105 | The Stanfield Hall Murders: James Blomfield Rush 'The Killer in the Fog'
44 minAudio
In November 1848, Wymondham in Norfolk became the scene of one of Victorian England’s most notorious crimes when James Blomfield Rush shot and killed local landowner Recorder Isaac Jermy and his son. The double murder at Stanfield Hall was the shocking culmination of years of legal disputes, fraud, forgery, riots and unexplained deaths. The incident and ensuing trial captured the public’s imagination so much that hundreds of hand-painted models of the house and ceramic figurines of the killer were sold as morbid mementoes, some of which still survive today. With thanks to Laura and John, who have a family connection to this case and recently got in touch to suggest I cover it. 📘 My latest book: Wartime London's 'Bonnie and Clyde': The Crime Spree of Betty Jones and Karl Hulten https://www.amazon.co.uk/Wartime-Londons-Bonnie-Clyde-Hulten/dp/1036129616 📺 Subscribe for video versions: https://youtube.com/@prashsmurdermap 📖 Prefer to read? Full story: https://prashganendran.com/penny_dreadfuls/james-blomfield-rush-stanfield-hall-murders 📬 Subscribe to my free newsletter and read more true crime articles: https://prashganendran.com Support my work 🔎 Patreon (ad-free early access episodes): https://www.patreon.com/prashsmurdermap ☕ Buy me a coffee: https://ko-fi.com/prashsmurdermap 💵 PayPal: https://www.paypal.me/prashsmurdermap 🎧 Listen to my other podcast Curious Britain Explore the mysteries, folklore, and forgotten stories of Britain. https://linktr.ee/curiousbritainpodcast 🙏 Thank you for listening. Your support helps keep Prash's Murder Map going and is very much appreciated. Music: "Unanswered Questions" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ "Long Note Two" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ "Long Note Three" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Sources include but are not limited to: 1845 and 1864 Directory of Norfolk, White Ancestry.co.uk Ancestry.com, England, Select Marriages, 1538-1973 Bell's Life in London and Sporting Chronicle, 1 Apr 1849 Bloodlands, 2026, Grosvenor House Publishing, Glenn Chandler Cambridge Chronicle and University Journal, Isle of Ely Herald and Huntingdonshire Gazette Dictionary of National Biography, Volume 10 (Oxford University Press) Dramas of the Dock, published by Stanley Paul, written by Guy B. H. Logan, 1930 Essex Chronicle, 8 Dec 1848 Genealogy Reviews https://www.genealogyreviews.co.uk/reviews/article/the-stanfield-hall-murders-ft/ Harrod & Co Directory of Norfolk, 1868 Ipswich Journal, 20 Apr 1889 London Gazette, 1838 pt.ii. pp.1946, 1965) Lost Country Houses of Norfolk (2015) by Wilkinson, Ringwood and Spooner Newry Examiner and Louth Advertiser, 14 Apr 1849 Norfolk Chronicle, 29 Sep 1838, 31 Mar 1849, 4 Apr 1949, 14 Apr 1849 Norfolk, England, Church of England Marriages and Banns, 1754-1938 - Sophia Jane Chevalier Norfolk Record Office Blog https://norfolkrecordofficeblog.org/2018/01/02/tales-of-the-great-and-the-not-so-good-norwich-archdeaconry-marriage-licence-bonds/ Norfolk Murders, The History Press, Neil R. Storey Norwich Mercury, 9 Dec 1848, 23 Dec 1848 Norfolk Record Office; Norwich, Norfolk, England; Norfolk Church of England Registers Norfolk Record Office; Norfolk, England; Norfolk Indexes to Wills, Marriage Bonds, Administrations, Probate Pigot’s Directory of Norfolk, 1839 Postcards from my own collection Suffolk Chronicle, 2 Dec 1848 The National Archives; Kew, Surrey, England; HO 8: Home Office: Convict Hulks, Convict Prisons and Criminal Lunatic Asylums: Quarterly Returns of Prisoners; Class: HO 8; Piece Number: HO 8/135 The Life and Execution of James Blomfield Rush, for the murders at Stanfield Hall, Walker Printer, Norwich (1849) The Stanfield Horror (1970s VHS transfer) Weekly True, 14 Oct 1838
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1In November 1848, Norfolk became the scene of one of Victorian England's most notorious crimes. The case involved fraud, forgery, riots and unexplained deaths, culminating in a shocking double murder at Stanfield Hall in Wyndham. The incident and ensuing trial captured the public's imagination so much that hundreds of hand-painted models of the house and ceramic figurines of the killer were sold as morbid mementos, some of which still survive today.
