Send us a message! And the podcast is live! From the original names for some of my fictional settings of Torte and Nitro to love stories that never made it to the page, we chat about the early brainstorming process and the cutting room floor where so many ideas have gone to die. 🎉 Join me on Patreon for bonus content. Website Instagram YouTube TikTok Etsy Bookbub Facebook
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Ellie AlexanderHello, hello, and welcome to our very first episode of our new podcast, Reality Writes. That's right, Reality Writes, where we are going to give you behind the scenes information and insight into all of the things that go into writing mysteries. That's my end of what we do. And also, Tech Guy, do you want to tell them what you do?
Tech GuyEverything after that, uh, everything from promoting books, marketing books, uh building readership audiences, um, managing all the technology, the logistics that go into simple things like book talks at bookstores, things like that.
Ellie AlexanderUm, and for anyone who doesn't know us, this is obviously our first episode of the podcast. So many of you may be familiar with um my books, perhaps, um, and they may have seen your face every once in a while on some of the live streams that we've done over the years. But I am author Ellie Alexander, and I have made a career out of killing people, fictionally speaking. And I don't know, maybe in this podcast, um we'll peel the curtain back and I'll talk about some of the people that I would love to kill fictionally in future books.
Ellie AlexanderWe'll see. We'll see where it goes.
Tech GuyAnd I am the tech guy, uh the other half of the Ellie Alexander Writing Empire. Um, and I manage all things technical and uh anything geek related, which is my background, uh bad in advertising. So here we go.
Ellie AlexanderYeah. Let's do it. Let's do it. So the first thing that we have to do uh is we have to come up with a fun and clever name for our listeners, aka viewers, because you will be able to listen to this podcast wherever you listen to your favorite podcasts. And we will also be airing it on places like YouTube if you want to see us. And we'll sometimes be showing multimedia, right? We'll we'll be working in some imagery, but you don't have to watch it if if you're not into it.
Tech GuyRight, right. Yeah, we'll we'll describe everything. I mean, we're we're gonna be talking about our successes, our failures, all the frustrations that's gone into things, the things that we're proud of, the things that uh we wish we had done better, that BL, it's gonna lend the gamut. But um, but yeah, sometimes we will show stuff. So we'll when we can, we'll we'll show it on video, and uh, but we'll try to make it as fun uh and entertaining as possible with just the audio.
Ellie AlexanderThat's right. So for starters, we have to think of something the listeners would love to be called. And I keep coming up with murderous ideas, but I'm wondering if that's is is that too dark? Do we need to do something um, you know, more lighthearted?
Tech GuyI think, I think probably yes. Um why? Come on. Try to keep this a little light. Uh uh, yeah. So um, but although I would like to hear some of your murderous ideas, um, maybe it'll spark some inspiration for other uh names.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, I mean, like um what keeps coming to mind is like dark horse. Um, and I have no idea why. Like the dark horses, it has nothing to do with my writing whatsoever. Not even remotely. All right, all right. Uh-huh. Um, the murderous mixers. Uh you know me, I always want to lean into alliteration. Um puns, yeah. Alliteration and puns. Yeah. Yeah.
Tech GuyYeah. Um, I don't know. That is uh that is a good question. I mean, it it has to be something different besides the listeners.
Ellie AlexanderListeners is lame. Listeners is like, no.
Tech GuyGot it, got it, got it.
Ellie AlexanderUm reality writers is also like, no, come on.
Tech GuyUh yeah. Yeah.
Ellie AlexanderHey, all you reality writers out there.
Tech GuyWell, not everybody's gonna be a writer. A lot of people.
Ellie AlexanderSo yeah, reality readers.
Tech GuyYeah.
Ellie AlexanderYou're realitiers. That isn't fly off the lips. No. No.
Tech GuyDefinitely not. Um uh yeah.
Ellie AlexanderUm see, this is really how brainstorming sessions for books go, too. Um, it's a lot of this where it's like you start with an idea. I think I might have had dark horse in my mind because it's my favorite wine.
Tech GuyUm, I would have said it's my favorite comic book company, but um, okay.
Ellie AlexanderUm, and I we've been we binged slow horses, so maybe I also have like a bit of that in my head. But um, this is usually how the writing process works, where if you're helping me brainstorm, we will like, you know, sit outside with a fun drink, and it's a lot of yes, no, no, definitely no, no. And then, you know, at some point you land on something.
Tech GuyRight. And, you know, a lot of the times you hear in brainstorming sessions that, you know, hey, just throw it out there, throw it out there. There are no bad ideas. Well, I'm here to tell you there are some really crappy ideas. So it's like, yeah, when people say that, they're they're lying to you because there are bad ideas for sure.
