Send us Fan Mail When homeowners who lost everything in the Eaton and Palisades Fires called their insurance companies, some of them had a rude awakening, adding more misery to families who had already lost nearly everything they owned. What happens when you lose your home to wildfire? Do you have enough insurance? Can you even get enough insurance in California in 2025? What about your mortgage? Do you still need to pay for a house that no longer exists? And if you still have a home, what can you do to lower your risks and your insurance payments. Cameron Barrett interviews Real Estate Broker and community resilience expert Pat Hanley in this episode of Rebuild:LA. Resources: California Association of Realtors https://www.car.org/ Ventura Regional Fire Safe Council https://venturafiresafe.org/ Team Rubicon https://teamrubiconusa.org/ Home Hardening https://www.wildfirela.org/home-hardening/ Defensible Space https://www.wildfirela.org/defensible-space/ California Fire Safe Council https://www.wildfirela.org/fire-safe-councils/ Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01If your home's a total loss, you will still be responsible for paying that mortgage. So, one of the things that God forbid this happens to you, and you um lose your home in a fire, you need to immediately call your mortgage servicer and find out what you can do.
SPEAKER_00You're listening to Rebuild LA, a production of My Safe LA. I'm Cameron Barrett, and that was Pat Hanley, a real estate broker who serves as a director of the California Association of Realtors. She combines her expertise of Southern California real estate with her passion for community building and disaster recovery. She's the treasurer for the Ventura Regional Fire Safe Council and a member of Team Rubicon, where she recently got certified in chainsaw brush management.
SPEAKER_00I am not kidding. We called her because we know you have a lot of questions about insurance and mortgages in the wake of the Palisades and Eaton fires. Pat has the answers, and there are some details here that might surprise you. Stay tuned, it's all ahead.
SPEAKER_01Thank you very much for the opportunity to speak to you.
SPEAKER_00Now you uh live in Ventura County, is that correct?
SPEAKER_01Yes, I do.
SPEAKER_00And you have faced plenty of wildfires. So you are not only speaking, yeah, from firsthand knowledge, but of course from your expertise uh in um the real estate market uh in Southern California. And there, I I think those are most of the questions that that people are really um yelling out there right now uh in the wake of the Palisades and eating fires. We're taping this on the 3rd of February. So most people have been able to get to their home site to take a look at it, but not much else.
SPEAKER_00What are some of the things that that people need to be thinking about right now, uh three weeks out, nearly a month out of the fires?
SPEAKER_01There are many, many things that uh people need to be thinking about, and everyone needs to be concerned about insurance and insurability of their homes. It is affecting every aspect of real estate as it as it should. Um first of all, people need to uh be mindful. All of us need to understand that our it's not just about our own homes, it's about our community. If your neighbors are not fire hardened, your home's gonna burn too, no matter what you do.
SPEAKER_01So it's very important for to get educated on how to deal with this new reality. Most folks, you know, that we're dealing with, uh, especially on the, you know, our our sellers and our buyers, they want that lush lawn, they want the the vegetation up against the house. It's just not sustainable anymore. You have to look at the home uh as it needs to be fire-hardened. So, and and if you don't want to make it that way for our sellers, um it needs to be that way because the buyers can't get insurance frequently when the when their insurance companies come over to to look at the property to determine whether or not they're gonna let the buyer obtain insurance.
SPEAKER_01They're looking at that landscaping. They're looking.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, let's drill down to that. So home hardening, it used to be like, well, I'm not gonna do it because I I just have to have that vulgar, you know, climb it up my wall. Well, it it act, there's a there's not just a smart reason to do it, there's a financial reason to do it. Can you tell us about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you will not oftentimes the insurance companies, when they come to assess whether or not they're going to insure you, and you know, whether you're selling your home or not, your insurance companies can come and do those inspections to determine whether they're gonna renew you at any time they choose. And um, obviously they'd set up an appointment, but if your home isn't hardened, they're gonna tell you to harden it, or they may just decide flat out not to insure you. Uh, you have to take responsibility for that. And yes, we all love our grass and we all love our homes with the plants right right up against the stucco.
