Thank you Lynda Craig, Jeff Steele, and many others for tuning into my live video with Exploring Western Thought! Join me for my next live video in the app. I had the pleasure of being interviewed by Paul from Exploring Western Thought. It’s always great to discuss Plato. Get full access to Philosopher's Holler at wdjames.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01We can go ahead and start. So hello, everyone. I'm here with W.D. James. I'm Paul. And today we're going to be discussing the Republic, Plato's Republic. And I would like to start this talk by just sharing a quote from St. Clement of Alexandria. He wrote, In Book 5, Chapter 14 of his work, The Stramata, Plato, all but predicting the economy of salvation,
SPEAKER_01says in the second book of the Republic, Thus he who is constituted just shall be scourged, shall be stretched on a rack, shall be bound, have his eyes put out, and at last, having suffered all evils, shall be crucified. So, good, good. That's their segue into the Republic. It's a prophecy of Salvation history. But so I would like to, while we were talking to one another,
SPEAKER_01you shared with me that on your way to Christianity, you found Platonism first and also that the Republic was just a very important, important work for you. You found it very inspirational. And I'd like to ask what about the Republic struck you when you first read it and what do you find Yeah, yeah. Well,
SPEAKER_00first of all, thank you for having me on here, Paul. It's nice to chat with you, and it's always good to talk about my beloved Plato. So, yeah, in terms of conversion, you know, it took me a little while to realize that's what had happened, and that was the correct term, but How it came about, I mean, I'd read Plato before. I'd read The Republic before in grad school.
SPEAKER_00And it was the summer right after I finished graduate school, which, you know, I was a little less than thrilled about how my dissertation had ended up. I mean, I defended it and You know, got my degree in that sort of stuff, but it was a little under enthused. And as the academic job market almost always is, prospects weren't looking super great.
SPEAKER_00And I don't even know why, but I decided that I should just read The Republic that summer. No idea where it came from. Well, it's a good thought.
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, it was a great thought.
SPEAKER_00I don't, you know... Where it came from, I don't know. So, you know, I had this little, you know, kind of part-time job. And especially on Saturdays, there wasn't much to do. I just had to kind of be in a place and make sure nobody walked away with stuff. So I remember, you know, reading there while I was at work and, you know, other places. But, you know, I got through the Republic fairly quickly and And it was just like a bolt
SPEAKER_00of lightning or something like I got it. Like, you know, I'd read it before, but it hadn't really clicked. I didn't realize how profound Plato's view of the world was. And, you know, I don't think it's easy to to get Plato and at least in teaching Plato for 30 years or so now. I think it's become a little harder for students
SPEAKER_00to put on the platonic lenses or whatever, to get what transcendence might be, right? To even think and to think, you know, he tells myths and stories and to Enter into that imaginatively. I think it's just become harder for us. But for whatever reason, that summer it clicked for me. And just kind of like overnight, I was basically a Platonist. I'm not sure I would still in any unqualified way describe myself as a Platonist,
SPEAKER_00but I sure love Plato. I think there are some limits and whatever. I don't know if there's one single... Philosophical label I'd be completely comfortable with, but still super influenced by Plato. And you asked me what it was I saw or what was going on with Plato there. And if I can figure out the technicality of screen share here, as you were trying to coach me on earlier, I will just share one slide that I use in teaching.
SPEAKER_01Great, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I think that's visible there.
SPEAKER_01Yep, I see it.
SPEAKER_00What I can try to convey to my students is that Plato's thought is beautiful. It has structure, it has order, it has harmony, and This slide comes up after about two weeks of studying Plato in my social and political philosophy class. So we're nearing the end and we've talked about and read a good bit of Plato.
SPEAKER_00And as we go through, we capture each line of this. The creation line there, I tell them the story from the Timaeus about how the Demiurge creates the material world. And the line on the soul there, I tell them the story from the Phaedrus about the winged chariot as a metaphor for the human soul. And then the other three we pick up from passages that we study together from the Republic.
SPEAKER_00And I don't know if your viewers here can start to tune into this. You know, it's very brief here and there's not a lot of background. But there's this pervasive structure that I think is a real key to understanding Plato. And it just keeps coming up. And it just struck me like, oh, this is beautiful. This is ordered. There's always the transcendent reality. There's the more mundane, material, earthly sort of reality.
SPEAKER_00And there's always some key intermediary. That exact bridge or a connection between those things. And once you lay this out as kind of like a map, not only do you have the five sort of layers there, but you can start going up and down the columns. Right. And so, you know, just take the first column there. Well, the forms rule. The forms are the truth. The forms are apprehended through reason.
SPEAKER_00And you just see all the connections. So, you know, well, I'll leave it up there for a little bit if people are trying to actually read it there. But, you know, I think that's what clicked with me that that summer was I finally tuned into, you know, I wasn't just taking it paragraph by paragraph or You know, you can get lost in the arguments in Plato, especially in the Republic. They're really relatively, you know, there's a few key arguments that he spends a good bit of time developing.
SPEAKER_00But, you know, it's a five or six hundred page book, depending on the translation. Way more of it. Stories and drama going on between the people talking to one another in the dialogue there than is devoted to arguments. So I think he clearly means for us to not get lost in the arguments, to see the bigger picture, so to speak.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, on that, too, about just like the easily getting lost. I know like a lot of people that I talk to about the Republic and especially people that haven't read a lot of Plato. I think Nietzsche actually got very hung up on that and thought that was like Plato's whole point was the eugenics.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, like you said, there's a few arguments that come in the beginning, middle, and end, and everything else is to serve that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and you know, there's stuff in there. Yeah, I mean, you're coming from a Christian perspective as well as I am. I mean, there are things in there that don't hold up well once you have Christianity, like the eugenics and whatever. Yeah. But, you know, that's the case with anything, really. And it's there. I mean, you know, I go into those things somewhat when I teach Plato with my students.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, I mean, he certainly qualifies the vision of the city that they lay out in speech in the, you know, as he says it in the Republic. And he says it may just be dreams laid up in heaven, may not be something that you can realize. If you did go to realize it, It's a radical vision, right? He banishes everyone over 14 or something like that because they've been miseducated. But it's not straightforwardly clear exactly what the Republic is.