Ellie AlexanderThere are such bad ideas, but I do I maintain the fact that there are no bad ideas when you're brainstorming because bad ideas often lead to good ideas.
Tech GuyYeah, yeah, that's true. That's true. Um, yeah, they can. Um, they can also lead to worse ideas. Uh so you know sometimes they can also coming coming from the advertising world, I'll tell you, like, you can go into a client presentation and think that you have nailed it, that you have gotten that creative brief and you just nailed it and come up with the most creative like thing that a client is gonna love, and they will tell you that it is absolute garbage. And you're just you've got to go back to the drawing board.
Tech GuySo, yeah, sometimes what you think is a good idea is really, you know, it's all subjective, right? Like books.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, and that segues in nicely to the topic of our first podcast, uh, which is going to be all about the plot ideas that never made the final cut. I have had to kill my darlings so often because I had ideas that just were pretty bad and terrible. We didn't even set this up, but to loop back, maybe what we need to do is we need to have our listeners, uh, for lack of a better word.
Tech GuyWe'll go for we'll go with listeners for right now and and we'll like as the as the episode progresses, maybe something something will come up.
Ellie AlexanderSomething will come up, but maybe they can also suggest ideas to us.
Tech GuyThat's true.
Ellie AlexanderThey're more clever than we are, probably.
Tech GuyProbably.
Ellie AlexanderFor sure. Yeah. Yeah. Uh yeah. Okay, so we thought it would be really fun to kick this one off with all of the plot ideas that you know just failed to go anywhere. I'm pausing just because you're are you are you looking up something?
Tech GuyNo.
Ellie AlexanderOh, you look like you're on your phone.
Tech GuyNo. I was trying to make sure the microphone wasn't falling.
Ellie AlexanderOkay, okay. I'm gonna start over from there. We thought it would be fun on this first podcast to talk about all of the plot ideas that I started with that we often brainstorm together and then that failed to turn into anything that should ever end up in a final version of a book, right?
Tech GuyRight. And there have been a lot. I mean, going back to that advertising example, like there have been many were, you know, ideas, book ideas, plot ideas, I should say not necessarily book ideas, but plot ideas for books that you like, I think came up with and thought, wow, this is gonna be the best, absolute best. And then whether it was you yourself, which happens a lot, or or you know, one of your initial um friends or or you know, early readers are like, no, that's not yeah, that doesn't work, or you know, you can't do that.
Ellie AlexanderSo exactly.
Tech GuyYeah.
Ellie AlexanderAnd we gotta start at the very beginning with the bake shop mysteries, I feel like, because um there are quite a few key ideas in that series in particular, when I was starting out that I thought were really gonna take off and then they went nowhere. But to back up even further, I have to tell the story of um how that series came to be. Because, in terms of writing, I was already writing a Pacific Northwest mystery series, and my agent called me. I will never forget this. You were at work and I was out at the lake.
Ellie AlexanderIt was the middle of summer, and my best friend Cassie was visiting from uh my best friend from college was visiting from Alaska with her twins. And our son, Sky Guy, was about their same age, and they were playing. And I got a call from my agent, which, you know, at that stage in my career, anytime I got a call from my agent, I was just excited because it meant something bookish. Um, and I got the voicemail from him saying, Hey, I have this opportunity for you. I have a new series that I would love for you to write. And then I had no service to call him back.
Ellie AlexanderUm, and of course, I wanted to do it in the moment, which now I would be like, why would I have that conversation out at a lake with the kids? But you know, in the moment, I was excited.
Tech GuyYeah, it was well, you should have been. But uh, yeah, you were a little panicked too, but you and then you were worried that you were gonna take too long to get back to them. And yeah.
Ellie AlexanderYes. So this particular series came to me as a brief from my editor Ed McMillan, who um she didn't have a lot for me to go on, but she wanted a mother-daughter baking team and sort of uh in the tone of the Gilmore girls. And so my agent was like, you have two weeks, two weeks to put together an entire series proposal with um the arc of the series, titles, and little mini synopses for the first three books in the series, and then the first 50 pages of the book.
Ellie AlexanderTwo weeks. Um, and at this point in time, we also had, you know, like an elementary school kid and you were working full-time and I was working part-time. Um, and this series ended up becoming the my long-running series, The Bake Shot Mysteries, which is set in Ashland, Oregon. And one of the first things that I said is, okay, if I'm gonna set this in Ashland, we have to go to Ashland like right away, which is like a five-hour drive from where we were living at the time.
Tech GuyRight, right. Yeah. So we packed up and we just left for Ashland.
Ellie AlexanderLiterally, pretty much. Yeah, you were such a trooper. I'm like, we gotta go to Ashland. You're like, okay, we're going to Ashland.