SPEAKER_01We can't do that anymore. We have to have a zone optimally and uh have the five feet from the house completely free of vegetation. And another thing uh people don't understand, you know, you don't keep your barbecue up against with propane tank up against your house. It's very dangerous. Things that are common sense that we've kind of ignored over the years, we now have to pay attention to just so that we can keep our insurance, just so that we can that when we're selling our house, buyers can obtain insurance.
SPEAKER_01And it's uh very important. The other thing I've seen coming out of the Palisades fire, which is interesting, things that I no one has ever thought about, but uh recently I was told that there have been some people that have had trouble if they um they go to their insurance company for a claim, and if their home is in a trust, they're getting some pushback from some of the insurance companies because they have the policy is in the individual names, it's not in the trust. So it's very important to check with your insurance company and see if you need to put if your home is held in a trust to see if you need to put that trust in as an additional insured.
SPEAKER_01Uh, I just did that on my own home the other day. I I wasn't aware of it. And and indeed, it's it's a thing. You need to to uh consider doing that.
SPEAKER_00What a great tip.
SPEAKER_01Just so that if you, if God forbid you have to file a claim that everything will, you'll have all your ducks in a row. Um, we've had a lot of um concern with you know, folks who've uh lost their homes, they still are paying their mortgage. And yes, you are still responsible after you you um if your fires if your home's a total loss, you will still be responsible for paying that mortgage. So one of the things that God forbid this happens to you and you um lose your home in a fire, you need to immediately call your mortgage servicer and find out what you can do.
SPEAKER_01Many of them will uh give you a year, you know, do a loan modification. You don't get forgiven that year's worth of mortgage and it's still accumulating in uh interest, but they may defer the payment for next year or just tack it on to the very end of the loan. You'll still be responsible, but you'll be good for a year. Problem is that a lot of people don't understand with that, is that it can take three, two, three years to rebuild your home. So you may be stuck for three years paying a mortgage in a home that you can't live in, uh, which is a huge problem.
SPEAKER_01Many, many, many of the um folks who have mortgages um end up uh having to sell their home, you know, taking the insurance money and then having to sell their property for land value. And it's it's simply because while they may be able to get a one-year extension on their mortgage payments and and and on their loans and not have to pay for a year, it's it's sometimes very unlikely that you'll get to uh extend it for two or three years.
SPEAKER_01There are some exceptions, but it depends on your mortgage servicer. But it's it frequently does uh cause you to have to sell your home for land value, take your insurance proceeds, and then move on. It's it's a really actually very sad situation that a lot of people don't talk about.
SPEAKER_00Truly heartbreaking, yes. Especially when you hear about some of the homes in the Palisades that were bought 40, 60 years ago, you know, for$40,000, or or even even, I mean, if you can measure heartbreak, uh the Eton uh fire took out houses that were generational sources of wealth for families. So I just correct a heartbreaking reality. So when uh so people have to call their their mortgage uh holder, absolutely, and and talk to them about what they can get.
SPEAKER_00But I I assume uh another really important call is obviously to your insurer.
SPEAKER_01First, that's the first call.
SPEAKER_00And there's a list of things people need to talk to their insurer about. Can you can you walk through some of those for us?
SPEAKER_01And and this is before the fire. They need to A, make sure that they're they have, you know, they're completely covered if they have a trust uh in terms of uh putting on any additional insurer. The other thing is they need to make sure that they have adequate coverage. You know, a lot of the people just on the California Fair Plan may not understand they need a wraparound policy so that they are fully insured. They, you know, otherwise you could very well get caught short. And so you cannot be um, you know, you you need to, you know, just face the reality of what you need to have in terms of a full insurance coverage, because any of us can have our house burned down with these winds the way they are.
SPEAKER_01And um, you need to be prepared.
SPEAKER_00So when you say a full insurance, that's that's your house, that's your belongings inside your house, right? That's can you yeah, drill down a little bit for us.