Speaker 1I'm your host Prash, and welcome to Prash's Murder Map. Before we begin, I'd like to say a big thank you to Laura and John, who recently got in touch
Speaker 1to suggest this case. John is related to the killer, Blomfield Rush, so I'm very grateful to them both for bringing it to my attention and for trusting me to research and present a case which for them has a very personal connection. James Blomfield was baptised on 10th January 1800 at All Saints Church in Tackleston. a village in Norfolk in the east of England, about 12 miles from Norwich and 100 miles from London. The baptism record gives
Speaker 1his surname as Bloomfield, but later records predominantly list him as Blomfield. His mother Mary was unmarried and his father is unknown, but was thought to be a gentleman farmer named Howe. The story goes that Mary sued Howe for breach of promise after he failed to marry her and was awarded a substantial payment for damages. However, there is no surviving documentation to prove it, so it's possible that this was a later reinvention or rumour. In September 1802,
Speaker 1when James was two years old, Mary married a farmer named John Rush. Young James took his stepfather's surname and became James Blomfield Rush. John was committed to bringing up his stepson with all the privileges he could afford and sent James to a boarding school in Suffolk, costing £ 16 a year, or around £ 1, 300 today. James received a good education there and later learned practical farming skills from his stepfather.
Speaker 1At this time, the family rented a farm in Felmingham from the Reverend George Preston, the rector of nearby Beeston St Lawrence. Preston also owns Stanfield Hall Estate, an impressive manor house and farm set within 30 acres of parkland near Wyndham. Wyndham is a small ancient market town whose name is pronounced very differently from what its spelling suggests, like several other Norfolk towns which have silent letters in
Speaker 1the middle. The town itself is around 10 miles southwest of Norwich, It was once famous for manufacturing wooden spoons and spindles and had a population of around 5,000 in the 1830s. A house had occupied the Stanfield Hall site from as early as the 13th century, but Reverend Preston rebuilt it in the late 1700s in a Tudor style. The house was accessed via a 16th century bridge across
Speaker 1the moat. When James Blomfield Rush was 24, his stepfather helped him take out a lease on his first farm at Wood Dorling, another village in the area. The farm did well and the tenancy included the right to live at Wood Dorling Hall, a grand country house. On 20th May 1828, James married Susannah Soam, a woman from a respectable local family. Together they had nine children. Mary, James, John, William, Eleanor, Jonathan, Horace,
Speaker 1Susan and Joseph. It was said that Blomfield Rush sexually harassed his female servants, and a friend of his later wrote, While his family rapidly increased around him to the extent of nine legitimate children, such were his unrestrained propensities that his servants were debauched and other intercourses kept up. deeply criminal of a man in his domestic position. Russia's reputation
Speaker 1began to decline, worsened by an incident involving a haystack fire on the farm. He was accused of arson, but not convicted, and his insurance company reluctantly paid out. There was also talk in the town that he had fathered several illegitimate children and was allegedly ordered to pay costs to a woman he had promised to marry, like his father before him, but there is very little documented evidence to support this. In his spare time, he read prolifically
Speaker 1and developed an interest in radical politics, joining the Norwich Revolution Club. In 1830 and 1831... of wave of unrest swept through southern and eastern England, sparked by agricultural labourers who were angry about low wages and the increasing use of mechanical farm equipment that threatened their livelihoods. The uprisings were known as the Swing Riots, with widespread destruction of farm machinery and acts of arson. While James Blomfield Rush
Speaker 1wasn't directly involved, he allowed some of the rioters to flee across his land. He was brought before Thetford Assizers in March 1831 for his role in their escape, but was simply bound over to keep the peace, which meant he would face a steep fine if he caused any further trouble. Shortly afterwards, he gave up the Wood Dorling farm and rented a much larger one at Felmingham, adjoining the land farmed by his stepfather. Both now shared the
Speaker 1same landlord, Reverend George Preston. but James was ambitious for more. Preston granted him a 12-year lease of Stanfield Hall Farm as well, with generous terms. As Reverend Preston was ageing, he placed increasing trust in Blomfield Rush and appointed him as land agent of the Stanfield Hall estate. This would have involved managing tenancies, collecting rents and supervising estate affairs.
