I’m joined by Harry Smith aficionado and folk singer Rodney Hargis (https://substack.com/@rlhargis) for a conversation about Harry Smith’s legendary 1952 Anthology of American Folk Music. It only sold 50 copies in the first years of its life but went on to be hugely influential on the folk revival, Bob Dylan, The Grateful Dead, and just about every other musician involved in Roots or really any serious popular music since then. Harry Smith Nevertheless, it is still a little hidden, a little mysterious, a little underground. That actually fits it very well because, as Rodney and I discuss, there is a lot going on in this compilation of 84 songs from 1927-1932. Harry was mainly known as a film maker, but he was also a magician, occult enthusiast, alchemist, etc… and ALL of that went into the making of his anthology. Sit back and listen and check out Rodney’s writing and Harry’s anthology. Get full access to Philosopher's Holler at wdjames.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Philosopher's Holler podcast. I'm W.D. James, your host, and I'm happy to have with me tonight Rodney Hargis, who is a fellow substacker. He writes at Rodney Writes About Music, and he's also a folk singer. So if you've paid any attention to anything I write or podcast about, you know I'm pretty into folk and roots music. Hello, Rodney. Hi there. Thanks for having me. Oh, my pleasure. Thanks for joining here.
SPEAKER_01How are you doing today?
SPEAKER_00Doing great. Doing great. It's a lovely Friday evening here in New Jersey.
SPEAKER_01All right. So you're both a musician and a enthusiast, I would say scholar based on your writing. And we definitely will get to Harry Smith's Anthology of American Folk Music, which A few people listening might already know about that, but I'm going to guess most don't, but they should. And it's based on that axiomatic assumption that I thought,
SPEAKER_01well, I really need to have this guy on and talk with him and get him to share some of what he knows about this, because you're writing onSubstack isn't maybe quite exclusively about the anthology, but it's definitely focused on the anthology. And man, it is in depth. So I will certainly point people in the notes here or whatever to your substack. But tell us just a little bit about yourself as a musician, as a person who came to like and appreciate folk music.
SPEAKER_00All right. Well, I was born and raised in the South and I grew up, I've mentioned a when we were speaking earlier that I was raised by a pack of Wild Baptists. And so I got, music has been part of my life ever since I was a kid. My dad sang in gospel quartets and I grew up inside a church. And then as I got older, I realized there was more to it than just church music and just what was on the radio. And when I was in my early 20s, a friend of mine turned me on to Bob Dylan and it completely blew my mind.
I'd actually, I had Highway 61 revisited that album when I was in high school.
SPEAKER_00And that was sort of like a secret text of mine because, you know, I graduated in the 80s and you can't walk around listening to Bob Dylan in the 80s. You're not. That's not cool. And so especially the way Dylan was in the 80s. But that's another story. Highway 61 really blew my mind when I was in high school, but I didn't know what to do. I didn't know where to go from there. And it's like, it's Bob Dylan. The catalog is so tremendous. And I was intimidated. And I'm like, I don't know. And so I met this guy when I was working in a record store and he introduced me to the Uber and he's like,
SPEAKER_00here, start here, then go here, then go here. And that was when it hit. That was when it all just sort of came cascading in. Bob Dylan has really been my primary musical educator ever since. Okay. I had my interest in folk music and all of this stuff came really from him because like in 92, 93, he released a couple of acoustic albums, solo acoustic albums, Good As I've Been to You and World Gone Wrong. And on Good As I've Been to You, he did covers of folk songs and just random things,
SPEAKER_00a few other oddball numbers. He did like Tomorrow Night do-off songs from the 50s. or maybe the 60s. I don't know the history of that song. But anyway, that's not the point. The Good As I've Been to You contained stuff like that. And then the second one, World Gone Wrong, was all more blues oriented. And that one was a little bit deeper. And there's a version of Stack Ali on that recording that just blew me away, just threw me for a loop. And I was like, oh, my God, this is incredible. And so this was sort of my introduction I started getting into
Doc Watson And started listening to some other stuff Listening to a lot of Grateful Dead The same friend of mine Who turned me on to Dylan Turned me on to the Dead Did me a very big favor there And I started going backwards I started listening to Dead shows
SPEAKER_00Listening to the stuff that they had done I'm like, who's Jesse Fuller? Who's this guy who did Beat It On Down the Line? What is that song? And I would just start tracing down these little Going down the rabbit holes Just to see where this stuff came from Because I'm fascinated And then in 97, the anthology was reissued and I was working in music retail at the time and I was like, I've heard about this thing, but I don't know. And I looked on the back and I'm like, I recognize a few of the names, but I'd never heard any of the songs. And I'm like, this has got to be pretty cool.
