97 | The Great Coram Street Murder: The Unsolved True Crime Case of Harriet Buswell
19 minAudio
On Christmas Day 1872, the body of 31-year-old Harriet Buswell was discovered in a Bloomsbury lodging house, her throat brutally cut inside a locked room. As detectives reconstructed her final hours, conflicting witness statements and rumours of a mysterious ‘German gentleman’ sent the investigation spiralling in the wrong direction. In this episode, we examine this baffling unsolved case that bears striking similarities to the later Jack the Ripper murders, and the tragic story of a young woman whose killer was never found. 📘 My latest book: Wartime London's 'Bonnie and Clyde': The Crime Spree of Betty Jones and Karl Hulten https://www.pen-and-sword.co.uk/Wartime-Londons-Bonnie-and-Clyde-The-Crime-Spree-of-Betty-Jones-and-Karl-Hulten-Hardback/p/57334 📺 Subscribe for video versions: https://youtube.com/@prashsmurdermap 💡 Support my work Patreon (audio-only ad-free episodes): https://www.patreon.com/prashsmurdermap Buy me a coffee: https://ko-fi.com/prashsmurdermap PayPal: https://www.paypal.me/prashsmurdermap 🙏 Thank you for listening. Your support helps keep Prash's Murder Map going and is very much appreciated. Music: Epidemic Sound "Long Note Three" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ "Long Note Two" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ "Unanswered Questions" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Sources: National Archives, Murder of Harriet Buswell at Great Coram Street MEPO 3/111 and 3/114 Birmingham Mail - Saturday 28 December 1872 Manchester Evening News - Wednesday 29 January 1873 Tromp, Marlene. “A Priori: Harriet Buswell and Unsolved Murder Before Jack the Ripper, 24-25 December 1872.” BRANCH: Britain, Representation and Nineteenth-Century History. Ed. Dino Franco Felluga. Extension of Romanticism and Victorianism on the Net. Web.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1It was Christmas Day eighteen seventy two. As family celebrated with loved ones and children sang carols. Beneath the glow of Victorian street lamps, a scene of horrific contrast was unfolding inside a rented room at twelve Great Koram Street in Bloomsbury. When the landlady, missus Wright, forced open the door, she discovered a murder scene that would later draw comparisons to the Jacknarriper killings committed sixteen years later. Yet somehow
Speaker 1nobody in the house had heard a thing hello and welcomed a Pressure's murder map. Before we begin, I'd like to quickly say they welcome to all the subscribers who've joined me recently, and thank you to everyone who has
Speaker 1been supporting the show by listening, commenting, leaving me a thumbs up or writing a review. Many of you also know that my wife and I recently had a true crime book published called Wartime London's Bonnie and Clyde The Crime Spree of Betty Jones and Carl Holton. It's the first comprehensive expiration of the nineteen forty four Cleft Chin murder, which reveals new information about the killers, victims and what happened afterwards. We also had the privilege of tracing and speaking to Betty Jones's surviving daughter, so we have been
Speaker 1able to share details of her life after prison for the very first time. It's available as a hardback or an ebook from Amazon and Waterstones. Thank you for your support. Harriet Buswell was born in eighteen forty one in Wisbeach, Cambridgeshire. She had three sisters and a brother named Henry, who worked at the antique in society at Somerset House. Harriet was unmarried but had a daughter with a man named Burton,
Speaker 1and she sometimes went by the alias Clara Burton. She lived on the margins of society in Victorian London, dreaming of becoming a dancer or appearing on stage, and was a regular at the Alhambra Music Hall in Leicester Square. Bar maids there remembered her drinking whiskey several times a week, though she was rarely seen intoxicated. Behind the glamour she hoped for, Harriet was struggling financially. She had been pawning
Speaker 1her belongings to keep up with debts owed to tradesman a lawn dress and the woman who cared for her eight year old daughter. The strain had become so great that Harriet had turned a prostitution to supplement her income. She had lodged in King's Cross for two years, but moved out following an argument with her landlady, and at the time of her death had been lodging at twelve Great Korham Street, near Russell Square for four weeks. Harriet's
Speaker 1daughter was due to visit on Christmas Day, so when Harriet failed to come downstairs before noon, her landlady, missus Wright, became concerned. She went up to the room and knocked repeatedly, but there was no answer. She fetched her son and they forced the door open, revealing a scene of shocking violence. Blood was splashed across the walls and Harriet was sprawled across the end of the bed, her throat cut and