SPEAKER_00I think you leave that somewhat open. Is this a blueprint or is it a thought experiment? I tell my students that they have to be careful when they read Plato and Because it can change your life like it did mine. So, you know, in the classic sense, it's a therapeutic test, I think. I think if we stay in it and live in it for a while, it actually starts to change our souls.
SPEAKER_00And I think Plato absolutely meant for it to do that. Not many books do that, you know, have the power. To do that. But I think the Republic does for sure.
SPEAKER_01I guess there's a point just to what is the point of this book. There's a part where I can't find exactly where, but he does reference, like you said, there's this blueprint in heaven that we want to model our cities after. But in the beginning, he describes the city very briefly with very few, like, characterizations. And I think it's Adiamantis is saying that, like, he wants to have more in the city.
SPEAKER_01He wants to have wealth and all these luxuries. And then Socrates says, I just found it, it's Republic Book 2. It's 372E. He says... So based off like the simplistic city that he's speaking of the simplistic city that he first talks about, he says, this is a true city, in my opinion, and a healthy one, as it were. But then with the Adi Mantis's description,
SPEAKER_01he says, let us then study a city with a fever if you want. And that's when you get all these like crazy notions that come in because he's trying to like balance the fever. So it's not necessarily, I think, like the goal that he's aiming at. And then again, he reigns it back in and is like, okay, now let's get back to the justice piece. So that's obviously the crucial thing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, one of the first essays I published on Substack was on that first city that he outlines there, which one of his interlocutors calls a city of pigs or a city fit for pigs because they don't have luxury and they eat nuts and they're healthy and naturally...
SPEAKER_01I'll have to go and read that after. I didn't know that. He does. I do think he takes the Philosopher King seriously, though. And one reason for it, I don't know what your opinions are about Plato's letters, but I think, or if you've read those, but I think letter number seven is normally the least contested. And in that, He actually says how he went out to try to make a philosopher king.
SPEAKER_01And so I think that was a real conviction he had, was that unless philosophers are kings, the city won't be ruled well. And part of, I think, book seven, he says he gets this conviction because he saw how a democracy put Socrates to death.
SPEAKER_00And yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I think it was the Tyrant of Syracuse or something that he, I believe, to become an enlightened monarch, but I think it was kind of let down, but yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right, it was like, it started with a D, Di, I forget the name, but yeah, it was, yeah, the Tyrant of Syracuse, and he didn't want to become a philosopher, and he tried to kill him, or he imprisoned Plato, or yeah, he didn't let him leave, and Yeah, they had quarrels. Do you think this philosopher king is, do you think that that is a good idea from a political perspective? Or, I mean, theoretically, I'm very, like, speaks to me, speaks to me theoretically, but I've thought of my own.
SPEAKER_01Like, it doesn't seem practical, but then again, I think like, well, Christ in a sense is like the philosopher king, wisdom incarnate.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, but. We didn't rehearse all this, and you may stop the recording right now when I go on this line of thought, but it struck me for the eight months now almost, seven and a half months that we've been at war with Iran, that their governmental structure actually bears a lot of Resemblance
SPEAKER_00to Plato's Republic. They don't have a philosopher king, but they have a theologian king in the supreme leader. So the guy with the ultimate veto is there because of religious credentials, not specifically philosophical. They call their military class the Revolutionary Guard Corps, right? Plato calls them the guardians. Then you have the whole citizen body who does the productive... And it seems like all
SPEAKER_00their Iranian Revolutionary Guard higher ups all seem to have multiple PhDs to me. The one that we assassinated around April wrote a dissertation on Kant and had a degree in mathematics. So I'm not sure whether I like the Iranian government, but it strikes me that to some extent, and when we talk about Plato and we talk about ideas or forms,
SPEAKER_00it's always only going to be to some extent that we, on Plato's own accounting, that we would manage to embody those In a material, historical, changing, imperfect existence. So, I mean, I think you can structure a society at least somewhat. And you do get the hierarchy. Just to a good extent, a spiritual hierarchy notion going on there.
SPEAKER_00I mean, Plato himself is pretty skeptical, though. You know, later in the Republic, he He goes through the five types of regime that you can have, with the republic being at the top, but he seems pretty committed to the idea that even if you did manage to set up something like an ideal society, it would decay, as all societies do, right? On his account, it ends up decaying into a democracy or a military aristocracy, right?
SPEAKER_00And then further decays into an oligarchy, a democracy, and a tyranny. Right. You know, I think these sort of tensions are always in Plato, which is one of the things I like about him. You can get fixated on the eternal forms and the idea of contemplating those. But there's sort of this realistic and dramatic element with Plato. I think he gets that we're always aspiring towards this,
SPEAKER_00but always struggling to realize anything that's ideal. And that goes all the way down into his discussion of the soul or the psyche and its multidimensional parts. And there's always this war going on Inside us between the different elements. And we can hope that our reason, the part of us that is able to connect to transcendent reality, to know it to some extent anyway, wins out.