Speaker 1By 1835, Rush was farming more than 1,000 acres and had been appointed as a valuer for the Four Hoe Union, an organisation responsible for giving relief to the poor in the local parishes. Blomfield Rush's role likely involved assessing the value of land and property to determine how much each landowner should pay towards the welfare fund. In November 1837, Reverend George Preston died at the age of 78. and
Speaker 1ownership of the Stanfield Hall estate passed to his eldest son, Isaac Preston, aged 48. Isaac now became James's new landlord. Isaac Preston was a practising barrister and had recently become recorder of Norwich, a senior legal position which involved acting as a judge for the city. Blomfield Rush's relationship with his new landlord would prove to be much less warm than the one he had enjoyed with the Reverend Preston.
Speaker 1There were legal complications surrounding Preston's ownership of Stanfield Hall. It originally belonged to the Jermey family and a will had been created in the 1700s which stipulated that the estate should pass to the nearest male blood relation bearing the name Jermey. Several heirs had died childless resulting in a complex chain of claims and transactions ending with the Preston family. To cement his claim and avoid future legal challenges,
Speaker 1Isaac Preston changed his name by royal licence to Isaac Jermie. His eldest son, born Isaac Jermie Preston, became Isaac Jermie Jermie. I'll be using the pronunciation Jermie, which is generally more common today, but in the past... The name may have been regionally pronounced Jarmy. Isaac Jeremy Senior, known professionally as Recorded Jeremy, needed to raise funds to refurbish Stanfield Hall.
Speaker 1He arranged an auction of his late father's furniture and books, and asked his tenant farmer, James Blomfield Rush, to act as the auctioneer. The planned auction drew attention to the uncertainty over the inheritance of and in June 1838, two men appeared at Stanfield Hall staking a claim to the estate. They were John Larner, a labourer from London, and his elderly cousin Thomas Jermie, a destitute man from a workhouse.
Speaker 1Thomas was the grandson of John Jermie of Yarmouth, who they argued was the rightful heir. Both men were illiterate and had been encouraged to pursue their claim by a man named Daniel Wingfield, who was employed in the paint trade but claimed to have knowledge of the law, perhaps seeking an opportunity to make some money. Larner challenged recorded Jeremy's authority to auction the contents of Stanfield Hall and demanded that the sale be stopped. pointing out clauses in
Speaker 1the original owner's will which said the library must be preserved and the estate must only pass to someone with the Jeremy name. The disagreement escalated. Lana, accompanied by ten relatives and supporters, forced his way into Stanfield Hall and tried to take possession of the property. Recorder Jeremy refused to acknowledge his claim and insisted that any dispute should be settled through the courts. James Blomfield Rush came to
Speaker 1Jeremy's assistance and gathered 200 men, many of them intoxicated and armed with crowbars, to chase away the claimants. The incident worried recorder Jeremy, who stopped the auction to comply with the will, but the damage had been done. Noticers were circulated in the area, warning farm labourers against working for him and the threat of future claims loomed large.
Speaker 1On 11th September 1838, Larner returned to Stanfield Hall with his supporters and tried to take possession of the hall once more until the local parish constables forced him to leave. He came back a few days later with a labourer, cut down an ash tree from the estate and carried it away. The labourer was fined for the incident which Larner paid on his behalf. A couple of weeks later, on 24th September, John Larner and Thomas Jermey made their
Speaker 1final attempt, this time bringing 20 men, including their legal champion, Daniel Wingfield. They used a crowbar to gain entry to the house via the kitchen door and forced the servants outside. They barricaded the doors and windows, settling in for what newspapers described as a siege. Alerted to the disturbance, Isaac Jermie arrived a few hours later with two constables from Wyndham. By now, a large crowd of spectators had gathered. Jermie
Speaker 1read the riot act, meaning that anyone who remained assembled unlawfully after one hour could be prosecuted for felony. What had started as a relatively small skirmish soon grew into a riot. Some of the spectators joined Lana's party and pockets of violence broke out, with Isaac Jermie and a constable both receiving minor injuries. Two county magistrates arrived at the scene and the riot act was read for a second time, which did little to quell the mob. Recorder
Speaker 1Jermie sent for a detachment of the 4th Dragoon Guards, who surrounded the mansion in a dramatic standoff as heavy rain poured down. Jeremy warned the rioters that if they didn't come out within five minutes, he would order the soldiers to shoot and enter by force. The occupants emerged one by one and offered no further resistance. Around 80 people were arrested and taken to Norwich Castle Jail, most
