100 | The 1928 Lake District Murder: The Honeymoon Killer of Borrowdale
30 minAudio
In June 1928, a newly married Chinese couple arrived in the Lake District to enjoy their honeymoon. Days later, 28-year-old Wai Sheung Siu was found strangled in woodland near Derwentwater. Suspicion fell on her husband as hidden jewellery, cryptic notes, and reports of mysterious men and secret societies became part of a sensational murder case. 📘 My latest book: Wartime London's 'Bonnie and Clyde': The Crime Spree of Betty Jones and Karl Hulten https://www.amazon.co.uk/Wartime-Londons-Bonnie-Clyde-Hulten/dp/1036129616 📺 Subscribe for video versions: https://youtube.com/@prashsmurdermap 📖 Prefer to read? Full article: https://prashganendran.com/the-1928-lake-district-murder-chung-yi-miao-wai-sheung-siu/ 📬 Subscribe to my free newsletter and read more true crime articles: https://prashganendran.com 💡 Support my work Patreon (audio-only ad-free episodes): https://www.patreon.com/prashsmurdermap ☕ Buy me a coffee: https://ko-fi.com/prashsmurdermap 💵 PayPal: https://www.paypal.me/prashsmurdermap 🎧 Listen to my other podcast Curious Britain Explore the mysteries, folklore, and forgotten stories of Britain. https://linktr.ee/curiousbritainpodcast 🙏 Thank you for listening. Your support helps keep Prash's Murder Map going and is very much appreciated. Music: Epidemic Sound "Long Note Three" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ "Long Note Two" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ "Unanswered Questions" Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Sources: Ancestry.co.uk Two Chinese Domestic Murders - H. J. Lethbridge UK, Calendar of Prisoners, 1868-1929 New York, New York, U.S., Marriage License Indexes, 1928 The Scotsman - Thursday 4 August 1927 Edinburgh Evening News - 21 June 1928 Reynolds's Newspaper - Sunday 22 July 1928 Newcastle Daily Chronicle - Thursday 02 August 1928 Sheffield Daily Telegraph - 2 August 1928 Cumberland and Westmorland Herald - Saturday 4 August 1928 Gloucestershire Echo - Tuesday 23 October 1928 The Nottingham Journal - 24 October 1928 Barrow News - Saturday 27 October 1928 Airdrie & Coatbridge Advertiser - Saturday 27 October 1928 Evening News (London) - 20 November 1928 Shields Daily News - Tuesday 20 November 1928 Evening Standard - 20 November 1928 The Journal - 21 November 1928 Dundee Weekly News - Saturday 24 November 1928 The News - 1 December 1928 The Sunday People - Sunday 2 December 1928 Daily Express - Saturday 8 December 1928 Liverpool Echo - Saturday 8 December 1928 The Cincinnati Enquirer - 25 December 1928 The Sunday People - Sunday 6 January 1929 The Sunday Sun - 6 January 1929 Tuesday Express - Tuesday 26 March 1929
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1The Lake district home to rolling fowls, sheep, woodland, water boats, and plenty of tourists. Its peaceful landscape seems one of the least likely settings for murder imaginable. When my wife and I recently visited the area and went for a walk near the village of Grasmere, I couldn't resist mentioning that a notorious murder had once taken place not far from where we were standing. In fact, our hotel room
Speaker 1was named after the novelist Hugh Walpole, who lived near Keswick at the time of the case and later attended the trial. It seemed like a sign my wife was rather less enthusiastic about discussing crime while on holiday, but I already knew this would be the next case I researched when we returned home. I wanted to find out how a happy honeymoon in the lake district in nineteen twenty eight had ended in murder. For that we begin,
Speaker 1perhaps surprisingly in China, Hello, and welcome to Prassia's murder map. Chung Yi Miao was born in nineteen hundred in Czechian
Speaker 1now called Jixiang, a wealthy coastal province in eastern China. The family, who were Christians, later lived in Shanghai before moving to Hong Kong, then a British colony, amid the unrest and political upheaval that marked the final years of China's last imperial dynasty. Chung's father was an affluent government official, and Chung received a good education. He was later sent to Parish to continue his studies, supported by a generous
Speaker 1monthly allowance from his father. While in Paris, the tall, slim young man put his sophistication and cosmopolitan manner to good use, spending more time pursuing women than pursuing his studies. He became engaged to a young englishwoman, but she ended the relationship after discovering that he was seeing other women. She had also heard a troubling rumour that he was a member of a Tongue, a Chinese secret society. Tongs
Speaker 1were originally formed to provide support and fellowship for Chinese communities living abroad, but some had gained a reputation for involvement in organized crime. After completing his education, Chung returned to Hong Kong, where he married and had a son. He later traveled to Chicago to study for doctorate in law, still financially supported by his father. In June nineteen twenty seven, Chung returned to Hong Kong for the summer break to
Speaker 1visit his wife's son and parents. Two months later, he traveled back to America, arriving first in New York. New York in the Roaring twenties would have been eye opening for Chung. A city of jazz clubs, speakeasies, and fast changing social attitudes. Liberated young women known as flappers symbolized the age with their bold new fashions, smoking, drinking, and dancing.
