, after the fires in February 2025, uh Governor Newsom uh had an executive order, among which things it included were an order to the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection that they would have a this regulation, this rule finalized by the end of the calendar year.

SPEAKER_00Wow. Okay, so that means we've got, I don't know, uh six months? Yeah, six, seven months left until this is supposed to be finalized. And I know maybe in your vast knowledge of zone zero, that that's nearly impossible. But let's yeah, let's let's define what they want to do or what you think they want to do.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean and more to the point, where it's going to apply.

SPEAKER_00Okay, got it.

SPEAKER_01So so firefighting in the state is divided between state responsibility area and local responsibility area. And um this is going to apply in the state responsibility area for the zones that are mapped very high and high. And then it's also going to apply in the local responsibility areas that are mapped very high.

SPEAKER_00Okay, we're talking very high and high fire severity zones. We're not talking altitude here.

SPEAKER_01Not altitude. This is the fire hazard severity zones. And so the um the complicating this is that the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection also just released new maps that change where these zones are. Because they used to be that the local jurisdiction, City of LA, for example, would map where the very high zones were and is like at Sunset Boulevard, blah, blah, blah, blah. Um, but now those are being mapped into the local responsibility areas by the state into areas that have never been mapped as very high before, or even in the hazard zone at all.

SPEAKER_01So, for example, Hollywood Boulevard, the Sunset Strip, uh northern part of Chinatown, uh Brentwood south of uh of Sunset, all these places that have never been mapped as high fire hazard zones or very high hazard hazard zones now are going to be in the very high zone by state law. And so having to do defensible space, vegetation management, etc., and the kicker are gonna have zone zero added onto that at the end of the year.

SPEAKER_00Uh these maps the uh you just mentioned four, three, four places that when I imagine them, uh it's they're just it's just pavement. It's big buildings and pavement. Yes. And these are high fire.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So that there's a map, uh uh a tool that you can go to at the the uh Board of Forestry website and put into your address, and uh it will show you where you are. And yes, some of these areas, because they what they've done is they haven't limited it to the wildland area with sort of wildland vegetation. They've sort of done some model. I haven't gotten under the hood of it yet. Um, I know the factors that go into it. I'm not particularly impressed because it's not an urban fire model, it's a wildland.

SPEAKER_01It's like this is where we think the embers might go if there's a bad fire in the wildland. Um, however, yes, there are some of these are blocks of five-story apartment buildings that uh uh you know are set back from each other by no more than you know, 10 feet from each other and five feet from the street. And you know, so yes, we're we're talking about applying this. So that new rule zone is going to apply to that all the way to the most remote cabin, you know, in Northern California that's uh on on a ranch, right?

SPEAKER_00Okay, got it. That's what zone zero is going to be. That that's where we have to enforce zone zero. And enforcement, I we're we're far from that question yet, which sounds completely uh impossible, but okay, so we're in the middle of these very densely populated, very city um uh locations in the in in downtown L. I mean Chinatown? Downtown LA.

SPEAKER_01Yes, the north part of Chinatown is is inside the very high zone on the new maps.

SPEAKER_00And we don't know exactly how these areas were were identified as high fire and very high fire.

SPEAKER_01What I've seen so far, and it could be more, and I haven't asked and gone too far into this, they have a webpage that tells you what the the sort of environmental factors are that they've considered. Okay, but I I don't know what the actual underlying model is, how they put those factors together to create that. But let's just say there's also you know Angel Island in the San Francisco Bay. Yeah, the the very high zone extends uh out into the San Francisco Bay around Angel Island. So they've actually mapped in this these new maps that they've just released, they've actually mapped San Francisco Bay water they have mapped as very high fire hazard severity zone.

SPEAKER_00Water. Okay. Yeah, water. Yeah, first of all, let's let's assure let's assure our listeners, first of all, that we we will link to these maps, we promise. We'll link to that place where you can put your your zip code, your address in and figure out if you're in one of these high fire or very high fire hazard zones. But uh, do you I mean, based on Angel Island, do you think somebody's made a mistake? Do you think these need to be corrected?

SPEAKER_01I they make a big deal, they have made a big deal about being hazard, not risk, meaning that um they're not they're looking at a place where there may be embers falling, but they're not giving you an opinion about whether there's a risk of it burning. Okay, so right?