Speaker 1her body twisted. As Harriet's parents were no longer living, it was her brother Henry who was called to identify the body. Inspector James Thompson, an experienced detective and superintendent of the local police division, was placed in charge of the investigation. He observed that Harriet's body was drawn up as though she had died in convulsions of agony. The fatal wound ran from beneath the left ear along the
Speaker 1side of the neck, and was described in one report as large enough to put a man's fist into. There was a bloody thumbprint on Harriet's forehead and a palm mark lower down, suggesting that she had been held down after the first injury while a second cut was inflicted. The pillows were saturated with blood, with several drops on the floor. Near the washstand in one corner of the room was a large bucket filled with blood tinged to water,
Speaker 1apparently left behind after the killer tempted to wash himself clean. A towel hanging by the washstand bore marks consistent with a knife having been wiped on it. On a small table was an apple with a single bite taken from it. This was a miner but in intriguing detail, as the post mortem found that Harriet's stomach contained food from the final meal she had eaten, but no trace of apple, raising the possibility that it was a killer who had
Speaker 1taken the bite. Most puzzling of all, the killer had locked the bedroom door behind him and taken the key, yet no trace of blood could be found on the handle or the frame, even if he had washed his hands. Police thought it was strange there were no visible marks given a level of bloodshed within the room. The murder weapon appeared to have been removed by the killer. Police later recovered a knife that was considered a possible candidate,
Speaker 1but they were unable to prove a connection, and it remains unknown whether it was linked to the crime at all. Some reports claimed that Harriet's jewelry and purse had also been taken, though this was never officially confirmed. The ten other occupants of the lodging house were interviewed, but nobody had heard a shout, a struggle, or anything else unusual during the night. Detectives also began examining Harriet's wider circle of acquaintances and former companions. Among them were George Studdart,
Speaker 1a veterinary student who happened to be in Ireland at the time of the murder, and William Kirby, a former lover with whom Harriet had been in contact until a few months before her death. Officers made inquiries into both men, but neither could be linked to the crime, as Kirby was in China at the time, and Studdart was in Ireland. With very little evidence to work with, police began reconstructing Harriet Buswell's final movements. At around ten pm on Christmas Eve,
Speaker 1Harriet borrowed a shilling from a friend named Alice Nelson and left Great Koram Street for the Alhambra Music Hall in Leicester Square. The Alhambra was one of the most fashionable entertainment venues in London, a place where people gathered for music, drinking and late night company, as well as a spot where prostitutes could meet potential clients. Several witnesses had seen Harriet there, and one bar maid remembered her calling for whiskies and brandies during the evening, while others
Speaker 1claimed to have seen her dining in a restaurant with an unidentified man. A waiter named William Stalker described the man as dark haired and unshaven, with red spots or blotches on his face, while another witness believed he had spoken with a German accent. A local greengrocer later recalled Harriet entering his shop with a man matching the same description. According to the shopkeeper, she turned to him and said, my dear will you buy me some grapes? I shall
Speaker 1like some. The man bought an orange and apple and nuts instead, which were later found in Harriet's room. Witness statements indicated that Harriet return to her lodgings at Great Corn Street with the man some time after midnight. Missus Wright remembered seeing the man hurrying upstairs to Harriet's room on the second floor at the back of the house, while Harriet remained downstairs, talking briefly with missus Wright and her friend Alice Nelson. During the conversation, Harriet described him
Speaker 1as a very handsome German gentleman, and remarked that his accent was so strong she could barely understand him. She also mentioned that he had bought her fruit and nuts and given her half a sovereign, some of which she handed over towards the wrench she owed. A short time later, Harriet went upstairs to join him. He was the last time she was seen alive. The following morning, some time between six and seven a m. Missus Wright noticed the
Speaker 1man leaving the house. Another resident had also seen him walking calmly down the stairs with no obvious sign of panic. Yet, despite seeing him at close quarters, neither witness was able to describe him clearly. Investigators offered a reward of one hundred pounds and circulated notices in English, French and German, though in the press Harriet Boswell was inaccurately reported as being twenty five years old when she was actually thirty one.