Speaker 1Life was booming colorful and modern in the years before the Wall Street Crash brought the decades exuberance to an abrupt end. It was in New York that twenty seven year old Chung met a twenty nine year old woman named Wishung See Yu Weischung was the daughter of a wealthy merchant from Macau. As a child, she had attended a Christian school in Hong Kong before continuing her education in England and later traveling to New York with her younger brother. Wishung was around five foot tall and was
Speaker 1described by friends in America as generous, intelligent, and good natured. She had graduated from Emerson College in Boston, where she had been president of the Chinese Students Club. She was well known in diplomatic and social circles, and her name had appeared regularly in newspapers in connection with academic and society events. Wishung was also friends with the wife of the Chinese ambassador to London, and moved in distinguished company.
Speaker 1While helping to manage her father's exhibits in the Chinese section of the British Empire Exhibition at Wembley Park, she rubbed shoulders with Sir Robert Houtung and Lady Hotung, two of the wealthiest and most influential Asian figures of the era. Shortly after the exhibition, Wi Shung's father died, leaving her a considerable fortune. She returned to Hong Kong, where she lived near her grandparents and ran an antique shop, occasionally
Speaker 1traveling to New York to sell pieces from her late father's collection. It was during one of these trips that Wi Shung crossed paths with a smooth talking and debonnair Chung Yi Miao. They first met her a dragon dance part of the celebrations for the Chinese New Year, Chung bought a motor car and began driving her to restaurants and dancers, and on twelfth of May nineteen twenty eight, they married in New York City. Wishung had no idea
Speaker 1that her new husband already had a wife and child back in Hong Kong. They began their honeymoon in Glasgow, where Wi Shung withdrew five hundred pounds from the National Bank of Scotland worth around thirty thousand pounds to day. The couple visited Lochlomond, posed for photographs together, and later stayed at the Caledonian Hotel in Edinburgh. Their next destination was the Lake District, where they arrived on Monday, eighteenth of June. Then, as now, the region was a favorite
Speaker 1with holiday makers. Set among the mountains of Cumbria in northwest England, its valleys, waterfalls, ancient woodlands and stretches of open water had long inspired poets and writers, most famously William Wordsworth and Beatrix Potter. By the nineteen twenties, its picturesque villages, dramatic scenery and romantic atmosphere also made it a popular destination for wealthy travelers and honeymooning couples. During
Speaker 1their stay, Chung was secretly writing letters to his wife and parents back in Hong Kong, omitting to mention that he had just married another woman. Chung and Weishung stayed at the Borrowdale Gates Hotel in Grange and Adylic Retreat, surrounded by three acres of wooded grounds at the head of Derwent Water. From the hotel, guests looked out towards the dramatic jaws of Borrowdale, where the river Derwent and
Speaker 1the road are squeeze between the steep slopes of Grangefell and Castle Cragg, marking the entrance of the upper Borredale Valley. The area would later be described by celebrated fell walker and guidebook writer Alfred Wainwright as the loveliest square mile in Lakeland. At the time, the hotel was owned by Miss Beatrice Elizabeth Crossley, who later recalled that the couple appeared happy and devoted to each other. Both spoke English
Speaker 1or the Weyshung was noticeably more fluent than her husband. She told Miss Crossley that they were from Hong Kong, that she had visited England before, and that this was Chung's first visit to the country. On the evening of their arrival, the newly weds went out for a walk together through the ancient woodland of Borredale. The valley's exceptionally wet climate supports a lush, temperate rainforest landscape of oak trees, ferns, mosses and lichens, as well as one of England's few
Speaker 1remaining red squirrel populations. The next morning, Tuesday, nineteenth of June, the couple went out together again. Chung had his camera with him and took several photographs. During their stay, they are believed to have visited the famous Bowderstone, an enormous two thousand ton boulder balanced improbably on one edge. A steep flight of wooden steps allowed visitors to climb to the top as much for the thrill as for the