SPEAKER_01It's your improvements. If you don't keep your insurance company up to date about, oh, I just put in new windows, I put on a new roof, I put on, you you you may not be fully covered. And uh for example, I just a couple of years ago, I decided to have them walk through my house again. I asked for them that my insurance company would come through and do a complete inspection of my house so that I made sure that I was fully insured. And yes, I'm paying more on an annual basis, but I have full coverage now. You want replacement cost coverage.
SPEAKER_01Some you need to make sure that the permitting process and any now new mandatory uh retrofits because if you're built, you know, if you build from the ground up, you're gonna have to uh get it all permitted to today's standards, not standards that were back in 1960 if your home's older. And you need, you know, you need to be aware of this.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Now, you also um want in that policy some kind of relocation uh um coverage too, don't you? I mean, folks are still relying on that right now, aren't they?
SPEAKER_01They are very much relying on that. And again, it gets down to this fact that you're still going to be paying, if you have a mortgage, you're still going to be paying your mortgage, or you know, unless you're lucky, you know, unless you are able to get an extension, but you'll still owe that in the long run. Um, you do need to make sure that you have adequate coverage and you need to, you know, make sure that you um can have it for more than a year typically. You need to be realistic about it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01The length of the term and the amount. And you need to make sure that your personal property is properly insured, too. Because you often, when you have to evacuate, you're not you're gonna leave most of your household things behind.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. You're gonna take, you know, the old saying, right? Do you take the Picasso or the cat? Well, of course you take the cat, but the Picasso was worth a little bit of money, and you need to be insured for such things.
SPEAKER_01You try to take both, but you know, you you panic is what happens to folks when they when they have to to do that. Another thing that I found uh in selling real estate out there with insurance companies that people don't talk about again is whether their carrier is admitted or not admitted into the state. It's very important to understand this because in these catastrophic events, admitted carriers, you know, they're gonna be they're gonna be required to perform or their consequences. Non-admitted insurance carriers, which are frequently out-of-state companies, and there's you know, typically smaller carriers, they won't be able to um necessarily uh cover these claims when there are this many uh losses that we've seen recently.
SPEAKER_01And they really don't have any consequences if they walk because they're not admitted into the state of California. And so sometimes, and this is a question I tell all of my clients, yes, you're looking for the cheapest premium, but is that carrier admitted? And uh there, like I said, there are huge consequences uh to you if you don't check that out. And there are mortgage companies that uh will allow non-admitted carriers, and people are doing it just to get their mortgage, but it's not worth the risk.
SPEAKER_00I had no idea that that uh a homeowner in California could get insurance from a non-admitted insurance carrier. I I didn't even know that that was allowed.
SPEAKER_01And it's and I I have brought this up in many of our meetings um just to make sure that people are aware of this, but it's something nobody talks about.
SPEAKER_00So make sure that your insurance company, when you're choosing it, um, is an admitted insurance carrier for the state of California.
SPEAKER_01Now, speaking about something that just recently happened too, um one of our major, major, major uh insurance companies, State Farm, was just uh downgraded to a B rating in the state. And what this means is they have a fair rating, and some of the mortgage companies are requiring their clients now to go and obtain insurance with someone else because they don't want to take that risk if for some reason you default the and that the house burden's down because the bank would sit on a poly sit on a home that didn't have any insurance coverage, which would be a complete loss to them.
SPEAKER_01So you need to make sure these days, too, that you know the rating, uh, which is basically the a risk of the uh insurance company defaulting. You need to make sure that you have somebody that has a good uh rating, credit rating.
SPEAKER_00So state farm insurance went from A to B rating. Is that right? No. Yes. How did that happen? Why did they, why were they downgraded?
SPEAKER_01They have had so many losses here in the state from all of these fires that they they uh it's pretty much um taken them out. I mean, it they have you know more claims than they are taking in revenue. And uh they are at very serious risk of potentially defaulting.
SPEAKER_00I think that there are um a lot of folks out there that might feel as though uh insurance companies are giant corporations with um endless wealth and vast amounts of of resources. You should probably set us straight on that pack. Can you help us understand this?