SPEAKER_00Okay, so this is just like an ember cast map.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, basically, but it's but it's what's to going to define this, and because then like risk would involve assessing you know the building code and what's there and what can get so this these maps don't take into account home hardening, defensible space, pools, irrigation, any of that thing, which kind of makes sense. It's like it really demonstrate the the fact that San Francisco Bay is mapped as a very high zone, uh, sort of gives you the the sort of proof in the pudding there. They they're not saying it there's a chance of it burning, they're just saying there's going to be embers that are going to fall there.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Um, and or or there's a possibility that a wildland fire in the nearby wildlands could result in stuff being ignited that ends up in that those areas.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01And so it's pretty clearly just a buffer around the vegetation map.

SPEAKER_00I'm feeling as though the maps and zone zero regulation should not necessarily be linked the way they are.

SPEAKER_01Um well uh I mean they are in the code, and that's the problem. Okay. Um, because it is by state law and code that says that anywhere that's mapped a very high zone, even in the local responsibility area, is subject to both the fire safe regulations that were adopted a few years back and the defensible space regulations that will be updated with zone zero. So, but which means if you want to solve this policy wise right now, you have to put more flexibility into your defensible space regulation that acknowledges the fact that this is not just being applied to what we refer to as you know, intermix or interface, you know, houses that are out in the midst of wildland versus or houses even that are just at the edge of wildland.

SPEAKER_01But this actually is also being applied to urban contexts for which there might not be a single bit of wildland and quotes vegetation for for blocks, uh, but that there's a possibility that in extreme wind event there may be embers. But again, that's always been a possibility anywhere in the city. You have high-rise fires and they cast embers. Uh, and this has happened in the past in in Los Angeles, that the homes get lost during uh urban fires because embers go.

SPEAKER_01So the so if the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection wants to deal with this, they've got to put some flexibility into the rule that they're developing and not, you know, have one rule from Chico to Chinatown.

SPEAKER_00There you go. Okay, one rule is just it it can't fit all the places that humanity in California. Okay.

SPEAKER_01I don't think so.

SPEAKER_00Well, let's talk about what the rule says currently and maybe eventually, I because I know there's a lot of details here, but let's talk about what it says and and then maybe what chance we have to amend it, influence it, whatever. So let's first of all talk about what zone zero requirements are currently in the proposal.

SPEAKER_01So, and and remember, keep in the back of your head that what the legislation says is ember resistant, removing materials that are likely to be ignited.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so right now it says that you will not be able to have any landscaping materials that are likely to be ignited by embers, including but not limited to grass, ornamental or native plants, shrubs, branches, fallen leaves and tree needles, weeds, and combustible marches, mulches, including bark and wood chips. You can have 10 or fewer pots, potted plants, if they're in areas that are not directly beneath, above, in front of a window, glass door, or vent, that they're kept unaffixed in a non-combustible pot that's no larger than five gallons and set apart by 1.5 times the height of the plant or 12 inches, which is whichever is greater, from the structure and each other.

SPEAKER_01And the plants shall be no more than 18 inches in height, with dead and dying materials removed, and potted plants shall be removed out of zone zero on wet red flag warning days. When the committee that's hearing this at the Board of Forestry in their most recent uh hearing, um, one of the members said, that seems a little overly prescriptive. That feels a little icky. Um a little icky. Icky was the exact word.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00A little barren is more like it to me. It sounds like you can have a pot and put some rocks in it. That's what I'm looking at.

SPEAKER_01Well, yes. Well, this is the intent. And because and you can tell because the pictures that they show as good examples of zone zero involve houses with five feet of gravel around them, right? This is the way that is being interpreted is like you will have nothing living within five feet of your house. Um, and and for people who live, you know, on small lots, people live in urban areas, people who, you know, all you have is five feet, and even new developments, like the people from Rancho Mission Viejo are testifying, they're building new homes that are completely fire resistant, you know, meet all the codes, the whole development setup, you know, for fire resistance.

