Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Reality Writes

Reality Writes artwork

Where Do Your Ideas Come From?—Inside a Writer’s Process

Nov 12, 202629 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us a message! “How do you come up with so many ideas?” This is the question I probably get asked the most by writers and readers. The answer might surprise you, because my problem is usually having too many ideas. In this episode, The Tech Guy and I go behind the scenes on where story ideas actually come from, why I have stacks of notebooks (no one will ever stop me from using pen and paper!), and the most important thing I do the moment an idea pops into my head. I share how one idea sat for years before eventually becoming a book, why movement and travel help generate some of my best thinking, and touch on some of the mistakes I see new writers make in this area. And, last but certainly not least, we talk about readers who love to weigh in with their murder suggestions. 😱 We'd love to hear from the writers out there. Where do your best ideas come from? Send us a message! 🎉 Join me on Patreon for bonus content. Website Instagram YouTube TikTok Etsy Bookbub Facebook

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Ellie AlexanderHello, hello, hello, and welcome to another episode of Reality Writes. I am author Ellie Alexander. This is the podcast where we talk about all things bookish, writer-ish, and whatever else is on our mind. And as always, I am here with the Tech Guy.

Tech GuyHello, hello. Back at it again. Uh fun topic this week.

Ellie AlexanderYeah, we're gonna talk about ideas. Ideas, ideas, and more ideas is the theme of this week's podcast. And hopefully, for all of you darlings, whether you're writers, readers, or both, like many of us are, we will be able to share some mistakes that I find new writers often make when it comes to ideas, how I come up with ideas, and um pretty much everything about how a seed of a little idea turns into an actual book.

Tech GuyBecause you only get one idea at a time, right?

Ellie AlexanderOnly one, yep. My brain just is like, here, I'm gonna dish this out. You get one little tiny piece of candy and then wait for another three years and I'll give you another one.

Tech GuyRight, right. No, but this is something that you get asked all the time.

Ellie AlexanderI would say I get asked this most frequently. In fact, I was just doing an event last week, and inevitably a reader was like, Hey, I'm just so curious, how in the world do you come up with so many ideas? And are you constantly stuck trying to figure out new book ideas? And for me, the opposite is always true. I have way too many ideas taking up space in my head.

Tech GuyYeah, that that is something that we talk about a lot, actually, and have covered here on Reality Writes, but this is this is because it is a question that comes up all the time, it is important to cover again. And and that is that you have notebooks and notebooks and notebooks of ideas that are always coming up.

Ellie AlexanderFor uh any darlings that are listening, this is just oh wait, wait, there are two more. They're just hiding in my stack, as well as like sticky notes. This is all just next to my desk, a lovely little stack of notebooks, all of which have some variation of ideas within them, whether that is notes on the story that I am currently writing that I want to change when I'm in the editing process or notes about future book ideas. There is never a shortage of notebooks of ridiculous notes on my phone when I go into the notes app where I have like 27 different notes.

Ellie AlexanderI try to categorize it and be like, okay, these are for Jules, this is for Annie, this is for you know, whatever future book I'm working on, but inevitably they all just get mixed up. And then when I'm going to work on a book, I'm like, wait, what does that mean? Like, who was that for?

Tech GuyBut but talk about how ideas evolve because the you come up with a bunch of ideas, and sometimes, like you just described, they are maybe nuggets of a story, and other times it's the full meal deal. Uh, you come up with the entire uh plot of a book and and and then everything in between.

Ellie AlexanderYeah, I mean, I think there's sort of like an evolution to ideas. And so one example that comes to mind is my new cozy spy thriller that's coming out, Murder Moves In. This is coming out next January, January of 2027. And that started with really just like a nugget of an idea over a decade ago. And I put it in a notebook and I wrote down that first thought, which was really based on the interaction that I had with a neighbor. And I came home and you and I were like, oh my gosh, like this is so much potential for a story.