SPEAKER_00And I'm like, I've got an employee discount. If I don't like it, I don't like it, whatever. I went home, I put that thing on to the CD player because I've never had it on vinyl, which is, well, I'll talk about that in a minute, but I've never had it on vinyl so I put it on a CD player and for the next almost four hours I went through it straight through 84 songs I had never heard before and my little mind was so blown because inside of this I'm hearing lyrics that I know lyrics that I'm quite familiar with from Dylan songs and from
Grateful Dead songs
SPEAKER_00and I'm like This is the secret. Holy crap. I call it the Rosetta Stone sometimes. I get a little bit hyperbolic in my discussions about the anthology because to me it's just an incredible collection. And so once I got into that, once I started going down that rabbit hole, I realized this is my world. This is the kind of music that really moves me. And so that was how I kind of fell headfirst into folk music. And then in 95 Jerry Garcia died in 95 the anthology was reissued in 97
chronology straight so after Jerry Garcia died I picked up the guitar because that's what you have to do because I thought of course I'm going to be Jerry Garcia and Bob Dylan all in one yeah it doesn't work like that you have to actually work on it it doesn't come
SPEAKER_00magically and so now here's some however many years it's been since 95 I have turned into a decent guitar player I have turned into a decent songwriter and I've had a wonderful time on the way because like the beauty of for me music is like the connected tissue of life it is the thing that just sort of binds me to everything around me it's it's how I interact and connect with the world it's how I understand the world because I there's a song for it whatever's good there's a song to fit whatever's going on and
Once I got into Dylan and once I got so deep into that and his work and I got into
SPEAKER_00The Grateful Dead and started going backwards into this stuff, it was like I really found my home in the 1920s and 1930s, which was kind of surprising. I was like, wow, I didn't know it, but I absolutely loved this music.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. All right. Yeah, we'll push more deeply into why it might perform that role and what it is and some of what's on there and how it came about. Yeah. So it's Harry Smith's anthology. Who is Harry Smith?
SPEAKER_00Who is Harry Smith? That's a question we've been asking for 75 years. He is a polymath, which means he was an expert in many areas, but he was a very eccentric cat. He collected paper airplanes. He collected Ukrainian Easter eggs. He collected all sorts of things. He He was also a filmmaker, and it was his filmmaking that actually caused the anthology to exist. So what happened was he was making these experimental films,
SPEAKER_00doing this little, you know, cell-by-cell animations, because this is what you did back in the early 1950s. This is how you did animation. And so he's doing these really neat, you know, kind of pre-psychedelic, before we even knew what psychedelic was, he was doing these nice, neat little psychedelic animations. And the Guggenheim Foundation was like, hey, man, we really like what you're doing. We'd like to commission you to do this, you know, for real. And he moved to New York and got set up there and he brought his record collection along with him. So when he, while Harry was living in San Francisco,
SPEAKER_00even before that, he grew up on the West Coast. He grew up in Oregon and was a big record collector while he was in San Francisco. Started going to a lot of jazz shows at that time. So he would be at live jazz shows and then when he wasn't at a jazz show, he'd be in the record store or the secondhand store looking for old 78s And when he got to New York, after he got this Guggenheim grant, he took everything that he had, took all of his records, and decided to compile this anthology. And boy, howdy, did he do it.
SPEAKER_00It's 84 songs that connect to each other, which just still blows my mind. So that's Harry I believe he is also a magician, not musician, magician, correct?
SPEAKER_01And the symbolism on the album covers Material included in the liner notes. Things like the colors of, you know, it's like a six, right? Six album collection. Three sets of two is how it was originally released. All have alchemical meanings, I believe, right? Yes, that is the term. Organizational scheme draws on maybe his magical background,
but certainly sort of Robert Flood like 17th century alchemist or something like that provides the cover art I believe mystical instrument and somehow this is also supposed to be some sort
SPEAKER_01of key into the heart of America I think right it tries to be Yeah.
SPEAKER_00It really does. It tries very hard to be, to present this incredible picture of America at the time. He misses a few areas of the country. You know, I live in New Jersey. There's no New Jersey performers on the anthology. But he did capture some, he gave us a good survey of things that were going on. The first volume, Ballads, is beautifully edited. beautifully assembled.