Speaker 1Harriet was buried in Brompton Cemetery on thirty first of December eighteen seventy two, but the question surrounding her murder could not yet be put to rest. The case soon became tangled with conflicting witness statements, uncertain timings, and contradictory sightings of both Harriet and the man she had been with. Descriptions of the suspect varied, though most witnesses agreed he appeared to be in his mid twenties, of medium height,
Speaker 1with several days worth of stubble, a blotchy complexion, heavy boots, and dark shabby clothing. More than one witness believed he spoke with a German accent. The timeline was far less clear. Harriet had mentioned to her Landlady and Alice Nelson that she met the man after leaving now Hamborough and walking back through Russell's Square, while listening to Christmas carollers in the street, but other witnesses were certain they had already
Speaker 1seen the pair together earlier that evening. Inside the alhambur itself. Some claim they saw Harriet and the man boarding an omnibus at Piccadilly Circus, before traveling north and getting off near Hunter Street, which would have taken them back towards Great Korham Street for an entirely different route. Geographically, this version appeared to make more sense, as a journey through Russell Square would not have taken them past the greengrocer's shop, where Harriet had supposedly asked for grapes. Yet the timings
Speaker 1given by missus Wright did not fully align with the omnibus account. Despite the contradictions, one detail stuck the suspects supposedly foreign appearance and German accent. Newspapers repeated the description so often and with such certainty that it was quickly accepted as fact and soon dominated the investigation. Police therefore became interested when they learned that a German ship called the Vangeland had recently run aground on the Goodwin Sands
Speaker 1and had been brought into Ramsgate in Kent for repairs Several passengers and crew had traveled on to London during the delay and were staying at the German run Kroll's hotel in America's Square in the Mineries. Among them were a pastor named doctor Gottfried Hessel, his wife, and a shipbroker named Carl Vohliber. Investigators became convinced that volibur resembled the man seen with Harriet Buswell before her death. He
Speaker 1was arrested on eighteenth of January eighteen seventy three and placed in an identification parade. Witnesses, including the greengrocer and a waiter from the Alhambra were brought in to identify him, but instead of pointing to Volerburg, several witnesses identified Dr Hessel, who had volunteered a stand in the lineup. One witness declared in court, if it is not he, it is his twin brother. Another asked Hessel to speak, then interrupted
Speaker 1him almost immediately, saying that's enough for me. He is the man who sat with a woman at supper. Following the identification, Volerburg was released and doctor Hessel was taken into custody. He was held in a detention center in Clarkenwell under harsh conditions, surviving largely on bread and gruel. Officials removed anything that might be used to commit suicide, and he was reportedly not even permitted a handkerchief to blow his nose. Hessel was allowed forty five minutes of
Speaker 1exercise each day in the prison yard, and received a ten minute daily visit from his wife. She brought him money so he could supplement his meager diet with eggs and steak, though the food had to be cut into small pieces beforehand so he could eat using only a spoon on his hands. The prison chaplain visited regularly to offer spiritual solace, but physical comfort was in short supply. Temperatures inside the prison were bitterly cold, and Hessel's friends
Speaker 1and family were outraged by his treatment. Hessel later appeared before the magistrates at bow Street Police Court, charged with the murder of Harriet Buswell. Harry Poland appeared for the prosecution, and Douglas straight for the defense. Witnesses from the hotel where Hessel had stayed after the Vanguland ran the ground testified that he'd been ill over Christmas, had spent much of the night coughing in his room. Staff had answered his bell, seen his boots outside the door, and recalled
Speaker 1in requesting tea and rum shortly before midnight. The hotel doors were locked overnight and nobody could enter or leave without the porter's knowledge. Other evidence further strengthened his alibi. Another bar made from the Alhambra insisted that Hessel was not the man she had seen with Harriet. One witness also recalled Hessel purchasing turpentine to remove some stains, briefly raising suspicions until it emerged that his wife had stained
Speaker 1her dress with painted ramsgate and had been advised to clean it using turpentine. Under closer questioning, the confidence of the witnesses began to falter. A barmaid who had previously identified Hessel later admitted she didn't think it was the same man after all. With the evidence against him rapidly unraveling, and magistrate dismissed the case, the press mocked the police investigation,
Speaker 1with one commenter remarking that if the same process were repeated with every grown man in London, the real killer might eventually be found by chance alone. The one hundred pounds reward, worth around ten thousand pounds a day, would have represented years of wages for some of the city's poorest workers, which may have encouraged people to come forward with over confident memories shaped by repetition, suggestion, or public speculation.