SPEAKER_00But he's not real optimistic there either. There's a lot of things, which is why I spend so much time on education in the Republic. There's a whole lot of things that have to go right for a human soul to end up ordered properly. On a platonic account.
SPEAKER_01And it seems like he has a similar view with the soul, as you were saying, with the state. Even though you have a just soul, a well-ordered soul, that doesn't mean it can't get thrown out of whack. And then you need to put it back into order again. Because, yeah, it seems like it's an ongoing process with the person, at least on this side of reality and his world becoming, so to speak. And same with the state. Um, he, he does mention too at, um,
SPEAKER_01one point, like, I think it's Adiomantus again that objects and is like, well, is this even possible? And he said, well, that doesn't really matter because we need an ideal to try to model it off of and then do the best we can from there. But you got to start with the ideal. If you don't start with the ideal, then it's like, cause whatever you produce will be a little worse than the exemplar you have. So I thought that was it. That was an interesting idea. And also too, with the, um, What you're saying, like the fact that he recognizes that it decomposes and we have to put it like kind
SPEAKER_01of back in order. And you can't have just like a perfect state everlasting here. I think kind of shows like, because a lot of people, and again, you were saying it's hard to really understand Plato the first time. I feel like a lot of times you think that he's just all about the forms and to him, that's all that's important. But I think like that just goes to show like he has his head in, In this world as well, and cares about the practical affairs, too, like, well, while we're here, maybe not as much.
SPEAKER_01And that appears again in the letter, Letter 7. He actually, one of the reasons why he's motivated to go to Syracuse is because he says, I don't want people to think I'm just purely theoretical. I want them to know that I'm practical, too, which is interesting. And I think that shows in this work. Like, it's not, yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think... What he excels at is understanding our aspirations and where those come from, right? Because if there were just the mundane world, just the material world around us, it would be awfully hard to explain why we hungered for something permanent, something perfect, something pure, right? Because we would have no experience of that. So where would we get these notions? And at least in part, I think he's trying to give an account of why human souls have these hungers
SPEAKER_00that we do. I forget which. It might be in the Republic, but I don't think so. Someone addresses Socrates as you erotic man, right? You loving man, you desiring, but it's not physical desire that's being talked about there. It's the aspiration for transcendence and wholeness that's taken to be, at least there, Socrates' primary attribute.
SPEAKER_00Not that he knows a bunch of stuff, it's that he loves strongly and that That love is what's shaping his philosophical quest in his life. That idea is absolutely fascinating. Maybe it's because I'm dim and I have a lot of trouble finding truths that I feel are satisfactorily. Like, okay, 100% this non-trivial truth I'm committed to for purely intellectual,
SPEAKER_00rational reasons. There are very few of those that I have, but I have a author that's with me constantly. And maybe that's just how I read Plato then and somebody else would read it differently, but I think he's all on to that. And I think this... This tension that he maintains, I mean, it might be getting far afield here, and you can reel me back in if you'd like, but when we were, well, you started off with a quote, was it Irenaeus?
SPEAKER_01St. Clement of Alexandria.
SPEAKER_00This is a Platonist, pretty much. And Augustine, I think, was pretty much a Platonist. He definitely was a Platonist earlier, and
SPEAKER_01he talks about that.
SPEAKER_00Even in the middle of his life, yeah, for
SPEAKER_01sure, because Ambrose was a Platonist. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But I think he just, in a sense, I think he just divides these things, right? The city of God becomes a somewhat incarnated version, I think, of Plato's Republic, a true city, right? Yeah. A city of genuine love. And
SPEAKER_00the thing that's in tension with is the city of man, the earthly city, the city driven by the desire for domination and glory. But to me, it seems like that's essentially the same struggle. He's just putting in a more historical and almost more sociological approach Right. But so then he sets history in motion, which Plato is not really a big historical thinker. Augustine is. So to me, it's like he takes this metaphysical existential struggle that Plato's talking
SPEAKER_00about, and he sets that in motion through history. And he goes, well, it's like these two cities fighting it out and neither, you know, completely dominates. And we won't get the realization of the city of the God of God. Here and now. And I think Plato would mostly agree with that. But it's still active, right? It's still doing something in the world.
SPEAKER_01I think you're right to see an influence of Augustine, City of God, City of Man. I don't know how far we should take it. But I think you're right that there's an influence of Plato there because it seems like Plato's two world thesis of The eternal world and then the world of becoming, the world of being, the world of becoming. And St. Augustine similarly has the city of God, which is spiritual, and the city of the flesh. And St. Paul makes a distinction between living according to the flesh, or according to this world,
SPEAKER_01versus living according to our true homeland, which is immaterial and God. I think you're right. There is a certain, there's a similarity happening. Yeah. And it's equally dramatic.
SPEAKER_00It's just the drama is more historical in Augustine. Right.
SPEAKER_01And then the truth shines forth brighter too in Augustine because he has the Christians, but Christianity. But yeah. Interesting. So, well, you were saying that it seemed like when you're talking about like, What really struck you when you were reading this work, when you talked about the harmony as one or like how you show the inner harmony of his work, how the threes go throughout all the work.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01One thing that I thought of in Plato's Timaeus, when he fashions the world soul and all the it goes to the whole geometry of like how he's dividing up the parts of the world soul. And I think it's, I think the first person to note, I don't know if it was noted earlier, it's definitely noted by the fourth century Neoplatonist Chalcidius and the medievals take this up too in the Timaeus that like that whole division is
SPEAKER_01a harmony. Like, so there's like this immediate, like that division corresponds to musical scales, which I couldn't be able to see that because I'm not a musician nor am I. A really good geometrician. But, yeah, I thought that was just really fascinating. And then, like, I think that's partly, like, for any of you who's read, like, C.S. Lewis, The Magician's Nephew. That's, I think, why he has Aslan, like, create the world while he's in song and dance.