SPEAKER_01And now they're finding out that they won't be able to have any vegetation around any of their homes because it's all their planting areas are within five feet of the house. And they're kind of be like, hey guys, can we cut a break here? Um, because we've done everything right uh at the landscape level and at the building code level, but you're gonna now come in and tell us we can't have any plants, which to me sounds as though it would be even worse as far as uh fire risk, because if you don't have any plants, it's gonna be hotter.

SPEAKER_00There's gonna be less oxygen. There's I mean, it's all the bad stuff that we don't want to have happen. I mean, it's gonna be it's gonna be incredibly hot, just the sun beating down on concrete and bouncing back up. It sounds like everything's gonna be preheated for a fire.

SPEAKER_01Uh well, it will certainly be hot and dry. Uh if you yes, this so there is, as far as I can tell at this point, no process by which the Board of Forestry, at least in the deliberations that I've seen in the committee, is trying to balance the benefits of vegetation against the the potential risks, which we can talk about later. And so the other part is the their treatment of trees. So it does say you can have a tree that has a trunk in zone zero as long as it is taller than the ridgeline of the adjacent structure, and then you have to cut it 10 feet away from the roof.

SPEAKER_01Now that now, first thing, that means that trees are gonna have to be cut another five feet away from roofs, because currently it's it's five feet. Uh you have to cut trees five feet away from roofs in under the current defensible space guidelines. Um so they want to increase that to 10, which is gonna damage a lot of trees, to be quite frank, um, and and make them, you know, and it's also there's not a clear uh demonstration of how this would be applied, like which is the adjacent structure when you've got a tree that's between two houses and one's on a slope and one's downslope, and so you're never gonna be taller than the one upslope, or but you're taller than the one downslope.

SPEAKER_01Is that tall? So there's like implementation problems with this.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01But more to the point is it's a recipe to eventually have no trees because you cannot plant any tree. And if that's your planting zone, so you're in some of these instances that I've described, that's your only planting area. You can't even get a tree if you lose your tree. Uh, or if you don't have trees and you want trees or you want shade or whatnot, you can't do that uh because you there's this period when the tree is not as tall as the building, and therefore it's not gonna buy a 40-year-old tree that's tall enough to yeah, to and then and then they put in, and this one I think they put in because I I testified at one of the hearings.

SPEAKER_01I said, What about you know, multi-story? You've got these zones now where you've got three to five story, multi-family, etc. UCLA, the north part of the UCLA campus, will be in this zone. Um, I said, You're basically saying you can't have trees within, you're gonna have to cut all the trees down within five feet. So they wrote an exception. The exception says, Oh, you can have a tree next to within zone zero as long as there's no balconies or porches. Well, that there you've just gotten rid of all those residential zones that have balconies and porches are now have been thrust into very high zone and consequently have zone zero applied to them.

SPEAKER_01Um and there's even instances where that will mean cutting down street trees. Um if you're if you follow the language of the law. Now, there are some board members at one at least who saying, oh no, no, we're allowing trees, but you have to actually read what the code says. Um it's you're going to be removing a massive number of trees. I know this already because the insurance industry is pushing on people. I know arborists who talk to me, they're like, we're having to just really butcher uh the urban forest uh because of trying to comply with this.

SPEAKER_01And from now, where's the science on this one? Okay. The there are papers that discuss that there's an increased risk of losing a structure when there is overhanging vegetation. Now, you can't define exactly what that overhanging vegetation is, um, but let's just imagine it's trees. I I've talked to folks who do these studies, and they're like, that is we interpret this, the people who write these things, and it's in some of their papers, as being the accumulation of leaf litter on roofs and gutters and whatnot, is the risk of an overhanging tree.

SPEAKER_01It is not generally that the tree lights on fire and then lights the structure. It's the fact that the tree produces litter that then accumulates on a roof, accumulates in gutters, accumulates whatnot, and that that provides the additional risk. Um there's no I have seen no compelling evidence. Um compelling, I've seen no evidence that a that raising the branches from five feet above a roof to ten feet above a roof is going to make a difference that couldn't be made by something that's in the in the zone zero, which is you've got to keep your roof and gutters clear of the room.

SPEAKER_00Clean out your gutters, clean off your roof.

SPEAKER_01Clean out your gutters, clean off your roof, do it before there's a massive fire event. Because the other, you know, the other big picture thing is we we try to pay attention just maybe to vegetation because that's in some ways it's easy.