Speaker 1of them pleading guilty to rioting. John Larner, who had masterminded the attempt to seize Stanfield Hall, was sentenced to three months' imprisonment while elderly Thomas Jermie was acquitted. Some time after the riots, recorder Jermie decided to expand his estate. When he saw that Potash Farm, which adjoined Stanfield Hall, was up for auction, he sent James Blomfield Rush to place a bid on his behalf, instructing him not to
Speaker 1go above £ 3, 500. His ambitious tenant outbid him and purchased it himself for £ 3, 750. The trouble was, he couldn't afford it. The situation wasn't what Jeremy had envisioned, but he agreed to advance Blomfield Rush the money via a mortgage, so Rush effectively became a tenant at Potash Farm and moved his family in. This prompted Jeremy to take a closer look at the documents for the Felmingham Farms. he discovered
Speaker 1that his late father, Reverend Preston, had been too permissive with the arrangements and the paperwork was not legally binding. Jeremy reissued the agreement and increased the rent, pushing Blomfield Rush further into his debt. There were no further disturbances for the next few years and claims to the Stanfield Hall estate were largely forgotten. Or at least... That was how it appeared. On 17th of October 1844, James Blomfield Rush,
Speaker 1now 44, visited his mother and stepfather's farm at Felmingham after a day's game shooting. He later explained that his stepfather, John Rush, had asked to have a look at his gun, which was still loaded. James had handed it over, then gone into another room to wash. a gunshot was heard and John Rush was found dead in the kitchen, a bullet having entered his left cheek and lodged in his head, killing him instantly. The inquest returned a verdict of accidental death,
Speaker 1but questions were raised about how a right-handed man could have inflicted a gunshot wound on the left side of his own head. John Rush's sizeable estate was worth more than £ 7, 000 and equivalent to around £ 800, 000 today. James Blomfield was not a beneficiary, but he was soon able to borrow large sums of money from his widowed mother, which helped him stave off his growing list of creditors. When alive,
Speaker 1John Rush had questioned his stepson's financial decision to take on so many farms. Some found the circumstances of his death suspicious. wondering if he had previously refused to lend James Blomfield money. Could it have been a motive for murder? The following year, Blomfield Russia's wife Susanna fell ill with tuberculosis. The night she died, a cattle dealer was staying with them at Potash Farm and later remarked that he thought
Speaker 1it strange a doctor had not been called in her last hours. In 1846, Blomfield Rush placed a newspaper advert for a governess to care for his youngest children, now that they were motherless. He hired 25-year-old Emily Sanford, the daughter of a solicitor's clerk, with a working knowledge of the law. By this time, Blomfield Rush's eldest son was 16, while six of the other children were at boarding schools
Speaker 1in London and France. This left just the two youngest for Emily to care for. It wasn't long before Blomfield Rush began an affair with Emily, promising to marry her. When she became pregnant, he hid her away in lodgings in London, posing as an uncle when he visited her. The child was stillborn, and Blomfield Rush brought Emily back to Potash Farm, where they began living together. But there
Speaker 1was more death yet to come. Blomfield Rush's mother, Mary, was taken ill in August 1848. Rush was said to have visited her one night, sent the nurses away and given her a cake soaked in a substance that appeared to be wine. She died two hours later. No inquest was held and her death certificate recorded the cause of death as unknown. At the time, official medical certification was
Speaker 1not yet required by law so vague or unknown causes were common. But in view of the accidental shooting of his stepfather four years earlier, rumours circulated about whether Blomfield had killed them both, though no evidence ever came to light to prove it. When the will was read, it turned out that Mary had left her estate to her grandchildren, bypassing her son altogether. But James Blomfield Rush forged a
Speaker 1codicil giving him control of the property until his youngest child came of age, delaying the inheritance and allowing him to benefit financially in the meantime. By now, Blomfield Rush's animosity towards recorder Isaac Jermey was growing and he blamed him for his mounting debts. He was now being threatened with foreclosure on the Felmingham farm and owed a total of £ 8, 000 to his creditors worth just under a million today.
Speaker 1Encouraged by his success with the forged codicil of his mother's will, he devised another plan. In October 1848, Blomfield Rush visited London and met John Larner and Thomas Jermey, who were both still convinced they had a claim to Stanfield Hall. He agreed to help them oust record a germy and recover the estate, on the condition that they would allow him to keep the Felmingham and Potash farms.