SPEAKER_01And it's just, like, flowing forth from him because it's, like, the good is diffusive. But so you see that order, like, that Getting back to Plato, that he's speaking to that in the Timaeus, that the world has this deep order. And I thought that was really interesting, the order of the threes that you highlighted. And I think you could probably even bring the threes and like the three better forms of government. And Aristotle even, because he has a six forms of government, he has a three good forms, three bad forms.
SPEAKER_01So he seemed to continue that too. Yeah, so the harmony was an interesting piece. And then you also, you seem, a lot of what stuck out to you seemed to be a lot of like the metaphysical component. Did the cave, the allegory of the cave and that two world thesis, did that jump out to you at all in the metaphysics or was it more the harmony, soul, peace?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, that all comes together in the allegory of the cave. And when it turns out that the sun is the form of the good, it's like, well, that blew my mind for a little. Well, in what way is it the good enlightens existence? But I should say another thing that. And this was probably actually the more decisive and I'm not. I struggle with it a bit now, but it was the hierarchy that got me, right?
SPEAKER_00That was what was completely alien from modern thought and the modern world.
SPEAKER_01The hierarchy of the world or the hierarchy of the state or both?
SPEAKER_00Metaphysical hierarchy, hierarchy of quality. And the whole idea that, you know, with Plato, that some things are more real. Then others, uh, or participate in existence more fully. Um, and it wasn't long after that conversion that I got interested in, uh, the traditionalist or the perennialists, whatever you want to call them, who pick up that side of Plato and then critique the modern world from that perspective. Uh, so I got quite into them for a while too, uh,
SPEAKER_00on my way to reconverting to Christianity, uh, I don't know, probably 10 years later. I think I told you when we were talking, I counted up and like told you, but I don't remember now the number of years. Um, but you know, nobody that you just, you know, happen to talk to in, in the modern world is, is going to come with that, that sort of mindset. And unless they're CS Lewis, that's like the only, the modern world who is saturated,
SPEAKER_00um, And he calls it the what the broken image or the discarded image.
SPEAKER_01Discarded image. Yeah. Yeah. That's such such a great work. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I'll just you know that and I still have that. I mean, I'm uncomfortable with some of the implications of that, right? Because some people will take that and apply it politically and advocate a very hierarchical, rigid, Class structure. Which I'm not a big fan of, but. But it does.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, so I think the metaphysical hierarchy in Plato is very interesting and like all the early Christians, you see that in their thought. I'm taking a class on Augustine right now and. He really runs runs with the whole hierarchy scheme. He actually has a whole proof on the free choice of the will. When he's proving God's existence, he starts out with the hierarchy of inanimate, animate, then rational beings. And then God's on the top, which,
SPEAKER_01and that, I mean, you see that, like, it just seems to be standard in all philosophy. And I think once you agree to this hierarchical structure, I feel like it makes it a lot easier to understand, like, a need for some hierarchy in government and how just, like, a full, like, democracy changes. Probably doesn't work because that's the way that I see it because it seems like the metaphysical structure should, if that really is truly what reality,
SPEAKER_01if our metaphysics is like telling us how reality really is structured, I think all things need to kind of follow from that because like ethics follows from our metaphysics and I think our politics should too. Now like, You can't have an exact one-to-one correspondence with everything because metaphysics is metaphysics and politics is politics. But I think, yeah, it does speak to you need some hierarchical, you need someone calling the shots, you need people that are doing more of the obeying.
SPEAKER_00I don't really agree with that. I probably would have when I first rediscovered Plato, but for Christian reasons, I don't agree with that. Just good gospel reasons. The gospel is quite clear that who Christ was most interested in and who were most interested in him were not the spiritually high or
SPEAKER_00the politically high. It was the humble, right? The people who knew that they weren't the high. So I think Christianity does throw up A different element into this. The saint will not necessarily be the best Platonic philosopher. Almost certainly the saint won't be. Well, there's some saints who are. But most saints aren't Platonic philosophers.
SPEAKER_00They're humble people with faith and love. So I take that seriously. And I take that as at least intention with Plato. What do you think of that?
SPEAKER_01So I think I think you're right that Christianity throws a curveball, but I don't think it destroys the hierarchy. I think it puts a twist onto it.
SPEAKER_00So instead of
SPEAKER_01being a hierarchy of metaphysics, it's more about a hierarchy of grace, because I think of like like. The devil, in a sense, is he's higher on the hierarchy than I am much higher in the tradition used after God was supposed to be the highest thing. But yet we don't acknowledge him as higher than us in any degree or it would seem wrong to do so. And I think it's because the hierarchy of grace became important, like by nature, the angels are higher than the Blessed Virgin.
SPEAKER_01But by grace, she is she's the one whom We look up to as the best imitation of Christ. So I think that that but I think, yeah, that that probably throws a wrench in it. And I think that is why I'm like Christ. That's connected to why Christ calls like the rulers to be servants of all, because like it isn't just about leading like the natural hierarchy of nature. But yeah, so I think he wants because he's looking at the end of the day.
SPEAKER_01I do like. And I guess like heaven does have this communal, like we're going to be in this peaceful community in heaven. And so I think even in the Republic, I guess I think of that too. Like Plato also tries, while having hierarchy, also tries to like eliminate it in some way too, by having like sharing things in common and stuff like that. So I see that a little bit in continuity with like the ultimate Christian vision.
SPEAKER_00I mean, in Augustine, he clearly places a hierarchy of power as an attribute of the city of man. Right. Attribute of the city of God that the leadership are servants.