SPEAKER_00It's like it begins with five child ballads. And child ballads are songs that came into this country from England, Scotland, Ireland that were cataloged by Francis James Child, I think, of Harvard in the 1800s. And so what Harry Smith did was he decided to open the anthology with child ballads, but he had to start with the lowest numbered one and work in sequential order based on the number of the child ballads. So he started with,
I think it was like 63 was Henry Lee and then Fatal Flower Garden was a little bit
SPEAKER_00higher up. And so that was how the first five songs moved. It was like you're moving progressively up child ballads. And then he switched gears and took us into what I call the relationship suite, the courtship suite, excuse me. Because each song for about six songs, there are about specific courtship interactions. Sometimes the girl And the guy get married, like in King Kong Kitchi Kitchi Kimeo. Other times it doesn't work out. Like in Omi Wise, her parents say,
SPEAKER_00excuse me, in Omi Wise, she was drowned by her lover, we think. We don't know exactly what happened. But then, you know, so then like each relationship situation ends differently. and the old shoes and leggings the relationship doesn't even get off the ground because the guy can't find a girl who is just too old and weird for any of the women to have interest in him so Harry incorporated humorous elements into this too but it was interesting because you've got this sequence of songs about courtship and they all have different outcomes then we get this timeline
which is sort of the
SPEAKER_00centerpiece of Volume 1 and it starts in 1804 with the song Peg and All which is talking about changes in the shoe industry in 1804 which really didn't happen in 1804 but we won't get into the details but it started out in 1804 and then the next song after that took place in 1807 and on down the line and there were a few spots where he kind of tweaked it a little bit because he's the curator, he's the editor, he gets to make the final call and so in a couple of spots he
took it out of order
SPEAKER_00just to make a point So he talked about John Hardy was a desperate little man and then he followed it up by a John Henry song and he did it because there was confusion over whether or not those were the same guy So that's mainly the first set of collections is mainly
SPEAKER_01ballads which what makes a ballad a ballad is it's a story song So he arranges the stories so that they tell a story, right? I mean, it's roughly, pretty closely, but as you said, with some tweaks, historically arranged. So that multiple layers of what's going on is kind of characteristic of the anthology, I think, and it's what has you know later people like Dylan and some other people in
the folk revival and stuff I think that's part of what like drew them in and once it draws you and it kind of keeps you right because it is like being in its own little universe it's not exactly how Grail Marcus used the phrase but he did use the phrase in including the anthology the old weird America right it's once you get in there you're in
SPEAKER_01in the old weird America, which is not a completely bad place to be. It might not be a real comfortable place to be either. But it is like a world and that has kind of its alchemical and cosmology and macrocosm, microcosm stuff that Harry knew all about and at least to some degree brought into how things were organized and described and presented. So name some of the Some of the artists recorded, at least on the first,
SPEAKER_01but don't have to limit yourself to the first set. Like some that we might have heard of if we're kind of into folk or have searched out some Dylan roots, and some we almost certainly will never have heard of.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so I've got one that everybody should have heard of.
SPEAKER_01It's the Carter family. Carter family appear actually the Carter family appear on every single volume of
SPEAKER_00the anthology appear on all three and even volume four which was released posthumously in 2004 they're there as well so Harry was very big into the Carter family so if you don't know anything about this they're sort of an anchor and they were my anchor the first time I listened to it I was like okay this I can I'm familiar with this um and then it gets a little you know you can get um Uncle Dave Macon, who's appears in the later part of the anthology was a Grand Ole Opry star. I'd heard the name, but I didn't really know that much about him.
SPEAKER_00Mississippi John Hurt is one of my personal favorite musicians ever. I could go on about him for days. He's on there and that just his performances on there really kind of changed my life and Charlie Patton is also on there if you're familiar with really old blues he was on there but he's listed as the Masked Marvel which is how they marketed that particular record which is pretty cool you know you can win a free record if you guess who the Masked Marvel
is by buying this record we'll give you another one for free so and then Buell
SPEAKER_00Casey who was a historian great singer and a great fiddler. Fiddle, right? I think. Oh, my God. My brain is frying here. Wagoner's Lad and Butcher's Boy. Yes, that was a banjo, Rodney. OK, sorry about that. There are 84 of these songs, as I've written about 46 of them. The details kind of get jumbled in my brain sometimes. So apologies for that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no problem. But um so yeah and then you can get into the completely unheard of people like the middle Georgia singing convention number one which I published about today and uh there we still to this day do not know the name of any person who appeared in that
SPEAKER_00group.