Speaker 1Rush asked Emily Sanford to prepare legal documents for the agreement. She wasn't present during the discussion, but he persuaded her to witness the documents after the fact, adding her own signature later. Blomfield Rush dedicated most of his time to researching the history of Stanfield Hall, its previous owners and the phrasing of the original will. He fabricated lease and mortgage documents to strengthen his claims to the farms, once
Speaker 1again asking Emily to witness forged signatures, including that of Isaac Jermey. One of them was a document supposedly signed by Jermey, releasing Rush from all his outstanding debts. and granting him a 21-year lease on the farms. As the collection of paperwork grew, he began hiding the documents under a floorboard in a closet at Potash Farm. That same year, recorded Jeremy took Blomfield Rush to court over an unpaid loan.
Speaker 1In response, Rush wrote and circulated a defamatory pamphlet describing Jeremy as villainous and disgraceful. and accusing him of having no right to Stanfield Hall. In May 1848, Rush declared himself bankrupt. The relationship now strained beyond any chance of reconciliation, a recorded germy made a final demand for repayment of all debts in full by 30th of November. Facing eviction
Speaker 1and financial ruin, Blomfield Rush made a fatal decision just two days before the deadline. On the morning of Tuesday 28th November 1848, James Blomfield Rush's 20-year-old servant, Solomon Savory, witnessed a scene that meant little to him at the time but took on immense significance later. Rush hired a young man named Robert Smith to lay straw along the path leading from Potash Farm to Stanfield Hall and asked
Speaker 1Savory to help. This was common practice in muddy conditions but it had another convenient advantage. It would conceal footprints. Emily Sanford, who was pregnant again, had recently noticed a change in Rush's behaviour. He had become increasingly preoccupied with the threat of poachers and had been going out in the evening with a gun. She asked him if it was really just poachers he was worried about, to which he replied cryptically, You could not wish to know now,
Speaker 1but you will know another time. it wouldn't be long before she understood his meaning. At around 8.30pm that evening, the Jermie family had just finished dinner at Stanfield Hall. The young Isaac Jermie Jermie, who had celebrated his 27th birthday a week earlier, was in the drawing room with his wife Sophia and 14-year-old sister Isabella about to begin a game of cards. His two-year-old daughter Sophia Henrietta was
Speaker 1asleep upstairs. Recorder Isaac Jermey, now 59, stepped outside for a breath of fresh air as he usually did after dinner. The night was foggy, shrouding the surrounding grounds in ghostly wisps and obscuring his view, revealing little more than indistinct shapes in the darkness. Just outside of his line of vision, a figure in a dark cloak and a black wig that partly concealed its face, was making its way towards
Speaker 1the hall from the direction of Potash Farm. Suddenly, a gunshot rang out and recorded Jeremy fell to the ground, bleeding from his chest. The butler, James Watson, heard the shot and rushed out from the pantry. Halfway along the passage, he bumped into an intruder who pushed him aside. Watson later described him as a man in a dark cloak, of lowish stature and stout, apparently with a mask on his face and something on his head. He was carrying
Speaker 1something in each hand which was likely a gun and a ramrod. A rod used to press the gunpowder, wadding and lead shot down the barrel of an old-fashioned firearm. Watson retreated towards the pantry as the cloaked man strode past, dropping two papers behind him as he went. After hearing the first shot, Isaac Jeremy Jr. ran from the drawing room and across the hall. The intruder raised his gun and fired at him from a distance of around three feet.
Speaker 1The shot struck him in the chest, knocking him onto his back. Sophia rushed from the dining room and found her husband lying in a pool of blood and ran towards the servant's passage, calling for help. The gunman fired in her direction and she was struck in the right arm. 14-year-old Isabella was the next to run into the hall. The cloaked figure aimed at her but missed. She escaped through the back of the house with the cook, Martha Reed,
Speaker 1and hid in the stables. The assailant reloaded his gun using the ramrod he'd been carrying and dropped the ramrod on the floor. Housemaid Eliza Chastney rushed to help Sophia. Moments later, the cloaked man emerged from the dining room and fired again, hitting Eliza in the thigh. She fell to the floor and Sophia fled upstairs while the attacker escaped through a side door and disappeared into the night.