SPEAKER_00In some ways, but then I mean the the price of a removal of a tree, which also is just heartbreaking to think about in a place that needs more trees, yes, on any urban landscape, you know, to benefit from more trees. And uh, I mean, that's that's very cost prohibitive for a lot of people.

SPEAKER_01Yes. And and just as an example, in the most recent border forestry uh meeting, they showed a uh a conversion of a home in Auburn, California. So it's sort of a suburban environment uh that they implemented zone zero on and they proudly demonstrated it. And they're like, and so to do this, we had to cut down 10 redwood trees and a black oak tree. Um and then and it would at the cost of I think it was$13,000 uh for just the vegetation portion. And then they did some home hardening and other things, and so the total cost was was in the 20,000s uh range.

SPEAKER_01And it was kind of surprised me to see that as the example because um, you know, first of all, there are some people who are saying, oh no, we're not gonna be cutting down trees. That comment came right after they had just demonstrated compliance by cutting down 11, you know, California natives. But to the point is, yes, it's good you can take that number and multiply it by three or five to do that work in Los Angeles. I don't know if you've hired tree crew lately, but uh yeah.

SPEAKER_00Uh first of all, they're they're not very thick on the ground right now, they are busy. Yeah. Um yeah, and uh it's it's uh quite a growth industry in this area. But um so you mentioned California natives. Oh, two lovely words. Um there's plenty of science, um, proven science that says that natives are going to help us uh not burn down the way that we've burned down. In fact, weren't the um the non-native um eucalyptus trees um in Oakland, weren't they the the villains for the Oakland firestorms?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um is tell you're the expert here. Tell us about that. California natives, are they gonna help us not burn?

SPEAKER_01Uh I think you have to be more specific than just native or not when it comes to fire risk. Okay. Uh, because the question is whether or not it's a plant that accumulates um dry matter that's easily ignitable uh or not. And and so some California natives that are summer deciduous may be the kinds of things we don't want directly around our home. Uh, whereas other things like Coast Live Oaks, which are very good at they drop, you know, they kind of do a pretty good job of self-pruning, and you can prune them out to to get any dead wood out, um, stay moist and are anecdotally uh associated with blocking embers.

SPEAKER_01Uh, and this this idea of of sort of healthy vegetation full of water blocking embers and saving structures is is not a new one that we just made up by the people looking at the Palisades and Eaton fires, which people have made this observation. Um, but this is uh something that's been discussed in fires all the way from Alaska to Australia. Um, that that having leaf on healthy, full of water blocks embers and can actually help save structures as well. And so this is not being uh appreciated in the rulemaking process.

SPEAKER_01And some to some degree, people are saying, well, this is uh it's just anecdotal. Uh, we don't know that. I'm I'm a scientist, I'm happy to say, yeah, we need to study this more. Um, but there is the fact of it does take more energy, you know, you have to sort of cook off the water before these things are going to ignite. Sure. And if you've ever tried to ignite dry wood, you know, good, good luck to you. I'm sorry, wet wood, you know, fresh, fresh wood. Newly cut wood. Yeah. Yeah, newly cleanly cut wood.

SPEAKER_01Water's pouring out of it. Um, so the idea that this rulemaking should be focused on all vegetation and not hazardous conditions, I think is a real strategic error.

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_01Um and it's and I call it a strategic error because the enforcement of this is gonna fall on local fire inspectors who had no role in writing the rule, who maybe don't even agree with with what the rule is. And there, and then it's gonna put a wedge between them and local residents who they want to be working collaboratively with, because there are good things that people can do, especially around home hardening and vents and you know, all this sort of thing. Um, and then the the complaints are gonna come to the local, you know, city council members who also had nothing to do with the rule.

SPEAKER_01Um, and I think this is the reason why in the past the local responsibility areas were under the local responsibility, and that they got to you know decide how they what what the rules were that they were gonna have. City of LA has had a 200-foot fuel modification zone for forever. Um, that's a hundred feet more than the state requires. Um and that was their prerogative, and that was it, but but it was theirs, right?