Speaker 1breathtaking view. Chung and Why Shung returned to the hotel for lunch. Then at about two pm that afternoon, hotel made Dorothy Holiday saw them going out together again, walking arm in arm and apparently in good spirits. She noticed that Wy Shung was wearing THRN colored kid gloves and carrying a brown umbrella and handbag. Around two hours later, Chung returned to the hotel alone. Another maid, Elizabeth Thompson,
Speaker 1noticed that he was holding one hand awkwardly against his side, as though trying to conceal something. He was unusually quiet. After drinking a cup of tea, he went upstairs, where the bathroom tap could be heard running several times over the next few minutes. Chung then came downstairs and told Miss Crossley that he had caught a cold, so his wife had gone shopping in Keswick to buy warmer clothes and medicine. He returned upstairs, where he could be heard
Speaker 1pacing up and down. Time passed, but Wishung did not return. Chung eventually asked Miss Crossley to telephone the local shops to inquire whether anyone had seen his wife. She did so, and later that evening went to the Keswick post office, but no one had seen Wishung. As concern grew, one of the hotel maids notified the police. At around eight
Speaker 1pm that evening, a retired farmer named Thomas Wilson made a terrible discovery in Comacata Wood between two rocks lay a young Chinese woman of slight build She was on her back with an open umbrella partially covering her head and shoulders. When Wilson moved closer, he realized that she was dead. He immediately contacted Detective Pendlebury of Southport, whom
Speaker 1he knew was holidaying in the area, and Pendlebury arrived at the scene within an hour. The dead woman was whyshong see you. Her skirt had been hitched up and her underwear torn, and her left glove lay nearby a window blind. Cord had been wrapped four times around her neck, pulled tightly into the flesh and secured with granny knots. A small amount of blood was visible around her mouth
Speaker 1that there were no signs of a struggle on the ground, but the third finger of the left hand showed evidence that a ring had been forcibly removed. Detective Pendlebury contacted Inspector Henry Graham of the Cumberland and Westmoreland Constabulary, who cycled to the scene to join him. Photographs of the body were taken and the attending doctor estimated that death had occurred at around sixty third, though he admitted that the timing could not be established with certainty. There was
Speaker 1no sign of sexual assault. Forensic pathologist Professor John McFall from Liverpool University discovered traces of blood on the victim's glove and clothing. Inspector Graham made inquiries in the area, leading him to the Borrowdale Gates Hotel accompanied by two of his constables. They arrived at the hotel around eleven PM and arrested Chung Ymao on suspicion of murder. The
Speaker 1police was struck by the fact that he had been sleeping soundly while his wife was still missing. When they told him that why Shung having found strangled, Chung seemed emotional and said, my wife's dead, suspicion, What do you mean by that? He then asked a question which seemed strange at the time and would later become a subject of bait in court. Did she still have her nickers on when you found her? Chung was taken to Keswick
Speaker 1Police station to make a statement. He told officers that why Shung had gone out wearing her necklace and diamond ring, adding if you have those things you will find the culprit. When he was informed that his clothing would need to be examined for traces of blood, Chung quickly replied, if you do find bloodstains, on my overcoat. Then this was God in New York, though he didn't elaborate on how this happened. When police searched the couple's hotel room, it
Speaker 1didn't take long for them to find Wy Shung's handbag. Her pearl necklace was still inside. The key to her jewelry box was found wrapped inside one of Chung's shirts, while a search of his suitcase reeled a cardboard box containing two camera film roles wrapped in tinfoil. The films were handed to a photographer to be developed in the hope they might reveal clues about the victim's final movements. When the rolls were opened, two rings fell out. They
Speaker 1were identified as Wey Shung's engagement and wedding rings. Chung himself had told police that finding the missing jewelry would lead them to the culprit, yet there was still more evidence to add to the growing pile. Investigators confirmed that the window blind cord used to strangle Wyshung had come from a cupboard in the hotel room occupied by the couple. While in custody, Chung's family in Hong Kong were notified
Speaker 1of his arrest. An initial hearing was held at Keswick Police Court on twentieth July nineteen twenty eight. This was to determine prima faishi, or in other words, to establish if there were sufficient evidence for the suspect to stand trial. Large crowds gathered outside the building, and novelist Hugh Walpole was among those who managed to gain admission. Chung was represented by Sir Gerald Thesiger, who entered a plea of not guilty on his behalf, while Sefton Cohen appeared for