Speaker 1The uninjured servants ran to get help from a neighbouring farm and constables from Wyndham and Norwich were summoned along with a doctor. They found recorder Jeremy lying dead on the porch, his son Isaac inside the house. Their bodies were carried into the dining room and laid side by side. Isaac's wife Sophia survived her injuries but underwent amputation of her right arm. Housemaid Eliza Chastney, still conscious despite her leg wound, told police she recognised the gunman as James
Speaker 1Blomfield Rush. It was well known that he'd been a frequent visitor for many years and was familiar with the layout of the house. Police surrounded Potash Farm and arrested Blomfield Rush on suspicion of the murder of the two germies. He was handcuffed while a search of the house revealed a black cloak lying on Rush's bed. When questioned, Emily Sanford told police that Rush had left the house at about 8pm that evening but insisted he'd been out for
Speaker 1only 10 minutes. Rush was taken to Wyndham Bridewell Prison on Norwich Road and later transferred to Norwich Castle Jail. police recovered the two papers dropped by the killer. Both bore identical messages which read, There are seven of us here, three of us outside, and four of us inside the hall, all armed, as you see us too. If any of you servants offer to leave the premises or to follow us, you will be shot dead. Therefore, all of you keep
Speaker 1in the servants' hall, and you will not take any harm, for we are only come to take possession of the Stanfield property. Thomas Jeremy, the owner. Investigators felt this was likely a crude attempt to place the blame on one of the men who had previously tried to seize the property by force. On 1st December 1848, police found further evidence in Rush's home, including a widow's cap, a black wig with a moustache and whiskers attached, a woman's wig
Speaker 1with long black hair and a travelling cap. A later search also revealed the forged deeds witnessed by Emily Sanford secreted in the closet. The inquest was held at the King's Head in Wyndham and the jury returned a verdict of willful murder against James Blomfield Rush. He was committed for trial at the Norfolk Assizes while Emily Sanford was held at Wyndham Bridewell Jail. The two Jermies were buried on 5th December 1848. Although Recorder Jeremy and his son
Speaker 1had not been especially popular with the townspeople, there was significant public sympathy and press interest. Shops closed out of respect and large crowds gathered to watch the funeral procession. The investigation continued in preparation for the trial. Police drained the moat in the hope of finding the murder weapon but were left empty-handed. Author Charles Dickens was visiting Stanfield Hall in January 1849 while the search was ongoing and
Speaker 1wrote scathingly about their methods. His lack of confidence proved to be justified as it took another five months for the weapon to be discovered. A fast-loading, double-barrelled blunderbuss had been hidden under a dung heap in the yard at Potash Farm. It had no ramrod but the one the killer dropped on the floor at Stanfield Hall fitted it perfectly. suggesting that it had been used to reload the weapon and accidentally left behind. But it was too late to be used as evidence, as by that time, the trial
Speaker 1had already concluded. Even without the weapon... investigators had been confident from the beginning that they had plenty of evidence against James Blomfield Rush. Emily Sanford gave a voluntary statement to the magistrate in February 1849 admitting that Rush had been out for longer than she'd previously stated on the night of the murders. She explained that he had returned home that night in a state of agitation after being out for at least an hour and a half. He
Speaker 1then urged her twice that if anyone should ask about his whereabouts, she should tell them he'd only been out for 10 minutes. When Blomfield Rush heard about her statement, he uttered a curse, hoping that Emily's hand would drop off and their child would be born with a brand upon it. A few days later, Emily gave birth to a baby daughter at Bridewell Jail, whom she named Emily Martha Sanford. The trial began on 29th March 1849, at
Speaker 1the Shire Hall courthouse next to Norwich Castle, before Baron Rolfe. The Shire Hall had opened in 1823, replacing an earlier building on top of the castle mound. Prisoners were escorted from the castle jail down a spiral staircase and through an underground tunnel and merging into the prisoners' lobby adjoining the Crown Court. James Blomfield Rush was charged with the murders of recorded Jeremy and his son as well as
Speaker 1the attempted murder of Sophia Jeremy and Eliza Chastney. Rush turned down offers of legal counsel and chose to defend himself. There was significant public interest in the proceedings and crowds gathered to watch the arrival of Eliza Chastney, the injured housemaid, who was carried in on a specially constructed sedan chair under police escort to give evidence. Eliza's firm identification of Blomfield Rush was corroborated by Watson the butler and Martha
Speaker 1Reid the cook. Another witness identified the handwriting on the paper found on the floor as that of Rush. and Thomas Jeremy and John Larner were confirmed to be in London at the time of the murders, so there was no possibility they'd been involved. Emily Sanford spent several hours in the witness box, as she repeated her statement about Rush's absence on the night of the murders. Rush tried to intimidate her with a lengthy cross-examination, which only served