SPEAKER_01Oh wow. We may have an idea well we know one person who was involved with the group in some capacity but I'm not willing to say he was a singer because I don't have that for
SPEAKER_00sure and I'm very particular When I publish, I'm very particular about not making guesses or assumptions without clearly saying, this is me making a wild guess on this based on the information I've got. So this guy that we found, J.W. Stroud, whose name appeared in the article I published today, he may have been a singer in the group. He was involved with the Middle Georgia Singing Convention for years. But I can't be the one to say he was on the recording. That's not my place. So I try to be very careful about the record that I'm working
with because I'm
SPEAKER_00trying to create a historical document here. I'm trying to collect the information that we have on this stuff and present it to people so that in the future, when more information is available, other people can pick up where I've left off and we may be able to learn more about these people. because for me I just I think it's critical for us to make sure that we hang on to these little pieces of our history because this is us this is our identity and so I'm trying to do my part to preserve the record and to advance
the research okay yeah yeah so that we don't even you know just adds more mystery to the overall thing right that we don't even know who some of the people are and uh yeah well I'm
SPEAKER_01gonna I'm gonna tell you what I heard about how uh Harry started his collection and you'll know more whether it's apocryphal or whether it's really real or whatever. But more broadly speaking, like the 1920s and maybe early 30s were pretty big on recording both early blues and mountain music. The the record companies were trying to find these new audiences um
and and they they thought turns out to be false that you can only market music to the same people who made it so that is if you're recording hillbillies which is what they call mountain music back then hillbilly music you can only sell that to hillbillies and they'll only buy hillbilly music and if you're a black person you can only make what they call the race musics because only black people right from right off that's wrong
SPEAKER_01because like Anybody had anything to do with music was listening to all of it because it was all great. But so there was this kind of flourishing with this new recording technology. And so a lot of stuff got recorded, even though not all of it got released. But then like the depression comes along and kind of puts a stop to it because nobody has extra money so only a few people like the real big names get to record during the depression because people
still buy them but they're not taking too many risks on you know this little Delta Blues singer or this person down in this holler in North Carolina or something and then the war comes World War II comes along and a lot of vinyl was I don't know if they melted
SPEAKER_01it but somehow they recycled it to make War Products. So there was all this stuff and then the government, you know, fighting a war, I'm not blaming them, largely destroy much of this stuff. And so by the time it's after World War II, if you were kind of interested in that stuff like Harry was, it took real searching, right? I mean, he had to really go in those old record stores and I've heard stories about him walking down the street with somebody and there'd be a stack of
SPEAKER_0178s sitting in a garbage can and like, oh, hey, I'm dumpster diving. I'm going to sort them out right here on the pavement. Yeah, I need this one. I need this one. I need this one. Now this one can go. Yep. Yeah, yeah. So, like, you know, it's this weird structured thing with all these different layers with all these crazy weird America 20s and 30s type musicians that almost got wiped out due to historical... circumstances and at least Harry to a good extent did a good
part of reviving interest in that and fortunately some of the recordings still existed at the recording studios and you know it wasn't really lost lost but people weren't interested in it anymore they didn't know to be interested until people like Harry started showing this is cool and like people who were in the early folk revival
SPEAKER_01like oh James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D.
SPEAKER_00James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. He sent somebody else to do it for him, but he was the one who figured out like where Mississippi John Hurt might be based on a 78 Avalon Blues. And so he had a friend was traveling down there and actually
went down to Avalon,
SPEAKER_00Mississippi and found John Hurt, found him still alive. And John Hurt got a good, John Hurt got a revived career out of the deal.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00He didn't particularly like living in the city. He didn't like it when he moved up to the Northeast, but he did get a revived career out of the deal. And so there were all these people who got turned on to this by Smith's anthology and went out and found some of these performers and they did get a second life. And I just think it's so cool. Like, because we do have more recordings of Mississippi John Hurt. Thank God. I mean, this world needs all the recordings of Mississippi John Hurt it can get.
SPEAKER_01Amen. And so my turn on to John Hurt, here I go, veering off to the side for a second.
SPEAKER_00My turn on to John Hurt was actually, the anthology was what turned me on, but then I found an album called The Very Best of John Hurt. It was a Vanguard movie. It was a live album. So yes, it is the very best of Mississippi John Hurt. I'm one of those people who will tell you that live music is better. Period. Hard stop. and to hear Mississippi John Hurt playing in front of an audience like I'm so grateful to Dick Spotswood for that never met the guy but like
he's got like a he's on my list of people that I love by default because he managed to find Mississippi John Hurt you know and was able to bring this stuff to us so sorry for that sidebar
SPEAKER_01no no I like side routes and whatever um So I think you kind of alluded to this a little bit, but I like to push into a little more. Right. So in your personal story, it was Dylan. And then that was augmented by the dead and starting to explore various strains. And then a few years after that, what you've described as the Rosetta Stone was reissued, the the anthology of American folk music.
SPEAKER_01What did that You know, from a personals perspective, what has it been? What's your engagement? Why that anthology? Why do you... Hopefully, I'll point people towards your substack. But, I mean, you focus on one song at a time, and they are long, long, long, detailed, detailed, detailed analyses. I mean, they're really good. But you don't do that just because... Like the idea that occurred to you last Tuesday, maybe that would...
SPEAKER_01So tell us about you and the anthology.
SPEAKER_00So my relationship with the anthology began that day. I took it home and listened to it all the way through. And I got hooked immediately. You know, I'm working in music retail, bought the anthology, took it home and sat through for the three and a half, four hours of it and was a different person when I came out the other side of it. Like I heard... lyrics that I already knew. There's lines that Bob Dylan stole wholesale from the anthology and some that he borrowed and tweaked a little bit. And then Robert Hunter,
who was the songwriter for The Grateful Dead, did the same thing.