Speaker 1the prosecution. Chung was offered an interpreter, but refused, insisting that he did not need one. It emerged that several other people described as being of Oriental appearance had been seen in the area on the day of Wyshung's death. Police had been unable to trace them, although there was no evidence that they were connected to the case. Professor mc full testified that he had found no traces of
Speaker 1blood on the defendant's clothing or signs of it having been recently washed, and Gerald Thesiger argued that there was insufficient evidence to justify sending chug Yi Miau for trial. He urged the magistrates to remember the case of Oscar Slater, a German born man who'd been convicted in Scotland in nineteen o nine for murdering an elderly woman. Slater's conviction was controversial as it had been largely based on circumstantial evidence and was eventually overturned. Despite Thesiger's warning, the magistrates
Speaker 1ruled that there was sufficient evidence for Chung Yimau to stand trial at the next assizors. When the decision was announced, Chung stood in the dock and declared, I did not kill my wife. The trial opened at the Cumberland Sizes in Carlisle on Monday twenty second of October nineteen twenty eight. Suades of newspaper reporters attended, along with curious members of the public, eager to catch a glimpse of the Chinese
Speaker 1defendant whose case had drawn national attention. Meao was defended by Joseph Cooksey Jackson Casey, while mister J. E. Singleton appeared for the Crown. Once again, Chung pleaded not guilty. This time an interpreter was present, with Jackson arguing that his client had only understood about sixty percent of the earlier police court hearing. A jeweler testified that the necklace and rings recovered from Chung's possession were valued at three thousand,
Speaker 1three hundred and eighty six pounds equivalent to approximately one hundred and ninety thousand to day. When questioned about the rings hidden inside the film roles, Chung claimed he had seen why Chung put them there, but this contradicted his earlier statement, in which he had said she had been wearing them when she left the hotel shortly before her death. Jackson put forward an alternative theory. He argued that Wishung's habit of wearing expensive jewelry had attracted the attention of
Speaker 1international thieves during their voyage from New York. According to the defense, two Chinese men had stared intently at Chung and Wei Shung while they were in Glasgow and had followed them to the Lake district. Chung claimed he had seen the same men near the hotel on the day of the murder, while another witness reporters seeing two men described as being of Oriental appearance traveling in a motor car. The defense suggested that the men waited for Weishung to
Speaker 1leave the hotel alone, supposedly on her way to Keswick to buy medicine for her husband. They then attacked and robbed her, placed her body in their car, and later dumped her in Kamakata Wood. There was further testimony from railway porter Stanley Atkinson, who said that on the morning after the murder he had seen two men whom he believed to be Japanese, boarding the ten am train to Carlyle. He remembered that they had asked about connections to Glasgow
Speaker 1or Edinburgh. The men were never traced. The prosecution argued that there were serious problems with this theory. No witnesses record seeing why Shung shopping in Keswick, and there was no evidence that her body had been dragged or carried into the wood from elsewhere. Forensic evidence also suggested that her clothing had been deliberately torn, possibly in an attempt to make the crime look like sexual assault. The prosecution
Speaker 1maintained that the missing jewelry found in Chung's possession pointed to greed as the motive for murder. Another intriguing and much debated piece of evidence involved three torn scraps of paper bearing handwritten Chinese characters found in the room where the couple had stayed in Edinburgh. Chung admitted the writing was his but disputed the translations and claimed he could not remember why he had written the notes. The translations
Speaker 1presented in court were arrival Europe. Again, consider be sure not to do this thing on the ship, and confusingly, be sure of doing it on the ship. Chung claimed the true meanings were arrival Europe. Then discuss do not discuss this on the boat, and be sure to discuss this matter on the ship. His main defense was that his words had been misinterpreted or mistranslated throughout the proceedings.