Ellie AlexanderSo I maybe wrote, I don't know, two, three paragraphs of that nugget of an idea, basically. And then that sat in a notebook like this on my desk in closets at various points in time, and I did nothing with it. I just like, I do think, especially for any new writers out there, it's important to take these out of your head. That's what I've learned. And that's why I have stacks of notebooks and a ridiculous list of notes in my notes app, because otherwise, what I will find is I will just try to keep spinning on that idea when it's not ready.

Ellie AlexanderIt's just that little hint, that spark of something that then needs to sit and wait for a little while.

Tech GuyYeah, and because you mentioned a notes app, I'm going to interject with some tech guy uh maybe tips for the writers out there. You know, storing notes in notebooks is great and writing them down is great. Um, searching for those notes at a later time is a little tedious then. Um so if you like to, and hey, if you want to use a pen, pencil, and a notebook and write write them down, that is awesome. But you can still take pictures of those pages and pull those into notes apps.

Tech GuyAnd there are so many notes apps out there that will uh through OCR optical character recognition, we'll be able to, you'll be able to search your notes very easily. So just a a tech guy tip there.

Ellie AlexanderYou are gonna have to pry my notebooks out of my cold dead hands. And look, I have a searchable way, I have little colored tabs, like darlings. For those of you who are listening to the podcast, I have a little yellow tab here. That's for Annie Murray. I have a little pink tab for Jules, I have a blue tab for new ideas.

Tech GuyYes, I know. This is a it is not uh for the darlings out there, this is something that I've been trying to like move Ellie toward forever, and it's not going to work. But I'm just saying for some writers out there, that might be a good strategy.

Ellie AlexanderNo, I love it in theory, and in my writers group, I have a couple writer friends who take notes on their iPad for that reason because then they can search them, they can categorize them. Like again, I love it in theory, but I have a process that works for me.

Tech GuyAnd that well, that but that's what's important, right? Is finding the process that does work for you. So there's nothing wrong with that.

Ellie AlexanderNo, there's nothing wrong with it. Okay, so I think the most important thing that I do from a writing perspective is this idea comes to mind. I have to put it somewhere because otherwise, I'm like I mentioned, I'm gonna spend hours perseverating on it, trying to think about what it is when I don't know yet. I just know that it's a potential story idea. So I have stacks of notebooks that those rest in. And then what happens is sometimes a month later, a few weeks later, I'm like, oh wow, this one really has legs.

Ellie AlexanderI would love to use this idea, let's say, in the next bake shop mystery. That's a little clearer cut, I feel like, if it's something that is related to a series that I'm already writing. But I still have stacks of ideas for future books for every series that I'm writing. If we're talking about something like Murder Moves In, this new mashup that's like kind of cozy, kind of spy, kind of thriller. It's got a little bit of everything. That just sat as a note for a while. And then it was like another five years before I was like, ooh, you know what?

Ellie AlexanderI'm I'm really feeling drawn to want to revisit that idea. And that kind of sparked because of another, while we were on a road trip, we've talked about this, where we were mapping things out, but there was also like this thing that happened in the neighborhood that kind of re-ignited my interest in that idea. And I kind of had some headspace where I was like, oh, I just I I'm not writing right now. So I want to, I want to noodle on this new idea. Um, and I think there's something to that, to letting new ideas have time to just simmer in the background if you're not sure what to do with it yet.

Tech GuyTo marinate.

Ellie AlexanderMarinate. Marinate.

Tech GuyJust to put it into bake shop uh lingo. Actually, you mentioning road trips is another important thing that, regardless of your note-taking uh technique or or you know, tools, or lack thereof, is that right?

Ellie AlexanderOr lack thereof. No, no, no.

Tech GuyRegardless of how you take notes for your ideas, make sure that you have that instrument or those instruments with you at all times, because an idea can strike anytime and anywhere. Um I just uh in fact, just yesterday, I remember I came running out of the shower on my towel and I said, Oh, I gotta take a note, I gotta take a note. You were like, What? I said, I mean notes in the shower. Halftime shower notes. Yeah. Yeah.