SPEAKER_00And they could also knee-jerk reaction to Bel Air, right? Yeah, perhaps. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um, um, but and I'll just parenthetically say the science will tell you that a hundred feet of fuel modification is adequate, and it doesn't even have to be Moonscape, it can be reduction by 40%, leaving 60%, you know, spreading things out and whatnot is adequate for the any benefit that you're going to get from the fuel modification. And any of that benefit is only, you know, like fuel mod or defensible space plus home hardening, which is probably the more important of those two things.

SPEAKER_01Those things together maybe explain 15% of whether you lose a structure in a fire or not. Um, so we're talking about really at the margins. But I think it's a real strategic error to be focusing this on all vegetation and to get themselves, you know, really it's tied into knots on, oh, we're going to allow a tree this way and not that way. They should be focused on the maintenance issues, truly hazardous things. Because every time people, you know, give their presentations, they're like, Well, here was a juniper that was right next to the house, and it's like, okay, I get it, you know.

SPEAKER_01Sure. Junipers accumulate a lot of dead stuff inside. We know that, or here's pampas grass and it burned. I was like, I get it. Here's an untrimmed palm, I get it.

SPEAKER_00Um, but those Mediterranean cypress that, you know, every every firefighter hates. They say they're like little torches. Well, they're not natives either.

SPEAKER_01Right. So, um, yeah, so we we do have, you know, a bunch of native species that that are evergreen um and hold on to water and whatnot. But it doesn't necessarily have to be natives either. Um, just recognizing there's a lot of sort of functional hedges in the in the in the region uh that uh I haven't seen anybody yet go, the hedge is what made me lose my house in in in Altadina or or or Palisades. It was like the house burned the hedge down, um, not not the other way around.

SPEAKER_00Well, you've you've stumbled right onto what makes up most of zone zero in an urban landscape, which is stuff we've built, not things that are growing.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00So um can talk about the current proposal and how it, you know, how it addresses the stuff we've built that lies up against our house.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, so they want you to so we talked about the um uh the the potted plants.

SPEAKER_00Pots, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. They want you to keep out uh combustible boards, timbers, firewood, synthetic lawn, and attached window boxes and trellises. There was a discussion about whether or not this included pergolas, probably it does. So is there like a focus on and and really this kind of stuff is probably you know, sort of pre-fire preparation, like not to leave stuff right next to the house that could burn.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, but stuff that you can move is what you're doing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, stuff that stuff that you can move, but some of this is stuff that you wouldn't be moving, like a like a trellis. Um decks are counted as part of the structure. So you would have to, if you've got a wood deck, um, you would have to keep the zone zero around the deck clear and no storage of flammable materials under the deck.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Um fences too, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Fences. Uh they they realize that it would be very difficult to force people to replace all their fences immediately. So it's like you're not supposed to install new sections of fence that aren't attached to the structure after the date, and you are supposed to replace gates and fences that tee into a structure that are flammable.

SPEAKER_00So that would be both wood and vinyl uh fences, which are yeah, we certainly saw a lot of those pools of what used to be fences all over the palisades and and Altadena.

SPEAKER_01Yep. Um, so those are those are those are and I have less of a conversation about those because you know some of the post-fire studies, which is the things that I trust the most as giving us insight is what actually happens after a fire. Um, what what contributed to loss and what didn't is uh fences within zone zero are significantly associated. There's the Thomas fire. There was a a uh thesis written about the Thomas fire, very, very clear signal there, but not a signal of vegetation um or oak woodland, which they mapped separately, which is like very interesting, right?

SPEAKER_01Um so that they very clearly could parse out zone zero, maybe had explained in this particular study area in that particular fire, explained maybe eight or nine percent of the risk of loss. But the thing that drove that was the fences.

SPEAKER_00I I guess I'm a little overwhelmed right now. And I know. Um, and I'm sure that everybody who is trying to adhere to a coming law, and I know it's it's law, but obviously it's not being enforced because it because um it hasn't been finalized. But uh everybody who's trying to comply with this and who's also trying to, you know, be safe and make their home survive, um, uh or give it the best chance it can to survive, um one, this this just seems like it's counterintuitive to what would make most sense.