Speaker 1On Wednesday, twenty fourth of October nineteen twenty eight, after ninety minutes of deliberation, the jury found Chung y Meau guilty of murder, and Justice Travers Humphreys passed the death sentence. When given a chance to speak, Chung told the court, if this will be my last moment, I did not kill my wife. As he was led from the dock, he shouted, I'm not guilty, my lord. The appeal was
Speaker 1held almost a month later. Rather than relying on his barrister, Chung chose to speak on his own behalf. As he entered the court with a large bundle of documents under his arm, he explained that although he respected the abilities of his counsel, he felt compelled by God to speak personally to the court. His command of English formed the mainstay of his appeal. Chung argued that his question to the police reported as did she still have a nickers
Speaker 1on when you found her, had been misunderstood, and that he had actually asked did she still have her necklace on? Even if true, however, this seemed to make little difference to the other evidence against him. He also claimed that prejudice against him as a Chinese man had influenced the case, pointing out failings in the investigation, such as the fact that footprints near y Chung's body had not been preserved by the police. Chung Yi Miao addressed the court for
Speaker 1nearly four hours and was worn several times not to repeat himself. The appeal judges Lord Hewitt, Mister Justice Avery, and Mister Justice Acton rejected the appeal. In dismissing it, Lord Hewitt said, the truth of the matter is that there was ample evidence on which the jury might find Miaou was guilty of this cruelly, diabolical and calculated murder. There is no ground at all for this appeal. Having
Speaker 1listened to his appeal, one is satisfied that whatever may have stood in his way, it is not a lack of acquaintance with the English language or procedure. Following the failed appeal, Chung's solicitor sent an appeal for clemency to the Home Office. Missus Mio traveled from China to England to campaign for a reprieve for her son and told reporters that she believed Chinese secret societies were responsible, insisting my boy is incapable of murder. A petition calling for
Speaker 1mercy was organized, with its supporters writing the spectacle of a possibly innocent person of foreign extraction suffering extreme penalty under English law through having been condemned on insufficient evidence is unbearable. Their efforts were unsuccessful, and Chung Yimau was hanged at Strangeways Prison in Manchester by executioner Thomas Pierpoint on Thursday sixth of December nineteen twenty eight. On the
Speaker 1same day, Wi Shung's body began its journey back to Hong Kong for burial at a Chinese Christian cemetery, while a killer was buried in an unmarked grave on prison grounds. Three months after his execution, the press reporter that Chung had made a confession to prison staff before his death. Allegedly, a doctor in New York had told Wei Shung shortly after their marriage that she was unable to have children,
Speaker 1so Chung had decided to kill her and find another wife. The papers quoted him as having said, she died so that I could marry another woman who could bear me a son and perpetuate my name. However, this account is questionable, as Chung already had a son with his first wife. Are The newspapers in Britain and America printed sensational theories linking Chungi Miau to a powerful Chinese Tongue or secret society.