Tech GuyYeah, I had never been to Ashland, so that was, yeah, that was a first.
Ellie AlexanderWas that your first trip to Ashland?
Tech GuyYeah, it was my very first trip. I'd never been Oh my gosh. We didn't go in high school. Yeah, like yeah, you did um for the Shakespeare Festival, but we didn't do that.
Ellie AlexanderI had totally spaced that was your first trip.
Tech GuyYeah, first ever.
Ellie AlexanderAmazing. Yeah. So awesome. We went all around town. I took a zillion pictures and was brainstorming ideas. Um, and I found a bunch of like the original materials that I have uh and I saved them all. So these are like original OSF brochures for everything that was playing at the time. Um, I had maps of town, uh, just everything I could possibly imagine. And after we did that trip, I came back home and I got to work.
Ellie AlexanderAlso, this sort of dates us, but look at like the brochures from back then. It's this tiny little thing for it's like scenic maps of southern Oregon. And it looks like it's straight out of the 80s. This was what, 2010, maybe?
Tech GuyYeah, yeah. No, it was yeah, yeah, right around then.
Ellie Alexander2012, something like that. Yeah. Anyway, um, so I came back home and I started brainstorming, and I still have my original notebook of all of this is a big yellow legal pad of all of the ideas uh that I had initially for Jules Juliet Montague Capshaw, who becomes you know, Jules, who we all know and love. Her original name was gonna be Jules Hudson.
Tech GuyBoom. Not as Shakespearean.
Ellie AlexanderNo. Um, but then the first victim is Nancy Hudson. So clearly I was feeling Hudson for some reason. Yeah. Um the bake shop, which is tort, was going to be Gooseberry Fool.
Tech GuyI remember that one. Um going back to the there are no bad ideas.
Ellie AlexanderI think you might have vetoed that one.
Tech GuyI did not like that one. I I think I was pretty honest about that.
Ellie AlexanderI'm sure you were. Um Shakespeare's Kitchen.
Tech GuyThat seems a little on the nose.
Ellie AlexanderUh-huh. Uh-huh. Um Marzipan. Exclamation point.
Tech GuyThat one wasn't bad. Marzipan, but um exclamation point, yeah. Marzipan!
Ellie AlexanderMarzipan!
Tech GuyYeah.
Ellie AlexanderUm As You Like It.
Tech GuyYeah, that was good. I like that one.
Ellie AlexanderCakes and Ale. Um Below the Salt.
Tech GuyI never got that one.
Ellie AlexanderI have a note here because I think I was trying to convince you of it at one point in time. Salt was prized and was always at the head of the table in Shakespeare's kitchen.
Tech GuyYeah, but I'd like I'd love to hear from listeners. Um, whatever it's whatever to be named.
Ellie AlexanderTo be named, yeah. Um below, I think everybody knows below the salt.
Tech GuyYou think everybody? Okay. I would so I'm just I'm I'm out of the loop. I'm not, I mean, I'm gonna I'm the first to admit Shakespeare is not my um my forte, but uh I've learned more about Shakespeare from you know being with you and you writing the series than I ever knew from school or anything, but uh blow the salt, I did no, I didn't know I didn't like it at all.
Ellie AlexanderCome on, that's amazing for who this is.
Tech GuyNo, it was just I I didn't think that like because with my my background in advertising and marketing, I immediately started thinking of like logos and and you know, merch and things like that that you know we could advertise it. And below the salt, I just I was like that, I don't I don't even know what like just there'd be just this cloud of it's the salt's coming at you, look out. Like it's just like I and the the first thing that comes to mind is like a sandstorm or something.
Ellie AlexanderSo but I'm I could have been flown, so yeah. Uh with murder, yeah.
Tech GuyBut when you when you came up with tort, that was yeah, that was it. It was like because it that I mean that goes back to the the whole brainstorming thing, right? Is that you knew when you when you thought of that, you knew that that was it, right?
Ellie AlexanderInstantly, yeah. When you learn something like that, it you just yeah, then it all comes together. Yeah. Um, so there was a lot of that. That was a lot of and a lot. We're still talking within two weeks. And obviously, what I wrote initially in that pitch morphed over time once I actually like signed the contract and then began writing the books. But um, I had to be able to build that world pretty quickly and to also think of a three-book arc. Um, usually, especially then, I was new in my career, I was never anticipating, as of this first podcast, um, I'm writing book 20 in this series.
Ellie AlexanderI never was anticipating, I would have been thrilled just to have it go three books at that point in time. So um I had ideas basically through that point and then um a few sketches of what could happen. But um, that leads me to, and this is a spoiler. Do we need some kind of like sound for a spoiler? Do you think?