SPEAKER_01You know, for every dollar they've been taking in lately, they've been paying out more than what they're taking in. And so at some point, it is not an endless pot of money. There we are seeing too many catastrophic losses all at once. And um, you know, it's a business. And you know, that it you have to, in order to stay in business, you need to make more than you are paying out. And they're now paying out more than they're making significantly. Uh, and to a certain extent, our rates have been too low over the years, which has caused some of this.
SPEAKER_00Okay, our rates have been too low in California. Talk to us about that.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, the our our insurance commissioner uh and the insurance California Insurance Department has kind of artificially kept the rates low for uh consumers here in California, which has been okay. Well, we haven't had any fires, but now that we're actually they're actually having to pay out on significant risks, it's a problem because they're underfunded.
SPEAKER_00Wow. So this could uh nightmare scenario here. You could turn to your insurance company having lost everything in the Palisades or Eaton or or even the Lydia or or Sunset or I mean there's Hearst fires, there were so many fires burning, um, fuse fire, uh, and they could just be gone. They they could just they they could have they don't have a way, you know. Yes, and that's why this investment is gone.
SPEAKER_00Oh my okay.
SPEAKER_01And this is to me, one of the things is the best insurance is to for us all as communities to get together, home harden our individual homes, and then join with our neighbors and becoming firewise communities. And that's where my Safe LA, Ventura Regional Fire Safe Council, we're all trying very hard to uh make this happen for people. And and folks need to reach out to these organizations and find out how they can um help them uh become more wildfire resilient.
SPEAKER_01They we just need to.
SPEAKER_00You're you've brought so many of these conversations that we have on Rebuild LA come back to the idea that we cannot fight fire one house at a time. We cannot uh be more resilient in a silo. We have to bring this to our communities, and I love that. I'm so glad you brought that around to us, Pat. Is there are there are a couple of options, firewise sites and fire safe councils. There's there's ways to work with your neighbors, proven ways to work with your neighbors to make your neighborhoods more resilient.
SPEAKER_01We've seen we've seen it work, and it what's really interesting is uh for a long time, I think that people have got become disconnected from their neighbors. Becoming firewise communities has actually uh resulted in neighbors getting to know neighbors, and they're a much happier community, and and at the same time they're they're more fire resilient. And one of the things that also happens is when these big fires occur, the fire department cannot be everywhere because there are too many houses on fire.
SPEAKER_01There's you know, it's too many, you know, schools and businesses. And at first, when they're first responding, they have to uh worry about just human lives. So that's what they're trying to um to protect initially. So we have to, we have to play a role in in and preventing the you know the spread of the fires. And also we need to know our neighbors so that if people that are elderly and shut into their homes are able to evacuate in the in the case of these um catastrophic events, we may need to help them if the fire department can't get there fast enough.
SPEAKER_01And so knowing your neighbors, becoming fire-wise communities, it helps and um and it protects all of us.
SPEAKER_00Our risk 40 years ago from wildfire, there was a risk, but it's nothing like it is today, which might it does explain why uh we have insurance crisis right now, why we are having these uh these incredible fires now, why we have to rethink how we rebuild our communities, or even retrofit our communities. And and those changes come from uh one of the the large changes is climate change.
SPEAKER_00Um the the hotter the place gets, the the more the the Santa Anna's howl and and and the uh the higher those wind speeds are. Wind speeds of 100 miles per hour gusting um does not mean that no matter what you do with your home, it's going to be protected if your neighbor's home is burning. It's just it's a reality. So making firewise communities and making um fire safe councils within your communities is a first step moving forward as we rebuild some of these communities.
SPEAKER_00But it's not too late if you uh have uh knock on what escaped a wildfire this particular January. How do people go about um making those first steps to making their whole neighborhoods more resilient?
SPEAKER_01Most people start uh with, you know, they I know with our organization in my safe, they start out just you know, checking out online and their seminars and and podcasts that they can review, but they start home hardening their own home and they just it's very inexpensive to get the screening. It's one sixteenth inch uh screening to put over your uh vents and things so that you eat the embers can't get through in the first place. You keep propane tanks from your barbecue away from your house.