SPEAKER_01Right. And then also, and again, this came up on free choice of the will, saying Augustine says it's not the higher lower things cannot be affected by higher things. And he is more of a metaphysical claim that he's making that like I can't be something. Sorry, lower things can only be affected by something higher. So I can't be caused to do anything. The cause of my actions has to be myself or from something higher.
SPEAKER_01But when he is When he's thinking about this, he puts the demons as something lower because they're basically nothing at this point because they have fallen so far. I think, again, that speaks to the grace component. I think the hierarchy is still there in Christianity, but it looks different and it serves a different end.
SPEAKER_00I think the metaphysical hierarchy is there. The impact on human communities is pretty profound, though.
SPEAKER_01And and we still have Christ as the head and the king. But I guess in terms of us, none of us are. Yeah, yeah, none of us is is really king. And I know there's there's parts in the New Testament where Christ in front of Pontius Pilate says, well, you have no authority unless it was given to you. And St. Paul mentions the authority of the state to wield the sword, I think.
SPEAKER_01But besides those, yeah, you're right. There's not a lot about the state really acting, and it's a lot more about the people of God. It's a spiritual hierarchy, too, between the bishops and And that becomes what's more important, adhering to them.
SPEAKER_00It's pretty platonic, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Because I don't think Plato really has a conception of self-sacrificing love. If he does, it's not the guiding force of the Republic. I think Eros is the guiding force. Aspiration, Desire is the guiding force. Right. Because it changes the world when Christianity centralizes Agape.
SPEAKER_01Right. So I think the closest thing you have to this is not really self-sacrificing yet for other people. I mean, you have Socrates that self-sacrifice for truth and St. Justin Martyr picks up on that in his apology, basically calling him like a proto-Christian in that way. Because he says like as Socrates died for a reason, he was in some way dying for reason himself. Because there's a continuity between like Logos with a lowercase l and a capital L.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, you don't really see him doing that for others. It seems a lot more like... Focused on self-purification. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Which I think is characteristic of most Greek and Roman philosophy. I love the Stoics, right? And the Christians also talked of our Seneca, right? When discussing his ethics and how pure his ethics were. So they certainly saw predecessors there. Yeah. And people who were much more friends than enemies, intellectually and spiritually. But there's a good bit that's not in Greek and Roman philosophy.
SPEAKER_00That is in Christian philosophy.
SPEAKER_01Speaking to, I just thought of it in the continuity with Plato and Christianity. It was taught to me... I've actually never went to see if this is true. I've taken it. But the word that Plato uses for turning around in book seven is metanoia.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01Which is like, yeah, the spiritual practice we have of turning around and repentance. So I thought that was really interesting that it's like that theme of education being a turning around from the lower things to the higher in Christianity of That's what enlightenment is, is turning from the carnal world to the spiritual world, as St. Paul would put it. So yeah, I thought that was an interesting frame. Although I'm not claiming that Plato was really Christian in saying that.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I know there's obviously differences, but yeah, I thought that was an interesting point of comparison there.
SPEAKER_00He prefigures a lot. He prefigures a lot.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah, it does. Yeah. And yeah, the early church definitely saw that because there's a lot of church fathers as I wrote in one of my posts. I gave like a smattering of just why I care about Plato is the post I wrote. It was the first one and it was just like all these things the church fathers saw in Plato of either. And yeah, there is. There's a ton of references, which was really cool. Um, one thing I want to ask you about.
SPEAKER_01So I've read through the Republic in full twice now, and then I've reread several sections multiple times, but the second time I reread it, I was like, wow, this is, this is just so amazing. And then I got to book 10 and I was like, I feel like book 10 could be discarded except for the end, the myth of her. But in Book 10, he basically criticizes poetry very heavily. And I think his reasons for that, for anyone listening who's not familiar, it's that poetry is basically...
SPEAKER_01So this world, he says, is an imitation of the eternal world. And so poetry is just creating another imitation. So it's more fake. He also says it stirs up the passions, which he says being overly passionate and not rational enough is... Characteristic of an unjust man, so it would make us unjust. And then he, there's definitely another criticism that he has, but when I'm reading it, I do feel like, I feel, I see where he's going at.
SPEAKER_01But then I'm like, no, but poetry needs to stay because I'm like, I have in my heart just like it's a big place in Christianity, Western culture. And it definitely teaches us. And I mean, going off of I don't know if you've read Sir Philip Sidney, his 16th century.
SPEAKER_00Not really.
SPEAKER_01Writer. He writes on the praise of poetry and it's a defense. He comes in to defend poetry. And I think he alludes to Plato's attack. But one thing that he says is he so he has a broader definition of poetry, but I think it's it's correct. It's basically using any like artistic language, any any language that's not necessarily just in prose to depict to depict the truth. And he's showing that like poetry can do things that prose cannot. And because prose falls short. And he said, like, that's why Christ speaks to us in parables.
SPEAKER_01Part of the reason and not just in prose. And I thought that seemed like very That seems accurate to me. And that's why, like, reading the Divine Comedy, like, you get, like, understandings of aspects of the faith that you wouldn't get just by sitting in a theology class. And, yeah, so I wanted to know, like, your thoughts of his critique and of poetry and, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So, I mean, he definitely says critical things of poetry and in the I mean, in the Republic, he banishes the poets. But then he sets about, we're going to have to create a new poetry, right? A true poetry to educate the guardians. Actually, I wrote a, I think it was like a seven essay series, kind of on this question as well. I think it was last summer. Not this past one, but the one before. Looking at the apology and...