Tech GuyI mean, I have a lot of sounds, but um um I don't know if like yeah, we could come up with yeah, I don't know.
Ellie AlexanderYes, yes. It's still going. Yeah. Yeah, I like that. Okay, so that you will now know, listeners, that there are spoilers coming. Okay, so this is the first big spoiler, which is, and I think this was a product of needing to write something quickly to get it out. Um, because what happened is after I did that in two weeks and sent that package to my agent, he ended up selling it in like another week.
Ellie AlexanderAnd then it was off to the races and I was writing, writing, writing. Um, and then I had a lot more time to really think about like the world and the plot and everything. But Carlos, who is Jules' estranged husband in book one in Meet Your Baker, I had written the first three books so that she was leaving him on the ship. And by book three, she was never gonna see him again. It was done, it was over.
Tech GuyVery sad.
Ellie AlexanderSo sad. I had I had an entirely different vision for who she was gonna end up with, and I'm sure her longtime readers will have some guesses as to obvious, yeah. Is it?
Tech GuyYeah, I think so.
Ellie AlexanderWhat's obvious?
Tech GuySo what the the other option. Yeah, if it wasn't Carlos, who the other option was, you know, yeah.
Ellie AlexanderCome on, I get more reader mail about that arc than probably anything else.
Tech GuyRight. I mean, because there was like for a long time, right? Early on, there were two teams. Uh, you know, like we and we can't I mean No, we can because we're spoiling. Okay, we did the dark. There was team, there was Team Carlos and there was Team Thomps. Yeah. And they and it got ugly. I I'm not gonna say it. Like it was it was a little uh it was ugly, ugly. Like it was a little like New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, uh Steelers, Browns, like it was it was your Steelers, Ravens, like I don't know, I'm a Steelers fan, so we've got a lot of lot of rivals.
Tech GuyIt got ugly. Like the two teams they battled it out.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, yeah. And that was also really cool at the time. Like I was kind of stunned by it. I wasn't anticipating that, and I hadn't written the I hadn't planned on writing it for like setting up this idea of Team Thomas versus Team Carlos. And so that just sort of happened organically. And then the first few big book events that we threw, and we'll have to do a whole podcast just on those because those were epic back in the day. Um people would show up with like Team Thomas t-shirts on and everything.
Ellie AlexanderI know it's like what?
Tech GuyOr or like not so subtly threaten you of like, yeah, jewels better not end up with Carlos or tools better not end up with Thomas, and it was just like, whoa, we easy bear. This is just like mystery series, like I don't know. Um they people were passionate about it. Let's just say that they were passionate.
Ellie AlexanderWhich, how can you not love that passion? Like, I have never cared about um, you know, being famous or anything like that. But if somebody like I have created something in my mind that someone else feels that passionately about, like that to me is the ultimate gift forever. Like, however, there were there was remember the reader who brought like pages and pages of notes of yes, what the thought might happen if I if I send jewels in the wrong direction.
Ellie AlexanderIt was it was a little intense, let's just say.
Tech GuyYeah, that was a lot. That was a lot. That was when we decided that maybe it wasn't such a good idea for people to know your home address.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, yeah. There's like more than a little nugget of truth to that, but also like completely awesome that people are like, I'm all in, I am all in. Um, and then also um feeling a little bit of fear myself of like, oh no, I am going to, because it was really divided. I think it still is. Um, I am potentially going to really make an entire group of readers very angry with whatever path Jules ends up taking.
Tech GuyRight, right. Well, and we talked about that because the you know, I mean, you you and I talked about that a lot because, you know, as you mentioned, this was early on in your writing career, and it's you know, I I think you might have had like five books or maybe six books out in the world at that point. Um, so you know, nothing compared to what you do now. But we I mean, we were am probably a little naively like worried that you were suddenly gonna lose like thousands of readers because of this one choice.
Tech GuyAnd it like we're probably blowing it actually in hindsight. Oh, we we blew it a lot out of proportion, but definitely but it but you know it is funny, and and and we'll get into more of that, like I guess, in in later episodes, just about like kind of the growth of just our knowledge of the industry and and you know that that sort of thing. But that that was I remember at the time just we debated that for a long like that was a lot of like dinners and everything of just talking uh about what might happen if you chose the the wrong way.
Ellie AlexanderThe wrong patch.
Tech GuyTo some readers, you know, others would be like, woohoo. But uh, but then there'd be others that'd be like, get the pitchforks, you know, like yes.