SPEAKER_00He borrowed a little piece here and there. And then the more you get into folk music, the more you realize a whole bunch of other people did it. And then you start to understand what the folk process is. And then you understand that it's not stealing. it's keeping it alive and it's that's how these songs stayed alive to get here is people tweaked them a little bit changed them up a little bit and kept them relevant for the times and they it stayed alive and so that's what's happened now is you have people like Dylan you have people who know this
stuff inside and out and who can go and pull things out and insert it into their own work and it works I mean boy does it work stuck inside of Mobile with the Memphis Blues again borrows
SPEAKER_00directly from I Wish I Was a Mole in the Ground by Bascom Lamar Lunsford. You know, all the railroad men drink up your blood light wine. Little things like that, just, I couldn't get enough of that. And so I started digging into this stuff just as a hobby. I was like, you know what, I want to learn more about this. And I started exploring the different, you know, different tendrils that it had. And then I finally, a couple of years ago, I, uh,
SPEAKER_00I was going through a difficult time. I had just recently lost my mother. And my health was in rough shape. I'm mostly deaf and have some other health issues. And I needed something to do. I needed something to pour my energy into because things were kind of difficult. My body was not agreeing with me. I was grieving. And I realized that if I didn't do something positive for myself, that, you know, I was at risk of all sorts of catastrophic issues.
SPEAKER_00And so that's what I did. I said, you know what? Let's go through the anthology. And I'll tell you, this didn't, the idea for this actually started a few years before that when this song of love by the middle Georgia singing convention number one got stuck in my head and I started digging around for information on them only to find there wasn't any. What just happened there? Why did I go fuzzy? Ah, there I'm back. I started rooting around trying to find something out about them and I couldn't and I'm like well you know what I'll figure this out one day and I
sort of backburned and I'm like one of these days I'm going to go through that anthology and figure all this stuff out because there's stuff to learn and then when you know in early
SPEAKER_002025 I was like you know what you need to do this just do it just take because I've never written anything professionally before I've never published research I've worked in instructional technology so I've worked in higher education for a long time but I did not have any experience publishing or sharing my research with a larger audience so this is all brand new to me the whole writing and publishing and but I felt like it just had to be done I felt like Somebody needed to take everything that was known about this
thing and put it out
SPEAKER_00there so that future generations can enjoy it as much as I have. And so that this music can stay alive. Because to me, it's critical stuff. It's important music. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, this sounds a little bit like a treasure hunt. Like, oh, there's this thing and it's not easy to find out, but I'm intrigued and I'm going to hunt and find out. But then there's this thing that's like, I mean, it's like religious mysticism or something, right? I mean, if you think, you know, some traditions will get into like, you know, the Bible or a sacred book and it's like looking for all the connections, right? Because there's secret meanings and there really might be
secret meanings, right?
SPEAKER_01I'm not poo-pooing that. Um, And looking for all the connections, you know, any, like, normal Bible will have, like, all, because, like, all the New Testament people are quoting the Old Testament, like, every other line, but they'll never say I'm quoting. So, like, they'll put little references in there just to help you see that. But, like, if you, like, are a spiritual mystic type person, and you're, like, looking for, like, what's the deeper non-literal, the spiritual meaning of that text, right? And how's it all connected? the anthology invites you to do that right as you went out
because the stuff even the stuff in there points to one another yes and then almost everything from at least the mid-50s forward in folk or roots or folk connected music like the dead
SPEAKER_01and whatever link to James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D. James W.D.
SPEAKER_00The anthology draws you in and it wants you to study it further. It wants you to dig deeper. And I can't suck myself. Okay, fine. You gave us a couple of little examples of this more contemporary person drawing this line. Tell us your favorite thread you found that runs through the anthology and steps
SPEAKER_01outside the anthology into somebody after the anthology.
SPEAKER_00What was the most interesting thing you traced down? I have found so many cool things here. I guess I should talk about Charlie Poole. Are you familiar with Charlie Poole at all?
SPEAKER_01I am not, I don't think.
SPEAKER_00Charlie Poole was a banjo player.
SPEAKER_01Oh, Charlie Poole.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah. I'm sorry. North Carolina Ramblers.
SPEAKER_01Ramblers, yeah. Cotton Mills and came up north and died of alcohol when he was about to get a contract.
SPEAKER_00Yep, exactly. He was almost going to go to Hollywood and drank himself to death. And he was a young, young man. So studying Charlie Poole got me to understand, like I was born and raised in North Carolina. I grew up down there. So it gave me a deeper understanding of where I'm from. I'm from a little bit further south than the cotton mills that line the North Carolina-Virginia border. But it was like a, oh my God.