SPEAKER_00I mean, quite clearly in his description of Socrates and his trial and his justification of his life, I mean, again and again and again, he presents Socrates as a new sort of hero, right? He even explicitly likens him to Hercules and these things. Look at how he's developing the story. It's like he's developing sort of this heroic journey that
SPEAKER_00So what I say there is that Plato ends up, well, so if you look at, so Socrates is the figure or the archetype of the philosopher for Plato. Right. But then Plato feels that he has to become a poet to tell the story of Socrates properly.
SPEAKER_01Hmm.
SPEAKER_00And so what I suggest is that the life of philosophy or the practice of philosophy as represented by Socrates' life ends up being framed in a poetic context to bring out the significance and the meaning of it. And Plato does talk about having made a choice between being a poet and becoming a philosopher. And he's obviously a very good writer. I mean, Tells myths. He doesn't shy away from these things.
SPEAKER_00He's a really good writer. It's fun to read him. More fun than Aristotle or somebody. I mean, Aristotle might end up being more true, but he's not nearly as fun to read as...
SPEAKER_01I think Plato wanted to be a playwright before, and no one accepted it, but yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but I think that basic Because he keeps doing this same move over and over in all kinds of different writings. There'll be a dialogue going on between two or three characters. And they'll be getting pretty far into this argument. And they'll have parried a few missteps. And we'll feel like, okay, we're about to get to the truth. And Plato then essentially has Socrates or someone go, Anne, let me tell you a story.
SPEAKER_00It's like this. Right. And the whole republic is that. Yeah, it's got these arguments, but the real point is the unfolding of the story. Right. Plato always, at the end, doesn't rest with arguments. He rests with having told a really good story.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. The Timaeus comes to mind. The whole thing is a likely tale. He says that I counted... It was 14 references to it being a likely tale or a likely story. And I probably missed some counts. So you're making it very clear that it's a myth. And again, I forgot about this part, but I was thinking about it when you're talking. In the Phaedo, at the end, Socrates, before he dies, feels like he needs to turn to poetry.
SPEAKER_01So I know that wasn't Plato's own conviction, but Yet as a follower of Socrates, I feel like that would have been very important to him. And I wonder if, so I know because poetry had a very important place with the Greeks, and he doesn't abandon it because he does appeal to Homer and stuff, or references Homer and seems to appeal to Homeric ideas. But at the end of the Republic,
SPEAKER_01After he critiques poetry, there is a line where he says, if anyone can refute me, please do, because I would love to have it. And then he goes and gives, I would call it a poem, The Myth of Ur. So I was wondering, is that his own justification? Is he trying to come to his own rescue there?
SPEAKER_00I don't think we should just take that as verse. I think his primary reference is the... The Tragedians and Homer. I mean, though Homer is inverse, but I mean, it's the telling of big stories that's really, you know, they're imaginative and educative. And in that sense, I think Plato in almost every dialogue is a poet.
SPEAKER_00Right. Always telling stories. He's always reframing things in a sort of a mythological way. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah. And you get that in the Republic, in the beginning, middle, and then the beginning with the Ring of Gyges, in the middle with the cave, and then at the end with the myth of Ur, the afterlife. And he's constantly, when it comes to things that are Like beyond human conception, that's when he's always true, turning to poetry, which I think I was saying with like Sir Philip Sidney, I think that was part of his point was that there's something only poetry can can do. Actually, yeah, this weekend I went to a talk that was titled that what only poetry knows
SPEAKER_01or what poetry only knows is that. Yeah. And that that was part of part of the point was that there's something poetry can do that prose can't.
SPEAKER_00And yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So, yeah, yeah, I.
SPEAKER_00But philosophy does have something to contribute to that for Plato, I think. And that's that, you know, I think he does think that the traditional poets lie. Right.
SPEAKER_01And the example of the gods, which was really.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. They present a god as doing a bad thing. Well, that's inconsistent with the idea of divinity. Right. And the same thing comes up in the always blank on the name of the dialogue. It's the one that chronologically would come before the Apology. Socrates is on his way walking to... Plato?
SPEAKER_01Oh, no, Euthyphro. Euthyphro.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And he's talking to the priest there. And, well, you must know what holiness is. You must... Because you're the expert, right? Yeah. But he keeps catching the guy up because the guy is inconsistent. And it seems like Plato does in his engagement with religion and with poetry... He does, in a sense, want to rationalize it. He wants it to become coherent in a way that a story about incestuous gods birthing their children out of their thigh
SPEAKER_00and killing their spouses and whatever isn't coherent. It might be an exciting story, but that's what Plato dislikes, I think. Not that it's a story about the gods. I think he's quite interested in stories about the gods, and he tells his own. Right. About the afterlife, anyway.
SPEAKER_01Or like in the symposium, he's using stories of the gods to explain what love is. And he's using stories that they know. He's using parts of stories that they know and love. And so he's not completely discarding their tradition.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I think they're both always there. I mean, he absolutely has a criticism of poetry as practice, but I don't think he's always a poet. He just is. Right. In addition to being a philosopher.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think also to the point of like that he doesn't completely abandon the gods either. Socrates right at his deathbed says go sacrifice for me. Yeah. Go sacrifice a chicken to asbestos or something. Yeah. Yeah. So.
SPEAKER_00In the beginning of a republic he's down at the Piraeus at a religious festival. Right. Right. As it opens, where it's just come from there as it opens. Socrates is always going around being pious. He is.
SPEAKER_01I'm glad you brought up in the beginning, in the beginning of the Republic, how he's going down to the religious festival. Because someone brought, I never thought of this before, someone brought up to me that that's like, it's important just the fact that he starts the story by going down, because it's like the Philosopher's King's Descent. Back down into the cave. And then he has to bring them back up. And I never thought of that before. And I was like, yeah, there's no accident. But but that's another point where he's being a poet, like even like the little.