Speaker 1to generate more public sympathy for Emily, though some members of the press painted her as a willing accomplice. On the fifth day of the trial, Rush spoke at length in his own defence. An exchange with one of his witnesses did more to seal his fate than some of those brought for the Crown. Maria Blanche Flower, a nurse at Stanfield Hall, said she had seen the disguised murderer but did not recognise the figure as Rush. In a
Speaker 1slip of the tongue, rather than asking, Rush said instead, Did you pass me quickly? Effectively admitting that the cloaked figure was him. Multiple witnesses testified to Rush's animosity towards recorder Jeremy and the deadline to pay his outstanding debts provided a clear motive for murder. It appeared that his plan had been to eliminate the incumbent Jeremy family or
Speaker 1planting clues that pointed towards Thomas Jeremy. Perhaps he hoped he would later have a chance to resent the falsified paperwork he'd been gathering to write off his debts and stake his own claim to the farms. The jury took just ten minutes to find James Blomfield Rush guilty of murder. In response he cried out, My Lord, I am innocent of that, thank God Almighty. Baron Rolfe donned the black
Speaker 1cap and sentenced him to death. Rush was reported to have smiled as he was removed to the condemned cell at Norwich Castle Jail. While he awaited execution, he gave every semblance of religious faith and conviction in his own innocence, though the prison chaplain, Reverend James Brown, didn't believe him. Brown wrote, He assumed the lofty and confident bearing of innocence, but he so unnaturally overacted his part, as to enable
Speaker 1the most casual observer to see through the flimsy veil which he attempted to throw over his real feelings. Blomfield Rush refused to prison food, instead ordering in his meals from the nearby Bell Public House. Along with hot meat, bread and tea, he asked for a roast suckling pig and added a note to send plenty of plum sauce with it. The execution was set for noon on Saturday 21st April 1849. As Saturdays were market days, a large
Speaker 1audience was guaranteed. During his final visit to the prison chapel, the Reverend urged him to repent, to which Rush replied, God knows my heart, he is my judge, and you have prejudged me. A real criminal will be known in two years. The scaffold was erected just behind the gatehouses on the medieval bridge leading to Norwich Castle, where groups started gathering early in the morning. Special trains from London
Speaker 1and East Anglia had been laid on for people to witness the hanging of the man whose story had dominated the press for the last few months. Hawkers made the most of the business opportunity, peddling hot pies, potatoes and drinks to many of the 20,000 onlookers. 49-year-old James Blomfield Rush was observed to look a little paler than usual, but retained his usual determined expression. As the bell tolled, Rush turned around on the platform so that his back
Speaker 1was to the crowd. As executioner William Cowcraft placed the noose and hood over the prisoner's head, Rush remarked loudly, This does not go easy. Put the thing a little higher. Take your time. Don't be in a hurry. These would be his last words. Calcroft withdrew the bolt and the trapdoor opened. After Rush's body was cut down, his hair was shaved off and a death mask was made by
Speaker 1applying plaster to his face to capture a mould of the executed man's features. Death masks were often displayed as a lasting record of serious crimes and were also studied by phrenologists who believed they could predict criminality by the shape of a person's skull, a practice which had largely been discredited by the late 19th century. Afterwards, Blomfield Rush was buried within the prison grounds. Copies of the death mask were subsequently made, with some examples surviving at Norwich
Speaker 1Castle Museum and the Science Museum Group. Blomfield Rush was one of the last men to be publicly hanged at Norwich Castle. He was followed by Henry Groom in 1851, William Thompson in 1854 and finally Hubbard Lingley in 1867. I covered Thompson's case in an earlier episode about the murder of watchmaker Lorenz Behar. The Stanfield Hall double murder and the execution of Blomfield Rush generated numerous publication and
Speaker 1ballads recounting details of the crime for a fascinated public with a thirst for morbid tales. Some of the more lurid accounts described him as the killer in the fog due to the weather on the night of the crime. Others took the opportunity to circulate pamphlets delivering religious and moral warnings. There was a public appeal to raise funds for injured housemaid Eliza Chastney who later married and moved to Cambridge. A similar appeal was held for Emily Sanford
Speaker 1who also married, emigrated to Australia and later to Germany where she died in 1901. The daughter she had with Blomfield Rush, Emily Martha Sanford, survived to adulthood and moved to America with her German husband, but died three years after her marriage when she fell down a flight of stairs. Solomon Savory, the young servant who worked for Blomfield Rush and helped to lay out the straw that would hide Rush's footprints, later fell foul of the law himself and