Ellie AlexanderYeah. And ultimately, um, I think that decision, maybe more than anything else that I've made in my writing career, really um like set the path for how I approach my writing. And even when I say this now, it still feels so cheesy, but it's true. Like, I really thought Carlos was gonna, that arc was gonna end at the end of book three. And that, you know, there wouldn't, there wouldn't be a ton of animosity. I wasn't thinking anything like that.
Ellie AlexanderLike they just they they had this intense love affair on the cruise line, and and he had the secret that really sent her reeling and ultimately sent her back to Ashland, which was was my whole goal with that, right? I it was just a plot device to get her back to Ashland.
unknownYeah.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, exactly. Because her story was really about finding home early on.
unknownYeah.
Ellie AlexanderUm, and so I had that in my head the whole time. And then every time I would sit down to write something, it would be like Carlos would just be like, hola, you know, yeah, I'm back. Here I am again.
Tech GuyHow many pictures of like hot shirtless mint you have hanging on the wall?
Ellie AlexanderI was trying to find all of my I'd love, yeah.
Tech GuyI exactly. I'd love, I'd love to hear from readers. Like if this if the tables were turned and I was writing a book and I just had like scantily clad women hanging all over my office, that would not fly. I have a feeling that would not fly.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, totally unacceptable. This is art. This is trying to get into a character's head space.
Tech GuyThis is this is the author. That's what I heard so many days. This is the author's process. I go I have to do it. What are you talking about, Carlos? I have to be able to see this imagery.
Ellie AlexanderExactly.
Tech GuyYeah.
Ellie AlexanderBut in general, what I do think that for sure. For sure. I I agree. I agree. Um, go ahead. You should write like something, you know, thriller-esque and you know, put up a bikini babe in your office and and I'll come in and rip her neck.
unknownYeah.
Ellie AlexanderUm, but no, what I think that process taught me was to um just trust the creative flow. Um, because then it really, and I think if you go back and read the early books, I never go back and read them, but I'm sure you see you could probably believe that Juliet was planning to go down this path with Thomas, right? Um, and then as I got to know the characters better, as they did like take up more space in my head, I would plot out.
Ellie AlexanderI know with book four, five, and six, I would plot out these stories that he wasn't in, and then it would be like, oh, nope, I'm riding away. And here he is, he's showing up again. Um, but I think it's made the story so much richer. There are um so many things that I've been able to develop with her. It it's like the characters do at some point in time take over, and that's amazing.
Tech GuyYeah, totally. I mean, it was it was really cool to see the um the the kind of whole process and how it played out. Because yeah, I mean, you did, and and I don't think like even longtime readers don't you don't understand like how much uh angst went into that decision, even when even when it came to you and you're like, of course, this is the story, this is why, but you like there was just a lot of like second guessing, I guess, that that you know went on um in terms of trying to make sure you were finding the right, the right path for jewels.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, totally. Um, yeah, and it's just a good reminder of like if you if you just sink into the process of writing, and this is true for anyone who, you know, who might be listening who's writing themselves, um, the story always like finds its way through. Not that you also don't want to have some sort of plans and visions, which I always do, um, but letting that be malleable a little bit and like giving yourself room to change things as you go.
Tech GuyRight. Well, and that's the whole point of this episode, right? Is that you had those visions and they changed. Um, yeah. You wanna um can we talk about um uh the next one? Um that involves okay, okay.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Um, I think we need another spoiler sound here though for that. This is gonna be another spoiler. Okay.
Tech GuyUm, how about uh okay, I like it.
Ellie AlexanderOkay, so this is just a spoiler for book one. Um book one is Meet Your Baker, and I had written the entire book, felt great about it, had a fantastic motive for the killer, understood the killer's motivation, how it had all come together. I was working on the third draft of the book, and I suddenly realized I love the killer, and I want the killer to be an ongoing person in this series.
Ellie AlexanderWho is the killer? Do you want to reveal or should I? Yeah, you can reveal.
Tech GuyYeah. Sterling.
Ellie AlexanderSterling.
Tech GuyYeah, who knew?
Ellie AlexanderWho knows?
Tech GuyIn the span of a couple of weeks, he went from being a uh a murderous scoundrel to like one of the most loved characters in the entire series. I still get so quite the quite the turnaround.
unknownYeah.
Ellie AlexanderQuite the turnaround, yeah. And I still to this day get so many lovely messages, DMs, emails about Sterling, and who's my inspiration for him and how people want a real Sterling in their life. Like that would have been so bananas. Why, why, why, why did I think that?
Tech GuyYeah, that one uh um that would have been interesting too. That that would have been almost as interesting as uh I mean, he hadn't um he hadn't quite been around or been as involved as uh Carlos or Thomas, but but it still would have been interesting to see the reader reaction had he ended up being the fill in that one.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, exactly. Yeah, and then it was so much work to have to go back and rewrite the entire book to change it. To still he was still a suspect in book one, um, but I had to change so much because the way that I had penned him the first time around obviously did not line up with the character that he became.