Speaker 1They claimed that Wei Shung's family had been enemies of the organization for generations, and speculated that when the tong discovered their marriage, Chung was summoned to a secret meeting and ordered to kill his wife or face the consequences himself. Some reports even suggested that the two mysterious men seen in the Lake District in Edinburgh were members of the Tongue, and that the scraps of paper bearing ambiguous messages have been instructions from the shadowy society. No solid evidence was
Speaker 1ever produced to support these claims, and the stories may have reflected the fascination of parts of the Western press with what they presented as a mystery and exoticism of Chi culture. Before returning to China, Chung's mother gave an interview to the press that was very different from her earlier statements, revealing that her son had already been married in Hong Kong. She also disclosed that the mysterious Chinese
Speaker 1men whom several witnesses had seen traveling in a motor car were not members of a secret society at all, but detectives employed by the father of Chung's first wife. According to missus Meao, rumors of Chung's bigamy had somehow reached China and aroused the family's suspicions. She said that she had originally traveled to England to try and clear her son's name, but had since become convinced of his guilt.
Speaker 1She told reporters, I came here in the belief that my son was innocent of the crime and that there had been a grave miscarage of justice. I know I was wrong in that belief, and I have to acknowledge the sentence was a just one. There is nothing more terrible for a mother than to have to see that her son has been guilty of a terrible crime. She went on to explain that Chung's first wife had sent telegrams announcing that she intended to travel to England. Chung
Speaker 1would have received these messages while honeymooning in the Lake district with Wey Shung. His mother suggested that her son had become overwhelmed by the prospect of his first wife arriving in England and confronting him. Even while accepting his guilt, she tried to place some of the blame on Wy Shung, saying, it is my belief that he was not in his right mind. I believe that he fell under the influence of this woman, who had rare gifts of fascination, and that he became so infatuated with her that he could
Speaker 1not be held accountable for his actions when too late he realized he loved his real wife more than this woman, and that he felt he must end the affair. I pity my boy. Had I been near at hand, I would have saved him from the influence of this woman. These revelations cast new light on the scraps of paper found in the hotel room. The phrase arrival Europe, then discuss, may have related to the imminent arrival of Chung's first
Speaker 1wife or her family, rather than to any secret society. Chung Yimao's possessions were auctioned in Kezick on twenty seventh of February nineteen twenty nine. Among the items were jade and gold cufflinks, his camera, some leather attache cases, a tennis racket, wristwatchers, book suit cases, and various items of clothing. Somewhere, an object once owned by Chung may still sit gathering
Speaker 1dust today, passed down through generations and tucked away in someone's home. Its owner is completely unaware that it once belonged to the Lake District killer. Miss Beatrice Crossley, who owned the Borrowdale Gates Hotel at the time of the murder, died in nineteen seventy. The hotel remains open today, still overlooking the wooded valley and the blue expanse of Derwent Water that formed the backdrop to one of the Lake District's most extraordinary murder cases. At the heart of the
Speaker 1case was Whyshong see you, a young woman with the distinction of being the first Chinese student to graduate from Emerson College in Boston, whose honeymoon ended violently and far from home in the woods of Borrowdale. You've been listening to Prasher's Murder Map. If you'd like to support the show, please leave a thumbs up, comment or review Spotify. I'd love it if you could leave me a rating. Patreon supporters get access to add free audio only episodes, and
Speaker 1you can also sign up separately to my free newsletter via my website for news and updates. I'll leave the links in the show notes. Thank you for your support, an I'll see you again soon.
In November 1848, Wymondham in Norfolk became the scene of one of Victorian England’s most notorious crimes when James Blomfield Rush shot and killed local landowner Recorder Isaac Jermy and his son. The double murder...
In September 2017, occupational therapist Dianna Mah-Jones and her husband Richard were murdered in their Vancouver home by a stranger who had watched Dianna from the street. CCTV, discarded murder weapons, and a...
In November 1966, respected Buckinghamshire doctor Helen Davidson was brutally murdered while walking her dog in Hodgemoor Woods, leaving her fox terrier as the sole witness. There was no clear motive for the strange...
In the summer of 1912, 21-year-old Minnie Morris left London for a working holiday picking fruit in the quiet fenland village of Walsoken. When her body was discovered beside a country lane, suspicion fell on fellow...
In January 1990, Ontario was gripped by one of Canada’s largest manhunts in 15 years. Peter John Peters, a violent ex-convict known as ‘The Tattoo Man’, terrorised the province for several days, leaving a trail of...