Ellie AlexanderI think you need to invent this. Who else wants shower notes? But I think there's that's true that a lot of times like the best ideas happen when we're not sitting in front of our computer. I talk about this all the time in our in my mystery series masterclass because I think you know, there's like different energy that comes when you're actually writing and drafting something or editing something versus just letting your creative energy run wild. And for me, ideas tend to happen when I'm out for a walk, when you and I are out for coffee. Yeah, when you're in the shower, when you're doing something where you usually don't have something on hand to take a note.

Tech GuyYeah. How many book ideas or series ideas do you think we have come up with on road trips alone over the years?

Ellie AlexanderI mean, I think on road trips it's gotta be at least a dozen, if not more. It might be a couple dozen because there are so many that are currently sitting in notebooks where we've sketched out, you know, like a pretty decent 10 to 12 page outline for a story or a series that I have not yet had time to write. And I do think there's something about that too. There's something about movement for me. I think that's why ideas tend to happen when I'm out for a walk, when I'm swimming, when I'm on a road trip, when I'm driving.

Ellie AlexanderLike, yeah, there's something about like the creative energy flowing that way.

Tech GuyBut we don't come up with all the ideas.

Ellie AlexanderWe do not come up with all the ideas. It's true. Let's talk about that. Tell me, what does that mean?

Tech GuyWell, that means that a lot of people that we know, which another way you could say it is literally everyone we know that's right, volunteers ideas all the time, all the time, and some of them are really good, some of them are out there.

Ellie AlexanderI know it's a mix, and the thing that I will say about the darlings in particular, and this really surprised me when I first started writing, I'm used to it now, but at least a few times a week I will get email from you, darlings, with murder suggestions. And I gotta tell you, you're scary.

Tech GuyYeah, I you know, it is funny the number of people over the years who have come up to you and said, Oh, Ellie, I have the best idea for you as to how to kill someone and get away with it. And I'm thinking, there are a lot of people out there thinking about murder all the time, and like putting a lot of energy into those plans, which is a little concerning. Some of you might need to scrub your browser histories.

Tech GuyThat's all I'm saying.

Ellie AlexanderThat's all you're saying. Just a word of caution. No, it's so great. I do think there's something collective about that that's so fun. And it's true. I mean, it's like I I remember one of the very first talks that I did when I came down to the Rogue Valley was at a big retirement community in Medford. Um, and it was so sweet because I had a line out the door. I thought for people wanting to have me sign books at the end of my talk, but no, everybody came and there were multiple sweet little um men and women, you know, like in their 90s and up that were like, I wrote a note for you, Ellie, about a way that you should kill someone here.

Ellie AlexanderSo it's always just too like yeah, you wonder.

Tech GuyI I don't know, living in a retirement community, there might be like I I think tensions can get a little hot sometimes, right?

Ellie AlexanderThere's some built-in drama and those sweet little grandmas, watch out. They they're taking notes. They they too have stacks of ideas, and they're like, Oh, there's a mystery writer in town. I'm gonna hook her up, which is really fun. Like, I love hearing ideas from readers uh because it does there's something just fun about the idea of oh, you finished one of my books, and now you're like, hmm, let me tell you, I've got an X I want you to off.

Tech GuyWell, and and and that's a good point. And I want to make sure that like we we're joking, you know, that like we love hearing the ideas. And that leads me into the next point that there are no bad ideas. Um, there, you know, even an idea that might not work at the time is something that could be reworked or might, after it marinates, might become something that that is is uh uh an idea for a book or or you know can be worked into the plot of an existing story later on, right?

Tech GuySo you want to keep track of those as well.

Ellie AlexanderYeah, this is something I talk about all the time when I'm coaching new writers, is there are no bad ideas, especially when you're in an early brainstorming creative flow like that. Every idea gets written down. Even if at the moment that it comes out, you're like, oh, I don't know, what am I gonna do with that? And we're gonna do like, I can't think of something. We're gonna murder someone with pickles. Are we? I well, okay, let's write that down because maybe the pickles then have been brined in some kind of poison. So actually, this is a great idea.

Ellie AlexanderI should write this down right now. A low bake shop, Jules is gonna make some kind of like delicious uh potato salad, and someone's gonna end up dead after they've sampled the potato salad because the killer snuck in and put poison in the brine. And now we also have no idea like what was the motive, not the motive, what was the method of murder? So yeah, I mean, you just you never want to discard an idea because it could lead you somewhere fantastic.