Tech GuyYeah, that that actually is um that's a good point because that took a lot of uh rereads and rewrites and the everything to catch all that stuff. Um, because once you go down one path, uh going back and catching all of the all of the pieces that um you need to remove or change in order to go with the story that you ended up, you know, the path that you ended up choosing, that that is tough. Um, it's tough to catch all that stuff.
Ellie AlexanderYeah, yeah, I know. Um, all right. Should we segue and talk about Sloan a little bit?
Tech GuyYeah, yeah. Leavenworth.
Ellie AlexanderLeavenworth.
Tech GuyWow, yeah.
Ellie AlexanderI know. We're gonna be there in a few weeks.
Tech GuyYeah.
Ellie AlexanderA month or so? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Uh yeah. So originally I had had this idea for this beer series, and I had pitched it to my agent, and he was like, I can't sell beer, can't do it.
Tech GuyNo, ridiculous.
Ellie AlexanderRidiculous. Um, and you were homebrewing at the time, so that was already like in my head. But that series originally was gonna be set in Portland.
Tech GuyRight, right.
Ellie AlexanderAnd I think I'd also talked about Bend. I have all these notes about Bend too.
Tech GuyWell, at the time, and they still are to a certain extent, but at the time, like Portland and Bend were like the center of the craft beer world, um, you know, for the at least for the Pacific Northwest. And so um, it made sense to set it in one of those places. But then then you started thinking about like Portland and Bend are pretty big cities um in comparison to the kind of tight-knit village atmosphere they wanted to create.
Ellie AlexanderAnd then we went to Leavenworth for Oktoberfest. And for a book event not related, I was doing a signing for my other series, and I was like, oh my gosh, no, it has to be here.
Tech GuyYeah, we were immediately like, this is it, this is it. And so, yeah, we went from a city with what Portland at the time was, I don't know, close to a million people with the the surrounding area, and Ben was probably a hundred thousand, and then the 120,000, and Leavenworth is 2,000.
Ellie Alexander2,000 residents.
Tech GuySo I mean, they have huge festivals. They they get what over a million tourists a year. But the the full-time residence in Leavenworth, it's like 2,000, to 2,000 or 2,500, something. It's very, very small.
Ellie AlexanderTiny, tiny. Uh well, the one um plot uh idea that definitely, or this is a name idea again to start with, that definitely did not make the cut is the brewery that our that Sloan Krause ends up working for is nitro in the book. And we brainstormed this together a lot. But the note that I have um that I was desperate to keep originally the brewery I wanted to call Bruins Brewing.
Tech GuyYeah.
Ellie AlexanderDo you remember that?
Tech GuyIt's that alliteration again. It's like I know. I'm like, holy crap, not everything needs to arrive. Can we just get like plus I made the case that tort being a one word, one syllable name, like it was just perfect.
Ellie AlexanderIt's clean.
Tech GuyIt's clean. Yeah, it instantly gives you that visual of like a really high-end uh pastry, you know, face shop type um uh um setting. Sorry, couldn't think of the word. Um, and uh and I thought that was great. And so I felt like we needed the same thing for this, um, it rather than Bruins Brewing.
Ellie AlexanderAnd the reason I wanted that is because our good friend Erica, who was doing a lot of marketing and everything for me in the early days, her youngest son was Bruin, and he was just this wild child, and I was like so inspired by yeah, he was not brewing, obviously, but he was like Bruins brewing. Yeah, that didn't get.
Tech GuyHe could have been.
Ellie AlexanderI don't I don't think it would have worked.
Tech GuyTotally, yeah. No, I mean it uh um yeah, that was do you have other do because you had more than just that as uh name ideas. Do you have other ideas still written down?
Ellie AlexanderI have so many ideas still written down for that. Um, and they're all terrible, they're all just really like, yeah. Um taps on flow? What?
Tech GuyThey just kept getting longer, too. That's the thing I don't understand. I'm it did go the other way, like, yeah.
Ellie AlexanderAnd what does that even mean? Taps on flow?
Tech GuyYeah, taps flow, but they hopefully there's a glass under them. So yeah.
Ellie AlexanderThis goes back to the no bad ideas, though, because that ultimately led to nitro. Um, and I think that came out came about because we were out having a beer somewhere talking about the series, and you got something on nitro. Yeah, I was and I was like, that's it. Yeah, yeah.
Tech GuyYeah, it was uh like it was winter at the time, I think. And it was like I think so, yeah. That was on nitro. I was very smooth.
Ellie AlexanderIt's perfect, yeah.