SPEAKER_01From transferring from text to text, a little like the words that he uses there, like they are meaningful and yet they have hidden meanings like that. And yeah, and that that's his poetry shining forth. So yeah. Cool. I guess, yeah, one more question I wanted to ask you is the, yeah, just, it's broad, but I guess like what your opinion between the city,
SPEAKER_01I guess two, there's two, your opinion about the city soul analogy, do you think that's helpful for us today in politics? And just other thoughts you might have, you can free to share the city soul analogy. And also just his idea of the soul, his tripartite of the soul. Do you think? Yeah, just from what you know about other other views of what we normally think about the Christianity, like, is that helpful? Is that something we should discard completely?
SPEAKER_01Should we moderate it? Those? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So, yeah, the city soul analogy. I mean, it's fine as an analogy. I think it's literally true. One of the things that made me happiest in my life was when a former very good student of mine, we were talking after he graduated and he attributed my class on Plato that he took. Well, he's in law school right now and he's probably going to spend a life engaged
SPEAKER_00in political activity. And he attributed that class to teaching him that politics is about souls. Yep, it is. That's what Plato said. And the society and the culture you're situated in and the values that inform it shape the souls of all the people who live in that society and that culture. I think that's essentially true.
SPEAKER_00For we contemporaries, not good news. Yeah. But I think that's essentially true. And it's almost the, I mean, it's kind of the inverse of, I think Marx actually sees the same truth, but it's kind of inverted in Marx, right? His idea of base and superstructure and that it's the material conditions of life that shape people's thinking, which flips Plato on its head.
SPEAKER_00But it's parallel in that, The larger social structures we inhabit, at least to a good extent, inform our internal lives. So it's structurally similar, although flipped. But I think that's essentially true, that the world we live in and grow up in and are educated by and are taught its values and are bombarded by its values via media and whatever shapes our souls. I think that's right.
SPEAKER_01What was the second part of the question? I guess the second part, that was actually more of a new question. I guess just his tripartite soul. Do you think that's correct? Do you think part of it is? Yeah, just your opinions on that.
SPEAKER_00You know, I mean, it's almost got to be overly simple. Yeah. But it seems essentially right. I mean, It was darn near good enough for Freud, right? I mean, the superego, ego, and id are pretty closely parallel to Plato's conception, except transcendence is cut off. Interesting, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I never put those connections
SPEAKER_00together. There's only internalized authority performing the role of reason because Freud doesn't believe in a transcendent reality, but the structure is still essentially the same. Mm-hmm. You know, it's close enough. I mean, it gets at why we would experience internal dialogues, why we would experience internal conflicts, and that's structured through a higher and a lower. I mean, it's certainly very helpful, you know, whether it's the truth or all of the truth.
SPEAKER_00You know, probably not, but it's a pretty good heuristic, right? And again, if you take these things largely as teaching stories, right, because that... Well, that account does come up explicitly in the Republic, but it comes up most memorably in the in the myth of the winged chariot with the light horse and the dark horse and the charioteer. It's like, it's a story. And as a story, it helps make a sense of our experience, I think.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah, I think I think the Phaedrus, the myth of the charioteer and the Phaedrus. I think it sheds a lot of light on what he's doing in the Republic. So, yeah. Yeah, I agree with that. And yeah, he doesn't have the notion of the will, which is probably my biggest issue, but it works. He's showing, at the end of the day, he's showing what justice is and that it's a balance between these different parts. And also,
SPEAKER_01I think the different parts of the soul, it's interesting because that analogy of having the different parts is very prominent in psychology and a lot of like, Psychological therapy and stuff that happens. It's like the internal dialogue that you kind of have between different parts of yourself. So I think it's kind of cool that Plato seemed very insightful into that.
SPEAKER_00It's your interview, but can I ask you a question?
SPEAKER_01Of course. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Ask me what you want.
SPEAKER_00Where did you first come across Plato and get hooked?
SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, where I first came, where I first, Heard about Plato, so I've written about this actually twice on my Substack. So it wasn't the first time, this isn't the first time I read Plato, but the first time I heard about him was through my brother-in-law. I was 11 years old. And he was engaged to my sister at the time. And we go on family vacations at our lake house. And so he came with on the family vacation that summer.
SPEAKER_01He was showing me how to use throwing knives, and he was teaching me about the different metaphysical framework of Plato and Aristotle. And then at the end, I had to recite to my mom the lineage that Socrates taught Plato, Plato taught Aristotle, Aristotle taught Alexander the Great. That was my test at the end. But I remember he was explaining basically the two-world thesis of Plato, The forms being up there and with Aristotle, the forms being like in in this world.
SPEAKER_01And I just was like Plato's right. I just like
SPEAKER_00you were loving.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was I was 11. But I was like, what you're telling me, Plato just makes more. It makes more sense with Christianity because the immediate connection I made was like. Well, like, yeah, like there's this world is true, but Plato is getting at something Important that heaven is more true as like, that's where truth comes from. And there's the immaterial angels up there, God's immaterial and that they're affecting this world. And that's kind of like what the Christian tradition has always held. So yeah, I was 11 and that was,
SPEAKER_01so I was like, I'm going to hold to the theological view and not the practical view. And I was like, that's going to be what I want to dictate my life. And then when I was in high school, um, We came, I read the Apology. I had to read the Apology into a classical Catholic. It was classical education and Catholic. But we read the Apology and the Crito. And after we read that, we had to watch A Man for All Seasons. And we compared St. Thomas More with Socrates.