SPEAKER_01If if your house starts burning, you uh keep uh cushions and things, you get them away from the house. The one thing I I I've been trying to, and our and actually our real estate association, Kenel Simi Moore Park Association of Realtors, has been uh passing out uh flyers, telling everybody about the ready set go program that the fire department and Calfire encourage, where you you figure out ahead of time what you're gonna do if you have to evacuate. One of the and some things uh in terms of saving your own home, if you have enough time, is you need to remember to uh you have your ready-set go bag and you get your things out and you get people and pets out, but shut your windows on your way out.
SPEAKER_01Make sure you know how to uh open up that garage door when you have no electricity, because you need to shut that garage door so you don't invite the fire in. You need to get those propane tanks away from the house. You need to uh get the uh patio furniture cushions away from the house. Um, and hopefully you don't have any mulch near the house because it acts like kindling, and you have the plant is a zero, you don't have anything planted within five feet of your structure. And hopefully you don't have wood fences touching your structure.
SPEAKER_01Within at least five feet, and you've taken care of your vegetation management. But there are also in some cases, I know in where I live, we have um opportunities for low-income people to do uh resident, um we have resident grants, and if you don't have enough money, they will um help you uh do some of these retrofits. And then there are organizations like I belong to, Team Rubicon, that you know, you can reach out to them and ask if if you're low-income or in a disadvantaged community, ask if we can come on in and help do that.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I'm an old woman and I help out with vegetation management. I can chainsaw and and um you know uh tree trim and and get all of the um things cleared away. But you know, you need to reach out to the organizations and where you can get help if you need it, and and it's available.
SPEAKER_00So Team Rubicon, we're gonna put a link to Team Rubicon uh on the show notes. So uh and and a list of what Pat just went through. Uh, if a wildfire threatens one of your ready's is to do some of the things, or the set actually is to do some of those things that Pat was talking about. But please do look into Team Rubicon because I want you to have Pat Hanley come to your house and show you her chainsaw skills. This woman is certified in in chainsaw, and I just think that's the coolest thing ever.
SPEAKER_00I'm signing up for a class. I really want to learn. I can I it sounds like a blast. It really does. How wonderful, though, that that is available to people who might not have the money or the physical ability to do some of the changes that we need to do to our houses to make them more uh more um fire-wise. Um but um there's another thing that um that uh uh communities can do too. Can you uh we're gonna delve way deep into it in another episode, but can you mention and just give us a little teaser about what beacon boxes are?
SPEAKER_01Beacon boxes are these big, um they're they are fantastic for first responders because oftentimes there are, you know, it's not just your local fire department fighting these big fires. We're bringing in people from other states, we're bringing in people from other counties, and they don't all communicate in the same way. So the beacon boxes are these big um uh basically uh weatherproof, rust resistant, and marine tolerant. So they don't, the moisture doesn't get in, uh distribution stations, they are located directly within your community so that firefighters, all firefighters, even ones from out of area, have access to critical communication under any condition.
SPEAKER_01And so what happens is they um they'll know where the fire hydrants are, they'll know where sources of water are from, like, for example, from swimming pools, and they may need to use that water. Um, they were going to be able to, because what people don't understand is frequently these fire trucks come into these places, they can't see in front of the fire truck. It is peach black, dark, and it could be as bright as day up above with the sun shining through it. There, the smoke is so dense they can't see through. So these boxes have little uh lights on top so they can find them easily too.
SPEAKER_01And so it gives you them the critical information, and then the each of the beacon boxes contains print and digital maps that are carefully crafted to provide the right level of information to the emergency personnel so they can make they can have strategic and tactical decisions rapidly because a lot of times it takes them more time to get up to speed when they have to go find each individual fire hydrant and they won't know where the sources of the, you know, where the pools are, where the homes are, even or where they can turn their fire trucks around, which is really important.
SPEAKER_01So um, they're able to position resources and then they understand where the more vulnerable areas are when they they come uh onto the streets. So it's really is a critical tool that can help uh firefighters fight in these large events, and every minute counts. And so that's why you want tools like this uh to be available.