Tech GuyUm and that was that was yeah, because we said uh I remember just like drinking that and going, oh, this is smooth. And and we started talking about what makes it smooth. And I was talking about the difference between uh um uh nitrogen and carbon dioxide and how the nitrogen bubbles are so much smaller, like they're just so much smaller than um the carbon dioxide bubbles. So when when you use nitrogen to um uh to um when you add nitrogen to a beer uh uh to carbonate it instead of carbon dioxide, um it the carbonation is very uh drinks a lot smoother than it does with a um uh with the carbon dioxide.
Tech GuyBut we we were talking about it and and that's when you were like, nitro, what about what if we did nitro? And so we were both like, yeah, that sounds great. And that's it's perfect. Um there it was.
Ellie AlexanderYeah. Um, okay, these next two are also related to Sloan, and they're they're like spoiler adjacent. I don't think it's gonna matter, so I don't think we need a sound effect for them. Um, because they're things that just like they would make sense, but they didn't come to fruition and they're not spoiling anything per se. So the first thing um that I had a whole stack of notes and plot points on was that so Sloan goes to work for Garrett at Nitro. He's starting this small startup nana brewery, right?
Ellie AlexanderAnd um, she had been working for years at Dirkeller, which is her soon-to-be ex-husband, Mac, his family brewery. Um, and Mac wants her back. Um, we learn in book one that he's shagging the beer wench, and that's what sends Sloan packing, and she's done with him. Um, so I had this whole plot point that throughout the series, Mac was constantly going to be sabotaging nitro. I don't think I don't even know if we ever talked about that.
Tech GuyUm that this is like that does not ring a bell.
Ellie AlexanderYeah. Um, he was gonna be like sneaking in at night and like disconnecting hoses and like stealing that remote.
Tech GuyA bunch of illegal stuff. Yeah.
Ellie AlexanderYeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Tech GuyOkay.
Ellie AlexanderUm, and I had that charted out for like the first five books that it in each book. And he wouldn't, he was never gonna be a suspect for murder, but it was always gonna be there was gonna be something shady that he was doing. And then um, as I started writing the first book and got to know him and the characters more, same thing, I realized like, no, he's gonna have a growth arc too. And I wanted him and Sloan to um co-parent together. There were all these great things about him as a character, too. Like they weren't right for each other anymore, but he's not just an asshole.
Ellie AlexanderHe's not a terrible guy. Um, he's made some really bad choices, and there's a reason for that. But Sloan is also like she's sort of gone along with this marriage for the wrong reasons, too. So there's a lot of growth for both of them. Um, and then it also just maybe seemed, I don't know, a little bit too campy too. So I think I just ditched that.
Tech GuyRight, right.
Ellie AlexanderPlus could have been fun.
Tech GuyIt's sad to see somebody ruin a lot of good beer.
Ellie AlexanderOh, see, I did not think about that.
Tech GuyYeah. Yeah. That would have been very sad.
Ellie AlexanderI did have, I did have one note, and you know, you know how this came up. We had um, we had a beer fridge in our basement at our old house.
Tech GuyThis is terrible, terrible.
Ellie AlexanderAnd you would brew little small batches, and so we would have it on tap in the basement, and our niece came for a visit. Do you want to jump in and share the rest of the story?
Tech GuyWell, I wasn't there. I was actually with your your dad and brother, I think, at a game down in Eugene. But um, but I remember hearing the the sultan uh secondhand. It was it was awful. So she was how old do you think she was at the time?
Ellie AlexanderThree.
Tech GuyThree, yeah, three, four.
Ellie AlexanderThree, four, something like that.
Tech GuySomething like that. Um, and so uh you and your sister and Heather, our sister-in-law, was um were watching the game on TV, and Mackenzie, our niece, had like wandered out of the family room into the second kitchen we had on the in the basement there and and um pulled one of the taps. And I had I hadn't replaced it yet. I had two taps, uh, one that was auto-close.
Tech GuySo when you pulled it, you just let it go and it would close, you know, to avoid situations like this. Unfortunately, she pulled the other one, which is not auto-close, no, and left it going and then went in back to show the three of you. Look what I did, guys. Come see what I did, guys. Come see what I did, guys. Come see what I did. And there were somewhere between three and five gallons of beer on on all over the floor. I had just been spewing out of that tap. So that tap was flowing.
Tech GuyIt was flowing.
Ellie AlexanderTaps of flowing. Taps of flowing, taps of flowing. Uh so I had written this scene where Mac had snuck into nitro late at night and hit all the taps and like flooded the whole bar, right?
Tech GuyYeah, tragic.
Ellie AlexanderHe could have died from that.
Tech GuyI know.