Ellie AlexanderIt could lead you nowhere, believe me. I have so many dead ends and then thoughts that were like, oh, that could be really cool. And then once you explore it a little further and you try to build a sketch or a plot around it, you realize, like, oh, that doesn't really have legs. But again, then there have been ideas where I think that initially. And one example of this is the Meg Reed Return, A Cozy Kind of Christmas, which came out last year.

Ellie AlexanderWe had sketched out this plot for another murder mystery. That was my very first mystery series. Meg, she's this bumbling journalist, if you're not familiar, darlings, who wants to be a New York Times investigative reporter but can't get a job. So she's writing for this extreme magazine. And we were in Bend for an event at Sun River Books, and we happened to be walking on the Deschutes, and we were like, oh my gosh, this would be a great way to force Meg to try her hand at surfing because there's this part of the river where you actually get to like practice surfing.

Ellie AlexanderThey've created like a little rapids, although it seems a lot more intense than someone starting out, right?

Tech GuyIt looks a little scary, honestly. Watching it, some of the some of the people practicing are very, very talented, and we've seen some epic wipeouts there too.

Ellie AlexanderYeah, and it was one of those epic wipeouts where I was like, oh, okay, I can imagine that Meg now, it's been 10 years, and now she has this social media following. She's a huge sensation on TikTok, and somehow she gets convinced to try this surfing thing, and then there's a murder that occurs. So that had been sitting in a notebook for a while, and I was like, yeah, I don't really think it has legs. I'm not sure that like the timing's gonna work to bring Meg back. And then when my publisher was like, hey, we would love to re-release all of the original titles, and in doing so, we would love for you to write another book.

Ellie AlexanderAnd I said, Well, gosh, you know, like I've had this idea for a while, but I'm not sure now that it's a murder. And so that evolved into this holiday rom-com. So I I had kind of written that idea off, and you just never know.

Tech GuyBut that that's another important point, I guess, is the impact of real-world events or or things that you come across and how that plays into ideas. So talk a little bit about that for writers and and how they should probably pay more attention. It it the act of coming up with ideas for books or plots or or or any elements of a story really involves kind of paying a little bit more attention to your surroundings and what's happening, right?

Ellie AlexanderYeah, which is another thing that I always love to do when I have some free time. And we were just traveling last week. And so I would write in the mornings and then I would go find another spot in the afternoons and bring my idea notebook and just kind of people watch and pay attention. And I just think that's such a rich way to start to develop ideas and whether that's like layering in the background of a story. So, like if we're thinking about the bake shop mysteries, for example, for those, let's say we're in Ashland, I'm thinking about like what's happening in Ashland.

Ellie AlexanderSo we were just there about a month ago. We obviously lived there for many years. Our son went all the way through school there. So, like every year in late October, there's this just like sweet, charming, wholesome small town homecoming parade where all of the kids at the school, all the different teams are making floats and they shut down Main Street and everybody like runs out from the businesses to watch and cheer them on. So I'm setting the next bake shop in late October, early November.

Ellie AlexanderAnd that's just gonna work in as sort of background color, but a way to really kind of like flesh out that world and bring in some real details. So then if you happen to be in Ashland in late October and it's homecoming, you're gonna be like, wait, the parade is real. I can go watch like the water polo team in their little pop-up pool on a flatbred truck. Like, that's so fun.

Tech GuyYeah, I love that parade. It's so much fun. What mistakes might new writers make when it comes to ideas?

Ellie AlexanderWho okay? Well, I think one of the first mistakes that a lot of new writers make is they get too attached to one idea. And so, or too attached to this has to be the idea. And what I've learned over the course of my writing career and writing almost 50 books now is that ideas do ebb and flow and change. And the more that you can lean into that and take the start of that idea, and then, like we've talked about, give it some time, see where it leads you, um, and not get so locked in in this like singular focus of okay, I have this one idea.