kind of moment and it sort of helped because I did grow up in a town where there were cotton mills had been cotton mills they weren't there by the time I grew up they were just old hollowed out buildings that I knew used to be the cotton mill and so that was the kind of stuff that got me that gave me my connection with it I guess and I'm kind of falling off topic here I'm sorry so with going through the
SPEAKER_00Charlie Poole thing he had a fiddler who played with him named Posey Roar R-O-R-E-R and Posey Rohrer ends up appearing on four tracks on Harry Smith's anthology he's never named in the credits but he turns up in a few different places one of the places he turns up is A Lazy Farmer Boy by Buster Carter and Preston Young well get this it's actually Preston Young and Posey Rohrer on the track Buster Carter is not there now who is Buster Carter
SPEAKER_00This begs the question. Buster Carter is the guy who wrote Rolling My Sweet Baby's Arms. And so this guy, whose name appears on the record label, was not in the studio and does not actually appear on the anthology. There was nothing about him out there. I was able to find biographical information on this guy and assemble the first biography of him. And I say that because it's actually now a hat tip to somebody who just passed,
SPEAKER_00who's Kenny Rohrer, who is the great nephew of Posey Rohrer. He was from Virginia, Floyd, Virginia area around over there in the mountains. And he kept all this stuff alive. He was one of the people who helped carry this forward in his book on Charlie Poole. was released in the early 80s and had gone out of print and I was able to find a copy of it while writing about Charlie Poole and it was one sentence in Kenny Rohrer's book that led me to the information that I needed
about Buster Carter and that opened up the floodgates and that allowed me to create a biography of this guy
SPEAKER_00that we never knew anything about. And so that's like... It may not be answering your direct question, but it's one of the more fascinating and meandering things that I've found. God, there's just so many things inside of this thing. Mention lyrics that Bob Dylan stole. Let's see. I'm drawing a blank now. I'm sorry. I'm not able to connect to anything else right now.
SPEAKER_01So is there... Anybody post-Dylan, post-The Dead, more contemporary, who you're aware of, who are sort of intentionally dipping back into this stuff and doing some of what it was meant to... Because it had a mission. I think for Harry, it had a mission in America. I think he meant to set it loose and it was going to do something good
in America um so is there still is it still doing something good in America with some contemporary musicians that you're aware of who are oh yeah yeah okay tell us a little bit you know something my personal favorites would be Rhiannon Giddens and Charlie Parr both of them dip into this well regularly uh Rhiannon Giddens doesn't
SPEAKER_00do it directly She's very clever in her dipping. And in her... Brianna Gibbs is a genius. She's a brilliant, brilliant woman and I absolutely love what she's doing. Because she can reach back and pull something out and give us a brand new insight on it. And so she's somebody who I follow very closely. Anything she does, I want to see. I want to hear. She's performed near my home a few times. I've been able to catch her in concert. It's been an incredibly educational experience because she tries to
entertain and educate.
SPEAKER_00Now, some people don't want to go to a lecture. They want to go to a concert. And I get that. But music means more to me than just dancing. Music means more to me than just turning on the radio. Music is life. It is like the essence of who we are. It is an expression that we've been able to put together as a people. and that we've been able to carry it on. And so I see what Rhiannon Giddens is doing. And I just, you know, it's incredible. Charlie Parr, who is a guitar player out of Minnesota,
is also doing the same thing.
SPEAKER_00And he'll pull out an anthology cover here and there in his sets. And it doesn't mean my name is John Johanna. He's a little less well-known, but his work is incredible. And I would highly recommend him to anybody who likes this type of music. And then there's also Nick Cade. who's sort of a surprising one. If you listen to his music, you're like, how on earth does he connect to the anthology? But the themes, the lyrical themes and the spookiness that underlies a lot of
this stuff in the
SPEAKER_00anthology, Nick Cave just dove right in. It doesn't sound the same, but the spirit is definitely informed by the old weird stuff. And then, of course, there's the late David Johansson. who originally were the New York Dolls and then went on to become Buster Poindexter. In his later years, he fronted a band called David Johansson and the Harry Smiths. And they would play these songs and do them for modern audiences.
SPEAKER_00And it was great stuff. Fantastic stuff. So those are a few.
SPEAKER_01All right. So... You know, this is probably a hard, well, I'm sure it's a hard question. It's maybe not a fair question. We've talked about, you know, Harry Smith having some intentions about this and this idea of America and maybe even a spirit of America, something like that. What do you think Harry Smith's vision was of America?
SPEAKER_01That He's communicating to us through this collection of, would you say, 84? 84. 84 songs. So Harry is holding up a mirror to us, and he's showing us something interesting.
SPEAKER_00He does not ever in the anthologies. In 1952, the race of any performer is never identified in Harry Smith's anthology. Never once. he does not reference he does not specifically call out these are black performers these are white performers he leaves that vague for a purpose I think because folks are folks it doesn't matter what they have what they look like on the outside they are folks and Harry was pulling from that and what he was
showing us is that we are
SPEAKER_00a wild and diverse group of people But that's cool. Because we have the ability to do some pretty incredible things when we put our minds to it. And a lot of the American innovations in music are showcased on this. A lot of the things that appear on here are American artists taking old traditional forms of music and transforming them to become a true, purely American thing. And so Harry talks about the transformative nature of America.