Ellie AlexanderYeah. So that did not make the cut.
Tech GuyOkay, kid. I'm glad that would have been yeah. I would, I I I don't have much editorial say in what you write, but that I would have I would have played my played my chip there.
Ellie AlexanderThat's right. No, you cannot murder the beer.
Tech GuyMurder people, but not beer. Yeah.
unknownYeah.
Ellie AlexanderExactly. Um, and then there's one other plot point for the Sloane Cross series that I had in mind. And this kind of goes back to the whole Carlos thing. So Sloane is very close to her brother-in-law, Hans. Um, and we we know that from day one. And I had had this vision. Um just didn't have pictures. Yeah, exactly. Uh-huh. It's true. Um, I had had a vision that at some point farther into the series, that Sloan and Hans might end up together.
Ellie AlexanderUh, and I think you can kind of pick up again, kind of like Carlos. I think you can kind of pick up a little tiny hint of that, maybe in the first couple of books. And then again, I realized, no, that's not right. Like she she's a foster, a former foster child. Like her whole arc is about family and creating her own family and and recognizing that she's done that herself. And he's such a brother to her that um that just felt wrong. And then that would have added, I mean, I guess from a writing perspective, this is good, but that would have added so much tension in the family dynamic with Mac and Hans and yeah.
Tech GuySo that would have been uh pretty much crosses a line. I I don't know. Like you if you can't really get together with your brother's ex-wife. I I I'm uh well, I mean, maybe in real life, but like in the cozy mystery world, I think that it's gotta cross like several lines of bad stuff that you you can't do, right?
Ellie AlexanderWell, there's still time. I don't know. We'll see. Yeah.
Tech GuyThat's yeah, that would have been a rough one.
Ellie AlexanderI got axed too. Yeah.
Tech GuyYeah.
Ellie AlexanderI know, but it's so fun to think back through all of those, like, it's like, you know, thinking about the multiverse. Like, there are all these possible book ideas that could have happened, and any of these that we've discussed today would have radically altered the path for both of these series, I feel like.
Tech GuyYeah, yeah. Well, and you've actually had readers suggest that too. Like, you should go back and write it, like the alternate version where you chose all this stuff. And I was like, uh, I mean, it's kind of cool, but I that the problem with that is that it would get people would mix up the books, and then it would be like new readers to the series might get like version like books one and two would be version A, and then book three, they picked version B on accident, and they have no idea what's going on.
Ellie AlexanderRight, they're completely lost.
Tech GuyLike, wait, who is this person? And like I thought that guy wasn't the killer, but now he is. I don't know what's happening.
Ellie AlexanderSo, yeah, yeah. No, I feel like it's all worked out the way it was meant to be.
Tech GuyYeah, definitely.
Ellie AlexanderUsually in spite of my own initial bad ideas.
Tech GuyCaps of flowing and gooseberry what?
Ellie AlexanderGooseberry tart, uh, gooseberry fool.
Tech GuyGooseberry fool. Gooseberry fool, yeah. So so all all you listeners out there, we we have the tort bait shop and the nitro craft brewery, or we could have had the gooseberry fool bait shop and the um taps of flow and craft brewery.
Ellie AlexanderSomething to think about.
Tech GuyI think you I think you chose the right path. That's my that's my opinion.
Ellie AlexanderOkay, all right, bye. Uh well, that seems like a good place to end our uh our first episode on that note, yeah?
Tech GuyYeah, yeah, this is fun. Um, I can't wait for more topics. We've got a lot uh coming up, a lot of peaks behind the curtain. Um, and we're gonna be taking suggestions from people as well. So uh I can't wait to get back at it with another episode.
Ellie AlexanderI know, it's gonna be great. And if you have a better thought for listeners, dark horses, etc. We'll come up with some suggestions for the next one. I like it.
Send us a message! In this episode, The Tech Guy and I share the strategies I’ve built over years of writing through the holiday season, including a stretch when I had books releasing each year just two days after...
Send us a message! “How do you come up with so many ideas?” This is the question I probably get asked the most by writers and readers. The answer might surprise you, because my problem is usually having too many ideas....
Send us a message! It's never too early to start your holiday reads, darlings, so The Tech Guy and I are each sharing six books on our respective holiday TBR stacks. A few are favorite rereads, several are brand-new to...
Send us a message! The Ashland Mystery Fest just wrapped its fourth year, and The Tech Guy and I are still riding high while we recap all of it for you. We talk through our favorite moments like the hilarious and...
Send us a message! This episode opens with an excerpt from A Murder at Midnight, book four in the Novel Detectives, releasing October 13th. Then The Tech Guy and I discuss the book, spoiler-free, of course. When a...