SPEAKER_01And so I bought a lot of that comparison. Because I remember when I first read the Crito, it was like, I was like, this is ridiculous. You should escape. And then he was like, well, everyone was like that in my class. And then he was like, I'm going to show you a man for all seasons and tell me if you think that's still true. And then, yeah, and then I had to read more Plato in college. And I just, I always, I felt like I needed to come to his defense because I felt like other professors
SPEAKER_01and stuff that I had when teaching would, and It wasn't necessarily Plato classes, but I think they brushed on him so briefly. It was too watered down and they have so much like the world, Plato thinks this material world is bad and the body is really evil. And I was like, I just don't get that exactly from Plato. I see a subordination, but not necessarily an evil. And yeah, when I read more of his works, I wrote something about this too on Substack. But yeah, when I read more of his works, I'm still very convicted of that.
SPEAKER_01And I see I just really came to see the Christian worldview. I mean, like, we say things and when we pray, like, we're not condemning the world, but like in the Hail Holy Queen, we refer to this world as a valley of tears. And the Church Fathers, too, talk about the prison house of the body. And it's Wisdom 7, verse 14 says that... It's important. It's the corruptible body, not the body as such, but the corruptible body, it says, is a burden on the immortal soul.
SPEAKER_01And St. Augustine speaks to that a lot. And so, I mean, I think Plato leaves out the fact that the soul is also darkened, which is what we hold by Christians. So it's not like the soul is like this pure good thing. I mean, it is a good thing, but as we experience it, it's not like it's in a pristine condition.
SPEAKER_00But But yeah, so I think problems go deeper than simply being ignorant.
SPEAKER_01Right, right. And deeper than, yeah, just just the body being an obstacle. But I think Plato is hitting on a lot of real truths and without divine revelation and knowing that. The fall, I think he was accurately describing the world as we see it, that it's that there's some there's some burden to the material world and that there's something liberating about the spiritual and then. I mean, Christianity fills that in with the fall and the resurrection of the body. But yeah, I saw those connections and parallels and I just became more and more fascinated.
SPEAKER_00And yeah, that's cool.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's my story. Yeah. And also the cave was really, the cave was really big. I think, I don't know if you heard of the TV show. I don't know how long it was on, but it was when I was a kid. It was called The Lion King. Oh no, between the, no, not, not the line between the lions, between the lions. And it's like, they, it's like, they're at the
SPEAKER_00library, like it's two lions outside the library or something. Right. Yes. Yes. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I, I forget everything. I was really young when I was watching it, but I have very vague memories of there was one point, like they would like put on like, um, like ancient, like they would give like a, like, it was like an, It was like some cartoon illustration of ancient Greek myth or something like that. And they had the Allegory of the Cave, I'm pretty sure, on one of the episodes. Because I remember reading the Allegory of the Cave and being like, in between the lines, I was like, I feel like I learned this on TV as a young kid.
SPEAKER_01So, yeah, maybe it was a different show, but I think it was that one. Yeah. Oh, yeah. But also, it's just like the allegory of the cave also seems more and more real to me, too, as like technology becomes really dominant in A.I. and like you really see this the shadowy world. I think someone also gave like. They handed out one of my professor, it was a guest lecture in one of my classes, and he he handed out like a paper that was comparing the the Ring of Power and
SPEAKER_01the Lord of the Rings To the phone and being like, we get sucked into this fake thing, talking to it, worrying if it's in our pockets or not and stuff like that. And I thought that was a great analogy with the phone, but the connection I have, it reminded me of just kind of like living in the cave, like the concern about winning the game on the shadows of the wall,
SPEAKER_01saying the right things for the prizes, seeing the prize of likes and comments and stuff on social media as the end goal. Yeah, it's like the shadow, but then you get out and then you realize that there's a good father that's waiting for us that will say, well done, good and faithful servant, and that's the real prize. And when you hear him say that to you, when you receive communion or participate in any of the sacraments, you're like, this is what I'm really living for. And everything else is just an illusionary world.
SPEAKER_01And that doesn't make everything else bad. And yeah, yeah. So, yeah, those are different parallels and connections that I had with Plato and Christianity and stuff. But all of that kind of is what brought me in. Got me Plato crazy. But, yeah. Well, it's been about an hour, so I think this is probably a good point to break. You're right.
SPEAKER_01Some people just tuned in. So this will be saved and posted on my Substack for people that came in late and want to see the whole thing. But WD, thank you for coming in, tuning in on this. This was very fun.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Paul. Yeah, it was a pleasure. It was mine. I love it.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, have a good night, everyone, and have a good night. You. Take care. Bye.
Thank you for tuning in! My guest on The Holler podcast this time is Blues legend, Dr. Corey Harris. Harris is an accomplished musician who has performed all over the world, played with the likes of BB King and Buddy...
I’m joined this time by Paul, ‘Pablo,’ Dordal. What is ‘retirement’? What is it ‘freedom from’? My guest today suggest it is more a ‘freedom to’. Our discussion was occasioned by Pablo’s essay 'When Your Life No Longer...
I’m joined once again by my favorite AI scientist, Terry Rankin. On this episode, we talk not about what has happened with AI in the past week or so, but some much deeper issues. First, we talk about the implications of...
I’m joined by Harry Smith aficionado and folk singer Rodney Hargis (https://substack.com/@rlhargis) for a conversation about Harry Smith’s legendary 1952 Anthology of American Folk Music. It only sold 50 copies in the...
This time I’m joined by Michael Martin to discuss folk music. Michael is in fact an actual folk musician (in addition to farmer, mystic, literati, etc…). We talk about what is folk music, how we each came to be...