SPEAKER_00And secondly, that it's concentrating on the wrong things. Uh I mean, these two fires that happened in LA County, Aldadina and Palisades, it was the like you said, the house ignited the shrub. The burning car ignited the house that ignited the shrub.

SPEAKER_01Right. And they're not gonna ban parking within five feet of uh structure. They're absolutely and they're not gonna they're not gonna ban you know battery walls, and and they're not gonna regulate your neighbor coming and putting an ADU four feet from the property line that forces you to clear, you know. So, yes, you're right. And and so there is no because we're down so far into the you know, weeds the weeds right here on like this is what we have to do under this law, it's very easy to lose sight of the big picture.

SPEAKER_01And the big picture is that where we develop in California defines the risk of that of of that development, right? So once you've put a home there and it is where it is, and the Santa Ana wins are they how they are, and you know, that's 85% of the story. And and so the decision to like you know, Altadina, you know, 100 years ago, 120 years ago, there was a buffer between you know the the development and the hills.

SPEAKER_01Um, and it it's we've done a you know the these two events notwithstanding, we've done a remarkable job of keeping fire from going from the wildland into the city, right? Um, and what happened here you know wouldn't have happened without ignitions. We really if we want to talk about where we're gonna invest time and effort and focus, ignition. If there are very few, almost no lightning fires, which would be the only natural fire here in Southern California at that time of year, right?

SPEAKER_01That just doesn't happen. It was a decadal Santa Ana wind event.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Once people and the and I I remember the National Weather Service, before it was eviscerated, was there busy um telling us this was danger to life, limb, and property. This was absolutely, I mean, they were for days, they're like, this is this doesn't happen. This is a particularly dangerous situation. This isn't just a red flag today. Why so if we want to talk about us and society and how what we pay attention to, we pay far too little attention to ignitions, ignition prevention, especially in chaparral.

SPEAKER_01And we should distinguish here between chaparral, which is our local vegetation here in Los Angeles, and sort of forest fires in the Sierra Nevada. Right. These are two different completely, two completely different things. And and so ignitions matter. Um, and when the ignition happens, and making sure there's like patrols and that every all you know staff on deck, when you have this, these, these uh Santa Ana wind events that are then you're not gonna stop the wind. So exactly, because the winds ground the helicopters, and once the helicopters and planes are grounded, then all bets are off, and that's exactly what we saw.

SPEAKER_00Right, right.

SPEAKER_01Um yeah, and and then the other thing, and the very hard conversation is what do we permit to be built? Where do we permit it to be? And and I'm not gonna be able to do that.

SPEAKER_00You're saying that where we build is pretty much you're saying that's the majority of the risk. That's that's the story.

SPEAKER_01And you know, so so we're busy telling people you have to make yourself miserable by taking out the camellia that you planted, you know, for something that is just a you know, vanishing. A vanishingly small element of that. And like I understand insurance companies, they have to charge you more. That if you buy a Maserati, you also have to pay more, right? Uh, you know, we pay for risk through the the market.

SPEAKER_00But what about these insurance companies, you know, that are sending up drones to to to make sure that you're doing your brush clearance, but also are denying you coverage when they're following the letter of this law that seems to be telling us the wrong things.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but are they? Because the law says an ember-resistant zone that removes materials that are likely to be ignited by embers. So is my oak tree likely to be ignited by embers? All you uh you talk to a lot of firefighters, you talk to the ones who've done wild lamp fire, you ask them if they're worried about my oak tree lighting my house on fire. Uh the answer is probably gonna be no, right?

SPEAKER_00They're a lot more worried about your electric car.

SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly. Which we're not, you know. So there's all sorts of policy levers we could push on. Um, and the fact of the matter is you have to just acknowledge this is California, it has natural disasters and is dangerous. We all live with the risk of the earth. Earthquake coming and you know and yes, we take steps and we encourage things, but we generally pick the the highest, highest priority things, you know, bolting the foundation, soft story retrofits or whatnot.

SPEAKER_01We're and and they may argue, some people may argue that we know this about zone zero. I don't think we know about vegetation in zone zero, to be quite honest.

SPEAKER_00Um is that what your research is going to be about?