SPEAKER_00You know, he talks about it being a a place of dreamers if you will and but he also gives us he also gives us the dark side of it because Harry's America is a place where presidents get killed two of them you know there's a lot of murder going on in Harry's world a lot like it's you know Camden New Jersey ain't got nothing on Harry Smith's world Like, so it does show,
SPEAKER_00like, there's a lot of tragedy, there's a lot of evil in the world, but there's also an incredible amount of beauty in all of it. And there's certain things that tie us all together, regardless of who, what, or where we are. And I think that was, you know, part of what Harry was trying to get across.
SPEAKER_01Well, transformation is, I mean, I'm not an alchemist, but I believe that's what alchemy is into, right? It's about transforming base things into refined things or higher things and that might be like poop into gold at like a material level but probably what's really going on there are more base elements say in human nature into higher how do you change what's the process of transformation
is at least a level and so it sounds like you're saying that's what Harry's trying
SPEAKER_01to show America is we're a transformative society and This is how hardness and ugliness get transformed. Partly just by making it into a song, right? Yeah. That's core to the blues, but it's really core to mountain music, which probably has more murder ballads than the blues, even. It's about a hard thing.
It's not like, oh, let me sing this on my birthday because it'll make me feel good.
SPEAKER_01It's about a hard thing, but telling the story well making it beautiful transforms it right now it's not just that horrible thing now it's a thing that we share in and we appreciate together and it can inform the larger story or whatever it might be something like that yeah and the thing the beauty of Smith is he never he never gives you any straight
SPEAKER_00answers okay it's everything is open to interpretation Herring never sat down and said, this is what it's all about. And in my writing, what I try to do is look for all these connections between the songs. It's like one section of each piece is devoted to just that. Just how does this song fit with the songs that preceded it? Because we know that there is a design. And what I'm trying to do is reverse design, you know, backwards engineer it and see what makes it tick. And it's pretty wild.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's the depth of thought and the degree of just like the way he assembled this and the way that he had to think to get it to this form is mind-blowing. That's the part that I can't wrap my brain around. It's like I look at it. I can appreciate that for what it is. It is a beautiful collage. It is an incredible piece of collage art. How in the heck did he do that?
Even the liner notes are printed in like a like a collage sort of form right which we'd associate with made with pop art a decade or two later but he's doing it in the early 50s like you know the song and then the numbers a separate thing yeah yeah man just the levels just the levels exactly and that's like that's that's the
SPEAKER_00thing that keeps me going it's like I know that there are connections between this song and the one before it what are they it all means something right you can trust that which which is what religious mystics is what guides them right they trust that you know whatever the sacred thing is of their tradition or whatever they trust that has meaning right and then that's what allows them to like go explore it and find that meaning and
SPEAKER_01Harry's kind of Well, we with Harry can go, well, I'm going to trust Harry's got the meaning in there, right? And look for all the things. But Harry was maybe trusting that American music had the meaning and we could find it. So I don't think I know at all the answer to this question. So I'm hoping you do. If you don't, fair enough. But I bet a dollar you do. So, you know, a lot of
the especially the folk music during like the the depression and leading up to
SPEAKER_01World War Two and then also in the folk revival had strong political uh associations um and I just I don't well it was my Mayday post so it's May 1st I published a uh thing on uh Led Belly and the Lomaxes and Woody Guthrie and Pete Seeger and the role of communism in that strand of reviving American folk music. I don't think Harry has those kind of connections.
SPEAKER_01He doesn't strike me as an ideologue. If you make that neutral or even positive, I don't think he is one. I think he's got this bigger thing is that right yeah he's he's Harry doesn't seem like a country's kind of guy you know in a certain way Harry seems more like a humanity kind of guy he seems from from my read on him he's you know he's looking at the bigger bigger picture he's not worried about the political
arguments of the day or
SPEAKER_00and he didn't, to my knowledge, get involved in a lot of the left-wing stuff that Hugh Akin and everybody was after a lot of the folk artists for. To my knowledge, Smith was never involved in that. And I think he just didn't feel like it was what, it just didn't jive with what he was trying to get across. I don't think he was opposed to anything that they were doing, but I don't think he felt that it was his place to endorse it. Yeah, which is probably part of why it's able to inspire so many different type people over
SPEAKER_01You know, well over a half century at this point, almost three. Well, I guess this year would be three quarters of a century. Is this the 75th anniversary?
SPEAKER_00Next year. Don't rush it. Yeah, yeah. I realized that I finished like halfway through the first volume and I was like, Oh snap, it's going to be 75 years in 2027. I've got to time this right. And so I was like, alright, we're going to do this now. It was another motivating factor.
SPEAKER_01Alright.
SPEAKER_00To finally produce the map to the thing 75 years after it was released.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So is it your goal to wrap up your song by song essay series during the... Well, the series, if I keep it going at its rate, it will wrap up sometime in 27, in early 27.
SPEAKER_00And I fully intend to keep going. I may take a break between volumes two and three just to catch my breath because it is a lot of work. But yeah, the intent is to make sure that it wraps up in 2027. And I've got some other wrap up pieces that I've been sort of writing as we've been going along. that I'm going to deliver at the end as well to sort of sum up the whole bigger thing because there are some very large things going on in here. And so I've been like keeping separate notes about that.