SPEAKER_00If you're a part of a homeowners association or a firewise uh site or a fire safe council, um don't worry, we're gonna um uh have an entire episode on beacon boxes. We'll tell you all about that and and be able to get you some critical information regarding it if that interests you. So, Pat, I I know that we need to kind of wrap things up pretty quickly, but as a real estate expert, tell me what the Palisades, Eaton, Sunset, Hughes, uh, Lydia, what all of the fire storms of early January have done to the Southern California real estate market.
SPEAKER_00Is there a way to sum it up?
SPEAKER_01It is a really difficult situation because we have more people looking for houses than we have supply of homes. It was already that way before these fires hit. There was very low supply of home, both rentals and of uh resale properties. And now it's the the uh that we even have a much lower supply. We have much greater demand, and so it's putting uh pressure on prices. Poor uh buyers are having a difficult time um getting in um into the and into homes, uh, and the rentals are through the roof because there's just no, there's nothing available.
SPEAKER_01And um it's a frightening situation. I I know a number of the a lot of the Palisades people that we know, they're either coming up our way, but primarily they're going down to the South Bay and into Orange County to just to find housing, which is pretty far from Pacific Palisades. It's just it's so sad. And then I feel bad about some of these neighborhoods, um, like the Eaton Fire, and you know, that we have a lot more than just Pacific, everybody's talking about Pacific Palisades, but we have many, many more communities, and they're not quite as affluent that people are forgetting about.
SPEAKER_01And um, we need to help people in every community with this this situation. And we need to, we need to get strong and be good neighbors and and really participate in communities because our homes depend on everybody else's home not catching on fire. And um we just I I I think that the good the upshot on this in terms of real estate and everything is that our communities are gonna become much stronger. We're gonna know our neighbors, we're going to help our neighbors, and they'll help us.
SPEAKER_01And and it's just in terms of societal thing, it's gonna be a good thing. And uh, and but we we need to make sure that we're in advance of a uh a fire, we need to make sure that we're protecting. Um we're protecting ourselves by you know practicing um evacuations and because when it hits you, the one thing I hear from uh fire uh victims is that they they just weren't prepared. They never knew it was going to be this bad.
SPEAKER_01You have to practice like you did the fire drills at school in elementary school. You need to practice those at home and and be ready and be ready to help your neighbors.
SPEAKER_00That's uh I love ending on that optimistic note. I mean, if Pat Hanley, a real estate expert in our area, can be optimistic about what's going to happen in the future for our region after these fires, I think we all can. And one of the things we can do in that optimistic way is to start with our own house and then knock on our neighbors' door and get to know them and work together with them. Pat, thank you so much for joining us. This was really, really informative.
SPEAKER_00And uh I hope folks are gonna be able to um take some of the expertise that you've shared with us today and make some differences in their own lives. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. And just know that we are California Strong, and we're gonna get out of this bigger and better and stronger than ever.
SPEAKER_00Rebuild LA is a production of the Safe Community Project. It's produced by Cameron Barrett, David Barrett, and Chris Neville. Our gorgeous theme song and closing credits music were composed by Michelle Sutath. Help our podcast and our nonprofit continue the work we do by taking just a few minutes to rate, review, and subscribe to our podcast. And if you'd like to learn more about the work we're doing to rebuild LA, or even to lend a hand, go to our website at mysafeala.org.
Send us Fan Mail This week on Rebuild:LA, host Cameron Barrett chats again with Erin Kyle and Caroline Nick. Both women escaped the Palisades Fire with their families and lost their homes. And both are returning to the...
Send us Fan Mail When a disaster strikes, there's complicated, mission-driven work to care for survivors. In the immediate aftermath, it’s all about the basics, and one of those basics is shelter. This week, host...
Send us Fan Mail Altadena has always been an alternative community. Historically, a place where people of color could escape racist redlining in LA County, Altadena has brought a small-town feel to one of the most...
Send us Fan Mail This week, we’re wrapping up our series on native plants by bringing you two experts who can help you plant a native garden. First, we meet Erik Blank, the head gardener at the Theodore Payne Foundation...
Send us Fan Mail On this week's episode of Rebuild:LA, host Cameron Barrett continues our series on native plants when she asks biologist and Loyola Marymount professor Dr. Demian Willette if LA is doing brush clearance...