Speaker 1was convicted of livestock theft on at least two occasions. He was sentenced to 14 years transportation to Bermuda where he worked as a labourer. Sophia Jermie, widow of Isaac Jermie Jermie, inherited Stanfield Hall. Her amputated arm was replaced with an early form of prosthetic limb made of cork with a realistic hand sculpted from beeswax. She allowed Russia's orphaned children to stay at Potash Farm for a time
Speaker 1where his eldest son worked the land with his wife. According to author Glenn Chandler, Rush's son James, who shared his first name, later served time in prison for theft and emigrated to New Zealand where he continued to add crimes to his charge sheet. He defended himself in court, just as his father had done. He later escaped jail while wearing a disguise but was recaptured. He committed his last robbery in 1908 at the age of 78 and
Speaker 1died two years later in an Auckland nursing home. In 1850 Sophia Jermie remarried and went on to have several more children. She died in 1890 at the age of 65. Her daughter with Isaac Jeremy Jr, Sophia Henrietta Jeremy, married a Captain Reginald Gwynne. In turn, the Hall passed to their only child, Reginald Preston Jeremy Gwynne. A double-barrelled blunderbuss,
Speaker 1used as the murder weapon, was kept by the Jeremy Gwynne family. Stanfield Hall fell into disrepair after the Second World War but was later refurbished and electricity was installed. It was sold to the Stern family and sold again in 2004 for around a million pounds. In 2023, it was listed for sale at 5 million, but to date, it is yet to find an owner. Wood-Dorling Hall, Blomfield Rush's first tenancy, still stands today and is a Grade
Speaker 1II listed building. Potash Farm, however, was demolished and the site was used as an airbase during World War II. Since the 1960s, it's been the headquarters of Lotus Cars. The murders inspired a 1939 novel called Blanche Fury, which was made into a film in 1948. However, both versions bear little resemblance to the historical facts. Some unanswered questions still linger. Was Blomfield Rush responsible for the deaths of
Speaker 1his stepfather, mother and wife? The circumstances were suspicious, but there was no evidence of his involvement. Why did Reverend George Preston grant such benevolent terms to Blomfield Rush? Was he simply a kind man lacking in business acumen, or was there more to their friendship? Why did recorded Jeremy agree to lend Rush the money to purchase Potash Farm when Rush had gone over his head at the auction?
Speaker 1In 1972, author F.R. Buckley hinted at a family tie. The identity of Blomfield Rush's father was never confirmed. Is there any possibility that Reverend George Preston was his father? He was, after all, a gentleman farmer himself. like the man said to have been sued for breach of promise by Rush's mother. Either way, Blomfield Rush had an extraordinary preoccupation with Stanfield Hall and its ownership, and seemed determined
Speaker 1to get recorder Jeremy out of the way. Did he know something nobody else did? Or did his ambitions simply grow beyond his financial means until they spiralled out of control? Rush left behind a curious legacy in the form of a wax model at Madame Tussauds displayed until 1971 and several surviving ceramic ornaments made shortly after his execution depicting Rush,
Speaker 1Emily Sanford and Stanfield Hall itself. A brass commemorative medal was also made bearing a portrait of Rush and the date of his execution along with the names of his victims and the date of their deaths. Several families in East Anglia today still carry the surname Jermie, but it is thought that none are directly related to the original Jermies of Stanfield Hall, a line which died out in the 18th century, and which led indirectly to so much anger,
Speaker 1deception and suffering. You've been listening to Prash's Murder Map. If you enjoyed this episode, please give me a thumbs up, comment, rating or review, whichever is available on the platform you're using as it really helps others to find the show. Patreon supporters can now get access to ad-free videos before they're released to the public and you can also sign up to my free newsletter via my website for news and updates. I'll leave the links in the show notes.
Speaker 1I really appreciate your support and I'll be back again soon with another true crime episode.
In September 2017, occupational therapist Dianna Mah-Jones and her husband Richard were murdered in their Vancouver home by a stranger who had watched Dianna from the street. CCTV, discarded murder weapons, and a...
In November 1966, respected Buckinghamshire doctor Helen Davidson was brutally murdered while walking her dog in Hodgemoor Woods, leaving her fox terrier as the sole witness. There was no clear motive for the strange...
In the summer of 1912, 21-year-old Minnie Morris left London for a working holiday picking fruit in the quiet fenland village of Walsoken. When her body was discovered beside a country lane, suspicion fell on fellow...
In January 1990, Ontario was gripped by one of Canada’s largest manhunts in 15 years. Peter John Peters, a violent ex-convict known as ‘The Tattoo Man’, terrorised the province for several days, leaving a trail of...
In June 1928, a newly married Chinese couple arrived in the Lake District to enjoy their honeymoon. Days later, 28-year-old Wai Sheung Siu was found strangled in woodland near Derwentwater. Suspicion fell on her husband...