SPEAKER_00So I've got a lot of things coming down the pipe. And then once I'm done, I'm not really done because there will be new information. And so it's a journey that will keep going for as long as I'm around and want to keep taking it.
SPEAKER_01All right, cool. Well, maybe when we... get near the end of the series we can uh hook back up again if you're if you're willing and and check in and see what uh what these big things are that you're gonna lay on us at the end to draw up the all the threads and nice bows or something like that we're gonna try all right all right man well I appreciate you uh coming on tonight any uh Any last things you want to share with us that we we should think about or know
SPEAKER_01about Harry Smith's anthology of American folk music and its influence?
SPEAKER_00Man, you know, I'm never good at the closing word thing. It's like one of those like, oh, no, the build up. Only that it's the best damn thing ever produced by humanity. No. It is, in my mind, it is really one of the most incredible pieces of art ever produced by a person. And it's not, the song selections are incredible. The way they're sequenced is incredible.
SPEAKER_00Just everything about it is just absolutely amazing. And it is a delight to be able to come in here and try and crack it open. trying to figure out exactly what it was that he was trying to get across or come up with my own interpretation and I guess now that we've gotten to this point I've rambled for a second I guess the big thing is that these songs still matter music still matters all of this stuff still matters Peg and All which is the 12th song on
the anthology is about shoemaking and revolutions in the shoemaking industry and
SPEAKER_00it's talking about how In 1801, in 1802, in 1803, every day, get up, go to the shoemaking place, peg and awl, peg and awl, peg and awl. Day in, day out. 1804, a new machine comes along and it transforms everything. But at the beginning, everybody's really excited about it. Like, yeah! New machine, less work, yippee! And then
SPEAKER_00Well, we know what happens after technological innovation. We know what happens after gigantic upheavals of technology come in and do things to societies. We've seen that before. So the songs are still alive. The songs are still relevant. It may not be the automated shoemaking machine that's coming for your job, but the AI might be. Something is. And so it's like these existential threats are still with us
and the same themes,
SPEAKER_00the same human themes that underlie it all are still with us. So it's still valid. Just about every singer for the past hundred years has done some version of John Henry and everyone in their own mind was thinking about the technology of their
SPEAKER_01decade, right? The song stays the same, though. I mean, there are variations, but you could just sing the same song the whole time. It's just what it means in the context gets nuanced. But that, we've been singing the same song for 100 years, also carries some meaning and connects us to some deeper human... It shows that our struggles and our opportunities aren't just ours. They're really... While there's new aspects, there's aspects that are shared by other humans and who have shared their
SPEAKER_01experiences in music and other ways.
SPEAKER_00Awesome.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. Well, thank you again. Thank you. So I will note that we are recording this in the relatively new Substack Recording Studio. And this is the first thing I have, first podcast I've recorded in here. So I'm assuming that it will post like most things post. And I will be able to put notes down below and put a link to your Substack. Just in case it works a little differently than that, would you tell people where to find your Substack and music if
you'd like?
SPEAKER_00Sure. Oh, yeah. I am a musician. I forget about that. I am also a singer and songwriter. My Substack is at rlhargis, r-l-h-a-r-g-i-s.substack.com. And on there near the top, there'll be a link to Linktree and that can take you to my music. I am on YouTube. If you look at Rodney Hargis, I'm over there. And my band, which my bandmate, if you've noticed a person moving in the background, that is my bandmate and wife of 18 years,
SPEAKER_00Eva. And she is my bass player and harmony vocalist supreme. And we've been playing together since 2009 and have a great time together.
SPEAKER_01Hi, Eva the bassist. Awesome.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, that's the number three, the word 20 and the number six. And that's it. That's how to find us. Alright, well, thank you again and wrapping up here for Philosopher's Holler.
Thank you for tuning in! My guest on The Holler podcast this time is Blues legend, Dr. Corey Harris. Harris is an accomplished musician who has performed all over the world, played with the likes of BB King and Buddy...
Thank you Lynda Craig, Jeff Steele, and many others for tuning into my live video with Exploring Western Thought! Join me for my next live video in the app. I had the pleasure of being interviewed by Paul from Exploring...
I’m joined this time by Paul, ‘Pablo,’ Dordal. What is ‘retirement’? What is it ‘freedom from’? My guest today suggest it is more a ‘freedom to’. Our discussion was occasioned by Pablo’s essay 'When Your Life No Longer...
I’m joined once again by my favorite AI scientist, Terry Rankin. On this episode, we talk not about what has happened with AI in the past week or so, but some much deeper issues. First, we talk about the implications of...
This time I’m joined by Michael Martin to discuss folk music. Michael is in fact an actual folk musician (in addition to farmer, mystic, literati, etc…). We talk about what is folk music, how we each came to be...