Ellie AlexanderI am going to let's think. Let's say I'm gonna send someone to the moon and on their way there, they're gonna get murdered in space. Oh, you should write this book. I'll work on pickles, you work on this. Okay.

Tech GuyOkay, got it.

Ellie AlexanderBut then you get a quarter of the way into that book and you realize I don't know anything about how space travel works. What is gravity like? How, how are they getting there? Is this a sci-fi? Like, you haven't done then any of the other work to help support where that idea leads. And specifically for a mystery, you need to do, especially for a first book, some serious plotting and planning in order to then let that idea run wild and flourish.

Ellie AlexanderBecause then I think what happens is with new writers in particular, you have this great idea and it's true. It's like, oh my gosh, yeah, I want to read that book. Like, how does the murder occur in space? All of those things. But you get, you know, past the first 20, 30 pages where you've got this fun, fresh idea. And then you're like, oh no, now what? And so I think then what happens is a lot of writers just stop writing because it's like, oh, I had this fun idea, but now I don't know what to do with it. Um, and if you spend a little more time planning and mapping that out and having a true sense of where you're going, then you're much more likely to keep writing past the point of the idea being fun and new and shiny.

Tech GuyUh, that makes sense. Um, do you want me to explain all that stuff right now? How space travel and everything? Because I can I can tell you all that. Okay, please.

Ellie AlexanderYeah, we need to know. And how can like would it be a gunshot in space?

Tech GuyThat's gonna kill the rest of the crew, like it would need to be a special kind of gun, but okay. Yeah. Yeah. Um we'll talk about this later. So I would say murdering somebody in space with a gun is a risky, risky maneuver because if the projectile were to go through the person and hit the exterior hole, you could kill yourself in the in the process. So just something to think about when it comes to murdering people in space. You know, if anybody, if you ever find yourself in that situation, just make sure you consider that before you try it.

Ellie AlexanderOr better yet, darling. Send us your ideas. Right.

Tech GuyRight. Exactly.

Ellie AlexanderBut see, this is kind of what can happen too, where it's like, oh, you we would have a fun conversation like this on a road trip where I'm like, oh my gosh, I should totally write that book. Like, we should write that together. And then that idea sits for a while. It's like, oh, okay, that's a great idea, but that's gonna take a lot of work and research that I am maybe not perfectly prime for. But hopefully then that idea goes out there into the ether. And whoever is meant to tell that story tells it.

Tech GuyAnd let me tell you, darlings, um, you've never been as uncomfortable as I have been driving a logging road in the backwoods of southern Oregon, sitting next to the murder mongress Ellie Alexander, and she just looks out the window and casually mentions, I could totally hide a body back here.

Ellie AlexanderRight.

Tech GuyI'm like, what? Like, oh great. Yeah. So yeah. Uh you just you just like look straight ahead and keep on going.

Ellie AlexanderYou just look straight ahead and keep on going. Well, and to circle back to the whole like real world piece of that, uh, you know, if we're talking about adding back background color into a story like the Homecoming Parade or um for my novel detective series, which is loosely based on Phyloli or inspired by Phyloli, and everything that I write about, let's say, for a Christmas novel that is in the novel detective's world, would be based on us going and walking the beautiful grounds and seeing all the lights and touring the historic mansion.

Ellie AlexanderSo there are all those layers that you can add in. But I do think there's a fine line, especially in writing cozy's. Now, this would not be true if you're writing a really like dark serial killer thriller or noir or anything that is like really like a modern mystery. But if we're talking cozy, there is a there's a firm line that I won't cross that is any sort of murder or crime that has occurred in real life, which makes me think about like driving the back roads of Ashland, right?

Ellie AlexanderWhere there was this long-running story of this guy who had gone missing and was thought to have like disappeared in the woods. And I remember for many years, especially early on before we were living in Ashland, readers would come up to me at the end of a book talk and say, like, hey, like this case is still unsolved. You can see the posters around town. I'm like, oh gosh, no, like I don't I don't want to touch that. I don't want any of that energy. I'm not writing true crime.