Speaker 1There were further force leads before the case went cold. Two men separately confessed to the murder, but both were found to be drunk and were released without charge. Neither matched the witness descriptions. No clear motive was ever established, and the murder weapon was never recovered. Looking back, the case bears some interesting similarities to aspects of the Jack the Ripper murders that took place sixteen years later. The
Speaker 1deep wounds of the throat, the blood stained room, the bucket of blood tinged water, and the apparent absence of any reported struggle all suggest a killer who was methodical, fast, and disturbingly calm. Although Harriet Buswell did not live in the East End, she occupied a similarly vulnerable position in society, lived in a lodging house, moved with transient social circles, and had turned to prostitution to manage her mounting debts.
Speaker 1The investigation's focus on a foreign suspect is also reminiscent of later suspicions directed at immigrants during the Whitechapel murders of eighteen eighty eight. There were even some details in the Buzzwell case that would later be echoed in the murder of Mary Jane Kelly in Miller's Court. Like Buswell, Kelly was attacked inside her room, and when her body was discovered, the door was locked. One witness in the Whitechapel investigation also described a man seen walking along the
Speaker 1road with Kelly and then entering her lodgings. He was said to have a blotchy face and dark, shabby clothing, which sounds eerily similar to descriptions of the man seen with Buzwell. The blotchy faced man of the Whitechapel murders was said to be in his mid thirties, and the man seen with Buzzwell was reportedly in his mid twenties. Allowing for the possibility that witnesses misjudged his age by a few years, could there be a remote chance that
Speaker 1it was the same man. Of course, there is no evidence linking the two cases, and whether these parallels are meaningful or simply coincidence is impossible to know. But at the center of the mystery remains Harriet Buswell herself a thirty one year old woman, but whom tragically little is known, who never got to see her eight year old daughter that Christmas Day, and whose killer was never brought to justice.
Speaker 1You've been listening to Prasha's Murder Map. As an independent podcaster, I really appreciate your support. Please follow and rate the show wherever you get your podcasts, and if you're on YouTube, remember to subscribe and hit the notification bell so you never miss an episode. I'll be back soon with another true crime case
In November 1848, Wymondham in Norfolk became the scene of one of Victorian England’s most notorious crimes when James Blomfield Rush shot and killed local landowner Recorder Isaac Jermy and his son. The double murder...
In September 2017, occupational therapist Dianna Mah-Jones and her husband Richard were murdered in their Vancouver home by a stranger who had watched Dianna from the street. CCTV, discarded murder weapons, and a...
In November 1966, respected Buckinghamshire doctor Helen Davidson was brutally murdered while walking her dog in Hodgemoor Woods, leaving her fox terrier as the sole witness. There was no clear motive for the strange...
In the summer of 1912, 21-year-old Minnie Morris left London for a working holiday picking fruit in the quiet fenland village of Walsoken. When her body was discovered beside a country lane, suspicion fell on fellow...
In January 1990, Ontario was gripped by one of Canada’s largest manhunts in 15 years. Peter John Peters, a violent ex-convict known as ‘The Tattoo Man’, terrorised the province for several days, leaving a trail of...