SPEAKER_01We're gonna look at that. We're gonna try to sort out and do a similar post-fire study of the losses in the Eaton Palisades fires that quantifies the amount of vegetation in zero to five feet because previous studies didn't. Um so there is, except for that one study I mentioned from the Thomas uh fire, literally no studies in the field showing zone zero, measuring zone zero, anything. Yes, there are studies showing the importance of defensible space, and that closer to the home is more important than further from the home. But defensible space allowing firefighters access safely is a very different thing than I'm getting rid of every single thing and gonna let all the embers just go up against the house.

SPEAKER_00Um, scientific study, especially in the academic world, takes a while. And this zone zero is supposed to be finalized the end of this year. What can people do to, I don't know, change the timing or change change what this law will say?

SPEAKER_01So my perception and what I've also heard from people who've listened to other parts of the Board of Forestry hearing is the engagement, they only recently in the last two workshops heard from anybody who was concerned about this. So basically, this was being it was being developed in a vacuum of and the vacuum was the vacuum was fire chiefs and insurance industry. That's who was in the room having the conversations and saying, oh, well, maybe we can let them have a potted plant, and they'll be happier then if they can have a potted plant.

SPEAKER_01They were not hearing from property owners, developers of like Rancho Mission Vieh. That all came after the word started getting out and this began, started getting serious. And so a couple of hearings now. The first one, they listened to everybody and they allowed for a conversation to happen, and I raised a bunch of concerns, and then they shut that off for the next hearing. And what they did is they just did five hours of presentations from hand-picked people that they wanted to support their view, and then so they start the meeting at 10, they got to public comment at three o'clock.

SPEAKER_00Holy cow.

SPEAKER_01And and then, and then they, you know, and then they said, Oh, we want to hear from the public, chair of the board. And I appreciate that. I take him at his word that he wants to hear from the public. But the meeting got changed from one that was very interactive, heard from the public, very conversational, where they heard they got nearful because people are like, I'm sorry, you're gonna do what? Um, and so they just changed the whole format of the meeting, put all the public comment at the end, listened to it, uh, went over, you know, to be fair. Um, but you know, I heard then at the main meeting, they basically said people are just concerned about aesthetics and they're just gonna have to learn that uh this is what they need to do for safety.

SPEAKER_01So I don't believe that the public input thus far has appreciably moved the needle with the Board of Forestry and Fiber Protection.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Now, none of them are elected. Okay, they're all appointed. They're all appointed.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Um, so that so and I respect and understand the power of non-elected boards as expert boards. Um however, I do believe that the people who appoint them, um, and ultimately local officials who have nothing to do with this process are going to find that it's in their interest to engage and perhaps put some pressure on the state to have a little more reasonable conversation about this and and ask um, because the only deadline here is the artificial one that was imposed by the governor.

SPEAKER_01And he could just as easily say, you know what, um, we're just gonna go forward with these things over here, we're gonna let this other thing go uh it's while we discuss it some more. Uh, and then of course, some state lawmaker could introduce legislation that clarifies that when they said, if this is what they meant, when they said a ember-resistant zone, they didn't mean a completely non-combustible, free of vegetation zone.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Because once you go down that road, you really you should be regulating, you know, electric cars and you know, every everything.

SPEAKER_00Everything's like absolutely everything. How many breaths you take during a wind event? Yeah, exactly. So it can, yeah. So you go down that route and it's it's hard to stop, slippery slope and all. So, okay, I'm at home. I'm worried about this. I want to be part of the solution. I don't like what seems to be happening. Who do I talk to? My local, my local elected official? Do I write to the governor? What what are you saying, Travis? People might be able to do that would make a difference.

SPEAKER_01Well, I have I've encouraged people to actually attend these meetings because it does show when there's 130 people and a hundred of them stick around until uh three o'clock to give their testimony, it does show that people are listening and care. So I, you know, but but it's on a work day, not everybody can do that.

SPEAKER_00That's crazy. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I would especially if you're in a local responsibility area and you can find that out from the map, and we'll put the link up.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we'll put that link up and we'll also put the link up of the I I assume the meetings are are scheduled and open to the public so we can put when the next meetings happen. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Yep. They are a little, they they get published like a week before they happen.