Tech GuyYeah. So that brings up another thing that I know that coaching clients and mystery series masterclass students of yours over the years have asked, and some have been concerned about, is, you know, the protection of their ideas. Like what worried about, you know, maybe people, other writers stealing their ideas or um, you know, their ideas showing up in the form of another book or maybe a TV show or something like that. Is that something that writers should be concerned about?

Ellie AlexanderI mean, obviously, I can only speak for myself. And my philosophy on this is absolutely not. I don't think you need to worry and be like uber protective of your ideas. And I have lots of writer friends who are, and they're superstitious about not just new writers, but professional writers who have long-running careers that don't like to talk about what they're writing about, which again, I understand. So this is personal to me, but I just have this firm belief that what we bring to the table ourselves is our own unique voice, our lens, our lived experiences is what we breathe life into, then with every story.

Ellie AlexanderAnd if you think about the scope of all of literature and television and movies and plays, like the themes are the same, right? And even with a murder mystery, like the themes are the same. Even if somebody kills someone the exact same way, or if I have a friend who writes a baking mystery that is set in Louisiana, that's gonna feel very different than my series that's set in Ashland and coming from my worldview. So I don't think you need to spend a lot of energy in terms of being really anxious and spun up about like, oh, I've got to just like hold tight and clench on to this idea.

Ellie AlexanderI think I always use the garden hose analogy, right? Where we want our creative energy to flow like the water through a garden hose. And when we start to like rest and get really anxious and everything, we're kinking it and we're shutting off that creative flow. So I I I'm fine with sharing ideas. I mean, we we already know from this podcast that there's gonna be a pickle murder and now there's gonna be a murder in space. So bring it on.

Tech GuyA very cautious murder in space.

Ellie AlexanderA very cautious murder in space, yeah.

Tech GuyYeah, for sure. Okay. Uh any other idea-related writing tips that you want to pass along to the darlings out there before we wrap it up today.

Ellie AlexanderI think just embrace whatever ideas come in, write them down, write them down, write them down, write them down, because you will also forget them. I promise you that. Even like some of the best ideas, if I don't write them down within a few days or weeks, they just sort of vanish into the ether. We'll be like, oh no, we had an idea for something. What was that? Yeah.

Tech GuyYeah. All right. Well, that about does it for this episode of Reality Writes. I'd love to hear from the darlings out there, especially writers with regard to ideas. Are you a pen and paper idea keeper or do you like to keep your ideas digitally? Let us know in the comments. And also if you've got any other questions for Ellie about ideas and how to keep them and catalog them and et cetera, just let us know. Uh use the send us the message link and uh we will get back to you.

Tech GuySo with that, I will say until next time.

Ellie AlexanderTill next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Protect Your Creative Time—Writing Through the Busiest Season

    Nov 19, 202630 minAudio

    Send us a message! In this episode, The Tech Guy and I share the strategies I’ve built over years of writing through the holiday season, including a stretch when I had books releasing each year just two days after...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Our Holiday TBR—From Cozy to Downright Creepy

    Nov 5, 202633 minAudio

    Send us a message! It's never too early to start your holiday reads, darlings, so The Tech Guy and I are each sharing six books on our respective holiday TBR stacks. A few are favorite rereads, several are brand-new to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Four Years of Mystery Fest—Highlights and What’s Next

    Oct 30, 202635 minAudio

    Send us a message! The Ashland Mystery Fest just wrapped its fourth year, and The Tech Guy and I are still riding high while we recap all of it for you. We talk through our favorite moments like the hilarious and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Inside A Murder at Midnight—A Spoiler-Free Sneak Peek

    Oct 1, 202631 minAudio

    Send us a message! This episode opens with an excerpt from A Murder at Midnight, book four in the Novel Detectives, releasing October 13th. Then The Tech Guy and I discuss the book, spoiler-free, of course. When a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How an Audiobook Gets Made—Inside Narration With Victoria Lynn Arbor

    Sep 24, 202641 minAudio

    Send us a message! Have you ever wondered what actually goes into making an audiobook? If so, you're in luck because this week I'm joined by my friend Victoria Lynn Arbor, a professional audiobook narrator. We talk...

    Credit the people on this episode