SPEAKER_00Ah, okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Uh I think we do know when the next one will be in June, though. Um, and I would talk to your local elected officials if you're in a local responsibility area. Um, so if you have your local fire department that's in charge and you can find that out from the map, talk to your local elections, make sure they know what's going on, make sure they know what's coming, and whatever issues people have. There may be people who's like, I'm more than happy to do this. I, you know, I'm so afraid. But there are also a lot of people that I've talked to who are like, oh my goodness, don't we need to balance this a little bit between the benefits that we have sense and the laws, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Um, and then I think ultimately then this does uh end up at the governor. If you have a relationship with your local assembly member or senator, you can talk to them because this is state law that's being being implemented. And we'll, you know, local electeds are the ones who are going to get the pushback uh when when their local fire department's forced to enforce something that they had nothing to do with with uh devising.

SPEAKER_00And just seems nearly unenforceable. It really does, if it went forward with the current proposal.

SPEAKER_01Um, no, dri drive drive around Los Angeles, especially in the new zones, even in zones that have been doing fuel management for in defensible space for years, there's uh uh there's nowhere that complies with what they have envisioned uh for zone zero.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Well, I can't tell you how much, Travis, we um appreciate your expertise. This is uh this is something that I think a lot of people don't know about. Certainly, the devil is in the details of uh the current proposal for zone zero. And um, you've given us at least some next steps so that this conversation can keep going and and maybe some, like you said, common sense can be injected into this. And um I I I'm gonna put you on the spot right now, and I would say, can we invite you back when we are closer to the deadline and see if there's been any kind of movement, uh positive or negative in this conversation?

SPEAKER_00Yes?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, no, I'm I'm happy to talk about this. And you know, look, this these are hard issues, and there are scientists who are gonna come down in different places, like, but it's like how close you are to your neighboring structure makes a huge difference about your risk of of burning in a fire. Um, and but but who gets to decide that? Local zoning, these are all really complex, you know, variances, development patterns, these are all complex things uh that all contribute to the situation that we're in. And and like like you said, I just think we need a more nuanced answer uh to the current question.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, not one size fits all on this one, that's for sure. All righty, Travis Lancourt, thank you so much for joining us. And um, and I'm really looking forward to our next conversation. I'm hoping there'll be some good news finally. So thank you.

SPEAKER_01Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Rebuild LA is a production of the Safe Community Project. It's produced by Cameron Barrett, David Barrett, and Chris Neville. Our gorgeous theme song and closing credits music were composed by Michelle Sutter. Help our podcast and our nonprofit continue the work we do by taking just a few minutes to rate, review, and subscribe to our podcast. And if you'd like to learn more about the work we're doing to rebuild LA, or even to lend a hand, go to our website at mysafela.org.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Cameron Barrett Host Feed-stated
  • Rebuild:LA Host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Chris Nevil Producer Feed-stated
  • David Barrett Producer Feed-stated
  • Dr. Travis Longcore Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Rebuild:LA Episode 101 - Returning Home to the Palisades

    Nov 18, 202644 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail This week on Rebuild:LA, host Cameron Barrett chats again with Erin Kyle and Caroline Nick. Both women escaped the Palisades Fire with their families and lost their homes. And both are returning to the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Rebuild:LA Episode 100 - Gimme Shelter

    Nov 10, 202640 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail When a disaster strikes, there's complicated, mission-driven work to care for survivors. In the immediate aftermath, it’s all about the basics, and one of those basics is shelter. This week, host...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Rebuild:LA Episode 099: How to Build a Resilient Home...FAST!

    Nov 3, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Altadena has always been an alternative community. Historically, a place where people of color could escape racist redlining in LA County, Altadena has brought a small-town feel to one of the most...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Rebuild:LA Episode 98: Can a Native Garden Save Your Home From Wildfire?

    Oct 27, 202643 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail This week, we’re wrapping up our series on native plants by bringing you two experts who can help you plant a native garden. First, we meet Erik Blank, the head gardener at the Theodore Payne Foundation...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Rebuild:LA Episode 097: Is LA Doing Brush Clearance All Wrong?

    Oct 20, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail On this week's episode of Rebuild:LA, host Cameron Barrett continues our series on native plants when she asks biologist and Loyola Marymount professor Dr. Demian Willette if LA is doing brush clearance...

    Credit the people on this episode